question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I have been running a multiple moderator analysis in a pretty simple model.</p> <p>X are Google search queries normalized to 0-100. Y are the new registrations of cars in one country and one moderator.</p> <p>After checking for normality of the dependent variable Y, the result has been that it is skewed to the left and not normally distributed.</p> <p>Here my two questions:</p> <ol> <li>Can I just go on with a moderator analysis via multiple regression?</li> <li>There has been an outlier in the dependent variable which could cause the violation of not being normally distributed, but must I exclude this item? Or can I keep it?</li> </ol>
36,799
[ -0.038871847093105316, 0.02075681835412979, 0.009647460654377937, 0.01779661886394024, 0.06301793456077576, 0.013081308454275131, -0.02471245266497135, -0.027432475239038467, 0.022709770128130913, -0.03140108287334442, 0.060728300362825394, 0.02483113296329975, 0.08089005202054977, 0.009943990968167782, 0.047223642468452454, 0.005089391488581896, -0.021324897184967995, 0.026655612513422966, 0.008050145581364632, 0.019183624535799026, -0.03355460613965988, 0.007720016874372959, -0.003917467314749956, 0.0030993325635790825, -0.05101064592599869, 0.03769531846046448, 0.016612710431218147, -0.010371072217822075, -0.0017876718193292618, 0.01664111763238907, -0.00044506986159831285, -0.028002901002764702, 0.006364055909216404, 0.02731914632022381, 0.029666434973478317, 0.025427289307117462, -0.01816013641655445, 0.022111553698778152, 0.003428347408771515, 0.005451069213449955, -0.001045415410771966, -0.03706766292452812, 0.003224589629098773, 0.04625675082206726, 0.0007392584811896086, 0.008447880856692791, 0.02932151034474373, -0.03752950578927994, 0.039429061114788055, -0.01827758178114891, 0.0815354734659195, -0.022328607738018036, 0.012747845612466335, 0.0582316629588604, -0.02038969285786152, -0.010096159763634205, 0.06925872713327408, 0.06282036006450653, -0.0014066979056224227, -0.0313437320291996, -0.01868106797337532, -0.006534137763082981, -0.0157032273709774, 0.01107015646994114, -0.020233474671840668, 0.009317019954323769, -0.0074029047973454, -0.02886294201016426, 0.06828687340021133, -0.02120952494442463, 0.017908964306116104, -0.008389855735003948, 0.02867104485630989, -0.024176329374313354, 0.024970635771751404, -0.05516248568892479, 0.018328437581658363, 0.03314732760190964, 0.011833704076707363, 0.01146535575389862, 0.026780158281326294, -0.0032094994094222784, -0.00009049893560586497, 0.034121815115213394, 0.025325868278741837, -0.0044311038218438625, 0.07946695387363434, -0.034988466650247574, 0.02338949218392372, 0.05157026648521423, -0.026992401108145714, -0.002656671218574047, 0.03877634555101395, 0.0005375571199692786, -0.0518391914665699, 0.04849257692694664, -0.015554698184132576, 0.031893290579319, 0.017873244360089302, 0.024206921458244324, -0.061011552810668945, -0.026055442169308662, 0.013233316130936146, 0.016513913869857788, -0.04129418730735779, 0.008152684196829796, -0.018881037831306458, 0.013678117655217648, -0.023851530626416206, -0.04366278275847435, -0.03638264909386635, 0.0005016099894419312, 0.00005731738201575354, -0.004550029989331961, 0.029270607978105545, 0.003648343263193965, -0.016857152804732323, -0.029402730986475945, 0.05058146268129349, 0.05065086483955383, 0.012562299147248268, -0.012839728966355324, 0.010443407110869884, -0.03615632280707359, -0.04832209646701813, 0.02644912526011467, 0.022976960986852646, 0.032488152384757996, -0.05038687214255333, 0.022150732576847076, 0.012603938579559326, 0.017832579091191292, -0.003906664904206991, -0.010233909823000431, 0.04880867898464203, -0.023196233436465263, -0.06807121634483337, -0.06772685796022415, 0.02819296345114708, 0.003007130231708288, 0.01807125099003315, -0.07322030514478683, -0.08477706462144852, 0.04587806761264801, 0.0536346435546875, 0.006687132176011801, 0.04518139734864235, 0.01420454028993845, 0.03600921854376793, -0.016083961352705956, -0.00455344095826149, -0.026723941788077354, -0.039461225271224976, -0.039150189608335495, -0.013975435867905617, -0.13282473385334015, 0.04011847451329231, 0.005583953112363815, 0.010197166353464127, 0.011873651295900345, 0.03698769584298134, 0.002015370409935713, -0.0009897516574710608, -0.012406201101839542, 0.028849666938185692, -0.02217918634414673, 0.06767523288726807, -0.0055598062463104725, 0.030150605365633965, 0.008420078083872795, 0.0013560709776356816, 0.036308664828538895, 0.0021599577739834785, 0.03332505002617836, 0.03966689482331276, -0.028778377920389175, 0.00011122136493213475, -0.04118229076266289, 0.03446561098098755, -0.006645549554377794, -0.06472710520029068, -0.0014759263722226024, -0.042933981865644455, 0.0404803566634655, 0.012105853296816349, 0.01480158232152462, 0.014291579835116863, -0.0060416413471102715, 0.05368544161319733, -0.03684130683541298, -0.029386209324002266, -0.038133107125759125, -0.014714832417666912, -0.007816619239747524, -0.025203455239534378, 0.028146130964159966, -0.01572125032544136, 0.062169741839170456, -0.016698462888598442, -0.009736190550029278, -0.005132175981998444, -0.009945061057806015, 0.05651607736945152, -0.05464448779821396, -0.010006621479988098, 0.04544563964009285, 0.04059181362390518, -0.011407212354242802, 0.023785706609487534, -0.013253952376544476, -0.025448020547628403, 0.01174924336373806, -0.02773192711174488, 0.0025874809361994267, -0.0027966995257884264, -0.03223225846886635, 0.02035018987953663, 0.0005721033667214215, -0.029347488656640053, 0.02011725679039955, -0.046273473650217056, 0.05741779878735542, 0.048343535512685776, -0.034190014004707336, -0.025753449648618698, -0.01007669884711504, -0.005583765916526318, 0.011134627275168896, -0.034036096185445786, -0.0390327014029026, -0.07571148872375488, -0.03258596733212471, -0.00398249039426446, 0.003336019814014435, -0.042791541665792465, 0.03367015719413757, 0.07832084596157074, 0.016191309317946434, 0.020328102633357048, 0.008602823130786419, -0.0008383603417314589, -0.02523280680179596, 0.04085459187626839, 0.027706308290362358, 0.0419456847012043, 0.036365948617458344, 0.0015279317740350962, -0.034114718437194824, 0.002803267678245902, 0.011632503010332584, 0.027827316895127296, 0.03344724699854851, 0.014457081444561481, 0.008126230910420418, 0.0015220274217426777, 0.051176268607378006, 0.06667166948318481, 0.0028843223117291927, 0.004329227842390537, 0.08154521137475967, 0.003677917178720236, -0.032041069120168686, 0.005914802197366953, 0.030881300568580627, -0.0018608981044963002, 0.0554516538977623, -0.07755780965089798, 0.007645574398338795, 0.01430500391870737, -0.008784934878349304, -0.0173958633095026, -0.03023933805525303, -0.014827652834355831, -0.019941581413149834, -0.006541791372001171, 0.0359637551009655, 0.017216991633176804, 0.015641191974282265, -0.05019382759928703, -0.0011669060913845897, -0.0130851399153471, -0.002318725688382983, -0.007294212002307177, -0.00598908681422472, -0.031561631709337234, 0.009885787032544613, -0.008594839833676815, 0.022497666999697685, -0.017170820385217667, -0.006466374266892672, 0.018915237858891487, 0.002863119589164853, -0.002467549405992031, -0.05668671801686287, -0.05069759860634804, -0.004109141882508993, 0.011222654953598976, -0.016917675733566284, -0.06260872632265091, 0.03833848983049393, 0.03285384178161621, -0.02103111520409584, 0.01131705567240715, -0.04841272905468941, -0.03057292103767395, -0.0255443025380373, -0.002540266141295433, 0.019995396956801414, 0.0335722416639328, 0.04083385318517685, -0.0020839660428464413, -0.036923207342624664, 0.011757764965295792, -0.0738474577665329, -0.04528076946735382, 0.029728444293141365, 0.004487174097448587, 0.07247009128332138, -0.029480433091521263, -0.008863330818712711, 0.04391523450613022, 0.06231109797954559, -0.02043859288096428, -0.06023067981004715, -0.02414858713746071, -0.06181153655052185, -0.0887899100780487, 0.027248268947005272, 0.006331401411443949, -0.000883504340890795, 0.02338382788002491, 0.01324713695794344, 0.0334937646985054, 0.010706131346523762, 0.019754815846681595, -0.04587642103433609, 0.009130367077887058, -0.001622815732844174, -0.0050949826836586, 0.04576268419623375, 0.05567362904548645, -0.0003301244287285954, -0.00833766721189022, -0.010935927741229534, 0.05504898726940155, 0.029297780245542526, -0.03345182165503502, 0.028785014525055885, -0.0000050882981668110006, -0.005204286891967058, -0.02299373224377632, 0.03607168793678284, 0.05650991573929787, -0.03175006061792374, -0.022612014785408974, -0.032135721296072006, 0.02825276553630829, -0.023473689332604408, 0.03917434811592102, 0.05959979072213173, 0.028081562370061874, -0.011541813611984253, -0.019227609038352966, -0.02714814990758896, -0.0019849592354148626, -0.01247070450335741, -0.016331344842910767, -0.00688319792971015, 0.017327940091490746, 0.02383614517748356, -0.0038353432901203632, -0.04086335748434067, -0.02483990415930748, -0.03045525960624218, -0.10070677101612091, 0.004455536603927612, -0.030449051409959793, 0.023001236841082573, 0.015076526440680027, -0.015636136755347252, 0.02179703116416931, -0.04196811094880104, -0.011675331741571426, -0.021556923165917397, -0.07122302055358887, 0.01812557503581047, -0.04231618717312813, -0.013789043761789799, 0.02113458327949047, -0.05341412127017975, 0.03453486040234566, -0.02202935516834259, 0.033432286232709885, 0.0020851828157901764, 0.03694605454802513, -0.03380166366696358, -0.0010568578727543354, -0.06098950654268265, -0.037071701139211655, 0.0363408587872982, -0.01827935129404068, -0.001471856259740889, -0.016071146354079247, -0.003434130921959877, 0.025699276477098465, 0.01791783608496189, -0.016642097383737564, -0.04471965879201889, -0.03395496681332588, 0.0048545952886343, 0.07536972314119339, -0.010414736345410347, 0.028195897117257118, -0.034289561212062836, 0.03812460973858833, 0.023877708241343498, 0.027159087359905243, 0.059963978826999664, 0.0054335989989340305, -0.03618404641747475, -0.033206626772880554, -0.04657040163874626, 0.011221705935895443, 0.003328526159748435, -0.011416759341955185, 0.01715736649930477, 0.03072894923388958, 0.021728334948420525, -0.05876544862985611, 0.029377391561865807, 0.03987911343574524, 0.03947852924466133, -0.010552400723099709, -0.01983688212931156, 0.00012239874922670424, 0.035722922533750534, -0.006031895987689495, 0.0012973012635484338, 0.006454933900386095, 0.004382910672575235, -0.022939415648579597, 0.015619637444615364, -0.02126474864780903, -0.005734914448112249, 0.0039743282832205296, 0.020732149481773376, 0.054027266800403595, -0.029727984219789505, -0.029748886823654175, 0.004440970253199339, 0.03576800599694252, 0.04402146488428116, 0.04342637211084366, -0.015503732487559319, -0.09190607815980911, 0.04257091134786606, 0.05219561606645584, 0.0322006456553936, -0.010779595002532005, 0.004217648413032293, -0.0016168103320524096, 0.007128525525331497, 0.003680613124743104, -0.03135242313146591, 0.02809087559580803, -0.010796486400067806, 0.01760290563106537, 0.014419411309063435, -0.019765278324484825, -0.06851613521575928, -0.00475418521091342, -0.003979681059718132, 0.027484068647027016, -0.01635117083787918, -0.053653862327337265, -0.06347740441560745, 0.019166266545653343, 0.03379307687282562, 0.03760102018713951, 0.006986443884670734, -0.005534976255148649, 0.009151882492005825, 0.012919528409838676, -0.01152937114238739, -0.06220543012022972, 0.01388204749673605, 0.020645013079047203, -0.007345614954829216, 0.06196926534175873, 0.021368395537137985, -0.02752400003373623, 0.017106177285313606, 0.027526870369911194, -0.023230943828821182, 0.022499099373817444, 0.0019143568351864815, 0.030277857556939125, 0.03297942131757736, 0.010719237849116325, 0.024417320266366005, 0.03748764842748642, 0.023186014965176582, -0.013626405037939548, -0.05045560747385025, 0.0026867117267102003, -0.05025697126984596, -0.02437276393175125, -0.029001979157328606, -0.0035615209490060806, -0.008991827256977558, 0.01495940238237381, 0.010177930817008018, 0.01659732311964035, -0.023982081562280655, -0.028865685686469078, -0.005562047939747572, 0.03299155831336975, -0.004019423853605986, -0.01209231186658144, -0.013397754170000553, -0.0023859329521656036, -0.034738700836896896, 0.0055608986876904964, 0.011943873949348927, -0.0382048562169075, 0.007138507906347513, 0.0013426044024527073, -0.030701253563165665, 0.02667262591421604, -0.0033560225274413824, -0.028731293976306915, -0.0029472680762410164, -0.02706303261220455, 0.034993045032024384, -0.004402489401400089, 0.04335962235927582, 0.006617644801735878, -0.012430726550519466, 0.015660269185900688, 0.024042362347245216, -0.0023732036352157593, 0.0031621495727449656, -0.005338277202099562, 0.052549175918102264, -0.021347934380173683, -0.007150119170546532, -0.0710710734128952, -0.027122898027300835, 0.018781544640660286, -0.04280998930335045, -0.004595248959958553, -0.0035349091049283743, -0.017618002369999886, -0.026430875062942505, -0.049828801304101944, -0.023243263363838196, 0.04280739277601242, -0.03042593039572239, -0.013262509368360043, -0.0037474404089152813, 0.046429093927145004, 0.09573795646429062, -0.023610340431332588, -0.022138912230730057, 0.04471656680107117, -0.03469463810324669, -0.016636062413454056, -0.015020148828625679, 0.03300446271896362, -0.02926688641309738, -0.000771026243455708, -0.05970697104930878, 0.012713858857750893, 0.024413352832198143, -0.03605401888489723, 0.008057749830186367, 0.026690930128097534, -0.00733525026589632, 0.011533202603459358, -0.03692815825343132, -0.03228503465652466, 0.002287402516230941, -0.0036109862849116325, 0.009826275520026684, 0.026336947456002235, 0.006412247195839882, 0.009491854347288609, 0.05380814149975777, -0.009551205672323704, 0.013067900203168392, 0.01624111272394657, 0.09312903881072998, 0.00007668624311918393, 0.03238046541810036, -0.029049070551991463, -0.02237471006810665, 0.051510654389858246, 0.002342566382139921, 0.00482923211529851, -0.0164810623973608, 0.007565479725599289, -0.034561239182949066, -0.05975823849439621, -0.02504379115998745, -0.004058348946273327, 0.036935366690158844, -0.006796014029532671, 0.010550999082624912, 0.046405356377363205, -0.0014970767078921199, -0.015717128291726112, -0.06467999517917633, -0.01534930057823658, -0.008819290436804295, 0.027978738769888878, 0.029226243495941162, -0.041370365768671036, 0.010942945256829262, 0.01881776936352253, 0.015336865559220314, 0.06121883913874626, 0.019034920260310173, 0.037744857370853424, 0.03609852120280266, 0.01909380406141281, -0.0309082493185997, -0.033553700894117355, 0.02501641772687435, -0.01918582059442997, 0.039385244250297546, -0.030326534062623978, -0.01115628331899643, 0.034849390387535095, 0.037127792835235596, 0.022623689845204353, -0.0486786812543869, -0.015481618233025074, -0.06964375823736191, -0.0024582701735198498, 0.011345339007675648, -0.0020981100387871265, 0.028015844523906708, 0.003023569006472826, 0.03847192972898483, 0.03553390875458717, 0.009209522977471352, -0.03623194247484207, -0.0746970921754837, -0.025782328099012375, -0.0025370214134454727, -0.009854021482169628, 0.013119903393089771, -0.043472424149513245, -0.03818780928850174, 0.0379626601934433, -0.055802732706069946, -0.007718619424849749, 0.017098039388656616, 0.0545160174369812, -0.018994631245732307, 0.044937051832675934, 0.013920677825808525, 0.01595776341855526, -0.004806224722415209, 0.014799477532505989, 0.1131112277507782, 0.06849317997694016, 0.0376189649105072, -0.055314067751169205, -0.014382321387529373, -0.01028829999268055, -0.011931134387850761, -0.02944933995604515, -0.006789184175431728, -0.024713966995477676, -0.00011727343371603638, 0.06563285738229752, 0.027620181441307068, -0.00001603965756657999, 0.0017715687863528728, 0.06988371908664703, -0.006591711193323135, -0.008419165387749672, 0.00038924679392948747, 0.03601369261741638, -0.040833186358213425, 0.003225780790671706, -0.04990387335419655, 0.04038119316101074, 0.0030662729404866695, -0.01857539266347885, -0.0044374107383191586, -0.011549380607903004, -0.011937912553548813, 0.001973815029487014, -0.022039588540792465, 0.003302961587905884, 0.015427826903760433, 0.010992332361638546, -0.007387863006442785, -0.019429581239819527, 0.03507925942540169, -0.028144441545009613, 0.0036481376737356186, 0.01888098381459713, -0.03194405138492584, 0.01619960553944111, 0.02802102640271187, -0.012641821056604385, -0.06765249371528625, -0.010520543903112411, 0.004222144838422537, 0.05233629420399666, -0.022236960008740425, -0.03379957377910614, -0.02339256927371025, 0.0019022367196157575, -0.007349092047661543, -0.017197798937559128, -0.01853369176387787, 0.012343025766313076, 0.0030776592902839184, -0.025072667747735977, -0.002767163095995784, -0.011514435522258282, 0.0031466279178857803, 0.003288180800154805, 0.022081628441810608, 0.03762628883123398, 0.016260378062725067, -0.03282051905989647, -0.022167552262544632, 0.06488118320703506, 0.015579442493617535, -0.017210787162184715, -0.031769536435604095, -0.034118957817554474, -0.033384572714567184, -0.009883816353976727, 0.0026135107036679983, 0.0027529916260391474, 0.02045390009880066, 0.010329504497349262, 0.0360453799366951, -0.06688805669546127, -0.03931301087141037, 0.015589688904583454, -0.020685438066720963, -0.024366922676563263, -0.0387674979865551, 0.00946344155818224, -0.005286335479468107, 0.03928826376795769, 0.02684316411614418, -0.0006758199306204915, 0.004609959665685892, 0.051392149180173874, 0.031575266271829605, -0.014256219379603863, -0.03248155489563942, 0.004762751050293446, -0.05499104782938957, -0.011835168115794659, -0.01742020808160305, 0.04677021875977516, 0.019846566021442413, -0.01631641946732998, 0.0008416181663051248, 0.02945052459836006, -0.00575230224058032, 0.016846638172864914, 0.039937395602464676, -0.08427725732326508, 0.00851459801197052, 0.017914095893502235, -0.014981098473072052, 0.005089099518954754, -0.028203634545207024, -0.014150849543511868, -0.013029123656451702, 0.03449628874659538, 0.01220453530550003, -0.01721706986427307, -0.0028276583179831505, -0.012079953216016293, 0.04162922129034996, -0.024700647220015526, -0.006069580093026161, -0.04419020190834999, -0.0020753145217895508, 0.011965900659561157, -0.00904232356697321, -0.0052209277637302876, -0.004277420230209827, 0.01759997010231018, 0.04361559823155403, 0.03957614302635193, 0.04653956741094589, 0.03427979350090027, -0.020794134587049484, 0.020620299503207207, -0.014910330064594746, 0.062055956572294235, -0.031568948179483414, -0.030244143679738045, 0.06300032883882523, -0.023837031796574593, -0.019979918375611305, 0.011264759115874767, 0.017934830859303474, 0.023411277681589127, -0.02309339866042137, 0.012676986865699291, -0.02061760611832142, 0.049668531864881516, -0.027000918984413147, -0.00557639030739665, -0.002351227914914489, 0.008216215297579765, 0.022881077602505684, -0.017193518579006195, 0.024316199123859406, 0.020341448485851288, -0.00667077861726284, 0.022777007892727852, 0.06848878413438797, 0.00491747772321105, -0.0015398929826915264, -0.013752504251897335, 0.045380376279354095, 0.021688329055905342, -0.028938572853803635, 0.019257521256804466, 0.010907267220318317, 0.05069385841488838, -0.024504482746124268, -0.0016705153975635767, -0.03210848197340965, 0.004563839640468359, -0.08405286818742752, -0.029224108904600143, 0.02995569445192814, 0.0026462781243026257, 0.038377221673727036, -0.029010944068431854, 0.0022734347730875015, 0.026471683755517006, -0.042589422315359116, -0.01471648272126913, -0.003216126235201955, -0.029993608593940735, -0.07407619059085846, -0.007044629659503698, 0.005969536490738392, 0.025288868695497513, 0.01415166724473238, 0.031017091125249863, 0.020054858177900314, 0.03591098636388779, 0.012691613286733627, -0.024622842669487, -0.012464776635169983, 0.017469309270381927, 0.020405977964401245, -0.04746842756867409, 0.03199463337659836, -0.045273348689079285, -0.02260286919772625, 0.040356747806072235, -0.006036872509866953, 0.027298061177134514, -0.009563468396663666, 0.022034140303730965, 0.024421418085694313, 0.04151056334376335, 0.03288930654525757, 0.03778589889407158, 0.015271724201738834, 0.029379354789853096, 0.00943905021995306, 0.03288213908672333, -0.004811529070138931, 0.03191176801919937, 0.006174747832119465, -0.05443793162703514, -0.010266604833304882, -0.00859918538480997, -0.010643528774380684, -0.010468050837516785, 0.0035411010030657053, 0.008692624978721142, 0.004444688558578491, -0.031384989619255066, 0.010774707421660423, -0.030251620337367058, -0.0013642341364175081, 0.055625781416893005, 0.03730044141411781, -0.029459308832883835, 0.015605855733156204, -0.004985228180885315, -0.03789516165852547, 0.024003133177757263, -0.02239255979657173, -0.029583631083369255, -0.04745819419622421, 0.008327404968440533, -0.013866434805095196, -0.02992994897067547, -0.041124388575553894, -0.004632613155990839, -0.032252535223960876, 0.045077964663505554, -0.030438056215643883, -0.006419497076421976, 0.002888766583055258, -0.04622551426291466, 0.0011105446610599756, -0.06288021802902222, 0.0331241600215435, 0.009457995183765888, -0.02222278341650963, -0.01297642383724451, 0.011723777279257774, -0.06314729899168015, -0.019039863720536232, 0.017615042626857758, 0.004252632614225149, 0.019050072878599167, -0.028078993782401085, 0.026239972561597824, 0.009378745220601559, -0.04330943152308464, 0.043833695352077484, -0.014715022407472134, -0.01438161637634039, -0.009770681150257587, -0.004274537321180105, -0.009195221588015556, 0.011011801660060883, 0.012297485955059528, -0.0052786157466471195, 0.024929100647568703, 0.05568486079573631, -0.03534838929772377, 0.03665157034993172, 0.003385091433301568, -0.008364132605493069, 0.015602797269821167, 0.00864346418529749, 0.021194593980908394, 0.06839060038328171, 0.021275999024510384, -0.04984080046415329, 0.01110568456351757, -0.01864365115761757, -0.037935588508844376, -0.015937481075525284, 0.012796776369214058, -0.005297437310218811, -0.04615526646375656, 0.01514650508761406, 0.023777278140187263, -0.013213317841291428, 0.012464453466236591, -0.010731779970228672, 0.020407099276781082, 0.026849566027522087, -0.0025879882741719484, 0.018404550850391388, 0.011087290942668915, -0.023279603570699692, 0.007910513319075108, 0.03179900348186493, 0.004954915959388018, 0.030472099781036377, -0.02085570991039276, 0.04220672696828842, 0.0008802600204944611, 0.05301295593380928, -0.023846454918384552, 0.030383598059415817, -0.03539010137319565, -0.006124312523752451, 0.026714550331234932, 0.02733665332198143, 0.05857620760798454, -0.018757063895463943, 0.030590517446398735, -0.00454671448096633, -0.04506027698516846, -0.016236748546361923, -0.05350492522120476, -0.023917829617857933, -0.019771398976445198, 0.025959618389606476, -0.01734362542629242, 0.009870382025837898, 0.025042926892638206, -0.00924465898424387, 0.01043167058378458, -0.0023506591096520424, 0.02045512944459915, -0.02239973470568657, 0.041433997452259064, -0.03416812792420387, -0.01925724931061268, -0.023335417732596397, -0.010701696388423443, -0.02940213680267334, 0.006397770252078772, 0.029790863394737244, 0.06901517510414124, -0.0034059344325214624, -0.06469745934009552, -0.017718395218253136, -0.02041187882423401, 0.04509507864713669, -0.03633756563067436, -0.017764776945114136, -0.029921002686023712, 0.006745517253875732, -0.017727438360452652, -0.032086439430713654 ]
<p>I would like to evaluate the goodness-of-fit of the following (<em>Pareto</em>-like) distribution: $$ f(r) = \sigma \centerdot r^{-\rho} $$ The function estimates the population of cities given the rank $r$ in a popularity ranking.</p> <p>I have not estimated the parameters ($\sigma$ and $\rho$) from the sample. However, I am unsure how to apply <em>Kolmogorov-Smirnov</em> (or similar tests) because I do not know the <em>CDF</em> of $f(r)$.</p> <p>How can I solve this problem?</p>
74,130
[ -0.028964171186089516, -0.03907639533281326, -0.016065876930952072, 0.00497484439983964, 0.04361557960510254, 0.016743013635277748, 0.0005031840410083532, -0.004927797242999077, 0.02991360053420067, -0.0490313358604908, 0.04188629984855652, 0.05498224124312401, 0.04422641545534134, 0.019228000193834305, 0.04021872207522392, -0.01097644679248333, -0.05194321647286415, 0.04973045736551285, 0.007332522887736559, -0.014116251841187477, 0.028573526069521904, 0.024182233959436417, 0.022543076425790787, -0.026346668601036072, -0.03015548549592495, 0.015253830701112747, 0.01879296451807022, -0.011679908260703087, 0.02473667450249195, 0.07169744372367859, -0.04391497001051903, -0.014778882265090942, -0.02043270133435726, 0.04364621266722679, 0.0071676201187074184, 0.024447128176689148, -0.033513277769088745, -0.02199147827923298, -0.03955844044685364, 0.026891764253377914, -0.008148797787725925, -0.020406827330589294, 0.023717638105154037, 0.029195062816143036, -0.007757444866001606, 0.020678851753473282, -0.02643270418047905, -0.048249922692775726, 0.0351145938038826, -0.04911871254444122, 0.06668750196695328, 0.04462890326976776, 0.0301554836332798, 0.034030020236968994, -0.015253094024956226, -0.026278799399733543, 0.015236370265483856, 0.05023336410522461, -0.04259386658668518, -0.04376721382141113, -0.012970698066055775, -0.0541621558368206, -0.019481481984257698, -0.030091144144535065, -0.0011670927051454782, -0.003588477848097682, -0.015122425742447376, 0.004423582926392555, 0.07139211893081665, -0.00562983937561512, 0.0012923358008265495, 0.0006269531440921128, 0.0583188459277153, -0.004550158977508545, 0.03038158267736435, -0.011903823353350163, 0.007807871792465448, -0.029743149876594543, 0.03328023478388786, 0.00007052974251564592, 0.010992997325956821, 0.005414651706814766, -0.007115438114851713, 0.0509355403482914, 0.024108463898301125, -0.03388410806655884, 0.04807569831609726, -0.011821758933365345, 0.0021040006540715694, 0.008963404223322868, -0.03007795661687851, -0.028179818764328957, 0.06258326768875122, -0.009474396705627441, -0.03790333867073059, 0.009676909074187279, -0.0023099416866898537, 0.037592463195323944, -0.021284570917487144, -0.017585275694727898, -0.0004423157370183617, -0.06552677601575851, 0.025706496089696884, 0.052237894386053085, -0.011987986974418163, 0.014167897403240204, 0.0011074987705796957, -0.0377163290977478, -0.043173834681510925, -0.018894311040639877, 0.0032661757431924343, 0.009686006233096123, 0.02457619085907936, -0.02864079549908638, 0.030097270384430885, 0.05676029622554779, -0.02496618963778019, -0.03828968480229378, 0.046360310167074203, 0.05021044239401817, 0.027207808569073677, 0.0016096787294372916, -0.0032430326100438833, -0.04055981710553169, -0.05114610865712166, 0.048192258924245834, 0.019716724753379822, -0.02772882767021656, -0.035410791635513306, 0.07092171907424927, 0.0012292437022551894, -0.019825492054224014, -0.013261542655527592, 0.011917498894035816, 0.024881891906261444, -0.007064584642648697, -0.09109193831682205, -0.023597421124577522, -0.02469741553068161, -0.015011896379292011, -0.016894614323973656, -0.05076843500137329, -0.00004183431883575395, -0.00977331306785345, 0.013141635805368423, 0.029087482020258904, 0.032957207411527634, 0.028755364939570427, 0.06327638030052185, 0.012269165366888046, -0.03427300229668617, -0.046104468405246735, -0.05366070196032524, -0.010316990315914154, -0.06153412535786629, -0.05725165829062462, 0.017790142446756363, 0.0037225752603262663, 0.014234109781682491, -0.04076592996716499, 0.07526525110006332, 0.04059029743075371, -0.03869299963116646, -0.009695331566035748, 0.0040842751041054726, -0.010272673331201077, 0.09133879095315933, 0.025252919644117355, 0.022036252543330193, -0.01105701643973589, 0.011670464649796486, 0.018858181312680244, 0.032002534717321396, 0.03908273205161095, 0.025354716926813126, -0.026119045913219452, -0.003152793040499091, -0.04241575300693512, 0.007577916607260704, -0.03147980570793152, -0.02846575155854225, -0.04444242641329765, -0.030748998746275902, 0.024230940267443657, -0.010593499056994915, 0.062160469591617584, 0.013320749625563622, -0.005823124665766954, 0.04319198057055473, -0.0766252651810646, -0.02496020682156086, -0.06067214906215668, 0.003331140847876668, 0.016621936112642288, -0.05247603729367256, 0.011723938398063183, 0.013096336275339127, 0.025898197665810585, -0.003598559182137251, -0.0030690680723637342, -0.03250841796398163, -0.00791115965694189, 0.03624671697616577, 0.0052368780598044395, 0.01442328654229641, 0.046394169330596924, 0.06461530923843384, 0.002244419651106, 0.043365515768527985, -0.01055493950843811, -0.06048349291086197, -0.01998181827366352, -0.038823049515485764, 0.02557532489299774, -0.005653991363942623, -0.0020753920543938875, -0.0068471054546535015, 0.004848082084208727, 0.04846166446805, 0.014674763195216656, -0.07865341752767563, 0.06023278087377548, 0.06914469599723816, 0.00625574542209506, 0.036077044904232025, -0.0035554496571421623, 0.01885918900370598, -0.013253351673483849, -0.016222374513745308, -0.03447527810931206, -0.048142269253730774, -0.043394334614276886, 0.04519857466220856, -0.017486296594142914, -0.04855545237660408, 0.0008982057333923876, 0.07587137073278427, 0.012622102163732052, 0.03941277787089348, 0.027266914024949074, -0.025253664702177048, 0.005869035143405199, 0.01303555816411972, 0.008452948182821274, 0.006525660865008831, 0.01768357679247856, 0.011875576339662075, 0.027249695733189583, 0.026212409138679504, -0.0153895178809762, -0.004447737243026495, 0.04831310734152794, -0.017609454691410065, 0.013378391042351723, -0.052336450666189194, -0.019134320318698883, 0.0546867772936821, 0.0031095233280211687, -0.015274636447429657, 0.0518529899418354, -0.016416987404227257, 0.0672437995672226, 0.029532060027122498, -0.035309091210365295, 0.023917565122246742, 0.05126028135418892, -0.040670961141586304, -0.04901948943734169, 0.020067259669303894, -0.031880468130111694, 0.013874818570911884, 0.011835633777081966, -0.0189232025295496, -0.01884434185922146, 0.006261814851313829, 0.02403089962899685, 0.011009635403752327, -0.016975821927189827, -0.009137025102972984, -0.001547668012790382, 0.004116708878427744, -0.025375867262482643, -0.01556054875254631, 0.06349291652441025, -0.022599615156650543, -0.004135299939662218, 0.012098440900444984, -0.013727699406445026, 0.0022836821153759956, 0.031365878880023956, -0.021521881222724915, 0.008083660155534744, -0.01825614459812641, -0.019924379885196686, -0.00031013943953439593, -0.031433843076229095, 0.021021690219640732, -0.033445797860622406, 0.004610136616975069, 0.035558346658945084, 0.005004330072551966, -0.004637595731765032, 0.031823791563510895, -0.03900536522269249, -0.029133645817637444, -0.02618008479475975, -0.010019173845648766, -0.015205240808427334, 0.0075838384218513966, 0.04282581806182861, -0.008779277093708515, -0.004114952869713306, -0.0031647207215428352, -0.04878818988800049, -0.059480633586645126, 0.03600388765335083, -0.016258707270026207, 0.053834229707717896, 0.015866724774241447, -0.06068037077784538, 0.054156363010406494, 0.02334914728999138, -0.02054073102772236, -0.01607198268175125, 0.0020757063757628202, -0.04811258986592293, 0.004660541191697121, 0.019042272120714188, 0.011846809647977352, -0.02320188656449318, 0.024415859952569008, 0.04302819073200226, 0.0037523650098592043, 0.05783111974596977, -0.028284166008234024, -0.04316844418644905, 0.03199613094329834, -0.00721670500934124, -0.012972998432815075, 0.07842300087213516, -0.008557045832276344, -0.0057277679443359375, 0.010114033706486225, -0.005676980596035719, 0.00499159237369895, 0.05791892111301422, -0.04780289903283119, -0.003240138990804553, -0.025917721912264824, -0.028302660211920738, -0.045113082975149155, 0.0594315342605114, 0.008220269344747066, -0.05530306324362755, 0.012451370246708393, 0.03497619181871414, 0.06507552415132523, -0.04918226599693298, 0.023567575961351395, 0.037607159465551376, 0.029998155310750008, -0.005939082708209753, -0.021928410977125168, -0.009884257800877094, -0.0012428557965904474, 0.012261944822967052, 0.004303749185055494, -0.015130327083170414, 0.0034688760060817003, 0.036171410232782364, 0.024771828204393387, -0.02497703768312931, -0.015767479315400124, 0.00012717350909952074, -0.020327694714069366, 0.0008575909305363894, -0.033242955803871155, 0.05366729199886322, 0.02030617743730545, 0.03892818093299866, 0.010497272945940495, -0.010373254306614399, -0.006107104942202568, 0.01097121462225914, -0.05247047170996666, 0.01508234441280365, -0.021287932991981506, -0.02365182153880596, -0.03100530244410038, 0.007166782394051552, 0.0418732650578022, 0.006992076989263296, -0.014941648580133915, 0.01494203507900238, 0.005359720904380083, -0.01715361326932907, -0.018747946247458458, -0.035463348031044006, -0.03410230204463005, 0.027780894190073013, 0.018295764923095703, 0.014405669644474983, -0.008237499743700027, 0.06797037273645401, 0.015951020643115044, -0.009544388391077518, -0.007331137545406818, -0.05160858482122421, -0.0001804639759939164, 0.0012489716755226254, 0.020001238211989403, 0.009617195464670658, 0.008869707584381104, -0.030117938295006752, 0.024581294506788254, -0.004853768274188042, 0.0777873694896698, 0.0338551290333271, 0.016889503225684166, -0.006331346463412046, -0.05705492943525314, 0.01142987422645092, -0.022724004462361336, -0.007218990940600634, -0.000060668073274428025, -0.008800551295280457, 0.08401734381914139, 0.011317191645503044, -0.04291270673274994, 0.028031153604388237, 0.042766258120536804, 0.0020576731767505407, 0.03038664348423481, -0.017798684537410736, 0.019367530941963196, -0.014576335437595844, 0.01181167084723711, -0.00047794097918085754, 0.010047744028270245, -0.020278936251997948, -0.0023708525113761425, 0.028422987088561058, -0.01697060652077198, -0.018110694363713264, -0.005517937708646059, 0.02635369449853897, 0.045423414558172226, -0.04130760580301285, -0.02936401590704918, 0.00680575193837285, 0.024502472952008247, 0.033149514347314835, -0.010499868541955948, 0.007303583901375532, -0.05874690040946007, -0.014657544903457165, 0.055465277284383774, 0.01663454808294773, -0.018635476008057594, 0.009162346832454205, -0.09608995914459229, 0.005486007779836655, 0.0366266705095768, -0.018325449898838997, 0.004311608616262674, 0.019563976675271988, -0.0027487606275826693, -0.0020305891521275043, -0.004574618302285671, -0.06571932882070541, -0.0005302940844558179, -0.03699783608317375, 0.05596290901303291, -0.08877477794885635, -0.009414086118340492, -0.03338651359081268, -0.0010515403700992465, 0.03680417686700821, 0.021227657794952393, 0.036874137818813324, -0.03223325312137604, 0.0031463124323636293, 0.001945312600582838, -0.009579472243785858, -0.03559521213173866, 0.007850554771721363, -0.004951229318976402, 0.01771625690162182, 0.04705481976270676, -0.01916312240064144, -0.0215973649173975, 0.045036621391773224, 0.008919085375964642, -0.005057513248175383, 0.0060663181357085705, -0.01870870217680931, 0.05062802881002426, 0.026879342272877693, 0.03306229040026665, 0.053486455231904984, 0.01334422454237938, 0.017512407153844833, -0.019739391282200813, -0.0008287137607112527, -0.02114885486662388, -0.01237037405371666, -0.000755330896936357, -0.028815733268857002, -0.011779654771089554, -0.007649117149412632, 0.0051489826291799545, 0.017064398154616356, 0.05055980384349823, -0.01849028468132019, -0.008414465934038162, 0.021570082753896713, 0.03332643583416939, -0.0073857977986335754, 0.023037850856781006, 0.026971939951181412, 0.03719471022486687, -0.008830162696540356, -0.0026352962013334036, 0.01593298278748989, -0.010553109459578991, 0.01674545183777809, -0.022622205317020416, -0.06852420419454575, 0.07410835474729538, -0.038309261202812195, -0.02571786753833294, -0.015355575829744339, -0.041919123381376266, 0.03117341734468937, -0.00645482586696744, 0.021335557103157043, -0.0114252595230937, -0.041640106588602066, -0.028692690655589104, -0.0007044269586913288, 0.015344559215009212, 0.04957476258277893, -0.011915551498532295, 0.03719592094421387, 0.011052560061216354, -0.0031417501159012318, -0.08384743332862854, -0.01876452937722206, 0.014938600361347198, -0.023720785975456238, -0.018289050087332726, -0.04161879047751427, 0.04828439652919769, 0.003936811815947294, -0.02632685750722885, -0.0006501509924419224, 0.037389323115348816, -0.0055804988369345665, -0.001590593601576984, -0.02095533348619938, 0.013500582426786423, 0.09102941304445267, -0.014660715125501156, -0.013936079107224941, 0.027814095839858055, 0.0032259703148156404, -0.010739174671471119, -0.020342109724879265, 0.027454791590571404, -0.02669643796980381, -0.0019528730772435665, 0.010330784134566784, 0.003390764817595482, -0.00676955608651042, -0.0020175911486148834, -0.018483012914657593, 0.0008059649262577295, 0.02336260676383972, 0.01223604567348957, 0.01526425126940012, -0.030745800584554672, -0.034508075565099716, -0.024453582242131233, -0.03739145025610924, -0.0009322167607024312, 0.005714436527341604, -0.003620689269155264, 0.038571517914533615, -0.0187519658356905, 0.014739904552698135, 0.012121138162910938, 0.07635066658258438, 0.007486233953386545, 0.013965456746518612, -0.011733686551451683, 0.006654820870608091, 0.02651742473244667, 0.007402246352285147, -0.02593451924622059, 0.016318529844284058, 0.05442434921860695, -0.052660029381513596, -0.017383115366101265, -0.054612062871456146, -0.013618783093988895, 0.05587586760520935, -0.011173868551850319, 0.03175038844347, 0.02715541236102581, 0.029084578156471252, 0.00677898433059454, -0.013068780303001404, -0.023942066356539726, -0.02685699239373207, 0.01613861508667469, 0.03715672343969345, 0.0019805850461125374, 0.036578644067049026, 0.037084754556417465, 0.03531767427921295, -0.027170758694410324, 0.07330065965652466, 0.012417999096214771, 0.057154327630996704, 0.015249539166688919, -0.01308806985616684, -0.01390521228313446, 0.06052536889910698, -0.043727435171604156, 0.019270621240139008, -0.025931349024176598, -0.025629615411162376, 0.044916387647390366, 0.05279865860939026, 0.015611644834280014, -0.013093936257064342, -0.01537808682769537, -0.017578475177288055, -0.0035759618040174246, -0.0012994847493246198, -0.027989931404590607, 0.0033969960641115904, -0.011037062853574753, 0.047096993774175644, 0.02249203622341156, 0.038562215864658356, -0.032899852842092514, -0.04335174337029457, 0.01951608434319496, -0.0036812815815210342, -0.06477872282266617, -0.0021972584072500467, 0.006489094812422991, -0.01759149506688118, 0.04145928472280502, -0.05239531397819519, 0.019671713933348656, 0.02539849281311035, 0.007990723475813866, 0.001864784280769527, 0.08109932392835617, -0.0023491024039685726, 0.02763279341161251, 0.011867620050907135, 0.008523954078555107, 0.10637510567903519, 0.08926313370466232, 0.017653387039899826, -0.06380755454301834, -0.0061654578894376755, -0.012055262923240662, 0.017140677198767662, -0.04263760894536972, 0.0012554897693917155, 0.018035409972071648, -0.030540164560079575, 0.04881633445620537, 0.016993746161460876, 0.01411924697458744, -0.010166504420340061, 0.03799641504883766, -0.009890527464449406, -0.03497537225484848, -0.004974587820470333, -0.03392944857478142, -0.05517522618174553, -0.04364551231265068, -0.026700397953391075, 0.028204768896102905, -0.0005423746188171208, -0.004314623773097992, -0.005914876703172922, 0.012729650363326073, -0.022921336814761162, -0.010883791372179985, -0.02291805110871792, 0.015019604936242104, 0.021270480006933212, 0.007843296974897385, -0.008030005730688572, 0.01361216139048338, -0.014209254644811153, -0.024861326441168785, 0.0074876402504742146, 0.05462555214762688, 0.011319191195070744, 0.028428494930267334, 0.007098990958184004, -0.006597498431801796, -0.048858292400836945, -0.007409870158880949, -0.05069711431860924, 0.011728262528777122, -0.024190610274672508, -0.004740370903164148, 0.0011919678654521704, -0.001278415904380381, -0.04492786154150963, -0.02943260595202446, 0.033033546060323715, 0.0040554772131145, 0.015975866466760635, -0.03040412813425064, -0.037182729691267014, -0.021694298833608627, 0.02149355411529541, -0.028175504878163338, 0.025673074647784233, 0.03431134298443794, -0.036427371203899384, -0.025000859051942825, -0.011881396174430847, 0.03432092443108559, -0.017381586134433746, -0.03001667931675911, -0.010903911665081978, -0.039978280663490295, -0.04935994744300842, 0.009644613601267338, 0.021248560398817062, -0.002704357262700796, 0.028621116653084755, 0.0179054606705904, -0.0017110013868659735, -0.03425431624054909, -0.020115360617637634, 0.0133383609354496, -0.05223582684993744, -0.010410727001726627, -0.02570193260908127, -0.015362302772700787, 0.04259634390473366, 0.033705003559589386, 0.043169137090444565, 0.022923076525330544, -0.00823774840682745, 0.06275387108325958, 0.02465423196554184, -0.06726572662591934, -0.02514880895614624, -0.03662841022014618, -0.029786592349410057, 0.005526822060346603, -0.0360867939889431, 0.033497244119644165, 0.03656037524342537, 0.03449682891368866, 0.007136455737054348, 0.01115171704441309, -0.04955453798174858, 0.04395695775747299, -0.013958582654595375, -0.037611208856105804, 0.00313617754727602, -0.012828328646719456, -0.025384845212101936, -0.017267731949687004, -0.013693185523152351, -0.010961762629449368, -0.039202965795993805, 0.019386963918805122, -0.0029320651665329933, -0.019993949681520462, -0.021194014698266983, -0.002809865865856409, 0.0013505700044333935, -0.0001314467954216525, 0.0034554230514913797, 0.008061136119067669, -0.008827418088912964, -0.05034061148762703, 0.02173805609345436, -0.018998708575963974, -0.006497954949736595, -0.023633334785699844, 0.04434390366077423, 0.00016324642638210207, -0.02270434983074665, -0.017531277611851692, 0.013603657484054565, 0.025528455153107643, 0.008091399446129799, 0.08889860659837723, -0.03875545784831047, 0.009469988755881786, 0.04890773817896843, -0.06774024665355682, -0.04260244965553284, 0.00980987586081028, 0.01895207352936268, 0.06711733341217041, 0.0012085336493328214, -0.0023662466555833817, 0.010869852267205715, 0.020181171596050262, 0.006917185615748167, 0.01667010970413685, -0.025345195084810257, 0.0064230733551084995, 0.032904598861932755, 0.00022550018911715597, -0.006745242979377508, -0.02538510225713253, 0.006741792429238558, 0.03553510457277298, 0.04618045315146446, -0.06371025741100311, 0.04156075045466423, 0.019671466201543808, -0.006878087762743235, -0.030978718772530556, 0.007214508019387722, 0.020621350035071373, 0.027557598426938057, 0.03661155328154564, 0.005596411880105734, 0.035866014659404755, -0.053086306899785995, -0.02938782051205635, -0.08581801503896713, -0.027295630425214767, 0.009692089632153511, -0.023318002000451088, 0.007929150946438313, -0.06432680785655975, -0.004276068415492773, 0.040911465883255005, -0.025264957919716835, 0.014077913016080856, 0.010649194940924644, 0.002117247087880969, -0.014095734804868698, 0.0012455390533432364, -0.019443707540631294, 0.013749341480433941, 0.0066318572498857975, 0.014587962068617344, 0.02907196618616581, 0.02275591343641281, 0.0017117832321673632, 0.006519165821373463, 0.04650013521313667, 0.061377882957458496, -0.004618226550519466, -0.04055551812052727, 0.053951606154441833, -0.011348385363817215, -0.010496499948203564, 0.024489711970090866, -0.04088541492819786, 0.029506832361221313, 0.004001203924417496, 0.029746750369668007, 0.0024824831634759903, 0.06509874761104584, 0.03385959938168526, -0.015035820193588734, -0.04342510178685188, 0.007160833105444908, -0.00013789143122266978, 0.024253299459815025, -0.052049048244953156, 0.012058229185640812, 0.03204493597149849, -0.026565156877040863, -0.032748039811849594, 0.0277582835406065, -0.01991819031536579, 0.005889064632356167, 0.02682843990623951, -0.02514428272843361, -0.005016694311052561, 0.001281263423152268, 0.046840447932481766, -0.046072058379650116, 0.0252994354814291, 0.027434909716248512, 0.007433382328599691, -0.023570241406559944, 0.018073663115501404, -0.014274436049163342, -0.053518764674663544, 0.023041347041726112, -0.006903491914272308, -0.029907196760177612, -0.04108104482293129, -0.005399604793637991, -0.02301057055592537, -0.0010626509319990873, -0.02924196980893612, -0.03694608062505722, -0.0063356803730130196, 0.029995663091540337, 0.025654088705778122, 0.013629889115691185, 0.015764964744448662, 0.00741212721914053, 0.021384984254837036, -0.08315716683864594, 0.05377238243818283, 0.024403613060712814, -0.01361347921192646, 0.004217586945742369, -0.033532969653606415, -0.02928515523672104, -0.034115567803382874, 0.022416943684220314, 0.022957805544137955, -0.01885555498301983, -0.014138595201075077, 0.04842786863446236, 0.009755432605743408, -0.0714605525135994, 0.008299664594233036, -0.02404705248773098, -0.006087948102504015, -0.015835924074053764, -0.021582698449492455, 0.01812688447535038, -0.0029461535159498453, 0.013410577550530434, 0.008852295577526093, -0.01600988209247589, -0.008789212442934513, -0.03907904773950577, 0.0424494743347168, 0.021651441231369972, -0.0157220009714365, 0.044021714478731155, 0.012772875837981701, 0.04143586754798889, 0.021183200180530548, 0.017255162820219994, -0.032108455896377563, 0.02798517793416977, 0.0033263922668993473, -0.06335951387882233, 0.015648353844881058, 0.02034047618508339, -0.00220702332444489, -0.05254516750574112, -0.006497375201433897, 0.028323868289589882, -0.05387597158551216, 0.0028776777908205986, 0.03281007707118988, 0.015327348373830318, 0.043997351080179214, -0.022545412182807922, -0.03858610987663269, 0.023435089737176895, -0.005407543852925301, -0.021537132561206818, -0.030531907454133034, 0.009846311062574387, -0.011400183662772179, 0.04998615384101868, 0.033254873007535934, -0.02922387234866619, -0.006025503855198622, -0.03193257004022598, 0.031160013750195503, -0.023316556587815285, -0.04365485534071922, 0.03900592401623726, -0.011482552625238895, 0.04144897684454918, -0.027632225304841995, -0.021919909864664078, 0.06792529672384262, 0.014203435741364956, 0.020787687972187996, -0.05089204013347626, -0.046793729066848755, -0.02358313277363777, 0.021033775061368942, 0.008437998592853546, 0.0018945089541375637, -0.023644927889108658, 0.015459184534847736, 0.013879326172173023, -0.0007073230226524174, 0.009717447683215141, -0.008907602168619633, 0.014971246011555195, -0.02403832972049713, -0.004898550920188427, -0.03324262052774429, -0.008982580155134201, 0.037899669259786606, -0.022299226373434067, 0.012406489811837673, 0.027157356962561607, 0.016489507630467415, -0.017712082713842392, -0.006851339712738991, 0.006266007665544748, 0.04719517379999161, -0.0645621120929718, -0.03036850318312645, -0.06819389015436172, 0.011410902254283428, -0.041357822716236115, -0.04910702630877495 ]
<p>I am curious to know exactly, what are the (possible) differences between inductive and deductive statistical inferences in applied statistics.</p> <p>Suggestions for some good resources to learn their differences, pros and cons properly are greatly appreciated. </p>
36,801
[ -0.037929218262434006, -0.027136629447340965, -0.018141698092222214, -0.024861443787813187, 0.031109843403100967, 0.020350489765405655, 0.021803317591547966, 0.0017715014982968569, 0.01815086416900158, -0.004388860426843166, 0.018132610246539116, 0.037482645362615585, 0.02853483334183693, 0.003495024051517248, -0.0058625321835279465, 0.02091958560049534, 0.0029626002069562674, 0.04700934886932373, 0.021402275189757347, 0.012186065316200256, -0.01006827037781477, 0.007061541546136141, 0.019312163814902306, 0.01802673190832138, -0.03291960805654526, 0.013779785484075546, 0.04178030416369438, 0.011651898734271526, 0.000555828504730016, 0.06886829435825348, -0.0015732707688584924, 0.01617099717259407, -0.02522825449705124, 0.04935900494456291, 0.028191272169351578, -0.031809765845537186, -0.02377365343272686, -0.01171617116779089, -0.0015588040696457028, 0.036693986505270004, -0.06251441687345505, -0.023167749866843224, -0.017692483961582184, 0.02102523483335972, -0.020774124190211296, 0.008970829658210278, -0.003757694037631154, -0.05445118620991707, -0.006686106324195862, -0.051543593406677246, 0.05131460726261139, -0.022709345445036888, 0.015446226112544537, 0.047842297703027725, 0.006464248988777399, 0.005652613006532192, 0.059139929711818695, 0.06765202432870865, -0.023798678070306778, -0.05466606467962265, -0.018608368933200836, -0.010863782837986946, 0.016530906781554222, -0.016094401478767395, -0.03704879805445671, 0.0451798290014267, 0.01718026027083397, -0.012638887390494347, 0.0441596694290638, -0.017478879541158676, 0.02594665065407753, 0.03498198464512825, 0.030942367389798164, 0.007075885310769081, 0.004017871338874102, -0.01087882835417986, -0.014584967866539955, -0.006792685016989708, 0.056173354387283325, 0.042920224368572235, 0.036419667303562164, 0.022637436166405678, 0.039999861270189285, 0.052050407975912094, 0.02292492985725403, -0.03158542141318321, 0.06659939885139465, -0.021152928471565247, -0.010928689502179623, 0.01733246259391308, -0.03230534493923187, -0.016101570799946785, 0.01846865937113762, -0.018890604376792908, -0.01999967359006405, 0.04218281805515289, -0.032369740307331085, 0.04756350442767143, 0.015585096552968025, -0.006182895973324776, -0.008875038474798203, -0.010439862497150898, 0.03909200802445412, 0.053128376603126526, -0.012585867196321487, -0.04481349140405655, -0.019240085035562515, 0.05462073162198067, -0.01315390970557928, -0.047101546078920364, -0.00021671650756616145, 0.06852485239505768, 0.01624368503689766, 0.02808956429362297, 0.01947067119181156, 0.010428628884255886, 0.012394958175718784, -0.038123030215501785, 0.05407680943608284, 0.06510554999113083, 0.03777891770005226, -0.04766164347529411, 0.04088287428021431, -0.016198107972741127, -0.047193728387355804, -0.02794608660042286, 0.03708667680621147, -0.02906918339431286, -0.01733901910483837, 0.05138308182358742, -0.009895583614706993, -0.025553613901138306, 0.028467724099755287, 0.021482665091753006, -0.015416995622217655, -0.007886962033808231, -0.06284669041633606, -0.04595563933253288, 0.03149864077568054, -0.017419496551156044, 0.0047063762322068214, -0.0475379042327404, 0.03286520391702652, 0.03033428080379963, 0.027107182890176773, 0.03152752295136452, 0.04502963274717331, -0.028065737336874008, 0.021925266832113266, 0.030500313267111778, -0.011284115724265575, -0.03471672907471657, -0.02211063541471958, -0.01624632440507412, -0.014421723783016205, -0.07900173962116241, 0.03900931403040886, -0.012190868146717548, -0.017765400931239128, -0.04892532154917717, 0.04021017998456955, -0.0197721216827631, -0.009937331080436707, -0.01792939193546772, 0.03908241540193558, 0.01587579771876335, 0.06853802502155304, 0.005617404822260141, 0.029863420873880386, 0.053182683885097504, -0.01960737444460392, 0.04366646707057953, 0.03110303357243538, 0.03843308240175247, 0.03265715017914772, -0.014488178305327892, -0.05696919932961464, 0.013889122754335403, 0.0333758182823658, -0.005900972057133913, -0.02751028910279274, -0.01206244993954897, -0.002425718354061246, -0.019516408443450928, 0.0036341918166726828, 0.02929491549730301, 0.0058479830622673035, -0.039337944239377975, 0.016256779432296753, -0.06414719671010971, -0.010163710452616215, -0.10803228616714478, -0.0066604954190552235, -0.005667593330144882, -0.020505020394921303, 0.032614801079034805, 0.036013342440128326, 0.01507288496941328, -0.0509636215865612, -0.028617996722459793, -0.014683276414871216, 0.018914667889475822, 0.03575543314218521, -0.06167466938495636, 0.026386352255940437, 0.056993596255779266, 0.032749686390161514, -0.025346126407384872, 0.053949493914842606, -0.08194690197706223, -0.06320546567440033, -0.004799914080649614, -0.03909114748239517, 0.0052461144514381886, 0.007743672467768192, 0.019154470413923264, 0.012964831665158272, -0.0008472693734802306, -0.045697297900915146, 0.04605761915445328, -0.045225780457258224, 0.09657862782478333, 0.04024279862642288, 0.0029434242751449347, -0.017579229548573494, 0.03300679102540016, -0.005757648032158613, -0.002386275678873062, 0.007795605808496475, 0.0013733245432376862, -0.05205174908041954, 0.020220806822180748, 0.07071639597415924, 0.01770714856684208, -0.02936079539358616, 0.029722459614276886, 0.014052175916731358, 0.025740906596183777, 0.0208890400826931, 0.05235808715224266, -0.020902076736092567, -0.01750233955681324, -0.0316929928958416, 0.04584641754627228, -0.007158623542636633, 0.016419759020209312, 0.018828844651579857, 0.011756944470107555, 0.04591142386198044, 0.026314016431570053, -0.03279844671487808, 0.051017846912145615, -0.017248060554265976, 0.011549361981451511, 0.007424874231219292, -0.029174242168664932, 0.00777977192774415, -0.04340240731835365, 0.014410778880119324, -0.004184850957244635, 0.002366294153034687, 0.016015347093343735, 0.007904876954853535, -0.01260240189731121, 0.0444570928812027, -0.0031064285431057215, -0.03177110478281975, 0.014051792211830616, 0.035695869475603104, -0.020513202995061874, 0.026738720014691353, -0.019338153302669525, -0.028747467324137688, -0.051677484065294266, -0.005443095695227385, -0.01391206867992878, -0.017344864085316658, 0.014349699020385742, -0.012305019423365593, 0.0001404433569405228, -0.011448211036622524, -0.03899172693490982, 0.026534302160143852, 0.010184809565544128, -0.053632061928510666, 0.015480125322937965, -0.03875024989247322, -0.026489412412047386, 0.04790204390883446, -0.021253036335110664, -0.003155902260914445, 0.0015142239863052964, 0.0010630337055772543, -0.07664315402507782, -0.014648810029029846, -0.01133540365844965, 0.020115258172154427, -0.02399965561926365, -0.03292558714747429, 0.011562548577785492, -0.012583061121404171, -0.02436446025967598, 0.04838041961193085, -0.042557865381240845, -0.0310098547488451, -0.029089970514178276, -0.004991394001990557, 0.02111598663032055, 0.018518120050430298, -0.022623416036367416, 0.052061498165130615, -0.05647186562418938, 0.00016907106328289956, -0.043164461851119995, -0.06079338490962982, 0.036288194358348846, -0.013110443949699402, -0.006406991742551327, 0.00941575225442648, -0.02581685222685337, 0.060247957706451416, 0.05018889904022217, -0.0401492714881897, -0.009718945249915123, -0.00783614907413721, -0.00953422300517559, 0.009340590797364712, 0.02542327158153057, 0.011621936224400997, -0.004827105440199375, 0.02048291079699993, 0.022764651104807854, 0.011053462512791157, 0.026856111362576485, 0.022934824228286743, 0.011981025338172913, 0.0299510695040226, 0.011608184315264225, -0.014139235951006413, 0.0210450179874897, 0.026169829070568085, -0.05975737050175667, 0.011399664916098118, -0.027956387028098106, 0.019971420988440514, 0.009318005293607712, -0.010330293327569962, 0.017994718626141548, -0.019136421382427216, 0.006297778338193893, -0.03485559672117233, 0.025437412783503532, 0.007978657260537148, 0.00011966557212872431, -0.0030556966084986925, -0.011777498759329319, -0.014865700155496597, -0.04315020889043808, -0.006244597490876913, 0.042437829077243805, 0.03177853301167488, -0.04071235656738281, 0.012147238478064537, -0.023610185831785202, -0.034387532621622086, 0.023457711562514305, 0.001460484229028225, -0.0038099433295428753, 0.0705016702413559, 0.054079364985227585, 0.005918960087001324, 0.011475070379674435, -0.029193416237831116, 0.020840754732489586, -0.06076813489198685, 0.05008069425821304, -0.02252708375453949, 0.04510052129626274, -0.0038259318098425865, 0.057708702981472015, 0.0004067610134370625, -0.018439140170812607, -0.021360596641898155, -0.00875483825802803, -0.06268642842769623, 0.020209716632962227, -0.04676222428679466, -0.0214796494692564, -0.016761280596256256, -0.025301216170191765, 0.005389586556702852, -0.0412670336663723, -0.01710856333374977, -0.026285292580723763, 0.015402467921376228, -0.05793803557753563, 0.0262848362326622, -0.03152261674404144, -0.03258178383111954, -0.008976830169558525, 0.012929894961416721, 0.015917133539915085, -0.031914059072732925, 0.047115981578826904, 0.029507359489798546, 0.008429224602878094, -0.024888919666409492, -0.02463361620903015, 0.0034100699704140425, 0.04356612637639046, 0.018710728734731674, 0.048688121140003204, 0.034447308629751205, -0.05148131400346756, 0.04872545972466469, 0.01495335716754198, 0.06428895890712738, 0.04463772103190422, -0.0311963502317667, -0.04453941434621811, -0.05607670545578003, -0.026849964633584023, -0.0035314287524670362, 0.03210911154747009, 0.007051323540508747, -0.00003578903488232754, 0.058555226773023605, -0.00237629609182477, -0.03619368001818657, 0.016754454001784325, 0.03615131974220276, 0.012376413680613041, 0.011477594263851643, -0.011209895834326744, -0.01087262760847807, -0.029085926711559296, -0.012073363177478313, 0.04973822087049484, 0.018101245164871216, 0.004599773790687323, 0.005857660435140133, 0.03208736330270767, -0.040063317865133286, -0.012670168653130531, -0.008908522315323353, 0.024500157684087753, 0.02534600906074047, 0.032072514295578, -0.036141522228717804, 0.04926101863384247, 0.0469028539955616, 0.03934183344244957, 0.06356333941221237, 0.017681926488876343, -0.06624902039766312, 0.018751610070466995, 0.09398212283849716, 0.03594985976815224, -0.05836821720004082, -0.002990664914250374, -0.027784662321209908, 0.003057285211980343, 0.04087657481431961, -0.017983125522732735, 0.02550537697970867, -0.011094828136265278, -0.0020470533054322004, -0.03676996007561684, -0.025968624278903008, -0.03465520963072777, 0.02828384004533291, -0.006457237061113119, 0.04693629592657089, 0.0007157782092690468, -0.014189510606229305, -0.08703672885894775, -0.006635830271989107, 0.04729137197136879, 0.03793811425566673, -0.010347297415137291, -0.0020754581782966852, 0.018055493012070656, 0.016713816672563553, 0.002643450628966093, -0.0600946880877018, -0.01894500106573105, 0.00793011486530304, 0.011944003403186798, 0.05698459595441818, 0.004468722268939018, -0.026405198499560356, 0.0017120875418186188, -0.026307497173547745, -0.025439374148845673, -0.0018819909309968352, -0.014040233567357063, 0.02090596780180931, 0.00009173010766971856, 0.012464215978980064, 0.06116403639316559, 0.005200594663619995, -0.017999233677983284, 0.0003264460538048297, -0.033439751714468, 0.03282380476593971, -0.036913421005010605, -0.04095717519521713, -0.05276547744870186, -0.004473943263292313, 0.007663360796868801, 0.009810672141611576, 0.01659955270588398, 0.02585434727370739, -0.043209563940763474, -0.02721014805138111, -0.00014255188580136746, 0.028362546116113663, 0.023752667009830475, -0.005852711386978626, -0.0022274742368608713, 0.028129491955041885, -0.011253852397203445, -0.0367099791765213, 0.02779490314424038, -0.01529818493872881, 0.0038387172389775515, 0.005823031067848206, -0.04744157940149307, 0.020060813054442406, -0.04492611065506935, -0.049702469259500504, 0.036679644137620926, -0.0021413748618215322, 0.050032228231430054, -0.037218041718006134, 0.032597728073596954, -0.0064742304384708405, -0.04252411425113678, -0.026490677148103714, 0.007290972862392664, 0.034852564334869385, 0.06754744797945023, -0.042121998965740204, 0.03072449378669262, -0.04528874531388283, -0.01215833518654108, -0.06704506278038025, -0.043106917291879654, 0.01392416749149561, 0.020101485773921013, -0.05864926427602768, -0.022699259221553802, 0.020395146682858467, -0.009101472795009613, -0.02754204347729683, -0.02981419675052166, 0.07531000673770905, -0.043133459985256195, -0.03620079532265663, -0.025729333981871605, -0.0007770658703520894, 0.05871119722723961, -0.026030421257019043, -0.016219843178987503, -0.009000886231660843, -0.017425427213311195, 0.009545110166072845, 0.02017911523580551, 0.013721829280257225, -0.015024572610855103, 0.00011203480244148523, -0.02771981619298458, -0.008080864325165749, 0.043799638748168945, -0.0498952679336071, 0.015012784861028194, 0.026214929297566414, 0.042504388839006424, -0.02277933619916439, -0.03389757126569748, 0.0016325757605955005, -0.03943450003862381, 0.022001443430781364, -0.004246516153216362, -0.002822937211021781, 0.026183776557445526, 0.01056147925555706, 0.019060887396335602, 0.03933893144130707, 0.03299545496702194, 0.03091738186776638, 0.02566438913345337, -0.028122806921601295, 0.028743712231516838, 0.0019615432247519493, -0.026691189035773277, 0.005651413928717375, -0.007635831367224455, 0.011335764080286026, 0.011742280796170235, 0.05463450402021408, -0.04485557600855827, -0.017448371276259422, -0.03314005956053734, 0.017666857689619064, 0.053421616554260254, 0.002304502995684743, 0.061719030141830444, 0.0710514560341835, 0.011032607406377792, -0.003407636657357216, -0.04204390570521355, 0.001612178049981594, -0.01370107289403677, -0.020310483872890472, 0.038536395877599716, 0.021934019401669502, -0.01849890500307083, 0.06330079585313797, -0.0018587299855425954, 0.003200030652806163, 0.02485026605427265, 0.014294825494289398, 0.029774833470582962, -0.007201866712421179, -0.02675030007958412, -0.057449955493211746, 0.014495717361569405, -0.0696040540933609, 0.025503547862172127, -0.00607318477705121, -0.023905418813228607, 0.04092584177851677, 0.03001699037849903, -0.007559537887573242, -0.06129501387476921, -0.013553936965763569, -0.056109990924596786, -0.00013649243919644505, 0.02175159752368927, 0.028126828372478485, 0.016133984550833702, 0.003954458981752396, 0.02529357559978962, -0.02334381826221943, 0.006034791003912687, -0.004183454439043999, -0.07582052052021027, -0.02939842827618122, -0.029292870312929153, -0.04212866351008415, 0.027359867468476295, 0.004614476580172777, -0.060030385851860046, 0.009214773774147034, -0.005825991742312908, 0.013678967021405697, 0.020037880167365074, 0.03328235447406769, -0.005278375931084156, 0.049907587468624115, -0.022362923249602318, -0.00003625041790655814, -0.01256113313138485, -0.024030275642871857, 0.11253068596124649, 0.06574974209070206, 0.03789951652288437, -0.08144523203372955, 0.01824565976858139, 0.0062559559009969234, 0.013468491844832897, -0.019464710727334023, 0.014460676349699497, -0.01235184632241726, 0.002161534270271659, 0.032750654965639114, 0.03495025262236595, -0.006130475550889969, -0.018223566934466362, 0.04783009737730026, -0.03548356518149376, -0.02355952374637127, -0.009233280085027218, 0.008400499820709229, 0.006229063495993614, 0.003269664477556944, -0.015828192234039307, 0.014495400711894035, 0.01520245335996151, -0.0003686601121444255, -0.031080322340130806, -0.009261474944651127, 0.03017752431333065, 0.0049278694204986095, -0.049215130507946014, -0.024096626788377762, 0.02857373282313347, 0.006542742718011141, -0.0525488443672657, -0.028495999053120613, 0.007886667735874653, -0.058424025774002075, 0.004627434071153402, 0.03978346288204193, 0.04753547161817551, -0.008110057562589645, -0.0011778706684708595, 0.012470284476876259, -0.04343578964471817, 0.0054067219607532024, -0.006869291886687279, 0.021249547600746155, -0.009260427206754684, -0.009954468347132206, -0.007825740613043308, -0.016886509954929352, 0.0008618318242952228, -0.03253748267889023, -0.0031725612934678793, 0.032963939011096954, 0.027742497622966766, -0.03025190345942974, -0.034309469163417816, -0.020405272021889687, 0.049934688955545425, -0.030025117099285126, 0.04317606985569, 0.00758967874571681, -0.03623460233211517, -0.014366703107953072, -0.019410759210586548, 0.01277597900480032, -0.03160109743475914, -0.003119351575151086, 0.011045092716813087, -0.005330421030521393, -0.015640756115317345, 0.011100661009550095, -0.006322617642581463, -0.0007346635102294385, 0.03762495517730713, -0.016002802178263664, 0.0028319829143583775, -0.0059735411778092384, -0.01952601782977581, 0.0005968413897790015, -0.022123778238892555, 0.014997006393969059, -0.023357946425676346, -0.009825455024838448, 0.04629149287939072, 0.05315317213535309, 0.028990939259529114, 0.036928072571754456, 0.018317608162760735, 0.010749543085694313, 0.006191804073750973, -0.05799395218491554, -0.009412656538188457, -0.022788122296333313, -0.018754122778773308, -0.004247533157467842, -0.029941895976662636, 0.03803883120417595, 0.054607126861810684, 0.03926417976617813, -0.017753122374415398, 0.0018250576686114073, -0.011991068720817566, 0.03383810073137283, -0.0215391106903553, -0.028483541682362556, 0.0361969918012619, 0.019565235823392868, 0.011464525945484638, -0.06191573664546013, -0.0412878692150116, -0.048219673335552216, -0.01862567663192749, 0.02965678460896015, -0.028423519805073738, -0.010288696736097336, 0.02184925600886345, 0.01470547541975975, 0.038724638521671295, -0.014433617703616619, -0.016537737101316452, -0.028112566098570824, -0.028325267136096954, 0.0038581164553761482, -0.030275816097855568, 0.02507450059056282, 0.006185099948197603, -0.004370656330138445, -0.012795157730579376, 0.038198716938495636, 0.023222818970680237, -0.004980873316526413, 0.0035060846712440252, 0.02685161493718624, -0.05462457239627838, 0.047736164182424545, -0.020910734310746193, -0.007307239808142185, 0.02101970463991165, -0.024536404758691788, -0.024000082165002823, 0.014371620491147041, -0.0035478046629577875, 0.0044639622792601585, 0.02347552962601185, 0.006880525033921003, -0.043913356959819794, 0.0383043996989727, -0.029627427458763123, -0.02635689079761505, -0.03849326819181442, -0.0060944342985749245, -0.012843548320233822, -0.01542515680193901, 0.01233294140547514, -0.009840529412031174, -0.014568657614290714, 0.017871510237455368, 0.03423944488167763, 0.02133694291114807, -0.024738386273384094, 0.0010379356099292636, 0.006030128337442875, 0.02953300066292286, 0.02633807435631752, -0.011976952664554119, 0.026079630479216576, 0.044332146644592285, -0.028727056458592415, 0.04267199710011482, -0.011272129602730274, 0.02014639414846897, -0.11617203801870346, 0.00011377232294762507, 0.018338574096560478, -0.016080761328339577, 0.026064643636345863, -0.05553494021296501, 0.018266063183546066, 0.034340765327215195, -0.03490768373012543, 0.006729946006089449, -0.024714820086956024, -0.017508722841739655, -0.022384747862815857, 0.018281204625964165, -0.013448059558868408, 0.037474606186151505, 0.009992597624659538, 0.010527209378778934, 0.008433789014816284, 0.0023717996664345264, 0.0024294492322951555, -0.01772892475128174, -0.036380115896463394, -0.0013713105581700802, -0.011677240952849388, -0.037759967148303986, 0.012938689440488815, -0.0453859381377697, -0.00605897419154644, 0.03432958573102951, 0.007466817740350962, 0.021745124831795692, 0.04357229918241501, 0.023559989407658577, -0.026107722893357277, 0.01886029541492462, 0.02777049131691456, -0.012920454144477844, -0.022737080231308937, 0.026140430942177773, 0.011778990738093853, 0.02658345364034176, -0.03070986084640026, -0.013232264667749405, 0.03223513811826706, -0.009647157974541187, -0.03370407968759537, 0.016447698697447777, -0.00738554447889328, -0.04378359392285347, 0.00337808346375823, -0.005580991040915251, -0.003365665441378951, -0.0034149019047617912, 0.03563051298260689, -0.05795294791460037, -0.0024015228264033794, 0.03307446837425232, 0.038027264177799225, -0.023741260170936584, 0.010838343761861324, -0.004350415896624327, -0.04017079994082451, 0.0015657453332096338, 0.016670694574713707, 0.026610491797327995, -0.055685196071863174, 0.010325705632567406, 0.0020445450209081173, -0.01211201399564743, -0.027280140668153763, -0.000882201362401247, -0.03591536357998848, 0.0497017465531826, 0.016759345307946205, -0.009670250117778778, 0.028231840580701828, -0.02136199362576008, -0.022098487243056297, -0.0913592129945755, 0.10567817091941833, -0.01392696239054203, -0.015716692432761192, -0.054146770387887955, 0.0026414552703499794, -0.011603905819356441, -0.004963919520378113, 0.04363574832677841, -0.0029199603013694286, 0.004996540956199169, -0.01316232793033123, 0.020926756784319878, -0.002569072414189577, -0.023870131000876427, 0.040924329310655594, -0.028587481006979942, -0.014453036710619926, -0.00442186463624239, -0.05439608544111252, -0.01401560939848423, 0.02034952864050865, -0.015983901917934418, 0.03520205616950989, 0.03732467070221901, 0.011770517565310001, 0.015022344887256622, 0.054424308240413666, 0.015949830412864685, 0.022055691108107567, 0.03967538848519325, -0.02222997508943081, 0.02002357691526413, 0.010489814914762974, -0.0034006827045232058, -0.045007262378931046, 0.06896471232175827, -0.022506393492221832, -0.0076484959572553635, -0.00809713825583458, 0.01390140876173973, -0.012337293475866318, -0.051884692162275314, 0.008107041008770466, 0.025104748085141182, -0.029880603775382042, 0.015883469954133034, 0.008798753842711449, 0.006725646089762449, 0.054244838654994965, -0.025546403601765633, -0.013371950946748257, 0.020630313083529472, -0.020916536450386047, -0.013261101208627224, 0.03136000782251358, 0.04039584472775459, -0.0073434170335531235, 0.00019442666962277144, 0.04151656851172447, 0.0029030004516243935, 0.034648604691028595, -0.02841070480644703, 0.024491796270012856, -0.025440147146582603, -0.020871683955192566, -0.007569091860204935, -0.031066354364156723, 0.009977052919566631, 0.040345851331949234, -0.021956421434879303, 0.06030335649847984, -0.04663129150867462, 0.0018128780648112297, -0.03722528740763664, -0.026794740930199623, -0.0003345753357280046, -0.03389439731836319, 0.03292383626103401, 0.032172467559576035, 0.019117314368486404, -0.005194957368075848, 0.013541914522647858, 0.01004188321530819, 0.035652197897434235, 0.019048437476158142, 0.014618314802646637, -0.0046189166605472565, -0.008434891700744629, -0.023562712594866753, -0.009703997522592545, -0.04722585156559944, 0.014282247982919216, 0.03793001174926758, 0.037774018943309784, 0.04653242975473404, -0.0028578394558280706, -0.043562501668930054, -0.00616021454334259, 0.030033092945814133, -0.10050617903470993, -0.010450596921145916, -0.05140730366110802, 0.008395601063966751, -0.008515484631061554, -0.009636604227125645 ]
<p>I have several markets across the US where a marketing program was launched, and I want to compare the mean weekly unit sales before and after the launch. I'm using the 10-weeks prior to launch as my baseline and the 10 weeks post-launch as my result. Now at the end I will use a paired t-test to compare the change relative to the control markets (not in the program).</p> <p>However my question is for the interim. Management wants to see updated results every week.</p> <ol> <li>Is it valid to recompute statistical significance each week while the program is still running?</li> <li>Which test is appropriate? The samples are linked so it should be a paired t-test, but that requires the same observations which I don't have until the end.</li> </ol>
74,131
[ -0.011403873562812805, 0.003373963525518775, -0.013665610924363136, 0.024223100394010544, 0.03980923816561699, 0.01582481525838375, 0.009145484305918217, 0.003522576531395316, -0.003884909674525261, 0.008670629933476448, 0.04036572203040123, 0.04568132013082504, 0.021867478266358376, 0.014867264777421951, -0.017513209953904152, -0.011010611429810524, -0.037219732999801636, -0.021940356120467186, -0.027071572840213776, 0.009900047443807125, 0.0021346097346395254, -0.008068570867180824, 0.00037506830994971097, -0.010517055168747902, -0.03929804265499115, 0.032107770442962646, 0.01112747099250555, -0.03296858072280884, 0.026912076398730278, 0.03544848412275314, -0.045068852603435516, -0.04886510595679283, 0.027048446238040924, -0.020279530435800552, 0.005595906171947718, -0.002838298212736845, -0.03035125322639942, -0.0024869751650840044, -0.01406442653387785, 0.022533131763339043, -0.030930571258068085, -0.00866739358752966, -0.01963256672024727, 0.06451199948787689, 0.02422376535832882, 0.013110922649502754, -0.024467390030622482, 0.0016519599594175816, 0.07096840441226959, -0.017451899126172066, 0.029074836522340775, -0.020637135952711105, -0.00273346365429461, -0.015049675479531288, -0.03875506669282913, -0.014079625718295574, 0.0336880162358284, 0.013038749806582928, 0.02118200622498989, -0.03987542912364006, 0.017783330753445625, -0.029290908947587013, -0.009172018617391586, -0.02361883409321308, -0.04459474980831146, 0.03865886852145195, 0.013953440822660923, 0.02676151879131794, 0.013464618474245071, -0.03296764940023422, 0.023235661908984184, 0.012025315314531326, 0.0174684040248394, -0.0031275551300495863, -0.005859638098627329, -0.043689798563718796, 0.03186391294002533, 0.02278072200715542, 0.06159675121307373, 0.05023010075092316, 0.019719945266842842, 0.008966250345110893, 0.03320708125829697, 0.03743826597929001, 0.05226674675941467, -0.014968772418797016, 0.05679750815033913, -0.008834652602672577, -0.004694754723459482, 0.06176077947020531, 0.021740181371569633, -0.008103991858661175, 0.04120897501707077, -0.011437151581048965, -0.02678769640624523, 0.015531656332314014, -0.01909835822880268, 0.03913160786032677, -0.013870094902813435, 0.040595892816782, -0.006598008330911398, -0.06328386068344116, 0.007841472513973713, 0.025688815861940384, -0.013238023966550827, -0.004867617040872574, -0.01857135444879532, 0.010546834208071232, -0.01825053058564663, -0.0028839106671512127, -0.030965058133006096, -0.0017770836129784584, -0.026629993692040443, -0.0014983535511419177, 0.01628585159778595, -0.01336338184773922, 0.003095229621976614, 0.008734067901968956, 0.05288627743721008, 0.060165613889694214, 0.06170901656150818, 0.0015535034472122788, -0.007678067311644554, -0.005385094787925482, -0.0215251874178648, 0.03401239216327667, 0.0009193801088258624, -0.06394127756357193, -0.020194126293063164, 0.03909246250987053, 0.019011884927749634, -0.015994606539607048, 0.028514759615063667, 0.003578750416636467, 0.004700212739408016, 0.021820249035954475, -0.05605357512831688, -0.05658561736345291, 0.028063368052244186, -0.032398488372564316, 0.02976405620574951, -0.06706031411886215, -0.004922899417579174, 0.01964505948126316, 0.012565713375806808, -0.0078324805945158, 0.05071581155061722, -0.018849054351449013, 0.031712260097265244, 0.013566670939326286, -0.00522609194740653, -0.04742204025387764, -0.043158043175935745, -0.04022270068526268, -0.011218643747270107, -0.06453695893287659, 0.0047830636613070965, 0.04162732884287834, -0.03891746327280998, -0.0017176521942019463, 0.03240952268242836, 0.0026038147043436766, -0.018403248861432076, -0.015128931030631065, 0.022705689072608948, 0.0052782101556658745, 0.025435587391257286, -0.007360484916716814, 0.015446631237864494, -0.00020697763829957694, 0.006322602741420269, 0.011949954554438591, 0.05627800151705742, 0.007419305853545666, 0.03011774644255638, -0.014675534330308437, -0.012566075660288334, -0.038453321903944016, 0.01404658704996109, 0.02265801467001438, -0.020397989079356194, -0.031277019530534744, -0.07848042249679565, -0.010643496178090572, 0.04071797803044319, 0.020375465974211693, -0.008692690171301365, 0.024767249822616577, 0.06064862012863159, -0.062078461050987244, -0.08297015726566315, -0.07741975784301758, 0.016918769106268883, -0.020841605961322784, -0.03811539337038994, -0.009550490416586399, -0.023672237992286682, 0.032323822379112244, -0.002766584511846304, -0.030862711369991302, 0.0053131901659071445, -0.011933444999158382, 0.055092718452215195, -0.057896099984645844, 0.014085342176258564, 0.033895816653966904, 0.036418117582798004, -0.015234233811497688, 0.04039710387587547, -0.048060040920972824, -0.05472198501229286, -0.02009163610637188, -0.01896485686302185, -0.010883365757763386, -0.013787953183054924, -0.04251695051789284, 0.02608288824558258, 0.016998806968331337, -0.04891547933220863, 0.05726057291030884, -0.044907983392477036, 0.030375253409147263, 0.07245054095983505, -0.01837829127907753, 0.04468169063329697, -0.0040976619347929955, 0.029901161789894104, 0.03456904739141464, 0.019281914457678795, -0.007730478420853615, -0.04564732685685158, -0.02162630297243595, 0.023035410791635513, 0.02343009226024151, 0.008201895281672478, 0.021254900842905045, 0.09422527998685837, -0.019386546686291695, 0.002679967088624835, 0.032797954976558685, -0.006914282217621803, -0.025444399565458298, 0.011205494403839111, 0.02599344216287136, 0.019124910235404968, 0.013841970823705196, 0.04240350052714348, -0.006358897779136896, -0.00047214218648150563, 0.042243994772434235, 0.036828529089689255, 0.014084841124713421, 0.027059905230998993, -0.010154771618545055, -0.04409920796751976, -0.053628113120794296, 0.06975261867046356, -0.04456248879432678, -0.002820187946781516, -0.02545906975865364, 0.030478380620479584, -0.007778682745993137, -0.0021745788399130106, -0.02867765910923481, -0.010592923499643803, -0.007932552136480808, -0.02228708565235138, -0.02136017568409443, 0.027131065726280212, -0.03174861893057823, -0.007885322906076908, -0.0424545556306839, -0.031252287328243256, -0.012765430845320225, 0.0005466386210173368, 0.034420568495988846, -0.02570956014096737, 0.030137695372104645, -0.02334628440439701, 0.03227902948856354, -0.0191651564091444, -0.0027434881776571274, 0.0315885916352272, -0.018878165632486343, -0.02609296888113022, 0.028195692226290703, 0.007005342748016119, -0.019822658970952034, 0.01977500133216381, -0.0010617005173116922, -0.009072805754840374, 0.06731100380420685, 0.01167679950594902, -0.021123815327882767, -0.03460267186164856, -0.03554300218820572, -0.025704653933644295, -0.020732196047902107, -0.022403312847018242, 0.05669296160340309, -0.00026530559989623725, -0.04646927863359451, 0.013039475306868553, -0.06308455765247345, 0.014609774574637413, -0.033097267150878906, 0.010408219881355762, -0.01596335880458355, 0.012945995666086674, -0.014479188248515129, 0.0051645576022565365, -0.018597062677145004, -0.002064640400931239, -0.08198539912700653, -0.0796392485499382, 0.004914421588182449, -0.024401212111115456, 0.06610392779111862, -0.03399209305644035, -0.023527707904577255, 0.10548950731754303, 0.04419344291090965, -0.0038192933425307274, -0.03601183369755745, 0.020695380866527557, -0.00015791393525432795, -0.03634827956557274, 0.024178769439458847, 0.004006350412964821, -0.006741384044289589, -0.017424030229449272, 0.0031847881618887186, 0.02280040644109249, 0.027896227315068245, 0.025408130139112473, -0.015461068600416183, 0.00390326464548707, 0.051116008311510086, 0.030970439314842224, -0.004664643667638302, -0.0024503341410309076, -0.0213321540504694, -0.02670672908425331, -0.03169842064380646, 0.03233936429023743, -0.0028479769825935364, -0.03618725389242172, 0.045745667070150375, -0.0009243882377631962, 0.006080458406358957, -0.0010077478364109993, 0.0394822359085083, 0.00012158089521108195, -0.026255900040268898, -0.01499722059816122, -0.02666008472442627, 0.0021267340052872896, -0.019407959654927254, -0.0331105962395668, 0.07669021934270859, 0.020143840461969376, -0.01964615099132061, -0.017218586057424545, -0.0068838512524962425, 0.00802445039153099, 0.041492972522974014, -0.07398340851068497, -0.04003399237990379, 0.013620688579976559, 0.05756151303648949, 0.0447804220020771, 0.011981350369751453, -0.06780163943767548, -0.03815600648522377, -0.06432539969682693, 0.011051321402192116, 0.00737833371385932, 0.02779773436486721, -0.004476782400161028, 0.037978604435920715, -0.004812801722437143, -0.016741018742322922, -0.014336337335407734, -0.013223936781287193, -0.05366223677992821, -0.002120025921612978, -0.0024230233393609524, -0.020105144008994102, 0.03946154937148094, 0.004911266267299652, -0.014499862678349018, 0.006263143848627806, -0.004632257856428623, -0.018113644793629646, 0.040947090834379196, -0.02344116009771824, 0.025285787880420685, -0.05004625767469406, -0.008547123521566391, -0.001143241417594254, -0.00911824218928814, 0.029947364702820778, -0.0019082225626334548, 0.06600385159254074, 0.027419563382864, -0.016895350068807602, 0.02455085515975952, -0.011647380888462067, 0.022198962047696114, 0.00337759917601943, 0.04786292836070061, 0.06724849343299866, 0.044667940586805344, -0.059744998812675476, 0.03413863107562065, 0.05766543373465538, 0.0419500470161438, 0.014413278549909592, 0.01643291302025318, -0.04955749586224556, -0.004681726917624474, -0.038053590804338455, 0.03237451985478401, 0.017154837027192116, 0.017791464924812317, -0.024037165567278862, 0.026962703093886375, 0.015706440433859825, -0.023368148133158684, 0.007922071032226086, 0.09024258702993393, 0.026633569970726967, 0.024418441578745842, -0.004626276902854443, -0.02283269353210926, -0.02564176358282566, -0.04332565888762474, 0.01887155883014202, 0.031188104301691055, 0.021733736619353294, 0.023968687281012535, 0.002053123665973544, 0.0031252107582986355, -0.042695626616477966, 0.010007440112531185, -0.0009718902874737978, 0.039646416902542114, 0.004938659258186817, -0.003965004347264767, 0.021924542263150215, 0.014381876215338707, -0.0007238632533699274, 0.0621335431933403, 0.02299194037914276, -0.06868286430835724, 0.02119210921227932, 0.04785168170928955, 0.060042690485715866, -0.03233354166150093, -0.021957334131002426, -0.01518942415714264, 0.02063838019967079, 0.017612863332033157, -0.03730121999979019, 0.013032414019107819, -0.01737826317548752, 0.0010250912746414542, -0.015560952946543694, -0.005751143209636211, -0.040156491100788116, 0.03494834899902344, -0.02689528837800026, 0.04204878956079483, -0.03460865095257759, -0.034123633056879044, -0.03617691993713379, 0.027228673920035362, 0.007633684668689966, 0.05792047083377838, -0.04948756843805313, -0.044301752001047134, 0.019130699336528778, -0.04257412254810333, -0.008981251157820225, -0.035482753068208694, -0.014476635493338108, 0.021431492641568184, 0.029167091473937035, 0.005022023804485798, 0.002900779480114579, -0.05849132314324379, 0.006659620441496372, -0.00613951263949275, -0.042788680642843246, -0.0029948747251182795, -0.023626722395420074, 0.046785928308963776, 0.05750974267721176, -0.0007885292288847268, 0.04013218358159065, 0.01414381805807352, 0.013979175128042698, 0.05993907153606415, -0.014153639785945415, 0.011685879901051521, -0.014325638301670551, 0.013536878861486912, -0.035913340747356415, 0.0012616747990250587, -0.03798114135861397, 0.05413605272769928, -0.0015778644010424614, 0.005934067536145449, -0.003663069335743785, -0.003144563641399145, 0.05469481274485588, 0.03744126483798027, -0.0023511757608503103, 0.0026580053381621838, 0.02304183691740036, -0.015964040532708168, -0.05809273198246956, -0.02481144294142723, -0.01760978437960148, -0.00687050074338913, 0.023419301956892014, 0.008793607354164124, -0.03139195963740349, 0.014479115605354309, -0.0496843196451664, -0.024848122149705887, -0.00426517752930522, -0.017208153381943703, 0.0008867633296176791, 0.006916141137480736, 0.015305744484066963, -0.01022026315331459, -0.04003995656967163, -0.016835708171129227, 0.0309220589697361, 0.015255894511938095, -0.0008697105222381651, -0.035263098776340485, 0.04658302664756775, -0.011664165183901787, -0.015874234959483147, -0.026983320713043213, -0.026253592222929, 0.04700490087270737, 0.014817946590483189, -0.02202289178967476, -0.020421262830495834, 0.01694626174867153, 0.0035086481366306543, 0.007154612336307764, -0.043661702424287796, 0.035623516887426376, -0.026278145611286163, -0.05749579519033432, 0.011247883550822735, 0.01407378725707531, 0.06629874557256699, 0.005575738847255707, 0.0075032529421150684, -0.010160857811570168, 0.024116341024637222, -0.018528200685977936, -0.010317755863070488, -0.0022317569237202406, -0.03508278355002403, -0.0006994607974775136, -0.07141336053609848, -0.015060761012136936, 0.04138065502047539, -0.026504099369049072, -0.026471182703971863, 0.03970200940966606, -0.02652168832719326, 0.009944760240614414, -0.05176617205142975, -0.0006542918854393065, -0.04260154440999031, 0.011438218876719475, -0.015094460919499397, 0.03345352038741112, 0.02214484103024006, -0.02251863293349743, -0.04099733754992485, 0.012163258157670498, -0.029779555276036263, 0.013715674169361591, 0.004925773944705725, 0.007392348721623421, -0.005188665818423033, -0.012620841152966022, -0.020076369866728783, 0.010479121468961239, 0.008326169103384018, -0.0014762781793251634, -0.0056236921809613705, 0.0005714910221286118, -0.04812448471784592, -0.010699844919145107, -0.007108884863555431, -0.005750356707721949, 0.04522563889622688, 0.012292693369090557, 0.04783960431814194, 0.057360921055078506, 0.03098297119140625, 0.03028690069913864, -0.04472687467932701, -0.0004918603226542473, -0.027909522876143456, 0.016547931358218193, 0.036973416805267334, -0.003262670710682869, -0.012040170840919018, 0.047287698835134506, 0.044016677886247635, 0.02028515562415123, 0.02667495608329773, 0.018464064225554466, 0.0012185974046587944, 0.014506700448691845, -0.03950338810682297, -0.05761559307575226, 0.00863612163811922, -0.06258925050497055, 0.02534269168972969, -0.06821531057357788, 0.006556014996021986, 0.018093224614858627, 0.0483894944190979, 0.00815178919583559, -0.050070639699697495, -0.02069772034883499, -0.07310657203197479, -0.004344923421740532, -0.002879593288525939, -0.014589989557862282, 0.02509569376707077, 0.008555998094379902, 0.046505145728588104, -0.0011144273448735476, 0.04151666909456253, -0.029336346313357353, -0.009442000649869442, -0.05657650902867317, 0.02725730463862419, -0.007820126600563526, 0.01911102794110775, -0.05430879816412926, -0.024095721542835236, -0.002410716377198696, -0.045218877494335175, 0.029678011313080788, 0.007293278817087412, 0.024955319240689278, 0.004723134450614452, 0.10275058448314667, 0.009232889860868454, 0.0273283701390028, -0.00011208884825464338, 0.013606464490294456, 0.1427791267633438, 0.040085338056087494, 0.04121197387576103, -0.034313373267650604, 0.028772110119462013, 0.01723826676607132, 0.023938629776239395, 0.01118975505232811, 0.014492394402623177, -0.011529182083904743, -0.032404426485300064, 0.07683563232421875, 0.03996353596448898, -0.005814787000417709, -0.015689266845583916, 0.035022836178541183, -0.0244431272149086, -0.03649372234940529, -0.0029804909136146307, -0.014501628465950489, -0.004694750066846609, -0.022831991314888, -0.02899758890271187, 0.02357763610780239, 0.01830293983221054, -0.01650644652545452, 0.015862569212913513, 0.00488198921084404, -0.03360995650291443, 0.009643047116696835, -0.003012417582795024, 0.017952898517251015, -0.012380783446133137, 0.04269365221261978, -0.036876656115055084, -0.031419217586517334, 0.012644081376492977, -0.042695146054029465, 0.035845451056957245, 0.059473916888237, 0.007542391307651997, 0.008056266233325005, -0.01198059692978859, 0.009874841198325157, -0.08135074377059937, 0.010187570936977863, -0.034560151398181915, 0.07266228646039963, -0.025571925565600395, -0.03264934569597244, -0.02754897251725197, 0.012635324150323868, 0.018051406368613243, -0.042900778353214264, -0.02175210416316986, 0.05358994007110596, -0.00044968645670451224, -0.002846941351890564, 0.034042611718177795, -0.04606269299983978, -0.0031918943859636784, 0.013803505338728428, 0.03376493602991104, 0.0642237439751625, 0.009393829852342606, -0.018026985228061676, -0.03504420816898346, 0.05660035461187363, 0.013070656917989254, -0.01275202352553606, 0.01853928156197071, 0.012297535315155983, -0.025122875347733498, 0.010889358818531036, 0.006821847520768642, 0.026831096038222313, -0.0002600999432615936, 0.01645602472126484, 0.004350272007286549, -0.010903279297053814, -0.008554741740226746, 0.008556452579796314, -0.005167828407138586, 0.013645314611494541, -0.016091272234916687, -0.02400706522166729, 0.023441798985004425, 0.0153232142329216, 0.024402637034654617, 0.02142634429037571, 0.021657589823007584, 0.06946070492267609, 0.005281164776533842, -0.053194768726825714, -0.014347181655466557, -0.0012761641992256045, -0.038824714720249176, -0.04011097922921181, -0.055292174220085144, 0.03565080836415291, 0.05154230818152428, -0.0010005634976550937, -0.016865266487002373, -0.010255148634314537, -0.0018248106352984905, 0.02673967555165291, -0.023794112727046013, -0.04555782303214073, -0.01752793788909912, 0.01664644666016102, -0.007937902584671974, -0.02554665505886078, -0.002698317402973771, -0.011273501440882683, 0.013063255697488785, -0.003232414834201336, -0.03547346591949463, -0.012029902078211308, 0.02184382639825344, -0.0014296105364337564, 0.055793505162000656, -0.02497163973748684, -0.007252010051161051, -0.05917024239897728, -0.03771260753273964, 0.009291688911616802, 0.024958156049251556, -0.013367942534387112, 0.04554692283272743, -0.04093370959162712, 0.015797235071659088, 0.06775851547718048, 0.007977202534675598, 0.02101501077413559, -0.0334857776761055, -0.014160914346575737, -0.005151194520294666, 0.025836704298853874, 0.023621035739779472, -0.03832169622182846, 0.04137462377548218, -0.01092314999550581, -0.015160145238041878, 0.0038456523325294256, 0.01632692664861679, 0.04972048103809357, 0.01913689635694027, 0.0063824402168393135, -0.01648661307990551, 0.003973325248807669, -0.03636551275849342, -0.030496522784233093, -0.011886203661561012, 0.013337792828679085, 0.059096984565258026, 0.0010674844961613417, -0.004995879717171192, 0.03463474288582802, 0.018089408054947853, 0.00290719885379076, 0.059910647571086884, 0.007380913011729717, 0.02195190079510212, -0.022543059661984444, 0.00744493817910552, -0.015384412370622158, 0.01341774221509695, -0.053745683282613754, 0.017150208353996277, 0.058369673788547516, 0.012100739404559135, 0.03441694751381874, -0.014717700891196728, -0.010234472341835499, -0.09996678680181503, -0.05458483844995499, -0.015848509967327118, -0.005477241240441799, 0.013005360029637814, -0.03993555158376694, 0.008778913877904415, 0.003863084129989147, -0.046459004282951355, 0.04116494581103325, -0.017181437462568283, -0.02564489282667637, -0.018922267481684685, 0.032846421003341675, 0.008383112028241158, -0.013738189823925495, -0.023785725235939026, 0.028284279629588127, 0.016639070585370064, 0.020666763186454773, 0.013329091481864452, -0.009889143519103527, -0.027300594374537468, -0.004602100700139999, 0.02608436904847622, -0.034787341952323914, 0.040670040994882584, -0.04314105957746506, -0.02038479410111904, 0.03568997606635094, -0.03036574274301529, 0.03789237141609192, -0.017663544043898582, -0.00031225671409629285, 0.0010562967509031296, 0.061185915023088455, 0.04945718124508858, -0.00019060377962887287, 0.017888931557536125, -0.021856365725398064, -0.0015282529639080167, 0.03864481672644615, 0.006160680204629898, 0.018253248184919357, 0.03976853936910629, 0.015338423661887646, 0.011983939446508884, -0.00831927265971899, -0.032274279743433, -0.008527116850018501, 0.015623628161847591, 0.018067143857479095, 0.015681885182857513, 0.010064706206321716, -0.015230793505907059, -0.037722863256931305, -0.005460734013468027, 0.01170919556170702, 0.005312058143317699, -0.06057797372341156, 0.0011102684075012803, -0.019602959975600243, -0.018366657197475433, 0.016362830996513367, -0.01688079908490181, -0.005916243884712458, -0.06508252769708633, -0.017907090485095978, -0.02292790822684765, 0.027254728600382805, -0.035254817456007004, 0.008017389103770256, -0.013532144017517567, 0.04275798052549362, -0.029201075434684753, 0.01852959766983986, 0.02855391800403595, -0.007489134557545185, 0.00874059833586216, -0.07194426655769348, 0.07555202394723892, 0.03019375540316105, -0.020654333755373955, -0.02631562389433384, -0.02476176992058754, -0.036256808787584305, 0.02130669541656971, 0.06597436219453812, 0.04184944927692413, 0.026723701506853104, -0.0040059443563222885, 0.02936970628798008, 0.0007097088964655995, -0.06727085262537003, 0.09209533035755157, -0.024250922724604607, -0.013481620699167252, -0.0023594542872160673, -0.02492332272231579, 0.023583125323057175, -0.001249221502803266, 0.007474192418158054, 0.005776382517069578, 0.02377176284790039, 0.0077276830561459064, -0.0038596265949308872, 0.03827514499425888, 0.01410236582159996, -0.01976264826953411, 0.019241813570261, 0.03208804875612259, 0.01600199192762375, 0.024708548560738564, -0.008269073441624641, -0.04497195780277252, 0.048750706017017365, -0.04350966960191727, -0.017754599452018738, 0.0072830538265407085, 0.0008748332620598376, -0.02701493166387081, -0.03689569979906082, -0.021009955555200577, 0.021173831075429916, -0.018128162249922752, 0.054438769817352295, 0.029753530398011208, 0.015335670672357082, 0.007728711236268282, -0.008634248748421669, 0.029138101264834404, 0.01572229340672493, -0.002987220883369446, -0.005465440917760134, -0.013761216774582863, 0.006484701298177242, 0.011948094703257084, 0.004589706659317017, 0.034110937267541885, -0.03218245506286621, 0.0032616215758025646, -0.015476967208087444, 0.020990123972296715, -0.011709701269865036, -0.04137510061264038, 0.035984281450510025, -0.011039773002266884, -0.013335074298083782, 0.021824968978762627, -0.01097929012030363, 0.03820495307445526, -0.0361197404563427, 0.013577825389802456, -0.05315820500254631, -0.007599450647830963, -0.029711274430155754, 0.03628990426659584, 0.05129435285925865, 0.0016464394284412265, 0.004756314214318991, 0.038536038249731064, 0.012960967607796192, 0.01565006747841835, -0.011816231533885002, 0.008173221722245216, 0.03424559533596039, -0.04533470422029495, 0.029469868168234825, -0.03401387110352516, -0.03727471083402634, -0.0671820193529129, -0.03983264043927193, 0.026820877566933632, 0.02191326580941677, -0.011436746455729008, -0.011466173455119133, -0.03902079910039902, -0.0022571405861526728, 0.03334483504295349, -0.05220169946551323, -0.04851307347416878, -0.08062095195055008, -0.014600344002246857, 0.004156268201768398, -0.009985026903450489 ]
<p>Its been a while since I did any serious statistics. I have been reading about contingency tables recently and it seems like they may offer a solution to my problem. There are people on here that know more about statistics than what I can ever expect to know, so rather than trying to "discover" things by myself, (and wasting time in the process), I decided to come here first, explain what I'm trying to do and ask the gurus here first, if it makes any sense, and second, if there is a better (and probably more simple/robust) way of achieving what I'm trying to do (highly likely I suspect).</p> <p>Here is an overview of what I am trying to model:</p> <p>I have a process which at any time, can be in one of N states. I have identified 4 other 'factors' that I believe are predictors of the state in which the system will be. The 'factors' are a mixture of categorical and real variables.</p> <p>I am thinking of creating a multidimensional contingency table like this:</p> <pre><code>Factor1, # Dimension 1 Factor2, # Dimension 2 ... Factor4, State1 | State2 | State3 | ... | StateN | </code></pre> <p>where the value in a cell is the count of the number of times that the system has been in that state given the 'levels' of the four factors.</p> <p>I am hoping to use this table then to build a probabilistic model (maybe using a suitable logistic function?) to be able to answer questions of the form:</p> <p>What is the probability of the system changing from state <em>i</em> to state <em>j</em>, given Factor1, .. Factor4 are at a certain specified level?</p> <p>Am I able to use a contingency table to do this?</p> <p>Last but not the least, I don't know if contingency tables are part of non parametric statistics - but I hope there are no strong assumptions of normality of the variables etc. If there are any strong assumptions required for the use of a contingency table, I will be grateful if someone could alert me of the fact, and hopefully suggest another method that can allow me to model the probabilities in the manner I described above.</p> <p>PS: If I have fudged up any of the terms in my question, please advise so I can edit my question to make it more clear. I know that the use of 'factors' and 'levels' in my question may be a tad confusing, but I could not think of any better labels.</p>
36,803
[ -0.02264587953686714, -0.01426953636109829, -0.03305623680353165, -0.008414052426815033, 0.06616812944412231, -0.02841467596590519, -0.00513044698163867, -0.006752407643944025, 0.0348333865404129, -0.00841085147112608, 0.016653312370181084, 0.027375318109989166, 0.03314675763249397, 0.018739696592092514, -0.008611760102212429, -0.012556828558444977, 0.03875591978430748, -0.003138879081234336, -0.05237225815653801, 0.01724574901163578, 0.02477819100022316, -0.000276723294518888, -0.013915986754000187, -0.022578487172722816, -0.009672862477600574, 0.06144139915704727, 0.02453308179974556, -0.030590195208787918, 0.004242075607180595, 0.06516861170530319, -0.02551865205168724, -0.010511832311749458, -0.009328905493021011, 0.02330360934138298, 0.004562155809253454, -0.008229531347751617, -0.030597727745771408, -0.0028322585858404636, -0.012453917413949966, 0.04262648522853851, -0.03491497412323952, 0.013060851953923702, -0.033082637935876846, 0.02757994458079338, -0.00023531710030511022, 0.02846059389412403, -0.0017399643547832966, 0.014212926849722862, 0.011694775894284248, -0.061706773936748505, 0.08369304984807968, -0.008576039224863052, 0.029360245913267136, 0.005849533248692751, -0.016651367768645287, -0.010254258289933205, 0.056425195187330246, 0.07249568402767181, 0.04573338106274605, -0.029126066714525223, -0.03167696297168732, -0.025650247931480408, -0.009315392933785915, -0.07640615850687027, -0.034211285412311554, 0.009789488278329372, -0.003615757916122675, -0.03306984901428223, 0.04754488542675972, -0.03215537220239639, 0.005297540687024593, -0.018929844722151756, 0.051502715796232224, -0.025120848789811134, 0.004875440150499344, -0.021319173276424408, 0.044878702610731125, -0.0070113311521708965, -0.00885073933750391, 0.057076118886470795, 0.000011820873623946682, 0.003941497299820185, -0.010374628007411957, 0.006086424924433231, 0.017923502251505852, -0.02101670578122139, 0.05619792267680168, -0.0220077782869339, 0.012046588584780693, 0.04920077323913574, -0.046629052609205246, -0.00424312986433506, 0.03667110204696655, 0.023068945854902267, -0.06234129145741463, 0.0001221568527398631, -0.032602615654468536, 0.04230543226003647, 0.019259141758084297, 0.0028676562942564487, 0.010159761644899845, -0.04718231409788132, 0.011872968636453152, 0.051461223512887955, -0.05071864649653435, -0.0103732505813241, 0.004098007921129465, -0.024374838918447495, -0.0006278149667195976, -0.0008397072087973356, -0.023350121453404427, 0.017254803329706192, 0.05345369502902031, -0.04983395338058472, -0.007080302573740482, -0.04354116693139076, -0.005321891978383064, -0.03194139525294304, 0.037526462227106094, 0.06943217664957047, 0.0072851101867854595, -0.07009583711624146, 0.009170440025627613, -0.011507969349622726, -0.038307320326566696, 0.009831002913415432, -0.003509522881358862, -0.00652665551751852, -0.009749655611813068, 0.036853473633527756, -0.011345245875418186, -0.019314004108309746, 0.03749878332018852, -0.011002743616700172, 0.0359930619597435, 0.027229296043515205, -0.08847058564424515, -0.056722622364759445, 0.04947187379002571, -0.04647267237305641, -0.00790505949407816, -0.04859607294201851, 0.008794723078608513, 0.026413757354021072, 0.03280653432011604, -0.02637149952352047, 0.023949699476361275, 0.03551558405160904, 0.023433707654476166, 0.04777822643518448, -0.04085846617817879, -0.0032227078918367624, -0.04811742901802063, -0.035241831094026566, -0.00889238528907299, -0.055462054908275604, 0.05275914818048477, -0.003907754085958004, -0.008007110096514225, 0.009951774962246418, 0.018938153982162476, 0.009123746305704117, -0.030373964458703995, 0.01610632799565792, 0.01902162842452526, -0.015169916674494743, 0.06379744410514832, -0.03631359711289406, 0.02785443142056465, 0.015019361861050129, -0.0009824984008446336, 0.02318655513226986, 0.009609365835785866, 0.028350036591291428, 0.029809314757585526, 0.016702087596058846, -0.036179058253765106, -0.017173513770103455, -0.024582527577877045, -0.041910164058208466, -0.01364364568144083, -0.034913379698991776, -0.019894607365131378, -0.0029023687820881605, 0.025433924049139023, 0.006998344790190458, 0.012617845088243484, -0.009460970759391785, 0.013687348924577236, -0.026367682963609695, -0.033251870423555374, -0.031196070834994316, 0.019214842468500137, -0.022127049043774605, -0.021513409912586212, 0.021327292546629906, -0.01228590589016676, 0.026627788320183754, -0.0021678837947547436, -0.01625874452292919, -0.0694747120141983, -0.009403561241924763, 0.023561956360936165, -0.07411837577819824, 0.0007999173831194639, 0.048035476356744766, 0.026298733428120613, -0.006364642642438412, 0.0759582445025444, -0.041663844138383865, -0.0487450435757637, -0.024115195497870445, -0.02299274504184723, 0.018434159457683563, -0.03599505499005318, -0.031824253499507904, 0.005748420022428036, -0.003110704245045781, -0.04975282400846481, 0.001589977997355163, -0.07226312160491943, 0.05006280913949013, 0.059986554086208344, -0.004132295958697796, 0.007169383578002453, -0.017934635281562805, -0.0006089278031140566, 0.010738357901573181, -0.0017298071179538965, -0.007378949783742428, -0.06655645370483398, -0.02915896847844124, 0.004581944085657597, 0.01854490488767624, -0.014720427803695202, 0.047939930111169815, 0.031503450125455856, 0.020277587696909904, 0.009940600953996181, 0.010496485978364944, 0.006548142991960049, -0.005560343153774738, 0.006440532859414816, 0.011038161814212799, 0.01079933624714613, 0.020856725051999092, 0.013963679783046246, 0.03111150674521923, 0.005975950043648481, -0.013165798038244247, -0.03775109723210335, 0.016495974734425545, -0.006663665175437927, 0.017582008615136147, -0.05178248509764671, -0.03326258808374405, 0.07546942681074142, -0.0013325209729373455, 0.012064555659890175, 0.033719923347234726, 0.019222693517804146, 0.004457460716366768, 0.02075505070388317, -0.030288174748420715, -0.01118343323469162, 0.06042059138417244, -0.04149981215596199, -0.012137633748352528, 0.021498749032616615, -0.0317617692053318, 0.05176609009504318, 0.0026176059618592262, -0.030306218191981316, -0.04026130586862564, -0.004353098571300507, 0.007569523062556982, -0.0010010076221078634, 0.020952275022864342, 0.0020191355142742395, 0.004809176549315453, 0.020244082435965538, -0.00757399620488286, 0.007721837610006332, 0.022805796936154366, -0.05106152594089508, -0.03002667799592018, -0.005760592874139547, -0.025970472022891045, 0.053487297147512436, -0.024356817826628685, -0.06575034558773041, 0.03840562328696251, -0.013482101261615753, -0.03528943285346031, -0.008807303383946419, -0.05188586562871933, 0.007491083350032568, -0.04922593757510185, -0.005639175418764353, 0.032092221081256866, -0.014207866974174976, -0.04880613088607788, -0.009760006330907345, -0.06590162217617035, -0.02419217862188816, -0.04313470050692558, 0.0030135216657072306, -0.01673429273068905, 0.008041765540838242, -0.020184798166155815, 0.011093555018305779, -0.01660601794719696, 0.025454120710492134, -0.0633063018321991, -0.039913494139909744, -0.009671597741544247, 0.002154660876840353, 0.07979924231767654, 0.003461834043264389, -0.020520925521850586, 0.05480615794658661, 0.029705388471484184, -0.024580612778663635, -0.03342076763510704, -0.020412208512425423, -0.06042398512363434, -0.028709350153803825, 0.0256879273802042, 0.02468668296933174, -0.003405389143154025, -0.020143214613199234, -0.004031773190945387, 0.0155141931027174, 0.043662190437316895, 0.0052258893847465515, 0.012061754241585732, 0.044493794441223145, 0.034335214644670486, -0.01636536419391632, 0.046681515872478485, 0.010553142055869102, 0.010234348475933075, 0.03594536706805229, -0.021645549684762955, 0.014932935126125813, -0.0079853106290102, -0.04513911157846451, 0.014120848849415779, -0.021192263811826706, 0.005857798736542463, -0.04038219526410103, 0.010846458375453949, 0.012371277436614037, -0.054001789540052414, 0.026735685765743256, 0.039209168404340744, 0.04065597802400589, 0.002414408605545759, 0.011557950638234615, 0.04342659190297127, 0.023580260574817657, -0.01744375377893448, 0.003916777670383453, 0.007631945423781872, -0.008813196793198586, 0.006432166323065758, -0.05876017361879349, -0.02097126469016075, 0.05808228254318237, 0.0015898261917755008, 0.042627543210983276, -0.012169119901955128, -0.019694041460752487, -0.02129913866519928, -0.05791958048939705, -0.0018229412380605936, -0.024928748607635498, 0.05901651084423065, 0.006212485022842884, 0.03796287626028061, -0.016792966052889824, -0.015225578099489212, -0.0022852597758173943, -0.005100579932332039, -0.0695132464170456, 0.0015148522797971964, 0.0006358782993629575, 0.039401825517416, 0.01786797307431698, -0.03480999544262886, 0.051669202744960785, -0.019995620474219322, -0.011878768913447857, 0.011155864223837852, 0.00972734298557043, -0.04035591334104538, 0.0017642610473558307, -0.018499594181776047, -0.004885036498308182, -0.044916555285453796, -0.014761311933398247, 0.0429040752351284, 0.039588890969753265, 0.03612430393695831, 0.04606057330965996, -0.015126705169677734, 0.016880296170711517, -0.012960735708475113, -0.024815145879983902, 0.0680275708436966, 0.00805688463151455, 0.0025596441701054573, 0.009721487760543823, -0.027636997401714325, 0.02046298049390316, -0.021787069737911224, 0.02773689106106758, 0.051750872284173965, 0.024727609008550644, -0.0029632647056132555, -0.012272738851606846, -0.032493483275175095, 0.006143223028630018, 0.012496217153966427, -0.009738816879689693, 0.020376000553369522, 0.01734909601509571, 0.04456964135169983, -0.051184359937906265, 0.028672175481915474, 0.06598411500453949, 0.02014024555683136, -0.013944088481366634, -0.02358429506421089, -0.001338586094789207, 0.0055977958254516125, 0.02411004714667797, 0.02785799466073513, 0.014928029850125313, 0.003987798932939768, 0.007397440727800131, 0.016922099515795708, -0.0019609553273767233, -0.042650654911994934, 0.013515367172658443, -0.0025563191156834364, 0.03517187759280205, 0.02090352773666382, -0.028441419824957848, 0.0120652224868536, 0.010570033453404903, 0.013822251930832863, 0.010404071770608425, 0.017414920032024384, -0.11076642572879791, -0.02404557727277279, 0.05179901421070099, 0.04004206135869026, -0.04850358888506889, -0.006264257710427046, -0.016488729044795036, -0.04480753093957901, -0.0002723583020269871, -0.02131224423646927, 0.030050378292798996, -0.018837902694940567, -0.003620854578912258, -0.015692153945565224, -0.07230235636234283, -0.00835894513875246, 0.014195396564900875, -0.026957958936691284, 0.04831628128886223, 0.005421468056738377, -0.01852651685476303, -0.03655621036887169, -0.0012567904777824879, 0.024660110473632812, 0.059305258095264435, -0.04545288532972336, -0.04469373822212219, 0.006938254460692406, -0.0016992015298455954, -0.02283533290028572, -0.0475577786564827, 0.01552705466747284, 0.01799830049276352, 0.004278411157429218, 0.03174801543354988, -0.0034578389022499323, -0.058862458914518356, -0.032382797449827194, -0.033739328384399414, -0.00010387379006715491, 0.008826278150081635, -0.014241604134440422, 0.06589072197675705, 0.007719806861132383, -0.03697996586561203, 0.011185881681740284, 0.0011756905587390065, -0.008244756609201431, 0.02887832187116146, -0.03166688606142998, 0.03438355401158333, -0.007770572789013386, -0.006042148917913437, -0.027253946289420128, 0.016024241223931313, -0.005599589087069035, 0.03130754828453064, -0.01232520118355751, 0.04146638140082359, -0.01986026205122471, -0.005397437140345573, 0.01745479181408882, 0.01849081553518772, -0.003127345349639654, -0.022699857130646706, 0.027813514694571495, 0.001987895229831338, 0.001487397006712854, -0.030293580144643784, 0.008470511995255947, -0.03916652873158455, 0.025845516473054886, 0.0012368845054879785, -0.027363644912838936, -0.009435029700398445, -0.06095931679010391, -0.04035992920398712, 0.014849495142698288, -0.028224119916558266, 0.035184405744075775, -0.02231018990278244, 0.03623685985803604, 0.02031388320028782, -0.03816100209951401, -0.02555517666041851, 0.052209556102752686, 0.014576232992112637, 0.04717276617884636, -0.005154305137693882, 0.01769530028104782, -0.060329314321279526, 0.002503297058865428, -0.060670170933008194, -0.0589875653386116, 0.06729317456483841, -0.002661899896338582, -0.052942294627428055, -0.060259927064180374, 0.0011400275398045778, -0.030281348153948784, -0.016522178426384926, -0.024594690650701523, 0.03240014985203743, -0.03947433456778526, 0.02435280941426754, 0.04527977854013443, 0.029334302991628647, 0.06690573692321777, 0.012373439967632294, -0.016700422391295433, -0.012369702570140362, 0.011186597868800163, -0.01047431118786335, -0.03253886476159096, -0.04044352099299431, -0.025203363969922066, -0.0033951548393815756, 0.012699712067842484, -0.0053774332627654076, 0.03786357119679451, -0.04729088395833969, -0.012144957669079304, -0.008111856877803802, -0.013914489187300205, 0.006720067001879215, -0.06830563396215439, -0.007595598232001066, 0.005279988050460815, -0.009907389059662819, 0.001106603886000812, 0.016186170279979706, -0.012239884585142136, -0.0011389103019610047, 0.009018585085868835, -0.026875287294387817, 0.0004352680698502809, 0.020752590149641037, 0.03628265857696533, 0.02402246557176113, -0.007059518247842789, -0.01347749587148428, 0.017904777079820633, 0.04838543385267258, 0.010238699615001678, -0.011690841987729073, 0.03335345536470413, 0.004199814051389694, -0.007861892692744732, -0.061773061752319336, -0.05341656506061554, -0.012424055486917496, 0.03846173360943794, 0.020278850570321083, 0.013784391805529594, 0.029709376394748688, -0.003995022736489773, 0.03244632109999657, -0.022441597655415535, -0.007885538041591644, 0.037303801625967026, 0.04494406282901764, 0.053823381662368774, 0.010308606550097466, 0.0024189921095967293, 0.025622805580496788, 0.0019059969345107675, -0.005395634099841118, 0.08534915000200272, 0.03957771509885788, -0.0114855682477355, 0.04712926223874092, -0.04351828992366791, -0.02683432400226593, 0.0340898334980011, -0.059941381216049194, 0.010717560537159443, -0.04814921319484711, -0.01302422396838665, 0.03061296045780182, 0.05446860194206238, -0.013206827454268932, -0.07736518234014511, -0.038745615631341934, -0.050327226519584656, 0.0013737825211137533, 0.024404708296060562, 0.003730365075170994, 0.049149416387081146, 0.004696131683886051, 0.03745066002011299, -0.0022291268687695265, -0.0004842585767619312, -0.01235057320445776, -0.051228512078523636, -0.027055490761995316, 0.01098894514143467, -0.03966500982642174, 0.035910602658987045, -0.00029678468126803637, -0.005891964305192232, -0.024925030767917633, -0.03106335550546646, -0.00431488361209631, 0.011338640004396439, 0.06286843866109848, -0.002286796225234866, 0.07107360661029816, -0.0003320409741718322, 0.014774279668927193, -0.013939649797976017, 0.032806120812892914, 0.12938588857650757, 0.09562721103429794, 0.02580646611750126, -0.045202553272247314, 0.005423000548034906, 0.023720361292362213, 0.03192118555307388, -0.007173573598265648, 0.0002157586277462542, 0.010670661926269531, -0.020405134186148643, 0.02614346146583557, 0.027858849614858627, 0.00603137630969286, 0.016955656930804253, 0.051678888499736786, -0.019700728356838226, -0.02411276288330555, -0.016704965382814407, 0.011844834312796593, -0.022988902404904366, -0.013436895795166492, -0.01650022156536579, 0.007188510615378618, 0.0014327408280223608, -0.010729367844760418, -0.028765033930540085, 0.02507668361067772, -0.021651465445756912, -0.0008058606763370335, -0.02506081573665142, 0.012076464481651783, 0.03027595952153206, 0.007036078721284866, -0.00896806176751852, -0.00589043227955699, -0.006382633466273546, -0.04481598362326622, 0.010806094855070114, 0.06546954810619354, -0.03156580775976181, -0.008399165235459805, -0.008449084125459194, -0.0030255476012825966, -0.04610003903508186, -0.02795814722776413, -0.05460118129849434, 0.02437855303287506, -0.007216794416308403, -0.013324919156730175, -0.006323660723865032, 0.028854185715317726, -0.0011473512277007103, 0.0016484016086906195, -0.030812108889222145, 0.0029804666992276907, 0.06616652756929398, -0.046817049384117126, -0.0013489298289641738, 0.0058716279454529285, -0.007618154864758253, 0.03300539404153824, 0.018342426046729088, 0.015671107918024063, -0.0011212396202608943, -0.029479732736945152, -0.041639961302280426, 0.06678779423236847, 0.03323044255375862, 0.03309009224176407, 0.00005723499634768814, -0.011931939981877804, -0.037486180663108826, -0.012295634485781193, 0.02693381905555725, 0.031680405139923096, 0.031671538949012756, 0.030147232115268707, -0.03949770703911781, 0.014535784721374512, -0.009860849007964134, 0.0000669141227263026, -0.006407739594578743, 0.010744787752628326, -0.037688832730054855, 0.008914245292544365, -0.0007201308035291731, 0.042459577322006226, -0.008058903738856316, 0.038936953991651535, 0.01311713270843029, 0.039215583354234695, 0.03446289896965027, -0.07897432893514633, 0.003809029469266534, -0.011035074479877949, -0.0192254651337862, -0.005425594747066498, -0.02300291508436203, 0.06946873664855957, 0.011517304927110672, -0.025790058076381683, 0.011622785590589046, 0.050714194774627686, 0.0006040956941433251, 0.01397865079343319, 0.012202012352645397, -0.05816492810845375, -0.00864009466022253, -0.022700730711221695, 0.014662891626358032, 0.00986847747117281, -0.008161875419318676, -0.014907021075487137, -0.01892794668674469, -0.025669623166322708, -0.00442225206643343, 0.00003129832839476876, 0.013990730047225952, -0.01606769859790802, 0.013415065594017506, -0.0039015018846839666, -0.026226818561553955, 0.005745887290686369, 0.0006832069484516978, 0.016342228278517723, 0.006599126383662224, -0.04766714572906494, 0.020741047337651253, -0.005980345886200666, 0.004332640673965216, 0.03392532840371132, 0.03498687222599983, 0.022230353206396103, -0.040928926318883896, 0.018864966928958893, 0.00943667907267809, 0.009693947620689869, -0.00681961327791214, -0.04187983646988869, -0.0020933442283421755, -0.03293958678841591, -0.010831537656486034, 0.044522974640131, -0.0023443279787898064, 0.0580710768699646, 0.04183359071612358, 0.03123209998011589, 0.013574046082794666, 0.014942563138902187, -0.029358403757214546, 0.0016727610491216183, -0.02085256204009056, 0.03819950670003891, -0.016194427385926247, 0.01923386938869953, -0.0025903822388499975, 0.05104174464941025, -0.0014784265076741576, 0.0005234188865870237, 0.059753015637397766, 0.020228514447808266, 0.01854204200208187, 0.0032425052486360073, -0.012396103702485561, 0.02289920300245285, 0.01052429061383009, -0.006360669620335102, 0.05941111966967583, 0.04417793080210686, 0.0029416894540190697, 0.016879303380846977, 0.010526590049266815, 0.03507164493203163, -0.08243279159069061, -0.05148482695221901, 0.023543454706668854, 0.029930753633379936, 0.04095027595758438, -0.026105467230081558, 0.006550921592861414, 0.025080278515815735, -0.051044005900621414, 0.007137153297662735, 0.03475655987858772, 0.015296729281544685, -0.021229123696684837, -0.007639644667506218, -0.019291525706648827, 0.036236029118299484, 0.005194549914449453, 0.019299110397696495, 0.029153045266866684, 0.04274411126971245, 0.007905881851911545, -0.03051101230084896, 0.00017755967564880848, 0.006583073642104864, 0.01830066554248333, -0.04331620782613754, 0.015346825122833252, -0.046544190496206284, -0.015900513157248497, 0.021441901102662086, -0.018173275515437126, 0.022679001092910767, 0.006974655203521252, 0.030750783160328865, 0.025662535801529884, 0.07183977961540222, 0.027854079380631447, -0.020821241661906242, 0.022945115342736244, -0.009709009900689125, 0.009739368222653866, 0.01665511168539524, -0.0521307997405529, 0.028464363887906075, 0.06791277974843979, -0.021517155691981316, -0.018694322556257248, -0.01646529510617256, -0.02730695903301239, 0.00754212960600853, 0.01123823318630457, -0.0530378483235836, -0.00930111389607191, -0.025532713159918785, -0.013471161015331745, -0.040528688579797745, 0.027126222848892212, 0.02803933434188366, 0.016794921830296516, -0.005303964950144291, 0.027113348245620728, -0.004546586889773607, -0.02769218198955059, 0.02882777526974678, 0.00004534743493422866, -0.01850954070687294, -0.053621210157871246, -0.013515994884073734, -0.03898228332400322, 0.003434808226302266, -0.02537648379802704, -0.01931685209274292, -0.05434519425034523, 0.019883036613464355, -0.01537334080785513, -0.000716590671800077, 0.0650692880153656, -0.016857851296663284, 0.016030913218855858, -0.08000216633081436, 0.05397596210241318, 0.036889463663101196, -0.03600352630019188, -0.03666181117296219, 0.0037661215756088495, -0.046477362513542175, 0.0382244698703289, 0.07103855162858963, 0.012115956284105778, 0.0020795546006411314, -0.019209450110793114, 0.05935113504528999, 0.018869994208216667, -0.04196067526936531, 0.04106661304831505, -0.03621244430541992, -0.015721969306468964, -0.035926055163145065, 0.00551237678155303, 0.033457837998867035, -0.03547317907214165, 0.036939818412065506, -0.029377885162830353, -0.007257310673594475, 0.000965719751548022, -0.024141468107700348, 0.03895934671163559, -0.025912553071975708, -0.041083116084337234, 0.019705604761838913, 0.015154669061303139, -0.003697942476719618, 0.031094737350940704, -0.01546263787895441, -0.04576026275753975, 0.029472699388861656, -0.00550473527982831, -0.0036422295961529016, 0.027300799265503883, 0.0049006082117557526, 0.012379282154142857, -0.047036781907081604, -0.002687660278752446, 0.017812257632613182, -0.026018787175416946, 0.031325191259384155, 0.05689574033021927, 0.04412834718823433, 0.06002146750688553, -0.006585131864994764, 0.04210104048252106, -0.008770874701440334, 0.003535975469276309, 0.04188045486807823, 0.05325349047780037, 0.02653324417769909, -0.0309351347386837, 0.02093871310353279, 0.014419712126255035, -0.04388684779405594, -0.00009030135697685182, -0.0010925219394266605, 0.02482549659907818, -0.017978480085730553, 0.02097952365875244, 0.045919500291347504, -0.002507916186004877, 0.02162088453769684, 0.026260098442435265, -0.024200376123189926, 0.0826687291264534, -0.021541720256209373, -0.02914406545460224, -0.054855506867170334, 0.024149416014552116, -0.0514473021030426, -0.01171183492988348, 0.01652095466852188, 0.06089954450726509, -0.015710001811385155, 0.028382346034049988, 0.0017604924505576491, 0.011354525573551655, -0.007004430051892996, -0.009572582319378853, 0.05033785104751587, -0.021688418462872505, 0.0395670123398304, 0.002745570382103324, -0.018612636253237724, -0.038320817053318024, -0.05710292235016823, 0.020171310752630234, -0.012200524099171162, 0.04010721668601036, -0.012812715023756027, -0.02985868975520134, 0.017920464277267456, 0.0362282432615757, 0.011335806921124458, -0.05190382897853851, -0.04610414057970047, 0.03948242589831352, -0.0029733525589108467, -0.023913662880659103 ]
<p>Say I have a random vector $Y\sim N(X\beta,\Sigma)$ and $\Sigma\neq\sigma^2 I$. That is, the elements of $Y$ (given $X\beta$) are correlated.</p> <p>The natural estimator of $\beta$ is $(X'\Sigma^{-1}X)^{-1}X'\Sigma^{-1}Y$, and $\text{var}(\hat{\beta})=(X'\Sigma^{-1}X)^{-1}$</p> <p>In a design context, the experimenter can fiddle with the design which will result in different $X$ and $\Sigma$ thus different $\text{var}(\hat{\beta})$. To choose an optimal design, I see that people often try to minimizes the determinant of $(X'\Sigma^{-1} X)^{-1}$, what is the intuition behind this?</p> <p>Why not, say, minimizes the sum of its elements?</p>
74,132
[ -0.03885369375348091, 0.03212958201766014, -0.010761004872620106, -0.012164824642241001, 0.013947536237537861, 0.0284521896392107, -0.027517445385456085, 0.001676953979767859, 0.02828964777290821, -0.027610374614596367, 0.007380212191492319, 0.03485581651329994, 0.07116594165563583, -0.012049281969666481, 0.038574978709220886, 0.0030576211865991354, -0.02173438109457493, 0.006768330466002226, -0.03755621239542961, -0.020062394440174103, 0.0026069674640893936, 0.02794363722205162, 0.008902649395167828, 0.0063875578343868256, -0.023840105161070824, 0.05150170996785164, 0.0038554284255951643, -0.06626620888710022, -0.005395372398197651, 0.05421559885144234, -0.04261517897248268, -0.03542110323905945, 0.03057747334241867, 0.04138055443763733, 0.0373227559030056, -0.021622464060783386, -0.023711448535323143, -0.009448044933378696, 0.011123730801045895, 0.036756742745637894, -0.03416476771235466, -0.03848063200712204, -0.01267913542687893, 0.027721751481294632, -0.05078241974115372, 0.045043062418699265, 0.008266802877187729, -0.03623451292514801, -0.0012012580409646034, -0.05442212149500847, 0.063900426030159, 0.012811976484954357, 0.024454765021800995, 0.04600803926587105, -0.024323919788002968, 0.003245802130550146, 0.01875605247914791, 0.028911307454109192, 0.026709631085395813, -0.06457855552434921, 0.009184309281408787, -0.04425496235489845, 0.017733145505189896, 0.0007559118093922734, -0.021446537226438522, -0.004409407265484333, 0.05928150936961174, 0.006995510775595903, 0.013676815666258335, -0.00511570880189538, 0.01967683434486389, 0.03050563484430313, 0.028897281736135483, -0.018884994089603424, 0.01188037358224392, -0.012651979923248291, 0.026942390948534012, 0.018545184284448624, 0.05044785141944885, -0.008433690294623375, 0.033209193497896194, -0.008731482550501823, 0.03763020411133766, 0.05462277680635452, -0.008639752864837646, -0.017365217208862305, 0.06308691203594208, -0.06786174327135086, 0.06347653269767761, 0.03373736888170242, 0.01609944738447666, 0.024975191801786423, 0.03707854449748993, -0.0014044558629393578, -0.028085563331842422, 0.04219403490424156, -0.02400633692741394, 0.031528789550065994, 0.04116488993167877, -0.023027004674077034, -0.025137078016996384, -0.030849747359752655, 0.006675374694168568, 0.040647584944963455, 0.002669569570571184, -0.0304110050201416, 0.0008007271680980921, 0.06606951355934143, -0.029807263985276222, -0.021250663325190544, -0.03293504938483238, 0.03149976581335068, -0.0061458079144358635, 0.01448268722742796, 0.02757791057229042, -0.0009385482408106327, -0.006040435750037432, -0.0032942595425993204, 0.04774956405162811, 0.07422041893005371, -0.004878203384578228, -0.01745704747736454, -0.0013583794934675097, -0.04304167628288269, -0.026456620544195175, 0.04114952310919762, 0.04617680236697197, 0.009451055899262428, -0.015110119245946407, 0.0026704345364123583, 0.05287725478410721, 0.0029226592741906643, 0.030492356047034264, 0.03149058669805527, -0.009792246855795383, 0.012420971877872944, -0.10172002017498016, -0.04801183566451073, 0.06738501787185669, -0.019567202776670456, -0.04386591166257858, -0.0797843486070633, -0.018274910748004913, 0.029023095965385437, 0.07952015846967697, -0.012076590210199356, 0.022950327023863792, 0.005720383487641811, -0.012233969755470753, 0.017151109874248505, -0.004096413031220436, -0.035793669521808624, -0.002718584844842553, -0.039770692586898804, -0.03466504439711571, -0.02136651799082756, 0.033603232353925705, 0.016564369201660156, 0.015699857845902443, 0.013387133367359638, -0.0022313734516501427, 0.01956283114850521, -0.019004974514245987, 0.01809782348573208, 0.015304558910429478, -0.04136154428124428, 0.07428143173456192, 0.011870866641402245, 0.03871653228998184, 0.03342035412788391, -0.01886032707989216, 0.016366951167583466, 0.008026349358260632, 0.07276339083909988, 0.04638713598251343, -0.04090062156319618, -0.015919970348477364, -0.009358219802379608, 0.005779063329100609, 0.0007144944975152612, -0.05308133363723755, -0.010027498006820679, -0.034013599157333374, 0.029841497540473938, 0.04153493791818619, 0.033443305641412735, 0.004549024626612663, -0.02582009881734848, 0.054889436811208725, -0.04434940591454506, -0.009406158700585365, -0.08069466054439545, 0.002833860693499446, 0.0053574941121041775, -0.06655187159776688, 0.04490808770060539, 0.014374789781868458, -0.01071424875408411, 0.0038725463673472404, -0.013535718433558941, -0.005173384677618742, -0.013302737846970558, 0.042386047542095184, 0.0016500140773132443, 0.006923587527126074, 0.02627449482679367, 0.05846109986305237, -0.003471135161817074, 0.03229977935552597, -0.024646559730172157, -0.08471658080816269, -0.015911435708403587, -0.016938023269176483, -0.004195806570351124, 0.04181407392024994, -0.025261133909225464, 0.00467307073995471, -0.039952754974365234, -0.02690381556749344, 0.027041509747505188, -0.04693813994526863, 0.04786967858672142, 0.07268255203962326, 0.016976531594991684, -0.0056695397943258286, 0.05087679252028465, 0.026595130562782288, 0.018830660730600357, -0.028404222801327705, -0.013242194429039955, -0.021735187619924545, 0.002425662474706769, 0.04839538782835007, 0.06729342043399811, -0.03817782178521156, -0.009923241101205349, 0.028508052229881287, 0.05063571408390999, 0.01406092569231987, -0.005649805534631014, 0.012473697774112225, 0.006536985281854868, 0.01277419924736023, -0.011337642557919025, 0.001133735291659832, 0.01688367687165737, 0.0033511233050376177, 0.0004193187633063644, 0.018698496744036674, 0.003357334528118372, -0.01012401469051838, 0.048098038882017136, 0.009670523926615715, 0.01973305456340313, 0.0005169564392417669, 0.015134676359593868, 0.024903694167733192, -0.01147348154336214, 0.038171906024217606, 0.033689796924591064, -0.0110170878469944, 0.02171030454337597, -0.00529211200773716, -0.0076081715524196625, 0.007863089442253113, -0.009851017035543919, -0.03694630786776543, 0.010322756133973598, 0.026736853644251823, -0.020502638071775436, 0.00998410489410162, -0.003407886251807213, -0.03578639775514603, -0.011180710047483444, 0.017586002126336098, 0.04486368969082832, -0.000850943848490715, 0.020637711510062218, -0.008342389948666096, -0.05741960555315018, -0.05434367060661316, -0.012601993978023529, 0.011510683223605156, 0.017776336520910263, -0.05213956907391548, -0.03371746093034744, -0.07384545356035233, 0.006751630455255508, 0.028999142348766327, -0.010613877326250076, 0.003403701586648822, -0.013122551143169403, -0.007544313091784716, -0.07216271013021469, -0.045975882560014725, -0.01664515770971775, 0.017747782170772552, -0.010766676627099514, -0.009003384970128536, 0.040508121252059937, -0.0007206946611404419, -0.02247016504406929, 0.019222896546125412, -0.024601878598332405, -0.04738858342170715, -0.01977478340268135, -0.03781156241893768, 0.05626862496137619, -0.008031009696424007, -0.025514623150229454, 0.0471724309027195, -0.022063853219151497, -0.025019843131303787, -0.08329080045223236, -0.05526246130466461, 0.009787729009985924, -0.018583061173558235, 0.04077361524105072, 0.032636649906635284, -0.0008095455705188215, 0.10290613770484924, 0.0504893958568573, -0.0018925582990050316, -0.0004175477661192417, -0.004655459895730019, -0.033990226686000824, -0.042499322444200516, 0.0324738547205925, 0.015569774433970451, 0.014345445670187473, 0.08210120350122452, 0.014116303063929081, 0.032528333365917206, 0.013582423329353333, 0.0005792570300400257, -0.0027633041609078646, 0.007931887172162533, 0.019468197599053383, -0.0036654125433415174, 0.044650599360466, -0.008065124042332172, -0.019101638346910477, -0.009151666425168514, 0.043740443885326385, 0.0413912832736969, 0.017611535266041756, -0.033829331398010254, 0.003838431555777788, -0.04440615326166153, 0.02685336396098137, -0.03543424606323242, 0.03233896568417549, 0.00241525168530643, -0.019062308594584465, -0.03823219984769821, 0.04246451333165169, 0.01355752069503069, -0.05297214537858963, 0.018770679831504822, 0.022451410070061684, 0.01338118314743042, -0.03860417753458023, 0.02277514897286892, 0.004410733934491873, 0.01212154608219862, 0.007166719995439053, -0.0543530099093914, -0.04196096956729889, 0.0012552570551633835, 0.016046462580561638, -0.011286737397313118, -0.031526364386081696, -0.06280864775180817, -0.03781330585479736, -0.06802491843700409, 0.0452711284160614, -0.02486131712794304, 0.039926379919052124, -0.006470303982496262, 0.04006899893283844, 0.005976008716970682, 0.011838301084935665, -0.034149348735809326, -0.019103266298770905, -0.08795366436243057, 0.004768183920532465, -0.01646815799176693, -0.008785603567957878, -0.002866490511223674, -0.03288213536143303, 0.05592763423919678, -0.04859209433197975, 0.014705548994243145, -0.006305960472673178, 0.030852625146508217, -0.02441314421594143, -0.016718659549951553, -0.020963316783308983, -0.01864352449774742, 0.0007931310683488846, 0.0178635586053133, 0.016926884651184082, -0.017194652929902077, 0.03156934678554535, 0.024546265602111816, -0.009321056306362152, 0.002822047332301736, -0.03724031150341034, 0.009740871377289295, 0.019637243822216988, 0.019832832738757133, -0.009391062892973423, 0.030500443652272224, -0.023251041769981384, 0.025771858170628548, 0.023151803761720657, 0.06521081179380417, 0.022890806198120117, 0.009214529767632484, -0.008835969492793083, -0.010686689987778664, -0.0344131775200367, -0.01233852282166481, -0.00061175343580544, 0.03293682262301445, 0.025592926889657974, 0.0764736533164978, 0.021464146673679352, -0.03517238795757294, 0.009686965495347977, 0.01881587877869606, 0.03842464089393616, 0.011404601857066154, -0.011505478993058205, 0.002999752527102828, -0.00660979188978672, 0.015309751033782959, 0.00687042810022831, -0.015338810160756111, -0.028260022401809692, -0.026773832738399506, 0.026225442066788673, -0.016046112403273582, 0.018985334783792496, 0.020291730761528015, 0.02231738530099392, 0.02040192298591137, -0.008081482723355293, -0.030262170359492302, 0.013597880490124226, 0.044212985783815384, 0.041078656911849976, 0.029280558228492737, 0.004904044326394796, -0.051788412034511566, -0.011283935979008675, 0.0022437458392232656, 0.026223288848996162, -0.050792381167411804, 0.01579163409769535, -0.03714843839406967, -0.024701811373233795, 0.02395913191139698, -0.022901667281985283, 0.012193672358989716, -0.022974641993641853, 0.012762044556438923, -0.03653274103999138, -0.020419523119926453, -0.061315592378377914, 0.04081818088889122, 0.005688279867172241, 0.031267356127500534, -0.0074938260950148106, -0.014544615522027016, -0.04353935271501541, 0.0026360147166997194, 0.012081345543265343, 0.06470848619937897, 0.00811691302806139, 0.013941983692348003, 0.03157367184758186, 0.038132358342409134, 0.0009058541618287563, -0.06206972524523735, 0.008129407651722431, 0.023455381393432617, -0.038774460554122925, 0.007737337611615658, -0.010837076231837273, -0.05576125159859657, -0.0017238789005205035, 0.0012717385543510318, -0.011627372354269028, 0.04110252112150192, -0.007932489737868309, 0.04615810513496399, 0.0649615228176117, 0.016738949343562126, 0.05610407888889313, -0.0035025884862989187, -0.023005668073892593, -0.021105682477355003, -0.05964653939008713, 0.022851545363664627, 0.0015821198467165232, -0.03913498669862747, -0.05761617422103882, -0.006502773147076368, -0.001649651792831719, 0.044367868453264236, 0.005432577803730965, 0.064860038459301, -0.022649502381682396, -0.04113997146487236, -0.010858592577278614, 0.0420120544731617, 0.03641992807388306, -0.04957403615117073, 0.016715772449970245, 0.020083408802747726, 0.009335543029010296, -0.039928704500198364, 0.01064017042517662, -0.020027397200465202, 0.031011147424578667, 0.02762511372566223, -0.019698595628142357, 0.018493132665753365, -0.05702134221792221, -0.03634727746248245, 0.039042651653289795, 0.0004675009404309094, 0.01304613146930933, 0.01964336819946766, 0.03778163716197014, 0.0043539321050047874, -0.017803415656089783, -0.005432565696537495, -0.002801039721816778, -0.034611959010362625, -0.004038062412291765, -0.04526623710989952, 0.027231575921177864, -0.05040193349123001, 0.029694346711039543, -0.07361616939306259, -0.025891883298754692, -0.026946356520056725, -0.004780089017003775, -0.010589854791760445, -0.011527866125106812, 0.01655912771821022, -0.017602043226361275, -0.060947056859731674, -0.024072732776403427, 0.036367010325193405, 0.005162953399121761, -0.029489191249012947, -0.006347852759063244, 0.052786849439144135, 0.052787259221076965, -0.03134579584002495, -0.005005150567740202, 0.04858151450753212, -0.03593788668513298, -0.01934107020497322, 0.009729890152812004, 0.006794073153287172, -0.019981389865279198, 0.003171677468344569, -0.020585834980010986, -0.01794612407684326, 0.03668087348341942, -0.008552332408726215, 0.008559339679777622, 0.02585322968661785, -0.009002180770039558, 0.005227695684880018, -0.022654276341199875, -0.02469426952302456, -0.011320725083351135, 0.048026591539382935, 0.012292206287384033, -0.01291835680603981, -0.03447411209344864, -0.023623336106538773, 0.02021675929427147, 0.014786211773753166, 0.003909229300916195, 0.015029530972242355, 0.03325813263654709, -0.02758767642080784, 0.023913610726594925, -0.0032903668470680714, 0.020943060517311096, 0.05207863077521324, 0.0590079240500927, 0.0004047826223541051, 0.008077972568571568, 0.03026677668094635, -0.033228419721126556, -0.012622430920600891, -0.042866725474596024, 0.06324170529842377, 0.06889646500349045, -0.023276638239622116, 0.033413294702768326, 0.053365688771009445, -0.017186470329761505, -0.02726658619940281, -0.04272188991308212, 0.010683747939765453, -0.024960093200206757, -0.019888266921043396, 0.04482291638851166, -0.030357403680682182, -0.03372269496321678, 0.04625125601887703, 0.01772374100983143, -0.01406018529087305, -0.0012013213708996773, -0.007550443522632122, 0.046081289649009705, 0.025776585564017296, -0.03465750440955162, -0.03172891214489937, 0.011668430641293526, -0.056795213371515274, 0.0026410154532641172, -0.010501770302653313, -0.02224508859217167, -0.002035616897046566, 0.012797812931239605, 0.0028372956439852715, -0.04165738448500633, -0.02086295187473297, -0.013144123367965221, 0.015940681099891663, 0.037256937474012375, -0.029291585087776184, -0.00321466033346951, 0.02962244488298893, 0.02926383912563324, -0.030950479209423065, 0.041804008185863495, -0.02863203175365925, -0.05872369930148125, -0.01541839074343443, -0.051199689507484436, -0.01653824932873249, 0.017064712941646576, -0.007343174424022436, -0.03135021775960922, 0.018328461796045303, -0.02778693474829197, 0.013755748979747295, -0.011276740580797195, 0.02694723941385746, -0.007225969340652227, 0.041089657694101334, 0.019806385040283203, 0.040032051503658295, -0.009483938105404377, 0.014813000336289406, 0.12254340946674347, 0.06487000733613968, 0.02451201155781746, -0.07347480952739716, 0.007446572184562683, -0.02562727965414524, -0.004502708092331886, 0.003936897963285446, 0.008297744207084179, 0.022848134860396385, 0.008065235801041126, 0.03454194217920303, 0.022413160651922226, 0.009904765523970127, -0.014762637205421925, 0.0410754568874836, -0.07153978198766708, -0.021002503111958504, 0.012401117011904716, -0.013775252737104893, 0.004501436837017536, -0.011332469992339611, -0.056418538093566895, 0.012354063801467419, -0.0000636396580375731, -0.032503269612789154, -0.004533416125923395, -0.01985194906592369, -0.014120416715741158, -0.006245296914130449, -0.0010881596244871616, 0.003489201655611396, 0.039033617824316025, -0.012829315848648548, -0.02259145863354206, -0.0030921052675694227, 0.004102230072021484, -0.027008486911654472, 0.0028861993923783302, 0.01564124785363674, -0.01355430856347084, 0.02270917408168316, 0.028590025380253792, 0.018259650096297264, -0.03160309046506882, -0.012660165317356586, -0.013593537732958794, 0.05854475870728493, -0.023901524022221565, -0.009516444057226181, -0.023253316059708595, 0.0009791861521080136, 0.004079146776348352, -0.03995141386985779, -0.04473571106791496, 0.016755225136876106, 0.04097145423293114, -0.036491718143224716, 0.0011419309303164482, -0.0027392087504267693, 0.010198449715971947, 0.009730711579322815, 0.05172509327530861, 0.02531731128692627, -0.04663371294736862, -0.008696171455085278, 0.0017675220733508468, 0.060591403394937515, 0.02465011179447174, -0.017985576763749123, -0.012537856586277485, -0.012238932773470879, -0.034046828746795654, -0.05566699430346489, -0.008414131589233875, -0.026075610890984535, 0.02792472206056118, -0.045883506536483765, 0.020960280671715736, 0.0035394064616411924, -0.038129597902297974, 0.011509577743709087, -0.03938541188836098, 0.0285235196352005, -0.015659160912036896, 0.00301145832054317, 0.02146664634346962, 0.040821194648742676, -0.004564187489449978, -0.02106528729200363, 0.02905358374118805, 0.04147894307971001, 0.0137191042304039, -0.03801128640770912, -0.052223995327949524, 0.0037465826608240604, 0.004916239529848099, 0.011445664800703526, -0.0001981880923267454, 0.016953658312559128, 0.019407249987125397, 0.05309531092643738, -0.00964079424738884, 0.023246165364980698, -0.04480800777673721, -0.011872850358486176, 0.04857926815748215, -0.07384426891803741, 0.017074501141905785, 0.028361940756440163, 0.006424472667276859, -0.017333032563328743, -0.015902353450655937, -0.01580013521015644, -0.004058922175318003, -0.01320626214146614, -0.009478546679019928, -0.02420635148882866, -0.014964508824050426, -0.016116492450237274, 0.04152575135231018, -0.03343310207128525, -0.031091898679733276, -0.06829389184713364, 0.04079005494713783, -0.010513977147638798, 0.014497971162199974, -0.011742951348423958, -0.011438481509685516, -0.045189227908849716, -0.031785912811756134, 0.008097179234027863, 0.04582897946238518, 0.03794390335679054, -0.010191477835178375, -0.024300117045640945, -0.020703356713056564, 0.04084381088614464, -0.02384144999086857, -0.02787921391427517, 0.00973166897892952, -0.019622523337602615, -0.057165902107954025, 0.0025968041736632586, -0.022933676838874817, 0.014800997450947762, -0.004732151515781879, 0.009683174081146717, -0.04736457020044327, 0.012350650504231453, -0.06515917181968689, -0.020793341100215912, -0.011279969476163387, 0.0205098744481802, -0.001669876161031425, -0.05320228636264801, 0.04243779182434082, -0.03370536491274834, -0.013348502106964588, 0.01940929889678955, 0.022390326485037804, -0.0145388999953866, -0.005440614651888609, 0.027012530714273453, 0.008962389081716537, 0.02612878382205963, 0.01563434489071369, 0.007091498468071222, -0.013563261367380619, 0.0642656683921814, -0.03771831840276718, 0.03606989607214928, 0.002950626192614436, 0.0231680478900671, -0.06855877488851547, -0.013684316538274288, 0.045982230454683304, -0.015869608148932457, 0.033791434019804, -0.044356316328048706, -0.007269566413015127, -0.005358352791517973, -0.04402419924736023, 0.0297908503562212, -0.01917470432817936, -0.02300761640071869, -0.04612854868173599, 0.00849727913737297, -0.0022101381327956915, 0.05247610807418823, -0.010740374214947224, 0.014623284339904785, 0.026942569762468338, 0.04215272516012192, 0.007474033627659082, -0.031017284840345383, -0.016961904242634773, 0.02474101632833481, -0.004759789910167456, -0.05337823927402496, 0.05414959415793419, -0.018572699278593063, -0.024809176102280617, 0.014030053280293941, -0.006383765023201704, -0.004096233751624823, 0.01894938386976719, -0.004917188081890345, -0.00817911233752966, 0.033191878348588943, 0.05754813924431801, -0.008594870567321777, 0.010167275555431843, -0.0067545510828495026, 0.04287153482437134, 0.02881944179534912, -0.019614024087786674, 0.022350331768393517, -0.008198089897632599, -0.005975640378892422, -0.010439157485961914, 0.0148982098326087, 0.005311494693160057, -0.05613582953810692, 0.0445694625377655, 0.034642595797777176, 0.0172297153621912, -0.04868622124195099, 0.04513787850737572, -0.02672913484275341, -0.021804098039865494, 0.021796802058815956, -0.0012640263885259628, 0.01235171314328909, 0.010859246365725994, -0.010420210659503937, -0.04825076088309288, 0.016749471426010132, 0.029254022985696793, 0.0020072427578270435, -0.0684160590171814, -0.020842252299189568, 0.005156411789357662, -0.018617801368236542, -0.000768026802688837, -0.029416454955935478, -0.012339415028691292, 0.04082926735281944, 0.041704073548316956, 0.014491287060081959, -0.04759557172656059, -0.039626799523830414, -0.005339822731912136, -0.07419652491807938, 0.05348001793026924, -0.007218556944280863, 0.0091624166816473, -0.015267851762473583, 0.006435394287109375, -0.030053306370973587, -0.005745815113186836, 0.0491955541074276, 0.00029625260503962636, 0.015704495832324028, 0.01161662582308054, 0.02509787678718567, 0.015152685344219208, 0.0007698287954553962, 0.06896553188562393, -0.0031472425907850266, -0.012900855392217636, -0.006869990844279528, -0.014896138571202755, 0.02797647751867771, -0.013994205743074417, -0.0008026029681786895, -0.03307650610804558, 0.023434285074472427, -0.00395955378189683, -0.004714534152299166, 0.0559573769569397, 0.003298598574474454, 0.002626199973747134, 0.03894258663058281, 0.02473909594118595, 0.03754758834838867, 0.010684073902666569, -0.021824918687343597, -0.0663333460688591, 0.007024421356618404, 0.004113479517400265, -0.03813149407505989, 0.010410081595182419, 0.012621209025382996, 0.01035646814852953, -0.013241535983979702, -0.0136000020429492, 0.0281694196164608, -0.0471484400331974, -0.026410773396492004, 0.02930832840502262, 0.035435810685157776, 0.017966624349355698, 0.012897870503365993, 0.011694064363837242, 0.008607032708823681, 0.003879489842802286, 0.01024763472378254, 0.03479940816760063, 0.03311345353722572, -0.0026360773481428623, -0.024745499715209007, 0.045383136719465256, -0.005023210309445858, 0.05602685362100601, -0.01826656237244606, 0.02307424321770668, -0.027370955795049667, -0.010606233030557632, 0.007700418122112751, -0.01130400039255619, 0.00680849002674222, -0.026196710765361786, 0.004807586316019297, 0.08613275736570358, -0.018001481890678406, -0.01578989252448082, -0.014909365214407444, 0.028051134198904037, -0.04482092335820198, -0.010871915146708488, -0.010204917751252651, 0.024351665750145912, 0.019034385681152344, -0.02357126958668232, -0.026533396914601326, -0.02237802743911743, -0.008345558308064938, -0.023056702688336372, 0.026102719828486443, -0.0077790310606360435, -0.02832755073904991, 0.0068224272690713406, -0.02519913949072361, -0.03400836139917374, -0.07315018773078918, 0.03422955423593521, 0.06331219524145126, 0.033821702003479004, 0.016568152233958244, -0.07703103125095367, 0.011436817236244678, 0.04501734673976898, -0.05527891963720322, -0.03515583276748657, -0.042062509804964066, 0.046408262103796005, -0.014616546221077442, 0.03262801840901375 ]
<p>My apologies if this has been answered here. It's my first time here.</p> <p>I am a developer by trade. I am not really into this thing, but I was asked to do some data simulation using SPSS. But I am not sure what significance level to use. I was given a small data set of 24 cases. This is medical research so I assume I have to use .01.</p> <p>I just don't know if it is proper to change the default level of .05 in SPSS given I have only a small data set. Somebody please shed some light.</p>
36,804
[ -0.03807530179619789, -0.019836248829960823, -0.015699665993452072, 0.027432233095169067, 0.039705462753772736, 0.036637432873249054, -0.003805428510531783, -0.03884698450565338, 0.006048514507710934, -0.01770879328250885, 0.0074976710602641106, 0.0436566099524498, 0.029180461540818214, 0.011770782992243767, 0.027074212208390236, 0.014959488995373249, -0.009952045045793056, -0.013749729841947556, -0.03150783106684685, 0.04386080801486969, -0.023716455325484276, 0.0044771418906748295, 0.007533544674515724, -0.007657983340322971, -0.0398106649518013, 0.058082085102796555, 0.04619697853922844, -0.055086757987737656, 0.008234706707298756, 0.04034369811415672, -0.030222218483686447, -0.01823459006845951, 0.029436929151415825, 0.019881267100572586, 0.042558472603559494, -0.005879322998225689, -0.03784312680363655, -0.031907517462968826, -0.01969706453382969, 0.033172886818647385, -0.01008928008377552, -0.0008367615519091487, 0.013111568056046963, 0.03123411163687706, -0.009060886688530445, -0.001631417078897357, -0.009117084555327892, -0.035107262432575226, 0.0363115593791008, -0.016389723867177963, 0.028054337948560715, 0.002872311510145664, 0.040637653321027756, 0.03846839815378189, 0.01858433149755001, -0.022696441039443016, 0.03402985259890556, 0.022783663123846054, 0.02145112119615078, -0.05333782359957695, -0.002436879090964794, -0.024286463856697083, -0.03167170286178589, -0.022583989426493645, 0.02120475471019745, -0.01076449640095234, -0.02679506689310074, -0.010664098896086216, 0.07043614238500595, 0.02871071919798851, 0.04043113812804222, 0.036024730652570724, -0.007914677262306213, -0.018343450501561165, 0.029173629358410835, -0.015706099569797516, 0.030473241582512856, -0.013261786662042141, 0.01342476811259985, 0.05129280686378479, 0.021383296698331833, 0.00577578553929925, 0.032511092722415924, 0.029258862137794495, 0.009820804931223392, -0.009438231587409973, 0.052387535572052, -0.015496580861508846, 0.027268381789326668, 0.05679941922426224, -0.022417396306991577, 0.009586768224835396, 0.01755000464618206, 0.015557951293885708, -0.027583476155996323, 0.014586985111236572, -0.0321907177567482, 0.03674287348985672, -0.017205221578478813, 0.015412545762956142, -0.011979245580732822, -0.04993271082639694, 0.025636695325374603, 0.026823127642273903, -0.043441496789455414, 0.030830100178718567, -0.028964992612600327, -0.017659515142440796, 0.011461012065410614, -0.029453638941049576, -0.005021146032959223, -0.0031885846983641386, 0.018257610499858856, -0.009622819721698761, 0.015775222331285477, -0.011220401152968407, -0.022218266502022743, -0.023121247068047523, 0.05801963061094284, 0.01103061530739069, 0.08093726634979248, -0.013171793892979622, 0.03302325680851936, 0.008490487933158875, -0.04032391309738159, -0.011638875119388103, 0.0010346127673983574, -0.016664132475852966, -0.04537709429860115, 0.06253769993782043, 0.014477518387138844, -0.00017420791846234351, 0.051956672221422195, -0.028795387595891953, 0.04421033337712288, 0.002681650687009096, -0.039932385087013245, -0.07131224870681763, 0.03774626925587654, -0.005662855692207813, 0.029655810445547104, -0.054727859795093536, -0.05572346970438957, 0.0068864403292536736, 0.02571919932961464, -0.006006329786032438, 0.03739394247531891, -0.008424167521297932, 0.019586535170674324, -0.015051059424877167, -0.0038517697248607874, -0.0076138791628181934, -0.03815808519721031, -0.04825117066502571, -0.000751668238081038, -0.09735313057899475, -0.0045364429242908955, 0.015811968594789505, -0.01103456225246191, -0.030781563371419907, -0.025027841329574585, -0.05102270469069481, -0.006229683291167021, -0.002341470681130886, 0.009144864045083523, 0.014947904273867607, 0.054651059210300446, -0.013431740924715996, 0.02552369423210621, 0.002308503957465291, -0.00571262463927269, 0.017190836369991302, 0.01906660571694374, 0.04278653860092163, 0.0473770946264267, -0.00383860245347023, 0.019112469628453255, -0.06109477952122688, 0.025001058354973793, 0.012824548408389091, -0.06347920000553131, 0.026332927867770195, -0.012046393938362598, -0.011341141536831856, 0.011706823483109474, 0.027250753715634346, 0.00046960351755842566, -0.01781413145363331, 0.012950601056218147, -0.04282430186867714, -0.05788595601916313, -0.06724410504102707, -0.009023094549775124, -0.03737286850810051, -0.029750822111964226, -0.0210794098675251, -0.003475346602499485, 0.03463636338710785, -0.03509175777435303, -0.002342574531212449, -0.022565152496099472, -0.03008158504962921, 0.020894961431622505, -0.06015899032354355, 0.008154364302754402, 0.08095087110996246, 0.00884108804166317, -0.04676813259720802, 0.027579165995121002, -0.062392767518758774, -0.012476607225835323, -0.0018404851434752345, -0.018497716635465622, 0.03329551964998245, 0.0023320347536355257, -0.04300689697265625, -0.027193361893296242, -0.017526039853692055, -0.0236713457852602, 0.04385561868548393, -0.049603171646595, 0.1047075167298317, 0.06731901317834854, -0.007009057328104973, -0.01354692317545414, 0.011268881149590015, 0.022637341171503067, -0.009794020093977451, -0.01239731814712286, -0.004900675732642412, -0.042239680886268616, 0.005649521015584469, 0.05391355976462364, -0.015660518780350685, -0.0338856503367424, -0.021704809740185738, 0.07640701532363892, 0.002992035588249564, 0.03930814936757088, 0.01586056314408779, 0.0033615746069699526, -0.017743226140737534, 0.021524105221033096, 0.027610255405306816, 0.029545629397034645, 0.03137980401515961, 0.014590988866984844, 0.018398422747850418, 0.05480374023318291, 0.012367763556540012, -0.0023181033320724964, 0.025951502844691277, -0.017568932846188545, 0.02851191535592079, -0.03756728395819664, 0.007018952164798975, 0.034535959362983704, -0.03677899017930031, 0.023777250200510025, 0.055113863199949265, 0.007960472255945206, -0.008617131039500237, 0.019780026748776436, -0.011802657507359982, 0.0259824488312006, 0.04126406088471413, -0.010798905044794083, 0.05650058388710022, 0.009831414557993412, -0.028611423447728157, -0.00430542416870594, -0.014466376043856144, -0.04336733743548393, -0.047077469527721405, -0.007958208210766315, 0.031657375395298004, 0.017343590036034584, 0.03454320877790451, -0.03239090368151665, 0.009183219633996487, -0.009933686815202236, 0.01711840182542801, 0.015499369241297245, 0.01892000064253807, -0.04673308879137039, -0.0036023235879838467, 0.015118211507797241, -0.032208606600761414, 0.044004667550325394, -0.035573333501815796, -0.00711640203371644, 0.023816987872123718, -0.004010557662695646, -0.01396564207971096, -0.000495223852340132, -0.026932498440146446, 0.004927176050841808, 0.000841513101477176, -0.028889644891023636, 0.010806014761328697, -0.002791206119582057, -0.024235982447862625, 0.017165478318929672, -0.02971087209880352, -0.025212867185473442, -0.036457061767578125, 0.029984233900904655, 0.021465223282575607, 0.008145895786583424, 0.0017174469539895654, -0.02907383255660534, -0.028740305453538895, -0.0060637169517576694, -0.032619934529066086, -0.06533177196979523, 0.029735278338193893, 0.0022765479516237974, 0.05879659578204155, -0.018972184509038925, -0.00940420851111412, 0.09266839176416397, 0.015401738695800304, 0.011348544619977474, -0.02762027271091938, -0.0020770160481333733, -0.016911141574382782, -0.021479608491063118, 0.02792060747742653, 0.0440516471862793, -0.010195894166827202, -0.00031617211061529815, 0.0007310746586881578, 0.05194050446152687, 0.03656627610325813, -0.010110430419445038, -0.005238010548055172, -0.009132307022809982, -0.006879554595798254, -0.00862716231495142, 0.049566980451345444, 0.017277520149946213, -0.024589207023382187, 0.004855616949498653, -0.0401419997215271, 0.03295031934976578, 0.005813026335090399, -0.010481367819011211, 0.03506992384791374, 0.006895276252180338, 0.01747497171163559, 0.00872538611292839, -0.003849972505122423, 0.017049772664904594, -0.00406607985496521, -0.03650104999542236, -0.013138656504452229, -0.0032895421609282494, -0.025823911651968956, -0.00791411753743887, 0.015856964513659477, 0.021235665306448936, -0.011274099349975586, 0.009285206906497478, -0.0018639249028638005, -0.010915885679423809, 0.01851077377796173, -0.022321833297610283, -0.018971113488078117, 0.03660745918750763, 0.05434635281562805, 0.057199254631996155, -0.007045849692076445, -0.064602792263031, 0.012348119169473648, -0.06721340119838715, 0.0036023948341608047, -0.011424100957810879, 0.032672904431819916, -0.03432462736964226, 0.013634980656206608, 0.0340891107916832, 0.004434026312083006, -0.002705890452489257, 0.01869376190006733, -0.06292229145765305, 0.06285115331411362, -0.03930239751935005, 0.02590910904109478, 0.03897872567176819, -0.009542645886540413, 0.006100106053054333, -0.01768537424504757, 0.03341934457421303, 0.022790100425481796, 0.014609097503125668, 0.002885030349716544, 0.018101781606674194, -0.020457614213228226, 0.012679760344326496, -0.034374576061964035, 0.008424894884228706, -0.0022326339967548847, 0.020700106397271156, 0.017191775143146515, 0.0015064087929204106, -0.005978543311357498, -0.02207065559923649, -0.01652359589934349, 0.01745492033660412, 0.03458864986896515, 0.058275558054447174, 0.034993309527635574, 0.03582138940691948, -0.0556584969162941, 0.0220824982970953, -0.009863422252237797, 0.017872096970677376, 0.03269346430897713, -0.02795008383691311, -0.027454812079668045, -0.041257087141275406, -0.036924879997968674, -0.020070746541023254, 0.03822962939739227, 0.004117689561098814, -0.008963815867900848, 0.04257718473672867, -0.01267586275935173, -0.06184184551239014, 0.014783013612031937, 0.09459719061851501, 0.020729215815663338, -0.01942470483481884, -0.06447617709636688, 0.01567353680729866, -0.03911101073026657, -0.02047743834555149, -0.0007904624799266458, 0.04405994340777397, 0.010393735952675343, 0.005252753384411335, 0.00919399969279766, -0.012841652147471905, -0.022899478673934937, -0.00929672084748745, 0.015608194284141064, 0.06745405495166779, 0.02345089428126812, -0.014240480959415436, 0.023728162050247192, -0.012461560778319836, 0.0021540552843362093, 0.03244837000966072, -0.005899158772081137, -0.06466250121593475, -0.0014842370292171836, 0.036022674292325974, 0.049078568816185, -0.028307421132922173, 0.00954807922244072, -0.026041889563202858, -0.005031573586165905, 0.06122402474284172, -0.03851638734340668, 0.01666894368827343, -0.008717126213014126, 0.012781776487827301, -0.02396533638238907, 0.014250809326767921, -0.0649278312921524, 0.014275058172643185, -0.047181617468595505, 0.04921010509133339, -0.027180425822734833, -0.021652063354849815, -0.08977526426315308, 0.025551294907927513, 0.002392616355791688, 0.06689613312482834, -0.030518071725964546, -0.03684283420443535, 0.005199833307415247, -0.0027770090382546186, -0.017979728057980537, -0.05690475553274155, 0.0033988456707447767, 0.01865631714463234, 0.06160031631588936, 0.02745320275425911, 0.005567713640630245, -0.027102632448077202, -0.008790457621216774, 0.020499130710959435, -0.030294174328446388, -0.003060760907828808, -0.005005069077014923, 0.06703925132751465, 0.006694302894175053, -0.004327466711401939, 0.036955367773771286, -0.00414494052529335, -0.009689784608781338, 0.0025873559061437845, -0.0421324148774147, -0.002903982065618038, -0.03432173654437065, -0.01369988638907671, -0.049077656120061874, 0.003239432582631707, -0.017947085201740265, 0.027343515306711197, -0.00475431839004159, 0.048648010939359665, -0.016716105863451958, -0.0055453479290008545, 0.01831972785294056, 0.02702084556221962, 0.030366718769073486, -0.003137160325422883, -0.016060568392276764, -0.025643136352300644, -0.021058250218629837, -0.00929471105337143, 0.008268248289823532, -0.03308508172631264, -0.004600190091878176, 0.04355943202972412, -0.06851539015769958, 0.00011103570432169363, -0.021186042577028275, -0.054828282445669174, 0.019730782136321068, -0.0906711295247078, -0.00491329887881875, -0.019318794831633568, 0.008229227736592293, -0.012857274152338505, -0.03229644149541855, -0.0012427482288330793, 0.04079535976052284, -0.004610526841133833, 0.061010174453258514, -0.05663395673036575, 0.032554857432842255, -0.05244697257876396, 0.02303231880068779, -0.0644187405705452, -0.05231953784823418, 0.0212006326764822, 0.02309558168053627, -0.012315820902585983, 0.007722693029791117, 0.021868841722607613, -0.015169626101851463, -0.007880601100623608, 0.010400551371276379, 0.06667406111955643, -0.013354078866541386, -0.03258969262242317, -0.022993676364421844, -0.0010692654177546501, 0.10034135729074478, -0.011928959749639034, -0.00597488833591342, 0.021585814654827118, -0.012658853083848953, -0.021742286160588264, -0.028567075729370117, 0.050887566059827805, -0.02468704991042614, -0.011517968960106373, -0.0238519087433815, -0.02592488005757332, 0.02984006516635418, 0.007563755381852388, 0.012022130191326141, 0.013722226023674011, 0.00008801009971648455, 0.028107352554798126, -0.02124626748263836, 0.0025776000693440437, -0.027030207216739655, 0.020702430978417397, -0.011523803696036339, 0.013554491102695465, -0.020833317190408707, 0.012221748940646648, 0.007105495315045118, 0.0021487295161932707, 0.006832896266132593, 0.04162827134132385, 0.0589335635304451, -0.00825378205627203, 0.0017067397711798549, -0.01718779280781746, -0.03281180188059807, 0.0025291298516094685, 0.044148966670036316, -0.03078605979681015, -0.003172604599967599, 0.020288383588194847, -0.010245155543088913, -0.02111045829951763, -0.02731809951364994, 0.012189666740596294, 0.04712304472923279, 0.007426423951983452, 0.030052822083234787, 0.04002262279391289, -0.0032566122245043516, -0.020745370537042618, -0.01426939107477665, -0.026351677253842354, -0.013537487015128136, -0.0018063740571960807, 0.02808651141822338, -0.029211975634098053, 0.007777002174407244, 0.021025007590651512, 0.004436754621565342, 0.04583378881216049, 0.08158432692289352, 0.0429900661110878, 0.006048533134162426, 0.05234690010547638, -0.05176350101828575, -0.030459528788924217, 0.05137380585074425, -0.01671421341598034, 0.029439028352499008, -0.04432728514075279, -0.025411147624254227, 0.04045621678233147, 0.019530681893229485, 0.011453606188297272, -0.022835595533251762, -0.013323009945452213, -0.043921008706092834, -0.022455556318163872, 0.01959913782775402, -0.05227718874812126, 0.01425730437040329, 0.002799156354740262, 0.0049036722630262375, 0.006126352585852146, 0.0251054298132658, -0.03680470213294029, -0.08119646459817886, -0.03467757627367973, 0.004951861687004566, -0.05766354501247406, 0.029657484963536263, -0.006467889063060284, -0.029597677290439606, -0.003188009839504957, -0.04964533820748329, 0.019376400858163834, 0.007294915150851011, 0.01169181615114212, 0.016460034996271133, 0.06761573255062103, 0.020144427195191383, 0.017249226570129395, 0.007077847607433796, 0.02280968800187111, 0.1302170753479004, 0.10345480591058731, 0.013538192957639694, -0.0648760125041008, 0.02043316513299942, -0.02816319279372692, 0.006426047533750534, 0.010394539684057236, 0.025068746879696846, 0.01723727211356163, -0.0006161898490972817, 0.036022767424583435, 0.053474243730306625, 0.021277472376823425, -0.009536382742226124, 0.07663670927286148, -0.03272119536995888, -0.0639655813574791, -0.009171219542622566, 0.029945775866508484, -0.002124543534591794, -0.01670713722705841, -0.03660321980714798, -0.007264676038175821, -0.006512070074677467, -0.012579238973557949, -0.007048473693430424, 0.005017428193241358, -0.020854422822594643, 0.0022906861267983913, -0.03510782867670059, -0.019316965714097023, 0.02245340123772621, -0.0018107194919139147, -0.083419069647789, -0.03479816019535065, 0.0356782004237175, -0.03979393467307091, 0.00701622199267149, 0.042394060641527176, -0.03746366500854492, 0.005203011445701122, -0.016768572852015495, 0.0030656836461275816, -0.04360046237707138, 0.0029574688524007797, -0.01756039448082447, 0.03019125573337078, -0.008910968899726868, -0.01317255012691021, -0.011838475242257118, -0.007715288549661636, -0.01268497109413147, -0.04639445245265961, -0.00003176064637955278, 0.01725040003657341, 0.034769825637340546, -0.0071153417229652405, -0.010969357565045357, -0.04545476287603378, -0.004848375916481018, -0.0010096983751282096, 0.04685894772410393, 0.04595470428466797, -0.009355930611491203, -0.01307008694857359, -0.02728375233709812, 0.048024144023656845, -0.032288145273923874, 0.012753273360431194, 0.06983772665262222, 0.0011188304051756859, -0.0545833595097065, -0.01043526828289032, -0.006440358702093363, 0.0026352887507528067, 0.041179005056619644, -0.014553842134773731, 0.002773740328848362, -0.03488548845052719, -0.043276913464069366, 0.028628166764974594, -0.015680503100156784, 0.012898330576717854, -0.02664884738624096, 0.0072049484588205814, 0.0005024629062972963, 0.03657836094498634, 0.010992919094860554, 0.02331162616610527, 0.01442793384194374, 0.020820386707782745, 0.030771709978580475, -0.06779030710458755, -0.02149437740445137, 0.009168578311800957, -0.04786284267902374, 0.020123710855841637, -0.04953537881374359, 0.06090273708105087, -0.027009163051843643, -0.023229727521538734, 0.02425364963710308, 0.04135218635201454, -0.02394513040781021, 0.037707820534706116, -0.030088018625974655, -0.07778211683034897, -0.01718074083328247, 0.03209203854203224, 0.0035085442941635847, -0.006186882499605417, -0.02240641787648201, -0.047558266669511795, -0.011801191605627537, -0.006692431401461363, 0.006437906064093113, 0.011255758814513683, 0.022020995616912842, -0.01194116659462452, -0.0030974496621638536, 0.02793649584054947, -0.015816323459148407, -0.027454223483800888, -0.023269565775990486, 0.03600505739450455, -0.004283837042748928, 0.0049102772027254105, 0.01688019186258316, -0.011657275259494781, 0.027030790224671364, 0.03520413860678673, 0.0017505441792309284, 0.024315310642123222, 0.003540045814588666, -0.024411620572209358, 0.016753315925598145, 0.03690784052014351, -0.042687419801950455, 0.005802042316645384, 0.04966392740607262, -0.052281733602285385, -0.01749829389154911, 0.037751998752355576, -0.003251298563554883, 0.0241745263338089, 0.011058480478823185, 0.005476307589560747, -0.013107778504490852, 0.051022760570049286, -0.03196711093187332, -0.018967807292938232, -0.03058284893631935, 0.02658853679895401, -0.005435779690742493, 0.009074634872376919, -0.016633328050374985, 0.002913649193942547, 0.003497288329526782, 0.04069695994257927, 0.02203213982284069, -0.007379062939435244, -0.008840211667120457, 0.023385457694530487, 0.012208357453346252, 0.003021134529262781, 0.010350083000957966, 0.01218019425868988, 0.06068623438477516, 0.024501297622919083, -0.04331059381365776, 0.004771485459059477, -0.01765597052872181, -0.016463814303278923, -0.10536804795265198, -0.054016586393117905, -0.01617245189845562, 0.021541858091950417, 0.02598915435373783, -0.056034527719020844, 0.037879034876823425, -0.004472329746931791, -0.03514168784022331, 0.018155967816710472, -0.008675017394125462, -0.024240804836153984, -0.03320584073662758, -0.039076872169971466, -0.010243083350360394, 0.03698619827628136, 0.008398662321269512, 0.02357463352382183, 0.04497498646378517, 0.0011721646878868341, 0.0026772087439894676, -0.015163993462920189, 0.014425568282604218, 0.060286592692136765, -0.015511755831539631, -0.075584776699543, -0.013727131299674511, -0.04235588386654854, -0.059633564203977585, 0.027125854045152664, 0.005163946654647589, 0.024524085223674774, 0.04569580778479576, 0.031581003218889236, 0.009774158708751202, 0.06773518770933151, 0.05670467019081116, 0.000565950816962868, 0.0037138410843908787, -0.011776559986174107, 0.020528052002191544, 0.05866186320781708, -0.042292460799217224, 0.031823694705963135, 0.03493250533938408, -0.04004853963851929, -0.013870234601199627, -0.03842988610267639, -0.028999648988246918, -0.012814565561711788, -0.002887160051614046, -0.021684909239411354, -0.00030257314210757613, -0.05418120324611664, 0.003299524774774909, -0.05075584724545479, 0.02851962298154831, 0.058814145624637604, 0.023084985092282295, 0.006033909972757101, -0.0007866762462072074, -0.023393897339701653, -0.01958952099084854, -0.016831938177347183, -0.020270153880119324, -0.03067510947585106, -0.05575399845838547, 0.012674624100327492, -0.026193516328930855, 0.00574332382529974, -0.02161470055580139, 0.003990525379776955, -0.028907684609293938, 0.03947878256440163, -0.04041290655732155, 0.004969567060470581, 0.03208047151565552, -0.02361498773097992, 0.021761169657111168, -0.0913296639919281, 0.04134739190340042, 0.033830687403678894, 0.0028242527041584253, -0.022790808230638504, -0.02854984998703003, -0.02661394700407982, 0.040060847997665405, 0.06529728323221207, 0.017902109771966934, 0.008617768995463848, -0.035571787506341934, 0.024533234536647797, -0.005043780896812677, -0.03292561322450638, 0.06396453082561493, 0.018851103261113167, -0.034061629325151443, -0.02677573822438717, 0.009190133772790432, 0.015438193455338478, -0.006814023479819298, -0.019132060930132866, 0.009250841103494167, 0.028461450710892677, -0.01693403162062168, -0.006739484146237373, 0.03311186656355858, 0.02649962157011032, -0.03326521813869476, 0.062292348593473434, 0.00958292093127966, -0.014066611416637897, 0.05119163542985916, 0.0027724970132112503, -0.008457551710307598, 0.027893545106053352, -0.022659828886389732, -0.016512732952833176, 0.0033417546655982733, 0.00824656616896391, 0.013344633392989635, -0.06321849673986435, 0.018440069630742073, 0.03577306121587753, -0.02148737944662571, 0.028046784922480583, 0.008413905277848244, 0.03772026300430298, 0.020697426050901413, 0.00778263621032238, 0.02289828099310398, -0.010241872631013393, -0.042544227093458176, 0.015212141908705235, -0.02279007062315941, 0.005421500187367201, -0.009049900807440281, 0.014117359183728695, 0.038637176156044006, -0.0032511278986930847, 0.011923234909772873, 0.012163128703832626, 0.014132861979305744, -0.0034050573594868183, 0.004230835475027561, 0.039829861372709274, -0.004326852038502693, 0.024468710646033287, -0.010029369033873081, 0.01720844767987728, 0.04835639148950577, -0.0260293148458004, 0.01183635275810957, -0.015442926436662674, 0.0019113748567178845, -0.03992268443107605, -0.023961711674928665, 0.018896713852882385, 0.014553429558873177, 0.008718186989426613, -0.012752325274050236, 0.02332284301519394, 0.008187223225831985, 0.04740308225154877, -0.04483489692211151, 0.023508839309215546, -0.04614300653338432, 0.017534419894218445, -0.022478975355625153, -0.011219064705073833, -0.023786161094903946, 0.01656177081167698, 0.03358637914061546, 0.015976373106241226, 0.01751634106040001, -0.009360418654978275, -0.05169342830777168, 0.025154683738946915, 0.04151858389377594, -0.05059061199426651, -0.016381483525037766, -0.046955790370702744, 0.014024338684976101, -0.021289750933647156, -0.013932551257312298 ]
<p>I asked a question earlier in the forum on auto arima click here <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/68261/performance-evaluation-of-auto-arima-in-r-and-ucm-on-one-dataset">Performance evaluation of auto.arima in R and UCM on one dataset</a>. The auto.arima provided strange forecast, upon further looking at the code I did not find anything wrong in my R code see code below. This seems a very straightforward problem. If auto.arima does not fit a simple straightforward dataset, I would be very cautious in using this function to fit more complicated datasets. I would encourage using other tools/ functions and verify forecast. </p> <pre><code>plot(eggs) ## Hold out 10 data points - 1984 thru 1993 egg_price = ts(eggs,start = 1900, end = 1983) ## Fit arima model fit &lt;- auto.arima(egg_price) fcast &lt;- forecast(fit,h=10) plot(fcast) </code></pre>
49,926
[ -0.026169274002313614, -0.008130268193781376, 0.008874454535543919, 0.002403705148026347, 0.018504541367292404, -0.034119613468647, -0.02768031880259514, -0.01079217717051506, 0.014458793215453625, 0.0051848432049155235, 0.042159371078014374, 0.05676371976733208, 0.034076716750860214, 0.019846072420477867, 0.015872107818722725, -0.027066024020314217, -0.025561586022377014, -0.007855423726141453, 0.001146430498920381, 0.010052403435111046, 0.02582615241408348, 0.009506123140454292, -0.02987726964056492, -0.016705365851521492, 0.026463257148861885, 0.03116505965590477, 0.03661457449197769, 0.004736032802611589, 0.013670383021235466, 0.03781866654753685, -0.04660496860742569, -0.008185756392776966, 0.031622644513845444, 0.016218973323702812, 0.039071522653102875, 0.00878743827342987, 0.028296910226345062, -0.02781824953854084, -0.015528975985944271, 0.06432018429040909, -0.0197868961840868, 0.005723557434976101, 0.0032730100210756063, 0.02323569729924202, -0.011670589447021484, 0.03441360220313072, 0.007818739861249924, 0.013573430478572845, 0.03913099318742752, -0.037582240998744965, 0.0483311302959919, -0.007064647041261196, -0.0035485425032675266, 0.034934643656015396, -0.03837908059358597, -0.014642380177974701, 0.06439056992530823, 0.043603312224149704, -0.02502228133380413, -0.04724246263504028, 0.02706313505768776, -0.04029187560081482, -0.007168172392994165, -0.011972607113420963, -0.029470063745975494, 0.04673841595649719, 0.01381461787968874, -0.030066069215536118, 0.02916196919977665, -0.03234527260065079, 0.04466379061341286, -0.00459015928208828, 0.009038984775543213, -0.02206219546496868, 0.013982921838760376, -0.027491096407175064, -0.011605164967477322, 0.01509860623627901, 0.04371574893593788, 0.050695061683654785, 0.01698422245681286, 0.073337122797966, 0.0483553446829319, 0.07363369315862656, 0.02696792036294937, 0.015031286515295506, 0.053302403539419174, -0.008845701813697815, 0.029763810336589813, 0.04008037596940994, 0.0030140492599457502, 0.024815218523144722, 0.08410181850194931, -0.014806173741817474, -0.04492291063070297, 0.031739361584186554, -0.0003089027013629675, 0.04457712918519974, -0.011017353273928165, -0.03863764554262161, -0.007865432649850845, -0.027583984658122063, 0.036135684698820114, 0.05567905679345131, -0.0012505089398473501, -0.017787331715226173, -0.014948583208024502, -0.04554290324449539, -0.001368749188259244, -0.03674443066120148, -0.03586030378937721, 0.020281868055462837, -0.02903311513364315, -0.008269000798463821, 0.016935845836997032, 0.0182904452085495, 0.019853780046105385, 0.016604427248239517, 0.018632587045431137, 0.03796015679836273, 0.05458632856607437, 0.0016361509915441275, -0.001294794725254178, -0.03440123796463013, -0.04450174421072006, 0.0019790877122431993, -0.023659570142626762, -0.02634330466389656, -0.049387019127607346, 0.051127370446920395, -0.04301611706614494, -0.03525397181510925, -0.009404025040566921, -0.030991459265351295, 0.04001966118812561, -0.02383856475353241, -0.09000128507614136, -0.06676866859197617, 0.03409148007631302, 0.006947997957468033, 0.015025262720882893, -0.03735477477312088, 0.018267590552568436, 0.00010594375635264441, 0.06223580613732338, -0.000934177718590945, 0.014796159230172634, 0.008081638254225254, 0.029745332896709442, -0.021832484751939774, -0.06512855738401413, 0.020449843257665634, -0.01722905784845352, -0.03674433007836342, -0.005043768789619207, -0.05664719641208649, 0.020979413762688637, 0.018694881349802017, 0.006691945716738701, 0.0002188951475545764, 0.0600220188498497, 0.0016331181395798922, 0.00824424996972084, -0.043949078768491745, -0.008756679482758045, -0.05137459933757782, 0.0727311223745346, 0.011793003417551517, 0.002191253239288926, -0.013445857912302017, -0.02643360011279583, 0.04928598552942276, 0.018652942031621933, 0.005484167020767927, 0.05068303272128105, -0.016386304050683975, 0.04175001010298729, -0.027785897254943848, -0.0029762370977550745, 0.020691437646746635, -0.013516201637685299, -0.008395209908485413, 0.006718300748616457, -0.005764430854469538, 0.022731538861989975, 0.03594972938299179, -0.03337698057293892, -0.00043117947643622756, 0.08626651763916016, -0.08772360533475876, -0.04196181148290634, -0.04405241459608078, -0.01182545255869627, -0.01958245038986206, 0.022218720987439156, 0.006874627899378538, -0.0050794463604688644, 0.04014170542359352, 0.011595850810408592, -0.012430665083229542, -0.026923879981040955, 0.005497240461409092, 0.04666157439351082, -0.01613198034465313, 0.036422282457351685, 0.058607980608940125, 0.005552766378968954, -0.024956203997135162, 0.0335707925260067, -0.03396158665418625, -0.014534280635416508, 0.020096085965633392, -0.03721332922577858, 0.024059327319264412, 0.003912997432053089, -0.003122241236269474, 0.0291287861764431, -0.025483112782239914, -0.0013498530024662614, 0.05756865814328194, -0.02291945554316044, 0.005849909037351608, 0.060522083193063736, 0.005995897110551596, 0.04458346962928772, 0.029138347133994102, 0.028151758015155792, -0.0023650170769542456, -0.00077155971666798, 0.004528893623501062, -0.04969106242060661, 0.01820562221109867, 0.0762723907828331, 0.013711852952837944, 0.002147897146642208, 0.019017638638615608, 0.07122614234685898, -0.00043914641719311476, -0.003406605450436473, 0.030278418213129044, 0.002606666414067149, -0.03255028650164604, 0.01118236593902111, 0.016025880351662636, 0.03967881575226784, -0.0025193137116730213, 0.011552304029464722, -0.01281251385807991, 0.010981952771544456, -0.004942409694194794, -0.03527995944023132, 0.08973924070596695, -0.02850821614265442, -0.01223588827997446, -0.02578076533973217, 0.005739446729421616, 0.024816861376166344, -0.05843311920762062, 0.010098416358232498, 0.028391648083925247, 0.02437848038971424, -0.010644793510437012, -0.003680180525407195, -0.028875475749373436, 0.0009138177847489715, 0.041233424097299576, 0.0075527373701334, -0.023725559934973717, 0.028563251718878746, -0.042309097945690155, -0.0022265659645199776, -0.04451245069503784, -0.016450410708785057, -0.06006301939487457, -0.006069478113204241, 0.029271449893712997, 0.022909168154001236, 0.009597772732377052, -0.02319422923028469, -0.020259402692317963, 0.013839922845363617, -0.020950334146618843, -0.007041883189231157, -0.023583758622407913, -0.022578192874789238, 0.03709866851568222, -0.018364405259490013, 0.018850894644856453, 0.028869502246379852, -0.00488200131803751, 0.00003015058064192999, 0.027232706546783447, -0.020622704178094864, -0.033536750823259354, -0.06346538662910461, -0.026975570246577263, 0.00445157615467906, -0.03164835646748543, -0.04564317688345909, 0.029311643913388252, 0.00285353884100914, -0.00619852589443326, 0.007222781423479319, -0.0344974659383297, -0.0015973512781783938, -0.006686695851385593, -0.009292406029999256, 0.03599157929420471, 0.007478517945855856, 0.027329884469509125, 0.016351426020264626, -0.06240679696202278, -0.009211896918714046, -0.05106962099671364, -0.061626363545656204, 0.01976264826953411, -0.026759428903460503, 0.015584319829940796, 0.025956952944397926, -0.017273273319005966, 0.019420914351940155, 0.03683808445930481, -0.020001044496893883, -0.08415739983320236, -0.01668659970164299, -0.014278413727879524, -0.058770712465047836, -0.029836274683475494, 0.016952862963080406, -0.022771907970309258, -0.010131879709661007, -0.023013172671198845, 0.012489466927945614, 0.0405963696539402, 0.021549543365836143, -0.01083745714277029, -0.017090890556573868, -0.04284284636378288, 0.0015363594284281135, 0.04817982390522957, -0.008142204023897648, 0.022589968517422676, -0.0038520966190844774, -0.019135167822241783, 0.022673599421977997, -0.015075134113430977, -0.059563979506492615, 0.008817577734589577, 0.009861975908279419, 0.03969862684607506, -0.03279925882816315, 0.006337014026939869, -0.00746808061376214, -0.03285377845168114, -0.009432393126189709, 0.004315430764108896, 0.019305584952235222, -0.004283634480088949, 0.011450191028416157, 0.0488993376493454, 0.002097521675750613, -0.029743118211627007, -0.018695268779993057, -0.004885486327111721, -0.0033061157446354628, 0.02247535064816475, -0.03324000909924507, -0.016855431720614433, 0.029148517176508904, 0.04844854772090912, 0.003978676162660122, 0.01974116824567318, -0.04828225076198578, 0.007035067770630121, -0.0778714120388031, -0.008331449702382088, -0.07565650343894958, 0.058999236673116684, 0.01789957284927368, 0.032851796597242355, 0.045631613582372665, -0.003741271561011672, 0.03040187619626522, -0.013367963023483753, -0.06488247960805893, 0.059147048741579056, 0.012653762474656105, -0.02657219022512436, -0.008096977137029171, -0.05612272769212723, 0.03246515244245529, -0.011565237306058407, 0.06830766052007675, -0.01225728914141655, 0.031149540096521378, -0.0372190959751606, 0.050431977957487106, 0.010779950767755508, 0.016395125538110733, -0.04472064971923828, -0.03354289382696152, 0.050386007875204086, 0.012526409700512886, 0.06535075604915619, 0.043183181434869766, -0.03329038992524147, -0.01934768632054329, -0.04262984171509743, 0.02721417136490345, 0.006800839211791754, 0.03153185546398163, 0.05163136497139931, 0.01053459569811821, -0.0808042362332344, 0.020955203101038933, 0.03787330538034439, 0.04552384465932846, 0.016561930999159813, -0.015199682675302029, -0.04732593148946762, -0.05960312485694885, -0.032235514372587204, 0.04219553619623184, -0.011945449747145176, -0.00681073684245348, -0.0037258928641676903, 0.06943761557340622, 0.024633320048451424, 0.01660354994237423, 0.018643969669938087, 0.05933380499482155, -0.006198622286319733, 0.009333410300314426, -0.0712456926703453, -0.031347695738077164, -0.004212473053485155, 0.010960512794554234, 0.03116811439394951, -0.009801064617931843, -0.0046513862907886505, 0.002185183810070157, 0.004966371227055788, -0.0534944124519825, -0.01526767946779728, -0.018300550058484077, 0.024646492674946785, 0.027608925476670265, 0.0070228553377091885, -0.03651363030076027, 0.022194508463144302, 0.038558829575777054, 0.01671866700053215, 0.027650397270917892, -0.007137601263821125, -0.09317873418331146, 0.03462275117635727, 0.04340662062168121, 0.05455654487013817, -0.008975094184279442, -0.0048887114971876144, -0.06128754839301109, -0.028913721442222595, 0.0131934629753232, -0.03605170175433159, 0.07811349630355835, -0.0020867912098765373, 0.02422787807881832, -0.008225974626839161, -0.060925934463739395, -0.04211647808551788, 0.0023529878817498684, -0.02497854083776474, 0.033048115670681, -0.011464498937129974, -0.01501909177750349, -0.019466733559966087, -0.009580980986356735, -0.013862891122698784, 0.0037992317229509354, -0.027853935956954956, -0.026808928698301315, 0.008584940806031227, 0.031852394342422485, -0.011122701689600945, -0.02332426607608795, -0.0092527586966753, -0.008100096136331558, -0.016016334295272827, 0.025628915056586266, 0.008521824143826962, 0.003249729285016656, 0.019560208544135094, 0.02051706425845623, 0.022345561534166336, -0.04529755190014839, -0.04814322665333748, 0.0323796272277832, -0.000980229931883514, -0.026535628363490105, 0.04506984353065491, 0.009121530689299107, 0.006831127684563398, -0.01155024953186512, -0.02858821116387844, -0.006191889755427837, -0.0105895372107625, -0.03424660116434097, -0.038523633033037186, -0.02305598556995392, -0.03187708556652069, 0.012980878353118896, 0.03395048901438713, 0.03241454064846039, -0.08562684059143066, 0.028486652299761772, 0.007645384408533573, 0.024151837453246117, -0.028547462075948715, -0.031054306775331497, -0.025434471666812897, -0.008943561464548111, -0.025295786559581757, 0.019281042739748955, -0.006248928140848875, -0.08071217685937881, -0.00493817962706089, 0.029690762981772423, -0.024710971862077713, 0.04803978651762009, 0.027531089261174202, -0.0055349417962133884, 0.013679441064596176, -0.0620831698179245, 0.027564214542508125, -0.015086457133293152, 0.04263203591108322, 0.008333941921591759, -0.04698403924703598, -0.008014936931431293, 0.029116449877619743, -0.006948355119675398, 0.025654921308159828, -0.026836881414055824, 0.0773998349905014, 0.0038555762730538845, -0.0267785657197237, -0.03869078680872917, -0.031954195350408554, 0.03935939446091652, 0.014112729579210281, -0.0323459655046463, 0.003969689831137657, -0.009124428033828735, -0.023160211741924286, 0.022663628682494164, -0.008252443745732307, 0.010406197048723698, -0.022215282544493675, 0.013666585087776184, 0.015483408235013485, -0.009574688039720058, 0.06398161500692368, 0.011327927932143211, -0.015685928985476494, 0.023705022409558296, 0.008624021895229816, -0.04123493283987045, 0.03203725442290306, 0.01112405676394701, -0.02675040438771248, 0.0025815602857619524, -0.012271168641746044, -0.02061128243803978, 0.033692050725221634, 0.005118163302540779, -0.01008368469774723, 0.0232088565826416, 0.0013012329582124949, 0.0002038827951764688, -0.021706687286496162, 0.013296660967171192, -0.01978754997253418, -0.028806252405047417, -0.00847187265753746, -0.020170217379927635, 0.018375715240836143, -0.007896116934716702, -0.001971462508663535, -0.026463359594345093, 0.0009099809103645384, 0.02673487178981304, 0.06506282091140747, 0.01164146326482296, -0.004741027019917965, -0.03413878753781319, -0.0007198266685009003, 0.030962739139795303, -0.015541539527475834, 0.003556421957910061, -0.013468784280121326, -0.0069549898616969585, -0.04823906347155571, -0.02916789799928665, -0.014601691626012325, -0.007760472595691681, 0.05663060024380684, -0.02400246076285839, 0.03332870826125145, 0.035015787929296494, 0.020614266395568848, -0.013146170414984226, -0.026415081694722176, 0.015215353108942509, -0.010545593686401844, 0.03666834905743599, 0.03471801429986954, 0.0009639326599426568, 0.02176017500460148, 0.036335211247205734, -0.00884392112493515, 0.04158289358019829, 0.021047348156571388, 0.025678718462586403, 0.023698898032307625, -0.003710917429998517, -0.01965123601257801, -0.06449595838785172, 0.011398197151720524, 0.000809832476079464, 0.020687874406576157, -0.04093415290117264, -0.0174279622733593, 0.03758341446518898, 0.051653895527124405, 0.019299693405628204, -0.03280568867921829, -0.02026621252298355, -0.0434415340423584, -0.006991784553974867, 0.025232063606381416, -0.001167051843367517, 0.009283923543989658, 0.02588595077395439, 0.08387310057878494, 0.0018023790325969458, 0.03414851799607277, 0.0025106703396886587, -0.05436013638973236, -0.007945026271045208, -0.03368730843067169, 0.007564947009086609, 0.05300193279981613, -0.014579237438738346, 0.00427520927041769, -0.0011366133112460375, -0.018496522679924965, 0.021062085404992104, -0.01800975576043129, 0.02921399101614952, 0.0046382443979382515, 0.07042685896158218, -0.02395586483180523, 0.0121611962094903, -0.021262237802147865, -0.002509370446205139, 0.14479422569274902, 0.027454040944576263, 0.016106972470879555, -0.050656456500291824, 0.021104712039232254, -0.004343852866441011, -0.01830613799393177, -0.003517494071274996, -0.01693055033683777, 0.025524284690618515, -0.011821967549622059, 0.04184718057513237, 0.062372416257858276, -0.028858697041869164, 0.024496877565979958, 0.02110091969370842, -0.043000832200050354, -0.011453786864876747, -0.007236030418425798, 0.01971449702978134, -0.00622232910245657, -0.02334379032254219, -0.053586672991514206, 0.025422168895602226, -0.015314842574298382, -0.007997057400643826, -0.016396520659327507, -0.025620751082897186, -0.01569640263915062, -0.013299892656505108, 0.00420331209897995, 0.015225225128233433, 0.02993859350681305, 0.027819380164146423, 0.01735236681997776, 0.016009308397769928, 0.0339323990046978, -0.051546089351177216, 0.0185118168592453, 0.05713985115289688, 0.017405949532985687, -0.012650800868868828, -0.003586213104426861, 0.03648476302623749, -0.002645473927259445, -0.008784734643995762, -0.031074047088623047, 0.025583436712622643, -0.014248072169721127, 0.013335186056792736, -0.015827074646949768, 0.01940557174384594, -0.005563902202993631, -0.040397804230451584, -0.014094586484134197, 0.011647420935332775, 0.029976025223731995, -0.03981202095746994, -0.027706211432814598, -0.044038016349077225, -0.01437220349907875, -0.015358816832304, 0.028983205556869507, 0.062345217913389206, -0.04369489476084709, 0.018666187301278114, -0.018914273008704185, 0.06031280755996704, -0.025203602388501167, -0.009634719230234623, 0.0025735024828463793, 0.002832178957760334, -0.045947737991809845, 0.003700863802805543, 0.007270267698913813, -0.015610997565090656, 0.05495341867208481, 0.0044729625806212425, 0.0018747620051726699, -0.03011537343263626, -0.027441207319498062, 0.010394937358796597, -0.04089482128620148, -0.013526646420359612, -0.019008424133062363, 0.013754117302596569, 0.030640004202723503, 0.008090220391750336, 0.011367768049240112, 0.034790314733982086, -0.04595889896154404, 0.027802780270576477, 0.003374234540387988, -0.0038887662813067436, -0.043943218886852264, 0.007256925106048584, -0.06249334290623665, -0.00017038504302036017, -0.01931523159146309, 0.08256633579730988, 0.042190276086330414, -0.00765101658180356, -0.0075337765738368034, 0.038897521793842316, 0.005481390748172998, -0.0011669234372675419, 0.017624732106924057, -0.043439675122499466, 0.02387993223965168, -0.010161994956433773, -0.006324312184005976, -0.04194560647010803, -0.006356359925121069, -0.04010474309325218, -0.04600171744823456, -0.0013314952375367284, -0.02121102437376976, -0.04265633597970009, 0.04880032315850258, -0.012111548334360123, 0.006841918453574181, -0.06748340278863907, 0.03998195752501488, -0.005048817954957485, -0.02501174435019493, -0.030848298221826553, -0.0655912533402443, 0.000669123837724328, 0.026671746745705605, -0.059321291744709015, -0.006922699511051178, 0.02449497953057289, -0.004332752898335457, 0.02404148504137993, -0.01892639324069023, 0.037655506283044815, 0.01776929199695587, 0.06767867505550385, -0.0295712873339653, -0.02326883375644684, 0.020928172394633293, -0.027993686497211456, -0.017175201326608658, 0.007418724708259106, -0.03057248704135418, 0.005872737616300583, 0.003317831549793482, 0.011257719248533249, 0.005323388148099184, 0.05704730376601219, -0.05345284566283226, 0.04301103949546814, 0.009579376317560673, 0.0014259639428928494, 0.04636123403906822, 0.04774739593267441, 0.0007006059167906642, -0.017878642305731773, 0.011559576727449894, -0.007662544492632151, 0.06158040463924408, 0.012668809853494167, 0.010077347978949547, -0.013645599596202374, -0.022213736549019814, -0.009032522328197956, 0.00012566141958814114, -0.02082415111362934, 0.0324406735599041, 0.037166777998209, -0.042814917862415314, 0.005841548088937998, -0.033890318125486374, 0.027871277183294296, -0.05808083340525627, -0.017130732536315918, -0.008606729097664356, 0.01742960698902607, 0.005410073325037956, -0.03990960493683815, 0.007452068384736776, 0.0077510736882686615, -0.014831756241619587, 0.033750422298908234, -0.004474458284676075, -0.005401798989623785, -0.024503804743289948, 0.0030919755809009075, -0.013535331934690475, 0.013312951661646366, 0.030291413888335228, -0.006349452305585146, 0.0204330924898386, 0.005507700610905886, 0.02483021281659603, -0.02524627186357975, -0.020698387175798416, 0.014207346364855766, -0.020761599764227867, -0.004864566959440708, 0.03589706867933273, -0.015573365613818169, -0.011283814907073975, 0.020508216693997383, -0.041632331907749176, 0.04416465759277344, 0.02553725056350231, 0.008739538490772247, 0.040978118777275085, 0.03048645332455635, 0.054623182862997055, 0.012081807479262352, -0.016906604170799255, 0.014011086896061897, 0.007864240556955338, 0.008710445836186409, -0.013413948938250542, 0.038064781576395035, 0.0011781600769609213, 0.014866101555526257, -0.04233596846461296, -0.016902660951018333, -0.009491728618741035, -0.010041503235697746, 0.012176348827779293, -0.007921537384390831, -0.06329008936882019, -0.016152532771229744, 0.006984002888202667, 0.015741173177957535, -0.00025861061294563115, 0.033738069236278534, 0.0404389463365078, -0.030363531783223152, -0.00495157903060317, -0.00902630016207695, -0.0375174954533577, 0.025137608870863914, -0.038540199398994446, -0.009080999530851841, -0.040870096534490585, 0.005684700794517994, -0.006498198490589857, -0.02604740671813488, -0.05100686475634575, 0.015985142439603806, -0.03535541892051697, 0.026818443089723587, -0.0023216656409204006, -0.0212881900370121, 0.05423956736922264, -0.023200474679470062, 0.032656230032444, -0.08997488021850586, 0.041386678814888, -0.016606125980615616, 0.013637479394674301, -0.020836153998970985, -0.02629931829869747, -0.019320404157042503, 0.028733549639582634, 0.029595473781228065, 0.00451553612947464, 0.02990347519516945, 0.011959449388086796, 0.008662204258143902, 0.00227276305668056, -0.02615579217672348, 0.030883951112627983, -0.03215639665722847, -0.03372033312916756, -0.0009405426098965108, -0.04283410683274269, -0.00806571263819933, 0.015459900721907616, 0.03812657296657562, -0.03686235472559929, -0.0020246829371899366, 0.006401530001312494, 0.007993696257472038, -0.01140504702925682, 0.010999541729688644, 0.019446251913905144, 0.07531888782978058, 0.0695897564291954, -0.010265156626701355, 0.04907062277197838, 0.02854132279753685, -0.06166744604706764, 0.045206908136606216, -0.05481702461838722, 0.009046793915331364, -0.024048253893852234, -0.015332086943089962, 0.009963974356651306, -0.07127915322780609, -0.027131950482726097, 0.0414842888712883, -0.00392974354326725, -0.0009912605164572597, 0.01818927563726902, -0.0039086053147912025, 0.03374665603041649, 0.010183800011873245, 0.0034024687483906746, 0.008690904825925827, -0.0038696667179465294, -0.02674839086830616, 0.00964156724512577, 0.016599325463175774, -0.002479403978213668, -0.007510604802519083, 0.04170851409435272, -0.029019759967923164, 0.024929791688919067, -0.021813636645674706, 0.09942508488893509, -0.03496897965669632, -0.04920841380953789, 0.006665030028671026, -0.019224250689148903, 0.020476030185818672, 0.0072469222359359264, -0.02558319829404354, 0.04550742730498314, -0.0487261600792408, 0.011089324951171875, 0.00859803706407547, 0.005657046567648649, -0.048992227762937546, -0.00007753837417112663, -0.0024937153793871403, 0.016388049349188805, -0.03751259297132492, 0.028707006946206093, 0.027180403470993042, -0.009245017543435097, 0.04491530731320381, -0.021048076450824738, -0.03710944205522537, 0.006813724059611559, -0.01140594482421875, -0.02768959105014801, -0.026178093627095222, 0.012118996120989323, -0.004499322269111872, 0.02832438424229622, 0.027861589565873146, -0.0038244547322392464, -0.028936151415109634, -0.006799526046961546, 0.02928837016224861, 0.06414636969566345, -0.07649639993906021, -0.028827054426074028, -0.03696376085281372, 0.0009670561412349343, -0.024118009954690933, -0.04159209132194519 ]
<p>Many of the questions I've posted on SE in the last month have been in the goal of helping me solve this particular problem. The questions have all been answered, but I still can't come up with a solution. So, I figured that I should just ask the problem I'm trying to solve directly. </p> <p>Let $X_n \sim F_n$, where $F_n = (1-(1-F_{n-1})^c)^c$, $F_0 = x$, $c\geq 2$ (integer), and every $F_n$ is a cdf over $(0,1)$.</p> <p>I want to prove that $\mathbb{E}X_n$ decreases with $n$ for all $c$ (or even, for any particular $c$)! I can show that $F_n$ converges to a Dirac mass at the unique solution to $x_c = (1-(1-x)^c)^c)$ For $c=2$, $x_2 = (3-\sqrt{5})/2 \approx .38$. When looking at a plot of cdfs for increasing $n$'s for the same $c$, all the cdfs cross at $x_n$. The value of $F(x)$ decreases for values of $x$ less than $x_n$ and increases for values of $x$ greater then $x_n$ (as $n$ increases) converging to a vertical line at $x_n$.</p> <p>Below is a plot of $\mathbb{E}X_n$ for $n = 1$ to $40$ for $c = 2$ to $7$. It is of course a discrete plot, but I have the lines joined for ease of viewing. To generate this plot, I used NIntegrate in Mathematica, though I needed to do it on $1-F^{-1}_n$, as for some reason Mathematica couldn't generate answers on high values of $n$ for the original function. The two should be equivalent, as per Young's theorem, $\int_0^1F(x)\,dx = \int_0^1 1-F^{-1}(x)\,dx$. In my case, $F^{-1}_n(x) = 1-(1-(F^{-1}_{n-1})^{\frac{1}{c}})^{\frac{1}{c}}$, $F^{-1}_n = x$.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GDFU6.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>As you can see, the $EX_n$ moves very quicky to a minute distance from its fixed point $x_c$. As $c$ increases, the fixed point decreases (eventually will go to 0).</p> <p>So, it certainly SEEMS to be true that $EX_n$ decreases with $n$ for all $c$. But I can't prove it. Can anyone help me out? (again, I'd be somewhat happy with even just a single $c$) And, if you can't, but you have insight as to why this particular problem may be unsolvable, please share that insight as well. </p>
49,160
[ -0.05151873081922531, -0.033546678721904755, 0.010513219982385635, -0.01644800417125225, 0.020953962579369545, -0.008518067188560963, -0.006182306911796331, -0.04368109256029129, -0.0026926875580102205, -0.06842976808547974, 0.042596958577632904, 0.019277382642030716, 0.04309490695595741, 0.06314057856798172, 0.024070927873253822, 0.019595464691519737, -0.019065121188759804, 0.004453101195394993, -0.039887621998786926, -0.04716892167925835, 0.0038252577651292086, 0.05364381894469261, 0.01882951706647873, -0.004603513050824404, -0.03385750576853752, 0.014229532331228256, -0.002763317432254553, -0.04594625532627106, -0.0037525200750678778, 0.12679223716259003, -0.05504994094371796, -0.026742223650217056, 0.016193391755223274, 0.021826820448040962, 0.0442766398191452, 0.04078657925128937, 0.008346549235284328, -0.04998503625392914, -0.012440312653779984, 0.027035262435674667, 0.005397244356572628, -0.026966668665409088, -0.005721117369830608, 0.01840595342218876, 0.015925712883472443, 0.03573989495635033, 0.002181838732212782, -0.03072105348110199, 0.08483533561229706, -0.07917720824480057, 0.10569937527179718, 0.0037405744660645723, 0.020328087732195854, -0.002934549003839493, 0.0006181646604090929, -0.06518972665071487, 0.0024978243745863438, 0.057196229696273804, 0.019622771069407463, 0.004468414466828108, -0.03156646713614464, -0.04614784196019173, -0.025407444685697556, -0.007772564888000488, -0.019309086725115776, 0.015584244392812252, 0.015594108030200005, -0.020996330305933952, -0.017856469377875328, -0.030727336183190346, -0.011982183903455734, 0.043784249573946, 0.0453551821410656, -0.01763829216361046, 0.017676198855042458, 0.009234420023858547, 0.01638440042734146, -0.004699737764894962, 0.041295722126960754, 0.033217769116163254, -0.03705434128642082, 0.04300221800804138, 0.0208548866212368, 0.01152755320072174, 0.013269240036606789, 0.017185727134346962, 0.07645218074321747, 0.012963281013071537, 0.011891367845237255, 0.008219849318265915, 0.011381742544472218, -0.02640422061085701, 0.07709202915430069, -0.03577233850955963, -0.033324189484119415, 0.017233535647392273, -0.02174633927643299, -0.004808483645319939, -0.013020343147218227, -0.01302983146160841, -0.01751336269080639, -0.06305361539125443, 0.03354677930474281, 0.07451437413692474, 0.01303645595908165, 0.0010655112564563751, -0.01551327109336853, -0.03814319148659706, -0.028602100908756256, 0.026369301602244377, 0.0013500117929652333, 0.035660270601511, 0.021992385387420654, -0.026282649487257004, 0.009515274316072464, 0.004032406490296125, -0.013157656416296959, -0.016879746690392494, 0.04412451386451721, 0.03675314411520958, 0.06856981664896011, -0.008551958948373795, 0.04165717959403992, -0.04183178022503853, -0.04514560475945473, 0.013127626851201057, 0.0337616503238678, -0.002565736649557948, -0.03158462047576904, 0.05869533121585846, 0.018119461834430695, -0.033059876412153244, 0.016032923012971878, 0.023059364408254623, 0.008232686668634415, 0.006171938963234425, -0.037241000682115555, -0.06786636263132095, 0.048125915229320526, -0.0145707493647933, -0.01451298501342535, -0.055313460528850555, 0.011929735541343689, 0.03889318183064461, 0.05021829158067703, 0.00594303896650672, 0.023108281195163727, -0.015319904312491417, 0.035035520792007446, 0.005939898081123829, -0.008835956454277039, -0.019375577569007874, -0.02198116108775139, -0.029771652072668076, -0.006461892742663622, -0.029049724340438843, 0.02481185644865036, 0.0201555285602808, 0.017707720398902893, -0.042530789971351624, 0.06256317347288132, -0.024599485099315643, -0.0054909116588532925, -0.04518876597285271, 0.0014381544897332788, -0.01857762597501278, 0.058341655880212784, 0.010951858945190907, -0.01586885377764702, 0.01116819866001606, -0.0266670323908329, 0.0027473492082208395, 0.00009746257273945957, 0.02680063247680664, 0.04729979857802391, -0.0199821088463068, -0.00945320539176464, -0.04038972035050392, -0.007727993186563253, -0.0062584602274000645, 0.01859349198639393, -0.015914542600512505, -0.07237033545970917, -0.03313671052455902, 0.02948361448943615, 0.027277175337076187, -0.0033435802906751633, -0.03658873587846756, -0.01781548000872135, -0.06371314823627472, -0.039014510810375214, -0.03948567062616348, -0.0025047215167433023, 0.008206550031900406, -0.032368253916502, 0.01935005374252796, -0.010919624008238316, -0.009450680576264858, -0.028842700645327568, -0.011651381850242615, 0.006575264036655426, 0.04777609184384346, 0.016109580174088478, -0.016545642167329788, 0.011934691108763218, 0.025060679763555527, 0.03919375315308571, -0.009527929127216339, 0.04568133503198624, -0.04510250687599182, -0.004839801695197821, -0.0045370422303676605, -0.050591353327035904, 0.039893053472042084, 0.004190296400338411, 0.06477687507867813, 0.027762236073613167, -0.027969367802143097, 0.01547404658049345, 0.02550107054412365, -0.029073210433125496, 0.027604086324572563, 0.0550113320350647, 0.025008078664541245, 0.013684095814824104, -0.004399814642965794, 0.018468834459781647, 0.024292128160595894, -0.03000674396753311, -0.04540124535560608, -0.05524883046746254, -0.0073334528133273125, 0.05111434683203697, 0.06277115643024445, -0.023349398747086525, -0.0008949676412157714, 0.07294911891222, 0.011168420314788818, 0.022420734167099, 0.001705419272184372, -0.027525780722498894, -0.01760449819266796, 0.031191540881991386, 0.008555462583899498, 0.010808328166604042, -0.007072430569678545, 0.014320330694317818, -0.012222742661833763, 0.021680962294340134, 0.01571480557322502, -0.028726384043693542, -0.0013052187860012054, 0.032413821667432785, 0.012570071034133434, -0.013732695952057838, 0.004132512491196394, 0.0054619163274765015, -0.0254378505051136, -0.028502823784947395, -0.0052059791050851345, -0.02407313697040081, 0.020842500030994415, 0.00991712138056755, -0.019888076931238174, 0.05623897165060043, 0.017519574612379074, -0.03135783225297928, -0.019597947597503662, 0.01480487734079361, -0.028563454747200012, 0.03979803994297981, -0.034649807959795, -0.039575666189193726, 0.022641491144895554, 0.001079003675840795, 0.0002975904499180615, 0.002005330752581358, 0.0011022682301700115, -0.040501851588487625, 0.026436004787683487, -0.0000011297837545498624, -0.022429006174206734, 0.022507138550281525, 0.009305829182267189, -0.04228534922003746, 0.00853906199336052, -0.025021545588970184, -0.015412500128149986, 0.04834452643990517, 0.02964100055396557, 0.00709022581577301, 0.049579817801713943, -0.004651135299354792, -0.06870374083518982, -0.041147954761981964, -0.02215159684419632, 0.004076432902365923, -0.05683101341128349, 0.0036662661004811525, 0.084112748503685, 0.018705736845731735, -0.02578803338110447, 0.013665997423231602, 0.010092497803270817, -0.01266101561486721, -0.0335046760737896, -0.004071490373462439, 0.019793959334492683, -0.02094171941280365, 0.018119417130947113, -0.029711192473769188, 0.020731989294290543, -0.0017348581459373236, -0.09426388889551163, -0.042045485228300095, -0.00922346394509077, -0.05172942578792572, 0.013104104436933994, -0.021710973232984543, 0.00425218790769577, 0.05005503445863724, 0.04540406912565231, -0.01118212565779686, -0.033056747168302536, 0.0031321023125201464, 0.018775038421154022, -0.018028108403086662, -0.008756652474403381, 0.023875156417489052, -0.03005245141685009, 0.01559101976454258, -0.00866775494068861, 0.03630199283361435, 0.05193057283759117, -0.03503384441137314, -0.005933682434260845, 0.07959739863872528, -0.031527768820524216, 0.024943547323346138, 0.023284632712602615, 0.02168007381260395, -0.01226374413818121, -0.01742389425635338, 0.02112443372607231, 0.01327419001609087, 0.006872988305985928, -0.05862487107515335, 0.029964659363031387, -0.0005645147757604718, 0.034975457936525345, -0.01583765260875225, 0.02804616466164589, 0.01707926206290722, -0.06075527146458626, -0.016508689150214195, 0.038643039762973785, 0.062238868325948715, -0.05224651098251343, 0.01065660361200571, 0.024479594081640244, 0.06454329192638397, -0.03341028466820717, -0.01714511215686798, -0.022228887304663658, -0.016394903883337975, 0.0008622535387985408, -0.01997276395559311, -0.0040931133553385735, 0.01270510908216238, 0.03890194371342659, 0.037616536021232605, -0.0110659534111619, 0.019075453281402588, -0.0009888362837955356, 0.0020322015043348074, -0.005219247657805681, 0.027529124170541763, 0.06949924677610397, 0.030546510592103004, 0.02822023071348667, -0.019865132868289948, -0.012203347869217396, -0.01714661531150341, 0.006998830940574408, -0.10891196131706238, -0.014677992090582848, 0.009050168097019196, 0.016041560098528862, -0.058388546109199524, -0.00680161127820611, 0.046840786933898926, 0.04523234814405441, -0.026186570525169373, -0.0432099923491478, 0.033313900232315063, -0.006299447268247604, -0.029644079506397247, -0.020888829603791237, -0.03122003749012947, -0.014137747697532177, 0.049111396074295044, 0.07920564711093903, -0.06302468478679657, 0.022576337680220604, 0.0023957369849085808, -0.014847205020487309, -0.022229034453630447, -0.02520778775215149, 0.014280509203672409, 0.00044676385005004704, 0.011431502178311348, -0.0112759405747056, -0.002372977789491415, -0.012258866801857948, 0.03230831399559975, -0.0028611980378627777, 0.061662428081035614, 0.04171052575111389, -0.014180158264935017, 0.03268609941005707, -0.02555381879210472, -0.026495888829231262, -0.0064177727326750755, 0.022183822467923164, -0.024567725136876106, 0.026062702760100365, 0.06674671173095703, 0.008960552513599396, -0.015648163855075836, 0.060014091432094574, 0.0401545986533165, -0.0006941098836250603, -0.028001509606838226, -0.04481416568160057, -0.038933005183935165, -0.04621915519237518, 0.046892277896404266, 0.022138865664601326, 0.015898102894425392, -0.005262263584882021, -0.012854436412453651, 0.08648543804883957, 0.0012504208134487271, -0.012977964244782925, 0.002515463624149561, -0.01100129634141922, 0.013765928335487843, -0.007882869802415371, -0.024936717003583908, -0.008855028077960014, -0.009690719656646252, 0.04034445434808731, -0.015286272391676903, 0.04082454368472099, -0.029844600707292557, -0.0239216610789299, 0.01572231575846672, 0.03617963567376137, -0.03172040358185768, 0.009531534276902676, -0.07804230600595474, 0.012270748615264893, 0.016284829005599022, -0.03791021555662155, 0.006461263634264469, -0.02137155272066593, 0.02066929265856743, -0.008735856972634792, -0.04171222820878029, -0.052353374660015106, 0.004873638041317463, 0.021808065474033356, 0.02289876714348793, -0.07212274521589279, 0.017021184787154198, -0.02298915944993496, 0.027065347880125046, 0.062280990183353424, 0.07667414844036102, -0.011894640512764454, -0.03175186365842819, 0.022442691028118134, -0.007563481573015451, 0.0016294386005029082, -0.061023008078336716, 0.03144929185509682, -0.013285210356116295, -0.003859297139570117, 0.04628121480345726, -0.028484879061579704, -0.032764606177806854, -0.0003672755556181073, -0.002006084891036153, -0.011551140807569027, 0.020458094775676727, -0.04884227737784386, 0.11687692999839783, 0.05127137899398804, -0.008494419045746326, 0.011451361700892448, 0.05133143439888954, -0.028933867812156677, 0.02522527053952217, -0.018770946189761162, -0.0009506073547527194, -0.008082151412963867, -0.020367208868265152, -0.030654294416308403, -0.023663030937314034, -0.015965266153216362, 0.008097244426608086, -0.03657776489853859, 0.04533679783344269, 0.005630793049931526, 0.010188967920839787, 0.045459017157554626, -0.003649859456345439, 0.0034580484498292208, 0.031435757875442505, 0.028306839987635612, -0.0024225919041782618, 0.018482010811567307, -0.048875272274017334, 0.016960345208644867, -0.006332035176455975, 0.016563905403017998, 0.03147047013044357, -0.007556779310107231, -0.026242634281516075, -0.05008849874138832, 0.015208100900053978, -0.0471188947558403, -0.03327668458223343, 0.03687508776783943, 0.025014791637659073, 0.04351336136460304, 0.012053865939378738, -0.012170202098786831, -0.0247047059237957, 0.0177938099950552, -0.005089393816888332, -0.0056390222162008286, -0.016397500410676003, 0.0058531747199594975, 0.025057081133127213, 0.00023609399795532227, -0.07336682826280594, -0.013390901498496532, -0.017785290256142616, -0.027886580675840378, -0.008206858299672604, -0.03378772735595703, -0.015211786143481731, 0.016967838630080223, -0.02671036496758461, 0.016129564493894577, 0.03821469470858574, -0.02936968021094799, -0.009500882588326931, 0.004200242459774017, -0.005784538574516773, 0.0896608754992485, -0.007508530747145414, 0.0007413987186737359, 0.015291774645447731, 0.002033616416156292, -0.034686379134655, -0.020726950839161873, -0.02278398908674717, -0.007111913058906794, -0.013022740371525288, 0.00961819663643837, -0.009362340904772282, 0.008296780288219452, -0.028743643313646317, -0.012691749259829521, 0.028454385697841644, -0.005469128489494324, -0.00016606569988653064, -0.001103968475945294, -0.02879306860268116, -0.01761316880583763, -0.00830379594117403, -0.006290568970143795, -0.003010365879163146, -0.01445339061319828, -0.07078765332698822, -0.01727605052292347, -0.029703868553042412, -0.007008728105574846, 0.030369842424988747, 0.07282434403896332, -0.020974891260266304, -0.05687820538878441, -0.03065895475447178, 0.009941511787474155, 0.0063061886467039585, 0.0007272710208781064, -0.016217943280935287, -0.022634251043200493, 0.022115608677268028, -0.002096803393214941, -0.034350283443927765, -0.03870926424860954, 0.003912798594683409, 0.03917420282959938, -0.0024484279565513134, 0.02183910273015499, 0.02297070249915123, -0.00021872861543670297, -0.00785865355283022, 0.01027466170489788, -0.016380662098526955, -0.009389410726726055, -0.0031831481028348207, 0.014242758974432945, -0.01207897812128067, -0.002915661782026291, 0.046146027743816376, 0.019474957138299942, -0.0013401743490248919, 0.036200154572725296, 0.01089627854526043, -0.0031813818495720625, 0.04285532608628273, -0.03648674115538597, -0.05525972694158554, 0.03450983762741089, -0.027660023421049118, 0.060431066900491714, -0.00840816181153059, 0.004923840053379536, 0.029718397185206413, 0.05716802552342415, -0.03494076430797577, -0.015760399401187897, -0.006637170445173979, -0.029800904914736748, -0.01375537645071745, 0.011839134618639946, -0.029326142743229866, 0.0008702943450771272, 0.0037813426461070776, 0.018612394109368324, -0.003020995995029807, 0.026306049898266792, 0.011432704515755177, -0.025540770962834358, -0.007710678968578577, -0.025251643732190132, -0.05867941305041313, 0.055584054440259933, 0.005539029836654663, -0.02129148133099079, 0.01158025860786438, 0.008716541342437267, 0.03377538174390793, 0.016153069213032722, 0.004716505296528339, 0.026241306215524673, 0.05590806156396866, -0.021098095923662186, 0.027310559526085854, -0.037107329815626144, 0.0029876206535845995, 0.13951310515403748, 0.036734603345394135, 0.015516972169280052, -0.03328847885131836, -0.03394322842359543, 0.008161252364516258, 0.03444194793701172, -0.007966484874486923, 0.00341300037689507, 0.014907636679708958, -0.017654191702604294, 0.010511351749300957, 0.06550102680921555, -0.03955210745334625, 0.035342924296855927, 0.02169509045779705, -0.01780238188803196, -0.010409747250378132, 0.007248364854604006, 0.036451179534196854, 0.02627558819949627, 0.007347756996750832, -0.05392908677458763, 0.022115224972367287, -0.041542790830135345, 0.0014828478451818228, -0.05207567289471626, 0.0030865848530083895, 0.01281392015516758, -0.01622256636619568, -0.04700072482228279, 0.0016100815264508128, 0.052623867988586426, -0.04606153443455696, 0.008484991267323494, 0.009257475845515728, 0.014158185571432114, 0.005273349117487669, -0.0001834077702369541, 0.07938242703676224, 0.012566291727125645, -0.008281893096864223, 0.0008597654523327947, 0.006774402689188719, -0.016697559505701065, -0.031262289732694626, -0.05275197699666023, 0.007609133142977953, -0.007888218387961388, -0.04353544861078262, -0.014259520918130875, 0.035505544394254684, -0.009425443597137928, -0.027564145624637604, -0.012764783576130867, -0.01309134904295206, 0.04578977823257446, -0.0186131801456213, -0.017395678907632828, 0.0019272216595709324, 0.026418587192893028, 0.025429558008909225, -0.010410766117274761, 0.009814930148422718, -0.05794437974691391, -0.03833044320344925, -0.01234174519777298, 0.03857040777802467, 0.014876637607812881, -0.030538978055119514, 0.02792293019592762, -0.006398034747689962, -0.0023301467299461365, -0.0017053209012374282, -0.015966691076755524, 0.019834714010357857, 0.037041645497083664, 0.0322505421936512, -0.04280975088477135, 0.017789723351597786, -0.070526123046875, 0.010131573304533958, -0.018075982108712196, 0.002815073821693659, -0.03817807137966156, -0.03198230639100075, -0.01106629241257906, 0.0005310709238983691, 0.00972055085003376, 0.02278890833258629, -0.005793903023004532, 0.06763909757137299, 0.021362531930208206, 0.0005584890604950488, -0.013839651830494404, 0.016239387914538383, 0.004163721576333046, -0.007811767049133778, -0.014364813454449177, 0.05653799697756767, 0.0047234282828867435, -0.034548576921224594, 0.02814822643995285, 0.032434482127428055, -0.022813772782683372, 0.040856264531612396, -0.007437460124492645, -0.03833913803100586, 0.0391695611178875, 0.03441908210515976, 0.024155136197805405, -0.050136029720306396, -0.026794178411364555, -0.032720454037189484, 0.015660028904676437, 0.0000025223757802450564, 0.01544464286416769, -0.025744933634996414, 0.004784893244504929, -0.03136668726801872, 0.002056096913293004, -0.03435017168521881, -0.023157885298132896, -0.027837486937642097, 0.0216584000736475, -0.002276254817843437, 0.01142220851033926, -0.022906867787241936, 0.04570211470127106, -0.01800418458878994, -0.010061265900731087, 0.015551171265542507, 0.013141131028532982, -0.01457605604082346, -0.056818101555109024, 0.023865874856710434, 0.019513066858053207, 0.003153198165819049, 0.020398985594511032, -0.03373607620596886, 0.05781775340437889, -0.05632615461945534, -0.06068529188632965, 0.020783556625247, 0.007872141897678375, 0.0034692222252488136, 0.01222759298980236, -0.020365459844470024, -0.014631085097789764, 0.01900816336274147, -0.04486846178770065, -0.022506216540932655, -0.021787500008940697, 0.01360243745148182, 0.02139282040297985, -0.019954754039645195, -0.006156933959573507, -0.006946265231817961, 0.037611931562423706, -0.010084904730319977, 0.024965103715658188, -0.02268242835998535, 0.00837609264999628, 0.020108375698328018, -0.04796067997813225, -0.024167237803339958, -0.02329511195421219, -0.0018570913234725595, 0.05529482662677765, 0.04639353230595589, -0.013901133090257645, 0.0014790170826017857, -0.00812477059662342, -0.005295322276651859, -0.09324242919683456, -0.03541896119713783, 0.0015622660284861922, 0.016256267204880714, 0.02612362615764141, -0.04613685980439186, -0.011624759063124657, 0.0017123688012361526, -0.04304462671279907, 0.028635568916797638, -0.017061283811926842, 0.008219152688980103, -0.02878054417669773, -0.042714331299066544, -0.053292982280254364, 0.04711085557937622, 0.013362896628677845, 0.05624699220061302, 0.03244335204362869, 0.027124712243676186, -0.04076026380062103, -0.02432817406952381, 0.020694267004728317, -0.012986237183213234, 0.021921221166849136, -0.03507876396179199, 0.04509006813168526, -0.006245066877454519, 0.032495059072971344, 0.011113708838820457, -0.008524990640580654, -0.021073685958981514, -0.030305299907922745, -0.003753949422389269, -0.01085606124252081, 0.04453574866056442, -0.015531513839960098, -0.0042887055315077305, 0.017720937728881836, -0.0036979278083890676, 0.009334415197372437, -0.005275091156363487, 0.017433244735002518, 0.0227535180747509, 0.06661109626293182, 0.00872240774333477, -0.04111315310001373, 0.03335965424776077, 0.021712128072977066, -0.0044669960625469685, -0.02687031775712967, -0.04523174837231636, 0.022241566330194473, -0.0077006942592561245, 0.009664604440331459, -0.016403252258896828, -0.023641731590032578, 0.004534549079835415, 0.015253249555826187, 0.012744245119392872, 0.0396963469684124, 0.0038823727518320084, -0.03578942269086838, 0.02119835838675499, 0.050752028822898865, -0.001444785506464541, -0.008966932073235512, -0.033123958855867386, -0.003809252753853798, 0.02712211385369301, -0.008781852200627327, -0.005690182093530893, -0.028962669894099236, 0.008754045702517033, -0.014683553017675877, -0.0040685441344976425, -0.03647353872656822, -0.0444549061357975, -0.016911832615733147, -0.07896880060434341, 0.008621031418442726, -0.011632093228399754, -0.017967630177736282, -0.002424725564196706, 0.03103584237396717, 0.006445989478379488, -0.011898626573383808, 0.03151451051235199, 0.007616344373673201, -0.021965010091662407, 0.014992034994065762, 0.014812933281064034, 0.04078642278909683, -0.07173826545476913, -0.0048515223897993565, -0.04385245591402054, 0.01227673888206482, -0.02369782328605652, 0.04469633102416992, 0.01646573282778263, 0.034920405596494675, 0.02454168163239956, 0.0044721877202391624, -0.024909593164920807, -0.01999206654727459, 0.00809910986572504, 0.015425416640937328, 0.0003768330789171159, -0.03196796402335167, 0.03972376883029938, -0.006526049226522446, -0.012499812990427017, 0.009352598339319229, -0.0010398452868685126, -0.04384982958436012, 0.01811758428812027, -0.02785276621580124, -0.01083625853061676, -0.015903247520327568, 0.0023023830726742744, 0.008955452591180801, -0.04073486849665642, -0.010700714774429798, 0.06536462903022766, -0.010350464843213558, -0.028698531910777092, 0.03554127365350723, 0.04708503186702728, 0.05983062833547592, 0.03294460475444794, 0.0161028690636158, -0.03229255974292755, 0.005129244178533554, 0.03879501298069954, -0.02087738923728466, 0.053657032549381256, -0.02076752483844757, 0.02178664691746235, -0.012472293339669704, -0.018919114023447037, 0.015477832406759262, 0.024974944069981575, 0.04032698646187782, 0.002177431946620345, -0.015952127054333687, 0.056378643959760666, 0.00435996986925602, -0.021547870710492134, 0.008713195100426674, -0.03155085816979408, 0.08823513984680176, 0.009693926200270653, 0.01940322108566761, -0.006347364280372858, 0.0010819380404427648, -0.015263061970472336, 0.046864625066518784, 0.024020764976739883, 0.055760350078344345, -0.015470647253096104, -0.002855895319953561, -0.009860319085419178, 0.015388596802949905, 0.006314906291663647, -0.018604902550578117, 0.017083927989006042, 0.046753160655498505, -0.0015144033823162317, -0.029626166447997093, -0.006511359941214323, 0.029711853712797165, -0.04606778919696808, 0.03600449860095978, 0.044253140687942505, -0.028543127700686455, -0.006626267917454243, -0.029056621715426445, 0.001300603966228664, 0.06541343778371811, -0.03963679075241089, -0.014439527876675129, -0.018445134162902832, 0.0017860515508800745, 0.02954290248453617, 0.00044805483776144683 ]
<p>I've been studying both discrete- and continuous-time Markov chains under stationarity assumption. Now I'm trying to move to non-stationary Markov chains. I did some google search and checked both Ross and Karlin on stochastic processes, but couldn't find anything. I'm hoping that someone can provide me with some references on this topic. Much appreciated.</p>
74,133
[ 0.01660737581551075, -0.044990114867687225, -0.01176413893699646, 0.005871691275388002, 0.011796016246080399, -0.007786346599459648, 0.004503762349486351, -0.004739799071103334, 0.008651996962726116, -0.040007226169109344, 0.0028232012409716845, 0.040421582758426666, 0.06058289855718613, 0.01584480330348015, 0.005952264182269573, -0.01571616530418396, -0.009693043306469917, -0.03548988699913025, -0.028865884989500046, 0.014479768462479115, 0.007735156454145908, 0.006376497447490692, 0.01876034587621689, 0.007428828626871109, -0.02530180849134922, 0.02548832632601261, 0.0014970873016864061, 0.03701137378811836, 0.007365286350250244, 0.05117737874388695, -0.04786858707666397, -0.020055824890732765, -0.02729485183954239, 0.06836964190006256, 0.013797106221318245, 0.007824443280696869, -0.057036012411117554, -0.07438444346189499, -0.006646022200584412, 0.019118791446089745, -0.03729880973696709, -0.012085260823369026, -0.007157661020755768, 0.040505364537239075, -0.030276047065854073, 0.02687264420092106, 0.011642771773040295, 0.008302791975438595, 0.04634776711463928, -0.05391314625740051, 0.10196597129106522, -0.04874987155199051, 0.02233811654150486, 0.03109295479953289, -0.016666214913129807, 0.00984047632664442, 0.06803750991821289, 0.03531759977340698, 0.017259251326322556, -0.036960337311029434, 0.0026155400555580854, -0.03591356426477432, 0.01049920916557312, -0.04141971096396446, -0.030366569757461548, 0.03892401605844498, -0.002061407081782818, -0.043424177914857864, 0.04440594092011452, -0.005329946056008339, -0.0015786993317306042, -0.011486437171697617, 0.08779185265302658, -0.01759624108672142, -0.0015419831033796072, -0.027701841667294502, 0.017098108306527138, -0.005949962418526411, 0.007268093526363373, 0.025479644536972046, 0.02111375331878662, 0.0011679024901241064, 0.020144671201705933, 0.011232955381274223, -0.027114007622003555, -0.020667770877480507, 0.0789717510342598, -0.014101458713412285, 0.002212503459304571, 0.0088501563295722, -0.012934267520904541, -0.011378886178135872, 0.030403845012187958, -0.006029982585459948, -0.04774228855967522, 0.0162055604159832, -0.007141750771552324, 0.023156482726335526, -0.010922021232545376, -0.025675762444734573, -0.0046805827878415585, -0.0522933304309845, 0.03039013408124447, 0.04414766654372215, 0.0068478877656161785, 0.022342396900057793, 0.0014690135139971972, -0.0038448600098490715, -0.02605990506708622, -0.0007757769199088216, -0.09961759299039841, -0.01126998569816351, 0.008442436344921589, 0.004027315881103277, 0.00736908009275794, 0.0021363229025155306, -0.020235121250152588, -0.014155835844576359, 0.03184505179524422, 0.10081809014081955, 0.013525882735848427, -0.0022534169256687164, 0.049274981021881104, -0.0391286164522171, -0.07613631337881088, 0.03319990634918213, 0.00622014794498682, -0.024284761399030685, -0.0330873467028141, 0.06490008533000946, 0.003096929984167218, -0.024305444210767746, 0.028141357004642487, -0.01619349978864193, 0.06564774364233017, -0.05589066445827484, -0.07242229580879211, 0.009315037168562412, 0.054461121559143066, -0.017353011295199394, 0.0331919863820076, -0.05970439314842224, 0.026430588215589523, 0.015982791781425476, 0.047900471836328506, 0.012082609347999096, 0.024543285369873047, -0.006582602392882109, 0.03905026987195015, -0.00608350895345211, -0.02472829446196556, -0.02314640022814274, 0.0049213538877666, -0.010818473994731903, 0.018089892342686653, -0.08167373389005661, 0.03550639748573303, 0.03673885390162468, -0.01958126202225685, -0.03595555201172829, 0.05014526844024658, 0.010021066293120384, -0.04146692529320717, -0.0022566751576960087, 0.019279778003692627, -0.04292050749063492, 0.052497923374176025, -0.004043251741677523, 0.01549266092479229, -0.021263113245368004, 0.03708702325820923, 0.03968449681997299, -0.012959674932062626, 0.04800661280751228, 0.05269328132271767, -0.04907436668872833, -0.010410930030047894, 0.0368167944252491, -0.008177770301699638, 0.025393346324563026, -0.04245108738541603, 0.001219464000314474, -0.00454018684104085, -0.012869236059486866, -0.016995061188936234, 0.05807601660490036, -0.00469566835090518, 0.004142818506807089, 0.01969844289124012, -0.0357089601457119, -0.028940929099917412, -0.030809124931693077, 0.016036424785852432, -0.013177708722651005, -0.0019886144436895847, 0.08295414596796036, 0.03248406574130058, 0.025600114837288857, -0.04766508936882019, -0.028084272518754005, -0.020882150158286095, -0.036710407584905624, 0.00036715195165015757, -0.06942840665578842, -0.0071625798009335995, 0.050352487713098526, 0.01779872365295887, -0.013526774011552334, 0.016231752932071686, -0.052352648228406906, -0.03125372529029846, -0.000496459542773664, -0.03221699595451355, 0.0319255031645298, -0.034526560455560684, -0.019943539053201675, 0.023497994989156723, -0.03085959702730179, 0.00458849873393774, 0.00908637698739767, -0.020170103758573532, 0.024347437545657158, 0.059280455112457275, 0.026201719418168068, -0.006032847333699465, 0.028203703463077545, 0.033453989773988724, 0.009440606459975243, -0.023021407425403595, -0.029011037200689316, -0.020066658034920692, -0.02901133894920349, 0.0545269250869751, 0.01876133680343628, -0.04789012670516968, -0.005449430085718632, 0.038065921515226364, 0.05375313386321068, 0.01430896483361721, 0.03639385476708412, -0.015578960999846458, -0.02547047846019268, 0.03047143667936325, 0.009750835597515106, 0.015405570156872272, 0.00015645616804249585, 0.005459606181830168, -0.028917429968714714, 0.02817608043551445, -0.008824631571769714, -0.049937982112169266, 0.027449561282992363, -0.017048072069883347, 0.014893890358507633, 0.005868936888873577, -0.059045810252428055, 0.05974796041846275, -0.018926458433270454, 0.010199809446930885, -0.000716758833732456, 0.012453115545213223, 0.03192697837948799, 0.020121950656175613, -0.054264213889837265, -0.013472076505422592, 0.011119736358523369, -0.023766692727804184, -0.0010487146209925413, 0.0357414186000824, -0.009343016892671585, 0.022792140021920204, -0.01155201718211174, -0.031888484954833984, -0.032844435423612595, -0.016535189002752304, 0.04076262563467026, -0.0005823938408866525, 0.034218475222587585, -0.008034273982048035, 0.020437918603420258, -0.03117281012237072, -0.03500265255570412, 0.03570825606584549, 0.02211369201540947, -0.027482667937874794, 0.02164810709655285, -0.0011002179235219955, -0.04232596606016159, 0.017949173226952553, -0.01809014193713665, -0.001470564748160541, 0.038440629839897156, -0.012534860521554947, -0.047851502895355225, -0.013620820827782154, -0.012207236140966415, 0.009242935106158257, -0.03271691873669624, -0.0011100958799943328, 0.03808657079935074, 0.01778426393866539, -0.02147059701383114, 0.023969171568751335, -0.05584998428821564, -0.03160027787089348, -0.06058469042181969, -0.00341226439923048, 0.02005871757864952, -0.04599269852042198, 0.03948066756129265, 0.036107245832681656, -0.024464024230837822, 0.0002007271978072822, -0.01147572323679924, -0.0720462054014206, 0.020100131630897522, -0.007246289402246475, 0.04884522408246994, 0.0026030601002275944, -0.03509214520454407, 0.033718008548021317, -0.006517122965306044, -0.018739065155386925, -0.018208380788564682, -0.020117701962590218, -0.05491245910525322, -0.03314419463276863, 0.010614224709570408, 0.006128240842372179, -0.029690386727452278, 0.015589619055390358, 0.017909133806824684, -0.002121157944202423, 0.05141131207346916, 0.0077506424859166145, 0.015603694133460522, 0.035874076187610626, -0.023753387853503227, 0.03516830876469612, 0.028141150251030922, 0.005287679843604565, -0.042649831622838974, -0.00010408960224594921, -0.0060915276408195496, -0.0026880409568548203, 0.0003578616597224027, -0.019998574629426003, 0.03384137898683548, -0.0249421838670969, -0.01689811609685421, -0.03405436873435974, 0.006227289792150259, -0.022661535069346428, -0.013228611089289188, -0.006697980221360922, 0.015175244770944118, 0.004507975187152624, 0.0035206908360123634, 0.042007047683000565, 0.026070179417729378, 0.03001425229012966, -0.045986831188201904, -0.03242272511124611, -0.0194705743342638, -0.02422456257045269, 0.04901173338294029, -0.028294390067458153, -0.032211001962423325, 0.026844797655940056, -0.00208718772046268, -0.015509690158069134, 0.005173718091100454, -0.056967753916978836, -0.013764462433755398, -0.08269843459129333, 0.02483661100268364, -0.004762602970004082, 0.04584137350320816, 0.004482373595237732, 0.036620885133743286, -0.019731875509023666, -0.022097432985901833, 0.05165086314082146, 0.010284326039254665, -0.08158287405967712, 0.04293503984808922, -0.01947205699980259, -0.028642350807785988, 0.020513299852609634, 0.03862462192773819, 0.03156646341085434, -0.03205830603837967, -0.0027527115307748318, -0.0058603170327842236, 0.02122938446700573, -0.07610154896974564, -0.0030870181508362293, -0.06007524952292442, -0.022476591169834137, -0.0477663055062294, -0.00232196063734591, 0.03188426047563553, -0.040376923978328705, 0.00774901919066906, 0.07228200882673264, -0.03715284913778305, -0.013211501762270927, -0.0183909609913826, 0.014289462938904762, 0.04506392404437065, -0.0031286608427762985, 0.06499187648296356, 0.040002647787332535, -0.019600454717874527, 0.03875401243567467, 0.0062288022600114346, 0.04825640469789505, 0.017807800322771072, -0.0269315242767334, -0.022193651646375656, -0.02568826638162136, -0.02195681259036064, 0.00791298970580101, 0.01376922708004713, 0.06400065124034882, 0.0033410312607884407, 0.05286703258752823, 0.02492287941277027, -0.021735195070505142, 0.004650169517844915, 0.04915874823927879, 0.011605544947087765, 0.005398615729063749, -0.01097172498703003, 0.015382747165858746, -0.0008130361093208194, -0.001055476488545537, 0.024655399844050407, -0.007340226788073778, 0.00644492544233799, 0.0327027328312397, -0.0024909579660743475, -0.017587920650839806, 0.013957222923636436, -0.010476615279912949, -0.006184620317071676, 0.028183087706565857, -0.012193998321890831, -0.022153927013278008, 0.03631356358528137, -0.011197649873793125, 0.0066696577705442905, 0.034319594502449036, 0.03581816330552101, -0.0920531153678894, -0.009490814059972763, 0.04744669422507286, 0.006049034185707569, -0.04197810962796211, -0.014294696971774101, -0.042924728244543076, 0.003662106115370989, 0.05471217632293701, -0.019647788256406784, 0.05505666509270668, 0.021730056032538414, -0.021253647282719612, -0.02585672028362751, -0.023999152705073357, 0.0001024422817863524, 0.0031151166185736656, 0.0031833923421800137, 0.027863360941410065, 0.011627701111137867, -0.009685720317065716, -0.04475294053554535, -0.02616889402270317, -0.00011820243526017293, 0.08321399241685867, -0.0063374717719852924, 0.01217622309923172, -0.011225016787648201, 0.055502504110336304, 0.005986273754388094, -0.08117940276861191, 0.0076447888277471066, 0.022680548951029778, -0.026935545727610588, 0.03772663325071335, 0.003920797258615494, -0.04417042061686516, 0.006251640152186155, 0.0033826855942606926, -0.036752548068761826, -0.007671882398426533, -0.01840134896337986, 0.021014908328652382, 0.03143155202269554, -0.010128380730748177, 0.05317476764321327, 0.04457933083176613, -0.014215447939932346, 0.01725865714251995, 0.009733662009239197, 0.04710322245955467, -0.028650617226958275, 0.027697483077645302, -0.04237912967801094, -0.014002453535795212, -0.029164334759116173, 0.05308886989951134, -0.01276787556707859, 0.04895011708140373, -0.013591684401035309, 0.022594718262553215, -0.004602446686476469, 0.07005538046360016, 0.004565751645714045, 0.0015097669092938304, 0.022392796352505684, 0.0074872663244605064, -0.006921102758497, -0.032503657042980194, 0.007859397679567337, 0.0019804611802101135, -0.01624196581542492, -0.006461455021053553, -0.016674477607011795, -0.013770129531621933, -0.08251779526472092, -0.04779389873147011, 0.0080910325050354, -0.004415570758283138, 0.05079386755824089, 0.023066945374011993, 0.02189101092517376, -0.0033896793611347675, -0.06489144265651703, 0.007762668188661337, 0.024549923837184906, -0.018156178295612335, 0.018417781218886375, -0.06406962126493454, 0.02439354546368122, -0.023509379476308823, -0.005669556092470884, -0.06213430315256119, -0.07570166885852814, 0.04917965456843376, 0.0033309091813862324, -0.027751782909035683, -0.052397470921278, 0.048455432057380676, -0.025366978719830513, -0.029048649594187737, 0.017708204686641693, 0.04105857014656067, -0.004508048761636019, -0.0013067403342574835, 0.037410713732242584, 0.014224237762391567, 0.07313530147075653, -0.0007138000219129026, 0.005412477999925613, 0.004420669283717871, -0.011221623979508877, -0.02190259099006653, -0.03786049038171768, 0.03047674149274826, -0.017247913405299187, -0.01987219788134098, -0.032252416014671326, 0.013205274939537048, 0.056292448192834854, -0.04386546090245247, -0.007286575622856617, 0.0590980127453804, -0.007683608680963516, 0.03149788826704025, -0.020995566621422768, -0.011347453109920025, 0.002379022538661957, 0.0033583210315555334, -0.01405479945242405, 0.0013231541961431503, 0.020297342911362648, -0.010303347371518612, 0.008853865787386894, -0.017792772501707077, 0.014926028437912464, 0.03895633667707443, 0.03363775089383125, 0.001999404514208436, 0.019501274451613426, 0.027851659804582596, -0.035000164061784744, 0.021945040673017502, -0.026408430188894272, 0.02702810987830162, 0.007703318726271391, -0.006994550582021475, -0.06194581091403961, -0.052719324827194214, -0.003366752527654171, 0.009157974272966385, 0.031102154403924942, 0.016515575349330902, 0.06045100837945938, 0.021161217242479324, 0.010263084433972836, -0.004315847065299749, -0.018129803240299225, -0.017428766936063766, 0.00037468806840479374, -0.005608375184237957, 0.0493028350174427, -0.01684739626944065, 0.039482519030570984, 0.02809925749897957, -0.009397558867931366, 0.03691428154706955, 0.023220514878630638, -0.01615406945347786, 0.026891184970736504, 0.05472860485315323, 0.0006383990403264761, -0.02012033388018608, 0.041960008442401886, -0.02908925712108612, 0.013099106028676033, 0.006646181456744671, -0.026426443830132484, 0.025050688534975052, 0.02228500507771969, 0.020705999806523323, -0.021305134519934654, 0.0012601601192727685, -0.0590408518910408, 0.020221786573529243, -0.009527222253382206, -0.02038094773888588, 0.047463156282901764, 0.011135553009808064, 0.014189542271196842, 0.021682174876332283, 0.028391286730766296, 0.0020441794767975807, -0.0504126250743866, -0.014458575285971165, -0.04133802279829979, -0.03436512500047684, 0.029057661071419716, 0.017025893554091454, -0.01645420677959919, -0.016905879601836205, -0.03452954441308975, 0.025057977065443993, 0.03792715072631836, 0.05325830355286598, -0.00886659137904644, 0.10817144811153412, -0.03017972968518734, 0.04436686262488365, -0.0005164782633073628, 0.01816481538116932, 0.1084814965724945, 0.06142927706241608, 0.023741867393255234, -0.08511833101511002, -0.0022338200360536575, -0.036980610340833664, 0.025525016710162163, -0.016365602612495422, 0.024632643908262253, 0.020022530108690262, -0.03097419999539852, 0.025418158620595932, 0.02246681973338127, 0.0035918757785111666, -0.014170589856803417, 0.06871345639228821, -0.03502426669001579, -0.011737080290913582, 0.015106757171452045, 0.011198664084076881, -0.0018807025626301765, -0.006847898010164499, -0.027390144765377045, 0.02582373097538948, -0.026949221268296242, -0.020858028903603554, -0.02445501647889614, -0.01144871674478054, 0.010709812864661217, -0.0033576483838260174, -0.008165634237229824, -0.027444874867796898, -0.0075752162374556065, 0.0040895589627325535, -0.0024341633543372154, 0.016641749069094658, 0.006576123647391796, -0.014430207200348377, 0.04719952866435051, 0.044877346605062485, 0.026404986158013344, -0.01976284198462963, 0.031841449439525604, -0.005737015511840582, -0.024552421644330025, -0.0019733246881514788, -0.046664848923683167, 0.019746072590351105, -0.04879866912961006, 0.005425389390438795, -0.00008935927326092497, 0.007515928242355585, 0.03918905556201935, -0.008247311227023602, -0.005874296184629202, 0.009647734463214874, 0.03849997743964195, -0.06233642250299454, 0.004411404952406883, -0.04818004369735718, -0.008726676926016808, 0.012415621429681778, 0.03460569307208061, 0.01881585828959942, -0.04559930041432381, -0.010650542564690113, -0.013315241783857346, 0.017694886773824692, -0.03861609101295471, -0.012519270181655884, 0.013992576859891415, 0.035497359931468964, -0.05414336919784546, -0.03729511424899101, 0.0011426396667957306, -0.005758301820605993, 0.02051844634115696, -0.020735276862978935, -0.009758556261658669, 0.04333321377635002, -0.04952763393521309, 0.009481441229581833, -0.0371442586183548, -0.005835957825183868, -0.0007696055108681321, -0.007054242305457592, 0.056195542216300964, 0.007408123463392258, -0.02201717346906662, 0.004531486425548792, -0.03392896056175232, 0.013353383168578148, 0.029912659898400307, -0.08298718184232712, 0.01971535198390484, -0.019482446834445, -0.04765583574771881, -0.00633520632982254, -0.03268279507756233, 0.016150187700986862, 0.026059117168188095, -0.00015243547386489809, -0.03361229971051216, 0.01275284867733717, 0.0253550186753273, 0.010050728917121887, 0.0005098061519674957, -0.04544692859053612, 0.0060492511838674545, 0.009237997233867645, 0.020551392808556557, -0.0187955591827631, -0.0021143786143511534, -0.01317931804805994, 0.05315430462360382, -0.0064971656538546085, 0.005799564998596907, -0.012752430513501167, 0.011874877847731113, -0.024868058040738106, 0.01747731678187847, -0.0337056964635849, -0.020350733771920204, -0.005143171176314354, 0.008367273956537247, 0.002611391246318817, 0.026823842898011208, -0.04259563609957695, 0.012832810170948505, 0.01284609641879797, -0.015721520408988, 0.007633120287209749, 0.023626232519745827, -0.010392761789262295, -0.026434632018208504, 0.023018859326839447, -0.030936013907194138, 0.051463544368743896, -0.05735904350876808, -0.02208051271736622, 0.0338049978017807, -0.029833287000656128, -0.03452252596616745, 0.015594931319355965, -0.026474185287952423, 0.007411826867610216, 0.022435875609517097, -0.029496727511286736, -0.011799516156315804, 0.045855309814214706, -0.016662541776895523, -0.008535212837159634, -0.0201034564524889, 0.00755748525261879, 0.01509884838014841, 0.020083706825971603, 0.001782638835720718, 0.008567037992179394, -0.005721588619053364, 0.018733546137809753, 0.06131261587142944, -0.012503281235694885, -0.020420778542757034, -0.002318629529327154, -0.015979623422026634, 0.019806696102023125, 0.04199111834168434, -0.0027204311918467283, 0.053362876176834106, 0.07623980939388275, -0.03455343097448349, 0.013367358595132828, -0.02385074831545353, -0.019973859190940857, -0.05270042270421982, 0.003378798021003604, 0.0065169441513717175, -0.00563344219699502, 0.07913088798522949, -0.06650025397539139, -0.00722125917673111, 0.013679237104952335, -0.07027190923690796, -0.008129092864692211, 0.022064009681344032, -0.02381371706724167, -0.0487220324575901, -0.017303617671132088, -0.018376830965280533, 0.047863177955150604, 0.002756053814664483, 0.05092271417379379, 0.009318267926573753, 0.020208174362778664, -0.019872087985277176, 0.0025739341508597136, -0.010111186653375626, 0.03700156509876251, 0.010310191661119461, -0.013265851885080338, 0.04056490585207939, -0.04488709196448326, -0.028741255402565002, 0.03558703884482384, -0.022085025906562805, 0.023553384467959404, 0.01598774828016758, 0.012323149479925632, -0.035588257014751434, 0.036453817039728165, 0.023207662627100945, -0.015760047361254692, 0.05726736783981323, -0.010972210206091404, -0.004640208091586828, 0.030754992738366127, -0.006850924808532, 0.024760102853178978, 0.008493628352880478, -0.04934624210000038, -0.032325539737939835, 0.015536932274699211, -0.014876039698719978, -0.03568842262029648, 0.017685947939753532, -0.004053952172398567, -0.004566311836242676, 0.008108528330922127, 0.04863867163658142, -0.017392832785844803, -0.0019088319968432188, 0.028535719960927963, 0.0016078534536063671, 0.024777840822935104, -0.012879587709903717, -0.00564073259010911, -0.05131513625383377, 0.028775423765182495, -0.0040314276702702045, -0.0056557185016572475, -0.04558321088552475, -0.031106574460864067, -0.0156323853880167, -0.004367067478597164, -0.05087108165025711, -0.02849740907549858, -0.033761654049158096, 0.03716422617435455, 0.006872617173939943, 0.001960125518962741, 0.01089545153081417, -0.008285905234515667, 0.0061948285438120365, -0.056440453976392746, 0.05696965008974075, 0.013162749819457531, 0.01619633287191391, -0.06324151903390884, -0.004975488875061274, -0.024921676144003868, -0.02700754813849926, 0.05123617872595787, -0.03902268782258034, -0.005308446940034628, -0.004196970257908106, 0.0173724927008152, 0.01276278868317604, -0.023260757327079773, 0.0072755576111376286, -0.023015601560473442, -0.009799562394618988, 0.01136530190706253, -0.0021399925462901592, 0.022347282618284225, 0.04361296072602272, -0.003961723763495684, -0.0029578623361885548, 0.016763074323534966, 0.02133847586810589, -0.05980075150728226, 0.03820901736617088, 0.032447848469018936, -0.016125619411468506, 0.052130427211523056, -0.04381359741091728, 0.015274309553205967, -0.007644578814506531, -0.003633178537711501, -0.02481381967663765, 0.037469517439603806, -0.049738720059394836, 0.005691275931894779, 0.017502831295132637, -0.03085283748805523, 0.0015311161987483501, -0.020967401564121246, -0.0076300110667943954, 0.02584719844162464, -0.03597302362322807, 0.009294260293245316, 0.046980440616607666, 0.04274122044444084, 0.03571555018424988, 0.037954263389110565, -0.0011236330028623343, 0.017927803099155426, 0.0694776326417923, -0.000948738306760788, 0.030541716143488884, 0.030299238860607147, -0.0010139839723706245, 0.04089856892824173, 0.0028971184510737658, -0.0478837750852108, 0.06635341048240662, -0.010201611556112766, 0.0333038866519928, -0.028363320976495743, -0.030256550759077072, 0.006773108616471291, -0.0026260633021593094, 0.01663035899400711, 0.03298266604542732, -0.018523335456848145, 0.04162254184484482, -0.034294020384550095, 0.021738270297646523, 0.0012328701559454203, -0.004458511248230934, -0.004636387340724468, -0.04607006162405014, -0.039121322333812714, -0.012300802394747734, -0.03447443246841431, 0.029762836173176765, 0.033531177788972855, 0.007959520444273949, 0.02123895101249218, -0.05033374950289726, 0.03034467250108719, -0.0015208326512947679, 0.012139896862208843, -0.013441743329167366, -0.051535770297050476, -0.020647967234253883, -0.008818401023745537, 0.017690865322947502, 0.06982932239770889, 0.003695171792060137, 0.014763114042580128, -0.0030649842228740454, -0.03045474737882614, 0.04912889748811722, -0.05718739330768585, 0.004334636032581329, -0.04112671688199043, -0.001360262860544026, -0.024061856791377068, 0.012459367513656616 ]
<p>When teaching regression, I used to do an exercise where students would try to guess where the line of best fit is on a scatterplot, and get the sums of squares. They'd move the line around, see how the slope and intercept changed, and see how the sum of squared residuals changed.</p> <p>It shows that the line of best fit really does minimize the sums of squares, and it's fun, because you have a little competition to see who can get the lowest sum of squares. </p> <p>(It also teaches a little about how iterative approaches work.) </p> <p>This relied on a horrible, horrible feature of Excel - that you could click on a graph and drag a point, and it would update the data. (Not that we need a reason to dislike Excel for data analysis).</p> <p>I've a vague memory of seeing a java (possibly) app, many years ago that did this, but I can't find it now. Is there something else out there?</p>
74,134
[ -0.018268074840307236, -0.0056193978525698185, 0.013034489005804062, -0.0007289097411558032, 0.030317438766360283, 0.03213442862033844, 0.03263744339346886, 0.0010271792998537421, 0.04691784456372261, -0.02266477420926094, 0.06550999730825424, 0.05494004115462303, 0.040879618376493454, 0.014687836170196533, 0.010557806119322777, -0.02704998292028904, -0.05210927501320839, -0.001812016242183745, -0.027428729459643364, -0.014716270379722118, -0.014296415261924267, 0.007643116172403097, -0.0125947380438447, -0.02066224068403244, -0.013147632591426373, 0.028777223080396652, 0.040539104491472244, -0.049529947340488434, -0.03353222459554672, 0.08024469763040543, -0.04256558418273926, -0.022180845960974693, 0.014511138200759888, 0.04641034081578255, 0.07744497805833817, -0.00450763339176774, 0.02360537461936474, -0.02315165102481842, -0.021351883187890053, 0.036357562988996506, 0.004772021435201168, -0.023600684478878975, -0.006468256004154682, 0.019497426226735115, -0.010456093586981297, 0.0355261005461216, -0.028958618640899658, -0.04451039806008339, 0.04543126001954079, -0.035902753472328186, 0.07855618000030518, -0.004249432124197483, 0.03122583217918873, 0.04831041768193245, -0.053119659423828125, 0.01408387441188097, 0.02221684157848358, 0.02064725011587143, 0.01768479496240616, -0.04649929702281952, 0.007949699647724628, -0.037467364221811295, -0.012357553467154503, 0.002189680701121688, -0.0876491442322731, 0.03643104434013367, -0.0068186381831765175, -0.018495777621865273, 0.027754001319408417, -0.015641143545508385, -0.034231532365083694, 0.04256331920623779, 0.06355321407318115, -0.03864669427275658, 0.00008037412771955132, -0.04110613092780113, 0.013003800995647907, 0.017715852707624435, 0.057446543127298355, 0.030168773606419563, 0.006148566026240587, 0.03235520422458649, 0.025323498994112015, 0.033846285194158554, 0.011327124200761318, -0.012866955250501633, 0.05695454031229019, -0.02162224054336548, 0.006396586075425148, 0.0660819262266159, 0.018545759841799736, -0.018682774156332016, 0.02320784702897072, 0.020716672763228416, -0.024033503606915474, -0.007488016039133072, -0.007569719571620226, 0.0032353934366256, 0.002756423782557249, -0.014262630604207516, 0.021589944139122963, -0.018323106691241264, -0.019394241273403168, 0.03186950832605362, -0.026564935222268105, -0.01815769262611866, -0.006431363057345152, 0.020267659798264503, -0.0013860268518328667, -0.002906800713390112, -0.019151877611875534, -0.009234936907887459, 0.027449922636151314, 0.009617427363991737, 0.01465747132897377, -0.01039897557348013, -0.02507089078426361, -0.006928550079464912, 0.04777228459715843, 0.049538321793079376, 0.01858336292207241, -0.05499470233917236, 0.003147218143567443, -0.03674371540546417, -0.04804803058505058, 0.0016916102031245828, 0.007792838849127293, -0.05070330947637558, -0.05815349891781807, 0.05842883884906769, -0.029591381549835205, -0.02238083817064762, 0.04523325338959694, 0.017804957926273346, 0.029872125014662743, -0.0003588189138099551, -0.05772947892546654, -0.06574372947216034, 0.03516700118780136, -0.020907262340188026, -0.003519743215292692, -0.022543340921401978, -0.024362318217754364, 0.03026038035750389, 0.06325259804725647, 0.022831374779343605, 0.002173274988308549, -0.005122059490531683, 0.02561611868441105, -0.007935836911201477, -0.00124742416664958, -0.0171393770724535, -0.0035178428515791893, -0.032861217856407166, -0.012406925670802593, -0.06776345521211624, 0.004931882955133915, 0.03083025850355625, -0.012066229246556759, -0.012007049284875393, 0.04316982254385948, 0.032596785575151443, -0.0019933898001909256, 0.002934149233624339, -0.045411013066768646, -0.0169250275939703, 0.09317728132009506, 0.016498379409313202, 0.01808325946331024, 0.026626234874129295, -0.014113875105977058, 0.023506317287683487, 0.01842550002038479, 0.020086627453565598, 0.048054538667201996, -0.024172428995370865, -0.01875825598835945, -0.00035598475369624794, 0.003662644885480404, 0.004900319967418909, -0.021732309833168983, -0.030783142894506454, 0.02586500532925129, 0.01207900419831276, 0.022937409579753876, 0.06712552160024643, -0.02388066239655018, -0.02074533887207508, 0.03798902779817581, -0.0720970630645752, -0.01103226188570261, -0.07684256881475449, 0.031246041879057884, 0.013147402554750443, -0.011130496859550476, -0.018823234364390373, 0.020776260644197464, 0.016060547903180122, -0.019017506390810013, -0.030803009867668152, -0.00945126824080944, 0.006257557310163975, 0.031080152839422226, -0.03511052206158638, -0.014230296947062016, 0.06403283029794693, 0.04158054292201996, -0.02870587259531021, 0.025374166667461395, -0.07124024629592896, -0.027375439181923866, -0.038098376244306564, -0.052694760262966156, 0.006473254878073931, -0.019904254004359245, -0.000470649974886328, -0.038986995816230774, -0.00024286883126478642, 0.012048100121319294, -0.0020199869759380817, -0.012614024803042412, 0.017795324325561523, 0.05333055555820465, 0.02433616667985916, 0.011761839501559734, -0.0023975337389856577, -0.009986321441829205, 0.024364791810512543, -0.0008934745565056801, -0.005583376158028841, 0.001225825515575707, 0.002406877698376775, 0.0263994000852108, 0.016250064596533775, -0.028328364714980125, -0.014882335439324379, 0.08403486758470535, 0.03479083999991417, 0.011383953504264355, 0.006639508530497551, -0.028024611994624138, 0.02586360089480877, -0.04472891613841057, 0.012852474115788937, 0.016670063138008118, 0.0006233438034541905, 0.014907983131706715, 0.03196687996387482, 0.01692420244216919, 0.04128383845090866, -0.03134439140558243, -0.005918699782341719, 0.027168020606040955, -0.03352539986371994, -0.022373132407665253, -0.007480435073375702, 0.02811557613313198, -0.028528299182653427, 0.01928490214049816, 0.0155899403616786, 0.01593691110610962, -0.02891473099589348, 0.01682847924530506, -0.009699114598333836, -0.006797407753765583, 0.008631093427538872, -0.006513822823762894, 0.014537028968334198, 0.029069527983665466, -0.020146764814853668, 0.05191252380609512, -0.02972249686717987, -0.026631152257323265, -0.03629375621676445, 0.01735466532409191, -0.014023356139659882, 0.025606704875826836, 0.022912492975592613, -0.019839268177747726, -0.014899139292538166, -0.01814533956348896, -0.02002449333667755, 0.035519927740097046, 0.010202011093497276, -0.027830693870782852, 0.009384291246533394, -0.006947705522179604, 0.004453536123037338, 0.037318963557481766, 0.02447819523513317, 0.00706019252538681, 0.043921083211898804, 0.0020141161512583494, -0.04813768342137337, -0.033186957240104675, -0.047655779868364334, -0.015230349265038967, -0.032416172325611115, 0.03961110860109329, 0.009167204611003399, 0.010053258389234543, -0.03908393904566765, 0.045995693653821945, -0.044622574001550674, -0.012484760954976082, -0.06611675769090652, -0.012085814028978348, 0.01887047290802002, 0.013584299944341183, -0.00016610758029855788, 0.014212334528565407, -0.023413030430674553, 0.013172854669392109, -0.05489306524395943, -0.05212414637207985, 0.00407770648598671, -0.004550989251583815, 0.028118373826146126, 0.00024489196948707104, -0.003470011055469513, 0.041656021028757095, 0.03268404304981232, -0.04607830569148064, -0.06194259226322174, 0.018624356016516685, 0.021966243162751198, -0.03186172991991043, 0.036857347935438156, -0.019749026745557785, -0.0015436456305906177, -0.012146164663136005, -0.09143488109111786, 0.02146492339670658, 0.056937992572784424, 0.025809453800320625, 0.01654374971985817, 0.011050972156226635, -0.03326515108346939, 0.01121297013014555, 0.03207037225365639, 0.025039853528141975, -0.03501801937818527, 0.0007041798089630902, 0.012100201100111008, 0.021314185112714767, 0.010967030189931393, -0.062601737678051, -0.0011118225520476699, -0.0023173035588115454, 0.0050309449434280396, -0.0010993259493261576, 0.00760118430480361, 0.022837433964014053, 0.028259558603167534, -0.0013453586725518107, 0.060760270804166794, 0.037161413580179214, 0.0025833123363554478, 0.0030951551161706448, 0.004806655924767256, 0.02646656520664692, -0.025447048246860504, 0.03462493419647217, 0.013305517844855785, 0.009693874046206474, 0.016103582456707954, 0.006951748859137297, -0.030142465606331825, 0.06231911852955818, 0.01945170760154724, -0.002655095886439085, -0.00965152308344841, -0.08490206301212311, 0.010938914492726326, -0.07799305021762848, -0.02805151604115963, 0.016479527577757835, 0.05151524022221565, -0.00273427227512002, 0.029192091897130013, -0.00630748737603426, 0.022013133391737938, 0.02717566303908825, -0.004990445915609598, -0.09565122425556183, 0.05875672027468681, -0.01804439164698124, -0.023708881810307503, -0.002391217276453972, 0.02308719791471958, 0.010777094401419163, -0.02746124006807804, 0.017505453899502754, -0.009265498258173466, -0.00040209112921729684, -0.026025764644145966, 0.011178298853337765, -0.010228223167359829, -0.0013559999642893672, -0.014270949177443981, 0.004642787855118513, 0.0452752448618412, -0.031109202653169632, 0.055755697190761566, 0.002635434502735734, -0.03272462263703346, -0.007235280238091946, 0.0015862887958064675, -0.01548552792519331, 0.035281211137771606, 0.0012359136017039418, -0.017203696072101593, 0.014583914540708065, -0.06118185445666313, 0.04934072867035866, -0.04059102013707161, 0.02033519372344017, 0.010683534666895866, -0.010358178988099098, 0.015727300196886063, -0.0299077071249485, -0.006969242822378874, 0.009853807277977467, 0.01799197494983673, -0.009523841552436352, -0.0005683648632839322, 0.025904616340994835, 0.025914279744029045, -0.049689095467329025, 0.030751634389162064, 0.09912673383951187, 0.0056603895500302315, -0.0050522200763225555, 0.0008519907714799047, -0.02321801334619522, -0.0011855135671794415, -0.014497405849397182, 0.02004217728972435, 0.005386540200561285, -0.0036497151013463736, -0.024294201284646988, 0.02440536580979824, -0.01917349360883236, -0.0013208981836214662, -0.017591048032045364, -0.016126658767461777, 0.04569019377231598, -0.010778786614537239, 0.01691310666501522, 0.044021811336278915, 0.04706824570894241, -0.004528129007667303, 0.016679197549819946, 0.014442404732108116, -0.08988367021083832, -0.011916681192815304, 0.032544173300266266, 0.03832704573869705, -0.022104386240243912, -0.005934675224125385, -0.01897001639008522, -0.04003274068236351, 0.05795853212475777, -0.047630660235881805, 0.02845279686152935, 0.014293584041297436, 0.014916026964783669, -0.055889565497636795, -0.02870204485952854, -0.04227057471871376, 0.009146849624812603, -0.03672536090016365, 0.028288977220654488, -0.020442383363842964, 0.0054256203584373, -0.06185181066393852, 0.015032259747385979, -0.010575917549431324, 0.06922512501478195, -0.005928671453148127, -0.005955411121249199, 0.023924551904201508, 0.004373212344944477, -0.07628576457500458, -0.04586336016654968, -0.0033857598900794983, 0.023480409756302834, -0.040310610085725784, 0.05234117433428764, -0.0039807530120015144, -0.057771582156419754, 0.037557754665613174, -0.005146484822034836, -0.02449941076338291, -0.0075230589136481285, -0.04290861636400223, 0.014357675798237324, 0.05848720669746399, 0.03383177891373634, 0.038711681962013245, 0.06573832780122757, -0.018559018149971962, -0.006040566600859165, -0.005284092854708433, 0.0058344039134681225, -0.0025565961841493845, -0.055558111518621445, -0.03732021152973175, -0.02943345345556736, -0.028976233676075935, 0.0016594092594459653, 0.016347648575901985, 0.01997402310371399, -0.030592812225222588, -0.018160494044423103, -0.03526290878653526, 0.0533742755651474, -0.004390395246446133, 0.02025059424340725, 0.07354392856359482, 0.028836559504270554, 0.013169201090931892, -0.043068766593933105, 0.031044047325849533, 0.006852663587778807, -0.023677749559283257, 0.03788693621754646, -0.004366314969956875, -0.007677935995161533, -0.045130081474781036, -0.010649079456925392, 0.003585402388125658, -0.04322945326566696, 0.04442286863923073, -0.027650445699691772, 0.026264719665050507, 0.02265431173145771, -0.02106468193233013, -0.030100198462605476, 0.020261110737919807, 0.01401895098388195, -0.0299601461738348, -0.02054690569639206, 0.03543207421898842, -0.011434534564614296, -0.0022251487243920565, -0.036690279841423035, -0.05767050385475159, 0.01146711502224207, 0.0038121608085930347, -0.04297477379441261, -0.027590587735176086, -0.0007979562506079674, -0.002979215933009982, -0.022511132061481476, 0.01119569968432188, 0.010146049782633781, -0.03695216402411461, -0.014853198081254959, 0.02773169055581093, 0.022971563041210175, 0.029872890561819077, -0.005209427326917648, 0.014863981865346432, 0.021756866946816444, -0.026700451970100403, -0.01823495328426361, 0.04522979259490967, 0.03877640888094902, -0.02562442608177662, 0.02276630699634552, -0.045620083808898926, 0.011180681176483631, 0.03167358413338661, -0.011458114720880985, 0.0030098743736743927, 0.044245459139347076, -0.008227931335568428, -0.017534205690026283, -0.06193066015839577, 0.016388988122344017, -0.020156927406787872, -0.009920556098222733, -0.01491518598049879, 0.006266585551202297, 0.0485176257789135, -0.00196242006495595, -0.015578017570078373, 0.03434719890356064, -0.030649036169052124, -0.001090040197595954, 0.033179983496665955, -0.001235387404449284, -0.02819625660777092, 0.01066982839256525, 0.013990930281579494, 0.04746633768081665, 0.031229067593812943, 0.026430824771523476, -0.02653277851641178, 0.06313824653625488, -0.03265855461359024, -0.020166469737887383, -0.009710494428873062, 0.0024670439306646585, 0.05957527831196785, -0.039462555199861526, 0.05528982728719711, 0.09775624424219131, 0.0002141512231901288, -0.009933738969266415, -0.04610004648566246, -0.010931792668998241, -0.031873609870672226, -0.01822781376540661, 0.06600059568881989, -0.0018260058714076877, 0.0090587567538023, 0.04592311382293701, 0.03230249136686325, -0.000037101875932421535, 0.0103383120149374, -0.017493069171905518, 0.02659604139626026, 0.05196959897875786, -0.014910045079886913, -0.07849087566137314, 0.012753382325172424, -0.042095500975847244, 0.045095931738615036, 0.015603926032781601, -0.042584970593452454, 0.021779989823698997, -0.00523808179423213, 0.02467365749180317, -0.035103939473629, -0.009494027122855186, -0.044876448810100555, 0.02237236127257347, -0.015350720845162868, -0.028042053803801537, -0.0016477181343361735, -0.00840441882610321, 0.028559429571032524, -0.012227905914187431, 0.02342412807047367, -0.0699954405426979, -0.06672821938991547, -0.005164490547031164, 0.0044804830104112625, -0.011043339036405087, 0.018784422427415848, 0.021426541730761528, -0.030327390879392624, 0.011368338949978352, -0.022534720599651337, 0.0077610015869140625, 0.022481607273221016, 0.06434829533100128, 0.012261292897164822, 0.04689742252230644, -0.040793973952531815, -0.0007725019822828472, -0.011189302429556847, -0.006483548320829868, 0.13806059956550598, 0.060890939086675644, 0.07434497773647308, -0.050065796822309494, -0.005939122289419174, -0.00961809977889061, -0.031695593148469925, 0.012296035885810852, 0.007502452936023474, -0.00888819806277752, 0.02262062393128872, 0.053823649883270264, 0.06381430476903915, 0.01896747574210167, 0.0442570336163044, 0.029736487194895744, -0.04981130361557007, -0.03272091597318649, 0.009417707100510597, 0.0024568571243435144, 0.043492041528224945, 0.033244650810956955, -0.06302252411842346, 0.01167408935725689, -0.015557243488729, -0.040700074285268784, -0.011677484959363937, -0.04901651293039322, 0.01588071510195732, -0.0017137419199571013, -0.06931006163358688, 0.021319430321455002, 0.04181327670812607, 0.006675117649137974, -0.021093498915433884, 0.03369107097387314, 0.0002536099636927247, -0.01239570789039135, -0.0019163737306371331, 0.024169636890292168, 0.019014352932572365, 0.007210209034383297, 0.008742447942495346, -0.0032843167427927256, -0.0015538159059360623, -0.008298722095787525, -0.05535309016704559, 0.0343046635389328, -0.04305720701813698, -0.003024992998689413, -0.039914656430482864, -0.0014711678959429264, 0.02456376887857914, -0.029961565509438515, -0.034174155443906784, 0.025865279138088226, 0.036739952862262726, 0.029653379693627357, 0.006153469905257225, 0.032893694937229156, 0.021725350990891457, -0.015207418240606785, -0.0074936761520802975, 0.07242453098297119, -0.036986272782087326, -0.013711443170905113, -0.008639668114483356, 0.04653296619653702, -0.009145143441855907, -0.009376153349876404, 0.04445832222700119, -0.01722138375043869, 0.005448088515549898, -0.02089618146419525, 0.030348407104611397, 0.052576493471860886, 0.001793573726899922, -0.005830434150993824, -0.013292552903294563, -0.018750546500086784, -0.05255165323615074, 0.01657678745687008, -0.08180159330368042, 0.03201518580317497, -0.042248472571372986, -0.03276018798351288, 0.06132776290178299, 0.033510755747556686, 0.026069696992635727, 0.0009689164580777287, 0.0050707668997347355, 0.02911282889544964, -0.006057524587959051, -0.032599058002233505, -0.06052998825907707, 0.0116685526445508, -0.015551229938864708, 0.004407546482980251, -0.021424835547804832, 0.10078033804893494, 0.017767056822776794, 0.011913266964256763, -0.016288727521896362, 0.029532084241509438, -0.019085610285401344, 0.017709048464894295, -0.009617617353796959, -0.07047850638628006, 0.019549746066331863, -0.004704389721155167, -0.00807913113385439, -0.02593114972114563, 0.01581546477973461, -0.04132496938109398, -0.015103884041309357, -0.011999589391052723, 0.04420838877558708, -0.044634852558374405, 0.06704846024513245, -0.003506855573505163, 0.007791873067617416, -0.02652529627084732, 0.005584185477346182, -0.06560012698173523, -0.03896550461649895, 0.00873633287847042, -0.003822678467258811, -0.01967855729162693, 0.005822294391691685, -0.0059014116413891315, 0.06127138063311577, 0.03245832771062851, 0.030825261026620865, 0.025964219123125076, -0.002658575540408492, 0.02944246493279934, -0.00990331918001175, 0.016793007031083107, -0.018361562862992287, -0.010752273723483086, 0.02977524884045124, -0.03599152714014053, -0.05393321439623833, 0.002410449553281069, -0.04918605834245682, 0.014341137371957302, 0.03185330703854561, -0.009739730507135391, 0.0015415535308420658, 0.042684994637966156, 0.005693596322089434, -0.00845263246446848, -0.012698707170784473, 0.005652228835970163, 0.043931666761636734, 0.01185688003897667, 0.025298595428466797, -0.0417918786406517, -0.03497231379151344, -0.006420189514756203, 0.036913249641656876, -0.029338199645280838, 0.005555436946451664, -0.01729758456349373, -0.0015393734211102128, 0.002776350826025009, 0.006807910278439522, -0.026783697307109833, 0.03385811299085617, 0.013000229373574257, -0.046815283596515656, 0.03559032827615738, 0.03208230435848236, 0.039178505539894104, -0.05454113706946373, -0.01446810644119978, 0.00012336872168816626, 0.0158243328332901, 0.021195227280259132, -0.05539199709892273, 0.010482829995453358, 0.06137774512171745, -0.0555742084980011, 0.04497308284044266, -0.01382062304764986, 0.0007563476101495326, -0.01780596189200878, 0.035786766558885574, -0.0007582889520563185, -0.0011365425307303667, 0.008118247613310814, 0.05853006988763809, 0.028225434944033623, 0.012146039865911007, -0.013973334804177284, -0.013544405810534954, -0.0025225242134183645, 0.006759573705494404, 0.023131176829338074, -0.034677356481552124, -0.01576613448560238, -0.05154358595609665, -0.004507629666477442, 0.01081130001693964, -0.020100567489862442, 0.003183330874890089, -0.02403314970433712, 0.0018133391859009862, -0.0007092683808878064, 0.06301452964544296, 0.021287135779857635, -0.015627089887857437, -0.022849321365356445, -0.013292857445776463, -0.0022209137678146362, 0.06384817510843277, 0.003547523869201541, 0.051316265016794205, 0.03662276640534401, -0.00208826782181859, -0.040178388357162476, 0.0020082914270460606, 0.0024925193283706903, 0.021176224574446678, 0.01860656775534153, 0.00006379141996148974, -0.0012579833855852485, -0.0043451073579490185, -0.027257530018687248, -0.05418156459927559, 0.024793323129415512, 0.00811157189309597, 0.005541604943573475, -0.004768148995935917, 0.00484509440138936, 0.009987454861402512, -0.02151917852461338, -0.013389729894697666, -0.020575199276208878, 0.005698741879314184, -0.04482283815741539, 0.01493719220161438, 0.0010117406491190195, -0.018415337428450584, -0.011639337986707687, 0.002435295609757304, 0.015485500916838646, 0.044285647571086884, 0.01780356653034687, -0.021134046837687492, 0.017945215106010437, -0.027047088369727135, 0.023129655048251152, -0.057416122406721115, 0.08951089531183243, 0.03288058191537857, -0.012460923753678799, 0.015668001025915146, 0.017565900459885597, -0.011395317502319813, 0.02068997174501419, 0.025628142058849335, -0.0367780402302742, 0.05069653317332268, -0.044636499136686325, -0.01651906967163086, 0.026006583124399185, -0.013580170460045338, 0.06374343484640121, -0.003116680309176445, -0.0453353188931942, -0.01277779322117567, 0.001814926858060062, 0.013480622321367264, -0.0156545490026474, 0.03876061737537384, -0.0013727843761444092, -0.004805403761565685, -0.03416959568858147, -0.014407070353627205, -0.006580722518265247, 0.024878041818737984, -0.06412914395332336, 0.03881460428237915, 0.011289054527878761, -0.0043310862965881824, 0.011013185605406761, -0.001665739924646914, -0.004188104998320341, 0.03396512567996979, -0.04597868397831917, -0.013951350934803486, -0.0026808083057403564, -0.014726459048688412, -0.031579554080963135, -0.05756917968392372, -0.00412282207980752, 0.018881402909755707, -0.016088468953967094, -0.037695400416851044, 0.020519733428955078, 0.007332395762205124, 0.007835593074560165, 0.01498970203101635, 0.02063532918691635, 0.003025446552783251, 0.00733081204816699, -0.00022617286595050246, -0.007500631269067526, 0.022360188886523247, 0.029341774061322212, -0.0002023743581958115, 0.03725104033946991, 0.006752043962478638, 0.032568857073783875, -0.019057167693972588, 0.006353150587528944, -0.017556991428136826, -0.004563274793326855, 0.0008466208819299936, -0.03620179370045662, 0.008492796681821346, -0.024402862414717674, -0.006932182237505913, 0.031023479998111725, -0.05965176597237587, -0.016557257622480392, -0.04997739940881729, -0.0011814746540039778, -0.010605456307530403, -0.021752145141363144, -0.009862041100859642, 0.013305671513080597, -0.02343728579580784, -0.004333578050136566, 0.00039236433804035187, 0.0004022287903353572, 0.04764936491847038, 0.010569463483989239, 0.013436337932944298, -0.022471025586128235, -0.0057703545317053795, -0.03817863389849663, -0.011158877052366734, -0.0284633357077837, -0.007304583676159382, 0.005577176343649626, 0.02308071404695511, -0.0029544634744524956, -0.016709890216588974, -0.036752380430698395, -0.02379848062992096, 0.01710590347647667, -0.0802910104393959, -0.033950284123420715, -0.024747498333454132, 0.034569673240184784, 0.004634914919734001, -0.013725812546908855 ]
<p>I have this statement, but I want to be able to add a probability statement to it, like "I'm 87% sure.."</p> <p>Here is the data I have</p> <blockquote> <p>I'm 100.00% sure that grpn will go down the next day, because it's happened 3 of the last 3 times.<br> Min move of 0.66%<br> Max move of 16.54%<br> Avg move of 8.74% </p> </blockquote> <p>I want to say (obviously replacing X, Y, and Z)</p> <blockquote> <p>I'm 100.00% sure that grpn will go down the next day, because it's happened 3 times. I'm X% sure it will move at least .66% and Y% sure it will move 8.7% and Z% sure it will move 16.5%.</p> </blockquote>
36,808
[ -0.01018252782523632, -0.03234647959470749, 0.00441967137157917, 0.016155047342181206, 0.05092565715312958, 0.013461839407682419, 0.021279091015458107, -0.010405867360532284, 0.02220478095114231, 0.004398355260491371, 0.04291795939207077, 0.07253372669219971, 0.030181635171175003, 0.03022347018122673, -0.0069376626051962376, 0.01904059387743473, -0.01091451570391655, -0.018723323941230774, -0.04314674064517021, -0.03513253852725029, -0.02666221372783184, -0.006484278943389654, 0.005759022664278746, 0.011932904832065105, 0.009379789233207703, 0.024952895939350128, 0.047488559037446976, -0.01833542436361313, -0.006902998313307762, 0.08849313855171204, -0.017939439043402672, -0.04896801710128784, 0.008303492330014706, 0.04005054756999016, 0.04784463346004486, 0.047517940402030945, -0.017806654796004295, -0.027839606627821922, -0.009078522212803364, 0.010750720277428627, -0.0468965508043766, 0.03947295993566513, -0.00008649841765873134, 0.057554833590984344, -0.019884483888745308, 0.027814775705337524, -0.010236010886728764, 0.016310682520270348, 0.025719908997416496, -0.030804330483078957, 0.08897164463996887, -0.03603799641132355, 0.03594222292304039, 0.013809556141495705, 0.006272734608501196, 0.002647005720064044, 0.024681905284523964, 0.11586266756057739, 0.016704227775335312, -0.019787142053246498, 0.020321466028690338, -0.02063809707760811, -0.009974511340260506, -0.04027668386697769, 0.01989385299384594, 0.011876796372234821, -0.0298453476279974, -0.013203487731516361, 0.028100792318582535, -0.011234582401812077, 0.025128871202468872, 0.0002555592218413949, 0.07355665415525436, -0.024427838623523712, 0.025917137041687965, -0.05076891556382179, 0.007381780073046684, 0.00622567068785429, 0.022454246878623962, 0.029688069596886635, -0.008061466738581657, 0.017588261514902115, 0.02424021251499653, 0.0300911758095026, 0.02604343183338642, -0.04760843887925148, 0.040857478976249695, -0.018355032429099083, 0.03028089739382267, 0.051865700632333755, -0.014112903736531734, -0.00673765828832984, 0.05041521042585373, 0.019318826496601105, -0.03158770501613617, -0.020546555519104004, 0.0028411652892827988, 0.004243334289640188, -0.0032662684097886086, 0.01957709714770317, 0.008876563981175423, -0.04157976061105728, -0.004342677071690559, 0.03475551679730415, -0.04742730036377907, 0.03175849840044975, -0.010918986052274704, -0.058819886296987534, -0.024628277868032455, -0.009345040656626225, -0.007245360407978296, 0.041640445590019226, -0.003576008602976799, 0.02280089072883129, 0.012226558290421963, -0.04278687387704849, -0.024825619533658028, 0.020320264622569084, -0.00004932787851430476, 0.04247990995645523, 0.04802815243601799, 0.02204926311969757, 0.04510395973920822, -0.05650608614087105, -0.02644485794007778, -0.026458818465471268, 0.012060645967721939, 0.0032019023783504963, -0.05471044033765793, 0.06045833230018616, 0.014425542205572128, 0.01235852763056755, 0.012279381975531578, 0.0009077624999918044, 0.04921449348330498, -0.013972613960504532, -0.06562837213277817, -0.04379323497414589, 0.049969691783189774, 0.004867070820182562, 0.004327983129769564, -0.05949980765581131, 0.020639270544052124, 0.03293495997786522, 0.03306214511394501, -0.012595119886100292, 0.04204898327589035, 0.0183363389223814, 0.02142656221985817, 0.010090518742799759, -0.03045479580760002, -0.022727563977241516, -0.018920384347438812, -0.04876979440450668, 0.008602493442595005, -0.06809093058109283, 0.05587119236588478, 0.02345885895192623, -0.032748978585004807, -0.040774960070848465, -0.022195791825652122, -0.03573546186089516, 0.00863654725253582, -0.01186248380690813, -0.022203821688890457, -0.03040449135005474, 0.0759374350309372, 0.038479145616292953, -0.01385620515793562, 0.008738878183066845, 0.02044425532221794, 0.01743461564183235, 0.008167073130607605, 0.029153060168027878, 0.06647148728370667, -0.04372335225343704, -0.0011179330758750439, -0.012035499326884747, 0.006680188700556755, 0.026463352143764496, -0.02251378819346428, 0.0037194308824837208, -0.010738817043602467, -0.012750201858580112, 0.007375868037343025, 0.03693436458706856, 0.035802070051431656, -0.0071074930019676685, 0.040242999792099, -0.037446022033691406, -0.026451772078871727, -0.049182530492544174, 0.03575830161571503, -0.04262750968337059, -0.002178844064474106, -0.026051903143525124, 0.019322827458381653, 0.004685153719037771, -0.03816375136375427, -0.02885809913277626, 0.026919342577457428, -0.019012920558452606, -0.003367023542523384, -0.0870843231678009, -0.025647291913628578, 0.07112761586904526, 0.03989390283823013, -0.0040835109539330006, 0.009064792655408382, -0.06686186790466309, 0.01585167646408081, -0.005012867506593466, -0.015299820341169834, -0.00741320988163352, 0.012731914408504963, -0.022995617240667343, 0.02209177054464817, 0.03735850006341934, -0.021445419639348984, -0.02061709389090538, -0.04402574896812439, -0.007792382035404444, 0.05956796184182167, 0.009148533456027508, 0.004074244759976864, -0.0013762983726337552, 0.00950962770730257, 0.03690489009022713, 0.025590423494577408, -0.04569074511528015, -0.03574756532907486, 0.015456125140190125, 0.032863497734069824, -0.011171557940542698, -0.021966667845845222, 0.00022162300592754036, 0.11049018800258636, -0.0051475148648023605, -0.0033223028294742107, 0.05381311848759651, -0.0031843194738030434, 0.03600460663437843, -0.01448671892285347, -0.012123512104153633, 0.01995018497109413, -0.025523431599140167, 0.03296498581767082, 0.04190459102392197, -0.000664647261146456, 0.006436867173761129, -0.015098328702151775, 0.01591576635837555, 0.030513141304254532, 0.024210989475250244, -0.0018622392090037465, -0.04649098590016365, 0.046785369515419006, -0.03346557170152664, -0.009207348339259624, 0.03103507123887539, 0.00037157590850256383, -0.003794229356572032, -0.02464439906179905, -0.05551643669605255, -0.04082965478301048, 0.041547857224941254, -0.04935621842741966, 0.01877867616713047, 0.02819046378135681, 0.02296973578631878, -0.004513171501457691, -0.017202619463205338, 0.006318777333945036, -0.008415725082159042, 0.04281998053193092, 0.04898868128657341, 0.007441229186952114, 0.03308304399251938, -0.0066205100156366825, 0.002133107278496027, 0.03220761939883232, -0.0016613092739135027, 0.008496676571667194, -0.028740378096699715, -0.07972647994756699, 0.003997014369815588, 0.01783243753015995, -0.07799480110406876, 0.009011657908558846, 0.007550283335149288, -0.03073003888130188, 0.021856557577848434, 0.017173415049910545, -0.03033503144979477, 0.0041196332313120365, -0.06293897330760956, -0.03710711747407913, -0.05184347927570343, -0.009402034804224968, 0.033109262585639954, -0.0019446384394541383, -0.018551770597696304, 0.008761447854340076, -0.011461546644568443, -0.001331707346253097, -0.01922859624028206, -0.009310856461524963, 0.010124629363417625, -0.015401423908770084, 0.0493268221616745, -0.0264077540487051, 0.00803707167506218, 0.01310873031616211, -0.06787174940109253, -0.07068756222724915, -0.01907823234796524, 0.0016259393887594342, 0.02871125005185604, -0.005056342575699091, 0.020932558923959732, 0.07616040855646133, -0.005947109777480364, -0.03526618704199791, -0.021923664957284927, -0.0021393513306975365, -0.03146615996956825, -0.06588185578584671, -0.018049053847789764, -0.015858184546232224, -0.031121058389544487, 0.011773763224482536, -0.033947013318538666, 0.0068409014493227005, 0.026470262557268143, 0.03146523982286453, -0.007537559140473604, 0.0035479862708598375, 0.00645351642742753, -0.006054575555026531, 0.019757933914661407, 0.035746414214372635, -0.06197342276573181, -0.0029289894737303257, -0.005319724790751934, -0.0072520882822573185, -0.0035495543852448463, -0.08217550814151764, 0.00818561390042305, 0.021245071664452553, 0.030469808727502823, -0.03605449199676514, 0.048719510436058044, -0.016925442963838577, -0.04511938616633415, 0.02774559147655964, 0.022118056192994118, 0.04953073710203171, 0.023266803473234177, 0.016108136624097824, 0.05223977938294411, 0.033621516078710556, -0.0019650780595839024, -0.016739705577492714, -0.035166021436452866, 0.015258935280144215, -0.009842297993600368, -0.019710388034582138, -0.01933305896818638, 0.026203731074929237, 0.013297753408551216, 0.0014243029290810227, 0.022889455780386925, -0.014666073024272919, -0.03874925896525383, -0.03105536475777626, 0.006358265411108732, 0.004078183323144913, 0.015031976625323296, -0.02148308977484703, 0.024980908259749413, 0.01960049569606781, -0.025196729227900505, 0.028560154139995575, 0.008900593034923077, -0.07910697907209396, 0.04583106189966202, 0.01748739369213581, -0.029705751687288284, 0.03548239916563034, -0.03841092064976692, -0.004971535410732031, -0.04469141364097595, -0.013455080799758434, 0.03793244808912277, 0.026015056297183037, -0.03343234956264496, 0.009477848187088966, 0.004766491241753101, -0.01350973267108202, 0.008657368831336498, -0.023193923756480217, 0.03931424766778946, -0.02417083829641342, 0.024063238874077797, 0.025788627564907074, -0.012016874738037586, -0.022321321070194244, -0.0307232104241848, 0.011891472153365612, 0.06920375674962997, 0.023889970034360886, 0.004635155200958252, 0.052280254662036896, 0.02283097244799137, 0.0013080460485070944, 0.013406234793365002, 0.03394408896565437, 0.035815928131341934, -0.014321014285087585, -0.028226828202605247, -0.0182987991720438, 0.01015736348927021, 0.015579700469970703, 0.04170221462845802, 0.012126781046390533, 0.016027791425585747, 0.008583039976656437, 0.030350321903824806, -0.04776030406355858, -0.007774048484861851, 0.089874267578125, 0.023572120815515518, -0.03850584477186203, -0.04476303607225418, 0.021355411037802696, -0.0016813355032354593, -0.03762168809771538, -0.010257819667458534, 0.017814967781305313, -0.002412445843219757, -0.0020983745343983173, 0.005834115203469992, -0.0020981766283512115, 0.0123128117993474, -0.010869992896914482, -0.022244367748498917, 0.03359352797269821, 0.019445229321718216, 0.010500075295567513, 0.012434643693268299, 0.023724500089883804, -0.01842486299574375, 0.03923538699746132, 0.0005119842826388776, -0.06451583653688431, 0.04174506291747093, 0.05524183064699173, 0.07189872115850449, -0.0014975423691794276, -0.03292339667677879, -0.05220847204327583, -0.004802347626537085, 0.02127715013921261, -0.048367660492658615, 0.03432438522577286, -0.01801057532429695, -0.009576785378158092, 0.0019129603169858456, -0.021178530529141426, -0.024925796315073967, -0.01903337426483631, -0.06528689712285995, 0.02731112763285637, -0.0034146197140216827, -0.01789127290248871, -0.04640180990099907, -0.010976916179060936, 0.05381712317466736, 0.053938355296850204, -0.010882463306188583, -0.0019077991601079702, -0.03175419196486473, 0.008715112693607807, -0.04260719195008278, -0.02437492273747921, 0.02291998825967312, 0.001826243125833571, 0.030442524701356888, 0.052889686077833176, -0.0016552814049646258, -0.046636492013931274, 0.035112351179122925, -0.016628112643957138, -0.029559604823589325, -0.006185680627822876, -0.016032109037041664, 0.04148990288376808, 0.03616314381361008, 0.024059323593974113, 0.051136333495378494, 0.040058888494968414, 0.005447172559797764, 0.026853017508983612, -0.007955248467624187, -0.011568897403776646, 0.007955485954880714, 0.021771635860204697, -0.0013988892314955592, 0.013460371643304825, -0.013981210999190807, -0.010826319456100464, -0.009558312594890594, 0.030708054080605507, -0.011648662388324738, 0.017087707296013832, -0.013721102848649025, -0.00002995751674461644, 0.01114391814917326, 0.0013780698645859957, -0.005369772668927908, 0.0013322687009349465, -0.040499549359083176, 0.006164963357150555, 0.03978405520319939, -0.061480529606342316, -0.019117314368486404, -0.0029519374947994947, -0.023477936163544655, 0.006562703754752874, -0.061580054461956024, 0.0060791075229644775, 0.029993291944265366, -0.022473169490695, -0.015091662295162678, -0.002958595287054777, 0.037828098982572556, -0.012336893938481808, -0.024111432954669, -0.02637569233775139, 0.010459509678184986, 0.026202978566288948, 0.02355901338160038, -0.01588263176381588, 0.025485901162028313, -0.002487585414201021, 0.005993312690407038, -0.06297177076339722, -0.02207759954035282, 0.02146173268556595, 0.03402894735336304, -0.04682323709130287, -0.04937102273106575, -0.03673579543828964, -0.03148884326219559, -0.015288149006664753, -0.03589588403701782, 0.028174322098493576, 0.005381643772125244, -0.013395716436207294, 0.01725129410624504, -0.006499184761196375, 0.08191577345132828, 0.012699354439973831, 0.018978141248226166, -0.016690675169229507, -0.004721031058579683, -0.03998328000307083, -0.003188980044797063, 0.018963340669870377, -0.039380285888910294, -0.02582230232656002, -0.0041197813116014, -0.017436325550079346, 0.03081457130610943, 0.01718490943312645, 0.01335789542645216, -0.008287202566862106, -0.0030151456594467163, 0.00992841087281704, -0.015997668728232384, -0.033001627773046494, -0.009892099536955357, 0.01699652150273323, -0.005941740702837706, 0.02982824109494686, -0.012448415160179138, 0.028198888525366783, 0.023035814985632896, -0.03443828225135803, 0.01565089076757431, -0.018086601048707962, 0.07830370217561722, 0.0035452041774988174, 0.015554533340036869, -0.013820529915392399, 0.0022327518090605736, 0.02709246426820755, -0.020140040665864944, -0.010877953842282295, 0.024391572922468185, 0.002814715262502432, -0.015202035196125507, 0.008180119097232819, -0.025033915415406227, -0.012258060276508331, 0.035404276102781296, -0.0322222039103508, 0.044775497168302536, 0.013084406033158302, 0.0171244777739048, -0.002100662561133504, 0.003731412347406149, -0.02917095087468624, -0.025091348215937614, 0.019116496667265892, 0.022480418905615807, 0.016384055837988853, 0.004678883124142885, 0.0017828320851549506, 0.00749233877286315, 0.04836363345384598, 0.014585943892598152, 0.01930411532521248, -0.00972144864499569, 0.03720007464289665, 0.017151784151792526, -0.029330354183912277, 0.037056565284729004, -0.04892488941550255, 0.05743084475398064, -0.024922968819737434, -0.045409541577100754, 0.040354352444410324, 0.03035672940313816, -0.0659065842628479, -0.015157099813222885, 0.008752436377108097, -0.08535856008529663, 0.02173769101500511, 0.019080260768532753, -0.003426166018471122, 0.013231701217591763, -0.01071676891297102, 0.02092074789106846, -0.030273418873548508, 0.0017052325420081615, -0.04504866153001785, -0.06472776085138321, -0.0029682335443794727, -0.016220489516854286, -0.06478632986545563, 0.03637306019663811, 0.02664346434175968, -0.029548635706305504, 0.005812406539916992, 0.013027915731072426, 0.035375360399484634, 0.03061624988913536, 0.027611566707491875, 0.006316836457699537, 0.0899876207113266, 0.0009698796202428639, 0.04710698500275612, -0.012338164262473583, 0.018696974962949753, 0.138496533036232, 0.08552640676498413, 0.02482764422893524, -0.029250985011458397, 0.014478721655905247, -0.029534094035625458, 0.0021959305740892887, -0.013102764263749123, 0.0034735591616481543, 0.03712005540728569, -0.007400414440780878, 0.03341951593756676, 0.0428653359413147, -0.05012144520878792, -0.007292737253010273, 0.03663750737905502, -0.06711891293525696, -0.01053118146955967, 0.022097833454608917, 0.03724851459264755, 0.0050627607852220535, -0.032695166766643524, -0.049960244446992874, 0.002049017231911421, -0.004368792288005352, -0.031998880207538605, -0.03568624332547188, -0.0548405647277832, 0.008027542382478714, 0.07014243304729462, -0.04580206423997879, -0.011043471284210682, 0.022899216040968895, 0.01700173318386078, -0.008755194954574108, -0.0234140083193779, 0.038992516696453094, -0.022273866459727287, 0.03078324720263481, 0.03148529678583145, 0.047318942844867706, 0.00014409676077775657, -0.041114162653684616, 0.018823137506842613, -0.046879492700099945, -0.03267386183142662, -0.06735903024673462, 0.0005995294777676463, -0.02626105397939682, -0.02196982316672802, 0.0004938994534313679, 0.01971018686890602, -0.012282474897801876, -0.05734740197658539, 0.019030950963497162, 0.04305395483970642, 0.027125094085931778, -0.025469226762652397, -0.0014721540501341224, -0.010637737810611725, -0.017436107620596886, 0.0019836770370602608, 0.002261229557916522, 0.02506708912551403, -0.0346766822040081, -0.02087138220667839, -0.02581792324781418, 0.028178133070468903, -0.04434517025947571, -0.00013961723016109318, 0.017562411725521088, 0.002029487630352378, -0.05546530336141586, -0.0360923670232296, 0.003362510120496154, -0.012316572479903698, -0.01980748027563095, -0.01951959915459156, -0.003574514528736472, 0.04446408525109291, 0.00029671285301446915, 0.0393928699195385, -0.026702340692281723, 0.004309698473662138, -0.03145410493016243, 0.007318607531487942, 0.03432201221585274, -0.016239896416664124, -0.0123169319704175, -0.02433803863823414, -0.04140912741422653, 0.049829479306936264, 0.02335703745484352, -0.04353195056319237, -0.03406046703457832, 0.005907540675252676, -0.039701107889413834, -0.0038104699924588203, 0.0017511160112917423, 0.043176986277103424, 0.034176092594861984, -0.010149456560611725, -0.01039714552462101, 0.0458441786468029, -0.022687409073114395, 0.01843155361711979, 0.001873071538284421, -0.04800458624958992, -0.05488772317767143, 0.03895821422338486, -0.02525726705789566, -0.014665902592241764, 0.016129834577441216, -0.016379892826080322, -0.023682409897446632, 0.055880382657051086, -0.03715088218450546, -0.05037873610854149, -0.0045399791561067104, -0.0009401367860846221, 0.027558179572224617, 0.021307362243533134, 0.020734282210469246, -0.030507348477840424, -0.02828286774456501, -0.012682965956628323, -0.01068588625639677, -0.029817748814821243, -0.0012808565516024828, 0.01289306115359068, 0.00914290826767683, 0.029357226565480232, 0.0019862432964146137, 0.030535999685525894, -0.05057448521256447, 0.04376945272088051, -0.024003412574529648, 0.03422606363892555, -0.03760794177651405, -0.0032709413208067417, 0.04648931697010994, -0.005009899847209454, 0.017118843272328377, 0.04930698871612549, 0.007586396299302578, 0.026533564552664757, 0.01643175445497036, -0.015949957072734833, 0.017100190743803978, 0.038625478744506836, -0.003195925150066614, -0.0293063223361969, -0.0006530755781568587, 0.019081590697169304, 0.004540111403912306, -0.013959063217043877, -0.008008147589862347, 0.0003827839973382652, -0.01536636520177126, -0.007990449666976929, 0.019351955503225327, 0.02218097262084484, 0.010527187958359718, -0.02455492690205574, 0.04368795081973076, -0.02621745504438877, 0.01643528789281845, -0.014269242063164711, 0.02261204831302166, 0.011264445260167122, -0.021691087633371353, 0.009010694921016693, -0.026799701154232025, -0.019295601174235344, -0.07888711243867874, -0.0212956964969635, 0.03178800269961357, -0.036666832864284515, 0.052805013954639435, -0.031543828547000885, 0.04691573977470398, 0.00855257362127304, -0.028007235378026962, -0.017786726355552673, -0.023676887154579163, 0.015891579911112785, -0.022505491971969604, 0.02970929630100727, 0.003320401068776846, 0.05284448340535164, 0.013986567035317421, 0.028674451634287834, 0.02886759303510189, -0.009970273822546005, -0.02181287854909897, -0.022757036611437798, -0.0009313671034760773, 0.01026102527976036, 0.033568497747182846, -0.03874489292502403, 0.00803526584059, -0.0725223496556282, -0.0035379009786993265, 0.05158879607915878, -0.009040601551532745, 0.013725914061069489, -0.010732246562838554, 0.042526062577962875, 0.021293077617883682, 0.05386709049344063, 0.014694689773023129, 0.030877364799380302, -0.03213005140423775, -0.029366130009293556, 0.00894527044147253, 0.026483885943889618, -0.00976035837084055, -0.017501771450042725, 0.03724323585629463, -0.03229914605617523, -0.04463139548897743, -0.0011232353281229734, 0.00602703308686614, 0.054609090089797974, -0.003302105702459812, -0.005975733045488596, -0.008403307758271694, -0.03562410548329353, 0.010003292001783848, -0.027043364942073822, 0.0591619648039341, 0.0025184391997754574, 0.0003251430462114513, -0.008621478453278542, -0.029407652094960213, -0.026290787383913994, -0.0412057600915432, 0.0022757775150239468, -0.010440045967698097, -0.02619141712784767, -0.04431011155247688, -0.028570037335157394, -0.005943845026195049, -0.02805776707828045, 0.00294864340685308, -0.00651893112808466, -0.03680122643709183, 0.037183139473199844, -0.027103673666715622, 0.013296866789460182, 0.009961668401956558, 0.0006447028135880828, 0.018621964380145073, -0.07825005054473877, 0.03312929347157478, 0.0648249089717865, -0.004588030278682709, -0.06692645698785782, -0.003955497872084379, 0.027510473504662514, -0.01792510598897934, 0.048108793795108795, -0.019457144662737846, -0.005607083905488253, -0.017878681421279907, 0.014368616975843906, 0.037335354834795, -0.04498305916786194, 0.033948689699172974, -0.029538189992308617, -0.028070718050003052, 0.023468537256121635, 0.01112265232950449, 0.0014122792053967714, -0.008887339383363724, 0.0183184165507555, -0.013782286085188389, 0.010333898477256298, 0.007648637983947992, -0.018352454528212547, 0.001265314407646656, -0.017364943400025368, -0.0671384260058403, 0.04274525120854378, -0.02827741578221321, -0.022192806005477905, 0.040158335119485855, -0.01399283204227686, -0.048987165093421936, 0.029514512047171593, -0.061378225684165955, -0.02671193517744541, 0.002961590653285384, -0.0218865554779768, 0.008039980195462704, -0.07357708364725113, 0.011608894914388657, 0.010963916778564453, -0.03090079501271248, 0.03080672025680542, 0.08219484984874725, 0.05432076379656792, 0.09318631142377853, -0.005983489099889994, 0.014100109227001667, -0.04044894129037857, -0.025173671543598175, 0.01897803507745266, -0.026796093210577965, 0.009259928949177265, -0.007782091852277517, 0.011962054297327995, 0.02364630065858364, 0.004948440007865429, 0.03798146918416023, 0.04622722417116165, -0.0034622440580278635, -0.01287890411913395, -0.016001328825950623, 0.034972380846738815, -0.008303617127239704, 0.030898526310920715, 0.02780301682651043, -0.011321109719574451, 0.030420534312725067, -0.03977011889219284, 0.0006656816694885492, -0.027025431394577026, 0.009465938434004784, -0.022775299847126007, 0.024466918781399727, 0.038606029003858566, 0.0010888263350352645, 0.016464045271277428, 0.04066503047943115, 0.018188999965786934, 0.050753526389598846, 0.007086214609444141, 0.011378711089491844, -0.014655085280537605, -0.027169231325387955, 0.01846235617995262, -0.010107996873557568, 0.001365643460303545, -0.05165533721446991, 0.006385228596627712, -0.003027871949598193, 0.008503359742462635, 0.006206443998962641, 0.012885845266282558, -0.03072815015912056, -0.003898392431437969, 0.02367318980395794, -0.05008251965045929, -0.009374146349728107, -0.08926333487033844, 0.01864277757704258, -0.005432783160358667, -0.009542294777929783 ]
<p>I am using a relevance vector machine as implemented in the kernlab-package in R, trained on a dataset with 360 continuous variables (features) and 60 examples (also continuous, so it's a relevance vector regression).</p> <p>I have several datasets with equivalent dimensions from different subjects. Now it works fine for most of the subjects, but with one particular dataset, I get this strange results:</p> <p>When using leave-one-out cross validation (so I train the RVM and try to subsequently predict one observation that was left out of the training), most of the predicted values are just around the mean of the example-values. So I really don't get good predictions, but just a slightly different value than the mean.</p> <p>It seems like the SVM is not working at all; When I plot the fitted values against the actual values, I see the same pattern; predictions around the mean. So the RVM is not even able to predict the values it was trained on (for the other datasets I get correlations of around .9 between fitted and actual values).</p> <p>It seems like, that I can at least improve the fitting (so that the RVM is at least able to predict the values it was trained on) by transforming the dependent variable (the example-values), for example by taking the square root of the dependent variable.</p> <p>so this is the output for the untransformed dependent variable:</p> <p>Relevance Vector Machine object of class "rvm" Problem type: regression </p> <pre><code>Linear (vanilla) kernel function. Number of Relevance Vectors : 5 Variance : 1407.006 Training error : 1383.534902093 </code></pre> <p>this, if I first transform the dependent variable by taking the square root:</p> <p>Relevance Vector Machine object of class "rvm" Problem type: regression </p> <pre><code>Linear (vanilla) kernel function. Number of Relevance Vectors : 55 Variance : 1.711355 Training error : 0.89601609 </code></pre> <p>How is it, that the RVM-results change so dramatically, just by transforming the dependent variable? And what is going wrong, when an SVM just predicts values around the mean of the dependent variable (even for the values and observations it was trained on)?</p>
74,135
[ -0.021431853994727135, 0.015215873718261719, 0.0088158855214715, -0.008111248724162579, 0.025052180513739586, -0.02802283503115177, -0.019978657364845276, -0.015306754969060421, 0.02645672857761383, -0.04849376901984215, 0.037144601345062256, 0.0026214912068098783, 0.07174725830554962, -0.0088851572945714, -0.0037512341514229774, 0.00020957848755642772, 0.010792335495352745, -0.01757107675075531, 0.01715092919766903, -0.009213400073349476, -0.002432603156194091, 0.01903865486383438, 0.03037741407752037, -0.017955221235752106, -0.015827717259526253, 0.057369012385606766, 0.028676390647888184, 0.006034624297171831, 0.018520040437579155, 0.04515502229332924, -0.03519536554813385, -0.01180444285273552, -0.003660763381049037, 0.024079782888293266, 0.028407033532857895, 0.04033093899488449, 0.019168300554156303, -0.030044320970773697, 0.010394968092441559, 0.034825701266527176, 0.018693285062909126, 0.006412050221115351, -0.016793563961982727, 0.09657957404851913, 0.015407239086925983, 0.03434981033205986, 0.013890216127038002, -0.003935480024665594, 0.06076187640428543, -0.010138076730072498, 0.10498751699924469, 0.007271754555404186, 0.02606583945453167, 0.027666432783007622, -0.059266988188028336, 0.013213456608355045, 0.0651019886136055, 0.04676708206534386, 0.001991370227187872, -0.03792117163538933, 0.000013173291335988324, -0.026563139632344246, -0.02688002400100231, -0.005816224962472916, -0.003562971716746688, 0.019632164388895035, -0.014845145866274834, 0.01028226874768734, 0.0603000745177269, -0.04163841903209686, 0.035194143652915955, 0.010588482953608036, 0.023825369775295258, -0.001343539566732943, 0.012593968771398067, -0.006482376251369715, 0.011331234127283096, 0.002697847317904234, 0.03747924417257309, 0.01726185716688633, 0.034094348549842834, 0.03897665813565254, 0.01428884919732809, 0.028433624655008316, 0.02250625379383564, -0.022467393428087234, 0.02169605903327465, 0.005404632072895765, 0.02792731486260891, 0.05844558775424957, -0.0307615976780653, 0.025373907759785652, 0.05961275100708008, 0.014934984967112541, -0.03340757638216019, 0.03521406650543213, -0.008481751196086407, 0.028098415583372116, 0.015208950266242027, -0.014447622932493687, -0.027945691719651222, -0.0005427968571893871, -0.012312107719480991, 0.043874237686395645, -0.036036714911460876, -0.011335484683513641, -0.02533406764268875, -0.0019421169999986887, 0.02445857599377632, -0.054574985057115555, -0.004732225555926561, 0.004780412185937166, -0.013850057497620583, -0.0027051435317844152, 0.025951853021979332, -0.04068366438150406, -0.019251035526394844, -0.04072852432727814, 0.027725515887141228, 0.018839625641703606, 0.030456827953457832, -0.02684464305639267, -0.017813103273510933, -0.03348563238978386, -0.010043187998235226, 0.004127772990614176, 0.015275121666491032, -0.012148735113441944, -0.02511397935450077, 0.041813936084508896, 0.010664576664566994, -0.039295122027397156, 0.02006276696920395, -0.034721408039331436, 0.013635188341140747, -0.006727166939526796, -0.07704935222864151, -0.06048619747161865, 0.029762687161564827, -0.017038092017173767, 0.018240250647068024, -0.01954001374542713, -0.007960355840623379, 0.020692128688097, 0.06631063669919968, -0.009941976517438889, 0.01778397336602211, 0.05472893267869949, 0.04487532749772072, 0.000584032095503062, -0.03352676331996918, -0.01621227338910103, -0.04819108173251152, -0.006851194892078638, -0.01900799572467804, -0.05100467428565025, 0.0021125630009919405, -0.007947752252221107, -0.021695803850889206, 0.035009145736694336, 0.01897481270134449, -0.02246275544166565, 0.0161709226667881, -0.013929381035268307, 0.004513706546276808, 0.0006449787761084735, 0.057990413159132004, 0.018094198778271675, 0.023892920464277267, 0.012425761669874191, -0.054758500307798386, -0.006212878506630659, 0.034605346620082855, 0.06076435744762421, 0.029828928411006927, 0.042275212705135345, 0.019343001767992973, -0.030081121250987053, 0.03943827003240585, 0.021504882723093033, -0.05842015892267227, -0.05414383485913277, -0.01216272171586752, 0.013011205941438675, 0.01432254258543253, 0.04543805494904518, -0.0007357831345871091, -0.01594707928597927, 0.04689474776387215, -0.0583551861345768, -0.018393201753497124, -0.01669689640402794, -0.014162641018629074, -0.018160073086619377, -0.02964773029088974, 0.0006022057496011257, 0.019828833639621735, 0.0297474954277277, -0.007861034944653511, -0.012326156720519066, -0.000075034964538645, 0.006670027505606413, 0.04224739223718643, -0.017237432301044464, 0.0033862434793263674, 0.04814425855875015, 0.04010424762964249, -0.024826688691973686, 0.030971555039286613, -0.009494197554886341, -0.03543867543339729, 0.02922634407877922, -0.02230461873114109, -0.01182976271957159, -0.03414754569530487, -0.005005499813705683, -0.002565928502008319, 0.008713907562196255, -0.010184069164097309, 0.013692892156541348, -0.03278306499123573, 0.03917180001735687, 0.0359097495675087, -0.03159363940358162, -0.019831936806440353, 0.04464605078101158, -0.019715795293450356, 0.048151396214962006, -0.03831123933196068, -0.02451721392571926, -0.0347626619040966, -0.04837729409337044, 0.06241799518465996, 0.019715631380677223, -0.029694486409425735, 0.00415906822308898, 0.07466749846935272, 0.028173521161079407, 0.01741953194141388, 0.03153729438781738, -0.003565103281289339, -0.04533622786402702, 0.0402255617082119, 0.02061927132308483, 0.0012742928229272366, -0.020605964586138725, -0.011083056218922138, 0.03400399535894394, 0.0541786253452301, -0.007607828360050917, 0.010596344247460365, 0.010164152830839157, -0.0014722865307703614, -0.02129681035876274, -0.002590164076536894, 0.008117087185382843, 0.020079059526324272, 0.015911582857370377, -0.04295947775244713, 0.04741722345352173, 0.00844773929566145, 0.010157911106944084, -0.030991099774837494, 0.008624276146292686, 0.035136736929416656, 0.05158017575740814, 0.001654154621064663, 0.027127504348754883, 0.003073593368753791, -0.07075420022010803, -0.009543676860630512, -0.016050152480602264, -0.024705879390239716, -0.05443563684821129, 0.045622918754816055, 0.03618454560637474, 0.012789822183549404, 0.004467487800866365, -0.022796960547566414, -0.01086418330669403, -0.012651246041059494, -0.025899291038513184, 0.038943879306316376, -0.008682915940880775, -0.01978018879890442, 0.03794021159410477, -0.03220502287149429, -0.00608354527503252, 0.025438038632273674, -0.012500141747295856, -0.027197714895009995, 0.02277933619916439, -0.05386171117424965, -0.053378812968730927, -0.03986554220318794, -0.0548320896923542, 0.003384251380339265, -0.009868410415947437, -0.023817164823412895, 0.0654229149222374, 0.021794719621539116, -0.053227730095386505, 0.023049073293805122, -0.01997176744043827, -0.011095503345131874, -0.03986198455095291, -0.029030591249465942, 0.03518366813659668, -0.005579077173024416, 0.019251450896263123, 0.03543797507882118, -0.009137490764260292, -0.0011277352459728718, -0.0716765746474266, -0.05141396448016167, 0.005602394230663776, 0.026540834456682205, 0.034577906131744385, 0.05509497970342636, 0.010098974220454693, 0.08272447437047958, 0.024801218882203102, -0.02292460761964321, -0.08484698832035065, 0.015038376674056053, -0.036832552403211594, -0.016132786870002747, 0.044234130531549454, 0.030651699751615524, 0.029287271201610565, 0.03945452719926834, -0.020123101770877838, 0.04508768022060394, 0.013572347350418568, 0.015469108708202839, -0.021003928035497665, 0.03871775045990944, -0.012910498306155205, -0.026344049721956253, 0.027549078688025475, 0.02716749720275402, -0.0017189732752740383, -0.006534188520163298, 0.03375732898712158, 0.011466742493212223, -0.01941980980336666, -0.06982152163982391, 0.03392079100012779, 0.000933400762733072, 0.04853696748614311, -0.051386818289756775, 0.00257420283742249, 0.0004016236343886703, -0.03290301933884621, -0.03445836156606674, -0.02145344950258732, 0.023525618016719818, -0.008791601285338402, 0.029582444578409195, 0.048398204147815704, 0.03248591721057892, 0.00964617170393467, -0.0075068301521241665, -0.028086451813578606, -0.03304259851574898, 0.03395802155137062, -0.006668092682957649, -0.03380068764090538, 0.09103647619485855, 0.025363830849528313, -0.004797916393727064, -0.02594790607690811, -0.03461689129471779, 0.030533108860254288, -0.021520014852285385, -0.015873942524194717, -0.03913871943950653, 0.060130052268505096, 0.037367578595876694, 0.04680517688393593, 0.022637242451310158, -0.015102548524737358, -0.0019082194194197655, 0.004445789381861687, -0.05882672592997551, 0.01742737926542759, 0.012381755746901035, 0.004679806064814329, -0.016011638566851616, -0.018734408542513847, 0.024503828957676888, -0.01263635978102684, 0.022426504641771317, 0.013923311606049538, 0.027575066313147545, -0.04041440039873123, 0.019584594294428825, 0.03081153891980648, -0.004902701824903488, -0.04533819481730461, 0.011073061265051365, 0.045998912304639816, -0.03330462425947189, 0.0396292582154274, 0.022667691111564636, -0.03588227182626724, 0.008323773741722107, -0.05467170849442482, 0.020711729303002357, 0.039862606674432755, 0.06877120584249496, 0.02309628389775753, -0.015027076005935669, -0.062005046755075455, 0.03165426105260849, -0.004139595665037632, -0.013665514998137951, 0.06816428154706955, -0.02771589159965515, -0.03316839784383774, -0.04547209292650223, -0.011099172756075859, -0.009302857331931591, 0.027403900399804115, -0.007176752667874098, 0.039434872567653656, 0.05001239478588104, 0.02252580039203167, -0.06235809996724129, -0.008208183571696281, 0.035834189504384995, 0.013666204176843166, -0.01864425092935562, -0.060631100088357925, 0.003737499238923192, 0.0302226971834898, 0.015353756956756115, -0.015415127389132977, -0.002403761027380824, -0.04719420522451401, -0.06318679451942444, 0.051233526319265366, -0.04064232483506203, -0.03373079001903534, -0.01659177429974079, 0.02274450473487377, 0.028551626950502396, -0.03919833526015282, -0.016601232811808586, 0.008094032295048237, 0.026642948389053345, 0.04377707093954086, 0.004006733652204275, 0.015850380063056946, -0.07513687014579773, 0.004563668742775917, 0.07493419945240021, 0.03633684664964676, -0.04165409132838249, -0.010482692159712315, -0.037735141813755035, 0.0024051410146057606, 0.023157382383942604, -0.07156089693307877, -0.006146532017737627, 0.020443685352802277, -0.005192389711737633, -0.007311737164855003, -0.04125421494245529, -0.07551216334104538, -0.014152558520436287, -0.03322405368089676, 0.048120949417352676, -0.03082478977739811, -0.047164030373096466, -0.050462886691093445, 0.010854034684598446, 0.037120167165994644, 0.039350852370262146, -0.028480416163802147, -0.020884353667497635, 0.00981344748288393, 0.026353882625699043, 0.009474022313952446, -0.06004844978451729, 0.016204731538891792, 0.029985053464770317, -0.020760294049978256, 0.050130169838666916, 0.01186602097004652, -0.059767141938209534, 0.0014537282986566424, 0.021059824153780937, -0.014857535250484943, -0.043236177414655685, -0.027604464441537857, 0.02341669425368309, 0.02402404323220253, -0.004743808414787054, 0.0713476613163948, 0.034337546676397324, 0.02466210350394249, -0.0382520966231823, -0.04388781636953354, 0.010892028920352459, -0.013339958153665066, -0.045794788748025894, -0.009020397439599037, -0.03062431327998638, 0.030060434713959694, 0.035108376294374466, 0.0064358776435256, 0.04863262549042702, -0.03990958258509636, 0.0196867436170578, 0.008697397075593472, 0.035836268216371536, -0.0322716198861599, -0.012800676748156548, -0.00040112584247253835, 0.024622924625873566, -0.015506421215832233, 0.006214817054569721, -0.0334230475127697, -0.014615601859986782, -0.021750951185822487, 0.052355099469423294, -0.05354131758213043, 0.0051826732233166695, 0.014583131298422813, 0.0022263042628765106, 0.005884657148271799, -0.01768307574093342, 0.016454052180051804, 0.021414047107100487, 0.0488024577498436, -0.0013517156476154923, -0.028171299025416374, 0.0029154832009226084, -0.024060698226094246, -0.002615402452647686, 0.02745346911251545, -0.005639560520648956, -0.008099068887531757, 0.017247475683689117, -0.015565658919513226, -0.04898345470428467, -0.047295209020376205, 0.006383815314620733, -0.01845785602927208, -0.013382974080741405, -0.03164663538336754, -0.024533899500966072, -0.0022674361243844032, -0.016416305676102638, -0.005163596943020821, 0.01792929507791996, -0.014525693841278553, 0.00518827373161912, -0.0014181076548993587, -0.0013438682071864605, 0.052784811705350876, -0.03757311776280403, 0.02269190363585949, -0.001989551354199648, 0.013497812673449516, -0.05086963623762131, 0.052936483174562454, -0.00985825527459383, -0.025503965094685555, -0.022026222199201584, -0.04992768540978432, 0.027072325348854065, 0.03710121661424637, 0.005724679678678513, -0.007271517533808947, -0.010669182986021042, -0.01946222223341465, 0.025612734258174896, -0.01906648464500904, 0.0027194831054657698, 0.04682747274637222, -0.03065154142677784, 0.02077900432050228, 0.01765258051455021, -0.031046608462929726, -0.050168588757514954, 0.015658851712942123, -0.009655408561229706, 0.0018074964173138142, 0.006054151803255081, 0.05575363710522652, -0.01702301576733589, -0.005777385085821152, -0.017379656434059143, -0.038169119507074356, 0.015109986998140812, 0.008645584806799889, 0.016306035220623016, -0.009087798185646534, 0.005052716471254826, -0.04450969770550728, -0.0045691076666116714, -0.03874870017170906, -0.019192412495613098, 0.06361174583435059, -0.0037656521890312433, 0.04435133934020996, 0.041320059448480606, -0.01145693939179182, -0.014127283357083797, -0.0772407203912735, -0.009365142323076725, 0.007423879578709602, 0.004517775494605303, 0.05112467333674431, -0.02267303690314293, -0.007010902278125286, 0.008798488415777683, 0.03246212750673294, 0.041294727474451065, 0.047773946076631546, -0.0029625329189002514, 0.020397566258907318, 0.028475699946284294, -0.03492920845746994, -0.027252810075879097, 0.014781882055103779, 0.0016732801450416446, 0.0043488540686666965, -0.0010697386460378766, 0.00199239538051188, 0.045527130365371704, 0.026257023215293884, 0.037837836891412735, -0.035072099417448044, -0.0332476943731308, -0.04906878247857094, 0.0043115923181176186, 0.04066460207104683, -0.005087488796561956, 0.021864263340830803, 0.03553193435072899, 0.017740124836564064, 0.017495539039373398, 0.024460026994347572, -0.07404893636703491, -0.07063999772071838, -0.04735419899225235, -0.05988159030675888, -0.03046099841594696, 0.08194801211357117, -0.02199157141149044, -0.04952458292245865, -0.004319946747273207, -0.0707528367638588, 0.040949348360300064, -0.010397273115813732, 0.01835351623594761, 0.00938064232468605, 0.03955158218741417, -0.024388667196035385, -0.003270084736868739, -0.010164102539420128, -0.009831935167312622, 0.13718350231647491, 0.06196043640375137, 0.019092198461294174, -0.05771482363343239, -0.040830861777067184, 0.005018041934818029, -0.009478894993662834, -0.02771771140396595, -0.0002161244337912649, -0.014945813454687595, 0.00009844130545388907, 0.024205300956964493, 0.022196143865585327, 0.06679441034793854, 0.001615708228200674, 0.02648048661649227, -0.00755723100155592, 0.019471557810902596, 0.011790378950536251, 0.015693390741944313, 0.004725917242467403, -0.004004138056188822, -0.019973628222942352, 0.013460573740303516, -0.012774401344358921, -0.013006053864955902, -0.029065584763884544, 0.008170370012521744, -0.0021148165687918663, -0.0010600099340081215, 0.013225790113210678, 0.015154482796788216, 0.014123699627816677, 0.021380484104156494, -0.002087678760290146, 0.01945497654378414, 0.005069288890808821, -0.04141590744256973, 0.03744366392493248, 0.020634524524211884, -0.00833395030349493, -0.02856728620827198, -0.0014461944811046124, -0.0011068142484873533, -0.04958241805434227, -0.0341683030128479, -0.045374903827905655, 0.06597054749727249, 0.03234124928712845, -0.05262528359889984, 0.007297596428543329, 0.021708497777581215, 0.0034062517806887627, -0.05804302170872688, -0.027696624398231506, 0.02162748947739601, -0.0042273737490177155, -0.013387874700129032, -0.0018060363363474607, -0.024763694033026695, 0.023433998227119446, -0.008614440448582172, 0.027176376432180405, 0.032067228108644485, -0.03289840370416641, -0.03356122225522995, -0.03772188723087311, 0.027798738330602646, -0.029719708487391472, 0.012743868865072727, 0.009863379411399364, 0.02169318124651909, 0.01763642579317093, -0.020436907187104225, 0.0427202507853508, -0.008875265717506409, 0.029519548639655113, -0.04697684943675995, -0.012617170810699463, -0.03959492966532707, -0.04658686742186546, -0.014270653016865253, -0.043456848710775375, 0.008162449114024639, -0.03615635260939598, 0.032710641622543335, 0.01350242830812931, 0.04009102284908295, 0.006620417349040508, -0.02831307053565979, 0.004771051928400993, 0.022201264277100563, 0.004987975582480431, -0.05834970995783806, -0.028067881241440773, 0.021118611097335815, -0.01746419072151184, 0.002342244843021035, 0.004831753671169281, 0.07653162628412247, 0.05344461277127266, -0.012022583745419979, -0.01615760661661625, 0.039312586188316345, 0.0017396743642166257, -0.021573305130004883, 0.015843519940972328, -0.021426638588309288, 0.029178567230701447, 0.00539911724627018, -0.01251980010420084, 0.003534926800057292, -0.019442493095993996, -0.04491464048624039, -0.06314469128847122, 0.0005302682984620333, 0.014035948552191257, -0.026446539908647537, 0.005515269003808498, -0.007832309231162071, 0.03767100349068642, -0.0003823647857643664, -0.017169080674648285, -0.03876253589987755, 0.006002518348395824, -0.05201738327741623, -0.04515471309423447, 0.009392840787768364, -0.00966345053166151, -0.009679252281785011, 0.015562262386083603, 0.018484169617295265, 0.03518863022327423, 0.026300722733139992, -0.020931847393512726, 0.03176943585276604, -0.013630073517560959, 0.042236171662807465, -0.019350139424204826, -0.029788807034492493, 0.04141407459974289, -0.054604653269052505, -0.04009963572025299, 0.01938571035861969, -0.01718953065574169, 0.04347997158765793, 0.008201985619962215, 0.05161159113049507, -0.024467868730425835, 0.049916476011276245, -0.006702692713588476, 0.011670522391796112, 0.001469490467570722, 0.009307997301220894, 0.025796515867114067, 0.029806096106767654, 0.04930451139807701, -0.015270124189555645, -0.0066069550812244415, 0.014828444458544254, 0.03048604167997837, -0.019395148381590843, -0.006468434352427721, 0.011304719373583794, -0.03538747876882553, 0.025973722338676453, -0.00029572067433036864, -0.004024657420814037, 0.020649723708629608, 0.023122381418943405, -0.025010457262396812, 0.03432350978255272, -0.008963992819190025, 0.022461863234639168, -0.08553887903690338, -0.012105808593332767, -0.02896731346845627, 0.03265201300382614, 0.007056523114442825, -0.042893797159194946, -0.00513796042650938, 0.02557932771742344, -0.03773147612810135, 0.02368798851966858, 0.012255311943590641, -0.013537641614675522, -0.03742063045501709, 0.01696387119591236, -0.009585781954228878, 0.012484138831496239, 0.06966499239206314, -0.0036363627295941114, 0.03726635500788689, 0.038136716932058334, -0.0051892600022256374, -0.0079965153709054, -0.05845579132437706, 0.03546645864844322, -0.02422277070581913, -0.043639376759529114, -0.002881658496335149, -0.011551846750080585, 0.00649102870374918, 0.015146646648645401, -0.017927261069417, 0.018976399675011635, 0.03660069778561592, 0.005428330507129431, 0.03432568907737732, 0.06257402896881104, 0.03714148700237274, -0.023502428084611893, -0.004321102984249592, 0.0023444509133696556, 0.027516309171915054, 0.005058377981185913, -0.017782650887966156, -0.003114647464826703, 0.010427200235426426, -0.0035648467019200325, -0.00441025011241436, -0.028771113604307175, -0.04679889976978302, -0.0373707078397274, -0.022309528663754463, 0.051050759851932526, -0.028142938390374184, -0.038822196424007416, 0.015658674761652946, -0.054463841021060944, -0.004752349108457565, 0.04488416016101837, 0.04400194436311722, -0.00997302494943142, 0.03250854089856148, -0.016451410949230194, -0.030559170991182327, -0.018984269350767136, -0.017887163907289505, -0.010632774792611599, -0.055176038295030594, -0.022205166518688202, -0.005936927627772093, -0.017040422186255455, -0.04459386318922043, -0.0014972612261772156, -0.04947281628847122, 0.023107534274458885, -0.005309291183948517, 0.05107365921139717, 0.018225178122520447, -0.01964651606976986, -0.006927345413714647, -0.10576509684324265, 0.0754903182387352, -0.001318160560913384, -0.03751177340745926, -0.029397768899798393, -0.002346163149923086, -0.0352587066590786, 0.009821644052863121, 0.045175451785326004, -0.002401667647063732, 0.001389649580232799, -0.02861666865646839, -0.012836368754506111, 0.02107825130224228, -0.04573696106672287, 0.02661728858947754, -0.0072840251959860325, 0.011868916451931, 0.003600978059694171, -0.01877073384821415, 0.005643207114189863, 0.01386546716094017, 0.021809687837958336, -0.030423734337091446, -0.023727625608444214, 0.00836659874767065, -0.0027444043662399054, 0.01401535328477621, 0.02326088957488537, 0.010080987587571144, 0.025115763768553734, 0.008972273208200932, 0.0004979270743206143, 0.041332557797431946, 0.010509263724088669, -0.0479060523211956, 0.00814590509980917, -0.02784733846783638, -0.03397059068083763, 0.0215514674782753, 0.01965469680726528, 0.009817032143473625, -0.04950753599405289, -0.005789938848465681, 0.041994690895080566, -0.014604713767766953, -0.0036698123440146446, 0.048204582184553146, 0.014174778014421463, 0.005809010937809944, 0.018299032002687454, 0.010004539042711258, 0.0005340105853974819, -0.02244439162313938, 0.036400940269231796, 0.012089592404663563, 0.013025995343923569, 0.023424606770277023, 0.004309943877160549, 0.016319185495376587, -0.03350374102592468, 0.027090316638350487, -0.03313785046339035, 0.037561435252428055, -0.05458971485495567, 0.004383374936878681, -0.0007265933090820909, -0.0004851364647038281, 0.009906633757054806, -0.028292976319789886, -0.03502577915787697, 0.04693317413330078, -0.03577139228582382, 0.01376655139029026, -0.03388626500964165, 0.00484611326828599, 0.01084517128765583, 0.02711722068488598, 0.03864669054746628, 0.03710932657122612, -0.0026174099184572697, 0.028077080845832825, -0.0025945622473955154, -0.012601744383573532, 0.04285245016217232, 0.005246500950306654, -0.02833014912903309, -0.0291440449655056, 0.015944411978125572, 0.01755199022591114, -0.016877640038728714, 0.001927573001012206, -0.01852216012775898, 0.00711070466786623, 0.02937677875161171, 0.02861912176012993, -0.011899878270924091, -0.03602810204029083, -0.008283787406980991, 0.05201248079538345, -0.09445472806692123, -0.035162363201379776, -0.01473154965788126, 0.02842177264392376, -0.009898028336465359, -0.027467183768749237 ]
<p>When preparing a summary document for policy-makers, it's fairly common to include a graphic that represents how the optimal policy solution varies with two variables. It may be the result of a formal or informal optimisation analysis. Below is an example of such a graphic. The graphic partitions the chart area into contiguous areas, with each area indicating that combinations of (x,y) within that area all share an optimal policy solution.</p> <p>What's the proper name for such data visualisation? And is there an easy way in Matlab (or even Excel) to generate such graphics relatively automatically from data, without having to just draw every component manually as a custom shape (because if I was going to do that, I'd just use Illustrator)?</p> <p>For now, please ignore the "CALM" / "SEGREGATE" labels and arrows - I'm interested in the partitioning of the chart into separate areas, and the distinct shading and labelling of each area. I'm not assuming this graph was generated from data: it's just to illustrate the chart style, nothing more. I want to generate a similar style of graph from data. As with the graph below, some of the boundaries may be non-linear.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/2LwvN.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
74,136
[ -0.04804520308971405, 0.013230698183178902, 0.01613214798271656, 0.03482683748006821, 0.007071764674037695, 0.032086800783872604, 0.0013042509090155363, -0.002724387450143695, 0.009237121790647507, -0.041065920144319534, 0.01224951446056366, 0.005581443663686514, 0.0470782071352005, 0.03491544723510742, 0.004235224798321724, -0.0004802244948223233, -0.0021852171048521996, 0.012848831713199615, -0.03063877485692501, -0.028852052986621857, 0.0059797498397529125, -0.013611482456326485, -0.01504032127559185, 0.010533050633966923, 0.001575340167619288, 0.043878551572561264, -0.001876306370832026, -0.00030596365104429424, -0.013227528892457485, 0.04319227859377861, -0.0666608065366745, -0.04771237447857857, 0.006976806093007326, -0.015506348572671413, 0.020190801471471786, -0.025367042049765587, 0.019718240946531296, -0.030807774513959885, -0.02898956835269928, -0.004860607907176018, -0.03295151889324188, -0.004509022459387779, 0.009909533895552158, 0.04327353835105896, -0.051668595522642136, 0.02397213689982891, -0.011305664665997028, -0.056687138974666595, 0.0378449410200119, -0.022899001836776733, 0.07335948944091797, -0.0004525788244791329, 0.046938735991716385, 0.0001973553153220564, 0.009216628968715668, 0.013842351734638214, 0.01815122924745083, 0.07630805671215057, 0.03191874921321869, -0.008096285164356232, -0.0035677910782396793, -0.011843306012451649, -0.011927725747227669, -0.010726477950811386, -0.03365633264183998, 0.051156021654605865, 0.003026650520041585, 0.010563178919255733, 0.030427737161517143, 0.0065400185994803905, -0.03565777465701103, 0.011088505387306213, 0.025768660008907318, -0.05631537362933159, 0.0047785434871912, 0.0034913436975330114, 0.011030650697648525, 0.03197365999221802, 0.04131948947906494, -0.00020113737264182419, 0.002192901913076639, 0.03481462597846985, 0.003349222941324115, 0.03121674433350563, -0.0021856555249542, 0.04238956794142723, 0.06414704769849777, -0.0549776554107666, 0.02088206633925438, 0.00494669983163476, -0.014314906671643257, 0.04245591536164284, 0.030419865623116493, 0.020118800923228264, -0.042549990117549896, 0.014756024815142155, 0.017260614782571793, 0.021162547171115875, -0.0035579379182308912, -0.030525119975209236, 0.02114049158990383, -0.008894612081348896, -0.039163317531347275, 0.00827317126095295, 0.013438643887639046, 0.015006856992840767, -0.04725814238190651, 0.022280141711235046, -0.005334789399057627, -0.01721145026385784, -0.04054708406329155, 0.029821380972862244, 0.012460318394005299, 0.02405734919011593, -0.017660629004240036, -0.03176428750157356, 0.001739833620376885, 0.03760502114892006, 0.03151606768369675, 0.06823849678039551, 0.015854183584451675, -0.03696897253394127, 0.06211322173476219, 0.004678511060774326, -0.0672144815325737, 0.02549600787460804, -0.012089324183762074, 0.0007863120408728719, -0.06697101145982742, 0.049484651535749435, -0.004121947567909956, -0.037918489426374435, 0.037779200822114944, 0.006733497139066458, 0.026042742654681206, -0.03302665054798126, -0.03697236627340317, -0.04205090552568436, 0.037877317517995834, -0.03425934165716171, 0.023457331582903862, -0.02909698523581028, -0.00994251947849989, 0.04706330969929695, 0.03367401286959648, -0.013122688047587872, 0.02975984290242195, 0.04966699704527855, 0.014990153722465038, 0.018468288704752922, -0.02362847700715065, 0.017453055828809738, -0.0018319531809538603, -0.06401164084672928, 0.015551439486443996, -0.06648273020982742, 0.003577867290005088, 0.05088592320680618, -0.019136972725391388, 0.008388488553464413, 0.05297644063830376, 0.020685190334916115, -0.007580958306789398, -0.01477162353694439, -0.021583814173936844, 0.015211455523967743, 0.08784984052181244, -0.018076300621032715, 0.00980882253497839, 0.006447531282901764, 0.01038318406790495, -0.0030294873286038637, 0.004619653336703777, 0.019515397027134895, 0.03847465291619301, -0.009022271260619164, 0.01637471839785576, -0.0225047767162323, -0.010330965742468834, 0.01671767048537731, -0.027653362601995468, -0.05890257656574249, -0.03183799237012863, 0.013563399203121662, 0.05899478495121002, 0.06822984665632248, -0.0031943696085363626, -0.04133766517043114, 0.04612458869814873, -0.06416551023721695, -0.06308569014072418, -0.054226793348789215, 0.011518298648297787, -0.03860558196902275, -0.03636382892727852, 0.03498973324894905, -0.007094956934452057, 0.017860867083072662, 0.04634316638112068, -0.05168985202908516, -0.004749811254441738, 0.007163196802139282, 0.04613465070724487, -0.016487309709191322, -0.010753908194601536, 0.031268298625946045, 0.032894011586904526, -0.013342447578907013, 0.013044207356870174, -0.05226171016693115, -0.05623144656419754, -0.014825709164142609, -0.04587910324335098, 0.05733991041779518, 0.013684960082173347, 0.005937105044722557, -0.02303415909409523, 0.017770882695913315, -0.01886480674147606, -0.004978204146027565, -0.04576459899544716, 0.03999026492238045, 0.0628337413072586, -0.019461417570710182, -0.015834061428904533, -0.001742835040204227, -0.005331479478627443, 0.020894059911370277, -0.011576494202017784, -0.02233801782131195, -0.023530438542366028, 0.020096436142921448, 0.06638170778751373, 0.025665314868092537, -0.05740419030189514, -0.006502398289740086, 0.05141830071806908, 0.024505287408828735, 0.027511775493621826, 0.0640387013554573, -0.00708369817584753, 0.04595785215497017, 0.027423547580838203, 0.04088211432099342, 0.022782284766435623, 0.014310021884739399, 0.009197255596518517, 0.011461588554084301, -0.005336083937436342, 0.01854347251355648, -0.01167616993188858, 0.05927714705467224, -0.0449930764734745, 0.02258441038429737, -0.00996372103691101, -0.021192364394664764, 0.06088569387793541, -0.041296299546957016, 0.004293696954846382, 0.06671348959207535, 0.007831323891878128, -0.02270382083952427, 0.024561019614338875, -0.022901643067598343, -0.00006004228271194734, 0.02179250866174698, -0.03759220615029335, 0.013215716928243637, 0.034212641417980194, -0.03733072802424431, 0.04823867231607437, -0.03720863536000252, -0.0025450626853853464, -0.021737856790423393, 0.0086243050172925, 0.04414631053805351, 0.0021289093419909477, -0.015476884320378304, -0.017407113686203957, -0.035793572664260864, -0.005903121083974838, -0.005340941250324249, 0.027661751955747604, 0.010348470881581306, -0.01644810289144516, -0.008245224133133888, -0.033533975481987, -0.036966368556022644, 0.048316773027181625, 0.004626087378710508, -0.01208934374153614, 0.02200915291905403, -0.017543191090226173, -0.04610888287425041, -0.03490240126848221, -0.06323400884866714, 0.03214135393500328, -0.016294939443469048, -0.015993373468518257, 0.02311631664633751, -0.0003286829451099038, -0.041544005274772644, -0.00958689022809267, -0.028383659198880196, -0.002712344052270055, -0.03938252851366997, 0.003160071326419711, 0.015124037861824036, 0.046154994517564774, -0.007743714842945337, 0.04530471935868263, 0.001022009993903339, -0.04575609788298607, -0.049966003745794296, -0.025942595675587654, -0.025448784232139587, 0.008514353074133396, -0.012617774307727814, -0.012312237173318863, -0.027383707463741302, 0.0685519427061081, 0.007839765399694443, -0.03605849668383598, -0.04144056886434555, -0.025852719321846962, -0.0018359040841460228, 0.0012000884162262082, 0.016661258414387703, 0.020288053900003433, 0.014701408334076405, -0.010429888032376766, -0.025758342817425728, 0.05389140918850899, 0.06364841014146805, -0.026901554316282272, 0.0029543573036789894, 0.01961909420788288, -0.013460314832627773, -0.0090824905782938, 0.026228858157992363, 0.024215519428253174, -0.021833958104252815, 0.004152916371822357, -0.003739601466804743, 0.009623954072594643, 0.026864850893616676, -0.0580282136797905, 0.0054000080563127995, -0.011200213804841042, 0.02866213209927082, -0.015816710889339447, 0.023828092962503433, 0.005483498331159353, -0.021369175985455513, 0.00024820625549182296, 0.036577120423316956, 0.017887646332383156, -0.016627470031380653, 0.002787286415696144, 0.0586695522069931, 0.04798605293035507, -0.013789140619337559, 0.004797131288796663, 0.005609749350696802, 0.017998896539211273, 0.015316243283450603, -0.0342988595366478, -0.01917034573853016, 0.039555083960294724, -0.008327861316502094, 0.031182561069726944, 0.06231103837490082, -0.056524865329265594, 0.009898195043206215, -0.10027969628572464, -0.022589173167943954, -0.0280492901802063, 0.04199545830488205, -0.0007572753238491714, 0.034442801028490067, -0.01628183014690876, 0.03851434215903282, 0.013256183825433254, 0.0004025294620078057, -0.04804162681102753, 0.007713940925896168, 0.024634631350636482, 0.01743721030652523, 0.03474671393632889, -0.013431846164166927, 0.011124380864202976, -0.03099249117076397, -0.0010892190039157867, 0.03006596304476261, 0.03826376795768738, -0.034825049340724945, -0.027752859517931938, 0.0021319969091564417, -0.024056430906057358, -0.030291620641946793, -0.018283167853951454, 0.029193682596087456, -0.032858483493328094, 0.03932816535234451, 0.007458064705133438, 0.009239545091986656, -0.017871716991066933, -0.018673641607165337, 0.006422352511435747, 0.02931695058941841, 0.0351782962679863, -0.01706603914499283, 0.051033876836299896, 0.01482628844678402, 0.004957051482051611, 0.009434144012629986, 0.07097296416759491, -0.0016403279732912779, 0.01000896468758583, -0.003480518702417612, -0.04785025864839554, 0.006358887068927288, -0.009771483018994331, 0.00428236648440361, 0.010635608807206154, 0.03393261507153511, 0.011419052258133888, 0.03013750910758972, -0.03688951954245567, 0.02047162689268589, 0.05992952361702919, 0.025703780353069305, -0.013284076005220413, -0.02548799477517605, -0.012466706335544586, -0.015409664250910282, 0.022588171064853668, 0.014091172255575657, 0.00198532035574317, -0.013724051415920258, 0.029397977516055107, 0.0460243783891201, 0.017445961013436317, 0.0029784697107970715, -0.008067571558058262, 0.04080351069569588, 0.06544375419616699, 0.025141611695289612, -0.007165919989347458, 0.04993997514247894, -0.0019180963281542063, 0.03301549330353737, 0.07048916816711426, -0.03306819126009941, -0.08170046657323837, 0.003329378552734852, 0.035901106894016266, 0.010566242970526218, 0.013567198999226093, -0.03605637699365616, -0.021223992109298706, -0.05085601285099983, 0.02925698831677437, -0.014365050941705704, 0.029572492465376854, -0.0407920740544796, 0.05347352847456932, -0.04623611271381378, -0.020217223092913628, -0.03354863449931145, 0.006394175812602043, -0.005171137396246195, 0.026045942679047585, -0.0012872118968516588, 0.0016054946463555098, -0.03158043324947357, -0.005732026882469654, -0.0065626404248178005, 0.03499836102128029, 0.01888214983046055, -0.03880278393626213, 0.02004547230899334, 0.01144777238368988, -0.029380105435848236, -0.0684572383761406, 0.0060751959681510925, 0.061064429581165314, -0.021452413871884346, 0.05932243913412094, -0.01405208557844162, 0.008570865727961063, -0.01173460204154253, -0.019522929564118385, -0.005011108238250017, 0.030529405921697617, -0.002545247320085764, 0.05093977227807045, 0.056666966527700424, -0.034080326557159424, 0.016793789342045784, 0.038967572152614594, -0.013135467655956745, -0.02301880344748497, -0.03500936180353165, 0.03933167830109596, -0.020256826654076576, -0.054332852363586426, -0.03310927748680115, -0.009034342132508755, -0.035894833505153656, -0.002334453398361802, -0.026166455820202827, 0.05872327834367752, -0.060353055596351624, -0.014089896343648434, -0.031597573310136795, 0.020161589607596397, -0.001097210799343884, -0.018110092729330063, -0.016733260825276375, 0.029525049030780792, 0.02001483552157879, -0.009107142686843872, -0.0009681620285846293, -0.0391361303627491, 0.005330347456037998, 0.05900795757770538, -0.018664227798581123, -0.0004598189552780241, -0.040045857429504395, -0.01702139899134636, 0.0017727143131196499, -0.02555910311639309, 0.04378511384129524, -0.011610613204538822, 0.03530660271644592, 0.023052867501974106, -0.05448298901319504, 0.0005874736816622317, 0.029694681987166405, 0.015437687747180462, 0.0030708671547472477, -0.0165337435901165, 0.03761880844831467, -0.03973928093910217, -0.02297079563140869, -0.059909477829933167, -0.06660047173500061, -0.0020106888841837645, 0.027043579146265984, -0.040396396070718765, -0.025257332250475883, -0.016977831721305847, -0.01401797216385603, -0.023096952587366104, -0.004011448938399553, 0.03524567559361458, -0.044254206120967865, -0.019308732822537422, -0.0018895650282502174, -0.0023435880430042744, 0.06998848915100098, 0.0107401292771101, -0.020491380244493484, 0.003117039566859603, 0.0011054032947868109, 0.0038769212551414967, -0.029452485963702202, -0.011611674912273884, -0.031744975596666336, 0.036252282559871674, -0.04477796331048012, 0.03718090057373047, 0.051594603806734085, 0.0014586321776732802, 0.03985972702503204, 0.024352746084332466, -0.011902702040970325, -0.011393187567591667, -0.021776776760816574, -0.015352580696344376, -0.03929683193564415, -0.011839324608445168, -0.015313437208533287, -0.04301450774073601, -0.016680791974067688, -0.04218146204948425, 0.012264098972082138, -0.009955426678061485, -0.04482624679803848, 0.029122745618224144, 0.0736444965004921, 0.02273869886994362, -0.0030465014278888702, -0.01206960715353489, -0.021099943667650223, 0.0072711557149887085, -0.015570132993161678, 0.013074113987386227, -0.014721359126269817, 0.012560279108583927, -0.010242483578622341, -0.013441197574138641, -0.01936608925461769, 0.04150192439556122, 0.03801792114973068, -0.06279673427343369, 0.02811710722744465, 0.05207397788763046, 0.012604687362909317, 0.009886039420962334, -0.06608648598194122, -0.0037179223727434874, -0.018088415265083313, 0.007682489696890116, 0.0575438030064106, -0.02622593194246292, -0.01798412948846817, 0.01410174835473299, 0.022862520068883896, 0.006191734224557877, 0.027400143444538116, -0.027227124199271202, 0.02004415914416313, 0.03210960701107979, -0.02965179830789566, -0.051047395914793015, -0.003327792277559638, -0.019044088199734688, 0.03306686133146286, -0.029304172843694687, -0.06125394254922867, 0.022266773506999016, 0.014614191837608814, -0.05967189744114876, -0.03051307611167431, 0.021026872098445892, -0.04119320958852768, 0.030662642791867256, 0.025616133585572243, -0.012555230408906937, 0.041519712656736374, -0.006038251798599958, 0.020654013380408287, 0.004024038091301918, 0.02040090411901474, -0.01664833165705204, -0.03436333313584328, -0.025038735941052437, -0.04892544448375702, -0.013487040996551514, 0.024679047986865044, -0.014849461615085602, -0.02613631635904312, 0.0034107714891433716, -0.02336267940700054, -0.03709854185581207, 0.010354376398026943, 0.012228201143443584, 0.04863215982913971, 0.0586908794939518, -0.0241713784635067, 0.04476052522659302, -0.018507380038499832, -0.0034894084092229605, 0.13464803993701935, 0.06725320965051651, 0.047670140862464905, -0.07605248689651489, 0.046511851251125336, 0.006897450890392065, -0.030665842816233635, -0.015066884458065033, 0.014993250370025635, 0.045727699995040894, -0.0067215184681117535, 0.006277495063841343, 0.053809721022844315, -0.02203034795820713, 0.040487635880708694, 0.08664620667695999, -0.0208086259663105, -0.013499964028596878, 0.02584885247051716, 0.03175198659300804, -0.01127970963716507, -0.009876636788249016, -0.10259779542684555, -0.011720661073923111, 0.026873750612139702, -0.010728783905506134, -0.0016301374416798353, -0.02013973891735077, 0.0681048110127449, -0.003948858939111233, -0.008224059827625751, 0.021994683891534805, 0.02057003043591976, 0.0021284925751388073, 0.009320390410721302, -0.015927176922559738, 0.013705815188586712, -0.017394894734025, 0.01335624698549509, 0.05756465345621109, 0.014984561130404472, 0.003617393784224987, -0.032285965979099274, -0.003088186029344797, -0.030794605612754822, -0.011007021181285381, -0.04752659797668457, -0.00020297207811381668, -0.019945301115512848, -0.037739697843790054, -0.000006095481694501359, 0.023143161088228226, 0.026287037879228592, -0.033434607088565826, -0.005102436523884535, -0.021181868389248848, 0.03672226890921593, 0.0058090356178581715, -0.022298650816082954, -0.0003922323230654001, -0.0032161041162908077, -0.021885255351662636, 0.0030183298513293266, 0.007482961751520634, -0.013344486244022846, 0.005599253810942173, -0.00837293267250061, 0.03899215906858444, 0.027969075366854668, -0.055547747761011124, 0.005196818150579929, -0.006968627218157053, -0.002801636466756463, -0.03686685487627983, -0.003131762845441699, 0.016924766823649406, -0.0014566093450412154, 0.02102491818368435, -0.012499228119850159, 0.009374668821692467, -0.015412362292408943, 0.05969230458140373, -0.025963112711906433, -0.012591259554028511, -0.015359669923782349, 0.014787786640226841, 0.05951165035367012, 0.03092799335718155, 0.020429160445928574, 0.010041825473308563, -0.014163395389914513, 0.038079433143138885, 0.003857493633404374, -0.036849431693553925, -0.06038753315806389, -0.015685463324189186, -0.024666933342814445, -0.0001300252479268238, -0.01854543201625347, 0.08327631652355194, 0.005406530108302832, 0.01944342628121376, -0.008395513519644737, 0.02275076135993004, 0.019954243674874306, 0.025326792150735855, 0.02024056948721409, -0.06476714462041855, -0.003753673518076539, -0.002362397499382496, -0.05374567583203316, -0.07246384769678116, 0.018853284418582916, 0.012454571202397346, -0.018944300711154938, -0.023275095969438553, 0.024954134598374367, -0.023428956046700478, 0.02757440134882927, -0.004077403340488672, 0.009751344099640846, -0.030870016664266586, -0.011041651479899883, -0.015050872229039669, -0.034452956169843674, -0.044847503304481506, -0.008786756545305252, -0.040191587060689926, 0.030303029343485832, -0.009448660537600517, 0.012659898027777672, 0.031305428594350815, 0.05825638771057129, 0.035836976021528244, 0.019207922741770744, 0.01697614975273609, -0.007677821908146143, 0.018330736085772514, -0.01238219067454338, 0.012067656964063644, 0.014619378373026848, -0.04060552641749382, -0.08201461285352707, -0.041379474103450775, -0.0017951529007405043, 0.03353048488497734, 0.006745964288711548, 0.0067615569569170475, -0.01105957105755806, 0.03962983563542366, -0.02302800677716732, -0.008464724756777287, 0.013497629202902317, 0.031976643949747086, 0.013739241287112236, -0.06341217458248138, 0.007259284146130085, 0.0019001165637746453, -0.008804748766124249, 0.0060217478312551975, 0.0013300151331350207, -0.014255305752158165, -0.052920762449502945, 0.0004328936629462987, -0.033672817051410675, 0.02444232441484928, -0.0030087153427302837, 0.0015577493468299508, 0.06240708753466606, 0.01846795342862606, 0.007518321741372347, -0.011216712184250355, 0.009739845059812069, 0.022723384201526642, -0.03914931043982506, -0.025892477482557297, -0.01107107661664486, -0.03104235976934433, 0.017808271571993828, -0.07281854748725891, 0.03340660408139229, -0.007929598912596703, -0.048012737184762955, 0.004302844405174255, -0.0078429551795125, 0.021770037710666656, -0.029964562505483627, 0.01612549088895321, -0.027743328362703323, 0.055851854383945465, 0.041646528989076614, 0.01878628134727478, 0.05891979858279228, 0.025220967829227448, -0.01157440897077322, -0.009223497472703457, 0.013470485806465149, -0.0027269667480140924, 0.01176458690315485, -0.05672050267457962, 0.05676451697945595, 0.0024691803846508265, -0.06610959768295288, 0.033091530203819275, -0.02314019203186035, 0.02175859548151493, 0.020107492804527283, 0.013543487526476383, -0.012544010765850544, 0.023990685120224953, 0.006059193518012762, -0.016502076759934425, -0.008436734788119793, -0.04326867312192917, 0.059711821377277374, -0.010020901449024677, 0.018548237159848213, 0.009030569344758987, 0.05585735663771629, -0.012277915142476559, -0.034344252198934555, -0.004372528288513422, 0.006875828839838505, -0.05054992809891701, -0.006125046871602535, -0.021364539861679077, 0.0634961873292923, 0.002726118080317974, 0.012224267236888409, -0.03927737846970558, 0.002860859502106905, 0.03441677987575531, -0.029889680445194244, 0.006570690777152777, -0.00623308913782239, 0.008786573074758053, -0.05811203271150589, 0.00997131783515215, 0.020134687423706055, -0.02128640189766884, -0.03289200738072395, 0.025761939585208893, -0.039528243243694305, -0.037808265537023544, -0.03317921236157417, 0.005731901619583368, 0.03341909497976303, 0.027555834501981735, -0.012856045737862587, -0.01307603344321251, 0.04331793263554573, -0.039372581988573074, 0.04739350453019142, -0.06014588102698326, 0.03975251317024231, -0.02014448121190071, -0.035434044897556305, 0.000021662361177732237, 0.015293086878955364, -0.04816905036568642, 0.04651879146695137, 0.045066144317388535, -0.015379687771201134, 0.025174224749207497, -0.0230085551738739, 0.02806691639125347, 0.022400543093681335, -0.02855071984231472, 0.03812156617641449, -0.013167026452720165, -0.003521191654726863, -0.0008594337268732488, -0.010144861415028572, 0.0017934180796146393, 0.004944304469972849, 0.03677227348089218, 0.020110588520765305, -0.0373934842646122, -0.010283172130584717, -0.00046994726289995015, -0.008210154250264168, -0.014027299359440804, -0.04918280988931656, 0.026732930913567543, -0.007661814801394939, -0.01672055386006832, 0.021150339394807816, 0.0022414885461330414, -0.04552469402551651, -0.01270222757011652, -0.04752352088689804, -0.03170132264494896, -0.012481603771448135, -0.011378335766494274, 0.05097736790776253, -0.07433447241783142, -0.0009201168431900442, -0.00014625157928094268, -0.024977033957839012, -0.03469160571694374, 0.04179318621754646, 0.0019682941492646933, 0.04320710524916649, -0.020649826154112816, 0.017511790618300438, -0.021755024790763855, 0.03837655112147331, -0.016672663390636444, -0.009696013294160366, 0.061134133487939835, 0.026598608121275902, -0.035019226372241974, 0.031109077855944633, -0.025415098294615746, 0.0730641633272171, -0.006862286943942308, 0.008271792903542519, 0.0009388736798427999, -0.005326115060597658, 0.044407814741134644, -0.02362174727022648, 0.00425723847001791, -0.006144930608570576, -0.007684210315346718, 0.02729535847902298, -0.016652530059218407, 0.00875948928296566, -0.05373134836554527, 0.032351721078157425, -0.02538544498383999, 0.0009741966496221721, 0.018485207110643387, 0.048292744904756546, -0.0038340450264513493, 0.00030610704561695457, -0.024786973372101784, -0.0077654835768043995, 0.04233314469456673, 0.018429497256875038, 0.0575842410326004, -0.037827033549547195, -0.024927204474806786, 0.006283951457589865, -0.0019588398281484842, -0.008179869502782822, -0.023189010098576546, 0.025102868676185608, 0.025024311617016792, 0.022049522027373314, -0.016635246574878693, -0.009216179139912128, -0.023765819147229195, 0.03777734562754631, -0.06380339711904526, -0.05482880398631096, 0.006718840915709734, -0.010168091394007206, 0.018715672194957733, 0.029260285198688507 ]
<p>I am new to R. I am building predictive model with gbm package. I have a problem that I retrieve different results for data from data frame that was used for building of the model and for separate data frame with same values.</p> <p>I randomly divide my data to two sets, training set is loaded to `head':</p> <blockquote> <p>head &lt;- read.csv(...)</p> </blockquote> <p>I build a model with gbm:</p> <blockquote> <p>fit1000x3 &lt;- gbm(V1 ~ V2+V3+V4+V5+V6+V7+V8+V9+V10+V11, data=head, n.trees=1000, distribution="gaussian", interaction.depth=3, bag.fraction=0.5, train.fraction=1.0, shrinkage=0.1, keep.data=TRUE)</p> </blockquote> <p>When I create a data frame with values equal to head[1,]:</p> <blockquote> <p>xxx &lt;- data.frame(V1=...)</p> </blockquote> <p>I receive different values for:</p> <blockquote> <p>predict(fit1000x3, newdata=head[1,], n.trees=100)</p> </blockquote> <p>and</p> <blockquote> <p>predict(fit1000x3, newdata=xxx, n.trees=100)</p> </blockquote> <p>Here is the series of commands I have run:</p> <pre> > head &lt;- read.csv(...) > fit1000x3 &lt;- gbm(V1 ~ V2+V3+V4+V5+V6+V7+V8+V9+V10+V11, data=head, n.trees=1000, distribution="gaussian", interaction.depth=3, bag.fraction=0.5, train.fraction=1.0, shrinkage=0.1, keep.data=TRUE) Iter TrainDeviance ValidDeviance StepSize Improve 1 0.1707 -nan 0.1000 0.0152 2 0.1581 -nan 0.1000 0.0122 3 0.1478 -nan 0.1000 0.0100 4 0.1395 -nan 0.1000 0.0079 5 0.1326 -nan 0.1000 0.0067 6 0.1267 -nan 0.1000 0.0056 7 0.1211 -nan 0.1000 0.0052 8 0.1168 -nan 0.1000 0.0039 9 0.1133 -nan 0.1000 0.0032 10 0.1103 -nan 0.1000 0.0027 100 0.0773 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 200 0.0734 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 300 0.0714 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 400 0.0695 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 500 0.0681 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 600 0.0672 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 700 0.0663 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 800 0.0655 -nan 0.1000 -0.0002 900 0.0648 -nan 0.1000 -0.0001 1000 0.0643 -nan 0.1000 -0.0001 > predict(fit1000x3, newdata=head[1,], n.trees=100) [1] 0.1420456 > head[1,] V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 V7 V8 V9 1 0 0.35 m01xrfn2 Effective resolution 5.1 Nu null null niceCharacter unitName V10 V11 1 null nextag > xxx &lt;- data.frame(V1=0, V2=0.35, V3="m01xrfn2 Effective resolution", V4="5.1", V5="Nu", V6="null", V7="null", V8="niceCharacter", V9="unitName", V10="null", V11="nextag") > xxx V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 V7 V8 V9 1 0 0.35 m01xrfn2 Effective resolution 5.1 Nu null null niceCharacter unitName V10 V11 1 null nextag > head[1,] V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 V7 V8 V9 1 0 0.35 m01xrfn2 Effective resolution 5.1 Nu null null niceCharacter unitName V10 V11 1 null nextag > predict(fit1000x3, newdata=xxx, n.trees=100) [1] 0.2068787 > str(head[1,]) 'data.frame': 1 obs. of 11 variables: $ V1 : int 0 $ V2 : num 0.35 $ V3 : Factor w/ 113 levels &quot;m01t_ Contains&quot;,..: 4 $ V4 : Factor w/ 884 levels ".","0","01","02",..: 503 $ V5 : Factor w/ 11 levels &quot;aN&quot;,&quot;aNu&quot;,&quot;aU&quot;,..: 4 $ V6 : Factor w/ 4 levels "null","propertyAlias",..: 1 $ V7 : Factor w/ 9 levels &quot;attach&quot;,&quot;block&quot;,..: 6 $ V8 : Factor w/ 8 levels "attach","block",..: 5 $ V9 : Factor w/ 4 levels &quot;null&quot;,&quot;propertyAlias&quot;,..: 4 $ V10: Factor w/ 2 levels "null","undef": 1 $ V11: Factor w/ 368 levels &quot;101reviews&quot;,&quot;123football&quot;,..: 223 &gt; str(xxx) &#39;data.frame&#39;: 1 obs. of 11 variables: $ V1 : num 0 $ V2 : num 0.35 $ V3 : Factor w/ 1 level "m01xrfn2 Effective resolution": 1 $ V4 : Factor w/ 1 level &quot;5.1&quot;: 1 $ V5 : Factor w/ 1 level "Nu": 1 $ V6 : Factor w/ 1 level &quot;null&quot;: 1 $ V7 : Factor w/ 1 level "null": 1 $ V8 : Factor w/ 1 level &quot;niceCharacter&quot;: 1 $ V9 : Factor w/ 1 level "unitName": 1 $ V10: Factor w/ 1 level &quot;null&quot;: 1 $ V11: Factor w/ 1 level "nextag": 1 </pre>
36,809
[ -0.016833987087011337, 0.0086115887388587, 0.012313544750213623, -0.0047364444471895695, 0.0015905741602182388, -0.00857849232852459, -0.020339680835604668, -0.0363788977265358, 0.046243950724601746, -0.013993464410305023, 0.06348264962434769, 0.04835035279393196, 0.020809469744563103, 0.04488557577133179, 0.008064985275268555, 0.017214253544807434, 0.005399896763265133, -0.005732038989663124, 0.00497896783053875, -0.011295691132545471, -0.03606696426868439, 0.04838431626558304, -0.006235605571419001, -0.023761868476867676, -0.012264242395758629, 0.07118071615695953, 0.022833459079265594, -0.00683507090434432, 0.011910376138985157, 0.024695931002497673, -0.03541335090994835, -0.05129601061344147, -0.015280015766620636, 0.03912242129445076, 0.027394123375415802, 0.0007320401491597295, 0.023492133244872093, -0.03282277658581734, -0.010328536853194237, 0.009113818407058716, -0.009309627115726471, -0.0024607719387859106, 0.0025687653105705976, 0.0714714527130127, -0.008572818711400032, 0.01837076060473919, -0.01052325963973999, -0.0069326977245509624, 0.04671980068087578, -0.026205770671367645, 0.026660149917006493, 0.005510151386260986, 0.05231903865933418, 0.07417351752519608, -0.026300983503460884, -0.0006249472498893738, 0.06063254177570343, 0.07665938884019852, -0.004300973378121853, -0.05905779078602791, -0.0054933782666921616, -0.048847511410713196, -0.006579129956662655, -0.0034794406965374947, -0.03911102935671806, 0.011666933074593544, 0.007704892195761204, -0.013365713879466057, 0.007361958734691143, -0.05067151039838791, 0.04901651665568352, 0.013487916439771652, 0.03235940262675285, -0.06172836571931839, 0.05381809175014496, -0.003688534488901496, -0.01739136315882206, 0.01055750623345375, 0.05952872335910797, 0.022035643458366394, -0.012496300972998142, 0.012860564514994621, -0.02278999239206314, -0.0241274181753397, 0.03958513215184212, -0.015471095219254494, 0.05492336302995682, -0.023877788335084915, 0.033241480588912964, 0.0386415496468544, -0.010900057852268219, 0.034490521997213364, 0.06126011162996292, -0.0298532135784626, 0.009093022905290127, 0.05940308794379234, -0.025847217068076134, 0.011200999841094017, -0.008788719773292542, 0.026978110894560814, -0.022053662687540054, -0.03862755373120308, 0.0001743026077747345, 0.053467731922864914, -0.06328354775905609, -0.025937000289559364, -0.042874377220869064, -0.02323971875011921, -0.008515621535480022, -0.03149287402629852, 0.015793709084391594, 0.05033784732222557, -0.008071193471550941, 0.0042786914855241776, 0.018782945349812508, -0.05083141475915909, -0.016809334978461266, -0.009747551754117012, 0.04913889244198799, 0.04599064216017723, 0.04627544432878494, -0.06434033066034317, 0.013630343601107597, -0.029894385486841202, -0.04556320607662201, -0.02958354912698269, 0.018101507797837257, -0.03211431950330734, -0.040940605103969574, 0.037995561957359314, 0.02797422744333744, -0.023800823837518692, 0.027616549283266068, 0.0004160927783232182, 0.033263467252254486, -0.011205488815903664, -0.05934257060289383, -0.0545257106423378, 0.05469885841012001, -0.01740083657205105, 0.025408102199435234, -0.04538334533572197, 0.003020358271896839, 0.008164508268237114, 0.03439828380942345, -0.0196374598890543, 0.016144685447216034, 0.011945941485464573, 0.015604030340909958, -0.0026636766269803047, 0.017104893922805786, 0.004146300721913576, -0.01355763804167509, -0.0038372150156646967, -0.03374345600605011, -0.0680232048034668, -0.014028305187821388, 0.032689280807971954, -0.061007723212242126, 0.03331495821475983, -0.011436768807470798, 0.0022506187669932842, 0.02463897503912449, -0.012457593344151974, 0.005768085829913616, -0.022697290405631065, 0.04678405076265335, 0.026505054906010628, 0.054634928703308105, 0.04365989938378334, -0.03005819208920002, 0.013646168634295464, 0.0002770164282992482, 0.03169335797429085, 0.029761701822280884, -0.009062866680324078, 0.0354500412940979, -0.03666914999485016, 0.02175307832658291, 0.02429322898387909, -0.00819313246756792, -0.025153227150440216, 0.023058656603097916, -0.043491218239068985, 0.032184261828660965, -0.003349130740389228, 0.009905881248414516, 0.007341471035033464, 0.02454662136733532, -0.03953378647565842, -0.054928455501794815, -0.07258688658475876, -0.0008096658857539296, -0.015690574422478676, -0.014554101973772049, 0.004298185929656029, -0.001500361249782145, 0.048720717430114746, 0.024630697444081306, -0.004040581174194813, 0.0017497673397883773, 0.013481684029102325, 0.03136283904314041, -0.026817169040441513, -0.03828389570116997, 0.07711875438690186, 0.019210385158658028, -0.027281835675239563, 0.06750542670488358, -0.031544264405965805, -0.03440086916089058, 0.0731203556060791, -0.03514789417386055, -0.002266806084662676, -0.03207944333553314, -0.022450005635619164, 0.03765216842293739, 0.031057102605700493, -0.0056571210734546185, 0.059781596064567566, -0.07629649341106415, 0.02894127368927002, 0.07545819878578186, -0.005827033892273903, -0.010300328955054283, -0.032594434916973114, -0.03834007307887077, 0.06391981244087219, -0.03103252686560154, -0.0038783405907452106, -0.05251772701740265, -0.03218450769782066, 0.016072694212198257, -0.007688949815928936, 0.01143742073327303, 0.009518316946923733, 0.04453365132212639, -0.018562082201242447, 0.004861359018832445, 0.011776763014495373, 0.0055611105635762215, -0.00815009605139494, 0.01581083983182907, 0.030212368816137314, 0.016305912286043167, 0.00006633232260355726, 0.028779158368706703, 0.006235226523131132, 0.06577383726835251, -0.0063970801420509815, -0.020869098603725433, 0.052918534725904465, 0.04748944938182831, -0.043532200157642365, -0.020787445828318596, -0.00512584438547492, 0.02776728756725788, -0.01665482111275196, 0.0011758720502257347, 0.06550449877977371, 0.0013939758064225316, -0.04662662371993065, -0.044657595455646515, -0.03193693608045578, 0.002441481687128544, 0.07454350590705872, -0.01100731547921896, -0.004409702494740486, 0.022597284987568855, -0.0415494330227375, 0.016176968812942505, 0.022232456132769585, -0.01995932124555111, -0.03645625337958336, 0.02452067658305168, -0.015123959630727768, 0.010443657636642456, 0.020986799150705338, -0.06569194793701172, -0.016223322600126266, 0.03173190355300903, -0.010622040368616581, 0.0325162447988987, -0.030977265909314156, -0.027655016630887985, 0.005467480979859829, -0.03705798462033272, 0.020008524879813194, -0.01547489408403635, -0.007287504617124796, -0.04332616925239563, 0.041052915155887604, -0.018230115994811058, -0.038697559386491776, -0.005090952385216951, -0.03720792382955551, 0.007046127691864967, 0.01621997356414795, -0.012699970975518227, 0.034249380230903625, 0.040417883545160294, -0.05518575385212898, -0.003762652399018407, -0.05248817056417465, -0.011035951785743237, -0.03616723045706749, -0.013756301254034042, 0.02900233119726181, 0.014014667831361294, 0.012782273814082146, 0.0022106843534857035, 0.022457001730799675, -0.0345812551677227, -0.05084684118628502, -0.05771241709589958, -0.01941974088549614, 0.0154884560033679, -0.010536565445363522, -0.018221111968159676, 0.04363223910331726, 0.07262901961803436, 0.055753014981746674, -0.01684299297630787, -0.030474022030830383, -0.008067309856414795, -0.04702829197049141, -0.021579772233963013, 0.01780764013528824, 0.014394203200936317, 0.006681828293949366, -0.0034597530029714108, 0.020308084785938263, 0.05124073848128319, 0.04688046872615814, -0.021306904032826424, -0.02792043425142765, 0.01879901997745037, -0.0005614268011413515, -0.044747963547706604, 0.031178869307041168, 0.000726439175195992, -0.01632755994796753, 0.005026033613830805, -0.030460959300398827, 0.007479218300431967, -0.03756082430481911, -0.04736865684390068, 0.01814195327460766, 0.023972760885953903, 0.07315574586391449, -0.0309941116720438, -0.003917854279279709, -0.012895772233605385, -0.03492801636457443, 0.011523646302521229, -0.0013526980765163898, 0.05424666032195091, -0.0011645402992144227, -0.02042197436094284, 0.0526069812476635, -0.008282787166535854, -0.015935413539409637, -0.0062756845727562904, -0.03430049121379852, -0.038226597011089325, 0.030788246542215347, -0.012044690549373627, -0.0038941556122153997, 0.012750639580190182, 0.028057895600795746, -0.015046537853777409, 0.011159943416714668, -0.04184475913643837, 0.008335039019584656, -0.051355671137571335, 0.0033360745292156935, -0.01823248155415058, 0.006640349980443716, 0.0018466514302417636, 0.0629662275314331, 0.03466615453362465, -0.01699795573949814, 0.02463972568511963, 0.03088541142642498, -0.0501999706029892, 0.024179017171263695, 0.035177700221538544, -0.005061916541308165, 0.0029811833519488573, -0.06461046636104584, 0.006386416964232922, -0.010545292869210243, 0.020360544323921204, 0.012867678888142109, 0.006358336191624403, -0.06137171387672424, 0.018209800124168396, -0.0345047265291214, -0.03466861695051193, -0.02961995080113411, 0.05012635141611099, 0.04755933955311775, 0.013184999115765095, 0.02862463891506195, 0.02609158121049404, 0.0017864314140751958, 0.007912302389740944, -0.031555186957120895, -0.004949389956891537, 0.03253309428691864, 0.050288788974285126, 0.039771031588315964, 0.030275648459792137, -0.05143722519278526, 0.03637198358774185, 0.030102672055363655, 0.0183421541005373, 0.05155903846025467, -0.03311028704047203, 0.020654937252402306, -0.038795556873083115, 0.003816217416897416, 0.0071890936233103275, -0.0017247500363737345, -0.013125531375408173, -0.02335428074002266, 0.0563315823674202, 0.03596244379878044, -0.03918767720460892, 0.04258415102958679, 0.03776710852980614, 0.03083382546901703, -0.021684562787413597, -0.013391072861850262, -0.0014190278016030788, -0.0057898941449820995, -0.009486165829002857, 0.017958728596568108, -0.020258432254195213, -0.01736452803015709, 0.00032080523669719696, 0.02361581288278103, -0.013937748037278652, -0.02736058086156845, -0.0072706639766693115, 0.03228676691651344, 0.04753900319337845, -0.04143001139163971, -0.011557481251657009, -0.03984428569674492, 0.04587193951010704, -0.004056002013385296, -0.008944784291088581, 0.02186603471636772, -0.0703730583190918, -0.002853855025023222, 0.0612865649163723, -0.0010534384055063128, -0.016755472868680954, -0.01607191376388073, -0.012910722754895687, -0.02012791484594345, 0.023016605526208878, -0.05302314832806587, 0.033916816115379333, 0.00004535295011010021, 0.024842221289873123, -0.014862765558063984, -0.02676251158118248, -0.037996966391801834, -0.01536234188824892, -0.08431203663349152, 0.008639516308903694, -0.021471573039889336, -0.010258336551487446, -0.017356026917696, 0.026669710874557495, -0.02313949726521969, 0.0374932587146759, -0.05295844003558159, -0.013100299052894115, 0.023919016122817993, -0.012258864007890224, 0.012196957133710384, -0.018779827281832695, 0.04438153654336929, -0.015436120331287384, 0.018618782982230186, 0.04740611091256142, -0.027264053001999855, -0.03079838491976261, 0.01606247015297413, 0.007023785263299942, -0.007631396874785423, -0.021452724933624268, -0.015593289397656918, 0.007699147332459688, 0.010613510385155678, -0.0013725350145250559, 0.09028676897287369, 0.016429349780082703, -0.0007736162515357137, -0.028411461040377617, -0.05829963833093643, 0.04710810258984566, -0.011165937408804893, -0.055621758103370667, -0.03280084952712059, -0.020369991660118103, -0.0024958145804703236, 0.006329589523375034, 0.0002854934718925506, 0.05171108618378639, -0.02825608290731907, -0.020979151129722595, 0.029195787385106087, 0.018189962953329086, -0.007403901778161526, 0.0044248453341424465, 0.007909304462373257, -0.02822825126349926, -0.0008326672250404954, 0.012185918167233467, 0.0074242656119167805, 0.01768229901790619, 0.0001395885628880933, -0.010433962568640709, -0.019840044900774956, 0.00290165888145566, -0.028357312083244324, 0.0032515295315533876, 0.033494364470243454, -0.002589042065665126, 0.0032309170346707106, 0.018061548471450806, 0.04870808124542236, 0.017900526523590088, -0.02252236381173134, -0.007192937657237053, 0.017782170325517654, -0.03295431658625603, -0.023665424436330795, -0.0018278289353474975, -0.007416639477014542, -0.025597140192985535, 0.005613348446786404, -0.038727547973394394, -0.021718565374612808, 0.006475737318396568, -0.025054430589079857, -0.010092990472912788, -0.04683782160282135, -0.0059233419597148895, 0.016861088573932648, 0.006910713389515877, -0.03976036235690117, 0.053176235407590866, -0.012209541164338589, 0.0028874019626528025, 0.0024379573296755552, 0.004007963929325342, 0.03855426609516144, 0.031160512939095497, -0.002836227649822831, -0.0068390099331736565, 0.023204568773508072, -0.013272728770971298, 0.006376282311975956, -0.0007778863655403256, 0.0028562110383063555, -0.00035512365866452456, 0.008073005825281143, -0.01549165602773428, 0.06294219195842743, 0.017344724386930466, -0.012867072597146034, 0.012095680460333824, -0.01974431797862053, 0.027396632358431816, -0.03317577391862869, 0.014210996218025684, -0.004612891934812069, -0.017572470009326935, -0.019054807722568512, 0.009164903312921524, -0.0018207469256594777, -0.037228718400001526, 0.02317030169069767, -0.025804901495575905, -0.012221874669194221, 0.035131219774484634, 0.09111202508211136, 0.015491733327507973, 0.0027168146334588528, -0.03261109068989754, -0.04753836989402771, 0.04665512591600418, 0.006664648652076721, -0.0004641258856281638, 0.0037325983867049217, 0.02911878004670143, -0.04450972378253937, -0.024143468588590622, -0.019107989966869354, 0.00975558627396822, 0.06399872153997421, 0.005444658920168877, 0.0553467757999897, 0.03060096688568592, -0.005083680618554354, 0.03400707617402077, -0.05454698204994202, -0.008301102556288242, -0.027533171698451042, 0.02516334503889084, 0.07248290628194809, 0.0034112902358174324, -0.02978142350912094, 0.06518197059631348, -0.010711198672652245, 0.04006831720471382, 0.03292909264564514, -0.018351983278989792, -0.020255688577890396, 0.00556165212765336, -0.020938031375408173, -0.00424161134287715, 0.038064949214458466, -0.012902713380753994, 0.00498961191624403, -0.02735152840614319, -0.014691042713820934, 0.04493498429656029, 0.046085942536592484, -0.011179514229297638, -0.031009677797555923, -0.016147583723068237, -0.08663028478622437, -0.004056354518979788, 0.05496064946055412, -0.05346783623099327, 0.014063384383916855, 0.07297424972057343, -0.002332465024664998, 0.0033850439358502626, 0.028172317892313004, -0.057045791298151016, -0.0934164822101593, -0.04711131751537323, -0.02036777138710022, -0.025816798210144043, 0.05981328710913658, -0.0033696575555950403, -0.01236742828041315, 0.00562323909252882, -0.02799590677022934, 0.030494384467601776, 0.0007317794370464981, 0.006802523508667946, 0.023169856518507004, 0.048095911741256714, 0.009317026473581791, 0.011909883469343185, -0.0006647194386459887, -0.0037213219329714775, 0.1308380365371704, 0.061740655452013016, 0.05399640277028084, -0.0489683635532856, 0.005084776319563389, 0.018999237567186356, -0.010216202586889267, 0.0015081607270985842, -0.01323821023106575, 0.02475121058523655, -0.013371759094297886, 0.01459608692675829, 0.0004309248470235616, 0.020022016018629074, 0.01747334934771061, 0.012007244862616062, -0.013194740749895573, -0.02313970774412155, -0.004287036135792732, 0.006630060728639364, 0.015767857432365417, -0.026734041050076485, -0.018352456390857697, 0.016053497791290283, 0.007831037975847721, 0.00020646721532102674, -0.026817992329597473, -0.0029237805865705013, 0.012438683770596981, 0.0401957705616951, 0.009158393368124962, 0.026020517572760582, 0.0058082155883312225, 0.006668420042842627, 0.05583060160279274, 0.02415325865149498, 0.001568096806295216, -0.008360255509614944, 0.014275440946221352, 0.023093633353710175, -0.007460413966327906, 0.004709071479737759, -0.014912940561771393, 0.014227173291146755, -0.04984083026647568, -0.03973034769296646, -0.03431006148457527, 0.05403970927000046, 0.003515128046274185, -0.04129387438297272, 0.011187140829861164, 0.028959184885025024, 0.0255436934530735, -0.04091056436300278, -0.001462401240132749, 0.03762565925717354, 0.017609000205993652, -0.034541890025138855, 0.0034302608110010624, 0.0010042957728728652, 0.038974322378635406, -0.038695983588695526, 0.035932108759880066, 0.012626837007701397, -0.027549322694540024, -0.0068540433421730995, -0.022337239235639572, 0.05458880588412285, -0.011884983628988266, 0.018124621361494064, 0.015703953802585602, -0.014068816788494587, -0.025099514052271843, -0.03960894048213959, 0.013665527105331421, 0.01685037836432457, -0.0071764541789889336, -0.027633214369416237, -0.02590537630021572, -0.021305767819285393, -0.03419503569602966, 0.014381157234311104, -0.03900744393467903, 0.02867867611348629, -0.02202010154724121, 0.01781393215060234, -0.0022452580742537975, 0.045408982783555984, 0.026559937745332718, 0.012543105520308018, -0.030098240822553635, 0.0344647578895092, 0.02222103253006935, -0.04538649693131447, -0.08107549697160721, 0.016986442729830742, -0.07864834368228912, -0.026415959000587463, -0.0007962598465383053, 0.07237943261861801, -0.006832411978393793, 0.008474152535200119, -0.014347990043461323, 0.05428936332464218, 0.0014428135473281145, 0.009895268827676773, 0.003562064841389656, -0.012510432861745358, 0.05291237682104111, 0.03503633663058281, 0.003619351889938116, -0.027614369988441467, -0.000817576190456748, -0.028713544830679893, -0.04089174047112465, 0.06032157316803932, -0.00018031956278719008, -0.031005671247839928, 0.008265002630650997, -0.012460792437195778, 0.01767754554748535, 0.0018228142289444804, -0.05246938392519951, -0.05666876956820488, -0.020396679639816284, -0.015892527997493744, -0.05395430698990822, 0.000626385968644172, 0.014334909617900848, -0.01823587715625763, -0.0027278652414679527, 0.03016388602554798, 0.0012601373018696904, 0.022328250110149384, -0.02967073768377304, 0.021981993690133095, -0.0032793437130749226, 0.04283572733402252, 0.03683266043663025, -0.03499765694141388, 0.01899528317153454, -0.020894628018140793, -0.04771493375301361, 0.013596510514616966, -0.01988094672560692, 0.03273879364132881, 0.007949966005980968, -0.01653444766998291, -0.02019946649670601, 0.08708742260932922, -0.03370825573801994, -0.0133977634832263, -0.01329092402011156, -0.010273140855133533, 0.013772969134151936, 0.016761617735028267, 0.026125792413949966, 0.04872610792517662, -0.02013249695301056, -0.006703527644276619, 0.036920104175806046, 0.017598794773221016, -0.0027514046523720026, -0.006581782829016447, -0.024258801713585854, 0.008379945531487465, 0.020668556913733482, -0.017345692962408066, 0.001581660588271916, 0.07083778828382492, -0.011372914537787437, 0.05348389968276024, -0.01671779528260231, 0.011470283381640911, -0.0688757374882698, -0.04359836503863335, 0.0020918475929647684, 0.020250903442502022, 0.011794544756412506, -0.015445863828063011, 0.015412405133247375, 0.016413770616054535, -0.03530986234545708, 0.03151300549507141, 0.007574534043669701, 0.011136029846966267, -0.02270294912159443, 0.02516176737844944, -0.03443779796361923, -0.011349002830684185, 0.06854988634586334, 0.0053019775077700615, 0.050756581127643585, 0.01871173456311226, -0.026413358747959137, -0.02515653520822525, -0.05071811005473137, -0.0027579397428780794, 0.001003529061563313, -0.022272055968642235, -0.016810080036520958, -0.011278735473752022, -0.008913401514291763, 0.008678685873746872, -0.016100844368338585, 0.0006177257746458054, 0.04167827591300011, 0.0282246395945549, 0.04848725348711014, 0.07031918317079544, -0.00044259525020606816, 0.03390737250447273, 0.004282586742192507, -0.032702136784791946, 0.0005735195591114461, -0.009052762761712074, -0.0017465767450630665, 0.00702626584097743, -0.019545884802937508, -0.017179928719997406, -0.03681342676281929, 0.0020367256365716457, -0.0174458846449852, -0.014875694178044796, -0.026395130902528763, 0.020286213606595993, -0.002878473838791251, -0.028452400118112564, 0.008320878259837627, -0.04618807137012482, 0.031026307493448257, 0.046648770570755005, 0.01659858599305153, -0.032118938863277435, 0.01475400198251009, -0.036060694605112076, -0.00877788569778204, 0.004346581641584635, 0.016199897974729538, -0.03903155028820038, -0.013581337407231331, -0.0413716658949852, -0.016443395987153053, -0.018109692260622978, -0.012751501053571701, -0.001275839633308351, -0.06405859440565109, 0.03882676735520363, -0.05304957181215286, 0.024161890149116516, -0.0003308747836854309, -0.03871450945734978, -0.0030183338094502687, -0.11716622859239578, 0.041057296097278595, -0.0026139819528907537, -0.047834914177656174, -0.06611346453428268, 0.004631446208804846, -0.023954618722200394, 0.04342564195394516, 0.045531850308179855, 0.015053651295602322, -0.0029505558777600527, 0.01053663156926632, 0.030556609854102135, -0.0023823443334549665, -0.03796361759305, 0.03958069905638695, 0.013566766865551472, -0.004270975943654776, 0.000684550788719207, -0.003932463936507702, 0.029203951358795166, 0.0285300612449646, -0.01654234528541565, -0.0314645953476429, -0.015313191339373589, 0.027791718021035194, -0.010395820252597332, 0.03404652699828148, -0.021538658067584038, 0.01392627228051424, 0.02954864874482155, -0.019619474187493324, 0.015487794764339924, 0.08634266257286072, 0.008388186804950237, -0.050786323845386505, -0.01405846793204546, -0.021514061838388443, -0.03366101533174515, 0.002191514242440462, 0.022753184661269188, 0.03926180303096771, -0.021876784041523933, 0.019031783565878868, 0.020647669211030006, -0.04161348193883896, 0.035699017345905304, 0.055352065712213516, 0.02870672568678856, 0.03629179671406746, -0.018603654578328133, 0.022329237312078476, -0.044775255024433136, -0.037379223853349686, 0.03635704144835472, -0.006126174237579107, -0.005298897624015808, 0.02163774147629738, -0.002623015781864524, 0.04243432730436325, -0.018202640116214752, -0.016143877059221268, -0.030936531722545624, 0.04299217462539673, -0.014733283780515194, -0.004301751963794231, -0.02854970656335354, -0.022711005061864853, -0.007067191880196333, -0.010532899759709835, -0.021016079932451248, 0.04353417083621025, -0.06220920383930206, -0.030740870162844658, -0.023353824391961098, -0.026397550478577614, 0.010327314957976341, 0.027672890573740005, 0.009717265143990517, 0.000972818408627063, 0.028515396639704704, 0.01608053594827652, 0.02644091099500656, -0.03371235355734825, 0.03211836516857147, -0.012119485065340996, -0.03758154809474945, -0.007066462654620409, 0.018272779881954193, -0.029644716531038284, 0.008686602115631104, -0.012436095625162125, -0.03650356084108353, 0.035624176263809204, 0.026655981317162514, -0.0001385317591484636, -0.033502787351608276, -0.015092534944415092, -0.018203632906079292, 0.04927283897995949, -0.02584424428641796, 0.0017734896391630173, -0.03144504502415657, -0.011114643886685371, 0.024325009435415268, -0.02909903973340988 ]
<p>I am trying to build an index that summarizes health care quality on different departments for a number of hospitals. I have selected a number of variables, each representing quality in a medical specialization.</p> <p>The weighting scheme is quite obvious for me. Since the index will be related to costs on an aggregated level it make sense to weight the diffrent quality indicators according to the specializations costs.</p> <p>I have another problem however. Diffrent indicators are measured on different scales. The usual solution is to Z - standardize them but this will introduce a problem where an indicator with irrelevant differences, say an indicator where hospitals differ but the difference is deemed non relevant medically will have the same effect on the index as an indicator with medically relevant differences and with the same costs. How should I handle this?</p> <p>To explain it further. Say I have reoperations of hip surgery, it has a cost of 200 and has values between 0.1 to 0.2 with 0.15 as mean. All results are deemed very good here and the diffrence is mostly related to sample size. </p> <p>I also have blood sugar levels that go from 100 to 200 with 150 as mean, this represent diabetes and has 200 in cost weighting too. This is however a medically relevant difference and not related to sample size. </p> <p>Using Z-standarization the highest value in the hip surgery indicator will have about the same effect on the index component as the highest value in the blood sugar levels while one is interesting and the other is not.</p> <p>Any ideas on how to handle this?</p>
74,137
[ -0.04233694449067116, -0.018367454409599304, -0.019117385149002075, 0.005489769857376814, 0.057823531329631805, 0.04817819222807884, -0.0029772950801998377, -0.029092900454998016, 0.03594375401735306, -0.015659146010875702, 0.0003474800905678421, -0.0033253279980272055, 0.08811166137456894, 0.03173651173710823, 0.012202709913253784, -0.01348514761775732, 0.014358988031744957, -0.004872898105531931, -0.0012643355876207352, -0.038620758801698685, 0.011392424814403057, 0.02307872101664543, 0.012191309593617916, -0.019343601539731026, -0.047699958086013794, 0.039017338305711746, -0.006189432926476002, -0.019253075122833252, -0.02491929568350315, 0.04160602390766144, -0.026236306875944138, -0.03199902921915054, -0.009938418865203857, 0.016216637566685677, 0.0011741477064788342, 0.015193002298474312, -0.030693307518959045, 0.005396140273660421, -0.05050808936357498, 0.046905893832445145, 0.0005107767065055668, -0.023085521534085274, -0.01420948002487421, -0.0025259959511458874, -0.018792860209941864, 0.026587001979351044, -0.023401841521263123, -0.0021721371449530125, 0.022318216040730476, -0.05414456129074097, 0.048179157078266144, 0.009166745468974113, 0.052535977214574814, 0.048299387097358704, -0.02260245569050312, -0.02251800335943699, 0.021753348410129547, 0.0760587826371193, 0.007851636037230492, -0.0072769965045154095, -0.030791331082582474, 0.014135840348899364, 0.031105320900678635, -0.010282441042363644, -0.007890798151493073, 0.016429269686341286, 0.0015810196055099368, -0.013371176086366177, 0.023384585976600647, 0.007039416581392288, -0.0065978155471384525, 0.0505271777510643, 0.014320089481770992, -0.03361571207642555, 0.04458773508667946, -0.041319165378808975, 0.012477457523345947, 0.022736836224794388, 0.07186749577522278, 0.020514825358986855, 0.009741057641804218, 0.007662102114409208, 0.0024121389724314213, 0.05050845071673393, 0.010363816283643246, -0.02701989933848381, 0.03748936578631401, -0.053740907460451126, 0.006760591175407171, 0.0066152941435575485, 0.011089515872299671, 0.014404875226318836, 0.05447708070278168, 0.016230398789048195, -0.0046623628586530685, 0.003849566215649247, -0.025198308750987053, 0.026075134053826332, -0.011525942012667656, 0.025618139654397964, -0.01211288757622242, -0.039970215409994125, 0.017553985118865967, 0.025672482326626778, 0.006642634980380535, 0.009051174856722355, -0.01740039698779583, -0.013424183242022991, 0.012696514837443829, -0.0049654096364974976, -0.0164986252784729, -0.019617104902863503, 0.026404600590467453, -0.017339050769805908, 0.04211992025375366, -0.016788585111498833, -0.005106174852699041, -0.016075868159532547, 0.020263781771063805, 0.07145204395055771, 0.050177764147520065, -0.000588421942666173, 0.004317937884479761, -0.023628897964954376, -0.08125339448451996, 0.05826663598418236, -0.007865533232688904, -0.023813297972083092, -0.0584167018532753, 0.054939575493335724, 0.0015832383651286364, -0.02162519283592701, 0.032853931188583374, -0.024228742346167564, 0.016904838383197784, 0.013295299373567104, -0.0828864723443985, -0.06725933402776718, 0.02177734673023224, 0.01875392347574234, 0.014253910630941391, -0.051553044468164444, 0.00053362303879112, 0.022411245852708817, 0.042055342346429825, 0.02633787877857685, 0.03403474763035774, 0.03873185068368912, 0.014817452058196068, 0.03187604993581772, -0.009886973537504673, -0.04532935842871666, 0.005487518385052681, -0.018278473988175392, 0.01583614945411682, -0.08749723434448242, -0.025011587888002396, 0.010218325071036816, -0.02592664398252964, -0.02631142921745777, 0.030976278707385063, 0.022710828110575676, 0.005480698775500059, 0.019497619941830635, 0.038815759122371674, -0.012597464956343174, 0.06906881928443909, -0.022581979632377625, 0.04293294996023178, 0.027165433391928673, 0.02390269935131073, -0.02551049180328846, 0.004244407173246145, 0.030859338119626045, 0.02918270416557789, -0.01817355491220951, 0.02659188210964203, -0.04989873617887497, -0.004118750803172588, 0.01850508712232113, -0.04513963311910629, -0.05041532963514328, -0.03810054436326027, 0.00664942292496562, 0.029873672872781754, 0.04928199201822281, -0.002838781103491783, -0.03531448915600777, 0.0797315239906311, -0.05741920322179794, -0.0334753692150116, -0.03643118962645531, -0.04277320206165314, 0.008462994359433651, -0.02011694945394993, 0.05441289767622948, -0.03664931282401085, -0.00992251094430685, -0.014082721434533596, -0.01715141534805298, -0.004917792044579983, -0.0148012675344944, 0.053944479674100876, -0.0427873432636261, 0.020058322697877884, 0.01974835991859436, 0.061156511306762695, -0.031226232647895813, 0.026232685893774033, 0.0003616090980358422, -0.05206042528152466, 0.0026756105944514275, -0.04686354845762253, 0.010334922932088375, 0.005544028244912624, -0.04521939903497696, 0.03286285325884819, -0.02318357676267624, -0.006696509663015604, 0.03235398977994919, -0.07512643188238144, 0.07841555774211884, 0.07725215703248978, -0.014425402507185936, 0.021372182294726372, 0.030664606019854546, 0.01362728700041771, 0.045923348516225815, -0.015409926883876324, -0.001636617467738688, -0.05723395571112633, 0.03081154264509678, 0.025231702253222466, 0.016089236363768578, -0.035643771290779114, -0.0037580642383545637, 0.059288643300533295, 0.012964053079485893, 0.033916670829057693, 0.020351875573396683, -0.0036365583073347807, 0.021739527583122253, 0.03317256271839142, -0.005132962483912706, 0.04776955395936966, 0.008191737346351147, 0.0035290741361677647, -0.011460219509899616, 0.013165165670216084, -0.027400825172662735, 0.05750373750925064, 0.042525917291641235, 0.015774108469486237, 0.04532076418399811, 0.0012670798460021615, -0.043079521507024765, 0.00321927759796381, -0.02678552269935608, 0.03343048319220543, 0.057661592960357666, 0.01647537387907505, 0.007205822039395571, 0.007255386095494032, -0.02897443249821663, 0.0017906248103827238, 0.03553004190325737, -0.034132808446884155, 0.02781411074101925, 0.007508384063839912, -0.008672266267240047, 0.017351996153593063, -0.015379384160041809, -0.019946599379181862, -0.04272918403148651, -0.04639630764722824, 0.02256631664931774, -0.013720422051846981, -0.007664851378649473, 0.009005296044051647, -0.021463632583618164, -0.009486990049481392, -0.007994973100721836, 0.0032153066713362932, 0.054619669914245605, -0.01604289561510086, -0.02289031445980072, -0.025617504492402077, -0.020032968372106552, 0.030166195705533028, -0.026151686906814575, 0.007145367097109556, 0.003137268591672182, 0.0452013835310936, -0.044842276722192764, -0.010590020567178726, -0.007296379189938307, 0.017330827191472054, -0.012581141665577888, -0.030769474804401398, 0.005988387390971184, 0.021126266568899155, -0.03748654946684837, 0.03399205952882767, -0.027023855596780777, -0.030670631676912308, -0.01022363267838955, -0.0006876931292936206, -0.002737484173849225, 0.0025679124519228935, -0.016053685918450356, 0.05502559617161751, -0.04928193986415863, 0.0024751273449510336, -0.0397191122174263, -0.03535120189189911, 0.013222573325037956, -0.01904997229576111, 0.04822944477200508, -0.016404306516051292, -0.03136909380555153, 0.06028789281845093, 0.018333708867430687, -0.023120176047086716, -0.050874706357717514, -0.011545568704605103, -0.011188984848558903, -0.021923821419477463, 0.025795310735702515, 0.06272821873426437, 0.0056795645505189896, -0.0055651417933404446, 0.035303108394145966, 0.04358717054128647, 0.055218011140823364, 0.03617361560463905, -0.010738273151218891, 0.027248138561844826, 0.024576587602496147, -0.006350784096866846, 0.05541285499930382, 0.03803963586688042, -0.041592929512262344, 0.020137712359428406, 0.014874191023409367, -0.0018187706591561437, 0.012798262760043144, -0.07379648834466934, 0.020916122943162918, 0.014870040118694305, 0.027299344539642334, -0.0478057898581028, 0.01815626211464405, 0.06204776465892792, -0.01396962534636259, -0.005864225793629885, 0.01453680545091629, 0.025704925879836082, -0.0416245236992836, 0.0006811344646848738, 0.08882603049278259, 0.038047466427087784, 0.0028728866018354893, 0.02109985053539276, -0.02593628317117691, -0.006417763885110617, 0.03662222996354103, -0.057448673993349075, -0.01072226744145155, -0.004423995967954397, 0.0276576429605484, 0.0019263100111857057, -0.01961260475218296, -0.04546657204627991, -0.010744880884885788, -0.11564310640096664, -0.032256096601486206, -0.02550303190946579, 0.08429549634456635, 0.007567185442894697, 0.01925097592175007, 0.02055295743048191, 0.00358357816003263, -0.024259384721517563, -0.014605705626308918, -0.043066661804914474, 0.04024002328515053, -0.01598990708589554, 0.02661101333796978, 0.06411945074796677, -0.02423778921365738, -0.021343890577554703, -0.014913548715412617, 0.034823354333639145, -0.011271518655121326, 0.04851772263646126, -0.009081811644136906, 0.009234074503183365, -0.005586819723248482, -0.010820996947586536, -0.004042118322104216, 0.001218613120727241, -0.007908008061349392, 0.015729226171970367, 0.02582680992782116, -0.0010812002001330256, -0.014035609550774097, 0.008272439241409302, -0.022711142897605896, 0.043824926018714905, 0.01094830222427845, 0.025261109694838524, -0.020873310044407845, -0.005679002497345209, -0.04616304114460945, 0.0070161474868655205, 0.033345114439725876, 0.02561413310468197, 0.007266816683113575, -0.022424058988690376, -0.0039508165791630745, -0.01411428488790989, -0.04334304854273796, -0.006104900036007166, 0.022787977010011673, 0.030684735625982285, -0.024059172719717026, 0.03776662424206734, -0.010701822116971016, -0.08458197861909866, 0.008446061052381992, 0.06449971348047256, 0.014452734030783176, -0.026825157925486565, -0.028565848246216774, -0.05178990587592125, -0.025336898863315582, -0.01645207405090332, 0.06638806313276291, 0.023372752591967583, 0.006159232929348946, -0.002395812189206481, -0.0025428051594644785, -0.000053423242206918076, -0.0363912470638752, -0.004442188888788223, 0.03982284665107727, 0.03943098336458206, 0.018769389018416405, -0.01372148934751749, 0.040978625416755676, -0.011669062077999115, 0.024441780522465706, 0.04234282672405243, -0.009565360844135284, -0.08470235019922256, -0.013007760979235172, 0.02340237982571125, 0.039008233696222305, -0.003951179329305887, -0.009752292186021805, -0.013462895527482033, 0.000004278439973859349, 0.054651834070682526, -0.03967111185193062, 0.013142973184585571, -0.041760578751564026, 0.0192221961915493, -0.013866900466382504, -0.014627560041844845, -0.03885049372911453, 0.024424871429800987, -0.026247084140777588, 0.04246198758482933, -0.015322616323828697, -0.008053279481828213, -0.034968301653862, -0.0030867676250636578, 0.03109976276755333, 0.04312196746468544, -0.017650224268436432, -0.02661551907658577, 0.004375468473881483, 0.0469229482114315, -0.03843635320663452, -0.0888160988688469, 0.02562016062438488, 0.009774623438715935, 0.046711090952157974, 0.03636874258518219, 0.021672319620847702, -0.035366810858249664, -0.0057913861237466335, -0.0026042889803647995, 0.013340586796402931, 0.028466887772083282, 0.026587247848510742, 0.04487099498510361, 0.06826462596654892, -0.007798012346029282, 0.04644504189491272, 0.010934047400951385, -0.024215105921030045, 0.03815582022070885, -0.02908175066113472, -0.01203893218189478, -0.052083853632211685, -0.0016257344977930188, -0.033279284834861755, 0.00788280088454485, -0.027909282594919205, 0.022444983944296837, -0.008334838785231113, 0.0514284186065197, -0.029580287635326385, -0.011629490181803703, 0.004567481577396393, 0.020741140469908714, 0.009543966501951218, -0.05271965637803078, 0.005208092276006937, 0.029348021373152733, 0.039237331598997116, -0.00755699910223484, 0.028841428458690643, -0.0032260569278150797, -0.03424966335296631, 0.0029567142482846975, -0.04846619814634323, -0.00013281447172630578, -0.026332728564739227, -0.019312657415866852, 0.012827776372432709, -0.031962912529706955, 0.0061669000424444675, -0.02431110106408596, 0.04166898503899574, 0.009582584723830223, -0.01939377747476101, -0.008582647889852524, 0.031366243958473206, 0.003424064489081502, -0.0060037472285330296, -0.04370200261473656, 0.02273860014975071, -0.003783744527027011, -0.005329608917236328, -0.07217301428318024, -0.004108676686882973, 0.050199735909700394, 0.03645522892475128, 0.010161303915083408, -0.010974135249853134, 0.018660644069314003, -0.012806559912860394, -0.036498088389635086, -0.054868198931217194, 0.04341234266757965, -0.021323375403881073, -0.012313410639762878, -0.02255258336663246, 0.03910594433546066, 0.09919663518667221, -0.02042677253484726, 0.0065933698788285255, 0.013704665936529636, -0.01442993339151144, -0.011676623485982418, -0.03338354453444481, -0.000268523464910686, -0.022699689492583275, -0.020629607141017914, -0.02165166661143303, 0.005815747659653425, 0.002163021359592676, 0.009390140883624554, 0.014580466784536839, -0.01795339584350586, -0.01771380566060543, 0.008714201860129833, -0.021312611177563667, -0.0006841262802481651, -0.016377786174416542, 0.012039809487760067, -0.02627437748014927, 0.04090487211942673, -0.02001888118684292, 0.0014255180722102523, 0.008894902653992176, 0.008979748003184795, -0.018171563744544983, -0.004058276768773794, 0.049520522356033325, 0.019020698964595795, 0.02138327620923519, 0.015027450397610664, -0.024224840104579926, 0.04222402721643448, -0.015823865309357643, -0.02294963225722313, 0.014191590249538422, 0.04795301333069801, 0.003663026262074709, 0.0005950217600911856, -0.0017057928489521146, -0.0002774738532025367, 0.06627301871776581, 0.031066929921507835, 0.03261425346136093, 0.03908558189868927, -0.025097882375121117, -0.008296109735965729, -0.03128274902701378, -0.0031582899391651154, 0.007260039448738098, 0.0005330327549017966, 0.05286135897040367, -0.007424504961818457, -0.0022101018112152815, 0.025812136009335518, 0.013593797571957111, -0.013744194991886616, -0.0005092688370496035, 0.02299165166914463, 0.016025345772504807, 0.02090650424361229, -0.04535800218582153, -0.05098375305533409, 0.026639962568879128, -0.03567938506603241, 0.02377570979297161, -0.034730877727270126, -0.05214929208159447, 0.015489775687456131, 0.03613108769059181, -0.003083340125158429, -0.06136434152722359, -0.009060826152563095, -0.07486257702112198, 0.0029641299042850733, 0.005990996956825256, -0.04226263612508774, 0.04850098490715027, -0.011444956995546818, -0.006971115246415138, 0.002986062550917268, -0.014056534506380558, -0.08662055432796478, -0.047216545790433884, -0.0242360420525074, -0.04600602760910988, -0.020634358748793602, 0.01864917203783989, -0.025054870173335075, -0.020218081772327423, 0.028706151992082596, -0.029857629910111427, 0.041811734437942505, 0.010020178742706776, -0.003347866702824831, 0.008466177619993687, 0.030471161007881165, 0.009563399478793144, 0.036095961928367615, 0.012910408899188042, 0.009218894876539707, 0.13169468939304352, 0.05827966332435608, 0.023781675845384598, -0.048511065542697906, 0.022233521565794945, 0.026844197884202003, 0.010246798396110535, 0.006437032949179411, 0.05870876461267471, 0.006984515581279993, -0.019529012963175774, 0.051382578909397125, 0.04621526226401329, 0.008871058002114296, -0.023250620812177658, 0.07816031575202942, -0.04016641154885292, 0.033604979515075684, 0.016555897891521454, 0.025611232966184616, -0.01476762630045414, -0.030436059460043907, -0.08769169449806213, 0.04764796048402786, -0.016152599826455116, -0.015415828675031662, -0.02865617163479328, -0.004900879692286253, -0.022894026711583138, -0.00329100270755589, -0.0004863484064117074, -0.010732732713222504, -0.014247299171984196, -0.001831826870329678, -0.013790133409202099, 0.006529541220515966, 0.034628525376319885, -0.022075209766626358, 0.002668695989996195, -0.013553915545344353, 0.019778506830334663, 0.001477692974731326, -0.021026093512773514, 0.027399593964219093, -0.05481545627117157, 0.004169397056102753, -0.055579692125320435, 0.03494644910097122, -0.0013414492132142186, -0.008387863636016846, -0.02563539333641529, -0.005487439688295126, -0.01245392207056284, -0.05737210437655449, 0.002496107714250684, 0.003237334778532386, 0.02405374124646187, -0.007899663411080837, 0.0008084001019597054, 0.011225230060517788, 0.03502597659826279, -0.005127019248902798, 0.018567198887467384, 0.03169512376189232, -0.021663818508386612, -0.01951054111123085, -0.02114100009202957, 0.02683090977370739, -0.006000326946377754, 0.004447229206562042, 0.03829354792833328, -0.015196830965578556, -0.018252739682793617, -0.02286561205983162, -0.033215031027793884, -0.007333432789891958, 0.018347060307860374, -0.03275340050458908, 0.021953245624899864, -0.05303749069571495, -0.00832459982484579, 0.025123249739408493, -0.02247571386396885, -0.02746139094233513, -0.0319971926510334, 0.005982197821140289, -0.002610541880130768, 0.027226267382502556, 0.004949773196130991, 0.006557936314493418, -0.016532769426703453, 0.05026544630527496, 0.012198216281831264, -0.06793944537639618, -0.013709969818592072, -0.01395928394049406, -0.042210835963487625, 0.04560202360153198, -0.028916670009493828, 0.07580365240573883, 0.016384681686758995, 0.022931238636374474, 0.023153025656938553, 0.05384349450469017, 0.022816723212599754, -0.011202933266758919, 0.018023131415247917, -0.05916454643011093, -0.018776753917336464, 0.03042365238070488, -0.006399173755198717, -0.0345185250043869, 0.0005220865132287145, -0.05282752960920334, -0.04684491455554962, -0.0018161236075684428, 0.0009382347925566137, -0.005508399568498135, -0.016784124076366425, -0.007128496188670397, 0.0063315462321043015, 0.007154252380132675, 0.012002935633063316, -0.026102758944034576, -0.00006174586451379582, -0.007630647625774145, 0.014252048917114735, -0.0025876339059323072, 0.008443228900432587, -0.017599675804376602, -0.01255801972001791, 0.0042829569429159164, -0.020328575745224953, 0.029013313353061676, 0.0048196339048445225, -0.020180825144052505, 0.0069358740001916885, 0.03652382269501686, -0.013562685810029507, 0.01582399196922779, -0.009352247230708599, -0.012812741100788116, -0.013426383025944233, 0.03377436846494675, -0.013147146441042423, 0.019406789913773537, 0.02016068994998932, -0.004860640503466129, -0.026660948991775513, 0.036564406007528305, -0.030756358057260513, -0.045525647699832916, -0.00844306405633688, 0.04293664172291756, 0.017418324947357178, -0.017868811264634132, 0.017792921513319016, 0.011119192466139793, -0.028724834322929382, 0.009898054413497448, 0.019379928708076477, -0.0023168358020484447, -0.024676229804754257, -0.010207949206233025, 0.03669600188732147, 0.00037849543150514364, -0.015234439633786678, 0.022224396467208862, 0.06116638332605362, 0.05622498691082001, -0.05008924752473831, 0.022380515933036804, -0.002788987709209323, 0.013356831856071949, -0.0595451183617115, -0.026125680655241013, -0.02638131193816662, -0.00044271606020629406, 0.03822144493460655, -0.037504468113183975, 0.025997135788202286, 0.007848203182220459, -0.05056605860590935, -0.00001720781256153714, -0.018423033878207207, -0.02509826421737671, -0.019513145089149475, -0.005446408875286579, -0.027406953275203705, -0.00045940588461235166, -0.020249739289283752, 0.032369550317525864, 0.023233547806739807, 0.018031498417258263, -0.0062601263634860516, -0.04233070835471153, -0.011169488541781902, -0.005169491283595562, -0.011937936767935753, -0.0834885984659195, 0.02765537239611149, -0.05129179358482361, -0.07752148807048798, 0.03398430719971657, -0.016000909730792046, 0.02032838761806488, 0.021509019657969475, 0.02169639617204666, 0.026299290359020233, 0.0772334486246109, 0.01328120194375515, -0.011223425157368183, -0.02334502339363098, -0.028655344620347023, -0.010514804162085056, 0.009476259350776672, -0.004080772399902344, 0.02370421588420868, 0.06157665327191353, -0.024125073105096817, 0.005555072799324989, 0.001594925532117486, -0.02368398942053318, -0.024451466277241707, -0.01900172047317028, 0.016506580635905266, 0.015545729547739029, -0.03551620617508888, 0.003918066620826721, -0.014948136173188686, 0.0409574955701828, 0.07957162708044052, 0.006384065840393305, -0.0026175992097705603, -0.045620013028383255, -0.01737063191831112, -0.0341867133975029, -0.009938572533428669, 0.010390236042439938, -0.05197121575474739, -0.009440204128623009, 0.0034044217318296432, -0.032901398837566376, -0.030120478942990303, -0.03425012528896332, 0.03199704363942146, -0.04460389167070389, 0.03320029750466347, -0.03694159910082817, 0.03484044596552849, 0.03256794437766075, 0.01017194613814354, 0.03496607393026352, -0.09661606699228287, 0.040483616292476654, 0.006315732374787331, -0.006158178206533194, -0.01031462475657463, -0.04832610860466957, -0.05243289843201637, 0.04126502573490143, 0.08936969935894012, 0.04021473601460457, 0.00036893883952870965, -0.01703273504972458, -0.0027177080046385527, 0.01509408000856638, -0.01660771481692791, 0.04628505930304527, -0.012998612597584724, -0.014963830821216106, -0.008035505190491676, 0.02946833334863186, 0.04108520969748497, -0.014592737890779972, -0.0048868232406675816, 0.0010231188498437405, -0.01908014714717865, -0.006351596675813198, 0.021900981664657593, 0.012862583622336388, -0.02700047753751278, -0.051816657185554504, 0.036430343985557556, -0.007795053068548441, 0.023555418476462364, 0.03869504854083061, -0.00044787576189264655, -0.06697007268667221, 0.01667611114680767, -0.00986164715141058, -0.04669060930609703, 0.030370747670531273, 0.008670797571539879, 0.017945023253560066, -0.08614969998598099, 0.01802503876388073, 0.03652317076921463, -0.020063648000359535, -0.023626986891031265, 0.044483885169029236, 0.05680537968873978, 0.015271349810063839, 0.000531545898411423, 0.012302628718316555, -0.002779097994789481, -0.03537523001432419, -0.0011931665940210223, 0.00389596214517951, -0.0203721821308136, 0.020517705008387566, -0.009215549565851688, 0.017113622277975082, 0.0008465912542305887, 0.027034472674131393, 0.016657480970025063, 0.020088063552975655, 0.0007437638123519719, -0.023297389969229698, -0.002155925612896681, 0.011319488286972046, 0.012903471477329731, 0.01916167140007019, 0.005084959790110588, 0.03587379306554794, -0.0017088419990614057, 0.010915410704910755, -0.040738847106695175, -0.009083050303161144, -0.0517444834113121, -0.015793608501553535, -0.020308276638388634, 0.0465715117752552, -0.03970453143119812, -0.023266157135367393, 0.005781104322522879, 0.009442421607673168, -0.016302378848195076, 0.005337827373296022, 0.03754556179046631, -0.02493220567703247, -0.0476914718747139, 0.04168141260743141, -0.005873804446309805, -0.03559842333197594, 0.011882694438099861, 0.019844630733132362, 0.020456159487366676, 0.03726039454340935, 0.013712567277252674, -0.04961822181940079, -0.005851441062986851, -0.009146299213171005, -0.0456501767039299, -0.028905972838401794, -0.050677936524152756, -0.008388441987335682, -0.013761647045612335, 0.022221829742193222 ]
<p>I am working on a model which predicts a binomial variable. I have millions of records and hundreds of variables to sample from. I have millions of records from individuals from each of the past several years. Most of the variables have specific data to the individual and to the year. However I do have a few variables that vary only on year and not with the individuals. Meaning that if I have ten years worth of data, I have only 10 unique variables within those millions of records. Furthermore, I have multiple year only variables that I would like to test to find out which ones will give the best predictive results. Because there are so few different values within these variables, and they are extremely highly correlated, they give dramatically different predictive results when substituted in and out. </p> <p>Will the Random Forest analysis allow me to substitute in and out these sets of year variables in order to come up with an average of models based on these different variables?</p> <p>If this is acceptable, can I, for instances say in R, specify which variable to not substitute, and which variables to substitute only keeping one of them at a time?</p>
35,031
[ -0.03860422596335411, -0.013277143239974976, -0.014553828164935112, -0.015357451513409615, 0.05994659289717674, -0.014110258780419827, -0.02033628523349762, -0.019641529768705368, 0.028572477400302887, -0.04951580613851547, 0.022302160039544106, 0.024436304345726967, 0.05704248696565628, -0.005178231745958328, 0.026412662118673325, 0.0034418858122080564, 0.014516361989080906, 0.004684470593929291, 0.004095872864127159, -0.014710372313857079, -0.037246715277433395, 0.03545279800891876, 0.04498235136270523, 0.013525120913982391, -0.007620989345014095, 0.052793800830841064, 0.02905067428946495, -0.005381538532674313, -0.009235771372914314, 0.03469377011060715, -0.037667252123355865, -0.02873365953564644, 0.020734993740916252, 0.10613998025655746, 0.04145036265254021, -0.019238919019699097, -0.02118266001343727, -0.03993211314082146, 0.0056022536009550095, 0.009322422556579113, -0.039538901299238205, 0.004703488666564226, 0.004615345969796181, 0.027624007314443588, -0.0011272645788267255, 0.03438393399119377, 0.004958587232977152, -0.012607295997440815, 0.013849636539816856, -0.03243839740753174, 0.06579505652189255, -0.00853932835161686, 0.05728171020746231, 0.0673140436410904, -0.0074691432528197765, -0.024511339142918587, 0.05339646711945534, 0.055838409811258316, 0.029740875586867332, -0.04444018378853798, 0.011538163758814335, -0.011229402385652065, 0.01767685078084469, 0.035064369440078735, -0.04875817894935608, 0.012067937292158604, 0.0050115869380533695, -0.014587940648198128, 0.01712539978325367, -0.03489690274000168, 0.03257891535758972, -0.008536138571798801, 0.022555828094482422, 0.03222482651472092, 0.02627752721309662, -0.00161203951574862, 0.04146450385451317, -0.0077536990866065025, 0.0507681630551815, 0.027518492192029953, -0.008113967254757881, 0.008504899218678474, 0.012462607584893703, 0.014845626428723335, 0.022841304540634155, -0.008058866485953331, 0.046879664063453674, -0.04754827916622162, 0.026127858087420464, 0.01247815228998661, -0.008325058966875076, 0.019570225849747658, 0.07421738654375076, 0.01872279867529869, -0.053194187581539154, 0.032289862632751465, -0.04285982623696327, 0.02957175299525261, -0.03158821165561676, 0.013524273410439491, 0.0030732136219739914, -0.02977747470140457, 0.025232631713151932, 0.01855851337313652, -0.024918146431446075, -0.02019350603222847, -0.02505333349108696, -0.023393455892801285, -0.013393783010542393, -0.01962561346590519, -0.01734074018895626, 0.012208306230604649, 0.000020465904526645318, -0.02023262530565262, 0.04647882282733917, -0.010795339941978455, -0.0290854349732399, -0.02185397408902645, 0.04621770232915878, 0.07178807258605957, 0.052526846528053284, -0.055271003395318985, 0.042430244386196136, -0.011538607999682426, -0.03946865350008011, 0.006652533542364836, -0.015066321939229965, -0.010754005052149296, -0.06459606438875198, 0.032926417887210846, 0.04070396348834038, -0.07263614237308502, 0.058129340410232544, -0.0013220410328358412, 0.06790871173143387, 0.019553711637854576, -0.10836334526538849, -0.04786889627575874, -0.008077776059508324, -0.052149366587400436, 0.02749575860798359, -0.06463006883859634, 0.023173624649643898, -0.02383367158472538, 0.017506517469882965, -0.01731101982295513, 0.056808751076459885, 0.007883924059569836, 0.03534737974405289, -0.0027692574076354504, -0.0024017097894102335, -0.01954132691025734, -0.007491386961191893, -0.015223408117890358, -0.0354762077331543, -0.1074540913105011, 0.03433157876133919, 0.02715187333524227, 0.001683143782429397, 0.006953998003154993, 0.008247485384345055, 0.011537866666913033, -0.0007005387451499701, 0.013104477897286415, 0.006507118698209524, 0.003165790345519781, 0.0498054102063179, 0.009454618208110332, 0.07573708891868591, 0.024430187419056892, -0.012305540032684803, 0.018861163407564163, 0.011450775898993015, 0.042587704956531525, 0.026689184829592705, 0.0061775436624884605, 0.003242535749450326, -0.01874273270368576, 0.03166883811354637, 0.027003807947039604, -0.05119731277227402, -0.022581277415156364, -0.013569260947406292, -0.02040119282901287, 0.01208088081330061, 0.04709716513752937, 0.0005847988650202751, -0.009253088384866714, 0.020563650876283646, -0.07383204996585846, -0.03527234122157097, -0.04902997612953186, 0.005930508021265268, -0.006706009153276682, 0.014390313066542149, 0.04172876849770546, 0.03206806257367134, 0.06514028459787369, -0.03104596771299839, -0.025874987244606018, -0.06519994884729385, -0.0076278080232441425, 0.044636961072683334, -0.04852363094687462, -0.009650852531194687, 0.04105684533715248, 0.04583069309592247, -0.02229863777756691, 0.028487062081694603, -0.04493867605924606, -0.06140930578112602, 0.020286602899432182, -0.05598825588822365, 0.0036998968571424484, 0.0010665137087926269, -0.01993509754538536, 0.03413252532482147, -0.008318864740431309, -0.010572347790002823, 0.03140920028090477, -0.0442412905395031, 0.0394718162715435, 0.06072170287370682, 0.01074326504021883, 0.0021383429411798716, 0.02011222392320633, -0.002842371817678213, 0.0118129663169384, -0.04239518195390701, -0.038781341165304184, -0.07581572979688644, -0.03227991238236427, 0.042912617325782776, 0.013363434001803398, -0.04614510387182236, -0.007201835047453642, 0.09116698056459427, 0.01283112820237875, 0.02795487269759178, 0.0238481555134058, -0.0008696757722645998, 0.022310500964522362, 0.0385182648897171, 0.03635444492101669, 0.0193030908703804, 0.02184375934302807, 0.029989134520292282, -0.03364397585391998, 0.03532415255904198, 0.022705964744091034, 0.004147144500166178, 0.011462561786174774, 0.008429015055298805, 0.020408688113093376, -0.006818651221692562, -0.024349644780158997, -0.0005950529593974352, -0.03907117247581482, 0.012409276328980923, 0.038463760167360306, 0.03873010352253914, -0.015006220899522305, 0.012367923744022846, -0.025833938270807266, 0.016395393759012222, 0.0658019483089447, -0.050911370664834976, 0.002104518236592412, 0.003686496987938881, -0.023109180852770805, 0.009361210279166698, -0.006660499610006809, -0.052444037050008774, -0.0692303404211998, 0.03505856916308403, 0.0036718035116791725, -0.0003277659707237035, 0.03722222521901131, 0.03133051469922066, -0.023673836141824722, -0.0080325398594141, -0.03940657526254654, -0.007249361369758844, -0.007217451464384794, -0.044479452073574066, -0.006770395673811436, -0.03998296707868576, -0.013795703649520874, 0.05006176233291626, -0.02935909852385521, -0.02619454637169838, 0.03509575128555298, -0.0031011663377285004, -0.06238346919417381, 0.0064116790890693665, 0.0026419973000884056, 0.006523824762552977, -0.0018506372580304742, -0.027092168107628822, 0.029301166534423828, 0.028674382716417313, -0.02221614122390747, 0.010608792304992676, -0.05203237757086754, -0.011034847237169743, -0.00017791947175282985, -0.0542747862637043, 0.022939203307032585, 0.003950848244130611, 0.024815671145915985, 0.023588379845023155, -0.03298882022500038, 0.005947617813944817, -0.03583664074540138, -0.06830685585737228, 0.025814782828092575, 0.012227288447320461, 0.029363591223955154, -0.006438244599848986, 0.016794010996818542, 0.05079389736056328, 0.04544757306575775, -0.026002777740359306, -0.0025373746175318956, -0.0033895650412887335, -0.02573768049478531, -0.035265062004327774, 0.038335010409355164, -0.0036647014785557985, 0.0022669078316539526, 0.016613852232694626, 0.008898121304810047, -0.0064152940176427364, 0.04027687385678291, -0.008900892920792103, -0.03036792390048504, 0.010190310887992382, 0.0178648941218853, -0.0051993499509990215, 0.025695450603961945, 0.007441276218742132, -0.0276364553719759, -0.016623694449663162, -0.008162332698702812, 0.027181990444660187, 0.01761353388428688, -0.03874966874718666, 0.035477641969919205, -0.04293011501431465, 0.06483764201402664, -0.00965497363358736, 0.00930225383490324, 0.007488767616450787, -0.04952336847782135, -0.006242013536393642, 0.012540284544229507, 0.03729591518640518, -0.023414310067892075, -0.007143188267946243, 0.03120187297463417, 0.06319324672222137, 0.0062453486025333405, 0.009541207924485207, -0.006017303094267845, -0.0076932841911911964, 0.04053551331162453, -0.004617868456989527, -0.012082640081644058, 0.045392271131277084, 0.031198017299175262, 0.013630964793264866, -0.015688395127654076, -0.04041199013590813, 0.020274503156542778, -0.060525648295879364, 0.01577182672917843, -0.019924890249967575, 0.036728136241436005, 0.0022273550275713205, 0.032202862203121185, 0.018237279728055, -0.009062048979103565, 0.006676305551081896, -0.01079989317804575, -0.04271422326564789, 0.0035056271590292454, -0.005049937404692173, 0.0053039733320474625, -0.00799071229994297, -0.008756057359278202, 0.043925534933805466, -0.018564756959676743, 0.022858751937747, 0.011641384102404118, 0.017942532896995544, -0.04642564058303833, -0.015002674423158169, -0.03077845461666584, -0.01802140288054943, -0.018587835133075714, 0.015429888851940632, 0.03077016957104206, -0.021114138886332512, 0.045713458210229874, 0.03997788578271866, -0.002841393928974867, -0.028147052973508835, -0.026826808229088783, -0.01165030337870121, 0.018518825992941856, 0.04401093348860741, 0.037979353219270706, 0.010812425054609776, -0.04548003152012825, 0.021471990272402763, -0.0018206858076155186, 0.03431672602891922, 0.027685290202498436, -0.007579749915748835, -0.026298783719539642, -0.04298515245318413, -0.025820406153798103, -0.00145798921585083, 0.005325281992554665, 0.05569055676460266, -0.002678625052794814, 0.07342757284641266, 0.037981513887643814, -0.05523646995425224, -0.00567196449264884, 0.05331307649612427, -0.02889839932322502, -0.008762025274336338, -0.030686043202877045, -0.005707702599465847, -0.016269704326987267, -0.009570008143782616, 0.010584622621536255, 0.027448225766420364, -0.006716714706271887, 0.011411952786147594, 0.036637745797634125, 0.0017344303196296096, -0.02768586203455925, 0.013681348413228989, 0.02967880852520466, 0.07088157534599304, -0.029313724488019943, -0.042074769735336304, 0.029734311625361443, 0.019088581204414368, -0.009709788486361504, 0.028149092569947243, 0.01136513240635395, -0.06747634708881378, 0.03328050300478935, 0.03619082272052765, 0.05398267135024071, -0.04108184203505516, -0.004346869420260191, -0.03616051375865936, 0.005392042454332113, 0.018686534836888313, -0.014416724443435669, 0.0007727955817244947, -0.0021596248261630535, 0.017880979925394058, -0.007364724762737751, -0.03881268948316574, -0.035393014550209045, -0.002462223172187805, -0.06342274695634842, 0.013930520974099636, 0.006578405853360891, -0.03760746493935585, -0.029628584161400795, 0.03266293555498123, 0.008592822588980198, 0.07117552310228348, -0.015333615243434906, -0.0018604060169309378, 0.038831815123558044, 0.016268419101834297, 0.015024087391793728, -0.07501064985990524, 0.013603666797280312, 0.0161460991948843, -0.00601158058270812, 0.028254782781004906, 0.0070776441134512424, -0.06693720817565918, -0.0019628547597676516, -0.00433860719203949, -0.026775656268000603, -0.0002456303918734193, -0.011687438003718853, 0.013989505358040333, 0.020314553752541542, -0.00784974079579115, 0.08343326300382614, 0.04658877104520798, -0.005934462882578373, 0.01016278937458992, -0.033318664878606796, 0.0045999702997505665, -0.03473284840583801, -0.010271991603076458, -0.06123195216059685, -0.02422216720879078, -0.006584644317626953, -0.003823284525424242, 0.0035509380977600813, 0.04160085320472717, -0.020766915753483772, 0.017457107082009315, -0.0043563623912632465, 0.024591149762272835, 0.006718938704580069, -0.01965765655040741, -0.04012995585799217, 0.003627276746556163, -0.020442942157387733, -0.0004287374613340944, 0.018696783110499382, 0.005560625344514847, 0.0005273182177916169, 0.014438420534133911, -0.02469748817384243, 0.014768166467547417, -0.06224688142538071, -0.045454394072294235, 0.011293547227978706, -0.016238750889897346, 0.04792908951640129, 0.015904583036899567, 0.06472231447696686, -0.002103047212585807, -0.042082641273736954, -0.012349371798336506, 0.0018892952939495444, -0.004637179896235466, 0.019743595272302628, -0.024811970070004463, 0.011006755754351616, -0.06617421656847, -0.004941058810800314, -0.05920933932065964, -0.055401187390089035, 0.01157640665769577, 0.004543969873338938, 0.009024785831570625, -0.01694282703101635, 0.025615189224481583, -0.02664952538907528, 0.007402094081044197, -0.04858200252056122, 0.03841831535100937, -0.01933058351278305, -0.008673726581037045, -0.014973372220993042, -0.008041122928261757, 0.08529229462146759, 0.029492603614926338, -0.0023494046181440353, 0.02862279862165451, -0.052187517285346985, 0.001475418102927506, -0.00998678058385849, 0.0031947637908160686, -0.013086899183690548, 0.009282879531383514, -0.031558193266391754, 0.003021164331585169, 0.023246152326464653, -0.020099733024835587, 0.017332784831523895, 0.026606550440192223, -0.01664583943784237, 0.020496485754847527, -0.06302042305469513, 0.0037987763062119484, -0.044860512018203735, -0.0004468967963475734, -0.02847464755177498, 0.04673457890748978, 0.003335197689011693, -0.005746909882873297, 0.025387128815054893, -0.008845759555697441, 0.002569967182353139, 0.03866039961576462, 0.060984645038843155, 0.009459162130951881, 0.025573713704943657, -0.016286253929138184, -0.04082823172211647, 0.027465857565402985, -0.006408242508769035, -0.009400988928973675, 0.007185803726315498, 0.034941039979457855, -0.027377625927329063, -0.04017694666981697, -0.013382313773036003, -0.01714043878018856, 0.03856034576892853, 0.0016070688143372536, 0.038176484405994415, 0.09091825783252716, 0.004279846325516701, 0.02105015516281128, -0.06114591285586357, 0.020397912710905075, 0.012833839282393456, 0.014782681129872799, 0.051952313631772995, 0.03631334751844406, 0.022607430815696716, 0.05261460691690445, 0.02405446209013462, 0.028992878273129463, 0.06840957701206207, -0.011453446000814438, 0.01902862638235092, 0.036336444318294525, -0.005391544662415981, -0.03686890751123428, 0.017418766394257545, -0.056589238345623016, 0.0013953904854133725, -0.027829598635435104, -0.005910573527216911, 0.033701930195093155, 0.05179784446954727, -0.0031828328501433134, -0.04853491857647896, -0.052647605538368225, -0.0607193298637867, 0.017903605476021767, -0.009750506840646267, 0.0029512885957956314, 0.05692712217569351, 0.030642198398709297, 0.0007599158561788499, -0.00112454267218709, 0.009333426132798195, -0.033005066215991974, -0.0719863772392273, -0.05723218619823456, -0.01306867878884077, -0.009400163777172565, 0.02002154104411602, -0.02766384743154049, -0.017456259578466415, 0.007560594938695431, -0.018824763596057892, -0.0030551920644938946, -0.0278936680406332, 0.012053659185767174, 0.02654474414885044, 0.051031310111284256, 0.02436557039618492, 0.01161380298435688, 0.008764844387769699, 0.017002301290631294, 0.10916583240032196, 0.055425602942705154, 0.05231985077261925, -0.04353082552552223, -0.003484734334051609, -0.0059541515074670315, -0.014601297676563263, -0.04214252531528473, -0.014485979452729225, 0.0008361520594917238, -0.017887214198708534, 0.04806189611554146, -0.016857527196407318, -0.0034085577353835106, -0.02605312317609787, 0.052864592522382736, -0.01568242907524109, 0.00021537451539188623, 0.004140916746109724, 0.05103689804673195, 0.016771819442510605, -0.018994595855474472, -0.02448893152177334, 0.014899667352437973, -0.0002734022564254701, 0.002077383454889059, -0.011995736509561539, -0.009163095615804195, 0.006842215079814196, 0.023197200149297714, 0.005749240051954985, 0.00888869073241949, 0.033499859273433685, 0.025685308501124382, -0.008227763697504997, -0.006189387291669846, 0.005278140772134066, -0.02577434852719307, -0.008277622982859612, 0.024206314235925674, -0.015835724771022797, 0.015233536250889301, 0.0026497531216591597, 0.00014052331971470267, -0.036963123828172684, -0.03000348061323166, -0.016909202560782433, 0.023394780233502388, -0.007403620518743992, -0.029527565464377403, -0.04567302018404007, -0.005133362952619791, 0.025542018935084343, -0.06073687598109245, -0.02267462946474552, 0.026460589841008186, 0.048778027296066284, -0.030047738924622536, -0.023353522643446922, -0.005085639655590057, 0.023997994139790535, 0.0030433956999331713, 0.01531419437378645, 0.009252035990357399, -0.016494300216436386, -0.029350681230425835, -0.03412385284900665, 0.038190022110939026, -0.019772175699472427, -0.009082069620490074, -0.014611618593335152, -0.002804703311994672, -0.031437262892723083, 0.005088299512863159, 0.022089548408985138, 0.028343629091978073, 0.031221672892570496, -0.03472701832652092, 0.014490099623799324, -0.02513379231095314, -0.025128517299890518, -0.005533894523978233, -0.016451789066195488, 0.01122364867478609, -0.004781639669090509, -0.00807893741875887, 0.015100724063813686, 0.04916449636220932, 0.008455650880932808, 0.01316003780812025, -0.0177715253084898, 0.06360606849193573, -0.017743563279509544, -0.05402187630534172, -0.023865314200520515, -0.040055785328149796, -0.04326687753200531, -0.0079738674685359, -0.029462451115250587, 0.0770830437541008, 0.03362647071480751, 0.002124583348631859, 0.0024294836912304163, 0.05045250430703163, 0.002526981057599187, 0.021580833941698074, 0.02216823771595955, -0.06682881712913513, 0.017832627519965172, 0.0018740725936368108, 0.0039136684499681, -0.007256234530359507, -0.022049978375434875, -0.0304120946675539, -0.00151210674084723, 0.03352188691496849, -0.01670270785689354, -0.024541327729821205, 0.004471323452889919, -0.005295612383633852, 0.005726462695747614, -0.03022569976747036, -0.00722948694601655, -0.07680211216211319, 0.01628737710416317, 0.009588781744241714, -0.044720303267240524, 0.022575190290808678, -0.022444799542427063, -0.00610651820898056, -0.012102753855288029, 0.0628475621342659, -0.0020547385793179274, -0.003657344961538911, -0.023238636553287506, -0.002686313819140196, 0.0171416774392128, 0.04213443025946617, -0.04536273330450058, -0.002034558216109872, 0.03359687700867653, -0.06312824040651321, -0.012350336648523808, 0.05662456154823303, 0.013669797219336033, 0.046398766338825226, 0.005937566515058279, 0.01658027246594429, -0.04360446333885193, 0.022939149290323257, -0.01743776910007, -0.0050053042359650135, 0.00027590495301410556, 0.006662888452410698, 0.011155745014548302, -0.020097926259040833, 0.017447106540203094, 0.011178653687238693, -0.013882993720471859, 0.03799089416861534, 0.03616967052221298, 0.035962022840976715, -0.03740810230374336, 0.029346074908971786, 0.016038313508033752, 0.02648656815290451, -0.004252619110047817, 0.019554609432816505, 0.02404998242855072, 0.06182747334241867, -0.012936792336404324, 0.03417281061410904, -0.01068105362355709, -0.0014128144830465317, -0.09297843277454376, -0.049769554287195206, 0.014905443415045738, 0.02355734072625637, 0.007851564325392246, -0.04513563588261604, 0.01968313567340374, -0.006876620929688215, -0.025884270668029785, 0.009988191537559032, -0.012838207185268402, -0.013483046554028988, -0.03776936233043671, 0.005862400867044926, -0.022259538993239403, -0.01702313870191574, 0.047237578779459, 0.03597826138138771, 0.015332557260990143, 0.026724090799689293, 0.011757859028875828, -0.07044388353824615, -0.02427106723189354, 0.007749201729893684, -0.013404074124991894, -0.0536455474793911, 0.02715415693819523, -0.027782509103417397, -0.05431734398007393, 0.013715637847781181, 0.004908491391688585, 0.042479198426008224, 0.015145933255553246, -0.007746114861220121, 0.006840681657195091, 0.05516357347369194, 0.056105829775333405, -0.01989055424928665, 0.0023751400876790285, -0.007564909756183624, -0.010280381888151169, 0.003802277846261859, -0.0352058932185173, 0.056235406547784805, -0.01717045158147812, -0.04144642502069473, -0.03267880901694298, 0.009760823100805283, 0.007328990381211042, -0.02886175364255905, -0.02028457075357437, 0.007570222020149231, -0.004706381820142269, 0.014729073271155357, -0.059484366327524185, -0.049147624522447586, 0.03706993907690048, 0.06999155133962631, 0.005053917411714792, -0.01464238204061985, 0.002627484267577529, -0.02811812050640583, -0.03764732554554939, -0.014972490258514881, 0.02337832562625408, -0.035050056874752045, -0.052465375512838364, -0.0016179304802790284, 0.016266949474811554, -0.013976375572383404, -0.03367488086223602, 0.002602691762149334, -0.05016403645277023, 0.02692926861345768, -0.009060133248567581, -0.000029891167287132703, 0.011204875074326992, -0.011937403120100498, 0.019989067688584328, -0.06462310254573822, 0.05707493796944618, 0.012815595604479313, -0.024169955402612686, -0.015417426824569702, 0.019618600606918335, -0.03278876841068268, -0.028400123119354248, 0.025240886956453323, 0.00901139434427023, 0.02092326432466507, -0.010962658561766148, 0.039426784962415695, -0.005536183714866638, -0.07343277335166931, 0.03700824826955795, -0.011369531974196434, -0.03784501180052757, -0.05040368065237999, -0.00555569538846612, 0.02812955155968666, 0.010397128760814667, 0.002734012436121702, -0.004675379488617182, 0.016428682953119278, 0.03184803947806358, -0.0025768692139536142, 0.03011537715792656, -0.02833116240799427, -0.00494513800367713, 0.0007263917941600084, 0.006947137415409088, 0.033501818776130676, 0.010683237574994564, 0.0037480646278709173, -0.022754861041903496, 0.03219037875533104, -0.06065261736512184, -0.030019478872418404, -0.006114014890044928, 0.013541088439524174, 0.002008758019655943, -0.03764420002698898, 0.02841399610042572, 0.057403404265642166, -0.04762979969382286, 0.01285627018660307, 0.04744243249297142, -0.003551086178049445, 0.06892912089824677, 0.0012402759166434407, -0.0014218819560483098, -0.009483383037149906, -0.044086236506700516, -0.027534011751413345, -0.017398899421095848, -0.0034913874696940184, -0.0007231440395116806, 0.008652341552078724, 0.0066110980696976185, -0.008663219399750233, 0.03255418688058853, 0.008717816323041916, 0.04539107158780098, -0.02335064858198166, -0.014974309131503105, -0.022975115105509758, -0.008353790268301964, 0.035359371453523636, 0.009557764045894146, -0.020507993176579475, 0.05311150103807449, -0.033804815262556076, 0.00913405790925026, -0.05613528564572334, -0.008566020987927914, -0.02210785634815693, -0.0034954831935465336, -0.03278997167944908, 0.033727675676345825, 0.015401149168610573, -0.010519848205149174, 0.0011801553191617131, 0.017489217221736908, 0.038037046790122986, -0.049448296427726746, 0.04416868835687637, -0.0346231572329998, -0.030229151248931885, 0.0070417714305222034, 0.03205694258213043, -0.049195822328329086, -0.032746557146310806, 0.023527484387159348, 0.03919003903865814, 0.04277627915143967, -0.020757971331477165, -0.024568047374486923, 0.026922639459371567, 0.005655582528561354, -0.040606286376714706, -0.01828932575881481, -0.03740045055747032, 0.009455000050365925, 0.001983184367418289, -0.008182748220860958 ]
<p>I am reading about influence diagrams, and I want to know how their utility function is calculated.</p> <p>In all of the examples listed in the literature, I am not able to find the formula of the utility function.</p>
74,138
[ -0.00008882071415428072, -0.04213765263557434, -0.006395346485078335, 0.0038239629939198494, 0.03559267893433571, 0.013708668760955334, -0.010978707112371922, 0.002748107770457864, 0.02408648654818535, -0.020451223477721214, -0.006173271685838699, 0.03770909830927849, 0.06960877031087875, -0.024386197328567505, 0.005208909977227449, 0.012659089639782906, 0.005557608790695667, 0.017392225563526154, 0.011555553413927555, -0.018169643357396126, -0.016664301976561546, -0.0010445875814184546, 0.00011190615623490885, -0.012907636351883411, -0.003336650552228093, 0.05243232101202011, 0.01897105574607849, -0.029026217758655548, 0.03317631036043167, 0.037565674632787704, -0.033878978341817856, -0.01125731784850359, 0.009275803342461586, 0.011615123599767685, 0.012023549526929855, -0.009666922502219677, -0.010263513773679733, -0.014363753609359264, -0.024963315576314926, -0.0009757879888638854, -0.020270897075533867, -0.029947683215141296, 0.02208261936903, 0.07430887222290039, -0.030153285712003708, -0.02300115115940571, -0.02742152102291584, -0.03197896108031273, 0.05805576965212822, -0.08571445196866989, 0.0884702280163765, -0.009916387498378754, 0.041380271315574646, 0.038359060883522034, 0.0007824913482181728, 0.012361964210867882, 0.052354831248521805, 0.05522412434220314, -0.02480572834610939, -0.040837131440639496, -0.0023552661295980215, -0.00797269307076931, -0.02233673632144928, -0.04625418037176132, -0.015016911551356316, 0.0009437039261683822, 0.0009429866331629455, 0.0018947077915072441, 0.05405858904123306, -0.0012892222730442882, 0.006963165011256933, 0.03707566484808922, 0.018041761592030525, 0.017572104930877686, 0.005782547872513533, 0.001734224846586585, 0.034922391176223755, 0.03397287800908089, 0.05075832083821297, 0.04412508383393288, -0.011023767292499542, 0.042086806148290634, 0.027882350608706474, 0.0455450676381588, -0.0023098608944565058, -0.011584604158997536, 0.069358229637146, -0.0191574115306139, 0.04972580820322037, -0.01298102829605341, -0.0465557724237442, -0.00019435389549471438, 0.027145419269800186, -0.01855393871665001, -0.02046837843954563, 0.010944982059299946, -0.013732817023992538, 0.022793589159846306, 0.0134692108258605, -0.04051671177148819, -0.013194488361477852, -0.04065103456377983, -0.013509482145309448, 0.03101775050163269, -0.0077387369237840176, -0.0010469398694112897, -0.0030844411812722683, 0.008245633915066719, -0.0095407385379076, -0.020697064697742462, -0.008976822718977928, 0.040538493543863297, 0.03598197177052498, 0.026913348585367203, 0.013018154539167881, -0.026874331757426262, -0.005548849701881409, -0.010844326578080654, 0.029589368030428886, 0.027862917631864548, 0.037799298763275146, -0.016085464507341385, 0.04526606202125549, -0.03507939726114273, -0.06376861035823822, 0.01737140864133835, -0.001967867137864232, 0.02441539242863655, -0.02003033086657524, 0.03756989538669586, 0.0026991034392267466, -0.03811907768249512, 0.020227402448654175, 0.016373267397284508, -0.019397689029574394, -0.03542516380548477, -0.06566449999809265, -0.014384270645678043, 0.024486806243658066, -0.03841108828783035, 0.05001692473888397, -0.05945475772023201, -0.02869092859327793, 0.07020253688097, 0.033988792449235916, -0.0060815890319645405, -0.011970660649240017, 0.018167855218052864, 0.024073392152786255, -0.010787421837449074, -0.030791543424129486, -0.026210911571979523, -0.018433410674333572, -0.004052450414747, 0.00021752937755081803, -0.061381809413433075, 0.04554295912384987, 0.041624076664447784, -0.03464122116565704, -0.031403664499521255, 0.05294649302959442, 0.005880530923604965, -0.05594813823699951, -0.01556557510048151, 0.0029327210504561663, -0.0018621229100972414, 0.0814429298043251, -0.02302047610282898, -0.006122102029621601, 0.013057009316980839, 0.0209539532661438, -0.0038316603749990463, 0.008066718466579914, 0.04286147654056549, 0.03314376249909401, 0.012295495718717575, -0.0028879924211651087, -0.05146742984652519, 0.007969100959599018, -0.0054656509310007095, -0.05210721120238304, -0.04600715637207031, -0.054960500448942184, 0.026954617351293564, 0.026718178763985634, 0.00457612331956625, -0.02501806430518627, -0.0031900799367576838, 0.016090139746665955, -0.05047927051782608, -0.06685551255941391, -0.10812652856111526, 0.042138390243053436, -0.015347982756793499, 0.0004288656637072563, 0.02611018903553486, -0.009589027613401413, 0.005026867613196373, -0.0005411357269622386, -0.03248494490981102, -0.026193391531705856, 0.007218072656542063, 0.03381495177745819, -0.038315050303936005, 0.01173336897045374, 0.04194306582212448, 0.05354908108711243, -0.032810743898153305, 0.0240446999669075, -0.0753595232963562, -0.03139791265130043, 0.0064427792094647884, -0.06354957073926926, 0.020469853654503822, -0.00427226722240448, -0.014969647862017155, -0.016135649755597115, 0.021792765706777573, 0.03317447751760483, 0.010182849131524563, -0.06503532081842422, 0.04204891622066498, 0.10962234437465668, 0.047082290053367615, -0.014468960464000702, 0.03776533156633377, 0.00475516589358449, 0.03459746390581131, 0.00995667651295662, -0.030122831463813782, -0.03844880685210228, -0.019389275461435318, 0.028971564024686813, 0.016362739726901054, -0.001101491041481495, -0.010789405554533005, 0.03912613168358803, 0.03867458552122116, 0.014874973334372044, 0.014212441630661488, -0.012973415665328503, 0.026745807379484177, 0.014730297029018402, -0.009170406498014927, 0.014361624605953693, 0.028030093759298325, -0.0320129320025444, 0.04882004112005234, 0.0012621338246390224, 0.03812094032764435, -0.035716310143470764, 0.06724317371845245, -0.037539418786764145, -0.0015332805924117565, -0.017874864861369133, -0.017179258167743683, 0.0437343455851078, -0.0433620885014534, 0.0003358026151545346, 0.049892690032720566, -0.002901053987443447, 0.0001824571518227458, 0.04124476760625839, -0.02334858849644661, 0.01923501491546631, 0.017606891691684723, -0.005285308230668306, -0.0038595141377300024, 0.02749989926815033, -0.007922208867967129, 0.03220057860016823, -0.01359094399958849, -0.021984469145536423, 0.003094157436862588, 0.013554017059504986, 0.034450970590114594, 0.0009165231604129076, 0.0025183192919939756, 0.0005303979851305485, -0.060370173305273056, -0.019203469157218933, -0.01528401393443346, 0.003825928084552288, 0.000948714092373848, -0.02950267121195793, -0.03662579134106636, -0.05332519859075546, -0.03691159561276436, 0.04949038848280907, -0.03232893720269203, -0.008941673673689365, 0.02915729582309723, 0.011785718612372875, -0.019751278683543205, -0.028566723689436913, 0.0029476205818355083, 0.0246095173060894, -0.005080271512269974, -0.02253376878798008, -0.0073052337393164635, 0.037011049687862396, -0.03320224583148956, 0.020667532458901405, -0.040304940193891525, -0.02065439708530903, -0.0008947590249590576, 0.020869959145784378, -0.0014717390295118093, -0.016651535406708717, 0.009649972431361675, 0.005906759761273861, -0.004736787639558315, -0.024596646428108215, -0.052256498485803604, -0.05895543470978737, 0.03246646374464035, -0.0014136688550934196, 0.024083172902464867, 0.010731853544712067, -0.041039831936359406, 0.09219963848590851, 0.02344568818807602, -0.053601376712322235, -0.03697730600833893, -0.05206200107932091, 0.021864216774702072, -0.023556066676974297, 0.002171826083213091, 0.045499514788389206, 0.0057868389412760735, 0.02821112982928753, 0.03703949972987175, -0.005123018752783537, 0.014641547575592995, -0.02607199363410473, -0.0017658694414421916, 0.03197784721851349, 0.0028023093473166227, -0.005795151926577091, 0.02450677752494812, 0.02899269014596939, -0.00011533287761267275, 0.0003626696125138551, 0.003305410733446479, 0.04116439446806908, 0.006560963578522205, -0.022569764405488968, 0.025188898667693138, 0.005489179398864508, 0.0007363500189967453, -0.05405627191066742, 0.06784259527921677, 0.0017453957116231322, 0.018565161153674126, -0.005188463255763054, -0.01784508489072323, 0.04334130883216858, -0.0502803772687912, 0.0151769258081913, 0.05885345861315727, 0.029616111889481544, -0.036803603172302246, -0.02597266249358654, -0.004393651615828276, 0.03688284009695053, 0.005016486160457134, -0.028800657019019127, -0.033822137862443924, 0.02872150018811226, 0.03278224542737007, 0.004971465095877647, 0.025279715657234192, -0.04674295708537102, -0.003952320199459791, -0.0656181052327156, -0.025716353207826614, -0.04022025689482689, 0.05432238057255745, 0.0037227843422442675, 0.040703676640987396, -0.009129418060183525, -0.0023894805926829576, -0.005700676701962948, -0.0036045550368726254, -0.03048582561314106, 0.07493717968463898, -0.0038297248538583517, 0.018398310989141464, 0.021098101511597633, -0.006981208920478821, 0.03589924797415733, -0.012889825738966465, -0.04081812873482704, -0.005038345232605934, 0.020861854776740074, -0.0020144854206591845, 0.002615161007270217, -0.013924728147685528, -0.0041973283514380455, -0.014549235813319683, 0.025500157848000526, 0.04067949578166008, -0.04635517671704292, 0.013239867985248566, 0.034534621983766556, -0.020989852026104927, -0.016800962388515472, -0.044063668698072433, 0.01226986013352871, 0.02819013223052025, 0.060289300978183746, 0.028591103851795197, -0.010444634594023228, -0.002023946726694703, 0.01622955873608589, -0.008447051048278809, 0.05150480940937996, 0.055780477821826935, -0.013873125426471233, -0.027122246101498604, -0.061654288321733475, 0.020167745649814606, -0.00424333056434989, 0.0010766186751425266, -0.017434224486351013, 0.03399358689785004, 0.06261533498764038, -0.005822668317705393, -0.022873295471072197, 0.020312882959842682, 0.022532125934958458, 0.045421287417411804, 0.004735288210213184, -0.011292838491499424, 0.02650490775704384, -0.037412650883197784, -0.01327518466860056, 0.007313843816518784, 0.017974788323044777, -0.03016621619462967, -0.008763330988585949, 0.014363766647875309, 0.011111310683190823, -0.022200701758265495, 0.0012300944654271007, 0.006307387258857489, 0.012325012125074863, 0.015624694526195526, -0.02111346274614334, 0.013602294959127903, 0.014444854110479355, 0.008298096247017384, 0.036946654319763184, 0.006735539995133877, -0.05792330950498581, 0.006133135408163071, 0.013946546241641045, 0.02919009141623974, -0.04511687532067299, -0.023623360320925713, -0.02247946336865425, -0.01383143663406372, 0.06455018371343613, -0.0075815035961568356, 0.013146530836820602, -0.007276102434843779, 0.046994399279356, -0.032810065895318985, -0.005368899088352919, -0.025334250181913376, 0.026441287249326706, -0.011680658906698227, 0.00882798619568348, -0.019499195739626884, 0.003568244632333517, 0.005049702245742083, 0.0026086450088769197, 0.04364025965332985, 0.04615945741534233, 0.007631903048604727, -0.022346239537000656, -0.016948655247688293, 0.017057504504919052, -0.010248110629618168, -0.04952293261885643, -0.014248774386942387, 0.020100291818380356, -0.018746454268693924, 0.05321580171585083, -0.016481313854455948, -0.007660314440727234, 0.001863947487436235, 0.018633095547556877, -0.03796468302607536, 0.00017901588580571115, 0.014073406346142292, 0.055675115436315536, 0.042122259736061096, -0.021301215514540672, 0.04232093319296837, 0.032024070620536804, -0.06587434560060501, 0.009318128228187561, 0.01450835820287466, 0.01470593549311161, -0.0020445226691663265, -0.006964402738958597, -0.02597464621067047, -0.00006749306339770555, -0.051760148257017136, -0.007088629063218832, -0.012022800743579865, 0.03592299297451973, -0.03937552869319916, -0.018934499472379684, -0.03144073486328125, 0.049383074045181274, 0.013688943348824978, -0.010810810141265392, 0.004148353822529316, 0.002352581126615405, 0.05862070992588997, -0.02613253891468048, 0.019646434113383293, -0.022578876465559006, 0.00319496332667768, 0.0025306781753897667, -0.0032129923347383738, 0.03815167024731636, -0.05920128524303436, -0.011584930121898651, 0.004319432191550732, -0.019244058057665825, 0.018907880410552025, 0.013106404803693295, -0.031334906816482544, 0.0076969824731349945, -0.05783945694565773, -0.029087428003549576, 0.020228872075676918, 0.017744190990924835, 0.030663030222058296, -0.025893688201904297, 0.010171646252274513, -0.02012987621128559, 0.01824009418487549, -0.07470927387475967, -0.0013052341528236866, 0.03464704006910324, 0.004959687124937773, -0.0331796295940876, -0.006416662596166134, -0.010762028396129608, -0.007693291176110506, -0.01824329048395157, -0.0063057998195290565, 0.038817647844552994, 0.0008630651282146573, -0.004176601301878691, -0.020138615742325783, -0.018094953149557114, 0.08578646928071976, 0.03217180818319321, -0.007652296684682369, 0.015713689848780632, -0.044104330241680145, -0.01565173827111721, 0.0028911903500556946, -0.0009482511668466032, -0.041621822863817215, -0.013362347148358822, -0.0174358282238245, 0.008025756105780602, 0.009531294927001, -0.023416241630911827, 0.007527762092649937, -0.02283475361764431, 0.04760752245783806, -0.0375547893345356, 0.0033510487992316484, 0.003775407327339053, -0.026316525414586067, 0.034575074911117554, 0.0033797763753682375, -0.00360495294444263, -0.04713921993970871, 0.005816266871988773, 0.001958700129762292, -0.02561270445585251, -0.01814533956348896, 0.010033981874585152, 0.04628962650895119, -0.0033494301605969667, -0.004135074093937874, -0.012728100642561913, -0.031250208616256714, 0.03104969672858715, -0.0028290520422160625, -0.012182057835161686, 0.01117030531167984, -0.009683618322014809, -0.017262611538171768, -0.020670372992753983, -0.07792414724826813, 0.012016145512461662, 0.039343785494565964, -0.07926379889249802, 0.047089312225580215, 0.018266776576638222, 0.009540349245071411, -0.018559100106358528, -0.019405407831072807, -0.011211888864636421, -0.006232828833162785, 0.012876961380243301, 0.04711180925369263, -0.024628303945064545, -0.002702791942283511, 0.0559125617146492, 0.011155621148645878, 0.01057914737612009, 0.020721817389130592, 0.00578836165368557, 0.03382444381713867, 0.031979478895664215, -0.061635248363018036, -0.014694582670927048, 0.03498777374625206, -0.042475149035453796, -0.0017885634442791343, -0.028758889064192772, -0.04949943348765373, 0.04174330085515976, -0.011174711398780346, -0.03257053717970848, -0.021920640021562576, -0.003909882158041, 0.02407563291490078, 0.0004023325745947659, 0.015360766090452671, 0.003290124237537384, 0.0028697357047349215, 0.02150641568005085, 0.007467304822057486, -0.050754614174366, 0.025737321004271507, 0.004965114872902632, -0.06576782464981079, -0.03404773399233818, -0.014752818271517754, -0.0644759014248848, -0.014162298291921616, 0.0172117929905653, -0.021383684128522873, 0.013406720012426376, -0.021441033110022545, -0.011748043820261955, 0.008439581841230392, 0.01988973282277584, 0.03350019082427025, 0.10645972192287445, -0.03636999800801277, 0.05406048893928528, -0.01271925587207079, -0.01738881692290306, 0.13008646667003632, 0.0481552928686142, -0.007145517971366644, -0.12244139611721039, 0.008559269830584526, -0.0028534037992358208, 0.009876511059701443, -0.0415569469332695, 0.025328470394015312, 0.015194264240562916, -0.014849414117634296, 0.0261321309953928, 0.03970237448811531, -0.03733018413186073, 0.0015346546424552798, 0.0461975522339344, -0.027498111128807068, -0.0648152306675911, 0.031932901591062546, 0.002273519290611148, -0.02921832725405693, -0.037374623119831085, -0.06915044039487839, 0.008008917793631554, 0.026753753423690796, 0.00010084078530780971, -0.00012227984552737325, -0.03666049242019653, 0.0005346834077499807, -0.02439279295504093, 0.004717005416750908, 0.01137393619865179, 0.0347834974527359, 0.02864072471857071, -0.010371329262852669, -0.010757566429674625, 0.012757283635437489, -0.01949894055724144, 0.00182137091178447, 0.07757658511400223, 0.023085417225956917, -0.024487221613526344, 0.013327023945748806, 0.04460101202130318, -0.05264059454202652, -0.012495026923716068, -0.023433592170476913, -0.021602150052785873, 0.0012376464437693357, -0.013074252754449844, -0.04236503690481186, 0.015139246359467506, 0.007858227007091045, -0.010818549431860447, -0.029445597901940346, 0.030240776017308235, 0.05075697600841522, -0.025591416284441948, -0.030496947467327118, -0.003663238137960434, -0.004242224153131247, -0.0018365955911576748, 0.046597227454185486, 0.02331761084496975, -0.044653695076704025, -0.014020239003002644, -0.029495181515812874, 0.04879406467080116, 0.025912366807460785, -0.029976364225149155, -0.0021615999285131693, -0.02878049574792385, -0.03390855714678764, -0.016015000641345978, -0.026392381638288498, 0.02420768328011036, 0.025150876492261887, -0.017137417569756508, 0.0029483407270163298, 0.0009845113381743431, -0.038658421486616135, 0.013865104876458645, -0.0575505793094635, -0.03666715696454048, -0.016044529154896736, 0.03305097669363022, 0.013307930901646614, 0.027019120752811432, 0.04708677530288696, 0.027669379487633705, 0.007006644271314144, 0.029836473986506462, 0.015196919441223145, -0.06016175076365471, -0.029610278084874153, 0.01043577678501606, -0.03670530393719673, -0.029103416949510574, 0.026538942009210587, 0.06604315340518951, 0.030484354123473167, -0.012894579209387302, -0.003077695844694972, 0.006269288714975119, -0.010385976172983646, 0.03064459003508091, 0.008451522327959538, -0.0575549378991127, 0.025977587327361107, -0.0017166744219139218, -0.00375930592417717, -0.059239644557237625, -0.013495753519237041, -0.02054215967655182, -0.0017705282662063837, 0.012638119980692863, 0.021724378690123558, -0.025930218398571014, 0.005212677177041769, 0.005794796627014875, 0.03205883502960205, -0.003347567515447736, 0.018207546323537827, -0.0030611029360443354, 0.0028211206663399935, -0.018456818535923958, 0.004731752909719944, -0.011033649556338787, 0.006960622034966946, -0.007458478678017855, 0.02159152179956436, 0.022952020168304443, 0.010751932859420776, -0.0018938088323920965, -0.01583275757730007, -0.004502235446125269, 0.004373380448669195, 0.05826330557465553, -0.019819600507616997, -0.0033198122400790453, 0.023439321666955948, -0.043912336230278015, -0.028335247188806534, -0.011149981990456581, 0.024516744539141655, 0.05858781933784485, -0.00778158800676465, -0.004889576230198145, -0.014345022849738598, 0.03682244196534157, -0.010896383784711361, -0.020550904795527458, 0.024549229070544243, 0.012005516327917576, 0.02459689788520336, -0.03246603533625603, -0.03452804684638977, -0.0026509338058531284, 0.016414087265729904, 0.010345575399696827, 0.04206943139433861, 0.001962085487321019, -0.01664329133927822, 0.01041982788592577, 0.007298565469682217, 0.004286494571715593, -0.014855585992336273, -0.028949877247214317, 0.033694714307785034, 0.06638550013303757, -0.01570822484791279, -0.004025740083307028, 0.03877801075577736, 0.019593650475144386, -0.068422332406044, -0.02687845379114151, -0.011296477168798447, 0.012187203392386436, 0.04024165868759155, -0.042705245316028595, 0.057264670729637146, 0.016954408958554268, -0.033784475177526474, 0.038963355123996735, 0.00008368824637727812, 0.023628054186701775, -0.01916450634598732, 0.008613317273557186, -0.028211114928126335, 0.08006711304187775, 0.02340264990925789, 0.027121154591441154, 0.03707663714885712, -0.018653379753232002, 0.0029959864914417267, -0.022794334217905998, 0.005790602415800095, 0.014485939405858517, -0.026672618463635445, -0.043189458549022675, 0.0592939630150795, -0.03898467868566513, -0.03967442736029625, 0.04442482814192772, -0.03418219834566116, 0.03553741052746773, 0.003215226111933589, 0.015744466334581375, 0.024368759244680405, 0.038125477731227875, 0.025745438411831856, -0.03162671625614166, -0.018840227276086807, -0.0016110753640532494, 0.043807778507471085, 0.004611981566995382, 0.004246038384735584, 0.019552694633603096, 0.010137672536075115, -0.013721300289034843, -0.03268637880682945, 0.04127311706542969, -0.021665137261152267, -0.040160439908504486, -0.04611659049987793, -0.06916370987892151, 0.04030595347285271, -0.03837435692548752, 0.01294645108282566, -0.06087648868560791, -0.007311425171792507, 0.0553092360496521, -0.020936274901032448, 0.042285121977329254, -0.028421174734830856, -0.021116897463798523, -0.048477597534656525, 0.024681389331817627, 0.015412271954119205, -0.026166457682847977, -0.041054174304008484, 0.026397384703159332, -0.042892951518297195, 0.0020194377284497023, -0.0005611467640846968, -0.00955912098288536, -0.039874572306871414, 0.03341354802250862, -0.020606255158782005, -0.015441169030964375, 0.04371126368641853, -0.05815630778670311, 0.038501013070344925, -0.060397543013095856, 0.06115545332431793, -0.0007769137155264616, -0.050372134894132614, -0.014262834563851357, -0.0426919162273407, 0.003576243994757533, 0.020405426621437073, 0.038483016192913055, -0.034798186272382736, -0.024880550801753998, -0.020620128139853477, 0.042299456894397736, 0.00446533877402544, -0.019087161868810654, 0.0033165307249873877, -0.03857150673866272, 0.020688101649284363, -0.024996919557452202, 0.0007778157596476376, 0.05163787677884102, 0.012393155135214329, -0.0217960923910141, 0.004762632306665182, 0.009167168289422989, -0.012712729163467884, -0.037814460694789886, 0.01350484136492014, 0.027084890753030777, -0.01192489080131054, 0.09322556108236313, -0.034861188381910324, 0.013999723829329014, 0.01876693032681942, 0.012808742001652718, -0.054135873913764954, 0.026002703234553337, -0.023677479475736618, -0.015914807096123695, 0.0299945417791605, 0.004364487249404192, 0.03924894332885742, -0.0617467425763607, -0.022275738418102264, 0.029164955019950867, -0.01472504436969757, -0.036134861409664154, 0.02796582505106926, 0.03580174222588539, 0.05218513309955597, 0.03326185792684555, 0.009995398111641407, -0.05265553295612335, 0.014450617134571075, 0.01582293212413788, 0.0038685540203005075, 0.011544765904545784, 0.015103456564247608, 0.014656394720077515, 0.03697891905903816, -0.020525328814983368, 0.057157307863235474, 0.010320870205760002, 0.004268219694495201, -0.0022806539200246334, 0.0016593774780631065, 0.039738669991493225, -0.0014543125871568918, 0.043127503246068954, 0.019092781469225883, -0.026758959516882896, 0.05132035166025162, -0.04266907274723053, 0.00697732251137495, -0.03701765090227127, 0.024592824280261993, -0.06018112972378731, 0.00990194920450449, 0.03296548128128052, 0.03836755082011223, -0.013428467325866222, 0.016465846449136734, 0.00543777272105217, 0.0038064124528318644, 0.004222535993903875, -0.01017074566334486, 0.04798080027103424, -0.014011548832058907, -0.014674087055027485, -0.025475788861513138, -0.058714162558317184, -0.014145944267511368, 0.022493820637464523, -0.017769280821084976, 0.052154697477817535, 0.04375902935862541, 0.013904299587011337, 0.006253598257899284, -0.032491423189640045, 0.07570194453001022, -0.06997353583574295, -0.02854158543050289, -0.053101781755685806, 0.006754891946911812, 0.02808496356010437, -0.0008290376281365752 ]
<p>am doing my dissertation involving cox model and i would like to understand how you interpret the survival table at mean of covariates. how i do u i determine the survival function from the output</p> <pre><code>Survival Table At mean of covariates Time Baseline SurvivalSE Cum Hazard 0 .023 .991 .006 .009 3 .033 .987 .007 .013 5 .044 .982 .009 .018 8 .058 .977 .011 .024 9 .088 .965 .014 .036 11 .107 .957 .017 .044 12 .128 .949 .019 .052 14 .173 .932 .024 .071 24 .232 .910 .033 .095 34 .326 .875 .048 .133 45 .481 .821 .068 .197 46 .668 .761 .088 .273 49 .946 .679 .109 .387 56 1.769 .485 .178 .723 Correlation Matrix of Regression Coefficients Sex Birthweight MartenaAgeBreatsfeeding Birthweight -.151 MartenalAge -.108 -.077 Breatsfeeding .030 .222 .057 Immunisation .240 -.085 .016 -.168 Covariate Means Mean Sex .552 Birthweight .129 MartenalAge 3.067 Breatsfeeding .238 Immunisation .124 </code></pre> <p>my output from my cox model and it contains the above covariates and immunisation and breatsfeeding are siginificant but i want to intepret the survival and hazard functions for young children from 0-60 months</p>
25,389
[ -0.029782485216856003, -0.001577454269863665, 0.026214301586151123, 0.00018379895482212305, 0.015389248728752136, 0.034543104469776154, 0.00040879135485738516, -0.03235926479101181, 0.08424465358257294, -0.03926022723317146, 0.03855731710791588, 0.06715552508831024, 0.05359330773353577, 0.00224848510697484, 0.058479469269514084, 0.01643432304263115, 0.0022470608819276094, -0.004343564622104168, 0.022534383460879326, -0.005899436771869659, 0.024144070222973824, 0.03305579349398613, 0.028393853455781937, 0.026268312707543373, 0.011975832283496857, 0.05779089778661728, 0.016574883833527565, 0.004004631191492081, -0.01331321895122528, 0.03650042042136192, -0.010865922085940838, -0.04522063955664635, 0.005401942878961563, -0.02312403731048107, 0.019521506503224373, 0.01562603749334812, -0.01251120027154684, -0.0064896768890321255, 0.025728274136781693, 0.018735762685537338, -0.020671583712100983, -0.004528034944087267, -0.010893823578953743, 0.04694630205631256, 0.014202521182596684, 0.01400921680033207, -0.012423550710082054, 0.01502909418195486, 0.014523692429065704, -0.0013090373249724507, 0.03831438347697258, -0.004472601693123579, 0.04493896663188934, 0.016613125801086426, -0.03140619769692421, -0.011294770985841751, 0.019262751564383507, 0.04371516779065132, -0.010675225406885147, -0.07491054385900497, -0.014571101404726505, -0.010359001345932484, 0.016768284142017365, -0.0018354497151449323, -0.02460501715540886, -0.006010892800986767, -0.011324157938361168, -0.04506263881921768, 0.03870207443833351, -0.018405642360448837, 0.020366623997688293, -0.0027928315103054047, 0.033280760049819946, 0.0010661962442100048, 0.01993590220808983, -0.02545246295630932, 0.01621234603226185, 0.013902390375733376, 0.027751609683036804, -0.0013531912118196487, 0.041436247527599335, 0.010791757144033909, -0.006973101757466793, 0.04213283210992813, 0.014931830577552319, 0.015615946613252163, 0.029514793306589127, 0.006759094074368477, 0.04407598450779915, 0.04741894081234932, 0.010879061184823513, 0.008228570222854614, 0.0589345283806324, 0.009158849716186523, -0.052501924335956573, 0.04827709123492241, 0.04758865758776665, 0.04314013570547104, 0.02085191383957863, -0.008271874859929085, -0.01815822161734104, -0.06415511667728424, 0.013087713159620762, 0.021335288882255554, 0.00567695964127779, -0.0008157188422046602, -0.05240509659051895, -0.035404834896326065, -0.023078924044966698, -0.049264173954725266, 0.005883966106921434, 0.005922001786530018, 0.05917109549045563, -0.0417061522603035, -0.0021031489595770836, -0.021493343636393547, -0.003483556443825364, 0.01252629142254591, 0.03459039703011513, 0.04064319655299187, 0.035007186233997345, 0.0016993599710986018, 0.030040733516216278, -0.007092409301549196, -0.06754143536090851, 0.015948524698615074, -0.006165510509163141, -0.015557202510535717, -0.011915117502212524, 0.08843616396188736, 0.0018717838684096932, -0.03435893729329109, 0.02930906042456627, 0.010790497064590454, 0.023025711998343468, -0.029067935422062874, -0.08717967569828033, -0.043525513261556625, 0.0314914807677269, -0.005175914149731398, 0.0030539999715983868, -0.04549664258956909, 0.03730783239006996, 0.026476731523871422, 0.04339592158794403, -0.005672859493643045, 0.00972866453230381, 0.009789478033781052, 0.005427672993391752, 0.04036364704370499, -0.03132926672697067, -0.007786399684846401, -0.013204297050833702, 0.00494011165574193, -0.025469863787293434, -0.07058113068342209, -0.01077634934335947, 0.002522826660424471, -0.01832175813615322, -0.04008018225431442, 0.04224627837538719, -0.033744487911462784, -0.027475742623209953, -0.010959086008369923, -0.03574133291840553, -0.047750819474458694, 0.0914335548877716, -0.0025129138957709074, 0.0338275283575058, 0.052374232560396194, -0.03543625399470329, 0.01979171670973301, -0.019293921068310738, 0.06316183507442474, 0.03643597289919853, 0.0037273461930453777, 0.023228585720062256, 0.012190831825137138, 0.02740335278213024, -0.0017261378234252334, -0.05560200288891792, -0.019958963617682457, -0.04859898239374161, -0.0037357730325311422, 0.043020885437726974, 0.032701075077056885, -0.0048364498652517796, -0.017698749899864197, 0.022646497935056686, -0.03507435321807861, -0.04402251914143562, -0.10072021931409836, -0.012097778730094433, -0.04495895653963089, -0.014529996551573277, -0.024418454617261887, -0.01442501600831747, 0.008359585888683796, -0.003207635600119829, -0.007642232347279787, -0.04628003388643265, 0.0032727355137467384, 0.021404234692454338, -0.017081722617149353, 0.006412524729967117, 0.02996990643441677, 0.0440811812877655, -0.005702933296561241, 0.02203313261270523, -0.03505650535225868, -0.000390685279853642, 0.03158770874142647, -0.03453047201037407, -0.017049051821231842, -0.0007379008457064629, -0.04040047898888588, 0.0201218593865633, 0.011957709677517414, -0.011120730079710484, 0.018461579456925392, -0.05875780060887337, 0.03585532680153847, 0.0465303435921669, -0.0020204256288707256, 0.006028841715306044, 0.0247524194419384, 0.005363618955016136, 0.05418555065989494, 0.0016956287436187267, -0.013951563276350498, -0.02619175985455513, 0.0022545873653143644, -0.008879320695996284, -0.013599247671663761, 0.007690060418099165, 0.016989201307296753, 0.05501789227128029, -0.03644705191254616, 0.003892742795869708, 0.01601533032953739, -0.0059336163103580475, 0.03174221143126488, 0.01072844211012125, 0.013128405436873436, -0.021664554253220558, -0.015440260991454124, -0.013336403295397758, 0.012857361696660519, 0.05364922061562538, -0.03263925388455391, -0.03181471303105354, 0.08665404468774796, -0.014553610235452652, -0.004014016594737768, -0.038216013461351395, -0.02016800455749035, 0.04786500334739685, -0.0397280752658844, 0.004041723441332579, 0.022991809993982315, -0.0013668494066223502, 0.01301529910415411, -0.01404295302927494, -0.051431383937597275, 0.010973441414535046, 0.006110677029937506, -0.01998613402247429, -0.025072991847991943, 0.003272439120337367, -0.016142213717103004, 0.020989486947655678, 0.011304207146167755, -0.07039862871170044, -0.022814154624938965, -0.01170306745916605, 0.0667015090584755, -0.017686069011688232, 0.04263497143983841, -0.006517674308270216, -0.010163377039134502, 0.01714308187365532, -0.02667469158768654, 0.025172673165798187, 0.0029937345534563065, -0.04501086100935936, -0.018537361174821854, -0.03516657277941704, -0.026556558907032013, 0.028194691985845566, -0.019664892926812172, -0.03291887789964676, 0.011019363068044186, -0.021022073924541473, -0.010175837203860283, -0.0711028203368187, -0.004698013421148062, 0.032705869525671005, -0.02129010297358036, -0.020492959767580032, 0.02933683432638645, 0.009828134439885616, 0.00598449120298028, 0.019908994436264038, -0.057652946561574936, -0.017206043004989624, 0.007514175493270159, 0.0032294001430273056, -0.0006472414243035018, 0.014671309851109982, 0.03603551536798477, 0.036786776036024094, -0.01758156530559063, -0.021840957924723625, -0.055275809019804, -0.018732530996203423, 0.009636462666094303, 0.008788111619651318, 0.02918868698179722, 0.0065827751532197, 0.0019444611389189959, 0.042375598102808, 0.014934740960597992, -0.04351630061864853, -0.0478861927986145, 0.018344471231102943, -0.034450676292181015, -0.021391287446022034, 0.027669131755828857, 0.015803184360265732, 0.003980248235166073, 0.015090914443135262, 0.017928587272763252, 0.03712352737784386, 0.03595239296555519, -0.034579984843730927, 0.02606557309627533, -0.0003601073694881052, -0.013606452383100986, 0.005749315954744816, 0.04213095083832741, 0.028071030974388123, -0.003562557976692915, 0.01631486974656582, -0.009404502809047699, -0.008072299882769585, 0.022421445697546005, -0.05037306621670723, 0.013463141396641731, -0.009935085661709309, 0.008299038745462894, -0.0488424189388752, 0.02455022558569908, 0.01764684170484543, -0.03289416804909706, -0.0010873295832425356, -0.023404251784086227, 0.05165089666843414, -0.0590798482298851, 0.004757216665893793, 0.02234221249818802, 0.04832032322883606, 0.026243554428219795, 0.022709501907229424, -0.04710880294442177, 0.021174579858779907, 0.0030591883696615696, -0.02985692024230957, -0.05157169699668884, 0.04531862586736679, 0.04591687023639679, -0.004961778409779072, -0.0008444466511718929, -0.04411634802818298, -0.011839982122182846, -0.043380044400691986, -0.013095395639538765, 0.002408210886642337, 0.046380478888750076, 0.02917974814772606, 0.01578819379210472, 0.029479386284947395, -0.006095726974308491, -0.023313995450735092, -0.025902006775140762, -0.08339235186576843, 0.04091329500079155, -0.00464760884642601, -0.005793614313006401, 0.020376931875944138, -0.044640958309173584, 0.008519773371517658, -0.009737709537148476, 0.016834130510687828, 0.04735012724995613, 0.030596623197197914, -0.010604538954794407, 0.014603122137486935, 0.007358360569924116, 0.012050571851432323, -0.004268694669008255, -0.004980196710675955, 0.03383086621761322, 0.008630028925836086, 0.02477211318910122, 0.05879644677042961, -0.029447944834828377, -0.009741837158799171, -0.03988344967365265, 0.00003412738078623079, 0.04009012132883072, 0.011007191613316536, 0.05373802036046982, 0.016333017498254776, -0.04115430265665054, 0.0042997002601623535, 0.008227012120187283, 0.03823747858405113, 0.05085066705942154, 0.020996758714318275, -0.009024159051477909, -0.0012535321293398738, 0.015345881693065166, 0.010492436587810516, -0.007661596406251192, 0.009727712720632553, -0.008757833391427994, 0.08265963941812515, 0.023934543132781982, -0.04034135118126869, 0.028150420635938644, 0.06497085094451904, 0.027782436460256577, 0.014796098694205284, -0.03010689467191696, -0.03554825112223625, -0.019490273669362068, -0.01868917979300022, 0.03611787408590317, 0.005280530545860529, -0.0012312785256654024, -0.00451494799926877, 0.0504477433860302, -0.008222301490604877, -0.03236567974090576, 0.0017442466923967004, 0.0264107845723629, 0.05956686660647392, -0.0009655055473558605, -0.036198247224092484, 0.010692763142287731, 0.029957082122564316, 0.016689734533429146, 0.016344644129276276, 0.025312187150120735, -0.08023364841938019, -0.011806150898337364, 0.013109887950122356, 0.055518392473459244, -0.009501781314611435, -0.027411270886659622, -0.03861983120441437, -0.005728716030716896, 0.03284768387675285, -0.044273629784584045, 0.02590787597000599, 0.0012179279001429677, -0.039540138095617294, 0.007443254813551903, 0.004210998769849539, -0.043904926627874374, -0.016457077115774155, -0.04365848749876022, 0.010576211847364902, 0.0009479114087298512, -0.0156573373824358, -0.021719859912991524, -0.0037669544108211994, -0.04035067558288574, -0.005254722665995359, -0.04558820649981499, -0.005406364798545837, 0.019147763028740883, 0.053230173885822296, -0.009643510915338993, -0.04303852468729019, 0.006315720733255148, 0.006346751470118761, -0.00174057821277529, 0.08381136506795883, 0.011960143223404884, 0.0002453710185363889, 0.023239118978381157, -0.007374706212431192, -0.005441997665911913, -0.012396222911775112, -0.014913438819348812, 0.019599908962845802, -0.01021160464733839, -0.03558676689863205, 0.05640087276697159, -0.0008866270072758198, -0.0159433763474226, -0.013540825806558132, -0.04413535073399544, -0.007486194837838411, -0.01514586340636015, -0.015546441078186035, -0.08025813847780228, 0.007958833128213882, 0.005024917423725128, 0.004003954119980335, -0.01915883459150791, -0.005429989192634821, -0.04315429925918579, 0.031980134546756744, 0.044001560658216476, 0.049074724316596985, -0.004053856246173382, -0.02758174203336239, -0.025050992146134377, 0.014709679409861565, 0.01695202849805355, -0.06965496391057968, 0.017096620053052902, -0.020878037437796593, 0.010306702926754951, -0.021380223333835602, -0.026593198999762535, -0.024530630558729172, -0.01569204032421112, -0.023318788036704063, 0.02471272088587284, -0.040936145931482315, -0.018756026402115822, -0.015220017172396183, 0.017218612134456635, 0.015624098479747772, -0.054273467510938644, -0.021354006603360176, 0.021382229402661324, 0.01707596331834793, 0.04378404840826988, 0.013039732351899147, 0.07365776598453522, 0.0010787807404994965, -0.013200249522924423, -0.046964794397354126, -0.04759353771805763, 0.021781139075756073, 0.013489172793924809, -0.06519445776939392, -0.006687960121780634, -0.017090551555156708, -0.02048625983297825, -0.018092786893248558, 0.007990904152393341, 0.012912093661725521, -0.03358891233801842, 0.006967781111598015, 0.0096577238291502, 0.037943027913570404, 0.0760718584060669, 0.0005494961515069008, 0.013393090106546879, 0.032288808375597, -0.012389009818434715, -0.008466094732284546, 0.01224145945161581, -0.020700203254818916, -0.02190205082297325, -0.011477530933916569, -0.01258587185293436, 0.04588213562965393, 0.036209333688020706, -0.009394683875143528, -0.018845995888113976, -0.03867855295538902, 0.02652573026716709, -0.00641087768599391, -0.03653274103999138, -0.010596818290650845, -0.009205776266753674, 0.04505215585231781, 0.007265865337103605, 0.0023688192013651133, -0.008128907531499863, -0.028064826503396034, 0.038390811532735825, -0.03789342939853668, -0.00825374387204647, 0.030026940628886223, 0.031412504613399506, -0.01113150455057621, 0.009439502842724323, 0.0038116585928946733, -0.013487238436937332, 0.023791572079062462, 0.031508900225162506, -0.011023390106856823, 0.013690538704395294, 0.01435129251331091, -0.059871431440114975, -0.013591867871582508, -0.07268200069665909, -0.014341001398861408, 0.08584165573120117, -0.03568660095334053, 0.03305261209607124, 0.02375822700560093, -0.006136386655271053, -0.015078054741024971, 0.0017600639257580042, -0.026775775477290154, -0.0208846777677536, 0.0267875324934721, 0.017966026440262794, -0.045715831220149994, -0.03596922755241394, 0.04894351586699486, 0.051440391689538956, 0.003842682344838977, 0.049167364835739136, 0.003733227960765362, -0.005659038666635752, 0.0027111999224871397, -0.01491251215338707, -0.03703586757183075, 0.03766956180334091, -0.016455894336104393, 0.014886169694364071, -0.054459985345602036, -0.009412767365574837, 0.05713193118572235, 0.0501481257379055, 0.007378314156085253, -0.05840906500816345, -0.01968086138367653, -0.015459961257874966, 0.012843874283134937, 0.039599914103746414, -0.038775503635406494, 0.027548089623451233, 0.0298619344830513, 0.056525617837905884, -0.02988065965473652, 0.05125201493501663, -0.082084059715271, -0.037462156265974045, -0.008113267831504345, -0.02331511862576008, -0.017887486144900322, 0.060215774923563004, 0.0045157852582633495, 0.0008203202160075307, -0.0053765177726745605, -0.03570316731929779, 0.0036048891488462687, 0.030834492295980453, 0.03421822562813759, -0.014015660621225834, 0.10513526201248169, 0.01292130071669817, -0.006781165953725576, 0.027450229972600937, -0.015909520909190178, 0.13321103155612946, 0.045080047100782394, 0.002660742262378335, -0.05793621018528938, 0.004493878688663244, -0.002552294172346592, 0.025869237259030342, -0.019213784486055374, -0.007614536676555872, 0.04217272996902466, -0.017218897119164467, 0.06443633139133453, 0.032350823283195496, 0.003706488059833646, 0.02821163460612297, 0.004741492215543985, -0.019216734915971756, -0.0724642351269722, -0.03103744052350521, -0.0016413440462201834, 0.012417440302670002, 0.010378110222518444, -0.064760223031044, 0.017734671011567116, 0.02530641295015812, -0.02505236119031906, -0.029669977724552155, 0.0073521374724805355, -0.004989073611795902, -0.009644300676882267, -0.014169875532388687, -0.024882154539227486, -0.01729629933834076, 0.013102567754685879, -0.0299857035279274, -0.001250542001798749, 0.0006590643315576017, -0.02203747071325779, 0.005302736535668373, 0.014949475415050983, 0.019075127318501472, 0.012741299346089363, 0.01755480095744133, 0.061263225972652435, -0.03062380850315094, -0.006059322506189346, 0.004458311013877392, 0.058492764830589294, -0.012776968069374561, -0.030970498919487, -0.030380485579371452, -0.00860495213419199, 0.041286323219537735, -0.06773605942726135, 0.0040941499173641205, 0.034478139132261276, 0.021387891843914986, -0.03557232394814491, 0.0009277125936932862, -0.06123083457350731, -0.030515918508172035, -0.015380721539258957, 0.03613175079226494, 0.0249338261783123, -0.045156486332416534, -0.018666250631213188, -0.05781512334942818, 0.05563714727759361, -0.008529219776391983, 0.01593860425055027, 0.03022640384733677, 0.0015017680125311017, -0.02888200804591179, -0.02079978585243225, 0.03261098265647888, 0.008734766393899918, 0.019432812929153442, -0.019143909215927124, -0.006160852964967489, -0.004464878235012293, -0.02890164963901043, 0.02179485373198986, -0.030935227870941162, -0.019333908334374428, -0.05684230849146843, 0.010419030673801899, 0.006419570185244083, 0.07869303226470947, -0.01668248325586319, 0.013439725153148174, -0.03741539642214775, 0.015750406309962273, 0.000650719681289047, -0.04088987410068512, -0.036423712968826294, 0.030272647738456726, -0.015378833748400211, -0.011149797588586807, -0.031163616105914116, 0.07334912568330765, 0.01008488517254591, 0.02350999228656292, -0.017628762871026993, 0.032518621534109116, 0.019178621470928192, -0.019053108990192413, -0.03361307829618454, -0.04279911145567894, -0.006662020459771156, -0.012540293857455254, -0.011601557955145836, -0.004621805623173714, 0.010521765798330307, 0.012229419313371181, -0.06450630724430084, 0.028166528791189194, -0.008461231365799904, -0.026983482763171196, 0.022018039599061012, -0.05819451063871384, 0.03437771275639534, -0.023515397682785988, 0.02298690192401409, -0.044415537267923355, -0.01156974583864212, 0.030769599601626396, -0.060667458921670914, -0.03611931577324867, 0.010707088746130466, -0.03320421278476715, 0.008088423870503902, 0.006742272526025772, 0.013213105499744415, 0.004654159769415855, 0.015475536696612835, 0.013741424307227135, 0.021397361531853676, 0.059325188398361206, -0.018142549321055412, -0.03437213972210884, 0.011308261193335056, -0.04871109873056412, -0.030319595709443092, 0.020244598388671875, 0.0072576310485601425, 0.057418808341026306, 0.0031735210213810205, 0.022830553352832794, -0.03617323935031891, 0.07991030067205429, -0.05481159687042236, -0.004738360643386841, -0.019127147272229195, -0.014479255303740501, 0.02989177405834198, 0.016047216951847076, -0.012724255211651325, 0.012093248777091503, -0.027994412928819656, 0.0039648208767175674, 0.06510422378778458, 0.011594034731388092, -0.011575695127248764, 0.007711450569331646, 0.016666188836097717, 0.0010750980582088232, 0.01639525219798088, 0.005263865925371647, 0.03649725019931793, 0.06541755050420761, -0.012058352120220661, 0.05226993188261986, -0.031232567504048347, 0.022499719634652138, -0.053402483463287354, -0.00474661635234952, -0.023933744058012962, -0.01160793099552393, 0.050856608897447586, -0.032148756086826324, 0.007108685560524464, -0.003650904633104801, -0.0424228236079216, 0.014150821603834629, -0.022015376016497612, -0.0028603842947632074, -0.04657689481973648, 0.016635611653327942, -0.03552670031785965, 0.07118720561265945, 0.027729135006666183, -0.005054418928921223, 0.04748418182134628, 0.007392021827399731, 0.019502384588122368, -0.04355015233159065, -0.020061876624822617, 0.025676388293504715, -0.0006405150634236634, -0.04327920824289322, 0.014772764407098293, -0.018823489546775818, -0.001625603879801929, 0.018871651962399483, -0.028804806992411613, 0.0236764345318079, 0.052389852702617645, -0.008581059984862804, 0.014830012805759907, 0.02586301788687706, 0.005818894598633051, 0.007968796417117119, -0.01010747067630291, -0.008967517875134945, -0.009806890040636063, 0.0009277454810217023, -0.019286420196294785, 0.04391361400485039, 0.014730091206729412, -0.011237827129662037, -0.025757012888789177, 0.020048843696713448, 0.011651515029370785, -0.009312979876995087, 0.0010957502527162433, -0.04368622973561287, 0.00658844830468297, -0.030140861868858337, 0.047857724130153656, -0.03565726801753044, 0.027222970500588417, 0.003394539700821042, 0.0243934728205204, -0.022554688155651093, 0.04590798169374466, -0.03004498779773712, -0.03819367289543152, -0.0328497439622879, -0.0077530452981591225, -0.022468121722340584, -0.02673744410276413, -0.015115580521523952, 0.019743017852306366, 0.00581752136349678, -0.03429335355758667, -0.008168034255504608, -0.06323201209306717, 0.04152948409318924, -0.016123678535223007, 0.007542842999100685, 0.030665291473269463, 0.016765108332037926, 0.03700745850801468, -0.08806023746728897, 0.05825286731123924, -0.010991537943482399, -0.040621671825647354, -0.06447381526231766, -0.01997804082930088, -0.02270728349685669, 0.025358181446790695, 0.05035211890935898, -0.00026680793962441385, 0.03782165050506592, -0.030340172350406647, 0.04057991877198219, -0.007241299841552973, -0.0346420519053936, 0.05603571981191635, -0.027915265411138535, -0.010662663727998734, -0.015492885373532772, 0.013703442178666592, 0.02100137062370777, 0.0023481296375393867, 0.004717796575278044, -0.0034878416918218136, 0.04208707809448242, -0.012774583883583546, -0.02220078930258751, -0.017758315429091454, 0.0001828201930038631, -0.008993750438094139, 0.04708804190158844, -0.011372256092727184, -0.010133909061551094, 0.07460913807153702, -0.0009459813009016216, -0.048465099185705185, 0.02947649545967579, -0.008111783303320408, -0.014296742156147957, 0.0006219343631528318, -0.04293449968099594, 0.015527383424341679, -0.07701617479324341, -0.0032600120175629854, -0.017682956531643867, -0.006468563340604305, 0.004157619085162878, 0.04854946583509445, 0.04387905076146126, 0.04208694398403168, -0.031001629307866096, 0.01806619018316269, -0.004693831782788038, -0.036832794547080994, 0.0311516635119915, 0.032102249562740326, 0.013653409667313099, -0.015677740797400475, 0.01857132650911808, 0.02537165768444538, -0.01582474075257778, 0.05413945019245148, -0.016817400231957436, 0.0559237003326416, -0.026695532724261284, -0.0042617954313755035, -0.015588684938848019, -0.02059706300497055, 0.004966590087860823, 0.01582328788936138, -0.013596901670098305, 0.022351939231157303, -0.028189076110720634, -0.021602332592010498, 0.01699245721101761, -0.029630374163389206, -0.09434854984283447, -0.0044702389277517796, 0.039317138493061066, 0.031606707721948624, -0.0034026720095425844, 0.009731992147862911, -0.007659172173589468, -0.030848653987050056, 0.023204142227768898, -0.0019553930032998323, 0.025751033797860146, 0.01562582142651081, -0.01855449005961418, -0.007049290928989649, -0.003325092140585184, -0.0031866664066910744, 0.01996402069926262, 0.05079842358827591, 0.021736934781074524, 0.009429309517145157, -0.0415482372045517, 0.012300790287554264, 0.011430460959672928, 0.06751115620136261, -0.051501549780368805, -0.030064210295677185, -0.04983393847942352, -0.011245065368711948, -0.004455026239156723, -0.006929929833859205 ]
<p>I turn to this forum for advice with the following problem. If you could please shed some light on any aspect of this question I'd be very grateful.</p> <p><strong>Problem decription:</strong><br> I'm trying to use an SVM to segment a grayscale image of a puncture in polymer (original res. 1280x1024, can't post, no reputation :)</p> <p>Now, I know this isn't probably the most conventional way to approach this problem, but still I'd like to try whether it is possible in any way.</p> <p><strong>My work so far:</strong><br> I think of the segmentation problem as follows: classify a given pixel based on its value and neighborhood pixel values, i.e. determine whether pixel belongs to the foreground (puncture) or background (anything other than puncture).</p> <p>I labeled this image using GIMP (for the SVM training purposes, i.e. marked the location of the puncture, i.e. each pixel is given a class (1 - puncture, -1 - background)) and tried to extract some simple features:</p> <ol> <li>central pixel value + neighborhood pixel values with varying size of neighborhood</li> <li>central pixel value + differences between central pixel value and neighborhood pixel values</li> <li>central pixel value + 2D FFT spectrum of the neighborhood (amplitude and phase components)</li> <li>standard deviation of the neighborhood</li> </ol> <p>Note that I varied neighborhood size from 3x3 = 9 dimensions to 11x11 = 121 dimensions. I couldn't go higher (I use MATLAB for this, i'm getting out of memory errors). None of these were found sufficiently discriminatory. (I used PCA to inspect, calculated between-class distance of centroids and their respective class covariance matrices).</p> <p><strong>Soo, at last, to my question:</strong><br> Could you think of any usefull features to use for this task? (I was thinking some measures of homogentity of the neighborhood would be helpfull, since inside of the puncture is more or less uniform in brightness, but haven't found any. Also maybe some texture features would be helpfull, but who knows.)</p> <p>Cheers, Jacob</p>
36,817
[ 0.014946592971682549, 0.007905783131718636, 0.02728794328868389, -0.006234911736100912, 0.051044680178165436, -0.007308571133762598, -0.057064566761255264, -0.03221935033798218, 0.020766275003552437, -0.06977187097072601, 0.02387302555143833, 0.07435417920351028, 0.004193809814751148, 0.07712248712778091, -0.010495775379240513, -0.0024146954528987408, -0.012817056849598885, -0.029914457350969315, -0.016929566860198975, -0.005750276613980532, 0.0062550934962928295, 0.013142947107553482, 0.023060332983732224, -0.024549150839447975, -0.037291787564754486, 0.05683758109807968, 0.0018608354730531573, -0.03780658170580864, 0.022506505250930786, 0.0327877439558506, -0.06141429394483566, -0.026273539289832115, -0.006503090262413025, 0.012311275117099285, 0.011384251527488232, 0.018168559297919273, -0.007362010423094034, -0.020072737708687782, 0.013216082006692886, 0.01709754578769207, -0.03942921385169029, -0.013873796910047531, 0.027696581557393074, 0.04850310459733009, -0.028882864862680435, 0.0031628592405468225, 0.006500987336039543, -0.04044494032859802, 0.03743062540888786, -0.04184982553124428, 0.08436104655265808, 0.01142991054803133, -0.007432909216731787, 0.027399536222219467, 0.00041807410889305174, 0.004521280061453581, 0.020307393744587898, 0.03689014911651611, 0.010380541905760765, -0.03168391063809395, 0.0009460979490540922, -0.0013390745734795928, -0.009900663048028946, -0.031696442514657974, -0.024550721049308777, -0.023045891895890236, 0.01688765361905098, -0.008866241201758385, 0.04172911122441292, -0.027260901406407356, -0.020384306088089943, -0.03922724351286888, 0.018824344500899315, -0.025936193764209747, 0.006451657507568598, -0.012952498160302639, -0.05969022586941719, 0.04867734760046005, 0.01056207437068224, -0.023588426411151886, 0.016416076570749283, 0.010002445429563522, -0.010550808161497116, 0.027268661186099052, 0.032334841787815094, -0.0005478817038238049, 0.06416241824626923, -0.01744178868830204, -0.01464791689068079, 0.03166002407670021, 0.02833051234483719, -0.006352828349918127, 0.04771146550774574, -0.0002934961812570691, -0.025933755561709404, 0.08023867011070251, 0.02940121665596962, 0.012279943563044071, -0.0038636375684291124, 0.020787028595805168, -0.004514374770224094, -0.020271023735404015, 0.03389551863074303, 0.09561443328857422, -0.03142932802438736, 0.013051492162048817, -0.027909547090530396, 0.007241600193083286, 0.0006666945409961045, 0.000038373618735931814, -0.04148139804601669, -0.012872506864368916, 0.0010139794321730733, -0.007066656835377216, -0.021251440048217773, -0.02806573547422886, 0.011061406694352627, -0.00642154086381197, 0.03175492584705353, 0.05085955560207367, 0.018733685836195946, -0.025118477642536163, 0.0023634005337953568, -0.030746115371584892, -0.08575964719057083, 0.037007592618465424, 0.03874426707625389, 0.010783934034407139, -0.032922662794589996, 0.046678707003593445, 0.023554988205432892, -0.014993327669799328, 0.051092758774757385, -0.04831482470035553, 0.04618598520755768, 0.0006926312926225364, -0.09030786156654358, -0.04875120148062706, 0.03859075903892517, 0.0025194508489221334, 0.009559967555105686, -0.039951831102371216, -0.022516921162605286, 0.009267207235097885, 0.04247569292783737, -0.019161995500326157, 0.031929537653923035, 0.013200857676565647, 0.006115595810115337, -0.002343706553801894, 0.015088586136698723, 0.01219740230590105, -0.013225097209215164, 0.005865304730832577, -0.023494713008403778, -0.0385483056306839, 0.009446917101740837, 0.038794275373220444, -0.011648195795714855, -0.0031988038681447506, 0.031018774956464767, 0.02099071443080902, -0.0005910825566388667, 0.0025398454163223505, -0.0209969412535429, -0.04247024655342102, 0.06126570329070091, -0.015479140914976597, 0.020056068897247314, 0.0061517939902842045, 0.0048909615725278854, 0.00021545971685554832, 0.01887768879532814, -0.008569134399294853, 0.020971110090613365, 0.02907041274011135, 0.006760517600923777, 0.0004612306656781584, 0.03901029750704765, -0.007059164345264435, -0.022166511043906212, -0.044239114969968796, -0.03826490789651871, 0.02941574528813362, 0.003353954991325736, 0.03827882930636406, 0.004851391073316336, -0.03837834298610687, 0.06315620988607407, -0.0023372634314000607, -0.02277560904622078, -0.06243116036057472, -0.004898859187960625, -0.016931917518377304, -0.03563984856009483, 0.007885063998401165, -0.040493883192539215, -0.010748199187219143, 0.013421653769910336, -0.02646986022591591, -0.04170244187116623, 0.004172883462160826, 0.06158040836453438, -0.051290154457092285, 0.006076539866626263, 0.028413401916623116, 0.020349126309156418, -0.014145663008093834, 0.011238154955208302, -0.025361863896250725, -0.016128771007061005, 0.005930734798312187, -0.02017662301659584, 0.020640093833208084, -0.042065590620040894, -0.005578218959271908, 0.012987117283046246, 0.00625944510102272, 0.013623278588056564, 0.018976911902427673, -0.0029036649502813816, 0.0801997110247612, 0.023052837699651718, 0.013094441033899784, 0.004785864148288965, -0.01549480203539133, -0.0077869282104074955, 0.05502583831548691, -0.007608119864016771, -0.008112501353025436, -0.023607807233929634, -0.02331623062491417, 0.09809821099042892, 0.017925109714269638, -0.037440139800310135, 0.003471339587122202, 0.027970124036073685, 0.02533723972737789, 0.018332116305828094, 0.00015791691839694977, 0.009093627333641052, -0.023334231227636337, -0.0160467978566885, 0.01528066024184227, 0.02361624874174595, -0.03265707194805145, -0.0038546875584870577, -0.01141431275755167, 0.0854758694767952, -0.011960765346884727, 0.014293714426457882, 0.052602339535951614, -0.02113848179578781, -0.022750617936253548, -0.0312507338821888, -0.0016212454065680504, 0.04784538969397545, 0.01411097589880228, -0.0008584329043515027, 0.05805906653404236, -0.045542873442173004, 0.014982009306550026, -0.04080880805850029, -0.04377447068691254, 0.037790898233652115, 0.020021498203277588, -0.012194715440273285, 0.013715473935008049, 0.012393755838274956, -0.0462372861802578, 0.024232538416981697, -0.0016485474770888686, -0.01011071540415287, -0.019084777683019638, 0.03243367373943329, 0.08197198808193207, -0.0094634173437953, 0.026267120614647865, -0.020917531102895737, -0.011549031361937523, 0.021246301010251045, 0.019362717866897583, 0.025558918714523315, 0.02258644998073578, -0.07456228882074356, 0.007014373317360878, -0.003185494802892208, 0.017385603860020638, 0.024898534640669823, 0.03591044992208481, -0.016625676304101944, 0.01602748967707157, 0.00027109039365313947, -0.027132626622915268, -0.03143196552991867, -0.020959308370947838, 0.010216220282018185, -0.034309737384319305, -0.028403926640748978, 0.009994402527809143, 0.022651532664895058, -0.054837021976709366, 0.04295077919960022, 0.0014201883459463716, -0.04001537337899208, -0.05782923474907875, -0.009389839135110378, 0.006712174043059349, -0.009585803374648094, 0.011188228614628315, 0.024177182465791702, 0.030389681458473206, 0.017826225608587265, -0.03818957507610321, -0.04294249042868614, -0.002453722059726715, -0.005379529669880867, 0.0439433678984642, -0.019743317738175392, 0.007133306469768286, 0.0863552913069725, 0.04147366061806679, -0.037724126130342484, -0.03445344790816307, 0.031685128808021545, -0.054496366530656815, -0.010016349144279957, 0.02088814787566662, 0.028561485931277275, -0.003353601088747382, 0.0176558718085289, -0.004564183298498392, 0.021974047645926476, 0.08792170137166977, 0.00538470596075058, -0.03236636146903038, 0.04233222454786301, -0.026203202083706856, -0.004174773581326008, 0.06088516488671303, 0.03689968213438988, -0.035139065235853195, 0.020794454962015152, -0.006654208060353994, -0.012067398056387901, 0.025995776057243347, -0.0517759844660759, -0.009314659982919693, -0.04742028936743736, -0.004941558465361595, 0.0022313103545457125, -0.005666782148182392, 0.032981157302856445, -0.04573408514261246, -0.010720545426011086, 0.003604227676987648, 0.03939065337181091, 0.02231842651963234, -0.006483882665634155, 0.05806020274758339, 0.018566366285085678, 0.002438786905258894, 0.018899116665124893, 0.013818779960274696, -0.02915794588625431, 0.008958634920418262, -0.01647009514272213, -0.034730907529592514, 0.01662510819733143, 0.06877678632736206, 0.037235647439956665, 0.037019360810518265, -0.0487557128071785, -0.0017154671950265765, -0.058349963277578354, -0.018477093428373337, -0.04919150099158287, 0.04407982528209686, 0.01838069036602974, 0.049201712012290955, 0.04972866550087929, -0.04641241207718849, 0.013057083822786808, 0.05440939590334892, -0.08684246987104416, -0.00396762415766716, 0.01991439424455166, 0.0013277075486257672, -0.02228369750082493, -0.02151493914425373, 0.018539980053901672, 0.0009503778419457376, 0.019088823348283768, 0.021836405619978905, 0.026393553242087364, -0.06262190639972687, 0.004615821409970522, -0.005994806531816721, -0.015021664090454578, -0.04868495464324951, 0.03132356330752373, 0.01882891356945038, -0.015415564179420471, -0.001556461676955223, -0.010850595310330391, -0.026381973177194595, 0.021586673334240913, -0.01094155665487051, 0.04464459419250488, 0.019902236759662628, 0.05631120875477791, -0.03379983454942703, 0.03415588289499283, -0.0129238935187459, -0.0006131217232905328, 0.00024605635553598404, 0.05077076330780983, 0.003984722774475813, -0.022995423525571823, -0.014902614988386631, -0.0478379912674427, 0.003474953817203641, 0.039343614131212234, 0.05190716311335564, -0.03155073896050453, -0.0012797886738553643, 0.023304712027311325, 0.024756386876106262, -0.08438937366008759, -0.022240517660975456, 0.05947830528020859, 0.0056118289940059185, -0.042080216109752655, -0.07587238401174545, -0.043827880173921585, -0.0004158838710281998, -0.008306914009153843, 0.009166864678263664, -0.030893541872501373, 0.0035750751849263906, -0.024850189685821533, 0.035945355892181396, 0.0023680273443460464, -0.005991783458739519, -0.0077723548747599125, -0.0010863225907087326, 0.0023436069022864103, -0.04750440642237663, -0.009300027042627335, 0.013097710907459259, 0.01686122827231884, 0.059001658111810684, 0.034641049802303314, -0.01733412966132164, -0.10002581775188446, -0.023196609690785408, 0.0581250935792923, 0.07147573679685593, 0.0036060402635484934, -0.04758547991514206, -0.031894758343696594, -0.028850354254245758, 0.021437868475914, -0.03376062214374542, 0.04034724459052086, 0.003978092223405838, -0.01093661691993475, -0.024642735719680786, -0.02678152546286583, -0.03943755850195885, -0.00756108108907938, -0.012165240943431854, 0.032103393226861954, -0.040666401386260986, -0.026691101491451263, -0.05467415228486061, 0.020929867401719093, -0.02801946923136711, 0.03605514392256737, -0.022131098434329033, -0.02004578337073326, -0.02402499131858349, -0.0012346520088613033, 0.0022743218578398228, -0.024202559143304825, 0.02123389206826687, 0.03813597932457924, 0.017640316858887672, 0.06253784149885178, -0.02906060591340065, -0.03179627284407616, 0.04673304781317711, 0.004886934068053961, -0.020958388224244118, 0.01279095932841301, -0.02849060669541359, 0.05170891806483269, 0.021644674241542816, 0.002801575232297182, 0.05246948450803757, 0.00835289154201746, 0.012757147662341595, -0.010397740639746189, -0.01657487265765667, 0.012143449857831001, -0.03694019094109535, -0.040564198046922684, -0.02056697942316532, 0.0070732710883021355, -0.015270792879164219, 0.045644424855709076, 0.0032328444067388773, 0.042174406349658966, 0.006251454818993807, -0.01099504716694355, 0.011731132864952087, 0.017339181154966354, -0.0536554679274559, 0.004689261317253113, -0.006096771918237209, 0.022158484905958176, -0.02405295893549919, 0.005931137129664421, -0.018565284088253975, -0.0171392522752285, 0.007320258766412735, 0.005265957675874233, -0.03179553151130676, -0.02949061058461666, -0.034513674676418304, 0.009658596478402615, 0.008616216480731964, -0.02465621754527092, 0.03736654669046402, -0.0004426335799507797, 0.040108583867549896, 0.008795357309281826, -0.04705353081226349, 0.010704999789595604, 0.011379235424101353, -0.024444717913866043, 0.04585918039083481, -0.031012052670121193, 0.014746444299817085, 0.005838644690811634, 0.02080482244491577, -0.045032694935798645, -0.05340347811579704, 0.003960568457841873, 0.05891181528568268, -0.037624895572662354, -0.012827207334339619, -0.021946724504232407, 0.01747104711830616, -0.05395025014877319, 0.0191082451492548, 0.0330682098865509, -0.00239779450930655, 0.012156601995229721, 0.02623378299176693, 0.01672285981476307, 0.06206577643752098, -0.017564872279763222, 0.03905404359102249, 0.024808762595057487, 0.014806310646235943, -0.030019160360097885, 0.019495364278554916, 0.0017245134804397821, -0.03334365040063858, -0.006762252654880285, -0.034358084201812744, 0.040461570024490356, 0.02398296445608139, 0.0024659051559865475, -0.014555125497281551, -0.029592126607894897, -0.00855860486626625, 0.01767970435321331, -0.00767965242266655, 0.010777554474771023, 0.008482201024889946, -0.009063857607543468, -0.01734493114054203, -0.013809198513627052, -0.005087859462946653, -0.029020102694630623, 0.014405310153961182, 0.05122499540448189, -0.01945582404732704, 0.01548366155475378, 0.048326969146728516, -0.025048036128282547, 0.024267850443720818, 0.024029549211263657, -0.02774379402399063, 0.04723433032631874, -0.03161735460162163, 0.023456363007426262, 0.005334985442459583, 0.052672937512397766, -0.04079238325357437, -0.00347143760882318, -0.07686416059732437, -0.014921403490006924, 0.05553887411952019, 0.011313207447528839, 0.02236485294997692, 0.03042024001479149, -0.051557235419750214, 0.011712338775396347, -0.009095624089241028, -0.006398831494152546, 0.02352142706513405, -0.024415338411927223, 0.05176832899451256, -0.026027368381619453, -0.009913017973303795, 0.03859413415193558, 0.0044506872072815895, -0.004398022312670946, 0.05328993871808052, -0.010216256603598595, 0.034177303314208984, 0.022837920114398003, -0.040605999529361725, -0.06296680122613907, 0.01676582358777523, -0.028424564749002457, 0.006259780842810869, 0.003996475599706173, 0.0005594335380010307, 0.048612330108881, 0.04839479923248291, 0.020659247413277626, -0.03258037567138672, 0.0072183446027338505, -0.06577513366937637, -0.007544382009655237, 0.01965770497918129, -0.01583891361951828, -0.005400662310421467, -0.014762744307518005, 0.028571579605340958, 0.020491041243076324, 0.012633133679628372, -0.0752260833978653, -0.03458426892757416, -0.01141260750591755, -0.037553999572992325, -0.0711154043674469, 0.040615763515233994, -0.004104392137378454, -0.0015990983229130507, 0.04957360029220581, -0.028837935999035835, 0.0069567193277180195, 0.0273020938038826, 0.040302153676748276, 0.019188322126865387, 0.034626495093107224, 0.0025941994972527027, 0.005177775397896767, -0.011886758729815483, -0.0013125884579494596, 0.14694656431674957, 0.10803832858800888, 0.04277501627802849, -0.016795553267002106, -0.010780771262943745, 0.023975569754838943, -0.010398955084383488, -0.0050183869898319244, -0.0005084379226900637, 0.0029922863468527794, -0.0679875984787941, 0.0005935032968409359, 0.04083865135908127, 0.04432721063494682, -0.042702265083789825, 0.01503839623183012, -0.009892992675304413, -0.004700878169387579, 0.001859210547991097, -0.011359871365129948, -0.04128421097993851, -0.01722293719649315, -0.04680480435490608, 0.055008187890052795, -0.00006739865057170391, -0.032455507665872574, -0.051965296268463135, -0.014326329343020916, 0.011790139600634575, -0.04836602881550789, 0.006270767655223608, -0.013673690147697926, -0.016973000019788742, -0.0005681058974005282, -0.018584277480840683, -0.012429746799170971, 0.01225291844457388, -0.03599294275045395, 0.03975323215126991, 0.03784459829330444, 0.019482169300317764, -0.0026231843512505293, -0.008109691552817822, -0.016261808574199677, -0.04557117074728012, -0.02970704436302185, -0.04139251634478569, 0.06312201917171478, 0.008301557041704655, 0.01026822067797184, 0.016495922580361366, 0.011732721701264381, 0.03845089673995972, -0.0637669488787651, -0.008643785491585732, 0.01965377666056156, 0.014593849889934063, 0.04070581868290901, -0.010424635373055935, -0.026071986183524132, 0.05766090750694275, 0.001032808213494718, -0.01246716734021902, 0.005523535888642073, -0.01665685884654522, -0.030670013278722763, -0.03253205865621567, 0.07611776888370514, -0.0003089230158366263, -0.005288655404001474, -0.008505386300384998, -0.0286308191716671, 0.00651906244456768, -0.014490424655377865, 0.005784372799098492, -0.0019661213736981153, 0.029402675107121468, -0.010140354745090008, -0.0384197011590004, 0.0010130315786227584, -0.019789718091487885, 0.007880053482949734, -0.040291499346494675, 0.01267804391682148, -0.0035063994582742453, -0.006897025741636753, 0.03981664776802063, 0.05743963643908501, 0.012275674380362034, 0.0319492369890213, -0.011881074868142605, 0.04622550308704376, -0.0074784597381949425, -0.004730552900582552, -0.04285092279314995, -0.03364036977291107, -0.024603208526968956, 0.04173697903752327, 0.010811957530677319, 0.004233089741319418, -0.0003687925636768341, -0.02510879747569561, 0.00970502570271492, 0.025067325681447983, -0.009797739796340466, -0.005697611719369888, -0.010565119795501232, -0.037224844098091125, -0.0304634440690279, -0.033500805497169495, 0.003453855635598302, -0.04974428191781044, -0.03864166885614395, 0.005250552203506231, -0.04069479554891586, 0.010760272853076458, 0.031913530081510544, 0.0018546412466093898, 0.007365413475781679, -0.053421951830387115, 0.035934776067733765, -0.01036621443927288, -0.008792311884462833, -0.009040973149240017, 0.02344689890742302, -0.03407726809382439, -0.030328627675771713, -0.015651371330022812, 0.010414346121251583, -0.01880825310945511, -0.01806996762752533, 0.02210935205221176, 0.012671666219830513, 0.012765517458319664, 0.009572116658091545, 0.0295316930860281, 0.004958422854542732, 0.05167597532272339, 0.0035629644989967346, 0.02640109695494175, 0.013988969847559929, -0.02902377024292946, -0.055132992565631866, 0.011071941815316677, -0.03686873987317085, 0.01640676148235798, 0.04584955796599388, 0.009773116558790207, 0.014583338052034378, 0.05489427223801613, 0.022133495658636093, -0.030121784657239914, 0.027864797040820122, 0.019602680578827858, 0.00001683778828009963, -0.004086214117705822, 0.047375474125146866, -0.015349972993135452, -0.023850776255130768, 0.02811277098953724, -0.01866256073117256, -0.0293728057295084, -0.02733631245791912, 0.0011335170129314065, -0.050860337913036346, 0.007390676997601986, -0.006346907466650009, 0.00726398965343833, 0.03899546340107918, 0.007174990139901638, -0.033295754343271255, 0.022623131051659584, 0.004039226099848747, -0.027480680495500565, -0.08802659809589386, 0.017619185149669647, -0.014366506598889828, 0.0390525683760643, 0.04029957950115204, -0.08206620812416077, 0.03330804407596588, 0.0226691085845232, -0.08595273643732071, 0.009317824617028236, 0.015477508306503296, -0.01604451797902584, -0.04829547554254532, 0.028083857148885727, -0.03608829528093338, -0.013176211155951023, 0.0057747927494347095, 0.04734069108963013, 0.038211558014154434, 0.08064951002597809, -0.02607737109065056, -0.005937006324529648, 0.0052963620983064175, 0.01380289625376463, -0.01164919137954712, -0.020116738975048065, 0.015535812824964523, -0.007687130477279425, 0.017434943467378616, -0.0008040664251893759, -0.037168677896261215, -0.003649097168818116, 0.012187449261546135, 0.027794864028692245, -0.027109317481517792, 0.01950388215482235, 0.031063571572303772, 0.03917156159877777, 0.015236406587064266, -0.026202285662293434, 0.023113630712032318, 0.025496812537312508, 0.006677302997559309, -0.01819414459168911, -0.001424764166586101, 0.0077926963567733765, -0.0009101323084905744, 0.00680688489228487, -0.030312554910779, -0.04471316188573837, 0.021463533863425255, -0.0022472802083939314, 0.00011896666546817869, -0.03761754184961319, 0.004552076570689678, -0.030519042164087296, -0.012669019401073456, -0.013767801225185394, 0.03455692529678345, -0.03680601343512535, 0.013471164740622044, -0.015330403111875057, -0.07158247381448746, 0.006795952096581459, 0.028669776394963264, -0.02119014784693718, -0.019946981221437454, -0.01195190567523241, 0.007194018457084894, -0.012149812653660774, 0.013196256011724472, -0.013738498091697693, -0.006112944800406694, 0.04505418241024017, -0.019605381414294243, 0.024784550070762634, 0.00734137836843729, 0.0014970810152590275, 0.00471258070319891, -0.06750720739364624, 0.01806827075779438, 0.003843329381197691, 0.006623351015150547, -0.023005317896604538, 0.0004930855357088149, -0.0005014227353967726, 0.03544814884662628, 0.050658851861953735, 0.006079631391912699, 0.008731941692531109, -0.017496414482593536, -0.017719367519021034, -0.0028067436069250107, -0.037791185081005096, 0.018133344128727913, -0.015524975024163723, -0.019508669152855873, -0.013476759195327759, -0.009210238233208656, 0.012003330513834953, 0.04199809953570366, 0.034767989069223404, -0.0044429185800254345, -0.02463315799832344, -0.0112447589635849, -0.007302630692720413, 0.012306098826229572, -0.008368557319045067, 0.001326325349509716, 0.07701794058084488, 0.028369378298521042, 0.005475651007145643, 0.023630447685718536, -0.017648126929998398, -0.0447862334549427, -0.041718412190675735, -0.04431943595409393, -0.027937667444348335, -0.02500605769455433, 0.023671317845582962, 0.0747251957654953, -0.07814929634332657, -0.0012704653199762106, 0.031703680753707886, -0.030055686831474304, -0.017837192863225937, 0.051445771008729935, -0.008997512049973011, 0.003754151752218604, -0.0008400171063840389, 0.030498243868350983, -0.006755040027201176, -0.017305754125118256, -0.006398328114300966, 0.003060383489355445, -0.0020890268497169018, -0.01921253651380539, 0.014313376508653164, 0.027993978932499886, -0.0012693771859630942, 0.006137225776910782, -0.040679119527339935, 0.01836634799838066, 0.008578588254749775, 0.023891791701316833, 0.009639071300625801, -0.03192262351512909, 0.021010810509324074, 0.01518136728554964, -0.03074413351714611, 0.06762415170669556, 0.009757373481988907, -0.030735701322555542, -0.032558150589466095, -0.028586119413375854, -0.02025318332016468, 0.04552653059363365, 0.05062195658683777, -0.007572689559310675, 0.047304727137088776, -0.007967245765030384, -0.03534948453307152, 0.007928640581667423, 0.050323113799095154, -0.04384620487689972, 0.037460874766111374, 0.006405218504369259, -0.003963920753449202, 0.03577794134616852, -0.015792353078722954, -0.033093586564064026, 0.012169147841632366, 0.012537563219666481, 0.04869595915079117, 0.02121611125767231, 0.02652144804596901, 0.020827822387218475, -0.005975923966616392, 0.04581305757164955, -0.08070961385965347, -0.01719835214316845, -0.01697227917611599, -0.02170729823410511, 0.008997082710266113, -0.01787177287042141 ]
<pre><code>library(mvtnorm) set.seed(1) x &lt;- rmvnorm(2000, rep(0, 6), diag(c(5, rep(1,5)))) x &lt;- scale(x, center=T, scale=F) pc &lt;- princomp(x) biplot(pc) </code></pre> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Jj6C7.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>There are a bunch of red arrows plotted, what do they mean? I knew that the first arrow labelled with "Var1" should be pointing the most varying direction of the data-set (if we think them as 2000 data points, each being a vector of size 6). I also read from somewhere, the most varying direction should be the direction of the 1st eigen vector.</p> <p>However, reading into the code of biplot in R. The line about the arrows is:</p> <pre><code>if(var.axes) arrows(0, 0, y[,1L] * 0.8, y[,2L] * 0.8, col = col[2L], </code></pre> <p>Where <code>y</code> is the actually the loadings matrix, which is the eigenvector matrix. So it looks like the 1st arrow is actually pointing from <code>(0, 0)</code> to <code>(y[1, 1], y[1, 2])</code>. I understand that we are trying to plot a high dimensional arrow onto a 2D plane. That's why we are taking the 1st and 2nd element of the <code>y[1, ]</code> vector. However what I don't understand is:</p> <p>Shouldn't the 1st eigenvector direction be the vector denoted by <code>y[, 1]</code>, instead of <code>y[1, ]</code>? (Again, here <code>y</code> is the eigenvector matrix, obtained by PCA or by eigendecomposition of <code>t(x) %*% x</code>.) i.e. the eigenvectors should be column vectors, not those horizontal vectors. </p> <p>Even though we are plotting them on 2D plane, we should draw the 1st direction to be from <code>(0, 0)</code> pointing to <code>(y[1, 1], y[2, 1])</code>? </p>
36,818
[ -0.01204534899443388, 0.01942587085068226, 0.011868164874613285, -0.01229327917098999, 0.06233329325914383, -0.007126230746507645, -0.020479200407862663, -0.026405714452266693, 0.012710430659353733, -0.06695514172315598, 0.007546978071331978, 0.04256199300289154, 0.04096933454275131, 0.058830052614212036, 0.00532511156052351, 0.0036135183181613684, -0.032125744968652725, 0.011401326395571232, 0.014432080090045929, 0.007611360400915146, -0.0020425368566066027, 0.0021293028257787228, 0.020489858463406563, -0.013973776251077652, -0.006030370946973562, 0.061540912836790085, 0.011212804354727268, 0.023588234558701515, 0.002818901091814041, 0.050161875784397125, -0.06735273450613022, -0.04636163264513016, 0.023801563307642937, -0.022102104499936104, 0.0021410800982266665, -0.004718034062534571, 0.000697496987413615, -0.02434494160115719, -0.0011749104596674442, 0.019010528922080994, 0.02347087301313877, 0.0016338087152689695, -0.01145668514072895, 0.07336046546697617, -0.004252242390066385, 0.0005050393519923091, -0.0025517544709146023, -0.009987290017306805, 0.07383059710264206, -0.012363103218376637, 0.08373676985502243, 0.0011091891210526228, 0.00600458076223731, 0.009898871183395386, -0.026337040588259697, -0.0031749177724123, 0.05877280607819557, 0.05292896926403046, 0.0013012525159865618, -0.07963544875383377, 0.00047480620560236275, -0.05135829746723175, -0.0393894761800766, -0.01758926920592785, -0.037048354744911194, 0.018354393541812897, 0.04890713840723038, -0.027754483744502068, 0.03225860744714737, 0.005485914181917906, -0.013589071109890938, 0.009062113240361214, -0.022486655041575432, -0.050647709518671036, -0.006209076382219791, 0.015326683409512043, 0.018246177583932877, 0.005857225973159075, 0.03587711974978447, 0.014703626744449139, 0.019715871661901474, 0.04375382140278816, -0.019474096596240997, 0.02675953321158886, 0.014533625915646553, 0.03751091659069061, 0.07684563100337982, -0.039144597947597504, 0.04511240869760513, 0.011862613260746002, -0.02704492025077343, 0.02817973494529724, 0.024869635701179504, 0.03978343680500984, -0.03975701332092285, 0.05412917211651802, 0.01176117267459631, 0.03596712648868561, -0.02896192856132984, -0.02609425224363804, -0.06092863529920578, -0.008874338120222092, 0.010553112253546715, 0.019712643697857857, -0.02439301460981369, -0.02382981963455677, -0.021767016500234604, 0.0040709408931434155, -0.007237058132886887, -0.0313539020717144, -0.044146616011857986, 0.008713147602975368, 0.004701653029769659, 0.013251181691884995, 0.016175512224435806, -0.02327282354235649, 0.002337211277335882, 0.07622857391834259, 0.035023584961891174, 0.026024674996733665, 0.016898062080144882, -0.02056841179728508, 0.04049210995435715, -0.011312810704112053, -0.06232432648539543, 0.029991919174790382, 0.006808039266616106, 0.010430880822241306, -0.00892640370875597, 0.03474486246705055, -0.0005649238592013717, -0.016401298344135284, 0.033599842339754105, -0.028396571055054665, 0.05278894677758217, -0.01922055147588253, -0.08660925924777985, -0.058524925261735916, 0.0314403772354126, 0.009181717410683632, -0.0013679028488695621, -0.02936687506735325, -0.0009452307131141424, -0.0009943939512595534, 0.03954938426613808, -0.030829185619950294, 0.04278228059411049, 0.02934807352721691, 0.0011116147506982088, 0.0157338734716177, -0.03877639025449753, -0.019744960591197014, -0.03186112269759178, -0.028478089720010757, -0.013846326619386673, -0.057040683925151825, 0.012984190136194229, 0.001954978797584772, 0.0017279695020988584, -0.02469291351735592, 0.0035336387809365988, -0.02251189388334751, -0.027401521801948547, -0.02293706312775612, -0.04638401418924332, -0.0018320309463888407, 0.052252396941185, 0.027421949431300163, 0.01720115728676319, 0.05608437582850456, -0.05685798451304436, 0.014341382309794426, 0.011903759092092514, 0.04571501538157463, 0.06887032836675644, -0.012845590710639954, 0.004933490883558989, -0.0383872427046299, -0.0013899673940613866, 0.0510241724550724, -0.023820118978619576, -0.0682060644030571, -0.017391590401530266, -0.04139501228928566, 0.012183892540633678, 0.03623850271105766, -0.000010220073818345554, -0.03371262177824974, 0.02742631733417511, -0.05084478482604027, -0.03526835888624191, -0.04555201157927513, -0.004875377751886845, -0.0016842206241562963, -0.028075823560357094, -0.015162061899900436, 0.02318895235657692, 0.020672263577580452, 0.039409179240465164, 0.007025005295872688, -0.05265155807137489, 0.012023200280964375, 0.06453138589859009, -0.014394889585673809, 0.008462086319923401, 0.035375889390707016, 0.027426648885011673, 0.0006690605077892542, 0.013042409904301167, -0.02449372038245201, -0.012065299786627293, 0.015678836032748222, -0.004970287438482046, 0.032136157155036926, -0.011637131683528423, -0.029964562505483627, 0.01875762641429901, 0.008457648567855358, -0.04108782857656479, 0.055535491555929184, -0.051561396569013596, 0.014245912432670593, 0.08897735178470612, -0.0032035394106060266, 0.0009562391205690801, -0.004930151626467705, 0.011060151271522045, 0.03355349600315094, -0.02929197996854782, 0.01583987846970558, -0.047405265271663666, 0.007362046279013157, 0.04637700691819191, 0.02567094750702381, -0.025646794587373734, 0.010442662052810192, 0.005968299228698015, 0.01632176898419857, -0.007689704652875662, 0.04398011788725853, 0.006627533119171858, -0.015298396348953247, -0.002617037855088711, 0.016300993040204048, 0.02430935762822628, -0.01978272572159767, 0.03082377277314663, -0.007181156892329454, 0.06960402429103851, -0.004837278742343187, -0.008806177414953709, 0.04555535316467285, -0.045158710330724716, -0.02145015075802803, -0.0068836817517876625, -0.007628247141838074, 0.045226458460092545, 0.021277938038110733, -0.0002080209378618747, 0.0529797188937664, 0.02218451537191868, -0.0027724106330424547, 0.01009832788258791, 0.018385328352451324, -0.025222593918442726, 0.03135240823030472, -0.036315467208623886, -0.014208965003490448, 0.03160642459988594, -0.01421020831912756, 0.05452389642596245, -0.018597349524497986, -0.04803239554166794, -0.055366165935993195, 0.016630778089165688, 0.05189107358455658, 0.037421710789203644, -0.006728052161633968, -0.031218476593494415, -0.021553300321102142, -0.007120480295270681, -0.032429080456495285, 0.010282997973263264, 0.00005512229836313054, -0.07103382796049118, 0.02278595231473446, -0.06118038296699524, 0.004106550011783838, 0.026670776307582855, 0.024030858650803566, -0.045276157557964325, 0.03316985443234444, -0.01230599544942379, -0.027425087988376617, -0.032827720046043396, -0.013411891646683216, 0.026903152465820312, -0.019974345341324806, -0.03388829156756401, 0.03307196497917175, 0.015372891910374165, -0.010297616012394428, 0.03030325099825859, -0.04457218945026398, 0.016430994495749474, 0.0066896118223667145, -0.024777911603450775, 0.027005517855286598, 0.03439973667263985, 0.02375020831823349, -0.00004953706229571253, 0.005711802747100592, -0.016330014914274216, -0.053369611501693726, -0.0355721041560173, -0.00014808472769800574, 0.008320714347064495, 0.015035462565720081, -0.010317515581846237, -0.00824717991054058, 0.0409712940454483, 0.021064579486846924, -0.013876406475901604, -0.05785677209496498, 0.011935940012335777, -0.026244964450597763, -0.014215972274541855, 0.03599752485752106, -0.003729395102709532, 0.015516436658799648, 0.0311223566532135, -0.02324204333126545, 0.03163169324398041, 0.04450797662138939, -0.028567442670464516, 0.0014404784888029099, 0.04133319854736328, -0.03620929270982742, -0.0316246896982193, 0.03301510959863663, 0.017827730625867844, 0.004778499249368906, 0.031106851994991302, -0.028342396020889282, -0.0022903813514858484, -0.007973902858793736, -0.0522717721760273, 0.01761350780725479, -0.004193021450191736, 0.053875867277383804, -0.060144707560539246, 0.021293995901942253, 0.019817030057311058, -0.025628522038459778, -0.015169092454016209, 0.014818741008639336, 0.062244486063718796, -0.03267626091837883, -0.03620529919862747, 0.014476443640887737, -0.01602734625339508, -0.013880212791264057, 0.0401066392660141, 0.0026102031115442514, 0.028853313997387886, 0.037677790969610214, -0.06084224209189415, -0.009886092506349087, 0.06430518627166748, 0.030386270955204964, 0.029938917607069016, 0.027234859764575958, -0.013366994448006153, 0.03686852753162384, -0.01813017576932907, 0.03571289777755737, -0.04135866463184357, 0.01597408391535282, 0.02395719103515148, 0.07575690746307373, 0.002819999121129513, 0.02835226058959961, 0.009720467031002045, -0.0329693965613842, -0.06518688797950745, 0.008859806694090366, 0.018487021327018738, 0.006237564608454704, 0.006052173208445311, -0.04955803230404854, 0.04697131738066673, -0.034206900745630264, 0.02548481710255146, 0.004213529638946056, 0.012060534209012985, -0.05004970356822014, 0.04001079499721527, -0.033378757536411285, 0.018825728446245193, -0.04359026253223419, 0.009838996455073357, 0.0767536461353302, -0.011734548024833202, 0.0617978535592556, 0.018517734482884407, -0.036033760756254196, 0.042962100356817245, -0.01747625134885311, 0.007842025719583035, 0.05718517675995827, 0.027296988293528557, 0.011367123574018478, 0.010251123458147049, -0.020189715549349785, -0.003963124006986618, -0.010046729817986488, 0.05192165821790695, 0.03295460715889931, -0.029616137966513634, -0.014956232160329819, -0.029752688482403755, 0.0070760841481387615, -0.029040684923529625, 0.03808186948299408, -0.016003690659999847, 0.03919188305735588, 0.04603424295783043, 0.020908253267407417, -0.017997603863477707, 0.01746213249862194, 0.04775170236825943, 0.0174593273550272, 0.002244981937110424, -0.04371551051735878, 0.004763573408126831, 0.005032375454902649, 0.009010524488985538, 0.021883640438318253, -0.020761869847774506, -0.05615942180156708, -0.013372222892940044, 0.039710234850645065, -0.03446831554174423, -0.03001256100833416, 0.03611554577946663, 0.009279659017920494, 0.019472526386380196, -0.024117082357406616, -0.007426921743899584, -0.01591094583272934, 0.044597845524549484, 0.008509534411132336, 0.0007732219528406858, -0.04767799749970436, -0.08393842726945877, -0.022255415096879005, 0.036197733134031296, 0.029993150383234024, -0.020417261868715286, -0.02457490749657154, -0.05616939440369606, -0.00845318753272295, 0.0027522677555680275, -0.038576509803533554, 0.039038706570863724, -0.006353521719574928, 0.015975309535861015, -0.02828037366271019, -0.014731742441654205, -0.03976599872112274, 0.009210622869431973, -0.06444306671619415, 0.01567576266825199, -0.0016621031099930406, -0.05310489609837532, -0.026401957497000694, 0.0010992838069796562, -0.015298640355467796, 0.030960917472839355, -0.0577063262462616, -0.023132141679525375, 0.028133373707532883, 0.0007311204099096358, 0.022531021386384964, -0.03899770975112915, 0.026113780215382576, 0.018373457714915276, -0.007622024044394493, 0.0733906552195549, -0.005907190963625908, -0.017900317907333374, 0.03152300789952278, -0.005463972222059965, 0.04035840183496475, 0.006463195662945509, -0.002451548120006919, 0.0544394813477993, 0.06656087934970856, -0.04571506753563881, 0.0338364914059639, 0.01944490149617195, 0.005195216741412878, -0.008841625414788723, -0.028656713664531708, 0.012857035733759403, -0.007771675940603018, 0.005782335996627808, -0.06037626042962074, 0.025647467002272606, 0.0053017521277070045, 0.02855050191283226, -0.0023915411438792944, 0.032152943313121796, -0.019366802647709846, -0.04030898958444595, -0.004862693604081869, 0.049326952546834946, -0.02731516771018505, -0.022077197209000587, 0.02984844520688057, 0.025257671251893044, -0.016198471188545227, -0.01445077359676361, 0.013854717835783958, -0.03617766126990318, -0.008928235620260239, 0.04253576695919037, -0.027686545625329018, -0.03107624128460884, -0.022179480642080307, -0.014766269363462925, 0.02302173711359501, -0.06087817624211311, 0.030767591670155525, 0.010024969466030598, 0.027970226481556892, 0.026916667819023132, -0.040728867053985596, -0.029436688870191574, 0.023400085046887398, -0.02977946028113365, 0.020165884867310524, -0.0013121434021741152, 0.0037022330798208714, -0.015465113334357738, 0.032061416655778885, -0.00545225664973259, -0.0548071451485157, -0.010580731555819511, -0.01859004609286785, -0.035058218985795975, 0.0021316686179488897, -0.054015420377254486, 0.03179413080215454, 0.02550583705306053, 0.004041111096739769, 0.004879507701843977, -0.03137270733714104, 0.022011730819940567, 0.00073444057488814, -0.008012784644961357, 0.07649824768304825, -0.044559694826602936, -0.01613548956811428, 0.026925737038254738, -0.021974408999085426, -0.005877132061868906, 0.043997280299663544, 0.01580577716231346, -0.03998206555843353, 0.014769972302019596, -0.01874336414039135, 0.027460234239697456, 0.04887356236577034, 0.0049441601149737835, 0.008914605714380741, -0.0040398393757641315, 0.010036451742053032, -0.01465644035488367, -0.061159294098615646, -0.0040499488823115826, -0.01411212794482708, -0.006620652973651886, -0.020502766594290733, -0.013866111636161804, -0.001075646374374628, -0.02538493275642395, 0.017895594239234924, 0.0004787640646100044, 0.010305510833859444, 0.05463004857301712, 0.06840348988771439, -0.011402891017496586, 0.030797617509961128, -0.014080082066357136, -0.03493531048297882, 0.004966954234987497, 0.047121014446020126, -0.002999400720000267, 0.02389042265713215, 0.029737690463662148, -0.04330085590481758, -0.005504973698407412, -0.043241385370492935, 0.04391837492585182, 0.060988299548625946, 0.009665955789387226, 0.036759305745363235, 0.03550103306770325, -0.01952427625656128, -0.003963305149227381, -0.019151123240590096, 0.00651955883949995, -0.0014271150575950742, 0.006562061607837677, 0.049505095928907394, -0.04390040040016174, -0.03938055410981178, 0.029653718695044518, 0.04506925866007805, 0.033524807542562485, 0.021722951903939247, 0.009914327412843704, -0.021304000169038773, 0.03496256098151207, -0.022818032652139664, -0.03517654910683632, 0.04800903797149658, 0.015508641488850117, 0.03820604085922241, -0.009827191941440105, -0.02336980029940605, 0.05700556933879852, 0.016844263300299644, -0.00533309206366539, -0.05844565108418465, 0.0023928426671773195, -0.04691675305366516, -0.04993204027414322, 0.022718455642461777, -0.03825419396162033, -0.015086990781128407, 0.035563766956329346, 0.04740731045603752, 0.0029617028776556253, 0.015100788325071335, -0.024765312671661377, -0.05014769360423088, -0.035481296479701996, -0.013211388140916824, -0.0264588575810194, 0.02910866215825081, 0.01446516439318657, -0.025851787999272346, 0.006622626446187496, -0.07345703989267349, 0.012222256511449814, 0.017409788444638252, 0.037298738956451416, 0.00004635770892491564, 0.057576365768909454, -0.03033328428864479, 0.008465810678899288, -0.00479073915630579, -0.039608899503946304, 0.12604179978370667, 0.07497883588075638, 0.029779525473713875, -0.05108538269996643, -0.015043621882796288, 0.010219802148640156, -0.024601534008979797, -0.02288099378347397, 0.0005846620770171285, 0.027972517535090446, 0.017483308911323547, 0.025163959711790085, 0.033636223524808884, -0.006404566112905741, 0.0407058522105217, 0.03369123861193657, -0.03104451671242714, -0.03909016773104668, -0.026292094960808754, 0.011152753606438637, -0.010187086649239063, -0.013611403293907642, -0.0803769901394844, 0.0004447203828021884, 0.025462528690695763, -0.027502598240971565, 0.008699177764356136, -0.012710358016192913, 0.01635415107011795, 0.0361827127635479, -0.009465237148106098, -0.01545113604515791, 0.02645265869796276, -0.005785566288977861, -0.007342511788010597, 0.026793235912919044, 0.0051496028900146484, -0.01316698919981718, 0.04547926038503647, 0.02762685902416706, -0.02024676837027073, 0.028442667797207832, -0.03851788863539696, -0.0073065184988081455, -0.0063486648723483086, -0.039119306951761246, -0.022422632202506065, 0.024634217843413353, -0.0019812029786407948, -0.031104879453778267, -0.014205834828317165, 0.023109467700123787, 0.03818898648023605, -0.07592233270406723, 0.010097783990204334, 0.03270428627729416, 0.014308887533843517, 0.025671780109405518, 0.02210734225809574, -0.0025363380555063486, -0.008043539710342884, -0.020955469459295273, 0.03593144193291664, 0.0349554568529129, 0.0034430157393217087, -0.011023161932826042, -0.060368314385414124, 0.05557164177298546, -0.007491950877010822, 0.027144813910126686, 0.009315126575529575, 0.0035550673492252827, -0.01853354461491108, -0.032629940658807755, 0.012742179445922375, 0.014896259643137455, 0.01081685721874237, 0.012659150175750256, -0.0341544970870018, -0.02885127067565918, -0.022602902725338936, -0.017889006063342094, -0.016850968822836876, -0.03661636263132095, -0.016959063708782196, 0.011064398102462292, 0.03973095491528511, 0.028992922976613045, 0.03928789123892784, 0.012817817740142345, -0.013241568580269814, 0.039176054298877716, -0.00042270164703950286, -0.048792965710163116, -0.07948083430528641, 0.04010222852230072, -0.014368953183293343, -0.031892240047454834, 0.010415718890726566, 0.045762788504362106, 0.034303516149520874, -0.009479841217398643, -0.020294688642024994, 0.007350926753133535, -0.008043310604989529, -0.035761479288339615, 0.024517936632037163, -0.044595181941986084, 0.05708790943026543, -0.0294859129935503, -0.03659335896372795, -0.07920918613672256, 0.00806612242013216, -0.03770620375871658, -0.05270012840628624, -0.023241564631462097, -0.020838122814893723, 0.007740001659840345, -0.025386538356542587, -0.0009829268092289567, 0.022657420486211777, -0.01644383929669857, -0.029310638085007668, -0.0035391345154494047, 0.004625970963388681, -0.012546448968350887, -0.008272423408925533, -0.036573756486177444, 0.03716491535305977, -0.045411787927150726, 0.02729450725018978, 0.0018247186671942472, 0.004296211060136557, -0.020120909437537193, -0.00008406947017647326, 0.016997864469885826, 0.024667711928486824, 0.039535798132419586, -0.02046588994562626, 0.020885977894067764, 0.0016561915399506688, -0.01929195411503315, -0.0415722131729126, 0.00016077941108960658, -0.003003013087436557, 0.03364730626344681, -0.025885017588734627, -0.008078721351921558, -0.05248898267745972, 0.04833141341805458, -0.01870574802160263, -0.0070934779942035675, -0.008347069844603539, -0.027397161349654198, 0.012396818026900291, -0.001602895325049758, -0.018681880086660385, -0.021821821108460426, 0.06726367771625519, 0.023984836414456367, 0.012423468753695488, -0.00791396014392376, -0.059350643306970596, -0.008357280865311623, -0.03967714682221413, 0.02224138379096985, 0.016747910529375076, -0.0428340807557106, 0.04293567314743996, 0.03534916043281555, -0.004391855094581842, 0.02513808198273182, -0.00937019381672144, 0.0060622417367994785, -0.08208147436380386, -0.025563234463334084, -0.01784416474401951, -0.0242465790361166, 0.03538772463798523, -0.04587549343705177, 0.02799001708626747, 0.004907229915261269, -0.049550801515579224, 0.01304721087217331, 0.008847713470458984, 0.00563813466578722, -0.012991746887564659, 0.049353815615177155, -0.014817583374679089, 0.03816837817430496, 0.07323478907346725, -0.009749720804393291, 0.07729664444923401, 0.019342487677931786, -0.02478613331913948, -0.028834974393248558, -0.026610225439071655, 0.04086824506521225, 0.00024983304319903255, -0.06009624898433685, 0.03354723006486893, -0.023020636290311813, 0.014934689737856388, 0.01747499592602253, -0.0037401856388896704, 0.015249053947627544, 0.005354768130928278, -0.004245138261467218, 0.026920044794678688, 0.046736788004636765, 0.010162359103560448, 0.020844219252467155, 0.021649478003382683, 0.004460478201508522, 0.025100715458393097, -0.0037716974038630724, 0.0038936277851462364, 0.029979584738612175, -0.0022816387936472893, 0.017718348652124405, 0.004361009690910578, 0.011277277022600174, -0.038530133664608, -0.03945523127913475, 0.0011281924089416862, 0.0022872877307236195, -0.03424122557044029, -0.03579016029834747, -0.010273232124745846, -0.050798386335372925, -0.02124973013997078, 0.05723121017217636, 0.0011004519183188677, 0.009381918236613274, 0.017193274572491646, 0.004367159213870764, -0.05298386514186859, 0.008421624079346657, 0.022927256301045418, -0.011349190957844257, -0.07571239769458771, -0.00804656371474266, 0.006127320230007172, -0.01713993400335312, 0.017102988436818123, 0.009660519659519196, -0.004937555640935898, 0.021274467930197716, 0.0035218405537307262, -0.0017423108220100403, 0.007357755675911903, -0.03022039867937565, 0.03227391839027405, -0.09721162915229797, 0.06795665621757507, 0.001487702364102006, -0.02842739038169384, -0.026318583637475967, -0.02961069718003273, -0.028490988537669182, 0.035027988255023956, 0.022790811955928802, 0.034611232578754425, -0.004510161001235247, -0.003309059189632535, 0.01961294375360012, 0.019023995846509933, -0.05665167421102524, 0.03199487179517746, 0.008142228238284588, -0.011214747093617916, 0.02292460948228836, 0.00045595390838570893, 0.02201719954609871, 0.020777978003025055, 0.03756662830710411, 0.02022824063897133, -0.0059295762330293655, 0.006565657444298267, -0.03577056899666786, -0.015756601467728615, -0.01842048391699791, -0.0316736064851284, 0.057540636509656906, 0.002677367767319083, -0.00923268124461174, 0.03100532852113247, -0.004436905030161142, -0.010309681296348572, -0.0006471814122051001, -0.04104413837194443, -0.007345378864556551, 0.016965651884675026, -0.027236662805080414, 0.039605703204870224, -0.08898697048425674, 0.010325822047889233, 0.003011074848473072, -0.03875235468149185, -0.016858728602528572, 0.06140012666583061, 0.009680158458650112, 0.022977259010076523, -0.015509415417909622, 0.0116285914555192, 0.01042040903121233, -0.034268759191036224, 0.03128589317202568, 0.007577876560389996, 0.015776706859469414, 0.0009260679362341762, -0.009522541426122189, 0.013465063646435738, -0.03898480162024498, 0.0376678891479969, -0.0032702002208679914, 0.06419751048088074, -0.03772590309381485, 0.00971181970089674, 0.01407181192189455, -0.0320940800011158, -0.022812340408563614, -0.01813386380672455, -0.005799851380288601, 0.05141811817884445, -0.03344471752643585, 0.0003372924984432757, 0.02016931213438511, -0.012945973314344883, -0.025385025888681412, 0.045025382190942764, -0.003109700744971633, 0.011498621664941311, 0.00765801128000021, 0.05573134496808052, -0.013958298601210117, 0.00007880106568336487, 0.0019277273677289486, -0.005993231665343046, -0.012150418013334274, 0.012101453728973866, 0.03017704375088215, 0.03783850371837616, -0.00218574539758265, -0.017030805349349976, -0.038488879799842834, 0.007423984818160534, -0.018579280003905296, -0.011648484505712986, -0.05851608142256737, -0.0033851151820272207, -0.01000035461038351, -0.019889235496520996, -0.0783897265791893, -0.00926251895725727, -0.013765000738203526, 0.018463127315044403, 0.02138359658420086, 0.009781897068023682 ]
<p>I am conducting an ordinal logistic regression. I have an ordinal variable, let's call it Change, that expresses the change in a biological parameter between two time points 5 years apart. Its values are 0 (no change), 1 (small change), 2 (large change).</p> <p>I have several other variables (VarA, VarB, VarC, VarD) measured between the two time points. My intention is to perform an ordinal logistic regression to assess whether the entity of Change is more strongly associated with VarA or VarB. I'm really interested only in VarA and VarB, and I'm not trying to create a model. VarC and VarD are variables that I know <em>may</em> affect Change, but probably not very much, and in any case I'm not interested in them. I just want to know if the association in the period of observation (5 years) was stroger for VarA or for VarB.</p> <p>Would it be wrong to not include VarC and VarD in the regression?</p>
74,139
[ -0.025784559547901154, 0.0009335767826996744, -0.02280340902507305, 0.036243878304958344, 0.015607818029820919, 0.021428197622299194, -0.007205361500382423, -0.01817302033305168, 0.04640806093811989, -0.04159882664680481, 0.025180235505104065, 0.004511732142418623, 0.02722005546092987, -0.02149379439651966, 0.014823264442384243, -0.008864268660545349, -0.008205834776163101, -0.0036000884138047695, -0.014847399666905403, 0.00020812053116969764, -0.0363970547914505, -0.005858191754668951, 0.037498362362384796, 0.028905656188726425, -0.009652324952185154, 0.07188756763935089, 0.021430738270282745, -0.025856509804725647, 0.002566760405898094, 0.03200153261423111, -0.031322672963142395, -0.01164404209703207, 0.025238756090402603, 0.03797018527984619, 0.027442872524261475, 0.016179019585251808, -0.009697318077087402, -0.002377939410507679, -0.013799970038235188, 0.027457771822810173, -0.009969089180231094, -0.05263758823275566, -0.01685173064470291, 0.019204620271921158, -0.033222343772649765, -0.009187554940581322, 0.014964000321924686, -0.020332777872681618, 0.050859130918979645, 0.004527851473540068, 0.06004258617758751, -0.033525291830301285, 0.04149806499481201, 0.03962734714150429, -0.021024856716394424, 0.00364636885933578, 0.023843983188271523, 0.04163157194852829, 0.0025479968171566725, -0.03864686191082001, -0.007961595430970192, -0.02662019245326519, -0.019860180094838142, 0.018976159393787384, -0.0442647710442543, 0.03743009641766548, 0.013339485973119736, -0.017838602885603905, 0.053923994302749634, -0.011843467131257057, 0.03152821958065033, -0.0028915435541421175, 0.059033870697021484, -0.015798306092619896, 0.012799236923456192, -0.040578071027994156, 0.004035079386085272, 0.027260469272732735, 0.03728272020816803, 0.044196758419275284, -0.0023263271432369947, 0.01987483538687229, 0.06641307473182678, 0.026182377710938454, 0.01194455660879612, -0.015499488450586796, 0.03522707149386406, -0.033773619681596756, 0.006349621806293726, 0.05207201465964317, -0.005969428922981024, -0.00903391931205988, 0.0488378144800663, 0.021708253771066666, -0.040215425193309784, 0.023825351148843765, -0.04729270562529564, 0.020144127309322357, 0.02435583434998989, 0.021530847996473312, -0.013254291377961636, -0.029545743018388748, 0.03117498755455017, 0.04791707918047905, -0.03405554220080376, -0.03036019206047058, -0.032354410737752914, -0.03540809080004692, -0.0025774906389415264, -0.0580727681517601, -0.013407428748905659, -0.0021336462814360857, 0.023318417370319366, -0.0011044794227927923, 0.033100832253694534, -0.0016651771729812026, -0.01183005515486002, -0.0017825320828706026, 0.06133745610713959, 0.05149662494659424, 0.04870337247848511, -0.02722197026014328, 0.03970009833574295, -0.013876956887543201, -0.022947199642658234, 0.008494049310684204, 0.03524761274456978, -0.017086874693632126, -0.03536528721451759, 0.061482466757297516, 0.010073302313685417, -0.015001226216554642, 0.0568130724132061, -0.011524328030645847, 0.038398563861846924, 0.012249498628079891, -0.05907415971159935, -0.032434623688459396, -0.002431887201964855, 0.0185242872685194, 0.022216644138097763, -0.05948706716299057, -0.007693979423493147, 0.007975089363753796, 0.03624733164906502, 0.029581263661384583, 0.022437909618020058, 0.026979554444551468, 0.0016180219827219844, 0.0351368710398674, -0.014191648922860622, -0.03403999283909798, -0.007756049279123545, -0.049056895077228546, 0.004185465630143881, -0.08967839181423187, 0.003662983188405633, 0.02931855246424675, -0.016929257661104202, 0.002020413288846612, 0.043376561254262924, 0.0063629127107560635, -0.01949220709502697, -0.03028031252324581, 0.02384202741086483, -0.00696561299264431, 0.08063613623380661, -0.049088265746831894, 0.01841401495039463, -0.003032623790204525, 0.03344329074025154, 0.038128845393657684, 0.024618593975901604, 0.05973539128899574, 0.07032416760921478, 0.015537525527179241, -0.0026132329367101192, -0.015375801362097263, -0.006707067135721445, 0.0166789498180151, -0.032726019620895386, -0.015995746478438377, -0.04458300769329071, -0.024933991953730583, 0.0035952934995293617, 0.0530136413872242, 0.011012258008122444, 0.0031901048496365547, -0.0058852084912359715, -0.039543189108371735, -0.06175444275140762, -0.0475318469107151, -0.005428608972579241, 0.014136179350316525, -0.011653888039290905, 0.03067464381456375, -0.018413793295621872, 0.04252171516418457, -0.010442239232361317, 0.036110978573560715, -0.04185514152050018, -0.009794284589588642, 0.03032657317817211, -0.05334756150841713, 0.017413785681128502, 0.042920708656311035, 0.05826645344495773, -0.02352099120616913, 0.012651942670345306, -0.06324855238199234, -0.039292141795158386, 0.030334392562508583, 0.008814873173832893, 0.00010622474655974656, -0.015743060037493706, -0.006652633659541607, -0.0001226953900186345, -0.0063931578770279884, -0.04636067897081375, 0.03212563693523407, -0.0776786133646965, 0.08309183269739151, 0.01734132505953312, -0.02873561903834343, -0.009535083547234535, 0.017900308594107628, 0.0231019239872694, 0.011363999918103218, -0.022898292168974876, 0.0013473668368533254, -0.021297140046954155, 0.008166962303221226, 0.030491698533296585, 0.043404243886470795, -0.022101666778326035, 0.033060964196920395, 0.055549491196870804, 0.03215562924742699, -0.026581747457385063, 0.03567763790488243, 0.028527118265628815, -0.02734886296093464, 0.009093721397221088, 0.020369593054056168, 0.014977367594838142, 0.03089267946779728, 0.026297874748706818, -0.010806415230035782, 0.0740671157836914, 0.0012695839395746589, -0.0014753768919035792, 0.01764603704214096, 0.011975555680692196, 0.007063242606818676, -0.01966167613863945, 0.024574415758252144, 0.05475825071334839, -0.010024075396358967, 0.006447594612836838, 0.028504062443971634, 0.015602590516209602, -0.017146214842796326, 0.005993349477648735, -0.006747349631041288, 0.01660655066370964, 0.05611623823642731, -0.08076129853725433, 0.037882961332798004, 0.004295256920158863, -0.03812814876437187, 0.0075982906855642796, -0.024188002571463585, -0.024952221661806107, -0.04996785894036293, -0.01814909838140011, 0.005811433307826519, 0.002127825515344739, 0.028316998854279518, -0.011587034910917282, -0.029687656089663506, -0.02182837948203087, -0.03481866419315338, 0.020614227280020714, -0.021039113402366638, -0.03955917805433273, 0.0038244749885052443, -0.009663269855082035, -0.008936988189816475, 0.03406957909464836, -0.046253081411123276, -0.02525133080780506, 0.047193195670843124, 0.020736239850521088, -0.08459039032459259, -0.02953338250517845, -0.015803851187229156, 0.00428994232788682, 0.015432779677212238, -0.019102793186903, 0.03224478289484978, 0.04414921626448631, -0.019735567271709442, -0.02669576182961464, -0.03080163709819317, -0.01775761879980564, -0.02513565681874752, -0.009459767490625381, 0.0038709782529622316, -0.013182152062654495, 0.015866251662373543, 0.02650652825832367, -0.038723986595869064, -0.005343145690858364, -0.0752553716301918, -0.06599029898643494, 0.0338447205722332, 0.009404510259628296, 0.03334010764956474, -0.023572871461510658, -0.011555006727576256, 0.05101340636610985, 0.03159330412745476, -0.029256677255034447, -0.057846829295158386, 0.003822955535724759, -0.033477358520030975, 0.00201057898811996, 0.01329740695655346, 0.014891243539750576, 0.02756706438958645, 0.02374018356204033, 0.0028180896770209074, 0.017014706507325172, 0.02513434737920761, 0.009394765831530094, 0.0027518749702721834, 0.03223450109362602, 0.048823315650224686, -0.02252369374036789, 0.034435756504535675, 0.029164589941501617, -0.0024334280751645565, 0.02906973659992218, -0.02054767496883869, 0.003258265322074294, 0.019460465759038925, -0.03635822609066963, 0.01616659015417099, -0.011107605881989002, 0.010195691138505936, -0.020530259236693382, 0.01292439829558134, 0.03883006051182747, 0.005044931545853615, -0.01192457601428032, -0.001813323120586574, 0.014379896223545074, -0.012488366104662418, -0.00513137923553586, 0.0347641296684742, 0.04841139540076256, 0.0004211291379760951, 0.02887803688645363, 0.007545386906713247, -0.00966134574264288, 0.01819106563925743, -0.04117339104413986, -0.02104858122766018, 0.02443777769804001, 0.04422137141227722, 0.020547114312648773, -0.017836572602391243, -0.07160141319036484, 0.02553631365299225, -0.03921811282634735, -0.0001572945184307173, 0.016536381095647812, 0.028874596580863, -0.009411417879164219, 0.04451066628098488, -0.008617803454399109, -0.022281428799033165, 0.015511958859860897, -0.003155688289552927, -0.09638170897960663, 0.013947244733572006, -0.02607576921582222, -0.005594378802925348, 0.0005725820665247738, -0.02546944096684456, 0.01655159704387188, -0.00775514030829072, 0.0013824132038280368, -0.011230484582483768, -0.004890640266239643, -0.007701238617300987, -0.01753273233771324, -0.03455817699432373, -0.00695402966812253, -0.0039189825765788555, -0.01799275353550911, 0.005050808656960726, -0.02312556840479374, 0.04016681760549545, 0.044780101627111435, 0.03306446969509125, -0.03823907673358917, -0.02474525384604931, -0.007225546520203352, 0.04317069798707962, 0.031219033524394035, 0.02494417503476143, 0.026696249842643738, -0.06055304780602455, 0.08152329921722412, -0.010636699385941029, 0.0264078751206398, 0.03319961950182915, -0.0004285271279513836, -0.015181687660515308, -0.013538822531700134, -0.04697570204734802, -0.00007392053521471098, 0.011611741967499256, 0.03665486350655556, -0.0002038468956016004, 0.03746609017252922, 0.02276616543531418, -0.03790322691202164, -0.015827616676688194, 0.08230438083410263, 0.042661357671022415, -0.02172122895717621, -0.013024494983255863, -0.009770778007805347, 0.007623689714819193, -0.04132092744112015, 0.014230138622224331, 0.015422298572957516, -0.02262166701257229, -0.011655408889055252, 0.030560605227947235, -0.015232594683766365, -0.05081063508987427, 0.012945947237312794, 0.016557132825255394, 0.018491780385375023, 0.005406144540756941, -0.037171438336372375, 0.042357783764600754, 0.030047325417399406, 0.018802275881171227, 0.025434216484427452, 0.0466887503862381, -0.09324874728918076, -0.001425050082616508, 0.028717590495944023, 0.08931801468133926, -0.04693366214632988, -0.04940984770655632, -0.0020930240862071514, -0.01589374430477619, 0.05930935591459274, -0.04287537932395935, 0.009530635550618172, -0.0332651287317276, -0.004412117414176464, -0.024181850254535675, -0.06291340291500092, -0.06271727383136749, 0.0021161034237593412, -0.032252874225378036, 0.03629448637366295, 0.017772044986486435, -0.041110143065452576, -0.030347153544425964, 0.007981417700648308, -0.014439462684094906, 0.06748297065496445, -0.05007537454366684, -0.0022439644671976566, 0.028986511752009392, 0.03271551802754402, 0.003288910025730729, -0.058942779898643494, 0.02705487236380577, -0.004291715566068888, -0.019483936950564384, 0.05352039635181427, 0.020906543359160423, -0.03364242985844612, 0.015941645950078964, 0.026686448603868484, -0.016718631610274315, 0.012910465709865093, -0.03150855377316475, 0.04964981600642204, 0.002989905420690775, -0.013299531303346157, 0.05603529140353203, 0.0723339095711708, 0.008476640097796917, 0.022970974445343018, -0.06932076066732407, 0.0011438603978604078, -0.022456074133515358, -0.0226040780544281, -0.028146589174866676, -0.017857611179351807, -0.013067715801298618, 0.01759691722691059, -0.0282646082341671, 0.022594455629587173, -0.020397068932652473, -0.005992359481751919, 0.0011725006625056267, 0.0549771785736084, -0.019188031554222107, -0.01989494450390339, -0.003197479760274291, 0.0127234673127532, -0.017045367509126663, -0.002739499555900693, 0.008576221764087677, -0.024628134444355965, -0.006455404218286276, -0.008035654202103615, -0.023338522762060165, -0.02785680815577507, -0.010898108594119549, -0.038713935762643814, -0.021890735253691673, -0.037181299179792404, 0.046061474829912186, 0.008510453626513481, 0.012356054969131947, 0.0018014564411714673, -0.03082074224948883, -0.006382826715707779, 0.017156844958662987, 0.011005260981619358, 0.026388684287667274, -0.05744081735610962, 0.03240261226892471, -0.009528555907309055, 0.007794979494065046, -0.06345849484205246, -0.07872878760099411, 0.031274959444999695, 0.003749340306967497, -0.021896308287978172, -0.010993040166795254, 0.031394846737384796, -0.024102581664919853, -0.021374966949224472, -0.023460619151592255, 0.07509447634220123, -0.019113928079605103, 0.012865778990089893, -0.008807491511106491, 0.009944375604391098, 0.05509767681360245, 0.01079681795090437, -0.020009741187095642, -0.01668219454586506, -0.04218574985861778, 0.02137826569378376, 0.025176767259836197, 0.01255884487181902, -0.027045587077736855, -0.036497194319963455, -0.01853802055120468, -0.0071527850814163685, 0.032473135739564896, -0.034152496606111526, -0.02927972376346588, 0.0243510864675045, -0.03046705201268196, 0.019356416538357735, -0.02424674481153488, -0.008610449731349945, -0.011737335473299026, 0.00904353428632021, -0.010823729448020458, 0.03280048072338104, 0.016793102025985718, -0.020287206396460533, 0.037602320313453674, 0.04505012556910515, -0.007820731960237026, 0.026240115985274315, 0.07380799949169159, 0.0005665971548296511, 0.007055450230836868, 0.011450957506895065, -0.020095137879252434, 0.06859099864959717, -0.015568749979138374, -0.03548479825258255, -0.023678334429860115, 0.03719228878617287, -0.06425023823976517, -0.029898621141910553, -0.025299711152911186, -0.017833193764090538, 0.06220628693699837, 0.03242017701268196, 0.041326940059661865, 0.03645338863134384, -0.030417505651712418, 0.006207763683050871, -0.03170816972851753, -0.003096851985901594, -0.0034881141036748886, -0.03504383936524391, 0.041773807257413864, -0.029928341507911682, 0.012574187479913235, 0.021995607763528824, 0.023918913677334785, -0.013886399567127228, 0.05588093027472496, 0.02253435179591179, 0.006128021981567144, 0.0347057580947876, -0.02758350595831871, -0.055680111050605774, -0.00976786483079195, -0.050587497651576996, 0.04053797200322151, -0.05249825492501259, -0.035806190222501755, 0.0360657162964344, 0.02384079620242119, -0.0007123508839868009, -0.09830614179372787, -0.03612186387181282, -0.07727789878845215, -0.00034373963717371225, 0.003818390192463994, -0.0056276991963386536, 0.05427655577659607, -0.013460375368595123, 0.04981633275747299, 0.01524089090526104, -0.02154337242245674, -0.026510439813137054, -0.08509840071201324, 0.00255896570160985, 0.010518623515963554, -0.037995364516973495, 0.020373133942484856, -0.012369709089398384, -0.013798099011182785, -0.02250252105295658, -0.01763232983648777, -0.02901970036327839, 0.005857137497514486, 0.02557551860809326, -0.002779478905722499, 0.08354521542787552, -0.009439943358302116, -0.0011024726554751396, 0.019819054752588272, 0.0076081594452261925, 0.14506877958774567, 0.07189089804887772, 0.02240038849413395, -0.032690826803445816, 0.05521158128976822, 0.0007999863009899855, 0.01117493025958538, -0.005633355583995581, -0.013098030351102352, -0.003933734260499477, -0.04677155986428261, 0.029355166479945183, 0.006342800334095955, 0.01420189905911684, -0.02921782247722149, 0.08201538026332855, -0.026091553270816803, -0.02199244312942028, 0.03680753707885742, -0.012490685097873211, 0.013266992755234241, 0.027221105992794037, -0.010952191427350044, -0.00012304972915444523, -0.0116904117166996, 0.002328583039343357, -0.003967271652072668, -0.011240276508033276, 0.0060853236354887486, 0.01487575750797987, -0.023074669763445854, 0.014077708125114441, 0.049421411007642746, 0.0286727175116539, -0.052845194935798645, -0.007016554940491915, -0.018221816048026085, -0.03200666233897209, 0.025500964373350143, 0.004383537918329239, -0.030476348474621773, -0.029232049360871315, 0.015532471239566803, 0.001991511322557926, -0.05397924408316612, -0.03848247602581978, -0.05318799614906311, 0.03857797384262085, 0.005171716678887606, 0.01351090706884861, -0.0202266164124012, 0.004108276683837175, 0.01656413823366165, -0.06769789755344391, -0.04026803746819496, 0.027863560244441032, 0.04178920015692711, -0.011817045509815216, -0.011954772286117077, 0.0021557891741394997, 0.005708705168217421, 0.012429863214492798, 0.038593046367168427, 0.029406297951936722, -0.02015318162739277, -0.013631667010486126, -0.024948352947831154, 0.03542649745941162, -0.014042655006051064, 0.041828930377960205, 0.02320188470184803, -0.01985434629023075, -0.03375190123915672, 0.008620649576187134, 0.00009470138320466504, -0.00603644410148263, 0.02966461330652237, -0.02491670660674572, -0.03404982015490532, -0.0219946950674057, -0.04363381490111351, 0.01276919525116682, 0.025008756667375565, -0.029316799715161324, -0.05485942214727402, 0.036052219569683075, 0.020588230341672897, 0.01837560161948204, -0.0038662508595734835, 0.04022473841905594, -0.011975315399467945, 0.06792176514863968, -0.004158318508416414, -0.046926043927669525, -0.025720056146383286, -0.00504143163561821, -0.020866068080067635, -0.02573593333363533, 0.0000692675675963983, 0.05417146906256676, 0.009110610000789165, -0.0038473529275506735, 0.012819396331906319, 0.02788139320909977, 0.0031898554880172014, 0.03613036498427391, 0.04238814115524292, -0.02669755183160305, 0.007664881646633148, -0.010075539350509644, -0.002514461986720562, 0.017883826047182083, -0.027633976191282272, -0.05564766749739647, -0.014188851229846478, 0.009966472163796425, -0.04088352993130684, -0.023629598319530487, 0.020784439519047737, -0.046061597764492035, 0.01729382947087288, -0.018728626891970634, -0.026678942143917084, -0.038529928773641586, 0.006732395384460688, 0.01450340449810028, 0.010452690534293652, 0.012121733278036118, 0.05583597719669342, -0.019637804478406906, 0.0362054817378521, 0.032807715237140656, 0.02731468714773655, -0.015472165308892727, -0.02595180831849575, 0.01572992652654648, -0.019775433465838432, 0.048296764492988586, -0.034873735159635544, -0.022391991689801216, 0.004442764446139336, -0.019323386251926422, -0.008133143186569214, 0.06493263691663742, -0.015269777737557888, 0.007808254100382328, 0.00024187656526919454, 0.007710347883403301, 0.00786577071994543, 0.03925338387489319, 0.0009793756762519479, -0.020469507202506065, -0.04216933622956276, 0.0037681646645069122, -0.0075658168643713, -0.008977331221103668, -0.027506941929459572, 0.04229354485869408, -0.015013957396149635, 0.015694361180067062, 0.028948746621608734, 0.0010970111470669508, -0.002380558755248785, 0.02003662846982479, 0.028496673330664635, 0.004401036072522402, -0.007245756685733795, -0.015314221382141113, 0.032040927559137344, 0.0787108913064003, -0.03558242693543434, 0.030523501336574554, 0.008548656478524208, 0.00942798238247633, -0.07077015191316605, -0.0297755915671587, 0.02042955346405506, 0.031519390642642975, 0.005019315052777529, -0.03296900913119316, 0.015536706894636154, -0.0033461283892393112, -0.030445104464888573, -0.010090439580380917, -0.007393817417323589, -0.0027417561504989862, -0.020410344004631042, -0.009936122223734856, -0.008054415695369244, -0.009246227331459522, 0.035389676690101624, 0.011019772849977016, 0.025341307744383812, 0.0404268316924572, 0.02432308904826641, -0.09472152590751648, -0.024620071053504944, 0.0038250272627919912, 0.012814830988645554, -0.083371601998806, -0.006828154902905226, -0.020969565957784653, -0.02560976892709732, 0.02226193994283676, -0.030827054753899574, 0.03960098326206207, 0.049158066511154175, 0.03479810431599617, -0.010457363910973072, 0.05545032396912575, 0.024566328153014183, -0.04098299518227577, -0.025310609489679337, -0.005229104310274124, 0.014362900517880917, 0.011089708656072617, -0.027427148073911667, 0.027044154703617096, 0.0283929742872715, -0.026036936789751053, 0.0069177234545350075, -0.01746288686990738, -0.03036949783563614, -0.021958520635962486, -0.040249262005090714, -0.0024474826641380787, -0.02350270003080368, 0.0025563628878444433, -0.03722064569592476, -0.036272138357162476, -0.007884299382567406, 0.03889366239309311, 0.02479572780430317, -0.004662616178393364, -0.004138306248933077, 0.035944946110248566, -0.028867222368717194, 0.0014619387220591307, 0.026642153039574623, 0.0035337060689926147, -0.06435971707105637, 0.025746507570147514, -0.034078869968652725, -0.03626067191362381, -0.03962286189198494, 0.012405138462781906, -0.03718939423561096, 0.030745431780815125, -0.012840868905186653, -0.029222765937447548, 0.017728719860315323, -0.001799008110538125, 0.03889076039195061, -0.06917828321456909, 0.08408531546592712, 0.025976529344916344, -0.04965810850262642, -0.04585223272442818, 0.009581766091287136, -0.048185452818870544, 0.021553024649620056, 0.03595412150025368, -0.008294790983200073, -0.008453287184238434, -0.009185192175209522, 0.07323680073022842, -0.0012729173758998513, -0.028396859765052795, 0.024696659296751022, -0.013580264523625374, -0.016699589788913727, -0.018721191212534904, 0.019146500155329704, 0.020476851612329483, 0.00020356691675260663, 0.019953260198235512, -0.023887818679213524, 0.025171970948576927, 0.000040456492570228875, -0.010091503150761127, 0.013892020098865032, 0.006943682208657265, -0.029921457171440125, 0.036055296659469604, 0.005247331224381924, 0.019470486789941788, 0.035224221646785736, -0.008390625938773155, -0.046044040471315384, 0.031415097415447235, -0.034677036106586456, -0.026458339765667915, 0.027321485802531242, 0.04511626809835434, -0.01591251976788044, -0.04042656719684601, 0.01619599387049675, 0.023880522698163986, -0.013981127180159092, 0.011025015264749527, 0.035225577652454376, -0.012380028143525124, 0.04268188402056694, -0.009057576768100262, 0.02437388338148594, 0.009647541679441929, -0.025741955265402794, 0.01396299246698618, -0.009813512675464153, 0.026609009131789207, 0.025269584730267525, 0.025276154279708862, 0.024600565433502197, -0.009991668164730072, 0.022870691493153572, -0.03430476784706116, 0.0406838022172451, -0.02715351991355419, -0.0061769126914441586, 0.007736841682344675, -0.0009609982371330261, 0.016294702887535095, 0.02847393788397312, 0.017710737884044647, 0.007916560396552086, -0.04705129191279411, -0.025663556531071663, -0.03681573644280434, -0.006799216847866774, -0.009999391622841358, -0.018602536991238594, 0.055679868906736374, -0.01370871253311634, 0.02783176675438881, 0.021126149222254753, 0.02539970353245735, -0.018173249438405037, -0.004629890434443951, 0.004709162749350071, 0.01581975445151329, -0.01632101461291313, 0.0066206082701683044, -0.018753033131361008, 0.015092865563929081, -0.03815697878599167, -0.011875675991177559, 0.005971170030534267, 0.03037145547568798, 0.05015021190047264, -0.037358079105615616, 0.005125053226947784, -0.030095485970377922, 0.0018447668990120292, -0.011149224825203419, -0.04811234772205353, -0.04917063191533089, -0.00343477469868958, 0.018647726625204086, -0.03447313979268074 ]
<p>I'm a bit of a novice at maths and am trying to get my head around a problem.</p> <p>I have 3 independent variables which affect 1 dependent variable. I want to create a 4D model which will give me the 4th dimension when I give it an (x, y, z) triplet. </p> <p>I am programming in Java and already have a regression function which will take a set of independent variables and give me coefficients of those independent variables which best fit the data supplied. </p> <p>What I am trying to figure out is which independent variables to use.</p> <p>I have tried various cubic functions, with independent variables something like: {1 + x + y + z + xx + xy + xz + yy + yz + zz + xxx + xxy + xxz + yyy + yyx + yyz + zzz + zzy + zzx + xyz}</p> <p>Then when the resulting model looked a bit wrong I thought, ah maybe the x and y values don't mean anything when multiplied, so took out the variables where x and y were together. Now it still isn't right and I'm worried I'm just going about it in entirely the wrong way. Maybe there's an exponential in there somewhere?</p> <p>Is there some mathematical method to finding exactly which variables I should be using?</p> <p>Cheers!</p> <hr> <p>The data I already have is like this. It's to do with calculating final scores in a cricket game based on which batsmen are in and how far through the game we are, the final score is the dependent variable:</p> <p>X axis ranges from 0 to 10 inclusive (the order of the first batsman in). Y axis ranges from 0 to 10 inclusive (the order of the second batsman in). Z axis ranges from 0 to 19 inclusive (the over we are in, basically means how far through the game we are).</p> <p>The lower x and y are, the higher the final score will be, as the team have better batsmen still in. The higher the over (when x and y are the same), the higher the final score will be, because the batsmen have lasted longer and so should have their eye in.</p> <p>I guess it's "what I expect the dependent variable to be" which is the question. How does each parameter effect the final score. I can post some sample data if you want.</p> <p>I have calculated a data point for each (X, Y, Z) combination, so can't get more. I have data from all the cricket games, and each data point is the average final score of games where this situation has occurred. Some situations ((x, y, z) triples) are far more likely to occur (in more average games) and have been weighted in the regression function accordingly.</p>
37,613
[ -0.021855946630239487, -0.04029678925871849, -0.008330539800226688, 0.021649321541190147, 0.05615435168147087, 0.02457793988287449, -0.010834731161594391, 0.020891986787319183, 0.019391406327486038, -0.02282196469604969, 0.024637650698423386, 0.00119462376460433, 0.07286180555820465, 0.03503817692399025, 0.026478631421923637, 0.004258545581251383, -0.005725943949073553, -0.015376588329672813, 0.02397034876048565, -0.011528096161782742, -0.01665155403316021, -0.0031247022561728954, -0.012707150541245937, 0.031096816062927246, -0.03540954366326332, 0.0795663520693779, 0.04832819476723671, -0.047050878405570984, -0.011698334477841854, 0.056002091616392136, -0.0033232849091291428, -0.06190032139420509, 0.03380204737186432, 0.07060548663139343, 0.06935179233551025, -0.005752875003963709, -0.004205011762678623, -0.05078904330730438, -0.018480977043509483, 0.014759481884539127, -0.007869891822338104, -0.009492384269833565, 0.0008127582841552794, 0.0051360176876187325, 0.007432855200022459, 0.06985954940319061, -0.023683596402406693, 0.00009847639739746228, 0.0787576287984848, -0.030556870624423027, 0.10399261862039566, -0.027636686339974403, 0.01643642969429493, -0.004833634942770004, -0.03363613784313202, -0.013938690535724163, 0.06105085834860802, 0.08130791038274765, 0.04705813527107239, -0.05107959732413292, 0.013565453700721264, -0.03162742033600807, -0.030580993741750717, -0.03778133541345596, -0.015081223100423813, 0.04266540706157684, 0.00637850072234869, -0.004607004579156637, 0.025365188717842102, -0.018650170415639877, -0.00020284997299313545, 0.020857051014900208, 0.03243538737297058, -0.024921461939811707, 0.002518250374123454, -0.0010711865033954382, 0.004801646806299686, 0.0007532126037403941, 0.047461479902267456, 0.01743418537080288, -0.01762228086590767, 0.024766601622104645, 0.0241748858243227, 0.03714469075202942, 0.006207332946360111, 0.018067602068185806, 0.05347808822989464, -0.04415459930896759, 0.026353545486927032, 0.038057804107666016, -0.005680680740624666, 0.028790775686502457, 0.05400636047124863, 0.01400730200111866, -0.014756465330719948, 0.029108885675668716, -0.004350794479250908, 0.038115616887807846, -0.002075954107567668, -0.010890556499361992, -0.020042259246110916, -0.040106359869241714, -0.03275164216756821, 0.047369468957185745, -0.013444258831441402, 0.02753792703151703, -0.0371793694794178, -0.019975824281573296, -0.02461925335228443, -0.0312996506690979, -0.011513927020132542, 0.028569243848323822, -0.006930081639438868, -0.013601263053715229, -0.030972052365541458, -0.031750284135341644, -0.01285588089376688, -0.012407032772898674, 0.05500919371843338, 0.03372764214873314, -0.005268100183457136, -0.04608842357993126, 0.007090788334608078, 0.018468914553523064, -0.06043020263314247, -0.006932367570698261, 0.02356923371553421, 0.017486488446593285, -0.00442677503451705, 0.04536640644073486, 0.026153571903705597, -0.04372791573405266, 0.03287734091281891, 0.016524948179721832, 0.01740213856101036, -0.0008131921640597284, -0.06602746248245239, -0.056906796991825104, 0.039509087800979614, -0.035048797726631165, 0.008138983510434628, -0.039320141077041626, -0.0025747627951204777, 0.03754882887005806, 0.07468901574611664, -0.01617809757590294, 0.06228094547986984, 0.005339795257896185, 0.011055679060518742, 0.029302893206477165, 0.02199588529765606, 0.0006488460348919034, -0.03627612441778183, -0.019160650670528412, 0.0012758264783769846, -0.047253672033548355, 0.022697437554597855, 0.0005175732658244669, -0.01669897325336933, 0.01186106912791729, 0.052938930690288544, 0.027962440624833107, 0.001285673351958394, 0.024061059579253197, -0.026360943913459778, -0.007172487210482359, 0.05842214450240135, -0.003095736261457205, 0.05339861661195755, 0.0004300817381590605, -0.018501069396734238, -0.020971130579710007, 0.007113403640687466, 0.027358969673514366, 0.043275799602270126, 0.030707459896802902, -0.011995780281722546, -0.06855161488056183, 0.007823917083442211, 0.02521110698580742, -0.07980318367481232, -0.04982243850827217, -0.023061957210302353, 0.0013272649375721812, 0.029410265386104584, 0.02163914032280445, 0.023746540769934654, -0.016956884413957596, 0.025712428614497185, -0.042083512991666794, -0.04227357730269432, -0.042168207466602325, 0.04291774705052376, 0.028495779260993004, 0.007970940321683884, 0.0026349022518843412, 0.01824265904724598, 0.051506321877241135, -0.011488355696201324, 0.007444928865879774, -0.011188172735273838, 0.03326326236128807, 0.06518281251192093, -0.018243873491883278, 0.013104255311191082, 0.052535854279994965, 0.05065452307462692, -0.010421336628496647, 0.06469829380512238, -0.02329411543905735, -0.01869300752878189, 0.004546706564724445, -0.012760370038449764, 0.008937297388911247, -0.03101588599383831, -0.01385575532913208, 0.0003518504381645471, -0.004749337211251259, -0.029906509444117546, -0.002262364374473691, -0.03217431902885437, 0.06038151681423187, 0.07083796709775925, 0.0036498382687568665, -0.005915807094424963, -0.007511095609515905, -0.030321763828396797, 0.0481586717069149, -0.010332259349524975, -0.016438115388154984, -0.03219209983944893, -0.004891360178589821, 0.020968301221728325, 0.025173870846629143, -0.04233483970165253, -0.023541957139968872, 0.07034908980131149, 0.005774239543825388, 0.0347726047039032, 0.03807021304965019, -0.0006532928673550487, 0.02154782973229885, -0.001503053237684071, 0.013680786825716496, 0.057628463953733444, 0.005810216069221497, 0.0011464348062872887, -0.004467485472559929, 0.028636686503887177, -0.02547442354261875, -0.0305130984634161, -0.010098590515553951, 0.04874084144830704, 0.05716657266020775, -0.017036767676472664, -0.023698123171925545, 0.04113025218248367, -0.03534233570098877, 0.026793397963047028, 0.03709027171134949, 0.07070966064929962, 0.004630655515938997, 0.010310863144695759, -0.008343094028532505, -0.022205282002687454, 0.051726412028074265, -0.04010632634162903, -0.005176970269531012, 0.027855979278683662, -0.027334589511156082, -0.00046732297050766647, -0.004044698551297188, -0.04506811872124672, -0.057647455483675, 0.000944092869758606, 0.04922673478722572, 0.04195493459701538, 0.009114976041018963, 0.0008039785316213965, -0.03166844695806503, -0.031495437026023865, 0.021930621936917305, 0.003225836670026183, 0.008041643537580967, -0.044293832033872604, -0.0004873638099525124, -0.009281288832426071, -0.05110851675271988, 0.02711002342402935, -0.018321508541703224, -0.0016699128318578005, 0.031067756935954094, -0.03271348029375076, -0.044827837496995926, -0.040607303380966187, -0.025020457804203033, 0.023125426843762398, -0.020923886448144913, -0.010432536713778973, 0.053066644817590714, -0.005705826450139284, -0.04853260517120361, 0.0375775583088398, -0.042493727058172226, -0.002715522423386574, -0.015867313370108604, 0.007671467028558254, -0.0006402891012839973, 0.0020857099443674088, 0.013378595001995564, 0.014485380612313747, 0.03651091828942299, -0.027984555810689926, -0.06749474257230759, -0.0731273666024208, 0.016391294077038765, -0.006779140327125788, 0.008528868667781353, 0.0008534433436580002, -0.01217901986092329, 0.062071461230516434, 0.03812078386545181, -0.011474537663161755, -0.06304697692394257, 0.0030693640001118183, 0.0006832226063124835, -0.013881178572773933, 0.05380876362323761, -0.00052064866758883, 0.005310492590069771, 0.028465012088418007, -0.018262065947055817, 0.025469984859228134, 0.03794924542307854, -0.01848854310810566, 0.03117111697793007, 0.018981466069817543, 0.002374602947384119, -0.0023374254815280437, 0.036813631653785706, 0.03621239960193634, 0.006307617761194706, 0.01234056893736124, 0.0030123419128358364, 0.02038523368537426, -0.0110021336004138, -0.05201632156968117, -0.022339120507240295, 0.00003714431659318507, -0.01643197052180767, -0.013877669349312782, 0.031453173607587814, 0.026146145537495613, -0.04149509593844414, 0.0059582083486020565, 0.03865807130932808, 0.037010446190834045, -0.01754039339721203, 0.012938371859490871, 0.03942028805613518, 0.0003416337422095239, -0.015037080273032188, 0.040455177426338196, -0.022208185866475105, 0.032022625207901, 0.024367989972233772, -0.04129863157868385, -0.03419467434287071, 0.04168570414185524, 0.025661082938313484, -0.014889159239828587, -0.021463073790073395, -0.057226937264204025, 0.0228860005736351, -0.06626072525978088, 0.012039247900247574, -0.05402074754238129, 0.07974814623594284, 0.023343771696090698, 0.09725742042064667, -0.00750001473352313, 0.004454296547919512, 0.01353356335312128, -0.0048670098185539246, -0.06775137782096863, 0.0250132754445076, -0.0032783905044198036, -0.00225768331438303, -0.005089517682790756, -0.021233854815363884, 0.013738349080085754, -0.036771804094314575, 0.000030372813853318803, -0.0006846998003311455, -0.040526244789361954, -0.025418121367692947, 0.021433118730783463, -0.02385118044912815, -0.01092491950839758, 0.00568624772131443, 0.014091677032411098, 0.029074668884277344, -0.012054568156599998, 0.0420202910900116, 0.03046664223074913, -0.008619984611868858, -0.012900562956929207, -0.007906834594905376, 0.009723440743982792, 0.03771085664629936, 0.02430424839258194, -0.029247239232063293, 0.01902616024017334, -0.017364833503961563, 0.016851086169481277, -0.008066932670772076, 0.02972811833024025, 0.01700848713517189, -0.012832066044211388, -0.006959575228393078, -0.019963983446359634, -0.005379245150834322, -0.014742020517587662, 0.0508914589881897, 0.021132217720150948, 0.026485586538910866, 0.03184928372502327, 0.01622164249420166, -0.04062191769480705, -0.03459708392620087, 0.0787603110074997, -0.005108785815536976, -0.015449775382876396, -0.023006444796919823, -0.019437992945313454, -0.03671777620911598, 0.007761066313832998, 0.011316373944282532, -0.004763143602758646, 0.003457018407061696, -0.02762772887945175, 0.07565514743328094, -0.01864432916045189, -0.023588959127664566, 0.05398457869887352, -0.017373017966747284, 0.04323532432317734, -0.03829247131943703, -0.0473940372467041, 0.02049695886671543, 0.01989888958632946, 0.0050745471380651, 0.034660544246435165, -0.011977755464613438, -0.06536298245191574, -0.008767117746174335, 0.009783003479242325, 0.04293408617377281, -0.02008785493671894, -0.007814127951860428, -0.03585365042090416, -0.058575037866830826, 0.028394263237714767, -0.04210445657372475, 0.02462022565305233, -0.001256335061043501, -0.02485068142414093, -0.03805357217788696, -0.022048484534025192, -0.07059793174266815, 0.0068512470461428165, -0.050496380776166916, 0.032581720501184464, -0.0015464501921087503, -0.034856922924518585, -0.034739814698696136, 0.06097457930445671, 0.022033164277672768, 0.034979768097400665, -0.0103909308090806, -0.012975859455764294, 0.0022342177107930183, 0.006328718736767769, -0.037206098437309265, -0.02745749056339264, 0.029425036162137985, -0.012195136398077011, -0.007744622882455587, 0.06645704805850983, 0.01922411099076271, -0.03958326205611229, 0.025525230914354324, 0.023324597626924515, 0.03148623928427696, 0.047698020935058594, -0.013822347857058048, 0.01643243059515953, 0.02958296798169613, -0.019768545404076576, 0.013608559966087341, 0.005068013910204172, -0.05117588862776756, -0.01131102442741394, -0.014433765783905983, -0.007799297571182251, 0.0162612646818161, -0.010678870603442192, -0.05890708416700363, -0.006595791317522526, -0.024755125865340233, -0.0026125581935048103, -0.03581971302628517, 0.022738361731171608, -0.04928849637508392, -0.0376032292842865, -0.0077419402077794075, -0.006515285931527615, -0.016401395201683044, -0.029668159782886505, -0.015971768647432327, 0.017617419362068176, -0.012052031233906746, -0.0036286981776356697, 0.021458178758621216, -0.002234803047031164, -0.007402151357382536, 0.012345162220299244, -0.0400625504553318, -0.004081160295754671, -0.029494382441043854, -0.00032234296668320894, 0.02218012884259224, -0.0467764288187027, 0.0006117717130109668, -0.020065294578671455, -0.00638447655364871, 0.030755070969462395, -0.0031188479624688625, -0.05650583282113075, -0.021655306220054626, 0.021970028057694435, 0.02444407157599926, -0.011118073016405106, 0.010436625219881535, -0.047885920852422714, -0.014196806587278843, -0.07221119850873947, -0.038440633565187454, 0.01610374264419079, -0.0054901475086808205, -0.023739060387015343, -0.006493856664747, -0.0005889711901545525, -0.010504738427698612, -0.03233952447772026, -0.02287263423204422, 0.030132802203297615, -0.023883061483502388, -0.0005521096754819155, 0.03487873077392578, 0.01338271889835596, 0.025968361645936966, 0.01564634032547474, -0.01521345879882574, 0.022566162049770355, -0.008984452113509178, -0.008275299333035946, 0.014457057230174541, -0.014980209060013294, -0.017255296930670738, -0.00423292675986886, -0.000237388550885953, 0.026719389483332634, 0.02123234048485756, -0.00954797025769949, 0.005324513651430607, 0.0009943186305463314, 0.004001173190772533, 0.011358129791915417, -0.03712823614478111, 0.0029773435089737177, -0.0035269728396087885, -0.01381813082844019, -0.029849721118807793, -0.010856647975742817, -0.021514253690838814, -0.03450169786810875, 0.01861928030848503, 0.019708111882209778, -0.037825245410203934, -0.017140744253993034, 0.0690092071890831, 0.04243852198123932, -0.022657671943306923, -0.007104027085006237, -0.0018500381847843528, 0.05473684147000313, 0.0005917175440117717, -0.037571173161268234, 0.0019918400794267654, 0.042256955057382584, -0.012813347391784191, -0.010306723415851593, -0.02823774889111519, 0.052893027663230896, 0.055390872061252594, -0.01415185909718275, 0.05580710619688034, 0.04121575132012367, 0.03451314568519592, -0.019478678703308105, -0.04030104726552963, 0.014944048598408699, 0.0248212032020092, -0.04416973143815994, 0.019938243553042412, -0.0029406265821307898, -0.003391657490283251, 0.03773997724056244, 0.03130606934428215, 0.0022780797444283962, 0.026217879727482796, -0.002709213877096772, -0.05306510627269745, 0.02795650064945221, -0.033908989280462265, -0.009254156611859798, 0.010001806542277336, -0.030123811215162277, 0.019520768895745277, 0.005399870220571756, 0.0038506730925291777, 0.049525026232004166, 0.05942809581756592, -0.03126480430364609, -0.07606334239244461, -0.004906018730252981, -0.046440090984106064, -0.025084836408495903, 0.022788720205426216, -0.017654135823249817, 0.04583744332194328, 0.0203188955783844, 0.05377872288227081, -0.003381915157660842, 0.039154984056949615, -0.04743393883109093, -0.04555454105138779, -0.007399490103125572, -0.022706549614667892, -0.05776602774858475, 0.027826186269521713, 0.036812204867601395, -0.0055197738111019135, 0.017017586156725883, -0.03962048888206482, 0.03046339750289917, -0.005196490325033665, 0.050341520458459854, -0.019384730607271194, 0.039357978850603104, -0.011585823260247707, -0.03513115271925926, -0.009308460168540478, 0.016338994726538658, 0.126374751329422, 0.062230270355939865, 0.01703784242272377, -0.02342364937067032, 0.004243080038577318, -0.0007430041441693902, -0.0164004098623991, -0.03297549858689308, -0.007547258399426937, -0.015956487506628036, -0.005487220827490091, 0.053518518805503845, 0.033602021634578705, 0.024603629484772682, 0.007193079683929682, 0.06620849668979645, -0.049272745847702026, -0.001331218401901424, -0.048869792371988297, 0.04049820825457573, 0.023131337016820908, -0.024358883500099182, -0.050783053040504456, 0.024056967347860336, -0.025787917897105217, -0.03692375868558884, -0.05785705894231796, -0.03073403425514698, 0.005091118160635233, 0.0005840546218678355, -0.03728863224387169, 0.037663962692022324, 0.0069342139177024364, 0.0059448713436722755, -0.018966251984238625, 0.03339086100459099, 0.01630605384707451, -0.03442322835326195, -0.01584942638874054, 0.052522074431180954, -0.004526753444224596, 0.03212277591228485, -0.012418665923178196, 0.008627410046756268, -0.02967664785683155, -0.04090055450797081, -0.07404780387878418, 0.05523184686899185, 0.024844883009791374, -0.009493017569184303, -0.022304382175207138, 0.026465604081749916, -0.008162443526089191, -0.04868866503238678, -0.009720252826809883, 0.031697727739810944, 0.049621473997831345, -0.013495692051947117, -0.007910486310720444, 0.029781747609376907, 0.008333967067301273, 0.017941424623131752, -0.01656770147383213, 0.01562504656612873, -0.028461700305342674, -0.002713238587602973, -0.025776535272598267, 0.0428570993244648, -0.014370188117027283, -0.01647121086716652, 0.02147316373884678, -0.029264681041240692, -0.012491793371737003, 0.007647411432117224, 0.017802327871322632, -0.006978111807256937, -0.02682957611978054, 0.0236294474452734, -0.0010454546427354217, -0.030928075313568115, -0.011784972622990608, -0.036026421934366226, -0.04887579753994942, 0.03666529804468155, -0.02529878541827202, 0.0052691674791276455, -0.004140641540288925, 0.02742459438741207, 0.05434456840157509, -0.003204847453162074, -0.0224253349006176, 0.06213342398405075, 0.001934027299284935, -0.05846724659204483, -0.046079009771347046, 0.0004618498496711254, -0.0301111601293087, -0.013483123853802681, -0.013390566222369671, 0.10518442094326019, 0.031984876841306686, 0.030101006850600243, -0.00962807796895504, 0.03772351145744324, -0.04049399122595787, 0.013006892055273056, 0.02239318937063217, -0.046769727021455765, 0.006991435773670673, 0.024405498057603836, 0.0005024633137509227, -0.03374940901994705, 0.014850055798888206, -0.022821685299277306, -0.027151554822921753, -0.036668598651885986, -0.021419929340481758, -0.035321399569511414, 0.00999485608190298, 0.00283222459256649, -0.02802709862589836, 0.004172259010374546, 0.021748986095190048, -0.026286674663424492, -0.0008075308869592845, 0.00030599778983742, -0.029903028160333633, -0.016767539083957672, -0.014210807159543037, -0.026717133820056915, 0.01135852187871933, 0.00820695236325264, -0.0009790005860850215, 0.02882497012615204, -0.054360706359148026, 0.01567619852721691, 0.010002097114920616, 0.012251964770257473, 0.00817304477095604, -0.02779010310769081, -0.025053339079022408, -0.025118805468082428, -0.024577956646680832, 0.01922713778913021, 0.003525660140439868, 0.0514104925096035, 0.030125759541988373, -0.0012038395507261157, -0.02277323789894581, 0.01317792572081089, 0.02451234497129917, -0.014960359781980515, -0.02745617926120758, -0.0022940284106880426, 0.028578899800777435, 0.014392235316336155, -0.009376049041748047, -0.012854179367423058, -0.016398373991250992, 0.022932760417461395, 0.028248678892850876, 0.0016377723077312112, 0.007463294081389904, 0.015234341844916344, 0.02111983299255371, 0.02116299793124199, -0.005091145634651184, -0.03289690241217613, 0.06118879094719887, 0.021887725219130516, -0.0016127822455018759, 0.005058849696069956, 0.008709167130291462, 0.026315586641430855, -0.06525346636772156, -0.006503872107714415, 0.007862391881644726, 0.010611406527459621, 0.037275929003953934, -0.08498906344175339, 0.02376030571758747, 0.006941268220543861, -0.0626506358385086, 0.044197093695402145, 0.021795593202114105, 0.021613024175167084, -0.010829797014594078, 0.001216929405927658, 0.027161817997694016, 0.03725241497159004, 0.03887030854821205, 0.009539325721561909, 0.02742542140185833, 0.009199443273246288, -0.026629991829395294, -0.05512101948261261, 0.00013163551921024919, 0.04160044714808464, 0.015182976610958576, -0.02883131429553032, 0.04265068098902702, -0.050331614911556244, -0.008254099637269974, 0.025974363088607788, -0.03524851053953171, 0.03444119170308113, 0.005776955746114254, 0.01290761586278677, 0.020875228568911552, 0.08818479627370834, 0.044237613677978516, -0.012285923585295677, 0.00004369751695776358, -0.0065888911485672, 0.03803524374961853, -0.013019858859479427, 0.0070700994692742825, 0.01203758642077446, 0.03455555438995361, 0.006620359141379595, -0.008379416540265083, 0.006941425614058971, -0.00416452344506979, 0.02385985478758812, -0.006569060496985912, -0.01316103059798479, 0.00015259806241374463, -0.043581441044807434, 0.0038786702789366245, -0.014116918668150902, -0.015112805180251598, 0.023471929132938385, 0.01551738940179348, -0.04312799498438835, -0.03001854568719864, -0.009237621910870075, -0.04367908090353012, -0.0310189388692379, -0.018675873056054115, 0.0032040553633123636, -0.00583274383097887, -0.006639453116804361, -0.019119393080472946, -0.053293708711862564, -0.006654389668256044, -0.03276120498776436, -0.05761006847023964, 0.022355971857905388, 0.02396887168288231, 0.01894204132258892, 0.021135658025741577, -0.032682064920663834, 0.03301987424492836, -0.10468875616788864, 0.06313789635896683, 0.02215457335114479, -0.03188927099108696, 0.00047764996998012066, -0.007082316558808088, 0.01236033346503973, -0.01617903634905815, 0.06936424225568771, -0.012940051965415478, 0.0069227805361151695, -0.03389684483408928, 0.0428178645670414, 0.001739794504828751, -0.03829997032880783, -0.003585690865293145, 0.012293733656406403, 0.005790292285382748, -0.038984086364507675, -0.02463972382247448, -0.0009507333161309361, -0.02776291035115719, 0.0361638069152832, -0.026854196563363075, -0.003816383657976985, 0.004970085807144642, -0.02259865030646324, -0.022787095978856087, -0.01273999735713005, -0.030522063374519348, 0.02349969744682312, 0.053799137473106384, -0.007609024178236723, 0.025198886170983315, -0.0031916815787553787, -0.06958095729351044, 0.018047332763671875, -0.03251871466636658, -0.003210399765521288, -0.026172157377004623, -0.021523665636777878, 0.011000235565006733, -0.04748807102441788, -0.0023249636869877577, 0.031434401869773865, -0.013437362387776375, -0.006192172411829233, 0.042387641966342926, -0.018634699285030365, 0.002137124538421631, -0.047586679458618164, 0.026130666956305504, -0.011395602487027645, -0.03936295956373215, 0.01322682574391365, 0.005603700410574675, 0.037253182381391525, 0.05600127577781677, -0.011773849837481976, 0.03477976471185684, 0.011622807942330837, 0.017242515459656715, -0.017810195684432983, 0.01897289790213108, 0.005530960857868195, 0.019505158066749573, -0.000911485985852778, -0.005813051480799913, 0.04184039682149887, 0.017538513988256454, -0.004189806990325451, 0.05286714807152748, -0.038639068603515625, -0.028618324548006058, -0.05427996441721916, 0.011387224309146404, -0.05472220107913017, -0.026273727416992188, 0.05495620146393776, 0.011028728447854519, -0.029231799766421318, -0.014167956076562405, -0.013639844954013824, -0.012301580980420113, 0.033970028162002563, -0.013625426217913628, -0.01581907831132412, -0.027920907363295555, 0.015441859140992165, 0.02601873129606247, 0.0019106442341580987, -0.04176704213023186, -0.020146934315562248, 0.06678525358438492, 0.032459571957588196, 0.009089699946343899, -0.007780362386256456, -0.009835259988904, -0.02180727757513523, 0.006682618521153927, -0.05412345379590988, -0.06825634092092514, -0.012687468901276588, 0.02871551923453808, 0.03592458367347717, -0.027099503204226494 ]
<p>I was wondering what relations and differences are between pivotal statistic versus distribution free statistic?</p> <ol> <li><p>From <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pivotal_quantity" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a></p> <blockquote> <p>a pivotal quantity or pivot is a function of observations and unobservable parameters whose probability distribution does not depend on the unknown parameters <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pivotal_quantity" rel="nofollow">1</a> (also referred to as nuisance parameters).</p> </blockquote></li> <li>If I understand correctly, a statistic T is said to be distribution free, if the distribution of T(X) doesn't depend on the distribution of X. Examples are Kolmogorov-Smirnov test statistic.</li> </ol> <p>My understanding about their differences are: a pivotal statistic still depends on the form of the distribution, but not on the value of its parameter? A distribution free statistic doesn't depend on either form or parameter of the distribution. Am I correct? </p> <p>My question comes from <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/a/324653/1281">a reply at MSE.</a> I also appreciate that if you could answer my question there.</p> <p>Thanks and regards!</p>
74,140
[ -0.027420518919825554, -0.00679147569462657, -0.00038448793930001557, -0.03079279139637947, 0.021710947155952454, -0.020848121494054794, -0.022033393383026123, -0.004350609146058559, 0.03728008270263672, -0.03433472290635109, 0.02380411885678768, 0.016715707257390022, 0.05005025118589401, 0.01479413267225027, 0.014815649949014187, 0.0163960512727499, -0.03200744837522507, 0.04725343734025955, -0.0016968542477115989, -0.01718420907855034, 0.013462613336741924, 0.030388958752155304, 0.050105009227991104, -0.00748199038207531, -0.037836525589227676, 0.05403163284063339, 0.005210344213992357, -0.0037555003073066473, 0.01325557753443718, 0.0859440267086029, -0.03138137236237526, -0.0038272333331406116, -0.040844399482011795, 0.05435483530163765, -0.0039585186168551445, 0.007934744469821453, -0.010489861480891705, 0.023272396996617317, -0.003362853778526187, 0.01881803758442402, -0.03543245419859886, -0.015870969742536545, -0.011648012325167656, 0.04422078654170036, -0.0288751982152462, -0.010061785578727722, -0.03363032266497612, -0.05248253792524338, 0.011175669729709625, -0.03109644539654255, 0.07683856040239334, 0.02348743937909603, 0.04259122908115387, 0.025742601603269577, -0.016973888501524925, -0.01853947527706623, 0.049479804933071136, 0.08489863574504852, -0.055265843868255615, -0.07635189592838287, -0.024859001860022545, -0.026458382606506348, 0.03077039308845997, -0.03505793958902359, -0.02794904075562954, 0.039829544723033905, 0.0038587022572755814, -0.036236945539712906, 0.0450955294072628, -0.02105501852929592, 0.02192038670182228, 0.005714081693440676, 0.026317980140447617, -0.0009719182271510363, 0.007067672908306122, -0.029305489733815193, 0.021683815866708755, -0.01794169656932354, 0.031214987859129906, 0.06838332861661911, 0.011764034628868103, 0.0480339415371418, 0.0005345713580027223, 0.000024490853320457973, 0.04717659577727318, -0.027972042560577393, 0.07531311362981796, 0.02100369520485401, 0.0016090908320620656, 0.041719723492860794, -0.02537519298493862, -0.008704185485839844, 0.039632175117731094, -0.016171343624591827, -0.041847918182611465, 0.013799953274428844, -0.009432788006961346, 0.03552336245775223, 0.01671123318374157, 0.011892763897776604, 0.009440846741199493, -0.03329707309603691, 0.006537547335028648, 0.058977194130420685, -0.022270387038588524, -0.03367544710636139, -0.03441096469759941, 0.001346367527730763, -0.05418289080262184, -0.055022742599248886, -0.035035375505685806, 0.018776128068566322, -0.03348950296640396, -0.0037377781700342894, 0.04422513768076897, -0.014681363478302956, -0.008214211091399193, 0.0016119214706122875, 0.04857872053980827, 0.021527012810111046, 0.04035443440079689, 0.005423466209322214, 0.010403786785900593, -0.018987437710165977, -0.05144369974732399, 0.03701900318264961, 0.04096212983131409, 0.015998538583517075, -0.018416283652186394, 0.06026792526245117, -0.007179387845098972, -0.03594289347529411, 0.034695688635110855, 0.04712318256497383, 0.02527870051562786, -0.011542701162397861, -0.07187764346599579, -0.016904879361391068, 0.039702318608760834, -0.022395232692360878, -0.025996189564466476, -0.056616973131895065, -0.006075618322938681, 0.014443077147006989, 0.030460894107818604, 0.009735521860420704, 0.0358092337846756, -0.02770955301821232, 0.035032838582992554, 0.0074661304242908955, -0.027850395068526268, -0.027465203776955605, -0.0023564600851386786, -0.04973943904042244, -0.01918025128543377, -0.06020202860236168, 0.01854665018618107, 0.006837290711700916, 0.01000681146979332, -0.0021107362117618322, 0.03491247072815895, -0.021088220179080963, -0.02093091607093811, 0.01568574644625187, -0.0022353141102939844, -0.025417735800147057, 0.061344750225543976, -0.01494332030415535, 0.03074325993657112, 0.04178837314248085, 0.02634848840534687, 0.03807130455970764, 0.006603052839636803, 0.06906533241271973, 0.03538273647427559, -0.019923251122236252, -0.03561476618051529, -0.04477963596582413, 0.028411321341991425, -0.006192989647388458, -0.042001865804195404, -0.005442906636744738, -0.016954442486166954, -0.01669156737625599, 0.019766777753829956, 0.05992738530039787, 0.0031867462676018476, 0.006113475188612938, 0.05647050961852074, -0.05255948379635811, -0.01742520183324814, -0.04577108472585678, -0.009668336249887943, -0.03181805834174156, -0.04545246437191963, 0.048442889004945755, 0.0074439020827412605, 0.006038841791450977, -0.009938607923686504, 0.008589896373450756, 0.004041461739689112, -0.03215591982007027, 0.02589702047407627, -0.03261631354689598, 0.013964011333882809, 0.0041361041367053986, 0.017059052363038063, -0.01562359556555748, 0.03712911903858185, -0.047098927199840546, -0.048045564442873, 0.018299926072359085, -0.04256212338805199, 0.028762223199009895, 0.030779678374528885, -0.03666537255048752, 0.05476576089859009, 0.009395834989845753, -0.023530447855591774, 0.053635161370038986, -0.05269525200128555, 0.02895399183034897, 0.052119117230176926, -0.0024501539301127195, 0.0072064525447785854, 0.004341710824519396, 0.012352963909506798, 0.004729690495878458, -0.02448553778231144, 0.023980457335710526, -0.06033423915505409, -0.0051375487819314, 0.04191594570875168, 0.009389863349497318, -0.00866750255227089, 0.01254848949611187, 0.08215001225471497, -0.004835961852222681, 0.02344989962875843, 0.007957889698445797, 0.000610904477071017, -0.023572877049446106, 0.018702233210206032, 0.029538068920373917, 0.014729895628988743, 0.008812901563942432, 0.027752507477998734, 0.006006383802741766, 0.05077452212572098, 0.007928206585347652, -0.0432177297770977, 0.051716968417167664, 0.001040064264088869, -0.028298838064074516, 0.007137807086110115, 0.045172400772571564, 0.048942383378744125, -0.00383093673735857, -0.010198011994361877, 0.0199221670627594, 0.006696589291095734, -0.004837015178054571, -0.025192422792315483, -0.021403642371296883, 0.046212390065193176, 0.021259887143969536, -0.04929194226861, -0.022945832461118698, 0.0014090517070144415, -0.012573178857564926, 0.006649716757237911, -0.01605883054435253, -0.03744671121239662, -0.012474838644266129, -0.005593476351350546, 0.023127255961298943, 0.008249650709331036, 0.028074882924556732, -0.013619035482406616, -0.056057341396808624, -0.020882882177829742, -0.004551385063678026, -0.003212830750271678, 0.029091281816363335, -0.042647939175367355, 0.016536353155970573, -0.026310406625270844, -0.034500233829021454, 0.045239318162202835, -0.030437489971518517, 0.01050086971372366, -0.018290705978870392, -0.006275160703808069, -0.07303836941719055, 0.0037832451052963734, -0.04270406812429428, 0.04592261463403702, -0.05404980480670929, -0.012530126608908176, 0.042449694126844406, -0.01898851990699768, -0.027928348630666733, 0.023883948102593422, -0.03599727526307106, -0.04837775602936745, -0.04498741403222084, 0.015085390768945217, 0.07600679248571396, -0.004974167328327894, 0.021048253402113914, 0.05212349072098732, -0.04987306147813797, 0.004345665220171213, -0.06776546686887741, -0.04666924849152565, 0.03760293871164322, -0.004837208893150091, 0.042804330587387085, -0.011028066277503967, -0.0629277378320694, 0.05314593017101288, 0.03276541456580162, -0.01927092857658863, -0.0432133786380291, -0.0007724108872935176, -0.03298083320260048, -0.02240823023021221, 0.006696176715195179, 0.00384143996052444, 0.009486755356192589, 0.0194679107517004, -0.0005964370211586356, 0.029996681958436966, 0.033662863075733185, 0.030890345573425293, -0.00028560770442709327, 0.0311911441385746, -0.002069804584607482, -0.0013809174997732043, 0.023598747327923775, 0.03404693678021431, -0.02521701157093048, -0.01666422188282013, 0.000681268866173923, 0.03041038289666176, 0.00003248911161790602, -0.045027486979961395, 0.030511777848005295, -0.011390662752091885, 0.011520489118993282, -0.017663434147834778, 0.021620549261569977, 0.009571181610226631, -0.027015892788767815, 0.000835334649309516, 0.014138143509626389, 0.045298460870981216, -0.03516208752989769, -0.023856550455093384, 0.050822220742702484, 0.05307934060692787, -0.014584322459995747, -0.016430865973234177, -0.016777731478214264, -0.022799910977482796, 0.01757030561566353, -0.004306265152990818, -0.005368099082261324, 0.03587251901626587, 0.021738605573773384, 0.012187663465738297, -0.013095888309180737, -0.024209842085838318, 0.000612900301348418, -0.07452621310949326, 0.02514520101249218, -0.038962241262197495, 0.06272035837173462, 0.016555147245526314, 0.0462779775261879, 0.022751016542315483, 0.008582381531596184, -0.05589419975876808, 0.012405911460518837, -0.0416097566485405, 0.021275673061609268, -0.03393074497580528, -0.022957101464271545, 0.0108520882204175, -0.0022135719191282988, -0.0066709681414067745, -0.008361238054931164, -0.001061856048181653, 0.0287574902176857, 0.031029043719172478, -0.050823356956243515, 0.031343426555395126, -0.011746038682758808, -0.009058386087417603, 0.0035516198258847, -0.0025596676860004663, 0.008527761325240135, 0.004465543664991856, 0.037671707570552826, 0.03708428516983986, -0.005740752909332514, -0.03142261877655983, -0.021411266177892685, -0.007285931147634983, 0.010415417142212391, 0.02708585374057293, 0.018118757754564285, 0.021252043545246124, -0.04531525820493698, 0.01326366700232029, 0.010081862099468708, 0.05646473169326782, 0.02352018654346466, -0.0033223468344658613, -0.0023367104586213827, -0.0822812169790268, -0.034690145403146744, 0.0017268811352550983, 0.03732173517346382, -0.021211713552474976, -0.0017080532852560282, 0.05452726408839226, 0.014578594826161861, 0.026763254776597023, 0.04467548057436943, 0.05883552134037018, 0.003671678714454174, 0.02008139342069626, -0.03886270523071289, 0.006756408605724573, -0.027732204645872116, -0.02185119315981865, 0.021511424332857132, 0.032014504075050354, 0.010437990538775921, 0.012302030809223652, 0.009458891116082668, -0.044546015560626984, -0.018072836101055145, -0.006917979102581739, 0.03337998315691948, 0.037305526435375214, -0.019191058352589607, -0.020654495805501938, 0.043747954070568085, 0.010353446006774902, 0.0248966533690691, 0.04419907554984093, 0.005782395601272583, -0.05370716005563736, 0.0012921622255817056, 0.0445011705160141, 0.035721443593502045, -0.03588951751589775, 0.014947337098419666, -0.024407176300883293, -0.004094780422747135, 0.009662870317697525, -0.05541827529668808, 0.007314187008887529, 0.019153859466314316, -0.002767169149592519, -0.013382294215261936, -0.019191714003682137, -0.04936949163675308, 0.004775563720613718, -0.01655004173517227, -0.0048694913275539875, -0.028554527088999748, -0.03260469809174538, -0.06695046275854111, -0.019802672788500786, -0.006281573791056871, 0.05445403978228569, 0.009152683429419994, -0.006965278182178736, 0.0175822451710701, 0.05775774270296097, 0.005229910369962454, -0.0823802798986435, 0.002717745490372181, 0.02216307818889618, 0.030984913930296898, 0.046218011528253555, -0.01425698958337307, -0.058363039046525955, 0.032174114137887955, -0.021361734718084335, -0.0015850188210606575, 0.027384351938962936, 0.008259323425590992, 0.05336696654558182, 0.032692354172468185, -0.02367459423840046, 0.05060109868645668, 0.038065310567617416, -0.003918557893484831, -0.014868383295834064, -0.0391208790242672, 0.027328284457325935, -0.03994806483387947, -0.01930408924818039, -0.03862577676773071, 0.006718737538903952, -0.0174367967993021, 0.01992601901292801, 0.002218634355813265, 0.01675497740507126, -0.061499953269958496, -0.008532305248081684, -0.021141594275832176, 0.011216488666832447, 0.04283292219042778, 0.033852338790893555, 0.010004394687712193, 0.005125835072249174, -0.011097552254796028, -0.034937918186187744, 0.006823084782809019, -0.024232840165495872, -0.0103305634111166, 0.007043261546641588, -0.0393240787088871, -0.008929887786507607, -0.01872524619102478, -0.03470178321003914, 0.029373155906796455, -0.00592922605574131, 0.045154672116041183, -0.01209076214581728, 0.0340675413608551, 0.0087286913767457, -0.03997134044766426, -0.03414534032344818, 0.021222878247499466, 0.00792580284178257, 0.057809289544820786, -0.052400898188352585, 0.04640072211623192, -0.0162932351231575, -0.02559010498225689, -0.07711371034383774, -0.007334718480706215, 0.002551222685724497, -0.0021531463135033846, -0.04559530317783356, -0.006828790530562401, 0.01809057593345642, -0.01108674518764019, -0.01932809315621853, -0.009781666100025177, 0.0629187524318695, -0.001021178555674851, -0.031007304787635803, -0.011134674772620201, 0.02262687310576439, 0.06448312848806381, -0.0519690178334713, -0.02949676662683487, -0.00903598964214325, -0.013130584731698036, 0.012277345173060894, 0.01963859237730503, 0.047590725123882294, -0.017719723284244537, -0.019954239949584007, -0.019469404593110085, -0.02369888871908188, 0.013221844099462032, -0.041158948093652725, -0.0030184625647962093, 0.020291253924369812, 0.012500381097197533, 0.01865152083337307, 0.02102181687951088, -0.014259926043450832, 0.00691670086234808, 0.018153905868530273, -0.01635804772377014, -0.0013886545784771442, -0.013376270420849323, -0.016108402982354164, 0.017691977322101593, -0.010538081638514996, -0.006288917735219002, 0.012589944526553154, 0.046382635831832886, 0.0002503739087842405, 0.0331580676138401, -0.008146658539772034, -0.045351333916187286, 0.050397418439388275, -0.00017345318337902427, 0.025468608364462852, -0.0062757390551269054, -0.03198637813329697, -0.0106144268065691, -0.014248857274651527, -0.04973248764872551, 0.014997744001448154, 0.06057706102728844, 0.002407880499958992, 0.029965776950120926, 0.03544623404741287, -0.02472970262169838, -0.01164593268185854, -0.050310537219047546, -0.005594421643763781, -0.04212412238121033, -0.004237577319145203, 0.040198951959609985, -0.013423730619251728, -0.02117943949997425, 0.06938948482275009, 0.016052698716521263, 0.009821522049605846, 0.03377222642302513, 0.018681252375245094, 0.007056935224682093, 0.01347904559224844, -0.003438217332586646, -0.05438242480158806, 0.0702921450138092, -0.05747784301638603, 0.020268892869353294, 0.013817135244607925, -0.01687854342162609, 0.02150575816631317, 0.0049864486791193485, 0.014075782150030136, -0.05846874415874481, -0.03442782908678055, -0.03171248361468315, 0.04256012663245201, 0.015485045500099659, -0.0012904272880405188, -0.034327976405620575, 0.005775091238319874, 0.0334586426615715, 0.024868523702025414, 0.03840090334415436, -0.017179835587739944, -0.08417441695928574, -0.015522786416113377, -0.015646737068891525, -0.032557059079408646, 0.01216153521090746, -0.014234066940844059, -0.016673842445015907, 0.017389589920639992, -0.07613622397184372, 0.024899011477828026, 0.03696991130709648, 0.011916778981685638, -0.02989116683602333, 0.09137541055679321, 0.02874409221112728, 0.021982794627547264, -0.000380443234462291, 0.006310984026640654, 0.11640197038650513, 0.029923977330327034, 0.011157861910760403, -0.050025735050439835, -0.0016273214714601636, -0.014604662545025349, 0.02744620479643345, -0.028273845091462135, -0.015150544233620167, 0.028108753263950348, -0.011608850210905075, 0.06788937747478485, 0.05511634796857834, 0.017100302502512932, -0.01196922454982996, 0.05388683080673218, -0.023213421925902367, -0.051020827144384384, 0.008258775807917118, -0.018360087648034096, 0.011475672945380211, -0.00016393413534387946, -0.03383323550224304, 0.02825017459690571, 0.015749599784612656, -0.005448535550385714, -0.04273718595504761, -0.021127799525856972, -0.012242065742611885, 0.04085168614983559, -0.027683675289154053, -0.022022373974323273, 0.05312257260084152, 0.015266677364706993, -0.02209395356476307, -0.0065554301254451275, -0.007912157103419304, -0.03031579591333866, 0.019642651081085205, 0.06928157806396484, 0.02117127925157547, -0.020419539883732796, 0.04973254352807999, 0.00712257344275713, -0.051518071442842484, -0.010884387418627739, -0.03981079161167145, 0.024753129109740257, -0.03377646952867508, 0.02705436944961548, -0.023757070302963257, -0.01592925190925598, -0.0382886677980423, -0.03768426924943924, -0.021930890157818794, 0.010147596709430218, 0.020222865045070648, -0.040512073785066605, -0.02025066688656807, -0.05769440531730652, 0.01661815494298935, -0.01847866177558899, 0.03956344351172447, 0.02008344605565071, -0.018845010548830032, -0.001777018653228879, -0.027351658791303635, 0.048688579350709915, -0.013605095446109772, -0.0013265033485367894, 0.03273225203156471, 0.005679799243807793, -0.023588554933667183, -0.0033524695318192244, 0.007772157900035381, -0.022678295150399208, 0.03383449837565422, -0.004999743774533272, 0.0352683961391449, -0.020240653306245804, -0.038503386080265045, 0.03150883689522743, -0.019137868657708168, -0.03363346680998802, -0.03795207664370537, 0.033486030995845795, 0.016513898968696594, 0.027570407837629318, -0.002197002526372671, 0.022029593586921692, -0.020075811073184013, 0.03587895259261131, 0.005941443145275116, -0.07156798988580704, -0.04010963439941406, 0.011800752952694893, 0.001455780235119164, -0.014236698858439922, -0.026878083124756813, 0.010945622809231281, 0.044183555990457535, 0.05242185667157173, -0.017399145290255547, 0.03130624443292618, -0.03134559094905853, 0.011386538855731487, -0.0047107660211622715, -0.02128666639328003, 0.006105503533035517, 0.02042728289961815, 0.0005590823711827397, 0.004278948996216059, -0.04747144132852554, -0.03550201654434204, -0.003670429578050971, 0.0229237899184227, -0.008512234315276146, -0.06323609501123428, -0.029862992465496063, -0.010488295927643776, 0.02054065652191639, 0.006511755753308535, -0.009080817922949791, -0.022865932434797287, -0.019035372883081436, 0.00801191944628954, 0.0010099904611706734, 0.045411914587020874, 0.0003880135191138834, -0.03187112510204315, -0.009758614003658295, 0.021548043936491013, 0.03724859282374382, 0.017006324604153633, 0.0012302043614909053, 0.01017321553081274, 0.004215908236801624, 0.06475124508142471, -0.032228101044893265, -0.013752371072769165, 0.04239701107144356, -0.031101344153285027, -0.02352738194167614, 0.03499209135770798, 0.0184023417532444, 0.026813514530658722, 0.026825230568647385, 0.021987775340676308, -0.010220064781606197, 0.03863966464996338, -0.03947388380765915, 0.011822170577943325, -0.008291693404316902, -0.009911858476698399, -0.0038324310444295406, -0.0062822806648910046, -0.0046556927263736725, -0.020037073642015457, -0.007458292879164219, 0.030702030286192894, 0.05653735622763634, 0.0021952728275209665, -0.011355464346706867, 0.040345147252082825, 0.03300431743264198, 0.001262559206224978, -0.027901487424969673, 0.03257342800498009, 0.02735232003033161, 0.0434686616063118, -0.056526068598032, 0.01296151988208294, -0.016044795513153076, 0.04289676621556282, -0.12118255347013474, -0.04258676618337631, 0.0098879961296916, 0.0029708021320402622, 0.04324866831302643, -0.025338925421237946, -0.05396420881152153, -0.0056564644910395145, -0.03299155831336975, 0.012532229535281658, -0.026729343459010124, -0.011468730866909027, -0.028903832659125328, -0.011182598769664764, -0.006044497713446617, 0.07058019191026688, 0.02961735613644123, -0.013409658335149288, 0.01916688121855259, 0.053291283547878265, 0.006615704391151667, 0.0257779099047184, 0.0042160265147686005, 0.009049806743860245, -0.027446964755654335, -0.0727512538433075, 0.04154431074857712, -0.024342449381947517, -0.03162417933344841, 0.05696847662329674, -0.00013749183563049883, -0.023932956159114838, 0.011154127307236195, -0.006645659450441599, 0.02194293402135372, 0.041004665195941925, 0.04397399723529816, 0.027929803356528282, -0.06367360800504684, 0.03539947420358658, 0.0206295233219862, 0.03541805222630501, -0.007899405434727669, -0.013013314455747604, 0.0023594151716679335, -0.0316188745200634, -0.0012153544230386615, -0.022807134315371513, -0.03146371990442276, -0.006606538314372301, 0.012124631553888321, -0.0074450005777180195, 0.013565476052463055, -0.017013758420944214, 0.030431147664785385, -0.06610052287578583, -0.02251490019261837, 0.022283639758825302, -0.0027849480975419283, 0.0063477796502411366, 0.039686109870672226, -0.02123137004673481, -0.03951716423034668, 0.024433406069874763, 0.012080722488462925, -0.0011249211383983493, -0.06307947635650635, -0.01163383387029171, -0.012931465171277523, -0.025440646335482597, -0.023390695452690125, 0.017309842631220818, -0.030642997473478317, 0.02875063754618168, -0.007744506001472473, 0.026165230199694633, 0.02335904724895954, 0.02097201719880104, -0.00525595573708415, -0.08819496631622314, 0.05120072886347771, 0.0343359000980854, -0.013900374062359333, -0.0552104189991951, 0.0044262949377298355, -0.03753795847296715, -0.005054158624261618, 0.028549792245030403, 0.014138517901301384, 0.025763938203454018, -0.00153668865095824, 0.006008273921906948, 0.014199789613485336, -0.0544312447309494, 0.01969354972243309, -0.01480533741414547, -0.03374290466308594, -0.022025667130947113, -0.019210457801818848, 0.01765776239335537, 0.015314232558012009, 0.02975541353225708, -0.0338873527944088, 0.04116379842162132, 0.014428908005356789, -0.028117885813117027, 0.0432867668569088, 0.05009886994957924, 0.004900411702692509, 0.03840688616037369, -0.019051291048526764, 0.00356096844188869, 0.009992809034883976, -0.013271902687847614, -0.03894936293363571, 0.04306289181113243, -0.03761305660009384, -0.026594743132591248, 0.030364902690052986, 0.01872400939464569, -0.028581105172634125, -0.03479408472776413, -0.029735619202256203, 0.03764791041612625, -0.021824197843670845, 0.00022512349823955446, 0.01618928648531437, 0.024613339453935623, 0.04931601136922836, -0.025294475257396698, -0.009045855142176151, 0.026449237018823624, -0.018271608278155327, 0.006365559063851833, 0.015807678923010826, 0.05812468007206917, -0.012458083219826221, -0.0045857722871005535, -0.0042511778883636, 0.015131070278584957, 0.017321161925792694, -0.007019389420747757, 0.03571058437228203, -0.02440515346825123, -0.04930457845330238, -0.0071477144956588745, 0.02323341742157936, -0.011373039335012436, -0.002303378190845251, -0.009752832353115082, 0.06605761498212814, -0.010367083363234997, -0.0006803967989981174, -0.010474247857928276, 0.0013780801091343164, -0.047741640359163284, -0.009718995541334152, 0.0025498573668301105, 0.0042981309816241264, -0.044227272272109985, -0.013175494968891144, -0.00043681703391484916, -0.022660598158836365, 0.014548053964972496, 0.0029496531933546066, 0.02283405140042305, -0.03526417165994644, -0.02322755940258503, -0.04547711834311485, 0.01185919065028429, -0.033201806247234344, 0.003193347482010722, 0.037876538932323456, 0.03816615790128708, 0.03580888733267784, -0.006759413983672857, -0.053669851273298264, 0.009579132311046124, 0.07694913446903229, -0.06971658021211624, 0.005568648222833872, -0.01541776955127716, 0.01012776605784893, 0.00784507766366005, 0.008996119722723961 ]
<p>Quick background:</p> <p>I am working on a political science project that involves analyzing the impact of different variables on the extent to which a candidate mentions other users when he or she tweets. </p> <p>One of these variables is whether the candidate answers the Political Courage Test (PCT). If he/she does, the value is 1. If they don't, it's 0.</p> <p>Another variable is the amount of money that the candidate raises over the course of his/her campaign. </p> <p>Someone more experienced crunched the data for me via a regression, and sent me the following results:</p> <pre><code>PCT Coefficient: 9.580 Standard error: 8.144 Amount of $$$ Raised Coefficient: 0.000 Standard error: 0.000 PCT*Amount of $$$ Raised Coefficient: 0.000 Standard error: 0.000 </code></pre> <p>I have basically no background in statistics, so I am at a loss of how to interpret this outcome effectively. </p> <p>From what I can tell, neither the amount of money raised nor whether the candidate answered the CPT has much of an effect on the tweets, but I am confused about the third one (CPT*Money Raised), which I am told is an interaction. What exactly is that saying? </p> <p>Thank you in advance for your help.</p>
74,141
[ 0.006309714168310165, -0.04202662780880928, -0.03841608762741089, -0.011757371947169304, 0.025901176035404205, 0.015609174966812134, 0.004657892510294914, -0.020037125796079636, 0.055783502757549286, -0.029612891376018524, 0.01215150486677885, -0.016117161139845848, 0.06906561553478241, 0.001660186448134482, 0.005652959458529949, 0.058785393834114075, -0.0020032075699418783, -0.004186621867120266, 0.008992262184619904, 0.011370265856385231, -0.010359534062445164, 0.04028160870075226, -0.004772528540343046, 0.02025076374411583, -0.008299430832266808, 0.08554406464099884, -0.014521281234920025, 0.01093265600502491, -0.012054250575602055, 0.05827227607369423, -0.04425844922661781, -0.06086266413331032, -0.028551336377859116, 0.0056468346156179905, 0.007277791388332844, -0.00024000201665330678, -0.029744267463684082, -0.0345081128180027, 0.009621938690543175, 0.03686303645372391, -0.014573100954294205, -0.03710217401385307, 0.007556568365544081, 0.04374884441494942, -0.014800872653722763, -0.015399359166622162, -0.0295996256172657, -0.02107495442032814, 0.03745531290769577, -0.0194063950330019, 0.04003838449716568, 0.0027024871669709682, 0.02394150383770466, -0.00017209206998813897, 0.010785124264657497, -0.006296530365943909, 0.05838073417544365, 0.04867109656333923, -0.03361376002430916, -0.025542637333273888, -0.0024237807374447584, 0.008059135638177395, -0.006894791033118963, -0.0037383995950222015, -0.045181527733802795, 0.01528479065746069, -0.011286783032119274, -0.0033112973906099796, 0.04291923716664314, 0.021448025479912758, 0.006669454276561737, 0.0382109135389328, 0.03793984279036522, 0.004505900666117668, -0.00023462591343559325, -0.03360380604863167, 0.0068622855469584465, 0.029117517173290253, 0.024273501709103584, 0.05372684821486473, -0.013578984886407852, 0.01075342483818531, -0.018502121791243553, 0.04515257850289345, 0.037308719009160995, 0.018883079290390015, 0.05729207396507263, -0.03175834193825722, 0.07408042252063751, -0.00525289960205555, -0.02302403561770916, 0.009795821271836758, 0.021402012556791306, 0.00781323853880167, -0.05964526906609535, 0.019816206768155098, -0.013979067094624043, 0.019277526065707207, 0.010018271394073963, -0.028186727315187454, -0.027755744755268097, -0.030736183747649193, -0.001283506047911942, 0.020676113665103912, -0.009975060820579529, -0.004782173782587051, -0.015527131035923958, -0.007575035095214844, 0.0012311653699725866, -0.04131939262151718, -0.03554562106728554, 0.015634184703230858, -0.020102225244045258, 0.000377995747840032, 0.006052597425878048, -0.05898532271385193, 0.0007688013138249516, 0.038018181920051575, 0.09335798770189285, 0.026982828974723816, 0.06617274135351181, -0.032688453793525696, 0.015580033883452415, -0.020401744171977043, -0.050060808658599854, 0.006471790373325348, -0.0133487768471241, -0.04550832509994507, -0.03259984403848648, 0.07495570927858353, -0.009705387987196445, -0.005377843510359526, 0.013839668594300747, 0.005625740624964237, 0.0104556605219841, 0.025693893432617188, -0.08391179144382477, -0.05528919771313667, 0.018430940806865692, 0.01337212324142456, -0.0009951881365850568, -0.04288934916257858, 0.025306157767772675, 0.01706901751458645, 0.04762868955731392, -0.0030991854146122932, 0.027831828221678734, 0.0014987700851634145, 0.03574909269809723, 0.05006604641675949, -0.049113720655441284, -0.021219834685325623, -0.016851138323545456, -0.000749887025449425, -0.0409640334546566, -0.027739141136407852, 0.016617555171251297, 0.01748216524720192, -0.01879052259027958, -0.002539890119805932, 0.05657237023115158, 0.004739421419799328, -0.011585005559027195, 0.02372974343597889, 0.005769203882664442, -0.025609686970710754, 0.03519841656088829, 0.028155073523521423, -0.01484772190451622, 0.023197432979941368, 0.03263618052005768, 0.018727678805589676, 0.03624826669692993, 0.04048627242445946, 0.05457773059606552, -0.00582753773778677, -0.003980827983468771, -0.0599086731672287, -0.022753600031137466, -0.01335526816546917, -0.0314079150557518, -0.030022261664271355, -0.051724351942539215, 0.012894462794065475, 0.03190947696566582, 0.056937482208013535, 0.022977190092206, 0.00834653154015541, 0.04882694035768509, 0.02353932149708271, -0.06260031461715698, -0.06261993944644928, -0.00006704188126605004, -0.0005180091829970479, -0.011633244343101978, 0.0009483801550231874, -0.008363365195691586, 0.03049554117023945, -0.020642148330807686, -0.01206603366881609, -0.020225543528795242, 0.007654772140085697, 0.055628035217523575, -0.011169700883328915, -0.027218179777264595, 0.032765306532382965, 0.018920116126537323, 0.013755345717072487, 0.01861601322889328, -0.04063199460506439, -0.013154519721865654, 0.023126069456338882, -0.031724996864795685, 0.030886467546224594, -0.023232603445649147, -0.004594532772898674, 0.021251996979117393, -0.002718863543123007, -0.03953954577445984, 0.04442679136991501, -0.08119551092386246, 0.08133512735366821, 0.043873146176338196, 0.010269666090607643, -0.024900851771235466, -0.0029712847899645567, 0.024280255660414696, 0.0105780940502882, -0.041623830795288086, -0.020604390650987625, -0.04615796357393265, -0.026902809739112854, 0.008906354196369648, -0.03230314701795578, -0.0021559875458478928, -0.012948964722454548, 0.06998315453529358, 0.008426769636571407, -0.013257522135972977, 0.013077320531010628, -0.021814174950122833, 0.037580106407403946, 0.012516501359641552, 0.020167957991361618, 0.02731289528310299, 0.0049744355492293835, -0.0010138378711417317, -0.023245930671691895, 0.041963301599025726, 0.043930329382419586, 0.02745777554810047, 0.032909780740737915, -0.005323404911905527, 0.004974444396793842, -0.06016331538558006, 0.007358440198004246, 0.05093786120414734, -0.0012648660922423005, -0.00716320751234889, 0.04836875572800636, 0.00152395642362535, -0.02402861788868904, 0.010055574588477612, -0.023065149784088135, 0.029450615867972374, -0.00790106039494276, -0.06849807500839233, -0.020487673580646515, 0.021398913115262985, -0.025293802842497826, 0.022623058408498764, -0.04339109733700752, -0.03510710597038269, -0.052888017147779465, -0.020476127043366432, 0.03906268626451492, 0.002212955616414547, 0.0430462509393692, -0.08521882444620132, -0.01233864389359951, 0.010155483148992062, -0.0025446205399930477, -0.014950676821172237, 0.03596721589565277, -0.06940948218107224, -0.006976861506700516, -0.014231911860406399, -0.010446356609463692, 0.009467576630413532, 0.015653861686587334, -0.05138547718524933, 0.03072209469974041, 0.010031860321760178, -0.0340287908911705, -0.024061044678092003, -0.03886009380221367, 0.0011321549536660314, -0.019797449931502342, -0.03354097902774811, 0.03043271414935589, -0.010276420041918755, -0.00812820065766573, 0.026865828782320023, -0.03667096048593521, -0.002167892176657915, -0.04716341942548752, -0.046219490468502045, -0.01793389581143856, 0.004946897737681866, 0.01139677781611681, 0.001984683331102133, 0.02537606470286846, -0.033030081540346146, -0.07806728035211563, -0.04064405709505081, 0.039881788194179535, 0.016198936849832535, 0.01156555861234665, -0.00639006681740284, -0.05045534670352936, 0.058849383145570755, -0.026494592428207397, -0.009677196852862835, -0.026200713589787483, -0.02294864133000374, -0.0714174434542656, 0.022078070789575577, -0.02924409694969654, 0.030511826276779175, 0.03146028518676758, 0.02771761454641819, 0.004897582344710827, 0.043404363095760345, 0.020862456411123276, -0.014823099598288536, 0.02675817348062992, 0.0011501997942104936, -0.013481881469488144, 0.029171062633395195, 0.04170937463641167, 0.0558774471282959, -0.013435518369078636, 0.0477062352001667, 0.013751416467130184, 0.013991041108965874, -0.013432805426418781, -0.028969651088118553, -0.0011147448094561696, 0.0208749882876873, -0.013646450825035572, -0.030211403965950012, 0.05704709514975548, 0.030932258814573288, -0.02353598177433014, -0.006675083190202713, 0.01978011429309845, 0.03782805800437927, -0.05456134304404259, 0.009633500128984451, 0.04162735864520073, 0.02374376729130745, -0.00731489434838295, -0.04183388873934746, -0.022631902247667313, -0.013862227089703083, -0.014371195808053017, 0.0026520162355154753, 0.029963934794068336, 0.0590946301817894, 0.028641315177083015, 0.021921467036008835, 0.03285132721066475, -0.047516483813524246, -0.0006427608896046877, -0.059027835726737976, -0.00036612298572435975, -0.024335937574505806, 0.0444687120616436, -0.007863681763410568, 0.07403484731912613, 0.0000832368532428518, 0.0327874980866909, 0.025971272960305214, -0.0063047888688743114, -0.03937743604183197, 0.03749881312251091, -0.013600311242043972, -0.017379039898514748, -0.008860040456056595, -0.009083515964448452, 0.025694644078612328, -0.018404396250844002, -0.014502603560686111, -0.01709774136543274, 0.005638943053781986, -0.01737223006784916, 0.04446769878268242, -0.01805436983704567, 0.02344614453613758, 0.003855663351714611, -0.017702437937259674, 0.042771559208631516, -0.01796744577586651, 0.010693436488509178, 0.039705246686935425, 0.014534170739352703, 0.0019899862818419933, -0.029414204880595207, -0.01185174472630024, 0.05468803271651268, 0.021442517638206482, 0.05318139120936394, 0.004750826396048069, -0.01376108918339014, 0.049735505133867264, 0.005815170239657164, 0.04741830378770828, 0.04225686565041542, -0.011114992201328278, -0.024971118196845055, -0.030544932931661606, -0.006922574248164892, 0.010272746905684471, 0.010300381109118462, -0.023121079429984093, 0.05267766863107681, 0.05607949197292328, 0.030004899948835373, -0.006814705673605204, 0.03255397453904152, 0.04963283613324165, 0.025965841487050056, -0.032405462116003036, -0.04081297293305397, 0.024266382679343224, 0.009322509169578552, -0.025190195068717003, 0.04811426252126694, 0.023396261036396027, 0.035846929997205734, 0.002469739643856883, 0.029861493036150932, -0.02028023637831211, -0.05629642307758331, 0.019404206424951553, 0.0002470789186190814, 0.031096506863832474, -0.01991959661245346, -0.0336274616420269, 0.028662361204624176, 0.05785341560840607, -0.004834359977394342, 0.0020190076902508736, -0.004426323808729649, -0.08817541599273682, -0.006162205245345831, 0.03427902236580849, 0.044189032167196274, -0.041433434933423996, -0.07876238226890564, -0.030943632125854492, 0.021199118345975876, -0.019008152186870575, -0.05196553096175194, 0.023778056725859642, -0.015906689688563347, 0.00013910123379901052, -0.0342913456261158, 0.013063263148069382, -0.04197325557470322, 0.016261160373687744, -0.022278277203440666, 0.002027377486228943, -0.02378913201391697, -0.056292466819286346, -0.018825871869921684, 0.021869519725441933, 0.005721487570554018, 0.01647084951400757, -0.0717650055885315, -0.024825863540172577, 0.02320871874690056, -0.0011967435711994767, -0.011662409640848637, -0.06286552548408508, -0.024358920753002167, -0.0017678015865385532, 0.0003420787106733769, 0.09725569188594818, -0.011032014153897762, -0.026961280032992363, -0.007649339269846678, 0.005503713618963957, -0.015341341495513916, -0.014672412537038326, -0.034023623913526535, 0.043793920427560806, 0.04143356531858444, -0.009114926680922508, 0.06544280052185059, 0.04697803035378456, 0.01801079325377941, 0.01868033967912197, 0.013542678207159042, 0.006412535440176725, 0.002680414356291294, 0.03229210898280144, -0.0287125613540411, 0.009148605167865753, -0.030871711671352386, 0.00895406398922205, -0.01791163720190525, 0.006520857568830252, -0.0558246374130249, 0.016496146097779274, -0.010546987876296043, 0.012498753145337105, -0.016355380415916443, 0.007225836627185345, 0.010610727593302727, 0.018311919644474983, -0.0021196911111474037, -0.009679988957941532, 0.01718508079648018, -0.06375625729560852, -0.0025811907835304737, 0.0175236277282238, -0.0016764206811785698, 0.0021483986638486385, 0.0029542436823248863, -0.008648025803267956, 0.017364785075187683, -0.006463665049523115, 0.03453240171074867, -0.010337772779166698, 0.014155860990285873, -0.011735225096344948, -0.026674505323171616, -0.030362436547875404, 0.020532328635454178, 0.009700631722807884, 0.022325299680233, -0.005455369595438242, 0.05946632847189903, -0.00755526265129447, -0.007035807240754366, -0.02846594713628292, -0.032370083034038544, 0.03713054955005646, 0.028450677171349525, -0.04200764745473862, -0.005248578265309334, -0.02362966537475586, 0.005590016022324562, -0.04127712547779083, 0.02231256105005741, 0.038912951946258545, -0.05060598626732826, -0.016076624393463135, 0.005626301746815443, -0.0031920659821480513, 0.04049164801836014, 0.033197857439517975, 0.021107859909534454, 0.020033273845911026, -0.015682678669691086, -0.054094284772872925, -0.009095446206629276, -0.007812278810888529, -0.02115361951291561, -0.03112986870110035, -0.029844526201486588, 0.02065054513514042, 0.0111455749720335, 0.010477297008037567, -0.017253203317523003, -0.017066054046154022, -0.018856745213270187, -0.006855534855276346, -0.011599673889577389, -0.01701928861439228, 0.022097796201705933, 0.00813345517963171, -0.016913194209337234, 0.008345725946128368, -0.03594393655657768, -0.005207909736782312, 0.026410484686493874, 0.025084834545850754, -0.05086642876267433, 0.013239019550383091, 0.06492061167955399, -0.016849689185619354, 0.035355743020772934, -0.004406423307955265, -0.008784362114965916, 0.05269281193614006, 0.004126302432268858, -0.0027639258187264204, 0.004200700204819441, 0.006313760299235582, -0.05809489265084267, -0.02376345731317997, -0.03375118225812912, 0.013930349610745907, 0.031674742698669434, -0.02862980216741562, 0.0506882481276989, 0.03566121309995651, -0.048917680978775024, 0.0405789352953434, 0.006269655656069517, -0.011353231966495514, -0.01451889332383871, -0.005944931413978338, 0.034187838435173035, -0.021200822666287422, -0.014866866171360016, 0.055757030844688416, 0.013782904483377934, 0.028506379574537277, 0.018659228459000587, 0.046571411192417145, -0.019646642729640007, -0.014244412072002888, -0.0361643061041832, -0.0264362171292305, 0.05190543457865715, -0.02138102613389492, 0.00389651907607913, -0.02999628335237503, -0.040977269411087036, 0.0394400916993618, 0.017703605815768242, 0.004428778309375048, -0.0485919713973999, -0.012649436481297016, -0.05919526889920235, -0.011968948878347874, 0.014878880232572556, -0.0515613816678524, -0.0019503299845382571, -0.030896760523319244, 0.016132524237036705, 0.014675864949822426, 0.044456128031015396, -0.021984128281474113, -0.071870356798172, -0.0339093878865242, 0.0021563335321843624, -0.021357035264372826, 0.020073091611266136, -0.042732447385787964, -0.016402296721935272, 0.08951409161090851, -0.031616780906915665, 0.011908340267837048, 0.031280651688575745, 0.008795087225735188, -0.04989101365208626, 0.054347746074199677, 0.010764878243207932, 0.016089659184217453, -0.01654362678527832, -0.012679152190685272, 0.11514537781476974, 0.07024088501930237, -0.00047039525816217065, -0.03773294389247894, -0.0004733306122943759, 0.018554190173745155, 0.02049766667187214, -0.012477380223572254, 0.011562257073819637, 0.02176639251410961, 0.006026876159012318, 0.07406526803970337, 0.024663636460900307, 0.0074059003964066505, 0.02500591054558754, 0.027656517922878265, -0.021617112681269646, -0.055170293897390366, 0.0294807069003582, 0.022097710520029068, -0.012222611345350742, -0.061068251729011536, -0.030375204980373383, -0.004981108941137791, -0.0017869970761239529, 0.017878800630569458, 0.02156876213848591, -0.020755227655172348, 0.02240246906876564, 0.04108448699116707, -0.03496929258108139, 0.021021245047450066, 0.007028969470411539, 0.028999552130699158, -0.028927870094776154, 0.0038480518851429224, 0.02907382696866989, -0.006998414173722267, -0.011978325434029102, 0.04276946932077408, -0.020110759884119034, -0.009520964697003365, -0.0019646035507321358, 0.022907372564077377, -0.06649848818778992, -0.02712913416326046, -0.03220154345035553, 0.04608729109168053, -0.007881737314164639, -0.00048295961460098624, -0.05276605859398842, 0.0361841581761837, -0.024687474593520164, -0.01371842809021473, -0.012295759283006191, 0.014137930236756802, -0.031581584364175797, -0.046625956892967224, -0.00004991712557966821, -0.053372595459222794, -0.004061608575284481, -0.008859993889927864, 0.020085901021957397, 0.04328718036413193, 0.0041739135049283504, -0.009029706940054893, -0.040684767067432404, 0.02002238854765892, -0.01933358982205391, -0.00343302171677351, 0.02679150551557541, -0.04014836996793747, -0.04768083617091179, -0.0071532041765749454, -0.008242134004831314, -0.002276650397107005, 0.01390387024730444, -0.004595083184540272, 0.024740610271692276, -0.055184099823236465, 0.011479323729872704, -0.024027591571211815, -0.016102319583296776, 0.013821108266711235, -0.032963309437036514, -0.0232172142714262, -0.009346546605229378, 0.011852134019136429, -0.008405551314353943, -0.014522162266075611, 0.01305270567536354, 0.07488492131233215, -0.0005762050859630108, -0.05408487841486931, -0.01896953396499157, -0.000560083135496825, -0.06249796226620674, -0.030733535066246986, -0.008107928559184074, 0.06069880351424217, 0.017187101766467094, 0.005303865764290094, -0.014699620194733143, -0.003582243574783206, -0.022320527583360672, 0.031998008489608765, 0.039233725517988205, -0.036895137280225754, -0.014696807600557804, 0.00649961968883872, -0.017238138243556023, -0.0069596352986991405, -0.023593949154019356, 0.005920468829572201, -0.014506496489048004, 0.014355352148413658, 0.0014289027312770486, -0.05979086086153984, -0.025876525789499283, 0.0022770604118704796, 0.03210581839084625, 0.01935715600848198, -0.014842282049357891, -0.08002667129039764, 0.007402617018669844, 0.04675475135445595, -0.017821568995714188, 0.0010249632177874446, 0.00523980101570487, 0.006808076985180378, 0.023282527923583984, 0.04036655277013779, -0.020338209345936775, -0.015317723155021667, -0.054652463644742966, 0.07917755097150803, 0.02175905741751194, 0.01832578331232071, -0.01690981723368168, -0.04843821004033089, 0.04348929226398468, -0.06085953116416931, -0.015262692235410213, 0.008935092948377132, 0.0004945560940541327, 0.07103697210550308, -0.0084228515625, 0.0005130479112267494, 0.003969292156398296, 0.04579034447669983, -0.02721296064555645, -0.024657251313328743, 0.005447416566312313, -0.029104840010404587, 0.021635204553604126, -0.03123134933412075, 0.006329053547233343, 0.0013759395806118846, 0.00019936695753131062, 0.021862348541617393, 0.04591381922364235, -0.019083140417933464, -0.014292081817984581, -0.03778647258877754, 0.005300218239426613, -0.015963910147547722, 0.01920616254210472, -0.000927276851143688, 0.0047004627995193005, 0.02997819520533085, -0.04308178275823593, 0.013920397497713566, -0.014318590052425861, 0.04597405344247818, -0.07491379231214523, -0.007076129782944918, -0.04022635146975517, -0.03326974809169769, 0.006745980586856604, -0.04618002474308014, 0.03315208479762077, -0.018490104004740715, -0.01087392121553421, 0.005147808231413364, -0.023003768175840378, -0.007806428242474794, -0.021176978945732117, 0.02452399767935276, -0.002004316309466958, 0.025913061574101448, 0.05038829520344734, -0.001621257048100233, 0.024089083075523376, 0.02313651330769062, 0.0071000391617417336, -0.012706095352768898, -0.034666888415813446, 0.042598363012075424, -0.013704749755561352, -0.03760021552443504, 0.0523281991481781, -0.04606848955154419, -0.021575208753347397, 0.05940832570195198, -0.020854972302913666, 0.022264890372753143, 0.009007436223328114, 0.05010206997394562, 0.03821386769413948, 0.017289450392127037, -0.012978796847164631, 0.017643122002482414, -0.022546963766217232, 0.019053854048252106, 0.014504116959869862, 0.02795070968568325, 0.022632554173469543, 0.025855453684926033, 0.02320334129035473, -0.05011449381709099, 0.02409384399652481, 0.006346842739731073, -0.011803030967712402, -0.007483506575226784, 0.022746628150343895, -0.07415861636400223, 0.0293295755982399, 0.000726979342289269, 0.039082206785678864, -0.04871569573879242, 0.00046963340719230473, 0.012755615636706352, 0.015500782988965511, -0.03193846344947815, 0.010758019052445889, -0.021188154816627502, 0.004609496798366308, 0.027455385774374008, 0.02828885428607464, 0.019520750269293785, -0.02284720540046692, -0.009640303440392017, 0.028919117525219917, 0.001070612808689475, 0.0023304640781134367, -0.01033093873411417, -0.019217872992157936, 0.01914464868605137, -0.016365841031074524, -0.013364199548959732, 0.030027717351913452, -0.01818721368908882, 0.0013573543401435018, -0.11812810599803925, 0.06331741809844971, 0.034067198634147644, 0.01735500991344452, -0.01245062705129385, 0.006786198355257511, -0.05887986347079277, -0.011642112396657467, 0.05862995609641075, -0.0032725180499255657, -0.025712382048368454, -0.025529056787490845, -0.010752205736935139, -0.02708345092833042, -0.05977645888924599, 0.030535995960235596, 0.011647926643490791, 0.03583694249391556, -0.02217720076441765, 0.004505825694650412, 0.009195979684591293, 0.01188911683857441, 0.00869506411254406, 0.0030236472375690937, -0.0016987260896712542, -0.023806529119610786, -0.012077368795871735, 0.018506934866309166, 0.05074549838900566, -0.010123834013938904, 0.05162062868475914, 0.03501293808221817, 0.03887230530381203, 0.05566289648413658, -0.008882089518010616, -0.05110054835677147, 0.09989243745803833, 0.01133736502379179, -0.0023043882101774216, -0.006523591466248035, -0.01907842420041561, 0.004813776817172766, -0.06529916077852249, -0.022624704986810684, 0.038406286388635635, -0.03853600099682808, 0.01641453243792057, 0.01781858503818512, 0.021885525435209274, 0.049011118710041046, 0.005760433617979288, 0.05576733127236366, -0.007105148397386074, -0.018970631062984467, 0.002396821975708008, 0.007508134935051203, 0.0446462444961071, 0.073462575674057, 0.029316093772649765, 0.02238994836807251, -0.008427681401371956, 0.029867710545659065, -0.011736447922885418, -0.010446188040077686, -0.013863046653568745, -0.019366661086678505, 0.014274334535002708, -0.028733570128679276, 0.003943523392081261, 0.0004939442151226103, 0.028765082359313965, 0.03662611544132233, -0.04702179878950119, 0.02613513357937336, -0.010779578238725662, 0.012649706564843655, -0.0038025639951229095, 0.006403901614248753, 0.021845100447535515, -0.013234893791377544, -0.004105976317077875, -0.04042792692780495, -0.023573484271764755, -0.005146054085344076, -0.000251076853601262, -0.03241506218910217, 0.0316389761865139, -0.011184136383235455, 0.008107111789286137, -0.03915777429938316, -0.051870930939912796, 0.005602491553872824, 0.0028076907619833946, 0.048641499131917953, 0.022157270461320877, 0.00925502460449934, -0.029624613001942635, -0.030252527445554733, 0.021208403632044792, 0.04788008704781532, -0.04305599629878998, 0.007234235294163227, -0.023165682330727577, 0.05111532658338547, 0.04062623903155327, -0.042946651577949524 ]
<p>I have some data gathered from a survey conducted within my city. All responses include an approximate geo location of where they were gathered (accurate to probably a couple of hundred yards which is relatively small), and things like the respondents age, sex, income range, number of dependents, etc. There are approx. 4000 responses.</p> <p>What I would like to is to be able to generate what I guess you would call a model, so that given a geo point (or box) I could characterize the typical respondent from there (it doesn't really have to be really rigorous, although some kind of formal confidence measurement would be nice).</p> <p>So, is the right thing to do to simply treat all the gathered attributes separately and say "Well the age of your typical respondent in that area is m with stdev s, and their income range is ..., etc."</p> <p>Or is there some better way to analyse the data together to get a better profile of the respondents.</p> <p>Some key phrases to google would even help at this stage, because I'm a bit lost. I thought this might be "data fusion" but I don't think it is.</p>
74,142
[ -0.025889521464705467, -0.013285854831337929, 0.03526175394654274, -0.0013838985469192266, 0.04524888098239899, -0.008792543783783913, 0.007146748248487711, -0.020617138594388962, 0.032768022269010544, -0.03584712743759155, 0.03677022084593773, 0.010977809317409992, 0.05083741992712021, 0.0057946559973061085, 0.017848016694188118, 0.021331198513507843, 0.027896400541067123, 0.02096393331885338, -0.02688046731054783, -0.0402841754257679, -0.006656386889517307, -0.004333296325057745, -0.011524762026965618, -0.03668347746133804, -0.027036001905798912, 0.020077373832464218, 0.03385826572775841, -0.044320862740278244, -0.002197113586589694, 0.06092742085456848, -0.025585774332284927, -0.026432683691382408, -0.018996601924300194, 0.05002845451235771, 0.024945396929979324, -0.00800432451069355, -0.052318278700113297, -0.0011137141846120358, 0.011870442889630795, 0.04536344110965729, -0.026111802086234093, -0.019436433911323547, 0.005647655576467514, 0.008283271454274654, -0.00888056680560112, -0.00015455826360266656, -0.011208874173462391, -0.02273278869688511, 0.040720097720623016, -0.032071880996227264, 0.08662250638008118, -0.008968890644609928, 0.024529701098799706, 0.04260832071304321, -0.03761987388134003, -0.0017591698560863733, 0.05757816880941391, 0.06430976092815399, 0.01566321589052677, -0.05543578043580055, -0.002027583308517933, -0.01193306501954794, -0.008573565632104874, -0.04254649206995964, 0.009847588837146759, 0.021049732342362404, -0.027807213366031647, -0.018774433061480522, 0.04679761454463005, -0.026445778086781502, 0.032686810940504074, 0.009990816935896873, 0.016842162236571312, -0.015301885083317757, -0.0013797692954540253, -0.041135843843221664, 0.001575361005961895, 0.010664965957403183, 0.03712849318981171, -0.006264124996960163, -0.009944912046194077, -0.015628062188625336, -0.007639378309249878, 0.016248421743512154, 0.025688866153359413, -0.020411770790815353, 0.04352811723947525, -0.033053796738386154, -0.008392593823373318, 0.031858477741479874, -0.03545621410012245, 0.009693151339888573, 0.05976972356438637, 0.011133952997624874, -0.06948453187942505, 0.05450030788779259, -0.014384854584932327, 0.04582446813583374, 0.009330632165074348, 0.0018781103426590562, -0.013696973212063313, -0.03471416234970093, -0.0005778768099844456, 0.03748423233628273, -0.015369990840554237, -0.000021795713109895587, -0.019805125892162323, -0.03466954082250595, 0.01566140539944172, -0.00046666624257341027, -0.01134683471173048, 0.0014179586432874203, 0.03237149491906166, 0.02369770221412182, 0.03844275325536728, -0.011285689659416676, -0.010138818994164467, -0.010551567189395428, 0.05873747169971466, 0.047729771584272385, 0.031147094443440437, -0.05895574763417244, 0.007425161078572273, -0.028928644955158234, -0.05621550604701042, 0.00007991280290298164, 0.0185040682554245, 0.009509495459496975, -0.0253842081874609, 0.03810251131653786, 0.0005880092503502965, -0.02679218351840973, 0.07299197465181351, -0.01124395802617073, 0.012607425451278687, -0.026718156412243843, -0.08541053533554077, -0.04926912859082222, -0.04790887236595154, -0.017017126083374023, 0.024145016446709633, -0.037044212222099304, 0.00373432831838727, -0.008262822404503822, 0.012520118616521358, 0.004202405922114849, 0.03551647439599037, 0.014639275148510933, 0.04363610967993736, 0.012246871367096901, -0.044668495655059814, -0.0336993969976902, -0.00668485090136528, -0.000547376403119415, -0.0203505028039217, -0.05813242122530937, 0.015678416937589645, 0.009646622464060783, -0.017195316031575203, -0.03335560858249664, 0.04916175827383995, 0.03281595557928085, -0.042278923094272614, 0.03133974224328995, 0.04114311560988426, -0.0067029790952801704, 0.055516887456178665, -0.004237796645611525, 0.04276374354958534, 0.032234642654657364, 0.002635359764099121, 0.024433374404907227, 0.0339762419462204, 0.020416248589754105, 0.029516976326704025, -0.004474469926208258, 0.015167967416346073, -0.00751981558278203, -0.011359344236552715, 0.023809561505913734, -0.04285804554820061, -0.03618137538433075, -0.0124688521027565, -0.0048080310225486755, -0.0016623184783384204, 0.04070885851979256, -0.016929032281041145, -0.053560368716716766, 0.038599010556936264, -0.05939647555351257, -0.02858690917491913, -0.05727190151810646, -0.020282519981265068, -0.053075846284627914, -0.006261985749006271, -0.017111942172050476, 0.02423461340367794, 0.015421675518155098, -0.010773579590022564, -0.05637357011437416, -0.03251434862613678, -0.030598534271121025, 0.04425109177827835, -0.03143342211842537, -0.012581530027091503, 0.0475664846599102, 0.009075061418116093, -0.06405302882194519, 0.04087445139884949, -0.008207722567021847, -0.047567203640937805, 0.010854089632630348, -0.04173028841614723, 0.04114646837115288, -0.0027571681421250105, -0.00740023935213685, -0.002474990440532565, 0.009502389468252659, -0.04690338298678398, -0.002970872214064002, -0.050714097917079926, 0.07622803002595901, 0.05265634506940842, -0.027240542694926262, -0.020022515207529068, 0.019495084881782532, 0.020491430535912514, 0.04249679297208786, -0.013296385295689106, -0.003282608464360237, -0.07069188356399536, -0.010950203984975815, 0.04651639610528946, 0.022754445672035217, -0.03236106410622597, 0.008250894024968147, 0.06273341923952103, 0.05132671445608139, 0.019560357555747032, 0.007758188061416149, 0.009195771999657154, 0.028911849483847618, 0.013599771074950695, 0.0034696627408266068, 0.004589573014527559, 0.036300960928201675, -0.013748519122600555, 0.009138235822319984, -0.020584799349308014, -0.022206004709005356, 0.017274238169193268, 0.06934691220521927, 0.006462176330387592, 0.018566306680440903, -0.009497379884123802, 0.013258769176900387, 0.054168328642845154, -0.03654211014509201, -0.0026819631457328796, 0.032545510679483414, -0.01635947823524475, -0.017697077244520187, 0.0014609305653721094, -0.0329698845744133, 0.010947149246931076, 0.07363682985305786, -0.03327661752700806, 0.00517921382561326, 0.009945903904736042, -0.0499025359749794, 0.01016667764633894, 0.006028116215020418, -0.012115797027945518, -0.04864969477057457, 0.024166429415345192, 0.05821000784635544, 0.0059532891027629375, 0.04364088550209999, -0.0000931749600567855, -0.03379760682582855, -0.02141726203262806, -0.001343855750747025, 0.00828052032738924, 0.006426066160202026, -0.09685423225164413, -0.019059333950281143, -0.015210350975394249, -0.04070235416293144, 0.02540449984371662, -0.00044404834625311196, -0.020833445712924004, 0.018888704478740692, 0.009689724072813988, -0.04125233367085457, -0.016596419736742973, -0.01467427983880043, 0.007133267354220152, 0.0003049040969926864, 0.007643524557352066, 0.027354996651411057, -0.010306520387530327, -0.03619641810655594, 0.01114792563021183, -0.05716666579246521, -0.06131914258003235, -0.021655503660440445, -0.0405009388923645, 0.03451710566878319, 0.04226437211036682, 0.009298768825829029, 0.04548570141196251, -0.008256168104708195, 0.014188979752361774, -0.08301448822021484, -0.0420113205909729, 0.024405548349022865, 0.01147349365055561, 0.06920637935400009, -0.002585269045084715, 0.02600574679672718, 0.0689096599817276, 0.013097137212753296, -0.03843390569090843, -0.02732907608151436, 0.007727114483714104, -0.024336684495210648, 0.027776960283517838, 0.027525119483470917, 0.011650685220956802, 0.00003349580947542563, 0.02218569442629814, -0.008448177017271519, 0.027774790301918983, 0.054223496466875076, 0.0056594014167785645, -0.011126816272735596, 0.015457052737474442, -0.02909325808286667, 0.007069779094308615, 0.026460058987140656, 0.046691134572029114, -0.059336673468351364, 0.01143676321953535, -0.03278587386012077, 0.021057697013020515, 0.04502463340759277, -0.04698612540960312, -0.013979058712720871, -0.024145686998963356, -0.012005247175693512, -0.032127052545547485, -0.033949512988328934, 0.009970123879611492, -0.058119192719459534, -0.01477003749459982, 0.044679876416921616, 0.06058979034423828, 0.030779536813497543, -0.0155367786064744, 0.07506618648767471, 0.03843667730689049, 0.024427108466625214, 0.0054596965201199055, 0.001049738610163331, -0.0015156023437157273, -0.018837029114365578, 0.023196116089820862, -0.008306249976158142, 0.0420282781124115, 0.04970838129520416, 0.021603528410196304, -0.004472509957849979, -0.03773384913802147, 0.03274787589907646, -0.10122998058795929, -0.018471630290150642, -0.020563004538416862, 0.08524823188781738, 0.0000016327899174939375, 0.027923960238695145, 0.03478320315480232, -0.015072760172188282, 0.01932508684694767, 0.046715524047613144, -0.05068507418036461, -0.006629372015595436, -0.0006615858292207122, 0.022584086284041405, -0.010943535715341568, -0.04585064947605133, 0.03338043391704559, -0.009631507098674774, 0.006477398797869682, -0.021226277574896812, 0.041095465421676636, -0.038828812539577484, 0.001253325492143631, -0.018297959119081497, -0.009466052986681461, 0.00550429243594408, 0.006945830769836903, 0.013212804682552814, 0.017374010756611824, 0.003605779493227601, 0.053627241402864456, 0.043198082596063614, -0.02802126295864582, -0.0338175892829895, 0.012437351979315281, 0.02603187784552574, 0.034045733511447906, -0.02967447228729725, 0.0285810437053442, -0.026163438335061073, 0.0318179652094841, -0.0248463936150074, 0.04873877018690109, 0.01836954802274704, -0.01397288590669632, -0.03121279738843441, 0.000012601176422322169, -0.03612483665347099, 0.018816199153661728, 0.010410520248115063, -0.02183547243475914, -0.00004036161408293992, 0.04552135616540909, 0.0661235973238945, -0.056464783847332, 0.03839309886097908, 0.05393574386835098, 0.011511593125760555, -0.01996777579188347, -0.04382888600230217, -0.019743507727980614, -0.004150247201323509, 0.005266259424388409, 0.016498690471053123, 0.022436022758483887, 0.0039077624678611755, -0.007007352076470852, 0.0578775480389595, -0.012290134094655514, -0.060442402958869934, 0.03238339349627495, 0.030057484284043312, 0.04303780943155289, 0.0022077860776335, -0.03248634189367294, 0.029103415086865425, 0.020888997241854668, 0.0459761843085289, 0.025713952258229256, 0.006820404902100563, -0.14473775029182434, 0.008718685247004032, 0.038269225507974625, -0.013281639665365219, -0.016464607790112495, -0.04406091943383217, -0.047444649040699005, -0.026893842965364456, 0.028332820162177086, 0.01833309233188629, -0.0062207006849348545, -0.003174790181219578, -0.005378415808081627, 0.005995739251375198, 0.018016494810581207, -0.030609790235757828, -0.012313194572925568, -0.005028055980801582, 0.0048339818604290485, -0.030204905197024345, -0.012450856156647205, -0.05697647109627724, 0.05725664645433426, 0.04399928078055382, 0.04226317256689072, 0.01827188767492771, -0.017088744789361954, 0.0021345450077205896, 0.0403473787009716, -0.014811021275818348, -0.05802678316831589, 0.008413033559918404, 0.04990128055214882, -0.018741309642791748, 0.06318504363298416, 0.0026535727083683014, -0.049751754850149155, 0.037231069058179855, -0.0020557688549160957, 0.01340668834745884, 0.00788816623389721, -0.027873564511537552, 0.05276709794998169, 0.021595250815153122, 0.03626639023423195, 0.021690869703888893, -0.0029678603168576956, -0.007090256083756685, 0.0014706783695146441, -0.01902935653924942, -0.025367330759763718, -0.03569456562399864, -0.007370936684310436, -0.03502758592367172, 0.010283556766808033, -0.0015907913912087679, -0.03249775990843773, 0.009313748218119144, 0.02954992651939392, -0.024052554741501808, -0.035828184336423874, 0.005344041623175144, 0.009557287208735943, 0.0024370525497943163, 0.010456797666847706, 0.005644325632601976, 0.03700679913163185, -0.007884284481406212, -0.014071555808186531, 0.006963333580642939, -0.017337340861558914, 0.008231320418417454, -0.021092282608151436, -0.01940268464386463, 0.003837005700916052, -0.05713892728090286, -0.012269534170627594, 0.01371572632342577, -0.02741304226219654, 0.04541264474391937, 0.007683584466576576, 0.04821596294641495, 0.03681734949350357, -0.043110355734825134, 0.0011270169634371996, -0.00854569859802723, 0.03986183553934097, 0.03207334131002426, 0.009673302993178368, 0.026081526651978493, -0.014814028516411781, -0.0209407489746809, -0.07290258258581161, -0.04721156880259514, 0.04513716697692871, -0.004846455063670874, -0.029750006273388863, -0.04801255092024803, 0.022020410746335983, -0.017906110733747482, -0.04082970321178436, -0.008725050836801529, 0.05101323872804642, -0.01813637651503086, -0.014097219333052635, -0.006691284012049437, 0.05138272047042847, 0.0768459290266037, -0.019235670566558838, 0.03380036726593971, 0.04788804426789284, 0.0005639308947138488, 0.003184875240549445, -0.01178840920329094, 0.02145291306078434, -0.03678470477461815, -0.008638578467071056, -0.05340586230158806, 0.019836122170090675, 0.05782788246870041, 0.0011752643622457981, 0.015621869824826717, -0.020244527608156204, -0.022578440606594086, 0.012831583619117737, -0.0010076643666252494, 0.018435796722769737, -0.03380650281906128, -0.030761774629354477, -0.07145735621452332, 0.051860131323337555, -0.01993362046778202, -0.0036487604957073927, 0.051386017352342606, -0.03016599453985691, 0.023150479421019554, 0.017741955816745758, 0.030192017555236816, 0.007784868590533733, 0.00343623710796237, 0.023459039628505707, 0.004846344236284494, 0.053533200174570084, 0.01892632618546486, -0.021243445575237274, 0.0236315056681633, 0.03592938184738159, -0.04094567522406578, -0.02498902752995491, -0.016096750274300575, -0.02037120796740055, 0.05564810335636139, 0.003010736545547843, 0.059750016778707504, 0.0576138012111187, 0.0034886631183326244, 0.014765455387532711, -0.007070735562592745, 0.007987385615706444, -0.0033181810285896063, -0.022046903148293495, 0.07416953146457672, 0.004683635197579861, -0.01741020567715168, 0.0208770502358675, 0.03646412119269371, 0.02918207086622715, 0.051076095551252365, 0.011527523398399353, 0.0328110046684742, 0.030225612223148346, -0.022372372448444366, -0.05393075570464134, 0.012090872041881084, -0.035246219485998154, -0.012328905053436756, 0.018008030951023102, -0.006831625942140818, 0.023009147495031357, 0.05699118226766586, 0.006527135148644447, -0.012643515132367611, 0.006636555772274733, -0.06641068309545517, 0.026721933856606483, 0.03468050807714462, -0.028403567150235176, 0.019602254033088684, 0.016023216769099236, 0.057332634925842285, -0.022789359092712402, -0.006393377669155598, -0.04687170684337616, -0.0695713609457016, 0.002537317108362913, -0.046806562691926956, -0.06700405478477478, 0.002933987881988287, -0.025109296664595604, -0.0016145966947078705, 0.005128586199134588, -0.044633686542510986, 0.010128644295036793, -0.0028706614393740892, 0.011395628564059734, -0.025119135156273842, 0.05400107800960541, 0.0074015031568706036, 0.013556992635130882, -0.02548057585954666, -0.02123112790286541, 0.11660435795783997, 0.07948628813028336, 0.0028778654523193836, -0.03594714775681496, 0.01204540953040123, 0.005381646100431681, -0.01113534439355135, -0.017407603561878204, -0.010144313797354698, 0.01712813787162304, 0.005185023881494999, 0.0493016317486763, 0.01691230572760105, 0.006540512666106224, -0.010170172899961472, 0.036154113709926605, -0.0136138079687953, -0.027715301141142845, 0.02159564383327961, 0.010860915295779705, -0.013647072948515415, -0.022273818030953407, -0.025008032098412514, 0.0308085884898901, -0.0009298734366893768, -0.03213921934366226, -0.0018107438227161765, -0.0019324555760249496, 0.007995816878974438, 0.03237506002187729, -0.04527891427278519, 0.029765987768769264, -0.006609414704144001, 0.011659646406769753, -0.031166696920990944, -0.00014455545169766992, 0.012487335130572319, -0.031551674008369446, -0.0006270234589464962, 0.009412097744643688, -0.032242339104413986, 0.006350821349769831, -0.016820227727293968, -0.0045623681508004665, -0.008321712724864483, -0.03151426464319229, -0.06194445490837097, 0.015812333673238754, -0.0017820911016315222, -0.02207525260746479, -0.030555814504623413, 0.04162253811955452, -0.001692260499112308, -0.02424752339720726, -0.02604478783905506, 0.02203141711652279, 0.04289090260863304, -0.01048648077994585, -0.04955679550766945, -0.01081480085849762, 0.008584205992519855, -0.010237137787044048, -0.005547180771827698, 0.011884937062859535, 0.011667035520076752, -0.017834726721048355, -0.05063401162624359, 0.04555374011397362, -0.005722203757613897, -0.016678500920534134, -0.0037049143575131893, -0.03724570944905281, -0.011071865446865559, -0.014370138756930828, -0.003564217360690236, -0.0027445624582469463, -0.00588704040274024, -0.027101946994662285, 0.027154389768838882, -0.009694335982203484, -0.014202192425727844, 0.000003849166660074843, -0.03962922468781471, 0.007861156947910786, -0.018722547218203545, 0.0145525261759758, 0.02343922294676304, 0.04129409417510033, 0.012572475709021091, 0.026772646233439445, -0.0009380833362229168, 0.0687999576330185, 0.005664907395839691, -0.04583742097020149, -0.0166171807795763, -0.005167876370251179, -0.07294406741857529, 0.014986708760261536, -0.034100085496902466, 0.04430259019136429, -0.002261907560750842, 0.003597656963393092, -0.037807900458574295, 0.017867036163806915, 0.00872480496764183, 0.02322043478488922, -0.015003633685410023, -0.04894758015871048, -0.0007081265794113278, -0.014406947419047356, -0.007185464724898338, 0.0009868110064417124, -0.009598840028047562, 0.012311129830777645, -0.04658597707748413, 0.018542135134339333, -0.00811285711824894, 0.008862065151333809, 0.01971052773296833, -0.010575728490948677, -0.021397361531853676, -0.0008860908565111458, 0.011061467230319977, -0.05165761336684227, -0.000843132846057415, -0.024206992238759995, -0.01649741642177105, 0.023204924538731575, 0.0035605200100690126, 0.0042935083620250225, 0.010070115327835083, 0.018830040469765663, 0.0009364806464873254, -0.0027110730297863483, 0.004479566588997841, 0.018518852069973946, 0.01072952151298523, 0.07755622267723083, -0.04782537370920181, -0.0016416303114965558, 0.042452678084373474, -0.030351724475622177, -0.02561216615140438, 0.024800265207886696, -0.012153681367635727, 0.032964762300252914, 0.0229691993445158, -0.0178473349660635, 0.011417281813919544, 0.046644844114780426, -0.027505287900567055, -0.01754634454846382, 0.006100744009017944, 0.030352724716067314, 0.02221629209816456, 0.00947250984609127, 0.023583130910992622, 0.013099894858896732, -0.017373664304614067, 0.004103611223399639, 0.020015856251120567, 0.004037510138005018, -0.01957152783870697, 0.01565103977918625, -0.008110780268907547, 0.017301149666309357, -0.028342152014374733, 0.00555033702403307, 0.027550626546144485, 0.033111926168203354, -0.0393407866358757, -0.019183199852705002, -0.025946468114852905, 0.009977665729820728, -0.01920131966471672, -0.04116921126842499, 0.01451737992465496, -0.006670583970844746, 0.015459097921848297, -0.07402875274419785, -0.0018655597232282162, 0.021603602916002274, -0.026978569105267525, -0.021021313965320587, 0.016790658235549927, 0.03988401219248772, -0.03986622393131256, 0.0279446542263031, -0.031601857393980026, 0.01945396326482296, 0.016426932066679, 0.02178620547056198, 0.008558863773941994, 0.04745619371533394, 0.005894878413528204, -0.017611557617783546, -0.021694522351026535, 0.0009038957068696618, -0.007657958194613457, -0.04731201380491257, 0.028669726103544235, -0.05239465460181236, -0.01837441511452198, 0.026510577648878098, -0.0009865046013146639, 0.022549759596586227, 0.01371570210903883, 0.009236649610102177, 0.019588030874729156, 0.038108475506305695, 0.034984517842531204, -0.001256882562302053, -0.020480982959270477, 0.037414874881505966, 0.038751062005758286, 0.05801382288336754, -0.035933248698711395, -0.005085739307105541, 0.03499578684568405, -0.005138485226780176, -0.009212123230099678, 0.027570059522986412, -0.017892906442284584, 0.00829351507127285, 0.02131648175418377, -0.02432195656001568, 0.018141863867640495, -0.02974102459847927, 0.04296692833304405, -0.03843969106674194, -0.004752043168991804, 0.04481184482574463, 0.003768748138099909, -0.04833018034696579, -0.008982203900814056, -0.03426128625869751, -0.05249599367380142, 0.008935391902923584, 0.02850830741226673, -0.027397213503718376, -0.0380825512111187, -0.021037045866250992, 0.014977145940065384, -0.013504373840987682, -0.02727353759109974, -0.005212143994867802, -0.03424392268061638, 0.06210698187351227, -0.03289870172739029, 0.012144527398049831, 0.04723699390888214, -0.017369093373417854, -0.019851863384246826, -0.0657399445772171, 0.05651595816016197, 0.03517426922917366, 0.02493927627801895, -0.01798929087817669, -0.017218807712197304, -0.02326156757771969, -0.021588489413261414, 0.03347679600119591, -0.024944117292761803, 0.0023284535855054855, -0.0046786954626441, -0.01078631728887558, 0.028442971408367157, -0.046301718801259995, 0.030490050092339516, 0.02153445966541767, -0.0232925433665514, 0.0016812363173812628, -0.004995058290660381, 0.00734364241361618, -0.03472212329506874, 0.021293794736266136, 0.008952835574746132, -0.00048507031169719994, 0.006189169827848673, -0.010199634358286858, 0.01229188684374094, 0.022390972822904587, -0.025616174563765526, 0.027907567098736763, -0.022545991465449333, -0.02686612494289875, 0.041497375816106796, 0.010868907906115055, -0.03252067789435387, 0.040515221655368805, -0.019862430170178413, -0.050530314445495605, -0.017264636233448982, 0.0225877296179533, -0.009842777624726295, -0.03535355255007744, -0.014544730074703693, 0.01603366993367672, -0.03611936792731285, -0.018324879929423332, 0.06074481084942818, 0.013662425801157951, 0.003824169747531414, -0.016265995800495148, -0.000010139437108591665, 0.022758346050977707, -0.05477699264883995, 0.019847340881824493, -0.0006239445647224784, 0.056451864540576935, 0.01935575157403946, 0.02432323805987835, 0.04444712772965431, 0.031748175621032715, 0.03718249499797821, -0.026932470500469208, 0.011291845701634884, -0.03989323601126671, -0.0015680320793762803, 0.021323299035429955, 0.028974374756217003, 0.041359104216098785, 0.006221255753189325, -0.024690568447113037, 0.05867581069469452, -0.03498328477144241, -0.08046869188547134, -0.05122700706124306, -0.01652796007692814, -0.04296652600169182, 0.011945653706789017, 0.046757154166698456, 0.045051876455545425, 0.03189142048358917, -0.002931323368102312, -0.017460690811276436, 0.018284786492586136, 0.04629574343562126, -0.025468777865171432, 0.03847907483577728, -0.022357361391186714, 0.01691925898194313, -0.00176427501719445, -0.017360283061861992, -0.031774114817380905, -0.01575467549264431, 0.01814340241253376, 0.02527938038110733, 0.041432637721300125, -0.009000915102660656, -0.01682090014219284, -0.013945984654128551, 0.0280473493039608, -0.10042514652013779, -0.04224139079451561, -0.06672520935535431, -0.004053421784192324, -0.01581939309835434, 0.011234592646360397 ]
<p>I am doubting myself on which analysis to run for the following: 18 participants were evaluated at 4 time points with different conditions at each time. They were given scores (on a discrete visual analog scale) by 2 raters.</p> <p>The scores were calculated for a pair of participants: the pairs changed at each time point. I do know which participant comprises each pair.</p> <p>Is that a 2-way repeated measures ANOVA? Some variation of Friedman test?</p>
37,931
[ -0.018667684867978096, -0.04004541411995888, -0.017288614064455032, -0.0035931423772126436, 0.05279961973428726, 0.016201967373490334, 0.010578788816928864, -0.023906657472252846, -0.010591540485620499, 0.010447178967297077, 0.04391154646873474, 0.009700453840196133, 0.04348009452223778, -0.015019250102341175, 0.016118161380290985, 0.008698157966136932, -0.024152636528015137, 0.014719509519636631, 0.0018966239877045155, 0.0021508238278329372, -0.005539321340620518, -0.010954976081848145, -0.019087206572294235, -0.036251943558454514, -0.0468272939324379, 0.025491200387477875, 0.036109790205955505, -0.05133663862943649, 0.00667487783357501, 0.04981941729784012, -0.08099235594272614, -0.06269325315952301, -0.014105441980063915, 0.0021943936590105295, -0.018580647185444832, 0.003290299093350768, -0.06275436282157898, -0.017908653244376183, -0.01679355278611183, 0.03406535089015961, -0.017079761251807213, -0.01661587320268154, -0.002581786597147584, 0.03645982965826988, -0.011824274435639381, 0.004824420902878046, -0.0055672843009233475, 0.02555878274142742, 0.0226335097104311, -0.034313831478357315, 0.10400436073541641, -0.0539051815867424, 0.014632070437073708, 0.014459114521741867, -0.013464920222759247, -0.004324976820498705, 0.03762044012546539, 0.04496638476848602, 0.009644751437008381, -0.08219087868928909, -0.03476591035723686, -0.01485392451286316, 0.002973054302856326, 0.013064863160252571, -0.023484133183956146, 0.012179925106465816, -0.0009387250174768269, -0.020311690866947174, 0.013799156993627548, -0.004116852302104235, 0.007700563408434391, 0.030837474390864372, 0.044829219579696655, -0.000982881523668766, -0.00438141543418169, 0.022195158526301384, 0.0371914766728878, 0.021731087937951088, 0.04565853998064995, 0.029617195948958397, 0.006705344654619694, 0.007924922741949558, -0.01076305378228426, 0.035396236926317215, 0.02404618449509144, -0.026387013494968414, 0.0656573548913002, -0.006651721894741058, 0.012569885700941086, 0.03309175372123718, -0.010680492036044598, -0.004983565770089626, 0.022765379399061203, 0.009523390792310238, -0.03374310955405235, -0.016147423535585403, -0.02553636208176613, 0.0436309352517128, -0.021137438714504242, -0.03519193455576897, -0.0027611448895186186, -0.04754682630300522, 0.004247599747031927, 0.02824651449918747, -0.013193653896450996, 0.00846338551491499, -0.04941922053694725, 0.015307772904634476, 0.009938196279108524, -0.013763869181275368, -0.03090941719710827, 0.03430100157856941, -0.007925071753561497, 0.01695241779088974, 0.03781029209494591, -0.0012136943405494094, -0.033988531678915024, 0.023137543350458145, 0.07619580626487732, 0.04659799113869667, 0.04109209030866623, -0.03201405704021454, -0.009320257231593132, -0.030289672315120697, -0.020154466852545738, 0.006643922068178654, -0.0049280691891908646, -0.008914618752896786, -0.0060481238178908825, 0.0627121552824974, 0.00017229423974640667, -0.013511684723198414, 0.037709902971982956, 0.007378433831036091, -0.0021910767536610365, 0.034851036965847015, -0.10433986037969589, -0.07598745822906494, 0.024862388148903847, -0.022385410964488983, 0.02967028133571148, -0.05219708010554314, 0.0028977978508919477, -0.008574103005230427, 0.047022271901369095, -0.0006733638001605868, 0.06257928162813187, 0.012207750231027603, 0.06205630302429199, 0.041143059730529785, -0.02364082634449005, -0.03254375606775284, -0.03228951618075371, -0.03643655404448509, 0.0014370373683050275, -0.06665612012147903, 0.008931747637689114, 0.021657228469848633, 0.006104768253862858, 0.007229183800518513, 0.027086392045021057, 0.0028278937097638845, -0.010757094249129295, 0.03359758481383324, 0.0017071941401809454, -0.019287558272480965, 0.047840725630521774, -0.009473270736634731, 0.04131341353058815, 0.0077352868393063545, 0.031324587762355804, 0.05626837536692619, 0.005068813916295767, 0.03046182170510292, 0.07035459578037262, 0.00466826930642128, 0.009549432434141636, 0.012933320365846157, 0.009160423651337624, 0.027452873066067696, -0.03022923320531845, -0.039921876043081284, -0.050510846078395844, -0.027590541169047356, 0.043319955468177795, 0.05633609741926193, -0.020730342715978622, 0.005471670068800449, 0.0028999655041843653, -0.04127814620733261, -0.022640392184257507, -0.07188262790441513, 0.009256879799067974, -0.03597169741988182, -0.021859971806406975, 0.024576336145401, -0.01944337785243988, 0.025479352101683617, -0.02092399261891842, -0.04215267673134804, -0.022965053096413612, -0.002298993058502674, 0.056908246129751205, -0.052694398909807205, 0.014457293786108494, 0.023134127259254456, 0.027390552684664726, -0.01962493732571602, 0.03110293112695217, -0.07518868148326874, -0.022661786526441574, 0.012571638450026512, -0.018900135532021523, 0.0222623273730278, -0.01861167885363102, -0.02559301257133484, 0.000018233375158160925, 0.042210325598716736, -0.007392510771751404, 0.04988781362771988, -0.07918190956115723, 0.05819174647331238, 0.06316222250461578, -0.046996016055345535, -0.002288683783262968, 0.009223264642059803, 0.039963800460100174, 0.025256449356675148, -0.02870304509997368, -0.02012534998357296, -0.04965011030435562, 0.008135553449392319, 0.05587663874030113, 0.0021598332095891237, -0.018258173018693924, 0.024172497913241386, 0.05518589913845062, 0.039321135729551315, -0.01464643981307745, 0.027788320556282997, 0.025904757902026176, -0.01660885475575924, -0.004984844010323286, 0.06011051684617996, 0.03276587277650833, 0.011509628035128117, 0.023570271208882332, -0.014259149320423603, 0.034132763743400574, 0.018022896721959114, 0.03182378038764, 0.05711419880390167, 0.011594695039093494, 0.03940794616937637, -0.04919731989502907, -0.029279107227921486, 0.022502977401018143, -0.012659825384616852, 0.013705214485526085, 0.05054435506463051, 0.040783245116472244, -0.015938635915517807, 0.011507740244269371, -0.03047417849302292, 0.007562739308923483, 0.03416403755545616, -0.03411663696169853, -0.020054621621966362, 0.03729483112692833, -0.004643350373953581, 0.022491635754704475, 0.0012822713470086455, -0.023998236283659935, -0.0013100521173328161, 0.0130025465041399, 0.02422364242374897, -0.003748216200619936, 0.015200475230813026, -0.05971129238605499, -0.019694052636623383, -0.01220149639993906, -0.017598053440451622, 0.021007882431149483, 0.016145961359143257, -0.05936063826084137, 0.004138536751270294, 0.00480489619076252, -0.0022535049356520176, 0.04601862654089928, 0.0012307611759752035, -0.005823340732604265, 0.05833084136247635, 0.008454084396362305, -0.03762831911444664, -0.03595561906695366, -0.03095714934170246, 0.04143340140581131, -0.026964103803038597, -0.019988978281617165, 0.07077210396528244, 0.025283632799983025, -0.03155389055609703, 0.03527572751045227, -0.0412730909883976, -0.005823340732604265, 0.042299799621105194, -0.003653593361377716, 0.02333434857428074, -0.0003804917214438319, 0.004025762435048819, 0.0061434912495315075, -0.0167307797819376, -0.017463788390159607, -0.05351678654551506, -0.0784258171916008, 0.02093670330941677, -0.01492212526500225, 0.026838576421141624, -0.020720267668366432, -0.03279178962111473, 0.058337628841400146, 0.023440739139914513, -0.017313580960035324, -0.04078991711139679, 0.0020721929613500834, -0.05452766269445419, -0.02280982956290245, 0.03850031644105911, -0.005481559317559004, -0.023950541391968727, 0.05258270353078842, 0.00897869560867548, 0.029943132773041725, 0.06774985790252686, 0.00033857152448035777, -0.019629240036010742, 0.017157355323433876, 0.05830013006925583, -0.010178577154874802, 0.01834854669868946, 0.010939400643110275, -0.018486909568309784, -0.014899220317602158, 0.011089473962783813, 0.026980048045516014, -0.005056084133684635, -0.039939239621162415, 0.0183170847594738, -0.0429660938680172, -0.00470239482820034, -0.0017312939744442701, 0.02160470001399517, 0.022344224154949188, -0.004513448104262352, -0.03060392662882805, 0.026859302073717117, 0.019721247255802155, -0.03802914172410965, 0.02889789268374443, 0.05291758105158806, 0.031885042786598206, -0.00032473323517479, -0.0403791218996048, 0.023018117994070053, 0.0019522977527230978, 0.02403983287513256, -0.022280531004071236, -0.005646866280585527, 0.0243250522762537, 0.005953775718808174, 0.0591810941696167, 0.026704274117946625, -0.04657857120037079, 0.001949699828401208, -0.0775076374411583, 0.0284821055829525, -0.04217558354139328, 0.04791361466050148, 0.003999464213848114, 0.05554388090968132, 0.012455391697585583, -0.010716338641941547, -0.0016062961658462882, -0.015391955152153969, -0.031104372814297676, 0.02529130131006241, -0.00832134485244751, 0.04133150354027748, 0.03384982794523239, -0.009579827077686787, 0.03302006796002388, -0.008675042539834976, 0.030016416683793068, 0.004912444856017828, 0.039409711956977844, -0.014558257535099983, 0.0010000666370615363, -0.03268533572554588, -0.02525930665433407, -0.029938681051135063, 0.018859529867768288, 0.02880915254354477, -0.06744562089443207, 0.03683912009000778, 0.017932476475834846, 0.006089097820222378, -0.012463041581213474, -0.026056569069623947, -0.012615777552127838, 0.03676842898130417, 0.03109201416373253, -0.00027755493647418916, 0.03135169669985771, -0.026443079113960266, 0.04589371010661125, 0.002140236319974065, 0.015274147503077984, -0.0009241668740287423, -0.013603399507701397, -0.014944890514016151, -0.02326262556016445, -0.044413551688194275, 0.006544709205627441, 0.030838793143630028, 0.04461856558918953, 0.005439422558993101, 0.024576831609010696, 0.02161967195570469, -0.03559737652540207, 0.03127045929431915, 0.05733364447951317, -0.017305457964539528, -0.019415542483329773, -0.01947009190917015, -0.006191708147525787, -0.01729830540716648, -0.027967896312475204, 0.03339001163840294, 0.005724808666855097, -0.018185239285230637, -0.02439386211335659, 0.051266349852085114, 0.0056308540515601635, -0.056035518646240234, 0.016067853197455406, 0.0024349221494048834, 0.001051614060997963, 0.03573784604668617, -0.03307045251131058, 0.014552203938364983, 0.041639845818281174, 0.01950850896537304, 0.017808789387345314, -0.01738310419023037, -0.07402113825082779, 0.02326616458594799, 0.05432789400219917, 0.039114322513341904, -0.016973137855529785, -0.010425045154988766, 0.0065468731336295605, -0.0006079861195757985, 0.004916126374155283, -0.028590228408575058, 0.03164810314774513, 0.009355705231428146, 0.019155245274305344, -0.0598335936665535, -0.022090954706072807, -0.020990828052163124, 0.003263287479057908, 0.0069886199198663235, 0.022355729714035988, 0.03120248205959797, -0.03935198113322258, -0.021888133138418198, -0.005979255773127079, 0.036672454327344894, 0.021968362852931023, -0.025993019342422485, -0.012497427873313427, 0.041159309446811676, 0.008834942243993282, -0.029793063178658485, -0.03802025318145752, 0.03242902457714081, -0.00013943217345513403, 0.0034039791207760572, 0.041708804666996, -0.009475987404584885, -0.04639146104454994, 0.00724011892452836, -0.026436368003487587, 0.04355616122484207, -0.01025948952883482, -0.0016847809311002493, 0.05282781273126602, 0.03007456101477146, -0.001700953347608447, 0.06636590510606766, 0.046128835529088974, -0.017982594668865204, 0.03784395009279251, -0.022030863910913467, -0.017370501533150673, -0.020969698205590248, 0.018151400610804558, -0.020153822377324104, -0.01820535957813263, -0.0029696880374103785, 0.04216717928647995, 0.011290048249065876, 0.03996838629245758, -0.016830647364258766, -0.007345415651798248, 0.010341602377593517, 0.004269997589290142, 0.007696126122027636, 0.0013643642887473106, 0.005470434203743935, -0.02623404935002327, 0.004102925769984722, -0.024228407070040703, 0.028361734002828598, -0.041991736739873886, -0.010187039151787758, 0.006778854411095381, -0.029296504333615303, 0.015662722289562225, -0.03392087668180466, -0.04062379151582718, 0.02239178493618965, -0.059765856713056564, 0.04401608556509018, -0.014966722577810287, -0.002818624023348093, -0.008330309763550758, -0.060716744512319565, -0.03702165186405182, 0.03634973615407944, 0.018276575952768326, 0.046171389520168304, -0.029822833836078644, 0.03284212574362755, 0.003856524359434843, 0.009631026536226273, -0.0771804079413414, -0.05322790890932083, 0.05654631927609444, 0.011637206189334393, -0.04288545623421669, -0.0005608882638625801, -0.0002889347088057548, -0.0077591207809746265, 0.016770964488387108, -0.03341776132583618, 0.06142117828130722, 0.0032174731604754925, -0.03032839111983776, 0.018766358494758606, 0.05665887892246246, 0.057967282831668854, 0.04083967208862305, 0.011531890369951725, -0.017657417804002762, -0.026106620207428932, -0.031489048153162, -0.016000602394342422, -0.005385966971516609, -0.05453771352767944, -0.01281940657645464, -0.04908319562673569, 0.023933779448270798, 0.0442885160446167, -0.004854963161051273, 0.0062782010063529015, 0.019195478409528732, -0.003547975327819586, 0.0038240069989115, -0.05501623824238777, 0.013040483929216862, -0.030291017144918442, 0.004225186537951231, -0.005646777804940939, -0.015779385343194008, 0.00005321482240105979, 0.013423694297671318, -0.0047005596570670605, 0.008177919313311577, -0.06980198621749878, 0.02166176028549671, 0.06953609734773636, -0.004208953585475683, -0.01386422198265791, 0.018611395731568336, -0.04701942577958107, 0.009174292907118797, -0.0045305537059903145, -0.01326256338506937, 0.03397276625037193, 0.02315875142812729, -0.03328767418861389, 0.006660529412329197, -0.022045936435461044, 0.0023672289680689573, 0.05685867741703987, 0.034907471388578415, 0.03767334669828415, 0.08639977127313614, 0.02513069473206997, 0.03696142137050629, -0.019977742806077003, 0.010413525626063347, 0.0010369601659476757, -0.004861332010477781, 0.05344083905220032, -0.02352174185216427, 0.00176966970320791, 0.006430644076317549, 0.013819616287946701, 0.012579701840877533, 0.035795651376247406, 0.018606366589665413, 0.005997162312269211, 0.038805995136499405, -0.015407835133373737, -0.049587566405534744, 0.018536947667598724, -0.04604676738381386, -0.008316745981574059, -0.07049758732318878, -0.014354837127029896, 0.04307542368769646, 0.04603736102581024, 0.028053736314177513, -0.05840243771672249, -0.009340541437268257, -0.04369930550456047, -0.018877092748880386, -0.005320021882653236, 0.00016152021999005228, -0.011093373410403728, 0.019576000049710274, 0.05151069536805153, 0.016461366787552834, 0.02164554037153721, 0.000906123430468142, -0.05423456430435181, -0.030052488669753075, 0.041556671261787415, -0.0026406808756291866, 0.0315641425549984, -0.02662501484155655, -0.019904475659132004, -0.002293757628649473, -0.03512660786509514, 0.005300991702824831, 0.006648089271038771, 0.03690016642212868, -0.03089555725455284, 0.060887668281793594, -0.021259425207972527, 0.02417682856321335, 0.02047506719827652, -0.02428518421947956, 0.0951678603887558, 0.06803078949451447, 0.007383271586149931, -0.06438390910625458, 0.08170129358768463, -0.013809059746563435, 0.02030498906970024, -0.007146625779569149, 0.02647014893591404, 0.016353357583284378, -0.026657743379473686, 0.05977042764425278, 0.044632069766521454, 0.03354358673095703, -0.007614856120198965, 0.0490507148206234, -0.01064207497984171, -0.0411815382540226, -0.0006237095803953707, -0.01048247143626213, -0.003900158917531371, -0.027884608134627342, -0.0013526338152587414, -0.007058470509946346, -0.003826879896223545, 0.008459972217679024, -0.0013761332957074046, -0.036319054663181305, 0.008985609747469425, -0.012966077774763107, 0.007746582850813866, 0.0597819946706295, -0.008487516082823277, 0.013230450451374054, -0.06371214240789413, -0.014099347405135632, -0.011631255969405174, -0.04405781626701355, 0.028673851862549782, 0.0432492271065712, 0.0044816541485488415, -0.01628871262073517, 0.008389431051909924, -0.003470472525805235, -0.0315537191927433, -0.04460670053958893, -0.03386131674051285, 0.04018648713827133, 0.019268810749053955, -0.03306582197546959, -0.005370244849473238, -0.009877530857920647, -0.02628786489367485, -0.07485843449831009, -0.030148575082421303, 0.0006516888388432562, -0.005379498936235905, -0.00861191563308239, -0.0354628749191761, -0.052375733852386475, -0.025974145159125328, -0.013788086362183094, 0.040862053632736206, 0.02071860246360302, -0.006825349293649197, 0.004000998567789793, -0.02105996571481228, 0.05417254939675331, 0.007193895988166332, 0.0020191045477986336, 0.0011111493222415447, -0.020570307970046997, -0.029186882078647614, -0.004864219110459089, -0.019514400511980057, 0.01184706762433052, 0.03615439683198929, 0.004282632376998663, -0.008806119672954082, -0.024763016030192375, -0.018853848800063133, -0.013857710175216198, -0.016639534384012222, -0.012737741693854332, -0.021057182922959328, 0.007378898561000824, 0.028826141729950905, 0.03386128693819046, -0.000426028564106673, -0.004451545886695385, 0.004982439335435629, 0.03906431794166565, 0.04246639832854271, -0.07043344527482986, -0.0071226609870791435, -0.007794877514243126, -0.02213123068213463, -0.04459492862224579, -0.06559805572032928, 0.04542548581957817, -0.0018868872430175543, -0.0063955411314964294, -0.0016823298064991832, 0.02755500003695488, -0.05241287127137184, -0.007417266722768545, 0.04167898744344711, -0.039132650941610336, -0.011441762559115887, -0.015929406508803368, -0.004050170071423054, 0.007216006983071566, -0.0425976999104023, -0.028517259284853935, -0.02824755385518074, -0.018384357914328575, -0.032573431730270386, -0.013903198763728142, -0.009012855589389801, -0.014274473302066326, -0.002087464090436697, -0.036838505417108536, 0.016447611153125763, -0.04761833697557449, -0.039372947067022324, 0.01465898659080267, 0.047454338520765305, -0.016892192885279655, 0.028157159686088562, 0.005886271595954895, 0.0010333926184102893, 0.04231258109211922, 0.0025500489864498377, 0.009152477607131004, -0.015328990295529366, -0.005037444178014994, -0.002410114509984851, 0.026267724111676216, 0.031224412843585014, -0.03141355887055397, 0.059619732201099396, -0.052740421146154404, 0.003435184247791767, 0.01304174680262804, 0.020107317715883255, 0.04205329343676567, -0.011167346499860287, 0.00853138417005539, 0.006443703547120094, 0.05204622074961662, -0.011983259581029415, -0.04039810225367546, -0.0021426512394100428, -0.046859126538038254, 0.00512699456885457, -0.007749777752906084, -0.0038006771355867386, 0.05416609346866608, -0.006249906960874796, 0.03563253954052925, 0.04800034314393997, 0.011467701755464077, -0.025168146938085556, -0.017058115452528, 0.017845917493104935, 0.04082603007555008, 0.01420525275170803, -0.0035035265609622, 0.03239449858665466, 0.03908582776784897, -0.02397806942462921, 0.003512820228934288, -0.04880247637629509, -0.03260304778814316, -0.03166009113192558, 0.0014272419502958655, 0.008379112929105759, 0.03109825775027275, 0.025028659030795097, -0.07587029784917831, 0.007757925894111395, 0.01889314129948616, -0.011144859716296196, 0.03838402032852173, 0.002074198331683874, -0.042924344539642334, -0.019066590815782547, 0.01854955032467842, -0.0013253979850560427, 0.02529936097562313, 0.015610345639288425, 0.004463656805455685, 0.014296228066086769, 0.011680806055665016, 0.011919969692826271, -0.050534382462501526, 0.040918197482824326, 0.028064001351594925, 0.038175251334905624, -0.08430121839046478, 0.017328107729554176, -0.03153722360730171, -0.056950557976961136, 0.028361482545733452, -0.02426854334771633, 0.021638620644807816, 0.005888617131859064, 0.04420628771185875, 0.002218755893409252, 0.05151517316699028, 0.008142737671732903, -0.006832689046859741, -0.03236982971429825, 0.010610741563141346, -0.00611978629603982, 0.01371247973293066, -0.009608598425984383, 0.007591890171170235, -0.009151644073426723, -0.012654798105359077, -0.02408929541707039, 0.031775396317243576, -0.01861373893916607, -0.02999040298163891, -0.015741553157567978, -0.028510520234704018, 0.04025223106145859, -0.024195319041609764, 0.017399987205863, -0.05292293429374695, 0.0076121119782328606, 0.04103124141693115, -0.014317074790596962, 0.004859123844653368, 0.034088246524333954, -0.0026492218021303415, -0.03569420799612999, 0.035468690097332, -0.030865056440234184, -0.013723096810281277, -0.07114461809396744, -0.009709460660815239, -0.006758909672498703, -0.010638930834829807, -0.03809766471385956, -0.008752221241593361, -0.01753232628107071, 0.012107323855161667, -0.010920874774456024, -0.003214280353859067, 0.03751692175865173, -0.0127548947930336, 0.03161732479929924, -0.09000208973884583, 0.08232507854700089, 0.02450660429894924, -0.05388174206018448, -0.05246381089091301, -0.017959706485271454, -0.040045373141765594, 0.00019950435671489686, 0.05941739305853844, 0.00790299754589796, -0.019337082281708717, -0.01033177599310875, 0.027945561334490776, 0.0012720103841274977, -0.06635837256908417, 0.039144400507211685, -0.03830428794026375, 0.020063167437911034, 0.030310608446598053, -0.0033931515645235777, 0.00007620836549904197, 0.009824496693909168, 0.013453519903123379, -0.024029752239584923, 0.024853801354765892, -0.006119530647993088, -0.011827063746750355, 0.00703088566660881, -0.008911002427339554, -0.01142024900764227, 0.027719568461179733, -0.03298277407884598, 0.01583314873278141, 0.01766062341630459, -0.035496294498443604, -0.04560193046927452, 0.025111626833677292, -0.02010902762413025, -0.01975204423069954, 0.012311817146837711, -0.010840296745300293, -0.014858845621347427, -0.06861060857772827, -0.02880489081144333, 0.01029498316347599, -0.0010517232585698366, -0.012277267873287201, 0.04281388968229294, 0.055517639964818954, 0.003975315019488335, -0.016488345339894295, 0.012119879014790058, 0.020494753494858742, -0.019013117998838425, -0.009168644435703754, 0.03451774641871452, 0.04578385874629021, 0.022988881915807724, 0.01463982556015253, 0.016624093055725098, -0.019630050286650658, 0.029072748497128487, -0.015861205756664276, 0.030857786536216736, -0.010508479550480843, 0.026586836203932762, 0.03622667118906975, -0.017811516299843788, 0.003493765601888299, 0.01525133103132248, -0.004892991855740547, 0.05600840598344803, -0.061211440712213516, -0.008252928964793682, -0.019993774592876434, -0.008599062450230122, -0.05934438109397888, -0.004370963200926781, 0.08112913370132446, -0.002639119978994131, 0.008399838581681252, -0.005383617710322142, -0.02384902909398079, -0.015914572402834892, -0.009386380203068256, -0.04267234355211258, 0.028901653364300728, -0.003667871467769146, -0.01637042500078678, -0.020415032282471657, -0.019681774079799652, -0.03847175091505051, -0.02507626637816429, 0.0220271535217762, 0.0053389789536595345, 0.04771464318037033, -0.0345563180744648, -0.0061773392371833324, -0.024520710110664368, 0.031536735594272614, -0.050060831010341644, -0.04175172001123428, -0.04582004249095917, 0.05657992139458656, 0.04095415025949478, -0.025741925463080406 ]
<p>I have an experimental sample, size of about 1000 values​​. I need to generate a much larger sample for simulation. I can create a samples like this:</p> <pre><code>library(ks) x&lt;-rlnorm(1000) y&lt;-rkde(fhat=kde(x=x, h=hpi(x)), n=10000, positive = TRUE)# z&lt;-sample(x, 10000, replace = TRUE) par(mfrow=c(3,1)) hist(x, freq=F, breaks=100, col="red") hist(y, freq=F, breaks=100, col="green") hist(z, freq=F, breaks=100, col="blue") </code></pre> <p>What fundamental limitations when using KDE or bootstrap? How else can I create such a sample?</p>
36,822
[ -0.023026879876852036, -0.0018582161283120513, 0.024460716173052788, -0.00041337666334584355, 0.057086504995822906, -0.006643433589488268, -0.005529587622731924, -0.04464283585548401, 0.0017403311794623733, -0.018538163974881172, 0.03828703984618187, 0.0492032952606678, 0.048114292323589325, 0.04602626711130142, -0.0016178980004042387, -0.019106458872556686, -0.013457391411066055, -0.015174202620983124, -0.004918059799820185, -0.03118692897260189, -0.013853559270501137, 0.020267708227038383, 0.006117459386587143, -0.010932871140539646, 0.00448920764029026, 0.021333742886781693, 0.04721006006002426, -0.019434858113527298, 0.03565080463886261, 0.08116183429956436, -0.028392808511853218, -0.007406046614050865, 0.013213769532740116, 0.0692000687122345, 0.0009082029573619366, -0.017069850116968155, -0.030869226902723312, -0.06234902888536453, -0.012801666744053364, 0.007192529737949371, -0.043134890496730804, 0.007726040668785572, 0.005790866911411285, 0.01136249303817749, 0.011090573854744434, 0.004478441551327705, 0.005515701603144407, -0.05677071958780289, 0.04117707908153534, -0.006338086444884539, 0.0365581177175045, -0.004081860650330782, 0.03507155552506447, 0.053224850445985794, -0.022588083520531654, -0.03221624717116356, 0.04200109466910362, 0.07385695725679398, -0.006298063788563013, -0.03285500034689903, 0.010950502939522266, -0.049982864409685135, -0.011825434863567352, 0.004376186523586512, -0.026613187044858932, -0.014887266792356968, 0.020004218444228172, -0.02582051232457161, 0.010076560080051422, -0.03420529142022133, 0.04809059947729111, 0.00857782457023859, 0.030334729701280594, -0.017744120210409164, 0.025165218859910965, -0.023821882903575897, 0.01077132299542427, -0.0024229721166193485, 0.03475812450051308, 0.03979569673538208, -0.027571149170398712, 0.010979906655848026, 0.017795277759432793, -0.003630963386967778, 0.04543743655085564, -0.0021705215331166983, 0.04998620226979256, -0.03246498107910156, 0.04062690585851669, 0.02179056778550148, -0.05044493079185486, -0.010637175291776657, 0.061002615839242935, 0.030377807095646858, -0.023258306086063385, 0.023481763899326324, -0.01010798942297697, 0.0698934942483902, -0.02133128046989441, 0.0006151959532871842, 0.005426342133432627, -0.001998473657295108, 0.02726227417588234, 0.015163376927375793, -0.0022249871399253607, 0.0010374417761340737, -0.012022069655358791, -0.04792480170726776, 0.0007444403017871082, 0.001816343399696052, -0.029703309759497643, -0.0008783170487731695, -0.019462794065475464, 0.006479806266725063, 0.0436474084854126, -0.05970362573862076, -0.009338317438960075, 0.009761029854416847, 0.03662613779306412, 0.04388684779405594, 0.03806617483496666, 0.016419686377048492, 0.02042139135301113, -0.05282235145568848, -0.050960998982191086, 0.04448186233639717, -0.012277710251510143, -0.005441315472126007, -0.006468803156167269, 0.05597524344921112, 0.00036824290873482823, -0.01549948938190937, 0.048284195363521576, -0.0018288925057277083, 0.03435176610946655, -0.028865249827504158, -0.1029234454035759, -0.0568380244076252, 0.048291366547346115, -0.020094508305191994, 0.034392934292554855, -0.0424489788711071, -0.0017329005058854818, 0.01423334889113903, 0.041553135961294174, 0.024120869114995003, 0.046753354370594025, -0.014234042726457119, 0.02930098958313465, 0.03643406182527542, -0.09102404862642288, 0.009389461018145084, -0.03199880197644234, 0.006072337739169598, -0.0025248404126614332, -0.09095081686973572, 0.025837216526269913, 0.010116701945662498, 0.0024037372786551714, -0.00029737254953943193, 0.019936032593250275, 0.00022082588111516088, -0.004307179246097803, -0.012976282276213169, -0.021720565855503082, -0.022598041221499443, 0.09048878401517868, -0.0013097944902256131, 0.013546977192163467, -0.02638787403702736, -0.029069041833281517, 0.003738006576895714, 0.02427087351679802, -0.007963412441313267, 0.01786980777978897, -0.004984764382243156, 0.03389213606715202, -0.026010088622570038, 0.046905867755413055, 0.004684372805058956, -0.0290183387696743, 0.018457576632499695, 0.024951837956905365, -0.02707846090197563, 0.033728037029504776, 0.01745290495455265, -0.0029564565047621727, -0.018552066758275032, 0.05382148176431656, -0.05084306746721268, -0.0313088558614254, -0.054696984589099884, 0.026469523087143898, 0.013132566586136818, -0.01280410960316658, 0.003199267666786909, 0.02258378081023693, 0.028182102367281914, 0.002987702377140522, -0.04304104298353195, -0.03156004101037979, -0.018827859312295914, 0.050667449831962585, -0.006355013698339462, -0.007674262393265963, 0.0457775816321373, 0.03906138241291046, -0.01523437350988388, 0.018707800656557083, -0.024568112567067146, -0.036233969032764435, -0.004199791233986616, -0.03457482531666756, -0.01859375461935997, -0.01706821843981743, -0.02221231907606125, 0.013145241886377335, 0.019275961443781853, -0.0038277837447822094, 0.04439837485551834, -0.06146502122282982, 0.030371015891432762, 0.07685469835996628, 0.0023979758843779564, 0.006540306843817234, 0.011188426986336708, -0.001556845149025321, 0.0076644523069262505, -0.012974102050065994, 0.03211653605103493, -0.032237570732831955, 0.0012987268855795264, 0.059526748955249786, 0.00584340700879693, -0.031710512936115265, 0.029079582542181015, 0.06884388625621796, -0.03388656675815582, 0.0541696734726429, 0.05829804763197899, 0.020966647192835808, -0.0113243842497468, 0.009055176749825478, 0.018167920410633087, 0.05521220341324806, -0.02525459975004196, 0.017968451604247093, -0.027039125561714172, 0.03497050330042839, 0.011030728928744793, 0.004560430534183979, 0.02415715903043747, -0.02041654661297798, -0.00798799842596054, -0.007096744142472744, -0.025940963998436928, 0.014541592448949814, -0.01507918443530798, -0.009659811854362488, 0.0532376654446125, 0.015131416730582714, 0.03502332419157028, -0.03471182659268379, -0.018153244629502296, 0.014775986783206463, 0.045599039644002914, -0.036972809582948685, 0.017097579315304756, 0.01811077445745468, -0.048314474523067474, -0.006719506811350584, -0.04603075608611107, -0.01007068995386362, -0.08575771003961563, -0.012281621806323528, 0.025101033970713615, 0.007124691735953093, 0.02787211909890175, 0.00278488383628428, -0.01484051812440157, 0.020812412723898888, -0.012157542631030083, 0.029600951820611954, -0.01662617176771164, -0.023159358650445938, 0.010122953914105892, 0.029044119641184807, -0.03397500887513161, -0.003321613185107708, -0.0037075981963425875, -0.0245647132396698, -0.019856052473187447, -0.031037839129567146, -0.0026763579808175564, 0.0023357172030955553, -0.018038567155599594, 0.007320045959204435, -0.010213837958872318, 0.002680049743503332, 0.06857823580503464, 0.04183383285999298, -0.04982476308941841, 0.03596934303641319, -0.05003005266189575, -0.016569839790463448, -0.053528521209955215, 0.03134408965706825, 0.01863267458975315, -0.03158450871706009, -0.004401372745633125, 0.03538636863231659, -0.03876091167330742, -0.005764275323599577, -0.015165675431489944, -0.060481246560811996, -0.0007059708586893976, 0.018802402541041374, 0.046981051564216614, -0.027427373453974724, 0.038865961134433746, 0.0735233798623085, 0.04257632791996002, -0.021420171484351158, -0.06055450439453125, -0.05225928872823715, -0.038839682936668396, -0.027461938560009003, 0.007364068645983934, -0.006822006311267614, 0.009708894416689873, 0.03440411761403084, -0.019431207329034805, 0.02271624095737934, 0.04209065064787865, -0.00925357174128294, -0.007042227312922478, -0.009434948675334454, -0.029626261442899704, -0.034267909824848175, 0.05930151417851448, 0.04575153440237045, -0.05140591785311699, -0.019548168405890465, -0.01345220860093832, -0.004474301356822252, 0.004291830118745565, -0.05154041945934296, -0.021950507536530495, -0.008995342999696732, 0.05026144161820412, -0.05513415485620499, 0.005609795451164246, -0.006638030521571636, -0.03166141360998154, -0.008448377251625061, -0.0031381247099488974, 0.028689691796898842, -0.028850780799984932, -0.017029665410518646, 0.018027732148766518, 0.02645382471382618, -0.0013211988843977451, 0.022672170773148537, -0.0216118972748518, -0.013894342817366123, -0.01075011771172285, 0.009998834691941738, 0.010160645470023155, 0.021893160417675972, 0.0503808930516243, 0.02671712264418602, -0.005290498025715351, -0.005669570993632078, 0.005770980846136808, -0.013231861405074596, 0.010714934207499027, -0.039171040058135986, 0.05449425056576729, -0.0017375815659761429, 0.05960376560688019, 0.010741869919002056, -0.024535497650504112, -0.00962422788143158, -0.009034426882863045, -0.08180148154497147, 0.022291548550128937, 0.0044670444913208485, -0.002298187231644988, 0.023372812196612358, -0.027490055188536644, 0.028697723522782326, -0.036454375833272934, 0.021353963762521744, 0.008441888727247715, -0.018845437094569206, -0.028417112305760384, 0.0026385330129414797, -0.010566247627139091, 0.009661001153290272, -0.024354761466383934, 0.005123998504132032, 0.05683000013232231, -0.013331480324268341, 0.030643990263342857, 0.022787461057305336, -0.022651541978120804, -0.01072942279279232, -0.001100358902476728, 0.04305019974708557, 0.01467951387166977, 0.059076834470033646, 0.04067122936248779, 0.008306896314024925, -0.03439021483063698, 0.02518927864730358, 0.00350718991830945, 0.08029166609048843, 0.05118482559919357, -0.008070094510912895, -0.008094271644949913, -0.012610845267772675, -0.01304647233337164, -0.009857325814664364, -0.006006542593240738, -0.02373572625219822, -0.0066378237679600716, 0.04892803728580475, 0.013790648430585861, -0.039327383041381836, 0.021189909428358078, 0.05796066299080849, -0.0012726103886961937, -0.03727816417813301, -0.03793589025735855, 0.02132384665310383, 0.023777643218636513, -0.002006254391744733, 0.03198610991239548, 0.016855670139193535, 0.007665925659239292, 0.03751334920525551, 0.027391789481043816, -0.01595061831176281, -0.017298100516200066, 0.041111622005701065, 0.05492657423019409, 0.029321517795324326, -0.044382885098457336, -0.016193997114896774, -0.02885378710925579, -0.0008472949266433716, 0.03146308660507202, -0.012989654205739498, -0.04748372361063957, -0.08548831194639206, 0.01829250156879425, 0.026790717616677284, 0.032096777111291885, -0.03353187441825867, 0.014957665465772152, -0.05122017115354538, -0.0265507735311985, 0.03959540277719498, -0.06028767675161362, 0.03139811009168625, -0.053411126136779785, 0.010440848767757416, -0.016565049067139626, -0.011718454770743847, -0.0334329679608345, 0.025618024170398712, -0.03556647151708603, 0.00500263599678874, -0.010167740285396576, -0.011675826273858547, 0.0018366134027019143, 0.039083920419216156, 0.019164636731147766, 0.07835651934146881, -0.04434244707226753, -0.026952426880598068, 0.04615514352917671, -0.010480663739144802, -0.0065769292414188385, -0.0490296334028244, 0.025376832112669945, 0.0010710633359849453, 0.04139656201004982, 0.04229048267006874, -0.010327487252652645, -0.06357993185520172, 0.007177549414336681, 0.03010565973818302, -0.029054634273052216, -0.013030082918703556, -0.0010535507462918758, 0.012950691394507885, 0.0035364441573619843, 0.007524267770349979, 0.06180315837264061, -0.016884909942746162, 0.011549686081707478, 0.03379134088754654, -0.03410978242754936, 0.040313832461833954, -0.05481531843543053, 0.004122069105505943, -0.0584428533911705, 0.004520409740507603, -0.013081127777695656, 0.039040591567754745, 0.03413075953722, 0.037650175392627716, -0.03343014046549797, -0.019188299775123596, 0.017614370211958885, 0.028790922835469246, 0.011159487999975681, -0.007356206886470318, -0.04621197655797005, 0.006603602785617113, 0.00223523355089128, -0.012881572358310223, 0.017322896048426628, 0.014397154562175274, 0.010850511491298676, 0.018879752606153488, -0.04758167266845703, 0.007078433409333229, -0.043099839240312576, -0.030002061277627945, 0.003536966862156987, -0.01625198684632778, 0.03818203881382942, -0.016007907688617706, 0.04655591771006584, 0.017833735793828964, -0.02575012668967247, 0.028158674016594887, -0.00128405902069062, -0.03723782300949097, 0.057316940277814865, -0.036986853927373886, 0.025749804452061653, -0.004807814955711365, 0.010586624033749104, -0.08981337398290634, -0.0524822399020195, 0.04498562961816788, 0.013845211826264858, 0.030083728954195976, -0.02536967396736145, -0.02017420530319214, -0.0022065204102545977, 0.020619269460439682, -0.014737789519131184, 0.04991398751735687, -0.01145110186189413, 0.007722502574324608, -0.008390520699322224, 0.02081652730703354, 0.05152449384331703, -0.010265426710247993, 0.026569826528429985, 0.025971630588173866, -0.03345934674143791, -0.022832099348306656, 0.002334312070161104, -0.026688920333981514, -0.04214746505022049, 0.0039011079352349043, 0.004791325889527798, -0.03962470963597298, 0.05067373439669609, 0.0023352529387921095, -0.015081586316227913, 0.0042639863677322865, -0.009919356554746628, 0.01862183026969433, -0.06882372498512268, -0.001836043200455606, -0.036837223917245865, 0.03477255254983902, -0.037460070103406906, -0.028465772047638893, -0.02588045410811901, -0.012481732293963432, 0.03883270174264908, 0.003727769013494253, 0.030083835124969482, 0.012302279472351074, 0.05586755648255348, 0.0012299681548029184, -0.007865620777010918, -0.028743542730808258, -0.04320397973060608, 0.031041735783219337, 0.017720725387334824, 0.0022475305013358593, 0.010229388251900673, -0.01184399425983429, 0.006257245782762766, -0.033966295421123505, -0.024320129305124283, 0.008822216652333736, 0.03977931663393974, -0.0007062212098389864, 0.0389859676361084, 0.02676677331328392, 0.0028077303431928158, -0.005620456300675869, 0.005836020689457655, 0.015021502040326595, 0.00942146684974432, 0.02625325135886669, 0.06940793991088867, 0.05525292456150055, -0.036920491605997086, -0.008296535350382328, -0.0006538379238918424, 0.030056225135922432, 0.05614573881030083, 0.005267156753689051, 0.037760403007268906, 0.02868783101439476, -0.04608309641480446, -0.008372340351343155, 0.004189074970781803, -0.04544079303741455, 0.01572677679359913, -0.028816085308790207, -0.013831781223416328, 0.013578214682638645, 0.022434912621974945, -0.01486710924655199, -0.03917169198393822, -0.012160969898104668, -0.03483295440673828, 0.01497009675949812, 0.02145126461982727, -0.03217307850718498, 0.032387688755989075, -0.02385447360575199, 0.013123403303325176, -0.000590695533901453, 0.022131120786070824, -0.066487155854702, -0.09928788989782333, -0.04324590042233467, -0.05293060094118118, -0.08198507875204086, 0.03304734081029892, 0.006191474851220846, -0.05232956260442734, 0.02145138569176197, -0.024101894348859787, 0.04012693092226982, -0.031837306916713715, 0.060791969299316406, 0.016808848828077316, 0.05045224726200104, -0.0003528304514475167, 0.013252243399620056, -0.017100738361477852, -0.003976654727011919, 0.12458379566669464, 0.05944741889834404, 0.05612087622284889, -0.07325824350118637, 0.0391421876847744, -0.007453753147274256, -0.005992707796394825, -0.015155077911913395, 0.03897698223590851, 0.022007310763001442, -0.010814711451530457, 0.025592856109142303, 0.06014416366815567, -0.048718422651290894, 0.030927227810025215, 0.04329827055335045, -0.033272918313741684, 0.0213145948946476, 0.022366706281900406, 0.0071871280670166016, -0.014296659268438816, 0.004972155671566725, -0.07113386690616608, -0.008497878909111023, -0.01989789493381977, 0.004201058764010668, -0.021119510754942894, -0.032758694142103195, 0.008045506663620472, 0.02003522589802742, -0.026086920872330666, 0.0073842559941112995, -0.0056438930332660675, -0.021585213020443916, 0.018934030085802078, -0.014143680222332478, 0.0066825635731220245, -0.018078001216053963, -0.0030067400075495243, 0.04332020878791809, 0.020073017105460167, -0.020576218143105507, -0.022767893970012665, 0.00118133588694036, 0.009755461476743221, 0.0011552328942343593, -0.014821895398199558, 0.03443772345781326, -0.012157407589256763, 0.011967449449002743, -0.04161703959107399, 0.03248545899987221, -0.02349468320608139, -0.03005290776491165, -0.012268930673599243, 0.01833168976008892, 0.015554895624518394, -0.03217155486345291, -0.01863006316125393, -0.02782651036977768, 0.005354120396077633, -0.026987474411725998, 0.0104989567771554, 0.014119506813585758, -0.018867507576942444, 0.0003998339525423944, 0.009467643685638905, 0.02082366868853569, 0.023088110610842705, -0.0157290268689394, -0.005132770165801048, -0.004121200181543827, -0.05521838739514351, -0.009060797281563282, 0.03299778327345848, -0.012083055451512337, 0.005771860480308533, -0.027605528011918068, -0.00025784107856452465, -0.039279211312532425, 0.007605285849422216, 0.00612991489470005, -0.0009407236357219517, -0.04699499160051346, -0.015736745670437813, -0.009865649044513702, 0.017261028289794922, 0.04741854965686798, 0.005666340235620737, 0.00989576242864132, -0.03856101259589195, 0.035159073770046234, 0.003506176173686981, -0.05680915340781212, -0.03466019034385681, 0.018253035843372345, -0.03880820795893669, 0.012543917633593082, -0.04418162256479263, 0.07100226730108261, 0.006773845292627811, 0.016045521944761276, -0.006582350004464388, 0.05205383151769638, 0.002781190210953355, 0.03609379753470421, 0.05902368575334549, -0.030307797715067863, 0.023806363344192505, -0.011937195435166359, 0.017377903684973717, -0.016416750848293304, -0.03190336003899574, -0.0411033108830452, -0.031671371310949326, -0.006952193100005388, -0.05424267426133156, -0.0031723531428724527, 0.008242243900895119, -0.005128937773406506, 0.009516049176454544, -0.025679202750325203, 0.007972365245223045, -0.018026484176516533, 0.0015096920542418957, -0.02230254001915455, -0.018361134454607964, -0.01145816408097744, 0.0018234967719763517, -0.004022865556180477, 0.000986510538496077, 0.023465801030397415, 0.039151862263679504, 0.025948278605937958, 0.013981725089251995, -0.016642747446894646, 0.028485769405961037, 0.03704826161265373, -0.0496097095310688, 0.002899611834436655, 0.051197122782468796, -0.10114920139312744, -0.044092606753110886, -0.008940858766436577, -0.027063297107815742, 0.020466836169362068, -0.0018933891551569104, -0.01097155548632145, -0.01751890778541565, 0.029681507498025894, -0.012191416695713997, -0.0376693531870842, 0.004256664775311947, -0.012391897849738598, -0.0005955428350716829, 0.018432745710015297, 0.012561311013996601, -0.0065023023635149, -0.023333031684160233, 0.05119231715798378, 0.003455151105299592, -0.014203667640686035, -0.01543422881513834, -0.003907926380634308, 0.0081543680280447, -0.01109403744339943, -0.016863934695720673, 0.0041361404582858086, 0.07080221176147461, 0.04542689025402069, -0.07391013950109482, -0.0012035934487357736, -0.05261516943573952, 0.036377307027578354, -0.07794328033924103, -0.023265492171049118, -0.01836516708135605, -0.01264960877597332, 0.03123684786260128, -0.026764316484332085, -0.008310309611260891, 0.013015024363994598, -0.0860520675778389, 0.013882077299058437, 0.008000103756785393, 0.03818840906023979, -0.06604182720184326, -0.02809540182352066, -0.012666833586990833, 0.00964504573494196, 0.05473965033888817, 0.036288097500801086, -0.013200373388826847, 0.01983352191746235, 0.026642320677638054, 0.015801172703504562, -0.032319437712430954, -0.008230934850871563, -0.0202937088906765, -0.052957285195589066, 0.03939225897192955, -0.03148895129561424, -0.042083125561475754, 0.01787583716213703, -0.012825689278542995, 0.0303095243871212, 0.004797264467924833, 0.015999363735318184, 0.005880880635231733, 0.07768948376178741, 0.016067052260041237, -0.01735014095902443, 0.0011300493497401476, -0.016355343163013458, 0.01271800510585308, 0.014696807600557804, 0.0032012872397899628, 0.01385403797030449, 0.03319297358393669, -0.008684772066771984, -0.014091047458350658, 0.048129379749298096, -0.033418990671634674, -0.06650423258543015, 0.02164541743695736, 0.04153146594762802, 0.0054075345396995544, -0.01750326156616211, 0.00664497958496213, -0.028466321527957916, 0.027224252000451088, 0.026356449350714684, 0.038098208606243134, 0.015333052724599838, 0.015778379514813423, -0.03548503667116165, -0.05133820325136185, 0.00819507334381342, -0.03019183874130249, -0.028569158166646957, -0.043573345988988876, -0.007943625561892986, 0.019539549946784973, 0.017335545271635056, -0.004109418019652367, 0.009644727222621441, -0.009508245624601841, 0.02142507955431938, -0.03673611581325531, 0.05849369987845421, 0.012479925528168678, 0.0029936619102954865, 0.04144950583577156, -0.10407675057649612, 0.051202502101659775, -0.017376884818077087, 0.02010468579828739, -0.030718423426151276, -0.012665839865803719, -0.027081424370408058, 0.012716090306639671, 0.05721837282180786, 0.0305416788905859, -0.009118006564676762, -0.05086231604218483, 0.01936289481818676, 0.014714619144797325, -0.05231690779328346, 0.002894171280786395, -0.0133312176913023, 0.0020763776265084743, 0.013717321678996086, -0.015538197942078114, 0.03481404855847359, 0.017026836052536964, 0.03085244446992874, 0.035117585211992264, 0.028277598321437836, 0.014749731868505478, -0.0008260292233899236, 0.019151506945490837, -0.0054604834876954556, -0.03414731100201607, 0.03433917835354805, 0.02165032923221588, -0.02023705653846264, 0.034202940762043, -0.005428673699498177, -0.015655506402254105, 0.02227502129971981, -0.01647169329226017, -0.03311954066157341, -0.02191394567489624, -0.03450436890125275, -0.011560788378119469, -0.0450766459107399, -0.003670535748824477, 0.017290057614445686, -0.0510268397629261, 0.026882922276854515, 0.04435500502586365, 0.044419582933187485, 0.0281363595277071, -0.01115182600915432, -0.014055558480322361, -0.018914436921477318, -0.017647933214902878, -0.033960264176130295, -0.0043016900308430195, 0.0044252206571400166, -0.032710961997509, 0.020527968183159828, 0.0328010693192482, -0.0348694771528244, 0.0223861001431942, 0.009061473421752453, 0.050970207899808884, 0.03659071400761604, -0.03231923654675484, 0.013045447878539562, 0.032005686312913895, 0.02189810201525688, -0.016573796048760414, -0.002069991547614336, 0.052507586777210236, -0.02299519255757332, -0.008335067890584469, 0.004825740586966276, -0.014857225120067596, -0.03856590762734413, 0.0292154960334301, 0.014249295927584171, 0.019117625430226326, 0.00778552470728755, -0.002373982220888138, -0.0031958268955349922, 0.011299267411231995, 0.008975214324891567, -0.004291260149329901, 0.013682147487998009, -0.023450162261724472, 0.0012163054198026657, 0.06529666483402252, -0.005905002821236849, 0.016428044065833092, -0.017174089327454567, 0.01420329138636589, 0.030262595042586327, 0.01201641745865345, -0.033433809876441956, -0.053097836673259735, 0.0074227433651685715, 0.02305188961327076, -0.023309577256441116, -0.0024360776878893375, -0.0048952787183225155, 0.019985994324088097, -0.004086728673428297, -0.0025147665292024612 ]
<p>I am required to use the Naive Bayes classifier to classify example 8, to see whether it is poisonous or not. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/SnscY.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I gained the following results:</p> <p>p(x|Poisonous=Y) = 0.0267857 and </p> <p>p(x|Poisonous=N) = 0.0101989</p> <p>If I am given extra information at a later stage that there is a 0.05 chance of poisonous plants being found, hence 0.95 chance of them not being found. How should I go about classifying example 8 based on the new data?</p> <p>Any help would be appreciated.</p>
36,823
[ -0.03461044654250145, -0.073218934237957, 0.003147900803014636, -0.025189632549881935, 0.02276517078280449, 0.00014992356591392308, -0.019052613526582718, -0.0277315154671669, 0.01876753382384777, -0.03402338922023773, 0.04260733723640442, 0.06994321942329407, 0.03563738241791725, 0.05572143942117691, 0.007176618557423353, 0.04308684915304184, -0.01797947660088539, -0.012651276774704456, 0.01708344928920269, 0.00826198048889637, 0.0021590273827314377, -0.011063970625400543, 0.030965333804488182, -0.018440181389451027, -0.000613100070040673, 0.05127231031656265, 0.024597683921456337, -0.013487930409610271, 0.035121116787195206, 0.026579273864626884, -0.023966683074831963, -0.04633625969290733, 0.028622495010495186, 0.01492555346339941, 0.054484546184539795, 0.008368116803467274, -0.02541208453476429, -0.01713564619421959, -0.05335197597742081, 0.023595500737428665, -0.015318814665079117, -0.04074207320809364, 0.018732812255620956, 0.05162426084280014, -0.03467404842376709, 0.015062766149640083, -0.020809728652238846, -0.04263085126876831, 0.036270108073949814, -0.02831508032977581, 0.05100378766655922, -0.004120788536965847, 0.008790320716798306, 0.03194935619831085, 0.015089616179466248, -0.02748008444905281, 0.029624689370393753, 0.060000330209732056, -0.052227847278118134, -0.033311642706394196, -0.028263404965400696, -0.02913985773921013, -0.015567627735435963, -0.009430277161300182, -0.016530349850654602, 0.001605065306648612, -0.0025257819797843695, -0.04904528707265854, 0.01608376018702984, 0.0248549971729517, 0.01720672845840454, 0.02439868077635765, 0.018012486398220062, -0.0037297673989087343, 0.008307740092277527, -0.0007002875208854675, -0.014364159666001797, 0.09184408187866211, 0.03144444152712822, 0.002192562445998192, 0.04081014543771744, 0.02847442775964737, -0.010380402207374573, 0.054427873343229294, 0.018744057044386864, -0.05283348634839058, 0.038267940282821655, -0.014237861149013042, 0.015284695662558079, 0.012488720938563347, -0.022243568673729897, 0.009641844779253006, 0.06671039015054703, 0.006111531984061003, -0.028948167338967323, 0.025170575827360153, 0.005461405031383038, 0.03893986716866493, -0.01762666180729866, -0.01701977849006653, 0.004583174828439951, -0.036591727286577225, 0.03592391312122345, 0.06257638335227966, -0.02200249582529068, -0.03693753853440285, -0.03139890357851982, 0.012541620060801506, 0.010237853974103928, -0.0065077440813183784, -0.028474722057580948, 0.04684185981750488, 0.040937989950180054, 0.006108390633016825, -0.000545254850294441, -0.022038906812667847, -0.0066850329749286175, -0.018165558576583862, 0.03193683177232742, 0.061043862253427505, 0.03806226700544357, 0.005127153359353542, 0.054743390530347824, -0.0030567555222660303, -0.027226833626627922, -0.030716290697455406, 0.008592909201979637, -0.050138674676418304, -0.019418535754084587, 0.04923521354794502, -0.03744914382696152, 0.023243343457579613, 0.05170983821153641, -0.008344200439751148, 0.010779832489788532, 0.005540463607758284, -0.07742289453744888, -0.04099535197019577, 0.006558727007359266, 0.005531417205929756, -0.013126076199114323, -0.06459809094667435, -0.012416092678904533, 0.05025552958250046, 0.013429558835923672, -0.016945207491517067, 0.02329142391681671, 0.010958665981888771, 0.021179279312491417, 0.018246669322252274, -0.023639999330043793, -0.003108535660430789, 0.00034362878068350255, -0.025744684040546417, -0.032291390001773834, -0.0713370069861412, 0.018591895699501038, 0.017207438126206398, -0.03547919541597366, -0.03392590954899788, 0.02901553176343441, -0.01435204315930605, -0.010094022378325462, -0.025731097906827927, -0.02859005145728588, -0.005093354731798172, 0.08423347771167755, 0.03420336917042732, 0.019695473834872246, 0.030533740296959877, 0.0077085718512535095, 0.059145767241716385, -0.002190376864746213, 0.004771646112203598, 0.0413256511092186, 0.01718105748295784, 0.005517289042472839, -0.008969679474830627, 0.03830579295754433, 0.01698128506541252, -0.003109581768512726, 0.0006593545549549162, -0.04427409544587135, 0.016458338126540184, 0.015734510496258736, 0.03612691909074783, 0.021115392446517944, -0.02562030963599682, 0.009336644783616066, -0.03724048659205437, -0.05303734540939331, -0.11068814992904663, -0.019915824756026268, -0.027047641575336456, -0.03873607516288757, -0.001429086783900857, 0.020975977182388306, -0.001385882031172514, -0.030380427837371826, 0.03272118791937828, -0.05903175473213196, -0.010415357537567616, 0.034711144864559174, -0.06627701967954636, -0.03493620827794075, 0.09087983518838882, 0.015824485570192337, -0.013045582920312881, 0.054419029504060745, -0.049509622156620026, -0.023957056924700737, -0.025790099054574966, -0.017065320163965225, -0.01648980937898159, 0.004451998509466648, -0.024366766214370728, 0.02591109089553356, -0.0050399648025631905, -0.008692559786140919, 0.020918115973472595, -0.052073851227760315, 0.0844353437423706, 0.06597182899713516, 0.0010156122734770179, 0.022587062790989876, -0.02123422548174858, 0.0007335986592806876, 0.048619914799928665, -0.005132061429321766, -0.01561625674366951, -0.05469835177063942, -0.0032366574741899967, 0.0349622443318367, 0.030969198793172836, -0.04146909713745117, 0.012033302336931229, 0.034017857164144516, -0.011499272659420967, 0.013410788029432297, 0.0192891675978899, 0.01675327681005001, -0.004709340166300535, 0.04793316498398781, 0.019295988604426384, -0.005599699914455414, -0.001415940118022263, 0.006403682287782431, 0.022521911188960075, 0.03556586429476738, -0.008524385280907154, -0.005200070329010487, 0.04964391514658928, -0.03253302723169327, 0.040111243724823, 0.02593269571661949, -0.005303936079144478, 0.04042806103825569, -0.004546805284917355, -0.022721344605088234, 0.022828716784715652, -0.010475419461727142, 0.010853422805666924, -0.0005113031947985291, -0.015831459313631058, 0.060451406985521317, 0.05191962048411369, -0.035316742956638336, 0.04308555647730827, 0.01975497044622898, -0.049983344972133636, 0.004206490237265825, 0.03531073033809662, -0.018432902172207832, -0.013852392323315144, 0.04509832337498665, 0.051867011934518814, -0.002476004185155034, 0.018424175679683685, -0.02242388017475605, 0.004325789399445057, -0.0006617126055061817, -0.008863196708261967, 0.007224089466035366, 0.016497129574418068, -0.06516845524311066, -0.01856181211769581, -0.03757698833942413, -0.020771866664290428, 0.03355680778622627, -0.006822226103395224, -0.03254108130931854, 0.005970089230686426, -0.007119891699403524, -0.0090749841183424, 0.0001667903270572424, -0.045653048902750015, 0.017228489741683006, -0.0242165494710207, -0.013841059058904648, -0.016838114708662033, 0.01044160034507513, 0.00649861479178071, 0.05191374570131302, -0.01276848278939724, -0.02743293158710003, -0.036043282598257065, 0.0024825306609272957, -0.03297673538327217, 0.01387848611921072, 0.0006968697416596115, -0.005633885972201824, -0.01755380630493164, -0.003135277424007654, -0.07359930872917175, -0.08110764622688293, -0.016225682571530342, 0.05442027002573013, 0.011628822423517704, 0.007811176590621471, 0.018123632296919823, 0.10448429733514786, 0.029175080358982086, -0.03974088281393051, -0.02432049624621868, -0.010745810344815254, -0.05018838867545128, 0.006300066132098436, -0.008636793121695518, 0.022546375170350075, 0.0027341190725564957, -0.0008511064224876463, -0.012480827048420906, 0.02478938363492489, 0.06967591494321823, -0.011399137787520885, -0.026364479213953018, 0.0258592888712883, -0.010089450515806675, -0.015559830702841282, 0.05497812479734421, 0.05144387111067772, -0.03329116478562355, 0.014185874722898006, -0.014135402627289295, 0.02211819775402546, 0.029648955911397934, -0.006173953413963318, -0.017265914008021355, 0.011882085353136063, 0.04659300670027733, -0.027050066739320755, 0.041324447840452194, -0.010293648578226566, -0.016094103455543518, 0.00992283783853054, -0.026508934795856476, 0.0345732681453228, -0.02282818965613842, -0.015975788235664368, 0.05511196702718735, 0.037974514067173004, 0.0044204192236065865, -0.005940481089055538, -0.015189879573881626, -0.01486912276595831, 0.022238584235310555, -0.0046335733495652676, 0.004725441802293062, 0.02621634118258953, 0.05644631013274193, 0.037162069231271744, 0.012701489962637424, -0.04317786172032356, 0.014905968680977821, -0.021540744230151176, -0.032198596745729446, -0.026493407785892487, 0.01212435681372881, -0.008590699173510075, 0.03566968813538551, 0.015234509482979774, -0.02453913912177086, 0.03564072772860527, 0.02072039246559143, -0.04486662894487381, 0.03336664289236069, -0.008861606009304523, -0.0008615069091320038, -0.021892143413424492, -0.025574125349521637, -0.007315083406865597, -0.0497514083981514, 0.05638858303427696, 0.022188855335116386, 0.016188068315386772, -0.04217015951871872, 0.004528663121163845, -0.013451451435685158, 0.014313841238617897, -0.017822526395320892, 0.01767655275762081, 0.027450555935502052, 0.0005636331043206155, 0.02784368209540844, 0.020080026239156723, -0.030039304867386818, -0.008953040465712547, -0.00566888740286231, -0.012576473876833916, 0.025712020695209503, -0.006022998597472906, 0.003987304866313934, 0.032975561916828156, -0.04211156815290451, -0.019106168299913406, 0.011063765734434128, 0.0824991837143898, 0.04825666919350624, 0.0006450922228395939, -0.00062898377655074, -0.03600160777568817, 0.000721702235750854, -0.0039048723410815, 0.019231116399168968, -0.014846667647361755, 0.013287020847201347, 0.009846091270446777, -0.0065465522930026054, -0.07138760387897491, 0.021841106936335564, 0.05470157414674759, 0.0022352535743266344, -0.005853702314198017, -0.007420538924634457, -0.015294796787202358, -0.04038574546575546, -0.0289907306432724, 0.029331231489777565, 0.05135501176118851, -0.01980612985789776, 0.006151935085654259, 0.030706560239195824, 0.027960604056715965, -0.03280167281627655, 0.008259451948106289, -0.004549250937998295, 0.015772653743624687, -0.004378559533506632, -0.018733732402324677, 0.017674336209893227, 0.03741223365068436, 0.006235936190932989, -0.02284587174654007, -0.01605880819261074, -0.07940036058425903, -0.03438866138458252, 0.05304913595318794, 0.07116533070802689, -0.03170103579759598, -0.016227498650550842, -0.07005228847265244, -0.007570305839180946, 0.044897764921188354, -0.044021643698215485, 0.013158180750906467, 0.000505952222738415, 0.006529413163661957, -0.004089517518877983, -0.011600355617702007, -0.062377575784921646, -0.0020150383934378624, -0.035444922745227814, 0.08722084015607834, -0.012408360838890076, -0.05350324884057045, -0.046321213245391846, -0.038978978991508484, 0.009754763916134834, 0.04369243606925011, -0.04568173736333847, -0.03544734790921211, 0.002295293379575014, -0.007822171784937382, -0.016752144321799278, -0.03114783763885498, 0.022225698456168175, -0.026148607954382896, 0.01815549097955227, 0.06360971927642822, -0.028381358832120895, -0.03615415096282959, 0.0402202233672142, 0.010826795361936092, -0.03276782110333443, -0.01895599439740181, -0.0014491697074845433, 0.021352890878915787, 0.04828605055809021, 0.016384869813919067, 0.013118874281644821, 0.017681658267974854, 0.020936397835612297, 0.006933961529284716, -0.03443650156259537, -0.009600293822586536, -0.03360915929079056, 0.004778038244694471, -0.059474967420101166, -0.0055285729467868805, -0.0010797767899930477, 0.046218305826187134, 0.04286180064082146, 0.004387283697724342, -0.020447509363293648, -0.02226974070072174, 0.032765425741672516, 0.012572209350764751, -0.00008523975702701136, -0.0263845045119524, -0.025502672418951988, 0.02029549330472946, 0.007551177404820919, 0.04107989743351936, 0.01828020252287388, -0.02214386686682701, 0.03437409549951553, -0.0013967726845294237, -0.04215111583471298, 0.03663695976138115, -0.044793374836444855, -0.00862042885273695, 0.03424602374434471, -0.03801650553941727, 0.05978963524103165, 0.022553905844688416, 0.05416925624012947, 0.010689119808375835, -0.02355802245438099, -0.02330079860985279, -0.015745539218187332, 0.009260917082428932, 0.04819008335471153, -0.04667884483933449, 0.013261384330689907, -0.03553604707121849, -0.009195689111948013, -0.04161716625094414, -0.014802573248744011, 0.016708480194211006, 0.01809137687087059, -0.055868227034807205, -0.023111173883080482, -0.0029858725611120462, 0.010093843564391136, -0.023325318470597267, -0.011544463224709034, 0.06510185450315475, -0.026718031615018845, -0.018404284492135048, -0.0007323452737182379, -0.02206476218998432, 0.06213732436299324, 0.007060626056045294, 0.024606989696621895, 0.00430141668766737, -0.017778318375349045, 0.006649971939623356, -0.016386277973651886, 0.013673212379217148, -0.050173692405223846, -0.005837765522301197, -0.02266939915716648, 0.01941104419529438, 0.03206121176481247, -0.0004501250514294952, -0.009751292876899242, -0.026983851566910744, 0.002697072457522154, -0.02715405635535717, -0.013641906902194023, 0.005995148792862892, 0.0076823849231004715, -0.007027844432741404, -0.03711609169840813, 0.03100561909377575, 0.013445763848721981, -0.007525434251874685, 0.01914846897125244, -0.011828494258224964, 0.009710236452519894, -0.01230149157345295, 0.037692464888095856, -0.034647371619939804, 0.007388443220406771, 0.010582772083580494, -0.045303378254175186, -0.00026347729726694524, 0.014075538143515587, -0.03898352012038231, -0.0017077401280403137, 0.03801535442471504, -0.039025597274303436, 0.012505927123129368, -0.06060107797384262, 0.024193011224269867, 0.060588862746953964, 0.049677807837724686, 0.02307562530040741, 0.021710198372602463, 0.04739651829004288, -0.03215616196393967, -0.019162500277161598, -0.011196277104318142, -0.01830087974667549, 0.03949311375617981, 0.04267803207039833, 0.01042452547699213, 0.03808193653821945, 0.06240467727184296, -0.014864523895084858, 0.013149046339094639, 0.0521845743060112, 0.04779816418886185, 0.004455185495316982, 0.02763795107603073, -0.026383373886346817, -0.03652055561542511, 0.029758848249912262, -0.020244058221578598, 0.028588149696588516, -0.012703006155788898, -0.06859759986400604, 0.04682689160108566, 0.02396545186638832, -0.024542570114135742, -0.06971043348312378, -0.00146109436172992, -0.03636490926146507, 0.0076981112360954285, 0.022439802065491676, 0.0010416939621791244, 0.04306915029883385, 0.014866132289171219, 0.01700170896947384, -0.024463433772325516, 0.009664144366979599, -0.030590426176786423, -0.0693337693810463, -0.032213740050792694, -0.007149154786020517, -0.03689366206526756, 0.012364734895527363, 0.01896539144217968, -0.04822619631886482, 0.02690204232931137, -0.0330892950296402, 0.021453846246004105, -0.008949202485382557, 0.03694932535290718, 0.012111958116292953, 0.034708816558122635, -0.007126985117793083, 0.025657450780272484, 0.012383797205984592, 0.029932579025626183, 0.12964388728141785, 0.05593954026699066, 0.032323285937309265, -0.037883371114730835, 0.0234031043946743, 0.009794571436941624, -0.0009725741692818701, -0.00531601021066308, -0.0028764107264578342, 0.041134562343358994, -0.01032355334609747, -0.008934997953474522, 0.004866815637797117, -0.00789082981646061, -0.014950511045753956, 0.06628779321908951, -0.010711977258324623, -0.028691953048110008, -0.006784775760024786, 0.03364795818924904, -0.012148356065154076, 0.010120430029928684, -0.0547557957470417, 0.0323999784886837, -0.008207683451473713, -0.02117740735411644, -0.017246006056666374, -0.027138659730553627, 0.007856851443648338, 0.021690746769309044, 0.01961798593401909, -0.01498163491487503, 0.010003911331295967, -0.009274514392018318, 0.004083539824932814, 0.006385870277881622, 0.030458975583314896, -0.04506166651844978, -0.011990678496658802, 0.028994936496019363, -0.00003196201578248292, -0.02835514396429062, 0.01636810041964054, 0.04927888140082359, -0.0475584901869297, -0.05296678468585014, -0.014131244271993637, 0.05228135734796524, 0.016062041744589806, 0.0000812381476862356, 0.008805425837635994, -0.0043070195242762566, 0.007232197560369968, -0.08471774309873581, -0.022049855440855026, 0.04660485312342644, 0.016813592985272408, -0.03510411083698273, -0.03809128701686859, -0.00545791769400239, 0.004365306347608566, -0.03250546008348465, 0.01195121556520462, 0.0332164391875267, 0.008883031085133553, -0.043248992413282394, -0.025655806064605713, -0.005147248972207308, 0.016165491193532944, 0.014373552054166794, -0.00676993653178215, -0.016382616013288498, -0.0032056591007858515, -0.012657387182116508, -0.008429399691522121, 0.024033840745687485, -0.010510746389627457, -0.007142710033804178, -0.035488493740558624, -0.01747152954339981, -0.04795712232589722, 0.013508465141057968, -0.03545650094747543, -0.003657919354736805, -0.02787581831216812, -0.0014435873599722981, 0.009073249064385891, 0.023054098710417747, 0.010537785477936268, 0.03169186785817146, 0.03289341926574707, 0.038939327001571655, 0.02132885344326496, -0.05434643477201462, -0.0028520445339381695, 0.006346356589347124, -0.049020227044820786, 0.017912955954670906, 0.03016398847103119, 0.08643103390932083, 0.027802087366580963, 0.021330952644348145, 0.025204189121723175, 0.022944483906030655, -0.011676290072500706, 0.02780318632721901, -0.017568200826644897, -0.01898929849267006, -0.03890907019376755, 0.001846291939727962, 0.0014745363732799888, -0.0496983677148819, -0.05291419476270676, -0.004313265904784203, -0.0319194532930851, 0.031507279723882675, -0.026461472734808922, -0.036585599184036255, -0.010966750793159008, -0.012210403569042683, 0.0044885966926813126, -0.017709486186504364, 0.0034319537226110697, -0.024792660027742386, -0.033999234437942505, -0.001866933424025774, -0.012323779053986073, -0.022833632305264473, 0.03085979074239731, -0.023500608280301094, -0.006759725045412779, 0.013907317072153091, 0.01831391267478466, 0.038306549191474915, -0.03860658407211304, 0.016120528802275658, -0.007133523467928171, 0.03988497704267502, -0.01814315654337406, 0.02520206943154335, 0.0392281711101532, -0.05007975921034813, -0.0034659244120121002, 0.01634647324681282, 0.018296673893928528, 0.05562087893486023, 0.03401250019669533, -0.0009040289442054927, 0.013168750330805779, 0.0439717099070549, -0.014350013807415962, -0.022298606112599373, 0.024029836058616638, -0.006404670886695385, -0.029932484030723572, 0.014443501830101013, -0.004303979687392712, 0.017733538523316383, -0.006280297413468361, -0.003388558514416218, -0.00404431764036417, 0.029784411191940308, -0.0342346727848053, 0.016046347096562386, -0.031037533655762672, 0.00995360966771841, -0.006572275888174772, -0.01412968710064888, 0.025245964527130127, 0.042105525732040405, -0.0110255042091012, 0.06406567245721817, -0.041610900312662125, -0.004750107880681753, -0.046978581696748734, -0.014460382983088493, 0.03574400022625923, -0.011654087342321873, 0.04752284288406372, -0.04617421329021454, -0.0071332091465592384, 0.04988053813576698, -0.03726344555616379, -0.001442516571842134, 0.02360285446047783, 0.0019570165313780308, -0.03253236785531044, 0.040193527936935425, -0.022228216752409935, 0.033124711364507675, 0.02098764479160309, 0.0402553491294384, 0.06817818433046341, 0.014226765371859074, -0.019804852083325386, -0.05153801292181015, 0.018985996022820473, 0.060114938765764236, 0.0008702321210876107, -0.05940362438559532, -0.0035779024474322796, -0.0665518268942833, -0.007804452441632748, 0.049413587898015976, 0.025547247380018234, 0.03047744557261467, 0.03928205370903015, 0.005210784263908863, 0.010499526746571064, 0.05902479588985443, 0.01918880082666874, -0.010090661235153675, 0.018657146021723747, 0.008520228788256645, 0.0029536839574575424, 0.0018505011685192585, 0.0004275696410331875, -0.008671486750245094, -0.0020397293847054243, -0.025731997564435005, -0.015236574225127697, -0.014453430660068989, -0.006901800632476807, -0.025201579555869102, 0.011705504730343819, -0.02471647784113884, -0.00421362929046154, -0.013149126432836056, -0.03865761309862137, -0.03336189314723015, 0.03467041626572609, 0.06114724650979042, 0.014845390804111958, -0.009025274775922298, -0.005548099521547556, -0.040451377630233765, -0.06506537646055222, -0.036827947944402695, 0.011084691621363163, -0.027054447680711746, -0.047706447541713715, 0.03476458415389061, -0.02174333855509758, 0.02344505861401558, 0.02653380297124386, 0.017810385674238205, -0.039622992277145386, 0.01708775758743286, -0.04148884117603302, -0.0003053811378777027, 0.021146902814507484, 0.007374726701527834, 0.001199843711219728, -0.055142126977443695, 0.06810995936393738, 0.0229608453810215, -0.03872842714190483, -0.06066335737705231, -0.008025772869586945, -0.043729037046432495, -0.008732426911592484, 0.018359575420618057, -0.012058236636221409, 0.0020059840753674507, -0.0279044508934021, 0.015559499152004719, 0.0009284716215915978, -0.06908303499221802, 0.05543747916817665, 0.01900390535593033, -0.02503851428627968, 0.015792174264788628, 0.009583225473761559, 0.029043029993772507, 0.026473812758922577, 0.005711415782570839, -0.014212261885404587, -0.006756564136594534, 0.005965977907180786, -0.006113829091191292, -0.00045370988664217293, -0.02661808580160141, 0.01028312835842371, 0.03871774300932884, -0.007469847798347473, -0.002336824545636773, 0.023068800568580627, -0.006980129983276129, -0.04255013167858124, 0.033944252878427505, -0.04563363641500473, -0.042574621737003326, 0.02545943483710289, -0.02624301053583622, 0.017191804945468903, -0.11328475922346115, -0.00286634243093431, 0.008599070832133293, -0.01932431571185589, -0.027911316603422165, 0.016026834025979042, -0.009220442734658718, 0.04894864559173584, -0.022381313145160675, 0.05014190077781677, -0.02013450302183628, -0.010629544965922832, 0.020639566704630852, -0.04333668574690819, 0.01928229071199894, -0.005330930929630995, 0.03671965375542641, 0.034051939845085144, -0.015781432390213013, -0.001833941088989377, -0.005537763703614473, 0.022478554397821426, -0.042074646800756454, 0.01158537995070219, 0.031603895127773285, -0.01924794539809227, 0.013564459048211575, 0.024017244577407837, 0.004787066485732794, 0.06379710882902145, -0.011796359904110432, 0.016710929572582245, -0.03924766182899475, -0.02510748989880085, -0.030052868649363518, 0.012971642427146435, 0.016321687027812004, 0.009486806578934193, -0.012397347949445248, 0.006426296662539244, 0.007064411882311106, 0.01938166841864586, 0.049836937338113785, -0.0335291363298893, 0.008078967221081257, -0.04823661968111992, -0.020033929497003555, -0.007046846207231283, -0.004572032950818539, -0.013749765232205391, 0.033867254853248596, -0.007501593790948391, 0.055023856461048126, 0.043809954077005386, -0.01232300978153944, -0.05506850406527519, 0.012801822274923325, 0.027454130351543427, -0.04200015589594841, 0.010933580808341503, -0.07990723848342896, -0.00597746716812253, -0.009284457191824913, -0.058210596442222595 ]
<p>This is probably a far too basic question for this board - but on the other hand, I know I'll get good answers. "Stats 101" is a metaphor, by the way. I'm asking for help with my work, not my homework!</p> <p>I am looking at aggregate financial data for hospitals. I have identified two hospital systems that accumulate unusually large operating surpluses (profits) compared to their peers - in the 8% to 12% range when the standard for a non-profit hospital is 3%. This amounts to hundreds of millions of dollars after expenses. I created a metric by dividing these profits by annual case-adjusted admissions and the results negate volume or mix of patient type as reasons for the difference. I've also looked at expenses and they are about the same as peer hospital, so low expenses is not an explanation, either. This suggests pricing as the remaining reason for the difference.</p> <p>Only aggregate data is available - I do not have case-level data. By simply ranking my list of 85 hospitals, the annual "profit per patient" for these two hospitals rises to the top of the list. The difference between these two hospitals is great enough that I am certain that the variance would be statistically significant if I ran the right test. I'd like to do that - show that it is highly unlikely that this is chance variation.</p> <p>Can you recommend the best test to run on these figures? By the way, I do not have access to SPSS or SAS through my employer, so I'd likely be trying this in Excel or possibly Access.</p>
38,185
[ -0.05421357974410057, -0.03941633552312851, -0.027781322598457336, -0.01848449744284153, 0.04232153296470642, 0.000956266070716083, 0.02722546085715294, 0.014396586455404758, 0.021594906225800514, -0.01619410701096058, 0.019894272089004517, 0.08579161763191223, 0.03711827099323273, 0.02731272578239441, 0.009931436739861965, 0.004215741530060768, -0.015851778909564018, 0.012149902991950512, 0.004041737411171198, 0.012706861831247807, 0.0043000224977731705, 0.027229413390159607, 0.0020564498845487833, -0.022536851465702057, -0.06943219155073166, 0.04320041090250015, -0.0033899310510605574, -0.06095857173204422, 0.003921257331967354, 0.05685841664671898, -0.047012947499752045, 0.006649900693446398, 0.02429840713739395, 0.04207691550254822, 0.023961903527379036, 0.008128682151436806, -0.023572025820612907, 0.0031859292648732662, -0.03648301959037781, 0.05764244496822357, -0.028393762186169624, -0.02342298813164234, -0.014069909229874611, 0.01358826830983162, -0.017000962048768997, 0.01950768008828163, 0.008891870267689228, -0.010203580372035503, 0.032280560582876205, -0.06056937947869301, 0.0644993782043457, 0.005125139839947224, 0.05677777901291847, 0.021298201754689217, -0.016312126070261, -0.005053867120295763, 0.012879380024969578, 0.06238379329442978, -0.015260353684425354, -0.0493236668407917, -0.02817719429731369, 0.0246756412088871, 0.006607832852751017, -0.011406303383409977, -0.03975594788789749, -0.014163002371788025, -0.00997009128332138, -0.03650068864226341, 0.06203924119472504, 0.008577567525207996, 0.03668525442481041, 0.030499091371893883, 0.03410673141479492, -0.0038597453385591507, 0.003401972819119692, -0.024478426203131676, 0.026084931567311287, 0.007969096302986145, 0.011493667960166931, 0.04344925284385681, -0.011359091848134995, -0.017663607373833656, 0.02292454242706299, 0.051281385123729706, 0.022085966542363167, -0.01902122236788273, 0.05280806124210358, -0.0497840978205204, 0.03484338894486427, 0.02492520958185196, 0.01496005430817604, -0.01357619185000658, 0.04918735474348068, 0.017661551013588905, -0.06174550950527191, 0.021871762350201607, -0.036796290427446365, 0.03774812072515488, 0.00519431522116065, -0.011811302043497562, -0.012228269129991531, -0.02499944344162941, 0.015914296731352806, 0.017187532037496567, -0.04722612351179123, 0.0056345295161008835, -0.04088401421904564, -0.009207171387970448, -0.013527868315577507, 0.02992299385368824, -0.025491876527667046, 0.007241853978484869, 0.036689020693302155, -0.013614381663501263, 0.014258713461458683, -0.007529358379542828, -0.031920772045850754, -0.023134786635637283, 0.043785303831100464, 0.05355839431285858, 0.06772618740797043, -0.030358143150806427, 0.018594123423099518, -0.044985707849264145, -0.000018878818082157522, 0.017299342900514603, -0.009779461659491062, -0.03665643930435181, -0.05202421545982361, 0.08196860551834106, 0.011180602945387363, -0.018351946026086807, 0.042624033987522125, -0.009249970316886902, 0.0195868331938982, -0.018192851915955544, -0.054539378732442856, -0.06386356800794601, 0.030960073694586754, 0.023549774661660194, 0.004605559632182121, -0.057256799191236496, 0.0013430314138531685, 0.010636175982654095, 0.02973756566643715, 0.010087884031236172, 0.02134871296584606, -0.002300140680745244, 0.00046121166087687016, 0.009683295153081417, -0.03630068153142929, 0.012461218982934952, 0.021947983652353287, -0.0234055332839489, -0.009943487122654915, -0.08693471550941467, -0.025168389081954956, 0.046160537749528885, 0.0023020694497972727, -0.04619425907731056, 0.019108042120933533, 0.0490952804684639, -0.006283533293753862, -0.00810012873262167, 0.011716686189174652, 0.009475614875555038, 0.057551659643650055, -0.018969319760799408, -0.014480258338153362, 0.03493621572852135, 0.0044531323947012424, 0.01824885420501232, 0.007751546800136566, 0.033136602491140366, 0.015365826897323132, -0.032147374004125595, 0.02341740019619465, -0.03430383652448654, -0.0070402049459517, -0.0005523936706595123, -0.0404663160443306, -0.013687808066606522, -0.0566270612180233, -0.03520537540316582, 0.02286754921078682, 0.0484098456799984, -0.007831830531358719, -0.013318167068064213, 0.047594260424375534, -0.040030889213085175, -0.06994569301605225, -0.07223069667816162, 0.009464466013014317, -0.006590953096747398, -0.05063438042998314, 0.026544665917754173, -0.00599173316732049, 0.010765381157398224, -0.04990764334797859, 0.025934021919965744, -0.010707887820899487, -0.018046129494905472, 0.0651252269744873, -0.043844323605298996, 0.03416550159454346, 0.038887422531843185, 0.054646871984004974, -0.046004436910152435, 0.02982957474887371, -0.04337479546666145, -0.042727187275886536, 0.017418701201677322, -0.040099140256643295, 0.011157416738569736, 0.010206266306340694, -0.019631361588835716, 0.018625332042574883, 0.02261992357671261, -0.02728564664721489, 0.05770452320575714, -0.060710810124874115, 0.0577826201915741, 0.04567438364028931, 0.008177836425602436, -0.004931121598929167, 0.018956558778882027, 0.02645968832075596, 0.01817663013935089, -0.006544178817421198, -0.010853170417249203, -0.045511700212955475, 0.005693348124623299, 0.03487535938620567, -0.006327699404209852, -0.009704641066491604, 0.04062880203127861, 0.0723450630903244, 0.008687262423336506, -0.0018010055646300316, 0.002086095977574587, -0.04779861122369766, 0.008249594829976559, 0.004823826719075441, 0.03333619236946106, 0.016305148601531982, 0.01859525963664055, 0.012543111108243465, 0.03553115576505661, 0.03966699540615082, -0.0012563708005473018, 0.05313536897301674, 0.025886021554470062, -0.013073340058326721, 0.047207996249198914, -0.010757497511804104, -0.013258730992674828, 0.06265588849782944, -0.030227692797780037, 0.004199582152068615, 0.04589681699872017, -0.005783515516668558, -0.003159275511279702, -0.031213361769914627, -0.05319130793213844, 0.048420049250125885, 0.014611128717660904, -0.054138828068971634, 0.03750087693333626, 0.016462087631225586, -0.021484799683094025, 0.037434861063957214, -0.01704942062497139, 0.007899309508502483, -0.036306172609329224, 0.00971572007983923, 0.018882229924201965, 0.0036255947779864073, 0.020284920930862427, -0.0061569963581860065, -0.013019435107707977, 0.051979273557662964, -0.04002266004681587, -0.0028697459492832422, 0.01646989956498146, -0.010591024532914162, 0.007376541383564472, 0.006434146780520678, 0.006610306911170483, 0.04942043870687485, -0.00893227569758892, -0.009599688462913036, 0.03519868478178978, 0.02103946916759014, -0.05667095631361008, 0.022409582510590553, -0.01580820232629776, 0.027300413697957993, -0.007287738379091024, -0.03105597384274006, 0.01104338001459837, -0.006991592235863209, -0.022534871473908424, 0.021409636363387108, -0.0230991430580616, -0.0073812599293887615, -0.00214939471334219, 0.026504235342144966, 0.015065858140587807, -0.02705569751560688, -0.030933374539017677, -0.003534460673108697, -0.02781892940402031, -0.011338172480463982, -0.0432024821639061, -0.03929734230041504, 0.004817551001906395, -0.02197323553264141, 0.021088838577270508, -0.028376737609505653, -0.06399669498205185, 0.009976880624890327, 0.0454181544482708, -0.022151395678520203, -0.053222447633743286, -0.01984255388379097, -0.033120982348918915, -0.024222830310463905, 0.0492333360016346, 0.05038827657699585, -0.013977442868053913, 0.02171744778752327, 0.01557124312967062, 0.05566305294632912, 0.03377070277929306, 0.013234012760221958, -0.0029102382250130177, 0.023777352645993233, 0.00289405370131135, 0.007833963260054588, 0.04425627365708351, 0.013244520872831345, -0.03011135943233967, -0.009540621191263199, 0.017299514263868332, 0.02209557592868805, -0.02357412315905094, -0.06841282546520233, 0.012452991679310799, 0.006992722395807505, 0.004689228255301714, -0.03132356330752373, -0.015763908624649048, 0.009336460381746292, 0.013526806607842445, -0.009229169227182865, -0.009545362554490566, 0.008441939018666744, -0.03224748745560646, 0.008101014420390129, 0.06425410509109497, 0.026191841810941696, -0.011609944514930248, -0.004009076859802008, -0.02526720240712166, -0.02041202038526535, 0.03999016806483269, -0.05763795226812363, -0.03572244197130203, 0.05635229870676994, 0.04407218471169472, 0.04257294163107872, -0.014280675910413265, -0.057418741285800934, 0.03672816604375839, -0.06859336048364639, -0.011410492472350597, -0.017454367130994797, 0.04914240911602974, -0.0019276883685961366, 0.05292576551437378, 0.018889378756284714, -0.016946641728281975, -0.005760103464126587, -0.01923936977982521, -0.0290174912661314, 0.022316837683320045, 0.0042678541503846645, 0.025004317983984947, 0.01795237511396408, -0.016599735245108604, -0.005723239853978157, -0.004849743098020554, 0.009475776925683022, -0.01076348964124918, 0.03161253407597542, -0.0344976931810379, 0.02265152335166931, -0.014056636020541191, 0.0092557268217206, 0.0010628667660057545, 0.0013979981886222959, -0.036859434098005295, 0.0030037355609238148, 0.031051257625222206, 0.011521201580762863, 0.009088112972676754, -0.0177144892513752, -0.014651939272880554, 0.02848166972398758, -0.004223667085170746, 0.04268810898065567, 0.0045001613907516, 0.005394556559622288, 0.0036736277397722006, 0.03567824512720108, 0.026099801063537598, 0.016363568603992462, 0.03298082575201988, 0.0026099514216184616, -0.0035309551749378443, -0.033947598189115524, -0.011553514748811722, 0.02165422961115837, 0.02191476710140705, 0.025228427723050117, -0.027507901191711426, 0.07448063045740128, 0.03884657844901085, -0.03658710792660713, 0.0017799786292016506, 0.059799619019031525, -0.0001830133842304349, 0.008325116708874702, -0.01900164783000946, -0.0052913278341293335, -0.019180038943886757, -0.03251728042960167, 0.041659846901893616, 0.017091089859604836, -0.016797246411442757, -0.008530307561159134, 0.03722844272851944, -0.009022379294037819, -0.009614984504878521, 0.00298495520837605, -0.008810586296021938, 0.01566832698881626, 0.011451872065663338, -0.01157391257584095, 0.04564521834254265, 0.016796808689832687, 0.02534693479537964, 0.03823444992303848, 0.01323028840124607, -0.08259094506502151, -0.014892969280481339, 0.07145853340625763, 0.05060407146811485, -0.03422197699546814, -0.02500697411596775, -0.019095642492175102, 0.01634269952774048, 0.0533619299530983, -0.02638304978609085, -0.0050652725622057915, 0.0024600443430244923, 0.0210019089281559, 0.019310276955366135, -0.005931283812969923, -0.028891511261463165, 0.007518502417951822, -0.019770842045545578, 0.04304319620132446, -0.04320098087191582, -0.019889608025550842, -0.03186986967921257, -0.012577067129313946, 0.0440223328769207, 0.08458365499973297, -0.025150109082460403, -0.05571385473012924, 0.0001299426658079028, 0.035710886120796204, -0.03237280249595642, -0.07965122163295746, 0.02160114236176014, -0.0046493886038661, 0.012739816680550575, 0.07423022389411926, -0.014224320650100708, -0.026198627427220345, -0.031032979488372803, -0.01431132573634386, -0.015223413705825806, 0.042674556374549866, 0.005969866178929806, 0.022022288292646408, 0.0352821908891201, 0.04140297695994377, 0.05971900373697281, 0.008026122115552425, 0.0043947515077888966, 0.004344299901276827, -0.0063645364716649055, 0.02354739047586918, -0.011892292648553848, -0.031099265441298485, -0.016303524374961853, 0.005460143089294434, -0.012146522291004658, -0.004228801466524601, 0.01185538712888956, 0.06772875785827637, -0.036236219108104706, 0.024658139795064926, 0.01661539077758789, 0.026830676943063736, 0.007344347424805164, 0.015688788145780563, -0.00906821433454752, 0.003711041761562228, -0.001355254789814353, -0.004821584094315767, 0.019431250169873238, -0.042833324521780014, -0.01456966158002615, 0.009820095263421535, -0.06411395221948624, 0.006826616358011961, -0.02070142701268196, 0.0023282954934984446, 0.002686907071620226, -0.01934506557881832, 0.019944120198488235, -0.017518308013677597, 0.046689391136169434, 0.03006371110677719, -0.03372357040643692, -0.043481871485710144, 0.011242352426052094, 0.015465723350644112, 0.04763365164399147, -0.013799617998301983, 0.03663516044616699, -0.035767607390880585, -0.023442348465323448, -0.07446837425231934, -0.02590370737016201, 0.06078623980283737, 0.05171839892864227, -0.05177929997444153, 0.008306505158543587, 0.011443348601460457, -0.01949913613498211, 0.000862128974404186, -0.03649657592177391, 0.07749524712562561, -0.02831239439547062, -0.015793832018971443, 0.0020597612019628286, -0.0028383794706314802, 0.09451615810394287, -0.024187609553337097, -0.011653557419776917, -0.024172460660338402, -0.011917267926037312, -0.010447988286614418, -0.0217365100979805, 0.0068763489834964275, -0.02643609419465065, -0.06088633835315704, -0.028718572109937668, -0.03776757791638374, 0.031627025455236435, -0.05590860918164253, 0.018579237163066864, 0.0133729949593544, -0.013998212292790413, 0.03322078660130501, 0.01805427484214306, 0.029697148129343987, -0.030502676963806152, 0.03635718673467636, -0.03383379057049751, -0.005631998647004366, -0.012871094979345798, 0.014312082901597023, -0.007225699722766876, 0.03638075664639473, -0.0008151309448294342, 0.030600612983107567, 0.06206653639674187, -0.0005538192926906049, -0.0225849486887455, 0.00522599508985877, -0.00030370286549441516, 0.014740219339728355, 0.018093684688210487, -0.0017914334312081337, -0.018764924257993698, 0.04389769956469536, -0.022084932774305344, -0.0030030151829123497, -0.02853401005268097, 0.02740154042840004, 0.06325416266918182, 0.04920760914683342, 0.03371337801218033, 0.051500994712114334, 0.019419405609369278, -0.03490343317389488, -0.03724325820803642, -0.006400188896805048, -0.006938946433365345, 0.013398364186286926, 0.0380999855697155, -0.039261817932128906, -0.006629281211644411, 0.050386253744363785, 0.015776555985212326, 0.008575581014156342, 0.028815899044275284, 0.02766910009086132, 0.007271067705005407, 0.06323406845331192, 0.004987157881259918, -0.049033261835575104, 0.029470836743712425, -0.03820044919848442, 0.04147005453705788, -0.06140844523906708, -0.04059130698442459, 0.06129545345902443, 0.02214112877845764, -0.025583164766430855, -0.045364439487457275, -0.010758113116025925, -0.03104334883391857, -0.010274361819028854, -0.003580433549359441, -0.02891806699335575, 0.028927916660904884, 0.03778836503624916, 0.021800097078084946, -0.00010314848623238504, 0.0017864708788692951, -0.045573826879262924, -0.0686916783452034, -0.004698399920016527, 0.00992682483047247, -0.0537496842443943, 0.032710105180740356, -0.04396473988890648, -0.04168315604329109, 0.0006933482363820076, -0.040344901382923126, -0.01380937546491623, 0.00616148067638278, 0.011847046203911304, 0.0075834644958376884, 0.058055028319358826, 0.02658972144126892, 0.016267623752355576, -0.008429347537457943, 0.004167291335761547, 0.1132495328783989, 0.04565095901489258, 0.0019862528424710035, -0.060671366751194, 0.011967460624873638, -0.028398307040333748, 0.013055723160505295, -0.02989140897989273, 0.038113970309495926, 0.024674348533153534, -0.0043393829837441444, 0.07678504288196564, 0.06348484754562378, 0.028436115011572838, -0.020758843049407005, 0.04936307296156883, -0.01563199795782566, 0.008297816850244999, 0.0022646605502814054, 0.011466254480183125, 0.01600826345384121, -0.021497879177331924, -0.020929856225848198, 0.0297329630702734, 0.005609414540231228, -0.012247703969478607, -0.014779110439121723, -0.0141722047701478, 0.0026308384258300066, 0.021894829347729683, -0.013025307096540928, 0.019703766331076622, 0.01412790734320879, -0.008657286874949932, -0.03019825369119644, -0.014196358621120453, 0.0058970823884010315, -0.07104024291038513, -0.016216611489653587, 0.03913508728146553, 0.013690919615328312, -0.03757568448781967, -0.009652460925281048, 0.015155855566263199, -0.04307287931442261, 0.009426235221326351, -0.017545511946082115, 0.02873123437166214, -0.015682220458984375, -0.024478496983647346, -0.043835967779159546, -0.029448682442307472, -0.01781311072409153, -0.047705307602882385, -0.0026192127261310816, -0.030784767121076584, -0.0036878783721476793, -0.020717885345220566, -0.009531053714454174, -0.026382409036159515, 0.007770126219838858, -0.011245626024901867, 0.03517373651266098, -0.0011125121964141726, -0.03409561142325401, -0.06953919678926468, -0.027816904708743095, 0.005984069779515266, -0.013144065625965595, 0.019957806915044785, 0.0341045968234539, -0.01423150859773159, -0.04258435219526291, -0.005655392538756132, -0.016505390405654907, 0.0005083587602712214, 0.03133914992213249, 0.02237049676477909, 0.0011093727080151439, 0.02894754149019718, -0.048837386071681976, 0.008805088698863983, -0.0029605466406792402, -0.013656838797032833, -0.06572632491588593, 0.003203708678483963, -0.012255243957042694, 0.015189951285719872, 0.026680730283260345, 0.04047638550400734, -0.012397545389831066, 0.08090941607952118, -0.022466035559773445, -0.06639394164085388, -0.03590643033385277, -0.040580593049526215, -0.03233407810330391, -0.02081422135233879, 0.0008985712775029242, 0.0562439039349556, -0.02461247891187668, 0.013241978362202644, 0.005044511053711176, 0.007502022664994001, -0.011652760207653046, 0.036356497555971146, 0.015416096895933151, -0.06002354621887207, -0.0175953209400177, 0.02344350516796112, -0.016452834010124207, -0.03601425141096115, -0.019845273345708847, -0.01575658656656742, -0.005031948909163475, -0.02054176665842533, 0.00817046407610178, -0.008146019652485847, 0.0009287727880291641, -0.0040363734588027, 0.018338564783334732, -0.030032379552721977, -0.00811940710991621, -0.030379286035895348, -0.0328974686563015, 0.018326979130506516, 0.030786193907260895, -0.009435501880943775, 0.01133221946656704, 0.005506529938429594, -0.012312346138060093, 0.049687113612890244, 0.0009218588238582015, -0.0002194453263655305, 0.030872534960508347, -0.004086135886609554, 0.013562818057835102, 0.024251701310276985, -0.04477445036172867, -0.0037055620923638344, 0.05056547746062279, -0.023828553035855293, -0.032331205904483795, -0.004312711302191019, -0.01061635185033083, 0.022073740139603615, -0.011001338250935078, -0.004857698455452919, -0.0299580879509449, 0.04172519966959953, -0.04526627063751221, -0.013436716049909592, -0.05085967853665352, 0.04736629128456116, 0.02198084630072117, -0.03143683820962906, -0.0075751421973109245, 0.004748458508402109, -0.02556728385388851, 0.013023773208260536, 0.01006410550326109, -0.04084175452589989, -0.008258052170276642, 0.0067869690246880054, -0.010313800536096096, -0.0046766274608671665, 0.03251010179519653, 0.038951046764850616, 0.06505046784877777, 0.023241272196173668, -0.03252410516142845, 0.04099428653717041, -0.009382645599544048, 0.01002277061343193, -0.06561587750911713, -0.03747996315360069, -0.026879511773586273, -0.013235852122306824, -0.0017480571987107396, -0.031143654137849808, -0.016904078423976898, 0.013505672104656696, -0.07680097222328186, 0.0012912492966279387, -0.008184120059013367, -0.03472333401441574, -0.058838583528995514, 0.010667010210454464, -0.011928281746804714, 0.011556479148566723, -0.012216157279908657, 0.00823996216058731, 0.025337696075439453, 0.017911089584231377, 0.012341798283159733, -0.010544249787926674, 0.003945696167647839, 0.010118627920746803, 0.02130446955561638, -0.06478868424892426, 0.006179738789796829, -0.03737418353557587, -0.04996127635240555, 0.025523750111460686, 0.0006100006867200136, 0.02915494702756405, 0.010891358368098736, -0.010673478245735168, 0.0023525601718574762, 0.05221924930810928, 0.012152151204645634, 0.02779574878513813, -0.005510369315743446, -0.021646341308951378, -0.012800774537026882, 0.04719790816307068, -0.0063215699046850204, 0.03988547623157501, 0.06835968047380447, -0.021589914336800575, -0.006926602218300104, -0.03446013107895851, -0.012241070158779621, -0.021099457517266273, 0.0003752106276806444, -0.03705913573503494, 0.03703662380576134, -0.0006142797647044063, 0.055978089570999146, -0.06580236554145813, 0.027400527149438858, 0.07210159301757812, 0.029875800013542175, -0.0169615987688303, 0.03956752270460129, -0.015932200476527214, -0.010069707408547401, 0.012629140168428421, 0.012566938064992428, -0.02314436063170433, -0.009998614899814129, -0.006389946676790714, -0.034747250378131866, -0.014231345616281033, 0.010642102919518948, -0.017219040542840958, -0.00803686399012804, 0.025804847478866577, -0.014248006045818329, -0.008866151794791222, 0.03637059032917023, 0.021724892780184746, 0.028326425701379776, -0.09906315058469772, 0.02572682872414589, 0.0039091575890779495, 0.008544107899069786, -0.04233875870704651, -0.04239335656166077, -0.06438717991113663, 0.004250463098287582, 0.07692109048366547, 0.013278977945446968, 0.011267323046922684, -0.015067375265061855, 0.008327334187924862, -0.027357881888747215, -0.04368741810321808, 0.057349614799022675, -0.020210949704051018, -0.034426599740982056, -0.0006517277215607464, 0.013740450143814087, 0.021988578140735626, -0.016601407900452614, 0.014219006523489952, -0.04708874598145485, -0.0015316758072003722, 0.0074820686131715775, -0.013120759278535843, 0.004585007671266794, -0.0026886865962296724, -0.03181286156177521, 0.05647433549165726, -0.0014074814971536398, 0.022055694833397865, 0.027815164998173714, -0.007674084976315498, -0.07005969434976578, 0.04071442037820816, -0.018350547179579735, -0.018798774108290672, 0.010747885331511497, 0.0002355259784962982, -0.02207314781844616, -0.03826985880732536, 0.03171165660023689, 0.030567118898034096, -0.044228456914424896, 0.02303747460246086, 0.04468032717704773, 0.042719949036836624, 0.002375977113842964, -0.025927668437361717, 0.011749438010156155, -0.025146394968032837, -0.020458688959479332, -0.014387033879756927, -0.009326339699327946, 0.038128018379211426, -0.008277488872408867, 0.020168600603938103, 0.05492525175213814, -0.02247403748333454, 0.020333532243967056, -0.01776583306491375, 0.03904284909367561, -0.025340136140584946, -0.0292104072868824, 0.015589343383908272, 0.006251924205571413, 0.01967165432870388, -0.010679654777050018, -0.004342983476817608, 0.06338545680046082, 0.008775413036346436, 0.04046658053994179, -0.03778735548257828, 0.0148911252617836, -0.017785167321562767, -0.03804226964712143, 0.031569771468639374, 0.020490987226366997, -0.03482535853981972, -0.03340272232890129, 0.049457352608442307, 0.030962886288762093, -0.00504178274422884, 0.00045636395225301385, 0.021262362599372864, -0.032346323132514954, -0.013354092836380005, -0.030501097440719604, -0.012198560871183872, 0.010665830224752426, -0.005300457123667002, 0.011725605465471745, 0.03677426651120186, 0.03518068417906761, -0.009014283306896687, -0.03568720072507858, 0.0029335797298699617, 0.06223734840750694, -0.05258035659790039, -0.024347811937332153, -0.04308394715189934, 0.016513705253601074, -0.000882307009305805, -0.0499141551554203 ]
<p>I wonder if <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorical_data" rel="nofollow">categorical data</a> by definition can only take finitely or countably infinitely many values? And no more i.e. not uncountably many values? </p> <p>Related question: is the distribution of a categorical variable always a discrete distribution or a continuous distribution?</p> <p>Thanks and regards!</p>
74,143
[ -0.0512792244553566, -0.012918244116008282, 0.0384148471057415, -0.004525030497461557, 0.04826951399445534, 0.006780174095183611, -0.011524251662194729, -0.007028235588222742, 0.0019215119536966085, -0.031543854624032974, 0.01428522914648056, 0.011519171297550201, 0.02277522161602974, 0.03193053975701332, 0.018152184784412384, 0.01873316429555416, -0.039567980915308, 0.036395832896232605, -0.012602252885699272, 0.02009817399084568, 0.0031474062707275152, 0.07072652876377106, 0.04003780335187912, -0.004894895013421774, -0.012937075458467007, 0.02345520816743374, 0.03951914235949516, 0.008109554648399353, 0.04430143162608147, 0.05583079159259796, -0.0016006387304514647, -0.037423714995384216, 0.021759454160928726, 0.0374942384660244, 0.017609242349863052, -0.002664148574694991, -0.08007555454969406, -0.03800376132130623, 0.0035388432443141937, -0.011126752011477947, -0.022802263498306274, -0.023462090641260147, -0.0003624432720243931, 0.033281248062849045, 0.00034944474464282393, 0.0011198535794392228, 0.008513553999364376, -0.05771433562040329, 0.010179547592997551, -0.022791696712374687, 0.1018499955534935, -0.007874909788370132, 0.060350216925144196, 0.014609047211706638, -0.004231822211295366, -0.003933111671358347, 0.05291479453444481, 0.06113360449671745, -0.021461108699440956, -0.0483250729739666, -0.016812564805150032, -0.021894609555602074, 0.009404675103724003, -0.019701411947607994, -0.01145118661224842, 0.03784632310271263, -0.013143147341907024, -0.03228645399212837, 0.02820000611245632, 0.0008440284291282296, 0.04171502962708473, 0.03425507992506027, 0.038938574492931366, 0.0164349228143692, 0.014904561452567577, -0.000021385119907790795, 0.04761546105146408, -0.00008574328967370093, 0.032336607575416565, 0.049109991639852524, 0.011962498538196087, 0.02102135680615902, 0.03641456365585327, 0.00971288327127695, 0.020548099651932716, -0.03317200392484665, 0.05276549234986305, -0.01549096405506134, 0.02409505844116211, 0.01051569078117609, -0.018055787310004234, -0.04048921912908554, 0.01411446463316679, -0.00910788495093584, -0.07044388353824615, 0.05036351829767227, -0.01025186013430357, 0.027409495785832405, -0.00638223672285676, -0.027103735134005547, 0.04936090111732483, -0.0363023467361927, 0.028963247314095497, 0.054871752858161926, -0.03162485361099243, 0.032009366899728775, -0.025037167593836784, 0.028798749670386314, -0.02012837678194046, -0.029195237904787064, -0.02100980281829834, 0.026167528703808784, 0.04099467769265175, 0.015052703209221363, 0.020639101043343544, -0.014095653779804707, 0.0032153551001101732, -0.0021115336567163467, 0.03275484964251518, 0.07761115580797195, 0.054869771003723145, -0.04270927235484123, 0.006421146914362907, -0.014980435371398926, -0.04264585301280022, 0.0049176327884197235, 0.009740734472870827, 0.018704785034060478, -0.03082142025232315, 0.05258440226316452, -0.04520157352089882, -0.012279927730560303, 0.04233501851558685, -0.0025254744105041027, 0.04414396360516548, -0.008366404101252556, -0.08966007828712463, -0.019106708467006683, -0.0062481374479830265, -0.012615959160029888, -0.01570502109825611, -0.0563364252448082, 0.041239116340875626, 0.030878642573952675, 0.009663771837949753, 0.011254115961492062, 0.04525149241089821, 0.010484465397894382, 0.015692923218011856, 0.032256558537483215, -0.04002919793128967, 0.023880984634160995, -0.0014202778693288565, -0.043196436017751694, -0.01055447943508625, -0.08363239467144012, 0.04803670942783356, -0.0011590071953833103, 0.030676882714033127, -0.043285273015499115, 0.01828775554895401, 0.010372304357588291, 0.00017782619397621602, 0.025027288123965263, 0.006897029932588339, -0.011917728930711746, 0.05904363840818405, 0.004269690718501806, 0.05719462409615517, 0.04063926264643669, 0.006108688190579414, 0.03310537710785866, 0.04619548097252846, 0.0774526447057724, 0.04456055909395218, -0.003182336688041687, -0.028779393061995506, -0.039474546909332275, 0.05493875592947006, 0.004430674947798252, -0.05246000736951828, 0.005759903229773045, -0.008825459517538548, 0.014332937076687813, 0.026232736185193062, 0.016144627705216408, 0.008702962659299374, -0.04257073998451233, 0.015201928094029427, -0.07918047904968262, -0.04283680394291878, -0.0286264605820179, 0.03414308279752731, -0.040937360376119614, -0.0004745647020172328, 0.02655216120183468, 0.03305504471063614, -0.025601640343666077, -0.05369978025555611, -0.025936543941497803, -0.020448345690965652, -0.03887087479233742, 0.014813488349318504, -0.06696116924285889, 0.003235217649489641, 0.06561288982629776, 0.01241670548915863, 0.004908915609121323, 0.03559093922376633, -0.024679498746991158, -0.05819011479616165, -0.013361841440200806, -0.034524105489254, 0.05309216305613518, -0.01202858705073595, -0.0005345167592167854, 0.012400060892105103, 0.030674895271658897, -0.05849674716591835, 0.05394216626882553, -0.04906507208943367, 0.04567752778530121, 0.04807606339454651, 0.012025358155369759, -0.010193142108619213, 0.009944871068000793, -0.0006405242020264268, -0.03729050233960152, -0.014822382479906082, -0.0184173621237278, -0.08240049332380295, 0.030047856271266937, 0.02663329802453518, 0.011226404458284378, -0.030657365918159485, 0.005782101769000292, 0.026497328653931618, 0.06054403632879257, 0.023378903046250343, 0.011985636316239834, -0.02396460808813572, 0.000407789193559438, -0.006563246715813875, 0.009657235816121101, 0.0209516491740942, -0.0038265527691692114, 0.03302554786205292, -0.009685694240033627, 0.04599481448531151, -0.00803940650075674, -0.01611831597983837, 0.05407135933637619, -0.03875436633825302, 0.009889205917716026, 0.01839636266231537, -0.020644018426537514, 0.034145206212997437, -0.0351036973297596, -0.004294203594326973, 0.026230638846755028, -0.0053893583826720715, -0.024117054417729378, 0.010156737640500069, 0.009069645777344704, 0.007019426207989454, 0.046744152903556824, -0.0684516504406929, -0.023030219599604607, 0.01877524144947529, -0.018167423084378242, -0.006620026659220457, -0.041991204023361206, -0.04356243088841438, -0.034615084528923035, 0.0074211666360497475, 0.030249349772930145, -0.005653268191963434, 0.02440181002020836, -0.013032598420977592, -0.027790261432528496, -0.010663694702088833, -0.054178837686777115, 0.020809154957532883, 0.008510035462677479, -0.04976595193147659, -0.005104974377900362, -0.02098207361996174, -0.03469539061188698, 0.03727434203028679, -0.019844962283968925, -0.002097825286909938, 0.01670534908771515, -0.042042095214128494, -0.031128764152526855, 0.02563069388270378, -0.012833784334361553, 0.022552119567990303, -0.035832904279232025, -0.0070909676142036915, 0.004306050483137369, -0.0016128707211464643, -0.027876729145646095, -0.004311222117394209, -0.04781091585755348, -0.0681912750005722, -0.040738120675086975, 0.011812638491392136, 0.04725923016667366, -0.028384387493133545, 0.010200696997344494, -0.011048516258597374, -0.03158344700932503, 0.004911381285637617, -0.07086563855409622, -0.057907696813344955, 0.0182157251983881, -0.023523874580860138, 0.034532323479652405, 0.004100893624126911, -0.013456831686198711, 0.07860954850912094, 0.04555449262261391, -0.053795162588357925, 0.0034335199743509293, -0.016970938071608543, -0.0059457505121827126, 0.0005798934726044536, 0.013683044351637363, -0.013825911097228527, 0.011567676439881325, -0.006075210403650999, 0.018436767160892487, 0.03227362036705017, 0.0076373605988919735, -0.004007077310234308, -0.022644827142357826, 0.028725774958729744, 0.027167590335011482, -0.005861835554242134, 0.015951236709952354, 0.03723914176225662, -0.044566016644239426, 0.0249316468834877, -0.015990518033504486, 0.05186324194073677, -0.014211532659828663, -0.007274550851434469, 0.01351012010127306, -0.018245281651616096, 0.0024405878502875566, -0.04146631807088852, 0.055250439792871475, -0.0006586733506992459, -0.03782111033797264, 0.008288450539112091, 0.03908633813261986, 0.02468826062977314, -0.0413656011223793, 0.003382755909115076, 0.04498451575636864, 0.061511896550655365, -0.048901867121458054, -0.019390450790524483, 0.004880751483142376, -0.022413719445466995, 0.06398467719554901, -0.015967778861522675, -0.00410840380936861, 0.034658558666706085, 0.02491024322807789, 0.04129986837506294, -0.011070257052779198, -0.02687401883304119, 0.014364135451614857, -0.058087579905986786, -0.012133324518799782, -0.024684244766831398, 0.039227865636348724, 0.009059659205377102, 0.036823466420173645, 0.005754758603870869, 0.015230773948132992, -0.01268357690423727, 0.03686338663101196, -0.07926740497350693, -0.025818997994065285, -0.02162308618426323, 0.016436520963907242, -0.0069837612099945545, -0.04244408383965492, 0.02293645776808262, -0.0033827093429863453, -0.02401719242334366, -0.004049157723784447, -0.017526129260659218, -0.04067748412489891, -0.0296650230884552, -0.017882341518998146, -0.025997867807745934, -0.014318674802780151, -0.0012592858402058482, -0.0027551555540412664, -0.023016560822725296, 0.03768815100193024, 0.022702686488628387, 0.0061007654294371605, -0.03907099738717079, -0.03069266490638256, -0.00007405092765111476, 0.04224850982427597, 0.033787745982408524, 0.0020739471074193716, 0.043329011648893356, -0.033606890588998795, 0.034401219338178635, -0.006426026113331318, 0.05901845544576645, 0.01828516460955143, -0.013982296921312809, -0.023353399708867073, -0.08598438650369644, -0.005527375731617212, -0.004954889416694641, 0.029373588040471077, 0.0288772601634264, -0.009002414532005787, 0.0660114586353302, 0.021914569661021233, -0.03494183346629143, 0.031103994697332382, 0.04991425573825836, 0.01982094533741474, -0.016153087839484215, -0.00620616041123867, -0.013806021772325039, -0.03735301271080971, 0.013523925095796585, 0.01842639036476612, 0.00015227109543047845, -0.009655141271650791, 0.04432254657149315, 0.015969187021255493, -0.009743575938045979, -0.040242526680231094, -0.008333859965205193, 0.03715244308114052, 0.012440021149814129, -0.019947495311498642, -0.041930895298719406, 0.062292322516441345, 0.02691221609711647, 0.03552478551864624, 0.021592194214463234, 0.005818231031298637, -0.09647709876298904, 0.025874430313706398, 0.031480856239795685, 0.022785037755966187, -0.005333630368113518, 0.007997818291187286, -0.034005142748355865, 0.0033819768577814102, 0.011208935640752316, -0.022438697516918182, 0.02920539304614067, -0.04847186803817749, 0.007356868125498295, 0.0025140081997960806, -0.014324530027806759, -0.008656571619212627, -0.004809576086699963, -0.0007727463962510228, 0.012308439239859581, 0.01108050998300314, 0.017364826053380966, -0.03843586891889572, 0.029232177883386612, 0.01146385446190834, 0.04522164911031723, 0.00025380501756444573, -0.0021435515955090523, 0.02883358672261238, 0.017342371866106987, -0.008271096274256706, -0.07002123445272446, 0.018271587789058685, 0.017704417929053307, 0.016915643587708473, 0.06500571221113205, -0.012773269787430763, -0.03983215242624283, 0.0008509333129040897, 0.005558445118367672, -0.01824214868247509, 0.014944590628147125, -0.029515553265810013, 0.04096526280045509, -0.027163727208971977, -0.009892646223306656, 0.05528249219059944, 0.03968382999300957, 0.010249092243611813, 0.004143619444221258, -0.02007506787776947, 0.042553775012493134, -0.011893382295966148, -0.017844516783952713, -0.043907780200242996, -0.016555840149521828, -0.014576428569853306, 0.001672797603532672, 0.008388962596654892, -0.01494190376251936, -0.001096248277463019, -0.03219147399067879, -0.01029730774462223, 0.013168777339160442, 0.04929797351360321, 0.013273137621581554, -0.04050114005804062, 0.03751908615231514, -0.004816465545445681, -0.04511553794145584, 0.015498687513172626, -0.016469910740852356, 0.00889870710670948, 0.0027316329069435596, -0.03929556906223297, -0.00887771975249052, -0.025599181652069092, -0.03463583067059517, 0.03296951577067375, 0.011594196781516075, 0.03031644970178604, -0.018838923424482346, 0.0073156096041202545, 0.0010214453795924783, -0.08447926491498947, -0.02473132684826851, -0.0018545897910371423, -0.001836608164012432, 0.02552581951022148, -0.04695236310362816, 0.06323948502540588, 0.012280762195587158, 0.004561624955385923, -0.06932054460048676, -0.051384929567575455, 0.02281920611858368, 0.03498078137636185, -0.03340638801455498, -0.010237866081297398, 0.029804155230522156, -0.01856127195060253, -0.03122306428849697, -0.00850208755582571, 0.06519583612680435, -0.006466608494520187, -0.015752559527754784, -0.007184542249888182, 0.016076743602752686, 0.06312894821166992, 0.024935677647590637, -0.02075081318616867, 0.027737680822610855, 0.0288973581045866, 0.001179795479401946, -0.011846999637782574, -0.011142386123538017, -0.011563264764845371, -0.01602860912680626, -0.0007206009468063712, -0.019626403227448463, 0.020970936864614487, -0.035322949290275574, -0.0023477114737033844, 0.0004098222416359931, -0.01892855204641819, 0.021322928369045258, -0.028035219758749008, 0.0014513455098494887, -0.013113950379192829, -0.031658321619033813, -0.031048139557242393, -0.023106683045625687, -0.028431205078959465, 0.015452331863343716, 0.025418752804398537, -0.000030083596357144415, -0.018566181883215904, 0.04682843014597893, 0.04700733348727226, 0.00977944117039442, -0.004109591245651245, -0.015086852945387363, -0.031723469495773315, 0.011099576018750668, 0.012778880074620247, -0.030835358425974846, 0.02570260688662529, 0.019239727407693863, -0.006561615038663149, 0.006347321905195713, -0.033633142709732056, -0.022081835195422173, 0.03804635629057884, 0.007584465201944113, 0.00023393851006403565, 0.020860860124230385, 0.013152036815881729, -0.015122578479349613, -0.04093996062874794, -0.00394922262057662, -0.0037657206412404776, 0.015354659408330917, 0.022319914773106575, -0.002718574833124876, -0.0036750296130776405, -0.0023523536510765553, 0.00023325839720200747, 0.00745450658723712, 0.03192564845085144, 0.01962614245712757, 0.013764611445367336, 0.017353884875774384, -0.02727862447500229, -0.04799631983041763, 0.013169803656637669, -0.06484471261501312, 0.007754272781312466, -0.014429316855967045, -0.05671463534235954, 0.005402320995926857, 0.010156618431210518, 0.021347856149077415, -0.051401033997535706, -0.014888068661093712, -0.024274084717035294, 0.033087536692619324, 0.0032511756289750338, 0.06378940492868423, 0.03235255926847458, -0.0437924787402153, 0.008026466704905033, 0.01689552702009678, 0.016936693340539932, 0.022875137627124786, -0.04035823047161102, -0.0406983345746994, -0.033377472311258316, -0.049176450818777084, 0.023282833397388458, 0.019947342574596405, -0.02601679041981697, -0.017767513170838356, -0.06782785803079605, 0.017389854416251183, 0.021906929090619087, 0.046662237495183945, -0.007795045152306557, 0.06681586056947708, -0.005443863570690155, 0.05552943795919418, -0.002440088428556919, 0.020335683599114418, 0.09102799743413925, 0.06719612330198288, 0.034397296607494354, -0.07267444580793381, 0.020760932937264442, -0.0019806926138699055, 0.017552576959133148, -0.037496473640203476, -0.015054270625114441, 0.015509671531617641, 0.036164164543151855, 0.05146082863211632, 0.04405314847826958, 0.007010715547949076, 0.020437167957425117, 0.0785079151391983, 0.002982133999466896, -0.022271012887358665, 0.0016343258321285248, 0.013841626234352589, -0.0019085472449660301, 0.0062205009162425995, -0.03923216834664345, 0.00045147258788347244, 0.04630449786782265, -0.0007500416249968112, -0.015527593903243542, 0.013050001114606857, 0.009189710952341557, 0.01430806890130043, -0.0504203662276268, -0.029740115627646446, 0.03692096099257469, 0.000801569374743849, -0.058608945459127426, -0.04900187999010086, 0.0005062699201516807, -0.02305779792368412, -0.0018221393693238497, 0.05010707676410675, -0.008743477053940296, -0.004972123075276613, 0.013596256263554096, 0.010878353379666805, -0.045147862285375595, -0.023460574448108673, -0.054572559893131256, 0.0014127249596640468, -0.05457504838705063, -0.002424928592517972, -0.03002876229584217, 0.01581401377916336, -0.015189079567790031, -0.04018430411815643, -0.03113671764731407, 0.010298991575837135, 0.016676899045705795, -0.009980344213545322, -0.0408141203224659, -0.025169914588332176, -0.014974611811339855, -0.019776223227381706, 0.021129297092556953, -0.0002899935352616012, -0.06287059187889099, -0.0003936949069611728, -0.002083053346723318, 0.02149856835603714, 0.028887521475553513, -0.0016048583202064037, -0.006488119717687368, -0.003557229181751609, -0.022838331758975983, 0.004206005018204451, 0.0038010994903743267, 0.009798604063689709, 0.014259086921811104, -0.010185321792960167, -0.00519438786432147, 0.012176149524748325, -0.015051063150167465, -0.003722810186445713, 0.004117936827242374, -0.008449560962617397, -0.04583444446325302, 0.028900722041726112, -0.006913983263075352, 0.021749116480350494, -0.035148199647665024, 0.03339136019349098, -0.01662193238735199, 0.021389776840806007, 0.0005642229807563126, -0.05107796937227249, 0.008636901155114174, 0.02499198354780674, -0.051619984209537506, 0.02550271525979042, -0.020287251099944115, 0.07219678163528442, 0.03968951851129532, 0.033128559589385986, -0.0031953754369169474, 0.022098278626799583, 0.02087455801665783, 0.03622496500611305, 0.02296426147222519, -0.04979005828499794, 0.03534708544611931, 0.018830472603440285, 0.0037909855600446463, -0.03401659429073334, -0.060378946363925934, -0.041813887655735016, -0.006457283161580563, -0.007025939878076315, -0.023754112422466278, -0.027626410126686096, -0.020402563735842705, -0.01579081453382969, 0.00899991299957037, -0.02177545242011547, -0.011373406276106834, -0.0633256733417511, -0.006377723999321461, -0.018848467618227005, -0.02388005144894123, -0.019935473799705505, 0.002840782282873988, -0.0201354268938303, 0.01479497179389, 0.0315488837659359, 0.02899530902504921, -0.016954317688941956, -0.00022082176292315125, 0.049687180668115616, 0.0269740279763937, 0.05084039270877838, -0.029363401234149933, -0.008975531905889511, 0.04854482039809227, -0.026100391522049904, -0.01616663858294487, 0.01502391416579485, -0.011838420294225216, 0.04001381993293762, 0.04092209413647652, 0.02667367458343506, -0.009532238356769085, 0.06463765352964401, -0.03279588371515274, 0.00031443589250557125, -0.02213437296450138, -0.006999772973358631, -0.020404428243637085, 0.013253634795546532, -0.008402898907661438, 0.019558290019631386, -0.026348276063799858, 0.03899095579981804, 0.053102388978004456, 0.03158051148056984, -0.026769937947392464, 0.027209866791963577, 0.005323563236743212, 0.03280226141214371, 0.03865588828921318, 0.019170308485627174, 0.013187379576265812, 0.05057043954730034, -0.02353532239794731, 0.04338040575385094, 0.012213270179927349, 0.012207807041704655, -0.07943455874919891, -0.018259689211845398, 0.03876955062150955, 0.008026540279388428, 0.03894984349608421, -0.0430581234395504, -0.024989910423755646, -0.004402030259370804, -0.06573900580406189, 0.012797218747437, -0.02348843403160572, -0.029117558151483536, -0.02952416241168976, 0.006111290771514177, -0.020081795752048492, 0.03671049699187279, 0.05866129323840141, 0.04544156789779663, 0.007682085502892733, 0.018153270706534386, -0.008677415549755096, -0.008636558428406715, -0.025771744549274445, 0.003946824464946985, -0.013003375381231308, -0.05318045616149902, 0.056076157838106155, -0.04510236904025078, -0.03798563405871391, 0.03424559906125069, -0.00017620142898522317, 0.021668149158358574, 0.08596538752317429, 0.026172054931521416, 0.008138921111822128, 0.022389233112335205, 0.03509069234132767, 0.008652239106595516, -0.03233543410897255, 0.05452863499522209, 0.02526017278432846, 0.017072554677724838, -0.025456296280026436, -0.01321431715041399, 0.04153268784284592, -0.03886709734797478, -0.03002975881099701, 0.01755494624376297, -0.0037282139528542757, 0.008062428794801235, 0.009091826155781746, -0.0068551162257790565, -0.008221390657126904, -0.01048473734408617, 0.0472925566136837, -0.037061963230371475, -0.024358848109841347, 0.02541228011250496, 0.0068657780066132545, 0.00415845587849617, 0.008383512496948242, -0.013861358165740967, -0.04418695345520973, 0.02362860180437565, 0.022238049656152725, -0.011718983761966228, -0.06694559752941132, 0.022657329216599464, -0.0000830081626190804, -0.006914547178894281, -0.0007718179258517921, -0.017336782068014145, -0.03605249524116516, 0.03179195523262024, -0.003179923864081502, 0.002804081654176116, 0.024520589038729668, -0.04997074604034424, -0.0019436893053352833, -0.09157072752714157, 0.07614021748304367, 0.011057008057832718, 0.02139258198440075, -0.04996940866112709, 0.00894650537520647, -0.05110631138086319, -0.02863912656903267, 0.03023841418325901, -0.014312292449176311, 0.02196424826979637, -0.00754384882748127, 0.05545099824666977, 0.0034714709036052227, -0.050556279718875885, -0.005391462240368128, -0.011457090266048908, -0.044058069586753845, -0.03360935300588608, -0.012302533723413944, -0.028346115723252296, -0.01985596865415573, 0.020273225381970406, -0.015971185639500618, 0.03243427351117134, -0.007371151819825172, -0.04101252928376198, 0.03359520807862282, 0.019991528242826462, -0.016281168907880783, 0.04674345254898071, -0.018993346020579338, 0.009223872795701027, -0.008551604114472866, -0.006001181434839964, -0.03511646017432213, 0.020288966596126556, -0.0058904909528791904, 0.008320571854710579, -0.02254810743033886, 0.02916768565773964, -0.009013296104967594, -0.02702345885336399, -0.011329375207424164, 0.05328251048922539, -0.031015589833259583, 0.00039039974217303097, -0.012009602040052414, 0.022261345759034157, 0.08621922880411148, -0.008434904739260674, -0.01872994191944599, 0.01435575820505619, -0.036878544837236404, 0.03643007576465607, 0.035985153168439865, 0.02131456322968006, -0.012414521537721157, 0.006834549363702536, 0.030660390853881836, -0.006133904214948416, 0.006086468696594238, 0.015695996582508087, 0.04392526298761368, -0.043253343552351, -0.01911192387342453, -0.0014537081588059664, 0.020639579743146896, 0.027072377502918243, 0.031327683478593826, -0.022399699315428734, 0.07146070897579193, 0.011408858932554722, 0.02204042114317417, -0.03172963112592697, -0.006954492069780827, -0.028655841946601868, -0.010645856149494648, 0.018134579062461853, 0.030489211902022362, -0.013669386506080627, -0.022833582013845444, -0.006489478517323732, 0.020269326865673065, 0.047839630395174026, -0.04577036574482918, 0.019780931994318962, -0.021170955151319504, 0.004674386233091354, -0.03617962449789047, -0.015065300278365612, -0.010236350819468498, -0.02471817098557949, 0.06871171295642853, 0.0263950414955616, 0.035564932972192764, -0.0003269014705438167, -0.012795819900929928, -0.024036461487412453, 0.04726110398769379, -0.05153867229819298, -0.018902886658906937, -0.07018600404262543, 0.01182654406875372, -0.010165619663894176, -0.03464982658624649 ]
<p>I'm trying to implement an ordered probit model in pymc, and I'm stuck. The model is similar to <a href="http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=web&amp;cd=1&amp;ved=0CCkQFjAA&amp;url=http://www.vision.caltech.edu/visipedia/papers/WelinderEtalNIPS10.pdf&amp;ei=fj17T-CvCoek8QS5--HTBA&amp;usg=AFQjCNEj4UZUHHVyjOQP7_RuWTKzjKSRdw" rel="nofollow">Welinder's "multidimensional wisdom of crowds"</a>, with coders (indexed by i) and documents (indexed by j). Coders assign codes to documents, but the coding process is noisy.</p> <p>We wish to estimate two things. First, $z_j$, the true, underlying value of each document along some latent dimension. Second, $\beta_i$, bias terms revealing how accurately each coder's assessments line up with the group average.</p> <p>This would be pretty easy if codes were on a continuous scale, but the data I have is ordinal. Codes fall in the range 1,2,...,5 .</p> <p>Formally, we can represent this as follows:</p> <p>$x_{ij} \sim Normal( \alpha_i + \beta_iz_j, 1)$</p> <p>$code_{ij} = cut(x_{ij}, w)$</p> <p>Where $cut$ is a cutoff function that assigns values based on the index of the highest cutpoints, $w$, exceeded by $x_{ij}$.</p> <p>So far, so good. The problem with this model is that the cutpoint function is deterministic, and codes are observed. But in pymc (and in other MCMC programs, e.g. JAGS), a deterministic node cannot also be observed. So this model can't be built directly in pymc.</p> <p>It seems that there's probably a way to treat $x$ as deterministic, and $codes$ as a random function of $x$. This would probably make $code$ involve a Categorical node. But I'm not sure how to specify the probability function, and I'm a little worried my whole approach may be off. Can anyone set me straight?</p> <p>Also -- long shot -- if there's anyone who codes in pymc, it'd be great to see source code for this. Ordinal probit/logit is a pretty standard model, but I can't find a pymc example anywhere online.</p>
36,825
[ -0.056515537202358246, -0.04369254410266876, 0.012059865519404411, -0.0171378031373024, 0.045972395688295364, 0.031845010817050934, -0.0027221273630857468, -0.005768782924860716, 0.018458440899848938, -0.0349254347383976, 0.07020041346549988, 0.03360498324036598, 0.046698667109012604, 0.07553936541080475, 0.037709351629018784, -0.018508968874812126, -0.02140646241605282, 0.01078876480460167, 0.005879556760191917, -0.01257305033504963, 0.01599869877099991, 0.034040406346321106, -0.0008382878731936216, -0.039834003895521164, -0.010053814388811588, 0.012999719940125942, 0.012458513490855694, 0.0032869046553969383, -0.00462250504642725, 0.03349189832806587, -0.020276518538594246, -0.04224056378006935, 0.012647478841245174, 0.0077994028106331825, -0.004935605451464653, 0.024994833394885063, -0.007235853001475334, 0.004218827933073044, -0.014710487797856331, -0.01750018261373043, -0.0023184502497315407, 0.0366903580725193, -0.005334888584911823, -0.0013241557171568274, -0.007911255583167076, 0.030392905697226524, -0.025656364858150482, -0.021091094240546227, 0.018444690853357315, -0.004937007091939449, 0.0687052384018898, 0.018611790612339973, 0.0009501280728727579, 0.004203653894364834, -0.03402424603700638, -0.004998269956558943, 0.02427937649190426, 0.11052669584751129, 0.030006837099790573, -0.046845003962516785, -0.0258551687002182, -0.01405757199972868, -0.003749994793906808, -0.017461318522691727, -0.01496603898704052, 0.03187355771660805, -0.010244743898510933, -0.011193109676241875, 0.03491134196519852, -0.025652656331658363, -0.006644566077739, 0.012768007814884186, 0.04016194865107536, 0.001097850501537323, 0.034333858639001846, -0.00941255409270525, 0.019014539197087288, -0.0036610558163374662, 0.010028112679719925, 0.01959965191781521, -0.007364171091467142, -0.015282431617379189, -0.005553775932639837, 0.05030158907175064, -0.007303457707166672, -0.03208662196993828, 0.05820786952972412, -0.07054365426301956, -0.012410201132297516, 0.05258702114224434, -0.040009256452322006, -0.006306368857622147, 0.03902085870504379, 0.02143954113125801, -0.03631334751844406, 0.04420439526438713, -0.018010934814810753, 0.0025002353359013796, 0.013232146389782429, 0.0008896196377463639, -0.030964460223913193, -0.04015802592039108, -0.02588079310953617, 0.0572672076523304, -0.022478923201560974, -0.014827710576355457, -0.01961248368024826, -0.0252524521201849, 0.003967593424022198, -0.03225347027182579, -0.0011156252585351467, 0.002537377877160907, 0.006149632390588522, -0.0029323017224669456, -0.009595008566975594, 0.0076357037760317326, 0.03423096612095833, -0.034042008221149445, 0.06030654534697533, 0.03784135729074478, 0.045120105147361755, -0.0180781539529562, 0.01638401485979557, -0.0378715880215168, -0.043206095695495605, 0.003941326402127743, 0.016502635553479195, -0.015708182007074356, -0.020328281447291374, 0.008485793136060238, 0.02307720296084881, -0.001782687846571207, 0.04070951044559479, 0.005500511731952429, 0.0028423157054930925, 0.022688742727041245, -0.044986799359321594, -0.034606724977493286, 0.025457844138145447, 0.01146325096487999, 0.043906260281801224, -0.06695511192083359, -0.011658699251711369, 0.04288557544350624, 0.0322481207549572, 0.01661030389368534, 0.037850409746170044, 0.03227528557181358, 0.0296317171305418, 0.01106060016900301, -0.018252840265631676, 0.0012337176594883204, -0.05933620035648346, -0.005175722297281027, -0.03989036753773689, -0.08441383391618729, 0.035632628947496414, 0.0067517696879804134, -0.007610971108078957, 0.003620963077992201, 0.021278755739331245, 0.02518155425786972, -0.02184484712779522, -0.01436102669686079, 0.02400089055299759, -0.020166587084531784, 0.01433554757386446, 0.0001887437974801287, 0.06536055356264114, -0.0019863597117364407, -0.0072220670990645885, 0.014353626407682896, 0.021816985681653023, 0.03021218627691269, 0.06290820240974426, -0.01863211579620838, 0.015943607315421104, -0.02570679411292076, -0.002650353591889143, 0.010084121488034725, -0.01830154098570347, -0.0754082128405571, -0.020403923466801643, -0.00540405185893178, 0.04087752476334572, 0.01724996417760849, -0.011178480461239815, -0.0025495344307273626, 0.027432873845100403, -0.048774465918540955, -0.022340185940265656, -0.044777628034353256, -0.02170751616358757, 0.011119420640170574, -0.007599476724863052, 0.03363367170095444, -0.021360009908676147, 0.011670234613120556, 0.012016532942652702, -0.012066123075783253, -0.04882737994194031, -0.005787774454802275, 0.0900377482175827, -0.02798522263765335, -0.011874082498252392, 0.021129228174686432, 0.05451156944036484, -0.001557926763780415, 0.049001291394233704, -0.011905130930244923, -0.05209919437766075, 0.007709607947617769, -0.005556796677410603, 0.021049635484814644, -0.022053973749279976, 0.01877731643617153, 0.031661663204431534, 0.026834284886717796, -0.015878861770033836, -0.0034547257237136364, -0.053581029176712036, 0.03861247003078461, 0.025473760440945625, -0.019989697262644768, -0.04231969639658928, 0.005191316828131676, -0.013729754835367203, 0.04189815744757652, -0.06358250975608826, -0.012126193381845951, -0.059740517288446426, -0.003533358685672283, 0.01990192010998726, 0.027627985924482346, -0.07695844024419785, 0.009839140810072422, 0.04771190509200096, 0.03298034518957138, -0.015029174275696278, -0.013449421152472496, 0.00821638759225607, 0.0019749929197132587, 0.014445380307734013, -0.014376606792211533, 0.048614807426929474, -0.001162397675216198, 0.003619350725784898, -0.015398121438920498, 0.01880941167473793, -0.012281994335353374, 0.021383825689554214, 0.0015056607080623507, -0.021158911287784576, 0.0010983167449012399, -0.03474856913089752, 0.004888523370027542, 0.06966350227594376, 0.018682535737752914, -0.005226205103099346, 0.0612042210996151, -0.015099527314305305, -0.030989928171038628, 0.03811301290988922, -0.00007365591591224074, 0.001877035479992628, 0.0704188123345375, -0.05983727052807808, -0.017167428508400917, 0.005757296457886696, -0.010075647383928299, 0.039927590638399124, -0.012546652927994728, 0.003156304592266679, -0.02905111387372017, 0.014249873347580433, 0.03169805556535721, 0.011163831688463688, -0.014740188606083393, -0.03731347993016243, 0.002107738982886076, 0.008444895967841148, 0.019174717366695404, 0.04380198195576668, 0.018985964357852936, -0.06566730886697769, -0.021793251857161522, -0.03912699222564697, -0.008947308175265789, 0.00925909448415041, 0.0021535931155085564, -0.03458071127533913, 0.025744162499904633, 0.002717987634241581, -0.031194131821393967, -0.01753339357674122, -0.04842061549425125, 0.04112803936004639, -0.03087860532104969, -0.00023132513160817325, 0.04499361291527748, 0.02933190017938614, -0.07179895043373108, 0.05272432044148445, -0.016323328018188477, -0.03927544504404068, -0.0633867084980011, -0.011700483970344067, -0.024506090208888054, -0.0019417423754930496, 0.027066269889473915, 0.014728721231222153, 0.028672346845269203, -0.005717072170227766, -0.08091069757938385, -0.04388989508152008, 0.015966001898050308, 0.002185035264119506, 0.034920819103717804, 0.05683234706521034, 0.006835354026407003, 0.08899746090173721, 0.040128063410520554, -0.03285079821944237, -0.05098052695393562, 0.005153712350875139, -0.0036426540464162827, -0.009165511466562748, 0.0331827849149704, 0.03885399177670479, 0.041200313717126846, 0.014004438184201717, 0.0035980823449790478, 0.029804838821291924, 0.08300888538360596, -0.018270086497068405, 0.018641285598278046, 0.018744250759482384, 0.04279876500368118, -0.03684953972697258, -0.0029170282650738955, 0.036720022559165955, 0.005015749484300613, 0.02744130976498127, 0.05083225667476654, 0.008286134339869022, 0.027058662846684456, -0.0409894734621048, -0.0011176379630342126, -0.009470962919294834, -0.011122031137347221, -0.023740747943520546, 0.029157524928450584, 0.003143126843497157, -0.05999640375375748, 0.0031960413325577974, 0.009262542240321636, 0.027718698605895042, -0.018362106755375862, 0.040348120033741, 0.06986203789710999, 0.024590132758021355, -0.02908148616552353, -0.005032224580645561, -0.018027931451797485, -0.015555642545223236, 0.012552307918667793, -0.07331696897745132, -0.019803496077656746, 0.025786252692341805, 0.04482897371053696, 0.021436242386698723, 0.008539240807294846, -0.024980589747428894, 0.04283853620290756, -0.0433507114648819, 0.019417889416217804, -0.053494714200496674, 0.023075522854924202, 0.01514851488173008, 0.03678921237587929, -0.012335212901234627, 0.01376437395811081, 0.006899464409798384, 0.022234920412302017, -0.050517693161964417, 0.011754680424928665, -0.015304702334105968, 0.018109161406755447, -0.0006604703376069665, -0.03558170795440674, 0.02800782024860382, -0.010800933465361595, -0.004156287293881178, -0.006081695202738047, 0.02602839469909668, -0.013353884220123291, 0.03132046386599541, 0.009671024046838284, -0.010794566012918949, -0.005143126007169485, 0.02945725992321968, 0.02949008345603943, -0.04786043241620064, 0.024403555318713188, -0.010031738318502903, 0.015302891843020916, -0.023161016404628754, -0.03478860855102539, 0.02835283987224102, 0.048575256019830704, 0.005037815310060978, 0.005808780435472727, -0.007072378881275654, -0.05232309177517891, 0.006255952641367912, -0.00008977509423857555, 0.03116438165307045, 0.04295922443270683, -0.03269606828689575, 0.031391825526952744, -0.023062322288751602, -0.005585475824773312, 0.027816666290163994, 0.022418946027755737, -0.0258945282548666, 0.01599307917058468, 0.026443665847182274, 0.03843892738223076, -0.04863476753234863, 0.02529250644147396, 0.05243866145610809, 0.013903189450502396, 0.012037261389195919, -0.019033055752515793, 0.015595844946801662, 0.007462633308023214, 0.010022182948887348, 0.007836035452783108, 0.004980091005563736, 0.002876420971006155, -0.027060752734541893, 0.031148122623562813, -0.006243214011192322, -0.04875914379954338, 0.006583333481103182, -0.026129838079214096, -0.0022384158801287413, -0.01902713254094124, -0.04789414256811142, 0.003286773106083274, 0.05888656899333, 0.025321610271930695, 0.008020180277526379, -0.017784250900149345, -0.09619181603193283, 0.004898995626717806, 0.005413753446191549, 0.046033360064029694, -0.016754038631916046, -0.006466060411185026, -0.05767994746565819, 0.007787580601871014, 0.048895083367824554, 0.007937596179544926, 0.034698497503995895, 0.014050857163965702, -0.0156963262706995, 0.0026355087757110596, -0.032455913722515106, -0.06054848060011864, 0.02454143762588501, -0.00032064481638371944, 0.021978825330734253, -0.04209636524319649, -0.0033136513084173203, -0.056959930807352066, 0.03414994478225708, 0.008554747328162193, 0.03287960961461067, -0.00610905047506094, 0.026839133352041245, 0.006280146539211273, 0.005078611895442009, -0.04346489906311035, -0.05723310261964798, 0.02975313737988472, 0.028789371252059937, -0.014369117096066475, 0.0572439543902874, -0.007127715740352869, -0.026874307543039322, 0.04734696447849274, 0.03719162195920944, 0.00781788770109415, 0.013646814972162247, -0.029281621798872948, 0.07155676931142807, 0.051398854702711105, -0.018907716497778893, 0.05647924914956093, 0.05435040965676308, -0.024714907631278038, -0.007232903502881527, -0.049559902399778366, -0.011603426188230515, -0.01321199256926775, 0.019701194018125534, -0.011540528386831284, -0.0032352430280297995, -0.020415915176272392, 0.017921557649970055, -0.02294967509806156, -0.000749537255614996, -0.018287358805537224, 0.04078023508191109, 0.013448667712509632, 0.009070035070180893, -0.04295407235622406, -0.020856032148003578, 0.03907468542456627, 0.03919065743684769, -0.019915375858545303, -0.021256644278764725, 0.03396792709827423, -0.03978870436549187, 0.01262929942458868, -0.028736596927046776, -0.05780511721968651, -0.01763061247766018, -0.03459019958972931, 0.014849748462438583, -0.0006784406723454595, -0.016675706952810287, 0.05213451758027077, -0.0037391516380012035, 0.038871780037879944, 0.00412597693502903, 0.008841029368340969, -0.01694050058722496, 0.005863940808922052, -0.002409603912383318, 0.00482818391174078, 0.006392701994627714, 0.02947191335260868, 0.011789808981120586, -0.0001023900622385554, -0.053530722856521606, -0.03849220648407936, 0.018183238804340363, -0.012099851854145527, -0.05374465882778168, -0.05270161107182503, 0.008861955255270004, 0.0024125627242028713, -0.0353999026119709, 0.008119137957692146, 0.051730915904045105, -0.019035495817661285, -0.014778117649257183, -0.04309529438614845, 0.024476107209920883, 0.05252142995595932, -0.008683365769684315, -0.02986498922109604, 0.029110727831721306, 0.0029105176217854023, 0.013813349418342113, 0.0088898791000247, -0.010285388678312302, -0.016751954331994057, -0.020655663684010506, -0.040899112820625305, 0.015363088808953762, 0.01756049320101738, -0.027021195739507675, -0.0038477620109915733, -0.004813882522284985, -0.015869969502091408, 0.009370372630655766, -0.019411491230130196, -0.031464412808418274, -0.019795408472418785, -0.019966524094343185, -0.06577039510011673, 0.02714320831000805, -0.025969404727220535, 0.0023446204140782356, 0.038023442029953, 0.018569955602288246, -0.01846511848270893, -0.011796576902270317, 0.07678329199552536, -0.014323839917778969, 0.03117223083972931, -0.03348248079419136, -0.022229086607694626, 0.0330197699368, -0.015492665581405163, -0.0021624581422656775, 0.008956228382885456, -0.007841994054615498, -0.046898700296878815, 0.010304228402674198, -0.052840881049633026, -0.00045334448805078864, 0.039620477706193924, 0.022289428859949112, 0.015060348436236382, 0.03036857210099697, -0.026061097159981728, 0.0077681224793195724, -0.048646632581949234, -0.016414787620306015, 0.07189994305372238, 0.020602690055966377, 0.0697968527674675, -0.027143286541104317, -0.0010166573338210583, 0.040666110813617706, 0.02980457805097103, 0.016060883179306984, 0.04880436882376671, 0.030081678181886673, 0.001134257996454835, -0.0072209835052490234, -0.04059191048145294, -0.01439959742128849, 0.03000846691429615, -0.05986630916595459, 0.02245946414768696, -0.03628126159310341, -0.0516878217458725, 0.04971904680132866, 0.03527821972966194, -0.022067813202738762, -0.02820485830307007, -0.012049183249473572, -0.06902873516082764, -0.00843921210616827, 0.014441206119954586, -0.016278544440865517, 0.031530752778053284, 0.00354302697815001, 0.02675410732626915, -0.043064236640930176, 0.057146769016981125, -0.03371310234069824, -0.05566561222076416, 0.01847795397043228, -0.019438574090600014, -0.0618097223341465, 0.04712769016623497, 0.02343681827187538, -0.0012825746089220047, 0.007052224595099688, -0.07111954689025879, 0.03623281419277191, 0.0010031313868239522, 0.01605140045285225, 0.008882911875844002, 0.0214376300573349, -0.005532735493034124, 0.027477344498038292, -0.019650401547551155, -0.08448366820812225, 0.17958904802799225, 0.08915435522794724, 0.03851265460252762, -0.06390959769487381, 0.04827838018536568, 0.010605210438370705, -0.010503130964934826, -0.02503661997616291, -0.01939845271408558, 0.01304564904421568, -0.028607994318008423, 0.02138909138739109, 0.05535895749926567, 0.010622017085552216, -0.030674194917082787, 0.04714403674006462, -0.06904483586549759, 0.00002064389263978228, 0.051365919411182404, 0.028078028932213783, -0.0030858719255775213, -0.009795105084776878, -0.005521393846720457, 0.03854448348283768, 0.05444174259901047, 0.01308603398501873, -0.036756712943315506, 0.0002609886578284204, -0.04652661085128784, -0.00040633403114043176, -0.00046690748422406614, 0.01795779913663864, 0.013307777233421803, -0.025512367486953735, 0.027171455323696136, -0.000048395082558272406, 0.000014675904822070152, -0.026131486520171165, -0.016893429681658745, 0.007280465681105852, -0.005999557673931122, 0.020955272018909454, 0.019380364567041397, 0.03237903118133545, -0.01817340962588787, -0.06524045765399933, -0.027551056817173958, 0.03115019015967846, -0.020803915336728096, -0.04072863981127739, -0.00038600299740210176, -0.005294906906783581, -0.0048229810781776905, -0.02465669810771942, -0.005525163374841213, 0.06308402866125107, 0.030466808006167412, -0.0014819309581071138, -0.004014892503619194, 0.026365872472524643, 0.025489412248134613, -0.01306929811835289, 0.01271374523639679, 0.011684196069836617, -0.05018513277173042, -0.0608697235584259, -0.02715127542614937, 0.05835241079330444, 0.0076293968595564365, 0.021924233064055443, -0.007186778821051121, -0.03855549544095993, 0.002711533335968852, -0.031175797805190086, -0.039022695273160934, -0.0169525109231472, 0.022941559553146362, 0.004632307216525078, -0.011722425930202007, -0.03287607803940773, 0.007410872727632523, -0.0023746786173433065, -0.007113514468073845, -0.03929984197020531, -0.03895723819732666, -0.023326873779296875, 0.005811369977891445, 0.03057393804192543, 0.0004089691210538149, 0.028624989092350006, -0.019156096503138542, 0.07488145679235458, 0.007745133247226477, -0.03195277974009514, 0.01738750748336315, 0.00233684410341084, -0.04827176034450531, -0.0009589918772689998, 0.034470103681087494, 0.058275241404771805, 0.016776790842413902, -0.010691032744944096, -0.004660385195165873, 0.046459317207336426, 0.015713507309556007, -0.013728668913245201, 0.03532436117529869, -0.06265409290790558, 0.0032885463442653418, -0.0061772409826517105, 0.0012300527887418866, -0.04401704668998718, -0.000039180660678539425, -0.03852789103984833, -0.025088125839829445, 0.005477141588926315, 0.005896348040550947, -0.0440223291516304, -0.0008445357671007514, -0.0677279680967331, 0.05646500736474991, -0.011032819747924805, -0.029088133946061134, 0.023691633716225624, -0.002209913684055209, -0.015789559110999107, 0.021057981997728348, -0.014697608537971973, -0.009493095800280571, -0.022905400022864342, -0.007913012057542801, 0.005534856580197811, -0.010538742877542973, -0.005724910646677017, -0.0020026785787194967, -0.006935538724064827, -0.00016694067744538188, 0.015241743065416813, 0.012779755517840385, -0.0656341165304184, -0.03332299739122391, -0.005171394906938076, -0.03944046050310135, 0.020691921934485435, 0.012047856114804745, 0.02634078823029995, 0.030150214210152626, -0.012396124191582203, -0.05362778529524803, 0.022289017215371132, -0.02469782717525959, -0.04188350588083267, 0.0008026285213418305, -0.021999593824148178, 0.00016021101328078657, -0.000832017045468092, -0.007001166697591543, 0.028400730341672897, -0.01557809766381979, 0.027846289798617363, 0.022566093131899834, -0.01914968155324459, -0.006485073361545801, 0.022415125742554665, -0.05738820508122444, 0.030140643939375877, -0.004477018490433693, -0.0049933940172195435, -0.010576988570392132, 0.039189886301755905, -0.03455951064825058, 0.020366819575428963, 0.013760171830654144, 0.006596659310162067, -0.09452454745769501, -0.0002444701094646007, 0.010806381702423096, -0.02367052435874939, 0.009294996038079262, -0.0505562499165535, 0.026578079909086227, 0.023054689168930054, -0.05309213697910309, 0.029936041682958603, 0.015987182036042213, -0.012150035239756107, -0.04508787766098976, -0.003978595603257418, -0.07102691382169724, 0.00323258014395833, -0.0073648844845592976, -0.005510895512998104, 0.0046522957272827625, 0.005539801903069019, -0.010422331281006336, -0.05380290374159813, -0.04155944287776947, 0.03314122185111046, 0.018621083348989487, -0.03311510011553764, 0.04639529809355736, -0.04094197228550911, 0.028103603050112724, 0.012684976682066917, -0.00817176140844822, 0.022798122838139534, 0.03312025964260101, 0.04686778783798218, 0.014155457727611065, 0.049303699284791946, -0.0006002125446684659, 0.027486978098750114, 0.017811769619584084, -0.006766185164451599, 0.029639210551977158, 0.019486436620354652, -0.0009018374839797616, 0.01752788946032524, 0.036028582602739334, 0.007249482441693544, -0.03970091789960861, 0.01645568013191223, -0.011859110556542873, -0.019544383510947227, -0.03722350299358368, -0.02543291077017784, -0.010858054272830486, -0.054486650973558426, 0.004470622632652521, -0.05789688974618912, -0.009035159833729267, 0.040537476539611816, 0.046318478882312775, -0.010782703757286072, -0.004872895311564207, -0.02133484184741974, -0.028603658080101013, -0.018308371305465698, 0.0347723625600338, 0.005241588223725557, -0.044652409851551056, -0.037958744913339615, -0.008833609521389008, 0.004339147359132767, 0.03168744593858719, 0.03368914872407913, -0.03131123632192612, 0.014403536915779114, -0.025153443217277527, -0.018499795347452164, 0.007036327384412289, -0.011856231838464737, -0.0036285906098783016, -0.06275509297847748, 0.06557713449001312, 0.009727631695568562, -0.00791893433779478, 0.008020402863621712, -0.019907260313630104, -0.036891162395477295, 0.024526624009013176, 0.062225110828876495, 0.025797028094530106, -0.030194735154509544, -0.007712661288678646, 0.03616597130894661, 0.016076836735010147, -0.04004766419529915, 0.03293473646044731, -0.0384155698120594, 0.022578498348593712, -0.038093049079179764, 0.001864863559603691, 0.017185447737574577, 0.013905989937484264, -0.007126592565327883, -0.006310364697128534, -0.03231549263000488, -0.015243863686919212, -0.009937135502696037, 0.012445739470422268, -0.00902356393635273, -0.0243829358369112, 0.01741725765168667, 0.021507373079657555, 0.003544264705851674, 0.02976154163479805, 0.03548504039645195, -0.03872079402208328, 0.03190319240093231, -0.0035797322634607553, -0.021677780896425247, -0.003847806714475155, 0.03515005111694336, -0.00514157023280859, -0.04213187098503113, 0.01380531582981348, 0.032582223415374756, -0.02504071593284607, -0.02118564583361149, 0.029391683638095856, -0.013587304390966892, -0.004257699940353632, -0.012119097635149956, 0.045798301696777344, 0.024541208520531654, -0.036959871649742126, 0.06491504609584808, 0.005906288977712393, 0.07392586767673492, 0.01287336740642786, 0.04084298759698868, 0.02889399603009224, -0.016382688656449318, 0.04154292866587639, 0.004143454600125551, 0.04629994556307793, 0.0005615774425677955, -0.023642513900995255, 0.03687816485762596, -0.021430760622024536, 0.006672977935522795, 0.01954159513115883, 0.01067117229104042, 0.04056280106306076, -0.022164450958371162, 0.016487905755639076, -0.05197129771113396, -0.0299657192081213, -0.0141946692019701, 0.011795978993177414, -0.010526965372264385, 0.019270801916718483, -0.003933583851903677, -0.008295143954455853, -0.0034135421738028526, -0.0010974295437335968, -0.0022108142729848623, -0.03390553221106529, 0.0031216645147651434, 0.019225042313337326, 0.008471515029668808, 0.0041610803455114365, -0.034251146018505096, -0.02682550437748432, -0.01710456982254982, 0.06896674633026123, 0.011422242037951946, -0.017729122191667557, -0.023408666253089905, -0.011312376707792282, 0.02093651331961155, 0.05919184535741806, -0.01226086262613535, 0.009056780487298965, -0.03771098703145981, 0.004924748092889786, 0.011595935560762882, -0.019405264407396317 ]
<p>For a method calculating expected claims in insurance I have to assume lognormal distribution. For testing I would use annual cumulated data. With a small sample capped at 20 years, my idea is to use disaggregated data - monthly, or individual claims. Now I have found hat the sum of lognormal claims is not a lognormally distributed. Are there any ideas to improve the power of the test?</p> <p>Edit: The general aim is to calculate the volatility of claims by maximum likelihood estimation. The test for the distribution is Kolmogorov-Smirnov. The problem is that I would have annual data with as few as 5 years of data, and a cap after 20 years. </p> <p>In pretesting with random samples from lognormal, normal and gamma distributions I get good results if the data is indeed lognormal even with 5 years of data, but the test will only decline about 5% of the gamma-distributed sample with 5 years of data (in 10,000 samples). </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/e5Le9.png" alt="Probability of declining H0 = sample is lognomally distributed"></p> <p>Here the code for the simulation, I'd be grateful for comments if there is a problem with the way I set it up. </p> <pre><code>n = 5:20 Loops = 10000 GammaRes = LogNormRes = NormRes = matrix(rep(NA, length(n)*Loops),nrow = Loops) for(j in 1:Loops) { count = 0 for(i in n) { count = count + 1 GammaVerluste = rgamma(i, shape =2 ) LogNormVerluste = rlnorm(i) NormVerluste = rnorm(i) GammaRes[j,count] = ks.test(GammaVerluste, "plnorm")$p.value LogNormRes[j,count] = ks.test(LogNormVerluste, "plnorm")$p.value NormRes[j,count] = ks.test(NormVerluste, "plnorm")$p.value } } Alpha = 0.01 DeclineGamma = DeclineNormal = DeclineLogNormal = rep(NA, length(n)) count = 0 for(i in 1:length(n)) { DeclineGamma[i] = sum(GammaRes[,i] &lt; Alpha)/Loops DeclineNormal[i] = sum(NormRes[,i] &lt; Alpha)/Loops DeclineLogNormal[i] = sum(LogNormRes[,i] &lt; Alpha)/Loops } </code></pre>
36,826
[ -0.014343529008328915, 0.004383966792374849, 0.016005992889404297, -0.016148239374160767, 0.04244209825992584, -0.026180999353528023, -0.0052482071332633495, -0.03757341951131821, 0.02286168932914734, -0.028755225241184235, 0.05264696851372719, 0.06441710144281387, 0.0022817375138401985, 0.01843123696744442, 0.052291013300418854, 0.005954958964139223, -0.016897542402148247, 0.013307416811585426, 0.009073345921933651, -0.004416851792484522, -0.00845702551305294, 0.021578561514616013, -0.0063398294150829315, -0.029262086376547813, -0.012773255817592144, 0.0634685531258583, -0.003058016300201416, -0.06032363697886467, -0.019715946167707443, 0.08531711995601654, -0.05785602331161499, -0.019350657239556313, 0.01928858645260334, 0.03451235219836235, 0.008025833405554295, 0.027290109544992447, -0.016110027208924294, -0.018450679257512093, -0.002457655966281891, 0.04014698043465614, 0.009027109481394291, 0.007258028723299503, -0.009222959168255329, 0.024605611339211464, 0.007739111315459013, 0.02640829235315323, 0.002391691319644451, -0.014267949387431145, 0.053288642317056656, -0.018096361309289932, 0.07386858761310577, 0.0009734552004374564, 0.04444815590977669, 0.014352958649396896, -0.03995174914598465, -0.06744652986526489, 0.008691644296050072, 0.06846438348293304, -0.011185845360159874, -0.0510990284383297, 0.0073691364377737045, -0.010931236669421196, -0.02587750554084778, -0.0529131181538105, -0.00909406691789627, -0.011106201447546482, 0.0009731127647683024, -0.01661575958132744, 0.017933184280991554, -0.022760016843676567, 0.016261588782072067, 0.013597250916063786, 0.014642610214650631, 0.0033318621572107077, 0.024723386391997337, 0.017535775899887085, -0.007352594751864672, 0.0030488900374621153, 0.03105766884982586, 0.029657213017344475, -0.0047958469949662685, 0.013949082233011723, 0.024711566045880318, 0.0069373734295368195, 0.020316939800977707, -0.009898034855723381, 0.05991794914007187, -0.020488131791353226, 0.023097779601812363, 0.007831416092813015, -0.019814666360616684, 0.0072366828098893166, 0.05395210161805153, 0.0319252647459507, -0.0396626777946949, 0.05150016397237778, -0.03210478648543358, 0.04530902951955795, -0.016179518774151802, 0.026781434193253517, -0.03317871689796448, -0.03789766877889633, 0.01685219071805477, 0.03132759407162666, -0.004312597680836916, -0.026886291801929474, -0.0028437196742743254, -0.02948496863245964, 0.0067777386866509914, -0.07554294168949127, -0.05876951664686203, 0.024263104423880577, -0.022368691861629486, 0.0001340167800663039, 0.018608810380101204, -0.02334376983344555, -0.014455086551606655, -0.009879850782454014, 0.002619300503283739, 0.04857876896858215, 0.016007669270038605, 0.027744751423597336, -0.006950234994292259, -0.04070745036005974, -0.05442938953638077, 0.03242696449160576, 0.014509106054902077, 0.006744923070073128, -0.06325861066579819, 0.027748307213187218, -0.020052466541528702, -0.058188457041978836, 0.050475772470235825, -0.030801864340901375, 0.06084895879030228, -0.02637348882853985, -0.08767993748188019, -0.03845061734318733, 0.015879876911640167, 0.01767754554748535, 0.020769964903593063, -0.03348642587661743, -0.0024779096711426973, -0.004434161353856325, 0.032882511615753174, 0.008366279304027557, 0.05593641847372055, -0.006989652290940285, 0.013054251670837402, 0.010946553200483322, -0.03064189851284027, -0.009329273365437984, -0.04052124544978142, 0.0033262567594647408, -0.027874674648046494, -0.08704352378845215, 0.004249918274581432, 0.005270101595669985, -0.01271648146212101, 0.00609250832349062, 0.004213643725961447, 0.01719091460108757, 0.015420055016875267, -0.03254475072026253, -0.009738098829984665, -0.05764829367399216, 0.06914766877889633, 0.03130646049976349, 0.024791207164525986, 0.02300361916422844, -0.009848653338849545, -0.018270889297127724, -0.015683867037296295, 0.03456217423081398, 0.07067204266786575, -0.031760476529598236, 0.027818946167826653, 0.020534701645374298, 0.031951017677783966, 0.0008436697535216808, -0.06394591182470322, 0.021817924454808235, -0.0031466581858694553, -0.0037678745575249195, 0.03406236320734024, -0.018649179488420486, 0.026610704138875008, -0.03112744726240635, 0.023864082992076874, -0.0065680681727826595, -0.07075955718755722, -0.028072331100702286, 0.019078277051448822, -0.0066917408257722855, -0.0329299196600914, -0.04302292689681053, -0.0051463907584548, 0.05291508138179779, -0.0047833542339503765, 0.0008596848929300904, -0.03592934086918831, 0.00007528888818342239, 0.04556853696703911, -0.003968898206949234, 0.0015921668382361531, 0.033872783184051514, 0.04090654477477074, -0.00977389607578516, 0.04358520731329918, -0.039718665182590485, -0.01620197854936123, -0.03687545284628868, -0.04203233867883682, -0.011374319903552532, 0.021576054394245148, -0.010821442119777203, 0.03941413015127182, -0.024836184456944466, 0.051676858216524124, 0.04223634675145149, -0.07942360639572144, 0.02563086897134781, 0.06670445203781128, 0.009352706372737885, -0.00376331084407866, -0.011006232351064682, -0.03177253529429436, 0.021207472309470177, -0.017963208258152008, 0.012186435982584953, -0.06313078850507736, 0.005709295626729727, 0.038804586976766586, 0.04431607946753502, -0.010563245974481106, -0.0012698555365204811, 0.06354529410600662, -0.0058038304559886456, 0.0029092542827129364, 0.03454354405403137, 0.02293883077800274, -0.021945694461464882, -0.003385921474546194, 0.02542160637676716, 0.021054210141301155, 0.013284552842378616, 0.02732897736132145, -0.006795485038310289, 0.057355526834726334, -0.03334030881524086, -0.016720429062843323, 0.008740131743252277, 0.008058344013988972, 0.011171752586960793, -0.03584679216146469, -0.01157066784799099, 0.054588720202445984, 0.017622917890548706, -0.02057538367807865, 0.03388972952961922, 0.003046379191800952, 0.0038238989654928446, -0.03499653562903404, -0.028229527175426483, 0.0396023727953434, 0.03858621045947075, -0.021851999685168266, -0.020271876826882362, 0.010123820044100285, 0.009716392494738102, 0.014049594290554523, -0.05062633752822876, -0.03599010407924652, -0.019566113129258156, 0.03447885438799858, 0.03840920701622963, 0.021754875779151917, -0.002246280899271369, -0.00800309982150793, -0.04383792355656624, -0.004237053450196981, 0.013792210258543491, 0.023590203374624252, 0.024442287161946297, -0.05540039762854576, -0.03222525119781494, 0.013659796677529812, -0.005686994642019272, 0.02970355562865734, 0.02566314861178398, -0.012754278257489204, 0.03349962458014488, -0.014205950312316418, -0.05822886526584625, -0.00893461424857378, -0.000752464693505317, 0.010330546647310257, -0.032772891223430634, -0.038271792232990265, 0.05779717117547989, 0.040998488664627075, -0.06258036196231842, 0.0035153180360794067, -0.0471612811088562, -0.03410482779145241, -0.03997407108545303, -0.02867691032588482, -0.029691118746995926, -0.010359172709286213, 0.0023468544241040945, -0.0013576527126133442, -0.024367081001400948, 0.00335729424841702, -0.06044766306877136, -0.03227673098444939, 0.011766106821596622, -0.037745896726846695, -0.00556372944265604, -0.009035558439791203, 0.026124900206923485, 0.07733789831399918, 0.035443201661109924, 0.011081550270318985, -0.02507789060473442, 0.013281899504363537, -0.024089163169264793, -0.022270824760198593, 0.02398913912475109, -0.014323629438877106, 0.002812472404912114, 0.009760027751326561, -0.03004823811352253, 0.016275309026241302, 0.05871501937508583, -0.0062032658606767654, 0.026733489707112312, 0.03857414424419403, -0.023267759010195732, -0.011145925149321556, 0.07360134273767471, 0.04103885591030121, -0.009433700703084469, 0.007526281755417585, 0.011271335184574127, 0.004695672541856766, 0.0034549266565591097, -0.09186219424009323, 0.04067061096429825, -0.016356656327843666, 0.03369174152612686, -0.013056623749434948, 0.014847585000097752, 0.0228367168456316, -0.03731060028076172, -0.02772078476846218, 0.029814204201102257, 0.03562863916158676, -0.0071883974596858025, -0.0057401107624173164, 0.0036457127425819635, 0.059902675449848175, -0.027741488069295883, 0.007645305246114731, -0.01914292387664318, -0.028984328731894493, 0.010547258891165257, -0.04317446053028107, 0.020157931372523308, 0.016130248084664345, 0.05570445954799652, -0.0066544911824166775, -0.021373501047492027, -0.04865191876888275, -0.012532626278698444, -0.047565728425979614, 0.007306072395294905, -0.034556057304143906, 0.05933236703276634, 0.04316651448607445, 0.011720492504537106, 0.0015445197932422161, -0.012038905173540115, 0.008824977092444897, 0.010991876013576984, -0.0844905897974968, 0.023354547098279, -0.0003241347149014473, -0.0002151085645891726, -0.005050799809396267, -0.06551662087440491, 0.048624493181705475, -0.0022526909597218037, 0.021134406328201294, -0.0030607106164097786, 0.00157282839063555, -0.03050188347697258, 0.028352968394756317, -0.015811778604984283, -0.02459987998008728, 0.007626056671142578, 0.01917840726673603, 0.02562057040631771, 0.003297097748145461, 0.04640030860900879, 0.030293190851807594, 0.0169963538646698, -0.008431299589574337, -0.011573919095098972, 0.02178417704999447, 0.015465768985450268, 0.01994485594332218, 0.044511545449495316, 0.017734158784151077, -0.0486229844391346, 0.0025310146156698465, -0.026286963373422623, 0.034126315265893936, 0.0610332116484642, 0.013461164198815823, 0.004269915167242289, -0.06381266564130783, -0.015102777630090714, 0.023200927302241325, -0.026594754308462143, 0.029605038464069366, 0.01290305145084858, 0.04280782863497734, 0.018949562683701515, -0.03167800232768059, -0.006264665629714727, 0.04563972353935242, -0.004789501428604126, 0.005734911188483238, 0.02343481220304966, -0.007865999825298786, 0.012063467875123024, -0.01118738017976284, 0.03273418918251991, 0.0041165887378156185, -0.07227656245231628, -0.018420128151774406, 0.07320045679807663, -0.04756815358996391, -0.022345570847392082, -0.0013593240873888135, 0.041303716599941254, 0.040644388645887375, -0.021730147302150726, -0.0292271189391613, 0.04600966349244118, -0.006745826918631792, 0.01760527305305004, 0.00886897835880518, 0.030587973073124886, -0.0923955887556076, 0.001890961779281497, 0.052218448370695114, 0.03550003841519356, -0.049957700073719025, -0.024614378809928894, -0.026408197358250618, -0.07512032985687256, 0.02665700577199459, -0.04675969108939171, 0.007538471836596727, -0.021503770723938942, 0.014510365203022957, -0.02305266261100769, -0.02436022460460663, -0.052574753761291504, 0.0037286910228431225, -0.044977400451898575, 0.02242405153810978, -0.03332210332155228, -0.025247208774089813, -0.04216453805565834, -0.014408580027520657, 0.025368142873048782, 0.07279320806264877, -0.038783758878707886, -0.03900553658604622, 0.0015788335585966706, -0.0008393530733883381, 0.0017204547766596079, -0.054320327937603, 0.06730619817972183, -0.038617007434368134, 0.001758717349730432, 0.04428473860025406, 0.023443900048732758, -0.026196498423814774, 0.031596146523952484, 0.021611573174595833, -0.000453803688287735, 0.02540399506688118, -0.015818804502487183, 0.03679415211081505, 0.003890383755788207, -0.0010911313584074378, 0.04278028756380081, 0.01593557931482792, -0.006760087329894304, 0.04787681624293327, -0.0520392544567585, 0.0006703813560307026, -0.019662780687212944, -0.014217202551662922, -0.03406409174203873, -0.007092528976500034, 0.00774367293342948, 0.02423570677638054, 0.025286080315709114, 0.012549090199172497, -0.04178331419825554, 0.018561173230409622, 0.05279422178864479, -0.023475902155041695, 0.008535569533705711, 0.002625791123136878, 0.017751524224877357, 0.01515649352222681, 0.0032126184087246656, -0.0011977395042777061, 0.015796789899468422, 0.013077959418296814, -0.03414447233080864, 0.018278786912560463, -0.04971171170473099, -0.03673110157251358, -0.0025257214438170195, -0.004367667715996504, -0.027026619762182236, 0.022714197635650635, 0.043543778359889984, 0.010796219110488892, 0.032291509211063385, 0.003187333233654499, 0.007121001835912466, 0.03423150256276131, 0.012065241113305092, -0.010734869167208672, 0.035033468157052994, -0.02681434527039528, 0.032811351120471954, 0.02126121148467064, -0.00374780991114676, -0.06613865494728088, -0.019035428762435913, 0.04270823672413826, 0.013030985370278358, -0.029285239055752754, -0.03195876255631447, -0.04102208837866783, -0.009692227467894554, -0.016036294400691986, 0.0013294159434735775, 0.04932292178273201, -0.019977252930402756, -0.0016294126398861408, -0.02466847561299801, 0.005147615447640419, 0.09445630013942719, -0.01854126900434494, -0.018343962728977203, 0.033272385597229004, -0.07214737683534622, -0.02896663174033165, -0.022654876112937927, 0.006246671546250582, -0.03724050894379616, -0.018890222534537315, -0.0309935100376606, -0.005716850981116295, 0.03246067464351654, -0.0038039968349039555, -0.05656203627586365, 0.014081601053476334, -0.019876113161444664, 0.030164863914251328, -0.04425976797938347, -0.012520411983132362, -0.0034820211585611105, -0.0029641329310834408, -0.0362478531897068, -0.00035219156416133046, -0.00013305236643645912, -0.01284319069236517, -0.014994229190051556, 0.014320514164865017, 0.03774270787835121, 0.03398905321955681, 0.07438725978136063, -0.021702833473682404, -0.0030967469792813063, -0.0007991790771484375, 0.005160175263881683, 0.00048497383249923587, 0.023960081860423088, -0.02211487665772438, 0.007885163649916649, 0.019329460337758064, -0.019867774099111557, -0.04310571774840355, -0.06916243582963943, 0.02759169228374958, 0.04753638058900833, -0.01281872671097517, 0.03331168740987778, 0.018028801307082176, 0.001260157790966332, 0.013319924473762512, -0.02710258774459362, -0.004521973896771669, -0.01701536402106285, 0.006719714030623436, 0.033817045390605927, -0.019494596868753433, 0.004039935301989317, 0.011197930201888084, 0.017356470227241516, 0.015561750158667564, 0.03769733011722565, -0.014545002020895481, 0.003707040101289749, 0.029598725959658623, -0.03506265580654144, -0.009500653482973576, 0.003066612407565117, -0.024161405861377716, 0.04898952692747116, -0.04160306975245476, -0.006320323795080185, 0.03360871225595474, 0.04306451231241226, 0.004246065393090248, 0.005751642864197493, -0.015923742204904556, -0.03437479957938194, 0.021058568730950356, 0.03726322948932648, -0.023724829778075218, 0.030707521364092827, 0.027185626327991486, 0.026571717113256454, -0.0013852028641849756, 0.02874876745045185, -0.04265395179390907, -0.07349604368209839, 0.009094600565731525, -0.005647507030516863, -0.0482906773686409, 0.0459551066160202, 0.02979888767004013, -0.010144660249352455, -0.000593592703808099, -0.04411434009671211, 0.02271297201514244, 0.019376102834939957, 0.014925715513527393, 0.024881582707166672, 0.08684894442558289, 0.0008976314566098154, 0.022866729646921158, -0.01490307878702879, 0.014519276097416878, 0.14111076295375824, 0.061065129935741425, 0.03534615784883499, -0.02042175643146038, -0.018102115020155907, 0.018713153898715973, 0.013839433901011944, -0.010005688294768333, -0.016514180228114128, -0.018790943548083305, -0.03985748067498207, 0.05948525294661522, 0.041988108307123184, -0.01809103600680828, -0.011326267383992672, 0.012864433228969574, -0.028520606458187103, -0.014681869186460972, -0.025942284613847733, 0.00404501473531127, 0.00760308001190424, -0.014458488672971725, -0.01620953157544136, 0.04309188574552536, 0.016703618690371513, 0.017390098422765732, -0.028805255889892578, 0.003241834696382284, -0.005991081707179546, -0.02858736179769039, 0.01283197570592165, 0.021214300766587257, 0.032677873969078064, 0.012323879636824131, 0.021918009966611862, -0.0005915241781622171, 0.029515517875552177, -0.0004146878782194108, 0.009396065026521683, 0.03555214777588844, -0.0059804413467645645, -0.00417068786919117, -0.007375843822956085, 0.004520969931036234, -0.05305446311831474, 0.001984155271202326, -0.05359627306461334, 0.07978855818510056, 0.0015107494546100497, -0.01081052515655756, -0.03930822014808655, -0.03220004215836525, -0.03241603076457977, -0.027761662378907204, -0.003643415868282318, 0.023024655878543854, 0.0435829795897007, -0.009178794920444489, 0.004840521607547998, 0.013828733935952187, 0.01368121337145567, 0.01406067330390215, 0.04183228686451912, 0.056913554668426514, -0.05430132523179054, -0.03173013776540756, -0.03859969973564148, 0.047449346631765366, -0.035221438854932785, 0.016971305012702942, -0.0007966319681145251, 0.020037954673171043, -0.038721054792404175, -0.01325287576764822, 0.0016951252473518252, 0.015263219363987446, 0.04609297215938568, -0.02821490913629532, -0.01374200638383627, -0.009771197102963924, -0.048842817544937134, 0.022759314626455307, -0.006917653139680624, -0.020398354157805443, -0.08684466779232025, 0.0124251339584589, 0.028332527726888657, 0.019732244312763214, 0.0321713425219059, 0.019164586439728737, -0.009656084701418877, 0.07306831330060959, 0.0069607882760465145, -0.011162812821567059, -0.05655193328857422, -0.037142444401979446, -0.04417119547724724, -0.005922284442931414, -0.018176279962062836, 0.026685021817684174, 0.013024631887674332, -0.00014236844435799867, -0.001265101833269, 0.04374896362423897, -0.015327077358961105, -0.0035429259296506643, 0.024884620681405067, -0.047222692519426346, 0.01857907697558403, -0.009870238602161407, -0.004115759395062923, -0.0003876143309753388, 0.024000173434615135, -0.03644133359193802, -0.03455357253551483, 0.013078740797936916, -0.03221198171377182, -0.01250494085252285, 0.02018837258219719, -0.0018667499534785748, 0.007147154305130243, -0.001885560224764049, -0.0325729101896286, -0.02261248789727688, -0.03133294731378555, -0.04832402989268303, 0.002113880356773734, -0.018403390422463417, 0.019252067431807518, -0.02906131185591221, -0.008450907655060291, 0.03166276961565018, 0.04439141973853111, 0.00626644492149353, -0.03614016994833946, 0.028916185721755028, 0.0209063608199358, 0.02181585319340229, -0.019693540409207344, 0.004643102176487446, 0.03181459754705429, 0.0018844368169084191, -0.021754935383796692, -0.033174242824316025, 0.025940272957086563, 0.0281148012727499, -0.015163790434598923, 0.020656654611229897, -0.04649612307548523, 0.03932059183716774, -0.01638203114271164, -0.0065794410184025764, -0.027746889740228653, 0.03856012225151062, 0.04332674294710159, -0.0177201796323061, 0.010890517383813858, 0.03641405701637268, 0.020084844902157784, 0.00615496002137661, 0.019681593403220177, -0.048331208527088165, 0.023821445181965828, 0.005856657866388559, 0.00531168794259429, -0.03371552377939224, 0.01373023260384798, 0.002347259083762765, 0.016912657767534256, 0.040273524820804596, -0.033485572785139084, -0.006969932001084089, -0.055569447576999664, 0.01130854245275259, -0.0817587599158287, -0.054687999188899994, 0.016246508806943893, 0.003250710666179657, 0.06235094740986824, -0.04425676912069321, -0.032698992639780045, 0.01633506827056408, -0.03854955732822418, 0.03258763626217842, 0.012691286392509937, 0.05173803120851517, -0.06291118264198303, 0.012443631887435913, -0.02446133829653263, 0.012446030043065548, 0.016294723376631737, 0.0487535297870636, 0.03181956335902214, 0.03490881249308586, 0.005572882480919361, 0.013414265587925911, -0.03092723712325096, 0.002742056967690587, -0.019062308594584465, -0.0735820010304451, 0.011096686124801636, -0.06239095330238342, 0.0021332791075110435, 0.03141947463154793, -0.014673585072159767, 0.06880385428667068, -0.026144549250602722, 0.0060813212767243385, -0.004767631180584431, 0.06683481484651566, 0.047055646777153015, -0.0067421188578009605, 0.01485914271324873, 0.0007671301136724651, 0.020802967250347137, 0.010210723616182804, -0.027763167396187782, 0.020312318578362465, 0.0673304945230484, 0.004937251564115286, -0.017910543829202652, 0.022919241338968277, 0.008542614057660103, -0.015008479356765747, -0.04674139991402626, -0.01128531526774168, -0.015386822633445263, -0.009769913740456104, 0.022748157382011414, -0.016330642625689507, 0.004662557039409876, 0.0475957952439785, 0.05481105297803879, 0.0035011039581149817, 0.0016351655358448625, -0.004016660153865814, -0.019808262586593628, 0.01606854423880577, 0.0012776812072843313, -0.02006925828754902, -0.03839762881398201, -0.01609187200665474, -0.021512813866138458, 0.00876851286739111, 0.0369214303791523, 0.005526000168174505, -0.04957699775695801, 0.020455408841371536, -0.026501810178160667, -0.00684826634824276, 0.029728638008236885, 0.007720630615949631, 0.04693692922592163, -0.11212030798196793, 0.08196595311164856, -0.04040946066379547, -0.0190854724496603, -0.013117513619363308, -0.030342046171426773, 0.021752871572971344, 0.014249925501644611, 0.036267250776290894, 0.013919656164944172, -0.037624046206474304, -0.0240488164126873, 0.035188253968954086, 0.024802662432193756, -0.04278312623500824, 0.02338295429944992, -0.03184138610959053, -0.022594310343265533, -0.011585109867155552, 0.03697488456964493, 0.047832854092121124, -0.006871330086141825, 0.02085030823945999, 0.005836904980242252, -0.022877713665366173, 0.013004650361835957, -0.024671010673046112, -0.004241281189024448, -0.019366508349776268, -0.02949419803917408, 0.032218337059020996, -0.01141391135752201, 0.019314035773277283, 0.010430770926177502, -0.002236722968518734, -0.05200791358947754, 0.0003700621018651873, -0.05219033733010292, -0.02660258114337921, 0.013848919421434402, -0.005208075512200594, -0.011456173844635487, -0.04169568046927452, -0.0056070671416819096, 0.035156164318323135, -0.012972326017916203, -0.002287471666932106, 0.008399737998843193, 0.012853633612394333, 0.0213850736618042, 0.0036672705318778753, 0.011539226397871971, 0.009693123400211334, -0.014653525315225124, -0.016211405396461487, -0.00943912286311388, 0.039785727858543396, -0.0533246248960495, -0.03258584067225456, 0.030681725591421127, -0.02212824672460556, 0.028159722685813904, -0.012504884973168373, 0.04349442943930626, -0.016464682295918465, -0.011752212420105934, 0.04151565581560135, 0.02099784091114998, -0.008177129551768303, 0.0026208923663944006, 0.004082591272890568, 0.03725530579686165, -0.008679852820932865, 0.011917862109839916, 0.027607623487710953, -0.0423111617565155, -0.034266918897628784, 0.001653236453421414, 0.01649516448378563, 0.022995958104729652, 0.0015096240676939487, 0.019606487825512886, 0.03339608386158943, -0.021934829652309418, 0.030152244493365288, -0.002399223390966654, 0.025543678551912308, 0.021846294403076172, 0.001921583665534854, 0.028202472254633904, -0.026679113507270813, -0.01028661709278822, -0.024728430435061455, 0.02762981690466404, 0.02526671625673771, 0.018112709745764732, -0.062421977519989014, -0.048336852341890335, 0.0140053890645504, 0.034000977873802185, -0.03174309432506561, 0.01941932551562786, -0.05513918027281761, -0.0013559771468862891, 0.01868666708469391, -0.016964711248874664 ]
<p>What are hierarchical priors? </p> <p>How do they differ from the general concept of priors?</p>
36,827
[ -0.05321167781949043, -0.030478857457637787, 0.05947066843509674, -0.032464854419231415, 0.037393275648355484, 0.007560256402939558, -0.00875980406999588, -0.012963371351361275, 0.027806703001260757, -0.05524247884750366, 0.0362732857465744, 0.049547694623470306, 0.045428719371557236, 0.016640663146972656, 0.005297038704156876, 0.02887091226875782, -0.004371020942926407, 0.012793634086847305, -0.0016739140264689922, -0.0206732377409935, 0.005299738608300686, 0.01319639291614294, 0.05310544744133949, -0.011820496059954166, -0.03388572856783867, 0.027265295386314392, 0.030872751027345657, -0.01587885431945324, 0.03577238693833351, 0.06528795510530472, -0.013644188642501831, -0.016370080411434174, -0.016769511625170708, 0.03187798336148262, -0.0043062432669103146, -0.0340580940246582, 0.005182502791285515, -0.01747310906648636, -0.018485810607671738, 0.01580260694026947, -0.0188278891146183, -0.04423234239220619, -0.022881289944052696, 0.052935581654310226, -0.06040513142943382, 0.0026713632978498936, -0.0071945348754525185, -0.024716142565011978, 0.0016305926255881786, -0.05008417367935181, 0.016400380060076714, -0.019055819138884544, 0.012388027273118496, 0.07703454047441483, -0.04783911630511284, -0.01739228330552578, 0.05880355462431908, 0.08614019304513931, -0.00975374411791563, -0.048610955476760864, -0.008702589198946953, -0.02811540849506855, 0.0017694674897938967, -0.04425221309065819, -0.015422430820763111, 0.05189196392893791, 0.006268789526075125, -0.011997946538031101, 0.0031218670774251223, 0.0013101312797516584, 0.02111426182091236, 0.01834218017756939, 0.014776144176721573, 0.007841055281460285, 0.02809474617242813, -0.03511499613523483, 0.00008962925494415686, 0.02159803919494152, 0.052450042217969894, 0.03719716519117355, 0.036825571209192276, -0.015339961275458336, 0.02539791353046894, -0.02529153972864151, 0.00784818734973669, 0.0009368829778395593, 0.09339601546525955, 0.01214679516851902, -0.004147270694375038, -0.010101608000695705, -0.04317653179168701, 0.007484701462090015, 0.00865152943879366, -0.029611090198159218, -0.047614045441150665, 0.05201209336519241, -0.018481554463505745, 0.018870670348405838, 0.005169960204511881, -0.002562742680311203, 0.017843907698988914, -0.020471995696425438, 0.015931781381368637, 0.020880525931715965, -0.020669009536504745, -0.004804613534361124, -0.036732565611600876, 0.012352010235190392, -0.019027967005968094, 0.00330803613178432, -0.0480780228972435, 0.08246318250894547, -0.014271723106503487, 0.018063059076666832, 0.005654305685311556, -0.002996385795995593, 0.01792561449110508, -0.029946159571409225, 0.06248660758137703, 0.03766103461384773, 0.03580443933606148, -0.020103203132748604, 0.005007003899663687, -0.009296453557908535, -0.05196785554289818, -0.005287713371217251, 0.018899155780673027, -0.0011425457196310163, -0.025015559047460556, 0.031194083392620087, -0.005504462867975235, 0.013504596427083015, 0.03222178295254707, 0.011733654886484146, -0.020590661093592644, 0.007531004026532173, -0.105963334441185, -0.07221878319978714, 0.034265171736478806, -0.0021515656262636185, 0.003332870313897729, -0.06219276040792465, 0.02143324539065361, 0.0557766929268837, 0.038199011236429214, -0.006964143365621567, 0.02089373953640461, 0.02736867032945156, 0.0033211528789252043, -0.01321201678365469, -0.012200581841170788, -0.012741569429636002, 0.014042765833437443, 0.009386183694005013, -0.01316386554390192, -0.08688343316316605, 0.031855691224336624, 0.015575233846902847, -0.020138196647167206, -0.01690571755170822, 0.0305331964045763, -0.02146107703447342, -0.03476102277636528, 0.009814523160457611, 0.010467750020325184, -0.014098996296525002, 0.07040122151374817, 0.00595874572172761, 0.011237019672989845, 0.06867633759975433, -0.006341579835861921, 0.04188719391822815, 0.02831004187464714, 0.04609605669975281, 0.0005573203088715672, 0.021480176597833633, -0.022537706419825554, 0.01790313981473446, 0.029050733894109726, -0.018474632874131203, -0.02084881067276001, -0.004194514825940132, 0.007329730316996574, -0.0005637051071971655, 0.017637573182582855, 0.02571129985153675, 0.01460100058466196, -0.04178323969244957, 0.014004271477460861, -0.0479225218296051, -0.025554968044161797, -0.07559124380350113, 0.028035487979650497, -0.015209026634693146, -0.012992705218493938, 0.04810338839888573, 0.010523862205445766, 0.033541299402713776, -0.044922105967998505, -0.009078525938093662, -0.040319010615348816, -0.015891045331954956, 0.0100793382152915, -0.048760779201984406, 0.01678585633635521, 0.04757846146821976, 0.03902323171496391, -0.005179164931178093, 0.01748071424663067, -0.006229590158909559, -0.04105886071920395, -0.002340306295081973, -0.044339194893836975, 0.008718743920326233, -0.019215097650885582, -0.003883447963744402, 0.006237530615180731, -0.009172332473099232, -0.028997361660003662, 0.016421252861618996, -0.05496535077691078, 0.07858048379421234, 0.060088250786066055, 0.0206398107111454, -0.013458040542900562, 0.03239331766963005, -0.00654937606304884, -0.006123844534158707, 0.01492252852767706, -0.008770336396992207, -0.07865263521671295, -0.003749180817976594, 0.036740370094776154, 0.0077363490127027035, -0.04271642118692398, 0.05445975065231323, 0.006676215212792158, 0.05356106907129288, 0.005220045335590839, 0.038115791976451874, -0.013003281317651272, -0.03573041036725044, 0.0028221560642123222, -0.04062647745013237, 0.00553267914801836, 0.010565606877207756, 0.05012121424078941, 0.01764451339840889, 0.044749077409505844, -0.026170507073402405, -0.022317176684737206, 0.04257122427225113, -0.038140565156936646, 0.03355727344751358, -0.002457347232848406, -0.04285638406872749, -0.010301600210368633, -0.018355898559093475, 0.011501058004796505, 0.003535378957167268, -0.006131585221737623, -0.0054288157261908054, -0.008219225332140923, -0.02489566244184971, 0.04192683845758438, 0.031129037961363792, -0.06645950675010681, 0.016750341281294823, 0.04402904212474823, -0.010520927608013153, 0.002104121260344982, -0.05037791654467583, -0.028811009600758553, -0.03762446716427803, -0.01716536656022072, 0.04593891277909279, -0.03916213661432266, 0.03305814787745476, -0.02953864261507988, -0.04749162122607231, -0.006159729324281216, -0.024236412718892097, 0.020571289584040642, -0.029093360528349876, -0.03026319481432438, 0.015346280299127102, -0.009448355995118618, 0.0046524908393621445, 0.019344044849276543, -0.007252444513142109, -0.046633295714855194, -0.020963335409760475, 0.010469014756381512, -0.029317477717995644, -0.04492000862956047, -0.022572774440050125, 0.010141937993466854, -0.03168503940105438, -0.03253895416855812, 0.02068808116018772, -0.024045366793870926, 0.003482853528112173, 0.02825901471078396, -0.022014157846570015, -0.013239631429314613, -0.005900218617171049, -0.014721672050654888, 0.007631293963640928, 0.00941514316946268, 0.006575549952685833, 0.027346855029463768, -0.07294399291276932, 0.023566987365484238, -0.05316014215350151, -0.0763557106256485, 0.04734783247113228, 0.017592938616871834, 0.042860016226768494, -0.027807094156742096, -0.018304549157619476, 0.0330992229282856, 0.01911279559135437, -0.0030928347259759903, -0.01452725101262331, 0.005114311818033457, -0.024080917239189148, 0.014148542657494545, 0.026287948712706566, 0.016339406371116638, -0.012402801774442196, 0.015658752992749214, 0.02520832046866417, 0.014470485970377922, 0.05480434000492096, -0.004097488708794117, 0.02151716873049736, 0.009286237880587578, -0.01860339567065239, -0.018438581377267838, 0.0008133758092299104, 0.005853282753378153, -0.024191731587052345, 0.008078129962086678, -0.025628361850976944, 0.016283666715025902, -0.019005782902240753, 0.00030298158526420593, 0.03613116219639778, -0.006851589772850275, -0.029465200379490852, -0.0495152622461319, 0.0726722925901413, 0.004520881455391645, 0.008211019448935986, 0.0032808827236294746, -0.0071576680056750774, 0.034677427262067795, -0.014121037907898426, 0.020803460851311684, 0.039942849427461624, 0.05619555339217186, -0.071414053440094, 0.0004980836529284716, -0.004429074004292488, -0.015117114409804344, 0.0021486906334757805, 0.008151921443641186, 0.034755442291498184, 0.04908646643161774, 0.04624618962407112, 0.020914282649755478, 0.01621624082326889, -0.056647513061761856, -0.0019288144540041685, -0.049375019967556, 0.02573378011584282, -0.0382697768509388, 0.02165316231548786, -0.0016915980959311128, 0.07126305997371674, 0.005091461818665266, 0.029798433184623718, 0.03103199228644371, 0.008136646822094917, -0.04731549695134163, -0.03270410746335983, -0.03382180631160736, 0.03165823593735695, -0.027902798727154732, -0.033291950821876526, 0.040221117436885834, -0.013364464044570923, -0.008268146775662899, -0.03358107805252075, 0.029697690159082413, -0.023726264014840126, 0.018607471138238907, -0.011574617587029934, -0.023295553401112556, 0.01801876910030842, -0.019218329340219498, 0.02233877219259739, 0.007789414841681719, 0.022437389940023422, 0.06807885318994522, 0.02082056924700737, 0.009347961284220219, -0.022367490455508232, 0.01084866002202034, 0.011646747589111328, 0.027799369767308235, 0.020550204440951347, 0.023694925010204315, -0.04987004026770592, 0.04666706919670105, 0.011979978531599045, 0.07302241027355194, 0.043856848031282425, -0.02071283757686615, -0.01136376615613699, -0.0402231402695179, -0.02761034667491913, 0.024743061512708664, 0.015965620055794716, -0.03778006136417389, -0.025726575404405594, 0.025951894000172615, 0.008168698288500309, -0.04137834534049034, 0.030448947101831436, 0.03147779777646065, 0.0037374994717538357, -0.011346527375280857, -0.0414033979177475, -0.029442790895700455, -0.03555968776345253, -0.029857629910111427, 0.038098614662885666, 0.015429596416652203, -0.03313196823000908, -0.0039384872652590275, 0.010005572810769081, -0.027878204360604286, -0.034417059272527695, -0.0011519106337800622, -0.0018549339147284627, 0.01185397058725357, 0.013806555420160294, -0.017970116809010506, -0.001187980524264276, 0.029867734760046005, 0.038860056549310684, 0.019250154495239258, -0.02973661944270134, -0.09992299973964691, -0.007754230406135321, 0.02903887815773487, 0.009441741742193699, -0.02875625155866146, 0.023528484627604485, -0.037765417248010635, -0.05440722033381462, 0.08328451961278915, 0.0008644078625366092, 0.030307238921523094, -0.027444200590252876, -0.005139289423823357, -0.01240504439920187, -0.03605502471327782, 0.0023727042134851217, 0.005252820439636707, 0.005726509261876345, 0.012825322337448597, -0.00033566239289939404, 0.027095528319478035, -0.042312297970056534, 0.0009333046618849039, 0.003020867006853223, 0.04082014784216881, 0.012102779932320118, -0.022695474326610565, -0.037810683250427246, 0.00470320787280798, -0.0028994695749133825, -0.04642489552497864, 0.0246836319565773, 0.005512573756277561, -0.021885255351662636, 0.033900726586580276, -0.02082519605755806, -0.0420965701341629, 0.022160455584526062, -0.0016823092009872198, -0.046623095870018005, 0.02241763472557068, -0.011125609278678894, 0.028957882896065712, 0.042502183467149734, 0.037634994834661484, 0.03592047095298767, 0.0014934688806533813, -0.020480066537857056, -0.008242860436439514, -0.03447600454092026, 0.038397416472435, -0.04375998675823212, 0.001803059596568346, -0.033237360417842865, 0.0031470302492380142, -0.02902858890593052, 0.05821974575519562, 0.01283262763172388, 0.03502703830599785, -0.004228367004543543, -0.04134038835763931, -0.015359521843492985, 0.0311615988612175, 0.027314431965351105, -0.002442533615976572, -0.012336441315710545, 0.012274453416466713, 0.010914778336882591, 0.010198397561907768, 0.03904183954000473, -0.005493915639817715, 0.03596653789281845, -0.02021775394678116, -0.03283912315964699, 0.01568009704351425, -0.042543426156044006, -0.024078598245978355, 0.06512980163097382, -0.04583253338932991, 0.048641230911016464, 0.009024890139698982, 0.015823008492588997, 0.009512527845799923, -0.053303301334381104, -0.02417420595884323, 0.023340661078691483, -0.03955715894699097, 0.04565490782260895, -0.035463254898786545, 0.031751345843076706, -0.003444913076236844, 0.023387307301163673, -0.034268587827682495, 0.0005827657296322286, -0.016572410240769386, 0.045152708888053894, -0.022584717720746994, -0.046224143356084824, 0.051229581236839294, -0.017428424209356308, 0.004041207488626242, -0.016688086092472076, 0.06882569193840027, 0.0010225577279925346, 0.0012450243812054396, -0.011337234638631344, 0.036411091685295105, 0.05996029078960419, 0.052907027304172516, -0.004676092881709337, 0.024299725890159607, -0.02184658870100975, 0.01684425212442875, -0.00015567908121738583, 0.0066736191511154175, -0.02277952805161476, -0.0010772316018119454, -0.014335057698190212, 0.03869327902793884, 0.0282769612967968, -0.015060218051075935, -0.007377426605671644, 0.013867953792214394, -0.0021907079499214888, -0.005001664627343416, -0.046077944338321686, -0.006603627931326628, -0.04797134920954704, 0.016874482855200768, -0.02327796071767807, -0.008431712165474892, -0.02391871064901352, -0.06155940890312195, 0.054168250411748886, -0.0021018260158598423, -0.012566749937832355, 0.0030880076810717583, 0.05308974161744118, -0.0398092083632946, 0.02753288671374321, 0.00889059528708458, -0.014069435186684132, 0.03570345789194107, -0.0203288272023201, 0.004258650820702314, 0.053692493587732315, 0.0011496703373268247, -0.020327195525169373, 0.016601817682385445, -0.022376831620931625, 0.012383566237986088, 0.07300036400556564, -0.023944556713104248, 0.0545024573802948, -0.0006078163278289139, -0.019246907904744148, 0.012607824057340622, -0.04695826768875122, 0.019272159785032272, 0.0001734602847136557, 0.014083328656852245, 0.032182030379772186, -0.0514647513628006, 0.018674176186323166, 0.05593045800924301, 0.007933923043310642, -0.008618004620075226, -0.01529175229370594, 0.018497612327337265, 0.0004108278371859342, 0.030850520357489586, -0.07223378866910934, -0.02963927574455738, 0.05704279616475105, -0.04902869835495949, -0.0115412762388587, -0.027341490611433983, -0.018141841515898705, 0.060762304812669754, 0.019111551344394684, -0.016582967713475227, -0.04333588480949402, 0.0013055338058620691, -0.013222581706941128, 0.03700665757060051, 0.01699337363243103, 0.03797796368598938, -0.0002679417375475168, -0.0019482001662254333, 0.032780084758996964, -0.03304103761911392, -0.0035035486798733473, -0.013464486226439476, -0.07517427951097488, -0.0484064556658268, -0.011357256211340427, -0.03587554022669792, -0.00792189035564661, -0.0024098751600831747, -0.020044945180416107, -0.008505045436322689, -0.01260942593216896, -0.008466711267828941, 0.031726717948913574, 0.025074878707528114, -0.03970719128847122, 0.04434140399098396, 0.01838817074894905, 0.02069827914237976, 0.0029599592089653015, 0.016773024573922157, 0.12944772839546204, 0.08555052429437637, 0.029427552595734596, -0.051312077790498734, 0.014991930685937405, -0.022010257467627525, 0.01312324684113264, -0.014715631492435932, 0.011991123668849468, -0.007419230882078409, -0.002024510409682989, -0.0062242597341537476, 0.03431025147438049, 0.011458877474069595, -0.008475068025290966, 0.07741960883140564, -0.07365254312753677, -0.036862462759017944, -0.009467357769608498, -0.0064278822392225266, -0.034160468727350235, 0.022260308265686035, -0.04564373195171356, -0.003956598229706287, 0.03308180347084999, -0.009625772945582867, -0.028756609186530113, -0.0011211064411327243, 0.010499193333089352, 0.03081442043185234, -0.021568892523646355, -0.022763418033719063, 0.04262546822428703, -0.0049762120470404625, -0.012243486009538174, 0.0023156353272497654, 0.006519074086099863, -0.041732173413038254, 0.009460429660975933, 0.025061767548322678, 0.005046644248068333, -0.01131432130932808, -0.027241628617048264, 0.017663465812802315, -0.047935012727975845, -0.013433853164315224, -0.028189539909362793, 0.013049907051026821, -0.009651976637542248, 0.007895098999142647, -0.0474478118121624, -0.01082762610167265, -0.016182441264390945, -0.0497712641954422, -0.004347998183220625, 0.025024289265275, 0.03211658447980881, 0.014450247399508953, -0.03743356093764305, -0.02482660859823227, 0.014765429310500622, -0.026153018698096275, 0.047444991767406464, 0.014138920232653618, -0.013748956844210625, -0.029067471623420715, -0.05134518817067146, 0.02059401199221611, 0.0029137255623936653, -0.0013333080569282174, -0.018107032403349876, 0.014970044605433941, -0.005052937660366297, -0.02378694713115692, -0.0016222016420215368, -0.022684553638100624, 0.04781394451856613, 0.028360014781355858, 0.004358727019280195, 0.010402603074908257, -0.018989721313118935, 0.0012964534107595682, -0.027781233191490173, -0.014015800319612026, -0.01983937993645668, 0.019181814044713974, 0.03807363659143448, 0.03392992168664932, 0.022947456687688828, 0.05527346581220627, -0.023529374971985817, 0.04037849232554436, 0.016596151515841484, -0.046275634318590164, -0.031103797256946564, 0.0030389262828975916, -0.01044585183262825, -0.003751276060938835, 0.007549175526946783, 0.07212972640991211, 0.038157869130373, 0.03141375258564949, 0.014820871874690056, 0.011040979996323586, -0.017032667994499207, 0.006923433858901262, -0.0037716380320489407, -0.04651608690619469, 0.0025708258617669344, 0.010816903784871101, 0.01569085195660591, -0.023477444425225258, -0.00438788253813982, 0.00008677725418237969, 0.012094831094145775, 0.03773372247815132, 0.0027441801503300667, -0.015359843149781227, -0.0015072511741891503, 0.018539050593972206, 0.06159466505050659, 0.008256887085735798, -0.0020075892098248005, 0.008822167292237282, 0.008090757764875889, -0.011737065389752388, -0.022908074781298637, 0.02156452089548111, -0.0041429162956774235, -0.02563764527440071, -0.016919821500778198, 0.00855608657002449, 0.00793615635484457, 0.005631479900330305, 0.003907482605427504, -0.0007408068049699068, 0.002104672370478511, 0.031682856380939484, -0.008749467320740223, -0.05714483931660652, 0.012677907943725586, -0.02737320400774479, -0.02714482508599758, -0.011292721144855022, 0.01724623143672943, 0.04671343415975571, 0.033978432416915894, 0.000466858473373577, -0.013443732634186745, -0.0037333318032324314, -0.05639750137925148, -0.025934599339962006, -0.0006975849391892552, 0.004878263454884291, -0.0038610748015344143, -0.010330942459404469, -0.001508849672973156, 0.010969211347401142, -0.020448755472898483, 0.017734723165631294, 0.026528790593147278, -0.004034574143588543, -0.024168170988559723, 0.016191985458135605, -0.02414562925696373, 0.004524348769336939, -0.017200637608766556, -0.010783502832055092, 0.059810250997543335, 0.018178369849920273, -0.0233908798545599, 0.046089235693216324, 0.01510639488697052, -0.015077054500579834, -0.1494363248348236, -0.01580607146024704, 0.006611671298742294, 0.038950737565755844, 0.020214738324284554, -0.011086899787187576, -0.011291274800896645, 0.05191480368375778, -0.031717412173748016, 0.05703676491975784, 0.020531421527266502, -0.0006318992236629128, -0.02329331636428833, 0.01776224561035633, -0.02478189766407013, 0.07217822223901749, -0.005636334884911776, 0.027427058666944504, 0.03694804757833481, -0.01456304918974638, 0.004970600828528404, -0.05696968361735344, -0.016521615907549858, 0.0019406164065003395, -0.02414388209581375, -0.0517951175570488, 0.03933082893490791, -0.019047249108552933, 0.0011179776629433036, 0.04584776237607002, 0.05112811177968979, 0.028967829421162605, 0.011477027088403702, 0.01686757802963257, 0.03680601716041565, 0.006664659827947617, 0.01136631891131401, 0.011344769038259983, -0.0026603301521390676, 0.01927858032286167, 0.00152805435936898, 0.049826402217149734, -0.023317959159612656, -0.02284899167716503, 0.022604264318943024, -0.038715895265340805, -0.01009418722242117, 0.011744492687284946, -0.03239092975854874, -0.031484175473451614, 0.024056321009993553, -0.023209618404507637, -0.010602213442325592, -0.00639764778316021, -0.005698762834072113, -0.03467986360192299, -0.011866510845720768, 0.05868726596236229, 0.0033676237799227238, -0.013790508732199669, 0.018867596983909607, -0.0024289609864354134, -0.04131608456373215, 0.010098685510456562, -0.010106106288731098, -0.005402880255132914, -0.0466812402009964, 0.02110728621482849, -0.010397872887551785, -0.006505503319203854, -0.016751501709222794, -0.020409991964697838, -0.049966227263212204, 0.020461924374103546, -0.03672337159514427, -0.018440643325448036, 0.006255459040403366, -0.02133907563984394, -0.03836752846837044, -0.06751406192779541, 0.07510732859373093, -0.013341540470719337, -0.07648696005344391, -0.059508565813302994, -0.0004015650483779609, -0.022245578467845917, -0.015690060332417488, 0.0660247802734375, 0.024013618007302284, 0.004735918715596199, -0.0022795526310801506, 0.02866273745894432, 0.023398183286190033, -0.0332949124276638, 0.021541280671954155, 0.0026278598234057426, -0.04031940549612045, -0.033246543258428574, -0.011514231562614441, 0.017302565276622772, 0.014318735338747501, 0.0009133325656875968, -0.012707156129181385, 0.02728533186018467, 0.002859897678717971, 0.037838444113731384, 0.019984543323516846, 0.010446636937558651, -0.029154125601053238, 0.01695418916642666, -0.012262580916285515, -0.00072260363958776, 0.031091345474123955, -0.01031250786036253, -0.05387269705533981, -0.009380476549267769, -0.011008047498762608, -0.030463941395282745, 0.013654153794050217, -0.003987867850810289, -0.006270442623645067, -0.03163148835301399, -0.03008151426911354, 0.04713163524866104, -0.07551189512014389, 0.009281054139137268, 0.07263839989900589, 0.01583239622414112, 0.07204782962799072, 0.023760799318552017, -0.0010624212445691228, 0.033419180661439896, -0.04906477779150009, 0.009157247841358185, 0.04650763049721718, 0.07816564291715622, -0.014709199778735638, 0.04206304997205734, 0.03638371080160141, 0.002418787684291601, 0.022068992257118225, 0.00027444103034213185, 0.06841297447681427, -0.040650930255651474, -0.003456418402493, -0.015879740938544273, -0.010215670801699162, 0.016175709664821625, 0.016605006530880928, -0.0014684480847790837, 0.06582438200712204, -0.005822805222123861, -0.01579822599887848, -0.03475825488567352, 0.0220379326492548, -0.0483989343047142, 0.013736172579228878, 0.02818896435201168, 0.03765258938074112, 0.024790136143565178, -0.001999732805415988, -0.011468936689198017, -0.006592772901058197, 0.03127444535493851, -0.02867940068244934, 0.04420012980699539, -0.004904767964035273, 0.0069562275893986225, 0.00974950660020113, -0.014904210343956947, -0.03788071125745773, -0.022143155336380005, -0.0018611554987728596, 0.03798481076955795, 0.051871586591005325, -0.007302647456526756, -0.04652226343750954, -0.03434591367840767, -0.0009032515226863325, -0.09875719994306564, 0.03522283583879471, -0.04410826042294502, 0.032991841435432434, 0.000018285203623236157, -0.007281775586307049 ]
<p>I'm currently storing the following things in my Database about user submitted content:</p> <ul> <li>Downloads: The total Download count of the Content</li> <li>Likes: A user can either like a content or do nothing</li> </ul> <p>How can I determine which Content has got the highest popularity by using these two numbers?</p> <p>I would try something like:</p> <p>$s = \frac{Downloads}{Likes}$</p> <p>and the Content with the lowest Value is the most popular.</p> <p>e.g.:</p> <ul> <li>$\frac{10000}{100} = 100$ not so good</li> <li>$\frac{10000}{1000} = 10$ lower value, better content</li> </ul> <hr> <p>Another approach could be adding both numbers together so:</p> <ul> <li>$10000 + 100 = 10100$ not so good</li> <li>$10000 + 1000 = 11000$ higher value, better content</li> </ul> <p>Would this work and is this "fair" in real life or should I do something different?</p>
36,828
[ -0.04395187273621559, -0.06513437628746033, 0.009106437675654888, 0.01771693490445614, 0.010314526967704296, 0.024152100086212158, 0.025854624807834625, 0.005365532357245684, 0.015356505289673805, 0.011063692159950733, 0.04432297870516777, 0.04381510615348816, 0.0026390510611236095, 0.045536115765571594, 0.03852250799536705, 0.03690022602677345, -0.03791170194745064, 0.0027245855890214443, -0.006333217490464449, 0.010316354222595692, -0.0002741761563811451, 0.008028914220631123, 0.019570961594581604, 0.006214023567736149, -0.013557780534029007, 0.004597874358296394, 0.03673820197582245, -0.007943772710859776, 0.013510982505977154, 0.027256187051534653, 0.0010099220089614391, -0.061606068164110184, 0.013319747522473335, 0.03862380608916283, 0.05727147310972214, 0.024270791560411453, -0.04892735183238983, 0.01492381189018488, -0.033884141594171524, 0.01788666658103466, 0.02650468610227108, 0.009244809858500957, -0.022110523656010628, 0.028283361345529556, -0.03012431226670742, 0.018616432324051857, 0.012257631868124008, -0.025826890021562576, 0.014435863122344017, -0.07282602041959763, 0.043789301067590714, 0.027765410020947456, 0.02651509828865528, 0.04672359302639961, -0.04388638958334923, -0.0012850373750552535, 0.029710547998547554, 0.07334806770086288, -0.008431595750153065, -0.046946994960308075, 0.013256745412945747, -0.04706687852740288, -0.018690863624215126, 0.008562835864722729, -0.006421302445232868, 0.026425393298268318, 0.023505978286266327, 0.014234049245715141, 0.02392091229557991, -0.005761637352406979, 0.009067337960004807, 0.00961407832801342, 0.058460842818021774, -0.0054778968915343285, 0.044976942241191864, -0.056288234889507294, 0.03628429025411606, 0.0007448092801496387, 0.05068435147404671, 0.0351959727704525, -0.023879265412688255, -0.0008535270462743938, 0.006093243137001991, 0.07992430776357651, 0.04631888493895531, -0.05162009969353676, 0.030304424464702606, 0.00012363131099846214, 0.01729065552353859, 0.021573057398200035, -0.0032397634349763393, -0.034767426550388336, 0.041900385171175, 0.01538743544369936, -0.027455825358629227, 0.035372622311115265, -0.006500802934169769, -0.0029294148553162813, 0.012912792153656483, 0.005029293242841959, -0.001283931196667254, -0.03514031693339348, 0.025326726958155632, 0.07020875066518784, -0.03268470987677574, -0.04379167780280113, -0.035481177270412445, -0.006443460937589407, 0.029708946123719215, 0.009641795419156551, 0.014814424328505993, -0.011981992982327938, 0.021963516250252724, 0.01444530300796032, -0.002755342284217477, -0.03236114978790283, -0.005126692354679108, -0.032948315143585205, 0.024970710277557373, -0.00003537254815455526, 0.04367498308420181, 0.0013960901414975524, 0.03991167992353439, -0.004351497162133455, -0.017267974093556404, 0.0171948354691267, 0.020288951694965363, 0.003984433598816395, -0.06843269616365433, 0.08186709135770798, -0.03598465025424957, 0.036244362592697144, 0.03005170449614525, -0.025962485000491142, 0.026624681428074837, 0.036977678537368774, -0.07154208421707153, -0.02385220117866993, 0.023115605115890503, -0.0001679112610872835, -0.016233352944254875, -0.05276518687605858, 0.0037671932950615883, 0.02492132969200611, 0.034340474754571915, 0.045453548431396484, 0.021327657625079155, 0.015063089318573475, 0.02961377426981926, 0.018797703087329865, -0.016531679779291153, -0.035462573170661926, 0.011974564753472805, -0.06115742772817612, -0.025108542293310165, -0.026010125875473022, -0.008563509210944176, 0.014291283674538136, 0.00038155080983415246, 0.01456928439438343, 0.012334965169429779, 0.023580729961395264, -0.008927947841584682, -0.01775953732430935, 0.0018092256505042315, -0.0009982321644201875, 0.06426334381103516, 0.022055570036172867, 0.018708834424614906, -0.0030784709379076958, -0.014232213608920574, 0.029546746984124184, 0.010375920683145523, -0.014779636636376381, 0.04850632697343826, -0.0030993223190307617, 0.023357752710580826, -0.03993421047925949, 0.03080236352980137, -0.010959065519273281, -0.01597900688648224, -0.05138364061713219, -0.012232976965606213, 0.03284637629985809, -0.003214868949726224, 0.006270857993513346, 0.00654351431876421, -0.0030693879816681147, 0.04575570300221443, -0.043510664254426956, -0.030813442543148994, -0.08967500180006027, -0.011058996431529522, 0.008017146028578281, -0.024329237639904022, 0.02508172206580639, -0.010649137198925018, -0.03359777107834816, -0.02259666472673416, 0.011333650909364223, 0.003295659786090255, 0.024482520297169685, 0.049667838960886, -0.014597523026168346, -0.023064473643898964, 0.09926661849021912, -0.01083241868764162, -0.04075850173830986, 0.0318203940987587, -0.023854730650782585, -0.08165410906076431, -0.02759655937552452, -0.028246287256479263, 0.03549044579267502, 0.030230076983571053, -0.004421056713908911, 0.03610667958855629, 0.015460286289453506, 0.02090390771627426, 0.013469853438436985, -0.07829126715660095, 0.07579674571752548, 0.047094374895095825, -0.003784347325563431, 0.017800629138946533, -0.015298562124371529, -0.01583758182823658, 0.01049040537327528, 0.00983835756778717, -0.042949363589286804, -0.08206277340650558, 0.028305819258093834, 0.010137521661818027, -0.0005989981000311673, -0.034130342304706573, -0.008387722074985504, 0.07398524135351181, 0.004750944674015045, 0.04819430038332939, 0.012675951234996319, -0.015043131075799465, 0.0043199555948376656, 0.015763210132718086, 0.022498242557048798, -0.0007567424909211695, 0.03932127356529236, 0.02092897519469261, 0.0023544502910226583, -0.015606869012117386, 0.0042268442921340466, -0.008878315798938274, 0.016165344044566154, 0.022914161905646324, 0.007416734471917152, 0.010772041976451874, -0.009638665243983269, 0.015488523058593273, -0.044801294803619385, 0.0060866717249155045, 0.048580098897218704, -0.027660096064209938, -0.04959435760974884, 0.027422424405813217, -0.01073190663009882, -0.0481826551258564, 0.03236449509859085, -0.053216274827718735, -0.02071436680853367, 0.023336660116910934, -0.005142985377460718, 0.00725291995331645, -0.0034852440003305674, 0.006147392094135284, -0.071200430393219, -0.005602829158306122, 0.012219035066664219, -0.010151500813663006, -0.00289928843267262, -0.0291630607098341, -0.02638750895857811, -0.020277798175811768, -0.022535935044288635, -0.03104531392455101, -0.0006099024321883917, -0.052951160818338394, -0.052511367946863174, -0.013823207467794418, -0.02284207008779049, 0.041393522173166275, -0.007247274275869131, 0.016669055446982384, 0.03856351226568222, -0.02539348416030407, -0.04634663462638855, -0.013203686103224754, -0.026032904163002968, 0.021716132760047913, -0.030822988599538803, -0.03574886545538902, 0.05360003188252449, 0.022285189479589462, -0.04332726076245308, 0.04839124530553818, -0.03803768381476402, -0.04089849442243576, -0.014556664042174816, -0.005797126330435276, -0.019878391176462173, -0.02017727494239807, 0.013129409402608871, -0.023952532559633255, 0.01888265274465084, -0.025040969252586365, -0.09196732193231583, -0.07803920656442642, 0.014185234904289246, -0.04512709751725197, 0.06729961931705475, 0.006166545208543539, -0.021561937406659126, 0.07230393588542938, 0.06497880816459656, -0.03407633304595947, -0.061841245740652084, -0.02103428728878498, 0.011043569073081017, 0.004912428092211485, 0.02683720365166664, 0.05764361843466759, -0.02579602226614952, 0.0026944740675389767, 0.039006974548101425, 0.01692929118871689, 0.06346852332353592, 0.013200291432440281, -0.026233958080410957, -0.012062912806868553, 0.02266494557261467, -0.006582414731383324, 0.06978730112314224, 0.05565262958407402, -0.04605173319578171, 0.03909045830368996, -0.008112798444926739, 0.04674355313181877, 0.011435052379965782, -0.02079359069466591, 0.0018729005241766572, 0.016576426103711128, 0.018547844141721725, -0.0010702835861593485, 0.026934728026390076, 0.018290163949131966, -0.004071480594575405, -0.014324933290481567, -0.015008058398962021, 0.02213142439723015, -0.020955365151166916, 0.01961871050298214, 0.022366825491189957, 0.05246766284108162, -0.005624949466437101, -0.02090957760810852, -0.014459501020610332, -0.012258563190698624, 0.012151549570262432, -0.031086567789316177, -0.04631832242012024, 0.053021516650915146, 0.031952761113643646, -0.013069137930870056, -0.008161408826708794, -0.04491133987903595, -0.01385736744850874, -0.11876179277896881, -0.044402826577425, -0.031863998621702194, 0.07689951360225677, -0.0039945789612829685, 0.049241263419389725, 0.0027803005650639534, 0.028885111212730408, 0.0366179458796978, 0.027641644701361656, -0.025902962312102318, 0.00925508327782154, -0.01062206830829382, 0.0174524188041687, -0.0120153883472085, -0.021596429869532585, -0.0006742411642335355, -0.04149416834115982, 0.02388891763985157, -0.0011871480382978916, 0.018882712349295616, -0.008048386313021183, 0.000580032414291054, -0.030829094350337982, -0.013464787043631077, 0.006994226481765509, 0.022763647139072418, 0.04728284478187561, -0.003880464704707265, 0.05953112244606018, 0.0282607302069664, -0.021654143929481506, -0.005803309381008148, -0.03739769756793976, -0.017044585198163986, 0.0021525591146200895, 0.04282965138554573, -0.02800435572862625, 0.009801195003092289, -0.02509879879653454, 0.03435606136918068, -0.017211224883794785, 0.025801263749599457, 0.014037824235856533, -0.0020054106134921312, -0.02518199384212494, -0.02861262857913971, -0.038208551704883575, -0.027234850451350212, 0.01567182131111622, -0.01373001467436552, 0.0007517996709793806, 0.03685413673520088, 0.008152787573635578, -0.02518819272518158, 0.037797410041093826, 0.06397685408592224, 0.008806836791336536, -0.02043469436466694, -0.023251671344041824, -0.010408244095742702, 0.00417353818193078, -0.01095672883093357, 0.00990049634128809, 0.023136554285883904, 0.00004250012352713384, 0.020826024934649467, 0.0204662773758173, -0.002746918937191367, -0.0235716812312603, 0.03727155923843384, -0.007921039126813412, 0.04708414152264595, -0.03869783133268356, -0.015095594339072704, -0.004006592091172934, 0.04962902516126633, 0.011626491323113441, -0.016576457768678665, -0.023135554045438766, -0.08911937475204468, -0.040296558290719986, 0.05897852033376694, 0.0250850897282362, -0.03585520386695862, -0.01356604602187872, -0.006094275042414665, -0.02916606515645981, 0.04266964644193649, -0.03387882187962532, 0.0555749349296093, -0.0016498924233019352, 0.0037965700030326843, -0.009840687736868858, -0.018251074478030205, 0.0030971162486821413, 0.039555005729198456, -0.027583589777350426, 0.024819811806082726, -0.006346152164041996, -0.030285555869340897, -0.04745199531316757, 0.018243001773953438, 0.016919376328587532, 0.04825764149427414, -0.047243740409612656, 0.00029081691172905266, 0.020971082150936127, 0.0004789798695128411, -0.05322236940264702, -0.07162617146968842, 0.01896589994430542, -0.003592156805098057, 0.02066376991569996, 0.03597467765212059, -0.02253565564751625, -0.0025385767221450806, 0.027539100497961044, 0.019664080813527107, -0.03214380145072937, 0.017669755965471268, -0.010352601297199726, 0.039195939898490906, 0.07345517724752426, 0.014531404711306095, 0.02719014696776867, 0.058115530759096146, 0.010721925646066666, -0.0051451814360916615, -0.00429212162271142, 0.002530047670006752, -0.003126158844679594, -0.0033243123907595873, -0.038071684539318085, -0.009364173747599125, -0.06828077882528305, -0.0013020709156990051, 0.010302525013685226, 0.026463786140084267, -0.04006621986627579, -0.0021561833564192057, 0.013123400509357452, 0.015234027989208698, 0.00268269213847816, -0.02519400790333748, 0.003988799173384905, 0.00982866995036602, -0.024894151836633682, -0.025845084339380264, 0.025226520374417305, 0.012920493260025978, -0.01554648857563734, -0.004928987473249435, -0.04805741086602211, 0.047655899077653885, -0.04937022551894188, 0.004306209739297628, 0.010317275300621986, -0.005011522676795721, 0.0398075170814991, -0.0046109044924378395, 0.020869901403784752, 0.0012308642035350204, 0.01094090472906828, -0.03642691299319267, 0.015309680253267288, -0.0040302397683262825, -0.005835195071995258, -0.028473298996686935, 0.06537552177906036, 0.012741775251924992, -0.012702202424407005, -0.04777855798602104, -0.02609948068857193, 0.039650723338127136, -0.013293911702930927, -0.022313106805086136, -0.008693450130522251, -0.021298201754689217, -0.0025131264701485634, 0.0037297606468200684, -0.02352043054997921, 0.028593188151717186, -0.015805881470441818, -0.025329751893877983, 0.009236529469490051, -0.013095716014504433, 0.09616173803806305, -0.020880622789263725, 0.005781908985227346, 0.01836632564663887, 0.024474820122122765, 0.0019418803276494145, -0.00729719502851367, 0.03116781637072563, -0.057615913450717926, -0.014269459992647171, -0.009588454850018024, -0.028932467103004456, 0.026328502222895622, 0.008053621277213097, -0.012320748530328274, 0.0024690055288374424, 0.011714421212673187, 0.022250324487686157, -0.005853431764990091, 0.037493620067834854, -0.007044498808681965, -0.0293881855905056, -0.004254026338458061, 0.003592374734580517, -0.025676535442471504, 0.004943685606122017, -0.0256161168217659, 0.03533933684229851, -0.01673237793147564, -0.0117179648950696, 0.06945855915546417, 0.013982627540826797, -0.01887025497853756, 0.01597781665623188, -0.005743013229221106, 0.06898258626461029, -0.029887700453400612, 0.006183801684528589, 0.001980347791686654, 0.055739082396030426, -0.054541539400815964, -0.020343944430351257, -0.02385427989065647, -0.04362446442246437, 0.05512489005923271, -0.05391191691160202, 0.020136984065175056, 0.03321622312068939, 0.02165537327528, 0.03521216660737991, -0.015655724331736565, -0.04367023706436157, -0.03161047026515007, 0.02972700260579586, 0.029638715088367462, -0.02119329571723938, 0.007662879303097725, 0.031578775495290756, 0.00021522692986764014, 0.05185779929161072, 0.05979020148515701, 0.017909573391079903, -0.001935341628268361, 0.004557773470878601, -0.04199932888150215, -0.04110394045710564, 0.04972179979085922, -0.07694784551858902, -0.0007593457703478634, -0.007230132818222046, -0.058775223791599274, 0.03492595627903938, -0.0018512147944420576, -0.008180643431842327, -0.03252227231860161, -0.012111902236938477, -0.0447329543530941, -0.011134673841297626, -0.015640519559383392, 0.00678714644163847, 0.017051806673407555, -0.035799991339445114, 0.04158439114689827, 0.03362368792295456, 0.030326154083013535, -0.040499087423086166, -0.06497973203659058, 0.005704864859580994, -0.004917812068015337, -0.05768760293722153, 0.010437640361487865, 0.06534527242183685, 0.0034971239510923624, 0.029842743650078773, -0.021450873464345932, -0.03681959956884384, 0.0009725359850563109, 0.04302108660340309, -0.01751306839287281, 0.06126333028078079, 0.0027255199383944273, 0.031031524762511253, 0.00044200653792358935, -0.008483018726110458, 0.123227559030056, 0.03722359240055084, 0.035090669989585876, -0.04901277646422386, 0.01639827899634838, -0.00010156582720810547, 0.01537162996828556, -0.04037059471011162, 0.01616840437054634, 0.020021162927150726, 0.035730209201574326, 0.04334431514143944, 0.028526470065116882, 0.006136205978691578, 0.00878281332552433, 0.05874970927834511, -0.04130192846059799, 0.008204742334783077, 0.04254983365535736, -0.02837422490119934, 0.016269026324152946, -0.02059895545244217, -0.021635428071022034, 0.009297986514866352, 0.030377326533198357, -0.00611133174970746, -0.0018806785810738802, -0.018669871613383293, -0.007020213641226292, 0.02447512373328209, 0.0026291408576071262, 0.054021500051021576, 0.006513360887765884, 0.0007634913199581206, 0.014594588428735733, 0.008104702457785606, 0.012020227499306202, -0.015334295108914375, -0.008323431015014648, 0.04700752720236778, 0.03594637289643288, -0.01261319313198328, -0.0038961777463555336, 0.043287213891744614, -0.0429750457406044, -0.007504499517381191, -0.03921090438961983, -0.00549474498257041, -0.006237077992409468, -0.0024167331866919994, -0.03839629516005516, -0.016810137778520584, -0.006457520183175802, -0.022846635431051254, -0.04500008374452591, 0.02222113311290741, 0.03439163416624069, 0.03510252758860588, -0.006762832868844271, -0.005625201854854822, -0.0006473402609117329, -0.051828499883413315, 0.0042076208628714085, 0.05286131426692009, -0.0066388132981956005, -0.024530179798603058, -0.034315500408411026, 0.041565731167793274, 0.018855834379792213, -0.009608052670955658, -0.022281402722001076, -0.006014998536556959, -0.022790247574448586, -0.002876586513593793, -0.014590142294764519, -0.0010426316875964403, -0.012355457060039043, -0.024445055052638054, 0.012687921524047852, -0.02698608860373497, 0.0007048254483379424, 0.05552065372467041, -0.0019119489006698132, 0.006693644914776087, -0.07459545880556107, -0.022894108667969704, 0.029831694439053535, 0.038114242255687714, 0.020684966817498207, 0.018425140529870987, 0.011433295905590057, 0.027266738936305046, 0.01536873821169138, -0.04955914616584778, -0.03527481481432915, -0.003407147014513612, -0.05440136790275574, 0.005737090948969126, 0.013564729131758213, 0.06166289746761322, 0.015231819823384285, -0.011787079274654388, -0.008417322300374508, 0.00589751685038209, -0.02504350058734417, 0.035557519644498825, 0.018351802602410316, -0.061819255352020264, -0.016745297238230705, 0.0013053279835730791, 0.00756563525646925, -0.008703022263944149, -0.013900275342166424, -0.028181608766317368, -0.0006591634592041373, 0.0071932049468159676, 0.013777704909443855, -0.008829894475638866, 0.027197668328881264, -0.04561719298362732, 0.035935916006565094, -0.03224664181470871, -0.0015977773582562804, -0.051735542714595795, -0.023682454600930214, 0.008425871841609478, -0.007875286974012852, -0.025796445086598396, 0.0031068380922079086, 0.008927733637392521, 0.02255721017718315, 0.010753463953733444, -0.00465940497815609, -0.0016728235641494393, -0.029207520186901093, 0.02438366785645485, -0.0014558701077476144, 0.0670018121600151, -0.07546163350343704, -0.05444877967238426, 0.0407232865691185, -0.026647329330444336, -0.019922152161598206, 0.0070527768693864346, 0.004577435087412596, 0.022864283993840218, -0.007777745835483074, -0.039931077510118484, -0.03128087520599365, 0.03420223668217659, -0.016891388222575188, -0.034057192504405975, 0.014654838480055332, -0.04664064943790436, 0.0477382056415081, 0.059288304299116135, -0.012441459111869335, -0.0053812661208212376, 0.010886461474001408, -0.003551068715751171, 0.044743478298187256, 0.002982524922117591, -0.014511281624436378, -0.020126761868596077, 0.018327724188566208, 0.003695847000926733, 0.007979773916304111, -0.02062983065843582, 0.0012448305496945977, 0.008984388783574104, -0.05482426658272743, -0.008246741257607937, -0.004839692264795303, 0.01595587655901909, -0.009406034834682941, -0.004140363074839115, 0.031125370413064957, -0.018635883927345276, 0.0003550688561517745, -0.03710917755961418, -0.009265737608075142, -0.005525992251932621, -0.048416782170534134, 0.04735489934682846, -0.0342370979487896, 0.021178893744945526, -0.041249655187129974, 0.02241041511297226, -0.06319402903318405, 0.023198895156383514, 0.016025720164179802, 0.03741120174527168, 0.004051561001688242, 0.00406791502609849, -0.002736382419243455, -0.009404356591403484, -0.026817860081791878, 0.010139110498130322, 0.001802587416023016, -0.049415357410907745, 0.045742228627204895, -0.010419792495667934, -0.05665237456560135, 0.06115192547440529, -0.036251250654459, 0.0004973328905180097, -0.016816185787320137, 0.022789951413869858, 0.008434180170297623, 0.039584074169397354, 0.0077933454886078835, 0.009169964119791985, -0.038419295102357864, -0.009154809638857841, 0.03748217597603798, 0.03427384793758392, 0.010035030543804169, -0.012318333610892296, 0.038508616387844086, 0.024428656324744225, -0.02671831101179123, 0.0451468899846077, 0.01071744691580534, -0.000648011511657387, -0.009036758914589882, 0.01193050853908062, 0.06310489028692245, -0.03074975684285164, -0.00420118635520339, -0.014238283969461918, 0.018734658136963844, 0.03813028708100319, -0.029037294909358025, -0.018378710374236107, -0.004051651805639267, 0.009255020879209042, -0.033985480666160583, 0.0019010769901797175, 0.03098912350833416, -0.006146250758320093, -0.04231012985110283, 0.02106279693543911, -0.013423946686089039, 0.005955008789896965, -0.0014392901211977005, -0.029962411150336266, -0.02507661283016205, 0.037488099187612534, -0.022380385547876358, 0.016653617843985558, 0.015150059014558792, -0.0390174463391304, -0.009846043772995472, -0.07878127694129944, 0.009910302236676216, 0.006915715988725424, 0.03764943778514862, -0.03556042164564133, -0.03331640362739563, -0.04245242848992348, 0.0036379522643983364, 0.041022662073373795, -0.025232573971152306, -0.03517386317253113, -0.027938680723309517, -0.011896034702658653, 0.03762044385075569, -0.030904868617653847, 0.014534590765833855, -0.03913452848792076, -0.016262896358966827, -0.0008150338544510305, 0.02958257682621479, -0.020347541198134422, -0.029278840869665146, 0.046341121196746826, -0.043240878731012344, -0.02503114752471447, -0.013828866183757782, -0.003480959916487336, 0.019397340714931488, 0.02064962312579155, 0.0002187208883697167, 0.028377296403050423, 0.030409324914216995, 0.01572928950190544, 0.02555748261511326, 0.007302931509912014, -0.032810620963573456, 0.040917832404375076, -0.04784395173192024, -0.05252917483448982, -0.012640739791095257, 0.027841636911034584, 0.004617051687091589, -0.057423848658800125, -0.02933960035443306, 0.04572322219610214, -0.034702274948358536, -0.005694440566003323, 0.041085030883550644, 0.0035367782693356276, 0.04935074225068092, -0.00824696384370327, 0.05807840824127197, -0.014201756566762924, -0.05026542395353317, -0.008744420483708382, -0.005614519584923983, 0.025545163080096245, -0.0014566224999725819, 0.024013284593820572, 0.0702432170510292, 0.03242108225822449, 0.0334162637591362, 0.013644463382661343, 0.06012263149023056, 0.01427044440060854, -0.0067737591452896595, -0.004657188430428505, 0.008103026077151299, -0.011831938289105892, 0.0318576954305172, 0.007395179942250252, 0.0349605418741703, -0.03339454531669617, 0.011264283210039139, -0.06228046491742134, 0.003238172736018896, -0.014170710928738117, -0.013444814831018448, -0.02916903607547283, 0.03522004187107086, -0.03003978729248047, -0.02878934144973755, 0.031011635437607765, 0.03666319698095322, 0.03578240051865578, -0.007090237457305193, 0.0032996898517012596, -0.007586030755192041, -0.006228750105947256, -0.00885352399200201, -0.04699267819523811, 0.009985247626900673, 0.0008458885713480413, 0.06761402636766434, 0.032096926122903824, -0.006490039173513651, 0.022275717929005623, -0.029673591256141663, -0.012262261472642422, 0.03124363347887993, -0.06267189979553223, -0.039653386920690536, -0.04689329117536545, 0.0025011261459439993, 0.019599802792072296, -0.059638116508722305 ]
<p>I need to test for correlation of 4 sets of weather parameters between 2 sites. I am not interested in interactions between the parameters. Because no weather parameter is independent from other weather parameters, if I was simply trying to determine if each parameter differed between the 2 sites, I would use a MANOVA followed by multiple-comparisons <em>t</em>-tests, and correct for family-wise error using a Bonferroni method. But since I want to see if the parameters are <em>correlated</em> between the sites, I'm not sure what to do. </p> <p>Is there an overarching test (like MANOVA) that should be applied prior to what amounts to multiple-comparison correlations? Or can I just do multiple Spearman's correlations and interpret from there?</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: I suppose in the long run it doesn't really matter to me if the 2 parameters are statistically significantly correlated. What <em>will</em> matter is the strength of their correlations. That, from what I understand, is subjective (based on the field)...is this correct? In this respect, is there any multiple-comparison sort of thing I should be keeping in mind?</p>
74,144
[ -0.03140760958194733, -0.01917511411011219, -0.015135165303945541, 0.02802383340895176, 0.026664037257432938, 0.02537144348025322, 0.038530901074409485, -0.0102289579808712, 0.02565119042992592, -0.024112796410918236, 0.03766106814146042, 0.02383124642074108, 0.01429247111082077, 0.01984463818371296, 0.023925235494971275, -0.0008358632912859321, -0.018875690177083015, 0.012117840349674225, 0.026576248928904533, -0.009638980031013489, -0.027830975130200386, 0.013364325277507305, -0.012221475131809711, -0.006052372511476278, -0.00812072679400444, 0.038205280900001526, -0.004799856338649988, -0.044320885092020035, 0.03403341397643089, 0.03183922916650772, -0.03635813668370247, -0.06604098528623581, 0.01849457621574402, 0.0791354849934578, 0.02130262739956379, -0.016049519181251526, -0.013194972649216652, -0.00368774333037436, -0.01315802987664938, 0.040122415870428085, -0.03690321743488312, -0.07631849497556686, -0.0016178530640900135, 0.010085362941026688, -0.03189521282911301, 0.01102537102997303, 0.001984005095437169, -0.015493144281208515, 0.06234775111079216, -0.057470131665468216, 0.059611476957798004, -0.002365732565522194, 0.037938959896564484, 0.07017416507005692, -0.019226552918553352, -0.027172531932592392, 0.067066989839077, 0.018101613968610764, -0.007321367971599102, -0.045586418360471725, -0.02135978825390339, -0.008042548783123493, 0.021292762830853462, 0.012397920712828636, -0.04847673699259758, 0.02554861456155777, 0.024900363758206367, -0.05100339278578758, 0.02752472087740898, 0.010244365781545639, 0.0013274744851514697, -0.011304146610200405, 0.05944571644067764, 0.015068775974214077, 0.0002991371147800237, -0.023301582783460617, 0.0032322651240974665, 0.020582666620612144, 0.05446663871407509, 0.03735028952360153, -0.004115287214517593, 0.028591597452759743, -0.008753623813390732, 0.023884927853941917, 0.06260065734386444, -0.003582566976547241, 0.053881868720054626, -0.03752269595861435, 0.0019735340029001236, 0.01878243498504162, -0.003618392860516906, -0.008845292963087559, 0.0441129244863987, 0.021132947877049446, -0.04931315779685974, 0.008379608392715454, -0.021006690338253975, 0.009481914341449738, 0.006498650647699833, 0.028543928638100624, -0.01704263500869274, -0.019285310059785843, 0.015034902840852737, 0.03779519721865654, -0.012023900635540485, 0.004580150358378887, -0.03640519455075264, -0.0037520602345466614, -0.026195891201496124, -0.02876237779855728, -0.024613678455352783, 0.01779204234480858, -0.023540809750556946, -0.008021566085517406, 0.02975824475288391, -0.03106372244656086, 0.025216728448867798, -0.010302253998816013, 0.08628703653812408, 0.04244207590818405, 0.0658993199467659, -0.01688448339700699, 0.008810985833406448, -0.02566518448293209, -0.020849375054240227, -0.0028099045157432556, -0.009787339717149734, -0.0047855074517428875, -0.005628085695207119, 0.054080113768577576, 0.026369018480181694, -0.0051963115110993385, 0.005181362386792898, -0.01524023525416851, 0.012449460104107857, 0.03492401912808418, -0.10133656859397888, -0.04376760125160217, 0.022789932787418365, 0.00001160129249910824, -0.010537718422710896, -0.06685004383325577, 0.007494541350752115, 0.007188891991972923, 0.052924711257219315, 0.005133202765136957, 0.04293638840317726, -0.01471797190606594, 0.03848891705274582, 0.023944556713104248, -0.030426783487200737, 0.005631772801280022, -0.010042397305369377, -0.03101266734302044, -0.010263463482260704, -0.07722882926464081, 0.02367302216589451, 0.026051286607980728, 0.014455031603574753, 0.024691499769687653, 0.06700411438941956, 0.03223012015223503, 0.0058376058004796505, -0.011453196406364441, 0.03780161216855049, 0.015515094622969627, 0.032434284687042236, -0.03736395388841629, 0.0148076880723238, -0.014780629426240921, 0.011370845139026642, -0.004169559571892023, 0.01175486110150814, 0.05248086899518967, 0.07034176588058472, -0.021351542323827744, 0.017620980739593506, -0.01552686095237732, 0.010047945193946362, 0.004144660197198391, -0.039056457579135895, -0.006815417669713497, -0.017260432243347168, -0.029327888041734695, 0.02156411111354828, 0.05350324884057045, -0.016061127185821533, -0.024339299649000168, 0.05769237503409386, -0.045865580439567566, -0.018344677984714508, -0.08769818395376205, -0.01130872592329979, -0.005784628447145224, -0.03501604124903679, 0.07436227053403854, -0.004013671074062586, 0.03408791497349739, -0.0127431470900774, -0.017625031992793083, -0.0212177112698555, 0.04191301017999649, 0.05270417779684067, -0.009945773519575596, 0.01598210632801056, 0.012816979549825191, 0.029449108988046646, -0.009350627660751343, 0.02938241884112358, -0.026862530037760735, -0.07785188406705856, -0.0016080127097666264, -0.01794726960361004, 0.005128312855958939, 0.019298385828733444, -0.03883741423487663, 0.015160634182393551, -0.006966773420572281, -0.034318599849939346, 0.03866344690322876, -0.05094330385327339, 0.06569430977106094, 0.042401328682899475, -0.015592552721500397, 0.0072517236694693565, 0.018508099019527435, 0.03041194938123226, 0.002468435326591134, -0.040811389684677124, 0.006204510107636452, -0.05293518677353859, -0.018364926800131798, 0.03414294496178627, -0.006356421392410994, -0.03231985494494438, 0.03379996865987778, 0.06175188347697258, 0.041550032794475555, -0.021199587732553482, 0.050384923815727234, 0.013778313994407654, -0.013608860783278942, 0.010183139704167843, 0.012643815018236637, 0.05014008656144142, 0.01579703390598297, 0.01991589367389679, 0.0065501355566084385, -0.0010674382792785764, -0.016041651368141174, 0.009798265993595123, 0.04969465360045433, 0.010231763124465942, 0.017395243048667908, -0.04192795231938362, -0.0018648545956239104, 0.04156339541077614, -0.010246671736240387, 0.011243731714785099, 0.020353173837065697, 0.019862692803144455, 0.000185285578481853, -0.024392416700720787, -0.035115908831357956, 0.04580777511000633, -0.0007522427476942539, -0.015158998779952526, 0.004707458894699812, 0.02653837949037552, -0.031734924763441086, -0.006791800260543823, -0.03155278041958809, -0.005900225136429071, -0.011128469370305538, 0.01550828292965889, 0.03938348963856697, 0.01284419372677803, 0.03421879559755325, -0.006332142744213343, -0.05550786852836609, -0.03259211778640747, -0.019282381981611252, -0.026346875354647636, -0.010113469325006008, -0.04390064999461174, -0.011947216466069221, -0.03479994460940361, 0.010420636273920536, 0.03207356855273247, -0.026872647926211357, -0.024454403668642044, 0.028553498908877373, 0.019021257758140564, -0.039251040667295456, -0.010486800223588943, -0.03172411397099495, -0.013350892812013626, -0.03156477212905884, -0.05690733343362808, 0.06500288844108582, -0.03825122490525246, -0.03641796484589577, 0.015137924812734127, -0.03729981556534767, 0.007558790501207113, 0.01808116026222706, -0.011132289655506611, -0.012531701475381851, -0.004502694122493267, -0.019805995747447014, 0.02972068078815937, -0.040976960211992264, -0.03525717183947563, -0.04693019762635231, -0.09282439202070236, 0.043634332716464996, 0.02038293145596981, 0.03466866910457611, -0.03634629771113396, -0.05616176500916481, 0.05442524701356888, 0.03945476934313774, -0.002223655814304948, -0.037694260478019714, 0.030476095154881477, -0.04539581388235092, -0.00413812231272459, 0.0037035970017313957, 0.01755247265100479, 0.0205509215593338, 0.06506186723709106, 0.03278147056698799, -0.002469735685735941, 0.04182644188404083, 0.02847852185368538, 0.007683198433369398, 0.005192149430513382, 0.014705981127917767, -0.012770945206284523, 0.057512782514095306, 0.020885653793811798, -0.02272050455212593, -0.016257913783192635, 0.006517820991575718, -0.007987674325704575, 0.02359095588326454, -0.025204360485076904, 0.03924113139510155, -0.0020367815159261227, 0.002602694323286414, -0.03683967515826225, 0.014722995460033417, 0.015571882016956806, -0.002048338996246457, -0.023030424490571022, 0.04360568895936012, 0.041220951825380325, 0.018052389845252037, 0.0007529846043325961, 0.032030608505010605, 0.040941305458545685, -0.03818303719162941, -0.00810148287564516, -0.011208741925656796, -0.014767199754714966, 0.012429791502654552, -0.020277202129364014, 0.003950461745262146, 0.030733902007341385, -0.007515431381762028, 0.005547542590647936, -0.00117404549382627, -0.060767412185668945, 0.003116995794698596, -0.05912114679813385, 0.01430665235966444, -0.0717993676662445, 0.028897620737552643, 0.012794082053005695, 0.024543097242712975, 0.01886097900569439, -0.006753877736628056, 0.03589389845728874, -0.01529949251562357, -0.042509909719228745, 0.03724394738674164, 0.008211120031774044, -0.018225058913230896, 0.015436581335961819, -0.05380879342556, 0.0009243524982593954, -0.03300604596734047, 0.039302848279476166, 0.0027991202659904957, 0.044054772704839706, 0.003804001957178116, -0.004470143932849169, -0.04118296504020691, -0.04544031620025635, 0.011484197340905666, 0.022573165595531464, 0.012697525322437286, -0.0285001453012228, 0.04442799463868141, 0.06633930653333664, -0.024453118443489075, -0.03410207852721214, -0.02713933028280735, 0.0034174241591244936, 0.0006156964227557182, 0.030374743044376373, 0.012102046050131321, 0.016629019752144814, -0.05154160037636757, 0.019042136147618294, 0.02209271676838398, 0.03389832749962807, 0.047350719571113586, -0.016082406044006348, -0.026862164959311485, -0.012784837745130062, -0.03291555494070053, 0.010960827581584454, 0.017537832260131836, 0.02905736304819584, -0.0032486238051205873, 0.05122834071516991, 0.03277147188782692, -0.04843262583017349, 0.018627198413014412, 0.04083595424890518, -0.0012267561396583915, 0.01830900087952614, -0.010997491888701916, -0.0311732217669487, 0.0060886298306286335, -0.004979679360985756, 0.028491917997598648, 0.03047446720302105, -0.02845769189298153, -0.005115919280797243, 0.03450760617852211, -0.019261155277490616, -0.025365550071001053, 0.04319549724459648, 0.008070950396358967, 0.04781636223196983, -0.02289210632443428, -0.04153607785701752, 0.00533555680885911, 0.03967162221670151, 0.009122691117227077, 0.009090634994208813, -0.022527718916535378, -0.07171417027711868, 0.02249813638627529, 0.07173874229192734, 0.036046694964170456, -0.060898810625076294, 0.0011677701259031892, -0.00665774941444397, -0.0061756307259202, 0.036273788660764694, -0.01587570086121559, 0.0006055912817828357, 0.021859796717762947, 0.010377002879977226, -0.046400442719459534, -0.044559456408023834, -0.04700877517461777, 0.0026087819132953882, -0.004811930004507303, 0.011541553772985935, -0.011207177303731441, -0.008444060571491718, -0.012284577824175358, 0.006457206793129444, 0.015336812473833561, 0.08462203294038773, 0.01522062812000513, -0.004961452912539244, -0.005479281302541494, -0.014168299734592438, 0.011058059521019459, -0.06365320086479187, 0.0018618591129779816, -0.005749834701418877, -0.057075195014476776, 0.0678711086511612, -0.014793614856898785, -0.033656273037195206, 0.02166779153048992, 0.015465420670807362, -0.035658691078424454, 0.023775195702910423, -0.020666401833295822, 0.0514327809214592, 0.01517895795404911, 0.03567907586693764, 0.046197984367609024, 0.0019019159954041243, -0.035997722297906876, 0.008718491531908512, -0.03160686790943146, 0.014698691666126251, -0.03095318004488945, -0.005146155599504709, -0.04968643561005592, -0.006949753034859896, -0.03942149132490158, 0.033359672874212265, 0.004790177568793297, 0.0379275418817997, -0.03997429832816124, -0.002317079110071063, -0.01981945149600506, 0.00032579299295321107, -0.011993851512670517, 0.013499018736183643, -0.026246724650263786, 0.02187403291463852, -0.014656662940979004, -0.046223610639572144, -0.00814246479421854, -0.038726888597011566, 0.014279479160904884, 0.01166212372481823, -0.05420268699526787, 0.03451085090637207, -0.037196364253759384, -0.029949000105261803, -0.022629182785749435, -0.03075401298701763, 0.03349742293357849, 0.04380862042307854, 0.010577834211289883, 0.050195205956697464, -0.02925148606300354, 0.011435028165578842, 0.058015115559101105, 0.001752809272147715, 0.03861071914434433, -0.024835195392370224, 0.004611663985997438, -0.01284131221473217, 0.0018475055694580078, -0.053919922560453415, -0.016622409224510193, -0.005458082538098097, 0.029621407389640808, -0.01637842133641243, -0.03522297739982605, 0.001575650880113244, -0.038396697491407394, -0.008213100954890251, -0.006486126221716404, 0.07186996936798096, -0.0007746578194200993, -0.001579150091856718, -0.0007910830317996442, 0.05481197312474251, 0.08544279634952545, -0.0182182677090168, 0.010365059599280357, 0.016167258843779564, -0.019915152341127396, -0.030649973079562187, 0.006557611282914877, -0.0131386024877429, -0.053897425532341, -0.005694138817489147, -0.020909130573272705, 0.009341861121356487, 0.04561549052596092, 0.006501858122646809, -0.02038426697254181, -0.014195435680449009, -0.013147111982107162, -0.021319888532161713, -0.02235930971801281, 0.01894179917871952, -0.001230693538673222, 0.03608781844377518, -0.0262913778424263, -0.005347247701138258, -0.011073264293372631, -0.022702863439917564, -0.0016023205826058984, 0.016517063602805138, -0.03124716319143772, 0.028545092791318893, 0.0956132784485817, 0.027622036635875702, -0.0047353459522128105, 0.0019206273136660457, -0.008790676482021809, 0.013355707749724388, -0.012778110802173615, -0.016482850536704063, -0.0010288211051374674, 0.05563807860016823, -0.019801901653409004, -0.05420742928981781, 0.0025706521701067686, -0.021989211440086365, 0.06915964186191559, -0.016898594796657562, 0.05204954370856285, 0.08567096292972565, -0.003262588754296303, -0.00850297324359417, -0.01786421798169613, 0.020503176376223564, 0.018569698557257652, -0.010583248920738697, 0.05327785760164261, 0.017143206670880318, 0.015908479690551758, 0.007484234869480133, 0.02205042541027069, -0.0012670874129980803, 0.0006024324102327228, 0.00820713210850954, 0.03126709163188934, 0.042120449244976044, -0.033563073724508286, -0.07244380563497543, 0.027570612728595734, -0.06175800412893295, -0.006255661603063345, -0.008579064160585403, 0.0036362111568450928, 0.037856120616197586, 0.04641808941960335, -0.02263219654560089, -0.047148942947387695, -0.04371201619505882, -0.018823621794581413, 0.011712806299328804, 0.013862788677215576, -0.019525406882166862, -0.013227101415395737, 0.04148959740996361, 0.057421986013650894, -0.0019489193800836802, 0.00297331134788692, -0.026346344500780106, -0.07951939105987549, -0.027775345370173454, 0.014724907465279102, -0.007483425550162792, 0.05755767598748207, -0.004038748797029257, -0.04191453382372856, 0.000068746114266105, -0.01741938665509224, 0.008231207728385925, -0.000532573729287833, 0.029636476188898087, -0.028346966952085495, 0.04642448201775551, -0.0018764857668429613, -0.011648875661194324, 0.03927897289395332, 0.0025395683478564024, 0.10306540876626968, 0.06735147535800934, 0.025048254057765007, -0.04454600811004639, 0.027654221281409264, -0.015946747735142708, 0.00663234805688262, -0.04859082028269768, 0.020736385136842728, 0.0018819314427673817, 0.028526272624731064, 0.06852181255817413, 0.029685016721487045, 0.009695255197584629, -0.024263402447104454, 0.07480119913816452, -0.005597859155386686, 0.0022294949740171432, -0.012300829403102398, 0.010862230323255062, -0.03037875145673752, -0.024065157398581505, -0.02348366752266884, -0.010864400304853916, -0.024663232266902924, 0.033581312745809555, -0.003542414167895913, -0.03450663387775421, 0.0037222213577479124, -0.015347499400377274, -0.016329601407051086, 0.009657773189246655, 0.012602364644408226, 0.021630484610795975, -0.029572071507573128, 0.004781501367688179, 0.015316278673708439, -0.02937551960349083, 0.02506733499467373, 0.02537674643099308, -0.03149819374084473, -0.030466962605714798, 0.034918781369924545, 0.032397396862506866, -0.011657064780592918, -0.013472672551870346, -0.043586041778326035, 0.04641277715563774, 0.01875080168247223, 0.015421146526932716, -0.007734944112598896, 0.007850989699363708, 0.017650727182626724, -0.04015009477734566, -0.004982829559594393, 0.012899079360067844, 0.01829264499247074, -0.06279347836971283, -0.011147921904921532, -0.05576478689908981, 0.010662236250936985, 0.02167777344584465, 0.001862767618149519, 0.04839186370372772, -0.03779233247041702, -0.01575322262942791, -0.0197422094643116, 0.04738418757915497, 0.05883107706904411, -0.03147077187895775, 0.008858934976160526, 0.008571519516408443, -0.010249380022287369, -0.004302435088902712, -0.004855530336499214, -0.024142803624272346, 0.06299443542957306, 0.013006436638534069, -0.010709211230278015, 0.008086330257356167, -0.052556879818439484, -0.02024661749601364, -0.04322220757603645, -0.006153385154902935, -0.031070156022906303, 0.0039010592736303806, 0.03607828542590141, 0.04009849950671196, 0.07286594808101654, 0.020538337528705597, -0.026388006284832954, 0.06165354698896408, 0.031018685549497604, -0.06629869341850281, -0.01449588406831026, 0.0016289084451273084, -0.031357020139694214, -0.02994304709136486, 0.013895701617002487, 0.054112259298563004, 0.0018008367624133825, 0.018399521708488464, -0.010419635102152824, 0.0009445046307519078, 0.0071915555745363235, 0.010506809689104557, 0.052598778158426285, -0.05779751017689705, -0.009449100121855736, -0.008058741688728333, 0.00906591396778822, -0.015047724358737469, -0.010346527211368084, -0.039336591958999634, -0.010923229157924652, 0.02496986836194992, -0.030758293345570564, -0.06144820153713226, -0.011891912668943405, -0.004294574726372957, 0.02789353020489216, -0.02802618220448494, -0.015381455421447754, -0.0553148128092289, -0.017037056386470795, 0.015039227902889252, 0.019897514954209328, 0.008072379976511002, -0.010969692841172218, -0.06080125272274017, -0.020418774336576462, 0.05293498560786247, 0.01967300847172737, 0.0029790534172207117, -0.0038616114761680365, -0.00893098022788763, 0.03463418409228325, 0.07498026639223099, -0.013182234019041061, -0.027100497856736183, 0.03753035515546799, -0.023474903777241707, -0.039387937635183334, 0.004379730671644211, -0.008852602913975716, 0.02060324139893055, -0.016003329306840897, -0.006025558337569237, -0.045958470553159714, 0.04714256152510643, -0.0009208624833263457, -0.001040309900417924, -0.010373407043516636, 0.006949335336685181, 0.016652310267090797, -0.011208812706172466, 0.020418139174580574, -0.0053146942518651485, -0.022627566009759903, 0.01216787938028574, 0.041685886681079865, -0.0026637474074959755, 0.00792445708066225, 0.006311727222055197, -0.021792607381939888, -0.0018208111869171262, -0.022133588790893555, -0.028884710744023323, 0.011599980294704437, 0.09223794937133789, -0.00941368006169796, 0.047208476811647415, 0.010631361044943333, 0.019725607708096504, -0.08378321677446365, -0.0034734311047941446, 0.0465361624956131, -0.0040006088092923164, 0.0187066737562418, -0.04727261886000633, 0.01945270411670208, 0.034039780497550964, -0.025564247742295265, 0.007307126652449369, 0.029007770121097565, -0.004944309592247009, -0.02392185851931572, -0.018204625695943832, -0.019799958914518356, 0.02223413810133934, 0.0208700280636549, -0.0014938575914129615, -0.016816165298223495, 0.06164572387933731, 0.008671848103404045, 0.005592051427811384, -0.034954387694597244, 0.01864248514175415, 0.04835985228419304, -0.07240604609251022, 0.007071077823638916, -0.022187434136867523, -0.035116877406835556, 0.027808301150798798, -0.017423437908291817, -0.005321744363754988, -0.03149618208408356, 0.013792870566248894, -0.0005355280009098351, 0.040559254586696625, 0.02375992015004158, -0.009227232076227665, 0.004361181054264307, 0.009380974806845188, 0.0014819225762039423, 0.036213796585798264, -0.029514659196138382, -0.00464432081207633, 0.006761219818145037, -0.027293017134070396, -0.03742926940321922, 0.010591469705104828, -0.023966185748577118, -0.02342851832509041, -0.010755038820207119, -0.019993850961327553, 0.032178398221731186, -0.0010675938101485372, 0.004939863923937082, -0.036589302122592926, -0.02175690047442913, 0.0452929325401783, 0.004879454150795937, -0.04418276995420456, 0.0026860572397708893, -0.017866577953100204, -0.02494497410953045, -0.015230252407491207, -0.014937772415578365, -0.032472144812345505, -0.049092356115579605, 0.00024560728343203664, -0.011752941645681858, -0.01069405023008585, -0.04479334503412247, -0.011300455778837204, -0.03253251686692238, 0.0370323583483696, -0.03217308595776558, 0.018692664802074432, -0.014907082542777061, -0.005516270641237497, 0.02420475147664547, -0.07596562802791595, 0.06219303235411644, -0.0012916785199195147, 0.004114182200282812, -0.03827043995261192, 0.001252074376679957, -0.026636863127350807, -0.019467530772089958, 0.05230071768164635, -0.018034301698207855, 0.007567979861050844, 0.01580941304564476, 0.028832843527197838, -0.0030613138806074858, -0.046271421015262604, 0.029407592490315437, 0.004079120233654976, -0.02113202214241028, 0.03080294467508793, -0.012381565757095814, 0.004263684619218111, -0.029072271659970284, -0.01510162465274334, -0.0396394357085228, 0.04070552811026573, -0.0003750578034669161, -0.019002370536327362, 0.03850420191884041, 0.0065567390993237495, -0.05450490489602089, 0.03503454104065895, -0.015814311802387238, 0.017119787633419037, 0.0400603711605072, -0.012071602046489716, -0.03968308866024017, 0.062020860612392426, -0.04795852303504944, -0.03351789340376854, -0.001970765646547079, 0.025908928364515305, -0.016244065016508102, -0.07062438130378723, -0.0037363783922046423, -0.009375636465847492, -0.03929293155670166, -0.02043912746012211, 0.03905930742621422, 0.012797684408724308, 0.02168748527765274, -0.0022407264914363623, 0.027905534952878952, 0.01304618176072836, -0.038694828748703, -0.03718584403395653, 0.03908523917198181, 0.044545989483594894, 0.015471610240638256, 0.036278799176216125, 0.030882060527801514, -0.024476170539855957, 0.01289677806198597, -0.020166674628853798, 0.01105452049523592, -0.01800355315208435, -0.05112287774682045, 0.03953288868069649, 0.026745634153485298, 0.022702299058437347, 0.016880201175808907, 0.009847289882600307, 0.04202122241258621, -0.04104584828019142, -0.004567657131701708, -0.04210734739899635, 0.028119100257754326, -0.030115604400634766, 0.029066400602459908, 0.008546528406441212, 0.02166084572672844, 0.0008624048787169158, 0.014062132686376572, -0.010852235369384289, -0.013201944530010223, 0.0028744966257363558, -0.06818895787000656, 0.020032474771142006, -0.01425875723361969, 0.02232092060148716, -0.013549954630434513, 0.01600297912955284, -0.050270359963178635, -0.02448515221476555, 0.02512076497077942, 0.032160378992557526, 0.015487033873796463, -0.01784615032374859, -0.036875318735837936, 0.021055450662970543, 0.024448908865451813, -0.08644244819879532, -0.003993228543549776, -0.0478614866733551, 0.008687632158398628, 0.01999068446457386, -0.023683881387114525 ]
<p>I have two questions related to cross validation in LIBLINEAR </p> <p>I have 1000 documents from which i take 300 documents for training and rest 700 for classification . I train 300 documents with parameter -s 0 having two class labels and then while prediction i feed 700 one by one document to the classifier with -b 1 parameter to get the probability and if the probability is greater than a defined thresh hold then that document i mark as classify and again feed another document till all 700 documents are iterated </p> <p>1:Is it possible to calculate Precision ,Recall,F-score,Accuracy after all 700 documents are classified based on above method.If yes then how?.Please give me one example for the same </p> <p>2:Is it possible to get number of TP,FP documents of a class label.Like get the TP and FP documents of a label For example out of 700 documents 300 are classified as Label1 and 300 classified as Label2 and 100 as unclassified then how to get Tp,FP of label1 300 documents and same for 300 label2..Label1:TP=Doc1,Doc2,Doc4,Doc5......FP=Doc3,Doc6,Doc9.....etc</p>
76
[ -0.04092679172754288, -0.02898765169084072, 0.027859248220920563, 0.01328317355364561, 0.04005992412567139, -0.0058078342117369175, -0.042199358344078064, -0.009940767660737038, 0.037276435643434525, -0.011392207816243172, 0.029746346175670624, 0.012651454657316208, 0.011113973334431648, 0.019553571939468384, -0.017965076491236687, 0.004344473127275705, -0.001154951169155538, 0.008796227164566517, 0.006423298269510269, -0.011807510629296303, -0.018315091729164124, 0.010493396781384945, 0.02205888368189335, -0.011375784873962402, -0.00886834692209959, -0.014591500163078308, 0.020561128854751587, -0.029787536710500717, 0.01862485520541668, 0.045464351773262024, -0.020521312952041626, -0.019699422642588615, 0.039030373096466064, 0.02019045688211918, 0.0293278731405735, -0.001076765707693994, -0.03153898939490318, -0.029164832085371017, -0.02608601190149784, -0.008493311703205109, -0.011101770214736462, -0.007341013289988041, -0.01701328530907631, 0.06628285348415375, -0.02933298982679844, 0.004887636750936508, -0.02805706486105919, 0.006140032783150673, 0.01677756942808628, -0.04509236291050911, 0.045102231204509735, -0.012275895103812218, 0.04693550616502762, 0.023593543097376823, -0.031373750418424606, -0.004045955836772919, 0.058294571936130524, 0.07093502581119537, 0.019098293036222458, -0.03238539770245552, -0.015143065713346004, -0.008907193318009377, 0.03131609782576561, 0.023907631635665894, -0.00515775615349412, 0.01781938225030899, -0.03203057497739792, 0.006439181510359049, 0.030796045437455177, 0.018147138878703117, 0.018889056518673897, 0.013115144334733486, 0.02639329433441162, 0.000877796788699925, 0.024416761472821236, -0.008159350603818893, 0.027072638273239136, 0.026854898780584335, 0.043990761041641235, 0.03980555757880211, -0.010820829309523106, 0.01086366642266512, -0.008707507513463497, 0.028978891670703888, 0.060417018830776215, -0.03448602557182312, 0.03732839971780777, -0.0035288254730403423, 0.053865306079387665, 0.010323786176741123, -0.009778359904885292, -0.006910890340805054, 0.04193175211548805, 0.011694781482219696, -0.041615139693021774, 0.03440908342599869, 0.03166227415204048, -0.00042030541226267815, 0.025567714124917984, -0.006789847277104855, 0.018469102680683136, -0.027674542739987373, 0.019236041232943535, 0.06552030891180038, -0.053624801337718964, 0.009372931905090809, -0.004278847947716713, -0.07005422562360764, -0.00588650070130825, 0.010785698890686035, -0.008513309992849827, 0.014600623399019241, 0.025913400575518608, -0.03480726107954979, -0.011543883010745049, -0.01609165407717228, -0.022249596193432808, 0.003305921098217368, 0.019351253286004066, 0.05271853879094124, 0.03929618373513222, 0.007898311130702496, 0.01579989120364189, -0.0064087831415236, -0.026169834658503532, -0.013931231573224068, 0.01615583524107933, 0.007832573726773262, -0.02635900303721428, 0.07684683799743652, -0.03294867277145386, 0.001441899687051773, 0.03230983018875122, 0.008851376362144947, 0.00001326500660070451, 0.016614006832242012, -0.06532258540391922, -0.05565063655376434, 0.012664987705647945, -0.0257974024862051, 0.04147770255804062, -0.06504762917757034, 0.03324329853057861, 0.017101360484957695, 0.02458273060619831, 0.027879491448402405, 0.032164186239242554, 0.05196552351117134, -0.0238643866032362, 0.0037684375420212746, -0.03132617473602295, 0.006242414936423302, -0.02825320139527321, -0.01735956035554409, -0.031196611002087593, -0.06406141072511673, -0.008688204921782017, -0.00516449473798275, -0.05822283774614334, -0.0006296129431575537, -0.005126502364873886, -0.045051831752061844, 0.00905587151646614, -0.00026633281959220767, -0.017015637829899788, -0.019501084461808205, 0.06281084567308426, 0.04851517081260681, 0.030112307518720627, 0.016025491058826447, 0.0038848824333399534, -0.00939541682600975, 0.004452984780073166, 0.02560640126466751, 0.03819992020726204, -0.024280063807964325, -0.024938402697443962, -0.034084342420101166, 0.045622289180755615, -0.01626363769173622, -0.029529700055718422, -0.017079468816518784, -0.027767272666096687, 0.017017904669046402, 0.009402847848832607, -0.008583752438426018, 0.008757439441978931, 0.04869656637310982, 0.024756355211138725, -0.025075819343328476, -0.0013682974968105555, -0.0299980565905571, 0.02830442599952221, -0.03892477601766586, -0.009806295856833458, 0.029802262783050537, 0.014861371368169785, -0.01050679013133049, -0.005522744730114937, 0.015086784027516842, -0.052693549543619156, 0.023843705654144287, 0.03440549969673157, -0.03949185833334923, 0.016174063086509705, 0.05394313856959343, -0.002035533543676138, -0.0304079819470644, 0.07256501913070679, -0.055489905178546906, -0.04868527501821518, -0.02094176784157753, -0.03612907603383064, -0.034411001950502396, -0.00878129806369543, -0.03819699585437775, 0.023134984076023102, 0.023830369114875793, 0.009805508889257908, -0.011470415629446507, -0.069116972386837, 0.08131151646375656, 0.06780533492565155, 0.030431149527430534, 0.018613876774907112, -0.007229787763208151, 0.007159428205341101, 0.0314674898982048, -0.0009450457291677594, -0.026138942688703537, -0.05344834178686142, -0.024679552763700485, 0.00805366039276123, 0.013653379864990711, -0.016884835436940193, 0.0033189633395522833, 0.04901909455657005, -0.03326551616191864, 0.026270246133208275, 0.011068937368690968, -0.03430547937750816, -0.01453255582600832, 0.01816840097308159, 0.06807676702737808, -0.009799813851714134, -0.014193445444107056, 0.025408096611499786, 0.002251627389341593, 0.04744504392147064, -0.03287775069475174, -0.027604840695858, 0.03817238286137581, -0.0013840647879987955, -0.009857846423983574, 0.009695329703390598, -0.02956080436706543, 0.049776606261730194, 0.030639363452792168, 0.0006356039084494114, 0.038072649389505386, -0.006615287624299526, 0.02089492417871952, 0.014197077602148056, -0.012022798880934715, 0.028986956924200058, 0.016102077439427376, -0.04952497407793999, -0.05469897761940956, 0.003317628987133503, -0.07028951495885849, 0.024283023551106453, 0.02186726965010166, -0.018579227849841118, -0.04618498682975769, 0.03822507709264755, 0.020021948963403702, -0.0034081207122653723, 0.03490837663412094, -0.024593869224190712, -0.028460249304771423, 0.006648319773375988, -0.01628260128200054, 0.03453054279088974, -0.04543019458651543, -0.05686836317181587, 0.029814498499035835, -0.01710793934762478, -0.0182964950799942, 0.028406374156475067, -0.01669446751475334, -0.04708919674158096, 0.010320439003407955, -0.003226970788091421, -0.0509914830327034, -0.05433826893568039, -0.03283100947737694, 0.002138995798304677, -0.010533577762544155, 0.011585450731217861, 0.003893578192219138, 0.005693900398910046, -0.0542108528316021, 0.002506776712834835, -0.006110858172178268, 0.0068728202022612095, -0.02296956069767475, -0.012579092755913734, -0.0259497482329607, 0.0022531633730977774, 0.04147379472851753, 0.0025718414690345526, -0.013046219944953918, 0.015627797693014145, -0.05003465712070465, -0.027351612225174904, 0.0299757719039917, 0.007200440391898155, 0.0343465730547905, 0.006217523477971554, 0.004006792325526476, 0.07527893781661987, 0.028246885165572166, -0.06666428595781326, -0.04772602766752243, 0.01670653373003006, -0.031409163028001785, -0.0017899259692057967, -0.01225824560970068, -0.009330587461590767, 0.0007845822838135064, 0.015823228284716606, 0.008651342242956161, 0.007360376883298159, 0.058093681931495667, -0.02095421776175499, 0.0011225464986637235, -0.010524947196245193, 0.0014551447238773108, -0.02900088205933571, 0.005307880230247974, 0.006771826650947332, -0.03848721832036972, 0.007052028551697731, 0.006848345976322889, 0.02483415976166725, 0.002017442835494876, -0.027570122852921486, 0.005846071522682905, 0.009606041945517063, 0.03116133250296116, -0.01928856037557125, 0.019050007686018944, 0.013584327884018421, -0.015165475197136402, -0.012821534648537636, 0.0008331493008881807, 0.06860143691301346, -0.015592274256050587, -0.012010008096694946, 0.0385916642844677, 0.08057966828346252, -0.037797845900058746, -0.05724992975592613, -0.026455223560333252, -0.01099275704473257, 0.011950857937335968, 0.002465331694111228, -0.01627189852297306, 0.012441081926226616, 0.06464444100856781, 0.004758663009852171, 0.0337056927382946, -0.013569939881563187, -0.00810119230300188, -0.04493089020252228, -0.02286725491285324, -0.03951963409781456, 0.0766330361366272, 0.012328384444117546, 0.021040815860033035, -0.01049957238137722, -0.035641517490148544, 0.01761884242296219, 0.030680112540721893, -0.04195022210478783, 0.02886255271732807, 0.008706998080015182, -0.019169950857758522, 0.019142089411616325, -0.003671779064461589, 0.0348736010491848, -0.05030810460448265, 0.014204658567905426, 0.0011258397717028856, 0.008265520446002483, -0.047674909234046936, 0.0017607673071324825, 0.0014399896608665586, -0.0046414765529334545, -0.033214420080184937, 0.026529058814048767, -0.007830987684428692, -0.003573017194867134, 0.05894437059760094, 0.028547944501042366, 0.022344376891851425, -0.031246379017829895, -0.03242732957005501, 0.012352166697382927, -0.010569975711405277, 0.05974297970533371, 0.054642364382743835, 0.0511147566139698, -0.09729281812906265, -0.0037117700558155775, -0.0027295502368360758, 0.0704546868801117, 0.069135881960392, 0.029060596600174904, -0.02635221555829048, -0.06160670891404152, 0.003219036851078272, 0.0067884731106460094, 0.013784327544271946, -0.02317112125456333, -0.03920784592628479, 0.06109020113945007, -0.0030222940258681774, -0.06357624381780624, 0.014029281213879585, 0.0930740237236023, -0.01966066099703312, 0.00951499491930008, -0.042162779718637466, -0.0021189709659665823, 0.008401179686188698, -0.012941098771989346, 0.037706080824136734, 0.0316622219979763, -0.018533483147621155, 0.015758924186229706, 0.028327414765954018, -0.034167785197496414, -0.029979435727000237, -0.01840655878186226, 0.045120593160390854, 0.01919725351035595, 0.015736130997538567, -0.01811828278005123, 0.013249442912638187, 0.05457295849919319, 0.04575033485889435, -0.0061578270979225636, 0.015559975989162922, -0.07857809960842133, -0.01870802231132984, 0.008733055554330349, 0.05217579007148743, -0.05882105976343155, -0.016193510964512825, -0.01785162091255188, -0.007596889976412058, 0.008922245353460312, -0.024607131257653236, 0.006204009521752596, -0.01113924104720354, 0.022620894014835358, -0.01424564141780138, 0.019276393577456474, -0.02842799387872219, 0.03407636284828186, -0.030764754861593246, 0.02075793221592903, -0.03675447776913643, 0.008206840604543686, 0.00047725957119837403, 0.004126564599573612, -0.0018103995826095343, 0.06375127285718918, -0.011822476051747799, 0.010131451301276684, -0.0019958443008363247, 0.014209321700036526, -0.01089168805629015, -0.06082484498620033, 0.008653750643134117, -0.03454936295747757, -0.016790881752967834, 0.04870795086026192, -0.00038210241473279893, -0.006199129391461611, 0.04622572287917137, 0.06593149900436401, -0.042850762605667114, -0.03125596046447754, -0.022552916780114174, -0.0013177498476579785, 0.029975533485412598, -0.0018177420133724809, 0.06541374325752258, 0.022650673985481262, 0.04879698157310486, 0.005790973547846079, -0.027777070179581642, 0.02745172567665577, -0.017929131165146828, -0.009216619655489922, -0.026410361751914024, 0.004997386131435633, -0.04560898616909981, 0.018192321062088013, -0.003945147152990103, 0.011711637489497662, -0.02547037973999977, 0.0023538367822766304, -0.06538797914981842, 0.03255875036120415, -0.031758058816194534, 0.001686464180238545, 0.015211747027933598, 0.044482193887233734, -0.017749648541212082, -0.013119243085384369, -0.002223009243607521, -0.03854942321777344, 0.039207544177770615, -0.006347712595015764, -0.019059715792536736, 0.002826182171702385, -0.024438969790935516, 0.03364631161093712, 0.011521337553858757, -0.01021723821759224, 0.030750567093491554, 0.05162015184760094, 0.05974053218960762, 0.0037391199730336666, -0.011876868084073067, 0.008820020593702793, 0.035032667219638824, 0.005770223680883646, 0.01947319693863392, -0.050854261964559555, 0.03754616901278496, 0.030842458829283714, -0.04573247209191322, -0.06724155694246292, -0.028064079582691193, 0.04388067126274109, 0.004747031722217798, -0.055608637630939484, -0.03440131992101669, 0.00416466174647212, -0.030038272961974144, -0.0027226789388805628, -0.0317162424325943, 0.024163004010915756, -0.007304398342967033, -0.03234982490539551, 0.0054743485525250435, -0.022156057879328728, 0.027226340025663376, -0.012889165431261063, 0.010553833097219467, -0.0074653420597314835, 0.02427307888865471, -0.046506524085998535, 0.012783425860106945, 0.01237539667636156, -0.02988176979124546, -0.01560868602246046, -0.02134433202445507, 0.048418376594781876, 0.037576500326395035, -0.009903039783239365, -0.00780306663364172, -0.034682922065258026, -0.010314205661416054, -0.016897613182663918, -0.016949981451034546, -0.004310339689254761, 0.03220565989613533, -0.0031879201997071505, -0.024368077516555786, 0.01956360973417759, -0.0008523856522515416, -0.026258202269673347, 0.01229908224195242, -0.02453562803566456, 0.013470851816236973, 0.005122377537190914, 0.08893786370754242, 0.012663530185818672, 0.009087824262678623, -0.019670065492391586, -0.02739819698035717, 0.0503319650888443, 0.010548372752964497, 0.00004543154136626981, 0.006592599209398031, 0.014665075577795506, -0.03644036501646042, 0.025330139324069023, -0.019111797213554382, -0.03417995572090149, 0.05275699496269226, -0.0028955170419067144, 0.03590019419789314, 0.03475037217140198, 0.05103463679552078, -0.018205365166068077, -0.011120022274553776, -0.003464731154963374, 0.007301054894924164, -0.01854504644870758, 0.09184858202934265, -0.006313343066722155, -0.047790393233299255, -0.005860317498445511, 0.03440554812550545, 0.047282442450523376, 0.0284532830119133, 0.012391453608870506, 0.024523859843611717, 0.006950968410819769, -0.01605415530502796, -0.009496618993580341, 0.06779316067695618, -0.03858961537480354, -0.0213678777217865, 0.015560557134449482, -0.05161513760685921, 0.011565213091671467, 0.02954399213194847, -0.0017603443702682853, -0.02131049335002899, -0.04051440954208374, -0.08278603106737137, 0.05939323082566261, 0.04314005374908447, 0.014968430623412132, 0.007600399199873209, -0.03181271255016327, 0.005970328580588102, 0.02875715121626854, 0.04247491434216499, -0.015552498400211334, -0.056372977793216705, -0.03786443546414375, -0.0652039498090744, -0.046473558992147446, 0.03066597506403923, 0.028566060587763786, -0.016571879386901855, 0.01703868806362152, 0.013113848865032196, 0.07054278254508972, 0.003904523327946663, 0.049542784690856934, 0.012514851056039333, 0.04605867713689804, 0.007502445485442877, 0.05426046624779701, 0.01267319731414318, 0.012319967150688171, 0.13604138791561127, 0.06726225465536118, 0.05700097605586052, -0.04637414962053299, -0.009817422367632389, 0.015134642831981182, 0.0018830745248124003, -0.05760723724961281, 0.02968391217291355, 0.0022218304220587015, 0.015319122932851315, 0.0008177829440683126, 0.02495463751256466, 0.010645393282175064, -0.0231503713876009, 0.0487305112183094, -0.03679155558347702, -0.009751231409609318, 0.021860986948013306, -0.009942854754626751, 0.03474385663866997, 0.010872785933315754, -0.05686673894524574, 0.021273326128721237, 0.020102882757782936, 0.0022724063601344824, -0.05884474515914917, -0.014776901341974735, 0.029361475259065628, -0.02494296431541443, -0.002372459974139929, -0.022310389205813408, -0.022526700049638748, 0.05199660733342171, 0.0027518586721271276, 0.007041463628411293, -0.01947909966111183, -0.012824460864067078, 0.019902128726243973, 0.024003606289625168, 0.015032968483865261, -0.011359350755810738, -0.00736824469640851, 0.0116207804530859, -0.02497640810906887, -0.0437668114900589, -0.03448961302638054, 0.016585173085331917, -0.0025108030531555414, -0.009116859175264835, -0.0012856279499828815, 0.010707128793001175, 0.028911270201206207, -0.022032344713807106, -0.03318999335169792, 0.038017332553863525, -0.007992166094481945, -0.024509144946932793, -0.04929214343428612, -0.06744561344385147, 0.031863562762737274, -0.016181306913495064, -0.030503977090120316, 0.008960757404565811, -0.019461316987872124, -0.026187852025032043, -0.02271335944533348, 0.010630705393850803, -0.005804985761642456, 0.0235555712133646, -0.011647731065750122, -0.005681910086423159, -0.029366277158260345, -0.017574770376086235, -0.0022812329698354006, 0.03963104262948036, -0.02071606181561947, -0.006145859137177467, -0.03083331696689129, -0.02786250226199627, -0.025772687047719955, -0.005087753292173147, -0.0178394578397274, 0.01384264137595892, -0.009192520752549171, 0.022434893995523453, 0.020136304199695587, 0.0043929219245910645, 0.006353574804961681, 0.004616409074515104, 0.02230049856007099, 0.03492148965597153, 0.002409057691693306, -0.039027485996484756, -0.0051211463287472725, -0.0026227645576000214, -0.0094978678971529, 0.005578836426138878, -0.01847364939749241, 0.057549767196178436, 0.04679853096604347, 0.014771650545299053, -0.02216755785048008, 0.018410446122288704, 0.005831392481923103, 0.007404271047562361, 0.005334431305527687, -0.03275215998291969, -0.012015122920274734, -0.0000648116329102777, -0.0052686575800180435, -0.015745993703603745, -0.012774871662259102, -0.035883188247680664, -0.04187450185418129, 0.040788181126117706, 0.005078223999589682, -0.07518105953931808, -0.029006198048591614, -0.005448880605399609, 0.019039493054151535, -0.010559877380728722, 0.020299246534705162, 0.017289288341999054, 0.025241203606128693, -0.03936616703867912, -0.04652825742959976, -0.031767383217811584, 0.0165468230843544, -0.020877977833151817, -0.005700670648366213, 0.04065915569663048, -0.008534879423677921, -0.006102192681282759, -0.010253498330712318, 0.003385258372873068, -0.028422871604561806, 0.016536781564354897, -0.02599829062819481, -0.0152444364503026, 0.04305930808186531, -0.08483658730983734, -0.029594913125038147, 0.03156353533267975, 0.025963734835386276, 0.038600318133831024, 0.05167171731591225, -0.02292138896882534, 0.019521169364452362, 0.05022479593753815, -0.026606431230902672, -0.015527059324085712, 0.001190334209240973, -0.01736915484070778, 0.014032598584890366, 0.035758696496486664, 0.043573133647441864, 0.001836191164329648, -0.023928387090563774, 0.012467504478991032, 0.027829181402921677, 0.005008511245250702, -0.00894925743341446, 0.03976275026798248, -0.0331568717956543, 0.02472875639796257, 0.011595215648412704, -0.004312430042773485, -0.0319877564907074, 0.04592379927635193, 0.03758125379681587, 0.00633732695132494, 0.006641891319304705, 0.04147767648100853, -0.09377005696296692, -0.03064151108264923, -0.0052920798771083355, -0.01158907264471054, 0.045251891016960144, -0.02154686115682125, 0.013508129864931107, 0.03255192190408707, -0.018632881343364716, 0.0016693249344825745, -0.034988898783922195, 0.001308923470787704, -0.05521628260612488, 0.023425329476594925, -0.04797208681702614, 0.0116247134283185, 0.053407955914735794, 0.01601416990160942, 0.026190368458628654, 0.02081749029457569, -0.04080618545413017, -0.027813520282506943, -0.04443197324872017, -0.008159828372299671, -0.005470937583595514, -0.06451133638620377, 0.033021580427885056, -0.02891596034169197, -0.04710492491722107, 0.016154944896697998, -0.009084544144570827, -0.017154280096292496, 0.04253794252872467, 0.028594007715582848, -0.0018117772415280342, 0.03413413465023041, 0.005449729040265083, -0.013879813253879547, 0.005741470959037542, 0.02850731834769249, -0.012199264019727707, 0.007048725616186857, -0.041309721767902374, 0.014488248154520988, 0.048039086163043976, -0.0009262480307370424, -0.02387307956814766, 0.05733202397823334, -0.01798032969236374, -0.053649041801691055, -0.01058886293321848, 0.0031026345677673817, 0.010853777639567852, -0.04093627631664276, 0.0019845478236675262, -0.025811046361923218, 0.015171157196164131, 0.008960630744695663, 0.02074727974832058, -0.011259338818490505, -0.006100392900407314, -0.025389116257429123, -0.03913410007953644, 0.030101167038083076, 0.0013354180846363306, -0.02041734755039215, -0.04088817164301872, 0.026748718693852425, 0.009651205502450466, 0.007668967358767986, -0.034550320357084274, -0.04572533443570137, -0.03758450970053673, 0.046420857310295105, -0.052772581577301025, 0.02728736214339733, -0.0035197564866393805, 0.017673563212156296, -0.007254001684486866, -0.08935217559337616, 0.04165903106331825, 0.00203987630084157, -0.03497539460659027, -0.04107072204351425, 0.05847392976284027, -0.047433335334062576, 0.005573892500251532, 0.02275311015546322, 0.038832105696201324, 0.031145816668868065, -0.021470993757247925, 0.009678049013018608, 0.0009029550128616393, -0.060235776007175446, 0.024272801354527473, -0.0119376415386796, -0.02764456532895565, -0.07099773734807968, 0.0004199505492579192, -0.01989845745265484, 0.03389127179980278, 0.0037192017771303654, -0.03661264479160309, -0.0013182259863242507, -0.003234146861359477, -0.035552047193050385, -0.012501672841608524, -0.01576082780957222, 0.032506439834833145, 0.03809686750173569, 0.010565325617790222, 0.021709885448217392, 0.017205385491251945, -0.019513478502631187, -0.018420308828353882, 0.008212553337216377, -0.048091910779476166, -0.028442634269595146, -0.003840516321361065, 0.05452810972929001, 0.004281651694327593, -0.06609784811735153, 0.014557854272425175, 0.03532364219427109, -0.017121201381087303, 0.01516118086874485, 0.06174895167350769, 0.03480194881558418, 0.04895073175430298, -0.032072506844997406, 0.022832980379462242, 0.0023032319732010365, -0.02715313620865345, 0.01635885052382946, -0.006399694364517927, 0.008345799520611763, -0.0025901501066982746, 0.05236521363258362, -0.00032884060055948794, -0.002464591059833765, 0.011163507588207722, -0.0029746785294264555, 0.07706397771835327, -0.004031220450997353, 0.003205899614840746, 0.03255264461040497, 0.04235711693763733, 0.029473796486854553, 0.04278530180454254, -0.0076070912182331085, 0.02883923053741455, -0.025222407653927803, 0.020584655925631523, -0.0775524228811264, -0.030673321336507797, -0.004764379933476448, 0.019977906718850136, 0.02834567241370678, 0.04805346205830574, 0.02816118113696575, -0.0028108865953981876, -0.023224633187055588, -0.025251928716897964, 0.03827901557087898, -0.005612546112388372, 0.014319992624223232, -0.03554774075746536, -0.026711849495768547, -0.013956885784864426, -0.00903414562344551, -0.021590394899249077, -0.031477704644203186, -0.007136043161153793, 0.02522231824696064, 0.06409180909395218, -0.010454979725182056, -0.07468916475772858, -0.005123432260006666, 0.030709531158208847, -0.024376723915338516, 0.015988986939191818, -0.06199974566698074, 0.019141115248203278, -0.017199749127030373, -0.021243181079626083 ]
<p>So, I think that I have a decent grasp of the basics of frequentist probability and statistical analysis (and how badly it can be used). In a frequentist world, it makes sense to ask such a question as "is this distribution different from that distribution", because distributions are assumed to be real, objective and unchanging (for a given situation, at least), and so we can figure out how likely it is that one sample is drawn from a distribution shaped like another sample.</p> <p>In the Bayesian world view, we only care about what <em>we</em> expect to see, given our past experiences (I'm still a bit vague on this part, but I understand the concept of Bayesian updating). If that is so, how can a Bayesian say "this set of data is different from that set of data"?</p> <p>For the purposes of this question, I don't care about statistical significance, or similar, just how to quantify difference. I'm equally interested in parametric and non-parametric distributions.</p>
74,145
[ -0.02507292851805687, 0.00466304924339056, 0.0012216492323204875, -0.034900177270174026, 0.027794212102890015, 0.03724402189254761, 0.02656399831175804, -0.010087438859045506, 0.024535756558179855, -0.006388644687831402, 0.012260884046554565, 0.03853268921375275, 0.04718541353940964, -0.0016066961688920856, 0.026483893394470215, -0.006869472563266754, -0.019859256222844124, -0.0158983301371336, -0.024847710505127907, 0.00027590582612901926, 0.01241190917789936, 0.02502126805484295, 0.02174016833305359, -0.03180275484919548, -0.044655941426754, 0.02802879735827446, 0.036578454077243805, -0.032788604497909546, 0.02493009902536869, 0.06210295110940933, -0.025541329756379128, -0.010356859304010868, 0.008802090771496296, 0.0635480061173439, 0.02306005172431469, -0.010987024754285812, -0.03987378254532814, -0.01293431967496872, -0.008271914906799793, 0.06910170614719391, -0.04890024662017822, -0.02885896898806095, -0.01249847374856472, 0.04384936764836311, -0.02364230901002884, -0.007893047295510769, -0.0042395442724227905, -0.05201856046915054, 0.013639986515045166, -0.04426984861493111, 0.06174357980489731, 0.0015933974646031857, 0.023173019289970398, 0.06118049845099449, -0.01479641068726778, -0.019075170159339905, 0.05107703059911728, 0.05319051817059517, -0.017787504941225052, -0.060067981481552124, -0.05335255339741707, -0.013994419015944004, 0.0131477490067482, -0.017076127231121063, -0.0431782528758049, 0.028567705303430557, -0.026930514723062515, -0.03741595521569252, 0.041686397045850754, 0.0041959104128181934, 0.006595936603844166, 0.05715290829539299, 0.04239458590745926, 0.014241853728890419, 0.020408524200320244, -0.03222345560789108, 0.023506376892328262, 0.012311352416872978, 0.04067813977599144, 0.033488254994153976, -0.012318412773311138, -0.027605753391981125, 0.03454383462667465, 0.055950552225112915, 0.024946698918938637, -0.04104726389050484, 0.08167693018913269, -0.016028009355068207, 0.013019907288253307, 0.007300976198166609, -0.010267178528010845, -0.02106781303882599, 0.05791371315717697, -0.028119556605815887, -0.04537985846400261, 0.040351223200559616, -0.024519160389900208, 0.03531340882182121, 0.002671952359378338, -0.026417484506964684, 0.0019329366041347384, -0.04831096902489662, 0.040917396545410156, 0.04330630227923393, -0.022482827305793762, -0.025112472474575043, 0.0038456928450614214, 0.01373706292361021, -0.037881482392549515, -0.008510075509548187, -0.014497298747301102, 0.07352010160684586, 0.02868945151567459, 0.0030602579936385155, 0.017447160556912422, 0.010772253386676311, 0.036380670964717865, -0.033962901681661606, 0.06592163443565369, 0.06769643723964691, 0.04915155842900276, -0.015251865610480309, 0.021080780774354935, -0.04549059271812439, -0.02421298250555992, -0.017526617273688316, 0.03137781471014023, -0.008063136599957943, -0.011995971202850342, 0.03200133144855499, -0.03674357756972313, -0.004046815913170576, 0.040538299828767776, 0.014726885594427586, 0.0012785258004441857, 0.01129133440554142, -0.07954463362693787, -0.04093019664287567, 0.041314497590065, 0.013052546419203281, -0.049679722636938095, -0.07098421454429626, -0.01787417009472847, 0.013046308420598507, 0.013692524284124374, -0.010546129196882248, 0.012435239739716053, -0.013106958009302616, 0.023069361224770546, -0.00853295810520649, -0.03763815760612488, -0.02424967661499977, 0.002071937546133995, -0.016274143010377884, -0.023580463603138924, -0.07216598838567734, -0.009246584959328175, -0.0005031519685871899, -0.005956748034805059, -0.015292366035282612, 0.05105090141296387, -0.009641376323997974, -0.03671564906835556, 0.00498571153730154, 0.025958005338907242, 0.0013200492830947042, 0.0875973179936409, 0.013983647339046001, 0.019420627504587173, 0.015984738245606422, 0.013038400560617447, 0.014446098357439041, 0.027243664488196373, 0.03461162745952606, 0.05812986195087433, -0.03358222171664238, -0.021424395963549614, -0.029501620680093765, 0.04502730444073677, -0.03349658474326134, 0.004466714803129435, 0.03004118800163269, -0.03627811372280121, -0.058039452880620956, -0.0005475346115417778, 0.01848246157169342, 0.038227468729019165, -0.0029060207307338715, 0.035953421145677567, -0.01984754204750061, -0.04668803513050079, -0.07798848301172256, -0.00699347909539938, -0.02132420614361763, -0.02156539261341095, 0.037714168429374695, 0.014061419293284416, 0.024930184707045555, -0.03135821595788002, -0.02248879335820675, -0.0009269912843592465, 0.006106218323111534, -0.0077855950221419334, -0.05607982352375984, -0.017147241160273552, 0.05467470735311508, 0.04247937351465225, 0.006628863513469696, 0.06496891379356384, -0.06182288005948067, -0.0863020047545433, -0.010104885324835777, -0.030485641211271286, -0.0032757334411144257, 0.008998746052384377, 0.015811091288924217, 0.007242119871079922, -0.01922234147787094, -0.04288849979639053, 0.029060078784823418, -0.04086920619010925, 0.08037455379962921, 0.051361922174692154, 0.01068235095590353, 0.00001532089117972646, 0.02756534144282341, -0.003151189535856247, -0.006752477027475834, -0.018721213564276695, -0.026846876367926598, -0.06383837014436722, -0.015356646850705147, 0.05115055292844772, -0.00508269714191556, -0.012432890012860298, 0.028400730341672897, 0.037586603313684464, 0.028241539373993874, 0.013635647483170033, 0.006307638715952635, -0.016217228025197983, -0.030633725225925446, 0.011617776937782764, -0.0006237020716071129, 0.0064070397056639194, 0.008626860566437244, 0.035221848636865616, 0.003422035602852702, 0.06148036569356918, -0.011221460066735744, 0.006301255896687508, 0.036332983523607254, -0.03293340653181076, 0.008633449673652649, -0.009679903276264668, -0.0022342402953654528, 0.010797468945384026, -0.018478794023394585, -0.01778435707092285, 0.01710614189505577, -0.0033440659753978252, -0.03323952481150627, 0.0023765426594763994, -0.003940860740840435, 0.04508068412542343, 0.03509640321135521, -0.04382786899805069, 0.020529109984636307, 0.011833617463707924, -0.025119639933109283, 0.03429557755589485, -0.02618991583585739, -0.028264576569199562, -0.0021055638790130615, 0.02575273998081684, 0.02266627736389637, 0.014566462486982346, 0.026173239573836327, -0.00007423633360303938, -0.03092791885137558, 0.025478243827819824, -0.018752843141555786, 0.006662128027528524, -0.006382402032613754, -0.06744004040956497, 0.025026792660355568, -0.02259092405438423, -0.022323429584503174, 0.011902889236807823, 0.0007513242890127003, 0.014030162245035172, 0.02514501102268696, 0.004887535236775875, -0.05452457442879677, 0.021618448197841644, -0.0386098176240921, 0.014923380687832832, -0.01873042806982994, -0.018312513828277588, 0.042741887271404266, -0.01864936575293541, -0.016448672860860825, 0.023042049258947372, -0.02106255479156971, -0.04006112739443779, -0.032274406403303146, -0.008490878157317638, 0.025661656633019447, -0.006829311139881611, 0.023750191554427147, 0.031065339222550392, -0.03656416013836861, 0.00786017719656229, -0.046016182750463486, -0.056803807616233826, 0.021776320412755013, -0.01499680895358324, 0.041167523711919785, -0.007508495822548866, -0.005555042065680027, 0.03581707924604416, 0.04625974968075752, -0.031752340495586395, -0.0058763944543898106, 0.042314548045396805, -0.04054098203778267, 0.0204271599650383, -0.016232630237936974, -0.023886118084192276, -0.010334817692637444, 0.011113354004919529, 0.02327064424753189, 0.04028196632862091, 0.027141964063048363, 0.01405299548059702, -0.0029221451841294765, 0.03791513293981552, 0.03007008135318756, 0.014580604620277882, 0.01378630381077528, 0.020399121567606926, -0.02075060084462166, 0.022732209414243698, 0.011499758809804916, 0.023482412099838257, 0.026974964886903763, -0.03657906875014305, 0.016759710386395454, 0.04103631526231766, 0.005168354604393244, -0.03489825129508972, 0.04654760658740997, -0.02025233954191208, -0.013123966753482819, 0.014712146483361721, -0.000049270453018834814, 0.02004280500113964, -0.03349978104233742, 0.01631690189242363, 0.06557714939117432, 0.04544932767748833, -0.025945469737052917, -0.013009503483772278, -0.020950639620423317, -0.0065092043951153755, -0.010294291190803051, -0.012795062735676765, -0.04115783050656319, 0.04667853191494942, 0.028447041288018227, 0.04802986606955528, -0.0461382120847702, -0.06795095652341843, -0.010380849242210388, -0.05353491008281708, -0.014290829189121723, 0.002824695548042655, 0.04712553322315216, -0.004715233109891415, 0.036156609654426575, 0.01861608773469925, 0.00206947885453701, -0.020341910421848297, -0.0036630630493164062, -0.07395250350236893, 0.0432937815785408, -0.04596652463078499, -0.010627301409840584, -0.014576221816241741, -0.010107474401593208, 0.04969760775566101, -0.010775968432426453, 0.016857914626598358, -0.025835884734988213, 0.0011285876389592886, -0.0511496439576149, 0.0015053341630846262, -0.0527491457760334, -0.034582484513521194, -0.00022917077876627445, 0.018282698467373848, 0.015530711971223354, -0.006682022009044886, 0.03942302241921425, 0.015538109466433525, 0.003839564509689808, 0.007538819685578346, -0.011227057315409184, 0.04100050404667854, 0.026349786669015884, 0.012784941121935844, 0.017794517800211906, 0.03702731430530548, -0.03162403404712677, 0.04680021479725838, 0.020479794591665268, 0.06907669454813004, 0.029981032013893127, -0.03090856410562992, -0.009841546416282654, -0.05455220118165016, -0.04247162863612175, -0.009973214939236641, 0.04935793951153755, -0.0020724537316709757, -0.00006821618444519117, 0.052496302872896194, 0.019844090566039085, -0.04558049142360687, 0.04214603081345558, 0.029650479555130005, -0.032579366117715836, -0.021161571145057678, -0.03018936887383461, 0.0035716313868761063, -0.028894413262605667, -0.014667878858745098, 0.026574667543172836, 0.025663310661911964, 0.0031261518597602844, 0.01460970751941204, 0.015278404578566551, -0.03151467815041542, -0.02473451942205429, -0.026096109300851822, -0.005261045414954424, 0.00563068175688386, 0.01625586673617363, -0.03433973714709282, 0.040333785116672516, 0.02392246015369892, 0.03820588439702988, -0.007406854070723057, 0.031748633831739426, -0.08174099773168564, -0.00039133394602686167, 0.05640074983239174, 0.040030449628829956, -0.03554661571979523, -0.010922103188931942, -0.030631111934781075, -0.008408689871430397, 0.07246790081262589, -0.03116179071366787, -0.01253370102494955, 0.004059585742652416, 0.01126090344041586, -0.01936638355255127, -0.008075423538684845, -0.04220011457800865, -0.00700867734849453, -0.013009204529225826, 0.04108641669154167, -0.008908634074032307, -0.02626115456223488, -0.06813543289899826, 0.002367484150454402, 0.018473798409104347, 0.07179567962884903, -0.03625404089689255, -0.030424688011407852, -0.016843099147081375, -0.018773837015032768, 0.005318481475114822, -0.0643833726644516, 0.01529074739664793, -0.00018700282089412212, -0.024776676669716835, 0.027787981554865837, -0.017752323299646378, -0.03078147955238819, 0.030065828934311867, -0.020457973703742027, -0.037966836243867874, 0.02202492766082287, -0.00953295174986124, 0.07202648371458054, 0.019466882571578026, 0.03260500356554985, 0.056725066155195236, 0.00695821875706315, 0.022192982956767082, -0.0012099649757146835, -0.028426527976989746, 0.03851793706417084, -0.05606609210371971, -0.015281188301742077, -0.07146905362606049, -0.028268758207559586, -0.01705404557287693, 0.04094512760639191, 0.0226175244897604, 0.02421296387910843, 0.004392622970044613, -0.035272933542728424, 0.015096732415258884, 0.016413353383541107, 0.007221590261906385, 0.026047321036458015, -0.007937542162835598, 0.009420082904398441, -0.01991383731365204, 0.0033269603736698627, 0.022370966151356697, 0.013765931129455566, 0.001075072563253343, -0.000798238324932754, -0.04611105099320412, 0.023693619295954704, -0.05338268727064133, -0.004897899925708771, 0.040141452103853226, -0.03268478065729141, 0.0253407321870327, 0.012147138826549053, 0.04891529306769371, 0.01075704675167799, -0.04586198180913925, -0.018511835485696793, 0.002132798545062542, -0.011868753470480442, 0.04859698936343193, -0.053481221199035645, 0.03240847587585449, -0.040331728756427765, -0.01692221872508526, -0.09492356330156326, -0.03645572066307068, 0.026269234716892242, 0.015535803511738777, -0.025054320693016052, -0.03017023764550686, 0.02544090710580349, 0.00402427650988102, -0.011717405170202255, -0.016530049964785576, 0.045360829681158066, 0.003186045913025737, -0.02182605303823948, -0.013588229194283485, 0.007132197264581919, 0.06914002448320389, -0.027519680559635162, 0.000645733904093504, -0.0007580139790661633, -0.006773302797228098, -0.010900354012846947, 0.01195771899074316, 0.014948267489671707, -0.033120088279247284, 0.009037691168487072, -0.017779670655727386, 0.019325681030750275, 0.032010115683078766, -0.06868768483400345, -0.010885367169976234, 0.028462236747145653, -0.022546421736478806, 0.02268669195473194, -0.03295140713453293, -0.025537308305501938, -0.01123767253011465, -0.0002550890785641968, -0.05495171993970871, -0.0006759938551113009, 0.043606601655483246, -0.03766066953539848, 0.04166176915168762, -0.0023208220954984426, -0.005712099373340607, 0.01819961704313755, 0.014196422882378101, -0.04280267283320427, 0.005700704641640186, 0.013369969092309475, -0.0025564590469002724, 0.025962408632040024, -0.0029438957571983337, -0.03290705382823944, 0.001132145756855607, -0.0159591194242239, -0.041569799184799194, -0.016363799571990967, -0.06360775232315063, -0.0216032974421978, 0.07267950475215912, 0.032356031239032745, 0.05178871378302574, 0.0350990816950798, -0.00044192472705617547, 0.013220824301242828, -0.0194872934371233, -0.012627569027245045, -0.01499249693006277, 0.01777839846909046, 0.032909929752349854, -0.026781627908349037, 0.01827123947441578, 0.06281768530607224, 0.005462280940264463, -0.01428463589400053, 0.02754298597574234, 0.03300013020634651, 0.02363218180835247, 0.09946537017822266, -0.018177706748247147, -0.05206535756587982, 0.02540244162082672, -0.04879290610551834, 0.003768996801227331, -0.011286736465990543, -0.04130373150110245, 0.053828321397304535, 0.05167469382286072, -0.0013418924063444138, -0.05183017626404762, -0.020563434809446335, -0.05765712261199951, 0.012388762086629868, 0.027203183621168137, 0.053901202976703644, 0.041788775473833084, -0.029731163755059242, 0.03137600049376488, -0.039754852652549744, -0.009163528680801392, -0.00015733554027974606, -0.07848306745290756, -0.04447326436638832, -0.012091311626136303, -0.022227883338928223, 0.003782122628763318, 0.004271244164556265, -0.022398222237825394, -0.00894938688725233, -0.04971126839518547, 0.001823673490434885, 0.0251645315438509, 0.042278025299310684, -0.015348373912274837, 0.07780160754919052, -0.05307578295469284, 0.05086439102888107, -0.007519729435443878, -0.02846887707710266, 0.10254339128732681, 0.04541449248790741, 0.027669157832860947, -0.03423603996634483, 0.023075006902217865, -0.02911568619310856, -0.0053602708503603935, 0.004346734378486872, 0.042976632714271545, 0.03660536929965019, 0.000019612267351476476, 0.017774613574147224, 0.03723561391234398, 0.022102458402514458, -0.022707438096404076, 0.0674210861325264, -0.03583923727273941, -0.013299311511218548, 0.013838016428053379, 0.01696164906024933, -0.008016233332455158, 0.005509109236299992, -0.0582713782787323, 0.014350634068250656, -0.018517807126045227, 0.011147785931825638, -0.010631133802235126, -0.02592581883072853, -0.015310213901102543, 0.01668568141758442, -0.0007264386513270438, -0.014279099181294441, 0.016656721010804176, -0.021577687934041023, -0.029514137655496597, -0.0001395596336806193, 0.026182329282164574, -0.01606408879160881, -0.005192685406655073, 0.05898422375321388, 0.0022433733101934195, -0.01651828922331333, -0.006244245916604996, 0.014702166430652142, -0.02555418387055397, -0.026380345225334167, -0.034031420946121216, 0.03706779330968857, -0.002516471780836582, 0.002473350614309311, -0.020591044798493385, -0.018788089975714684, 0.0009100224124267697, -0.05831468850374222, -0.012409876100718975, -0.0011304679792374372, 0.037253741174936295, -0.009192700497806072, -0.03134546056389809, 0.011845383793115616, 0.03981761261820793, 0.015887901186943054, 0.03686646372079849, 0.029409995302557945, -0.02233247086405754, -0.05263450741767883, -0.001207119319587946, 0.03304423391819, 0.002839884487912059, -0.01973353885114193, 0.009245514869689941, -0.0027470753993839025, -0.041334621608257294, -0.004020866006612778, 0.00616097915917635, 0.016890520229935646, 0.018342653289437294, -0.009305386804044247, 0.010608960874378681, 0.017453206703066826, -0.023870393633842468, -0.0004444414225872606, -0.027337392792105675, 0.042116984724998474, -0.0010860024485737085, 0.009455109015107155, 0.03593587130308151, 0.04159960895776749, 0.04244256019592285, 0.015730177983641624, -0.0015310791786760092, 0.053598690778017044, 0.013312611728906631, -0.05770350247621536, -0.019071953371167183, 0.016564758494496346, -0.04300592467188835, -0.034065671265125275, -0.005767954979091883, 0.03084591031074524, 0.02316371351480484, 0.012548594735562801, -0.020256998017430305, 0.02486628107726574, -0.003452082397416234, 0.039960164576768875, -0.025731613859534264, -0.046019844710826874, -0.030322862789034843, 0.002636965597048402, -0.001321237999945879, -0.013038200326263905, -0.05142462998628616, -0.024294761940836906, -0.016096442937850952, 0.0005734949954785407, -0.021831391379237175, -0.021745305508375168, -0.021433798596262932, 0.020059028640389442, 0.030062027275562286, -0.005512014497071505, 0.011712929233908653, -0.03141743689775467, -0.017435651272535324, 0.013259141705930233, 0.004642552230507135, 0.024652034044265747, 0.018578089773654938, -0.037464242428541183, -0.03654751926660538, 0.026304466649889946, 0.01080725621432066, 0.005950973369181156, 0.010656439699232578, 0.014112607575953007, -0.009951256215572357, 0.02722388505935669, -0.021306268870830536, -0.021953674033284187, 0.06518611311912537, -0.025474611669778824, -0.06014358997344971, 0.062453120946884155, 0.000595667923334986, 0.04321897402405739, 0.016564739868044853, 0.0021717040799558163, 0.005049297586083412, 0.042378537356853485, -0.02677021361887455, 0.004104055464267731, -0.008192681707441807, 0.00799813587218523, -0.033330872654914856, -0.005701100919395685, 0.03526151925325394, 0.014195496216416359, -0.0061043258756399155, 0.05022713914513588, 0.016727278009057045, 0.016326820477843285, -0.002124302787706256, 0.010884961113333702, -0.016787659376859665, -0.017958424985408783, 0.01402032095938921, 0.006327914539724588, 0.0374070443212986, 0.059767577797174454, 0.002918234560638666, 0.040175653994083405, -0.036012668162584305, 0.0007407906814478338, -0.12030819803476334, -0.020625228062272072, 0.019550276920199394, 0.0023519094102084637, 0.027757365256547928, -0.048684801906347275, -0.0016233825590461493, 0.005269436631351709, -0.034417130053043365, 0.018597334623336792, -0.016309786587953568, -0.010478002019226551, -0.023810826241970062, 0.021002816036343575, -0.013082531280815601, 0.035536784678697586, 0.018543485552072525, 0.037587929517030716, 0.008766469545662403, 0.022670485079288483, 0.003997796215116978, -0.0020259437151253223, -0.008506691083312035, 0.027808954939246178, 0.013773437589406967, -0.04698636755347252, 0.021806616336107254, -0.027277791872620583, -0.023505453020334244, 0.03954899311065674, 0.025613484904170036, 0.03033723682165146, -0.020060595124959946, 0.013529765419661999, 0.03142949938774109, 0.043636754155159, 0.03795122355222702, -0.009636622853577137, -0.03139082342386246, 0.004581377375870943, -0.003103614551946521, 0.030167855322360992, -0.030092425644397736, 0.0023986634332686663, 0.021093888208270073, -0.04604289308190346, 0.012183493934571743, -0.009006735868752003, 0.000012458439414331224, -0.0288540106266737, -0.02005946636199951, 0.005164653528481722, 0.02552645653486252, 0.0022174573969095945, 0.0338788740336895, -0.04311053827404976, 0.0016991219017654657, 0.029987988993525505, 0.014008898288011551, -0.027961479499936104, 0.026717551052570343, -0.033643681555986404, -0.04049581289291382, -0.011395077221095562, -0.019301043823361397, -0.008803930133581161, -0.05302632972598076, 0.0020058618392795324, -0.01715925708413124, -0.00017923071573022753, -0.004459118936210871, -0.03568294644355774, -0.059670623391866684, 0.008144576102495193, -0.0189223513007164, -0.007911302149295807, 0.010660392232239246, -0.008320947177708149, -0.01071013230830431, -0.05725203454494476, 0.07188479602336884, 0.007405073381960392, -0.030457105487585068, -0.06830223649740219, -0.005118655506521463, -0.0305038895457983, 0.014717534184455872, 0.04608267918229103, 0.02170395851135254, 0.009654088877141476, -0.014759338460862637, -0.013185913674533367, 0.024138247594237328, -0.06373295187950134, 0.02812184952199459, -0.02764475904405117, -0.010454144328832626, -0.017464717850089073, -0.001975016202777624, 0.0006659156642854214, 0.033305298537015915, 0.03761744126677513, -0.021622978150844574, 0.014206559397280216, 0.00198787497356534, 0.002247079275548458, 0.061705637723207474, 0.006833938881754875, -0.002462893957272172, 0.008624951355159283, 0.0016625599237158895, 0.028323404490947723, 0.007139123510569334, 0.006792276166379452, -0.03991316631436348, 0.05033116415143013, -0.0019037277670577168, -0.04702357202768326, 0.034533120691776276, 0.0008897993247956038, 0.022338705137372017, -0.048843804746866226, -0.022301513701677322, 0.04962882027029991, -0.028397083282470703, 0.01652613840997219, 0.009258024394512177, 0.03155248239636421, 0.01559541281312704, -0.0013424507342278957, 0.0014409373980015516, 0.0013216010993346572, -0.0038448714185506105, -0.022226477041840553, 0.0010249235201627016, 0.0375024676322937, -0.0031781441066414118, 0.024919286370277405, 0.028254568576812744, -0.038935426622629166, 0.011551467701792717, -0.005647724028676748, 0.06906869262456894, -0.025622941553592682, -0.005048300605267286, -0.004423781298100948, 0.01039833016693592, -0.003100062720477581, 0.012158583849668503, 0.005631556734442711, 0.08498797565698624, 0.03063899464905262, -0.008891482837498188, -0.009517492726445198, 0.02479216642677784, -0.047801341861486435, -0.02722407691180706, 0.03913116827607155, 0.015625599771738052, 0.029605969786643982, 0.013996432535350323, -0.0011195434490218759, 0.002313164761289954, 0.052236661314964294, -0.05584079772233963, 0.030914751812815666, -0.008850786834955215, -0.005157005973160267, -0.03910547122359276, -0.02662005089223385, -0.05797700956463814, -0.008167069405317307, 0.009249410592019558, 0.0342828668653965, 0.06442803889513016, 0.01719164103269577, -0.04715628921985626, -0.024994852021336555, 0.04528891667723656, -0.07991920411586761, -0.0017372457077726722, -0.05723932757973671, 0.014625722542405128, 0.010252895765006542, -0.03702091798186302 ]
<p>I've been reading the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levene%27s_test" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia page</a> for Levene's test, and it cites the degrees of freedom as (k - 1, N - k), where k is the number of different groups to which the sampled cases belong, and N is the total number of cases in all groups. However, it does not explain why this is so. There is a very thorough answer <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/16921/how-to-understand-degrees-of-freedom">here</a> which would suffice to answer this question in relation to the chi square goodness of fit. However, I have not been able to find a satisfactory answer to the question in relation to Levene's test.</p>
6,937
[ -0.031785789877176285, -0.01982177421450615, 0.022560974583029747, -0.011724614538252354, 0.05748410150408745, 0.022411786019802094, -0.0006250345031730831, 0.017424436286091805, -0.0028247726149857044, -0.018475160002708435, 0.016976283863186836, 0.05614093318581581, 0.030384719371795654, 0.01877397671341896, -0.007557410281151533, -0.005905416794121265, -0.04090471938252449, 0.02090853452682495, -0.014734788797795773, -0.020445581525564194, -0.006447527091950178, 0.04379989206790924, 0.010399749502539635, -0.013327457942068577, -0.049772489815950394, 0.0014569849008694291, 0.0339042991399765, -0.025984376668930054, 0.03725525364279747, 0.05092734843492508, -0.03878060728311539, -0.006207691505551338, 0.0022899573668837547, 0.0006217607879079878, 0.00852909218519926, -0.04565263167023659, 0.0018998192390426993, 0.00971537921577692, -0.003760712221264839, 0.07027231901884079, -0.07240117341279984, -0.012306947261095047, -0.04309426248073578, 0.02905152179300785, -0.04881426319479942, 0.03197697550058365, 0.004702053032815456, -0.06245331093668938, 0.012940301559865475, -0.02058563195168972, 0.08968199044466019, -0.01339212991297245, 0.0039690895937383175, 0.0013248766772449017, 0.011113678105175495, -0.022811051458120346, 0.0473811998963356, 0.0466105118393898, -0.02735680714249611, -0.04215680807828903, -0.046563372015953064, -0.04251830652356148, 0.02605915255844593, 0.0019196384819224477, -0.02698817290365696, 0.024365462362766266, 0.006143947131931782, -0.025631267577409744, 0.037127576768398285, -0.006641211453825235, 0.004236054141074419, 0.02128605730831623, 0.04563389718532562, -0.02373925782740116, 0.006997839547693729, -0.019810082390904427, 0.024172024801373482, 0.03803138807415962, 0.005539150908589363, 0.025577882304787636, -0.01370920054614544, 0.026594946160912514, 0.022510800510644913, 0.02684015780687332, 0.04029260575771332, -0.05369570478796959, 0.06745829433202744, -0.007523479405790567, 0.00669186981394887, 0.04551573097705841, -0.028027132153511047, 0.014557155780494213, 0.0624961219727993, -0.009664872661232948, -0.08023760467767715, -0.005624536890536547, -0.024090556427836418, 0.03115062601864338, 0.013856464996933937, -0.011339648626744747, -0.02966446243226528, -0.043425053358078, 0.0581190288066864, 0.06788334250450134, -0.03845478594303131, 0.0047220392152667046, -0.017805757001042366, 0.006631627678871155, 0.012337745167315006, -0.020712660625576973, 0.0005874161142855883, 0.007599014323204756, 0.009036224335432053, 0.009691095910966396, -0.005532128270715475, 0.008896964602172375, -0.05680081993341446, -0.01976311393082142, 0.0610545352101326, 0.06902391463518143, 0.06191997602581978, -0.03697030991315842, 0.021491970866918564, -0.009627321735024452, -0.03450154513120651, 0.03831544145941734, 0.000060330869018798694, -0.0190618634223938, -0.03325887769460678, 0.043383900076150894, -0.01873471774160862, -0.0008336192695423961, -0.002970007248222828, 0.008982062339782715, -0.0026554728392511606, -0.023567594587802887, -0.10693112015724182, -0.05349411815404892, 0.028376851230859756, -0.024903208017349243, -0.036097683012485504, -0.0793781504034996, 0.009139535017311573, 0.02261621505022049, 0.07841289043426514, -0.03280298411846161, 0.03181071579456329, -0.022417990490794182, 0.005238991230726242, 0.0329497866332531, -0.04315903037786484, -0.010526551865041256, -0.042348891496658325, -0.08001621812582016, -0.021431805565953255, -0.051638513803482056, 0.05654504895210266, 0.0368480458855629, 0.0010030315024778247, -0.009742110967636108, 0.0068328906781971455, 0.019252927973866463, -0.009228875860571861, -0.008792081847786903, 0.02680828794836998, 0.0009092483087442815, 0.07462123781442642, 0.016794685274362564, 0.032413411885499954, 0.014390386641025543, -0.0034808251075446606, 0.019664110615849495, 0.021261202171444893, 0.074945367872715, 0.022429795935750008, 0.004839514847844839, 0.0010248514590784907, -0.028200296685099602, 0.046505119651556015, -0.010086633265018463, -0.05929892882704735, 0.009903418831527233, 0.010363353416323662, 0.0159605722874403, 0.015693657100200653, 0.004752413835376501, -0.023629702627658844, -0.014468275010585785, 0.03492392599582672, -0.04984252154827118, -0.019480779767036438, -0.05812802165746689, 0.006491989362984896, -0.0037930281832814217, -0.046253494918346405, 0.009208683855831623, 0.029368752613663673, 0.02960481494665146, -0.01808658428490162, 0.00012549398525152355, -0.019797932356595993, -0.03439721837639809, 0.015448044054210186, -0.05566253885626793, 0.029441509395837784, 0.06923943758010864, 0.03565915673971176, -0.024247143417596817, 0.058493491262197495, -0.017550505697727203, -0.027010271325707436, 0.011771311052143574, -0.02248336747288704, 0.0276133231818676, 0.026712780818343163, 0.005343698896467686, -0.020433679223060608, 0.04529053717851639, -0.013392127119004726, 0.06952012330293655, -0.0595531091094017, 0.0776984766125679, 0.0724102184176445, 0.006806340999901295, -0.0072691538371145725, 0.004109793342649937, -0.0037160171195864677, -0.03695010021328926, -0.02817998081445694, 0.0007973100291565061, -0.06880620867013931, -0.018900563940405846, 0.016613155603408813, -0.012408480048179626, -0.028737207874655724, -0.021613890305161476, 0.05189592018723488, 0.04830486699938774, -0.00867923628538847, -0.0008411375456489623, -0.03117450140416622, -0.04313062131404877, -0.005075976252555847, 0.04508379474282265, -0.004356093239039183, -0.017317375168204308, 0.007303627673536539, 0.024813314899802208, 0.009559131227433681, 0.026436593383550644, -0.03474309295415878, 0.06962341070175171, -0.01772291585803032, 0.00018278647621627897, -0.029144473373889923, -0.009213624522089958, 0.04473581537604332, -0.03449293598532677, -0.010552662424743176, 0.05487935245037079, 0.013197414577007294, 0.017885524779558182, -0.016648991033434868, 0.009594201110303402, 0.05298413336277008, 0.007796549238264561, -0.03703930228948593, 0.007770192809402943, 0.012269427999854088, -0.01617697812616825, 0.0010275336680933833, -0.024490617215633392, -0.04077683389186859, -0.0207048486918211, 0.029210926964879036, 0.01283570658415556, 0.002827513264492154, 0.02648676186800003, -0.02018868178129196, 0.0021029373165220022, 0.0009462460875511169, 0.001692777732387185, 0.030314447358250618, 0.016849253326654434, -0.03407175838947296, 0.004662423860281706, -0.007843480445444584, 0.0012694922043010592, 0.0035469753202050924, 0.014796104282140732, 0.003264128929004073, 0.010725133121013641, 0.0016391442622989416, -0.03639918565750122, 0.003492704126983881, -0.003422822104766965, -0.006937883794307709, -0.027977293357253075, -0.01262943260371685, 0.016887059435248375, -0.002760030794888735, -0.039567142724990845, 0.0786624327301979, -0.053141213953495026, -0.043258462101221085, -0.02601834200322628, 0.006085120141506195, 0.02030649036169052, 0.005992590915411711, 0.020365417003631592, -0.0011231303215026855, -0.002602238208055496, -0.014453038573265076, -0.01996331848204136, -0.0720982775092125, 0.01758640632033348, -0.01421611662954092, 0.055211056023836136, 0.017367616295814514, -0.02856380119919777, 0.06880223751068115, 0.03537438437342644, -0.0003638204943854362, -0.015357539057731628, -0.007305542938411236, -0.05504731833934784, -0.016808243468403816, 0.04502315819263458, 0.04876744747161865, -0.0058349077589809895, 0.04960811138153076, -0.005819727201014757, 0.03872397169470787, 0.05540941655635834, -0.038259897381067276, 0.0015649455599486828, 0.01424062717705965, 0.00006878636486362666, -0.009543588384985924, 0.03989458829164505, 0.03891173377633095, -0.020704634487628937, -0.004508781246840954, -0.0011684885248541832, 0.030599115416407585, 0.022889280691742897, -0.05029303580522537, 0.020934496074914932, -0.0015403041616082191, 0.007379855029284954, -0.06513629853725433, 0.017086252570152283, -0.02841675654053688, 0.0045532770454883575, 0.018504910171031952, 0.04546385258436203, 0.051370203495025635, -0.024437371641397476, -0.03792256489396095, 0.019852496683597565, 0.018285179510712624, 0.008595388382673264, 0.011142739094793797, -0.023629972711205482, -0.035013750195503235, 0.03791991248726845, -0.02725514955818653, -0.011941608041524887, -0.015394472517073154, 0.03259725868701935, 0.045929085463285446, 0.0185242947191, -0.050295013934373856, 0.022034600377082825, -0.021349864080548286, -0.0022177337668836117, -0.03244577720761299, 0.03912627324461937, -0.01898464746773243, 0.032978396862745285, 0.027399657294154167, -0.030053740367293358, -0.060013074427843094, -0.013464289717376232, -0.047415364533662796, 0.01753103919327259, -0.004600550979375839, -0.008379305712878704, -0.003227775916457176, 0.004545724485069513, 0.05595649778842926, 0.016396068036556244, -0.002020233543589711, 0.03144117444753647, 0.007372464518994093, -0.01535970252007246, 0.019143549725413322, -0.0013501833891496062, 0.030090637505054474, 0.033250901848077774, 0.06808911263942719, 0.015766847878694534, -0.0033129153307527304, 0.00603087991476059, 0.045556094497442245, -0.0056856428273022175, 0.01259361021220684, 0.02295750193297863, 0.017683761194348335, 0.002968378132209182, 0.012758645229041576, 0.020270418375730515, -0.012229316867887974, -0.019724924117326736, 0.017854396253824234, -0.011518281884491444, 0.013874444179236889, 0.06129761412739754, -0.020734339952468872, 0.00003656978879007511, -0.04634404554963112, -0.00672643119469285, -0.0029471481684595346, 0.0064421105198562145, 0.020842229947447777, 0.03706779703497887, 0.0644695907831192, 0.02197120524942875, -0.03188718855381012, 0.03956086188554764, 0.04778412729501724, -0.036139488220214844, 0.013717114925384521, -0.022696522995829582, 0.025690436363220215, 0.018694981932640076, 0.010680555365979671, -0.012229343876242638, 0.022094711661338806, -0.008633265271782875, 0.017718950286507607, 0.028764117509126663, -0.018602920696139336, -0.005165685433894396, -0.014380031265318394, 0.010891228914260864, 0.05265066400170326, -0.023651082068681717, -0.020700428634881973, 0.014868137426674366, 0.03974582627415657, 0.05686825141310692, 0.06541824340820312, -0.0054079038091003895, -0.038855019956827164, -0.008779925294220448, 0.009345237165689468, 0.025922507047653198, -0.03665103390812874, 0.018184402957558632, -0.026592645794153214, 0.008568532764911652, 0.02030959539115429, -0.034402791410684586, 0.018092157319188118, 0.004526242148131132, -0.001656459062360227, -0.03466222062706947, -0.04287315532565117, -0.007981219328939915, 0.02684549055993557, -0.018187927082180977, 0.031897641718387604, -0.02806263230741024, -0.023215996101498604, -0.028410131111741066, -0.016211777925491333, 0.022625835612416267, 0.047099918127059937, 0.002975726965814829, -0.01089970301836729, -0.004972380585968494, 0.03122924268245697, -0.024353956803679466, -0.044002898037433624, 0.04660925641655922, 0.011777621693909168, 0.05253496766090393, 0.050493303686380386, -0.0559295117855072, -0.012004991993308067, 0.014309405349195004, 0.0023946380242705345, -0.01593397930264473, -0.03332512080669403, -0.021958498284220695, 0.041325345635414124, 0.03651391714811325, 0.012891682796180248, 0.06910313665866852, -0.004067710135132074, -0.0060782525688409805, 0.006315112579613924, -0.022710401564836502, 0.02643914707005024, -0.02724236249923706, -0.03606286272406578, -0.0154623594135046, 0.013701150193810463, -0.008573225699365139, 0.039236146956682205, 0.006598972249776125, 0.056307170540094376, -0.03499230369925499, 0.000977391842752695, -0.011721593327820301, 0.009423893876373768, -0.00899545568972826, 0.014174255542457104, 0.03614578768610954, 0.0429525263607502, 0.028499364852905273, -0.0170126985758543, 0.057975176721811295, -0.04080130532383919, -0.0000012495020200731233, 0.026083169505000114, -0.008831055834889412, -0.022960012778639793, -0.052019212394952774, 0.0031686928123235703, 0.010140303522348404, 0.002838743384927511, 0.026804648339748383, -0.04032202810049057, 0.0174631979316473, -0.0004986324347555637, -0.045405689626932144, -0.016945214942097664, 0.008580614812672138, -0.026148390024900436, 0.07917730510234833, -0.002820093184709549, -0.01630493812263012, 0.02089371345937252, -0.01214737817645073, -0.08826158195734024, -0.03246018663048744, -0.0050064860843122005, 0.013651731424033642, -0.018094466999173164, -0.04535474255681038, -0.02445743791759014, 0.0050127035938203335, -0.02902405522763729, 0.015742063522338867, 0.0558302216231823, 0.0071233101189136505, -0.03378341719508171, -0.04235079512000084, 0.01287250965833664, 0.08423107117414474, -0.004681186284869909, -0.05105001851916313, 0.017922360450029373, -0.02357020415365696, -0.003054537810385227, 0.012366772629320621, 0.02861582487821579, -0.04547538608312607, 0.03174300864338875, 0.008570828475058079, -0.010310918092727661, 0.03197362273931503, -0.016928382217884064, -0.052580058574676514, 0.0032908921130001545, -0.00803186185657978, 0.022519618272781372, -0.041479531675577164, 0.002312681870535016, -0.0193623173981905, 0.022415151819586754, 0.003541420679539442, 0.011056508868932724, 0.017422640696167946, -0.02690131403505802, 0.030945053324103355, -0.005884317681193352, 0.03395593911409378, 0.03606830909848213, 0.0733257308602333, 0.0122311320155859, -0.021602479740977287, -0.021520329639315605, 0.0024647016543895006, 0.02005026675760746, 0.022759368643164635, 0.003168111899867654, -0.008162210695445538, 0.03224753588438034, 0.02302739955484867, -0.0210383590310812, -0.03945270553231239, 0.030503252521157265, 0.06006734445691109, 0.000976072798948735, 0.029475469142198563, 0.05646953359246254, -0.016001006588339806, -0.02422255463898182, -0.02963244356215, 0.029098568484187126, -0.03136223182082176, 0.009759852662682533, 0.028343889862298965, -0.030651288107037544, -0.034536704421043396, 0.03838061913847923, 0.01485538762062788, -0.0013701304560527205, 0.029866613447666168, 0.04648139327764511, 0.030762800946831703, 0.0387437529861927, -0.02168572135269642, -0.046384792774915695, 0.033961016684770584, -0.033638495951890945, 0.05930774658918381, -0.015507593750953674, -0.013374126516282558, 0.04886774718761444, 0.029010390862822533, -0.002448680344969034, -0.044595930725336075, -0.06134694814682007, -0.040114086121320724, 0.0073696947656571865, 0.021434077993035316, -0.0005028787418268621, 0.0196253452450037, -0.021272197365760803, 0.02188028022646904, 0.02712198533117771, 0.001194269279949367, -0.00846576876938343, -0.0644543394446373, -0.03491022437810898, 0.016804369166493416, -0.01756863296031952, 0.011225633323192596, -0.007132477127015591, -0.04979449138045311, -0.01981823891401291, -0.028856053948402405, 0.019708843901753426, 0.0026541308034211397, 0.033058907836675644, 0.014615517109632492, 0.055024076253175735, 0.020875686779618263, 0.021712489426136017, -0.03284866735339165, -0.025676168501377106, 0.10224087536334991, 0.0673324316740036, 0.017222873866558075, -0.05358419567346573, -0.007791214156895876, -0.015826236456632614, -0.03746424987912178, -0.004370092414319515, 0.007332044653594494, 0.02942238561809063, 0.007830263115465641, 0.021183909848332405, 0.08348764479160309, 0.033423200249671936, -0.029295986518263817, 0.027725085616111755, -0.017969436943531036, -0.0451337955892086, -0.02798754908144474, 0.0003454824327491224, 0.00010611280595185235, -0.006321627181023359, -0.02938016690313816, -0.007880373857915401, 0.03552247956395149, -0.027707669883966446, -0.019598737359046936, -0.0314486064016819, 0.009259773418307304, 0.014975807629525661, -0.048045843839645386, 0.005589592736214399, 0.018271196633577347, -0.006537876091897488, -0.06652809679508209, -0.008637049235403538, 0.005205139517784119, -0.03702930733561516, 0.02832798659801483, 0.029698124155402184, -0.026646310463547707, -0.02425101399421692, -0.0009786513401195407, -0.01596180349588394, -0.036471690982580185, -0.010164868086576462, -0.038833022117614746, 0.02069210819900036, 0.004109760280698538, -0.016708146780729294, -0.005795523524284363, -0.016855495050549507, -0.011282426305115223, -0.06922981888055801, -0.0011256963480263948, 0.0017030921299010515, 0.05568341165781021, -0.02836783044040203, -0.021963579580187798, -0.016232650727033615, 0.007559441961348057, -0.009593497030436993, 0.030348895117640495, 0.009787557646632195, -0.014577656984329224, -0.0253681018948555, -0.04061063751578331, 0.0029112612828612328, -0.02365655079483986, -0.012050180695950985, 0.014758557081222534, -0.0332428477704525, -0.05153060331940651, 0.022214137017726898, -0.02476339228451252, 0.01924157701432705, 0.049006473273038864, -0.014256883412599564, -0.029954444617033005, -0.03736070543527603, -0.04736858978867531, 0.018676068633794785, -0.020140262320637703, 0.006545847747474909, -0.017444467172026634, -0.03247322514653206, 0.0364028662443161, 0.0174256619066, -0.018878348171710968, 0.040612488985061646, 0.007512596435844898, 0.015476271510124207, 0.0011256876168772578, -0.05111580342054367, -0.030285878106951714, -0.016708871349692345, -0.05444657430052757, 0.007303332444280386, -0.04195655509829521, 0.06444161385297775, 0.023809239268302917, 0.025510713458061218, 0.012754305265843868, 0.026229964569211006, 0.010288964956998825, 0.011175116524100304, 0.0069164796732366085, -0.029306810349225998, -0.0018199585611000657, 0.031693235039711, -0.0018850496271625161, -0.02259574644267559, -0.04169542342424393, -0.058197133243083954, -0.03565773367881775, 0.026021361351013184, -0.008603929542005062, -0.05431521311402321, -0.0047080302610993385, -0.03471613675355911, 0.0013604704290628433, 0.00103175884578377, -0.010538766160607338, -0.00820203311741352, 0.015530684031546116, -0.009021629579365253, -0.00021656898024957627, -0.01391530316323042, 0.0037582777440547943, -0.032138776034116745, 0.013930343091487885, 0.026547878980636597, 0.002807837212458253, 0.05383645370602608, -0.029121948406100273, 0.015710817649960518, -0.011904376558959484, 0.02830907329916954, -0.041714511811733246, 0.023398734629154205, 0.059712059795856476, -0.07360193133354187, -0.029516328126192093, 0.020055469125509262, 0.0035980925895273685, 0.017632635310292244, 0.0046006315387785435, 0.0020895469933748245, -0.03570809215307236, 0.0008656774880364537, -0.04683232307434082, 0.018954429775476456, -0.014975729398429394, 0.01761489547789097, 0.019452253356575966, -0.031740423291921616, -0.015256544575095177, 0.005491077434271574, -0.021781768649816513, 0.025873184204101562, 0.05747917667031288, 0.014508428052067757, -0.027442213147878647, -0.0068992869928479195, -0.011056306771934032, 0.023097364231944084, 0.016404202207922935, 0.04427850991487503, 0.04267958551645279, 0.037265267223119736, -0.03401873633265495, 0.014509575441479683, -0.038858894258737564, 0.07139598578214645, -0.10473835468292236, -0.048552557826042175, -0.026212001219391823, 0.03482384979724884, 0.02473490871489048, -0.049249593168497086, -0.020221129059791565, 0.011454390361905098, -0.03174076974391937, 0.029827376827597618, -0.038751229643821716, 0.013584665022790432, -0.09610943496227264, 0.000835669634398073, 0.0015631470596417785, 0.04516119509935379, 0.036383721977472305, 0.0016203480772674084, 0.04266234487295151, -0.024063343182206154, -0.043909329921007156, -0.009617862291634083, 0.024484969675540924, 0.015648823231458664, 0.012773038819432259, -0.05789528042078018, 0.01571173220872879, -0.0027758125215768814, -0.0382227748632431, 0.009515751153230667, -0.010047592222690582, 0.019168270751833916, 0.04564620926976204, 0.027183888480067253, 0.02180645987391472, 0.020713331177830696, 0.02408715710043907, -0.011337779462337494, -0.013120257295668125, 0.006314486730843782, 0.019800279289484024, 0.03951045870780945, -0.0059055848978459835, -0.020021766424179077, 0.02752816490828991, -0.02603995054960251, -0.011171027086675167, 0.02665570005774498, -0.009751057252287865, -0.02942267619073391, 0.0024887765757739544, -0.04460369050502777, 0.0003195210301782936, -0.007551679387688637, 0.05409101024270058, -0.04319686070084572, -0.014530358836054802, 0.018610801547765732, 0.04254239797592163, -0.0073949797078967094, 0.013107657432556152, 0.0057952264323830605, -0.03121829219162464, -0.0004977580392733216, -0.007908917032182217, -0.0009155846782959998, -0.050199009478092194, -0.027832871302962303, -0.013709276914596558, -0.011922628618776798, 0.0020964443683624268, -0.03581351786851883, -0.015230868011713028, 0.02607952058315277, 0.009920005686581135, 0.0024613928981125355, -0.002267534611746669, -0.04114725440740585, 0.01970738172531128, -0.07508878409862518, 0.060096368193626404, -0.01831534318625927, 0.01025465689599514, -0.04448462277650833, -0.01290314830839634, 0.006215475033968687, -0.013916540890932083, 0.03698139265179634, 0.027811892330646515, 0.010759605094790459, -0.01316692866384983, -0.0073084537871181965, 0.0020195276010781527, -0.02195204794406891, 0.029972059652209282, -0.03267691656947136, -0.0320613719522953, -0.010276690125465393, -0.010419821366667747, 0.013192079029977322, -0.039298638701438904, 0.032451462000608444, -0.027113335207104683, 0.012063662521541119, -0.019794540479779243, -0.022670965641736984, 0.033009231090545654, 0.0404820442199707, -0.0003706311108544469, 0.04066328704357147, -0.005145438946783543, 0.008128952234983444, 0.06120530888438225, -0.0013988522114232183, -0.0596170611679554, 0.04665565490722656, -0.021664924919605255, -0.026612523943185806, 0.024210134521126747, 0.004637939855456352, -0.0059606535360217094, -0.04384544491767883, -0.0049818833358585835, 0.02963232435286045, -0.029039546847343445, -0.004046639893203974, 0.05727623403072357, 0.02255328744649887, 0.04280930757522583, -0.00714890705421567, -0.00540787260979414, -0.009764297865331173, -0.0311026219278574, 0.025075774639844894, 0.005367174278944731, 0.02881610207259655, -0.006508859805762768, -0.03859782591462135, 0.015731779858469963, -0.023224156349897385, 0.009020064026117325, 0.010875293053686619, 0.017735766246914864, -0.034087006002664566, -0.004150555469095707, 0.005459165200591087, -0.008209926076233387, 0.03175119683146477, 0.004370927345007658, -0.054789427667856216, 0.06558313965797424, -0.01769396848976612, 0.04627544805407524, -0.009517026133835316, -0.009454096667468548, -0.016340965405106544, -0.007930677384138107, 0.039252713322639465, 0.06021607667207718, -0.027449212968349457, 0.00395552720874548, -0.0018422057619318366, -0.041009072214365005, 0.045355457812547684, -0.023705707862973213, 0.01944066770374775, -0.017758041620254517, 0.015570596791803837, -0.0006399607518687844, -0.015988701954483986, -0.018809597939252853, -0.030995938926935196, 0.024554196745157242, 0.005272116977721453, 0.03905386105179787, -0.01959005557000637, -0.03441134840250015, 0.027102679014205933, 0.04734361171722412, -0.02613760717213154, 0.0031336527317762375, -0.09162960201501846, 0.04133544862270355, -0.02683597430586815, 0.004489055369049311 ]
<p>I am particularly interested in hearing thoughts on what are logical next steps in the research agenda of people who are interested in "The experimental approach to development economics" or in the evaluation of policy.</p> <p>Many people reject the notion that a randomized controlled trial (RCT) can estimate relevant policy parameters. They generally argue for a more "structural" approach. Is there a good middle-ground and will structuralism begin to take hold?</p>
48,513
[ -0.039849866181612015, 0.0026405497919768095, -0.011080068536102772, -0.03675395995378494, 0.021268310025334358, 0.04640085622668266, -0.024528754875063896, -0.022779034450650215, 0.038091324269771576, -0.02559426985681057, 0.004660481587052345, 0.03842191770672798, 0.024318402633070946, 0.00397290987893939, -0.0005247821100056171, -0.0018060816219076514, -0.026519732549786568, 0.009618371725082397, -0.016800133511424065, 0.018417280167341232, 0.024044709280133247, 0.03913294896483421, -0.019916007295250893, 0.0075296699069440365, -0.01602061837911606, 0.037271272391080856, -0.010354477912187576, -0.02303198166191578, -0.0013684715377166867, 0.07032056897878647, -0.004854490980505943, 0.00023795326706022024, -0.01665455475449562, -0.027826260775327682, 0.00011322541831759736, 0.006062415894120932, -0.03108624368906021, -0.03958350419998169, -0.004974475596100092, 0.0013227082090452313, -0.05504892021417618, 0.004077406600117683, 0.0005652589024975896, 0.025477809831500053, -0.02947854995727539, 0.0073413606733083725, -0.0018124744528904557, -0.01257262472063303, 0.05938080698251724, -0.030982494354248047, 0.035669270902872086, -0.01155558880418539, -0.020900476723909378, 0.03505047783255577, -0.022694002836942673, -0.030566468834877014, 0.07595734298229218, 0.06435617804527283, -0.0012754726922139525, 0.00395155418664217, -0.00831534992903471, -0.003953057341277599, 0.02612045779824257, -0.01721092499792576, -0.045015476644039154, 0.05700330063700676, 0.008676561526954174, 0.0041498164646327496, 0.0378706157207489, -0.03976406157016754, -0.014068212360143661, 0.00847204402089119, 0.01479966938495636, 0.04243878647685051, 0.013847330585122108, 0.005019346252083778, 0.009440336376428604, 0.017677828669548035, 0.007912160828709602, 0.06690413504838943, 0.029586533084511757, 0.01499882061034441, 0.03277292475104332, 0.08939773589372635, -0.005754393525421619, -0.03791843354701996, 0.06964147835969925, -0.01982927694916725, 0.01391978282481432, 0.03411849960684776, 0.0030216891318559647, -0.021663421764969826, 0.04719829559326172, -0.02849862538278103, -0.046801306307315826, 0.019734913483262062, -0.015130927786231041, 0.05324861407279968, -0.027950456365942955, -0.00979922991245985, -0.019765332341194153, 0.005297750234603882, 0.005991590674966574, 0.034187402576208115, -0.019257420673966408, -0.020561128854751587, -0.005817441735416651, 0.009438924491405487, -0.011279232800006866, -0.03041677549481392, -0.027405474334955215, 0.044872745871543884, -0.004237485583871603, -0.017488529905676842, 0.043083105236291885, -0.016465846449136734, -0.004773787222802639, -0.021477436646819115, 0.08910901099443436, 0.03875796124339104, 0.03620769456028938, -0.04137195646762848, 0.02269754558801651, -0.009476670995354652, -0.05456768348813057, 0.01628127694129944, 0.029278071597218513, -0.04350174963474274, 0.0011043628910556436, 0.025515178218483925, 0.0500338189303875, -0.02399536594748497, 0.00009763160778675228, 0.006808600388467312, 0.041581954807043076, -0.007761248387396336, -0.07208453863859177, -0.0713067278265953, 0.08534929156303406, 0.024764275178313255, 0.008716892451047897, -0.03104519098997116, -0.031952109187841415, -0.01700640842318535, 0.08420620113611221, -0.03720657527446747, 0.03190220519900322, 0.02126236818730831, 0.060460738837718964, 0.009008686058223248, -0.010458877310156822, -0.006942063104361296, 0.026910951361060143, 0.020260578021407127, -0.0018051854567602277, -0.055806778371334076, 0.029738474637269974, 0.035177361220121384, -0.048145294189453125, -0.015665195882320404, 0.07871793955564499, 0.02766762487590313, -0.04374784976243973, -0.013043570332229137, -0.007746458984911442, -0.008906646631658077, 0.03373537212610245, -0.006043760105967522, 0.02522265538573265, -0.0009987058583647013, 0.005581289529800415, 0.012685670517385006, 0.0306538138538599, 0.02686483785510063, 0.019693704321980476, -0.044802092015743256, -0.007995943538844585, -0.006426407024264336, 0.0011313891736790538, -0.038229767233133316, -0.010642273351550102, 0.03801905736327171, -0.006878681015223265, -0.02144092507660389, 0.04959561303257942, 0.0366588793694973, -0.006548631936311722, 0.002390526235103607, 0.016090016812086105, -0.06351020932197571, -0.061934683471918106, -0.08699910342693329, -0.028912639245390892, -0.006162868347018957, -0.02416575700044632, 0.02483137883245945, -0.044188790023326874, 0.028160203248262405, 0.0060934205539524555, -0.03157741203904152, -0.01864013448357582, 0.031219759956002235, 0.013172771781682968, 0.03226085752248764, 0.02901465818285942, 0.02855902723968029, 0.032533131539821625, -0.01810266450047493, 0.025441907346248627, -0.030947057530283928, -0.07751975208520889, 0.006639641709625721, -0.00958273932337761, 0.026352213695645332, -0.025739071890711784, -0.019657384604215622, -0.012400373816490173, -0.026606108993291855, -0.01713179051876068, 0.03471739590167999, -0.05525669455528259, 0.07215221226215363, 0.05187893658876419, -0.001163239125162363, 0.019374290481209755, 0.03707430511713028, 0.022278349846601486, 0.02742823399603367, -0.019032398238778114, 0.007856406271457672, -0.036456670612096786, -0.012527618557214737, 0.029797125607728958, 0.03148304298520088, -0.02295449748635292, 0.03151931241154671, 0.025239290669560432, 0.03693396598100662, 0.01781560108065605, 0.054893434047698975, -0.00898683164268732, -0.012228844687342644, -0.0004666899621952325, 0.012551089748740196, -0.0289011113345623, 0.023855801671743393, 0.015362671576440334, -0.02163555845618248, 0.0018069539219141006, -0.00734652578830719, -0.0013227668823674321, 0.023645564913749695, 0.006797438021749258, -0.012692730873823166, -0.015580612234771252, -0.029225384816527367, 0.02631562203168869, -0.026597939431667328, 0.015285736881196499, 0.020730488002300262, 0.04942568019032478, 0.0040952470153570175, -0.028887903317809105, -0.009772655554115772, 0.0328395701944828, 0.013279099948704243, -0.01622747629880905, -0.011417999863624573, 0.033328618854284286, -0.0059265317395329475, -0.006751410663127899, -0.04015769436955452, -0.005809643305838108, -0.05178659036755562, 0.007945223711431026, 0.012811694294214249, -0.0018418054096400738, 0.010640780441462994, -0.03425898030400276, 0.014549610204994678, -0.002993860049173236, -0.003337207483127713, 0.036597322672605515, 0.02192278765141964, -0.011375133879482746, 0.0029015024192631245, -0.015351900830864906, 0.0007790199597366154, 0.04997740313410759, -0.00753457797691226, 0.018737317994236946, 0.057962823659181595, 0.02821582742035389, -0.03516296297311783, -0.03328429162502289, 0.002603663131594658, 0.0031398748978972435, -0.04819391667842865, -0.029588300734758377, 0.011653563939034939, 0.006266547832638025, -0.01740347035229206, 0.018151085823774338, -0.036007773131132126, -0.023382063955068588, -0.022699717432260513, 0.008706299588084221, -0.017826233059167862, 0.0004496696055866778, 0.04602166265249252, 0.0556563138961792, -0.024185283109545708, -0.005079846363514662, -0.06268773227930069, -0.07729875296354294, 0.0338139533996582, -0.013352331705391407, 0.028043625876307487, 0.008464903570711613, 0.004597581923007965, 0.08046936243772507, -0.007004852406680584, -0.026217367500066757, -0.06161827966570854, -0.011861414648592472, 0.001690132892690599, 0.019404349848628044, 0.012346052564680576, 0.020903175696730614, -0.006656889338046312, 0.04337561875581741, 0.005268471781164408, 0.0574670284986496, 0.009854380041360855, 0.007955080829560757, 0.030120087787508965, -0.006137484218925238, 0.04741040989756584, 0.0046925353817641735, 0.0314561128616333, 0.029621759429574013, -0.004724572412669659, -0.026079224422574043, -0.009780794382095337, -0.012172981165349483, 0.035795800387859344, -0.048644937574863434, 0.016372738406062126, -0.002412965754047036, -0.016956983134150505, -0.015261877328157425, 0.026538323611021042, 0.016086507588624954, 0.005402041599154472, 0.011498850770294666, -0.0262076947838068, 0.0012789394240826368, -0.0077170683071017265, -0.0020661898888647556, 0.015198810957372189, 0.027841757982969284, 0.005264100152999163, -0.020965714007616043, -0.017665361985564232, 0.001255068345926702, 0.03386665880680084, 0.001859011477790773, 0.0070596192963421345, 0.026815487071871758, 0.03833940252661705, 0.04461858049035072, -0.03037656471133232, -0.04468965530395508, -0.006782503332942724, -0.0656929463148117, 0.0021263037342578173, -0.06499001383781433, 0.055268026888370514, -0.00422570900991559, -0.005359584465622902, -0.009055920876562595, -0.005562849808484316, -0.0019410890527069569, 0.02463686279952526, -0.07708635926246643, 0.040539782494306564, -0.02958778664469719, 0.01863357611000538, -0.015498187392950058, 0.03280152007937431, 0.009516906924545765, -0.014623872935771942, -0.034472037106752396, -0.03912706300616264, 0.012721993960440159, -0.023487016558647156, 0.0021985534112900496, -0.055475685745477676, -0.063702292740345, -0.0006084758206270635, -0.006235487759113312, 0.025414463132619858, -0.02896447852253914, -0.00320738204754889, -0.0008840447408147156, -0.021721169352531433, -0.00405332213267684, -0.038500845432281494, 0.003342181211337447, 0.041872162371873856, 0.06338350474834442, 0.022063758224248886, -0.006122644990682602, -0.06840547174215317, 0.07759570330381393, 0.05480248108506203, 0.009830091148614883, 0.0019189744489267468, -0.027301855385303497, -0.0249532051384449, -0.009720939211547375, -0.019481176510453224, 0.002129167318344116, -0.0043939645402133465, 0.043016135692596436, 0.008811667561531067, 0.05270135775208473, 0.0059987581335008144, -0.035483572632074356, 0.0002317572507308796, 0.037518516182899475, -0.010037512518465519, -0.024367906153202057, -0.05521267279982567, -0.06510398536920547, -0.010023758746683598, -0.002912855474278331, 0.020892320200800896, 0.002190259750932455, 0.019717367365956306, 0.018672572448849678, 0.05659284442663193, 0.003845363622531295, -0.01668260060250759, 0.001330845640040934, -0.006012239493429661, 0.0466085746884346, 0.017794454470276833, -0.0035294617991894484, 0.025970160961151123, 0.03768421709537506, 0.02829086035490036, 0.045348890125751495, 0.010077444836497307, -0.0527799129486084, 0.01331150159239769, 0.031049033626914024, 0.018842972815036774, -0.07851643860340118, 0.0020805669482797384, -0.02965131215751171, -0.020612036809325218, 0.023180080577731133, -0.0390966460108757, 0.016286911442875862, -0.055655546486377716, 0.00027037490508519113, -0.04561549425125122, 0.0006125943036749959, -0.03433547168970108, -0.023934798315167427, 0.04057515412569046, 0.009640558622777462, 0.001589686144143343, 0.0013916309690102935, -0.03972512111067772, 0.01823783665895462, 0.024124082177877426, 0.03798600286245346, -0.01135569903999567, -0.00042444790597073734, 0.02400406263768673, -0.0033726447727531195, -0.03480517119169235, -0.0706687793135643, 0.008263231255114079, 0.025199757888913155, -0.0009706158889457583, 0.03614373505115509, 0.006735051050782204, -0.04279286786913872, 0.0038303339388221502, -0.035425279289484024, -0.03761223331093788, -0.005407372023910284, -0.025894921272993088, 0.022703278809785843, 0.0021385217551141977, 0.01638776995241642, 0.029113683849573135, 0.03411596268415451, -0.01129357609897852, 0.0020063158590346575, 0.030498379841446877, 0.004396580625325441, -0.04058612883090973, 0.01605634205043316, -0.03680401295423508, 0.010712023824453354, 0.0030649248510599136, 0.024956878274679184, 0.0250540841370821, 0.010683807544410229, -0.041410207748413086, -0.0628189966082573, -0.008929283358156681, 0.042488984763622284, -0.013133401982486248, -0.025631990283727646, 0.045773234218358994, 0.03042185679078102, -0.01128468755632639, -0.04459286853671074, -0.0025162738747894764, 0.010803413577377796, 0.02277834713459015, 0.03048589453101158, -0.055626723915338516, -0.01086087990552187, -0.014966225251555443, -0.02365281619131565, 0.03389478847384453, -0.03470504283905029, 0.064620241522789, -0.0046712118200957775, -0.011868790723383427, -0.013367950916290283, -0.048607852309942245, 0.018532048910856247, 0.028404558077454567, 0.020536264404654503, 0.013451804406940937, -0.03728855401277542, 0.004259452689439058, 0.0095681706443429, -0.004675759468227625, -0.07229211181402206, -0.031037712469697, 0.008844095282256603, -0.02107076160609722, -0.018504537642002106, -0.020601022988557816, 0.04802177473902702, -0.013665645383298397, -0.026857946068048477, -0.02501002326607704, 0.07018241286277771, -0.04303677752614021, 0.006476883310824633, -0.002701069228351116, 0.023481769487261772, 0.0532873272895813, -0.02626773715019226, -0.025281548500061035, 0.005911057349294424, -0.03142620250582695, 0.002198337810114026, -0.026828613132238388, -0.02931954339146614, -0.010435759089887142, 0.005369584541767836, -0.0659564733505249, 0.005802779924124479, -0.007355823647230864, 0.0014910530298948288, 0.014431742951273918, 0.03980926796793938, -0.02401834726333618, -0.025890810415148735, -0.054401520639657974, 0.007259490434080362, 0.022612353786826134, 0.039748962968587875, -0.004397078417241573, 0.03481709957122803, 0.014641810208559036, -0.021280137822031975, 0.04748797416687012, -0.019053218886256218, -0.04333063215017319, 0.024444526061415672, 0.00023820072237867862, -0.023683754727244377, -0.016078826040029526, 0.0035468689166009426, -0.040613386780023575, 0.0307651087641716, -0.01411447860300541, 0.007781864609569311, -0.008664644323289394, 0.004716234747320414, -0.0359497107565403, -0.09367668628692627, -0.025151574984192848, 0.00998752936720848, 0.04630693420767784, 0.006606690585613251, 0.06185620650649071, 0.032009489834308624, -0.024239609017968178, -0.03336609899997711, -0.03516341373324394, 0.03373890742659569, -0.010379960760474205, 0.003777777776122093, 0.05712054297327995, -0.02008107863366604, -0.02329835668206215, 0.021497420966625214, 0.036680854856967926, 0.025561098009347916, 0.044669486582279205, 0.014991690404713154, 0.031565774232149124, 0.055603135377168655, -0.07737604528665543, -0.05985664576292038, 0.026835404336452484, -0.04388326779007912, -0.008267732337117195, -0.01369690801948309, -0.04356756433844566, 0.02900727652013302, 0.02186121977865696, 0.032568566501140594, -0.00857730582356453, 0.014315299689769745, -0.04981141537427902, 0.010863829404115677, -0.003106421325355768, -0.006101956591010094, 0.029247699305415154, -0.02022102288901806, 0.0014432229800149798, 0.0047196210362017155, 0.02024794928729534, -0.018935350701212883, -0.07969251275062561, -0.023967962712049484, -0.0007979983929544687, -0.033817075192928314, 0.03451645001769066, 0.01471733208745718, -0.026492610573768616, 0.01139412634074688, -0.02742798440158367, -0.030206745490431786, 0.022713730111718178, 0.026965336874127388, -0.017424145713448524, 0.04712424427270889, -0.023232433944940567, 0.02136916108429432, -0.003873731242492795, -0.031740348786115646, 0.12496867030858994, 0.03905290365219116, -0.00013915574527345598, -0.06580214202404022, 0.039802975952625275, -0.01977025717496872, 0.01788489706814289, 0.010179096832871437, 0.024857329204678535, 0.020632481202483177, -0.013010884635150433, -0.008472084999084473, 0.05342346429824829, 0.004458584822714329, 0.020475191995501518, 0.07176685333251953, -0.04235241562128067, -0.05733606964349747, 0.008435366675257683, 0.012418108060956001, 0.01508080679923296, 0.006286311894655228, -0.025873443111777306, 0.015561782754957676, -0.015436848625540733, -0.03569657355546951, 0.025546833872795105, -0.0027875415980815887, 0.005211168434470892, -0.025526417419314384, -0.016169175505638123, -0.025938063859939575, 0.017286505550146103, -0.012181009165942669, -0.07214007526636124, -0.02882397547364235, -0.01933097466826439, -0.011675702407956123, 0.027196655049920082, 0.026566999033093452, 0.0186673104763031, 0.0028926816303282976, 0.016422869637608528, 0.02305225282907486, -0.051055897027254105, -0.0036363531835377216, 0.0024580685421824455, 0.04417558014392853, -0.046854596585035324, -0.038851410150527954, -0.033053018152713776, 0.02158859744668007, 0.023293327540159225, -0.02535230666399002, -0.050515517592430115, 0.019510051235556602, 0.03284835442900658, -0.03822321444749832, -0.018618132919073105, -0.004354189150035381, 0.03463582694530487, -0.02538343146443367, 0.05307883396744728, 0.013477175496518612, -0.05128419026732445, -0.018353169783949852, -0.024388421326875687, 0.03017638437449932, 0.006667274981737137, -0.028375860303640366, -0.020068567246198654, 0.006387509871274233, -0.045394331216812134, 0.020994767546653748, 0.001037128851749003, 0.009547567926347256, 0.050778694450855255, -0.014552787877619267, 0.013622305355966091, -0.02271978184580803, -0.02142195776104927, -0.020293544977903366, -0.061646003276109695, 0.030409539118409157, -0.045294389128685, 0.03676328808069229, 0.04050236940383911, 0.03865405172109604, -0.02748175710439682, -0.005045004654675722, 0.0162766482681036, -0.021650465205311775, 0.017875265330076218, -0.0461568720638752, -0.0016943331575021148, -0.007510438561439514, -0.03255603462457657, -0.011353089474141598, -0.034588273614645004, 0.05009356886148453, -0.011578265577554703, -0.017573032528162003, -0.02643459290266037, 0.024335939437150955, 0.0025944430381059647, 0.023586438968777657, 0.03587598726153374, -0.03907071799039841, -0.023803846910595894, -0.025688594207167625, 0.029034482315182686, -0.03216421604156494, -0.012397159822285175, -0.07540814578533173, -0.027376649901270866, -0.0028579719364643097, -0.04980169236660004, -0.0264431145042181, 0.021992430090904236, -0.014343994669616222, 0.03633464500308037, -0.031847137957811356, -0.02410421147942543, -0.06427497416734695, -0.03680459037423134, -0.014079662971198559, 0.008466393686830997, -0.015472754836082458, 0.01973358541727066, 0.006951595190912485, -0.01549482624977827, 0.005222052335739136, 0.031157314777374268, -0.03525396063923836, 0.007383065763860941, 0.038095757365226746, 0.025944221764802933, 0.04195834696292877, 0.005942872725427151, -0.04163395240902901, 0.017886830493807793, -0.03622026368975639, -0.03371644765138626, 0.0017026156419888139, -0.021991612389683723, 0.048435140401124954, 0.02381369099020958, -0.01164602767676115, -0.015390931628644466, 0.02892865613102913, -0.004774155560880899, -0.02032790146768093, 0.010043580085039139, -0.019564559683203697, -0.0052598994225263596, 0.0026066272985190153, 0.011458274908363819, -0.016704492270946503, -0.03555142879486084, 0.031698331236839294, 0.036938540637493134, 0.00282959989272058, 0.02346048690378666, 0.030778123065829277, 0.014217372052371502, 0.008902858011424541, -0.015157502144575119, -0.028319260105490685, -0.0010738908313214779, 0.051006536930799484, -0.04056986793875694, 0.03394448757171631, 0.004744374193251133, 0.02822820283472538, -0.07088297605514526, 0.002941521815955639, -0.015085412189364433, 0.01907043717801571, 0.004514495842158794, -0.0172311719506979, 0.04262412711977959, -0.02482762187719345, -0.06957148015499115, 0.01420172955840826, -0.01517405267804861, 0.004647186025977135, -0.030321266502141953, 0.032516419887542725, -0.0153730483725667, 0.0020867830608040094, -0.002842664485797286, 0.03582137078046799, 0.004973696079105139, 0.031047489494085312, 0.014643475413322449, 0.016979578882455826, -0.010148297064006329, 0.03180396556854248, 0.019048316404223442, -0.01108456589281559, 0.07752379029989243, -0.05323648080229759, -0.04484584555029869, 0.04070190340280533, 0.014345874078571796, 0.06625392287969589, 0.010502914898097515, 0.015824463218450546, 0.00030022795544937253, 0.07408732920885086, 0.03781900182366371, -0.0009627570980228484, 0.0029706957284361124, -0.02432396449148655, 0.022114422172307968, 0.03272304683923721, -0.03397233039140701, 0.00975417997688055, 0.033020682632923126, 0.01709696836769581, -0.006566047668457031, -0.004982308018952608, -0.011103217490017414, -0.03337429463863373, 0.014850813895463943, -0.01276121661067009, 0.007744170725345612, 0.03778602555394173, 0.021144680678844452, -0.009570841677486897, -0.016250554472208023, 0.03391730785369873, 0.03246016800403595, -0.005959006957709789, 0.023599734529852867, -0.008870002813637257, -0.010545080527663231, 0.014397132210433483, -0.02084212377667427, 0.025361334905028343, -0.07750082015991211, -0.010391725227236748, 0.014571203850209713, -0.030112963169813156, -0.024243254214525223, 0.003962833434343338, 0.006537351757287979, 0.02767765522003174, -0.01925699971616268, 0.01967863366007805, 0.034265536814928055, -0.04829420894384384, 0.022504428401589394, -0.09286810457706451, 0.09191878885030746, 0.02342543564736843, 0.015552486293017864, -0.007337350398302078, -0.03692276030778885, -0.017672967165708542, -0.020501352846622467, 0.08292950689792633, -0.029224418103694916, -0.025214815512299538, -0.028345542028546333, 0.023533016443252563, 0.02500554732978344, -0.005638390313833952, 0.03725825995206833, -0.018758689984679222, 0.028778312727808952, -0.023466721177101135, -0.0577564537525177, -0.002366174478083849, 0.0017425009282305837, 0.019440604373812675, 0.02020011469721794, 0.010626346804201603, 0.013637905940413475, 0.0041810194961726665, 0.0755295380949974, 0.03726370632648468, 0.007114729378372431, 0.02464209496974945, -0.0259078461676836, 0.030718034133315086, 0.010899122804403305, -0.030946113169193268, -0.055010341107845306, 0.019488485530018806, -0.015964450314641, -0.03599383682012558, -0.048962902277708054, 0.01003284752368927, 0.02732992358505726, -0.001927875680848956, -0.010314065963029861, 0.009233096614480019, -0.026764698326587677, 0.009038236923515797, 0.06975965201854706, 0.017719971016049385, 0.012438934296369553, 0.00052525574574247, 0.04276616498827934, 0.013205642811954021, 0.011923315934836864, -0.027686750516295433, 0.02469363994896412, 0.07472539693117142, 0.02893335185945034, -0.0013523160014301538, 0.028830762952566147, -0.019424008205533028, 0.037647638469934464, -0.024075603112578392, 0.03825950622558594, -0.021562177687883377, 0.0010179165983572602, 0.004775233566761017, 0.011741220019757748, -0.01253217738121748, -0.014845644123852253, 0.012447435408830643, 0.05648786202073097, 0.03806222230195999, -0.03153909742832184, 0.01280008815228939, -0.05426595360040665, -0.04516281187534332, -0.005570107139647007, 0.013576428405940533, 0.03498975932598114, -0.013257832266390324, 0.03767896816134453, -0.030000347644090652, 0.01659829542040825, 0.05327974632382393, 0.01232131477445364, 0.023578858003020287, -0.04598749801516533, -0.028635745868086815, -0.030839499086141586, -0.012072254903614521, -0.02107391320168972, -0.0027306233532726765, 0.04900805652141571, 0.03294811397790909, 0.03471344709396362, 0.0036060400307178497, 0.013414471410214901, -0.01147583220154047, 0.07755568623542786, -0.06773523986339569, -0.01422217208892107, -0.02136135660111904, -0.010014778934419155, 0.017706794664263725, -0.011225373484194279 ]
<p>Akaike's model selection criterion is usually justified on the base that the empirical risk of a ML estimator is a biased estimator of the true risk of the best estimator in the parametric family, say the family of linear regressors on a m-dimensional variable, $S_m $</p> <p>On the other hand, this family, $ S_m$, is known to have finite VC dimension ($VC = m+1$). Having finite VC-dimension should grant that the empirical risk minimizer is asymtotically consistent (Vapnik, "An overview of statistical learning theory")</p> <p>What am I missing? </p> <p>Thanks Jake</p>
36,839
[ -0.05399084836244583, 0.0033080684952437878, 0.0175572969019413, 0.0182782094925642, 0.01366444118320942, 0.0017295301659032702, -0.02562030963599682, 0.027502890676259995, 0.030459566041827202, -0.047957513481378555, 0.04793195053935051, 0.014235963113605976, 0.07905883342027664, 0.04583882912993431, 0.00020396386389620602, 0.005686772521585226, -0.030560864135622978, -0.028874000534415245, 0.020847991108894348, -0.03584674000740051, -0.016476286575198174, 0.06251637637615204, 0.01881035603582859, -0.028846239671111107, -0.044153179973363876, 0.041277866810560226, 0.01145946141332388, 0.015008609741926193, 0.016073480248451233, 0.045963726937770844, -0.03780012205243111, -0.012703065760433674, 0.010632870718836784, 0.04044022411108017, 0.033113639801740646, -0.012048356235027313, -0.03515157848596573, -0.01875164546072483, 0.011183062568306923, 0.025180760771036148, 0.0076270452700555325, -0.03308642655611038, 0.01150397676974535, 0.03076477162539959, -0.03320208936929703, 0.025493592023849487, -0.022833779454231262, -0.027776183560490608, 0.013320902362465858, -0.02169632911682129, 0.06250593811273575, 0.008082018233835697, 0.01224758755415678, 0.014016437344253063, -0.012335781008005142, 0.010187056846916676, 0.052502188831567764, 0.0822780504822731, -0.015259942971169949, -0.046016037464141846, -0.03475151211023331, -0.04277965426445007, 0.003536640200763941, -0.01740989461541176, -0.03460349515080452, 0.0388341061770916, -0.011911969631910324, -0.017198851332068443, 0.024594534188508987, -0.014853808097541332, -0.02341856248676777, -0.007181798107922077, -0.00807135459035635, 0.018405497074127197, -0.0060942708514630795, 0.03240609169006348, -0.025441942736506462, 0.05270853266119957, 0.030350903049111366, 0.011702503077685833, 0.023449307307600975, 0.004186925943940878, -0.008468318730592728, 0.017082300037145615, 0.01669970154762268, -0.025044245645403862, 0.06467917561531067, 0.005328718107193708, 0.002963155973702669, 0.06113944575190544, -0.026979269459843636, -0.021833308041095734, 0.03436362370848656, -0.010674306191504002, -0.035903990268707275, 0.05992165952920914, 0.00562142301350832, 0.03481707721948624, 0.027715986594557762, -0.037539608776569366, -0.047746721655130386, -0.020097600296139717, -0.008531305007636547, 0.012532101944088936, -0.02198350615799427, 0.002865554764866829, -0.009030545130372047, 0.014429328963160515, -0.04370753839612007, 0.0062768603675067425, -0.031749825924634933, 0.0326983816921711, -0.02369384467601776, 0.001566923107020557, 0.054081641137599945, 0.025202617049217224, 0.02006765641272068, -0.03392133116722107, 0.030554743483662605, 0.04270203039050102, 0.017098942771553993, -0.025379035621881485, 0.006258675362914801, -0.027593933045864105, -0.05106343328952789, 0.005738247651606798, 0.026844128966331482, 0.005961049813777208, 0.008471881039440632, 0.058005332946777344, 0.0015511675737798214, -0.026698511093854904, 0.02031012624502182, 0.007943056523799896, 0.020820140838623047, -0.03254835680127144, -0.04069393873214722, -0.04541909322142601, 0.05327687785029411, 0.0018754185875877738, 0.022831087931990623, -0.08837924152612686, -0.019166339188814163, 0.026460768654942513, 0.07915038615465164, 0.0017706198850646615, 0.09150886535644531, 0.037190333008766174, 0.0034790222998708487, 0.024644790217280388, -0.03709224611520767, -0.028728531673550606, -0.003278701100498438, 0.033522412180900574, -0.036804959177970886, -0.08933151513338089, 0.01725578121840954, 0.004417479038238525, 0.017022451385855675, 0.036081161350011826, 0.030160710215568542, -0.03667406737804413, -0.03253389522433281, -0.007121265400201082, 0.007743047550320625, 0.002799922600388527, 0.02682252787053585, 0.02851284295320511, 0.07045017182826996, 0.05050564557313919, -0.005840223282575607, 0.022635892033576965, 0.009013601578772068, 0.03544500470161438, 0.040281347930431366, -0.01936841756105423, -0.010494614019989967, -0.02510092779994011, 0.03629947826266289, -0.014590147882699966, -0.019367549568414688, -0.005369550082832575, -0.025817086920142174, 0.028482740744948387, 0.015204385854303837, 0.030188290402293205, -0.015415417961776257, -0.017423365265130997, 0.019085077568888664, -0.04198356345295906, -0.05249645933508873, -0.05835186690092087, 0.043083615601062775, -0.0050995913334190845, -0.037236932665109634, 0.03979902341961861, -0.024819394573569298, -0.005967169534415007, -0.03438349813222885, 0.0011199783766642213, -0.04225236922502518, 0.0012322523398324847, 0.017169220373034477, -0.021496977657079697, -0.0021169341634958982, 0.018061473965644836, 0.06194493547081947, -0.0151441041380167, 0.044674716889858246, -0.011105917394161224, -0.0777251273393631, 0.006140758283436298, -0.010179685428738594, 0.013363229110836983, -0.0002029519819188863, -0.03098374418914318, 0.011232842691242695, -0.00281398999504745, -0.01479184441268444, 0.03260749578475952, -0.014514009468257427, 0.06824149936437607, 0.031055567786097527, 0.05006961524486542, 0.010391024872660637, 0.01077920850366354, 0.0035011577419936657, 0.011887204833328724, -0.008576772175729275, 0.015514327213168144, -0.017558589577674866, -0.03475159779191017, 0.04802335053682327, 0.061792585998773575, -0.05401471629738808, 0.03491445258259773, 0.0468522384762764, 0.04649758338928223, 0.0026146245654672384, 0.01565684750676155, -0.010680082254111767, -0.01837783493101597, 0.02021160162985325, 0.00633119884878397, -0.017886480316519737, -0.03608260676264763, -0.005642169155180454, -0.0020085410214960575, 0.04568695276975632, -0.02311382070183754, -0.0030084087047725916, 0.04560611769556999, -0.020306020975112915, -0.022305117920041084, -0.006587415002286434, -0.016310900449752808, 0.0013795956037938595, -0.03166923671960831, 0.011107674799859524, 0.05891944095492363, -0.03392528370022774, 0.015674768015742302, -0.007423754781484604, -0.003233682131394744, 0.06545981764793396, 0.011451567523181438, -0.025998177006840706, 0.005924729630351067, 0.051083195954561234, -0.06958174705505371, -0.04074128717184067, -0.019773142412304878, -0.03213294595479965, -0.0003818172845058143, 0.037449631839990616, 0.0325494259595871, -0.019637659192085266, 0.019001178443431854, 0.0056654647924005985, -0.03643587976694107, 0.02944086864590645, -0.0273264292627573, 0.050894029438495636, 0.015680084004998207, -0.039900097995996475, -0.022087091580033302, -0.046825360506772995, 0.025927307084202766, 0.0651070699095726, 0.0053787450306117535, 0.008152555674314499, -0.006590985227376223, 0.02690773643553257, -0.02480306290090084, -0.03423135355114937, -0.01338943000882864, 0.030605515465140343, 0.003919258713722229, -0.03753715008497238, 0.031309936195611954, -0.018155058845877647, -0.03036605194211006, 0.01814374513924122, -0.03096877411007881, -0.050903864204883575, -0.015105417929589748, -0.03140312060713768, -0.0016374742845073342, -0.029772771522402763, 0.020597174763679504, 0.025786085054278374, -0.01825445145368576, 0.010615737177431583, -0.06418951600790024, -0.06880542635917664, 0.01286725141108036, 0.0013021116610616446, 0.03169940784573555, 0.006868033669888973, -0.03629227355122566, 0.08210565894842148, 0.05637303367257118, -0.014610441401600838, -0.04759892076253891, 0.017671579495072365, -0.06053101271390915, -0.04012298211455345, 0.0009863044833764434, 0.005815510638058186, 0.024672856554389, 0.03954608738422394, 0.002178576309233904, 0.019904840737581253, 0.04293130338191986, -0.01693793386220932, 0.009657162241637707, 0.019265279173851013, -0.02078762650489807, 0.006949587259441614, 0.018621686846017838, 0.011748570017516613, 0.021633481606841087, -0.0014175156829878688, -0.020476073026657104, 0.03303529694676399, -0.01788182370364666, -0.052741751074790955, 0.03536992520093918, -0.028674086555838585, 0.003150257281959057, -0.0013276214012876153, 0.0059910924173891544, 0.02068280056118965, -0.006414027418941259, -0.031566500663757324, 0.025996843352913857, 0.016221094876527786, -0.05269058793783188, 0.0331089086830616, 0.02236432209610939, 0.0013108126586303115, 0.02537975274026394, 0.012636694125831127, -0.015902196988463402, -0.01483712624758482, -0.016868596896529198, 0.003225558204576373, -0.04718581214547157, 0.014720728620886803, 0.011791402474045753, 0.002712398301810026, -0.036736518144607544, -0.0751214548945427, 0.002811115002259612, -0.02404709905385971, -0.014578470960259438, -0.00980578362941742, 0.05760028958320618, 0.022489577531814575, -0.01364079862833023, 0.012635907158255577, -0.046496570110321045, 0.014701362699270248, 0.020494693890213966, -0.08529845625162125, -0.012163902632892132, -0.020143136382102966, -0.0039832862094044685, 0.020445099100470543, -0.015312074683606625, 0.02535296231508255, -0.026594411581754684, 0.006389186717569828, 0.0006660087965428829, 0.032328005880117416, -0.021150635555386543, -0.00527605228126049, -0.04001755639910698, -0.041517473757267, -0.0294253658503294, 0.0017163230804726481, 0.03172094747424126, -0.03566765412688255, 0.03377567604184151, 0.05491459742188454, -0.025126753374934196, -0.010073227807879448, 0.0138026038184762, 0.026298288255929947, 0.0073518152348697186, 0.015628959983587265, 0.011439948342740536, 0.001027784077450633, -0.04822239652276039, 0.006584657356142998, 0.00849797111004591, 0.017731893807649612, 0.048834871500730515, 0.014377500861883163, -0.01785285584628582, -0.05740436911582947, -0.05162502080202103, 0.052804749459028244, 0.0018369012977927923, 0.002755965804681182, -0.006358257029205561, 0.09285405278205872, 0.008015584200620651, -0.041279137134552, -0.016575798392295837, 0.0664086639881134, -0.0024019968695938587, -0.00739184208214283, 0.010948467068374157, -0.01864461787045002, 0.005955792497843504, 0.005677756387740374, 0.01152039971202612, 0.00514985853806138, -0.022940874099731445, -0.01682274416089058, 0.02641168050467968, -0.046223536133766174, -0.04113932326436043, 0.0021227423567324877, 0.016618479043245316, 0.015326629392802715, 0.008305595256388187, -0.02986926957964897, 0.014715158380568027, 0.04739444702863693, 0.060694944113492966, 0.05000182241201401, 0.013158026151359081, -0.06714145094156265, -0.01359496545046568, 0.06323027610778809, 0.033864494413137436, -0.03205006197094917, -0.005698292050510645, -0.06473075598478317, -0.06296747922897339, 0.030730631202459335, -0.0006462710443884134, 0.040152985602617264, -0.002690410939976573, -0.009788782335817814, -0.013484932482242584, -0.05195702239871025, -0.06458385288715363, -0.016381055116653442, 0.037158116698265076, 0.03703853115439415, -0.028418350964784622, -0.01813744753599167, -0.05662498250603676, 0.0004674634546972811, -0.029529521241784096, 0.047606755048036575, 0.035982146859169006, -0.012436299584805965, -0.019055286422371864, 0.020794527605175972, 0.013126851990818977, -0.051812175661325455, 0.007771387696266174, 0.0011734969448298216, -0.035628434270620346, 0.023139623925089836, -0.025727249681949615, -0.05077192187309265, 0.02890174835920334, 0.03399160876870155, -0.029398731887340546, 0.008292622864246368, -0.003999638371169567, 0.046543024480342865, 0.018499577417969704, 0.019320650026202202, 0.03172506019473076, 0.02080334722995758, -0.009107080288231373, -0.005162880755960941, -0.028907988220453262, 0.015434547327458858, -0.06740694493055344, -0.02031782828271389, -0.03126749396324158, -0.012568097561597824, -0.036592256277799606, 0.01712065562605858, 0.021373409777879715, 0.015733741223812103, -0.029550237581133842, -0.013684997335076332, -0.017268942669034004, 0.01000217068940401, -0.018116138875484467, -0.0489661879837513, 0.04042907431721687, 0.023014327511191368, -0.03340602293610573, 0.015802431851625443, 0.012923968955874443, -0.05342765897512436, 0.022025953978300095, 0.02929685078561306, -0.025210583582520485, 0.010691531002521515, -0.02474871650338173, -0.02910676971077919, -0.013207046315073967, -0.008826942183077335, 0.025682387873530388, 0.0006839793059043586, 0.045766331255435944, -0.00957579631358385, -0.02908821403980255, 0.006063777022063732, -0.006189470179378986, -0.037241704761981964, 0.05839374661445618, -0.008202625438570976, 0.025476574897766113, 0.0019215457141399384, 0.03813815116882324, -0.06023386865854263, -0.017957134172320366, 0.008645179681479931, 0.022493595257401466, -0.032851442694664, 0.011179143562912941, 0.011057698167860508, -0.02630452997982502, -0.033380456268787384, 0.03556932881474495, 0.02646607905626297, -0.004071756266057491, -0.016701575368642807, 0.0428931899368763, 0.07154726982116699, 0.008089304901659489, 0.00943182036280632, 0.040694624185562134, 0.03406905382871628, -0.018399814143776894, -0.0085068941116333, 0.011018229648470879, 0.015998557209968567, -0.04458358883857727, 0.0012787909945473075, -0.04694541171193123, -0.02783004380762577, 0.022522030398249626, -0.006711020600050688, 0.002325272187590599, 0.02530975081026554, -0.054009031504392624, 0.004366829060018063, -0.019437238574028015, 0.008660410530865192, 0.02029580809175968, 0.010214840061962605, -0.004067478701472282, -0.006846752017736435, 0.009640919044613838, 0.00007665568409720436, 0.034696679562330246, -0.007181284483522177, -0.0021878781262785196, -0.0030796409118920565, 0.007892663590610027, -0.03931155428290367, 0.039269741624593735, -0.04093994200229645, -0.019847635179758072, 0.010793766006827354, -0.0018205535598099232, 0.035560138523578644, 0.021804142743349075, 0.039566416293382645, -0.001245205639861524, -0.036375369876623154, -0.008108699694275856, 0.0686136931180954, 0.04618022218346596, 0.0018931346712633967, 0.05322011560201645, -0.004252485930919647, -0.0012747320579364896, -0.021604664623737335, -0.040371641516685486, 0.01009407825767994, -0.0015788567252457142, 0.00047659705160185695, 0.017982957884669304, -0.028317967429757118, 0.013819827698171139, 0.03697225823998451, 0.014627216383814812, -0.010632752440869808, 0.021962836384773254, 0.02830144390463829, -0.007465692237019539, 0.028067147359251976, -0.016489779576659203, -0.03153597190976143, 0.07471887767314911, -0.056344788521528244, -0.006468998268246651, -0.005562616046518087, -0.0321216806769371, 0.007909207604825497, 0.03129063919186592, 0.034876517951488495, -0.048884328454732895, -0.030019138008356094, -0.05757337063550949, 0.025650208815932274, 0.01733311638236046, -0.022385718300938606, 0.030074045062065125, -0.012585545890033245, 0.026718057692050934, -0.008814563043415546, 0.013777059502899647, 0.0002898495877161622, -0.055011410266160965, -0.012922437861561775, -0.008595122955739498, -0.03724798932671547, 0.0191352441906929, 0.014376599341630936, -0.032404474914073944, 0.0009486409253440797, -0.03165339678525925, -0.015644880011677742, 0.04141148179769516, 0.02328178845345974, 0.019356293603777885, 0.06302535533905029, 0.014380764216184616, 0.005943472497165203, -0.012601068243384361, -0.009385008364915848, 0.11528728157281876, 0.11451468616724014, 0.016287175938487053, -0.05177647992968559, 0.010305097326636314, -0.028936654329299927, -0.017844589427113533, -0.012316752225160599, 0.01951683685183525, 0.002833561273291707, 0.023693878203630447, 0.02444298565387726, 0.024551453068852425, -0.007174843922257423, -0.028603611513972282, 0.012475990690290928, -0.042747922241687775, -0.013325397856533527, 0.00010924125672318041, 0.002739496296271682, 0.007742130197584629, -0.015422862023115158, -0.02033465914428234, 0.010684601962566376, -0.013790416531264782, -0.0346677303314209, -0.028614239767193794, -0.027518179267644882, -0.005109800957143307, -0.04108772426843643, -0.003572169691324234, -0.03680451214313507, 0.028837723657488823, 0.02427353337407112, 0.01357321161776781, 0.015239326283335686, -0.03234060853719711, -0.0388852134346962, 0.01283625140786171, -0.0016937751788645983, -0.007052517496049404, -0.028358323499560356, 0.03022056631743908, -0.02613515965640545, -0.03513108193874359, -0.02743498422205448, -0.031705331057310104, 0.04855118319392204, -0.019647879526019096, -0.010912607423961163, -0.019749658182263374, -0.02497643232345581, 0.04867209494113922, -0.023547343909740448, -0.030795350670814514, 0.02698470465838909, 0.033310167491436005, -0.032182905822992325, -0.010619815438985825, -0.007292455993592739, 0.008873590268194675, -0.000346005690516904, 0.0367547869682312, 0.012536386027932167, -0.05137186124920845, -0.037484850734472275, 0.0038747249636799097, 0.049583595246076584, 0.03772341087460518, 0.019851963967084885, -0.013634216040372849, -0.006907082628458738, -0.03631945699453354, -0.04432841017842293, -0.011118398979306221, 0.011057736352086067, 0.049938447773456573, -0.006702453829348087, -0.004405207931995392, 0.011801783926784992, -0.053790442645549774, 0.006748364772647619, -0.02754812501370907, -0.031044665724039078, -0.05765717476606369, 0.007556774187833071, -0.02241450734436512, 0.02582811377942562, 0.0007917470647953451, -0.0033774946350604296, -0.009963850490748882, 0.03931121155619621, 0.0036727110855281353, -0.03296368196606636, 0.0034671707544475794, -0.012409023940563202, -0.04956241324543953, 0.024351226165890694, 0.01909252069890499, 0.04361020773649216, 0.03604672849178314, 0.0278537068516016, -0.0023280938621610403, 0.04490189999341965, -0.013282924890518188, 0.021102432161569595, 0.0539780892431736, -0.023066459223628044, -0.042238108813762665, 0.010653242468833923, 0.039045300334692, -0.05517350137233734, -0.028741849586367607, -0.0461760051548481, 0.01623029075562954, 0.012964596971869469, -0.02151719108223915, -0.04861881211400032, 0.0490979366004467, -0.0024161506444215775, 0.027035264298319817, -0.039355192333459854, -0.025304598733782768, 0.009500833228230476, -0.0018696794286370277, 0.011685974895954132, 0.02214306965470314, 0.02560342662036419, -0.02078253962099552, -0.01629222370684147, -0.010593383572995663, -0.004419874865561724, 0.015122350305318832, -0.012058787047863007, -0.03078223578631878, 0.013009069487452507, 0.017315786331892014, 0.09702413529157639, -0.040020618587732315, 0.017338132485747337, 0.032849714159965515, -0.05487317591905594, -0.04642173647880554, 0.010547270067036152, -0.02987000346183777, 0.011365617625415325, 0.023324163630604744, 0.027546918019652367, -0.02420256845653057, 0.025089533999562263, 0.008793151937425137, -0.018024342134594917, -0.022450193762779236, 0.008191414177417755, 0.014937966130673885, -0.011335024610161781, -0.022826459258794785, -0.008285083808004856, 0.005873547401279211, 0.0010932738659903407, 0.05689244344830513, 0.040766481310129166, -0.044981446117162704, 0.025524422526359558, 0.003283450845628977, 0.012071628123521805, 0.025425517931580544, 0.0052728173322975636, 0.020459704101085663, 0.032591015100479126, -0.026569262146949768, 0.031643711030483246, 0.014025503769516945, -0.02203201688826084, -0.10388975590467453, -0.044616952538490295, -0.01052431296557188, 0.05789318308234215, 0.025002943351864815, -0.05971203371882439, 0.004339755978435278, 0.057151809334754944, -0.0899355486035347, 0.0072824121452867985, 0.001268615247681737, 0.0016872655833140016, -0.06606962531805038, -0.015592515468597412, -0.01949932612478733, 0.027686508372426033, -0.01718602515757084, 0.014775661751627922, 0.037401121109724045, 0.009212159551680088, -0.03584133833646774, -0.018597876653075218, -0.02700822986662388, 0.03082677349448204, -0.013271701522171497, -0.03841996192932129, 0.06754573434591293, -0.026086028665304184, -0.026469141244888306, 0.04563929885625839, 0.02475833147764206, 0.015295480377972126, 0.04986906424164772, 0.03491220623254776, 0.031035808846354485, 0.04626451060175896, 0.04363231360912323, 0.03380902484059334, 0.023662438616156578, 0.023111674934625626, 0.010627762414515018, -0.004282190464437008, -0.013117738999426365, 0.0008833529427647591, -0.008862192742526531, -0.046924371272325516, -0.028818560764193535, 0.016796663403511047, 0.02448008581995964, -0.04812201112508774, 0.026356922462582588, -0.015053744427859783, 0.01395958662033081, -0.03514056280255318, 0.03483423590660095, -0.03293659910559654, -0.04691627249121666, 0.01770532689988613, 0.01861693523824215, -0.01982693001627922, -0.017800474539399147, -0.01342015527188778, -0.06524652242660522, 0.024408405646681786, 0.031725022941827774, -0.043573301285505295, -0.029713893309235573, 0.013392484746873379, -0.0025284604635089636, -0.0473170280456543, 0.0037852239329367876, -0.014241294004023075, -0.06762892007827759, 0.05976966395974159, -0.03205540031194687, 0.03758960962295532, 0.027233559638261795, -0.03404808044433594, -0.007977905683219433, -0.08785562217235565, 0.08996354043483734, -0.002494850428774953, -0.008920734748244286, 0.010503414086997509, -0.002473930362612009, -0.015865905210375786, -0.019087310880422592, 0.055499494075775146, 0.005326590966433287, 0.027017951011657715, -0.021095359697937965, 0.01771586388349533, -0.014197333715856075, -0.0319676510989666, 0.040617700666189194, 0.015011657029390335, -0.013956895098090172, 0.022061491385102272, -0.029478810727596283, 0.03485516831278801, -0.007687564939260483, 0.01892692781984806, -0.014981928281486034, 0.006778832525014877, 0.04639036953449249, 0.013637795113027096, 0.03227640315890312, 0.020044468343257904, 0.008327432908117771, 0.06070142239332199, -0.019921479746699333, 0.011500544846057892, 0.018590496852993965, -0.0014592752559110522, -0.042152781039476395, -0.01995440572500229, -0.018491646274924278, -0.012847857549786568, -0.012784716673195362, 0.03715098649263382, 0.02184346877038479, -0.031817156821489334, -0.009951166808605194, 0.03629216551780701, -0.0045584384351968765, -0.016002260148525238, -0.023875737562775612, -0.007715456187725067, 0.033779896795749664, -0.003540090750902891, 0.04280867427587509, 0.00329416966997087, -0.0020196770783513784, 0.014395779930055141, 0.03756076097488403, 0.05454833805561066, -0.017237968742847443, 0.02082652971148491, 0.04060956463217735, -0.03450188785791397, 0.0371582992374897, -0.022138342261314392, 0.02085353061556816, -0.058794859796762466, -0.010557670146226883, 0.025089312344789505, 0.010217813774943352, -0.0004308315983507782, -0.035704173147678375, -0.03033699281513691, 0.05927156284451485, -0.032031070441007614, 0.0035431422293186188, -0.028564943000674248, -0.00010264946467941627, -0.008718783967196941, 0.03185364603996277, 0.01753074862062931, 0.0026064224075526, -0.005378334783017635, 0.015179548412561417, 0.01667603850364685, -0.020666033029556274, 0.023990917950868607, -0.02873142994940281, 0.033044882118701935, 0.021644845604896545, -0.013412845320999622, -0.021482814103364944, 0.013663344085216522, 0.021131612360477448, -0.004720586817711592, -0.017608866095542908, 0.050025686621665955, 0.029013056308031082, -0.030454188585281372, -0.01946861296892166, -0.015073122456669807, 0.054241180419921875, -0.054896801710128784, 0.01639019139111042, -0.03060780093073845, 0.029560765251517296, 0.008840237744152546, 0.005452447570860386 ]
<p>I am using R, I searched on Google and learnt that <code>kpss.test()</code>, <code>PP.test()</code>, and <code>adf.test()</code> are used to know about stationarity of time series.</p> <p>But I am not a statistician, who can interpret their results</p> <pre><code>&gt; PP.test(x) Phillips-Perron Unit Root Test data: x Dickey-Fuller = -30.649, Truncation lag parameter = 7, p-value = 0.01 &gt; kpss.test(b$V1) KPSS Test for Level Stationarity data: b$V1 KPSS Level = 0.0333, Truncation lag parameter = 3, p-value = 0.1 Warning message: In kpss.test(b$V1) : p-value greater than printed p-value &gt; adf.test(x) Augmented Dickey-Fuller Test data: x Dickey-Fuller = -9.6825, Lag order = 9, p-value = 0.01 alternative hypothesis: stationary Warning message: In adf.test(x) : p-value smaller than printed p-value </code></pre> <p>I am dealing with thousands of time series, kindly me tell how to check quantitatively about stationarity of time series.</p>
36,841
[ 0.014656640589237213, -0.029582422226667404, -0.03170880675315857, 0.01130443811416626, 0.04242771491408348, 0.00495870178565383, -0.0031921793706715107, -0.049738701432943344, 0.0014689629897475243, -0.04023420065641403, 0.04631827026605606, 0.04142014682292938, -0.006333041004836559, 0.019316822290420532, 0.03699168935418129, 0.004064012784510851, 0.007312791887670755, 0.012619921937584877, 0.03473636507987976, -0.005404510535299778, -0.0102886613458395, -0.003540343139320612, 0.026301341131329536, -0.016597168520092964, 0.0005856314091943204, 0.039989784359931946, 0.02790502831339836, 0.01597909815609455, -0.018809324130415916, 0.051827941089868546, -0.03315962851047516, -0.012494447641074657, 0.0005634943372569978, 0.03347523510456085, -0.002936237957328558, 0.03950121998786926, -0.008136448450386524, -0.06545186787843704, -0.016527142375707626, 0.04211492836475372, -0.05087227746844292, -0.029472902417182922, 0.048908405005931854, 0.020066088065505028, -0.0025152075104415417, 0.022871477529406548, 0.05793050304055214, -0.0035324792843312025, 0.04921834170818329, -0.022063281387090683, 0.05419798567891121, -0.022367864847183228, 0.013003021478652954, 0.010662240907549858, -0.019745998084545135, -0.00694256741553545, 0.09272654354572296, 0.04222845658659935, -0.05622238665819168, -0.08182419836521149, -0.017094826325774193, -0.0186760313808918, 0.0074850767850875854, -0.01201302744448185, -0.03926162049174309, 0.0263823289424181, -0.0387871190905571, -0.013753538019955158, 0.04233309626579285, -0.014608037658035755, 0.001709686010144651, 0.00008772471483098343, 0.028937287628650665, 0.005881437100470066, -0.016783548519015312, -0.012349625118076801, -0.004287049174308777, 0.027148375287652016, 0.024300748482346535, 0.07296425849199295, 0.010422424413263798, 0.025978265330195427, -0.006456948816776276, 0.058318741619586945, 0.06543596088886261, -0.015960510820150375, 0.052796248346567154, -0.03970123082399368, 0.028570087626576424, 0.041139986366033554, -0.03815536946058273, 0.0020400271750986576, 0.02543283812701702, 0.017823543399572372, -0.022401591762900352, 0.0022287273313850164, -0.007565283216536045, 0.052254579961299896, -0.02485138364136219, -0.028821315616369247, 0.01623149961233139, -0.06694155931472778, 0.04107046127319336, 0.0359526053071022, -0.014542578719556332, 0.009480256587266922, -0.03291160613298416, -0.027760008350014687, -0.013474997133016586, -0.014791606925427914, -0.030450740829110146, 0.020654523745179176, -0.02489701844751835, -0.011942652054131031, 0.012704153545200825, -0.026864543557167053, -0.013630389235913754, 0.02006453089416027, 0.04312276840209961, 0.0575871542096138, 0.07043590396642685, 0.02866436541080475, 0.017536042258143425, -0.03471464663743973, -0.06761614233255386, -0.000735198613256216, -0.0043449802324175835, -0.0029146524611860514, -0.030661698430776596, 0.05261662229895592, -0.03714270517230034, -0.042677268385887146, 0.018833599984645844, -0.03469575196504593, 0.0877653956413269, 0.014527863822877407, -0.10945407301187515, -0.036554522812366486, 0.05934705212712288, 0.0008697551093064249, 0.02028007060289383, -0.0709141418337822, 0.029567627236247063, -0.011994174681603909, 0.024013597518205643, 0.002874583238735795, 0.019355108961462975, -0.010121164843440056, 0.013168620876967907, 0.023342136293649673, -0.06944660097360611, 0.00277928845025599, -0.028225911781191826, -0.013287102803587914, 0.009397175163030624, -0.053865667432546616, -0.007839782163500786, 0.02602614089846611, -0.007058237679302692, -0.014056590385735035, 0.0502968467772007, 0.0014081167755648494, -0.021662449464201927, -0.017077257856726646, -0.02083890326321125, -0.025121470913290977, 0.07906658202409744, 0.01647738553583622, 0.0065261549316346645, -0.022725675255060196, 0.006502433679997921, -0.0031658941879868507, 0.01597043313086033, 0.04043539613485336, 0.0192168727517128, -0.01089239027351141, -0.00007777824794175103, -0.02332569845020771, 0.013268876820802689, 0.019872693344950676, -0.08326268196105957, -0.007416774518787861, -0.02054774761199951, -0.0024476011749356985, 0.0031968532130122185, 0.04902439936995506, -0.01244359090924263, 0.003947252407670021, 0.04854252189397812, -0.0771852359175682, -0.0440409891307354, -0.08328726142644882, 0.03168020024895668, 0.01527753472328186, -0.019937356933951378, 0.03454653546214104, 0.023723779246211052, 0.01408615242689848, -0.03350943699479103, -0.020662946626544, -0.028920866549015045, 0.004850336350500584, 0.035359904170036316, -0.052976343780756, -0.023091211915016174, 0.017697492614388466, 0.028515802696347237, -0.019411787390708923, 0.03709618002176285, -0.023352423682808876, 0.007080200128257275, 0.012300713919103146, -0.04794126749038696, -0.023017864674329758, -0.029123833402991295, -0.034056078642606735, 0.04184434190392494, 0.003031387459486723, 0.008314155042171478, 0.03412637114524841, -0.06549737602472305, 0.04514401778578758, 0.05948183313012123, 0.03764861449599266, 0.011106968857347965, -0.02496717870235443, 0.017173826694488525, 0.03365390747785568, -0.06338430941104889, 0.019061118364334106, -0.052758168429136276, -0.02070995792746544, 0.0734344944357872, 0.0163477323949337, -0.021702082827687263, -0.00030955803231336176, 0.04576946794986725, 0.0054961382411420345, 0.011672028340399265, 0.04648403823375702, -0.007141823880374432, -0.04346846789121628, -0.0012719586957246065, 0.002734301146119833, 0.0015553138218820095, 0.052518680691719055, 0.06226537749171257, 0.01009170338511467, 0.028911828994750977, 0.0022258213721215725, 0.007514648139476776, 0.026921570301055908, -0.025500666350126266, 0.012909617274999619, 0.0072333356365561485, -0.05960688367486, 0.019030356779694557, -0.011095230467617512, -0.032685257494449615, -0.013785548508167267, 0.047471366822719574, 0.029780980199575424, 0.012273761443793774, -0.002860847394913435, 0.01321216206997633, 0.013949687592685223, -0.04210084676742554, -0.038236960768699646, 0.016918456181883812, -0.03277062997221947, -0.013070497661828995, -0.030144479125738144, -0.02568110078573227, -0.0644860491156578, 0.004974323324859142, 0.06561039388179779, 0.010966029949486256, 0.026612266898155212, -0.014074832201004028, -0.0016998599749058485, 0.007933082059025764, -0.02088603936135769, 0.04258301109075546, -0.03576122596859932, -0.0016079628840088844, 0.018765898421406746, -0.0166908148676157, -0.01337395515292883, 0.029072150588035583, -0.026428215205669403, -0.018373288214206696, 0.029810775071382523, -0.021740484982728958, 0.001692074816673994, -0.03679689019918442, -0.034272074699401855, 0.020771566778421402, -0.03697103261947632, -0.010055824182927608, 0.06905128061771393, -0.013853397220373154, -0.01912909559905529, -0.002303897403180599, -0.039441946893930435, 0.012188856489956379, -0.03263505548238754, -0.014276102185249329, -0.03114626556634903, -0.014316833578050137, 0.007761638145893812, 0.037835754454135895, -0.0745115801692009, -0.02500920742750168, -0.017599640414118767, -0.05831006541848183, 0.034386467188596725, -0.019500508904457092, 0.02655530534684658, -0.018735013902187347, -0.04983009770512581, 0.06197403743863106, 0.022625118494033813, -0.0001389981189277023, -0.038725346326828, -0.021821118891239166, -0.0437920019030571, -0.03224916756153107, 0.00025685224682092667, 0.03785667568445206, 0.043887317180633545, 0.04408444091677666, -0.007493059616535902, 0.043458323925733566, 0.0016519291093572974, 0.0022333257365971804, 0.00625971844419837, 0.004480017349123955, -0.06432082504034042, 0.009489879012107849, 0.02068408764898777, 0.014480765908956528, -0.03521152213215828, 0.010082614608108997, 0.021633023396134377, 0.0007942550582811236, -0.008262764662504196, -0.006089967675507069, 0.030701445415616035, 0.00637361453846097, -0.002357177436351776, -0.03474927693605423, 0.04626220837235451, 0.005103586241602898, -0.028731560334563255, -0.04855232685804367, -0.01677725464105606, 0.02747867815196514, 0.004197392612695694, 0.011882062070071697, 0.04299357160925865, 0.00016343565948773175, -0.016284465789794922, -0.002977491822093725, -0.023787854239344597, -0.0027805918361991644, 0.01251703780144453, -0.04611803591251373, -0.0374750941991806, 0.08109429478645325, 0.024695172905921936, 0.025827009230852127, 0.020055506378412247, -0.023893248289823532, 0.010104022920131683, -0.05028902739286423, 0.004890700802206993, -0.018931394442915916, 0.038612231612205505, 0.00885520875453949, 0.043266430497169495, 0.06291332095861435, -0.030803628265857697, 0.006762578152120113, -0.021050799638032913, -0.0348772369325161, 0.05797585844993591, -0.0015419402625411749, -0.06554539501667023, 0.013924282975494862, -0.0008300118497572839, 0.012049143202602863, -0.05135861784219742, 0.052080199122428894, 0.03173937276005745, 0.0030674003064632416, -0.04668033868074417, -0.008919688872992992, -0.00020136531384196132, 0.004089021589607, -0.011211447417736053, 0.008630874566733837, 0.06520796567201614, -0.03444366529583931, 0.030693242326378822, 0.048714809119701385, -0.016821090131998062, 0.012895682826638222, -0.02719094231724739, 0.0016943623777478933, 0.04529842734336853, 0.02767595835030079, 0.06567928940057755, -0.021101007238030434, -0.03459809347987175, 0.011506442911922932, 0.014495228417217731, 0.01990532875061035, 0.0698145404458046, -0.00985695980489254, -0.033225081861019135, -0.014978385530412197, 0.028467262163758278, 0.003950975369662046, 0.01294082310050726, 0.03883260115981102, -0.015672918409109116, 0.03164574131369591, 0.018344009295105934, -0.02833111211657524, -0.00014670228119939566, 0.06267320364713669, -0.0006710871821269393, 0.016376547515392303, -0.026680132374167442, -0.03257578983902931, -0.014733928255736828, 0.012871803715825081, 0.05654315650463104, 0.012441894970834255, 0.005967267323285341, 0.006663876120001078, 0.03910372778773308, -0.0335819385945797, -0.024026351049542427, 0.00018647767137736082, 0.028139900416135788, 0.04001106321811676, -0.002231423743069172, -0.01108250766992569, 0.04698421061038971, 0.028898466378450394, 0.011350958608090878, 0.008004600182175636, -0.0191770251840353, -0.07787777483463287, 0.031039513647556305, 0.06640353053808212, 0.031348858028650284, -0.028239622712135315, -0.018650658428668976, -0.06694811582565308, 0.012830216437578201, 0.03319002687931061, -0.06456690281629562, 0.059380628168582916, 0.0034650948364287615, 0.024446524679660797, -0.04018862918019295, -0.013762464746832848, -0.037286024540662766, 0.00876820832490921, -0.012513594701886177, 0.059476081281900406, -0.03439262881875038, -0.021199150010943413, -0.021057717502117157, 0.007813505828380585, -0.014507831074297428, 0.03565940260887146, -0.045387472957372665, -0.02882666327059269, -0.015651900321245193, 0.013455548323690891, 0.0024390509352087975, -0.0630597323179245, 0.01218709908425808, -0.009699036367237568, 0.02552967518568039, 0.04086949676275253, 0.009474611841142178, -0.016380341723561287, -0.008216914720833302, 0.0018945136107504368, -0.053116098046302795, -0.011144723743200302, -0.015371492132544518, 0.050453998148441315, 0.018375663086771965, 0.017951596528291702, 0.06732453405857086, 0.014421740546822548, 0.00021544468472711742, 0.027432259172201157, -0.026037031784653664, 0.012344659306108952, -0.051044657826423645, -0.0016691540367901325, -0.0555475652217865, 0.008164066821336746, -0.03800410032272339, 0.03709451109170914, 0.02715175226330757, 0.014252736233174801, -0.037457194179296494, 0.03334110602736473, 0.000890276103746146, 0.04874565824866295, 0.019869834184646606, -0.013845741748809814, -0.003961584996432066, -0.01417066901922226, -0.007797068916261196, -0.010952032171189785, -0.006270079407840967, -0.014671691693365574, -0.013964013196527958, 0.028669871389865875, -0.03026890754699707, 0.014558308757841587, 0.00077842763857916, -0.019297242164611816, 0.020809343084692955, -0.008934350684285164, -0.01378487329930067, 0.009548905305564404, 0.016218814998865128, 0.002178685972467065, -0.03543686121702194, -0.011702886782586575, 0.03783973678946495, -0.00678166514262557, 0.041717108339071274, -0.049768079072237015, 0.05110873281955719, 0.00555810984224081, -0.000507158343680203, -0.07344979047775269, -0.027791298925876617, 0.044390346854925156, 0.029730113223195076, -0.03705791383981705, -0.0320093035697937, -0.018374726176261902, -0.02015717327594757, 0.005188085604459047, -0.020469767972826958, 0.04032886028289795, -0.05676907300949097, -0.015359194949269295, -0.015902336686849594, -0.008696279488503933, 0.08886231482028961, -0.009905108250677586, -0.007022305857390165, -0.010082741267979145, -0.01880144700407982, -0.0390876829624176, 0.009088361635804176, -0.001802910235710442, -0.023073406890034676, -0.011456827633082867, -0.045948877930641174, -0.027128949761390686, 0.021915599703788757, -0.012634369544684887, -0.04760093614459038, 0.00997617095708847, -0.022358030080795288, 0.0072876764461398125, -0.03268957883119583, 0.005570336245000362, -0.027200972661376, 0.024064142256975174, -0.018091877922415733, -0.01205860823392868, -0.008443689905107021, -0.01713952235877514, 0.005932345986366272, 0.005898271221667528, -0.023555174469947815, 0.058120135217905045, 0.07993245869874954, -0.027149492874741554, 0.008614608086645603, -0.011906107887625694, -0.01236541848629713, -0.0023494733031839132, -0.0063682617619633675, 0.02735484577715397, -0.02283194661140442, 0.04268306493759155, -0.028144225478172302, -0.005192408338189125, -0.024940764531493187, -0.020303349941968918, 0.05780002474784851, 0.03198564425110817, 0.04312538728117943, 0.0373687744140625, 0.012506749480962753, 0.022814318537712097, 0.014110962860286236, -0.009238325990736485, 0.00040289078606292605, -0.01368657872080803, 0.04339582473039627, 0.00019032286945730448, 0.002642781473696232, 0.014636514708399773, 0.007842266000807285, 0.023475877940654755, 0.019790582358837128, 0.0024912585504353046, 0.003844441380351782, -0.01127394288778305, -0.06986255198717117, -0.04887516424059868, 0.045421697199344635, -0.032587312161922455, 0.0228313896805048, -0.03668878600001335, -0.0193958543241024, 0.0487683042883873, 0.025083176791667938, -0.013834439218044281, -0.0492388978600502, -0.021674953401088715, -0.07889430224895477, -0.001425853231921792, 0.03963474929332733, -0.04365786164999008, 0.052145037800073624, 0.005350596271455288, 0.017837611958384514, 0.02572241984307766, 0.025382157415151596, -0.011074913665652275, -0.04820124804973602, -0.054200321435928345, -0.021357940509915352, -0.028917524963617325, 0.03895909711718559, -0.024292245507240295, -0.03643445298075676, 0.042768508195877075, -0.03827973082661629, 0.04102577269077301, 0.020424438640475273, 0.019962893798947334, -0.022372115403413773, 0.07606517523527145, -0.034627582877874374, 0.017124151811003685, -0.02099130116403103, -0.03440243750810623, 0.12021802365779877, 0.0872841328382492, 0.04521713778376579, -0.06057747080922127, 0.032364897429943085, 0.03731076046824455, 0.039751335978507996, -0.046129822731018066, 0.015266906470060349, 0.008146439678966999, -0.005740632768720388, 0.02649928256869316, 0.05405331775546074, 0.029607675969600677, -0.015797778964042664, 0.05900699272751808, -0.025720350444316864, -0.02239418402314186, -0.0118108494207263, 0.03552456572651863, 0.02216147817671299, -0.030384887009859085, -0.06648815423250198, 0.019875314086675644, 0.018303006887435913, -0.0033207465894520283, -0.02106599695980549, -0.017259320244193077, 0.009095583111047745, -0.003259623423218727, -0.006072815507650375, -0.009845398366451263, 0.021957295015454292, 0.010999373160302639, -0.014937328174710274, -0.01659916155040264, 0.027655016630887985, -0.027918528765439987, 0.0615541934967041, 0.011320910416543484, 0.015449698083102703, -0.031365763396024704, -0.007733967620879412, 0.04216276854276657, -0.031738173216581345, 0.009869146160781384, -0.021890990436077118, 0.03619423881173134, -0.017544802278280258, 0.01328511256724596, 0.00043440648005343974, 0.01638846844434738, -0.015986209735274315, -0.022892316803336143, -0.025014307349920273, 0.01842515915632248, 0.0368003323674202, -0.04682745039463043, -0.020125800743699074, -0.07384499907493591, 0.0018436831887811422, 0.003992926795035601, 0.03750576078891754, 0.015923231840133667, 0.0026609592605382204, 0.016978180035948753, -0.0026895685587078333, 0.04210953414440155, -0.04078597202897072, 0.017333051189780235, 0.05918564647436142, 0.012744783423841, -0.054144635796546936, 0.00020487644360400736, 0.040824756026268005, 0.027802035212516785, 0.006698163226246834, 0.0015206197276711464, -0.017398634925484657, -0.0074505265802145, -0.01799982227385044, 0.028987295925617218, -0.023552460595965385, -0.008281202055513859, -0.024781620129942894, -0.011765273287892342, 0.025313491001725197, 0.017305107787251472, 0.012240140698850155, 0.020218389108777046, -0.014790298417210579, 0.05543399229645729, 0.013269060291349888, -0.07934028655290604, 0.01802176795899868, 0.0025438880547881126, -0.02256261557340622, -0.0051916977390646935, -0.02770151197910309, 0.04653562232851982, 0.040413372218608856, 0.001715001999400556, -0.011214070953428745, 0.008149933069944382, -0.02982206642627716, -0.022919854149222374, 0.010094894096255302, -0.013644437305629253, -0.015051192604005337, 0.024157343432307243, -0.0009584725485183299, -0.04325323924422264, -0.020315347239375114, -0.012682772241532803, -0.03060566820204258, 0.0017870557494461536, -0.03230789676308632, -0.027467899024486542, 0.011616840027272701, -0.00475859921425581, -0.005502073559910059, -0.050549495965242386, -0.009056314826011658, -0.03790491819381714, -0.03250381723046303, -0.024480711668729782, -0.01762482337653637, -0.02445724606513977, -0.01996617205440998, -0.012820307165384293, 0.01812855340540409, 0.014908690936863422, -0.0005091402563266456, 0.023025527596473694, -0.015372048132121563, -0.00030757911736145616, -0.008746716193854809, 0.015314823016524315, 0.012331295758485794, -0.05462140589952469, 0.03764694184064865, -0.04099404439330101, -0.05481869354844093, 0.024738546460866928, 0.00393288116902113, 0.03043777123093605, -0.01838885247707367, 0.024728873744606972, -0.008311793208122253, 0.035223573446273804, -0.0029750228859484196, 0.024925293400883675, 0.01904761977493763, 0.021607616916298866, 0.008717034012079239, 0.003838649485260248, 0.0012082874309271574, 0.03464224562048912, 0.0024807618465274572, 0.031299691647291183, 0.04383039101958275, 0.011618043296039104, 0.0007722977898083627, -0.005563096143305302, -0.03236563876271248, -0.010819217190146446, 0.0401778407394886, -0.008300887420773506, 0.03969826176762581, 0.028604980558156967, -0.01910722441971302, 0.015376679599285126, -0.046976178884506226, 0.003710369346663356, -0.062208641320466995, -0.005015683360397816, -0.0212112870067358, 0.013490570709109306, 0.05079517140984535, -0.041308656334877014, 0.019870152696967125, 0.017987769097089767, -0.017854811623692513, 0.02153763547539711, 0.0015161600895226002, -0.005961104761809111, -0.0198771134018898, 0.01360186655074358, -0.03392421454191208, 0.02608368545770645, 0.03811805322766304, 0.03996625170111656, 0.023855263367295265, 0.013126589357852936, 0.05146501213312149, 0.007018806878477335, 0.007827391847968102, 0.01507110707461834, 0.003165642498061061, -0.04819361865520477, 0.047195494174957275, -0.036927226930856705, -0.0003450523945502937, 0.023385006934404373, -0.013806912116706371, 0.03698188066482544, 0.016192594543099403, 0.0420832522213459, 0.014891029335558414, 0.06230650842189789, -0.019457411020994186, -0.01928485371172428, -0.06631726771593094, -0.009030374698340893, -0.00961083360016346, 0.028029808774590492, -0.003079670947045088, 0.016197122633457184, 0.022349925711750984, -0.04312708601355553, -0.010461689904332161, -0.005790555849671364, -0.03452088683843613, 0.000003338244368933374, -0.0031652874313294888, -0.02045907825231552, -0.00412838626652956, -0.035295989364385605, 0.002877248451113701, -0.04185328260064125, 0.025772739201784134, 0.024412808939814568, -0.00009730685997055843, -0.04138312488794327, 0.0311607513576746, -0.031146898865699768, -0.034539107233285904, 0.0432814285159111, -0.014712068252265453, 0.006131934933364391, -0.04717564582824707, -0.026939069852232933, -0.021738480776548386, 0.003558266907930374, -0.05506071820855141, 0.013032346963882446, -0.013111003674566746, 0.047272272408008575, 0.02018224447965622, -0.016685685142874718, 0.01002463512122631, 0.0006029289797879755, 0.023886216804385185, -0.07370385527610779, 0.05850791931152344, -0.012838278897106647, -0.006692340597510338, -0.0340798944234848, -0.016345033422112465, -0.03808456286787987, 0.014199256896972656, 0.029869431629776955, 0.009894881397485733, 0.008269407786428928, 0.017834823578596115, -0.0024580173194408417, -0.015593957155942917, -0.05827192962169647, 0.0205332413315773, -0.0008872493635863066, -0.03362841159105301, -0.010422537103295326, -0.02544625848531723, 0.03217542544007301, 0.016275417059659958, 0.011054952628910542, 0.017153741791844368, 0.009662596508860588, 0.029461730271577835, -0.025999661535024643, 0.031199892982840538, 0.011680730618536472, -0.00579681433737278, 0.06140618771314621, 0.01626642234623432, 0.002165908692404628, 0.03670749068260193, 0.0011910073226317763, 0.00965573824942112, 0.05871557071805, -0.013734139502048492, 0.03294653818011284, 0.03313996642827988, -0.013493865728378296, 0.007020752411335707, -0.029387585818767548, -0.03309851884841919, 0.032640255987644196, -0.025005297735333443, -0.000156665439135395, 0.01287635788321495, 0.02886424958705902, 0.028119923546910286, -0.010563752613961697, 0.01107347197830677, 0.003575533162802458, 0.011635797098279, 0.010914960876107216, -0.0023347786627709866, 0.02011864259839058, -0.022277874872088432, -0.013191495090723038, 0.02708514779806137, -0.048503875732421875, 0.016257841140031815, -0.025291213765740395, 0.04236048832535744, -0.010956984013319016, -0.02476000227034092, 0.01036521140486002, 0.011730522848665714, 0.008519263938069344, -0.025039296597242355, 0.013527528382837772, 0.0335121750831604, -0.04406137764453888, 0.003419100306928158, -0.004869586788117886, -0.06830373406410217, -0.002983533311635256, 0.005986085627228022, 0.01648479700088501, -0.0202802587300539, -0.027488909661769867, 0.042966246604919434, 0.020305976271629333, 0.008481939323246479, 0.0019050973933190107, -0.01401461660861969, -0.014915348030626774, -0.013449646532535553, -0.022756481543183327, 0.0279187373816967, 0.0017434203764423728, -0.018969550728797913, 0.0026390717830508947, 0.019668536260724068, 0.01442125253379345, 0.004803698975592852, -0.04529156908392906, 0.009551753289997578, 0.04003564640879631, 0.014378457330167294, -0.08298313617706299, 0.006783044897019863, -0.03161414712667465, 0.014070959761738777, 0.020508388057351112, -0.00347442040219903 ]
<p>I have responses to a questionnaire item from a number of people, measured at equidistant timepoints. I wish to fit a growth mixture model (in R, using the LCMM package) to this data to find latent classes. My data looks something like this:</p> <pre><code> ID item-response timepoint ----------------------- 1 3 1 1 2 2 1 2 3 2 2 1 2 3 2 2 2 3 2 1 4 2 1 5 2 3 6 2 2 7 2 2 8 2 2 9 2 1 10 2 4 11 2 2 12 3 1 1 3 1 2 3 1 3 3 1 4 3 1 5 . . . . . . . . . </code></pre> <p>The item is one of 13 on a questionnaire on mood states. Responses are given on a Likert-scale (1 to 5).</p> <p>A plot of the response curves of the first four individuals looks like this: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/BFVqM.png" alt="Response curves of the first four individuals"></p> <p>I am worried about the fact that the number of measurements per person is not the same. Is this a huge problem for growth mixture models or not so much? </p> <p><strong>[edit] included a column of timepoints</strong></p>
74,146
[ -0.041738033294677734, -0.005060119088739157, 0.015814319252967834, -0.004638138692826033, 0.035827621817588806, 0.009810598567128181, -0.025815598666667938, -0.026468107476830482, 0.03378719091415405, -0.025856534019112587, 0.03612370416522026, 0.013974622823297977, 0.08288133889436722, 0.018090520054101944, 0.00380121823400259, 0.01235794834792614, 0.010706690140068531, 0.012024635449051857, -0.03820740059018135, 0.009164116345345974, -0.02436639927327633, -0.007106843404471874, 0.02040291018784046, -0.054022908210754395, -0.0360315665602684, 0.04015861079096794, 0.015539536252617836, -0.012095656245946884, -0.009207322262227535, 0.07398121058940887, -0.055436115711927414, -0.043585870414972305, 0.010631827637553215, 0.0244660135358572, 0.0017202412709593773, -0.008029294200241566, -0.029224788770079613, -0.028241151943802834, -0.006209611427038908, 0.04135884717106819, -0.026361217722296715, -0.009600871242582798, -0.008455541916191578, 0.03833630681037903, 0.013482840731739998, 0.0072363195940852165, -0.001999967498704791, -0.009748104028403759, 0.06292270869016647, -0.03313571959733963, 0.11144193261861801, 0.0077117145992815495, 0.013591499999165535, 0.0067467354238033295, -0.017100641503930092, -0.042851660400629044, 0.05917300283908844, 0.0710580125451088, -0.0007023031357675791, -0.03178662806749344, -0.028310678899288177, 0.001857801340520382, 0.018944593146443367, -0.005013796966522932, 0.0008093912620097399, 0.03611993044614792, 0.013528063893318176, 0.0068277157843112946, 0.024783123284578323, -0.020194746553897858, 0.011542788706719875, 0.030652860179543495, 0.08730605989694595, -0.017035411670804024, 0.052925605326890945, -0.016127120703458786, 0.01852911338210106, 0.022643690928816795, 0.05093208700418472, 0.042676202952861786, -0.013718212023377419, 0.013748367317020893, 0.022440724074840546, 0.0070895180106163025, -0.015514107421040535, -0.020083488896489143, 0.05870255455374718, -0.03467780351638794, 0.008525439538061619, 0.04625457897782326, -0.0456419438123703, 0.03857747092843056, 0.035778023302555084, 0.01594381593167782, -0.02990821562707424, 0.05050824582576752, 0.005045419558882713, 0.035394009202718735, 0.023779483512043953, 0.030996698886156082, -0.029536494985222816, -0.03320631757378578, 0.006312821991741657, -0.0031019386369735003, -0.002516547217965126, -0.017387986183166504, -0.027851805090904236, -0.019718073308467865, 0.009330959059298038, -0.011746900156140327, -0.005153384525328875, 0.010861805640161037, 0.025980981066823006, 0.00020448584109544754, 0.012075208127498627, -0.03683125972747803, -0.010511519387364388, -0.032341234385967255, 0.04934948682785034, 0.04435860365629196, 0.02196057140827179, -0.036981966346502304, 0.021133575588464737, -0.03505181521177292, -0.04325699061155319, 0.012962565757334232, 0.00759601965546608, -0.022252360358834267, -0.019373351708054543, 0.02436249330639839, -0.003766838228330016, 0.0032102952245622873, 0.0677417442202568, -0.029216352850198746, 0.017225438728928566, 0.031139539554715157, -0.08260063081979752, -0.0628545954823494, -0.01208828017115593, 0.0032442985102534294, -0.022296685725450516, -0.05935610458254814, 0.006752416491508484, 0.0031185313127934933, 0.02531866356730461, 0.005242863204330206, 0.054737698286771774, 0.01085892878472805, 0.05096673220396042, 0.03510328382253647, -0.03145705163478851, 0.0342584103345871, -0.037872835993766785, -0.03158557415008545, 0.0008315524319186807, -0.061437156051397324, 0.013479755260050297, 0.052474264055490494, -0.0070792557671666145, 0.04393911734223366, 0.006389550864696503, 0.01197388581931591, 0.003018440678715706, -0.003725469345226884, 0.033216215670108795, 0.016113365069031715, 0.0424087755382061, -0.013524559326469898, 0.013670713640749454, 0.001870559761300683, -0.009712823666632175, 0.015064987353980541, -0.01564840041100979, 0.04821004718542099, 0.03931471332907677, -0.0024934501852840185, 0.00996636413037777, 0.012560059316456318, 0.021868867799639702, 0.060240019112825394, -0.015601851977407932, -0.0232076533138752, -0.04005758464336395, -0.016753273084759712, 0.02468438632786274, 0.03359387069940567, -0.003114080522209406, -0.004216320347040892, 0.046403918415308, -0.0010841678595170379, -0.042276326566934586, -0.06105605512857437, 0.049300793558359146, -0.02412419579923153, -0.032521892338991165, 0.011716599576175213, 0.011958773247897625, 0.047871895134449005, 0.037037286907434464, -0.03999534621834755, -0.021955691277980804, -0.022899972274899483, 0.027522027492523193, -0.02724692039191723, -0.01908453181385994, 0.047439541667699814, 0.026124080643057823, -0.02632443793118, 0.036118727177381516, -0.01678016595542431, -0.028690114617347717, -0.0058653224259614944, -0.021374942734837532, 0.04172969609498978, -0.012295966036617756, -0.009231540374457836, -0.04304865002632141, 0.028523534536361694, -0.06326450407505035, 0.05039051175117493, -0.0425507053732872, 0.08365105837583542, 0.08563517779111862, -0.03261558711528778, -0.005374789237976074, 0.003947243094444275, 0.010370329953730106, 0.03146577998995781, -0.01407330296933651, -0.00492544611915946, -0.07167387753725052, -0.0025763101875782013, 0.01162865199148655, 0.007070659194141626, -0.01253318041563034, -0.004204789642244577, 0.03563932329416275, 0.003787682857364416, -0.009506753645837307, -0.020243406295776367, -0.024396056309342384, -0.018883179873228073, 0.010201673023402691, 0.04508443549275398, 0.003911256790161133, 0.00019052640709560364, 0.0009220800711773336, -0.02429548278450966, 0.029956568032503128, -0.01810964196920395, 0.05269574373960495, 0.009558458812534809, 0.0018361888360232115, 0.0017670304514467716, -0.028988750651478767, 0.008954671211540699, 0.03262219950556755, -0.013907147571444511, 0.001440631109289825, 0.05815684795379639, 0.0030297667253762484, -0.02499476447701454, 0.01869182288646698, -0.026576461270451546, 0.025258144363760948, 0.04463675618171692, -0.023974578827619553, -0.023299699649214745, 0.013531165197491646, -0.02228626050055027, 0.033054497092962265, -0.03032076545059681, -0.04164405167102814, -0.048899102956056595, 0.030531564727425575, 0.009666159749031067, -0.00380098819732666, 0.017980825155973434, -0.05329447612166405, -0.010178930126130581, 0.0334671288728714, 0.0008518251124769449, 0.03227483108639717, -0.0014501521363854408, -0.07128886878490448, -0.003721321700140834, -0.02930864691734314, -0.024682901799678802, -0.007574309594929218, 0.04905156046152115, -0.004820913542062044, 0.0397232249379158, -0.03029746748507023, -0.028744127601385117, -0.03345256298780441, -0.01692459173500538, -0.004524474497884512, -0.0036019249819219112, -0.01836322247982025, 0.0452958382666111, 0.004895721096545458, -0.025179781019687653, -0.002586520276963711, -0.06438817828893661, 0.0005444486741907895, -0.02430569753050804, -0.01919468864798546, 0.027258623391389847, 0.023436885327100754, -0.01376120001077652, 0.02941536158323288, -0.0020833055023103952, 0.0008735187584534287, -0.08153911679983139, -0.05639564245939255, 0.022102249786257744, 0.0009190739947371185, 0.04910082742571831, 0.025535916909575462, 0.008319570682942867, 0.06329140812158585, 0.03820650279521942, -0.04130985960364342, -0.04962708428502083, 0.00804605707526207, 0.004146895837038755, 0.004204815719276667, 0.03589463233947754, 0.052072372287511826, 0.005023234058171511, -0.009306804277002811, -0.011346782557666302, 0.017143726348876953, 0.07557045668363571, -0.006789904087781906, 0.0032353231217712164, 0.011890171095728874, 0.003993549849838018, -0.007007027044892311, 0.025243142619729042, 0.03565707802772522, 0.0011301519116386771, 0.005742902867496014, -0.014786616899073124, 0.03257812559604645, -0.015878653153777122, -0.0483083575963974, 0.00232290499843657, -0.017940782010555267, 0.01581318862736225, -0.04832422360777855, 0.016136953607201576, 0.009780572727322578, -0.050264738500118256, -0.02426634542644024, 0.030001912266016006, 0.06120650842785835, -0.006807225756347179, 0.01169724389910698, 0.057468995451927185, -0.012243788689374924, -0.009922076016664505, -0.016811896115541458, -0.015129650011658669, 0.009352772496640682, 0.00831692572683096, -0.05774896219372749, -0.010579104535281658, 0.05172835290431976, 0.016922742128372192, 0.016437483951449394, -0.009096767753362656, -0.06542272865772247, 0.005208511371165514, -0.05170030891895294, -0.01113145612180233, -0.020241858437657356, 0.02827366627752781, 0.001428824383765459, 0.06599891930818558, 0.026191504672169685, -0.029765961691737175, 0.03549405559897423, 0.012291539460420609, -0.08195876330137253, -0.013423319905996323, -0.019996875897049904, 0.0132488664239645, 0.042917411774396896, -0.005536272656172514, 0.028258277103304863, -0.0060971579514443874, 0.020427357405424118, -0.028466319665312767, 0.009179367683827877, -0.021053239703178406, -0.013794836588203907, -0.0010864228243008256, -0.012284004129469395, 0.00361558492295444, 0.020717965438961983, 0.03518810495734215, -0.024371758103370667, 0.03999940678477287, 0.04807930812239647, -0.0009119926253333688, -0.0132051482796669, -0.044262200593948364, -0.0037966719828546047, 0.01471265871077776, 0.04554904252290726, 0.018101409077644348, 0.008048828691244125, -0.028072260320186615, 0.05032680183649063, 0.020796282216906548, 0.004549887962639332, 0.05606812983751297, -0.02923882193863392, -0.03207056596875191, -0.018350528553128242, -0.029656801372766495, 0.030063506215810776, 0.016395770013332367, 0.018827270716428757, -0.018538611009716988, 0.016848571598529816, 0.0383385494351387, -0.01533081941306591, 0.0073634423315525055, 0.059617772698402405, 0.008540020324289799, -0.03411199152469635, -0.04852360114455223, -0.014741159975528717, 0.0006738280062563717, 0.002341880463063717, 0.006689229980111122, 0.029480382800102234, 0.01019094418734312, 0.01827986352145672, 0.04060143232345581, -0.014286056160926819, -0.03738991171121597, 0.025536363944411278, 0.009160056710243225, 0.028121139854192734, -0.01676788739860058, -0.020466402173042297, -0.005687730386853218, 0.032091174274683, 0.03502625599503517, -0.00995715707540512, 0.011380004696547985, -0.11704879999160767, 0.002321637934073806, 0.014371844008564949, 0.020602285861968994, -0.04304872825741768, 0.001962445443496108, -0.03134698420763016, -0.008305295370519161, 0.0524275079369545, -0.04173357039690018, 0.03843385726213455, 0.005481588188558817, -0.002668630564585328, -0.056904952973127365, -0.022795815020799637, -0.06044039875268936, 0.002868164796382189, -0.00738633144646883, -0.0005129268392920494, 0.021835995838046074, -0.011848744004964828, -0.01642102561891079, 0.0029867549892514944, -0.007971608079969883, 0.05846485123038292, -0.06314433366060257, -0.016917584463953972, 0.019419901072978973, -0.004475238732993603, 0.0014227954670786858, -0.017620395869016647, 0.02724093198776245, -0.008350081741809845, -0.031574852764606476, 0.030090169981122017, -0.0141395078971982, -0.043061476200819016, 0.034138619899749756, 0.01754956878721714, 0.008578681387007236, 0.019386043772101402, -0.053122278302907944, 0.04900934174656868, 0.036846671253442764, -0.005129674915224314, 0.06484073400497437, 0.03180462867021561, -0.019662311300635338, 0.020907066762447357, -0.028847478330135345, 0.014069478027522564, -0.04756595194339752, -0.020911404862999916, 0.001877638977020979, 0.004180219490081072, -0.020143181085586548, 0.04359101131558418, -0.014302968047559261, -0.005066554993391037, -0.04612968862056732, -0.036314018070697784, 0.030419889837503433, 0.01788637787103653, 0.002734735142439604, 0.012670483440160751, 0.017267964780330658, 0.026134181767702103, 0.046553101390600204, -0.019516650587320328, 0.02262282930314541, -0.06778876483440399, 0.001492485054768622, 0.012411786243319511, -0.04097934812307358, -0.016762882471084595, -0.009109140373766422, -0.0042248498648405075, 0.011859862133860588, -0.013786593452095985, -0.008883737027645111, 0.002883712062612176, 0.024567697197198868, 0.02792399749159813, -0.027610793709754944, 0.017954593524336815, 0.004433497320860624, -0.03783959895372391, 0.0305503997951746, -0.0015019105048850179, 0.03574205935001373, -0.021319592371582985, 0.021753162145614624, -0.07617577165365219, -0.04276850447058678, 0.009164733812212944, -0.03433047980070114, -0.01439590658992529, -0.025960128754377365, -0.04931214824318886, 0.010767587460577488, -0.0397271066904068, -0.008702490478754044, 0.044597819447517395, 0.0001253606315003708, -0.02777322567999363, -0.02031823620200157, 0.029640408232808113, 0.07116469740867615, 0.04675692319869995, 0.009232280775904655, 0.026582833379507065, 0.007308136206120253, -0.015861963853240013, -0.024760590866208076, 0.005203209351748228, -0.03846617043018341, -0.006779075134545565, -0.02225303277373314, 0.0006417744443751872, 0.0534362718462944, -0.042086414992809296, -0.04388478398323059, 0.0015742689138278365, -0.006488065235316753, -0.015343716368079185, -0.0573921874165535, 0.003190218936651945, -0.011939182877540588, -0.03976695239543915, -0.046233244240283966, 0.019109221175312996, -0.018873056396842003, -0.003358356421813369, 0.031005006283521652, 0.004687801469117403, -0.034355103969573975, 0.00970803014934063, 0.07593692094087601, 0.002138732932507992, -0.020888233557343483, 0.012856635265052319, -0.04607526957988739, 0.036354489624500275, 0.0015176779124885798, -0.027703551575541496, 0.016701027750968933, 0.026678720489144325, -0.006492688786238432, -0.02125619910657406, -0.028630895540118217, -0.0093685956671834, 0.01630539633333683, 0.04808895289897919, 0.020084625110030174, 0.06219043210148811, -0.014463811181485653, 0.008431170135736465, -0.025259992107748985, 0.005618952214717865, -0.009801995940506458, -0.007648181635886431, 0.06900449097156525, -0.009069482795894146, -0.012588528916239738, 0.02811519429087639, 0.0026024894323199987, 0.0007640702533535659, 0.010635004378855228, 0.008927985094487667, 0.00662393681704998, 0.023229479789733887, -0.006560633424669504, -0.0495767816901207, 0.011302895843982697, -0.029378047212958336, 0.024973778054118156, -0.042260121554136276, -0.0609828382730484, 0.03167075663805008, 0.00839189812541008, 0.0008871257887221873, -0.05966661870479584, -0.011149044148623943, -0.01974582113325596, -0.0016271868953481317, 0.060124754905700684, 0.012280939146876335, 0.00914627406746149, 0.009641357697546482, 0.046442911028862, 0.014744751155376434, 0.046354252845048904, -0.022405549883842468, -0.0743507370352745, -0.06381350010633469, 0.0028748223558068275, -0.03166721761226654, 0.056350428611040115, -0.012038804590702057, -0.02719619870185852, 0.012197381816804409, -0.052311547100543976, 0.012924186885356903, -0.013047927059233189, 0.03507720306515694, -0.026440195739269257, 0.04519462212920189, 0.006039104424417019, 0.006429637316614389, -0.017088713124394417, -0.00923570990562439, 0.13320736587047577, 0.04828474298119545, 0.03571819141507149, -0.02723138965666294, 0.05528772994875908, 0.04184767231345177, -0.021762507036328316, -0.003038799623027444, 0.030398298054933548, -0.009985187090933323, -0.018817203119397163, 0.02250693179666996, 0.0485614649951458, 0.034541379660367966, 0.018904749304056168, 0.04384887218475342, 0.005204763263463974, -0.012536969035863876, -0.0011346866376698017, -0.008397538214921951, -0.0045520165003836155, -0.006079321261495352, -0.019752273336052895, 0.017660845071077347, 0.012221435084939003, -0.018342584371566772, -0.014749541878700256, -0.026424437761306763, -0.0030745689291507006, -0.014112354256212711, -0.02956799790263176, 0.0412725955247879, 0.0036835637874901295, -0.02812616340816021, -0.003713047131896019, 0.010573592968285084, 0.002363130683079362, -0.012654720805585384, 0.0034690566826611757, 0.08060148358345032, -0.031274765729904175, -0.00012952381803188473, -0.01391235925257206, 0.04141418635845184, -0.04175480455160141, -0.013937902636826038, -0.047595616430044174, 0.02506866492331028, 0.02216603420674801, -0.03136191889643669, 0.008370183408260345, 0.022452956065535545, 0.0034268107265233994, -0.02410939149558544, -0.03883993625640869, 0.01890883967280388, 0.005191400181502104, -0.015012296847999096, -0.012248121201992035, -0.01747954823076725, -0.0072482735849916935, -0.017356738448143005, 0.029740458354353905, 0.008123978041112423, -0.010228716768324375, -0.015301902778446674, -0.06009017676115036, 0.01800050027668476, 0.04268203303217888, 0.012124036438763142, 0.003913856111466885, 0.004886989016085863, -0.03351616486907005, -0.002591019496321678, -0.0007809845847077668, 0.0205763541162014, 0.027934880927205086, -0.03141069784760475, -0.027888601645827293, -0.04534350335597992, -0.035572249442338943, -0.0038916233461350203, 0.01296151615679264, -0.003834004746749997, -0.03230404481291771, 0.02625899389386177, 0.023587314411997795, 0.020751191303133965, 0.0056986259296536446, 0.0156434066593647, -0.029928456991910934, 0.08690889179706573, -0.03209174424409866, -0.05690693482756615, 0.005082222167402506, 0.014939788728952408, -0.021641168743371964, -0.005381508730351925, 0.008399208076298237, 0.06755578517913818, 0.005285822320729494, -0.0008958938997238874, -0.0050865961238741875, 0.023974675685167313, -0.002458583563566208, 0.0011767408577725291, 0.042152710258960724, -0.029940027743577957, 0.01835976168513298, -0.005119686480611563, 0.00861383881419897, -0.020732449367642403, -0.017847906798124313, -0.04829716682434082, -0.04717635735869408, -0.008041386492550373, -0.03481731936335564, -0.0184787567704916, -0.015821002423763275, -0.016222355887293816, -0.024042444303631783, -0.04884495213627815, -0.003526232438161969, -0.03592907264828682, 0.021873418241739273, -0.03168170154094696, 0.007644158322364092, 0.011356484144926071, 0.01556134782731533, -0.019486600533127785, 0.012861162424087524, 0.048338256776332855, 0.0006485128542408347, 0.019443845376372337, 0.012174052186310291, 0.043314360082149506, 0.014769094064831734, 0.024951033294200897, 0.031147779896855354, -0.04826432839035988, 0.009781628847122192, -0.03839431330561638, -0.07778093218803406, 0.015553535893559456, -0.010961608029901981, 0.015916340053081512, 0.02237662859261036, 0.03569837287068367, 0.007267854176461697, 0.019529270008206367, 0.014631022699177265, -0.005580361001193523, 0.005407225340604782, -0.00043204124085605145, 0.015315111726522446, 0.006281631533056498, -0.024082474410533905, 0.02823808416724205, 0.01304920669645071, 0.0297749862074852, 0.043869245797395706, 0.01034925039857626, -0.004561318550258875, -0.02604001760482788, -0.013332718051970005, 0.03476201370358467, -0.023401863873004913, -0.007148034870624542, 0.0702863559126854, 0.048595741391181946, -0.021252701058983803, 0.04088743031024933, -0.029308605939149857, 0.03188765421509743, -0.0874212458729744, -0.01833992451429367, -0.0439579039812088, 0.015017541125416756, 0.003225726541131735, -0.03096887841820717, -0.01876917853951454, 0.03429800644516945, -0.04545503482222557, 0.01922198012471199, -0.021121863275766373, 0.037109408527612686, -0.035604339092969894, 0.011738869361579418, -0.03668259456753731, 0.02738717570900917, 0.047649357467889786, 0.05858413502573967, 0.06376189738512039, 0.0462966151535511, 0.03826163336634636, -0.021559933200478554, -0.00833289884030819, -0.0013049663975834846, 0.029403792694211006, -0.05755753442645073, 0.05323879420757294, -0.05755864456295967, -0.02468327060341835, -0.003395243315026164, -0.012324463576078415, 0.030296899378299713, 0.05412466451525688, 0.022218871861696243, 0.02463667467236519, 0.06176530569791794, 0.013232845813035965, -0.007420380599796772, 0.006219587754458189, 0.003330043749883771, -0.028011292219161987, 0.016719838604331017, -0.030884359031915665, -0.0009924835758283734, 0.030411401763558388, -0.02270502597093582, 0.018745608627796173, 0.0068911905400455, -0.0012361414264887571, -0.025626571848988533, -0.02431473135948181, -0.030482299625873566, 0.005594159942120314, -0.03477899730205536, 0.007375409826636314, -0.02758202701807022, -0.005725007504224777, 0.040459733456373215, 0.016506588086485863, -0.023963281884789467, 0.01970863901078701, -0.0506792850792408, -0.01257992908358574, -0.02205921709537506, -0.005168206058442593, 0.015229281969368458, -0.040565185248851776, 0.009790318086743355, 0.010450025089085102, 0.004066007677465677, -0.04280983284115791, 0.03141774982213974, -0.029702525585889816, 0.04352996125817299, -0.04785095900297165, 0.0009909721557050943, 0.00793047621846199, -0.00912587158381939, 0.005968369543552399, -0.11194636672735214, 0.04497261345386505, 0.015258301980793476, -0.011495978571474552, -0.03604889288544655, 0.0051679592579603195, -0.045365963131189346, 0.037973109632730484, 0.05562543123960495, -0.02136959321796894, -0.02749800868332386, 0.011279117316007614, 0.03674236312508583, 0.029468858614563942, -0.041336894035339355, 0.013558227568864822, 0.0165029838681221, 0.037145424634218216, 0.006111959461122751, 0.00851073395460844, 0.020368823781609535, -0.03016570210456848, 0.02415446564555168, -0.03747199475765228, 0.008047860115766525, -0.013457529246807098, -0.025353148579597473, 0.015185222029685974, 0.004992634989321232, -0.014606142416596413, 0.0365724116563797, -0.028670525178313255, 0.015485234558582306, 0.06107240170240402, -0.010599839501082897, -0.11893173307180405, -0.012864580377936363, -0.04725940153002739, -0.012023933231830597, 0.009335643611848354, 0.004476902075111866, -0.011490412056446075, -0.073553666472435, -0.023206137120723724, 0.0067531149834394455, -0.008013157173991203, -0.007692668121308088, 0.05456450581550598, 0.0038418590556830168, 0.04130170866847038, -0.0007214996148832142, 0.005414887331426144, 0.025248218327760696, 0.002918470185250044, 0.009271509014070034, 0.00177569140214473, 0.047592006623744965, 0.001369562349282205, 0.016758982092142105, 0.019102225080132484, -0.03111639805138111, 0.02526850439608097, 0.0026498667430132627, 0.030264919623732567, -0.01034405454993248, -0.007689799647778273, 0.027137113735079765, -0.009524796158075333, -0.001386040123179555, 0.02172260917723179, -0.021314028650522232, 0.03995494544506073, -0.0407935194671154, -0.01694917120039463, -0.017802748829126358, -0.03773967921733856, -0.030742095783352852, 0.03669925779104233, 0.016545260325074196, 0.032189805060625076, 0.023231616243720055, 0.01987137272953987, -0.022982947528362274, -0.03176474571228027, -0.01280134916305542, -0.04651733115315437, 0.00940738432109356, -0.007698279805481434, 0.018538739532232285, -0.003906295634806156, -0.019811417907476425, -0.04092991724610329, -0.06590402126312256, 0.030259214341640472, -0.007014395669102669, 0.029219359159469604, -0.05942843109369278, -0.035674985498189926, 0.004111225716769695, 0.06399459391832352, -0.03406475484371185, -0.04483449086546898, -0.0394207201898098, 0.006168411113321781, 0.024273809045553207, -0.06149863451719284 ]
<p>I have web log analysis data (AWStats) from a university library website. I'm looking at the number of visits per month divided by the number of faculty plus student enrollment (visits per headcount). This shows a downward trend, along with strong seasonality. Also, the undergrad enrollment has gone up steadily the last few years, while the graduate enrollment has stayed flat. </p> <p>Therefore, I am fitting a regression with ARMA errors model, with the ratio of grad student headcount to undergrad headcount as an explanatory variable (since graduate students use the library more than undergrads). My interest is in explaining the downward trend, not forecasting. The time series plots for the response and explanatory variables look very similar, seasonal with spikes in the summer and a downward trend.</p> <p>I have taken regular and seasonal differences for both variables and fit a model with ARMA errors. The estimate for the ratio is significant.</p> <p>My question is, how can I estimate how much of the downward trend the does the regression variable explain? I don't think it explains all of it.</p> <p>The AIC without the regression term is -20.02, and with the regression term is -35.16. The estimate of the slope is 3.71.</p> <p>I'm more familiar with SAS, and I am using proc arima, but I could use R as well.</p> <p>I want to emphasize that the question is not prediction. As there are more options to gather information online, it is natural that there might be less library usage per person. The question, at our particular institution, can part of the per-person usage be explained by the fact that the proportion of grad students in the entire student enrollment is less, as undergrad enrollment rises? We know, from survey data, that grad students use the library more. Then how much of the trend is attributable to that? 10%? 20%? 50%?</p> <p>I will try posting some graphs, output, etc. when I get a chance.</p>
74,147
[ -0.02676825411617756, -0.04127053916454315, 0.002033829689025879, -0.02797035500407219, 0.0539461150765419, 0.019323162734508514, 0.005978959612548351, -0.016986994072794914, 0.03357376903295517, -0.027457866817712784, 0.013338685967028141, 0.051481202244758606, 0.062259797006845474, 0.02215786650776863, 0.03561035543680191, 0.008997324854135513, -0.014316529966890812, 0.01070118322968483, 0.010928408242762089, 0.012660200707614422, 0.008984348736703396, 0.021816447377204895, 0.009099369868636131, 0.006048043258488178, -0.03424540534615517, 0.010017299093306065, 0.028079140931367874, -0.03946808725595474, -0.01641279272735119, 0.06284666061401367, -0.026013383641839027, 0.016306787729263306, -0.011190997436642647, 0.02400469407439232, 0.04149215668439865, 0.01778116449713707, -0.01888764649629593, -0.024372927844524384, 0.0021212988067418337, 0.06425832211971283, -0.046869318932294846, -0.0009630417334847152, 0.010987692512571812, 0.02119208313524723, -0.033961012959480286, 0.0045917099341750145, 0.010079320520162582, -0.013025548309087753, 0.07218480855226517, -0.043520838022232056, 0.06213255226612091, 0.004849995020776987, 0.02151036635041237, 0.023400766775012016, -0.03080778755247593, -0.018923170864582062, 0.026098474860191345, 0.05246421694755554, -0.03447728976607323, -0.03943847492337227, -0.025363221764564514, -0.009075392037630081, -0.03061465360224247, -0.009746575728058815, -0.0423576794564724, 0.01462608017027378, -0.017801888287067413, -0.0043819015845656395, 0.04995978623628616, -0.03547864779829979, 0.01809174194931984, -0.017432549968361855, 0.0392996184527874, 0.0009365189471282065, 0.02806755155324936, -0.06644257158041, 0.01899682730436325, 0.03821982815861702, 0.04532502219080925, 0.031247543171048164, 0.009739397093653679, 0.014899391680955887, 0.007421775721013546, 0.03431115671992302, 0.04696287959814072, 0.013967021368443966, 0.05689547583460808, -0.06422307342290878, -0.00949089601635933, 0.020092882215976715, -0.012231244705617428, 0.009576807729899883, 0.029275646433234215, 0.009788657538592815, -0.04042302444577217, 0.015556604601442814, -0.019784612581133842, 0.045096855610609055, 0.009925922378897667, 0.007512538228183985, 0.008085642009973526, -0.013811690732836723, -0.00651572085916996, 0.04765405133366585, -0.053570449352264404, -0.027349509298801422, -0.03776468709111214, -0.033535100519657135, -0.03336217626929283, -0.06147129088640213, -0.04415842145681381, 0.032847918570041656, 0.025303581729531288, 0.007036405149847269, -0.01904478296637535, -0.007115172687917948, -0.005681726615875959, -0.013529879972338676, 0.040139034390449524, 0.03606051206588745, 0.058513931930065155, 0.006652233190834522, 0.007383399177342653, -0.05250319838523865, -0.038145776838064194, 0.014908522367477417, -0.002081451937556267, -0.06225357577204704, -0.05779075622558594, 0.028754092752933502, -0.023082414641976357, 0.02182743325829506, 0.020566103979945183, -0.021572919562458992, 0.029889339581131935, 0.015491505153477192, -0.06799047440290451, -0.062033481895923615, 0.036579862236976624, 0.005134060513228178, 0.0659644678235054, -0.05167393386363983, 0.0035078232176601887, 0.016582053154706955, 0.05937379226088524, 0.02815840020775795, 0.020377755165100098, -0.011326776817440987, 0.00579823600128293, 0.008767087943851948, -0.05047331377863884, 0.00021115354320500046, -0.024700550362467766, -0.02258056402206421, -0.011443010531365871, -0.09929458051919937, 0.018132999539375305, 0.04936148226261139, 0.01992507092654705, 0.002130231587216258, 0.039548635482788086, 0.027502894401550293, -0.021654751151800156, 0.014430861920118332, -0.014186025597155094, -0.020042700693011284, 0.06482458114624023, -0.0025822455063462257, -0.011622733436524868, 0.010871297679841518, 0.025688957422971725, 0.03647806495428085, -0.021157829090952873, 0.010861318558454514, 0.06980430334806442, -0.02394079603254795, 0.0327632874250412, 0.0006973440176807344, -0.03517722710967064, 0.0013786860508844256, -0.031177273020148277, -0.056675005704164505, -0.040509503334760666, -0.03372422605752945, 0.027008989825844765, 0.01973801478743553, -0.01557837799191475, -0.01616334728896618, 0.016901886090636253, -0.04979034513235092, -0.04032759740948677, -0.06783545017242432, 0.010623622685670853, -0.02610492706298828, -0.0005259337485767901, 0.02716835029423237, 0.004309972748160362, -0.006392022594809532, 0.010707641951739788, 0.015081482008099556, 0.01918870396912098, -0.02097451314330101, 0.03593143820762634, -0.03452061861753464, -0.005165457725524902, 0.002209503436461091, 0.016959240660071373, -0.019331013783812523, 0.0440327450633049, -0.08938255161046982, -0.042556267231702805, -0.01822025142610073, -0.037360601127147675, 0.02214549481868744, -0.022216355428099632, -0.020358674228191376, -0.015668753534555435, 0.025657491758465767, -0.009353025816380978, 0.050578415393829346, -0.06948447227478027, 0.015397518873214722, 0.06265096366405487, 0.011668956838548183, 0.041482195258140564, 0.028078969568014145, -0.0027991279494017363, 0.011577140539884567, -0.05262983217835426, -0.02421458810567856, -0.03889130800962448, -0.0006222926895134151, 0.04762323573231697, -0.0026189424097537994, -0.0069845919497311115, 0.03291046619415283, 0.05552768334746361, 0.041527967900037766, -0.016893357038497925, 0.044101499021053314, -0.0090732267126441, 0.019712094217538834, -0.009151079691946507, 0.025271764025092125, -0.011204821988940239, -0.008984392508864403, 0.030061298981308937, 0.009165002964437008, 0.04310056194663048, 0.03168032690882683, 0.006343181245028973, 0.01629980280995369, -0.002710942644625902, 0.04622192680835724, 0.008659875020384789, 0.016621088609099388, 0.07761847972869873, -0.0392235666513443, -0.049401912838220596, 0.01524511817842722, -0.008275850676000118, 0.02428778074681759, 0.025774797424674034, -0.032540298998355865, 0.008438711985945702, 0.00020804934320040047, -0.05022069439291954, -0.014692304655909538, 0.013522260822355747, -0.02483651600778103, 0.019537536427378654, -0.031529247760772705, -0.05661112815141678, -0.04695182666182518, 0.020930396392941475, 0.012909553945064545, 0.008049867115914822, 0.030466753989458084, -0.022926688194274902, -0.022147882729768753, -0.0026400608476251364, -0.019704051315784454, -0.017359508201479912, 0.0027500540018081665, -0.030716029927134514, 0.051802858710289, 0.010346616618335247, -0.012385943904519081, 0.013478175736963749, -0.023201940581202507, -0.00833209604024887, -0.008498281240463257, -0.012971052899956703, -0.06130402907729149, -0.04570603743195534, -0.022964783012866974, -0.02179950661957264, -0.03219934552907944, -0.005893146153539419, 0.009534163400530815, -0.012556171976029873, 0.00907083973288536, 0.018238214775919914, -0.04259570688009262, -0.024496983736753464, 0.006988334469497204, 0.012740876525640488, -0.005044377408921719, 0.0015248453710228205, -0.001380711211822927, -0.010160969570279121, 0.012771218083798885, -0.05000371113419533, -0.07137051224708557, -0.04696495831012726, 0.013490318320691586, 0.02757059596478939, 0.02921796590089798, 0.0018439580453559756, 0.01621542125940323, 0.04586317390203476, 0.046665795147418976, -0.018583469092845917, -0.0015081253368407488, -0.039766598492860794, -0.005695954896509647, -0.05792544037103653, 0.029313497245311737, 0.041349634528160095, 0.014531820081174374, 0.03956405445933342, -0.024632008746266365, 0.02049245499074459, 0.011548885144293308, 0.047228388488292694, -0.0168251171708107, 0.029522733762860298, -0.022738052532076836, 0.016115501523017883, 0.02453390136361122, 0.012176256626844406, -0.03780415281653404, -0.0006069166120141745, -0.054982081055641174, 0.0025992649607360363, 0.0009027894702740014, -0.00008131728100124747, 0.017320146784186363, -0.03844673931598663, -0.009144972078502178, -0.05301479995250702, 0.01332254521548748, 0.006470129359513521, -0.0207300316542387, -0.01649286225438118, 0.01823323778808117, 0.020934579893946648, -0.017434081062674522, 0.008678747341036797, 0.037089478224515915, 0.035339996218681335, -0.03695649281144142, -0.014211374334990978, -0.05850382149219513, -0.032160501927137375, -0.01798626407980919, -0.0030213394202291965, -0.0033617126755416393, 0.043146390467882156, 0.020904619246721268, -0.035771749913692474, -0.04256192222237587, -0.04779312387108803, 0.014156797900795937, -0.08508339524269104, 0.005581309087574482, -0.0320613719522953, 0.07637014240026474, -0.014765619300305843, -0.015950623899698257, 0.004524094518274069, 0.011817027814686298, 0.03280239552259445, -0.010636037215590477, -0.06808087229728699, 0.022577350959181786, -0.016481081023812294, 0.011189420707523823, 0.03612891584634781, 0.011029812507331371, 0.055546581745147705, -0.019938170909881592, -0.020702902227640152, -0.0011601523729041219, 0.010980330407619476, -0.005927267484366894, 0.009232709184288979, -0.022975686937570572, 0.0004626951995305717, -0.00506143132224679, -0.02520533837378025, 0.04511693865060806, -0.028289806097745895, 0.029305873438715935, 0.02476869709789753, 0.017696058377623558, -0.060460496693849564, -0.06629619747400284, 0.023393968120217323, 0.01071273721754551, 0.05157516896724701, 0.04842424392700195, 0.01290220208466053, -0.08319193869829178, 0.03380751237273216, -0.009405357763171196, -0.0004314875404816121, 0.03134738653898239, -0.010849379003047943, -0.02975565195083618, -0.020863445475697517, -0.02254958264529705, 0.018374592065811157, 0.016660399734973907, -0.006284740753471851, 0.0050787003710865974, 0.05677376314997673, 0.023196829482913017, -0.03368755429983139, 0.03160109743475914, 0.070909783244133, -0.0021653990261256695, 0.03472685068845749, -0.020917333662509918, 0.006949933711439371, -0.007694016210734844, 0.019070671871304512, 0.029495900496840477, -0.02427120879292488, 0.00580632034689188, 0.005398693028837442, 0.041946396231651306, 0.0033546772319823503, -0.056721922010183334, 0.012462014332413673, 0.0028440174646675587, 0.05660395696759224, 0.028903212398290634, -0.04045533016324043, 0.03859752416610718, 0.06693955510854721, 0.04682881012558937, 0.012837805785238743, 0.02834393084049225, -0.08927524089813232, -0.02992945723235607, 0.06895007938146591, 0.03773384541273117, -0.05243584141135216, -0.017648769542574883, -0.01740410178899765, -0.00957166962325573, 0.0026340552140027285, -0.0076495264656841755, 0.019092679023742676, -0.02078685350716114, 0.023449329659342766, 0.0011224707122892141, -0.05887516587972641, -0.04059688746929169, -0.016999095678329468, -0.058410003781318665, 0.014761394821107388, -0.025097941979765892, -0.0394628643989563, -0.0685075968503952, 0.013426939025521278, 0.03630337491631508, 0.02989741414785385, -0.002905001398175955, -0.028562145307660103, 0.021239930763840675, 0.025758393108844757, 0.01172318123281002, -0.03427950665354729, 0.010651527903974056, -0.004354058299213648, -0.01024419255554676, 0.051737748086452484, 0.002620123326778412, -0.02553010918200016, 0.01041355449706316, 0.026898277923464775, -0.022379528731107712, -0.023970847949385643, -0.03227798268198967, -0.0033188695088028908, 0.04362483322620392, -0.011928882449865341, 0.0515541210770607, 0.023072373121976852, -0.002051683608442545, 0.010042871348559856, -0.05095658823847771, -0.004790387582033873, -0.031027091667056084, -0.006554394494742155, -0.02659904956817627, 0.019270034506917, 0.010016201995313168, 0.03491739556193352, -0.008981379680335522, 0.04264283552765846, -0.04859268665313721, -0.02147846855223179, 0.02056572400033474, 0.0024243718944489956, -0.019419340416789055, 0.021825473755598068, 0.06933627277612686, 0.028623884543776512, -0.04226330667734146, 0.01729847490787506, 0.015603703446686268, -0.05619516223669052, -0.013459946028888226, 0.025393499061465263, -0.03205396234989166, 0.025417905300855637, 0.00012934541155118495, -0.028881067410111427, 0.008144667372107506, -0.009806850925087929, -0.000023593076548422687, -0.0565551333129406, 0.023064790293574333, 0.02839476242661476, -0.0010016827145591378, 0.005748750641942024, 0.005020220298320055, 0.01261679083108902, 0.008129964582622051, -0.004534638021141291, 0.035034868866205215, -0.020010214298963547, -0.011023175902664661, -0.05406230688095093, -0.054035600274801254, -0.004722812678664923, -0.008836791850626469, -0.05956694111227989, -0.013240463100373745, -0.012821169570088387, -0.03188923001289368, -0.0006202089134603739, -0.006253728177398443, 0.039063598960638046, -0.05722113326191902, -0.020175578072667122, 0.0013682846911251545, 0.018676554784178734, 0.05906352400779724, -0.003521655686199665, -0.01897536776959896, 0.0031974143348634243, 0.009480418637394905, -0.02565307356417179, -0.000023573393264086917, 0.06104667857289314, -0.0146033288910985, -0.02750905603170395, -0.020482603460550308, -0.03190327063202858, 0.06484358012676239, -0.04350465163588524, 0.016057047992944717, 0.0019155998015776277, 0.01710592210292816, 0.029749484732747078, 0.0029135129880160093, 0.03474337235093117, -0.0011564345331862569, 0.0037477719597518444, -0.01345301978290081, -0.033455990254879, -0.005205336958169937, 0.0053939311765134335, 0.024222662672400475, 0.07115256041288376, -0.00555375125259161, 0.024336639791727066, 0.06255399435758591, -0.00963597372174263, -0.0267417561262846, 0.022497890517115593, 0.00309593859128654, 0.04978862404823303, 0.031935643404722214, 0.04345020279288292, -0.012818959541618824, 0.004320258740335703, -0.018292084336280823, -0.06315021216869354, -0.031595755368471146, -0.02484460547566414, 0.0695091038942337, 0.007779862731695175, 0.028691021725535393, 0.030122430995106697, -0.005784045439213514, 0.007969546131789684, -0.04973435774445534, 0.006114219781011343, 0.014919244684278965, -0.0055139814503490925, 0.026844611391425133, -0.043565575033426285, -0.02243136614561081, 0.017922043800354004, 0.0020771166309714317, -0.0010833393316715956, 0.07833798229694366, 0.05611364170908928, 0.00968871358782053, 0.004125059582293034, -0.02604375034570694, -0.055373359471559525, 0.015417119488120079, -0.013271787203848362, 0.040401265025138855, 0.0008605440380051732, -0.002322564600035548, 0.05107436701655388, 0.03374409303069115, 0.010797133669257164, -0.055064767599105835, -0.0014982713619247079, -0.05178102105855942, -0.04375390708446503, 0.01441059447824955, 0.0059503233060240746, 0.032400015741586685, 0.05371216684579849, 0.02593543939292431, 0.006066252943128347, 0.027087291702628136, -0.015991711989045143, -0.09452582150697708, -0.01108346227556467, -0.003214160678908229, -0.03434194251894951, 0.05994579941034317, -0.020069312304258347, -0.001875462243333459, 0.012272309511899948, -0.022073721513152122, -0.004798454698175192, 0.0016666608862578869, 0.03627852350473404, 0.03438490256667137, 0.10007165372371674, 0.014920775778591633, 0.00044889809214510024, -0.028333501890301704, 0.021217795088887215, 0.13782544434070587, 0.05451042577624321, 0.021692758426070213, -0.057381026446819305, -0.0003879236173816025, -0.0027620417531579733, 0.014144884422421455, -0.04383755102753639, -0.011859551072120667, -0.015318484976887703, -0.02211218699812889, 0.07455814629793167, 0.03516771271824837, -0.02092541754245758, 0.002378772245720029, 0.05887337028980255, -0.03569977730512619, -0.008475854061543941, 0.019663052633404732, -0.0034588391426950693, 0.009530649520456791, 0.016001665964722633, -0.009446002542972565, 0.028852015733718872, -0.01718532107770443, -0.0016122075030580163, -0.01426209881901741, -0.022663095965981483, -0.0232713483273983, -0.024548107758164406, -0.04325657710433006, 0.027855059131979942, 0.008561321534216404, 0.046220991760492325, -0.0014870751183480024, 0.009507458657026291, -0.000044338263251120225, -0.04427240043878555, 0.011113559827208519, 0.05220148339867592, -0.002158178249374032, -0.02607002668082714, 0.017646368592977524, 0.03304680064320564, -0.013951248489320278, -0.006759673822671175, -0.030545376241207123, 0.00944085605442524, -0.011152326129376888, -0.012894872575998306, -0.059554323554039, -0.014790160581469536, -0.007981311529874802, -0.010946329683065414, -0.011622104793787003, 0.02919619157910347, 0.02359517104923725, -0.02112526260316372, -0.021583525463938713, -0.027569036930799484, -0.023690275847911835, -0.0022667201701551676, 0.03171331062912941, 0.045868147164583206, -0.009722576476633549, -0.01362577173858881, 0.010883981361985207, 0.015040295198559761, -0.020997142419219017, 0.0018062710296362638, -0.005141217727214098, 0.014674540609121323, -0.03125008940696716, -0.004899029154330492, 0.03348223865032196, -0.039871200919151306, 0.029292695224285126, 0.005603923927992582, -0.03214547783136368, -0.012154745869338512, -0.04639061540365219, 0.007259702775627375, -0.018676498904824257, 0.024020886048674583, -0.03621553257107735, -0.010490263812243938, -0.006258995737880468, -0.0190295223146677, 0.0438091978430748, -0.013142666779458523, 0.02008245512843132, 0.06772487610578537, 0.024280844256281853, -0.03635888546705246, -0.03632117807865143, -0.02921466901898384, -0.024325091391801834, -0.02332313545048237, 0.014848423190414906, 0.02786995843052864, -0.0028235241770744324, 0.003729254240170121, -0.039936624467372894, 0.003941548056900501, -0.0055846404284238815, 0.012338750064373016, 0.024365538731217384, -0.03211233764886856, 0.007837730459868908, 0.024938834831118584, -0.018938181921839714, -0.044701457023620605, -0.03908460587263107, 0.016160598024725914, 0.010384418070316315, 0.007100449409335852, 0.00814893189817667, -0.010732191614806652, 0.07048244774341583, -0.028272055089473724, -0.0021864038426429033, -0.0796450600028038, 0.030457766726613045, -0.0332929864525795, -0.04435127601027489, 0.008275113068521023, -0.015599539503455162, 0.019053880125284195, 0.01980763114988804, -0.020907588303089142, -0.005352427717298269, 0.06032576784491539, -0.007080203853547573, 0.01110515370965004, -0.003005694132298231, 0.012324309907853603, -0.007083919830620289, 0.019402720034122467, -0.028016556054353714, -0.03966858983039856, 0.07129829376935959, -0.050115760415792465, -0.01734822802245617, 0.018497101962566376, -0.02925758622586727, 0.015611836686730385, -0.036380019038915634, -0.02393295243382454, 0.001833729911595583, 0.04217354208230972, -0.027723977342247963, 0.01876506768167019, -0.02601938135921955, 0.04540356621146202, 0.05354958027601242, -0.022179247811436653, -0.013482555747032166, 0.0011434053303673863, 0.020753109827637672, 0.023612404242157936, 0.06250040978193283, -0.013191231526434422, -0.004169261548668146, -0.0016717732651159167, -0.003113962011411786, -0.03888394683599472, 0.0074790604412555695, -0.011497686617076397, 0.048885904252529144, 0.018505224958062172, -0.026919910684227943, 0.031074991449713707, -0.009651334024965763, 0.020612530410289764, -0.032482393085956573, -0.010863268747925758, -0.0005183785688132048, -0.019707748666405678, -0.01619677059352398, -0.04844323545694351, -0.028902167454361916, 0.026480145752429962, -0.018289564177393913, 0.017946969717741013, -0.02035055309534073, -0.02242225967347622, -0.026064645498991013, -0.01055145263671875, -0.003999592736363411, 0.019572535529732704, 0.029452960938215256, 0.0341842956840992, 0.029416540637612343, 0.019567085430026054, 0.029569821432232857, -0.02729068137705326, -0.013314015232026577, 0.016360020264983177, 0.0004020033229608089, -0.06195445731282234, 0.03770418465137482, -0.02964252419769764, -0.01135173812508583, 0.04275612533092499, -0.015205126255750656, 0.034544557332992554, 0.03137308731675148, -0.013704774901270866, -0.002329105045646429, 0.060603853315114975, 0.04449117183685303, -0.003370976308360696, 0.002543018199503422, 0.004594982136040926, -0.0018434824887663126, 0.07218404859304428, -0.013324087485671043, 0.02487822063267231, 0.0222880020737648, -0.013999213464558125, -0.003881637006998062, -0.0013130017323419452, -0.018857905641198158, 0.03895396366715431, -0.02907297946512699, 0.007605480030179024, -0.006762546021491289, -0.03352891653776169, 0.027467258274555206, -0.025623366236686707, -0.010748153552412987, 0.03339235484600067, 0.03557473421096802, -0.021331625059247017, 0.02177596092224121, -0.016784552484750748, -0.030031755566596985, -0.0032075410708785057, -0.006144328508526087, 0.0005415700143203139, -0.04338345676660538, -0.027157949283719063, -0.03758593276143074, 0.019899500533938408, -0.02819814160466194, 0.03573363646864891, -0.07168427109718323, 0.06352324783802032, 0.008023789152503014, 0.005355226807296276, 0.03130844607949257, -0.015938319265842438, 0.028390979394316673, -0.06353319436311722, 0.07878405600786209, 0.05418438836932182, 0.008893183432519436, -0.017957504838705063, -0.03687598928809166, -0.03171389177441597, 0.0009693788015283644, 0.0453789196908474, 0.01193901989609003, 0.015669159591197968, -0.017773989588022232, 0.02293894812464714, -0.02918153814971447, -0.04635016992688179, 0.041900910437107086, -0.011188377626240253, -0.003985509276390076, -0.001980686793103814, 0.00046904777991585433, 0.02164929360151291, 0.014384247362613678, 0.0036736694164574146, 0.01983591914176941, 0.008582939393818378, 0.038154035806655884, -0.019216474145650864, 0.02427520602941513, -0.012584167532622814, 0.015863457694649696, 0.038742125034332275, 0.01408512145280838, 0.0045428345911204815, 0.03875453397631645, 0.01600251905620098, -0.04953756928443909, 0.06903572380542755, -0.02900826558470726, 0.006312048062682152, 0.010052252560853958, 0.01514406781643629, -0.011008667759597301, -0.019934438169002533, 0.010984774678945541, 0.043543197214603424, -0.02531057596206665, -0.0002704650105442852, 0.0009164629736915231, -0.011533009819686413, 0.05078209564089775, -0.029874999076128006, 0.04763772338628769, 0.0269943755120039, 0.00013335520634427667, -0.03442695364356041, 0.028144149109721184, 0.01091786753386259, 0.005950176622718573, 0.0014356642495840788, 0.028624150902032852, 0.01255357638001442, 0.0028437660075724125, -0.010281735099852085, 0.03988676145672798, -0.04233793541789055, -0.04647063463926315, 0.022371357306838036, -0.00906528439372778, 0.0043288604356348515, 0.02976098097860813, 0.0126968864351511, 0.051896557211875916, -0.008091192692518234, -0.02150821126997471, -0.029342634603381157, -0.0198958870023489, -0.016736865043640137, 0.03373764082789421, 0.0016233823262155056, 0.010498840361833572, -0.0010799267329275608, 0.02177739143371582, 0.05355462431907654, -0.03453568369150162, -0.014161910861730576, -0.0005150717333890498, 0.006436320953071117, 0.01251189224421978, -0.043277308344841, -0.009991299360990524, -0.008830279111862183, -0.025571711361408234, -0.021064145490527153, 0.05221091955900192, 0.029293671250343323, 0.03519388288259506, 0.001399631379172206, -0.005684007424861193, 0.0022099509369581938, 0.0442599356174469, -0.03484710678458214, -0.0011136520188301802, -0.02000512182712555, -0.00905281025916338, 0.007193038705736399, -0.07267014682292938 ]
<p>Let $X_{n}$ be an $\mathcal F_{n}$-martingale and let $B\in \mathcal B$.<br> Show that $T=\min\{n:X_{n}\in B\}$ is an $\mathcal F_{n}$-stopping time.<br> $\mathcal B$ is Borel $\sigma$-algebra and filtration is $\mathcal F=\sigma(X_{1},\dots,X_{n})$. Thanks for help.</p>
74,148
[ -0.008874964900314808, -0.047705382108688354, 0.019769778475165367, -0.014983026310801506, 0.010659770108759403, -0.0033183551859110594, -0.00016412371769547462, -0.023506736382842064, 0.042287908494472504, -0.002192574553191662, 0.03520459681749344, 0.03677184134721756, 0.03259287402033806, 0.02142982929944992, -0.007812199182808399, -0.0027251143474131823, -0.04018298164010048, -0.01158498227596283, -0.05181015655398369, 0.001214846852235496, -0.00845304224640131, 0.050459038466215134, 0.049982208758592606, 0.015552525408565998, -0.01958734728395939, 0.03325492516160011, -0.01789741963148117, 0.010342973284423351, -0.036370400339365005, 0.0820981115102768, -0.05799100920557976, -0.027832256630063057, 0.0011679001618176699, 0.02226715162396431, -0.00853104516863823, 0.03554083779454231, -0.03499351814389229, -0.026846418157219887, 0.010406487621366978, -0.010368588380515575, 0.008586456999182701, -0.03868122771382332, -0.016703207045793533, 0.04351549968123436, 0.00878457073122263, 0.02398219145834446, -0.019103066995739937, -0.033455170691013336, 0.03062974289059639, 0.0031877392902970314, 0.07098542898893356, 0.008910445496439934, 0.010203271172940731, 0.003137157764285803, 0.012598728761076927, -0.022084606811404228, 0.01527856383472681, 0.10029902309179306, -0.014376879669725895, -0.020635295659303665, -0.014547335915267467, -0.04014473035931587, 0.0516718365252018, -0.03312167152762413, -0.042036134749650955, 0.03184754401445389, -0.0047040958888828754, -0.008207225240767002, 0.009234162047505379, -0.017360148951411247, 0.0014455060008913279, -0.023891739547252655, 0.04578661918640137, -0.00015707954298704863, 0.007272676564753056, 0.0059515200555324554, 0.02596534602344036, 0.025841761380434036, 0.05137457326054573, 0.0445312038064003, 0.004174770787358284, 0.025264108553528786, -0.0001950835867319256, 0.021223992109298706, -0.008092141710221767, 0.013453987427055836, 0.029802842065691948, -0.01410074345767498, 0.012796747498214245, 0.02842319943010807, -0.0004050805000588298, -0.012996877543628216, 0.027909887954592705, 0.002998196054250002, -0.07742013782262802, 0.05835603177547455, -0.012446441687643528, -0.006162792909890413, 0.013294478878378868, -0.023760758340358734, -0.02642831578850746, -0.0824795812368393, 0.026076139882206917, 0.0401126965880394, -0.011111268773674965, 0.035045325756073, -0.04657452553510666, -0.00709762005135417, -0.06256900727748871, 0.010797853581607342, -0.05716191977262497, 0.045819953083992004, -0.03203259035944939, 0.02577264979481697, -0.001012600609101355, -0.008992617018520832, -0.0092174606397748, -0.012514843605458736, 0.029032418504357338, 0.053126245737075806, 0.05570850521326065, 0.01300471369177103, 0.02438235655426979, 0.008006419986486435, -0.07216013222932816, -0.004764367360621691, 0.01007910631597042, -0.0013268237235024571, -0.08460364490747452, 0.0432552769780159, -0.008817659690976143, -0.008726566098630428, 0.05066818743944168, 0.026491940021514893, 0.058626413345336914, -0.04563683643937111, -0.05534500628709793, -0.034652285277843475, 0.056092917919158936, -0.023501625284552574, -0.005142551846802235, -0.06309054046869278, -0.000157194648636505, 0.020551878958940506, 0.06119530647993088, -0.014176948927342892, 0.05655502527952194, 0.04759594798088074, 0.013857262209057808, -0.006742136552929878, -0.02921845018863678, -0.05750275030732155, 0.04462026432156563, 0.06208155304193497, -0.001909526064991951, -0.00790785625576973, 0.025309907272458076, 0.02539040520787239, -0.03933713585138321, -0.039973463863134384, 0.0633595660328865, -0.01780492067337036, -0.0332784578204155, -0.01580534130334854, 0.008460302837193012, -0.007654561661183834, 0.04328834265470505, 0.041410449892282486, 0.014237616211175919, -0.007699209731072187, 0.021050145849585533, 0.012080253101885319, -0.009870418347418308, 0.05529135465621948, 0.00980376172810793, -0.040460795164108276, -0.017082149162888527, 0.046953778713941574, 0.027941551059484482, 0.025854066014289856, -0.012673038989305496, 0.019956452772021294, -0.04869033768773079, 0.005066841375082731, -0.003697024891152978, 0.03460044041275978, 0.0014831515727564692, -0.008886775933206081, 0.002643582643941045, -0.04680195450782776, -0.03958991542458534, -0.07013028115034103, 0.016938265413045883, 0.032333437353372574, -0.038869019597768784, 0.030459551140666008, -0.003403345588594675, -0.03481969237327576, -0.027825044468045235, -0.017307579517364502, -0.0053756628185510635, 0.01891687884926796, -0.0036455087829381227, -0.0637880489230156, 0.007158251479268074, 0.0657186433672905, 0.06470337510108948, -0.016840998083353043, 0.05149003490805626, -0.018946951255202293, -0.026654670014977455, 0.012159150093793869, -0.03586208447813988, 0.025683222338557243, -0.02875376120209694, -0.025779785588383675, 0.04357874393463135, -0.00491889426484704, 0.008412014693021774, 0.02800566516816616, -0.04949159175157547, 0.015798961743712425, 0.0375697948038578, 0.03477342799305916, -0.0047496915794909, -0.015348000451922417, 0.018549863249063492, 0.04098962992429733, -0.004250465426594019, -0.019722655415534973, -0.01970130018889904, -0.03118334896862507, 0.03758663684129715, 0.07269637286663055, -0.013322253711521626, 0.0025348144117742777, 0.04217331111431122, -0.01573774591088295, 0.0426781065762043, 0.03295890986919403, 0.01244084257632494, -0.013881955295801163, 0.0004877570900134742, 0.0068250796757638454, -0.03295056149363518, 0.007963711395859718, -0.013924174942076206, 0.0038241087459027767, 0.06301939487457275, -0.021773703396320343, -0.0023379724007099867, 0.03525081276893616, 0.04973391070961952, 0.021999308839440346, 0.02628942020237446, -0.03284025564789772, 0.005489634349942207, -0.03829216584563255, 0.004206114914268255, 0.036731019616127014, 0.003123715752735734, 0.0715043917298317, -0.002149810316041112, -0.034084513783454895, 0.03471549227833748, 0.029328254982829094, 0.01487788651138544, 0.009200284257531166, 0.025310266762971878, -0.028329910710453987, -0.0050943875685334206, -0.012905641458928585, -0.007711941841989756, -0.014166926965117455, 0.010199060663580894, 0.043740276247262955, -0.05411785840988159, -0.016557002440094948, -0.01746165007352829, 0.0019519546767696738, 0.018378617241978645, 0.0038368504028767347, 0.05673368647694588, -0.054707903414964676, -0.04293207824230194, 0.001991148805245757, -0.015190721489489079, 0.0038323954213410616, 0.005780660081654787, -0.02523150108754635, 0.023221338167786598, 0.03299861028790474, -0.014773242175579071, -0.04660843685269356, -0.007210800424218178, -0.014558074995875359, 0.010842216201126575, -0.011734281666576862, 0.016319885849952698, 0.016484523192048073, 0.058219049125909805, -0.055182598531246185, -0.013190893456339836, -0.027811532840132713, -0.006072040647268295, -0.0704290121793747, -0.0277954563498497, 0.016503753140568733, -0.011692713014781475, 0.04616253823041916, -0.0011785897659137845, -0.043212082237005234, 0.014263167046010494, -0.05268576741218567, -0.021236618980765343, -0.014112448319792747, -0.0030353679321706295, 0.028984248638153076, -0.031219901517033577, -0.0318814255297184, 0.0747692734003067, 0.0642387643456459, -0.025546682998538017, -0.022373521700501442, 0.003932645544409752, -0.0003298652300145477, -0.019434360787272453, 0.042808897793293, 0.0020275944843888283, -0.034353453665971756, 0.029299885034561157, -0.0047594341449439526, 0.06204386427998543, 0.08465325832366943, -0.0061746626161038876, -0.010251009836792946, 0.008015208877623081, -0.03251626342535019, 0.03571499139070511, 0.019771546125411987, -0.01767716370522976, -0.00620924262329936, 0.028638117015361786, 0.008279576897621155, 0.009735222905874252, 0.00946350209414959, -0.04598040133714676, 0.004779034294188023, -0.025098077952861786, -0.024491403251886368, -0.02374427765607834, 0.03915299102663994, 0.007842356339097023, -0.028638698160648346, -0.0009522567270323634, 0.03692387789487839, 0.020746666938066483, -0.011169611476361752, 0.020999783650040627, -0.0024520785082131624, 0.030226821079850197, -0.03645622730255127, -0.015284913592040539, -0.014819292351603508, -0.05062590911984444, 0.01704346016049385, -0.026430903002619743, -0.03737260773777962, 0.0058537800796329975, 0.059449203312397, 0.04114922136068344, -0.03409760072827339, -0.01587408035993576, -0.027806170284748077, -0.011315320618450642, 0.00569151621311903, 0.00034005241468548775, 0.07998286187648773, 0.03302791342139244, 0.05043821409344673, -0.006449975073337555, -0.010549645870923996, -0.012129615060985088, 0.02785797230899334, -0.06411506235599518, 0.01328307669609785, -0.020574919879436493, 0.014921163208782673, -0.012072989717125893, -0.008083154447376728, 0.036598674952983856, 0.018426667898893356, 0.007650313433259726, -0.0030613394919782877, 0.009620272554457188, -0.08065345883369446, -0.003445088630542159, -0.039649903774261475, -0.018909845501184464, 0.01570064388215542, 0.01500618550926447, 0.04421151429414749, -0.006000585854053497, 0.04757769778370857, 0.03506891056895256, -0.00541748758405447, -0.0064443377777934074, 0.011960990726947784, -0.004404968116432428, 0.026991451159119606, 0.023162132129073143, 0.03504721447825432, 0.028637174516916275, -0.014444131404161453, 0.029798271134495735, -0.00018486674525775015, 0.03846361115574837, 0.02523116208612919, -0.011714586988091469, 0.003418829059228301, -0.07272133976221085, -0.009829259477555752, 0.01586039550602436, 0.04291030764579773, 0.006566149182617664, -0.036156002432107925, 0.09879395365715027, 0.009775477461516857, -0.03585272654891014, 0.025688698515295982, 0.026570189744234085, 0.03304507955908775, -0.0004327402566559613, -0.008231689222157001, -0.039640337228775024, -0.030559875071048737, 0.007765453774482012, 0.0016321977600455284, -0.011099833995103836, -0.026652134954929352, 0.018992265686392784, 0.05075957998633385, -0.003339336486533284, 0.005904481280595064, -0.014798590913414955, 0.0240264143794775, -0.02478942461311817, 0.027701478451490402, -0.02232494205236435, 0.03684715926647186, 0.000014751776689081453, 0.022231485694646835, 0.029982101172208786, 0.03684406727552414, -0.05038264021277428, -0.030539413914084435, 0.0015516900457441807, 0.041154999285936356, -0.016353463754057884, -0.02911032922565937, -0.0594208650290966, -0.0150765310972929, 0.05305575206875801, -0.024628177285194397, 0.03440764173865318, -0.03591735288500786, 0.0017068941378965974, -0.01691473461687565, -0.040144339203834534, 0.00018115151033271104, -0.0032856923062354326, 0.027254370972514153, 0.02921765297651291, 0.009575756266713142, 0.002070785965770483, -0.011377924121916294, -0.02535027451813221, 0.005819082260131836, 0.032112013548612595, -0.007630942855030298, -0.008187953382730484, -0.005856914445757866, 0.03949063643813133, -0.02987011708319187, -0.03589431941509247, 0.021033642813563347, -0.0241507887840271, -0.02120932750403881, 0.02768098935484886, -0.0007042089710012078, -0.02326328493654728, 0.06974023580551147, 0.03957667574286461, -0.039703454822301865, 0.05574987828731537, -0.04910430312156677, 0.04123171046376228, 0.0245989803224802, -0.01714092493057251, 0.04824569821357727, 0.017209503799676895, 0.04815997928380966, 0.037979815155267715, 0.009003165178000927, 0.007842393592000008, -0.03848317638039589, 0.007864043116569519, -0.028853818774223328, -0.03913642093539238, -0.03258609399199486, 0.0411774218082428, -0.012957976199686527, -0.014191517606377602, -0.002201288938522339, -0.011191044002771378, 0.007745579816401005, 0.025311460718512535, 0.025245852768421173, -0.0062015666626393795, 0.02208769880235195, 0.0029911608435213566, 0.03735972195863724, -0.026608480140566826, 0.013986475765705109, -0.02342589944601059, 0.04739595204591751, 0.04100659489631653, 0.018036264926195145, 0.031205005943775177, -0.023896705359220505, -0.020468855276703835, -0.01310928724706173, -0.009408069774508476, 0.01631416380405426, 0.0054467059671878815, -0.003999467007815838, -0.00016492485883645713, -0.02164185233414173, -0.006246751639991999, 0.006691963877528906, -0.012932438403367996, -0.02077413909137249, -0.06193659082055092, 0.07646551728248596, 0.03780125081539154, -0.01179264485836029, -0.08524571359157562, -0.03547869622707367, 0.004914324264973402, -0.0050292424857616425, -0.05979696661233902, -0.07236136496067047, 0.022447099909186363, -0.007394023239612579, -0.04009547829627991, -0.0015372224152088165, 0.052865978330373764, -0.025274842977523804, -0.02467009611427784, -0.016392653807997704, -0.015498974360525608, 0.0387323722243309, 0.01946313865482807, 0.011524266563355923, -0.0030993397813290358, -0.02369246445596218, -0.048764411360025406, -0.0031399368308484554, 0.031710900366306305, -0.009446296840906143, 0.0026154587976634502, -0.009896388277411461, -0.005464212037622929, 0.005730642471462488, 0.011693100444972515, -0.0030540989246219397, 0.03234832361340523, 0.0016153958858922124, -0.02089487761259079, 0.02551855333149433, -0.018229573965072632, -0.0006212255102582276, 0.01766566000878811, -0.026047471910715103, -0.007222252897918224, 0.022938599810004234, -0.031677525490522385, 0.0036663473583757877, -0.02912500686943531, 0.00821903720498085, -0.012461443431675434, 0.05626266449689865, -0.018116209656000137, 0.03442152962088585, -0.0031221387907862663, 0.01682678423821926, 0.009184355847537518, -0.048037752509117126, -0.02029557339847088, 0.006292995531111956, 0.0014239981537684798, -0.043865859508514404, -0.03581435978412628, -0.02790849842131138, 0.010819741524755955, 0.039785515516996384, 0.002240949310362339, 0.0010546321282163262, 0.004663200117647648, -0.019512930884957314, 0.0322200171649456, -0.006582986563444138, 0.032299384474754333, -0.009783945046365261, 0.008467665873467922, 0.051142618060112, -0.01926029659807682, -0.006630274932831526, 0.051668550819158554, 0.015263952314853668, -0.004106635693460703, 0.027770504355430603, 0.029573123902082443, -0.0013525205431506038, 0.009905681945383549, -0.022138049826025963, -0.06355452537536621, 0.02224421687424183, -0.06472533196210861, 0.02371111325919628, 0.0034310619812458754, -0.03223289176821709, 0.004252281971275806, 0.022118665277957916, 0.007009780500084162, 0.023986535146832466, 0.0011683778138831258, -0.04358112812042236, 0.0019715616945177317, -0.005190165713429451, 0.017840418964624405, 0.06146787479519844, -0.0066897450014948845, 0.051501188427209854, -0.017477797344326973, 0.02742643468081951, -0.024383001029491425, 0.00029064659611321986, -0.004666632041335106, -0.06261836737394333, -0.07924440503120422, 0.03971172496676445, -0.021171951666474342, -0.019574670121073723, 0.011092268861830235, -0.052642278373241425, 0.018680943176150322, -0.002406074432656169, 0.014174024574458599, 0.026634780690073967, 0.08857433497905731, 0.007734506856650114, 0.04962519183754921, -0.009314434602856636, 0.004510929342359304, 0.11997712403535843, 0.07080298662185669, 0.0012486415216699243, -0.0754694864153862, -0.006801762618124485, -0.007819407619535923, 0.003505007131025195, -0.03903627023100853, 0.016351722180843353, 0.014814668335020542, -0.022936882451176643, 0.016877032816410065, 0.0337899886071682, -0.0193620678037405, -0.036579713225364685, 0.029057078063488007, -0.044622231274843216, -0.006369421258568764, 0.04447022080421448, -0.004111156798899174, 0.016736872494220734, -0.021866613999009132, -0.047746382653713226, 0.01364252157509327, 0.005201803054660559, -0.004298285581171513, -0.030062656849622726, -0.027295397594571114, 0.0044296300038695335, -0.02070929855108261, 0.018629565834999084, -0.00016017298912629485, 0.025611503049731255, -0.04111185669898987, -0.005120337475091219, -0.0046796430833637714, 0.008680973201990128, 0.013271046802401543, 0.021347764879465103, 0.05164904147386551, 0.005820156540721655, 0.01261229906231165, 0.022941095754504204, 0.035701606422662735, -0.04855090752243996, -0.01483567152172327, -0.013601161539554596, 0.006372926291078329, -0.02252465859055519, -0.0019646771252155304, -0.028248118236660957, 0.0008453010232187808, 0.0231963861733675, -0.026560477912425995, -0.0322132334113121, 0.020263493061065674, 0.02749205380678177, -0.015066451393067837, -0.018582889810204506, -0.031147461384534836, 0.014447866007685661, -0.007209057454019785, 0.005182446446269751, -0.006014780141413212, -0.049044691026210785, -0.01223036553710699, -0.001518868375569582, -0.004133447073400021, 0.004242861643433571, 0.015219282358884811, 0.0006933495751582086, -0.001591354375705123, 0.015072287991642952, -0.007435289677232504, 0.023999454453587532, -0.000704941397998482, 0.021059436723589897, -0.009793045930564404, -0.039008233696222305, 0.006401355843991041, -0.06825131922960281, 0.005512179806828499, -0.04181492328643799, -0.011208077892661095, -0.032868642359972, 0.0004037815087940544, -0.006318241357803345, 0.021260201930999756, -0.008010034449398518, 0.0187081191688776, -0.01516264583915472, 0.027796192094683647, 0.05356094241142273, -0.05882688984274864, -0.01473486889153719, -0.026273198425769806, 0.00946799200028181, 0.032179251313209534, -0.005998474080115557, 0.07215609401464462, 0.04787243902683258, 0.007922851480543613, 0.015820704400539398, 0.0014238300500437617, -0.02719441056251526, 0.000045456807129085064, -0.015267455019056797, -0.05486159399151802, -0.007299385964870453, 0.05803664028644562, 0.026895076036453247, -0.08326029032468796, -0.04194537177681923, -0.023282749578356743, 0.06324891746044159, 0.03077106736600399, -0.01861613430082798, -0.07476092129945755, 0.012950095348060131, -0.010989584028720856, 0.06418518722057343, -0.041864559054374695, -0.005575268529355526, -0.02080104686319828, 0.024707430973649025, -0.03853750601410866, 0.02110462263226509, -0.035493526607751846, 0.001212294795550406, -0.003911721985787153, -0.023937417194247246, 0.019769717007875443, 0.020073436200618744, 0.015105756931006908, 0.0022379369474947453, 0.019324250519275665, 0.002728026593104005, 0.02049551159143448, -0.03306903690099716, 0.008511682972311974, 0.05260663852095604, -0.056161053478717804, 0.015934014692902565, 0.024146581068634987, 0.04851652309298515, 0.004677703604102135, 0.006463487632572651, -0.005775683559477329, -0.019412057474255562, 0.04388188198208809, -0.027469947934150696, -0.016802899539470673, 0.011759967543184757, -0.005271700210869312, 0.01182510331273079, -0.03851716220378876, 0.009989527054131031, 0.013141164556145668, 0.013469940051436424, -0.03658824414014816, 0.02823673002421856, -0.019147831946611404, -0.011474468745291233, 0.021771995350718498, -0.03831527382135391, 0.020463600754737854, -0.011836051940917969, -0.007225648034363985, 0.01991179957985878, 0.03440546244382858, 0.00752243772149086, 0.03050735592842102, -0.0074670701287686825, -0.009323119185864925, -0.06998716294765472, -0.003394482657313347, 0.011468444019556046, 0.04498383402824402, 0.06988447159528732, -0.018308918923139572, -0.00805896706879139, 0.04985694959759712, -0.03498929738998413, 0.007541466969996691, -0.0006919087027199566, 0.023988591507077217, -0.03784535825252533, -0.012776348739862442, -0.049616940319538116, 0.006209881976246834, -0.006385503336787224, 0.01608555018901825, 0.05492081120610237, 0.04022040218114853, -0.009757908061146736, -0.012347707524895668, 0.005562358535826206, -0.0009405617602169514, -0.014006220735609531, -0.05846802517771721, 0.05497966334223747, -0.03469311445951462, -0.011823469772934914, 0.012981465086340904, 0.03186500072479248, -0.021739227697253227, 0.005879288073629141, 0.01742560788989067, 0.011923675425350666, 0.006915126461535692, 0.008668793365359306, 0.00120904843788594, 0.06063869222998619, 0.0001416058948962018, 0.013692964799702168, -0.004366791807115078, -0.02511228248476982, -0.027880704030394554, 0.0709022507071495, -0.02516772784292698, -0.012626470997929573, 0.0019523224327713251, 0.013622247613966465, -0.021538594737648964, 0.015560896135866642, -0.03899972885847092, -0.012628729455173016, -0.02934986539185047, -0.013316076248884201, 0.008466886356472969, -0.03635792061686516, 0.03802606463432312, -0.010450383648276329, -0.019980819895863533, -0.012842679396271706, 0.008064895868301392, -0.06766155362129211, 0.03751746192574501, 0.03427430987358093, -0.046768900007009506, -0.022528406232595444, -0.038220085203647614, -0.002131409477442503, 0.009901592507958412, -0.06044481694698334, -0.021265316754579544, -0.02226213365793228, 0.016903024166822433, -0.034133076667785645, 0.0028770812787115574, -0.020834216848015785, 0.03240969404578209, -0.015871264040470123, -0.07309577614068985, 0.024560540914535522, -0.05071501061320305, -0.009601056575775146, -0.040848832577466965, -0.007195719517767429, -0.02198072150349617, 0.006641646381467581, 0.03593909740447998, -0.016523651778697968, -0.010737019591033459, 0.014045380987226963, 0.027207879349589348, 0.04180605337023735, -0.05571857467293739, 0.023606928065419197, -0.03388308361172676, -0.004110218491405249, -0.033307433128356934, -0.012064200825989246, -0.004412796348333359, 0.0016812360845506191, -0.021486660465598106, 0.01946849189698696, -0.03273850679397583, -0.02492200769484043, 0.009586126543581486, 0.033693306148052216, 0.004577393643558025, -0.004210642538964748, 0.053617238998413086, -0.006158072035759687, -0.00619483832269907, 0.02604866400361061, -0.012201512232422829, -0.06344818323850632, -0.0266447551548481, -0.054081983864307404, -0.010643229819834232, -0.004553366452455521, -0.0037513591814786196, -0.03411548584699631, -0.03388224542140961, -0.02321922779083252, 0.047162171453237534, -0.02285977452993393, -0.011722255498170853, 0.04349803179502487, 0.027834612876176834, 0.07231896370649338, 0.013649560511112213, 0.03865223005414009, 0.004748142324388027, 0.0054567535407841206, 0.013808832503855228, 0.01758449710905552, -0.002109467750415206, -0.04020222648978233, 0.022333858534693718, 0.009264431893825531, -0.031579408794641495, 0.04836691915988922, 0.012825614772737026, 0.03687919303774834, -0.014839572831988335, -0.05856955796480179, 0.025517771020531654, -0.008642520755529404, 0.0069938404485583305, -0.0006886954652145505, -0.034641388803720474, 0.05312977358698845, 0.002386342966929078, 0.035981472581624985, -0.0022936335299164057, 0.027164144441485405, -0.045284949243068695, 0.00865100882947445, 0.04659485071897507, 0.001975269289687276, -0.0369286835193634, 0.02861139364540577, -0.009183288551867008, 0.010716919787228107, 0.046644024550914764, -0.06501907110214233, -0.002516748383641243, 0.05514904484152794, -0.011772035621106625, -0.036440350115299225, -0.05899803340435028, 0.00003645537071861327, -0.022360792383551598, -0.027667857706546783, 0.07478341460227966, -0.03356629237532616, 0.01901826448738575, -0.008495138958096504, 0.010616610758006573, 0.04930040240287781, -0.07797151058912277, 0.014238331466913223, -0.047667235136032104, -0.023494990542531013, -0.01892780512571335, 0.009384374134242535 ]
<p>I was just wondering if someone could help me understand this derivation of the probability generating function for a Poisson distribution, (I understand it, until the last step):</p> <p>$$\pi(s)=\sum^{\infty}_{i=0}e^{-\lambda}\frac{\lambda^i}{i!}s^i$$ $$\pi(s)=e^{-\lambda}\sum^{\infty}_{i=0}\frac{e^{\lambda s}}{e^{\lambda s}}\frac{(\lambda s)^i}{i!}$$ $$= e^{-\lambda}e^{\lambda s} $$</p> <p>This is a re-production from some lecture notes, but I'm not sure how it jumps from the 2nd last step to the last step?</p> <p>If someone can show me the intermediate steps I would be very grateful!! </p>
36,844
[ 0.006208909675478935, -0.02211403101682663, 0.012876234948635101, -0.021489085629582405, 0.004008338786661625, -0.005476218182593584, 0.010432619601488113, 0.002937772311270237, 0.010307615622878075, -0.029726576060056686, 0.007717559579759836, 0.0558047816157341, 0.03753618523478508, 0.007834134623408318, 0.01652943342924118, -0.005845162086188793, -0.012328717857599258, 0.012828614562749863, -0.0020707533694803715, -0.005764416418969631, 0.009928293526172638, 0.008934658952057362, -0.0193409975618124, 0.0005771337891928852, -0.035387251526117325, 0.01946270279586315, 0.01812063530087471, -0.008332055062055588, 0.005070897284895182, 0.10566805303096771, -0.052532922476530075, -0.004295618738979101, -0.006881405133754015, 0.03883206471800804, 0.017629453912377357, 0.026394285261631012, -0.04248466342687607, -0.04132382944226265, -0.006853175815194845, 0.04177013784646988, -0.046404968947172165, -0.008853374049067497, -0.011573772877454758, 0.030484411865472794, -0.03764529526233673, 0.02554352581501007, -0.03365902975201607, -0.03873750939965248, 0.02503027953207493, -0.06754633039236069, 0.04527856409549713, 0.024574825540184975, 0.05779008939862251, 0.01769629679620266, 0.006623133085668087, 0.019099680706858635, 0.05078275129199028, 0.03158288449048996, 0.011058619245886803, -0.06749727576971054, -0.01565501280128956, -0.032800015062093735, -0.016374683007597923, -0.047811802476644516, 0.0038671977818012238, -0.006260853726416826, -0.006575114093720913, -0.048775553703308105, 0.04060390219092369, -0.012061648070812225, 0.023286456242203712, 0.025583921000361443, 0.05195760726928711, -0.03825969621539116, -0.013075663708150387, -0.02176329493522644, 0.025631634518504143, -0.019236508756875992, 0.00433126138523221, 0.021222490817308426, 0.024096334353089333, 0.03380076214671135, 0.024551529437303543, 0.06970225274562836, 0.023507237434387207, -0.022787893190979958, 0.09527775645256042, 0.007645404897630215, 0.013208472169935703, 0.025212254375219345, -0.03949557617306709, 0.025120709091424942, 0.02381342276930809, -0.018594779074192047, -0.011992002837359905, 0.046036455780267715, -0.014366965740919113, 0.015662169083952904, 0.004412480164319277, 0.0009512769756838679, -0.013044862076640129, -0.024588800966739655, 0.02362954057753086, 0.053850166499614716, -0.03029821813106537, 0.004703514743596315, -0.04702039435505867, 0.013112707994878292, -0.018068011850118637, -0.04292244091629982, -0.03338401019573212, 0.03525731340050697, 0.029647979885339737, -0.005702422931790352, -0.05678588151931763, -0.033438343554735184, -0.005740610416978598, -0.008954336866736412, 0.012744426727294922, 0.04687667265534401, -0.0007547186105512083, 0.01728816144168377, 0.03757984936237335, -0.020009372383356094, -0.03664729744195938, 0.010833936743438244, 0.018119022250175476, 0.00020376160682644695, -0.037717171013355255, 0.04048836976289749, 0.002289690775796771, -0.003480122657492757, 0.03550107404589653, 0.015491068363189697, 0.039581842720508575, -0.021410120651125908, -0.07720936834812164, -0.012874620035290718, 0.02025682106614113, -0.022902896627783775, -0.0007275626412592828, -0.06090860813856125, 0.008847536519169807, 0.06078866124153137, 0.038108471781015396, 0.00602330919355154, -0.012826965190470219, -0.040814440697431564, 0.01498629804700613, 0.014187166467308998, -0.030134372413158417, -0.03500942140817642, -0.022795571014285088, -0.03621620684862137, 0.021407267078757286, -0.05418391525745392, 0.025586899369955063, 0.03440926596522331, 0.018376559019088745, -0.024715278297662735, 0.038155440241098404, 0.010348092764616013, 0.00887120608240366, -0.014226519502699375, 0.0026694205589592457, -0.03301948681473732, 0.07853525876998901, 0.03025638870894909, -0.04044686630368233, 0.03435615077614784, 0.007361136376857758, -0.0014701944310218096, -0.023123471066355705, 0.04457554966211319, 0.027261657640337944, -0.03234543278813362, -0.035117827355861664, -0.058528292924165726, 0.020011695101857185, 0.00935290101915598, -0.046303849667310715, -0.0162254199385643, -0.00785740651190281, 0.00572187639772892, 0.02308104932308197, 0.006819047499448061, -0.009282510727643967, -0.01148975919932127, -0.012851215898990631, -0.03354497253894806, -0.060852210968732834, -0.05385270714759827, 0.01921677775681019, -0.003151864977553487, -0.02565813809633255, 0.056367021054029465, 0.03524261340498924, 0.017910240218043327, -0.009152726270258427, -0.028678150847554207, -0.028187191113829613, -0.02375049889087677, 0.03686446696519852, -0.030679946765303612, 0.02113494835793972, 0.07608972489833832, 0.029634175822138786, -0.00041461613727733493, 0.03318077325820923, -0.02562299370765686, -0.026471609249711037, -0.0030724068637937307, -0.031051455065608025, 0.039036136120557785, -0.014282410964369774, 0.01693214476108551, 0.02446090430021286, 0.0109254764392972, 0.01447090320289135, 0.010520309209823608, -0.05184215307235718, 0.02352951653301716, 0.0675988644361496, 0.058052558451890945, 0.003238363889977336, 0.0021251796279102564, 0.016740987077355385, 0.0015578920720145106, 0.01771089807152748, -0.041388820856809616, -0.027438903227448463, -0.01860298030078411, 0.03965364024043083, 0.005983044393360615, -0.00047044450184330344, -0.001360397320240736, 0.04374856501817703, 0.011565407738089561, 0.028985556215047836, 0.04941904544830322, -0.0375528484582901, 0.015461046248674393, 0.030535181984305382, 0.01502832118421793, -0.000316213583573699, -0.005105496849864721, 0.043502327054739, 0.0034778236877173185, 0.007910509593784809, 0.00859362818300724, -0.051718130707740784, 0.0447496734559536, -0.014863166958093643, 0.02914653904736042, -0.01896246336400509, -0.02884904108941555, 0.028999479487538338, -0.010266633704304695, 0.013885612599551678, 0.024039078503847122, -0.0021115595009177923, 0.009981387294828892, -0.051666032522916794, -0.014600365422666073, 0.017212137579917908, -0.01809663698077202, -0.035086002200841904, -0.007567243650555611, -0.0030149980448186398, -0.05973780155181885, 0.035686034709215164, 0.005886766593903303, -0.036439087241888046, -0.051393672823905945, 0.041266728192567825, 0.029600808396935463, 0.028959771618247032, 0.01420962531119585, -0.03355696424841881, -0.07640194147825241, 0.007264613173902035, 0.008664513006806374, 0.017496386542916298, 0.028595751151442528, -0.055583395063877106, -0.000772132771089673, -0.04794829711318016, -0.052941229194402695, 0.048801299184560776, -0.003232700517401099, 0.0007518363418057561, -0.008069382980465889, -0.007752587553113699, -0.018472636118531227, 0.01801333762705326, 0.009291639551520348, -0.020101916044950485, -0.024558255448937416, -0.012180904857814312, 0.029782701283693314, 0.009815426543354988, -0.023121900856494904, 0.0348479263484478, -0.036036547273397446, -0.04433971643447876, -0.04097304493188858, 0.008130635134875774, 0.043280795216560364, -0.030221594497561455, 0.04696439579129219, -0.018692869693040848, -0.015313507989048958, 0.020345395430922508, -0.05205720290541649, -0.0662011131644249, -0.01921982131898403, 0.022222215309739113, 0.05128950625658035, -0.005325491540133953, -0.027170542627573013, 0.07356662303209305, 0.008615421131253242, 0.007325627375394106, 0.0190116036683321, 0.026836717501282692, -0.0332874096930027, -0.007281154859811068, 0.025393646210432053, -0.012364648282527924, -0.04235917702317238, 0.04800359904766083, 0.006591974291950464, 0.04245413839817047, 0.04247378557920456, -0.017850568518042564, 0.0014667758950963616, 0.03577516973018646, 0.01398764830082655, 0.02397109940648079, 0.0387873537838459, -0.011857615783810616, 0.009915952570736408, -0.008797849528491497, 0.0048887524753808975, 0.020541030913591385, -0.004597056191414595, -0.024468107149004936, 0.02813962660729885, 0.009068240411579609, -0.005764380097389221, -0.04048317298293114, 0.052332423627376556, -0.010657921433448792, -0.03539279103279114, 0.030500762164592743, 0.0034356534015387297, 0.036382127553224564, -0.04629144445061684, 0.016596483066678047, 0.036431934684515, 0.044285934418439865, -0.046361472457647324, -0.06292575597763062, -0.021701425313949585, -0.008187253959476948, 0.004939979407936335, -0.0018537892028689384, -0.031133020296692848, 0.023131238296628, 0.042470768094062805, 0.020731685683131218, -0.032798927277326584, -0.030724376440048218, -0.011125914752483368, -0.02170114777982235, -0.0020129599142819643, -0.0034451119136065245, 0.04861501231789589, -0.0007812569965608418, 0.06891617923974991, 0.034171100705862045, 0.020999617874622345, -0.004296143539249897, 0.03188800811767578, -0.08590151369571686, 0.0290733240544796, -0.00036490196362137794, -0.017933782190084457, -0.02225739136338234, 0.009115001186728477, 0.03562958538532257, -0.03054620511829853, -0.009327484294772148, -0.0024689696729183197, -0.002313917735591531, -0.02878386341035366, 0.018958499655127525, -0.041156236082315445, -0.007715107873082161, -0.008269336074590683, -0.0012382023269310594, 0.017759548500180244, 0.016290245577692986, 0.017331402748823166, 0.03938421607017517, -0.010904397815465927, 0.005341606680303812, 0.005018556956201792, 0.010392503812909126, 0.009106389246881008, 0.0034771456848829985, 0.04908892139792442, 0.02298332192003727, -0.0015916000120341778, 0.008238802663981915, -0.005043449811637402, 0.06769119948148727, 0.07062380015850067, -0.019902819767594337, 0.012027028948068619, -0.06617026776075363, -0.028569107875227928, -0.003067514393478632, 0.04601867124438286, 0.01160306017845869, 0.006964602041989565, 0.04911935329437256, 0.017598263919353485, -0.04690944775938988, 0.04265391081571579, 0.035475701093673706, -0.01788434013724327, -0.02724413387477398, -0.03185778483748436, 0.01178419217467308, -0.038907162845134735, 0.00802519265562296, 0.0018305149860680103, -0.0022259128745645285, -0.03335000202059746, 0.029294095933437347, 0.0443430058658123, -0.055416181683540344, -0.01568925566971302, -0.024163171648979187, -0.03725949302315712, 0.05623304843902588, -0.008897894062101841, -0.013991957530379295, 0.03206165134906769, 0.020246339961886406, 0.0035292955581098795, 0.02468365617096424, -0.009408026933670044, -0.02969495579600334, -0.03012988716363907, 0.02606479451060295, 0.03505333885550499, -0.025037484243512154, 0.016656165942549706, -0.06429582834243774, -0.03510923683643341, 0.034755416214466095, -0.026437345892190933, 0.04183191806077957, -0.018390923738479614, -0.016384346410632133, -0.004071560688316822, -0.03538929671049118, -0.05038313940167427, 0.04077783599495888, -0.01972041465342045, 0.03050624392926693, -0.03949238359928131, 0.006776101887226105, -0.06823065876960754, -0.007150544319301844, 0.023151572793722153, 0.06797768920660019, 0.016587676480412483, -0.027974069118499756, -0.012274951674044132, 0.029520530253648758, 0.012387096881866455, -0.059870991855859756, -0.003208448411896825, -0.0069672176614403725, -0.00860194768756628, 0.03773224726319313, -0.058168865740299225, -0.029900861904025078, -0.01077495701611042, 0.03345685452222824, -0.02012570947408676, -0.0035478128120303154, -0.010509878396987915, 0.034972596913576126, 0.02089538797736168, -0.033521197736263275, 0.06921332329511642, 0.033801380544900894, -0.04255078732967377, 0.03248259425163269, -0.038735922425985336, 0.023214587941765785, -0.003700795117765665, -0.01615150086581707, -0.0677337795495987, 0.028971122577786446, -0.03250834718346596, 0.002940480364486575, -0.015234332531690598, 0.00955523457378149, -0.023934805765748024, -0.024648472666740417, 0.015396959148347378, 0.03754224628210068, 0.0018539634766057134, 0.014040370471775532, 0.008972365409135818, 0.03939018025994301, 0.0387972928583622, -0.023396318778395653, 0.00668682437390089, 0.011155681684613228, 0.01964229717850685, -0.020818404853343964, 0.011318057775497437, 0.026780592277646065, -0.011497163213789463, -0.0063801235519349575, 0.052638940513134, -0.051687922328710556, 0.0174409132450819, -0.03684143349528313, -0.006999174132943153, 0.010776220820844173, -0.04151926934719086, -0.04495564103126526, -0.02951708808541298, -0.030238278210163116, 0.03925340995192528, -0.03139941021800041, 0.01442453358322382, 0.012213081121444702, -0.03977753221988678, -0.09715456515550613, -0.0258527509868145, 0.02501644380390644, 0.0042831776663661, -0.04937208816409111, -0.04077543690800667, -0.028443777933716774, -0.018950600177049637, -0.02150072529911995, -0.0002355234610149637, 0.00970503780990839, -0.027191363275051117, -0.00044051429722458124, 0.0060152350924909115, -0.011888738721609116, 0.08386272937059402, -0.005857979413121939, -0.005867478437721729, 0.027146626263856888, -0.029383279383182526, -0.02016391232609749, 0.030086718499660492, 0.059397920966148376, -0.005771266296505928, -0.03050808422267437, 0.023723924532532692, 0.02252831682562828, -0.022011224180459976, -0.031461816281080246, -0.04143693298101425, -0.0026171531062573195, 0.030863089486956596, 0.05378555506467819, -0.011530083604156971, -0.01262646447867155, 0.017306633293628693, 0.040674466639757156, -0.011149902828037739, -0.01703869365155697, -0.026937857270240784, -0.009359342977404594, 0.025762196630239487, -0.012758070603013039, 0.09199400991201401, 0.035103388130664825, 0.04676396772265434, -0.015064550563693047, 0.015293351374566555, 0.04412283003330231, 0.009032119065523148, 0.03956226259469986, 0.0044212061911821365, -0.0036946383770555258, 0.04235966131091118, -0.002063724212348461, -0.00022527181135956198, 0.015330778434872627, -0.0921177789568901, 0.012699575163424015, 0.045025784522295, -0.022111432626843452, 0.034279223531484604, 0.028382452204823494, 0.013322771526873112, -0.005783016327768564, -0.016895348206162453, -0.039855655282735825, -0.03401586785912514, -0.006422969978302717, 0.010608519427478313, -0.04343881085515022, 0.029401401057839394, 0.050240274518728256, 0.038309238851070404, -0.0006133623537607491, 0.051856908947229385, 0.00763743557035923, -0.0008935635560192168, 0.02491302788257599, 0.0065943957306444645, -0.021741770207881927, 0.017950836569070816, -0.02240697480738163, 0.03752780333161354, 0.00867478922009468, -0.043458811938762665, 0.056445781141519547, 0.022142138332128525, -0.004010912496596575, -0.03533335402607918, -0.008521459065377712, -0.006779747549444437, 0.035708315670490265, 0.03038685955107212, -0.016145989298820496, 0.019878601655364037, 0.02571106143295765, 0.018178753554821014, 0.03050723858177662, 0.034853290766477585, -0.010482477955520153, -0.038815680891275406, -0.024671943858265877, -0.02981342189013958, -0.05346785485744476, 0.030268577858805656, -0.011476005427539349, -0.024885209277272224, -0.017578700557351112, -0.005067000165581703, 0.010510174557566643, 0.023552246391773224, 0.027144337072968483, -0.027814051136374474, 0.0997331440448761, 0.008019098080694675, 0.00528742466121912, 0.0062082866206765175, 0.005286406725645065, 0.10801813751459122, 0.03980184718966484, -0.010960282757878304, -0.06855346262454987, -0.0068972911685705185, -0.00515734264627099, 0.0018351107137277722, -0.016713518649339676, 0.022876916453242302, 0.020859956741333008, 0.0064728399738669395, 0.04671508073806763, 0.0928320661187172, -0.02658107690513134, -0.0027622671332210302, 0.046917930245399475, -0.027071276679635048, -0.046684734523296356, -0.026184096932411194, 0.021547000855207443, -0.0019792011007666588, 0.019575681537389755, -0.06872227042913437, 0.009172488003969193, -0.006744592450559139, 0.012225264683365822, -0.03846094384789467, -0.0037432797253131866, -0.027641896158456802, 0.021817779168486595, -0.03977733105421066, -0.03056248463690281, 0.028354406356811523, -0.0013761224690824747, 0.012686637230217457, -0.006321059539914131, -0.0056833866983652115, -0.028855115175247192, 0.04065445810556412, 0.06302262097597122, 0.037095166742801666, -0.006297121290117502, 0.03993432968854904, 0.007339217700064182, -0.04018783941864967, -0.03900083526968956, -0.03444650396704674, 0.05151741951704025, -0.01363533828407526, 0.02387220785021782, -0.029715703800320625, -0.027911920100450516, 0.01971546746790409, -0.02619262784719467, 0.0061604781076312065, -0.02005508728325367, 0.04082314670085907, -0.059472717344760895, -0.04232766479253769, -0.04211405664682388, -0.00443150894716382, 0.01865171082317829, 0.043372415006160736, 0.032102834433317184, -0.03196275234222412, -0.03566901013255119, -0.038966696709394455, 0.015215015038847923, -0.013571832329034805, -0.012424154207110405, -0.0006541160983033478, -0.03722282871603966, -0.04030316695570946, 0.0036208685487508774, -0.021385516971349716, -0.02541244588792324, 0.046945977956056595, -0.028034726157784462, -0.00793919526040554, -0.020974110811948776, -0.0510488860309124, 0.014221496880054474, -0.03928621485829353, -0.00956458505243063, -0.010470256209373474, -0.03787429258227348, 0.019627775996923447, 0.07007899880409241, -0.028291240334510803, 0.024944687262177467, 0.01084574218839407, 0.03847907856106758, 0.021673234179615974, -0.048938896507024765, 0.003604522906243801, 0.014874765649437904, -0.009831949137151241, -0.0032938981894403696, -0.03923698887228966, 0.011883781291544437, 0.02845996990799904, 0.04042923077940941, -0.0024120190646499395, 0.005454850848764181, -0.036108940839767456, 0.008531809784471989, -0.006001458037644625, -0.017806503921747208, -0.009218517690896988, 0.020497534424066544, -0.004049673676490784, -0.028040599077939987, -0.004272373393177986, 0.000822243804577738, -0.004064386710524559, 0.010435962118208408, 0.010735402815043926, -0.05219282954931259, -0.024703113362193108, -0.022766755893826485, 0.002437375020235777, -0.006567956414073706, -0.007606904488056898, -0.03909510746598244, 0.04051356762647629, 0.005136752035468817, -0.008077709935605526, -0.01662958413362503, 0.01751411147415638, -0.004674730822443962, -0.022778412327170372, 0.020751139149069786, 0.009234488010406494, 0.014489746652543545, -0.017711443826556206, 0.03597969189286232, -0.023553818464279175, 0.030732447281479836, 0.002694583497941494, 0.0016523741651326418, 0.04985709488391876, -0.034853383898735046, -0.05930835008621216, 0.03232336416840553, 0.059878088533878326, 0.05216486006975174, 0.036314863711595535, -0.019453756511211395, -0.02782060019671917, 0.016855482012033463, 0.016728689894080162, -0.03321648761630058, -0.025629311800003052, 0.002684573642909527, 0.011892045848071575, 0.01462639681994915, -0.008408755995333195, -0.007748874835669994, 0.002244063187390566, 0.008665132336318493, 0.014390790835022926, -0.04076288640499115, 0.0023186225444078445, 0.007733939681202173, -0.018987806513905525, -0.00530640734359622, 0.037584032863378525, -0.012480145320296288, 0.012783500365912914, 0.07641330361366272, -0.028364431113004684, 0.03100067563354969, -0.03951923921704292, 0.006371091119945049, -0.04500601440668106, 0.0009278524667024612, -0.035183366388082504, -0.026366963982582092, 0.014507884159684181, -0.06248248368501663, -0.026350323110818863, 0.01745975762605667, -0.011115776374936104, 0.01162757258862257, -0.017289210110902786, 0.009804891422390938, -0.034061405807733536, -0.0018366469303146005, 0.00006808165198890492, 0.05676279589533806, 0.04647186025977135, 0.027881493791937828, 0.03139723464846611, -0.0013010107213631272, 0.007055580150336027, -0.009640795178711414, -0.018509630113840103, 0.06722401827573776, 0.002616504207253456, -0.0634184330701828, 0.0659041702747345, -0.011051568202674389, -0.012135307304561138, 0.01995728351175785, -0.0024621838238090277, -0.02452431432902813, -0.011354419402778149, 0.012024697847664356, 0.008889184333384037, 0.043003492057323456, -0.0013119764626026154, 0.0027962697204202414, 0.023095542564988136, 0.02900809794664383, 0.02497345209121704, 0.026592900976538658, -0.03667185828089714, -0.018631817772984505, 0.058567166328430176, -0.05147450789809227, -0.04697004705667496, 0.057032499462366104, 0.005573616363108158, -0.020566457882523537, 0.01861002668738365, -0.014010369777679443, 0.029389815405011177, -0.021094229072332382, 0.06277035176753998, -0.06365488469600677, -0.03232915326952934, 0.0356382355093956, 0.019425896927714348, -0.028746768832206726, 0.006503997836261988, -0.0006188463303260505, -0.062435463070869446, 0.013305947184562683, 0.013933793641626835, -0.012763479724526405, -0.04198343679308891, 0.014771958813071251, -0.003919998649507761, 0.009341033175587654, 0.014499254524707794, -0.012525256723165512, -0.05392976850271225, 0.021382424980401993, 0.009529937990009785, 0.02527177706360817, 0.002691797213628888, -0.03257186338305473, 0.01869412697851658, -0.06321141123771667, 0.012100149877369404, 0.00541716581210494, -0.03754613175988197, -0.061262842267751694, -0.03578012436628342, 0.010246907360851765, 0.010609283111989498, 0.04344790801405907, -0.0024907018523663282, -0.050022583454847336, 0.012055974453687668, 0.03353510797023773, 0.025226447731256485, -0.040699198842048645, -0.011940096504986286, -0.011118493042886257, -0.03677462786436081, -0.03163236379623413, 0.007026258390396833, -0.024195220321416855, 0.01768716610968113, -0.011146768927574158, -0.025568334385752678, 0.0070676724426448345, -0.03475497290492058, -0.05076392740011215, 0.02310877852141857, 0.012039653025567532, -0.026082487776875496, 0.047911521047353745, -0.014152279123663902, -0.002295650541782379, 0.029556527733802795, -0.01155729778110981, -0.04438164830207825, 0.03019525855779648, -0.02687079831957817, -0.02343359775841236, 0.0006246912525966763, 0.011269220151007175, 0.01101964246481657, -0.032741840928792953, 0.021596169099211693, -0.001604264136403799, -0.027072837576270103, -0.013834117911756039, 0.07270529866218567, -0.0071515971794724464, 0.039007723331451416, 0.008583171293139458, -0.019496077671647072, 0.013961562886834145, -0.0033962600864470005, 0.017527936026453972, 0.04384562373161316, 0.011126247234642506, -0.02768521197140217, 0.007026846054941416, 0.011626004241406918, -0.018476296216249466, 0.03715518116950989, 0.0033395783975720406, 0.04139937087893486, -0.03532591834664345, 0.01920001395046711, -0.001967090182006359, -0.021718105301260948, 0.03230596333742142, 0.045573022216558456, -0.027655966579914093, 0.09671810269355774, 0.004114032723009586, 0.07244939357042313, 0.01475809421390295, 0.005030520725995302, -0.040324922651052475, -0.016406824812293053, 0.017511889338493347, 0.06358195841312408, -0.01879243552684784, 0.0020249292720109224, -0.020090095698833466, -0.021205158904194832, 0.0363854244351387, -0.032619498670101166, 0.032400306314229965, 0.04816162958741188, -0.006840703077614307, -0.03708741068840027, -0.04653974249958992, 0.03064018115401268, -0.02296867035329342, 0.046365685760974884, 0.036953702569007874, 0.009507535956799984, 0.015664521604776382, 0.011114003136754036, -0.0009132699924521148, 0.046447303146123886, -0.04585207626223564, 0.0022506206296384335, -0.04617545008659363, 0.019784247502684593, -0.013596491888165474, -0.021397950127720833 ]
<p>I have a cycle that I filtered out from an original series using a Baxter deterministic filter. However, the cycle plot still has some noise and I would like it to be more determinisitc and follow a perfect sinosiod. I can run a trig-regression of the cycle on a $\sin(2\pi\cdot\text{index}/12)$ but I wouldn't know how to test for the trig-variables significance as the model is plaqued by auto-correlation. I can add AR terms but I am trying to find the perfect sine wave to fit the cycle without have to constantly guess its periodicity. Does anyone have a method for determining the best trig function variable without the constant trial and error? </p> <p>The cycle I have looks very similar to this one:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ibOUm.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>which has a natural cyclyical pattern but I want to model it to more like this:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hCZCZ.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Anyone comments would be highly appreciated.</p>
36,845
[ 0.01454677153378725, -0.010935221798717976, 0.017078228294849396, 0.002257142448797822, 0.0665564090013504, -0.03164591267704964, 0.00957870576530695, -0.02881026268005371, 0.021792493760585785, -0.04170799255371094, 0.026970434933900833, 0.03374076262116432, 0.0554312989115715, 0.06595400720834732, -0.0013594655320048332, -0.033978208899497986, -0.00760621577501297, -0.015770109370350838, -0.025699997320771217, -0.021881362423300743, -0.01785103976726532, -0.0016587557038292289, 0.002374595496803522, 0.015610195696353912, -0.022799037396907806, 0.0301596038043499, 0.05373523011803627, -0.01082900632172823, 0.0010970216244459152, 0.038479965180158615, -0.039912011474370956, -0.04189910739660263, 0.015566816553473473, 0.06273549050092697, 0.027054546400904655, 0.008777860552072525, -0.020892543718218803, -0.018017934635281563, -0.0001536396739538759, 0.025311285629868507, -0.06448761373758316, 0.006092181894928217, -0.01951361633837223, 0.03844242915511131, -0.008831366896629333, 0.015362082980573177, 0.029464447870850563, -0.0036716361064463854, 0.06752185523509979, -0.029577309265732765, 0.09593647718429565, 0.008142701350152493, 0.025605808943510056, -0.0008436315110884607, 0.006666930858045816, -0.05420603230595589, 0.05003605782985687, 0.05289828032255173, -0.04169872775673866, -0.03924223408102989, -0.008642866276204586, -0.024694068357348442, -0.011137695983052254, -0.005911028478294611, -0.04631563648581505, 0.011516561731696129, -0.004463865887373686, -0.054301559925079346, 0.01410308014601469, 0.025343656539916992, 0.00830139685422182, -0.011617613025009632, 0.023372268304228783, -0.027190903201699257, -0.02409781701862812, -0.03387228399515152, -0.010046599432826042, 0.03984640911221504, 0.01887124590575695, 0.021052422001957893, -0.012665693648159504, -0.002313723089173436, -0.006007686723023653, 0.07607968151569366, 0.003303902456536889, -0.003917229827493429, 0.06361044198274612, -0.01634806953370571, 0.006940485443919897, 0.025228753685951233, -0.013480616733431816, 0.006568684708327055, 0.0816941037774086, 0.015164813958108425, -0.04017723351716995, 0.0411987267434597, 0.006164486985653639, 0.03251239284873009, 0.007215246092528105, -0.02384624071419239, -0.029785340651869774, -0.028938140720129013, -0.015380257740616798, 0.07051558792591095, 0.01782519929111004, 0.02630322054028511, -0.002560078166425228, 0.008736344054341316, -0.010376027785241604, -0.028979916125535965, -0.01682208850979805, 0.006666946224868298, 0.005372375715523958, 0.010441545397043228, -0.016128933057188988, 0.017236091196537018, -0.018596725538372993, -0.04223255813121796, 0.019926531240344048, 0.0668535903096199, 0.03479224443435669, -0.014795880764722824, 0.017957238480448723, -0.031738586723804474, -0.041510991752147675, 0.009925983846187592, 0.0015340549871325493, -0.006318722385913134, -0.01703565940260887, 0.01219667587429285, 0.028741050511598587, -0.016631662845611572, 0.02340104430913925, -0.003220043843612075, 0.032116591930389404, 0.000542036781553179, -0.06215353682637215, -0.0458078570663929, 0.056532472372055054, -0.011624539270997047, 0.008328888565301895, -0.055966880172491074, 0.014752636663615704, 0.03354721888899803, 0.08603201806545258, -0.012333396822214127, -0.01716984622180462, 0.02706397883594036, 0.028714237734675407, 0.013750884681940079, 0.0034581648651510477, -0.009355888701975346, -0.004749084357172251, -0.06495014578104019, -0.040546417236328125, -0.021913137286901474, 0.01237869169563055, 0.024839259684085846, -0.01324374694377184, -0.010639461688697338, 0.05787503346800804, 0.009079737588763237, -0.0385286919772625, -0.0017206110060214996, 0.021058108657598495, -0.05666090175509453, 0.0577690526843071, 0.005114860832691193, -0.000735013687517494, -0.02577732503414154, 0.0024494421668350697, 0.061041198670864105, 0.036884892731904984, 0.03479486703872681, 0.04457968845963478, -0.03767428919672966, 0.01218195166438818, 0.0168905146420002, 0.034550637006759644, 0.012949004769325256, 0.0023877371568232775, -0.03848392143845558, -0.020643701776862144, 0.0018467605113983154, 0.007040069904178381, 0.041308462619781494, -0.03227952867746353, -0.013316905125975609, 0.0718206837773323, -0.05380998179316521, -0.01451660506427288, -0.017823124304413795, -0.009844563901424408, -0.022238388657569885, -0.015442349016666412, 0.004761213902384043, -0.0038748832885175943, 0.009209209121763706, 0.0066935536451637745, -0.004647504538297653, -0.002913140691816807, 0.04165653511881828, 0.04553227126598358, 0.005435866303741932, 0.05828661099076271, 0.020443810150027275, 0.03075379878282547, 0.016357483342289925, 0.04292264208197594, -0.022428492084145546, -0.012441890314221382, -0.010829892009496689, -0.05773431435227394, -0.0007939486531540751, -0.03282742202281952, 0.00384168210439384, 0.029164951294660568, -0.04975283145904541, 0.018261155113577843, 0.02809131145477295, -0.0034678399097174406, 0.05655558407306671, 0.059070661664009094, 0.0228005088865757, 0.027242721989750862, 0.02945879101753235, 0.0021338523365557194, 0.03831079602241516, -0.019263839349150658, -0.04574061557650566, -0.03630678728222847, 0.01583552174270153, 0.06147703528404236, 0.016075730323791504, -0.03832466900348663, -0.01004830189049244, 0.07055045664310455, 0.005865663755685091, 0.05635460466146469, 0.02652025781571865, 0.03386835381388664, -0.0025293747894465923, 0.007432297337800264, 0.054855093359947205, -0.013762547634541988, -0.020136665552854538, 0.048928383737802505, 0.002254601800814271, 0.03472414240241051, -0.03160475939512253, -0.035333048552274704, 0.0392577089369297, -0.007095731794834137, 0.027444107457995415, -0.01437611784785986, -0.010694506578147411, 0.05781098082661629, -0.02066318690776825, -0.01988370716571808, 0.020906725898385048, -0.011615648865699768, -0.009903906844556332, -0.010224785655736923, 0.021819619461894035, -0.0021467460319399834, 0.03249390795826912, -0.013221172615885735, -0.026233214884996414, 0.024319147691130638, -0.025096915662288666, 0.019257044419646263, -0.04830457270145416, -0.015932930633425713, -0.024388566613197327, -0.00003718996958923526, 0.045104216784238815, 0.07584820687770844, -0.024100888520479202, -0.01916573755443096, -0.015787828713655472, -0.028429191559553146, 0.01684790849685669, 0.019945183768868446, 0.026479747146368027, -0.05089472606778145, -0.037607427686452866, -0.03343387320637703, 0.02335922047495842, 0.023545311763882637, -0.005595515947788954, 0.009288051165640354, 0.0038261779118329287, -0.025389447808265686, -0.05855540931224823, -0.00045540244900621474, -0.06831352412700653, -0.0038809950929135084, -0.03689016029238701, -0.05388876050710678, 0.04473342001438141, 0.025923319160938263, -0.06360562145709991, 0.0334840752184391, -0.021864905953407288, 0.032357655465602875, 0.008879169821739197, 0.014166555367410183, 0.01319852378219366, -0.036682918667793274, 0.04265469312667847, 0.01314530149102211, -0.007061353884637356, 0.02997143194079399, -0.061926182359457016, -0.029438428580760956, 0.022314568981528282, -0.018240079283714294, 0.024593310430645943, 0.02289850451052189, -0.020699502900242805, 0.10794952511787415, 0.06417665630578995, -0.03399213030934334, -0.021990034729242325, 0.0180291049182415, -0.03998792916536331, -0.061110686510801315, 0.0020003714598715305, 0.04146075248718262, 0.017041414976119995, 0.022570839151740074, -0.03669806942343712, 0.00948102306574583, 0.030902322381734848, 0.006123646628111601, -0.0023634671233594418, 0.05280959978699684, -0.01914205029606819, 0.00011636706767603755, 0.05013760179281235, 0.024314312264323235, -0.0208078995347023, 0.014497676864266396, -0.005631511565297842, -0.011500170454382896, 0.03045349195599556, -0.052527640014886856, -0.009071717038750648, 0.0011899658711627126, -0.019686583429574966, -0.02268453687429428, -0.01286586094647646, 0.010913359001278877, -0.011146418750286102, -0.048756036907434464, 0.03957255929708481, 0.03154820576310158, 0.040908850729465485, 0.03871145844459534, 0.037662968039512634, 0.009190409444272518, 0.007324978243559599, -0.0033031979110091925, -0.04183724895119667, -0.018711412325501442, 0.05075123906135559, -0.0486077144742012, -0.020071104168891907, 0.03630566969513893, -0.0022572875022888184, 0.05823477730154991, 0.0036323091480880976, -0.06965883821249008, 0.0064230309799313545, -0.0774398148059845, -0.03171267360448837, -0.04474429041147232, 0.06924530863761902, 0.019613416865468025, 0.027638034895062447, 0.020025456324219704, 0.00017408840358257294, 0.009165633469820023, 0.034265533089637756, -0.0703689232468605, 0.05202145501971245, 0.008352845907211304, -0.0022597997449338436, -0.0009283639956265688, 0.002619087230414152, 0.026400107890367508, -0.028602031990885735, 0.004174341447651386, -0.007534559350460768, -0.029191233217716217, -0.02200479991734028, -0.008130785077810287, -0.0013582132523879409, 0.006721325684338808, -0.035901494324207306, 0.04262329265475273, 0.02036251500248909, -0.0597478412091732, 0.03984467685222626, 0.021996252238750458, -0.0033149635419249535, -0.0022731127683073282, -0.017596550285816193, 0.026132766157388687, 0.015401317737996578, 0.01886250078678131, 0.03044380061328411, 0.018272729590535164, -0.01628347672522068, -0.005712471902370453, 0.021965468302369118, 0.021036997437477112, 0.04362419992685318, 0.018441611900925636, -0.016559036448597908, -0.037824440747499466, -0.012563046999275684, 0.049850426614284515, 0.009823909029364586, 0.018610594794154167, 0.011163122951984406, 0.05120166763663292, -0.006865090224891901, -0.059009432792663574, 0.039489246904850006, 0.025988657027482986, 0.018938330933451653, 0.015629351139068604, -0.018018877133727074, -0.02931680902838707, 0.021580494940280914, 0.01990620233118534, 0.019811606034636497, 0.01514790765941143, -0.015388121828436852, -0.036311060190200806, 0.016994699835777283, 0.026830116286873817, -0.004566961899399757, 0.012884884141385555, 0.007068598177284002, 0.07509435713291168, -0.015464418567717075, -0.027508845552802086, 0.0008280578767880797, 0.014490385539829731, 0.036037277430295944, 0.020501095801591873, -0.02719299867749214, -0.09772462397813797, -0.03673887997865677, 0.03490389883518219, 0.04948077350854874, -0.0229052621871233, -0.01499532163143158, -0.07734236121177673, -0.049380991607904434, 0.026652883738279343, -0.02614661678671837, 0.0245652012526989, -0.019024480134248734, 0.017812829464673996, -0.027731016278266907, -0.03895971551537514, -0.019627394154667854, 0.008730168454349041, -0.0027590147219598293, 0.0005496881203725934, -0.03350089490413666, -0.043519288301467896, -0.027110042050480843, 0.03460664674639702, -0.009784331545233727, 0.049033720046281815, -0.012806505896151066, -0.01861787773668766, 0.009319540113210678, -0.007929820567369461, 0.0016952853184193373, -0.03849436715245247, 0.006220465991646051, 0.003208918496966362, -0.00955115258693695, 0.0253461841493845, -0.017681878060102463, -0.035036224871873856, -0.037462055683135986, 0.011959211900830269, 0.0020134628284722567, 0.021768581122159958, -0.03681650385260582, 0.04248206689953804, 0.013290423899888992, -0.014314154163002968, 0.03191795572638512, 0.07692914456129074, -0.008123915642499924, -0.025872787460684776, -0.013886790722608566, 0.01246209628880024, -0.023914124816656113, 0.02284247614443302, -0.04337584972381592, -0.012220902368426323, -0.030145717784762383, 0.005805407650768757, -0.008569209836423397, 0.05514293536543846, -0.014762716367840767, 0.003291469067335129, 0.05092545971274376, 0.023739848285913467, -0.0002514590451028198, 0.011681434698402882, 0.017177339643239975, 0.0021528436336666346, -0.0014531298074871302, -0.019592827185988426, -0.0028045326471328735, -0.0256432443857193, 0.019620632752776146, 0.02012242190539837, -0.021823439747095108, 0.05500156804919243, -0.051992740482091904, 0.018495813012123108, -0.008499442599713802, -0.03358598053455353, 0.05442181974649429, -0.017428232356905937, 0.03138226270675659, -0.01102717500180006, -0.04518492892384529, 0.003618332790210843, -0.012750668451189995, -0.03282545879483223, 0.03672536090016365, -0.027170808985829353, 0.02483084239065647, -0.01530857291072607, 0.01490345411002636, -0.04830097034573555, -0.07103531062602997, 0.03927583247423172, -0.013329826295375824, -0.00528223579749465, -0.02039932645857334, 0.0267241932451725, -0.018481265753507614, 0.0060704778879880905, 0.020006200298666954, -0.005011260975152254, -0.02977805957198143, -0.02112516388297081, 0.007029969710856676, 0.034434571862220764, 0.0864502415060997, 0.023634273558855057, -0.033483512699604034, 0.0023149102926254272, -0.03336113318800926, -0.022786758840084076, 0.016998978331685066, 0.0017921471735462546, -0.04637329652905464, -0.006653319112956524, -0.01879456825554371, -0.00022746033209841698, 0.05708429217338562, -0.03609465807676315, -0.0018706328701227903, -0.007846486754715443, 0.008320213295519352, 0.048168156296014786, -0.010779769159853458, -0.03308812528848648, -0.01715577021241188, 0.024017687886953354, -0.015108629129827023, -0.0196848101913929, -0.03182598948478699, -0.057087600231170654, -0.004265856929123402, 0.02470044232904911, -0.03338860720396042, -0.00875937007367611, 0.013650046661496162, 0.017640534788370132, -0.028720673173666, -0.013107015751302242, -0.01812754198908806, 0.0003392373910173774, 0.009976968169212341, 0.04821298271417618, 0.033967025578022, 0.0036217637825757265, -0.029758084565401077, -0.03850828483700752, -0.06282336264848709, 0.001053837826475501, 0.055747173726558685, -0.037203576415777206, 0.04015379026532173, -0.016116419807076454, 0.0046415189281105995, -0.042505521327257156, 0.004046332556754351, -0.015692835673689842, -0.0007527507259510458, -0.006245802156627178, 0.06446212530136108, -0.008576964028179646, 0.02091093920171261, -0.013641116209328175, 0.012094804085791111, 0.026350876316428185, 0.05140888690948486, 0.019180361181497574, 0.043022073805332184, 0.01865598000586033, -0.024968693032860756, -0.022401250898838043, -0.018147872760891914, -0.032785359770059586, 0.05734293907880783, 0.004806214012205601, -0.002521305112168193, 0.03153010085225105, 0.047963015735149384, -0.014423002488911152, -0.02620762772858143, -0.002063370542600751, -0.04983685910701752, -0.008742114529013634, 0.07155296206474304, 0.0033630672842264175, 0.023929547518491745, 0.026716696098446846, 0.04252634197473526, 0.002969474531710148, 0.05936480313539505, -0.028322769328951836, -0.06733112782239914, 0.030439529567956924, -0.000012918005268147681, -0.023102732375264168, 0.043812096118927, -0.0013501220382750034, -0.014500996097922325, 0.006286048796027899, -0.007171278819441795, 0.007033457979559898, 0.035938605666160583, 0.016525346785783768, -0.00003551908230292611, 0.07710288465023041, -0.034389618784189224, 0.021146593615412712, -0.004002452827990055, -0.0031958732288330793, 0.11620496213436127, 0.04656711220741272, 0.005625331774353981, -0.06122499331831932, -0.0003853784000966698, -0.01714354008436203, -0.007538676727563143, -0.020875338464975357, 0.032476168125867844, 0.02858152613043785, -0.0632890909910202, 0.02767597883939743, 0.018159441649913788, -0.0071027823723852634, -0.011279711499810219, 0.04628494381904602, -0.01731335185468197, -0.012023404240608215, -0.019527003169059753, 0.04564564675092697, 0.03579697757959366, -0.0004710437497124076, -0.03103957325220108, 0.020721804350614548, -0.03143712878227234, -0.052311647683382034, -0.03643745183944702, -0.033219195902347565, -0.018035296350717545, 0.006350564770400524, 0.0008959273691289127, 0.051784712821245193, 0.016909319907426834, -0.00760857667773962, 0.0142219802364707, 0.007267586886882782, 0.0030836244113743305, -0.008212837390601635, 0.021923791617155075, 0.046151477843523026, -0.002530681900680065, 0.019425757229328156, 0.020917298272252083, 0.003696029307320714, -0.03319616988301277, -0.027288326993584633, -0.04382610321044922, 0.02842189371585846, -0.006392103619873524, -0.0709075853228569, -0.02104097232222557, -0.0022578928619623184, -0.003875630907714367, -0.033840909600257874, -0.019400309771299362, -0.010930762626230717, 0.003955489955842495, -0.04731085151433945, -0.06485886871814728, 0.0003820718848146498, -0.004198912996798754, 0.022753393277525902, 0.05029759183526039, 0.03678760305047035, -0.046370647847652435, -0.024073680862784386, 0.005165599752217531, 0.07737245410680771, 0.025096241384744644, -0.023317579180002213, 0.039118241518735886, -0.02339235134422779, -0.03626679256558418, 0.0002524897863622755, 0.01504491176456213, 0.011571518145501614, 0.07554267346858978, 0.0036606115754693747, -0.014148756861686707, -0.018801983445882797, -0.016688114032149315, 0.0010541388764977455, -0.032565757632255554, 0.022242669016122818, -0.023201078176498413, -0.03599745035171509, 0.0540417805314064, 0.024050747975707054, -0.00478509021922946, 0.02261631190776825, 0.010314259678125381, 0.04670819640159607, 0.053034063428640366, -0.076388418674469, 0.0011789847631007433, -0.011569629423320293, -0.010880504734814167, -0.0014320282498374581, 0.00420297309756279, 0.07630568742752075, 0.05678153410553932, -0.007469339296221733, -0.02689451351761818, 0.05677739158272743, -0.01483323983848095, -0.0033105059992522, -0.023157253861427307, -0.08168192207813263, 0.01885395310819149, -0.019950509071350098, 0.014674496836960316, -0.0416681133210659, -0.023718493059277534, -0.027923045679926872, -0.004296047147363424, -0.01104371715337038, -0.018093952909111977, -0.04921930283308029, 0.05737777799367905, -0.009501966647803783, -0.023441269993782043, -0.0666990652680397, 0.004769694991409779, -0.014771726913750172, 0.006241852417588234, -0.0038511641323566437, 0.010348948650062084, -0.000630651309620589, 0.015595275908708572, 0.009809060022234917, -0.025172576308250427, 0.03592362999916077, 0.01834654062986374, 0.017097219824790955, -0.0037975667510181665, -0.00527334725484252, -0.024387631565332413, 0.041668862104415894, -0.031322330236434937, -0.017465822398662567, 0.003282740479335189, -0.0247653778642416, 0.002678618999198079, -0.004942150320857763, -0.057922761887311935, -0.000440361414803192, 0.01887275092303753, -0.03977988660335541, 0.02624174952507019, 0.005237211473286152, 0.023221109062433243, -0.002031398005783558, 0.010732361115515232, 0.029267773032188416, 0.004926440771669149, 0.002500136848539114, -0.0017730557592585683, -0.021707158535718918, 0.027455784380435944, 0.009297794662415981, 0.047384459525346756, 0.052211061120033264, -0.01130082830786705, -0.005404964089393616, -0.04579228535294533, -0.024403858929872513, 0.0046649896539747715, 0.011394122615456581, -0.01599222421646118, -0.011548961512744427, -0.017563220113515854, 0.022323470562696457, -0.01578792743384838, -0.015500165522098541, -0.04200742766261101, 0.00006236670014914125, 0.007284954655915499, -0.01098027266561985, 0.021908827126026154, -0.04600006714463234, 0.000024654087610542774, 0.022762609645724297, -0.032924965023994446, -0.004142912570387125, -0.02356058731675148, 0.014164607971906662, -0.04967314004898071, -0.042304132133722305, -0.027240995317697525, 0.01345154084265232, 0.037973351776599884, 0.046278633177280426, 0.018129706382751465, 0.04090244695544243, 0.006180359050631523, -0.017918335273861885, 0.04146668314933777, 0.006755475886166096, 0.0035299398005008698, -0.01296638697385788, 0.02972329780459404, -0.03849160298705101, -0.041924767196178436, 0.016196399927139282, -0.015213686041533947, 0.04140656441450119, -0.03775950148701668, 0.006176929455250502, -0.01738813892006874, 0.02618507109582424, 0.036143090575933456, -0.05228428542613983, 0.015974009409546852, 0.005081715993583202, 0.030125025659799576, 0.032373733818531036, -0.01897851936519146, 0.012617937289178371, 0.012668738141655922, -0.00125776301138103, -0.06229156255722046, 0.008578340522944927, 0.003323817625641823, 0.013406067155301571, 0.01023805420845747, -0.01779807172715664, -0.0041825720109045506, -0.026921067386865616, -0.023802056908607483, 0.0050011915154755116, 0.00972765777260065, 0.03236773982644081, 0.003804292995482683, 0.009734845720231533, -0.025132756680250168, -0.019153736531734467, -0.06298714131116867, 0.0201977901160717, -0.015184713527560234, -0.043131809681653976, -0.037898849695920944, -0.017821265384554863, -0.006049306597560644, 0.0074464017525315285, -0.01697794534265995, -0.0268270131200552, -0.02319118194282055, 0.03405562415719032, 0.004955507814884186, -0.013443320989608765, 0.009820012375712395, -0.025342728942632675, -0.00828853901475668, -0.05305813252925873, 0.02632651850581169, -0.015541108325123787, -0.01764007844030857, -0.02290293201804161, -0.016734907403588295, -0.039233941584825516, -0.0018835983937606215, 0.05413248762488365, -0.03391014412045479, -0.006591285578906536, 0.014639072120189667, 0.017149854451417923, 0.028712010011076927, -0.020371591672301292, 0.03431539610028267, -0.039047494530677795, -0.015720184892416, 0.02087000384926796, -0.019436560571193695, -0.020902540534734726, 0.04141702130436897, 0.009126322343945503, -0.027685754001140594, 0.04143728315830231, 0.011167585849761963, -0.01608043722808361, 0.026560500264167786, -0.045124247670173645, -0.015314711257815361, 0.08687271177768707, 0.008734672330319881, -0.011338668875396252, -0.00817434024065733, -0.02461238019168377, -0.0984925627708435, 0.04731488227844238, -0.03546850383281708, -0.03293847665190697, -0.009455897845327854, -0.003915666602551937, 0.01948883756995201, -0.01909606158733368, 0.02027129754424095, 0.01062658242881298, -0.013450981117784977, -0.01576266624033451, 0.03515511751174927, -0.023802705109119415, 0.028752528131008148, -0.002346988068893552, 0.02102663367986679, 0.022178076207637787, -0.009188776835799217, 0.0068983761593699455, -0.0015175166772678494, 0.028398754075169563, 0.005735380109399557, 0.020711397752165794, 0.028515027835965157, -0.003762189531698823, 0.020737159997224808, 0.011401796713471413, 0.06063326820731163, -0.02382342703640461, -0.028567517176270485, 0.05381287634372711, -0.02543608471751213, -0.006082326173782349, 0.008259960450232029, 0.005964334588497877, 0.044675931334495544, -0.015543515793979168, 0.0034720110706984997, -0.023388540372252464, -0.010885516181588173, -0.0442364364862442, 0.01478901132941246, -0.004198344890028238, 0.015342630445957184, -0.028262093663215637, 0.018412675708532333, -0.019508827477693558, -0.008661073632538319, 0.007219637278467417, -0.023660963401198387, -0.01747727207839489, 0.004691915586590767, -0.01652383804321289, -0.013682668097317219, 0.0035949053708463907, -0.06260316073894501, -0.09199440479278564, 0.036205463111400604, 0.0657767727971077, -0.03272414952516556, -0.02813914604485035, -0.008936837315559387, -0.002276147948578, 0.06700833886861801, -0.07707193493843079, -0.014553277753293514, -0.011288376525044441, 0.009108342230319977, -0.00007734425162198022, 0.0005720140761695802 ]
<p>Given the number of users of an application was 70 in total, it's <a href="http://www.measuringusability.com/five-users.php" rel="nofollow">my understanding that research shows</a>:</p> <blockquote> <p>Five users is the number of users needed to detect approximately 85% of the problems in an interface, given that the probability a user would encounter a problem is about 31%.</p> </blockquote> <p>Thing is that over time, it seems likely that a given user's abilities to detect problems compared to other users would likely become more predictable. Is this true, and if not why? If it is true, what would be the best formula for knowing when to switch from random selection to optimal selection?</p> <p><strong>Note:</strong> Please note that this question is roughly understood by me, and it's very possible that there's a fundamental issue with the premise and/or gaps in the assumptions provided. If so, please comment and I'll attempt to address any concerns, questions, etc. </p>
74,149
[ -0.06627245992422104, -0.02213454246520996, 0.032812777906656265, -0.009581463411450386, 0.03281961381435394, -0.011383293196558952, 0.01073420699685812, -0.029686639085412025, 0.01728629507124424, 0.011108293198049068, 0.007560900412499905, 0.01960894837975502, 0.04302317276597023, 0.02450145222246647, 0.02342095598578453, 0.019806301221251488, 0.012918580323457718, -0.015464778989553452, -0.010794944129884243, 0.006622275337576866, -0.02027803286910057, 0.005517990328371525, 0.03408839553594589, -0.02214641124010086, -0.03737202286720276, 0.022352127358317375, -0.02008352242410183, -0.0348907895386219, 0.03342467546463013, 0.025445418432354927, -0.04565175250172615, 0.03955844044685364, 0.01427384652197361, 0.039256688207387924, 0.05647261440753937, 0.013687112368643284, -0.028195567429065704, -0.00889650173485279, -0.05590314790606499, -0.0017602932639420033, -0.0007949213031679392, 0.0051367757841944695, -0.0013776971027255058, 0.01910616084933281, -0.03201589360833168, -0.0020726348739117384, -0.027156488969922066, -0.028569120913743973, 0.03468365594744682, -0.04493197798728943, 0.09818297624588013, -0.02907494828104973, 0.039099887013435364, 0.01364013459533453, -0.023234449326992035, -0.03741317614912987, 0.04280419275164604, 0.026937177404761314, -0.03596974536776543, -0.028998931869864464, -0.015923794358968735, -0.017567956820130348, -0.01923077367246151, 0.006094510667026043, -0.03386341407895088, 0.023084551095962524, -0.004137747455388308, -0.023415198549628258, 0.04424581304192543, 0.0058330362662673, 0.00824970006942749, 0.004683789797127247, 0.03741779550909996, 0.01078803651034832, 0.036643072962760925, -0.04295751452445984, 0.020275495946407318, 0.007715002633631229, 0.026806682348251343, 0.023724958300590515, -0.04606363922357559, 0.005498445127159357, 0.017093678936362267, 0.04301852360367775, 0.019323071464896202, -0.036144424229860306, 0.047078199684619904, -0.06010344997048378, 0.02806379459798336, 0.009188181720674038, -0.006442875135689974, 0.018087688833475113, 0.04109920188784599, 0.006671242881566286, -0.05535823106765747, 0.025646954774856567, 0.005827677436172962, 0.02209208346903324, 0.0030030878260731697, 0.0014159497804939747, -0.013045255094766617, -0.021472113206982613, 0.014096749946475029, 0.0628727376461029, -0.030367236584424973, -0.027303393930196762, -0.056706756353378296, -0.024001846089959145, -0.0353340283036232, -0.021913139149546623, -0.021212680265307426, 0.020409388467669487, -0.0024192992132157087, 0.01553418580442667, 0.016346344724297523, 0.023257216438651085, -0.007018814794719219, -0.021668368950486183, 0.07266875356435776, 0.060400743037462234, 0.04070451855659485, -0.026176881045103073, 0.010991265997290611, -0.04523961991071701, -0.024576712399721146, 0.019781380891799927, 0.002034698147326708, -0.038115277886390686, -0.03254898265004158, 0.0294665340334177, -0.010989288799464703, -0.002984147984534502, 0.02652307227253914, 0.030535290017724037, 0.0054311128333210945, -0.005413323640823364, -0.07731710374355316, -0.06161842122673988, 0.05379049852490425, -0.011004311963915825, -0.0037423234898597, -0.08004426956176758, -0.010202827863395214, 0.031367089599370956, 0.06471578776836395, -0.012669201008975506, 0.042887501418590546, -0.007871362380683422, 0.016825715079903603, 0.007926388643682003, -0.045732781291007996, -0.001654833904467523, -0.0066651287488639355, -0.03221535682678223, -0.024174369871616364, -0.10530441999435425, 0.005964391864836216, 0.023291267454624176, -0.0033779654186218977, -0.03329598531126976, -0.008670495823025703, 0.01747392676770687, -0.029970478266477585, -0.04741799831390381, 0.043283335864543915, -0.03095490299165249, 0.09808338433504105, -0.005321791395545006, 0.03517397120594978, 0.024146897718310356, 0.010766606777906418, 0.010143503546714783, 0.010639458894729614, 0.05878453329205513, 0.043106213212013245, -0.014526793733239174, 0.04062787443399429, -0.030025498941540718, -0.0019216419896110892, -0.0543552041053772, -0.037968333810567856, -0.03070899099111557, -0.023968668654561043, -0.0006166599923744798, 0.026187129318714142, 0.025248296558856964, -0.009383500553667545, 0.010006400756537914, 0.04749620705842972, -0.04141756892204285, -0.04904041811823845, -0.09536835551261902, 0.021623520180583, 0.023123640567064285, -0.009250004775822163, 0.03324231132864952, -0.04417199268937111, -0.006915847305208445, -0.01415081787854433, -0.010471989400684834, -0.021686172112822533, -0.013420267961919308, 0.04948766157031059, -0.03088776394724846, -0.020956657826900482, 0.06410938501358032, -0.011064944788813591, -0.030504925176501274, 0.06177743151783943, -0.06982482224702835, -0.05465878173708916, 0.007753724232316017, -0.0056973048485815525, 0.04686476290225983, -0.0024415140505880117, -0.04129428416490555, 0.0050978087820112705, 0.00047899573110044, -0.021633896976709366, 0.027458753436803818, -0.05033944174647331, 0.043610572814941406, 0.019963717088103294, 0.005513278301805258, 0.018793532624840736, 0.01256329845637083, 0.0006879995344206691, -0.021313101053237915, 0.005806015804409981, -0.016221247613430023, -0.07172148674726486, -0.04392203316092491, 0.042510103434324265, -0.00022146309493109584, -0.034775007516145706, 0.03118666261434555, 0.05046054348349571, 0.04617539793252945, 0.0011283350177109241, 0.013394658453762531, 0.028082450851798058, 0.012841124087572098, 0.0031796833500266075, 0.061314765363931656, 0.013716006651520729, 0.03139957785606384, 0.006822218187153339, 0.006177916191518307, -0.008178353309631348, 0.0010119035141542554, 0.011134033091366291, 0.014916462823748589, 0.031160617247223854, 0.038181986659765244, -0.025144480168819427, -0.002464522607624531, 0.02737647481262684, -0.0046080611646175385, -0.021177608519792557, 0.0301558505743742, 0.012204633094370365, 0.006281358189880848, -0.020210474729537964, -0.02388513833284378, 0.017074938863515854, 0.001870899461209774, -0.021529966965317726, -0.006874914281070232, 0.022829536348581314, -0.010886121541261673, -0.026070576161146164, -0.002090862952172756, -0.007187069393694401, -0.02046772837638855, -0.007735409773886204, 0.030513716861605644, -0.01435171253979206, 0.035630762577056885, 0.0010575709166005254, -0.034308165311813354, 0.013572783209383488, 0.01615247130393982, 0.010381845757365227, -0.0013497411273419857, -0.050610605627298355, -0.011935382150113583, 0.011420536786317825, -0.05029934644699097, 0.02180316485464573, -0.020759867504239082, -0.004687369801104069, 0.009996611624956131, -0.014641755260527134, -0.03748989477753639, -0.03931696340441704, -0.042274780571460724, 0.04230931028723717, -0.023817213252186775, -0.032454099506139755, 0.04419868066906929, -0.00729890912771225, -0.023201271891593933, 0.034342892467975616, -0.015092134475708008, -0.07479413598775864, -0.03828705847263336, -0.004846679978072643, 0.007955912500619888, -0.005432972684502602, -0.028976421803236008, 0.02833685837686062, 0.0007224407163448632, -0.01540094893425703, -0.07449378818273544, -0.10068344324827194, 0.02670350857079029, -0.01591002382338047, 0.04720671474933624, 0.00026229146169498563, -0.0018211171263828874, 0.07395192235708237, 0.024693675339221954, -0.02159406989812851, 0.011341951787471771, -0.012210753746330738, -0.01455785147845745, -0.03229954093694687, 0.036073289811611176, 0.060498327016830444, -0.009233174845576286, 0.03158087655901909, -0.03278885781764984, 0.023889949545264244, 0.025831416249275208, -0.00984945334494114, 0.0288999006152153, -0.00008913256169762462, 0.007510513067245483, -0.0032949824817478657, -0.01793013885617256, -0.0007171235047280788, -0.022390859201550484, 0.01810223050415516, -0.020274251699447632, 0.024532556533813477, 0.021102190017700195, 0.01457772683352232, -0.011058202013373375, -0.02446535788476467, 0.0358056016266346, -0.0029449337162077427, -0.012010736390948296, -0.04494667798280716, -0.029057983309030533, -0.02363092079758644, 0.029220005497336388, 0.028722554445266724, -0.051054637879133224, -0.030423305928707123, 0.05283559486269951, 0.029320579022169113, 0.018963636830449104, -0.038206443190574646, -0.020493291318416595, -0.04118150845170021, -0.0244893841445446, -0.009244659915566444, -0.015500018373131752, 0.02019452676177025, 0.018742388114333153, 0.034901127219200134, -0.024015534669160843, -0.06527966260910034, 0.013173261657357216, -0.0753275528550148, 0.0016802053432911634, -0.03147419914603233, 0.06415053457021713, -0.022716067731380463, -0.00243247183971107, -0.004511087667196989, -0.01662558875977993, -0.0346234068274498, 0.0064824726432561874, -0.09661617875099182, -0.005785485729575157, -0.02096511982381344, -0.00736854737624526, 0.005373960826545954, -0.022004323080182076, 0.08191625028848648, -0.011872319504618645, 0.0005342356744222343, 0.010323349386453629, 0.06532271206378937, -0.04503645747900009, 0.025711309164762497, -0.017577340826392174, -0.020913871005177498, 0.005553400609642267, 0.012102660723030567, -0.00814853236079216, -0.02127797156572342, 0.06295626610517502, 0.02215249463915825, -0.041253551840782166, -0.04517142474651337, -0.052239421755075455, -0.00929334294050932, 0.0056959777139127254, 0.021217934787273407, 0.01250666007399559, 0.020919689908623695, -0.022796591743826866, 0.04572122171521187, -0.0235295332968235, 0.03719490021467209, 0.03339724987745285, 0.009840828366577625, -0.002849105279892683, -0.05605904757976532, -0.03772483393549919, 0.032830860465765, 0.006924452725797892, -0.0034441575407981873, 0.010083991102874279, 0.03267671912908554, 0.0009636649047024548, -0.04124385118484497, 0.017448971047997475, 0.061891455203294754, 0.0061808992177248, -0.002374885603785515, -0.006084897555410862, 0.01316727977246046, 0.00865230429917574, -0.010504283010959625, 0.0017064072890207171, 0.07006525993347168, -0.01618169993162155, 0.007397516630589962, 0.04674537479877472, -0.007312646601349115, -0.03828427568078041, 0.01727898418903351, -0.03682035207748413, 0.04230915755033493, 0.011691421270370483, -0.014731336385011673, 0.03032897226512432, 0.031033504754304886, 0.010113249532878399, 0.038805246353149414, -0.03411548584699631, -0.054604556411504745, 0.01621410809457302, 0.04556787386536598, 0.0633140355348587, -0.059483014047145844, 0.025369035080075264, -0.01914885640144348, 0.012288699857890606, 0.03796982765197754, -0.04921341687440872, 0.039702482521533966, 0.011060652323067188, 0.02071991004049778, -0.019129052758216858, -0.0024745375849306583, -0.005040030460804701, 0.005572028923779726, -0.022021066397428513, 0.04537812992930412, -0.022554442286491394, 0.007437338121235371, -0.03991246595978737, 0.007875894196331501, -0.0030558921862393618, 0.07195953279733658, -0.025845635682344437, 0.002396134426817298, -0.023168107494711876, -0.008024568669497967, -0.020109618082642555, -0.045807648450136185, 0.06543608754873276, -0.012282130308449268, 0.012911672703921795, 0.02486545592546463, 0.0017052143812179565, -0.03188055008649826, 0.026511922478675842, 0.04209977760910988, -0.016270315274596214, -0.013545907102525234, -0.046904921531677246, 0.012717852368950844, 0.042403947561979294, 0.0041175782680511475, 0.012323800474405289, -0.013190182857215405, 0.01198124885559082, 0.020747581496834755, 0.028995735570788383, -0.01150541938841343, -0.014317624270915985, -0.01716396026313305, 0.012512451969087124, -0.0035202172584831715, -0.032940156757831573, 0.05141618475317955, 0.03447238728404045, 0.054315559566020966, -0.04325428977608681, -0.03357508406043053, -0.033681947737932205, -0.02988196164369583, -0.0024792945478111506, 0.012871923856437206, 0.06276765465736389, 0.00549470866099, 0.020818298682570457, 0.0005849011358805001, 0.002019981388002634, -0.03584945201873779, 0.050858788192272186, 0.04031914100050926, 0.005010766442865133, 0.0019058872712776065, -0.06436177343130112, -0.008519216440618038, -0.0002904761058744043, -0.04324641451239586, 0.041966769844293594, -0.024393893778324127, 0.03310304880142212, 0.033691197633743286, -0.007985413074493408, 0.008976932615041733, 0.051383063197135925, -0.007980124093592167, 0.02092749997973442, -0.028792524710297585, 0.038920264691114426, -0.04799969494342804, -0.002556134946644306, -0.04834366217255592, -0.023893609642982483, 0.012483641505241394, 0.009768153540790081, -0.022972658276557922, -0.011206618510186672, 0.0007321786833927035, -0.053206637501716614, -0.04919816926121712, -0.0007557912031188607, 0.029714759439229965, -0.00134237390011549, -0.02753623202443123, 0.018270045518875122, 0.010772784240543842, 0.06295327097177505, 0.01596735417842865, -0.011022422462701797, -0.014190910384058952, -0.021106800064444542, 0.0011295453878119588, -0.009012458845973015, 0.012514145113527775, -0.025083797052502632, -0.018665721639990807, -0.026850828900933266, -0.007390094920992851, 0.031389765441417694, 0.0000408747982874047, 0.024314982816576958, -0.009256109595298767, -0.05068438500165939, -0.005863884463906288, -0.039106372743844986, 0.01578068546950817, 0.007463941350579262, 0.01421404629945755, 0.045708123594522476, 0.0212014839053154, 0.011617327108979225, 0.007984967902302742, 0.045820996165275574, 0.04549037665128708, -0.010667722672224045, 0.038913846015930176, 0.05402860790491104, -0.00800017174333334, 0.025949830189347267, -0.045983489602804184, -0.05070072039961815, 0.025395436212420464, 0.015650350600481033, -0.018772175535559654, -0.02484101429581642, 0.04088050127029419, -0.02044886164367199, -0.03250397369265556, -0.04117221757769585, 0.03516462817788124, 0.03602612763643265, -0.03829453885555267, 0.004279430489987135, 0.07242079079151154, -0.021917706355452538, -0.03647220507264137, -0.00047723352327011526, 0.007935757748782635, -0.010814200155436993, -0.005329527426511049, 0.02181364595890045, -0.013499941676855087, 0.006375391036272049, 0.03382434695959091, 0.014680346474051476, 0.046316903084516525, 0.02370811626315117, 0.005553954280912876, 0.021291958168148994, 0.039717789739370346, -0.05126873031258583, -0.031057192012667656, 0.01831621304154396, -0.040087003260850906, -0.011866162531077862, -0.02109408751130104, -0.012712585739791393, 0.033313486725091934, 0.02719971165060997, -0.03583027049899101, -0.00011665326019283384, 0.006105521693825722, -0.011774717830121517, -0.0005646377103403211, 0.021862147375941277, -0.0047683436423540115, 0.027583319693803787, 0.007895226590335369, 0.017992667853832245, 0.024825334548950195, 0.02927282638847828, -0.004134939983487129, -0.07229367643594742, -0.02417558617889881, -0.02369188331067562, -0.05173924192786217, 0.02825883962213993, 0.0016532109584659338, -0.04108251631259918, -0.0109964394941926, -0.04488028213381767, 0.009882460348308086, 0.02124776318669319, 0.06368503719568253, 0.017334001138806343, 0.0720619335770607, 0.018739797174930573, 0.021640894934535027, -0.016112731769680977, 0.015905531123280525, 0.13494279980659485, 0.09745114296674728, 0.02151697874069214, -0.025824667885899544, -0.014467446133494377, -0.023480502888560295, -0.015708211809396744, 0.01337430439889431, 0.038241513073444366, -0.01322723738849163, 0.02665567211806774, 0.06433794647455215, 0.022699808701872826, 0.03724605590105057, 0.0034716499503701925, 0.01913554035127163, -0.08248544484376907, -0.010839682072401047, 0.019579458981752396, -0.018744265660643578, 0.02531038038432598, -0.012540447525680065, -0.033758532255887985, 0.013102072291076183, -0.022797618061304092, 0.012661860324442387, 0.03486398234963417, 0.006329037714749575, -0.009407329373061657, -0.019263645634055138, 0.005055826622992754, 0.023949237540364265, 0.027746818959712982, -0.014598453417420387, -0.021249612793326378, 0.016227005049586296, -0.024084102362394333, -0.0245521143078804, 0.02745334804058075, 0.0686374232172966, 0.006973653566092253, -0.016977442428469658, 0.012496043927967548, 0.04317377507686615, -0.02466575615108013, -0.009297586977481842, -0.03233805298805237, 0.018643822520971298, -0.03237786516547203, -0.002263707108795643, -0.016477279365062714, 0.0008942409185692668, -0.02474731020629406, -0.03964882344007492, -0.043850596994161606, 0.0034002845641225576, 0.048626020550727844, -0.020134583115577698, -0.00789678655564785, 0.0073003219440579414, 0.01647881790995598, -0.005337713286280632, 0.013058298267424107, 0.038087133318185806, -0.046464044600725174, -0.045638661831617355, -0.03802057355642319, 0.019758522510528564, 0.0229631457477808, 0.0031299281399697065, 0.006610730662941933, -0.019826015457510948, -0.048548661172389984, 0.008198670111596584, 0.010333118960261345, -0.004850461613386869, 0.0664222240447998, -0.005879654549062252, 0.021708587184548378, -0.009255308657884598, -0.049512431025505066, 0.018866153433918953, -0.0218528900295496, 0.008732756599783897, -0.03811587765812874, 0.012226537801325321, -0.026244046166539192, 0.03872740641236305, 0.009717210195958614, -0.017474178224802017, 0.03044939413666725, 0.012422110885381699, -0.016589418053627014, -0.028869805857539177, -0.020098742097616196, -0.01578744687139988, -0.024058612063527107, 0.004478955175727606, -0.00479597644880414, 0.07665231823921204, 0.00010059628402814269, 0.02553633041679859, 0.013868899084627628, 0.056184884160757065, 0.0015924061881378293, -0.008803716860711575, 0.0015945597551763058, -0.0428556464612484, -0.04893995821475983, 0.010892895981669426, -0.0022559710778295994, -0.03627032786607742, -0.0715012326836586, -0.057751577347517014, 0.012955245561897755, 0.023211190477013588, -0.0007514769677072763, -0.009353813715279102, -0.0022472094278782606, -0.003844047198072076, 0.02331104874610901, -0.04724656790494919, -0.02370559424161911, -0.02776610292494297, 0.0059397099539637566, 0.008677243255078793, 0.03211183100938797, 0.011757555417716503, 0.011829650029540062, 0.0025609151925891638, -0.013955547474324703, 0.00022347320918925107, -0.015275552868843079, 0.007072001695632935, -0.016874436289072037, 0.0015544608468189836, -0.0268842950463295, 0.044962719082832336, -0.04166727513074875, -0.001146344467997551, 0.07035726308822632, -0.03501797839999199, -0.04227963835000992, 0.02500653639435768, -0.022778863087296486, 0.030058380216360092, 0.017328405752778053, -0.001900063594803214, 0.0144893117249012, 0.07341837882995605, -0.026080386713147163, -0.016703272238373756, -0.0143571887165308, 0.06002568081021309, 0.012012457475066185, -0.0032906443811953068, 0.010917501524090767, 0.0008384266402572393, -0.0007107917335815728, 0.012846739962697029, 0.02038644254207611, -0.017144734039902687, 0.0013994323089718819, 0.031787317246198654, 0.027098847553133965, 0.0051194713450968266, -0.01933765970170498, -0.00290088914334774, 0.03551458567380905, 0.018435457721352577, -0.036030568182468414, -0.006146048195660114, 0.00023160090495366603, 0.008889156393706799, -0.05666210874915123, -0.0012547500664368272, 0.019299114122986794, 0.02488146349787712, 0.019923055544495583, -0.060140933841466904, 0.016837941482663155, 0.050747085362672806, -0.04669537767767906, 0.01620003953576088, 0.016048332676291466, -0.0179898664355278, -0.10014224797487259, 0.0407462976872921, -0.05577930063009262, 0.016481740400195122, 0.017116496339440346, -0.00466737849637866, 0.027662301436066628, 0.06295304745435715, -0.01333220861852169, -0.037219755351543427, -0.008184713311493397, 0.04793459549546242, -0.037915125489234924, -0.028833651915192604, 0.0591074600815773, -0.01884535327553749, -0.037805065512657166, 0.04851696640253067, 0.019451646134257317, 0.009041945450007915, 0.0016653945203870535, 0.02180550992488861, 0.04258092865347862, 0.031032521277666092, 0.038670267909765244, -0.051794812083244324, -0.0017810212448239326, 0.007697034627199173, -0.002729143714532256, 0.023299625143408775, 0.010668584145605564, 0.017709463834762573, -0.014344319701194763, -0.01612839661538601, -0.06640268862247467, -0.017084557563066483, -0.008854756131768227, -0.04150795191526413, 0.03342919051647186, -0.006142599042505026, 0.0041314829140901566, -0.010450566187500954, -0.0072378963232040405, -0.04075183346867561, -0.008990578353404999, 0.0387176088988781, 0.016541743651032448, 0.0197590459138155, -0.012751856818795204, -0.03251098096370697, -0.01366855762898922, 0.032067909836769104, 0.016830625012516975, 0.02221694216132164, -0.06305665522813797, 0.013445604592561722, -0.011884110048413277, -0.01113983616232872, -0.017000852152705193, -0.005948255769908428, 0.010455138981342316, 0.022530993446707726, -0.0018552358960732818, 0.004576357547193766, 0.007393537554889917, -0.060032669454813004, -0.009289166890084743, -0.061727382242679596, 0.06616240739822388, 0.01209474727511406, 0.004472525790333748, -0.06493173539638519, -0.016169140115380287, -0.04723836109042168, 0.0008743006037548184, 0.031494900584220886, -0.013358709402382374, -0.0018269371939823031, -0.02784174680709839, 0.015707150101661682, 0.008858563378453255, -0.04345281049609184, 0.040994301438331604, -0.00640841294080019, -0.014964120462536812, -0.024925561621785164, 0.0102163664996624, 0.05356176197528839, -0.03881026431918144, 0.011274769902229309, -0.027924593538045883, -0.012240000069141388, -0.008293913677334785, -0.01620103232562542, 0.025938330218195915, 0.04507243633270264, 0.030188897624611855, 0.037739064544439316, -0.023395130410790443, 0.032449085265398026, -0.0011765834642574191, 0.02999531291425228, -0.05841558799147606, 0.024580957368016243, -0.015883222222328186, 0.0031674266792833805, 0.01843065209686756, 0.02939763106405735, -0.040104638785123825, -0.0239398330450058, -0.008358363062143326, 0.03714417666196823, -0.028080003336071968, -0.019784141331911087, 0.0004585331189446151, -0.004510180559009314, 0.04613906517624855, 0.005729440599679947, 0.027973270043730736, 0.022092098370194435, -0.01919061504304409, -0.014173806644976139, 0.02670316770672798, 0.028134062886238098, -0.0006670668954029679, 0.04278174415230751, 0.027464859187602997, -0.0039850398898124695, 0.0650036633014679, -0.011932549998164177, 0.05187898129224777, -0.02075902931392193, 0.036576591432094574, 0.029620137065649033, 0.00017430598381906748, -0.04267975315451622, 0.05912226811051369, -0.008829962462186813, 0.062354810535907745, 0.0126967653632164, -0.0064703174866735935, -0.026555174961686134, 0.02103036642074585, -0.02528298646211624, 0.012067477218806744, 0.036546263843774796, 0.01120607741177082, -0.008494608104228973, 0.02722117118537426, 0.006546897813677788, -0.0005344558740034699, 0.04755741357803345, 0.00030792620964348316, 0.008891940116882324, 0.016865916550159454, 0.011411682702600956, -0.01986408233642578, 0.004995561204850674, -0.021028364077210426, -0.00703109335154295, -0.013012806884944439, 0.042054999619722366, 0.042687416076660156, -0.023286573588848114, -0.04474781081080437, 0.011646908707916737, 0.025357745587825775, -0.016688741743564606, 0.008997420780360699, -0.04923897236585617, 0.02392328530550003, -0.005365925375372171, -0.014655585400760174 ]
<p>Is there any interesting problem in the area of "Document Image Analysis and Retrieval" which by nature needs an online/incremental clustering process ? The problem may be in the context of "Logical Structure Analysis", or "Document Layout Analysis" to identify regions of interest in a scanned page, or any other related topics. What matters is that the considered problem naturally needs an online/incremental clustering. Do you have any ideas or suggestions about such problems ?</p> <p>Note: the considered document images are actually a scanned administrative documents</p>
36,848
[ -0.023951534181833267, -0.027810975909233093, -0.005128256045281887, -0.010838387534022331, 0.023091813549399376, -0.007189550902694464, -0.007801733911037445, -0.010269646532833576, -0.008861750364303589, -0.06945253908634186, 0.002419659635052085, 0.02138780616223812, 0.026112059131264687, 0.023117102682590485, -0.018331270664930344, -0.0010072268778458238, -0.024654200300574303, -0.0019184444099664688, 0.011587347835302353, 0.004322338849306107, 0.010991434566676617, 0.005140379536896944, 0.017247509211301804, 0.007191047538071871, 0.0034660527016967535, 0.0072983382269740105, -0.010775832459330559, -0.04662742093205452, 0.03665117174386978, 0.04385773092508316, -0.03861290588974953, -0.014729409478604794, -0.009471427649259567, 0.021271955221891403, 0.014874177053570747, -0.04852396622300148, -0.03782510384917259, -0.03020074963569641, -0.008705180138349533, 0.009144135750830173, -0.028628133237361908, -0.018002811819314957, 0.002482773968949914, 0.03931572660803795, -0.018717072904109955, 0.01627075858414173, -0.026493782177567482, -0.033350132405757904, 0.009499093517661095, -0.04882954806089401, 0.09687554836273193, -0.016604473814368248, -0.0026534288190305233, 0.011187408119440079, -0.020478855818510056, 0.0005008568987250328, 0.02347833290696144, 0.08625146001577377, 0.009436184540390968, -0.016148129478096962, -0.037551820278167725, 0.01025452185422182, 0.021080318838357925, 0.00388952880166471, -0.05100972577929497, 0.01935696043074131, -0.02147543802857399, 0.00906958058476448, 0.04301920905709267, -0.017563967034220695, -0.036041680723428726, 0.024143746122717857, 0.04060624539852142, -0.04372161626815796, -0.008393107913434505, -0.02361270599067211, -0.023810923099517822, 0.024965787306427956, 0.031330205500125885, 0.009031662717461586, -0.003919258248060942, -0.004802707117050886, -0.0035909945145249367, 0.03046572208404541, 0.01822601445019245, 0.0034541969653218985, 0.10981487482786179, -0.05847477540373802, 0.02081935666501522, -0.00009086444333661348, -0.01489415392279625, -0.005143843125551939, 0.04710274934768677, -0.007987859658896923, -0.028620798140764236, 0.026669636368751526, -0.007978890091180801, 0.03315604850649834, 0.031158242374658585, -0.003714854596182704, 0.010665436275303364, -0.04621589556336403, 0.00033684124355204403, 0.06603263318538666, -0.009709267877042294, -0.04750898480415344, -0.03891366347670555, 0.0006767334998585284, 0.02843828685581684, 0.03188742324709892, -0.027743574231863022, 0.04221659526228905, 0.0378187820315361, 0.04094049334526062, 0.03817398473620415, 0.001122036948800087, 0.011754045262932777, -0.003161620581522584, -0.004802232142537832, 0.04775404557585716, 0.02848018892109394, -0.02371944859623909, 0.025010062381625175, -0.025090416893363, -0.042481038719415665, 0.0387965589761734, 0.023151123896241188, -0.03267159312963486, -0.028829624876379967, 0.0558180958032608, 0.010567279532551765, 0.011797284707427025, 0.05870172381401062, -0.05287592485547066, 0.05776665359735489, 0.024315889924764633, -0.0654623880982399, -0.002642519073560834, 0.015749529004096985, 0.03067196160554886, 0.016839345917105675, -0.06397324055433273, 0.005675169639289379, 0.020558862015604973, 0.04934744909405708, -0.016838718205690384, 0.024247216060757637, 0.0332387275993824, 0.013731304556131363, -0.015483111143112183, 0.012882268987596035, 0.011875421740114689, -0.03900977596640587, -0.034772854298353195, 0.02194526419043541, -0.10596249252557755, 0.0012920526787638664, 0.012973071075975895, -0.01798945665359497, -0.04113906994462013, 0.017982250079512596, 0.019270455464720726, 0.00543610006570816, -0.028563151136040688, 0.022165758535265923, -0.0037008775398135185, 0.05371344834566116, 0.009871197864413261, 0.05950092896819115, -0.015139852650463581, 0.049367982894182205, 0.04544742777943611, 0.023896992206573486, -0.0022773188538849354, 0.07383625209331512, -0.012485572136938572, 0.00288226711563766, -0.003096955129876733, 0.024113869294524193, 0.006358770187944174, 0.04256405681371689, -0.06091669201850891, -0.012165645137429237, 0.025299709290266037, 0.03259383514523506, 0.0076888808980584145, -0.0020131103228777647, -0.03710075095295906, 0.026652030646800995, -0.06405932456254959, 0.03403397649526596, -0.0769001916050911, 0.004213603213429451, -0.015461179427802563, 0.004346664063632488, 0.04703063890337944, -0.036352936178445816, -0.02262531965970993, 0.023528538644313812, -0.034933287650346756, -0.0390290841460228, -0.032647162675857544, 0.016340304166078568, -0.0349399670958519, 0.006272591184824705, 0.005998420529067516, -0.006339810788631439, -0.028004908934235573, 0.00742813665419817, -0.05807330459356308, -0.06073470786213875, -0.023479795083403587, -0.03319652006030083, 0.04581860080361366, -0.047814857214689255, 0.01503155566751957, 0.012436280027031898, 0.009434466250240803, 0.0009381039417348802, 0.001301801996305585, -0.0053388457745313644, 0.04784173145890236, 0.05602910369634628, 0.017736192792654037, -0.028684405609965324, 0.02909940294921398, 0.05452263727784157, 0.022866621613502502, -0.0065940385684370995, -0.06730784475803375, -0.07841460406780243, -0.009331657551229, 0.08117005228996277, 0.00778030464425683, -0.05647516995668411, 0.03367409482598305, 0.03679491952061653, 0.03562511131167412, -0.0009861418511718512, -0.005653334781527519, -0.051153481006622314, 0.005272707901895046, 0.0028720085974782705, 0.02189762331545353, 0.00887390784919262, 0.025951286777853966, -0.002491921652108431, -0.003740058047696948, 0.053684528917074203, 0.010126061737537384, 0.013899105601012707, 0.014709866605699062, 0.0044582006521523, 0.0071618640795350075, -0.013394452631473541, 0.009717442095279694, 0.06808030605316162, -0.03153124824166298, 0.014086301438510418, 0.018318818882107735, -0.004365403670817614, 0.009266740642488003, -0.011522148735821247, -0.0355515219271183, 0.005345467943698168, 0.04323141649365425, -0.003410048084333539, 0.008074190467596054, 0.015542182140052319, -0.04427579790353775, 0.03368004783987999, 0.013789082877337933, -0.0029081227257847786, 0.010119986720383167, 0.04880550503730774, 0.010708595626056194, 0.03117288649082184, 0.016546597704291344, -0.020504914224147797, 0.008819877170026302, -0.005002009682357311, -0.03469068929553032, 0.012443614192306995, -0.014820528216660023, -0.031824201345443726, 0.004106381442397833, 0.012015250511467457, 0.006692938972264528, 0.009639143012464046, -0.014333938248455524, 0.04486031457781792, 0.010993617586791515, 0.0033206387888640165, -0.08923450857400894, -0.02230686880648136, -0.029307782649993896, 0.008113708347082138, -0.0303193386644125, -0.012586588971316814, 0.007473889272660017, 0.004329381510615349, -0.02820047363638878, 0.000774478365201503, -0.002439322415739298, -0.033816803246736526, -0.03631601855158806, 0.0006182643119245768, 0.00034712234628386796, -0.021721815690398216, 0.01072164811193943, 0.03368479385972023, 0.005612922366708517, 0.01815120130777359, -0.027306199073791504, -0.10810647159814835, 0.00623332429677248, -0.004122847691178322, 0.055196214467287064, -0.02069920301437378, -0.018193615600466728, 0.07323089987039566, 0.008625084534287453, -0.0329241007566452, -0.05079192668199539, -0.03002280928194523, -0.037624046206474304, -0.022796686738729477, -0.010152371600270271, -0.002242789836600423, 0.009367205202579498, -0.011114208959043026, 0.018950343132019043, 0.03166114538908005, 0.07864761352539062, 0.02836836874485016, -0.05821345001459122, 0.034184716641902924, 0.003824109211564064, 0.004294318612664938, 0.010118523612618446, 0.027606861665844917, -0.042569663375616074, 0.008474430069327354, -0.03518280014395714, 0.0006322952685877681, 0.026054926216602325, -0.035606466233730316, 0.034189943224191666, 0.010003950446844101, 0.0037156373728066683, -0.011144643649458885, 0.012190758250653744, 0.026068739593029022, 0.0012359230313450098, -0.018226196989417076, 0.033567432314157486, 0.009936632588505745, 0.009759804233908653, -0.015292642638087273, 0.04631434753537178, 0.03566068410873413, -0.024330373853445053, -0.0017931974725797772, -0.015746403485536575, -0.05312192440032959, 0.022492213174700737, -0.011202001012861729, -0.00027766829589381814, 0.020481344312429428, 0.031992796808481216, 0.014450032263994217, 0.009484829381108284, -0.011339332908391953, -0.009325015358626842, -0.05974837765097618, -0.01067514717578888, -0.02078658901154995, 0.05261531099677086, -0.03759713098406792, -0.0031909355893731117, 0.015340946614742279, -0.004671210888773203, 0.016427217051386833, 0.05677689239382744, -0.07413283735513687, -0.03316173329949379, -0.03252868726849556, 0.026825357228517532, -0.025794662535190582, 0.016559846699237823, 0.03367694839835167, 0.007990974001586437, -0.05017644912004471, -0.018255168572068214, 0.08419391512870789, -0.03950364887714386, 0.006721938960254192, -0.019338291138410568, 0.0017372360453009605, -0.005655706860125065, 0.016694793477654457, 0.03299463540315628, -0.010340029373764992, 0.04776635766029358, 0.04282568022608757, 5.212756946093577e-7, -0.027770237997174263, -0.03138848766684532, 0.03860900178551674, 0.012828771956264973, 0.016396965831518173, -0.007142961956560612, 0.033658716827631, -0.057153575122356415, 0.05013919249176979, -0.019176825881004333, 0.033476393669843674, 0.012121261097490788, 0.006607678718864918, -0.011541756801307201, -0.06161753833293915, -0.03972852975130081, 0.00948901753872633, -0.007059254217892885, -0.012258338741958141, 0.007627891376614571, 0.002202456584200263, 0.029369112104177475, -0.04538317397236824, 0.007760902401059866, 0.06622995436191559, 0.030236944556236267, -0.03263663128018379, -0.044991109520196915, -0.038375373929739, -0.004875276703387499, -0.033944930881261826, 0.01671394519507885, 0.016849765554070473, 0.017749205231666565, 0.0021715215407311916, 0.032574206590652466, -0.04505714774131775, -0.01711275987327099, 0.012707198970019817, 0.0013102636439725757, -0.042377930134534836, 0.005285395309329033, 0.016296586021780968, 0.002039728919044137, 0.04259686917066574, 0.05981992185115814, 0.046548325568437576, 0.010486073791980743, -0.09828881919384003, -0.0070637590251863, 0.020857542753219604, 0.04602246358990669, -0.043723396956920624, 0.002998380223289132, -0.02093726582825184, -0.0006543784984387457, 0.038243770599365234, -0.024096747860312462, 0.013441253453493118, -0.023166051134467125, -0.02932870201766491, -0.01863393746316433, -0.004453964065760374, -0.0009493552497588098, 0.005017423536628485, 0.007777195889502764, 0.010896839201450348, -0.05319153517484665, 0.005036358721554279, -0.07548969238996506, -0.0037244935519993305, 0.009732944890856743, 0.016465939581394196, 0.030297596007585526, 0.036205191165208817, 0.0006337742670439184, 0.04035517945885658, -0.05965797230601311, -0.04890664666891098, 0.007853019051253796, -0.020451979711651802, -0.02858666516840458, 0.028049131855368614, -0.026916902512311935, -0.0344797819852829, 0.029126426205039024, 0.029132995754480362, -0.03014380857348442, -0.01541178673505783, -0.015811128541827202, 0.04922632873058319, 0.049346670508384705, 0.022144740447402, 0.013343936763703823, 0.021039798855781555, 0.015541731379926205, 0.00357990269549191, -0.018867632374167442, 0.012172495014965534, -0.01712392456829548, 0.013946512714028358, -0.002564200898632407, 0.029312891885638237, -0.023810943588614464, 0.07449042797088623, -0.054157860577106476, 0.023797141388058662, -0.016732828691601753, -0.0278063602745533, 0.0022515933960676193, 0.02926555648446083, -0.03834350407123566, -0.00487354164943099, 0.02438271977007389, 0.040102794766426086, -0.017064742743968964, -0.020503414794802666, 0.043437737971544266, -0.0067308442667126656, -0.023352008312940598, 0.012143148109316826, -0.02336122654378414, -0.04120532050728798, -0.012381859123706818, -0.0026720163878053427, -0.008439595811069012, 0.031326472759246826, 0.06454794853925705, -0.009897899813950062, 0.035736676305532455, 0.005969498306512833, -0.049830056726932526, -0.01630762591958046, 0.020605603232979774, -0.010105008259415627, -0.004335132893174887, 0.014828957617282867, 0.02827332355082035, 0.012794913724064827, -0.05176197737455368, -0.04486720263957977, -0.04582531377673149, 0.0462041050195694, 0.024484017863869667, -0.019385868683457375, -0.055551499128341675, 0.01825566217303276, 0.00013203515845816582, -0.0205043014138937, -0.03361758962273598, 0.07748835533857346, 0.005953076761215925, -0.0385972298681736, 0.024060668423771858, 0.028011949732899666, 0.07958140969276428, -0.0006369002512656152, 0.0067588211968541145, 0.013527389615774155, -0.013536308892071247, 0.003513969946652651, -0.020714571699500084, 0.023485787212848663, -0.043482303619384766, 0.006378367077559233, -0.05069335177540779, 0.02504967898130417, 0.01823238469660282, -0.020799018442630768, -0.02180582471191883, 0.0033494234085083008, -0.011033052578568459, 0.030600208789110184, -0.02275220677256584, 0.02709173783659935, 0.024762488901615143, -0.01081390306353569, -0.01883484423160553, 0.014349851757287979, -0.0034503210335969925, -0.01653178781270981, 0.01939471997320652, 0.014109832234680653, -0.01605042815208435, 0.03797163441777229, 0.06217089295387268, -0.00980119127780199, 0.004858325235545635, 0.04045826569199562, -0.019198168069124222, 0.020329538732767105, 0.0030344107653945684, 0.0063232420943677425, -0.012371591292321682, 0.016428377479314804, -0.037346918135881424, -0.04191459342837334, 0.0099173067137599, -0.03307002782821655, 0.06380454450845718, 0.0015659300843253732, 0.03650286793708801, 0.04057413339614868, 0.0006989346002228558, -0.013251693919301033, -0.012740710750222206, -0.0008311867131851614, -0.04531700909137726, -0.020966988056898117, 0.06863348186016083, -0.04765554517507553, -0.006460973061621189, -0.008917899802327156, 0.01242148969322443, 0.028769085183739662, 0.031359490007162094, 0.02344900369644165, 0.012218237854540348, 0.04879537224769592, -0.056951429694890976, -0.07769078761339188, 0.00988161563873291, -0.043527401983737946, -0.0067759063094854355, 0.010461968369781971, -0.0564500130712986, 0.03791297972202301, 0.014089717529714108, 0.008360648527741432, 0.004519693553447723, -0.0028977314941585064, -0.06129976734519005, 0.027901187539100647, -0.010409447364509106, -0.003844699589535594, 0.008538973517715931, 0.003634684020653367, 0.009424935095012188, 0.003962382208555937, 0.0016219459939748049, 0.013025890104472637, -0.05397430434823036, -0.04324210807681084, -0.04319589212536812, -0.03899775445461273, 0.04415752738714218, 0.01700657419860363, -0.0032912418246269226, 0.01574077270925045, -0.007411313708871603, 0.04452866315841675, 0.010214813984930515, 0.044506628066301346, -0.019821064546704292, 0.03889757767319679, -0.02964218333363533, 0.024749964475631714, -0.014318311586976051, 0.011840726248919964, 0.09556058049201965, 0.09144052863121033, 0.0335521437227726, -0.041779715567827225, 0.029973242431879044, 0.012416754849255085, -0.014994615688920021, -0.028763411566615105, 0.04698169603943825, 0.028327839449048042, -0.004306596238166094, 0.02753688022494316, 0.020988916978240013, 0.00313146086409688, 0.04042628034949303, 0.04184717684984207, -0.050883080810308456, -0.06456398963928223, 0.012440228834748268, -0.014089352451264858, -0.0015687011182308197, 0.02310139872133732, -0.0942227840423584, 0.06530402600765228, 0.013135183602571487, -0.018147248774766922, -0.014719775877892971, -0.060552675276994705, 0.02885027974843979, -0.047257740050554276, -0.032489411532878876, 0.0086723817512393, 0.0002486670855432749, 0.014169120229780674, -0.04026949033141136, -0.021468576043844223, -0.013181598857045174, -0.0021757567301392555, 0.014102022163569927, 0.005642221309244633, 0.03259491175413132, -0.03241642192006111, -0.026099761947989464, -0.010951023548841476, -0.025155529379844666, -0.013101153075695038, -0.018109524622559547, 0.020968211814761162, 0.0017795201856642962, 0.02518012933433056, -0.006540641188621521, -0.007860656827688217, 0.02482837811112404, -0.02463982068002224, -0.029730521142482758, 0.02972143515944481, 0.047119464725255966, 0.0060545336455106735, -0.018344465643167496, -0.07771196961402893, 0.021286461502313614, -0.010956446640193462, 0.019518159329891205, 0.016834359616041183, 0.010904306545853615, 0.00997509527951479, -0.057964812964200974, 0.041610922664403915, 0.02991725504398346, -0.01870604045689106, -0.022136695683002472, 0.0034026606008410454, 0.024852022528648376, 0.009300188161432743, -0.05653029680252075, 0.0306113138794899, 0.02579115517437458, 0.020002614706754684, -0.012475498020648956, 0.011361120268702507, -0.05353220924735069, 0.01211833767592907, -0.05380120500922203, -0.01589391380548477, -0.030570928007364273, 0.02002800814807415, 0.04686785116791725, 0.03943435847759247, 0.026027752086520195, 0.02201915718615055, 0.00023282722395379096, 0.037685707211494446, 0.012823836877942085, -0.02397824451327324, -0.02215532958507538, -0.010529499500989914, -0.027298806235194206, 0.023527994751930237, -0.005232275929301977, 0.0037057918962091208, -0.014265579171478748, -0.044257957488298416, 0.01699162647128105, 0.047898851335048676, -0.0007425268413498998, 0.01993372291326523, 0.0353228896856308, -0.036186669021844864, 0.026761187240481377, 0.0027493785601109266, -0.0030954694375395775, -0.04181321710348129, -0.009606529027223587, -0.026205090805888176, -0.034801337867975235, 0.012277238070964813, -0.011558338068425655, -0.004293741658329964, -0.006944227032363415, -0.03805170953273773, 0.029392648488283157, -0.03067534789443016, 0.01778019778430462, -0.023044487461447716, -0.024660123512148857, -0.04287426173686981, -0.024356843903660774, -0.034656718373298645, 0.03177681937813759, -0.006196138449013233, 0.008204583078622818, 0.0362301766872406, 0.0325179360806942, 0.019639329984784126, 0.009830021299421787, 0.0033109677024185658, -0.012183621525764465, 0.01935405284166336, -0.011094058863818645, -0.005089892540127039, 0.030919164419174194, -0.059881970286369324, -0.03998425975441933, 0.020727653056383133, -0.03456844016909599, -0.019215639680624008, 0.02605828084051609, -0.04054669663310051, 0.01564677245914936, 0.06352709233760834, -0.007702559698373079, -0.02158442884683609, 0.01966894045472145, -0.0025908765383064747, 0.03114689700305462, -0.004084199201315641, 0.005615468602627516, 0.010921874083578587, -0.04008273035287857, 0.005791096016764641, 0.06321120262145996, 0.018877217546105385, -0.028385629877448082, 0.014591471292078495, 0.001969868317246437, 0.03935513645410538, -0.03414062038064003, 0.01482780184596777, 0.05075129494071007, 0.050873443484306335, -0.06498640775680542, 0.018510980531573296, 0.01338948868215084, -0.00902885477989912, -0.04316294193267822, 0.0009930467931553721, 0.027156012132763863, 0.03346231207251549, 0.03672393038868904, -0.04015335440635681, -0.0446365661919117, 0.05837395787239075, -0.047317828983068466, 0.027824334800243378, -0.044057030230760574, -0.04679613560438156, -0.0498964786529541, 0.00791990663856268, -0.04162190482020378, 0.0040835668332874775, 0.03281339257955551, 0.0434512123465538, 0.0024267120752483606, 0.03367191180586815, -0.028156938031315804, 0.018602201715111732, -0.0129995197057724, 0.00827623251825571, 0.020176704972982407, -0.031920209527015686, 0.03188251703977585, -0.03875308483839035, -0.0556396022439003, -0.009023159742355347, -0.026510391384363174, 0.028201280161738396, 0.0841447189450264, -0.01596330851316452, -0.021830204874277115, 0.03307162970304489, 0.05126916989684105, -0.004970190115272999, -0.022436372935771942, 0.013203979469835758, 0.0228822510689497, 0.0402611643075943, -0.0037860663142055273, 0.04441450163722038, 0.0009752234909683466, -0.002372210146859288, -0.003438806626945734, 0.017970355227589607, -0.05730263516306877, -0.03267966955900192, 0.015655413269996643, 0.02738121710717678, -0.005675786640495062, 0.0028174209874123335, 0.009387454017996788, -0.030562134459614754, -0.006884589325636625, 0.012337682768702507, 0.020177384838461876, -0.003141488879919052, 0.03828304260969162, -0.003214114811271429, -0.06187507137656212, 0.01360110379755497, -0.026345878839492798, -0.008063175715506077, -0.07062366604804993, 0.010535120964050293, 0.0034017139114439487, -0.0012836476089432836, -0.011877276934683323, -0.006271436810493469, 0.058583904057741165, 0.027942396700382233, -0.041943248361349106, 0.030122343450784683, 0.022292587906122208, -0.03774967044591904, 0.007565186358988285, -0.033569350838661194, 0.067592553794384, -0.010900611989200115, 0.02009148895740509, 0.00361378095112741, -0.01928757317364216, -0.024037735536694527, 0.020693175494670868, 0.054201822727918625, -0.03342563658952713, 0.01502075046300888, 0.00295319058932364, -0.004996227100491524, 0.01565789431333542, -0.02121824212372303, -0.005559032317250967, -0.03894815221428871, -0.011522702872753143, 0.019657231867313385, -0.031017843633890152, 0.011098985560238361, 0.011959392577409744, 0.026249947026371956, 0.027286244556307793, -0.030775589868426323, -0.018717540428042412, -0.01518700085580349, -0.006608513183891773, 0.015724878758192062, -0.02003457583487034, 0.059217069298028946, 0.0038262447342276573, 0.012636990286409855, 0.008798791095614433, 0.02095678448677063, -0.0427374504506588, 0.014544457197189331, -0.035413600504398346, -0.05098509415984154, 0.01589561253786087, 0.01685948111116886, 0.02337096631526947, -0.06108426675200462, 0.01932740956544876, 0.022521503269672394, -0.02227097749710083, 0.002712033921852708, 0.03799295425415039, -0.006505248602479696, 0.01909773238003254, 0.035972729325294495, 0.027964379638433456, 0.036023154854774475, -0.012174058705568314, -0.011130888015031815, 0.00031594675965607166, -0.00224480964243412, -0.004877762869000435, 0.046839337795972824, -0.009529301896691322, 0.004724027588963509, 0.028462745249271393, -0.022604646161198616, -0.01653117500245571, -0.040521811693906784, -0.01189220231026411, 0.01182366069406271, 0.005859579425305128, 0.02151200734078884, 0.004865560680627823, 0.00290065654553473, 0.06160110980272293, -0.002388773486018181, 0.030281906947493553, -0.03819117695093155, -0.02771187014877796, -0.038269732147455215, 0.0229029580950737, 0.006490642670542002, 0.0504864938557148, 0.006079932674765587, 0.0034119724296033382, -0.018945837393403053, 0.01104612834751606, 0.06605857610702515, 0.014020400121808052, 0.021209610626101494, -0.04630887135863304, -0.007730304729193449, 0.004802157171070576, -0.03519032150506973, -0.060818061232566833, -0.008690951392054558, 0.00421918835490942, 0.03363543003797531, 0.05428877845406532, 0.012570525519549847, -0.011497934348881245, -0.04963238164782524, 0.05642616003751755, -0.017496753484010696, 0.005174383986741304, -0.0204254612326622, -0.0042713843286037445, -0.01451614685356617, -0.03437543660402298 ]
<p>I want to test the influence of exchange rates on a price index and struggle with the interpretations. My variables are I(1)</p> <p>First, I ran an OLS on first differenced variables which indicated a negative short term relation between FX and PI. Then, I tested it on co-integration and constructed a VECM.</p> <p>My VECM suggests that there is a long term equilibrium with a speed of adjustment of 50% per period but no short term effect.</p> <p>Both of my models are robust.</p> <p><strong>So, what is the implication of my VECM finding?</strong></p> <p>Does a long term equilibrium mean that, in the long-run, FX will not be able to influence the price index, since these variables always rebalance back to equilibrium?</p>
74,150
[ -0.017558962106704712, -0.013829992152750492, -0.0068192435428500175, 0.011625668965280056, 0.04460743069648743, 0.05928780883550644, -0.007779710926115513, -0.011057046242058277, 0.039643336087465286, -0.04516815394163132, -0.0032272483222186565, 0.03674784302711487, 0.06677873432636261, 0.01942436397075653, 0.0047249989584088326, 0.005860865581780672, 0.020226646214723587, -0.048463329672813416, -0.004541486967355013, -0.010176744312047958, -0.014574280008673668, 0.037430062890052795, 0.003023521974682808, 0.022864174097776413, -0.04824087768793106, 0.036224182695150375, 0.019702205434441566, -0.015085337683558464, -0.013299863785505295, 0.05010383948683739, 0.0061365277506411076, -0.0021133585833013058, -0.011343835853040218, 0.007631394080817699, 0.02239520475268364, 0.04180910065770149, 0.008872957900166512, -0.053096313029527664, -0.020481470972299576, 0.04937995225191116, -0.025912590324878693, 0.01392856240272522, 0.0352669283747673, 0.023791180923581123, -0.001275850459933281, 0.005437172949314117, 0.005985637195408344, -0.0033689301926642656, 0.04111158475279808, -0.0033890833146870136, 0.06707333028316498, 0.030573604628443718, 0.012726673856377602, 0.04748646914958954, 0.0057568978518247604, -0.03415711224079132, 0.04495033621788025, 0.06434877216815948, -0.016217362135648727, -0.023247715085744858, -0.016001131385564804, -0.02220439538359642, 0.020747099071741104, 0.009879572317004204, -0.03786040470004082, 0.033126816153526306, -0.012005596421658993, 0.006559818051755428, 0.02868836559355259, -0.004493059124797583, 0.017397847026586533, 0.01679128408432007, 0.0026245464105159044, 0.005918475333601236, 0.03954979404807091, -0.028353584930300713, 0.011755961924791336, 0.01974920928478241, 0.027915112674236298, 0.044505275785923004, -0.014021230861544609, 0.026021672412753105, 0.036041662096977234, 0.0653037503361702, 0.050569601356983185, -0.01471433974802494, 0.06862007081508636, -0.030582604929804802, 0.0006807217723689973, 0.050743114203214645, -0.0001962268288480118, 0.0127578629180789, 0.03329206258058548, -0.020921682938933372, -0.06077687069773674, 0.021342871710658073, -0.012619695626199245, 0.04837546497583389, 0.008944259025156498, 0.005222924053668976, -0.0029657098930329084, -0.05026894807815552, -0.003560303943231702, 0.011057531461119652, -0.004349134862422943, 0.008031767792999744, -0.013297928497195244, -0.010265491902828217, -0.00720882136374712, -0.08346185088157654, -0.011810017749667168, 0.01832825317978859, -0.024765262380242348, 0.011588724330067635, 0.023893136531114578, -0.0076538510620594025, -0.013037662021815777, -0.02228870801627636, 0.029103167355060577, 0.0330880731344223, 0.02767968364059925, -0.02067738026380539, 0.027326732873916626, -0.0011045429855585098, -0.08943384885787964, -0.015931079164147377, -0.009647812694311142, -0.025011509656906128, -0.061293985694646835, 0.040186211466789246, 0.043901387602090836, -0.040321070700883865, 0.007736054714769125, -0.013361535966396332, 0.05679117515683174, 0.022192124277353287, -0.07781347632408142, -0.06751403957605362, 0.060754530131816864, -0.019164403900504112, -0.009073514491319656, -0.10200202465057373, -0.01986147277057171, 0.017709270119667053, 0.06629199534654617, -0.016610069200396538, 0.026140324771404266, 0.008121822960674763, 0.04568811133503914, 0.052463334053754807, -0.05506201460957527, -0.05367153137922287, -0.0043922048062086105, -0.0180291049182415, 0.012486951425671577, -0.09177196770906448, -0.006505435798317194, 0.048448093235492706, -0.014055662788450718, -0.013651669956743717, 0.04433349892497063, 0.04770071431994438, -0.02083870954811573, -0.012332401238381863, -0.016378996893763542, -0.022641770541667938, 0.05669694393873215, -0.003936569672077894, 0.04475189000368118, 0.03264860808849335, -0.0012783329002559185, 0.019020462408661842, -0.008144758641719818, 0.01470196433365345, 0.013343614526093006, -0.052326500415802, 0.023224186152219772, -0.029883569106459618, 0.0064032659865915775, 0.010506438091397285, -0.05178678408265114, -0.039826761931180954, -0.030991999432444572, -0.012615375220775604, 0.02683311142027378, 0.04451267421245575, -0.029323503375053406, 0.0164867602288723, 0.007374481298029423, -0.06584590673446655, -0.07103778421878815, -0.0631580725312233, 0.010009754449129105, 0.018534772098064423, -0.04076790437102318, 0.023212691769003868, -0.024249926209449768, -0.0009316544164903462, -0.011071743443608284, -0.009927320294082165, -0.039600569754838943, 0.0056498064659535885, 0.03655894845724106, -0.019650166854262352, 0.04019764065742493, 0.008425014093518257, 0.03847378492355347, -0.0045488327741622925, 0.006670793518424034, 0.0006702311220578849, -0.04498990997672081, 0.023802470415830612, -0.0320042259991169, 0.01944896951317787, 0.023198924958705902, -0.043821677565574646, 0.004949905909597874, 0.006145818624645472, 0.0037741593550890684, 0.058049313724040985, -0.03164033964276314, 0.05241716280579567, 0.053746871650218964, -0.012993869371712208, 0.015347309410572052, 0.02880590781569481, 0.02878660149872303, 0.06045600771903992, -0.037477411329746246, -0.020458431914448738, -0.04785297438502312, -0.022939123213291168, 0.0077378638088703156, 0.04869009181857109, -0.02691633068025112, 0.01972787268459797, 0.0668426975607872, -0.013323606923222542, -0.005669960752129555, 0.04938637092709541, 0.03963962942361832, -0.02334410510957241, 0.013032583519816399, -0.009841189719736576, 0.027535876259207726, 0.03674031421542168, 0.031073197722434998, -0.008904007263481617, -0.0055371979251503944, -0.021529778838157654, 0.03521934524178505, 0.054477594792842865, 0.013251629658043385, 0.018664192408323288, -0.020878946408629417, -0.020876150578260422, 0.04320625960826874, -0.01230582594871521, 0.006616692990064621, 0.01871620863676071, 0.04126705229282379, -0.022553717717528343, -0.012436341494321823, 0.017423011362552643, 0.023621929809451103, -0.01686285436153412, -0.02234145626425743, -0.00968377199023962, 0.02038324438035488, -0.043764226138591766, -0.00503973662853241, 0.019000651314854622, -0.022988228127360344, -0.010676352307200432, 0.01116520632058382, 0.02954522892832756, -0.011477104388177395, -0.0008214166737161577, -0.01404157467186451, -0.01937362179160118, 0.03016740083694458, -0.022576555609703064, -0.018047044053673744, 0.015994347631931305, -0.03396378085017204, 0.038201041519641876, -0.04380783811211586, -0.03913286328315735, 0.01908109150826931, -0.012279384769499302, 0.06289102882146835, 0.041138384491205215, -0.016315508633852005, -0.04049617424607277, -0.05115089565515518, -0.017015749588608742, 0.007786978967487812, -0.053002651780843735, -0.04577985033392906, 0.03440789133310318, 0.01797495223581791, -0.0139267323538661, 0.023815494030714035, -0.054693419486284256, -0.008672968484461308, -0.01014118641614914, -0.012163927778601646, -0.014124372974038124, -0.03154640644788742, 0.012671580538153648, -0.006645292043685913, -0.02901705540716648, 0.001140313339419663, -0.05782853811979294, -0.06750901788473129, 0.029772264882922173, 0.01246917899698019, 0.0096967164427042, -0.005985775962471962, -0.07902521640062332, 0.07548052817583084, 0.017956029623746872, 0.0030626875814050436, -0.042572613805532455, -0.0006183853256516159, -0.01913049817085266, -0.05153992399573326, 0.0014726025983691216, -0.007453523110598326, 0.010599816218018532, 0.03752033784985542, -0.0005136264953762293, 0.019853146746754646, 0.006704942788928747, 0.015861785039305687, -0.014717776328325272, 0.017313793301582336, -0.005859463941305876, -0.0009981606854125857, 0.0013476762687787414, 0.0191063042730093, 0.006458827760070562, -0.029783496633172035, 0.034659452736377716, 0.01703519932925701, 0.04713001847267151, -0.04683864489197731, 0.03855719417333603, 0.0012729341397061944, -0.0034503876231610775, -0.020344754680991173, 0.04047299176454544, 0.03226984292268753, 0.0007646265439689159, -0.025764724239706993, -0.05297911912202835, 0.02772778458893299, -0.00422183470800519, 0.0072264778427779675, 0.06917065382003784, 0.013289885595440865, 0.01142135076224804, -0.02619025483727455, -0.025448549538850784, 0.01611301302909851, -0.0178616214543581, -0.03211043402552605, -0.004815747495740652, 0.05056292191147804, 0.0194960068911314, 0.02692515216767788, -0.0011106043821200728, -0.05970895662903786, 0.001059541362337768, -0.06790153682231903, -0.0032728395890444517, -0.006193377543240786, 0.05185893550515175, 0.024809356778860092, 0.0298725888133049, 0.05960574001073837, -0.0018338903319090605, -0.00429810443893075, 0.006487950216978788, -0.06873171031475067, 0.06395398080348969, -0.022101804614067078, -0.006864568218588829, -0.016119524836540222, -0.02234221063554287, -0.0013202117988839746, -0.011544273234903812, 0.020629500970244408, -0.019177701324224472, 0.009622573852539062, -0.022779181599617004, -0.00042485835729166865, -0.016330527141690254, -0.016511494293808937, 0.00186307227704674, -0.010131699964404106, 0.022266240790486336, -0.02911275066435337, 0.03687572851777077, 0.04799974337220192, -0.018243033438920975, 0.015098966658115387, -0.025522679090499878, 0.0015123642515391111, 0.03822191432118416, 0.013688462786376476, 0.03154613822698593, -0.01595592126250267, -0.034088779240846634, 0.06271245330572128, 0.07618600130081177, 0.040742870420217514, 0.05022819712758064, 0.034764066338539124, -0.01287063304334879, -0.049107640981674194, -0.017500529065728188, 0.04112475737929344, 0.04444325715303421, 0.026792222633957863, -0.007751105818897486, 0.05726373568177223, 0.012482930906116962, -0.032390013337135315, -0.01480565220117569, 0.08915922045707703, 0.03587323799729347, 0.022996176034212112, -0.018334634602069855, -0.04387878254055977, -0.005984747316688299, 0.027459854260087013, 0.021508466452360153, 0.0013991942396387458, -0.027565835043787956, -0.010663268156349659, 0.055221397429704666, 0.012230435386300087, -0.03453337028622627, 0.03087983839213848, -0.0008111370261758566, 0.028279565274715424, 0.012080776505172253, -0.03754844889044762, 0.025385037064552307, 0.023804454132914543, 0.027025315910577774, 0.043712224811315536, -0.008643058128654957, -0.08216014504432678, -0.0019668741151690483, 0.03349371254444122, 0.0295611172914505, -0.035530466586351395, -0.018704837188124657, -0.06938370317220688, -0.011164985597133636, 0.01791142113506794, -0.039662908762693405, 0.012745666317641735, -0.020435215905308723, 0.027791351079940796, -0.03692386671900749, -0.06185787171125412, -0.060580819845199585, 0.010845109820365906, -0.0006825881428085268, 0.03989094868302345, -0.04343940690159798, -0.039113711565732956, -0.03621723875403404, -0.004919671919196844, 0.039772406220436096, -0.006077266298234463, 0.007960193790495396, 0.02156093157827854, -0.0054360865615308285, 0.013396776281297207, -0.00021891891083214432, -0.09768953919410706, 0.04708876088261604, -0.017654825001955032, 0.02127668634057045, 0.03100399114191532, -0.0005709743709303439, -0.041635800153017044, 0.02478954754769802, 0.01782720535993576, 0.029915673658251762, 0.018756119534373283, -0.0486847423017025, 0.05674942955374718, 0.021248815581202507, -0.004852204117923975, 0.02632155455648899, 0.007550452835857868, 0.010006320662796497, 0.03832688555121422, 0.01959184557199478, -0.0018202938372269273, -0.034631237387657166, 0.023739570751786232, -0.010170331224799156, -0.00910874828696251, -0.012410635128617287, 0.01728896051645279, 0.02329857647418976, 0.04503841698169708, -0.05129294469952583, 0.0011076482478529215, 0.008669842965900898, 0.038098737597465515, 0.009391559287905693, -0.0054207914508879185, -0.019048018380999565, -0.0075579313561320305, -0.0039027584716677666, -0.013981438241899014, -0.004162462893873453, -0.03985489532351494, -0.02118869312107563, 0.012934897094964981, -0.01752934604883194, 0.015218411572277546, 0.009113618172705173, -0.009768801741302013, -0.024342771619558334, -0.0210996363312006, 0.025202834978699684, -0.02246958576142788, 0.005811791867017746, 0.015347016975283623, -0.04915377125144005, 0.00477828923612833, 0.003598396433517337, -0.0011571059003472328, 0.016111448407173157, -0.008671189658343792, 0.0317462757229805, 0.015781762078404427, 0.0059112426824867725, -0.06551642715930939, -0.06878646463155746, 0.02943960763514042, -0.0358562096953392, -0.04966374859213829, 0.021830402314662933, -0.016289308667182922, -0.02650195173919201, -0.022153984755277634, -0.04069891199469566, 0.03481096401810646, -0.012853551656007767, 0.006615035701543093, 0.04176737368106842, 0.03216283768415451, 0.050980519503355026, -0.0487821102142334, -0.026221681386232376, 0.03209630027413368, -0.04699874296784401, 0.0003527629014570266, -0.004964581225067377, 0.011029531247913837, -0.002935824217274785, 0.017991866916418076, -0.010618533007800579, -0.026459386572241783, 0.011360441334545612, -0.004850293509662151, -0.026359552517533302, 0.03896823525428772, -0.006364173721522093, -0.0023936782963573933, -0.018724758177995682, 0.02696364000439644, -0.008000089786946774, 0.03604563698172569, 0.01883494295179844, 0.00980971660465002, -0.02653498575091362, -0.03106992319226265, 0.044510260224342346, -0.02564287930727005, -0.03446941077709198, 0.024178117513656616, 0.07121555507183075, -0.023922918364405632, 0.03996963053941727, -0.013021486811339855, -0.014153949916362762, 0.0026347250677645206, -0.016760140657424927, -0.009326783008873463, 0.00692305713891983, 0.0319928377866745, -0.022918084636330605, -0.038559917360544205, -0.005148396827280521, 0.014590774662792683, 0.0608539879322052, 0.002909834263846278, 0.02771175652742386, 0.036818280816078186, 0.026159904897212982, -0.008994100615382195, 0.0004830528632737696, 0.007522255182266235, 0.011495928280055523, -0.03993232920765877, 0.02262241207063198, -0.03478952497243881, -0.026872543618083, 0.04646074399352074, 0.04606262966990471, 0.023538192734122276, -0.004992015194147825, 0.012214201502501965, 0.004570612218230963, 0.02962028607726097, -0.002407494466751814, -0.0729370042681694, 0.04630393534898758, -0.021698836237192154, 0.03207692503929138, -0.09152055531740189, -0.021289102733135223, 0.054076891392469406, 0.04205096885561943, 0.03720017522573471, -0.07217831164598465, -0.028002921491861343, -0.03944161906838417, 0.009765158407390118, 0.04016663879156113, 0.005012769252061844, 0.014661392197012901, 0.013947336934506893, 0.0638604611158371, 0.032586682587862015, -0.006261888425797224, -0.03544151782989502, -0.08296355605125427, -0.030229724943637848, -0.006852542981505394, 0.03310643881559372, 0.016990892589092255, -0.012272749096155167, -0.019187595695257187, 0.0009306496358476579, -0.06033910810947418, -0.008944784291088581, -0.017252936959266663, 0.0012983947526663542, -0.015356049872934818, 0.07526300102472305, -0.005320519208908081, 0.018468674272298813, -0.00901628378778696, 0.008318502455949783, 0.09638798981904984, 0.012682645581662655, -0.0174650177359581, -0.05004484951496124, 0.03479257598519325, 0.04892805218696594, 0.024154145270586014, -0.023526014760136604, 0.010149850510060787, 0.008631420321762562, 0.010443522594869137, 0.04053345322608948, 0.058127664029598236, -0.02714293636381626, -0.021098323166370392, 0.05846383795142174, -0.038511525839567184, 0.00823062565177679, -0.006495284847915173, -0.011388772167265415, 0.004470502957701683, -0.019605785608291626, -0.055842407047748566, 0.04169979318976402, -0.035910602658987045, -0.018147189170122147, 0.021950094029307365, -0.02752104587852955, -0.0014373131562024355, 0.013580304570496082, -0.018313955515623093, 0.0011007600696757436, 0.020048998296260834, 0.008428494445979595, -0.02368258498609066, -0.0029605457093566656, 0.02041286788880825, -0.0163063183426857, 0.03674890846014023, 0.01904035173356533, -0.0035635409876704216, -0.025665950030088425, 0.022818000987172127, 0.02130535989999771, -0.04575550556182861, -0.04935463145375252, -0.022282157093286514, 0.031080959364771843, 0.011349914595484734, -0.02902485616505146, -0.04792376607656479, -0.005382237955927849, 0.005651636514812708, -0.05596461519598961, 0.00035333348205313087, 0.002309566829353571, 0.009435644373297691, -0.037143658846616745, -0.0027786593418568373, -0.05489540472626686, 0.012818916700780392, -0.04464954137802124, 0.037255119532346725, 0.0026245086919516325, -0.08776291459798813, -0.018869522958993912, -0.037144456058740616, 0.0654410570859909, 0.00546217942610383, -0.0070470962673425674, 0.009814901277422905, -0.0022332281805574894, -0.031142396852374077, -0.013928706757724285, 0.0003438372223172337, 0.010309262201189995, -0.00630396930500865, -0.012048585340380669, -0.005380258895456791, -0.045391570776700974, -0.0383140929043293, 0.06296966224908829, -0.014457481913268566, -0.03105795755982399, -0.04560736194252968, 0.019243808463215828, 0.02470066398382187, 0.0576326958835125, -0.004494624678045511, 0.018147820606827736, -0.030876845121383667, 0.01416644174605608, 0.004647234920412302, -0.06062097102403641, -0.035820163786411285, 0.0042796446941792965, -0.026293957605957985, -0.031976353377103806, -0.025171980261802673, 0.055152978748083115, 0.025542685762047768, 0.013660553842782974, 0.02252550609409809, 0.02973856031894684, -0.0007808979135006666, 0.003618459915742278, 0.04546605795621872, -0.016104120761156082, 0.005272072274237871, 0.0328344888985157, 0.02786758914589882, -0.04579024016857147, -0.014624255709350109, -0.04524002969264984, -0.01636512763798237, -0.012847723439335823, -0.010238593444228172, -0.05679134652018547, 0.021383382380008698, -0.017281582579016685, 0.03278641402721405, -0.02346908487379551, 0.008065267466008663, -0.0231220331043005, -0.013382413424551487, 0.01325008925050497, -0.01479726005345583, 0.01439014170318842, 0.028520818799734116, -0.006190123036503792, -0.037019792944192886, 0.01833220198750496, 0.012687121517956257, 0.02097260393202305, 0.029371138662099838, 0.012561531737446785, 0.010593525134027004, 0.05120468884706497, -0.02157381922006607, -0.055646710097789764, 0.031327154487371445, -0.010698762722313404, -0.02366572804749012, 0.0013006539084017277, -0.009876907803118229, 0.018364684656262398, 0.027801573276519775, 0.017574695870280266, -0.042035263031721115, 0.06580042839050293, -0.002616561483591795, 0.026964575052261353, 0.003836577059701085, -0.044041551649570465, 0.014378954656422138, 0.006925370078533888, -0.006685785949230194, -0.014542668126523495, -0.009125163778662682, 0.02996058203279972, 0.05818038061261177, -0.010090992785990238, 0.01223920937627554, 0.03210754692554474, -0.014426087960600853, -0.01792486384510994, 0.002389468951150775, -0.014864922501146793, 0.04801125079393387, 0.028669234365224838, -0.01699685864150524, 0.034293826669454575, -0.043021950870752335, 0.013307024724781513, -0.033682212233543396, 0.015084010548889637, 0.005736665800213814, 0.03674701601266861, 0.057956013828516006, -0.03808140754699707, -0.010347610339522362, -0.01179412193596363, -0.05369524657726288, -0.010359040461480618, -0.0033232765272259712, 0.00020799374033231288, -0.046561356633901596, -0.023283444344997406, -0.028282983228564262, 0.03282318264245987, 0.04162418097257614, 0.018045583739876747, 0.04009651392698288, 0.03560582548379898, 0.02387416362762451, -0.028432929888367653, 0.039950791746377945, 0.0025741232093423605, -0.012285660952329636, -0.04221352934837341, 0.04267076402902603, -0.04468280449509621, -0.010928899981081486, 0.016148267313838005, -0.010645325295627117, 0.009599114768207073, 0.020856710150837898, 0.023340536281466484, 0.014286735095083714, 0.013270029798150063, 0.01348912063986063, 0.010116876102983952, 0.010647226125001907, -0.018932702019810677, 0.01816495694220066, 0.011422212235629559, 0.009762111119925976, 0.016123853623867035, -0.0026683148462325335, -0.056908272206783295, 0.02719380334019661, -0.017273930832743645, -0.03255956619977951, -0.004304149188101292, -0.0053174057975411415, 0.015221785753965378, 0.012945667840540409, -0.003200306324288249, 0.0008251974359154701, 0.007159155327826738, -0.04397529736161232, 0.05176382139325142, 0.03288568928837776, -0.05726760998368263, -0.012475455179810524, -0.006974613294005394, -0.010171028785407543, 0.028641799464821815, 0.01832583360373974, 0.0005569769418798387, -0.03549403324723244, 0.0010952639859169722, 0.012656653299927711, -0.002091399859637022, -0.04273981600999832, 0.012952501885592937, -0.004520037677139044, 0.03615253046154976, 0.008894183672964573, -0.015255117788910866, 0.013454348780214787, -0.03263310715556145, 0.025935621932148933, -0.052414849400520325, 0.04316136986017227, -0.000662107951939106, -0.05532544478774071, -0.02737422287464142, -0.056286074221134186, -0.054945189505815506, -0.016381092369556427, 0.0383625328540802, 0.017591532319784164, -0.0010167417349293828, 0.041116416454315186, 0.013957511633634567, 0.010177429765462875, -0.027588259428739548, 0.04921961575746536, -0.020084576681256294, -0.008235804736614227, 0.04993417114019394, -0.03599490970373154, 0.00255393423140049, -0.010159255005419254, 0.039117611944675446, -0.04696616157889366, 0.011424070224165916, -0.0024428192991763353, -0.04437160864472389, 0.02010629139840603, -0.023213166743516922, 0.008404495194554329, 0.04917058348655701, 0.017281459644436836, 0.014749210327863693, 0.010250849649310112, -0.020001204684376717, -0.09492805600166321, 0.01212193351238966, -0.03526421636343002, -0.0011400149669498205, 0.00839665625244379, -0.012037028558552265, -0.022543542087078094, -0.049896158277988434, 0.0011015442432835698, 0.0037673369515687227, -0.0344909206032753, -0.029847223311662674, 0.04422833397984505, -0.0048678042367100716, -0.0062718880362808704, 0.00263263494707644, 0.03646249324083328, 0.011973661370575428, 0.015386327169835567, 0.0020335449371486902, 0.01646486669778824, 0.04109981283545494, -0.005698434077203274, -0.010533751919865608, 0.01722070202231407, -0.001325517427176237, 0.02131863310933113, -0.020518368110060692, 0.036588359624147415, -0.041265618056058884, -0.039705805480480194, -0.00394767289981246, 0.03517366945743561, -0.01550375483930111, 0.028595101088285446, -0.011370538733899593, 0.05350635573267937, -0.05980530008673668, 0.01275603100657463, -0.010810728184878826, 0.00329502671957016, -0.03544819727540016, 0.005736734252423048, 0.03306237980723381, 0.015396353788673878, -0.010971629992127419, 0.01963883638381958, 0.006733909714967012, -0.028272569179534912, 0.016785934567451477, 0.004478260409086943, -0.019906537607312202, 0.04221712425351143, -0.03783530369400978, -0.030577829107642174, 0.033147260546684265, -0.030201248824596405, 0.003034717170521617, 0.035965561866760254, 0.017153792083263397, 0.022419508546590805, -0.03796229511499405, -0.03240927308797836, 0.004048607777804136, 0.046484384685754776, -0.05900748074054718, -0.00526680052280426, -0.0005917513044551015, -0.02612800896167755, 0.012071378529071808, -0.007556571159511805 ]
<p>Here is the problem (not homework),</p> <p>Let $U_1,\cdots,U_n$ be i.i.d. uniform$(-n,n)$ random variables. For $-n&lt;a&lt;b&lt;n$, we set $1_{U_i}(a,b)$ be the indicator function such that $1_{U_i}=1$ if $U_i\in(a,b)$ and 0 otherwise. What is approximate distribution as n large of $U_1+,\cdots,+U_n$.</p> <p>I computed the characteristic function of $U_1+,\cdots,+U_n$, i.e., $\phi(t) = \left(\frac{sin(nt)}{nt}\right)^n$, but I don't know how to get the final result. By the way, I have no idea to use the hint in the problem. Please provide me some hints or references. Thanks!</p>
74,151
[ -0.0016186535358428955, -0.04289751872420311, -0.0039059603586792946, 0.018890079110860825, 0.02775140292942524, 0.0223299078643322, 0.00791541300714016, -0.021739332005381584, -0.006291944533586502, -0.04203258827328682, 0.02226267009973526, 0.02057420276105404, 0.021433169022202492, 0.04635533690452576, 0.008883165195584297, 0.01809796877205372, -0.055759042501449585, -0.007779443636536598, -0.022461527958512306, -0.03612443059682846, 0.03940717130899429, 0.025975843891501427, 0.021580394357442856, -0.01348632201552391, -0.07101087272167206, -0.006807470228523016, 0.016282353550195694, -0.040295086801052094, -0.014831025153398514, 0.056451648473739624, -0.05325138196349144, -0.013908271677792072, 0.047624677419662476, 0.05860662832856178, 0.0023433344904333353, 0.01928113028407097, -0.04088487848639488, -0.01919764280319214, 0.015738273039460182, 0.009976550936698914, -0.04665602371096611, -0.055640481412410736, -0.023185154423117638, 0.024584675207734108, 0.011371903121471405, -0.012415503151714802, -0.01874300092458725, -0.033239804208278656, 0.048414457589387894, -0.052125200629234314, 0.09883449226617813, 0.011171991005539894, 0.04299844801425934, 0.010284464806318283, 0.003404562594369054, -0.054809633642435074, 0.03386959806084633, 0.07750841230154037, 0.013688591308891773, -0.030543794855475426, 0.012791678309440613, -0.043933093547821045, -0.010197829455137253, -0.02427971363067627, -0.01886625401675701, 0.0157320536673069, -0.047947246581315994, -0.04087193310260773, 0.022302214056253433, -0.01657426729798317, 0.03138115629553795, 0.02713710255920887, 0.00813534390181303, -0.04293284937739372, 0.013770826160907745, 0.008418304845690727, 0.007736710365861654, 0.007977444678544998, 0.03382765129208565, 0.005056088324636221, -0.06205117329955101, 0.040934640914201736, 0.06733381003141403, 0.037779733538627625, 0.019807010889053345, -0.009609001688659191, 0.061107803136110306, 0.004688257817178965, 0.049476657062768936, 0.02022138237953186, -0.04738610237836838, 0.00964666809886694, 0.023632291704416275, 0.0023287925869226456, -0.038244251161813736, 0.03397924825549126, -0.002377735683694482, 0.03006056882441044, -0.0010489524574950337, -0.047229114919900894, -0.021988676860928535, -0.050597433000802994, 0.0759197399020195, 0.08699367940425873, -0.027189379557967186, -0.034003667533397675, -0.05099746584892273, 0.004349633120000362, 0.031475238502025604, -0.008396720513701439, -0.020633086562156677, 0.04700980335474014, -0.00674169696867466, -0.02114878036081791, 0.026937957853078842, -0.00617150729522109, 0.034448977559804916, -0.012277597561478615, 0.007562773767858744, 0.0572630949318409, 0.0756380558013916, 0.004858197644352913, 0.07090576738119125, -0.018906570971012115, -0.04339776933193207, -0.0025935417506843805, 0.02692766673862934, 0.011302507482469082, -0.044136494398117065, 0.05633964017033577, -0.0032660476863384247, -0.05185917019844055, 0.029913345351815224, 0.013369467109441757, 0.037183478474617004, -0.021080318838357925, -0.05781956762075424, -0.046722158789634705, 0.03191943094134331, -0.018443182110786438, 0.029198115691542625, -0.06717455387115479, 0.010602923110127449, 0.05716438591480255, 0.032891646027565, 0.013873995281755924, 0.028108883649110794, -0.0017784407828003168, 0.03927355259656906, 0.03796393424272537, -0.03536656126379967, 0.0004931515431962907, -0.02166065387427807, -0.03320174291729927, 0.014864830300211906, -0.06939322501420975, 0.021976888179779053, 0.017067989334464073, 0.015668414533138275, -0.040124665945768356, 0.022917162626981735, -0.005607003346085548, 0.022485217079520226, -0.04565734416246414, 0.023338081315159798, -0.013702630996704102, 0.10312924534082413, 0.0031173594761639833, 0.00036170866223983467, 0.03221142664551735, -0.016568858176469803, -0.005352695472538471, 0.0008768440457060933, 0.03996068984270096, 0.039014365524053574, -0.029911518096923828, 0.008494634181261063, -0.02597387507557869, -0.006025710608810186, 0.03847473859786987, -0.01141695398837328, -0.018541187047958374, -0.024158025160431862, -0.001727850642055273, 0.012366928160190582, 0.03405372053384781, 0.004967504180967808, -0.02134295366704464, 0.03145093098282814, -0.02673003263771534, -0.018526801839470863, -0.015191452577710152, 0.006506526842713356, 0.008109455928206444, -0.04658356308937073, 0.04339732974767685, 0.015153936110436916, 0.011579803191125393, 0.009219499304890633, -0.014020366594195366, -0.05379214882850647, -0.012793634086847305, 0.01577623374760151, -0.06206967681646347, 0.014500378631055355, 0.014955691061913967, 0.025747785344719887, -0.02850884012877941, 0.07043720781803131, -0.026215894147753716, -0.018777916207909584, 0.002920054132118821, -0.031777143478393555, 0.02423795312643051, -0.014699086546897888, -0.03588900715112686, -0.00426187738776207, -0.031316906213760376, -0.00665311561897397, 0.013344711624085903, -0.049186479300260544, 0.04460471495985985, 0.046544793993234634, 0.03921419009566307, -0.0027566824574023485, 0.013172014616429806, 0.040944281965494156, 0.022230034694075584, -0.0017919536912813783, -0.043572042137384415, -0.04588396102190018, 0.020711809396743774, 0.050424519926309586, 0.04104717820882797, -0.017881156876683235, -0.018544360995292664, 0.05677744373679161, 0.008222563192248344, 0.052054211497306824, 0.016513433307409286, -0.00543323066085577, -0.02002558670938015, 0.014410608448088169, 0.047784771770238876, -0.0014469593297690153, -0.013509630225598812, -0.006171310320496559, 0.005513476207852364, 0.012879574671387672, 0.0004616582009475678, -0.017357900738716125, 0.00980366487056017, 0.006132667418569326, 0.03310061991214752, -0.0336296446621418, 0.043601762503385544, 0.05926404893398285, -0.007908209227025509, 0.0003531393886078149, 0.021582428365945816, 0.005949694197624922, 0.010344521142542362, 0.018963469192385674, -0.030499141663312912, 0.0573660172522068, 0.013807118870317936, -0.00026150792837142944, -0.04148031398653984, 0.019500184804201126, -0.022101065143942833, 0.013447968289256096, -0.02914338931441307, -0.01328346412628889, 0.004040279425680637, 0.004174026194959879, 0.04197291284799576, 0.04260987043380737, -0.016845354810357094, -0.03625020012259483, -0.00854960735887289, -0.004920223727822304, 0.005939384922385216, 0.03341756388545036, 0.0009575571748428047, -0.04753957688808441, 0.018976429477334023, 0.0010587108554318547, -0.0229741670191288, 0.05135282129049301, -0.015323447063565254, 0.00004176528091193177, -0.013201975263655186, 0.00414160406216979, -0.06539515405893326, -0.007838192395865917, -0.026522282510995865, 0.01615111716091633, -0.039291396737098694, -0.019747698679566383, 0.02296193689107895, 0.03338472545146942, -0.01469102781265974, 0.02745702862739563, -0.031655725091695786, -0.04114717245101929, -0.022159529849886894, -0.004247922450304031, 0.035778217017650604, -0.0005806328845210373, 0.05090988054871559, 0.0014042268740013242, -0.0005401832750067115, -0.017556369304656982, -0.041460007429122925, -0.04687882214784622, 0.009929823689162731, 0.016369545832276344, 0.029918445274233818, -0.008792221546173096, -0.012864642776548862, 0.050540726631879807, -0.004573417361825705, -0.014124280773103237, 0.032998789101839066, -0.004108998458832502, -0.00022021371114533395, 0.006844120565801859, -0.03351205959916115, 0.013116221874952316, -0.010358594357967377, 0.03893124684691429, 0.026782914996147156, 0.0035950937308371067, 0.06160736456513405, 0.032742660492658615, 0.01475843507796526, 0.04538363218307495, -0.02436213567852974, 0.022178715094923973, -0.0009334792848676443, -0.000019077444449067116, -0.00421019084751606, 0.00019407091895118356, -0.0027999570593237877, 0.0008341720094904304, 0.00828277226537466, -0.02161276340484619, 0.025900380685925484, 0.005049896892160177, 0.03217155858874321, -0.007459702435880899, 0.01683950424194336, 0.015020742081105709, -0.03005681373178959, -0.023898689076304436, 0.03769250214099884, 0.039024773985147476, -0.01813732087612152, 0.004774995613843203, 0.025237178429961205, 0.026474665850400925, -0.015255341306328773, -0.004754872992634773, -0.021830076351761818, 0.016428155824542046, 0.008153557777404785, -0.02416813187301159, -0.011472535319626331, 0.0171134602278471, 0.0636051669716835, -0.004881547763943672, 0.0012244925601407886, -0.02408023364841938, 0.0025153602473437786, -0.046831950545310974, -0.015646666288375854, -0.058123018592596054, 0.061518698930740356, 0.01036752201616764, 0.02599388360977173, 0.000263303576502949, 0.021817415952682495, 0.0034118450712412596, 0.02310235984623432, -0.06937218457460403, 0.0519145242869854, -0.011453498154878616, -0.0033419744577258825, -0.0033051669597625732, -0.026715781539678574, 0.06139387562870979, 0.012029001489281654, 0.012661986984312534, 0.021686814725399017, -0.0072256592102348804, -0.02675728127360344, -0.003508236026391387, -0.02065861225128174, -0.015825867652893066, -0.0398736335337162, 0.01602070778608322, -0.02070309780538082, -0.027695009484887123, 0.02186623588204384, 0.008105194196105003, -0.03532528877258301, -0.009191674180328846, -0.04552162066102028, 0.010796966031193733, -0.01520590577274561, 0.028262276202440262, 0.02373645268380642, 0.04311102628707886, -0.013914988376200199, -0.0039499676786363125, -0.0044885971583426, 0.07004117965698242, 0.022641712799668312, -0.006892580073326826, -0.011552630923688412, -0.044479966163635254, -0.03431078419089317, 0.02548835054039955, 0.046950727701187134, 0.006442919839173555, -0.013269717805087566, 0.04998820275068283, -0.022908683866262436, -0.02434566617012024, 0.009621808305382729, 0.007459169719368219, -0.007006129715591669, 0.0022505547385662794, -0.010883761569857597, 0.004012356046587229, 0.019971653819084167, 0.010518022812902927, 0.04575483500957489, 0.0007570565212517977, -0.017519304528832436, -0.018588630482554436, 0.051096100360155106, 0.027556033805012703, 0.0019760234281420708, -0.0005766628892160952, 0.006506922654807568, 0.02589799463748932, 0.018374694511294365, -0.026890063658356667, 0.04083360731601715, 0.006302168592810631, 0.04686421528458595, 0.03841206431388855, 0.012943816371262074, -0.05369117110967636, -0.008643701672554016, 0.017005911096930504, 0.004751555621623993, -0.03106383979320526, -0.020354121923446655, -0.06422889977693558, -0.0016512772999703884, 0.05904914811253548, -0.00571148656308651, 0.013223744928836823, 0.0007578561780974269, -0.005296712275594473, -0.018722370266914368, -0.057789396494627, -0.04804933816194534, -0.009618358686566353, -0.011801941320300102, 0.03219461813569069, -0.02086663991212845, -0.0317569226026535, -0.037522878497838974, 0.004396779928356409, 0.03582439944148064, 0.10700773447751999, -0.02558509074151516, -0.040257085114717484, 0.008816313929855824, 0.026522831991314888, 0.028586195781826973, -0.07582436501979828, 0.06180717796087265, -0.005500456318259239, -0.0034971211571246386, 0.04603228718042374, -0.0525473952293396, -0.04571472108364105, 0.05319122225046158, 0.010244020260870457, 0.0031477585434913635, -0.011042804457247257, -0.03432002663612366, 0.04798315465450287, 0.006295764818787575, -0.010951059870421886, 0.029286721721291542, 0.008741895668208599, 0.03045842796564102, -0.012220037169754505, 0.0031115850433707237, 0.026706835255026817, -0.03710079565644264, -0.010163280181586742, -0.0015464085154235363, -0.037222158163785934, -0.03500276431441307, 0.048812124878168106, 0.007267154287546873, 0.015589464455842972, -0.022233329713344574, -0.013754119165241718, -0.0019594004843384027, 0.005651511251926422, -0.004721175413578749, 0.031327180564403534, 0.013442127965390682, 0.013394677080214024, 0.03549009934067726, -0.023727184161543846, 0.0005401537637226284, -0.04701300337910652, -0.004409311339259148, 0.034887731075286865, -0.012789583764970303, 0.005462202709168196, -0.02729322388768196, -0.01977616734802723, -0.019172679632902145, -0.044908542186021805, 0.04300977289676666, 0.008185389451682568, 0.058422017842531204, 0.01522738579660654, -0.04142855480313301, -0.0005735715385526419, 0.02949400246143341, 0.03939300402998924, 0.06486497074365616, -0.04019516333937645, 0.007690763566643, -0.0027672199066728354, -0.008288460783660412, -0.06309640407562256, -0.04449145495891571, 0.014592064544558525, 0.03904954716563225, -0.02759096398949623, -0.06285910308361053, -0.011816621758043766, -0.007077059242874384, -0.012172786518931389, 0.0050949822179973125, 0.0243229977786541, -0.0008350213174708188, -0.026238637045025826, 0.011743860319256783, 0.027474205940961838, 0.09379397332668304, -0.0035728877410292625, -0.01830841600894928, 0.047562118619680405, -0.027894729748368263, -0.04221055656671524, 0.017443586140871048, 0.03129621222615242, -0.03510376065969467, 0.015371765941381454, 0.00703838188201189, 0.00801754929125309, 0.012727193534374237, -0.02802077867090702, -0.04039091616868973, 0.036578964442014694, 0.024043254554271698, 0.010299686342477798, 0.007417113985866308, -0.018811631947755814, -0.0023591674398630857, -0.013959025032818317, -0.04001622274518013, -0.019939595833420753, -0.005172440782189369, -0.006145802326500416, 0.0442189946770668, -0.00838383287191391, 0.028056873008608818, -0.0026434168685227633, 0.061906393617391586, -0.017407098785042763, -0.02693481370806694, 0.00946703553199768, 0.0436147004365921, 0.03960590437054634, 0.0026466757990419865, -0.0037130536511540413, 0.010441635735332966, -0.007941287010908127, -0.013923405669629574, -0.040691446512937546, -0.06753704696893692, 0.018391672521829605, 0.03589484840631485, 0.01870298758149147, 0.04328589513897896, 0.011483105830848217, 0.015728777274489403, -0.01297709159553051, 0.022314192727208138, -0.019925948232412338, -0.01855003833770752, -0.012661190703511238, 0.020384017378091812, -0.022467557340860367, 0.005450160708278418, 0.0011824136599898338, -0.0037276458460837603, 0.03390802443027496, 0.06255988776683807, -0.028797907754778862, 0.02544996328651905, 0.018735893070697784, 0.003724348032847047, -0.04133446887135506, 0.026029057800769806, -0.04162842407822609, 0.019171688705682755, -0.0045530409552156925, -0.008840256370604038, 0.03904665261507034, 0.040956027805805206, 0.036987755447626114, -0.02484358847141266, -0.03513341397047043, -0.02083716168999672, -0.009598741307854652, 0.016715072095394135, 0.025790546089410782, 0.009636052884161472, 0.01526656560599804, 0.0005444056587293744, 0.0037640912923961878, 0.06461293250322342, -0.017575616016983986, -0.07618234306573868, -0.00738151278346777, -0.057203348726034164, -0.05820425972342491, 0.015091334469616413, 0.004560701549053192, -0.018062176182866096, 0.07205487042665482, -0.028643427416682243, 0.009859705343842506, 0.013225643895566463, 0.019777322188019753, 0.0023386278189718723, 0.10803785920143127, 0.030181776732206345, 0.061574339866638184, 0.013074775226414204, -0.004781570751219988, 0.09651942551136017, 0.04677801951766014, 0.01270762924104929, -0.04115932434797287, 0.013842297717928886, -0.04837818443775177, -0.009074135683476925, -0.058595724403858185, -0.018186798319220543, 0.00835829135030508, -0.032275665551424026, 0.022730961441993713, 0.04329358786344528, 0.008411841467022896, 0.0163472481071949, 0.010364449582993984, -0.02726236917078495, -0.04332728311419487, 0.013386714272201061, 0.01767408475279808, 0.0024579979944974184, -0.020629387348890305, -0.008131668902933598, 0.029377873986959457, -0.019755825400352478, -0.029790518805384636, -0.07010247558355331, 0.005380184855312109, -0.005494262557476759, -0.0055504050105810165, -0.0008123826119117439, 0.00892217643558979, 0.04341789707541466, -0.031028328463435173, 0.0079169487580657, 0.017809860408306122, 0.016409361734986305, -0.025738978758454323, 0.037641867995262146, 0.020904915407299995, 0.02336345799267292, -0.002159988274797797, 0.03278769925236702, 0.01687454804778099, -0.04113044962286949, -0.0269787535071373, -0.03335703909397125, 0.043577875941991806, 0.029187703505158424, 0.009519965387880802, -0.02163037098944187, 0.024601077660918236, -0.002842050278559327, -0.023809269070625305, -0.007936161942780018, -0.02074422501027584, 0.0037553180009126663, -0.043121337890625, -0.025032110512256622, -0.0027374238707125187, 0.003717223647981882, 0.0391845740377903, 0.023363621905446053, 0.01833031326532364, -0.0520319826900959, 0.0145048126578331, 0.004736560396850109, 0.04296610876917839, -0.0072503420524299145, -0.027580510824918747, -0.004109715577214956, -0.012012885883450508, -0.01052649226039648, -0.0077766356989741325, -0.022942697629332542, -0.02856653369963169, 0.045290619134902954, 0.008570502512156963, 0.01767156831920147, -0.026004096493124962, -0.08272818475961685, 0.008053625002503395, -0.0488123893737793, -0.034351084381341934, -0.025397198274731636, -0.03408734127879143, 0.023163849487900734, 0.037226565182209015, 0.016798751428723335, -0.02632051333785057, -0.01755092851817608, 0.0797671377658844, 0.0352289043366909, -0.02158682607114315, -0.0015812343917787075, -0.033364538103342056, -0.04045993462204933, 0.02618493139743805, -0.01661120168864727, 0.045913856476545334, 0.04716267064213753, 0.006698473356664181, 0.024641577154397964, 0.007902142591774464, -0.0535590723156929, -0.007017643190920353, -0.0444425605237484, -0.06304491311311722, 0.001494234660640359, 0.02906748652458191, -0.022665852680802345, -0.01555086299777031, -0.015509514138102531, -0.007626787759363651, 0.002350996481254697, 0.004487563855946064, -0.017892222851514816, -0.024680597707629204, -0.024988388642668724, -0.00845426693558693, -0.02561425417661667, -0.015498381108045578, 0.0008986309985630214, 0.009377304464578629, -0.015020790509879589, -0.02303207479417324, 0.023715808987617493, -0.04174449294805527, 0.04276423901319504, -0.015584367327392101, -0.022414077073335648, 0.008676283061504364, 0.005857477895915508, 0.021503543481230736, 0.00243236287496984, 0.007615529932081699, -0.032001763582229614, 0.0332728736102581, -0.011745895259082317, -0.029867665842175484, 0.057021282613277435, -0.037114012986421585, -0.025128750130534172, 0.011197969317436218, 0.0027349572628736496, 0.03568495064973831, 0.0009366770391352475, -0.007739492692053318, -0.02801331877708435, 0.04274509474635124, -0.01609823666512966, -0.02462843805551529, 0.03888281062245369, -0.00106374965980649, 0.002904938766732812, -0.0366840660572052, -0.014831701293587685, 0.004829836077988148, 0.026391077786684036, 0.005592602305114269, 0.04660505801439285, -0.00028438313165679574, -0.016612783074378967, 0.029476545751094818, 0.010673384182155132, 0.02975691296160221, 0.0011896316427737474, 0.007464196998625994, 0.014646400697529316, 0.04563156142830849, -0.011081748642027378, -0.03880338743329048, -0.04091625288128853, 0.02193567529320717, -0.07149618119001389, -0.040031932294368744, 0.029876384884119034, -0.033982567489147186, 0.05510883778333664, -0.07270311564207077, -0.02118598110973835, 0.04820459708571434, -0.04242436960339546, 0.027754364535212517, -0.024135684594511986, 0.012929695658385754, -0.0657108947634697, -0.01896837167441845, -0.04063156992197037, 0.004453178029507399, 0.0036193097475916147, 0.026997612789273262, 0.04894706606864929, 0.03206673264503479, -0.048848509788513184, -0.04431577026844025, 0.0015552910044789314, -0.01031870674341917, 0.031157201156020164, -0.04676974192261696, 0.031089039519429207, -0.011972893960773945, -0.040436144918203354, 0.046053871512413025, -0.03813359513878822, -0.05135979503393173, -0.004572269041091204, 0.0444205179810524, 0.008461150340735912, 0.032748427242040634, 0.04598546400666237, 0.00827579852193594, 0.006714732851833105, -0.019164882600307465, 0.04182783514261246, -0.013109924271702766, -0.044816333800554276, 0.001122616813518107, 0.030488191172480583, -0.02029690518975258, -0.030245637521147728, 0.014141709543764591, 0.0343947596848011, -0.011381122283637524, 0.006366162560880184, -0.058807361871004105, 0.0024980686139315367, -0.06555352360010147, 0.007989129051566124, -0.02408450096845627, -0.03942655771970749, 0.018004246056079865, 0.03843298181891441, 0.011597036384046078, 0.0009981505572795868, -0.004934980068355799, -0.0633007138967514, 0.01888958550989628, -0.012060272507369518, -0.031118398532271385, -0.052222155034542084, 0.002907807705923915, -0.004141929559409618, 0.014370896853506565, -0.042677950114011765, -0.05453621596097946, -0.048153072595596313, 0.02988857962191105, 0.007026893086731434, -0.002212062245234847, 0.02127092331647873, -0.013852939009666443, -0.0250768531113863, -0.06251592189073563, 0.02079998329281807, -0.01570950634777546, -0.004811412189155817, -0.051334962248802185, -0.022220000624656677, -0.027978666126728058, 0.03458895534276962, 0.06728490442037582, 0.03733503445982933, 0.0021692709997296333, 0.03500784561038017, -0.014600744470953941, 0.0405878908932209, -0.036789532750844955, 0.01731964759528637, -0.05220713093876839, -0.0435175895690918, -0.0006704432307742536, -0.0027717729099094868, 0.049806851893663406, 0.010791935957968235, -0.010873906314373016, -0.013473841361701488, -0.0613858699798584, 0.008286550641059875, -0.036008067429065704, 0.016728604212403297, -0.034637268632650375, 0.002737688133493066, 0.053263090550899506, -0.007669026497751474, 0.014480036683380604, -0.009643915109336376, 0.00534824887290597, -0.06548617780208588, 0.03857395425438881, -0.03693581745028496, -0.022970153018832207, 0.021502582356333733, 0.019844457507133484, -0.013888386078178883, -0.03901699185371399, -0.04294956848025322, 0.007785195019096136, -0.045744385570287704, 0.028515402227640152, 0.00948438048362732, -0.002425449201837182, 0.0568275973200798, 0.019947050139307976, -0.009931388311088085, 0.018010370433330536, 0.007871994748711586, 0.02769019827246666, 0.04575036093592644, -0.006199431139975786, -0.050161734223365784, -0.003875446505844593, -0.003275748807936907, -0.015366744250059128, 0.0424535758793354, -0.00922490656375885, 0.028941290453076363, -0.03549342602491379, 0.020505374297499657, 0.006109865382313728, -0.04145609587430954, -0.02548522874712944, 0.056099701672792435, -0.022835154086351395, 0.06114012375473976, -0.007175043225288391, 0.03311474248766899, -0.020425722002983093, -0.0084287840873003, 0.008577323518693447, 0.019030699506402016, 0.036566946655511856, -0.011274896562099457, -0.011778358370065689, 0.008872068487107754, -0.004810672719031572, -0.029210101813077927, 0.008919033221900463, -0.02533186785876751, -0.01872435212135315, -0.0004781775933224708, 0.009302402846515179, -0.0036161388270556927, -0.029893167316913605, 0.01610991731286049, -0.01426586415618658, 0.033992502838373184, 0.049861304461956024, 0.026751069352030754, 0.00017584826855454594, -0.019316483289003372, 0.0263723935931921, 0.07132493704557419, -0.07933460921049118, 0.01779114454984665, -0.03886841610074043, -0.006585207302123308, -0.027265207841992378, -0.01157535333186388 ]
<p>I was recently looking for ways to resample time series, in ways that</p> <ol> <li>Approximately preserve the auto-correlation of long memory processes.</li> <li>Preserve the domain of the observations (for instance a resampled times series of integers is still a times series of integers).</li> <li>May affect some scales only, if required.</li> </ol> <p>I came up with the following permutation scheme for a time series of length $2^N$:</p> <ul> <li>Bin the time series by pairs of consecutive observations (there are $2^{N-1}$ such bins). Flip each of them (<i>i.e.</i> index from <code>1:2</code> to <code>2:1</code>) independently with probability $1/2$.</li> <li>Bin the obtained time series by consecutive $4$ observations (thre are $2^{N-2}$ such bins). Reverse each of them (<i>i.e.</i> index from <code>1:2:3:4</code> to <code>4:3:2:1</code>) independelty with probability $1/2$.</li> <li>Repeat the procedure with bins of size $8$, $16$, ..., $2^{N-1}$ always reversing the bins with probability $1/2$.</li> </ul> <p>This design was purely empirical and I am looking for work that would have already been published on this kind of permutation. I am also open to suggestions for other permutations or resampling schemes.</p>
36,850
[ -0.014477092772722244, -0.004590450786054134, -0.008916471153497696, 0.0220386553555727, 0.03560587763786316, -0.009617382660508156, 0.0038797217421233654, 0.019163835793733597, 0.021961553022265434, -0.03675420209765434, 0.0267272237688303, 0.009247422218322754, 0.039836201816797256, 0.022106729447841644, 0.04593370854854584, 0.00037319742841646075, -0.04750987887382507, 0.02571243792772293, 0.00376149732619524, -0.03989113122224808, 0.02599729783833027, -0.0056652408093214035, 0.003219205653294921, 0.008384285494685173, -0.06976282596588135, 0.035431500524282455, -0.022621406242251396, -0.049375515431165695, -0.007894225418567657, 0.06159666180610657, -0.042786747217178345, -0.03522372245788574, 0.01965007185935974, 0.04886290803551674, -0.03523091599345207, -0.015856264159083366, -0.016976794227957726, -0.062264587730169296, 0.03510146215558052, 0.036660101264715195, -0.0808638483285904, -0.0008274504216387868, -0.05894611403346062, -0.0012584154028445482, 0.040246184915304184, -0.012978041544556618, -0.008257502689957619, -0.008040150627493858, 0.01550686452537775, -0.03430185839533806, 0.05467717722058296, 0.00423421198502183, 0.0027086776681244373, 0.02122289128601551, -0.025087738409638405, 0.000818265660200268, 0.03509996458888054, 0.0332389734685421, 0.018109606578946114, -0.04377741366624832, 0.0015361364930868149, -0.02856937237083912, 0.02610289491713047, 0.027298325672745705, -0.0060402643866837025, 0.024078482761979103, -0.022738711908459663, -0.005393252242356539, 0.01708131842315197, -0.031546931713819504, 0.04912220314145088, 0.014787745662033558, 0.038943465799093246, 0.0019995011389255524, 0.02083742246031761, 0.005631821695715189, 0.01166075561195612, 0.004548064898699522, 0.04497738927602768, 0.049745019525289536, 0.004390914924442768, 0.026405055075883865, 0.011844895780086517, 0.05348709598183632, 0.0014687199145555496, -0.00890178419649601, 0.07195776700973511, -0.04428168386220932, 0.014584249816834927, 0.029522310942411423, 0.019353648647665977, -0.027832042425870895, 0.05437660962343216, 0.020752863958477974, -0.05603203922510147, 0.029533877968788147, 0.02088266983628273, 0.03326369822025299, -0.031602777540683746, -0.02028203383088112, -0.03419717773795128, -0.02582520805299282, -0.0038429403211921453, 0.0616704598069191, -0.012939400039613247, -0.000014491071851807646, -0.009562728926539421, -0.006761545315384865, -0.022443946450948715, -0.027005819603800774, 0.005981453228741884, 0.003033539280295372, 0.018656225875020027, -0.010610395111143589, 0.016715528443455696, 0.009699263609945774, -0.020158737897872925, -0.0044019753113389015, 0.041363950818777084, 0.08997977524995804, 0.036104150116443634, -0.015852823853492737, 0.016835719347000122, -0.027037685737013817, -0.0355982668697834, 0.03828417509794235, 0.027139296755194664, -0.015142373740673065, -0.039789676666259766, 0.059376128017902374, 0.029488854110240936, -0.024982817471027374, 0.06919868290424347, -0.031261593103408813, 0.061109062284231186, 0.009572130627930164, -0.08810784667730331, -0.04617852345108986, 0.04922443628311157, -0.02664511278271675, -0.022057443857192993, -0.06507240235805511, 0.0299655944108963, 0.01723834127187729, 0.06087012588977814, -0.005848622880876064, 0.050486691296100616, 0.016132544726133347, 0.0011926688021048903, 0.06754964590072632, -0.054934754967689514, -0.0039861686527729034, 0.003914249129593372, -0.013114691711962223, 0.0031276713125407696, -0.069089874625206, 0.02511780895292759, 0.00784077774733305, -0.016077741980552673, 0.011770551092922688, 0.045953113585710526, 0.0008450489258393645, -0.02915080077946186, -0.014452564530074596, -0.01364431343972683, -0.0420076958835125, 0.07230314612388611, 0.013312214985489845, 0.024583369493484497, -0.028158782050013542, -0.036013275384902954, 0.01635180599987507, 0.023671632632613182, 0.03796936944127083, 0.017364295199513435, -0.04570448398590088, 0.005422181915491819, 0.02062174119055271, -0.00766441784799099, -0.0002591939992271364, 0.02849060669541359, -0.0015240894863381982, -0.003195597557350993, -0.010729583911597729, 0.04386669769883156, -0.001846372615545988, 0.010088431648910046, -0.020457798615098, 0.023924941197037697, -0.06112733855843544, -0.0007375732529908419, -0.037988174706697464, -0.009431908838450909, -0.008984771557152271, 0.001001738477498293, 0.046314410865306854, -0.022775009274482727, 0.04624878242611885, 0.012698333710432053, -0.07051721960306168, -0.011808508075773716, -0.013497150503098965, 0.02067636139690876, -0.046663399785757065, 0.005960405804216862, 0.028934182599186897, -0.0027458667755126953, -0.011140098795294762, 0.03114946000277996, -0.00612638657912612, -0.04624342918395996, 0.012677187100052834, -0.03430263698101044, 0.033240240067243576, -0.028188208118081093, -0.025530776008963585, 0.004638977814465761, -0.02757841721177101, -0.0003847848274745047, 0.05207023397088051, -0.023250313475728035, 0.03667362034320831, 0.04466373845934868, -0.001825768151320517, -0.004892455413937569, 0.03824089467525482, 0.03985922411084175, 0.008538348600268364, -0.052552297711372375, 0.00935212429612875, -0.07550675421953201, 0.010353736579418182, 0.044297248125076294, 0.05900444835424423, -0.03330244868993759, 0.04772546887397766, 0.0572848916053772, 0.026413150131702423, 0.0016434217104688287, 0.009056161157786846, 0.010132687166333199, -0.012765515595674515, -0.00803295336663723, 0.013535133562982082, 0.04296203702688217, -0.01795298419892788, -0.0022646128199994564, -0.01447710208594799, 0.013316472992300987, 0.03068101964890957, -0.035809747874736786, 0.008804857730865479, -0.02260690927505493, 0.01444698590785265, -0.05787291377782822, -0.05503673106431961, 0.02750382013618946, -0.00422675209119916, -0.015948494896292686, 0.024070575833320618, 0.02233201079070568, 0.016156798228621483, 0.022203033789992332, -0.006394671741873026, 0.003263975027948618, 0.0033762736711651087, -0.03259311243891716, -0.021706614643335342, 0.005304692313075066, -0.013006964698433876, 0.04139973595738411, -0.026760686188936234, -0.03346538171172142, -0.049516499042510986, 0.022088127210736275, 0.02731437236070633, 0.0008788813138380647, -0.020695507526397705, -0.011946440674364567, 0.024065814912319183, 0.029568718746304512, 0.03720954805612564, 0.039801184087991714, 0.006116632372140884, -0.0530707873404026, -0.011265847831964493, 0.01815146766602993, 0.03908727690577507, 0.017820900306105614, -0.006806508172303438, 0.01698586344718933, 0.0077360523864626884, -0.008203943260014057, -0.06573894619941711, -0.03350686654448509, -0.030060989782214165, 0.021382231265306473, -0.05498373135924339, -0.02848605439066887, 0.0943906307220459, 0.048748623579740524, -0.05091964453458786, -0.011767183430492878, -0.01270164642482996, 0.006006163079291582, -0.054828792810440063, -0.02436630055308342, 0.01720019057393074, -0.018506141379475594, 0.007986015640199184, 0.0018526845378801227, -0.014322281815111637, -0.008501934818923473, -0.03881877660751343, -0.06292080879211426, 0.0030791976023465395, 0.01618725061416626, 0.025764863938093185, 0.01678575947880745, -0.01588425412774086, 0.030018800869584084, 0.024452678859233856, 0.023928802460432053, -0.040505606681108475, -0.012027247808873653, 0.005982246249914169, -0.04828432947397232, 0.0044816904701292515, 0.01186922937631607, -0.02812793478369713, 0.011708048172295094, -0.03580787405371666, 0.03023574873805046, 0.04481121525168419, -0.016429917886853218, -0.009509798139333725, 0.020772328600287437, 0.0118777547031641, -0.023712381720542908, 0.0016631244216114283, -0.02799999713897705, -0.01831326074898243, -0.00009440231224289164, 0.0007161505054682493, -0.017701558768749237, 0.028676481917500496, -0.03754180669784546, 0.0354379303753376, -0.028124434873461723, -0.0051664924249053, -0.02980748936533928, 0.030801277607679367, 0.009150570258498192, -0.025534121319651604, -0.047329653054475784, 0.04107457399368286, 0.011469334363937378, -0.005002307239919901, 0.0641937404870987, 0.026720993220806122, 0.056376829743385315, -0.02518821693956852, -0.023768845945596695, -0.008829114958643913, -0.02560318633913994, 0.03739470615983009, -0.04369726404547691, -0.0010606409050524235, 0.012199544347822666, 0.02601233869791031, 0.029720492660999298, -0.01254451647400856, -0.02810487523674965, -0.007912400178611279, -0.05229722335934639, 0.029027683660387993, -0.054117098450660706, 0.03844946622848511, 0.009423249401152134, 0.04073343798518181, 0.02037951722741127, -0.008937089703977108, 0.001912857755087316, 0.006283126305788755, -0.05239354074001312, 0.028856106102466583, -0.01584296114742756, 0.02126704342663288, 0.004829504061490297, 0.020602989941835403, 0.055989474058151245, -0.018662774935364723, 0.03256971761584282, 0.0017241769237443805, 0.03556692972779274, -0.04060213267803192, -0.015237482264637947, -0.019020739942789078, -0.0281296968460083, 0.002580175641924143, 0.009470533579587936, 0.020516762509942055, -0.031507521867752075, 0.04586683586239815, 0.011765148490667343, 0.014144807122647762, 0.014131266623735428, -0.024656539782881737, 0.02876034379005432, 0.004274568986147642, 0.016400650143623352, 0.05008701607584953, -0.00491394754499197, -0.06716170907020569, 0.016156062483787537, 0.032778412103652954, 0.02166154235601425, 0.021890632808208466, 0.03444352000951767, 0.01529982965439558, 0.0031720874831080437, -0.020905539393424988, 0.05254887416958809, 0.02204323001205921, 0.038003064692020416, 0.023221516981720924, 0.04130372032523155, 0.03707800433039665, -0.07594210654497147, -0.007465939037501812, 0.06269720196723938, -0.011045540682971478, 0.00035115377977490425, -0.009826974011957645, -0.028304193168878555, 0.03834058716893196, 0.022199543192982674, 0.03165460005402565, -0.009939881972968578, 0.0004959551151841879, 0.02363092452287674, 0.039311766624450684, 0.033706169575452805, -0.004792551510035992, 0.04200956970453262, 0.03377010300755501, 0.05771744251251221, 0.03052772767841816, 0.004698613658547401, 0.001338341855444014, 0.005481468979269266, 0.02564825676381588, 0.054155271500349045, -0.03012149967253208, -0.08376605808734894, 0.024987133219838142, 0.026454472914338112, 0.038988206535577774, -0.024524161592125893, 0.04107870161533356, -0.06074332073330879, -0.045206066220998764, 0.020237872377038002, -0.019309230148792267, 0.059667717665433884, -0.026479676365852356, 0.005908172577619553, -0.018681446090340614, -0.02628295123577118, -0.03394865617156029, 0.008306561969220638, 0.0028051906265318394, 0.01627742499113083, -0.018524836748838425, -0.033728133887052536, -0.06363403052091599, -0.01412187609821558, 0.019381048157811165, 0.04926139861345291, -0.04362097755074501, 0.022572170943021774, -0.0068525937385857105, -0.03622674569487572, -0.031065670773386955, -0.0586501806974411, 0.013130571693181992, -0.0022382268216460943, -0.026604367420077324, 0.013888375833630562, 0.0003182733489666134, -0.03232795372605324, -0.01448672916740179, -0.01855725608766079, 0.007846447639167309, -0.009630723856389523, -0.013282709755003452, 0.06257646530866623, 0.01501361932605505, 0.006096214056015015, 0.06190596893429756, 0.07179196923971176, 0.0006317193037830293, 0.01381608285009861, -0.007981784641742706, 0.013331081718206406, -0.044680312275886536, 0.026925809681415558, -0.014867071062326431, -0.03074164316058159, -0.05530807003378868, 0.0710357055068016, 0.021076230332255363, 0.04564497992396355, 0.015341646037995815, 0.01151342038065195, -0.017898907884955406, 0.0681741014122963, -0.006534447893500328, -0.0071298484690487385, -0.006635702680796385, 0.037473782896995544, -0.009604298509657383, -0.0022792164236307144, 0.026061704382300377, -0.02691303938627243, -0.029480164870619774, 0.04899796098470688, -0.043685831129550934, 0.00860570278018713, -0.06972409039735794, 0.0011558375554159284, -0.008895644918084145, -0.005282219033688307, 0.033488135784864426, 0.0341055803000927, 0.02292613312602043, 0.000026318975869799033, -0.035652417689561844, 0.012771852314472198, 0.021424854174256325, -0.030017822980880737, 0.02244957536458969, -0.06771082431077957, 0.013954593800008297, 0.006842675618827343, -0.00011761528730858117, -0.08726324141025543, -0.05994381755590439, 0.04838193953037262, 0.015776624903082848, -0.011257829144597054, -0.03616548329591751, -0.01920638419687748, 0.0063723851926624775, -0.01832469366490841, -0.04455224797129631, 0.057749323546886444, -0.006853493396192789, -0.013792552053928375, -0.005137251690030098, 0.038743697106838226, 0.09578106552362442, 0.01681642048060894, -0.04055523872375488, 0.007179182954132557, -0.028241531923413277, -0.03326089307665825, -0.004509833175688982, -0.018313227221369743, -0.03777841478586197, -0.0009919214062392712, -0.025072945281863213, 0.00891163945198059, 0.018311336636543274, -0.048124127089977264, -0.042992159724235535, 0.03710191696882248, 0.005705342628061771, 0.001378794084303081, -0.0226327832788229, -0.027901004999876022, -0.05372890084981918, 0.022277403622865677, -0.005482214502990246, -0.02026073820888996, -0.023847335949540138, -0.019830424338579178, -0.007618176285177469, 0.021442892029881477, -0.041317783296108246, 0.02764599770307541, 0.0048946188762784, -0.012804858386516571, -0.030687758699059486, -0.006751375738531351, -0.0267068799585104, 0.01761254109442234, 0.021834276616573334, 0.026284443214535713, 0.006134637165814638, -0.020779838785529137, -0.030587883666157722, -0.03061101585626602, -0.01502892468124628, -0.033484622836112976, 0.06631256639957428, -0.007263793610036373, 0.029989615082740784, 0.050947483628988266, 0.009041068144142628, 0.04946369677782059, 0.01579435169696808, 0.03137683868408203, 0.010122949257493019, 0.006793655920773745, 0.044128574430942535, -0.011124233715236187, 0.018163517117500305, -0.008260618895292282, -0.021817661821842194, 0.042830001562833786, 0.019035065546631813, 0.024070676416158676, 0.03877299278974533, 0.011064734309911728, -0.031642477959394455, -0.015628816559910774, 0.03702465817332268, -0.03164054453372955, -0.014228224754333496, -0.023598654195666313, -0.006503100041300058, 0.04332796111702919, 0.031693410128355026, 0.02885076217353344, -0.045454323291778564, -0.05383458361029625, -0.06322120130062103, -0.013923171907663345, 0.015969598665833473, 0.0021798620000481606, 0.0337303951382637, -0.009123570285737514, 0.04843685030937195, -0.008739793673157692, 0.009648222476243973, 0.012380925938487053, -0.03771284967660904, -0.011827831156551838, -0.01656954176723957, -0.04058152064681053, 0.07709559798240662, 0.010588236153125763, -0.02639082446694374, 0.01737329736351967, -0.0009417099063284695, 0.011675294488668442, 0.03948662057518959, 0.009612088091671467, -0.022432735189795494, 0.06085434928536415, 0.018422694876790047, 0.025530291721224785, -0.05243749916553497, -0.02335539646446705, 0.1303197592496872, 0.06489159911870956, 0.022084975615143776, -0.07651118189096451, 0.017103096470236778, 0.003311580279842019, 0.019199585542082787, -0.04604822397232056, 0.011362360790371895, 0.017016824334859848, -0.024798372760415077, 0.016756320372223854, 0.06450533866882324, -0.014236771501600742, -0.010431408882141113, 0.04799320921301842, -0.004521087743341923, 0.03844250738620758, -0.0034692201297730207, 0.026088809594511986, 0.02345013990998268, -0.0077563063241541386, -0.0950717106461525, -0.018162934109568596, -0.001564922509714961, -0.013095280155539513, 0.007180432789027691, -0.03757576271891594, -0.019517606124281883, -0.021210165694355965, -0.0019983360543847084, -0.000985572929494083, 0.08000856637954712, 0.0004110053996555507, 0.035634759813547134, -0.03291018307209015, 0.005176039412617683, -0.015649907290935516, 0.02062809094786644, 0.036057546734809875, 0.008188463747501373, 0.0002648763475008309, -0.0005824066465720534, -0.010443668812513351, -0.012962670996785164, -0.06424079090356827, -0.041967231780290604, 0.018924184143543243, -0.022147849202156067, -0.006467557046562433, -0.0018872313667088747, -0.0035087335854768753, -0.005065266042947769, -0.033838193863630295, -0.022633830085396767, 0.03158511221408844, 0.019013645127415657, -0.042793646454811096, -0.023722292855381966, -0.01763085648417473, -0.02870997227728367, -0.014984125271439552, 0.05018826574087143, 0.016148459166288376, -0.012007203884422779, -0.01594683900475502, -0.0020958895329385996, 0.01980254240334034, 0.012984703294932842, -0.029992081224918365, 0.0006876274128444493, -0.017790384590625763, -0.06208227574825287, -0.02428995817899704, 0.0170427355915308, -0.011421875096857548, 0.007398603484034538, 0.025555692613124847, -0.036953553557395935, 0.0015429736813530326, -0.009670592844486237, 0.01529838889837265, -0.025657789781689644, -0.011148691177368164, -0.004250277765095234, -0.02776290662586689, 0.04332401230931282, -0.01922532357275486, 0.01755923591554165, -0.010779383592307568, 0.00011846588313346729, 0.05404097959399223, 0.04329375550150871, -0.08318987488746643, 0.01171041652560234, -0.0009595208684913814, -0.0065960050560534, -0.0022449693642556667, -0.01655304990708828, 0.05581521615386009, 0.015347946435213089, -0.0033226970117539167, -0.00008073681965470314, 0.019074879586696625, -0.026257498189806938, 0.01039686519652605, 0.029607152566313744, -0.01964126154780388, -0.00917702354490757, -0.007438678294420242, -0.018922653049230576, -0.023079536855220795, -0.04914453625679016, -0.00269153225235641, 0.007834036834537983, -0.03596539422869682, -0.021793272346258163, -0.060294363647699356, -0.02223612740635872, -0.018671482801437378, -0.0018226236570626497, 0.006533993873745203, 0.0008600223227404058, -0.026369353756308556, -0.018216567113995552, -0.04927290603518486, 0.0013307787012308836, 0.02585405483841896, 0.029254332184791565, -0.020607661455869675, -0.019020460546016693, 0.06492737680673599, 0.025988847017288208, 0.0015838606050238013, -0.018903657793998718, -0.011177007108926773, 0.009590895846486092, -0.0069509525783360004, -0.009228905662894249, -0.056674033403396606, 0.04176623001694679, -0.027103891596198082, -0.029180103912949562, 0.03110845759510994, -0.05254637077450752, 0.028910353779792786, 0.021937726065516472, -0.0018442836590111256, -0.019958486780524254, 0.023947635665535927, -0.03808560222387314, 0.007243501953780651, 0.0072739748284220695, 0.049548592418432236, 0.03299686312675476, 0.028461923822760582, 0.006079669110476971, 0.0030210220720618963, -0.008239533752202988, 0.008042673580348492, 0.06665433198213577, 0.02400362864136696, -0.0037712750490754843, 0.005032512359321117, -0.014227700419723988, 0.04518302157521248, -0.030490104109048843, -0.010885169729590416, 0.04327354580163956, 0.054086796939373016, -0.026488568633794785, 0.01617501489818096, -0.03559001907706261, -0.031614791601896286, -0.06913913786411285, 0.007540649734437466, 0.0038498681969940662, 0.020645329728722572, 0.06502687931060791, -0.051743872463703156, -0.007999816909432411, -0.007039133459329605, -0.013513592071831226, 0.05927659571170807, -0.00635204091668129, -0.01139510702341795, 0.0188478771597147, -0.0031199369113892317, -0.033200863748788834, 0.03096567466855049, 0.01886906661093235, -0.01480771042406559, 0.02929915115237236, 0.01292329654097557, 0.002310264389961958, -0.0018160546896979213, 0.0023373065050691366, -0.0030786595307290554, 0.04600485786795616, -0.039670180529356, 0.02096807025372982, -0.023852966725826263, -0.013393819332122803, 0.03933865204453468, 0.00032900343649089336, -0.008970128372311592, -0.022926844656467438, 0.005575304850935936, -0.053708452731370926, 0.03514356538653374, 0.018810642883181572, -0.019086698070168495, 0.023965245112776756, -0.021895742043852806, 0.035508643835783005, 0.017179643735289574, -0.015259752050042152, 0.0058572799898684025, 0.049613725394010544, -0.0014423925895243883, -0.02081449143588543, 0.009022404439747334, 0.00810022559016943, 0.014422688633203506, 0.0049172258004546165, 0.008712513372302055, 0.005604482255876064, 0.02247844636440277, 0.027545830234885216, -0.020270196720957756, -0.008181532844901085, 0.03263185918331146, -0.006214190274477005, 0.006355727557092905, 0.018295086920261383, -0.023255765438079834, -0.02098304219543934, 0.0036546613555401564, -0.010495820082724094, -0.01735442876815796, -0.04821547865867615, -0.026248576119542122, 0.021454185247421265, 0.01532839611172676, -0.04899951070547104, -0.01725667342543602, -0.0005360067589208484, 0.04262987896800041, -0.03242969885468483, 0.01742328703403473, 0.0031878002919256687, -0.0029698482248932123, 0.021831316873431206, -0.06430580466985703, 0.0332517996430397, -0.008715967647731304, -0.004001431167125702, -0.030723320320248604, -0.020994888618588448, -0.013214627280831337, 0.01430661603808403, 0.0780106708407402, 0.020071515813469887, 0.0105369808152318, -0.008393310941755772, 0.026131603866815567, 0.04172137379646301, -0.020984169095754623, 0.029525917023420334, -0.034391120076179504, -0.009897949174046516, 0.0258012767881155, -0.026687314733862877, 0.01253123302012682, -0.012979910708963871, 0.001742081018164754, -0.03851814568042755, -0.02234078012406826, 0.02705421671271324, -0.022255972027778625, 0.024654265493154526, -0.04233848303556442, -0.03681052103638649, 0.02439124509692192, 0.02534274011850357, 0.019059304147958755, -0.012077879160642624, -0.008717643097043037, -0.07762162387371063, 0.0038243583403527737, -0.029190057888627052, -0.06148015335202217, -0.0119807543233037, 0.03008206933736801, 0.0235296580940485, -0.042527858167886734, -0.023015828803181648, 0.0009003565646708012, -0.04365586116909981, 0.01586266979575157, 0.057121872901916504, 0.01222858764231205, 0.016362618654966354, -0.004243109375238419, 0.03296549990773201, 0.014852011576294899, 0.04153620824217796, -0.010205846279859543, 0.007334956433624029, 0.03474792093038559, -0.01686887815594673, -0.003843753132969141, 0.027801809832453728, -0.014259988442063332, 0.0022751777432858944, 0.014418989419937134, 0.026083558797836304, -0.005683769937604666, -0.011452065780758858, 0.058530256152153015, -0.02682574652135372, -0.01624930091202259, 0.00003195278986822814, -0.015298782847821712, 0.05704242363572121, -0.01993025466799736, 0.024026254191994667, -0.027041001245379448, -0.03430793061852455, -0.03529379889369011, 0.013561329804360867, -0.03228931874036789, 0.006545081268996, 0.0067059071734547615, 0.029937008395791054, -0.010370666161179543, -0.01547073945403099, -0.007255041506141424, -0.017578275874257088, 0.009163395501673222, 0.008573940955102444, 0.0043882885947823524, -0.02508392371237278, -0.034907642751932144, -0.06303790211677551, -0.10515992343425751, -0.025632914155721664, -0.0021824613213539124, 0.04254366084933281, -0.009080709889531136, -0.016626916825771332, 0.014055854640901089, 0.057306189090013504, -0.06467092037200928, -0.007609347812831402, -0.03151073679327965, 0.024137325584888458, -0.012963250279426575, 0.01454577874392271 ]
<p>I have two variables that predict fraud behavior (dependent variable). The independent variables are perception of fraud being wrong (1-5) and probability of being caught (1-5). The dependent variable is frequency of committing fraud in the last 5 years (never, once, 2-3 times, 4 times and more). Two questions: </p> <ol> <li>What kind of regression should I use? Ordinal?</li> <li>Theory predicts that interaction of these two variables predicts the fraud. For those who perceive it wrong, the probability of being caught affects differently than for those who perceive it right. How should I enter this to the model?</li> </ol>
36,851
[ -0.0035795331932604313, -0.027313711121678352, -0.0001578432129463181, -0.012894928455352783, 0.052141740918159485, -0.010863109491765499, 0.008505151607096195, 0.013901809230446815, 0.06712671369314194, 0.057265352457761765, 0.059834953397512436, 0.011999353766441345, 0.048627156764268875, 0.008286884985864162, 0.03449217602610588, 0.03889590874314308, -0.008555283769965172, 0.019408375024795532, -0.007157739717513323, 0.019405027851462364, -0.025641940534114838, -0.006666901521384716, -0.00677483482286334, -0.007414534687995911, -0.03845987468957901, 0.0701633021235466, 0.052114084362983704, -0.005568427033722401, 0.017026882618665695, 0.027497434988617897, 0.0017839954234659672, 0.012352253310382366, 0.019444480538368225, 0.0423492006957531, 0.03529450669884682, 0.017372023314237595, -0.010404990054666996, 0.005267786327749491, 0.003775328164920211, 0.027516009286046028, -0.009452728554606438, -0.016422277316451073, 0.022512339055538177, 0.04007091745734215, 0.016201801598072052, -0.029168501496315002, -0.004966761451214552, -0.016686316579580307, 0.017770858481526375, -0.0385817252099514, 0.07278028130531311, -0.03249438479542732, 0.012596054002642632, 0.04377300292253494, 0.016959020867943764, -0.005499279126524925, 0.0601983517408371, 0.05171073228120804, -0.004772566258907318, -0.0720238909125328, -0.02952057309448719, -0.012782570905983448, -0.010995369404554367, 0.0025525337550789118, -0.022248581051826477, 0.02431086264550686, -0.012818890623748302, -0.03577067703008652, 0.007817368023097515, 0.003062899224460125, 0.016669170930981636, 0.006690371315926313, 0.04231875017285347, -0.025080762803554535, 0.0319288894534111, -0.0407869815826416, -0.017888160422444344, 0.01708083041012287, 0.03004530631005764, 0.010506120510399342, 0.0029570411425083876, -0.005992846563458443, -0.0004886761889792979, 0.021136486902832985, 0.007830686867237091, -0.039873477071523666, 0.0562683567404747, 0.00676149595528841, 0.017988089472055435, 0.038088686764240265, -0.047830045223236084, 0.02222594805061817, 0.04426948353648186, 0.03225582093000412, -0.025186602026224136, 0.008291724137961864, -0.0236479751765728, 0.012130708433687687, 0.020902587100863457, 0.03152472525835037, -0.04813910275697708, -0.03975224494934082, 0.005137557163834572, 0.07056938111782074, -0.058611925691366196, -0.03425102308392525, 0.021130921319127083, -0.025323161855340004, 0.0011592034716159105, -0.07200798392295837, 0.005613199435174465, 0.03655030205845833, 0.025521714240312576, 0.03757995739579201, 0.041446998715400696, -0.0031386190094053745, -0.016354164108633995, -0.025498485192656517, 0.05208276957273483, 0.04048103094100952, -0.0004970364389009774, -0.0366361029446125, 0.04053904861211777, -0.014078800566494465, 0.0002383158716838807, 0.005288513842970133, 0.029276607558131218, -0.012348578311502934, -0.023661963641643524, 0.048097748309373856, -0.009302017278969288, -0.07195039838552475, -0.007905914448201656, 0.017328845337033272, 0.021710772067308426, 0.008907062001526356, -0.09263458102941513, -0.044008225202560425, 0.03424861282110214, 0.01634419895708561, 0.03954986482858658, -0.033565107733011246, -0.016404906287789345, 0.022853877395391464, 0.0672001987695694, 0.032224539667367935, 0.03223137930035591, 0.02265195921063423, 0.005909867584705353, 0.015432479791343212, -0.022526761516928673, 0.0016973605379462242, -0.008582704700529575, -0.025994490832090378, -0.03210367634892464, -0.05638321489095688, -0.015295338816940784, 0.019486498087644577, -0.03468248248100281, -0.03548594191670418, 0.05018192157149315, 0.015008138492703438, -0.02045295387506485, 0.021414391696453094, 0.005877214018255472, -0.013982260599732399, 0.07692989706993103, -0.016931619495153427, 0.03666335344314575, 0.034023039042949677, -0.012802157551050186, 0.020381536334753036, -0.017240380868315697, 0.03536553680896759, 0.03579205647110939, 0.0046509429812431335, 0.034848812967538834, -0.018678901717066765, -0.03212415426969528, 0.010668559931218624, -0.06331345438957214, 0.00896749272942543, -0.03893551230430603, -0.05165070295333862, 0.0072911810129880905, 0.0005223278421908617, -0.016445884481072426, -0.023386377841234207, -0.00403645820915699, -0.03304402157664299, -0.08902154862880707, -0.04938375949859619, 0.010413222014904022, -0.03449235484004021, -0.05390056595206261, 0.009531615301966667, -0.03096432238817215, 0.034134965389966965, -0.016746914014220238, 0.012664373964071274, -0.05277364328503609, 0.0030120485462248325, 0.059252820909023285, -0.03224935755133629, 0.0022092140279710293, 0.04090135172009468, 0.033602580428123474, -0.014837256632745266, 0.023213259875774384, -0.04690298065543175, 0.001184096559882164, -0.005629426799714565, -0.012060555629432201, 0.013159343041479588, -0.046246372163295746, -0.002658118959516287, 0.06811948865652084, -0.013089182786643505, -0.008399836719036102, 0.015113616362214088, -0.08008670061826706, 0.04371417686343193, 0.07035394757986069, 0.011644205078482628, 0.000767913181334734, 0.013106673955917358, -0.015543404966592789, 0.007951715961098671, -0.012690456584095955, -0.045582301914691925, -0.047382041811943054, -0.008305130526423454, -0.005268366541713476, 0.02211359143257141, -0.017367903143167496, 0.06225154548883438, 0.06857499480247498, 0.022709937766194344, -0.016846103593707085, 0.02051730453968048, -0.038343578577041626, -0.011383363045752048, 0.0024350592866539955, -0.021493321284651756, 0.026507606729865074, 0.0394323393702507, -0.00880345143377781, 0.030392451211810112, 0.053190991282463074, 0.01724470779299736, -0.035581424832344055, 0.051484670490026474, -0.02156752534210682, 0.034441955387592316, -0.011813869699835777, 0.030989836901426315, 0.06697117537260056, -0.01388173270970583, -0.013194321654736996, 0.0460401214659214, -0.03287868574261665, -0.016810942441225052, 0.0250010434538126, 0.018476707860827446, -0.0023875508923083544, 0.07664218544960022, -0.02097281441092491, 0.024849098175764084, -0.0025289636105298996, -0.00728659937158227, -0.02211817353963852, -0.014187460765242577, -0.01596943289041519, -0.04297357052564621, 0.02081548422574997, 0.010634914971888065, -0.00144657539203763, 0.008290224708616734, -0.00528993085026741, -0.03960966318845749, -0.0008338611805811524, -0.015967631712555885, 0.03116234578192234, 0.007533182855695486, -0.053933314979076385, -0.010772742331027985, -0.036247335374355316, -0.006044783629477024, 0.02719363383948803, -0.011627104133367538, 0.006165918428450823, 0.015835028141736984, 0.014829864725470543, -0.07149866223335266, -0.049456384032964706, -0.025078345090150833, -0.0023925937712192535, 0.006438393145799637, -0.03929116949439049, 0.002587593160569668, 0.029843302443623543, 0.005818098783493042, -0.012738436460494995, -0.04511408507823944, -0.0299698356539011, -0.03971899300813675, -0.02127576619386673, -0.001249929890036583, 0.0173511765897274, 0.01629772037267685, 0.012318680994212627, 0.005266249179840088, -0.0011199497384950519, -0.10350075364112854, -0.05898192524909973, 0.018194636330008507, -0.009548262692987919, 0.01207213755697012, -0.004224763717502356, -0.011324248276650906, 0.05799049511551857, 0.02851312793791294, 0.012508940882980824, -0.058281827718019485, -0.03695133700966835, -0.03841008245944977, -0.05112529173493385, 0.0418572798371315, 0.04424053058028221, 0.006775835528969765, 0.00484805041924119, -0.031147567555308342, 0.016011523082852364, 0.04240337014198303, -0.018130963668227196, -0.021875206381082535, 0.004737888928502798, 0.005853538401424885, -0.027618926018476486, 0.03691147640347481, 0.021246759220957756, -0.04256328567862511, 0.0294436514377594, 0.006706996820867062, 0.009466558694839478, 0.029682647436857224, -0.024222558364272118, -0.03388126939535141, 0.007281056605279446, -0.012819300405681133, 0.006226886995136738, 0.013177277520298958, 0.0017534468788653612, -0.027532482519745827, -0.016213329508900642, 0.00553811714053154, 0.029244314879179, -0.026398206129670143, 0.007198614533990622, 0.047782253473997116, 0.019718339666724205, -0.00429623294621706, 0.0013238661922514439, -0.036870695650577545, -0.02213742397725582, 0.019930284470319748, -0.023322992026805878, 0.0021869742777198553, 0.03667154535651207, 0.03576643764972687, 0.034638289362192154, 0.016670741140842438, -0.022036956623196602, 0.0026710450183600187, -0.053969647735357285, -0.018897654488682747, -0.012436269782483578, 0.07705090194940567, 0.014827883802354336, 0.012544059194624424, 0.007141715846955776, -0.010917453095316887, 0.029755525290966034, 0.02213362418115139, -0.0607694610953331, 0.06676395237445831, 0.0045065623708069324, 0.03155815973877907, -0.006224413402378559, -0.010949543677270412, 0.05219539254903793, -0.029605813324451447, 0.026406411081552505, 0.019053541123867035, 0.02624349482357502, -0.0188441164791584, -0.0018590920371934772, -0.028257271274924278, -0.0029079921077936888, -0.025732828304171562, -0.0009755387436598539, 0.0016232182970270514, -0.016514647752046585, 0.06412550061941147, 0.028082478791475296, 0.01647007092833519, -0.017783688381314278, -0.04528842493891716, -0.03181910887360573, 0.04471663013100624, 0.046261727809906006, 0.004664525389671326, 0.005311545915901661, -0.05786500126123428, 0.07686568051576614, -0.013408114202320576, 0.029157431796193123, 0.04227314889431, -0.0014331196434795856, -0.03575880080461502, -0.04162561520934105, 0.0004222363349981606, 0.013049286790192127, 0.01442848239094019, -0.00864921323955059, 0.009413398802280426, 0.04415780305862427, 0.001934089232236147, -0.023285791277885437, 0.026396865025162697, 0.07871580123901367, 0.04149124026298523, 0.011325354687869549, 0.01726216822862625, -0.013827552087605, 0.011813257820904255, -0.002224209951236844, 0.04926067963242531, 0.037053972482681274, -0.02960389293730259, -0.004375862888991833, 0.042804401367902756, 0.0040497672744095325, -0.02989008277654648, 0.020426921546459198, 0.009020823985338211, 0.02935127541422844, 0.00023635300749447197, -0.05275370553135872, 0.0061556436121463776, 0.053181201219558716, 0.0458633229136467, 0.050543662160634995, -0.024473002180457115, -0.09464288502931595, -0.009347331710159779, 0.03957301005721092, 0.04018712788820267, -0.07689666748046875, -0.03386014699935913, -0.040581073611974716, -0.039275381714105606, 0.017740022391080856, -0.055730435997247696, 0.011593899689614773, 0.013108591549098492, 0.03899919614195824, -0.0420282818377018, -0.03143369406461716, -0.05901158228516579, 0.02494821697473526, -0.012134972959756851, 0.06992989778518677, 0.004765684716403484, -0.0479903370141983, -0.030330022796988487, 0.01606941409409046, 0.046797532588243484, 0.034128587692976, -0.0011569997295737267, -0.002480375114828348, -0.011200923472642899, 0.014167730696499348, -0.029500558972358704, -0.03530063480138779, 0.03906366601586342, -0.012551517225801945, 0.014608331024646759, 0.0393843799829483, 0.02428801730275154, -0.02885018102824688, -0.02555564045906067, 0.026392901316285133, 0.00641488004475832, 0.0034832730889320374, -0.04364146664738655, 0.04252292588353157, -0.0024396551307290792, 0.007715580519288778, 0.026111414656043053, 0.05740738287568092, 0.0302736833691597, -0.021866021677851677, -0.020916730165481567, 0.006271634250879288, -0.013036713935434818, -0.03808974847197533, -0.009538128040730953, -0.005984283518046141, -0.022493915632367134, 0.01739410124719143, 0.02208443358540535, 0.022845029830932617, -0.04292748123407364, -0.029586702585220337, -0.00029120221734046936, 0.0382663868367672, -0.028299568220973015, -0.017228664830327034, -0.013252749107778072, 0.012929311953485012, -0.009324840269982815, -0.017091864719986916, -0.02472670190036297, -0.029783621430397034, 0.0010335223050788045, 0.023298269137740135, -0.03074106015264988, 0.02042912133038044, -0.02374250814318657, -0.021686574444174767, -0.0064077009446918964, -0.044656042009592056, 0.04739244282245636, -0.0005685394280590117, 0.047518324106931686, -0.007147419732064009, 0.0022077588364481926, 0.0020831450819969177, 0.012920337729156017, 0.0218462273478508, 0.03194379061460495, -0.04845720902085304, 0.07341491430997849, -0.035177282989025116, -0.03045986033976078, -0.06531374156475067, -0.07547195255756378, 0.0277460478246212, -0.024287452921271324, -0.04980115965008736, 0.008348068222403526, 0.014346393756568432, -0.027095213532447815, -0.031834010034799576, -0.02637859620153904, 0.0649515762925148, -0.0037534667644649744, -0.029150662943720818, -0.01624595746397972, -0.02642844431102276, 0.0700385645031929, 0.026953937485814095, -0.01322221104055643, 0.008435050956904888, -0.04699331521987915, -0.03346791863441467, 0.016340205445885658, 0.018899939954280853, -0.043340180069208145, -0.03625386580824852, -0.05342620983719826, 0.02416723594069481, 0.03579680249094963, 0.006348331458866596, 0.027486737817525864, -0.0054726917296648026, 0.012152443639934063, 0.0030796444043517113, -0.018752437084913254, -0.008586342446506023, 0.01754830777645111, 0.030325977131724358, 0.009524509310722351, 0.004091023933142424, -0.023006806150078773, 0.0014195317635312676, 0.01969469152390957, 0.03430237993597984, -0.05675947666168213, 0.028754618018865585, 0.04352370277047157, -0.01286686584353447, 0.010782096534967422, -0.006649415008723736, -0.026112806051969528, 0.05215567722916603, -0.016361525282263756, 0.0034046366345137358, 0.02066483534872532, 0.04904570430517197, -0.05920194089412689, -0.07921264320611954, -0.019384823739528656, 0.02292441762983799, 0.04050495848059654, -0.034620821475982666, 0.03288177400827408, 0.04767816513776779, -0.017593489959836006, -0.022750796750187874, -0.053853463381528854, -0.011189211159944534, -0.024025915190577507, 0.020749613642692566, 0.04542401432991028, -0.03257078304886818, 0.00965668261051178, 0.02383551187813282, 0.040068093687295914, 0.02778513915836811, 0.03779180720448494, 0.04296646639704704, 0.0038798097521066666, 0.009679419919848442, -0.0357685387134552, 0.004001958295702934, 0.021472088992595673, -0.04624088108539581, 0.04360116273164749, -0.027621151879429817, -0.024552512913942337, 0.026702161878347397, 0.06871076673269272, 0.025060268118977547, -0.04881058260798454, -0.026708202436566353, -0.04817124456167221, 0.004974540788680315, 0.026247791945934296, -0.019865816459059715, 0.05225873738527298, -0.00027343028341419995, 0.03143525496125221, 0.001526859006844461, 0.030152112245559692, -0.010712165385484695, -0.08960280567407608, 0.02204008400440216, -0.013015318661928177, -0.010185318998992443, 0.015509456396102905, -0.02403033897280693, -0.01098233088850975, 0.04243847355246544, -0.04294797405600548, -0.015595744363963604, 0.032541338354349136, 0.039532195776700974, 0.0006611183052882552, 0.055215056985616684, 0.009537882171571255, 0.00029948988230898976, 0.009402293711900711, 0.012173851951956749, 0.12277429550886154, 0.08574330061674118, 0.026414839550852776, -0.055503733456134796, 0.050360504537820816, 0.022631419822573662, 0.01834849640727043, -0.009497569873929024, -0.0028806535992771387, -0.012732785195112228, 0.0007543876417912543, 0.04629528522491455, 0.05139676854014397, -0.000984799931757152, -0.020117798820137978, 0.04573564976453781, -0.03735930845141411, 0.004705645143985748, -0.008391638286411762, 0.0015526977367699146, 0.007472031284123659, 0.024074768647551537, -0.025799788534641266, 0.002507614204660058, -0.016550838947296143, -0.03280750289559364, 0.016627568751573563, -0.006564510054886341, 0.01599428802728653, 0.019996289163827896, -0.014208855107426643, 0.01544700376689434, 0.01886693947017193, 0.03211589902639389, -0.025626856833696365, 0.005426567979156971, 0.012331497855484486, -0.08473639190196991, 0.01705852337181568, 0.019898798316717148, -0.026394551619887352, -0.029914971441030502, 0.025739869102835655, 0.02008814364671707, -0.059385091066360474, -0.03357313945889473, -0.01807340793311596, 0.025878828018903732, 0.015934886410832405, 0.01712997816503048, -0.011252284049987793, -0.0175032801926136, -0.005595059599727392, -0.05581214651465416, -0.026533009484410286, 0.022568460553884506, 0.02207922376692295, -0.021790536120533943, -0.03803763911128044, -0.015878422185778618, 0.007860817015171051, -0.017062533646821976, 0.037399835884571075, 0.02266673557460308, -0.0146433524787426, -0.020599709823727608, -0.03097590059041977, 0.05384278669953346, -0.015560475178062916, 0.022051865234971046, -0.0044156769290566444, -0.015467367134988308, -0.030553732067346573, 0.02776930294930935, -0.015819905325770378, 0.005341003183275461, -0.028353888541460037, -0.02538209967315197, 0.00013161404058337212, -0.02539725787937641, -0.03519950434565544, 0.04257858544588089, -0.0026876255869865417, -0.00587328290566802, -0.06272976100444794, -0.01287804078310728, -0.0007743187597952783, -0.004986243322491646, 0.015080052427947521, -0.011577770113945007, 0.02954685129225254, 0.0351739376783371, 0.026838138699531555, -0.015626855194568634, 0.005624377168715, -0.060520026832818985, -0.04881025105714798, -0.03712262213230133, -0.005969939287751913, 0.06386241316795349, 0.02222287654876709, 0.01181389857083559, 0.013278031721711159, 0.03272111341357231, -0.02103722095489502, 0.0057694208808243275, 0.022369898855686188, -0.04634864628314972, -0.0007688836776651442, -0.00743061862885952, -0.004722950980067253, -0.019432177767157555, -0.018044274300336838, -0.015278318896889687, -0.026585513725876808, 0.01088746078312397, -0.001292057684622705, -0.026652634143829346, 0.04875617101788521, -0.006013176869601011, 0.039773210883140564, -0.021651718765497208, 0.0027751768939197063, -0.027061622589826584, -0.007937653921544552, 0.03118981420993805, -0.014003061689436436, -0.022567961364984512, 0.033590640872716904, 0.0029126484878361225, 0.03950120508670807, -0.015163406729698181, 0.02199179120361805, 0.026912091299891472, -0.025548560544848442, 0.02464604191482067, -0.007658046204596758, 0.032368529587984085, -0.03982624039053917, -0.016159983351826668, 0.03623426705598831, -0.03393150120973587, -0.02883055992424488, 0.036092888563871384, 0.0004829928220715374, 0.021833492442965508, -0.00038545270217582583, 0.010132819414138794, -0.030603507533669472, 0.016752149909734726, -0.032604049891233444, -0.0047958120703697205, -0.037056390196084976, 0.04991687089204788, 0.016693968325853348, -0.003290917258709669, 0.0036697511095553637, 0.023350289091467857, -0.01421388704329729, -0.01849963143467903, 0.04152631759643555, -0.007971479557454586, 0.02999279275536537, 0.02085171826183796, -0.007654513698071241, -0.023459086194634438, -0.007712602615356445, -0.021914567798376083, 0.002088483888655901, 0.027878621593117714, -0.025799715891480446, 0.007091175299137831, -0.009613697417080402, 0.012006794102489948, -0.10740682482719421, -0.03913671523332596, 0.053359635174274445, 0.018431805074214935, 0.02489980310201645, -0.024495679885149002, -0.004162148106843233, 0.02915329486131668, -0.028283577412366867, 0.0015812607016414404, -0.021633600816130638, -0.017201831564307213, -0.04397197440266609, -0.004081045743077993, -0.03406384959816933, 0.0005927852471359074, 0.02434157393872738, -0.009911228902637959, 0.04265625402331352, 0.005880049429833889, 0.030754391103982925, -0.04807841777801514, -0.005465621594339609, 0.012493378482758999, -0.014403256587684155, -0.05998503044247627, 0.006117876153439283, -0.06256414204835892, 0.015262894332408905, 0.05815797671675682, -0.007164777722209692, 0.013767135329544544, 0.006024823058396578, 0.018503010272979736, 0.00814511626958847, 0.04630725458264351, 0.01171058788895607, -0.024655519053339958, -0.005130268633365631, 0.023215893656015396, 0.020324669778347015, 0.023947952315211296, -0.0026552637573331594, 0.031266216188669205, -0.004003104288130999, -0.02753792703151703, -0.006604430265724659, -0.021090928465127945, 0.019640788435935974, -0.03379398584365845, -0.006658703088760376, -0.02419564500451088, 0.010991805233061314, -0.03422072157263756, 0.02394271455705166, -0.03752504289150238, -0.028851641342043877, 0.037195414304733276, 0.03532887622714043, -0.01708567701280117, 0.01511059608310461, -0.009798689745366573, -0.03123871609568596, 0.013513718731701374, -0.01666814275085926, 0.007125692442059517, -0.023689018562436104, -0.0008877625223249197, 0.016275322064757347, 0.010817794129252434, 0.007169436197727919, -0.04047399014234543, -0.014172958210110664, 0.048144299536943436, -0.03832974657416344, -0.006448309402912855, 0.013022210448980331, -0.041922327131032944, 0.021892765536904335, -0.0803447961807251, 0.07234497368335724, -0.017089687287807465, -0.046858638525009155, -0.0072836847975850105, -0.00813023466616869, -0.043080516159534454, 0.002303872723132372, 0.04513632506132126, 0.014664769172668457, -0.015159325674176216, -0.02520172856748104, 0.03735307231545448, -0.00186206737998873, -0.042960334569215775, 0.01956959441304207, -0.005629871506243944, -0.016936613246798515, -0.049862489104270935, 0.023381199687719345, 0.0034196972846984863, 0.007620185147970915, 0.0019195531494915485, 0.0202821996062994, 0.015325460582971573, 0.009572356939315796, -0.0534733384847641, -0.0027448113542050123, 0.018542997539043427, 0.019068626686930656, 0.03288281708955765, 0.009761757217347622, 0.007263262290507555, 0.018747858703136444, -0.023092171177268028, -0.05310152843594551, 0.024060018360614777, -0.02195165865123272, -0.011567803099751472, -0.012839744798839092, 0.028600342571735382, -0.050700534135103226, -0.0698612630367279, 0.01423228345811367, 0.023958120495080948, -0.016987450420856476, -0.00895034708082676, 0.024452103301882744, 0.001029198756441474, 0.04901539534330368, -0.02197546698153019, 0.006018067244440317, -0.009408011101186275, -0.022285277023911476, -0.01469439547508955, -0.024478470906615257, 0.034835703670978546, 0.033385053277015686, 0.025242138653993607, 0.04212930053472519, 0.019689781591296196, 0.03464829549193382, -0.016885410994291306, 0.014964913949370384, -0.017493702471256256, 0.015724822878837585, 0.03245921805500984, -0.0054825362749397755, 0.030404994264245033, 0.021321311593055725, 0.010259675793349743, 0.0399155467748642, -0.050731632858514786, 0.007558678276836872, -0.017809651792049408, -0.025427687913179398, -0.03300948813557625, 0.016187597066164017, 0.04694242775440216, 0.02131045050919056, 0.03019765391945839, 0.006119713652879, 0.015155495144426823, 0.01873745396733284, 0.030057288706302643, -0.01349473837763071, 0.014551470056176186, -0.016478432342410088, -0.03952119126915932, -0.05939958244562149, -0.032169099897146225, -0.02143579162657261, -0.013530028983950615, 0.010329160839319229, 0.04036176577210426, 0.033879395574331284, -0.023074578493833542, -0.024379165843129158, 0.012093252502381802, 0.03103233128786087, -0.06179434061050415, -0.02690553106367588, -0.024293066933751106, 0.02524804137647152, 0.004712667781859636, -0.016669102013111115 ]
<p>I need to explain the concept of linear mixed models in an article targeted at a mainstream audience. Is there a way of communicating the gist of the concept in a sentence or two?</p>
36,852
[ -0.03822926804423332, -0.006544926203787327, 0.006755957845598459, -0.004798368085175753, 0.03604570031166077, 0.03594858944416046, 0.0021561761386692524, 0.027618033811450005, 0.031165270134806633, -0.01856335625052452, 0.0532195121049881, 0.02962339296936989, 0.037656720727682114, -0.010030797682702541, 0.013977745547890663, 0.025405367836356163, 0.009809568524360657, 0.006080478895455599, -0.025980724021792412, 0.0004915291210636497, -0.015055366791784763, -0.030690914019942284, -0.003755148034542799, 0.00812655221670866, 0.010369585826992989, 0.04786878824234009, 0.054445575922727585, -0.010165148414671421, 0.012325790710747242, 0.01908009499311447, -0.02073303610086441, -0.026871107518672943, 0.040810175240039825, 0.015883997082710266, 0.02376817725598812, -0.018753936514258385, -0.01601465232670307, -0.014112312346696854, 0.03683860972523689, 0.05102293938398361, -0.03064609132707119, -0.04930911958217621, 0.017299184575676918, 0.01952732913196087, -0.05051099509000778, 0.03604229539632797, 0.01625441201031208, -0.037286724895238876, 0.008187985979020596, -0.04810851439833641, 0.08463995903730392, -0.011596783064305782, 0.07007504999637604, 0.029643356800079346, 0.004390175454318523, 0.054475028067827225, 0.04261939600110054, 0.0392029732465744, 0.018545597791671753, -0.036523595452308655, -0.021221717819571495, 0.00020017863425891846, 0.03266032412648201, -0.023026907816529274, -0.017610497772693634, 0.032126329839229584, 0.026885855942964554, -0.0005892002955079079, 0.035972196608781815, 0.005468218587338924, -0.012551633641123772, 0.007941567339003086, 0.031799063086509705, 0.015087287873029709, -0.008000736124813557, -0.040304314345121384, -0.006939522456377745, 0.0212712362408638, 0.022825049236416817, -0.004477859009057283, 0.001711408025585115, 0.009185501374304295, 0.0009747673175297678, 0.01957857981324196, 0.003490590024739504, -0.0232960507273674, 0.08180763572454453, -0.00825407449156046, 0.01978032849729061, 0.0219879187643528, -0.004527355078607798, 0.014902931638062, 0.06065935641527176, 0.017673075199127197, -0.09057015180587769, 0.026594774797558784, 0.0023240367881953716, 0.05341643840074539, 0.04685450345277786, -0.02109605260193348, -0.01570233516395092, -0.03216583654284477, 0.03372502699494362, 0.032386623322963715, -0.0019278114195913076, -0.023216450586915016, -0.0191460233181715, 0.009748696349561214, 0.0006594228325411677, -0.025707999244332314, -0.04555955156683922, 0.01203483808785677, 0.036589365452528, 0.0038833385333418846, -0.00028130877763032913, -0.012486405670642853, 0.016934745013713837, -0.0078572453930974, 0.054459623992443085, 0.07989165186882019, 0.042496491223573685, -0.07117439061403275, 0.048685964196920395, 0.02590855397284031, -0.05660654976963997, 0.014874323271214962, -0.00209432328119874, -0.03478141501545906, -0.062486421316862106, 0.051395416259765625, 0.014642436988651752, -0.012496383860707283, -0.015545440837740898, -0.010865500196814537, 0.01425226591527462, -0.009943703189492226, -0.0756010189652443, -0.03995206952095032, 0.03494768217206001, 0.005309117026627064, 0.013198909349739552, -0.057916756719350815, -0.0087314797565341, 0.037862762808799744, 0.04313407093286514, 0.003423947375267744, 0.013304559513926506, 0.02996201068162918, -0.021748794242739677, -0.014877104200422764, -0.020345540717244148, -0.007184986490756273, -0.017174677923321724, -0.0012423389125615358, -0.008453369140625, -0.08178988099098206, 0.025497743859887123, -0.007611667271703482, -0.021879924461245537, 0.003083460498601198, 0.013766041956841946, -0.023827312514185905, -0.015589488670229912, 0.033115725964307785, -0.013556391932070255, -0.014246012084186077, 0.0596080981194973, -0.06518539041280746, 0.03818783164024353, 0.044413972645998, 0.015057279728353024, -0.014920445159077644, 0.04363947734236717, 0.05717507004737854, 0.024100298061966896, -0.011090380139648914, 0.027524225413799286, 0.029935412108898163, -0.018740402534604073, 0.026010720059275627, -0.05575152859091759, -0.03648242726922035, -0.0015137667069211602, 0.03795245289802551, -0.008563782088458538, 0.03593239560723305, -0.006539013236761093, 0.0022978989873081446, 0.05613899976015091, -0.011414743959903717, -0.04286162182688713, -0.0718802884221077, 0.022939372807741165, -0.02484872378408909, 0.009160352870821953, 0.01332913152873516, -0.01474300492554903, -0.002235222840681672, -0.014501182362437248, -0.01203460805118084, -0.0055801114067435265, -0.004846304189413786, 0.05335088446736336, -0.03981060907244682, 0.004593893885612488, 0.04842500016093254, 0.059866514056921005, -0.0009545044740661979, 0.02167406864464283, 0.013124185614287853, -0.013609995134174824, -0.015504441224038601, -0.005867831874638796, 0.026746539399027824, -0.011998562142252922, 0.001261986675672233, -0.023735536262392998, 0.0013815498678013682, -0.019478023052215576, 0.03644983842968941, -0.02900051139295101, 0.05097801610827446, 0.07478298246860504, -0.0030306826811283827, -0.001960454508662224, 0.0028578517958521843, 0.01660257764160633, -0.000766454788390547, 0.012840712442994118, -0.011189159005880356, -0.04655686393380165, -0.0041229198686778545, 0.04274684190750122, 0.011119618080556393, -0.027529345825314522, 0.038039132952690125, 0.06936091929674149, 0.03523603826761246, 0.009351206943392754, 0.026666803285479546, -0.046336181461811066, 0.0006143056671135128, 0.0024530095979571342, -0.01870678924024105, -0.020863357931375504, 0.0022975546307861805, -0.0061032408848404884, 0.015879929065704346, 0.008648606948554516, 0.0254423338919878, 0.0003103074850514531, 0.0691566988825798, 0.0015267692506313324, 0.007021470461040735, -0.021806390956044197, -0.0379667766392231, 0.05193374678492546, -0.03943334519863129, 0.01734626293182373, 0.023592570796608925, -0.007445855066180229, -0.009567459113895893, 0.028055761009454727, -0.0010458562755957246, 0.009538376703858376, 0.02949714846909046, -0.01768985204398632, 0.007766371127218008, 0.04021215811371803, -0.05159112811088562, 0.03349949046969414, -0.0313517302274704, -0.01579834334552288, -0.005992388352751732, -0.023599915206432343, 0.010886326432228088, 0.0029434876050800085, 0.02436758391559124, -0.0029255407862365246, -0.0251570176333189, 0.01128888688981533, 0.0076769436709582806, 0.028363030403852463, -0.015232863835990429, -0.04193705692887306, 0.0025539081543684006, -0.04566916450858116, -0.02777102217078209, 0.03262152895331383, -0.01378884632140398, -0.028979850932955742, 0.0027385822031646967, -0.04088436812162399, -0.059764314442873, -0.03091518022119999, -0.017180724069476128, 0.024213651195168495, -0.0009485339396633208, -0.026196515187621117, 0.010889625176787376, -0.011980364099144936, -0.02994868904352188, -0.032427430152893066, -0.03560984879732132, -0.005664035212248564, -0.01875092275440693, -0.032861921936273575, 0.015149533748626709, 0.017881115898489952, 0.021596679463982582, 0.032535795122385025, -0.04716179892420769, 0.041065748780965805, -0.06447147578001022, -0.04287111759185791, 0.030420128256082535, 0.004617132246494293, 0.009098012931644917, -0.0050078886561095715, -0.030538665130734444, 0.08813857287168503, -0.012776613235473633, -0.024240024387836456, -0.033696144819259644, -0.009579431265592575, -0.024929462000727654, -0.022729678079485893, 0.049541622400283813, 0.00741348834708333, -0.0013443176867440343, 0.03343956917524338, 0.0024865446612238884, 0.0019421997712925076, 0.060618892312049866, 0.04574957862496376, 0.003034380031749606, -0.002502181800082326, -0.025922274217009544, 0.016753679141402245, -0.011738818138837814, 0.05580844730138779, -0.04168025404214859, 0.0644378811120987, -0.029704788699746132, 0.03856205195188522, 0.00901369471102953, -0.03193254396319389, 0.016314493492245674, -0.022098448127508163, -0.04694659262895584, -0.002228716854006052, 0.044079072773456573, 0.023337604478001595, -0.022891350090503693, 0.024675611406564713, 0.013609363697469234, 0.02625166065990925, -0.009756836108863354, 0.0008396280463784933, 0.02837502583861351, 0.05498849228024483, -0.03435465693473816, -0.006840849295258522, 0.010334924794733524, 0.005964738316833973, -0.003154439851641655, -0.016150297597050667, 0.017171600833535194, 0.023806950077414513, 0.017142506316304207, -0.01417692843824625, 0.016665136441588402, -0.030564259737730026, -0.009164667688310146, -0.07692822813987732, 0.0034777072723954916, 0.006401208229362965, -0.016739360988140106, -0.025651488453149796, 0.022040583193302155, 0.004590002819895744, -0.03448033332824707, 0.020549319684505463, -0.008633613586425781, -0.051940981298685074, 0.0390562042593956, -0.04230325669050217, 0.007319124881178141, 0.022268233820796013, -0.0009133598650805652, -0.010135664604604244, -0.03102675825357437, -0.04457801580429077, -0.030731605365872383, 0.003463892498984933, 0.012531721033155918, 0.03692493960261345, 0.008961793966591358, -0.04028632864356041, 0.004388610366731882, -0.011615173891186714, 0.01845473051071167, -0.01735624670982361, -0.0028644276317209005, 0.015625055879354477, 0.03256971016526222, -0.034387554973363876, -0.03442634269595146, 0.0025414947886019945, 0.026796521618962288, 0.013103324919939041, 0.00020685659546870738, 0.002645177533850074, -0.03479985520243645, 0.053612012416124344, 0.0031840107403695583, 0.047652892768383026, 0.00756872771307826, -0.004156256560236216, -0.020014271140098572, -0.029061919078230858, -0.0088694728910923, 0.022890407592058182, -0.011129869148135185, -0.016379958018660545, 0.002790988190099597, 0.05183758959174156, 0.02763739414513111, -0.04113531857728958, 0.038532186299562454, 0.05210033804178238, 0.009418143890798092, -0.0030388860031962395, -0.009843072853982449, -0.004239595495164394, 0.011143716052174568, -0.011258451268076897, 0.044910259544849396, 0.0002462039119563997, 0.028683099895715714, 0.013243298977613449, 0.025943119078874588, -0.029933974146842957, -0.044479068368673325, -0.01964655891060829, -0.025620736181735992, 0.01908375509083271, -0.007506018038839102, -0.06481652706861496, 0.00721766846254468, 0.061198364943265915, -0.0015572768170386553, 0.024329353123903275, -0.020752882584929466, -0.11323867738246918, -0.011290783993899822, 0.03815735504031181, 0.04057411104440689, -0.02894672378897667, -0.0023305818904191256, -0.028657352551817894, -0.01828780025243759, -0.0020760702900588512, 0.02226591482758522, -0.000756952678784728, -0.039172034710645676, 0.005404572933912277, 0.0021246217656880617, -0.005385815165936947, -0.04084276407957077, 0.01568411849439144, -0.0071807983331382275, 0.004142443183809519, -0.014237279072403908, -0.008981351740658283, -0.02555684931576252, 0.029469100758433342, 0.007420910056680441, 0.021372701972723007, -0.024530772119760513, -0.011191424913704395, 0.017217611894011497, 0.041801318526268005, -0.045685213059186935, -0.07149899005889893, 0.02860092744231224, 0.010393019765615463, 0.0029703115578740835, 0.045785751193761826, -0.025480985641479492, -0.033921461552381516, 0.008004586212337017, -0.0006714566261507571, -0.028411606326699257, -0.01158771850168705, -0.0352693647146225, 0.01922220177948475, 0.0411919467151165, 0.044830989092588425, 0.0622955784201622, -0.010947569273412228, -0.0027705482207238674, 0.002249636920168996, -0.028740134090185165, 0.03843901678919792, -0.03287584334611893, -0.04857597500085831, -0.053775496780872345, 0.006636276841163635, -0.04749729856848717, 0.04752514511346817, -0.0030661846976727247, 0.014911063015460968, -0.00489806616678834, -0.07146605849266052, -0.003547694766893983, 0.026796361431479454, -0.02703094109892845, -0.043600354343652725, 0.017682403326034546, 0.009441605769097805, -0.011006273329257965, -0.012905975803732872, 0.022627759724855423, -0.04140263795852661, 0.026797650381922722, 0.025616567581892014, 0.007469262462109327, 0.02322475053369999, -0.026099126785993576, -0.04353785514831543, -0.001981722889468074, -0.03906531259417534, 0.04469255357980728, 0.002584075089544058, 0.03229841962456703, -0.04154292494058609, -0.09113692492246628, -0.005318196024745703, 0.024045275524258614, 0.03188684955239296, 0.04159160330891609, -0.009142233990132809, 0.029400523751974106, -0.035043299198150635, -0.028662286698818207, -0.06458481401205063, -0.05257401987910271, 0.02957077883183956, 0.001680369139648974, -0.012060676701366901, -0.040834471583366394, -0.0013642257545143366, -0.015576675534248352, -0.03391836956143379, -0.013769873417913914, 0.051439303904771805, -0.02928975224494934, 0.001165503985248506, -0.03738809749484062, -0.003354050451889634, 0.05990397930145264, 0.018840886652469635, -0.045717377215623856, 0.02050131931900978, -0.022038709372282028, 0.011764779686927795, -0.0397433303296566, 0.030097005888819695, -0.0543179027736187, 0.014077534899115562, -0.06526829302310944, -0.001946974778547883, 0.058239880949258804, -0.032616257667541504, -0.004234471824020147, 0.008083182387053967, 0.0184157881885767, -0.0015282705426216125, -0.02907416969537735, -0.005417491775006056, -0.03504426032304764, 0.023291535675525665, -0.024767272174358368, 0.0289472546428442, 0.007655713707208633, -0.009668493643403053, 0.055823132395744324, -0.002994891721755266, -0.006648199167102575, -0.004787952173501253, 0.055113501846790314, 0.026375001296401024, 0.043677978217601776, 0.023747479543089867, 0.010275918059051037, 0.019813790917396545, -0.0027416867669671774, 0.02849607542157173, -0.01236480288207531, 0.022634468972682953, -0.017727678641676903, -0.008427557535469532, -0.015878016129136086, -0.002977286232635379, 0.05017443373799324, 0.0010275949025526643, 0.04135952889919281, 0.04385865107178688, -0.02882414311170578, 0.0006501637399196625, -0.02890944480895996, 0.001345730503089726, -0.01915479451417923, -0.003249461529776454, 0.06298354268074036, -0.009638446383178234, 0.006059339269995689, 0.03417018800973892, 0.04222813621163368, 0.026830660179257393, 0.05046011134982109, 0.04050784558057785, 0.018046753481030464, -0.00898647215217352, 0.02532239630818367, -0.049244653433561325, 0.03776834160089493, -0.06871278584003448, -0.0017635154072195292, -0.03792770206928253, -0.004552781581878662, 0.02883882448077202, 0.03212757036089897, 0.0252870861440897, -0.0388433039188385, -0.03339275345206261, -0.07742909342050552, 0.03516701981425285, 0.011430811136960983, -0.023930756375193596, 0.03118334710597992, -0.02182159014046192, 0.04115859791636467, -0.044082704931497574, 0.004223026800900698, -0.05246549844741821, -0.05998151749372482, -0.03061762824654579, -0.042124275118112564, -0.021046746522188187, 0.007866143248975277, -0.0036122999154031277, -0.03105216473340988, 0.011448326520621777, -0.008914150297641754, 0.01205228827893734, 0.027378732338547707, 0.04500031843781471, -0.02179870568215847, 0.07117311656475067, 0.005199165549129248, -0.016466232016682625, -0.028088504448533058, -0.00632141949608922, 0.14298567175865173, 0.06553386896848679, 0.05336879938840866, -0.08569907397031784, 0.0456579364836216, 0.01736406423151493, 0.00008493263158015907, -0.003392252139747143, 0.010051226243376732, -0.005059642251580954, 0.0024065899197012186, 0.019332200288772583, 0.04454365372657776, 0.007811654359102249, 0.002616825047880411, 0.03310074657201767, -0.04051566123962402, -0.010926429182291031, 0.002364610554650426, -0.03188057616353035, -0.01982199028134346, 0.0034318892285227776, -0.061793431639671326, 0.030124684795737267, 0.025319768115878105, -0.03456374257802963, -0.0036955333780497313, -0.02047409676015377, 0.023508969694375992, 0.03169791027903557, -0.027357641607522964, 0.011222555302083492, 0.014557164162397385, 0.02905442751944065, 0.0005694346618838608, -0.02352062053978443, 0.0457431823015213, 0.006032872013747692, 0.009817016310989857, 0.025531839579343796, -0.015757258981466293, 0.0013954841997474432, 0.012922782450914383, -0.0001979576627491042, -0.02147059515118599, -0.0171076450496912, -0.005127523560076952, 0.027977967634797096, 0.005492184776812792, -0.034987032413482666, 0.0020950045436620712, 0.023611323907971382, -0.04230055212974548, -0.027562538161873817, 0.007348400540649891, 0.03697735443711281, 0.012909911572933197, -0.015969213098287582, -0.018733521923422813, -0.023298222571611404, 0.017329717054963112, -0.016829894855618477, 0.026353690773248672, 0.03595363721251488, -0.008904044516384602, 0.010731520131230354, -0.03137896955013275, 0.01751154474914074, 0.004891333170235157, 0.02925431914627552, -0.020618582144379616, -0.002604095498099923, -0.03785264119505882, -0.016786500811576843, 0.031251709908246994, -0.004273290280252695, -0.012524113990366459, -0.0007215335499495268, -0.004677904769778252, -0.022447725757956505, -0.0425993949174881, 0.02513781376183033, 0.058254893869161606, -0.02569286711513996, -0.011633746325969696, 0.009608633816242218, 0.02570977434515953, 0.04287565499544144, -0.011516674421727657, 0.02022206224501133, -0.013630684465169907, 0.07130412757396698, -0.0026079006493091583, -0.06014981493353844, 0.00044576224172487855, 0.023975253105163574, -0.035625357180833817, -0.0036729821003973484, 0.03141679987311363, 0.049062129110097885, 0.05155031755566597, 0.014816069044172764, -0.015951387584209442, 0.03831687569618225, -0.012271258048713207, 0.0029110254254192114, 0.010276010259985924, -0.040379878133535385, -0.039260026067495346, 0.028111804276704788, 0.016914106905460358, -0.014435933902859688, -0.04024343192577362, -0.02425496280193329, -0.061587247997522354, 0.01712576486170292, 0.021364251151680946, -0.031149540096521378, 0.04632050171494484, -0.01894243434071541, 0.012079805135726929, -0.03625095635652542, -0.00295164342969656, -0.037204448133707047, 0.020177463069558144, 0.029948880895972252, -0.026890963315963745, 0.006888576317578554, -0.009641561657190323, -0.016596762463450432, 0.014433886855840683, 0.042723510414361954, -0.02391371876001358, 0.01777469366788864, 0.020461315289139748, 0.013220533728599548, -0.01258195098489523, 0.05451587215065956, -0.031178854405879974, -0.010547516867518425, 0.0262716393917799, 0.002696835668757558, -0.002409139880910516, -0.021061360836029053, -0.0005804179236292839, 0.04292350262403488, 0.015132060274481773, -0.011070646345615387, -0.022257892414927483, 0.017872044816613197, -0.03504378721117973, -0.03599746525287628, -0.022934183478355408, 0.023840613663196564, -0.006632545962929726, -0.0035410148557275534, -0.0178561732172966, 0.01815604418516159, -0.019360609352588654, 0.019341247156262398, 0.06322576105594635, 0.021672334522008896, -0.011989087797701359, 0.013917515985667706, 0.005430064629763365, 0.05408783629536629, -0.008031591773033142, 0.020775316283106804, 0.024787919595837593, 0.021114567294716835, -0.038597870618104935, 0.006385752931237221, 0.008508280850946903, 0.0016008032253012061, -0.09519795328378677, -0.025028644129633904, 0.010615936480462551, -0.023543618619441986, 0.033898841589689255, -0.04147182032465935, 0.005492831114679575, 0.06083913519978523, -0.040394965559244156, -0.049930017441511154, -0.014714309945702553, -0.018346218392252922, -0.03451019525527954, 0.014104951173067093, -0.04064953327178955, 0.009494276717305183, -0.00985109992325306, 0.047540728002786636, 0.014971080236136913, 0.01524374820291996, 0.023337528109550476, -0.034121666103601456, 0.005034003872424364, -0.02083197981119156, 0.026307638734579086, -0.05067608132958412, 0.06960677355527878, -0.02477336674928665, -0.045555174350738525, 0.08026495575904846, 0.005170173477381468, 0.035890545696020126, 0.05248252674937248, 0.03999170660972595, -0.0007496688049286604, 0.018069421872496605, 0.021069400012493134, 0.011963257566094398, -0.0035594908986240625, -0.011687702499330044, 0.01355571486055851, 0.0316874198615551, -0.00006456865958170965, 0.01615259237587452, 0.015272905118763447, -0.008892937563359737, -0.04595281556248665, 0.0056665921583771706, -0.04694737493991852, -0.03783903270959854, -0.004691361915320158, -0.022038528695702553, 0.039809949696063995, -0.04921860992908478, 0.009051893837749958, -0.03425930440425873, 0.01316038891673088, 0.041050322353839874, 0.019927771762013435, -0.048703938722610474, 0.011693870648741722, -0.06133134663105011, -0.01488087885081768, -0.009830731898546219, 0.0144659373909235, -0.020634809508919716, -0.06797199696302414, -0.014104246161878109, 0.015606554225087166, -0.017108116298913956, -0.043025169521570206, 0.00029205725877545774, -0.028234215453267097, 0.026212098076939583, 0.01761733554303646, -0.0013779123546555638, -0.005237751640379429, -0.023745182901620865, 0.0019410249078646302, -0.05392323061823845, 0.08222862333059311, 0.035117682069540024, 0.011592968367040157, -0.029609067365527153, 0.0000378761142201256, -0.021707698702812195, 0.024358822032809258, 0.07711171358823776, 0.02493561990559101, -0.00450555607676506, -0.011024322360754013, 0.04304996877908707, 0.00020603410666808486, -0.032341014593839645, 0.04641681909561157, -0.03039657324552536, 0.001324637676589191, -0.03212617337703705, -0.040865208953619, -0.016555434092879295, -0.013444148004055023, 0.027838649228215218, 0.008358622901141644, 0.013579797931015491, -0.0188800897449255, -0.00858716294169426, 0.04080129414796829, 0.052869342267513275, -0.05501185730099678, 0.03615181893110275, -0.029543548822402954, -0.0063070934265851974, 0.02284228429198265, 0.006712789181619883, -0.061719827353954315, 0.017900850623846054, -0.035386890172958374, 0.012831056490540504, -0.0034264575224369764, -0.005246210377663374, -0.02613675408065319, -0.0580853670835495, 0.01304513867944479, 0.003972746431827545, -0.022709321230649948, 0.011261606588959694, 0.0042340634390711784, 0.03712477162480354, 0.06970681995153427, 0.02077004685997963, -0.03449716791510582, -0.007871396839618683, -0.02129618637263775, -0.016657426953315735, 0.009150562807917595, 0.039625104516744614, -0.006590818986296654, 0.011084399186074734, 0.025694720447063446, -0.017946602776646614, 0.06275399774312973, -0.022209903225302696, 0.0341285802423954, -0.042330704629421234, -0.01682954840362072, -0.02796163782477379, -0.006556159816682339, 0.012715502642095089, 0.020604345947504044, 0.01485330518335104, 0.075138621032238, -0.04665937274694443, 0.0019988007843494415, -0.042979031801223755, 0.009972785599529743, -0.025609470903873444, -0.017361756414175034, 0.03310941904783249, 0.03421318158507347, 0.004483338445425034, -0.006723799742758274, -0.03862110897898674, -0.023970074951648712, 0.05182100459933281, 0.01840393804013729, 0.017162565141916275, -0.028656410053372383, -0.02370881661772728, -0.0029532189946621656, -0.0038217827677726746, -0.019045569002628326, 0.00981689989566803, 0.007552417926490307, 0.0005977519322186708, 0.033391427248716354, -0.03243691101670265, -0.038621917366981506, -0.028536565601825714, 0.018007881939411163, -0.12742698192596436, -0.03622844070196152, -0.05519980192184448, 0.0006227224366739392, -0.0019048990216106176, 0.0012394238729029894 ]
<p>Consider approximating the following expectation: $$\mathbb{E}[h(x)] = \int h(x)\pi(x) dx$$</p> <p>Where $h(x)$ is an arbitrary function and $\pi(x)$ is a distribution for which the <strong>normalizing constant is not known</strong>. Also, assuming the above integral is highly variable and high dimensional the standard approach would be to use MCMC methods to sample points $\{x^{(i)}\}_{i=1}^N$ that are distributed according to $\pi(x)$ and return the sample average: </p> <p>$$ \mathbb{E}[h(x)] \approx \frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N \ h(x^{(i)}) $$</p> <p>My question is, if the function $h(x)$ happens to be highly variable as well, that is, $\pi(x)$ is very different from the optimal sampling distribution $q^*(x) = |h(x)|\pi(x)/Z$, is there a straightforward way to modify MCMC methods to improve the variance of the estimate? That is, how can MCMC (and related methods) take into account the variability (or sparsity, etc.) of $h(x)$? </p> <p>Also, I <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/19456/optimal-importance-sampling-with-ratio-estimator">asked a related question</a> earlier about whether one could use Monte Carlo methods for sampling from $q^*(x)$ and use the weighted importance sampling estimator to compensate for the fact the normalizer is not known. The answer was basically that this is not a good idea, since it requires estimating the harmonic mean of $h(x)$ under $q^*(x)$ which, in practice, is likely to have infinite variance. So, at the least, let's put aside this approach for now.</p> <p>Edit: The keywords "variance reduction MCMC" are actually useful in finding methods that address this issue, I've found a few methods using control variates, antithetic variates, and some adaptive methods like zero variance Monte Carlo. Perhaps someone is able to comment on the viability of these methods or to add more to my list. Thanks.</p> <p>Edit: In response to Xi'an's answer I thought I would update the question.</p> <p>First of all, it appears that my <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/19456/optimal-importance-sampling-with-ratio-estimator">first question</a> where I asked how MCMC could be used to sample from $q^*(x)$ in the case where the normalizer for $\pi(x)$ was known is addressed in the literature primarily as the problem of computing the normalization constant, or equivalently: model evidence, partition function, or energy function. </p> <p>It appears there are a number of different methods for doing this with MCMC and I found chapter 4 of Iain Murray's <a href="http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/imurray2/pub/07thesis/murray_thesis_2007.pdf" rel="nofollow">PhD thesis</a> to be an excellent overview of the main ideas. Also, the very recent paper cited in Xian's answer details a method, MCIS, that offers some particular advantages over these existing methods. However, after reviewing many of these papers I would have to conclude none of these ideas have turned out to be as "straightforward" as I would have hoped.</p> <p>Regarding this question, the answer is essentially: no, there is no straightforward way to solve this problem other than estimating the normalizing constant for $\pi(x)$ separately. That is, if we let: $\hat\pi(x) = \pi(x)/Z$ denote our unnormalized distribution and $I = \int h(x)\hat\pi(x) dx$ denote the quantity of interest up to a normalizing constant, we can use any MCMC methods designed for estimating normalization constants to estimate $I$ and $Z$ separately and return the ratio $\frac{I}{Z}$. How this simple procedure relates to bridge sampling I'm still a bit unsure though.</p>
74,152
[ 0.014831091277301311, 0.004027919378131628, 0.03625591844320297, -0.06916102021932602, 0.03973060101270676, 0.01322120800614357, -0.03358396887779236, -0.07168245315551758, 0.004429584834724665, -0.06459555774927139, 0.02433772198855877, 0.05161300674080849, 0.07647932320833206, 0.04110913351178169, 0.011356976814568043, 0.0006776886875741184, -0.010204634629189968, -0.004249988589435816, -0.023535797372460365, -0.005087379831820726, 0.015426890924572945, 0.048056986182928085, 0.02347423881292343, -0.004121128469705582, -0.05390471965074539, 0.0065896534360945225, 0.02655278891324997, -0.020692069083452225, -0.005534916650503874, 0.09506965428590775, -0.04095420613884926, 0.005668742582201958, 0.04265378788113594, 0.0846172422170639, -0.013310185633599758, 0.010426386259496212, -0.015436963178217411, -0.023711219429969788, -0.016656432300806046, 0.04721350222826004, -0.0398656502366066, -0.020072318613529205, 0.011472952552139759, -0.0017493502236902714, -0.013551137410104275, 0.04626728966832161, -0.018369043245911598, -0.07490731030702591, 0.0633065477013588, -0.06166420504450798, 0.041472651064395905, 0.02087625116109848, -0.007490253541618586, 0.040424782782793045, 0.0035878007765859365, -0.041473083198070526, 0.017893683165311813, 0.04398518055677414, 0.018186645582318306, -0.058682844042778015, 0.003737402381375432, -0.009663661941885948, 0.012388753704726696, -0.0013201686087995768, -0.006190411746501923, 0.013574293814599514, 0.003720559412613511, -0.01507923100143671, 0.0067852637730538845, -0.011001394130289555, 0.03164060413837433, 0.04512818530201912, -0.002277722116559744, -0.008060947060585022, 0.006637954618781805, 0.022162465378642082, -0.024348808452486992, 0.015192817896604538, 0.051786407828330994, 0.026380343362689018, 0.035170264542102814, -0.02018934115767479, 0.0473199188709259, 0.01810285449028015, 0.009731639176607132, 0.004327674861997366, 0.05788057669997215, -0.044695764780044556, -0.00040809670463204384, 0.02571583166718483, -0.03915347531437874, 0.0000903315594769083, 0.04046563431620598, -0.04578070715069771, -0.03673374652862549, 0.03919881582260132, -0.02266138792037964, -0.003874586196616292, -0.008298741653561592, -0.01212338451296091, -0.026553617790341377, -0.058478184044361115, 0.008957048878073692, 0.033236484974622726, 0.0009170773555524647, -0.04026680439710617, -0.013118780218064785, -0.013918152078986168, -0.045271679759025574, -0.019318031147122383, -0.0012025705073028803, -0.006617995910346508, 0.0046224817633628845, 0.006155711133033037, 0.011086491867899895, 0.029710741713643074, 0.006507404148578644, -0.04920298606157303, 0.05550834909081459, 0.0765087753534317, -0.01111698430031538, 0.0018457554979249835, 0.03460386022925377, -0.0500735379755497, -0.0606582947075367, 0.03472593426704407, -0.013389944098889828, 0.0007217309903353453, -0.05411076918244362, 0.032462187111377716, 0.030114322900772095, 0.010749694891273975, 0.04603491351008415, 0.03337293118238449, 0.005522633902728558, -0.012380885891616344, -0.08357802778482437, -0.026932435110211372, 0.03334345296025276, -0.0285081434994936, -0.029827015474438667, -0.07369895279407501, 0.0027191489934921265, 0.05783550813794136, 0.014883739873766899, 0.03666739538311958, 0.04106254130601883, 0.001391325262375176, 0.04834435135126114, 0.03778523579239845, -0.023653507232666016, -0.04655613750219345, -0.004311510361731052, 0.005976403597742319, -0.011953344568610191, -0.08735188841819763, 0.01772061176598072, 0.026431282982230186, -0.01728779450058937, -0.009035403840243816, 0.021411137655377388, 0.02552783489227295, -0.03691455349326134, -0.02160317450761795, 0.007991466671228409, -0.04277089238166809, 0.050112515687942505, 0.0038399891927838326, 0.035421501845121384, -0.03125309571623802, -0.02533208578824997, -0.013736206106841564, -0.022255562245845795, 0.0058289687149226665, 0.04694415628910065, -0.054051779210567474, 0.0009996292646974325, -0.04699796065688133, 0.03245476633310318, 0.038764551281929016, 0.00581321120262146, -0.0029884055256843567, -0.023097503930330276, -0.011659310199320316, 0.026958627626299858, 0.03608834743499756, 0.009738054126501083, -0.019354412332177162, 0.03293489292263985, -0.032418303191661835, -0.060701023787260056, -0.034835334867239, -0.05022180825471878, 0.015477881766855717, -0.026329483836889267, 0.03558395057916641, -0.007809831760823727, 0.0016818217700347304, -0.0037023210898041725, -0.023142719641327858, -0.015411149710416794, -0.013663590885698795, 0.041075803339481354, -0.04457918182015419, 0.0105140320956707, 0.006265007890760899, 0.014850780367851257, -0.00475930655375123, 0.03963270038366318, -0.02176622487604618, -0.058735787868499756, -0.0544758178293705, -0.04776006564497948, 0.005596823990345001, -0.015542016364634037, -0.03759174421429634, 0.03712168708443642, -0.05523116514086723, -0.0028567721601575613, 0.006176749709993601, -0.056493330746889114, 0.05245419964194298, 0.055511362850666046, -0.03638508915901184, -0.027196193113923073, 0.017825422808527946, -0.0007297551492229104, -0.011083416640758514, -0.021344436332583427, -0.036897093057632446, -0.054022204130887985, 0.01555972546339035, 0.05963529273867607, 0.03663018345832825, -0.04722447320818901, -0.03101363405585289, 0.07172160595655441, 0.02112266980111599, 0.059474505484104156, 0.027717020362615585, -0.02216378226876259, -0.049504440277814865, 0.06417793780565262, 0.007674178574234247, 0.019588107243180275, 0.008493015542626381, -0.0026903438847512007, -0.008975492790341377, 0.014069933444261551, 0.001284557394683361, 0.022472960874438286, 0.0029740959871560335, -0.009025853127241135, -0.010458845645189285, -0.005226826760917902, -0.007155439350754023, -0.0027018620166927576, -0.02032206393778324, -0.006834026426076889, 0.011979191564023495, 0.003517398377880454, 0.020770899951457977, -0.005352571606636047, -0.02596699632704258, 0.025161007419228554, 0.032665252685546875, -0.025483185425400734, 0.04514656215906143, 0.02185755968093872, -0.0015614990843459964, 0.0007470588316209614, -0.02915199287235737, 0.022232836112380028, 0.0043650721199810505, -0.008692794479429722, 0.00958290696144104, 0.009377707727253437, -0.025892002508044243, -0.023660656064748764, -0.0002224382187705487, 0.03853873163461685, 0.02600123919546604, -0.026354338973760605, 0.04501724988222122, -0.009995945729315281, -0.026217183098196983, -0.03399499133229256, -0.006786596495658159, 0.01784604601562023, -0.009630253538489342, -0.0037343178410083055, 0.02165989764034748, 0.04200374335050583, -0.07039064168930054, 0.00958943273872137, -0.03076189197599888, 0.025573646649718285, -0.02466627024114132, -0.03145565837621689, 0.04436778277158737, 0.04196358099579811, -0.0563092865049839, 0.045284025371074677, -0.0041891601867973804, -0.03713947907090187, -0.07119937986135483, 0.00048471291665919125, 0.02218550257384777, -0.008430620655417442, -0.009465747512876987, 0.023091549053788185, -0.002273349557071924, -0.013448651880025864, -0.056341156363487244, -0.043272487819194794, 0.03521205484867096, -0.0004931844887323678, 0.03886369988322258, 0.028713954612612724, -0.025970155373215675, 0.06930087506771088, 0.03842833638191223, 0.003908774349838495, -0.013956451788544655, -0.00010816310532391071, 0.009358441457152367, -0.013128365390002728, 0.004042354412376881, 0.023290306329727173, -0.011102150194346905, 0.017231736332178116, -0.013184668496251106, 0.027064472436904907, 0.03119697980582714, -0.0019298631232231855, 0.04687286540865898, 0.042961057275533676, -0.03237241134047508, 0.02368152141571045, 0.029002638533711433, 0.013661139644682407, -0.012647505849599838, -0.03011617623269558, 0.03842395171523094, 0.006193080917000771, 0.003957025706768036, -0.03463181480765343, 0.02330620028078556, -0.014353185892105103, 0.004995960276573896, -0.03301214054226875, 0.02436407282948494, 0.009166278876364231, -0.03287907689809799, -0.01766803301870823, -0.004020582884550095, -0.00798250362277031, -0.0008974005468189716, 0.016995633020997047, 0.04666659235954285, 0.06217174977064133, -0.02691321074962616, -0.0022516886238008738, -0.025220008566975594, 0.002752783242613077, 0.019070127978920937, -0.06411421298980713, -0.028841419145464897, 0.011844526045024395, 0.08302661031484604, 0.015870558097958565, -0.01462825108319521, -0.03719323128461838, 0.007426855619996786, -0.03994559124112129, -0.0018141918117180467, -0.05871821567416191, 0.07176666706800461, 0.007273025345057249, 0.04952571168541908, 0.011472141370177269, 0.018497835844755173, -0.030945705249905586, -0.0010620806133374572, -0.06885968893766403, 0.021624412387609482, -0.027015527710318565, -0.03715904802083969, -0.01587017998099327, -0.0258231982588768, 0.039002444595098495, 0.01944495551288128, 0.010682499967515469, -0.02975098229944706, 0.00327390362508595, -0.02282603830099106, 0.010959622450172901, -0.005078548565506935, -0.014859158545732498, -0.022386355325579643, 0.04461178183555603, 0.036669135093688965, -0.04093712568283081, -0.006513952277600765, 0.019350072368979454, -0.03741323947906494, 0.0016658739186823368, -0.0006774635403417051, 0.0204776618629694, 0.0021558713633567095, 0.05784129723906517, 0.02195730060338974, 0.04309561103582382, -0.01770918071269989, 0.021295100450515747, 0.03282623365521431, 0.058302123099565506, 0.03799572214484215, -0.030422940850257874, 0.04532559588551521, -0.0048021129332482815, -0.023618049919605255, 0.02395826391875744, 0.013009601272642612, -0.024370577186346054, -0.010862347669899464, 0.047395043075084686, 0.03227515146136284, -0.05094464123249054, -0.0242333821952343, 0.015606059692800045, 0.011089827865362167, 0.006550684105604887, -0.04079368710517883, 0.020704319700598717, -0.031516604125499725, 0.001924857497215271, 0.012435326352715492, 0.02671903558075428, 0.007501540239900351, 0.002351911971345544, 0.02372468076646328, 0.04323601350188255, -0.033158671110868454, 0.002591582713648677, 0.019900882616639137, 0.011905166320502758, 0.012275689281523228, -0.0034468432422727346, -0.013498667627573013, -0.004919431172311306, 0.025018738582730293, 0.0318618007004261, 0.013673550449311733, -0.05850294604897499, -0.037369709461927414, 0.007894580252468586, 0.04294232651591301, -0.03465104103088379, 0.018141888082027435, -0.052159134298563004, 0.003376391250640154, 0.0665288195014, 0.00019152447930537164, -0.0029221803415566683, -0.033707600086927414, 0.011796988546848297, -0.021323975175619125, -0.0444081649184227, -0.04348379373550415, -0.0026074680499732494, -0.029671411961317062, 0.02334752306342125, -0.04858403280377388, -0.019493309780955315, -0.0575413815677166, 0.03158804029226303, 0.0007307330379262567, 0.06366554647684097, -0.008237279951572418, -0.014502844773232937, -0.026170779019594193, 0.0244743674993515, 0.0061515080742537975, -0.09218233823776245, 0.009621620178222656, -0.012933790683746338, 0.007701165974140167, 0.042477164417505264, -0.019322469830513, -0.06426839530467987, 0.05779512599110603, 0.014197366312146187, -0.010791001841425896, 0.03991212695837021, -0.013126538135111332, 0.0367140993475914, 0.02768830768764019, 0.03988425061106682, 0.06650777161121368, 0.045752495527267456, -0.023568453267216682, 0.01508163008838892, -0.024442506954073906, 0.0010196641087532043, -0.04705880954861641, -0.04174202308058739, -0.014583763666450977, -0.02416228875517845, -0.0030777836218476295, 0.024258514866232872, -0.019133733585476875, 0.07849210500717163, 0.013230722397565842, -0.023258084431290627, 0.034379344433546066, 0.03392250835895538, -0.0006439333083108068, -0.006071568001061678, -0.013642481528222561, 0.010619944892823696, 0.037967026233673096, 0.0008956011733971536, -0.012854316271841526, 0.029378406703472137, 0.0015183361247181892, 0.029247846454381943, -0.03683518245816231, -0.028950773179531097, -0.031040919944643974, -0.018381783738732338, 0.019233550876379013, 0.013284347020089626, 0.03839781880378723, 0.0022661120165139437, 0.04357679560780525, 0.0016725922469049692, -0.034242406487464905, -0.02583353780210018, 0.011721356771886349, -0.023217568174004555, 0.018825551494956017, -0.03041808493435383, 0.015397663228213787, -0.03790818154811859, 0.028526760637760162, -0.05634015426039696, 0.007668174337595701, -0.01608002558350563, 0.024159621447324753, 0.008402159437537193, -0.03571946173906326, 0.006698341574519873, 0.031507283449172974, -0.019106853753328323, -0.034865085035562515, 0.04001149535179138, 0.0036363177932798862, 0.013593585230410099, -0.00809397641569376, 0.022572360932826996, 0.056950345635414124, -0.039101045578718185, 0.00981576181948185, 0.03985653817653656, -0.026216372847557068, -0.012216340750455856, -0.01962207816541195, 0.007856402546167374, -0.043811481446027756, -0.016931233927607536, -0.015053576789796352, -0.024915164336562157, 0.017678966745734215, 0.0051245782524347305, -0.02123107574880123, 0.06700544059276581, 0.00836386252194643, 0.008856642059981823, -0.010666929185390472, -0.06445920467376709, 0.010107391513884068, 0.047645747661590576, -0.010974274016916752, -0.006960519589483738, -0.013417053036391735, 0.0014024734264239669, 0.035417359322309494, 0.00017197646957356483, -0.03812846168875694, 0.025655068457126617, 0.018285628408193588, -0.02563530206680298, -0.023499175906181335, 0.005929957143962383, -0.03434416279196739, 0.01705304905772209, -0.009339762851595879, -0.0020317065063863993, 0.005710439290851355, 0.0017685580532997847, 0.008963758125901222, -0.061805080622434616, -0.08441124856472015, 0.007283500395715237, 0.009199023246765137, 0.024058349430561066, 0.02742667682468891, 0.013434364460408688, -0.02503395266830921, -0.043196577578783035, -0.0017881423700600863, -0.05029316619038582, -0.008892093785107136, -0.042910028249025345, 0.01213696040213108, 0.003040863433852792, -0.0021693536546081305, 0.03509051352739334, -0.00269151059910655, -0.019670845940709114, 0.046852465718984604, -0.01913413032889366, 0.022301731631159782, 0.013884666375815868, -0.04406855255365372, -0.03833257779479027, 0.03938642889261246, -0.059519294649362564, 0.015991052612662315, -0.027798928320407867, -0.03122735023498535, 0.04227873310446739, 0.03819581866264343, -0.014989235438406467, -0.038108084350824356, -0.016599858179688454, -0.04278309643268585, 0.0019934310112148523, 0.013051810674369335, -0.015123536810278893, 0.06466839462518692, 0.002303072949871421, 0.0035957058425992727, -0.013210820965468884, 0.03242763504385948, -0.007384369149804115, -0.0834152027964592, 0.0019158925861120224, 0.003952156752347946, -0.04295048117637634, 0.007839085534214973, 0.01616961695253849, -0.03338796645402908, 0.02461460791528225, -0.0486266128718853, 0.040745142847299576, -0.005395799875259399, 0.00018827759777195752, -0.038876768201589584, 0.0703621655702591, 0.0048734815791249275, 0.021473640576004982, -0.022787723690271378, 0.0015956187853589654, 0.13048717379570007, 0.042396776378154755, 0.03526795655488968, -0.05002762749791145, 0.006959761492908001, -0.001881070202216506, 0.0038406786043196917, -0.018902486190199852, -0.014737185090780258, 0.01638437621295452, -0.036657728254795074, 0.002898547099903226, 0.04693637415766716, 0.00665742252022028, -0.010854759253561497, 0.03669154271483421, -0.0026139297988265753, -0.01613866351544857, 0.017408296465873718, 0.020057443529367447, -0.01703624054789543, 0.008780787698924541, -0.06784975528717041, 0.022513186559081078, -0.012418213300406933, 0.008025990799069405, -0.01405652891844511, -0.002997172996401787, -0.033891644328832626, -0.030985837802290916, -0.03528192639350891, 0.0031751126516610384, 0.022341052070260048, -0.039620183408260345, 0.04034300148487091, -0.025498760864138603, 0.03404257446527481, -0.024004055187106133, -0.019117290154099464, 0.041908491402864456, 0.01621989533305168, 0.0063704438507556915, -0.037835102528333664, -0.0032405138481408358, -0.037597205489873886, -0.04465458169579506, -0.04444510489702225, 0.034616611897945404, -0.025829046964645386, -0.002024236600846052, -0.012373179197311401, -0.011070352047681808, -0.013774128630757332, -0.010843702591955662, 0.04911452904343605, -0.00275325495749712, 0.024286052212119102, -0.024333419278264046, -0.013748974539339542, 0.00935096014291048, 0.02808384783565998, -0.01089021097868681, 0.056338053196668625, 0.017842622473835945, -0.06212962046265602, -0.05186629667878151, -0.00608386006206274, 0.01543899904936552, -0.004027875140309334, -0.016835562884807587, 0.008030074648559093, -0.013673792593181133, -0.01086411252617836, -0.03206838667392731, -0.023749738931655884, -0.037338946014642715, 0.08574876189231873, -0.026536915451288223, 0.0030612568370997906, -0.036403413861989975, -0.044727910310029984, 0.04699109122157097, -0.0243629552423954, 0.008064019493758678, -0.0249714907258749, -0.028341984376311302, 0.013199702836573124, 0.03822890296578407, 0.04808143898844719, -0.015028022229671478, -0.014807144179940224, 0.057121530175209045, 0.00795746874064207, -0.013163278810679913, -0.014069813303649426, -0.014156508259475231, -0.0338812954723835, -0.0059007215313613415, 0.02355906553566456, 0.029071660712361336, 0.020512085407972336, 0.002585374051705003, 0.0005642083706334233, 0.014681534841656685, 0.003839187091216445, 0.024528592824935913, -0.0006069907685741782, -0.04071016609668732, -0.003639807691797614, 0.021477561444044113, 0.028884831815958023, -0.02821796014904976, 0.022753294557332993, -0.019860466942191124, -0.0021595957223325968, 0.0033459924161434174, 0.023461176082491875, -0.051418520510196686, -0.013709532096982002, -0.006333875469863415, 0.037865545600652695, -0.0005291911074891686, 0.01894453354179859, 0.0001850355474743992, 0.0022844956256449223, -0.030422063544392586, 0.016901709139347076, 0.002145838923752308, -0.0072913216426968575, 0.007721113506704569, 0.031001299619674683, 0.04362126439809799, -0.016682706773281097, 0.04817648231983185, 0.00874299742281437, -0.014061310328543186, 0.031779054552316666, -0.006987764500081539, -0.022749384865164757, 0.010764403268694878, 0.03547051548957825, -0.06375890225172043, -0.03722967207431793, 0.03814574331045151, 0.006635194178670645, 0.011469191871583462, 0.050458475947380066, -0.0009512798860669136, -0.03562340885400772, -0.008319624699652195, -0.021585633978247643, -0.0063835252076387405, -0.014215843752026558, 0.024237727746367455, 0.01753404177725315, -0.029508860781788826, 0.03066209703683853, 0.004302854184061289, 0.029512299224734306, 0.0392548032104969, 0.0203059371560812, 0.0022937862668186426, 0.0009806868620216846, 0.042039815336465836, 0.008076798170804977, 0.02101838029921055, 0.009206661023199558, 0.03422044590115547, 0.07123778015375137, 0.07144377380609512, -0.05259574204683304, 0.03648671135306358, -0.033331695944070816, -0.011107122525572777, -0.09887677431106567, -0.04409094899892807, -0.0137029392644763, 0.013056477531790733, 0.04243897274136543, -0.02147890441119671, -0.009028184227645397, 0.02058769203722477, -0.07157563418149948, 0.0346936360001564, 0.024559613317251205, 0.02214728854596615, -0.039773840457201004, -0.00684827147051692, -0.006737407296895981, 0.007735517807304859, 0.024269700050354004, -0.0013170375023037195, 0.05297357589006424, 0.053690068423748016, 0.006961831822991371, 0.004816039931029081, 0.0035840230993926525, 0.00927288644015789, -0.006653302349150181, -0.030031772330403328, 0.04401396960020065, -0.044916145503520966, -0.003062807023525238, 0.008618832565844059, 0.06508347392082214, 0.03883657604455948, -0.014227570965886116, 0.009765730239450932, 0.03773815557360649, 0.036564815789461136, 0.01333549153059721, -0.012237069196999073, 0.012942296452820301, -0.0040070549584925175, 0.037295788526535034, 0.016845792531967163, -0.0022903226781636477, 0.009184690192341805, 0.030433891341090202, -0.023543529212474823, -0.018998023122549057, 0.017278315499424934, 0.02940567024052143, -0.03973032906651497, 0.0003172115539200604, -0.018492629751563072, 0.0003785350127145648, -0.005392265971750021, 0.03320486098527908, -0.023541338741779327, 0.024563005194067955, 0.05231548473238945, -0.0009003073791973293, -0.002204861491918564, -0.011901999823749065, -0.03241242840886116, -0.06343613564968109, 0.03949226438999176, 0.013366213999688625, -0.030778473243117332, -0.05005118250846863, -0.018703848123550415, 0.028039513155817986, 0.045345455408096313, -0.0033961592707782984, 0.010991004295647144, -0.03165019303560257, 0.015443192794919014, -0.003285075072199106, 0.011743385344743729, -0.013810939155519009, -0.010709627531468868, -0.009426196105778217, -0.0548480823636055, 0.04688318446278572, 0.03068718872964382, -0.024092618376016617, 0.001441081054508686, -0.010553613305091858, -0.02888893522322178, -0.004093524068593979, 0.0712178498506546, 0.023514555767178535, -0.0199198629707098, -0.009411201812326908, 0.04385801777243614, 0.047043874859809875, -0.04257480427622795, 0.003522078040987253, -0.01747954450547695, 0.01248780358582735, -0.011927271261811256, 0.011854497715830803, 0.02325969934463501, 0.013557872734963894, 0.004181623458862305, -0.020506005734205246, 0.002189100254327059, -0.0015443390002474189, 0.030868178233504295, 0.03484597057104111, 0.0023931863252073526, -0.01280505582690239, 0.01859114319086075, -0.007553006988018751, 0.003836644347757101, 0.007091099396348, -0.003798485966399312, -0.07348622381687164, -0.00839976966381073, -0.04456831142306328, -0.046373166143894196, 0.02262560836970806, 0.023599723353981972, 0.0037773638032376766, -0.03591208904981613, -0.009580315090715885, 0.04228469356894493, -0.037441186606884, 0.0034010920207947493, 0.04570955038070679, 0.01297389343380928, 0.05240003019571304, 0.03926169499754906, 0.01872091367840767, 0.024952653795480728, 0.005033364053815603, -0.010905664414167404, 0.0006118424935266376, 0.023396506905555725, -0.01698075607419014, 0.00809736829251051, 0.004704650491476059, 0.0007803849293850362, 0.004351744428277016, 0.004835321102291346, 0.02107449434697628, -0.04489317163825035, -0.026145659387111664, 0.027545299381017685, -0.04345882311463356, 0.001636639004573226, 0.012360746040940285, 0.0032339130993932486, 0.09000035375356674, 0.014813359826803207, 0.00680014630779624, -0.03289449214935303, -0.01429951936006546, -0.03469046577811241, 0.0033626931253820658, -0.049803584814071655, 0.06516297161579132, -0.014883438125252724, -0.011976494453847408, -0.004646642133593559, -0.004831515718251467, 0.035034339874982834, -0.03574731573462486, 0.025002172216773033, 0.019080642610788345, -0.0022216227371245623, -0.011195640079677105, -0.03568996489048004, -0.020072123035788536, -0.019909707829356194, -0.025561796501278877, 0.037536539137363434, 0.06923291832208633, 0.03868446126580238, -0.01524373609572649, 0.01676619052886963, 0.043028008192777634, -0.045849721878767014, 0.03344853222370148, -0.029257608577609062, -0.02031954750418663, -0.0013591835740953684, -0.0003008589264936745 ]
<p>I am working with a batch of about 1000 univariate time series in R . For every time series, I have to perform following tasks , before deciding upon a model be it ARIMA, TAR or Holt Winter's Model </p> <ol> <li>Trend Detection and its type , i.e. whether trend is deterministic or stochastic</li> <li>Seasonality Detection and then deciding whether it is additive or multiplicative</li> <li>Does the series needs transformation. If yes then what kind of transformation is required, i.e whether box-cox or logarithmic.</li> </ol> <p>Currently I have to visualize every series and then take a call , are there any mathematical criterion available, which can reduce this effort</p> <p>Also what are the other factors that I need to consider before deciding on which model to use</p>
74,153
[ -0.04354895278811455, -0.019378652796149254, -0.007487580180168152, -0.011343737132847309, 0.017323141917586327, -0.01472274586558342, 0.0034605488181114197, -0.035823285579681396, 0.03671254590153694, -0.009746495634317398, 0.04984787479043007, 0.03546823561191559, 0.04771241545677185, 0.05373091995716095, 0.018667377531528473, -0.01723944954574108, -0.02935168892145157, 0.01165092084556818, -0.016953466460108757, 0.0310104601085186, -0.021005762740969658, 0.005197014659643173, 0.04318090155720711, -0.00472003361210227, -0.034550607204437256, 0.05638231709599495, 0.02076093852519989, 0.008502746000885963, -0.0030306128319352865, 0.06705429404973984, -0.033090561628341675, -0.027933821082115173, 0.02615601383149624, 0.04584949463605881, 0.03497826308012009, 0.013366962783038616, -0.01856142096221447, -0.019478540867567062, 0.005249788984656334, 0.03703233599662781, -0.01860686019062996, -0.0032422561198472977, 0.017893487587571144, -0.0005878489464521408, -0.021336883306503296, 0.03257594257593155, 0.016939224675297737, 0.012274382635951042, 0.05095988139510155, -0.05185166001319885, 0.05742758885025978, -0.020393000915646553, 0.020939167588949203, 0.0388888455927372, -0.025248417630791664, -0.024933645501732826, 0.05558861419558525, 0.049960676580667496, -0.008090394549071789, -0.06842470914125443, 0.01137341558933258, -0.007275207433849573, -0.01892371103167534, -0.04010338336229324, -0.04570193588733673, 0.015053069218993187, 0.0030220714397728443, 0.003927746322005987, 0.02839760109782219, 0.01782110519707203, 0.015318488702178001, -0.010761204175651073, 0.020515022799372673, -0.010600430890917778, -0.010403363034129143, -0.008072885684669018, -0.017085127532482147, 0.014053615741431713, 0.04968986660242081, 0.04603651165962219, 0.008631187491118908, 0.022650500759482384, 0.003736162791028619, 0.05202333256602287, 0.03859743848443031, -0.0037370079662650824, 0.06633113324642181, -0.031669411808252335, -0.006510396953672171, -0.001641946379095316, 0.0015981430187821388, -0.005035405978560448, 0.05981694161891937, 0.007638074457645416, -0.034034162759780884, 0.036318711936473846, -0.027249831706285477, 0.0133641567081213, -0.00280941859818995, 0.0030091272201389074, 0.012109036557376385, -0.015317379496991634, 0.0039234166033566, 0.030083978548645973, -0.045149851590394974, 0.06467331945896149, -0.025132786482572556, -0.014181000180542469, -0.025485774502158165, -0.02654789201915264, -0.05484885722398758, 0.007653788663446903, -0.018470168113708496, 0.03217066451907158, 0.011837996542453766, -0.005809980910271406, -0.02498544007539749, -0.024780170992016792, 0.04316866025328636, 0.06057453155517578, 0.05786130949854851, -0.012009162455797195, 0.02662961371243, -0.02394484169781208, -0.04605279490351677, -0.0005025215214118361, -0.034872230142354965, 0.00011816501501016319, -0.053018346428871155, 0.05308178439736366, -0.010501667857170105, -0.07402973622083664, 0.04598848894238472, -0.021814633160829544, 0.06109512597322464, -0.004157048650085926, -0.05244846269488335, -0.058803971856832504, 0.024139901623129845, -0.02452944591641426, 0.03302660956978798, -0.043020229786634445, 0.011249683797359467, 0.035267412662506104, 0.02964562363922596, -0.010838158428668976, 0.04210647568106651, 0.04555566981434822, 0.026651233434677124, -0.02675086073577404, -0.045463643968105316, -0.0009691318846307695, -0.010520979762077332, -0.0010201173136010766, 0.009859987534582615, -0.07012788951396942, 0.0015410615596920252, 0.02936817705631256, -0.03575209528207779, -0.017008129507303238, 0.020297106355428696, 0.004294730257242918, -0.015611913055181503, 0.0042433543130755424, 0.0038982268888503313, -0.0032326497603207827, 0.044896580278873444, -0.014371995814144611, 0.04007802903652191, 0.0044347746297717094, -0.020022548735141754, 0.02188561111688614, 0.05091623589396477, 0.04223928973078728, 0.049729056656360626, -0.0192339476197958, -0.003386138938367367, -0.0236589927226305, -0.026458440348505974, 0.04525037854909897, -0.0453401543200016, -0.02982497401535511, -0.05398895964026451, -0.05007225275039673, 0.040799494832754135, 0.040462423115968704, -0.008463255129754543, -0.03758435696363449, 0.08373935520648956, -0.06975352764129639, -0.038473427295684814, -0.05510938912630081, -0.015678009018301964, -0.04184340685606003, 0.007154218852519989, 0.02574307844042778, -0.01650182344019413, 0.024953316897153854, -0.028410393744707108, -0.011490595526993275, 0.006275882478803396, -0.013990581035614014, 0.06684232503175735, -0.03930002823472023, 0.009583779610693455, 0.018396325409412384, 0.027503494173288345, -0.045368485152721405, 0.006567782256752253, -0.0470658540725708, -0.04110763221979141, -0.003199733328074217, -0.061206646263599396, 0.013874913565814495, -0.03865891322493553, -0.019302794709801674, 0.03327993303537369, -0.007080863695591688, -0.03151350095868111, 0.02976614236831665, -0.035848189145326614, 0.04464016854763031, 0.04056452214717865, 0.018472347408533096, 0.03132179006934166, 0.026589982211589813, 0.028872089460492134, 0.039435286074876785, 0.004316064994782209, -0.007021940778940916, -0.06480354815721512, 0.018063105642795563, 0.05198066309094429, 0.03303147479891777, -0.025020701810717583, 0.02646862529218197, 0.05123300477862358, 0.03210025653243065, -0.0009607394458726048, 0.030526643618941307, -0.004824936855584383, 0.014564553275704384, -0.006537103094160557, 0.02576545625925064, 0.005330625455826521, 0.0019861527252942324, 0.008017357438802719, -0.01000280026346445, 0.05685243383049965, -0.0076447417959570885, -0.05108238756656647, 0.04181722179055214, 0.03154803812503815, 0.015885842964053154, 0.0007209555478766561, 0.01548311673104763, 0.03388558328151703, -0.03816280514001846, -0.03460390865802765, 0.036315713077783585, 0.03690596669912338, 0.01223785150796175, 0.03505507484078407, 0.002433599205687642, -0.0011687303194776177, 0.02789405733346939, -0.016716109588742256, -0.012816164642572403, 0.030386924743652344, -0.031583938747644424, 0.024554090574383736, -0.015338389202952385, -0.052749767899513245, -0.06465194374322891, -0.002068279543891549, 0.06935761123895645, 0.0016216590302065015, 0.012658658437430859, -0.0184610765427351, -0.024289201945066452, -0.004520495887845755, -0.02328171394765377, 0.012820178642868996, -0.0026507878210395575, -0.04435381293296814, 0.009138201363384724, -0.00828144047409296, -0.027231071144342422, 0.032961152493953705, -0.04528457298874855, -0.0035437087062746286, 0.033310696482658386, 0.010127865709364414, -0.04768141359090805, -0.07125003635883331, -0.02835160307586193, 0.03479257598519325, -0.0371694415807724, -0.011894961819052696, 0.03870008513331413, 0.014473870396614075, -0.028173426166176796, -0.031003080308437347, -0.04398103430867195, 0.005466514732688665, -0.04121461883187294, 0.0011995348613709211, 0.024595914408564568, 0.005074653774499893, 0.00030619086464866996, 0.004349221009761095, -0.029768269509077072, 0.005954255815595388, -0.05012611299753189, -0.02054435759782791, -0.026502078399062157, 0.006059231702238321, 0.05192789062857628, 0.00964303407818079, -0.02968522720038891, 0.03227178007364273, 0.07052653282880783, -0.05787159502506256, -0.06495923548936844, -0.035812780261039734, -0.028196780011057854, -0.058958977460861206, 0.03822919353842735, 0.03229479119181633, 0.01857970654964447, -0.0046148840337991714, -0.001735260826535523, 0.020384253934025764, 0.009541751816868782, -0.004091258626431227, -0.01944938488304615, 0.006893832236528397, -0.02361666038632393, 0.006907491013407707, 0.025885682553052902, 0.012594860047101974, -0.0321710966527462, 0.020434416830539703, -0.036982737481594086, -0.005536013748496771, 0.04740307480096817, -0.026870708912611008, 0.025955883786082268, -0.013902236707508564, 0.0044030677527189255, -0.010826476849615574, -0.0030371276661753654, 0.03285721689462662, -0.012294876389205456, -0.009593842551112175, 0.035315047949552536, 0.009824893437325954, -0.009600909426808357, 0.0034517496824264526, 0.05828555300831795, 0.051892004907131195, -0.042736537754535675, 0.02342773973941803, -0.03838649019598961, -0.030828827992081642, 0.026100225746631622, -0.0661521703004837, -0.0076926168985664845, 0.04890330135822296, 0.010470492765307426, 0.0384058803319931, -0.0055531966499984264, -0.07324765622615814, -0.016186833381652832, -0.053859855979681015, -0.03908316418528557, -0.030169589444994926, 0.08222004771232605, 0.01613699272274971, 0.012324878945946693, 0.050823647528886795, -0.0024753878824412823, 0.04442521184682846, -0.0071900589391589165, -0.027827899903059006, 0.042911868542432785, 0.006683597806841135, 0.01952631026506424, -0.002461683936417103, 0.01695753075182438, -0.0016693932702764869, -0.03351007401943207, 0.014256622642278671, -0.026591956615447998, 0.03942817822098732, -0.03299039229750633, 0.047864872962236404, -0.041849344968795776, -0.02585744671523571, -0.018388722091913223, 0.011362887918949127, 0.030123069882392883, -0.03404470533132553, 0.03771229088306427, 0.027501722797751427, 0.01932048425078392, -0.022844644263386726, -0.011715809814631939, 0.016611166298389435, 0.00951998122036457, 0.04474282264709473, 0.006243944633752108, -0.0019311682553961873, -0.05725866183638573, 0.042429886758327484, 0.03421277180314064, 0.021935004740953445, 0.007498488295823336, -0.013296002522110939, -0.03389020636677742, -0.05548683553934097, -0.015266994945704937, 0.039334967732429504, 0.01177253294736147, 0.06342075765132904, 0.008699849247932434, 0.058361537754535675, 0.009609649889171124, -0.04169175401329994, 0.018405631184577942, 0.07658744603395462, 0.004128139000386, 0.011075387708842754, 0.00010798332368722185, -0.047006361186504364, 0.012193259783089161, 0.008265871554613113, 0.03678669407963753, 0.02725927159190178, 0.004788422491401434, -0.001024966943077743, 0.007955091074109077, -0.03871757909655571, -0.04201336205005646, -0.006988653913140297, 0.0667949989438057, 0.07175576686859131, 0.006245496217161417, -0.03385264053940773, 0.0377996452152729, 0.028805512934923172, 0.015707608312368393, -0.0028238154482096434, 0.007878507487475872, -0.09096121788024902, 0.022435257211327553, 0.06357581913471222, 0.03048243187367916, -0.030434036627411842, -0.03096717596054077, -0.045248501002788544, -0.030409064143896103, 0.030760368332266808, -0.022476082667708397, 0.024460509419441223, 0.0059473286382853985, 0.03869308903813362, -0.015630202367901802, -0.055624838918447495, -0.005160917527973652, 0.02302960865199566, -0.01670619286596775, 0.04203134402632713, -0.03564762696623802, -0.04147495701909065, -0.04681827500462532, 0.024703247472643852, -0.04460398480296135, 0.02630537934601307, -0.013564866036176682, 0.019858703017234802, 0.004249845165759325, 0.011308430694043636, 0.006303128786385059, -0.03743697330355644, -0.006166355684399605, 0.0010907825781032443, -0.01534360833466053, 0.033831920474767685, -0.008158933371305466, -0.05830052122473717, -0.020058052614331245, 0.019350610673427582, -0.012590957805514336, 0.02701414003968239, -0.01863536238670349, 0.038700953125953674, 0.017998328432440758, 0.027552876621484756, 0.048287905752658844, 0.04422362893819809, 0.009266303852200508, 0.0029392114374786615, -0.020631937310099602, -0.018249789252877235, -0.021084224805235863, -0.001594896661117673, -0.02294747717678547, -0.003279708791524172, -0.03257334604859352, 0.01564115099608898, -0.005628314800560474, 0.029259128496050835, 0.00766406673938036, 0.05248811095952988, 0.010614301078021526, 0.03911161422729492, 0.027624817565083504, -0.04938574135303497, 0.008661982603371143, 0.037905093282461166, -0.06554975360631943, -0.009554503485560417, 0.017205290496349335, -0.023903783410787582, -0.0018348892917856574, 0.01251313742250204, -0.02543310448527336, 0.03592124581336975, -0.010548406280577183, 0.018734309822320938, -0.021066967397928238, 0.026245348155498505, 0.031201239675283432, 0.03448924794793129, 0.04459979012608528, 0.022937454283237457, -0.04768531024456024, -0.010910849086940289, 0.028530068695545197, 0.011322766542434692, 0.028569674119353294, -0.027568886056542397, 0.038200754672288895, -0.0416979044675827, 0.004790900275111198, -0.012785816565155983, -0.08574680984020233, 0.034175578504800797, 0.030729219317436218, -0.009700959548354149, -0.035068560391664505, 0.018917031586170197, -0.036112140864133835, 0.024467583745718002, -0.022117966786026955, 0.06601746380329132, -0.027402425184845924, -0.01935822144150734, 0.012704708613455296, 0.04944877326488495, 0.08099431544542313, -0.0017821487272158265, 0.007516653276979923, 0.031132236123085022, 0.014428899623453617, -0.01748095080256462, -0.0008158374112099409, 0.012116510421037674, -0.023806501179933548, -0.022088784724473953, -0.033194009214639664, -0.02829958125948906, 0.05082745477557182, -0.017021380364894867, 0.0067454734817147255, 0.030242832377552986, -0.0012223719386383891, 0.003291264409199357, -0.02587202936410904, 0.008218071423470974, -0.0009459907887503505, 0.004434819798916578, -0.01304292120039463, -0.023127026855945587, -0.009662607684731483, -0.03894522041082382, 0.01583815924823284, -0.009826808236539364, 0.01885528862476349, 0.03171803057193756, -0.0027791159227490425, 0.00011590521899051964, -0.005648801568895578, -0.00702378386631608, -0.024185657501220703, 0.03664517030119896, 0.00030241531203500926, 0.009842732921242714, -0.007869085296988487, -0.01741151325404644, -0.02474520169198513, -0.051323309540748596, 0.005349983461201191, -0.013075664639472961, 0.05894540622830391, 0.013268006965517998, 0.03427509963512421, 0.03735847398638725, 0.016140537336468697, 0.014397907070815563, -0.032239027321338654, -0.011928712017834187, -0.003975095227360725, 0.02661943808197975, 0.029336780309677124, -0.00102746463380754, -0.00001483655159972841, 0.004061354789882898, -0.004861569497734308, 0.033806104212999344, 0.04073856398463249, 0.03439489006996155, -0.004149962682276964, 0.026040339842438698, -0.05756431445479393, -0.03573606163263321, -0.006469233892858028, -0.029077671468257904, 0.04699012637138367, -0.028075112029910088, -0.018981605768203735, 0.03503180295228958, 0.06586232781410217, -0.008444122038781643, -0.04616153985261917, 0.00830885861068964, -0.0810614600777626, -0.00929140206426382, 0.019707612693309784, -0.02947382442653179, 0.014729189686477184, 0.013220840133726597, 0.05264338105916977, -0.0010004974901676178, 0.03695825859904289, 0.0009740208042785525, -0.07388026267290115, -0.012434976175427437, -0.003811096539720893, -0.04367842897772789, 0.04559929668903351, 0.0019405995262786746, 0.004701314959675074, -0.036423418670892715, -0.0074210441671311855, -0.012962987646460533, 0.006247219163924456, 0.047511521726846695, -0.014380495995283127, 0.07381302863359451, -0.01793530210852623, 0.01428151410073042, -0.02097790502011776, 0.013246297836303711, 0.13146786391735077, 0.045013174414634705, 0.04744882136583328, -0.042714979499578476, -0.00442242668941617, -0.0032487574499100447, 0.01280898042023182, -0.016382185742259026, 0.029444914311170578, 0.030908232554793358, -0.0029942612163722515, 0.044206343591213226, 0.019112862646579742, -0.007551142014563084, -0.025482410565018654, 0.061413832008838654, -0.039390888065099716, -0.005588260479271412, -0.023106615990400314, 0.046691376715898514, 0.009716296568512917, 0.023073650896549225, -0.07555072754621506, 0.019769933074712753, -0.012903962284326553, -0.033990006893873215, 0.019730662927031517, -0.009606188163161278, 0.0045391893945634365, -0.00028042501071467996, -0.038909781724214554, 0.03089327923953533, 0.04914337769150734, 0.02821003645658493, -0.01850525476038456, -0.002454290399327874, -0.006797494366765022, -0.05485987290740013, 0.022542962804436684, 0.021858129650354385, -0.006572260987013578, -0.0043600318022072315, -0.004979482386261225, -0.012076708488166332, -0.018202293664216995, 0.00719259399920702, -0.06803702563047409, -0.007590715307742357, 0.021806497126817703, -0.02183389477431774, -0.012835808098316193, 0.0067261746153235435, -0.014620264060795307, -0.04128587990999222, -0.02288503758609295, -0.00291057419963181, 0.03880150616168976, -0.029439406469464302, -0.04618395119905472, -0.02867039106786251, -0.005926556885242462, 0.009994803927838802, 0.0359165333211422, 0.022611552849411964, -0.04758218675851822, -0.024098219349980354, 0.008414747193455696, 0.06726311147212982, -0.010800085961818695, 0.040611837059259415, -0.0111559322103858, -0.0298687182366848, -0.026886753737926483, 0.01391254086047411, 0.04602428153157234, 0.0009954634588211775, 0.013886119239032269, -0.01138846855610609, 0.009456033818423748, 0.015241535380482674, -0.03857351839542389, -0.009393530897796154, 0.005887560546398163, -0.015963265672326088, -0.025147240608930588, 0.017265720292925835, 0.02275262400507927, 0.019913936033844948, 0.014588017016649246, 0.013196864165365696, -0.0154502484947443, 0.04749733582139015, 0.053399696946144104, -0.06922343373298645, -0.012534056790173054, -0.01915642060339451, 0.006827184464782476, 0.006600758992135525, 0.00398288294672966, 0.06952134519815445, 0.044557806104421616, -0.0018070089863613248, -0.05392963066697121, 0.03262694552540779, 0.009033839218318462, 0.026522748172283173, 0.006719304248690605, -0.031571440398693085, 0.032775506377220154, 0.015265160240232944, -0.002412596717476845, -0.06254049390554428, -0.03549790754914284, -0.024302074685692787, 0.030082203447818756, 0.010269139893352985, -0.015203786082565784, -0.03298771753907204, 0.047617848962545395, -0.020083976909518242, 0.038029298186302185, -0.05793197080492973, 0.013242478482425213, -0.025236915796995163, 0.010124932043254375, 0.005896326620131731, -0.039622712880373, 0.0033772026654332876, 0.017857851460576057, -0.014277080073952675, -0.006798938848078251, 0.027537282556295395, -0.001395535422489047, 0.041693318635225296, -0.022328443825244904, -0.00672528799623251, -0.048217903822660446, 0.018450722098350525, -0.03284314647316933, -0.04477301612496376, 0.027760755270719528, -0.022650672122836113, -0.004053040873259306, 0.017957858741283417, -0.03278119117021561, -0.007235729601234198, -0.018839441239833832, -0.0012480701552703977, -0.010339164175093174, 0.013848287053406239, -0.008545665070414543, -0.009415295906364918, -0.0029508587904274464, 0.022066611796617508, 0.010011482983827591, -0.01821902208030224, 0.023858169093728065, 0.004151300527155399, -0.0013882963685318828, 0.032670773565769196, 0.05319145694375038, 0.023279041051864624, -0.010468502528965473, -0.027734262868762016, -0.03195928409695625, 0.00980483926832676, 0.024829905480146408, -0.012575637549161911, 0.052681829780340195, 0.0209260955452919, -0.039084989577531815, 0.026147017255425453, -0.020999310538172722, -0.0014466525753960013, -0.053145669400691986, -0.010687872767448425, 0.01600603014230728, -0.016026809811592102, 0.019414912909269333, -0.04977409169077873, -0.004621598403900862, 0.0431063212454319, -0.020178796723484993, 0.06194612383842468, -0.016659993678331375, 0.0065488750115036964, -0.018940795212984085, -0.0058038742281496525, 0.0019006602233275771, 0.025958968326449394, 0.015108581632375717, 0.008603124879300594, 0.026116931810975075, 0.04649368301033974, 0.03733057156205177, -0.014001837931573391, -0.015087987296283245, 0.0073484862223267555, -0.014471509493887424, -0.07429785281419754, 0.026755794882774353, -0.04174033924937248, -0.024085085839033127, -0.00809366162866354, -0.020377807319164276, 0.04118150845170021, 0.02693241462111473, -0.006069388706237078, 0.010472365655004978, 0.06471787393093109, 0.02184038795530796, -0.06895983964204788, -0.010873457416892052, 0.005663045682013035, 0.02365424670279026, 0.021435832604765892, -0.03547888994216919, 0.02118668146431446, -0.008629712276160717, -0.026950309053063393, -0.036475494503974915, -0.02253730036318302, -0.00528400344774127, -0.015293674543499947, 0.009189617820084095, -0.012284855358302593, -0.030613061040639877, 0.006925647146999836, 0.011610215529799461, -0.013951942324638367, -0.012300434522330761, 0.022390050813555717, 0.017544981092214584, -0.01540844701230526, -0.02330288290977478, 0.00256344024091959, -0.04387161135673523, 0.008978600613772869, -0.007706660311669111, -0.032717205584049225, -0.038788411766290665, 0.018123876303434372, -0.0021184051875025034, 0.0050848196260631084, -0.055989306420087814, -0.015738101676106453, -0.038619592785835266, 0.05104443058371544, -0.018822697922587395, 0.010875013656914234, 0.013457287102937698, -0.008440785109996796, 0.000005828530447615776, -0.07263432443141937, 0.058259595185518265, 0.023211801424622536, 0.026300130411982536, -0.025038545951247215, -0.0022389183286577463, -0.07579272985458374, 0.009341520257294178, 0.08146727830171585, 0.027399588376283646, 0.01748688891530037, -0.003843039507046342, -0.008337173610925674, -0.009692645631730556, -0.04234820976853371, 0.008870841935276985, -0.03795575350522995, -0.0246860533952713, -0.004784435499459505, -0.06286146491765976, 0.015581528656184673, -0.022687945514917374, 0.002000500215217471, -0.0183500237762928, 0.019083037972450256, 0.009591610170900822, -0.015845073387026787, 0.0007305392064154148, -0.013951626606285572, -0.024807559326291084, 0.01976708322763443, 0.023311644792556763, -0.0006881519802846014, 0.009889156557619572, 0.0058801365084946156, -0.036371275782585144, 0.07853715866804123, -0.07140979915857315, -0.04610000550746918, 0.015854021534323692, 0.0017212589737027884, 0.006225023418664932, -0.06117435544729233, -0.0002518145483918488, 0.03533688560128212, -0.013498359359800816, 0.010342712514102459, 0.03229677677154541, -0.019322087988257408, 0.04483712464570999, 0.001901570474728942, 0.0095905726775527, 0.007605888415127993, 0.0196190495043993, -0.0201481394469738, -0.0037878677248954773, 0.021738536655902863, -0.004106228705495596, 0.003006814746186137, 0.021417569369077682, -0.0031531588174402714, 0.04217684268951416, -0.005804256070405245, 0.01637032814323902, -0.03859551623463631, -0.006360024679452181, 0.035359982401132584, -0.0012645474635064602, -0.0032905233092606068, 0.030315842479467392, -0.00966651365160942, 0.03461870551109314, -0.05063658580183983, -0.002407995518296957, -0.03083512745797634, -0.010376938618719578, -0.04609924554824829, 0.029439164325594902, 0.0032739946618676186, 0.013399023562669754, -0.036562539637088776, 0.04989272728562355, 0.005013647023588419, 0.017053401097655296, 0.058469172567129135, -0.012767324224114418, 0.0027996664866805077, -0.011950177140533924, -0.022516649216413498, 0.001931810169480741, -0.03738612309098244, -0.049834225326776505, -0.0006181565695442259, 0.011089642532169819, 0.04713914915919304, -0.006902518216520548, 0.012817112728953362, -0.030483528971672058, -0.021627433598041534, 0.017303314059972763, -0.06817333400249481, -0.02068459428846836, -0.04454638808965683, -0.004266317468136549, 0.008762151002883911, -0.020408870652318 ]
<p>How to calculate uncertainty of linear regression slope based on data uncertainty (possibly in Excel/Mathematica)?</p> <p>Example: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/duJ8T.jpg" alt="Example plot"> Let's have data points (0,0), (1,2), (2,4), (3,6), (4,8), ... (8, 16), but each y value has an uncertainty of 4. Most functions I found would calculate the uncertainty as 0, as the points perfectly match the function y=2x. But, as shown on the picture, y=x/2 match the points as well. It's an exaggerated example, but I hope it shows what I need.</p> <p>EDIT: If I try to explain a bit more, while every point in example has a certain value of y, we pretend we don't know if it's true. For example the first point (0,0) could actually be (0,6) or (0,-6) or anything in between. I'm asking if there is an algorithm in any of the popular problems that takes this in account. In the example the points (0,6), (1,6.5), (2,7), (3,7.5), (4,8), ... (8, 10) still fall in the uncertainty range, so they might be the right points and the line that connects those points has an equation: y = x/2 + 6, while the equation we get from not factoring in the uncertainties has equation: y=2x + 0. So uncertainty of k is 1,5 and of n is 6.</p> <p>TL;DR: In the picture, there is a line y=2x that's calculated using least square fit and it fits the data perfectly. I'm trying to find how much k and n in y=kx + n can change but still fit the data if we know uncertainty in y values. In my example, uncertainty of k is 1.5 and in n it's 6. In the image there is the 'best' fit line and a line that just barely fits the points.</p>
74,154
[ 0.01242441963404417, 0.011592497117817402, -0.015576151199638844, 0.0070270090363919735, 0.02955603040754795, -0.008827190846204758, -0.011986181139945984, -0.028725018724799156, 0.012163490056991577, -0.03596772998571396, 0.0066332584246993065, 0.01950438693165779, 0.06103549152612686, 0.04111892357468605, -0.0008780760108493268, 0.039204925298690796, -0.03763438016176224, 0.013689743354916573, -0.027686359360814095, -0.03124028816819191, 0.018399974331259727, 0.026368841528892517, -0.0002877018414437771, -0.024372605606913567, -0.022708740085363388, 0.012178595177829266, 0.050231028348207474, -0.011487548239529133, 0.0291154608130455, 0.06163435056805611, -0.005193614866584539, -0.04647296294569969, 0.030326513573527336, 0.03273027390241623, -0.013077416457235813, -0.0028431795071810484, 0.022470401600003242, -0.008121579885482788, -0.03587574511766434, 0.04545299708843231, -0.050192978233098984, -0.03087882697582245, 0.004243474453687668, 0.03714476525783539, 0.010858013294637203, 0.02536400407552719, -0.005164673551917076, -0.03696051612496376, 0.050302136689424515, -0.04271237924695015, 0.10638427734375, -0.004326208960264921, 0.029036782681941986, 0.040855128318071365, -0.027812160551548004, -0.0055246176198124886, 0.05435663089156151, 0.07956871390342712, -0.025958266109228134, -0.060438189655542374, -0.023592650890350342, -0.03804592043161392, 0.035314179956912994, 0.004618444480001926, -0.014243275858461857, 0.010030071251094341, 0.0007274579256772995, -0.009612258523702621, 0.016373073682188988, 0.015287789516150951, -0.036206141114234924, 0.037120427936315536, 0.043609656393527985, -0.027144847437739372, 0.015200252644717693, -0.01823464035987854, -0.003641402116045356, 0.050158631056547165, 0.052449267357587814, 0.0202522873878479, -0.006353223696351051, 0.036880042403936386, 0.014909457415342331, 0.014175113290548325, 0.02243957296013832, -0.026502758264541626, 0.05560007691383362, 0.0010259951232001185, 0.04678206890821457, 0.014196758158504963, -0.0330178365111351, 0.01572367176413536, 0.03830408304929733, 0.010540182702243328, -0.014997088350355625, -0.0005975922103971243, 0.031719718128442764, 0.024393901228904724, 0.006169227417558432, -0.024321122094988823, 0.031108876690268517, -0.008257009088993073, -0.004139978904277086, 0.05643535777926445, 0.0016217842930927873, -0.014861307106912136, 0.013949742540717125, -0.019251305609941483, 0.012807846069335938, -0.013480635359883308, 0.0137954605743289, 0.012136254459619522, 0.025724370032548904, -0.0012846329482272267, 0.04261261224746704, -0.029183268547058105, -0.028499748557806015, -0.017773309722542763, 0.05992896482348442, 0.06057495251297951, 0.03019770048558712, -0.047982003539800644, 0.012515172362327576, 0.010647978633642197, -0.03748316690325737, 0.026843635365366936, 0.01589118503034115, -0.026794089004397392, -0.028900422155857086, 0.020949924364686012, 0.007802844513207674, -0.026067839935421944, 0.04957204684615135, 0.005699927918612957, 0.03835677355527878, -0.0004293746023904532, -0.05538339912891388, -0.07800614088773727, 0.0015133069828152657, -0.002497344743460417, -0.009704560972750187, -0.033519092947244644, 0.0011725331423804164, 0.04923718050122261, 0.06207003444433212, 0.00633360305801034, 0.017246654257178307, 0.027439814060926437, 0.004568005446344614, -0.0008301680791191757, -0.02367132529616356, -0.027422036975622177, -0.015611070208251476, -0.04806946963071823, -0.010711404494941235, -0.04373328015208244, 0.01782059483230114, 0.04059121757745743, -0.01802307367324829, -0.036510493606328964, 0.05400938168168068, -0.0063622500747442245, -0.022673994302749634, 0.000023074448108673096, 0.002636902965605259, -0.00766511308029294, 0.08849697560071945, 0.0129151726141572, 0.0020345402881503105, -0.003960915841162205, -0.00648097600787878, -0.0004193834902253002, 0.008958552964031696, 0.025871125981211662, 0.07386652380228043, 0.0028394139371812344, -0.015729160979390144, -0.02229631133377552, 0.025503529235720634, 0.03164736181497574, -0.04497344046831131, -0.028876299038529396, -0.00042879345710389316, 0.0006138543831184506, 0.010202995501458645, 0.05779310315847397, -0.0017366131069138646, -0.019053662195801735, 0.027415806427598, -0.027870358899235725, -0.02377946302294731, -0.029327383264899254, 0.018290603533387184, 0.02659553289413452, -0.011404713615775108, -0.029470054432749748, -0.002023922512307763, -0.021603966131806374, -0.024335313588380814, -0.03025246225297451, 0.0013941917568445206, -0.019226722419261932, 0.023894986137747765, -0.031133871525526047, 0.004924660082906485, 0.06452041119337082, 0.044853925704956055, -0.01627391390502453, 0.07632913440465927, -0.04801647737622261, -0.004550013225525618, -0.0003006666374858469, -0.04431874677538872, 0.002898845123127103, -0.003189901588484645, -0.037919048219919205, -0.019866012036800385, -0.009564678184688091, -0.009854072704911232, 0.03078259713947773, -0.03117501735687256, 0.04385831579566002, 0.08354995399713516, 0.033301323652267456, 0.0006152316345833242, -0.01620771549642086, 0.0009819954866543412, 0.029202604666352272, -0.027437414973974228, -0.057196445763111115, -0.048537351191043854, -0.017033424228429794, 0.010379635728895664, 0.0438811294734478, -0.044035404920578, -0.038815177977085114, 0.08953022211790085, -0.0008974966476671398, 0.021624669432640076, 0.01790015399456024, -0.006488416343927383, 0.005571725312620401, -0.02248254232108593, 0.005046179052442312, 0.014470845460891724, 0.010758101008832455, -0.0059099649079144, 0.06711935997009277, 0.03512082248926163, -0.02487381547689438, -0.013314246200025082, 0.024146754294633865, -0.007638028357177973, -0.013160832226276398, -0.010288759134709835, -0.005846845451742411, 0.03516627475619316, 0.00013636371295433491, 0.003965951036661863, 0.024374309927225113, 0.007948056794703007, -0.012529092840850353, 0.019413189962506294, 0.005983294919133186, 0.03153988718986511, 0.031447090208530426, -0.057740483433008194, -0.003468838520348072, 0.0047342851758003235, -0.0014514642534777522, 0.005958042573183775, -0.05019763857126236, -0.02187923528254032, -0.013667733408510685, 0.017068760469555855, 0.06625287234783173, -0.0022960416972637177, 0.021510165184736252, -0.014753900468349457, -0.03135116025805473, -0.02341701090335846, -0.0301351435482502, 0.018153565004467964, -0.009885805658996105, -0.032103367149829865, -0.021378938108682632, -0.0336487777531147, -0.016912095248699188, 0.04520295560359955, -0.020016750320792198, 0.027684273198246956, 0.03491981327533722, -0.018988942727446556, -0.05306107923388481, -0.0161599088460207, -0.026072397828102112, -0.03753167763352394, 0.0036424873396754265, 0.0023938044905662537, -0.0003878347924910486, -0.00414400827139616, -0.05560329556465149, 0.05181947723031044, -0.027749907225370407, -0.02282520942389965, -0.05755813419818878, 0.012087476439774036, 0.022024916484951973, 0.023297328501939774, 0.028187215328216553, 0.027482755482196808, -0.010052390396595001, 0.002630555769428611, -0.03391927108168602, -0.07304282486438751, 0.020053774118423462, -0.012394582852721214, 0.021909506991505623, -0.0023927814327180386, -0.00775972381234169, 0.08738191425800323, 0.0054415808990597725, -0.03661641106009483, -0.052526626735925674, 0.017399292439222336, -0.009252353571355343, -0.0066096060909330845, 0.01402612216770649, -0.007125914562493563, 0.03218888118863106, 0.040601328015327454, -0.03625740110874176, -0.011364119127392769, 0.06698265671730042, -0.02601500041782856, 0.017056161537766457, -0.008420578204095364, -0.0003034437249880284, -0.017370283603668213, 0.02881227433681488, 0.01249450072646141, -0.033303383737802505, 0.03491852805018425, 0.008164123632013798, 0.015735385939478874, 0.0076361591927707195, -0.0459623821079731, 0.01727616786956787, -0.020388953387737274, 0.013460062444210052, -0.028569456189870834, 0.004956253804266453, 0.018630187958478928, 0.0028516610618680716, 0.035093918442726135, 0.02993541583418846, 0.06240692734718323, 0.007735103368759155, 0.012206376530230045, 0.025240862742066383, 0.016703812405467033, -0.016718896105885506, 0.013072450645267963, -0.007623875048011541, 0.00090963946422562, 0.019871266558766365, -0.02979305014014244, -0.030914904549717903, 0.04858871176838875, 0.02020520716905594, -0.014370432123541832, 0.0031070157419890165, -0.003250132082030177, 0.02497236430644989, -0.049553610384464264, -0.020318320021033287, 0.003972334787249565, 0.0342165008187294, 0.011968616396188736, 0.023280994966626167, 0.013628177344799042, -0.010073395445942879, 0.018880099058151245, 0.004672658629715443, -0.08711446076631546, 0.04005065932869911, -0.01917778141796589, -0.061137862503528595, -0.020349303260445595, -0.011649106629192829, -0.0059191021136939526, -0.025242693722248077, -0.0010130953742191195, -0.008289264515042305, 0.03821641579270363, -0.04878295212984085, -0.015012967400252819, -0.005348469130694866, 0.005166766699403524, -0.02348092943429947, 0.029816802591085434, 0.027917610481381416, -0.06490390002727509, 0.012401418760418892, 0.029010405763983727, -0.018740378320217133, -0.005395484622567892, -0.02639203891158104, 0.009643198922276497, 0.02783859707415104, 0.06910865008831024, 0.02955729328095913, 0.016782715916633606, -0.022091392427682877, 0.030709952116012573, -0.023496244102716446, 0.04574053734540939, 0.05635802075266838, -0.001564186648465693, -0.023443002253770828, -0.0077540031634271145, 0.01818065717816353, -0.02610255405306816, 0.02125927247107029, -0.021695183590054512, 0.023629670962691307, 0.044439997524023056, 0.009545150212943554, -0.041059643030166626, 0.004599639680236578, 0.06047765165567398, 0.0060613867826759815, 0.0165338683873415, -0.022200534120202065, -0.038105037063360214, -0.01820303127169609, 0.008867379277944565, 0.006052542943507433, 0.013934316113591194, 0.006693420931696892, -0.021976402029395103, 0.07535343617200851, 0.008175130002200603, -0.009938836097717285, 0.0013766943011432886, 0.030161935836076736, 0.05816289037466049, -0.002861990360543132, -0.023745663464069366, 0.029085170477628708, 0.018464498221874237, 0.030608514323830605, 0.03515854477882385, 0.011006668210029602, -0.08790717273950577, 0.01489290501922369, 0.04287000000476837, 0.05291067808866501, -0.029293272644281387, -0.04900949075818062, -0.033911462873220444, -0.011430954560637474, 0.08474589139223099, -0.017738284543156624, 0.02967819757759571, -0.021360157057642937, 0.028462449088692665, -0.03339717164635658, 0.01657162979245186, -0.02434803545475006, -0.0020857497584074736, -0.0044681909494102, 0.003044410841539502, -0.06839989870786667, -0.0216204896569252, -0.03984967991709709, -0.0022364691831171513, 0.04265240579843521, 0.08414622396230698, 0.004993528593331575, -0.04278939217329025, 0.02189233899116516, -0.005345011129975319, -0.04397503659129143, -0.049777254462242126, -0.0015460032736882567, 0.03235691040754318, -0.0048951948992908, 0.06474015861749649, -0.019915875047445297, -0.038646601140499115, 0.01673269271850586, -0.01116272434592247, 0.0006952518597245216, -0.007473794277757406, 0.005455550272017717, 0.027116624638438225, 0.05697401240468025, 0.03519950434565544, 0.05661475658416748, 0.046119432896375656, 0.00721725495532155, 0.0017682204488664865, -0.0455363504588604, -0.01708162948489189, -0.004826200194656849, -0.04162995517253876, -0.03332009166479111, 0.0024157022126019, -0.01829363964498043, 0.0286995992064476, 0.005356993060559034, 0.022496044635772705, -0.023376688361167908, -0.015681417658925056, -0.029704080894589424, 0.05087129771709442, 0.0016889343969523907, 0.02878572791814804, 0.014693653210997581, 0.04551466554403305, 0.012187237851321697, 0.0010508920531719923, 0.0037665809504687786, 0.022815842181444168, 0.010805387049913406, 0.013262685388326645, -0.028940333053469658, 0.0006115456926636398, -0.05264437198638916, -0.025793394073843956, -0.00935912411659956, -0.02472515217959881, 0.034101903438568115, 0.00115937867667526, -0.0033050875645130873, -0.03344101831316948, -0.01898045837879181, -0.005240551196038723, -0.017424603924155235, 0.023946566507220268, 0.0405845008790493, -0.04608133062720299, 0.008944733068346977, -0.007423626258969307, 0.014414345845580101, -0.04740413278341293, -0.04586881771683693, 0.0008524066070094705, 0.018990766257047653, -0.03620035573840141, -0.03517788276076317, -0.020809780806303024, 0.00885267648845911, -0.012993790209293365, -0.011930611915886402, 0.04081787168979645, -0.010186520405113697, -0.03929472714662552, 0.003227276960387826, -0.002492584753781557, 0.04954402893781662, -0.011229018680751324, 0.03490130603313446, 0.014789212495088577, -0.03436325863003731, -0.003754881676286459, 0.02012040838599205, 0.008513477630913258, -0.04151710122823715, -0.005184837616980076, -0.049233660101890564, 0.02205403335392475, 0.05709439516067505, -0.0019300454296171665, -0.006094262003898621, -0.0006168198306113482, 0.029327254742383957, -0.0023948911111801863, 0.007368681952357292, 0.0017150199273601174, -0.03999188542366028, -0.024767648428678513, 0.004181994590908289, -0.007387667894363403, -0.0017255684360861778, 0.012884782627224922, -0.0007648403407074511, -0.009050856344401836, -0.00914718583226204, 0.0031490749679505825, 0.05893273651599884, 0.025472521781921387, -0.0423855222761631, -0.02519572526216507, -0.028509078547358513, 0.04814130812883377, 0.03277952969074249, -0.021851317957043648, -0.00013574819604400545, 0.051858749240636826, -0.038302741944789886, -0.05744129419326782, -0.040711719542741776, -0.0026624887250363827, 0.05041874572634697, -0.04055324196815491, 0.0383249931037426, 0.03683707118034363, 0.03248218819499016, -0.032846130430698395, -0.02856561727821827, -0.014938972890377045, -0.0008193319081328809, 0.004737929906696081, 0.05265452712774277, 0.004008568823337555, -0.01810278557240963, 0.015005506575107574, 0.01522163674235344, 0.04784271493554115, 0.017135754227638245, -0.027132678776979446, 0.0631382092833519, 0.03151860460639, -0.00005394678737502545, -0.06661704182624817, 0.010399878025054932, -0.0053610121831297874, -0.0008842325769364834, -0.003672360209748149, -0.06681150197982788, 0.01708868332207203, 0.028866169974207878, -0.016186697408556938, -0.006000802386552095, -0.021807052195072174, -0.044229596853256226, 0.022801898419857025, 0.005651162937283516, -0.015751980245113373, 0.01727578230202198, 0.027588732540607452, -0.00024355262576136738, 0.01831354759633541, -0.005256783217191696, -0.04901330918073654, -0.0689506009221077, -0.004742645192891359, -0.026752717792987823, -0.026155168190598488, 0.008226552978157997, 0.02912317030131817, -0.07728322595357895, 0.03133165463805199, 0.005576496943831444, 0.02292698621749878, 0.03114987723529339, 0.015318789519369602, -0.014582508243620396, 0.04531007260084152, -0.010761664249002934, 0.010484552942216396, -0.03743039816617966, 0.011763188987970352, 0.1259666383266449, 0.08177340030670166, 0.00437193363904953, -0.07128676772117615, 0.0005262391641736031, 0.001225202577188611, -0.02571146748960018, -0.03013732098042965, 0.032555729150772095, 0.062197498977184296, -0.009367112070322037, 0.028604552149772644, 0.023780688643455505, -0.014208843000233173, 0.01735900714993477, 0.04233083128929138, -0.04731419309973717, -0.02292804606258869, -0.0032320809550583363, -0.024011600762605667, 0.02248602733016014, -0.010135920718312263, -0.053266700357198715, 0.01862279884517193, -0.009132920764386654, -0.009031335823237896, -0.00022033476852811873, -0.01898551546037197, 0.028905704617500305, 0.00791236199438572, -0.05794718116521835, 0.04924725741147995, 0.03852841630578041, 0.0103966249153018, -0.014246644452214241, 0.04672675207257271, 0.042577341198921204, -0.01844645105302334, 0.014315574429929256, -0.01790737174451351, 0.005474243313074112, -0.013835107907652855, -0.01642814837396145, -0.015582652762532234, 0.0013656107475981116, -0.051829744130373, -0.038885463029146194, 0.031237417832016945, 0.018775630742311478, -0.030851997435092926, 0.032647427171468735, 0.024237724021077156, 0.0037369881756603718, -0.04390012472867966, -0.015893951058387756, 0.05173172056674957, 0.03568451106548309, -0.0025127632543444633, 0.0012355756480246782, 0.021466514095664024, -0.00040062126936390996, 0.0018518330762162805, 0.01914299465715885, 0.0889488235116005, -0.015427322126924992, -0.021673107519745827, -0.01606687344610691, 0.033537596464157104, -0.02180854044854641, -0.005322908982634544, 0.014851250685751438, -0.03823968768119812, -0.007515722885727882, -0.034916795790195465, 0.024876952171325684, 0.020374992862343788, -0.000201948729227297, -0.012825176119804382, -0.0023812504950910807, 0.030479397624731064, -0.0375683456659317, 0.006764481775462627, -0.046495020389556885, 0.016319792717695236, -0.03809669613838196, -0.008813542313873768, 0.08098684251308441, -0.0033862788695842028, -0.007977193221449852, 0.022469114512205124, -0.038803715258836746, 0.004553641192615032, -0.013127812184393406, -0.0775018110871315, -0.03008189983665943, -0.011886169202625751, -0.039248645305633545, 0.0006092516705393791, 0.0030238705221563578, 0.05520104244351387, -0.007190964184701443, 0.044175710529088974, -0.004263937473297119, 0.06135300546884537, -0.043260358273983, 0.02071450836956501, -0.017848597839474678, -0.02896042913198471, 0.0204121395945549, 0.001231599017046392, 0.02814837172627449, -0.04415794089436531, -0.013147411867976189, -0.027190634980797768, -0.06244856119155884, 0.011432396247982979, -0.0025126365944743156, -0.042078521102666855, 0.0013413577107712626, 0.008391804993152618, -0.03161667659878731, -0.021285954862833023, 0.0045913089998066425, -0.02704165317118168, -0.012376496568322182, -0.04723884165287018, -0.028155190870165825, -0.014685632660984993, -0.01121517363935709, -0.015134810470044613, -0.004404141567647457, 0.04784597456455231, 0.031763769686222076, 0.013037282973527908, -0.009531368501484394, 0.012716730125248432, 0.009385128505527973, 0.07316634058952332, -0.06002192199230194, -0.023451339453458786, -0.004159292206168175, -0.048223692923784256, -0.03965313360095024, 0.02732195146381855, -0.02556740492582321, 0.015392950735986233, 0.04830329120159149, -0.016044463962316513, -0.02645185962319374, 0.05889454111456871, -0.004159440752118826, 0.009782123379409313, -0.0007062851218506694, 0.024554595351219177, -0.0449959859251976, 0.0014854333130642772, -0.009330474771559238, -0.02446659281849861, 0.014740080572664738, 0.02122531458735466, 0.04674747958779335, -0.025074977427721024, -0.012842648662626743, 0.03401907905936241, 0.007311827968806028, 0.03140754625201225, 0.02270854450762272, 0.004896753933280706, 0.022600794211030006, 0.03095487877726555, -0.02426619827747345, 0.03677650913596153, -0.006485299672931433, 0.058113325387239456, -0.0863688662648201, -0.01425505243241787, -0.008402346633374691, 0.014453278854489326, 0.0458286851644516, -0.05743299424648285, 0.02677680179476738, 0.04767701029777527, -0.010019002482295036, -0.022867262363433838, -0.034585580229759216, 0.019624013453722, -0.02842567302286625, 0.023411719128489494, -0.006268836557865143, 0.010286896489560604, 0.060149241238832474, 0.02746858447790146, 0.029822487384080887, -0.025546303018927574, -0.019638098776340485, -0.024136673659086227, -0.00585896847769618, 0.004682760685682297, 0.006093608681112528, -0.05128871649503708, -0.009676544927060604, -0.02739030309021473, -0.03707873076200485, 0.014083399437367916, -0.03772633522748947, 0.015678612515330315, -0.016620123758912086, 0.04133811220526695, -0.012350204400718212, 0.07408501952886581, 0.0034405726473778486, -0.005633560009300709, 0.0016486623790115118, -0.02894478850066662, -0.0030990587547421455, 0.009870952926576138, 0.006880770903080702, 0.058686915785074234, 0.019017091020941734, -0.015614890493452549, -0.05631823465228081, -0.001024223631247878, 0.009763653390109539, 0.0032678518909960985, 0.0007114436011761427, 0.008728882297873497, -0.0153682054951787, -0.0966431200504303, 0.006507067941129208, -0.037459179759025574, 0.00200260104611516, 0.03134028613567352, 0.04166145995259285, -0.00509182084351778, -0.009004726074635983, -0.022198664024472237, -0.06713101267814636, 0.005478095728904009, -0.005559008102864027, -0.007148087956011295, -0.07725025713443756, -0.007389368023723364, -0.01368831004947424, -0.0670291855931282, 0.03088562749326229, -0.03154556453227997, -0.024272708222270012, 0.027928901836276054, -0.028780058026313782, -0.02046480029821396, 0.018905986100435257, -0.02233300916850567, -0.025251545011997223, -0.07424421608448029, 0.08108953386545181, -0.006948390044271946, -0.013054958544671535, -0.02532912604510784, 0.028319038450717926, -0.013177337124943733, -0.017675207927823067, 0.02086019515991211, -0.0019724697340279818, 0.004569526296108961, -0.012381581589579582, 0.012608930468559265, 0.0325537845492363, -0.01256482396274805, 0.014857880771160126, -0.0034470544196665287, -0.012385113164782524, 0.0029008311685174704, -0.0032526878640055656, 0.0237133651971817, 0.008338267914950848, 0.03384247049689293, -0.008497720584273338, 0.028131233528256416, 0.026354679837822914, -0.006623049266636372, 0.0064183613285422325, 0.011277089826762676, -0.029382722452282906, 0.05793866142630577, -0.0057139466516673565, -0.0061380937695503235, 0.022467026486992836, 0.03616831824183464, -0.030117807909846306, 0.05926160514354706, -0.026134464889764786, -0.02959403581917286, -0.011594423092901707, 0.0015130379470065236, 0.017892634496092796, -0.08614671975374222, 0.006417904049158096, 0.03572628274559975, -0.03614217787981033, -0.030504195019602776, 0.05042319372296333, 0.0002661282487679273, 0.04229900985956192, 0.028073491528630257, 0.017380481585860252, 0.029123205691576004, -0.021537862718105316, 0.029321391135454178, -0.037268444895744324, 0.03880366310477257, -0.0011317298049107194, 0.010288145393133163, 0.018583888188004494, -0.011879106983542442, 0.003781787818297744, -0.012373141013085842, 0.026180576533079147, -0.011165213771164417, -0.04059523716568947, 0.02448025718331337, -0.040323685854673386, 0.017987065017223358, -0.04995105788111687, -0.019987281411886215, 0.04530711844563484, -0.04765923321247101, 0.003599408082664013, -0.073262520134449, -0.0005141955916769803, 0.003935548942536116, 0.013003101572394371, -0.017732394859194756, 0.023929795250296593, 0.004365464206784964, 0.024521131068468094, 0.012589072808623314, 0.009072947315871716, 0.022738490253686905, -0.010360044427216053, 0.03842964768409729, -0.0438748337328434, 0.007299983408302069, -0.033563148230314255, -0.027133608236908913, -0.027995888143777847, -0.024437854066491127, 0.019609719514846802, 0.040150001645088196, 0.01755589433014393, -0.012329285964369774, -0.022373253479599953, -0.0329781249165535, 0.039518214762210846, -0.08461569249629974, -0.015576658770442009, -0.016852209344506264, -0.005769389681518078, 0.005954174790531397, -0.04727590084075928 ]
<p>I just realised that even though I know how to perform an independent samples t-test or a Mann whitney test, I am not sure how their results should be reported in a paper. I was given this study to read in preparation for a Research Methodology class but it does not report the "easy" tests, so I wonder.</p> <p>Edit in response to the comment:</p> <p>I mean reporting according to strict scientific guidelines. I suppose there is a rule, similarly to when eg we report normally distributed variables we mention the mean and the SD. </p> <p>Edit number two :)</p> <p>I am sorry I didn't realise I wasn't specific. My orientation is medical research so I am primarily interested in knowing what is the best way to present data in papers that result from medical studies. The class I am taking right now is more general though (the article was from a study from the Law school) so it did not occur to me that this was a detail I should have mentioned in the first place. </p> <p>So lets assume I checked if x_bubblenephrine is different between say, a group of people who have Y-itis and a group who of people who do not. Say that I got p>0,005. Is there a "correct way" per se to report this? Or I can get away with "there was no difference between the two groups (p>0,05)"? </p>
74,155
[ -0.029861295595765114, 0.0014116812963038683, -0.028272246941924095, -0.03157641366124153, 0.028993258252739906, 0.029386738315224648, -0.01643054559826851, -0.019729621708393097, -0.0045827701687812805, -0.001667078584432602, 0.060857679694890976, 0.03472621366381645, 0.01936323568224907, 0.0192403681576252, 0.006543377414345741, -0.004835082218050957, -0.02647389844059944, 0.018969673663377762, 0.01308433897793293, -0.03804171830415726, 0.01850118860602379, -0.029400108382105827, -0.02560862898826599, 0.010104407556355, -0.041555047035217285, 0.059884920716285706, 0.02248767949640751, -0.019158082082867622, -0.031156012788414955, 0.04002479836344719, -0.048887256532907486, -0.015906892716884613, 0.01650281250476837, 0.0011862021638080478, 0.04317877069115639, 0.01753632351756096, -0.029697397723793983, -0.058681122958660126, -0.02886039949953556, 0.032258231192827225, -0.013134267181158066, 0.007840815000236034, 0.02856186218559742, 0.018392642959952354, -0.03315364196896553, 0.05314749479293823, 0.008855107240378857, -0.0405728816986084, 0.019869375973939896, -0.0608026422560215, 0.05619873106479645, 0.003392222337424755, 0.07788550853729248, 0.02638253942131996, -0.006581998895853758, 0.007711534388363361, 0.02142610400915146, 0.03452897071838379, -0.011414555832743645, -0.03734276443719864, -0.022916099056601524, -0.010045170783996582, -0.020795686170458794, -0.017515994608402252, -0.030324222519993782, -0.0005568870692513883, -0.027318598702549934, -0.04236025735735893, 0.01394823007285595, -0.026184188202023506, 0.04423094540834427, 0.0016345847398042679, 0.04469777271151543, -0.05600040405988693, 0.01376392412930727, -0.026966799050569534, 0.055081285536289215, 0.013741422444581985, 0.04031539335846901, 0.01900678500533104, -0.01670241914689541, 0.011519632302224636, 0.013864939101040363, 0.03428206965327263, -0.01094029564410448, -0.0181594081223011, 0.0475747287273407, -0.0407211109995842, 0.019756216555833817, 0.043088722974061966, -0.00630407128483057, -0.02362867072224617, 0.04751094803214073, 0.019375154748558998, -0.05388423800468445, 0.02198130264878273, -0.03240682929754257, 0.029699189588427544, -0.05576849356293678, -0.00908665545284748, -0.030979763716459274, -0.07705730944871902, 0.061726778745651245, 0.06643696129322052, 0.01016452070325613, -0.031935881823301315, 0.0010501060169190168, -0.014826369471848011, 0.00499605480581522, 0.00020087353186681867, -0.011957616545259953, -0.010204003192484379, 0.0076566725037992, -0.010831606574356556, 0.02230447717010975, -0.00870177336037159, -0.011188268661499023, -0.02190786600112915, 0.06787771731615067, 0.06917043030261993, 0.0672997459769249, -0.0013197242515161633, -0.003023418365046382, 0.024631133303046227, -0.04818163067102432, 0.012742197141051292, 0.021293140947818756, -0.021906862035393715, -0.06278251856565475, 0.07242224365472794, 0.009776992723345757, 0.006302747409790754, 0.017310284078121185, -0.026198847219347954, 0.039508286863565445, 0.038038529455661774, -0.07816541939973831, -0.04703835770487785, 0.03101251646876335, 0.03909612074494362, -0.012352190911769867, -0.06110413745045662, -0.025020452216267586, 0.04331967979669571, 0.057552214711904526, -0.001542007434181869, 0.04219018295407295, -0.013930344954133034, 0.03317298740148544, 0.029150789603590965, -0.029591623693704605, -0.020205827429890633, -0.019947564229369164, -0.07340510934591293, -0.005349512677639723, -0.062300194054841995, 0.020300284028053284, -0.014778955839574337, -0.030176334083080292, 0.010127401910722256, 0.033970095217227936, -0.018508510664105415, 0.013777458108961582, -0.015936143696308136, 0.013157705776393414, -0.03130505979061127, 0.058210428804159164, -0.02085045911371708, 0.04255257174372673, -0.03600145876407623, -0.023364564403891563, 0.044572778046131134, 0.0034271893091499805, 0.030071299523115158, 0.049428023397922516, -0.02266761288046837, -0.030122514814138412, -0.021493129432201385, 0.02719295769929886, 0.005870190914720297, -0.06185590848326683, 0.027286088094115257, -0.013303258456289768, 0.027086816728115082, -0.006989238318055868, 0.04179299622774124, -0.0015676701441407204, -0.028109556064009666, 0.01446604635566473, -0.02944590523838997, -0.039410315454006195, -0.045100580900907516, -0.009273047558963299, -0.0014541815035045147, -0.04278705641627312, 0.036880988627672195, -0.034211017191410065, 0.02404181845486164, -0.015230357646942139, 0.014664520509541035, -0.008643281646072865, -0.03706623986363411, 0.07034502178430557, -0.0652000904083252, 0.0027918408159166574, 0.036570340394973755, 0.02924109250307083, -0.014750543981790543, 0.051066141575574875, -0.03334157168865204, -0.0064778574742376804, -0.00046824172022752464, -0.011998288333415985, 0.010663535445928574, 0.016282381489872932, -0.027774076908826828, -0.008199954405426979, 0.0028174298349767923, -0.021026967093348503, 0.05895726755261421, -0.08475159853696823, 0.09358271956443787, 0.03968124836683273, -0.0038713421672582626, -0.021191848441958427, 0.01333648432046175, 0.015957029536366463, -0.00011598483251873404, 0.006757946684956551, -0.028290022164583206, -0.025183729827404022, -0.014941328205168247, 0.012116018682718277, -0.013717666268348694, -0.006204588338732719, 0.007376191206276417, 0.05557449907064438, 0.007159375585615635, -0.006804082542657852, 0.05402933061122894, 0.037854764610528946, -0.06152170151472092, 0.02195041999220848, 0.03662492334842682, 0.04843039810657501, 0.03365941345691681, 0.01761741004884243, -0.012494923546910286, 0.0595795102417469, 0.02896115928888321, 0.006636190228164196, 0.056996069848537445, -0.001400611363351345, -0.0013201945694163442, -0.02106938697397709, -0.001302420045249164, 0.06654678285121918, -0.005235199350863695, 0.021586531773209572, 0.028905577957630157, -0.008822635747492313, -0.01058986783027649, 0.012499726377427578, -0.020293517038226128, 0.02301577851176262, 0.040465034544467926, -0.0634472444653511, 0.058363884687423706, 0.013692486099898815, -0.07119118422269821, 0.018060261383652687, -0.012375483289361, -0.013519063591957092, -0.04857659712433815, -0.03652455657720566, -0.0056170993484556675, 0.0016905679367482662, 0.019525565207004547, -0.04808344319462776, -0.005704433191567659, 0.006702108774334192, 0.019734743982553482, 0.020503098145127296, -0.018711432814598083, -0.040951862931251526, 0.03332265466451645, -0.026147080585360527, -0.04291212558746338, 0.03195375204086304, -0.04345034435391426, -0.037450455129146576, 0.030333518981933594, -0.00013100153591949493, -0.023421306163072586, 0.013797972351312637, -0.03009781986474991, 0.014133947901427746, 0.011512075550854206, -0.020837942138314247, 0.025010794401168823, -0.012815527617931366, 0.002870001131668687, 0.057336654514074326, -0.0019529663259163499, -0.010548762045800686, -0.028833743184804916, 0.003733534598723054, 0.002586633898317814, 0.011098085902631283, 0.011075952090322971, 0.012824798002839088, -0.04065825045108795, -0.047401536256074905, -0.06104014441370964, -0.060259848833084106, 0.006479412782937288, 0.007173764519393444, 0.022767232730984688, -0.014114100486040115, -0.015988469123840332, 0.0779477134346962, 0.02052861452102661, 0.002161828801035881, -0.016930220648646355, -0.00911390408873558, -0.03260049596428871, -0.016932213678956032, 0.012696168385446072, 0.06973031908273697, 0.006048345007002354, 0.029351409524679184, 0.023159319534897804, 0.049207594245672226, 0.030646124854683876, -0.0022006698418408632, -0.021399591118097305, 0.017918376252055168, 0.039302367717027664, -0.047118112444877625, 0.03373585268855095, 0.05176696553826332, -0.029491059482097626, 0.03270283341407776, 0.017771318554878235, 0.010594489052891731, 0.024713721126317978, -0.029419247061014175, 0.028646320104599, 0.0052690827287733555, -0.003718877676874399, -0.028551865369081497, 0.020277783274650574, 0.012714847922325134, 0.003866117214784026, 0.004217429086565971, 0.03569776937365532, 0.048725251108407974, -0.014686675742268562, 0.012912211008369923, 0.03632955998182297, 0.033226147294044495, -0.00770221371203661, -0.011161364614963531, -0.013608782552182674, -0.013747785240411758, 0.017260940745472908, -0.012911347672343254, -0.04345778748393059, 0.03482954576611519, 0.03293338418006897, 0.02554815262556076, -0.025292187929153442, -0.026968862861394882, -0.0015815888764336705, -0.05305194854736328, 0.0154762277379632, -0.040247753262519836, 0.021519705653190613, -0.01261507160961628, 0.04406066983938217, -0.015519457869231701, 0.008640213869512081, -0.0292060486972332, -0.0027974576223641634, -0.030146151781082153, 0.03714028745889664, -0.011831077747046947, -0.019676413387060165, 0.020739132538437843, -0.012671117670834064, 0.04534561187028885, -0.010876244865357876, 0.029750611633062363, 0.016712456941604614, 0.03095807507634163, -0.030052149668335915, 0.03900005668401718, 0.01712791621685028, -0.035156916826963425, -0.007619255688041449, 0.011026805266737938, -0.007175212260335684, 0.027861371636390686, 0.016710098832845688, -0.0070556276477873325, 0.006742632016539574, -0.015560595318675041, -0.01141310017555952, 0.012012279592454433, 0.002486439421772957, 0.0420035645365715, -0.0012468213681131601, 0.024566322565078735, -0.03113097883760929, 0.011145547963678837, -0.02787303365767002, 0.002724249381572008, 0.022047998383641243, -0.025485627353191376, -0.013620475307106972, -0.006977687124162912, -0.030672529712319374, -0.0077303554862737656, 0.030859656631946564, 0.006440385244786739, -0.008821598254144192, 0.005925778299570084, 0.0098964162170887, -0.00928887166082859, 0.04965778812766075, 0.06257617473602295, -0.004470796789973974, -0.01605093479156494, -0.02131413295865059, -0.013513348996639252, -0.009582017548382282, 0.00628756545484066, 0.026901284232735634, 0.06885866075754166, -0.009078748524188995, -0.04645011946558952, 0.0330432690680027, -0.011507281102240086, -0.007340640760958195, -0.03281118720769882, 0.02087632566690445, 0.02865639515221119, -0.02355794981122017, -0.019321409985423088, 0.05323360115289688, 0.0398336723446846, 0.01855374500155449, 0.025055088102817535, -0.03089858591556549, -0.03575485572218895, 0.003864794038236141, 0.024369804188609123, 0.0367349237203598, -0.030710799619555473, -0.0069176689721643925, -0.030092518776655197, 0.022066112607717514, 0.03415215387940407, -0.05437970161437988, -0.009705329313874245, 0.01538441888988018, -0.02713767997920513, -0.020808452740311623, 0.020520733669400215, -0.03975880146026611, 0.01798609085381031, 0.0166042298078537, 0.030836518853902817, 0.0006996000302024186, -0.045403242111206055, -0.0538649708032608, -0.059787970036268234, 0.006243784911930561, 0.046463899314403534, -0.055545710027217865, -0.011786162853240967, -0.006373323034495115, 0.020594768226146698, -0.04391894489526749, -0.06366115063428879, 0.03311828523874283, -0.007464208174496889, 0.029129715636372566, 0.07564511150121689, -0.005411600228399038, -0.03187469020485878, 0.03694555163383484, 0.04593440517783165, -0.04606545716524124, 0.0034560717176645994, -0.017108872532844543, 0.05761314928531647, 0.04761066660284996, 0.014716838486492634, 0.04000009223818779, 0.04395745322108269, 0.023682646453380585, -0.0014437503414228559, -0.03890690580010414, 0.019804302603006363, -0.06613326817750931, -0.010605503804981709, -0.046676456928253174, -0.02659989520907402, -0.0314532034099102, 0.02505487948656082, 0.015599286183714867, 0.014575443230569363, 0.012532738037407398, -0.02949950471520424, 0.025752222165465355, 0.009721453301608562, -0.01052034366875887, -0.012629260309040546, -0.011093438602983952, 0.011049010790884495, 0.0062863449566066265, 0.026948101818561554, 0.015856074169278145, -0.01976018212735653, -0.02914666198194027, 0.031777262687683105, -0.033502861857414246, -0.023249100893735886, 0.007152249105274677, -0.02323792316019535, 0.017888935282826424, -0.06786727160215378, 0.025816647335886955, -0.015994209796190262, 0.01605549268424511, -0.005866447929292917, 0.005942603573203087, 0.011431346647441387, 0.05174647644162178, -0.004742543678730726, 0.045014455914497375, -0.08730645477771759, 0.051258932799100876, -0.013520905748009682, -0.010293778032064438, -0.10742728412151337, -0.031866006553173065, 0.04100209102034569, -0.0006211228319443762, -0.019345320761203766, -0.03250361233949661, 0.056010372936725616, -0.022143276408314705, -0.034569721668958664, -0.004882615525275469, 0.02891024388372898, -0.007728128228336573, -0.03338349610567093, -0.03354449197649956, 0.017551401630043983, 0.08022963255643845, -0.019766487181186676, -0.0008220006711781025, 0.026944221928715706, -0.016431817784905434, 0.0027089794166386127, -0.01191279198974371, 0.00642663799226284, -0.024457290768623352, 0.0074706654995679855, -0.017128273844718933, 0.009021122008562088, 0.00019861242617480457, -0.04408537596464157, -0.02471790835261345, 0.03483809903264046, -0.009993191808462143, 0.02086786739528179, -0.023145338520407677, 0.011157932691276073, -0.04022638127207756, 0.0037726315204054117, -0.01744123362004757, 0.026160841807723045, 0.011447261087596416, -0.00814598985016346, 0.0225131306797266, 0.02159031480550766, -0.018776562064886093, 0.01716555468738079, 0.07301841676235199, 0.012708595022559166, 0.010851976461708546, 0.023586958646774292, -0.013056072406470776, 0.020455945283174515, 0.012375290505588055, -0.03139645606279373, -0.022681565955281258, -0.0016067082760855556, -0.031991515308618546, -0.026858439669013023, -0.04619944840669632, 0.021784795448184013, 0.06401950865983963, 0.015262248925864697, 0.022734610363841057, 0.053578443825244904, 0.005354186519980431, -0.03537340462207794, -0.03945549204945564, -0.009618634358048439, -0.0330355130136013, -0.02978915348649025, 0.06132006645202637, -0.00747782364487648, -0.0021478517446666956, 0.05800061672925949, 0.029833098873496056, 0.011230671778321266, 0.05522777885198593, 0.030181884765625, -0.006536760367453098, 0.02237585559487343, -0.026437660679221153, -0.02415984496474266, 0.04375222697854042, -0.04937029257416725, 0.02518070489168167, -0.047194954007864, -0.0204794779419899, 0.057086020708084106, 0.012950040400028229, 0.007785625755786896, -0.044623132795095444, -0.03772689029574394, -0.036857347935438156, -0.02302124723792076, 0.05815882608294487, -0.01786099560558796, 0.0320267453789711, -0.007699965965002775, 0.030326761305332184, 0.003363553900271654, 0.026569683104753494, -0.03229716792702675, -0.055360060185194016, -0.0396617129445076, -0.029344437643885612, -0.029272321611642838, 0.018700018525123596, -0.011551816947758198, -0.055785950273275375, 0.011865015141665936, -0.05072516202926636, 0.031014343723654747, -0.03508119657635689, 0.022438164800405502, -0.0005966160097159445, 0.05122547224164009, -0.015734897926449776, 0.027945585548877716, -0.020971354097127914, 0.008789781481027603, 0.1345185488462448, 0.04600256681442261, 0.059494808316230774, -0.03047339804470539, 0.026062235236167908, -0.022234005853533745, 0.02212846465408802, 0.020784106105566025, 0.022328823804855347, 0.017969217151403427, -0.010316283442080021, 0.00767277367413044, 0.06789596378803253, 0.042125631123781204, -0.04574672505259514, 0.036513231694698334, -0.027090037241578102, -0.010804543271660805, 0.02881678007543087, 0.02763631008565426, 0.023864343762397766, -0.027368884533643723, 0.045307714492082596, 0.027488572522997856, 0.005678525660187006, 0.007196811959147453, 0.006642100401222706, -0.03535278141498566, 0.014495780691504478, 0.0532609261572361, -0.03678232431411743, -0.01467493362724781, 0.011244628578424454, 0.021016957238316536, -0.03364339470863342, -0.004834507592022419, 0.019907895475625992, -0.03443419188261032, -0.007537148892879486, 0.045791786164045334, 0.0008589650969952345, -0.020071277394890785, 0.036790892481803894, 0.0470096617937088, -0.03792509809136391, -0.03233644366264343, 0.01299969106912613, 0.02106713131070137, -0.013400066643953323, -0.018424060195684433, -0.018424302339553833, 0.01585647091269493, -0.01221836730837822, -0.08507858216762543, -0.03394480049610138, 0.011096219532191753, -0.00019757196423597634, -0.013792554847896099, 0.002434964757412672, 0.009681455790996552, 0.009312578476965427, -0.005482442677021027, 0.020199859514832497, 0.046636246144771576, -0.024078095331788063, -0.04296553507447243, 0.01227510254830122, -0.0014781876234337687, -0.00783038605004549, 0.010002478957176208, -0.01323083508759737, -0.02258167415857315, -0.04164748266339302, 0.020501768216490746, -0.01617329753935337, 0.0015175468288362026, 0.013549905270338058, -0.0003809330228250474, -0.020079171285033226, -0.02852153591811657, -0.03476497530937195, 0.04115254431962967, 0.009113014675676823, 0.003850567853078246, -0.030966604128479958, -0.024204568937420845, 0.013792996294796467, 0.04884298890829086, -0.008072218857705593, 0.00886810477823019, 0.019398963078856468, 0.05717474967241287, 0.004005521070212126, -0.029493791982531548, -0.03538382425904274, 0.009996121749281883, -0.04262008145451546, 0.020093532279133797, 0.008851190097630024, 0.031001850962638855, 0.023546742275357246, 0.0030052722431719303, 0.01274147816002369, 0.005551219917833805, -0.014659232459962368, 0.02080443687736988, -0.0013303584419190884, -0.05270536243915558, -0.038501184433698654, 0.014924679882824421, 0.01712924614548683, 0.012818458490073681, 0.0038151710759848356, -0.057422004640102386, -0.020194297656416893, 0.025681272149086, -0.022339172661304474, 0.004121612291783094, 0.022313345223665237, -0.020316753536462784, 0.00675280811265111, 0.001250843401066959, 0.00197620945982635, -0.04335922747850418, -0.03676307201385498, 0.009920129552483559, 0.01939583010971546, -0.010727356187999249, 0.020243709906935692, -0.019472211599349976, 0.015038488432765007, 0.03902839124202728, -0.02320864051580429, -0.010019403882324696, 0.044019270688295364, -0.0007272112998180091, 0.023149045184254646, 0.022154755890369415, -0.0032604653388261795, -0.009247862733900547, 0.02443355694413185, -0.02264612540602684, -0.03622761741280556, 0.04595808684825897, 0.0026347720995545387, 0.031167831271886826, 0.008953128941357136, -0.012521850876510143, -0.020848972722887993, 0.041871506720781326, -0.07228095829486847, -0.02318120002746582, 0.033776964992284775, 0.0007444426300935447, -0.008547103963792324, 0.009010987356305122, 0.002599128521978855, 0.014024020172655582, -0.026819515973329544, 0.03332104533910751, 0.010939941741526127, 0.020962374284863472, -0.00571866100654006, -0.002181720221415162, 0.01482097152620554, -0.010983300395309925, -0.02069312520325184, -0.005195229779928923, 0.039870645850896835, 0.061441343277692795, -0.0402180440723896, 0.00275440257973969, -0.03939496725797653, 0.012064289301633835, -0.07871463894844055, -0.03402051329612732, 0.007186282426118851, 0.04163480922579765, 0.03133876994252205, -0.03653489798307419, 0.028778480365872383, 0.025078827515244484, -0.07378726452589035, -0.016684778034687042, -0.05056633800268173, -0.010482373647391796, -0.03660257160663605, 0.007235079538077116, -0.00850355252623558, 0.014860503375530243, 0.007648104801774025, 0.015059733763337135, 0.025862479582428932, 0.016253484413027763, 0.020167255774140358, 0.022662628442049026, -0.0383233018219471, 0.020055580884218216, -0.0034825881011784077, -0.07655603438615799, 0.011347239837050438, -0.014730380848050117, -0.040722984820604324, 0.024793826043605804, -0.014305002987384796, 0.005120773799717426, 0.0001727823109831661, 0.037692874670028687, 0.0297411922365427, 0.0338883250951767, 0.04543379321694374, -0.0005037944647483528, -0.017299005761742592, 0.0249275341629982, 0.01960689015686512, 0.03386486694216728, 0.00632036617025733, -0.01575465500354767, 0.013235267251729965, -0.0027587818913161755, -0.015488178469240665, -0.02037842571735382, -0.03264037147164345, -0.009029258042573929, -0.0016791061498224735, -0.013304593041539192, 0.04340111464262009, -0.04112955555319786, 0.0016357949934899807, -0.04315267130732536, 0.02138005755841732, 0.052836038172245026, 0.029055416584014893, -0.015025443397462368, 0.02460903860628605, -0.05567552521824837, -0.04720574989914894, -0.0035751673858612776, 0.006404922343790531, -0.020933520048856735, -0.03901924565434456, 0.028457462787628174, -0.028361517935991287, -0.004277239553630352, -0.01555059663951397, -0.008855526335537434, -0.04974662885069847, 0.03311537206172943, 0.00837000086903572, 0.029024191200733185, 0.006366284564137459, 0.008244945667684078, 0.014080850407481194, -0.05873681977391243, 0.042736783623695374, 0.027827167883515358, 0.006644194480031729, -0.02485113963484764, -0.03286736458539963, -0.04129694774746895, 0.026370299980044365, 0.0854569599032402, 0.0035922240931540728, -0.009768445044755936, 0.016800513491034508, 0.0027468837797641754, -0.03693947568535805, -0.04989396408200264, 0.035766419023275375, -0.0019559375941753387, -0.024329297244548798, -0.02313574217259884, 0.029417704790830612, 0.019457945600152016, 0.015889139845967293, 0.032671064138412476, 0.035837847739458084, 0.030258676037192345, -0.01830846071243286, -0.003286814084276557, 0.014409068040549755, 0.05361826345324516, -0.046801403164863586, 0.059793513268232346, 0.0025466366205364466, 0.0009258183999918401, 0.01777339167892933, 0.010632933117449284, -0.06946249306201935, 0.0037661611568182707, 0.006031875964254141, -0.025620264932513237, 0.01522940956056118, 0.0026644389145076275, -0.030876195058226585, -0.057888854295015335, 0.016127023845911026, -0.0006522682961076498, -0.006109005771577358, -0.020807217806577682, 0.019280560314655304, 0.05817601457238197, -0.004398043267428875, -0.03827722743153572, 0.01321677677333355, 0.006545243784785271, -0.018821056932210922, 0.0017672574613243341, -0.03730957582592964, 0.026697877794504166, 0.03479401767253876, -0.0026498748920857906, 0.02911408245563507, -0.045438263565301895, 0.05479472875595093, -0.002146093873307109, 0.04579748585820198, -0.008694768883287907, -0.010108021087944508, 0.036180026829242706, -0.014278946444392204, 0.019891876727342606, 0.008737328462302685, 0.025839338079094887, 0.05506988242268562, -0.03678196668624878, -0.002044219058007002, -0.03167013078927994, -0.034921254962682724, 0.0002144781465176493, 0.008955197408795357, 0.028302818536758423, -0.0066310386173427105, 0.011456098407506943, -0.023401282727718353, -0.04115433618426323, -0.032665468752384186, 0.01957840844988823, -0.010333945043385029, 0.008252669125795364, -0.0527324303984642, 0.013253405690193176, -0.05036015063524246, -0.011041447520256042, -0.008616040460765362, -0.006880561821162701, 0.005622674245387316, -0.012736097909510136, -0.004742366261780262, -0.04317634552717209, -0.024269036948680878, -0.012842892669141293, 0.03054012358188629, -0.08057792484760284, -0.01638811081647873, -0.05164303630590439, 0.040104158222675323, -0.008023690432310104, -0.03497690707445145 ]
<p>As per Wikipedia, I understand that the t-distribution is the sampling distribution of the t-value when the samples are iid observations from a normally distributed population. However, I don't intuitively understand why that causes the shape of the t-distribution to change from fat-tailed to almost perfectly normal.</p> <p>I get that if you're sampling from a normal distribution then if you take a big sample it will resemble that distribution, but I don't get why it starts out with the fat-tailed shape it does.</p>
913
[ -0.015503539703786373, -0.03613174334168434, 0.03587989881634712, -0.04817698150873184, 0.039356645196676254, 0.012226159684360027, 0.02306690439581871, 0.0157292652875185, 0.012943420559167862, -0.05176842585206032, 0.007325705606490374, 0.0530988872051239, 0.02056111954152584, -0.00906981062144041, 0.05829493701457977, -0.022358601912856102, -0.024689679965376854, 0.007614819332957268, -0.023588502779603004, -0.03409499302506447, 0.025260556489229202, 0.03571206331253052, 0.020064489915966988, -0.020117085427045822, -0.05335120111703873, 0.01937999203801155, 0.016880609095096588, 0.0046529280953109264, 0.055182840675115585, 0.06956873834133148, -0.0537191703915596, 0.003092753002420068, 0.022729292511940002, 0.0355704091489315, 0.002183680422604084, -0.012198896147310734, -0.03398893401026726, -0.004658586345613003, -0.01135648787021637, 0.022009043022990227, -0.04525979980826378, -0.01441880315542221, -0.0258021280169487, 0.01774808019399643, -0.020502153784036636, 0.026441145688295364, -0.009858619421720505, -0.06762225180864334, 0.05120036378502846, -0.04824994504451752, 0.06168164312839508, 0.009664235636591911, 0.050118930637836456, 0.02393723838031292, 0.01260650996118784, -0.021369876340031624, 0.056355636566877365, 0.0445273295044899, -0.02329644188284874, -0.06879175454378128, 0.01330755464732647, -0.02029544487595558, -0.023612240329384804, -0.012088749557733536, -0.004225060809403658, 0.02819248102605343, -0.010963110253214836, -0.03877539932727814, 0.042122550308704376, -0.023495707660913467, 0.027794217690825462, 0.04244844987988472, 0.02027282305061817, -0.011501633562147617, 0.002215694636106491, -0.02977198362350464, 0.04177111014723778, 0.0015688077546656132, 0.07452178746461868, 0.023580286651849747, 0.032873742282390594, 0.019099600613117218, 0.005268547218292952, 0.04668385162949562, 0.024286868050694466, -0.0060784295201301575, 0.06919486820697784, -0.03129266947507858, -0.008344628848135471, 0.05152164027094841, -0.02859232760965824, 0.020160380750894547, 0.06191856786608696, -0.03214802220463753, -0.04933827370405197, 0.04460405185818672, -0.0057101622223854065, 0.028428152203559875, 0.015473941341042519, -0.014150550588965416, 0.0015369950560852885, -0.06467220187187195, 0.0042046550661325455, 0.04153932258486748, -0.03782667592167854, -0.026570439338684082, -0.03657253459095955, 0.0070241899229586124, -0.011044158600270748, -0.011006223037838936, -0.03191471844911575, 0.011579199694097042, 0.013370766304433346, -0.02062021754682064, 0.026752274483442307, -0.025758977979421616, 0.016606979072093964, -0.02616420015692711, 0.041342489421367645, 0.04371051862835884, 0.024089675396680832, -0.020440243184566498, 0.040022049099206924, -0.002869558287784457, -0.03820903226733208, 0.04114248603582382, 0.05373906344175339, -0.015052944421768188, -0.025428736582398415, 0.04714110493659973, -0.02381405606865883, -0.03474152088165283, 0.05647044628858566, 0.006962666753679514, 0.04559458792209625, -0.030558310449123383, -0.07607591152191162, -0.037142667919397354, 0.06160639598965645, -0.03815476968884468, -0.012422934174537659, -0.08965660631656647, 0.007998778484761715, 0.04612535983324051, 0.03263770043849945, -0.0031480512116104364, 0.01908630132675171, -0.0017606604378670454, 0.017581330612301826, -0.004468838684260845, -0.026063410565257072, -0.029129082337021828, -0.0022279247641563416, 0.003927793353796005, 0.031652431935071945, -0.07488113641738892, 0.005835091695189476, 0.010147061198949814, -0.02140107750892639, -0.044123683124780655, 0.022724978625774384, -0.0073742372915148735, -0.042750850319862366, -0.023459237068891525, 0.016511213034391403, -0.03395713120698929, 0.07477547228336334, -0.0008297376334667206, -0.008381749503314495, 0.04204536974430084, 0.004877467639744282, 0.027355795726180077, 0.009081169962882996, 0.06600974500179291, -0.00048278385656885803, -0.030841272324323654, -0.0027638671454042196, -0.034176234155893326, 0.013425876386463642, 0.006533629726618528, -0.037289734929800034, 0.0009351455373689532, 0.007409467827528715, 0.01109474990516901, 0.027030006051063538, 0.027670133858919144, 0.0010424245847389102, -0.019809994846582413, 0.040897436439991, -0.07237593084573746, -0.07108739018440247, -0.05351126194000244, -0.01809232495725155, -0.03734828531742096, -0.013119898736476898, 0.012816326692700386, 0.016877558082342148, 0.025376053526997566, -0.014971774071455002, 0.006248754449188709, -0.011730094440281391, 0.0054281335324049, 0.033917929977178574, -0.05272321775555611, 0.029192190617322922, 0.05253301560878754, 0.026019316166639328, 0.02152164652943611, 0.019199436530470848, -0.033173590898513794, -0.038835592567920685, 0.005758292973041534, -0.0515066534280777, 0.03693624585866928, -0.020257310941815376, -0.04882197454571724, -0.023295817896723747, -0.018655138090252876, -0.009826845489442348, 0.03424398973584175, -0.033709727227687836, 0.059967730194330215, 0.06201864406466484, -0.017006579786539078, -0.04546260088682175, 0.03939182683825493, 0.0017041439423337579, -0.023933906108140945, -0.030744031071662903, 0.00288057466968894, -0.0662505179643631, -0.025768941268324852, 0.04359784349799156, 0.02960435301065445, -0.03420248627662659, 0.015544991940259933, 0.039442598819732666, 0.0396658331155777, 0.018420247361063957, 0.056110069155693054, -0.008264909498393536, -0.010274088010191917, -0.0021186431404203176, 0.029196390882134438, 0.008980347774922848, -0.016711963340640068, 0.020776456221938133, 0.007559341378509998, 0.018427502363920212, -0.004843757953494787, -0.03696446865797043, 0.02544683963060379, -0.021209394559264183, 0.010086378082633018, 0.005930430255830288, -0.01812894456088543, 0.02033604308962822, -0.036517415195703506, -0.021528325974941254, 0.03583146631717682, -0.008479957468807697, 0.0015946627827361226, -0.03904081508517265, -0.01535880658775568, 0.036470625549554825, 0.04580507427453995, -0.008691580034792423, 0.0025733192451298237, 0.025186900049448013, -0.012018830515444279, 0.005997350439429283, -0.018311431631445885, -0.024450257420539856, -0.035019125789403915, 0.02391824871301651, 0.02408789098262787, 0.009419403970241547, 0.0006974910502322018, 0.007421338465064764, -0.058269668370485306, -0.010519142262637615, -0.005352390930056572, -0.0033345490228384733, -0.013204838149249554, -0.06263568997383118, 0.020831212401390076, -0.007664383389055729, -0.027716942131519318, 0.03052334673702717, 0.007657055743038654, 0.034207720309495926, -0.005858341697603464, -0.0007753096870146692, -0.04481176659464836, 0.011056858114898205, -0.009269733913242817, 0.011863768100738525, -0.009390773251652718, 0.013249686919152737, 0.052639853209257126, -0.022831788286566734, -0.02277892827987671, 0.05001344159245491, -0.05660964548587799, -0.060336243361234665, -0.0553169883787632, -0.008381227031350136, 0.02308358997106552, -0.0029226029291749, 0.024333644658327103, 0.024724068120121956, -0.058708757162094116, 0.010266503319144249, -0.021996933966875076, -0.03813955560326576, 0.020067280158400536, 0.013525283895432949, 0.041468799114227295, 0.00822019949555397, -0.030871765688061714, 0.07107950001955032, 0.02649979293346405, -0.03432248532772064, 0.011805512942373753, -0.010043749585747719, -0.03946736827492714, -0.031960561871528625, 0.04715356230735779, 0.028548408299684525, -0.008934400044381618, 0.03506078943610191, 0.029049139469861984, 0.03974512219429016, 0.04813903942704201, 0.0036977611016482115, -0.008459842763841152, 0.014205820858478546, -0.0028263023123145103, -0.0005862317630089819, 0.009201318956911564, -0.0019375901902094483, -0.03971040993928909, 0.019885221496224403, 0.011029236949980259, 0.017779065296053886, -0.008071184158325195, 0.007804826833307743, 0.044654786586761475, -0.02796977385878563, 0.0036173134576529264, -0.06197679042816162, 0.01111765019595623, -0.014500828459858894, -0.015085305087268353, -0.003415837185457349, 0.0312906913459301, 0.03880332037806511, -0.04883275181055069, 0.013620011508464813, 0.03975940868258476, 0.021399937570095062, -0.04637889191508293, -0.008904729038476944, -0.014917448163032532, -0.03688271716237068, 0.01451608445495367, -0.021881848573684692, -0.0034238798543810844, 0.047335006296634674, 0.054421279579401016, 0.025850217789411545, -0.015257546678185463, -0.04902360215783119, 0.0015329451998695731, -0.043978556990623474, -0.012731238268315792, 0.008552281185984612, 0.03566756099462509, 0.0028341140132397413, 0.06982976198196411, 0.01991313137114048, 0.03562987595796585, 0.017046963796019554, 0.0031088534742593765, -0.06474415957927704, 0.025191830471158028, -0.04495255649089813, -0.009956425055861473, -0.0057080877013504505, -0.007755438797175884, 0.026839615777134895, 0.018885700032114983, 0.0013436564477160573, -0.009777570143342018, -0.023720908910036087, -0.047800175845623016, 0.007786591071635485, -0.007239350117743015, 0.014851290732622147, -0.037383727729320526, 0.014448572881519794, 0.004974110051989555, -0.008569354191422462, 0.023359525948762894, 0.04267353564500809, -0.012021245434880257, 0.0013079486088827252, -0.03547372296452522, 0.01754843071103096, 0.04225924238562584, 0.02083386294543743, 0.03773382678627968, 0.012163625098764896, -0.030461473390460014, 0.015561627224087715, -0.002751230960711837, 0.09374228119850159, 0.0402173213660717, -0.011890249326825142, -0.010433382354676723, -0.08213987946510315, -0.04228182137012482, 0.011633473448455334, 0.015845146030187607, -0.0003851314540952444, 0.03075420670211315, 0.04922051727771759, 0.020787527784705162, -0.040444713085889816, 0.028569607064127922, 0.019023647531867027, 0.011016318574547768, 0.002003486966714263, -0.0390254445374012, 0.008348599076271057, -0.043164633214473724, -0.012743154540657997, 0.014049632474780083, -0.0030562826432287693, -0.026254717260599136, 0.04131656885147095, 0.046768613159656525, -0.02549119107425213, -0.012346803210675716, -0.033454105257987976, 0.003132241778075695, 0.04548266902565956, 0.010698074474930763, -0.03555341437458992, 0.04073130711913109, 0.02150009758770466, 0.0563872754573822, 0.0398763045668602, -0.0034626098349690437, -0.06856304407119751, -0.018021585419774055, 0.02684752643108368, 0.01575394719839096, -0.03571833670139313, 0.0039681000635027885, -0.040780726820230484, -0.010811205953359604, 0.0453011617064476, -0.05675135925412178, 0.004712176509201527, -0.029031852260231972, -0.014565572142601013, -0.011092815548181534, 0.002412970643490553, -0.02463383600115776, -0.00288727437146008, -0.010478870011866093, -0.005904070101678371, -0.013549871742725372, -0.01817006804049015, -0.07027723640203476, -0.0015421079006046057, -0.0024638953618705273, 0.044148292392492294, -0.016743624582886696, -0.03175783529877663, -0.004171084146946669, 0.05188986659049988, -0.01977328583598137, -0.055790334939956665, 0.0007284447201527655, -0.005356603302061558, 0.023006681352853775, 0.023027490824460983, -0.018524933606386185, -0.04417874291539192, 0.02442423440515995, 0.00802170392125845, -0.01372741162776947, 0.007279183249920607, -0.02125503309071064, 0.006875599734485149, 0.029435157775878906, -0.003088246798142791, 0.05148153007030487, 0.028029533103108406, 0.0064074755646288395, -0.03533739596605301, -0.027570025995373726, 0.026995783671736717, -0.05107080936431885, -0.02202100306749344, -0.044844381511211395, -0.0018985758069902658, -0.01920316368341446, 0.021323643624782562, 0.004852209240198135, 0.005018545780330896, -0.025848187506198883, -0.019239455461502075, 0.007181951776146889, 0.040154777467250824, 0.0455847792327404, -0.0016436270670965314, 0.013004980981349945, 0.035500332713127136, 0.039123911410570145, -0.02750525064766407, 0.01695556566119194, -0.016957206651568413, 0.003707309253513813, 0.0276443250477314, -0.01593746617436409, 0.020662065595388412, -0.02334294654428959, -0.04010741785168648, 0.03522553667426109, -0.0042897374369204044, 0.02693144604563713, -0.05427367985248566, -0.016062963753938675, 0.020930593833327293, -0.046657465398311615, -0.010735099203884602, 0.013916289433836937, -0.01211936492472887, 0.056168198585510254, -0.05041003227233887, 0.05873655900359154, 0.01020712498575449, -0.007151235826313496, -0.09247680008411407, -0.033364392817020416, 0.04368991032242775, 0.009754075668752193, -0.025968225672841072, -0.01586092635989189, 0.0036910679191350937, -0.0038050138391554356, -0.04119756817817688, -0.015149836428463459, 0.028957916423678398, 0.013073129579424858, -0.028085418045520782, -0.02526053413748741, 0.0033447123132646084, 0.06862260401248932, -0.0010285116732120514, -0.015651267021894455, 0.002980978926643729, -0.048457030206918716, -0.015557833015918732, 0.004292293451726437, 0.0535382404923439, -0.041456546634435654, 0.01845906861126423, 0.018266474828124046, -0.018204981461167336, 0.03900590166449547, -0.010088306851685047, -0.0062266080640256405, 0.003011354710906744, -0.029006419703364372, 0.024585597217082977, -0.018368903547525406, -0.002184528624638915, -0.002509737154468894, 0.027064582332968712, -0.02094968967139721, -0.03391232714056969, 0.0010078148916363716, -0.031058162450790405, 0.047894302755594254, 0.013057509437203407, 0.019151372835040092, 0.03484426438808441, 0.033237800002098083, -0.021895911544561386, 0.008514218963682652, -0.038210269063711166, -0.022359861060976982, 0.019457049667835236, 0.044786494225263596, -0.038053009659051895, 0.0165422223508358, 0.015068013221025467, -0.026865651831030846, -0.011689248494803905, -0.03524346649646759, 0.018201371654868126, 0.05445321276783943, -0.009291701018810272, 0.039875227957963943, 0.026045164093375206, -0.008548877201974392, -0.0003216368204448372, -0.0037597280461341143, -0.01253458671271801, -0.010313163511455059, -0.02281242422759533, 0.02241751179099083, -0.01906205527484417, -0.008440012112259865, 0.017110146582126617, 0.015438142232596874, -0.0027072636876255274, 0.058898936957120895, 0.03891889750957489, -0.013949688524007797, 0.010734392330050468, 0.012593977153301239, -0.03627854213118553, 0.016236018389463425, -0.018452122807502747, 0.03201792389154434, 0.00712718116119504, -0.005463363602757454, 0.05429587513208389, -0.013083139434456825, -0.0007439687033183873, -0.04846718907356262, -0.014549510553479195, -0.019669184461236, 0.012748335488140583, 0.019854402169585228, 0.003941322211176157, 0.043731652200222015, 0.01240164041519165, 0.012173826806247234, 0.00326060364022851, 0.021880535408854485, -0.01491197943687439, -0.025683388113975525, -0.05020739138126373, -0.036319389939308167, -0.05319150537252426, 0.03022025153040886, -0.022542281076312065, -0.009734846651554108, 0.007919864729046822, -0.0681830570101738, 0.01297888532280922, -0.016552980989217758, 0.023659924045205116, -0.020449332892894745, 0.10193079710006714, 0.026198580861091614, 0.02445411868393421, -0.017670992761850357, -0.030622966587543488, 0.10361108928918839, 0.06130586564540863, 0.003626815276220441, -0.0825982391834259, -0.005185360088944435, -0.04088052362203598, -0.007108996622264385, -0.02286815084517002, 0.013329492881894112, 0.03271361067891121, 0.04372798651456833, 0.06256430596113205, 0.029354222118854523, 0.020568083971738815, 0.0033992277458310127, 0.06705736368894577, -0.05277922749519348, -0.031713150441646576, 0.0004737818380817771, 0.014739842154085636, -0.01671292819082737, -0.01867072843015194, -0.10100272297859192, 0.04023547098040581, -0.03408747538924217, 0.021070420742034912, -0.015315864235162735, -0.028290897607803345, -0.021007677540183067, -0.012091682292521, -0.048365917056798935, 0.002891037380322814, 0.007696140091866255, -0.000990167842246592, -0.028222884982824326, 0.00003589521656977013, 0.008759967982769012, -0.012918036431074142, 0.011395488865673542, 0.030413638800382614, 0.012386428192257881, -0.011110881343483925, 0.009080578573048115, 0.009225058369338512, -0.018519140779972076, -0.03171363100409508, -0.011854279786348343, 0.029049862176179886, -0.022457217797636986, 0.03241121768951416, -0.020054245367646217, 0.020626841112971306, 0.0068153501488268375, -0.04351280257105827, -0.00143008166924119, -0.004349447321146727, 0.021865056827664375, -0.018253143876791, -0.03763166442513466, 0.0072576990351080894, 0.01588847115635872, -0.005160490982234478, 0.043399397283792496, 0.017665889114141464, 0.02040083333849907, -0.008893358521163464, -0.026893114671111107, 0.047509364783763885, -0.0034686471335589886, -0.004861417226493359, 0.002980231074616313, 0.0010202202247455716, -0.05342796444892883, 0.01355690322816372, -0.0053740255534648895, -0.012644393369555473, 0.024286868050694466, 0.0145026333630085, 0.016983740031719208, -0.015072173438966274, -0.026819072663784027, 0.045331213623285294, -0.019356578588485718, -0.014644170179963112, -0.06326351314783096, 0.002727072685956955, 0.005402121227234602, 0.04430267959833145, 0.02745218016207218, 0.07154694199562073, -0.021833354607224464, 0.05181729421019554, 0.0009236636105924845, -0.0447486937046051, 0.006989093031734228, 0.010972637683153152, -0.027796322479844093, -0.004775037989020348, 0.026087015867233276, 0.05347723141312599, 0.03645941615104675, 0.03948717936873436, -0.025970736518502235, -0.01344173215329647, 0.00021235618623904884, -0.012944989837706089, -0.015382939018309116, -0.058894671499729156, -0.005327299237251282, 0.016716159880161285, -0.013644244521856308, -0.05229688063263893, -0.022870412096381187, -0.03823675215244293, -0.024309711530804634, 0.008974541909992695, 0.014567658305168152, -0.004681668244302273, -0.008937143720686436, -0.013863759115338326, 0.04465784132480621, -0.008391211740672588, -0.01605115458369255, -0.04118598252534866, 0.011503330431878567, -0.016451355069875717, 0.0132778100669384, -0.02271873503923416, 0.021711992099881172, -0.015611651353538036, -0.027591608464717865, 0.03392791748046875, 0.006350789684802294, 0.034441497176885605, 0.006035684607923031, 0.019848184660077095, -0.010624668560922146, 0.031186971813440323, -0.016146840527653694, -0.0117333447560668, 0.06788582354784012, -0.053026605397462845, -0.021137898787856102, 0.02188642881810665, -0.002032207092270255, 0.03623106703162193, 0.01053332444280386, -0.016901610419154167, -0.01823369972407818, 0.03160569444298744, -0.05689124017953873, 0.0024585630744695663, -0.005364491604268551, 0.0016920864582061768, 0.003916164860129356, 0.00797039270401001, -0.005737642291933298, 0.008798016235232353, -0.017860570922493935, 0.013102889992296696, 0.03865887224674225, -0.022551724687218666, 0.010153901763260365, 0.03357083722949028, -0.005968483630567789, 0.024710578843951225, 0.0022309748455882072, 0.02877972275018692, 0.05920220911502838, 0.06331544369459152, -0.023279212415218353, 0.022948412224650383, -0.04558577761054039, 0.007267323322594166, -0.07356123626232147, 0.006995962467044592, 0.002697746502235532, -0.04010734707117081, 0.052993036806583405, -0.045816756784915924, -0.041028015315532684, 0.02936645969748497, -0.057469889521598816, 0.029485637322068214, -0.03142770007252693, -0.01897403970360756, -0.04742642119526863, -0.0010684119770303369, -0.00642259418964386, 0.04278920963406563, 0.041725270450115204, 0.011281359940767288, 0.04581698775291443, 0.019683878868818283, -0.011409569531679153, 0.015201781876385212, -0.026533624157309532, 0.04198478162288666, -0.001151700271293521, -0.035028304904699326, 0.0041199843399226665, -0.0005940090632066131, -0.02238239161670208, 0.04268345609307289, 0.021532520651817322, 0.019838489592075348, 0.006912331562489271, 0.01622789353132248, 0.026221314445137978, 0.02779317833483219, 0.04610179364681244, -0.004116647411137819, -0.015133543871343136, 0.044654443860054016, 0.053733594715595245, 0.023723356425762177, 0.025182975456118584, -0.005231628194451332, 0.030726494267582893, -0.04118926450610161, 0.0010814026463776827, 0.02981685847043991, 0.010182366706430912, -0.020196275785565376, -0.0053244298323988914, -0.0005130842910148203, 0.019730791449546814, -0.045601293444633484, 0.04744705185294151, -0.046821072697639465, -0.03222622722387314, 0.05085737258195877, 0.019808126613497734, 0.014177733100950718, 0.016378361731767654, -0.019410502165555954, -0.06738974153995514, 0.014992408454418182, 0.010775333270430565, -0.02782168611884117, -0.02701708674430847, 0.011604944244027138, -0.001201515318825841, 0.0010063259396702051, 0.0007607935694977641, -0.02276994101703167, -0.04486869275569916, 0.03080609440803528, 0.03158588334918022, 0.024973517283797264, 0.012238887138664722, -0.048175111413002014, -0.027791261672973633, -0.06471818685531616, 0.09125062078237534, -0.07297538965940475, -0.03473690152168274, -0.04972698912024498, 0.013260822743177414, -0.0206955187022686, 0.029796384274959564, 0.02984246052801609, 0.02876868098974228, 0.008444434963166714, 0.009165627881884575, 0.035750359296798706, 0.023877480998635292, -0.06927821785211563, 0.019288090988993645, -0.006228198297321796, -0.016216039657592773, 0.0006475046975538135, -0.011345087550580502, 0.01991053856909275, 0.03417984023690224, -0.00492677791044116, -0.009235349483788013, 0.04116671159863472, -0.009695783257484436, 0.01604953035712242, 0.038625556975603104, 0.01514598447829485, -0.01857978291809559, 0.0517788864672184, -0.022502336651086807, -0.002884416840970516, 0.009393795393407345, -0.029617728665471077, -0.024092691019177437, 0.03371037170290947, 0.0013192316982895136, -0.007970801554620266, -0.01568751409649849, 0.03283580020070076, -0.0028469935059547424, -0.05021597072482109, -0.007195243611931801, 0.010471240617334843, -0.031432464718818665, 0.008618736639618874, 0.04003028944134712, 0.019247351214289665, 0.030536223202943802, -0.023294536396861076, 0.0035787883680313826, -0.002003242028877139, -0.005097752436995506, 0.004109508823603392, 0.0351448655128479, 0.01800178363919258, -0.024917583912611008, 0.018739869818091393, -0.021510794758796692, -0.038469038903713226, 0.03276476636528969, -0.040675368160009384, 0.052222155034542084, -0.05284540355205536, -0.06181380897760391, 0.02575565129518509, -0.006409323308616877, 0.049765344709157944, -0.002616745186969638, -0.010867069475352764, 0.08787483721971512, 0.012867489829659462, 0.0023333143908530474, 0.01782146655023098, -0.0047395555302500725, -0.03463536128401756, -0.041143737733364105, 0.010354990139603615, 0.030770501121878624, -0.013628456741571426, 0.0036444144789129496, -0.003261213656514883, -0.008735156618058681, 0.047877199947834015, 0.00579287251457572, 0.02013874053955078, -0.012509352527558804, -0.005651228595525026, -0.05279440060257912, -0.003329384373500943, -0.043648526072502136, -0.03131801262497902, 0.0016870145918801427, 0.04943878576159477, 0.030309295281767845, 0.02704598382115364, -0.019283348694443703, -0.00034585202229209244, 0.03357979282736778, -0.08554258942604065, 0.009688871912658215, -0.04693220928311348, 0.030972303822636604, 0.019795645028352737, -0.029185311868786812 ]
<p>Suppose I have a Netflix-style recommendation matrix, and I want to build a model that predicts potential future movie ratings for a given user. Using Simon Funk's approach, one would use stochastic gradient descent to minimize the Frobenius norm between the full matrix and the item-by-item * user-by-user matrix combined with an L2 regularization term. </p> <p>In practice, what do people do with the missing values from the recommendation matrix, which is the whole point of doing the calculation? My guess from reading Simon's blog post is that he ONLY uses the non-missing terms (which consist of (say) ~1% of the recommendation matrix) to build a model (with some judicious choice of hyper-parameters and regularization) to predict the other 99% of the matrix? </p> <p>In practice, do you really skip all those values? Or do you infer as much as possible BEFORE doing stochastic gradient descent? What are some of the standard best practices for dealing with the missing values?</p>
74,156
[ 0.0033674028236418962, 0.00622742623090744, 0.0007916725007817149, 0.015899259597063065, 0.0425679087638855, -0.0002792217710521072, -0.014213357120752335, -0.035323143005371094, 0.04624883458018303, 0.0012887290213257074, 0.007334154564887285, 0.007347745820879936, 0.04340600594878197, -0.0030621327459812164, 0.011821508407592773, -0.004534889478236437, -0.0003869509673677385, -0.030866796150803566, -0.0010487446561455727, 0.011663462035357952, -0.02778291329741478, 0.025189798325300217, 0.0190937127918005, 0.013917203061282635, -0.01875743269920349, 0.017331231385469437, 0.016438329592347145, 0.022840488702058792, -0.004552620928734541, 0.0019213103223592043, -0.054682984948158264, -0.010470484383404255, -0.0002474620414432138, 0.03365540876984596, 0.04030701518058777, 0.029626892879605293, -0.052903030067682266, -0.017044251784682274, -0.03223767876625061, 0.004093656782060862, 0.017405590042471886, -0.006307755596935749, 0.030906975269317627, 0.03524292632937431, -0.003545461455360055, 0.028517097234725952, -0.009242074564099312, -0.03589921444654465, 0.044571392238140106, -0.035427480936050415, 0.052451424300670624, 0.028624003753066063, 0.022272728383541107, 0.03345802053809166, -0.028817927464842796, 0.013914024457335472, 0.08980187028646469, 0.06507615000009537, 0.00807733740657568, -0.05571568384766579, -0.0018292798195034266, -0.031975481659173965, 0.002925494220107794, -0.027935650199651718, 0.0003032586828339845, 0.05049250274896622, 0.007326234597712755, -0.021577170118689537, 0.05827980488538742, -0.0060411011800169945, -0.014092001132667065, 0.012969668954610825, 0.03481481969356537, -0.012291816994547844, 0.014182522892951965, 0.002312915865331888, 0.008694395422935486, 0.05050576850771904, 0.03216073662042618, -0.028649281710386276, 0.007758432067930698, -0.0041099730879068375, 0.05137646943330765, 0.060529906302690506, -0.005315652582794428, -0.012915713712573051, 0.05424639210104942, -0.02389833703637123, -0.0012113022385165095, -0.008293598890304565, 0.002428490435704589, 0.0077319336123764515, 0.026847558096051216, -0.013631694950163364, -0.05300099402666092, 0.05384066328406334, -0.018978765234351158, 0.009022273123264313, 0.014606171287596226, -0.004273319151252508, -0.04056558758020401, 0.01562205795198679, -0.011577047407627106, 0.038398757576942444, -0.05161812901496887, -0.025528429076075554, -0.01521573681384325, 0.0025905435904860497, -0.03825891762971878, 0.007285166997462511, -0.03831389918923378, 0.020441807806491852, -0.007576142903417349, 0.0062758708372712135, 0.02601531147956848, 0.010362372733652592, -0.0021609514951705933, -0.023417899385094643, 0.05120749771595001, 0.06294658035039902, 0.02913157269358635, 0.008525052107870579, 0.028811825439333916, -0.004269431810826063, -0.04697881266474724, -0.0030335995834320784, 0.03154459595680237, -0.011074207723140717, -0.03772455453872681, 0.015917202457785606, -0.030599422752857208, -0.023025326430797577, 0.0416453517973423, 0.0009270801674574614, 0.006831818725913763, -0.0017868244322016835, -0.05338720232248306, -0.027421364560723305, 0.006235259585082531, -0.03711331635713577, 0.016898859292268753, -0.057262860238552094, -0.027689049020409584, 0.017501424998044968, 0.06438886374235153, 0.039005983620882034, 0.02127980813384056, 0.020620517432689667, 0.027782093733549118, -0.00032951339380815625, -0.022144123911857605, -0.0106464559212327, -0.023724839091300964, -0.004376629367470741, -0.036361388862133026, -0.05477731674909592, 0.0366559699177742, 0.04302914813160896, 0.010724088177084923, -0.0065670614130795, 0.03710907697677612, 0.008194772526621819, -0.019282018765807152, -0.011271454393863678, 0.0040614912286400795, -0.04517208784818649, 0.03635559231042862, -0.00529928645119071, 0.07548728585243225, 0.030749458819627762, -0.013184826821088791, -0.0057958816178143024, 0.007348494604229927, 0.03619419410824776, 0.0825432613492012, 0.021911241114139557, -0.019698506221175194, -0.007521787658333778, 0.039499226957559586, -0.019559983164072037, -0.03348850831389427, -0.05748886987566948, 0.01655450463294983, 0.022101404145359993, -0.00973103940486908, 0.056479524821043015, 0.005331392399966717, -0.02622847631573677, 0.06021546572446823, -0.04826241731643677, -0.018111538141965866, -0.04036339744925499, -0.0030506106559187174, -0.0004727416962850839, 0.007600666023790836, 0.06597549468278885, -0.01588616892695427, -0.005445415619760752, 0.009216692298650742, 0.003452213481068611, -0.040100082755088806, 0.0012172235874459147, 0.028559032827615738, -0.0450865775346756, 0.017483370378613472, 0.04870060458779335, 0.010917885228991508, 0.0011970868799835443, 0.056642644107341766, -0.06907989084720612, -0.08715049922466278, -0.009291973896324635, -0.0327511765062809, 0.02633657678961754, 0.004994730930775404, -0.031658124178647995, -0.0017613447271287441, -0.019269119948148727, -0.02969033271074295, 0.011435219086706638, -0.06681141257286072, 0.05040421336889267, 0.06848952919244766, 0.019397709518671036, -0.008585721254348755, 0.04288017377257347, 0.004502135328948498, 0.012018204666674137, 0.008223941549658775, 0.010166753083467484, -0.05835183709859848, -0.029118509963154793, 0.06985171884298325, 0.04370053857564926, -0.03177589178085327, -0.0160137377679348, 0.03339557349681854, 0.011837498284876347, 0.03884952515363693, 0.021320592612028122, -0.04286487400531769, -0.02094521000981331, 0.003627805970609188, 0.014650066383183002, -0.025292014703154564, -0.013925663195550442, -0.004011975601315498, 0.021004121750593185, 0.024486945942044258, 0.0196249820291996, -0.01244434341788292, 0.032917119562625885, 0.012032466009259224, -0.0017227139323949814, 0.000434757093898952, -0.0037859503645449877, 0.0445033460855484, 0.0006350371986627579, -0.007009480614215136, 0.04150782525539398, 0.013064051978290081, 0.01089857704937458, -0.006751975975930691, -0.016802078112959862, 0.0020243229810148478, 0.025961901992559433, -0.050899989902973175, 0.007915436290204525, 0.02951795794069767, -0.04742475599050522, 0.03173629194498062, -0.04985759034752846, -0.034620918333530426, -0.054620832204818726, 0.013783404603600502, 0.02304021641612053, -0.026553165167570114, 0.021433025598526, -0.023185476660728455, -0.03844701498746872, 0.005950498394668102, -0.0021021785214543343, 0.021103432402014732, 0.01815509982407093, -0.042605236172676086, 0.027479587122797966, 0.004254867788404226, 0.0035740721505135298, 0.019857553765177727, -0.007794534787535667, 0.03581032156944275, 0.019520295783877373, -0.015950452536344528, -0.06551846861839294, -0.04164241999387741, -0.000304253218928352, 0.02439958043396473, 0.01244253572076559, -0.03860301151871681, 0.056327659636735916, 0.0198200773447752, -0.07437197118997574, 0.02400525100529194, -0.008254874497652054, -0.026832841336727142, -0.0533706359565258, -0.02018442004919052, 0.022675063461065292, -0.010775305330753326, -0.019725002348423004, 0.01997423730790615, 0.009791349992156029, 0.02905396744608879, -0.0682021975517273, -0.04950612783432007, 0.03700736165046692, 0.008251171559095383, 0.02906486578285694, 0.019972313195466995, 0.010277441702783108, 0.09794428199529648, 0.03128805011510849, -0.034301843494176865, -0.016743794083595276, 0.015436992980539799, -0.0007427841192111373, -0.04323764517903328, 0.01575154811143875, 0.03187068924307823, 0.02645874209702015, 0.01571235992014408, -0.013305725529789925, 0.043140608817338943, 0.05017811805009842, 0.038898568600416183, 0.0066701737232506275, -0.004968234803527594, 0.013765891082584858, -0.007380805443972349, 0.015420367009937763, 0.0037338831461966038, 0.009994935244321823, 0.01587296836078167, -0.01655496098101139, 0.03698231652379036, 0.024218926206231117, -0.02780853770673275, 0.02460286021232605, -0.051784493029117584, 0.013983497396111488, -0.013711471110582352, 0.03253757953643799, 0.022635649889707565, -0.013814005069434643, 0.0028014201670885086, 0.0016529575223103166, 0.0444585382938385, -0.03200538456439972, 0.01638423651456833, 0.06134083867073059, 0.02017446979880333, -0.036552831530570984, 0.00466395216062665, 0.010945159010589123, -0.00557575561106205, 0.0005474428180605173, -0.020741388201713562, -0.014205432496964931, 0.014081250876188278, 0.05757799372076988, -0.009976274333894253, -0.013810449279844761, -0.03200896456837654, 0.021335173398256302, -0.07664979249238968, -0.005934871733188629, -0.014059801585972309, 0.05634397268295288, -0.041320085525512695, 0.01345519907772541, -0.014732114970684052, 0.03454764559864998, -0.001981425564736128, 0.026903832331299782, -0.06454060226678848, 0.01765233650803566, 0.006094492506235838, 0.012205005623400211, -0.06606436520814896, -0.009786461479961872, 0.047522176057100296, -0.02544729970395565, -0.004308602772653103, -0.030030006542801857, 0.030320623889565468, -0.03573263809084892, 0.027557995170354843, -0.015168397687375546, 0.0005734002916142344, -0.005870800465345383, -0.05147990584373474, 0.025062326341867447, -0.013782240450382233, -0.004228646866977215, 0.046993743628263474, -0.002242765622213483, -0.027736259624361992, -0.010480798780918121, 0.027705825865268707, 0.012160048820078373, 0.06433653086423874, 0.033140432089567184, 0.04765414819121361, -0.038708895444869995, 0.030346674844622612, -0.002323138527572155, 0.04368115961551666, 0.02388247847557068, 0.004603252746164799, -0.027405455708503723, -0.0739695131778717, -0.05075957626104355, 0.0006319471867755055, 0.01589656062424183, -0.0067869690246880054, 0.02127765864133835, 0.060584209859371185, 0.032378003001213074, -0.046415384858846664, 0.008711284026503563, 0.05270291119813919, 0.017578911036252975, -0.04882386699318886, -0.036224134266376495, 0.006831812206655741, -0.007479310035705566, 0.00796341709792614, 0.012714339420199394, -0.0024467080365866423, -0.011169126257300377, 0.006595670711249113, 0.012059750966727734, -0.002418285934254527, -0.017292365431785583, 0.01193962898105383, 0.05319622904062271, 0.0739709883928299, -0.024893514811992645, -0.0032141506671905518, 0.006586567964404821, 0.05240492522716522, 0.04450996220111847, 0.02223794534802437, 0.013818654231727123, -0.06017756834626198, 0.009042056277394295, 0.03775262087583542, 0.05304250866174698, -0.04961638152599335, -0.03341631218791008, -0.05299898609519005, -0.01774059422314167, 0.004779215436428785, 0.015466616488993168, 0.037263985723257065, 0.012555559165775776, 0.018926823511719704, -0.016707107424736023, -0.033082786947488785, 0.017637649551033974, -0.005400931462645531, -0.015965383499860764, 0.05909399315714836, -0.03445766866207123, -0.018632058054208755, -0.03602433577179909, 0.047869447618722916, 0.0303680207580328, 0.0831451267004013, 0.0008501449483446777, -0.002454602625221014, -0.004602951463311911, -0.011138392612338066, -0.006854195613414049, -0.07104746997356415, -0.01980036310851574, 0.003297594841569662, -0.0563386045396328, 0.055770233273506165, -0.007866883650422096, -0.05397194251418114, 0.01367510948330164, 0.06300792843103409, -0.010069981217384338, 0.0033576800487935543, -0.009372602216899395, 0.025038667023181915, 0.012395154684782028, 0.028124390169978142, 0.06808184087276459, 0.040888335555791855, 0.011484010145068169, 0.024354634806513786, -0.03213195875287056, 0.008495521731674671, 0.004106426145881414, 0.007819396443665028, -0.06791426241397858, -0.04908110946416855, -0.014820614829659462, 0.010109462775290012, 0.04073799401521683, 0.03465675935149193, -0.009192789904773235, -0.0158673282712698, -0.021925419569015503, 0.049961138516664505, -0.005135973449796438, -0.015704205259680748, 0.016742492094635963, 0.042863503098487854, -0.047386009246110916, 0.009548944421112537, 0.025182519108057022, -0.020293785259127617, 0.047144003212451935, 0.02793041616678238, -0.026134110987186432, -0.004268058575689793, -0.04115317761898041, -0.006128212902694941, 0.05626654252409935, -0.0009165857336483896, 0.03352193161845207, -0.015045280568301678, 0.01790606416761875, -0.023410428315401077, -0.020984472706913948, -0.002879718318581581, -0.010306109674274921, -0.0046712979674339294, -0.0032123872078955173, -0.04682328552007675, 0.03904150053858757, -0.02818274311721325, -0.00888801459223032, -0.05356774106621742, -0.03092486970126629, 0.016754554584622383, 0.022447098046541214, -0.05201876908540726, -0.023518063127994537, 0.02096094749867916, -0.033252108842134476, -0.022939980030059814, -0.02577926404774189, 0.015897130593657494, -0.042079005390405655, -0.016621656715869904, -0.035043105483055115, 0.01867903210222721, 0.07685940712690353, 0.016062766313552856, -0.00989910401403904, 0.03978557512164116, -0.0029079164378345013, 0.00587453693151474, -0.0019119945354759693, 0.011306998319923878, -0.011341777630150318, 0.024225864559412003, -0.05570236220955849, 0.022782493382692337, 0.03912312164902687, -0.0011758519103750587, 0.016617830842733383, 0.022313566878437996, 0.0016695486847311258, 0.04086359590291977, -0.00155559740960598, -0.00841364823281765, -0.03272373601794243, 0.00604282459244132, 0.030997691676020622, 0.008777533657848835, 0.016288815066218376, 0.017192374914884567, 0.031127385795116425, 0.03497613966464996, 0.02061692252755165, -0.018535027280449867, 0.022658158093690872, -0.006999202538281679, -0.021481124684214592, 0.018144551664590836, -0.030512958765029907, 0.0724477544426918, 0.012118838727474213, 0.033099956810474396, 0.01844862475991249, 0.04200984165072441, -0.056351445615291595, -0.06573054939508438, -0.04271029308438301, 0.012777354568243027, 0.0685703381896019, -0.02209561876952648, 0.004770413041114807, 0.010049075819551945, -0.03923856467008591, -0.025909338146448135, -0.07498445361852646, -0.03286243975162506, 0.001987036783248186, -0.018138382583856583, 0.01589200459420681, 0.018926968798041344, 0.00785751361399889, 0.013072608970105648, -0.006766616366803646, 0.01580685004591942, 0.021730978041887283, 0.02140224166214466, 0.02483736164867878, 0.048016030341386795, -0.036754339933395386, -0.0344841405749321, 0.0034240311942994595, -0.035951804369688034, -0.0032675086986273527, -0.007414671592414379, -0.024845561012625694, 0.04618648812174797, 0.021522071212530136, 0.017111703753471375, -0.016971126198768616, -0.0008211206877604127, -0.030718453228473663, 0.006197683047503233, 0.016383115202188492, -0.008314365521073341, 0.027686914429068565, -0.03758221119642258, 0.038128212094306946, 0.011387873440980911, 0.060301508754491806, -0.0036612770054489374, -0.08380158245563507, -0.024087514728307724, 0.01013114396482706, -0.03677845373749733, 0.00819393154233694, 0.038316819816827774, -0.005559375975281, 0.006188851781189442, -0.003281755605712533, 0.028994817286729813, 0.0013308596098795533, 0.039260901510715485, -0.02828649803996086, 0.057642482221126556, -0.02214428037405014, -0.0070534925907850266, -0.0027202048804610968, -0.015462839044630527, 0.1297212690114975, 0.08149461448192596, 0.03436300903558731, -0.07940354943275452, -0.00506554776802659, -0.02962525561451912, -0.006953889038413763, -0.0384940579533577, 0.029381684958934784, 0.008751469664275646, -0.0004420086042955518, 0.0488329753279686, 0.01385277509689331, -0.0015568920644000173, 0.015290808863937855, 0.03335538133978844, -0.05912133678793907, 0.038789693266153336, 0.03910136967897415, 0.01655225083231926, 0.015413613989949226, -0.032675471156835556, -0.027807312086224556, 0.0022785121109336615, 0.016317123547196388, -0.020755860954523087, -0.006096296478062868, -0.01328473724424839, 0.024318797513842583, -0.03157132863998413, 0.001953055732883513, 0.03360074386000633, 0.011544455774128437, 0.015558077953755856, 0.025171224027872086, 0.010501005686819553, 0.03717588260769844, -0.030128389596939087, 0.001853634836152196, -0.004332751501351595, -0.0028093375731259584, -0.006445733364671469, -0.024222059175372124, 0.003999284002929926, -0.03474722430109978, -0.039958406239748, -0.027903271839022636, 0.03650924935936928, -0.011822031810879707, -0.02564660832285881, 0.001957168336957693, -0.012055471539497375, 0.01853902079164982, -0.03154269978404045, -0.031982358545064926, 0.04962335154414177, 0.0584944412112236, 0.013616671785712242, -0.0031232668552547693, -0.003121498040854931, -0.0159789826720953, 0.008118728175759315, 0.018379144370555878, 0.01602400280535221, -0.009029855951666832, -0.01848030835390091, -0.005849543493241072, 0.006943780463188887, 0.009440170601010323, -0.010357648134231567, -0.04135548695921898, -0.04112895205616951, 0.0021259100176393986, -0.06505188345909119, 0.013956778682768345, -0.014386305585503578, 0.05443529784679413, -0.05500980094075203, -0.011974005028605461, -0.030707813799381256, -0.04763176292181015, 0.0189936812967062, -0.01846758835017681, -0.023414205759763718, -0.02301667258143425, 0.0027483138255774975, -0.027768049389123917, 0.040811628103256226, 0.004285389091819525, -0.0029025322292000055, 0.030693983659148216, 0.05133424699306488, -0.001062778988853097, -0.041263461112976074, -0.03248137980699539, -0.027876654639840126, -0.05711666867136955, 0.0026427023112773895, 0.007954562082886696, 0.03918156400322914, 0.007644179277122021, 0.01093228254467249, -0.04423926770687103, -0.0035825965460389853, 0.015282506123185158, 0.013016828335821629, -0.002490114187821746, -0.07495999336242676, 0.021616682410240173, 0.024030383676290512, -0.0023903283290565014, -0.036170899868011475, -0.0012491391971707344, -0.003240809077396989, 0.0033322551753371954, 0.04355582594871521, 0.007213621400296688, -0.034377798438072205, 0.02141006849706173, -0.00020903299446217716, 0.03259280323982239, -0.005987957585602999, -0.04023413360118866, -0.035867296159267426, 0.04311276227235794, -0.03567053750157356, -0.06250961869955063, -0.0033681215718388557, -0.008770526386797428, -0.01401416677981615, 0.0005628191865980625, -0.0028878787998110056, -0.012671605683863163, -0.00880790688097477, -0.03531018644571304, 0.012108171358704567, -0.04780779406428337, 0.03991076722741127, -0.0276590995490551, -0.043614573776721954, 0.025704694911837578, -0.040843136608600616, -0.05215932056307793, 0.012665923684835434, -0.015128742903470993, 0.020068425685167313, -0.0033954319078475237, -0.04192601516842842, -0.028254976496100426, 0.03340068832039833, -0.032410893589258194, -0.004794080276042223, 0.02308618649840355, 0.035924989730119705, 0.002660859376192093, -0.004562712740153074, 0.0067064412869513035, 0.0012624359223991632, 0.025339994579553604, -0.03301694989204407, 0.024754531681537628, -0.005282832775264978, 0.010800110176205635, 0.014689159579575062, -0.0185235645622015, 0.006250453181564808, 0.013025803491473198, 0.015376870520412922, -0.010870277881622314, 0.06500659883022308, 0.024932006374001503, -0.016599904745817184, 0.021588824689388275, 0.023427510634064674, -0.09090259671211243, -0.03213914483785629, 0.018730049952864647, -0.01383850909769535, 0.007512061856687069, -0.05267956852912903, 0.027335476130247116, 0.03531554341316223, -0.04347023740410805, 0.036776360124349594, -0.010900777764618397, 0.0019419738091528416, -0.02509010210633278, -0.0014818175695836544, -0.022178854793310165, -0.024438543245196342, 0.028507625684142113, -0.023487690836191177, 0.0011610339861363173, -0.01838141679763794, 0.009841740131378174, -0.04887528717517853, -0.013739991933107376, 0.03768903389573097, -0.03198850527405739, -0.042597122490406036, 0.013314465060830116, -0.0016419345047324896, -0.017066476866602898, -0.0017380312783643603, -0.022376369684934616, -0.00649367505684495, 0.004590330179780722, 0.04647469148039818, -0.0019437007140368223, 0.05478201061487198, 0.015825537964701653, -0.000756886787712574, 0.003923458978533745, -0.00963063258677721, 0.015321023762226105, 0.023866377770900726, -0.021324049681425095, 0.027002690359950066, 0.012634921818971634, -0.013683982193470001, -0.03788043186068535, 0.005383100360631943, -0.020174957811832428, 0.010466434992849827, -0.00036670270492322743, 0.004521233029663563, 0.007034887559711933, -0.050974637269973755, -0.002833568723872304, -0.02792714349925518, -0.02765733003616333, 0.015584150329232216, -0.019636373966932297, -0.025148602202534676, -0.010523521341383457, -0.013355864211916924, -0.04341258853673935, 0.059149377048015594, -0.011830794624984264, -0.046861082315444946, -0.0728507936000824, -0.026730986312031746, -0.0067502097226679325, -0.03475020080804825, -0.029060745611786842, -0.021397830918431282, -0.0549042634665966, 0.08519498258829117, 0.007205909118056297, 0.04805399477481842, -0.02530501037836075, -0.04495370760560036, 0.009356845170259476, -0.06522094458341599, 0.06000572815537453, -0.007040965836495161, -0.025127023458480835, -0.005206225905567408, 0.02410532534122467, -0.0074446662329137325, -0.015248834155499935, 0.06059357523918152, -0.01437997817993164, 0.01257456187158823, -0.042479127645492554, 0.019186150282621384, 0.023483511060476303, -0.01671689935028553, 0.033547867089509964, 0.005143928807228804, -0.006826053839176893, -0.04486558586359024, 0.009902984835207462, -0.027838917449116707, -0.016791081055998802, 0.023466316983103752, 0.016614241525530815, 0.022109512239694595, -0.0027533574029803276, 0.01777024194598198, 0.06286469101905823, 0.06286242604255676, 0.006036373320966959, 0.017891407012939453, 0.002984756138175726, 0.039301227778196335, 0.03406766429543495, -0.004923507571220398, -0.0990419089794159, 0.011927291750907898, -0.03114226832985878, -0.02583341859281063, -0.0035264543257653713, -0.0020797383040189743, 0.011823935434222221, -0.04341615363955498, -0.013311497867107391, 0.057920653373003006, -0.03036443516612053, 0.011681285686790943, 0.001518076634965837, -0.0022086238022893667, 0.03370800241827965, 0.010610546916723251, 0.026081407442688942, 0.05639178678393364, -0.017257463186979294, 0.015883270651102066, 0.02969062328338623, 0.021501101553440094, 0.03611302375793457, 0.020210226997733116, 0.03424898907542229, -0.0297982320189476, 0.011255929246544838, -0.01886243000626564, 0.03903105482459068, -0.055915772914886475, -0.009474102407693863, -0.02971932850778103, 0.0056305015459656715, -0.015447050333023071, -0.009803736582398415, -0.030011005699634552, 0.028418568894267082, -0.03781993314623833, -0.001866170554421842, -0.08805905282497406, -0.01238168217241764, -0.005330985877662897, 0.029536502435803413, -0.009037813171744347, 0.04351377487182617, 0.004909194074571133, 0.01744735799729824, -0.0066666495986282825, -0.004679886158555746, 0.02006744220852852, -0.02575347200036049, 0.019609685987234116, -0.014679905027151108, 0.01880967617034912, -0.019048286601901054, -0.041051141917705536, -0.01578131876885891, -0.007557304576039314, 0.0030628968961536884, 0.049092650413513184, 0.013173062354326248, -0.04586908221244812, 0.02636050432920456, -0.061545852571725845, 0.014439632184803486, -0.0744597464799881, -0.001823044614866376, -0.06474997848272324, 0.017696164548397064, -0.020042983815073967, -0.003702720394358039 ]
<p>I'm working with a survey that uses a rolling data collection format (i.e., there are multiple waves of sampling and initial contacts). I'm trying to develop a model to predict how likely a sample member is to respond to the survey within 7 weeks from today. Predicting whether a respondent who is first contacted today will respond within 7 weeks is fairly straightforward - just a basic propensity model predicting response within seven weeks of initial contact. However, predicting whether a case that's been in the field for several weeks already will respond in the next 7 weeks is more difficult.</p> <p>My question is how do I take into account that the probability of response changes based on how long the case has been a nonrespondent (i.e., a respondent's initial probability of response may have been .75, but if they're still a nonrespondent after 4 weeks, they'll probably remain a nonrespondent)? I could just include the amount of time the case has been in the field as a variable in the propensity model, but I'm not sure if that's the appropriate way to handle it. It seems like this may be a situation for survival analysis, but my knowledge in that area is limited.</p> <p>Any suggestions of an approach, model, or previous research I should consider would be much appreciated. </p>
74,157
[ -0.022221781313419342, -0.05957639217376709, 0.009514367207884789, 0.00957409106194973, 0.02943744696676731, -0.01183137483894825, 0.008075977675616741, -0.01333854254335165, 0.030535243451595306, -0.024560900405049324, -0.010000324808061123, 0.020460914820432663, 0.027394356206059456, -0.01565513201057911, 0.0074842278845608234, 0.015261713415384293, 0.00872395746409893, 0.017728742212057114, -0.03543758764863014, 0.03003757819533348, 0.021669359877705574, 0.012024514377117157, 0.012737548910081387, -0.02215222641825676, -0.022589661180973053, 0.030977576971054077, 0.05124254524707794, -0.03185664489865303, 0.02239290438592434, 0.05975339561700821, -0.027974089607596397, -0.032090164721012115, 0.012222920544445515, 0.033276814967393875, 0.011564874090254307, 0.014250676147639751, -0.04788118973374367, -0.05126098915934563, -0.02222670055925846, 0.050513189285993576, -0.019261322915554047, 0.008032916113734245, 0.016153454780578613, 0.06445665657520294, -0.02388242445886135, -0.007084432058036327, -0.038365740329027176, -0.014355817809700966, 0.060289375483989716, -0.03732464835047722, 0.0615515299141407, -0.012036980129778385, 0.022641468793153763, -0.0027771720197051764, -0.03009583242237568, -0.04462314024567604, 0.06769393384456635, 0.05305499583482742, 0.01153904851526022, -0.02513125166296959, -0.042342256754636765, -0.04274579882621765, -0.028836390003561974, -0.004545168951153755, -0.02398448809981346, 0.023540155962109566, -0.011280328035354614, -0.02834366448223591, 0.05638457089662552, -0.03926414996385574, 0.04358913004398346, 0.0150981480255723, 0.04327971860766411, 0.010615208186209202, 0.007560324855148792, -0.03147857263684273, -0.005004653241485357, 0.03762273117899895, -0.00922448467463255, 0.032392680644989014, -0.034032680094242096, -0.009296035394072533, -0.0056942119263112545, 0.038152799010276794, 0.022423170506954193, -0.05383509770035744, 0.03561073914170265, -0.006102327257394791, 0.04514151066541672, 0.00895328912883997, -0.017756270244717598, 0.013889012858271599, 0.00513679813593626, -0.03346286714076996, -0.0545923076570034, 0.030798114836215973, 0.0007845652289688587, 0.062379900366067886, -0.0010339145082980394, -0.0012992204865440726, -0.008277333341538906, -0.04363786429166794, 0.007393222767859697, 0.022053187713027, -0.020824061706662178, -0.028838740661740303, -0.02477981336414814, -0.024454737082123756, 0.006732045207172632, -0.027915120124816895, -0.02777118608355522, 0.009946574456989765, 0.004484391305595636, -0.006705690640956163, 0.009101559408009052, -0.017040399834513664, -0.03710048273205757, -0.025893595069646835, 0.07360052317380905, 0.07912521809339523, 0.058505166321992874, -0.05712214857339859, 0.014133348129689693, -0.05374527350068092, -0.03468935191631317, -0.021063869819045067, 0.02141406387090683, -0.017748676240444183, -0.030957641080021858, 0.032722700387239456, 0.02323981188237667, -0.02087760716676712, 0.05972527712583542, -0.0292961448431015, 0.04530513659119606, 0.028777126222848892, -0.04960821941494942, -0.025409746915102005, 0.027220332995057106, 0.005059246905148029, -0.005189817398786545, -0.058853987604379654, -0.012434099800884724, 0.03413676470518112, 0.03196605667471886, -0.012272011488676071, 0.04504981264472008, -0.004361236467957497, 0.0242073405534029, 0.014991356991231441, -0.0261837188154459, -0.027142679318785667, -0.003256772179156542, -0.025851793587207794, -0.011976264417171478, -0.08613988757133484, 0.02696600928902626, 0.007029817905277014, -0.011680145747959614, -0.04758381471037865, 0.07152149081230164, -0.03292907401919365, -0.026047902181744576, -0.019973570480942726, 0.011674867942929268, 0.0015741405077278614, 0.07054905593395233, -0.02529843896627426, -0.0039010283071547747, 0.05032769590616226, 0.03605297952890396, 0.02368539571762085, 0.013545758090913296, 0.04247211664915085, 0.03530903905630112, -0.005510751623660326, 0.002844739705324173, 0.007152102887630463, -0.006266026757657528, 0.0005588767817243934, -0.00935245119035244, -0.010993939824402332, -0.03993963077664375, -0.02884555235505104, 0.046996183693408966, -0.0065665640868246555, 0.030101651325821877, -0.03031640499830246, 0.017963558435440063, -0.03242559731006622, -0.04971059411764145, -0.0663822665810585, 0.04580377787351608, -0.00008974006050266325, 0.0004106255655642599, 0.029050232842564583, 0.009502164088189602, 0.009866139851510525, -0.00925549864768982, -0.010411876253783703, -0.027015917003154755, -0.02566256746649742, 0.02940751612186432, -0.05538228154182434, -0.02522033266723156, 0.048179689794778824, 0.0005272231646813452, -0.010607483796775341, 0.03745357692241669, -0.04595988988876343, -0.016327133402228355, -0.011637786403298378, -0.0173597801476717, 0.04720339551568031, -0.03454231098294258, 0.015642452985048294, 0.002791912527754903, -0.01107755582779646, -0.014151303097605705, 0.023964444175362587, -0.045756395906209946, 0.06684989482164383, 0.08411446958780289, -0.023737434297800064, -0.01862248405814171, 0.004647338297218084, -0.0002507030440028757, 0.025180865079164505, -0.020561112090945244, -0.034964773803949356, -0.06785959005355835, -0.006679435260593891, 0.007397988811135292, -0.04598604142665863, 0.020291365683078766, 0.020124366506934166, 0.06357266008853912, 0.06157447770237923, 0.03433837741613388, 0.012140034697949886, 0.023775987327098846, 0.008988560177385807, 0.014672961086034775, -0.0018907319754362106, -0.013317697681486607, -0.045255210250616074, 0.010266546159982681, -0.004799491725862026, 0.0410941056907177, -0.0005234958371147513, -0.02326151356101036, 0.008703879080712795, 0.027118615806102753, 0.035728100687265396, -0.020431453362107277, -0.004636240191757679, 0.03871855139732361, -0.01630369760096073, -0.014502889476716518, 0.048757411539554596, 0.018811343237757683, 0.02719292789697647, -0.006898129358887672, -0.06372706592082977, 0.04144618287682533, 0.010322224348783493, -0.04941713809967041, -0.00029602006543427706, 0.01106161717325449, -0.0352860689163208, -0.009467355906963348, -0.027157578617334366, -0.0578581877052784, 0.000838889682199806, -0.022785812616348267, 0.02928532287478447, 0.014979947358369827, 0.0436931811273098, -0.006357541773468256, -0.016937389969825745, 0.010245057754218578, 0.00037747668102383614, -0.0036589112132787704, 0.02270733006298542, -0.07506054639816284, -0.0020287770312279463, -0.02684049680829048, -0.049228932708501816, 0.02103416807949543, 0.000987422652542591, -0.05604022741317749, 0.047264087945222855, 0.008631854318082333, -0.05434173718094826, 0.0053109657019376755, -0.009241875261068344, 0.008899676613509655, -0.0164942666888237, -0.01810166984796524, 0.06202823668718338, 0.02999863028526306, -0.01723000407218933, 0.019894475117325783, -0.048074815422296524, 0.008070453070104122, -0.004497116431593895, -0.0230243019759655, 0.022013362497091293, -0.001608409103937447, 0.036627184599637985, -0.022133003920316696, 0.00427872221916914, -0.01454607117921114, -0.06573320925235748, -0.07837282866239548, -0.004374371375888586, -0.020094865933060646, 0.024668188765645027, 0.016636263579130173, 0.015571794472634792, 0.06969134509563446, 0.05288054794073105, 0.017570819705724716, -0.024385714903473854, -0.01053786650300026, -0.04573081061244011, -0.004036910831928253, -0.010815532878041267, 0.009751037694513798, 0.020498748868703842, -0.01726730912923813, -0.011573970317840576, 0.023374779149889946, 0.05186338350176811, 0.018045488744974136, 0.0069271414540708065, 0.0003257872594986111, 0.012823853641748428, 0.020622191950678825, -0.00610899506136775, 0.01502307876944542, -0.02087303437292576, 0.03079710341989994, -0.04768391326069832, 0.003177035367116332, -0.012032090686261654, -0.031064776703715324, -0.0030538307037204504, -0.003163688350468874, 0.01054792758077383, -0.013748993165791035, 0.043372318148612976, -0.031491801142692566, -0.04367402195930481, -0.01432752888649702, 0.01081721018999815, 0.06223054602742195, -0.025789374485611916, 0.029945319518446922, 0.0465884730219841, 0.04453878477215767, -0.023915253579616547, 0.0007356620626524091, -0.028323957696557045, -0.028802689164876938, 0.020808955654501915, -0.04950456693768501, -0.011264056898653507, 0.024687182158231735, 0.030915122479200363, 0.03608530014753342, -0.03308429569005966, -0.040070801973342896, -0.017151931300759315, -0.03442762792110443, 0.007283815182745457, 0.02841069921851158, 0.0653546079993248, 0.002117448952049017, 0.006585076916962862, 0.025879576802253723, -0.02106728032231331, 0.04778093844652176, 0.042416300624608994, -0.07139460742473602, 0.039374545216560364, -0.019777148962020874, -0.0042959097772836685, 0.0004745488695334643, -0.0012852026848122478, 0.04508313536643982, 0.04897526279091835, -0.0005609593936242163, -0.020827775821089745, 0.02463885396718979, -0.02734905295073986, -0.009923619218170643, -0.04046010598540306, 0.02836865559220314, -0.044170208275318146, 0.026174474507570267, 0.009574845433235168, 0.00826152041554451, 0.02265075035393238, 0.03345377743244171, 0.004953473806381226, -0.02373388409614563, -0.0354410745203495, -0.023531664162874222, 0.02774169109761715, 0.034313976764678955, 0.04642629623413086, -0.009236225858330727, -0.10199844092130661, 0.026387520134449005, -0.017680037766695023, 0.020782725885510445, 0.04543962702155113, 0.005289900582283735, 0.00278252805583179, -0.059051137417554855, -0.007458506152033806, 0.011685356497764587, 0.005622736643999815, 0.004416120238602161, 0.0007033332949504256, 0.06613460183143616, -0.029345814138650894, -0.051743436604738235, -0.0017025490524247289, 0.06591493636369705, 0.03539524972438812, 0.0055295382626354694, -0.01946299523115158, 0.017816783860325813, -0.01483980193734169, -0.006884983740746975, 0.027230387553572655, 0.01620832271873951, 0.016363078728318214, -0.023523613810539246, 0.0274213720113039, -0.02277892455458641, -0.015870019793510437, 0.031811073422431946, 0.005765343550592661, 0.04254724085330963, 0.04219468683004379, -0.05137336626648903, 0.0200258269906044, 0.0897541418671608, 0.05737452954053879, 0.032706648111343384, 0.03493237867951393, -0.08416534960269928, -0.015245379880070686, 0.026386993005871773, 0.027947863563895226, -0.0330996997654438, -0.04668566957116127, -0.03936852142214775, -0.012840143404901028, 0.04779323190450668, -0.03655590862035751, -0.003029701765626669, -0.00024582428159192204, -0.031955406069755554, -0.022351685911417007, -0.044723618775606155, -0.04746345430612564, 0.04619426280260086, -0.028072528541088104, 0.006859029643237591, 0.000056824141211109236, -0.013611329719424248, -0.03540225327014923, -0.0023687919601798058, 0.016905855387449265, 0.057036515325307846, -0.013122685253620148, -0.007471854332834482, 0.022091658785939217, -0.026368914172053337, -0.015598881989717484, -0.03564190864562988, 0.007171147968620062, 0.02496861107647419, 0.008128668181598186, 0.04043455421924591, -0.00844536256045103, -0.03492545709013939, 0.029559072107076645, 0.025319671258330345, -0.019943244755268097, -0.03717673569917679, -0.05323409289121628, -0.0009015897521749139, -0.005705306306481361, -0.012131616473197937, 0.07074227184057236, 0.062311504036188126, 0.028516827151179314, -0.008359215222299099, -0.008460788987576962, -0.003519575111567974, 0.0005802205414511263, -0.014288412407040596, -0.014504426158964634, 0.002671086462214589, -0.0461115762591362, 0.02969316765666008, -0.013615583069622517, 0.014791074208915234, -0.04113912209868431, -0.01037201564759016, -0.001460856175981462, 0.010565487667918205, 0.010660501196980476, 0.003897350048646331, 0.021124068647623062, 0.017327632755041122, -0.0033487158361822367, -0.005316197872161865, 0.012577356770634651, -0.015870386734604836, 0.00866482499986887, 0.030486756935715675, -0.04273546487092972, -0.013497782871127129, -0.03274594992399216, -0.034376613795757294, 0.021546823903918266, -0.012375986203551292, 0.03565908223390579, -0.006103824824094772, 0.016574179753661156, 0.032517943531274796, -0.03209397941827774, 0.004892594181001186, 0.053744517266750336, -0.0012387091992422938, 0.03623463958501816, -0.03640193119645119, 0.057623084634542465, 0.00814889371395111, -0.00419016694650054, -0.06735590100288391, -0.06279714405536652, 0.041486192494630814, -0.0036338907666504383, -0.03473068028688431, -0.02373507246375084, 0.020620588213205338, -0.029675567522644997, -0.023389944806694984, 0.02183784544467926, 0.024921270087361336, -0.014843289740383625, 0.027420029044151306, -0.003006340702995658, 0.04532109946012497, 0.07279098033905029, 0.001712038996629417, -0.02899264171719551, 0.03994358330965042, -0.040051501244306564, -0.009590238332748413, -0.022358005866408348, 0.0068865674547851086, -0.05244878679513931, -0.015431422740221024, -0.040446631610393524, 0.009834605269134045, 0.06402299553155899, -0.01380404643714428, -0.034309741109609604, -0.020513121038675308, -0.03173449635505676, 0.024754095822572708, -0.03476817160844803, 0.001699758693575859, 0.00043760586413554847, -0.03009839542210102, -0.0394955649971962, 0.04050058126449585, 0.008119922131299973, 0.005061799194663763, -0.00040734439971856773, 0.001951092854142189, 0.0016395188868045807, 0.012258985079824924, 0.03983619436621666, -0.017261473461985588, 0.010677591897547245, 0.00257017370313406, -0.020252704620361328, 0.047219887375831604, 0.00690613454207778, -0.008815218694508076, 0.017406871542334557, 0.0030186374206095934, -0.03926537185907364, -0.04455950856208801, 0.004452647641301155, -0.05588354915380478, 0.06207390874624252, -0.04247666895389557, 0.03085433691740036, 0.027932606637477875, 0.016095979139208794, -0.030716560781002045, 0.012665126472711563, 0.01511494442820549, 0.006319773383438587, -0.0032635803800076246, 0.06431331485509872, -0.008642551489174366, 0.002796730725094676, 0.025862831622362137, 0.014014826156198978, 0.038483910262584686, 0.045542195439338684, 0.048768386244773865, 0.02785455249249935, 0.05888735502958298, -0.008633403107523918, -0.03602747246623039, 0.003923677373677492, -0.03972676023840904, 0.01750877872109413, -0.02267834171652794, -0.053990527987480164, 0.056705012917518616, 0.03618640825152397, 0.004549663048237562, -0.021731607615947723, -0.006911121308803558, -0.027823857963085175, -0.014673360623419285, 0.01543665211647749, -0.0036563631147146225, 0.060992274433374405, 0.024082381278276443, 0.05003434792160988, -0.018471775576472282, 0.02914433740079403, -0.01570070907473564, -0.04169206693768501, -0.004885317757725716, -0.04225132241845131, -0.0649280995130539, 0.01963016204535961, -0.013793786987662315, 0.002411156427115202, 0.0009246188565157354, -0.013795659877359867, -0.03183232620358467, 0.002880842424929142, 0.016095058992505074, -0.03568954020738602, 0.10001980513334274, 0.007262244820594788, 0.01440693624317646, -0.016382629051804543, 0.012163207866251469, 0.10189688205718994, 0.07946758717298508, 0.04813961684703827, -0.04808514937758446, 0.019529243931174278, 0.009846246801316738, 0.015213738195598125, -0.04440711438655853, -0.013050870038568974, 0.009723782539367676, -0.05739922448992729, 0.06179990619421005, 0.01921740174293518, -0.03641131892800331, 0.029443224892020226, 0.04771384596824646, -0.028096163645386696, -0.011510340496897697, -0.005524670705199242, -0.014233877882361412, 0.009747550822794437, -0.02810731902718544, -0.02537389285862446, 0.021706651896238327, 0.024176914244890213, -0.032160162925720215, -0.009938472881913185, -0.011790906079113483, -0.011929558590054512, 0.0006182566285133362, 0.007670850958675146, 0.016498064622282982, 0.019262704998254776, 0.042997609823942184, -0.011573893018066883, -0.000599027902353555, 0.002865272108465433, -0.04325822740793228, 0.01046181283891201, 0.059139184653759, -0.016268612816929817, -0.011983940377831459, 0.00913335382938385, 0.042774952948093414, -0.053450096398591995, -0.023357989266514778, -0.04734620451927185, 0.03959233686327934, -0.006035286001861095, 0.003888250095769763, 0.007401763927191496, 0.013676044531166553, 0.04134983941912651, -0.028010698035359383, -0.04648885130882263, 0.015217198058962822, 0.026472700759768486, -0.047194335609674454, -0.030264878645539284, 0.006889235693961382, -0.005459134466946125, 0.023813452571630478, 0.02483595907688141, 0.04036770388484001, -0.04350695759057999, -0.012103856541216373, -0.03417343273758888, 0.03384599834680557, -0.02005130983889103, 0.0010662012500688434, 0.01856507919728756, -0.024641795083880424, -0.042029645293951035, 0.023253362625837326, 0.005368570797145367, -0.0020716353319585323, 0.030241340398788452, -0.06871768087148666, 0.007291726768016815, -0.034231849014759064, -0.03580107167363167, -0.0046784537844359875, -0.026138074696063995, 0.012639722786843777, -0.047317225486040115, 0.00948033481836319, 0.02025740221142769, 0.043699201196432114, -0.0396219901740551, 0.008672568015754223, -0.026642827317118645, 0.043257758021354675, 0.015789220109581947, -0.06900060176849365, 0.002376927761361003, -0.00041713082464411855, -0.02280808612704277, 0.01300208829343319, -0.016334399580955505, 0.05211082473397255, 0.0006434735259972513, -0.01916569657623768, 0.00617836881428957, 0.012954608537256718, -0.027583763003349304, 0.028064122423529625, -0.01373348943889141, -0.048617374151945114, -0.004123291000723839, -0.005317621864378452, 0.029543990269303322, -0.03261895105242729, -0.03907782584428787, -0.010462606325745583, -0.015621224418282509, -0.0021419916301965714, -0.03669717535376549, -0.03758859261870384, 0.01752139814198017, -0.031170397996902466, 0.028142761439085007, -0.010364620015025139, 0.0026062193792313337, -0.044402435421943665, -0.017800938338041306, -0.013240188360214233, -0.010225567035377026, 0.008667664602398872, -0.00029472948517650366, 0.008201432414352894, -0.018513787537813187, 0.025190796703100204, -0.016040099784731865, 0.010015343315899372, -0.007002576719969511, 0.021017633378505707, -0.017380734905600548, 0.06417857110500336, -0.0036177339497953653, -0.028443677350878716, 0.03751056268811226, -0.042392581701278687, -0.062378011643886566, 0.04135707765817642, 0.017703058198094368, 0.05200249329209328, 0.03146713227033615, 0.016643568873405457, 0.052744146436452866, 0.045269377529621124, -0.02113216184079647, -0.026775583624839783, -0.025891277939081192, 0.0068467664532363415, -0.008602827787399292, -0.027499226853251457, 0.028300505131483078, 0.038864217698574066, -0.005214519798755646, 0.022996097803115845, 0.048187270760536194, -0.016526786610484123, -0.011429465375840664, -0.0012000070419162512, -0.002920736325904727, 0.02259608916938305, -0.021648533642292023, -0.02410741336643696, 0.05070484057068825, 0.035404711961746216, 0.009139409288764, 0.03566056862473488, -0.010782808065414429, 0.005970718339085579, -0.044600095599889755, -0.011928416788578033, 0.006369462236762047, 0.013527109287679195, 0.042155224829912186, -0.04782400280237198, -0.029071716591715813, 0.02188470959663391, -0.012176365591585636, 0.022506332024931908, -0.004299453925341368, 0.022660233080387115, -0.020347539335489273, 0.038316916674375534, -0.004684785380959511, -0.0035072420723736286, 0.03538934141397476, 0.005601920187473297, -0.013394776731729507, 0.05187481269240379, -0.011887483298778534, -0.007804606109857559, 0.005232302937656641, 0.041872911155223846, 0.033783212304115295, -0.036059875041246414, 0.02408800646662712, -0.03667694330215454, -0.017791638150811195, 0.03945749253034592, -0.014405963011085987, 0.027091050520539284, 0.021977350115776062, 0.010116813704371452, 0.03508623689413071, 0.025731472298502922, 0.015034520998597145, -0.025903835892677307, 0.03142634779214859, 0.003079532878473401, 0.03774717450141907, 0.03024156019091606, -0.026668895035982132, 0.02290545590221882, 0.011943968012928963, 0.003775134449824691, -0.013267629779875278, 0.02625693567097187, -0.015482012182474136, -0.0006326660513877869, 0.01122742984443903, -0.006328781601041555, 0.015877556055784225, -0.03283459693193436, 0.02891792729496956, -0.028065796941518784, 0.0158864576369524, 0.03294840827584267, -0.009493229910731316, -0.023214705288410187, 0.025135310366749763, -0.03823819383978844, -0.03254000097513199, 0.033069491386413574, -0.00840925145894289, 0.005900275893509388, -0.05432974919676781, -0.017027294263243675, -0.022338123992085457, -0.008247478865087032, -0.04432925581932068, 0.012561265379190445, -0.017327768728137016, 0.029465870931744576, -0.024440741166472435, -0.012880489230155945, 0.03879578784108162, 0.020110532641410828, 0.03119031898677349, -0.08462619036436081, 0.0765225887298584, 0.01090284064412117, -0.047177135944366455, -0.03028295561671257, -0.021739592775702477, -0.02831459417939186, 0.009144304320216179, 0.09040212631225586, -0.030679548159241676, -0.02147102728486061, 0.019457943737506866, 0.016586430370807648, -0.02733681909739971, -0.027473876252770424, 0.060687825083732605, -0.0027682308573275805, -0.007973367348313332, -0.014188588596880436, -0.009801816195249557, 0.0004227544413879514, 0.00335827749222517, -0.012227362021803856, -0.029819976538419724, 0.03163205459713936, 0.0002947923494502902, -0.020775051787495613, 0.012182091362774372, 0.03674378618597984, -0.02621905319392681, 0.02127266302704811, 0.006088116206228733, 0.024199865758419037, 0.009855532087385654, -0.004420714918524027, -0.04206627234816551, 0.041542958468198776, -0.05709359049797058, -0.017545539885759354, 0.03287259116768837, 0.02119695022702217, -0.0318482331931591, -0.05296522378921509, 0.0005641405005007982, 0.03144136071205139, -0.012273968197405338, 0.02426968328654766, 0.03158971667289734, 0.03829481080174446, 0.05526087060570717, -0.019831672310829163, 0.023485196754336357, 0.006203796714544296, 0.017892293632030487, -0.021134162321686745, -0.007829373702406883, 0.038192134350538254, -0.04142150655388832, -0.0054383547976613045, 0.026885176077485085, 0.006129363551735878, 0.036825548857450485, -0.03701576963067055, 0.0009238992934115231, -0.03664446249604225, 0.01835828647017479, 0.010828069411218166, 0.0020913132466375828, -0.02348393201828003, 0.027625957503914833, 0.007541723549365997, 0.04795287549495697, 0.005219739396125078, 0.011016692034900188, -0.05319563299417496, 0.004264144692569971, -0.018886437639594078, 0.04521932825446129, 0.03357575461268425, 0.02198788709938526, 0.003143757814541459, 0.013393214903771877, 0.013799428939819336, -0.02618769370019436, 0.01630578562617302, -0.020532414317131042, 0.02369365096092224, -0.011562756262719631, 0.013384344056248665, -0.05218719691038132, -0.021676156669855118, -0.020969333127141, -0.017621539533138275, 0.01931111514568329, 0.024617645889520645, 0.02530163712799549, -0.002940233564004302, -0.01683218963444233, 0.028980672359466553, 0.04888102784752846, -0.08109652996063232, -0.027613544836640358, -0.08368222415447235, 0.0008164588361978531, 0.02661062777042389, -0.012410205788910389 ]
<p>Suppose we have $p$ dimensional vectors $Y_i$ which we model with $f_Y (y |\theta) = \sum \pi_k N(y | \mu_k, \Sigma_k)$ with $\theta$ being a catch all for the model parameters (the number of components might be a finite known/unknown number or infinite as in Dirichlet process mixtures). The prior on $\pi$ will either be a uniform or Stick-breaking prior with perhaps a hyperprior on the associated precision parameter. What are good default prior choices for the cluster components $(\mu_k, \Sigma_k)$? I have been using a conjugate Normal-inverse-Wishart, i.e. $$ (\mu_k, \Sigma_k) \sim \mathcal N(\mu_k |m, \Sigma_k / n_0) \mathcal W^{-1} (\Sigma_k | \Psi, \nu). $$ I then fix $\nu, n_0$ relatively small and either estimate $m$ and $\Psi$ empircally, or specify independent hyperpriors and estimate the key parameters of the hyperpriors empircally (from what I can tell, there is some evidence that people do this since it seems to be what is done in the vignettes for DPpackage). </p> <p>Ultimately, I'd like to set things up so that the prior should be relatively uninformative (with at least some hope of adding prior knowledge in a systematic way), but there are a lot of parameters floating around and the individual influence of each one isn't always transparent. I've come across some papers on this issue that give guidance for choosing parameters empirically but they mainly focus on $p = 1$. Given that these models are pervasive in Bayesian nonparametrics, I figure guidelines must exist and that I just haven't found them.</p> <p>Ideally, I'd like answers here to be specific as possible; in particular, I'm most interested in choosing the hyperparameters in the priors/hyperpriors. </p>
48,548
[ -0.014717514626681805, -0.01188037171959877, 0.033919449895620346, -0.02506118454039097, 0.06221544370055199, 0.013702163472771645, -0.03389619663357735, -0.00618465943261981, 0.008447724394500256, -0.06741901487112045, 0.006180983502417803, 0.017456579953432083, 0.08174168318510056, 0.0006045061745680869, 0.005186799913644791, 0.005444658920168877, -0.015755193307995796, -0.007048263680189848, -0.024725010618567467, -0.01817064732313156, 0.006549302488565445, 0.02873242273926735, 0.01124079804867506, -0.042871296405792236, -0.028769386932253838, 0.028795531019568443, 0.005326411686837673, -0.004066128749400377, -0.037466611713171005, 0.05002943426370621, -0.009066084399819374, 0.0003940979077015072, -0.013205230236053467, 0.04207544028759003, -0.03759314492344856, -0.015572719275951385, -0.01464118529111147, -0.023413849994540215, -0.00976847019046545, 0.03389028087258339, -0.05105575919151306, -0.03952282294631004, -0.003295429516583681, 0.0008733480353839695, -0.005735535640269518, -0.004258986096829176, -0.011736287735402584, -0.04133126139640808, 0.044526733458042145, -0.034649550914764404, 0.07000674307346344, 0.030650649219751358, 0.016423752531409264, 0.04042473062872887, -0.01991371251642704, -0.011333869770169258, 0.04047904908657074, 0.0841049775481224, 0.010895517654716969, -0.06672904640436172, -0.053562719374895096, -0.015273075550794601, 0.025835439562797546, -0.0661819577217102, -0.03253130242228508, 0.02583070658147335, -0.007389188278466463, -0.010341404005885124, 0.027249349281191826, -0.024926448240876198, 0.027148514986038208, -0.0027704956009984016, 0.02330109104514122, 0.008061664178967476, -0.011965092271566391, -0.00995209626853466, -0.025872783735394478, 0.024798739701509476, 0.06795994192361832, 0.03122161142528057, -0.023820949718356133, 0.0012093016412109137, 0.021536558866500854, -0.0020133182406425476, -0.03175264224410057, 0.005649254657328129, 0.07978468388319016, -0.01561361737549305, -0.011077268049120903, 0.042674362659454346, -0.03785138949751854, -0.006341555155813694, 0.009041823446750641, -0.019553082063794136, -0.05279966816306114, 0.045752257108688354, -0.03031277470290661, 0.0307406485080719, -0.021305901929736137, -0.016200276091694832, -0.0107959546148777, -0.041030969470739365, -0.010077564977109432, 0.06437657028436661, -0.018526755273342133, -0.01773863658308983, -0.016411632299423218, 0.0062482887879014015, -0.04493502527475357, -0.033604301512241364, -0.017436524853110313, 0.03217592090368271, -0.032566994428634644, -0.03435700759291649, 0.01870628260076046, 0.004850903060287237, -0.01176593266427517, -0.06705032289028168, 0.070738285779953, 0.07557163387537003, 0.04340275749564171, 0.005289528518915176, 0.02787018194794655, -0.038053564727306366, -0.07632474601268768, -0.024227013811469078, 0.015518748201429844, -0.011000524275004864, -0.025370946153998375, 0.012616588734090328, 0.009125146083533764, 0.006554401945322752, 0.073308065533638, -0.01324120070785284, -0.014476513490080833, 0.02685392089188099, -0.03123650699853897, -0.02285885438323021, 0.04857558757066727, -0.0036130123771727085, 0.011712607927620411, -0.05290692672133446, -0.02969011291861534, 0.028762001544237137, 0.055230025202035904, -0.027039725333452225, 0.02347470447421074, 0.02690509520471096, 0.02349216677248478, 0.002691905712708831, -0.045167382806539536, -0.04283065348863602, 0.0038292601238936186, 0.00004154918860876933, -0.020033791661262512, -0.07268629968166351, 0.05039149150252342, 0.03486742451786995, -0.002886042231693864, 0.03682459890842438, 0.06744079291820526, 0.012622633017599583, -0.011126848869025707, -0.0016605934360995889, 0.0004849202814511955, -0.019870387390255928, 0.03224242106080055, 0.007042469456791878, 0.01715654879808426, -0.02151045762002468, -0.02284114621579647, -0.005010642111301422, 0.03786240518093109, 0.05584229901432991, 0.05946532264351845, 0.0013918918557465076, -0.012648372910916805, -0.022415831685066223, 0.027812933549284935, 0.007314617745578289, -0.009486041963100433, -0.03773067519068718, -0.03313134238123894, -0.038264717906713486, -0.004775080364197493, 0.0325104296207428, -0.014617057517170906, -0.049693573266267776, 0.01653965562582016, -0.05940660461783409, -0.020459212362766266, -0.02456110343337059, -0.0209531057626009, -0.024067355319857597, -0.011238999664783478, 0.10026805102825165, -0.04280863329768181, -0.0030249771662056446, 0.019182609394192696, -0.012868198566138744, -0.03105715475976467, -0.006092884577810764, 0.05673649534583092, -0.018534408882260323, 0.005297604016959667, 0.023868462070822716, 0.02090429700911045, -0.002227942692115903, 0.022577635943889618, -0.025003215298056602, -0.08094056695699692, -0.019421279430389404, -0.0463903583586216, -0.0004129437729716301, -0.006975381635129452, -0.006493101362138987, -0.015354972332715988, 0.0051543014124035835, -0.03575703129172325, -0.002358636585995555, -0.06505318731069565, 0.03914419189095497, 0.047455791383981705, 0.00941967312246561, -0.024337248876690865, 0.04488884657621384, -0.014348463155329227, 0.01521222572773695, 0.0039475844241678715, 0.016712117940187454, -0.03136869892477989, 0.0002265855873702094, 0.05196679010987282, 0.0210136566311121, -0.02358889952301979, 0.029832499101758003, 0.01091924961656332, 0.03299349173903465, 0.01884640008211136, 0.0002249663812108338, -0.017518533393740654, -0.0265747532248497, 0.024472786113619804, 0.0018128391820937395, -0.015792056918144226, 0.004755587317049503, 0.00526978587731719, 0.010721605271100998, 0.033166807144880295, -0.01675374060869217, -0.007317784707993269, 0.02235572785139084, 0.012681902386248112, -0.03552624210715294, -0.026403481140732765, -0.029177404940128326, 0.04157169535756111, 0.005094354506582022, 0.0329042412340641, 0.030410200357437134, 0.01932406984269619, -0.023099208250641823, -0.02603040635585785, -0.007350879721343517, 0.033073846250772476, 0.03405262529850006, -0.0547306202352047, 0.0288914293050766, 0.02445310540497303, -0.02842565067112446, 0.029386738315224648, -0.03437596559524536, -0.038709916174411774, -0.021030744537711143, 0.013995199464261532, 0.031129755079746246, 0.01129902619868517, -0.0074135554023087025, -0.006976447533816099, -0.024804063141345978, 0.031236710026860237, 0.010191516019403934, 0.03426435589790344, 0.029604630544781685, -0.06548909097909927, 0.014040585607290268, -0.04166219010949135, 0.027231503278017044, 0.011014843359589577, 0.0006926016067154706, -0.021745972335338593, -0.0004805742355529219, 0.018250178545713425, -0.044745638966560364, -0.013061245903372765, -0.007951983250677586, 0.028535570949316025, -0.023677514865994453, -0.000326392735587433, -0.025174258276820183, 0.02052764967083931, -0.03570162132382393, 0.05702028423547745, -0.02723749354481697, -0.027883611619472504, -0.021939067170023918, -0.009106728248298168, -0.015962893143296242, -0.008210113272070885, 0.007967736572027206, 0.03552580624818802, -0.041380640119314194, 0.034192293882369995, -0.08960100263357162, -0.06454981863498688, 0.016654666513204575, 0.01637129671871662, 0.02237851172685623, 0.007156273815780878, -0.026100480929017067, 0.05889870226383209, 0.0058512017130851746, -0.026381487026810646, -0.05190851539373398, 0.05272439867258072, -0.011644229292869568, -0.04380534589290619, 0.004783859942108393, 0.05458952859044075, 0.021063797175884247, 0.009118672460317612, 0.000944162136875093, 0.01144038513302803, 0.030261129140853882, 0.01614784635603428, -0.006276008207350969, 0.04498733580112457, 0.00252629816532135, -0.011279843747615814, -0.012671146541833878, 0.022659657523036003, -0.0009621799690648913, 0.024831673130393028, -0.011409279890358448, 0.023335961624979973, 0.0194433331489563, -0.027142655104398727, 0.02257588505744934, -0.027792640030384064, -0.030601562932133675, -0.028954802080988884, 0.008068589493632317, -0.012323594652116299, -0.04726855829358101, -0.0025231698527932167, 0.012158983387053013, 0.023227877914905548, -0.007321437355130911, 0.0014162359293550253, 0.061046212911605835, 0.020283695310354233, -0.008945570327341557, 0.011642403900623322, 0.006013086531311274, -0.000375432864530012, -0.0043023633770644665, -0.010941185988485813, -0.006860736757516861, 0.023421846330165863, 0.03471433371305466, 0.014513582922518253, -0.02565024420619011, -0.02515551634132862, 0.02162693254649639, -0.04707513377070427, 0.04269722104072571, -0.04317716136574745, 0.018943456932902336, 0.00381859322078526, 0.019190868362784386, 0.018995122984051704, 0.006466709543019533, -0.014837173745036125, 0.034843310713768005, -0.0671883225440979, -0.007620090153068304, -0.003632128704339266, 0.01611877791583538, -0.009502720087766647, 0.004209526814520359, 0.04170652851462364, 0.009650721214711666, 0.04405798390507698, 0.009270702488720417, 0.01290816254913807, -0.035366564989089966, 0.03952837362885475, -0.03467667102813721, -0.012628111988306046, -0.023015044629573822, 0.040204014629125595, 0.059118229895830154, 0.012018916197121143, 0.03373390808701515, 0.012131718918681145, 0.009765070863068104, -0.012246680445969105, -0.02030211314558983, 0.028864022344350815, -0.007643666584044695, 0.016160501167178154, 0.03218035772442818, 0.038804203271865845, -0.022678181529045105, 0.024773409590125084, -0.0017738972092047334, 0.07746584713459015, 0.04674585908651352, -0.004960469901561737, 0.016358621418476105, -0.049761928617954254, -0.024279756471514702, 0.014972299337387085, 0.051003169268369675, -0.012984903529286385, -0.0073694949969649315, 0.0449170246720314, 0.005047761835157871, -0.04260982200503349, 0.01467018574476242, 0.03986350819468498, 0.015559356659650803, -0.028746075928211212, -0.030448246747255325, -0.010145820677280426, 0.0153952082619071, 0.031178651377558708, -0.01625223271548748, 0.02983708865940571, 0.00020835745090153068, 0.017837712541222572, 0.031184064224362373, -0.016940629109740257, 0.006893697194755077, -0.0029764508362859488, 0.03273281455039978, 0.05420462042093277, 0.020195407792925835, -0.028947990387678146, 0.03946154564619064, 0.0013894869480282068, 0.053771160542964935, 0.03443395346403122, -0.007077836897224188, -0.07994762063026428, 0.01106850616633892, 0.028386272490024567, 0.03931953012943268, -0.02545655332505703, -0.008834621869027615, -0.06441237032413483, -0.009063435718417168, 0.04552660509943962, 0.017176225781440735, -0.007681653834879398, 0.007211188320070505, -0.00856572575867176, -0.0018617521272972226, -0.007353932596743107, -0.06872747838497162, 0.03146783635020256, -0.004702165722846985, 0.030673598870635033, -0.04372241720557213, -0.01822892762720585, -0.05725179240107536, 0.045145392417907715, 0.01931663788855076, 0.04847904294729233, 0.032396744936704636, -0.03767034411430359, 0.005353630054742098, 0.00667231110855937, 0.011581547558307648, -0.08609810471534729, 0.030669473111629486, 0.0022548495326191187, -0.028797881677746773, 0.05105337128043175, -0.01566370390355587, -0.06408806145191193, 0.03142595663666725, 0.004978276789188385, -0.0128676388412714, 0.0621175542473793, -0.009440641850233078, 0.061130329966545105, 0.034075286239385605, 0.018993552774190903, 0.04024588689208031, 0.001031319028697908, -0.01035365927964449, 0.01758040487766266, -0.04800400510430336, -0.00393929285928607, -0.02394082024693489, 0.0015007517067715526, -0.06644025444984436, 0.0015822930727154016, 0.0016869211103767157, 0.022660579532384872, 0.01725420169532299, 0.03259509801864624, -0.012518408708274364, -0.04697776585817337, -0.012866268865764141, 0.04558466747403145, 0.026731565594673157, 0.00481379684060812, 0.007476331200450659, 0.019020115956664085, -0.00708162784576416, 0.042347151786088943, 0.011851062066853046, -0.017991168424487114, 0.015674496069550514, -0.007652210537344217, -0.02272489294409752, 0.0024336492642760277, -0.034797243773937225, 0.012504099868237972, 0.046838633716106415, -0.00009345191938336939, 0.04507342353463173, 0.006895778700709343, 0.0480174720287323, 0.008946779184043407, -0.03972839564085007, -0.007121237926185131, 0.014872683212161064, -0.022394703701138496, 0.06963156908750534, -0.03558409586548805, -0.03374215215444565, -0.03993230313062668, 0.01652362570166588, -0.04917367547750473, -0.005938566755503416, 0.028556929901242256, -0.03873716667294502, -0.025374287739396095, -0.0379195399582386, 0.05422591418027878, -0.03776796534657478, -0.0509478934109211, -0.007903724908828735, 0.060119397938251495, -0.03425168618559837, -0.03006090596318245, -0.021037878468632698, 0.07162922620773315, 0.06487378478050232, -0.02728184126317501, 0.029359683394432068, 0.04767269641160965, -0.013943079859018326, 0.017727529630064964, 0.012445822358131409, 0.0040671429596841335, -0.047433335334062576, 0.038586169481277466, -0.0011050535831600428, 0.001846655854023993, 0.05774106830358505, -0.011926703155040741, -0.03157293051481247, 0.03260703757405281, -0.022007903084158897, 0.0013966941041871905, -0.01626082882285118, -0.004024039022624493, -0.03644163906574249, -0.009560490027070045, -0.052275437861680984, -0.010207630693912506, -0.027296384796500206, -0.034238673746585846, 0.05388389155268669, -0.021339960396289825, -0.00666862353682518, 0.006143901031464338, 0.020915841683745384, 0.014365322887897491, 0.0033853542990982533, 0.014152794145047665, 0.016265857964754105, 0.05833512544631958, -0.010178386233747005, -0.005826503038406372, 0.03899502754211426, 0.012525489553809166, -0.01958918757736683, -0.053517650812864304, -0.02700721099972725, 0.0069314115680754185, 0.05543524771928787, 0.008976069279015064, 0.019341181963682175, 0.016346510499715805, 0.008200809359550476, -0.012081251479685307, -0.03206637501716614, -0.009900063276290894, 0.0034651514142751694, -0.0013346511404961348, 0.05602805316448212, -0.02563452534377575, -0.006997623480856419, 0.017680006101727486, -0.01643223874270916, 0.030132461339235306, 0.018166558817029, 0.016910945996642113, 0.009092621505260468, 0.05002867802977562, -0.06808571517467499, -0.035608064383268356, 0.03031080961227417, -0.0701322853565216, -0.0012878351844847202, -0.022190174087882042, -0.0506693571805954, 0.024014467373490334, 0.05305568501353264, 0.011873876675963402, -0.01995999552309513, -0.03545758128166199, -0.01595292240381241, 0.004294558893889189, 0.056432273238897324, -0.008439005352556705, 0.01309382077306509, -0.01919519156217575, 0.023738523945212364, 0.016305796802043915, 0.015192174352705479, 0.0007019903277978301, -0.09746413677930832, -0.061158351600170135, 0.006103115156292915, -0.01711713895201683, -0.002665171166881919, 0.01011808030307293, -0.02270812727510929, 0.047501035034656525, -0.02325880527496338, 0.03769458830356598, -0.019385643303394318, 0.00881645642220974, -0.006512031424790621, 0.05404715612530708, -0.012859083712100983, 0.013131250627338886, -0.01762373186647892, -0.00903843343257904, 0.11046718060970306, 0.09118082374334335, 0.04132804274559021, -0.039847616106271744, 0.01250980980694294, 0.02773597650229931, 0.00010770835069706663, -0.026889553293585777, 0.03253663703799248, 0.02731790952384472, -0.06403034925460815, 0.006519252900034189, 0.04061304032802582, 0.007721942383795977, 0.020949285477399826, 0.05288039520382881, -0.06518702208995819, -0.015554253943264484, 0.010481182485818863, 0.0003823281731456518, -0.0007577282958664, -0.03761298209428787, -0.06164909154176712, 0.02353142574429512, 0.009361096657812595, -0.005545120220631361, -0.0016259265830740333, -0.016518782824277878, 0.004249843303114176, 0.03558400645852089, 0.0055083828046917915, -0.005855809431523085, -0.0073516895063221455, 0.036355260759592056, 0.01708202436566353, 0.0015208905097097158, 0.02792457491159439, -0.03700672835111618, 0.016614092513918877, 0.01693161018192768, -0.012684017419815063, -0.021548166871070862, 0.01636481285095215, -0.01581828109920025, -0.014819697476923466, -0.04594321548938751, -0.0036705771926790476, 0.04955093562602997, 0.0018653509905561805, 0.002096576150506735, -0.011717147193849087, -0.004394632298499346, 0.010501159355044365, -0.022763002663850784, -0.006280014757066965, 0.01773970015347004, 0.052400559186935425, 0.0019410991808399558, 0.011673574335873127, -0.0016040983609855175, 0.0023478406947106123, 0.009393606334924698, 0.038143351674079895, -0.019013606011867523, -0.026898879557847977, -0.03677000477910042, -0.024846576154232025, 0.049777280539274216, 0.04821803420782089, -0.021616563200950623, 0.027125870808959007, -0.012070788070559502, -0.033946048468351364, -0.05035530775785446, 0.003596965689212084, -0.02267550118267536, 0.05612557753920555, -0.0108342245221138, 0.002377972938120365, 0.01374468021094799, -0.02315985970199108, -0.024616343900561333, -0.029855772852897644, -0.027707301080226898, -0.03749559074640274, 0.0025987718254327774, 0.0248939860612154, 0.020196154713630676, 0.024451488628983498, -0.0012084642658010125, -0.03794162720441818, 0.04748552292585373, 0.00013385189231485128, -0.039568014442920685, -0.026863943785429, -0.0009219257044605911, -0.03133836388587952, 0.004872182849794626, -0.00032403162913396955, 0.03276798874139786, 0.012489563785493374, 0.007429091259837151, 0.027472728863358498, 0.03174324333667755, -0.04102263227105141, 0.004160366486757994, 0.0036915286909788847, -0.07682549953460693, -0.002155348425731063, 0.00010003193892771378, 0.0066301943734288216, -0.03635060414671898, -0.026951443403959274, -0.01528581976890564, -0.007764696143567562, 0.008864994160830975, -0.02119392715394497, -0.049180660396814346, 0.023717094212770462, 0.00020338111789897084, 0.005659911781549454, 0.012367019429802895, 0.009571249596774578, 0.052122361958026886, 0.012282551266252995, -0.0425698347389698, -0.009361928328871727, 0.011976385489106178, 0.021528126671910286, -0.05674929916858673, -0.007785310503095388, 0.021409573033452034, 0.015672147274017334, 0.045514464378356934, -0.02616177313029766, -0.02653874084353447, -0.022512879222631454, 0.03501595929265022, -0.015832457691431046, -0.044657930731773376, 0.022830303758382797, -0.05493873357772827, -0.04173637926578522, -0.02108536660671234, 0.018391888588666916, 0.007773535791784525, 0.02269485965371132, 0.019038496538996696, -0.012188248336315155, 0.053779393434524536, -0.0381365530192852, -0.010373692028224468, 0.03250795602798462, 0.0314229391515255, -0.027398157864809036, -0.02699263021349907, 0.01760527864098549, -0.0007642284035682678, -0.0021680346690118313, 0.04129575937986374, 0.01555540319532156, 0.014122432097792625, 0.00838868785649538, 0.04846018925309181, -0.032855045050382614, 0.028470350429415703, -0.024023257195949554, -0.018697375431656837, 0.02185915596783161, 0.01891489140689373, -0.052474915981292725, 0.028274664655327797, -0.03001595102250576, -0.019298313185572624, -0.1085624247789383, -0.019585542380809784, -0.004223406780511141, 0.04921742156147957, 0.03977285698056221, -0.040688104927539825, 0.0002655317366588861, 0.02025206759572029, -0.03704749420285225, 0.029187887907028198, 0.00978785939514637, 0.02907453291118145, -0.03740360215306282, 0.008404324762523174, -0.017152031883597374, 0.006290201097726822, -0.004317487124353647, 0.035868413746356964, 0.011222457513213158, -0.02144181914627552, 0.015245791524648666, -0.022283310070633888, 0.03577543795108795, 0.014918312430381775, 0.029535651206970215, -0.06918422132730484, 0.04374800994992256, -0.0103015610948205, -0.04441911727190018, -0.0012917177518829703, 0.027709772810339928, 0.025111012160778046, -0.002856384962797165, 0.05160824954509735, -0.017902705818414688, 0.04858997464179993, 0.03312462940812111, 0.0050675878301262856, 0.035254985094070435, -0.006111816503107548, 0.007527112495154142, 0.024531135335564613, -0.024566084146499634, 0.004536165855824947, 0.020702606067061424, -0.011350399814546108, -0.009484385140240192, -0.005529410671442747, -0.020588809624314308, -0.018263554200530052, 0.008947309106588364, -0.01969611644744873, 0.0020933623891323805, -0.00128193071577698, 0.025773387402296066, -0.05948410555720329, 0.0038804407231509686, 0.03996896371245384, 0.021821387112140656, 0.013589737005531788, 0.013684490695595741, -0.030952628701925278, -0.04110157489776611, -0.010613122954964638, 0.011244511231780052, -0.013197951950132847, 0.003499526297673583, -0.0033428946044296026, 0.0006329656462185085, 0.01682114787399769, -0.05774536356329918, -0.012870663776993752, -0.01883031241595745, 0.06164560839533806, -0.0444304496049881, 0.00984574481844902, 0.006974419578909874, 0.018781473860144615, 0.0283072367310524, -0.05477742850780487, 0.05677555501461029, -0.0021672656293958426, -0.009359069168567657, 0.02211485058069229, -0.023934446275234222, -0.008478380739688873, 0.0077897123992443085, 0.06846331059932709, -0.020558154210448265, -0.0030864400323480368, 0.02138381265103817, 0.005057525355368853, 0.007773813791573048, -0.05363192781805992, 0.02876904234290123, -0.018669815734028816, -0.03361816704273224, -0.01982651837170124, -0.011959210969507694, 0.025039661675691605, -0.017375951632857323, 0.025699032470583916, -0.014758563600480556, -0.009825932793319225, 0.02488570846617222, 0.0003004176542162895, 0.010254994034767151, -0.015801675617694855, 0.024120835587382317, 0.026547767221927643, 0.01830015704035759, 0.003809270216152072, 0.02028333768248558, -0.006025138311088085, -0.0739629790186882, 0.019175393506884575, -0.02295650541782379, -0.07247377187013626, 0.00344466301612556, 0.013504860922694206, 0.006386117078363895, -0.05983675643801689, 0.02526821196079254, 0.06267552077770233, -0.04519820585846901, 0.0028139769565314054, 0.04883449897170067, 0.03382420167326927, 0.045539505779743195, 0.043557748198509216, 0.0024084371980279684, 0.03972933813929558, 0.01432753261178732, 0.044030435383319855, 0.025736141949892044, 0.0588565357029438, 0.014915012754499912, 0.025544390082359314, 0.009264398366212845, -0.036154855042696, 0.02787591703236103, -0.058223262429237366, 0.043170418590307236, -0.022151775658130646, -0.03234672173857689, 0.05224555730819702, -0.024082699790596962, -0.0046762521378695965, 0.005553757771849632, 0.0017491694306954741, 0.06859621405601501, -0.019667237997055054, -0.012308022007346153, -0.06643720716238022, -0.006341452244669199, 0.004015363287180662, -0.027604755014181137, -0.009057248011231422, 0.037047453224658966, 0.031477153301239014, -0.001522415317595005, -0.035607170313596725, -0.038961976766586304, 0.010404767468571663, -0.07807176560163498, 0.013288660906255245, -0.008562678471207619, 0.016915233805775642, 0.011705735698342323, -0.039354778826236725, -0.03168284893035889, -0.04381178691983223, 0.009673647582530975, 0.012721612118184566, 0.021224338561296463, 0.0022122077643871307, -0.04413480684161186, -0.015775244683027267, -0.0036703895311802626, -0.06757163256406784, 0.012577234767377377, -0.017595192417502403, 0.0022721027489751577, -0.00116439419798553, 0.026914576068520546 ]
<p>Given a set of extracted data from different sources with different accuracies, how can I combine the accuracy of those who give the same output?</p> <p>Example :</p> <pre><code>Data from source A are 80% correct Data from source B are 85% correct Data from source C are 90% correct </code></pre> <p>If two of the sources give the same result (ResultA) and the third disagrees (ResultB) what's the probability of (A) being correct? This is not a homework question. I am a software developer and I don't have a clue about statistics and probability.</p> <p><strong>Update :</strong></p> <p>I've done an experiment using a random number generator</p> <p>Test 1 - 2 Possible outcomes (0/1) three methods (Acc: 0.5, 0.3, 0.1)</p> <pre><code>Samples : 100000000 Method A : 0,49993692 Method B : 0,30023622 Method C : 0,09994145 Method A+B : 0,794567779569577 Method B+C : 0,0455372643070089 Method C+A : 0,205615801945512 Method A+B+C : 0,0455215295368209 </code></pre> <p>Test 2 - 2 Possible outcomes (0/1) three methods (Acc: 0.8, 0.85, 0.9)</p> <pre><code>Samples : 100000000 Method A : 0,80003639 Method B : 0,8500426 Method C : 0,90005791 Method A+B : 0,715942797491352 Method B+C : 0,927408281972288 Method C+A : 0,864147967527417 Method A+B+C : 0,995137034088319 </code></pre> <p>That's the numbers I am looking for but I don't know how to calculate them...</p>
74,158
[ -0.01620628498494625, -0.004605358466506004, -0.006477111019194126, -0.04226640984416008, 0.03256050497293472, 0.00447235768660903, 0.010110179893672466, -0.03797782212495804, 0.003526597749441862, 0.0082821911200881, 0.06851804256439209, 0.03963879868388176, 0.025738203898072243, 0.04116252064704895, 0.026558229699730873, 0.023069823160767555, 0.004738385323435068, 0.025777019560337067, 0.01391028892248869, -0.001871214248239994, -0.003008633852005005, -0.014480231329798698, 0.021575476974248886, -0.023937951773405075, -0.022743359208106995, 0.016002610325813293, 0.047326136380434036, -0.01891738548874855, -0.02559344656765461, 0.06978250294923782, -0.040549203753471375, -0.031038280576467514, 0.011360091157257557, 0.048034053295850754, 0.033737681806087494, 0.023310592398047447, 0.00946875475347042, 0.02350667305290699, -0.025639470666646957, 0.05268651992082596, -0.020010218024253845, -0.0005717595922760665, -0.023523502051830292, 0.02430598996579647, 0.004750325810164213, 0.01602965034544468, -0.025514837354421616, -0.003222274361178279, 0.030550625175237656, -0.022106647491455078, 0.06559516489505768, 0.01629071682691574, 0.04055800288915634, 0.03864861652255058, -0.04609454795718193, -0.02400900609791279, 0.04398582503199577, 0.058266643434762955, 0.010082821361720562, -0.07172207534313202, 0.004234687425196171, 0.00483518373221159, 0.006286184303462505, -0.017033332958817482, -0.03932196646928787, 0.048367053270339966, -0.007014796603471041, 0.0033236672170460224, 0.013717412948608398, -0.012423194944858551, 0.02444644086062908, 0.03291446343064308, 0.029833806678652763, -0.01344788633286953, 0.01084374450147152, -0.007786971982568502, 0.007986368611454964, 0.013085536658763885, 0.048442065715789795, 0.02782406657934189, -0.02025618962943554, 0.012815156020224094, 0.026220588013529778, 0.029131358489394188, 0.037870634347200394, -0.03288593143224716, 0.05164322629570961, -0.03435619920492172, 0.0003100875474046916, 0.02001599781215191, 0.00653653871268034, -0.0033026100136339664, 0.032866813242435455, 0.0013373644324019551, 0.00037467837682925165, 0.031941913068294525, 0.0051180399022996426, 0.006698003504425287, -0.020691560581326485, 0.006649247370660305, -0.022443579509854317, -0.014726786874234676, 0.006514301523566246, 0.049033425748348236, -0.025014754384756088, -0.013080514036118984, -0.011361667886376381, 0.0052778166718780994, -0.024249562993645668, -0.010992065072059631, 0.04065963625907898, 0.0005971801583655179, 0.016103873029351234, 0.01265333779156208, 0.0070214103907346725, -0.01931745372712612, 0.009443751536309719, -0.036897215992212296, 0.07928638905286789, 0.0009746366995386779, 0.03390602394938469, -0.017529740929603577, 0.005970484111458063, -0.024765867739915848, -0.035763368010520935, -0.04394504427909851, -0.01929122768342495, -0.001152652082964778, -0.018479501828551292, 0.05912302806973457, -0.013012479990720749, -0.04998627305030823, 0.012041490525007248, 0.011724297888576984, -0.013628048822283745, 0.0029032810125499964, -0.07458235323429108, -0.05563628301024437, 0.03507668524980545, -0.02478882297873497, -0.005895687732845545, -0.05429163575172424, 0.046445172280073166, 0.03735451027750969, 0.040140826255083084, 0.004645845387130976, 0.055736277252435684, 0.009418264031410217, 0.01718093641102314, 0.037369344383478165, -0.0049823434092104435, -0.0026681276503950357, -0.040963802486658096, -0.009835407137870789, -0.046948377043008804, -0.051069699227809906, 0.00549426069483161, -0.005435248836874962, -0.03146727383136749, -0.006215046625584364, -0.027128295972943306, 0.0016515846364200115, 0.005033770110458136, -0.007631653919816017, 0.006232708692550659, 0.015811536461114883, 0.05909575894474983, 0.034554220736026764, -0.004827246069908142, 0.03831567242741585, -0.04786478355526924, 0.007648090366274118, 0.016009267419576645, -0.0400230772793293, 0.05604364722967148, -0.051315128803253174, 0.012339630164206028, -0.030378585681319237, 0.02530170977115631, 0.025318095460534096, -0.02553270384669304, -0.00285036931745708, -0.02766846865415573, -0.015440491959452629, 0.021700434386730194, 0.04607577994465828, 0.04070498049259186, -0.013238746672868729, 0.017733918502926826, -0.03874710574746132, -0.018716877326369286, -0.06533923000097275, -0.023749718442559242, 0.006870428565889597, -0.032468006014823914, 0.015578096732497215, 0.0031558366026729345, 0.014791653491556644, -0.0076053873635828495, -0.0003224331303499639, -0.059174712747335434, 0.003236641176044941, 0.021540135145187378, -0.004778505768626928, -0.00020121783018112183, 0.04220990464091301, 0.048491284251213074, -0.013297134079039097, 0.06439604610204697, 0.010015202686190605, -0.02100175805389881, -0.0015430242056027055, -0.04574607312679291, -0.02894570305943489, 0.0246522706001997, -0.026493996381759644, 0.022661589086055756, 0.011012202128767967, 0.0009374560322612524, 0.006551680620759726, -0.06578753143548965, 0.045219920575618744, 0.06959183514118195, 0.0067677004262804985, -0.010947885923087597, -0.007367263548076153, -0.008699790574610233, 0.02926979586482048, 0.005746733862906694, -0.008484297432005405, -0.058871060609817505, 0.008079140447080135, 0.016561569646000862, 0.04167657345533371, -0.05075405538082123, 0.01770370826125145, 0.056690678000450134, 0.005277120973914862, -0.018988797441124916, 0.054014332592487335, -0.019290568307042122, 0.0086024459451437, 0.02210347168147564, -0.0007231610943563282, 0.008251907303929329, 0.014316583052277565, 0.006209444720298052, 0.014297493733465672, 0.00023647428315598518, 0.0072679538279771805, -0.01780196651816368, -0.007793688680976629, 0.0027952766977250576, -0.013837159611284733, -0.028578266501426697, -0.006445473525673151, 0.01588032767176628, 0.018179699778556824, 0.016227208077907562, 0.0061277649365365505, 0.00020937099179718643, -0.023487748578190804, 0.003582179779186845, -0.040121037513017654, 0.009834934026002884, 0.031205635517835617, -0.04701108857989311, -0.007183634210377932, 0.014846018515527248, -0.01630316860973835, 0.0028460188768804073, -0.04543697088956833, 0.006995343137532473, -0.05980352684855461, 0.020934700965881348, 0.010571541264653206, 0.010425268672406673, 0.0441238209605217, -0.047331053763628006, -0.020303992554545403, -0.06175835803151131, -0.010150611400604248, -0.0021291724406182766, 0.001986296148970723, -0.056627966463565826, 0.01896687224507332, -0.009290430694818497, -0.015349416993558407, 0.03875131905078888, -0.013804665766656399, -0.04920144006609917, 0.0635385662317276, 0.026405202224850655, -0.033371392637491226, -0.0010551282903179526, -0.014911819249391556, 0.023814374580979347, -0.049180950969457626, 0.005297612398862839, 0.03999907523393631, 0.00036069683847017586, -0.048812463879585266, 0.029049141332507133, -0.027325812727212906, -0.013823850080370903, -0.010478486306965351, -0.014969214797019958, -0.004039110615849495, -0.028778357431292534, 0.00924916472285986, 0.013033097609877586, -0.002330163726583123, -0.028987154364585876, -0.06453553587198257, -0.08140703290700912, 0.00014168843335937709, 0.009112858213484287, 0.029816342517733574, 0.007164116483181715, -0.008850449696183205, 0.09146355837583542, 0.028226889669895172, -0.04178869351744652, -0.01950135827064514, 0.011953230015933514, 0.011447442695498466, 0.005138829816132784, 0.004658900201320648, 0.023005465045571327, -0.006058512255549431, 0.02826964296400547, 0.0026069513987749815, 0.01475191954523325, 0.06119079887866974, 0.005490838550031185, 0.02811889722943306, 0.020684564486145973, 0.021498138085007668, -0.011565210297703743, 0.029582791030406952, 0.013696514070034027, -0.03180892765522003, 0.00008472752961097285, 0.003574150148779154, 0.017706777900457382, -0.016609806567430496, -0.009110887534916401, -0.00706943916156888, 0.01654893532395363, 0.010884210467338562, -0.08623288571834564, 0.04262246936559677, 0.01424761675298214, -0.021327903494238853, 0.01384319830685854, -0.006410124246031046, 0.03396407142281532, -0.03109077364206314, -0.007619925774633884, 0.0665547326207161, 0.07712078839540482, -0.04068395122885704, -0.016593070700764656, -0.010818535462021828, 0.015351303853094578, 0.02509748749434948, -0.040494054555892944, -0.017648514360189438, 0.04254095256328583, 0.052810557186603546, 0.015209760516881943, 0.024374159052968025, -0.027917681261897087, 0.0002627586654853076, -0.07215072959661484, 0.006004985887557268, -0.05135900154709816, 0.04951741173863411, 0.0026105940341949463, 0.09479972720146179, 0.020376142114400864, -0.03256570175290108, -0.0041528018191456795, -0.004347868263721466, -0.04697070270776749, 0.03983441740274429, 0.03345271572470665, -0.05897081643342972, -0.02518775500357151, -0.06303665786981583, 0.010635605081915855, -0.03334372863173485, 0.01398531999439001, -0.008863530121743679, 0.02022336609661579, -0.006297318264842033, 0.02004118636250496, -0.016119644045829773, -0.0021237218752503395, -0.008197563700377941, 0.030489910393953323, 0.016350407153367996, 0.014439175836741924, 0.07974263280630112, 0.000261749024502933, -0.020926445722579956, -0.016828682273626328, -0.013497520238161087, -0.0045228684321045876, 0.011808502487838268, 0.038182828575372696, 0.0190573800355196, 0.05939214676618576, -0.004796994384378195, 0.008368097245693207, 0.013079659081995487, 0.05566318333148956, 0.06341098994016647, -0.0522942841053009, -0.04969124123454094, -0.00485978601500392, 0.0077963643707334995, -0.00883412640541792, 0.010871400125324726, 0.00455458415672183, 0.02154380828142166, 0.01826111227273941, 0.02660231478512287, -0.05661943182349205, 0.024836862459778786, 0.07625216990709305, -0.023648539558053017, 0.025633210316300392, -0.026084136217832565, -0.01989426277577877, -0.0003295554197393358, -0.019479960203170776, -0.0032733669504523277, 0.018942302092909813, -0.00894660409539938, -0.025550594553351402, 0.034459132701158524, 0.022392896935343742, -0.07179491966962814, 0.038467369973659515, 0.02453180029988289, 0.0020937577355653048, 0.02040693536400795, -0.016524607315659523, -0.007520320359617472, 0.03858545050024986, 0.0173480324447155, 0.00784948468208313, -0.013800014741718769, -0.054587893187999725, 0.008944601751863956, 0.05545811355113983, 0.033814702183008194, -0.05382421612739563, -0.0017896544886752963, -0.027557190507650375, -0.007838652469217777, 0.012868460267782211, -0.04005191847681999, 0.024955863133072853, 0.008669843897223473, 0.04570325091481209, -0.03486832603812218, -0.05767669901251793, -0.05968749523162842, 0.03707369789481163, -0.0433168038725853, 0.010659481398761272, -0.03304976224899292, -0.03170963376760483, -0.012056617997586727, 0.012429555878043175, 0.05431988462805748, 0.053545672446489334, -0.07965626567602158, -0.03009353019297123, -0.016422701999545097, 0.048233404755592346, 0.012490462511777878, -0.06972617655992508, 0.04784351587295532, -0.019621970131993294, -0.0356534905731678, 0.05127223953604698, -0.016360893845558167, -0.02695108950138092, 0.038846056908369064, -0.00926534365862608, 0.025479335337877274, 0.01991475187242031, 0.0011024413397535682, 0.03570343926548958, 0.06483516097068787, 0.02419799007475376, 0.04296208173036575, -0.010559405200183392, -0.038201943039894104, -0.008129590190947056, -0.048649709671735764, -0.027522170916199684, 0.0027802293188869953, -0.017501704394817352, -0.037466518580913544, 0.0006723830592818558, -0.016913481056690216, -0.0013305775355547667, 0.03324916213750839, 0.00781977642327547, -0.03921985253691673, 0.02087538316845894, 0.0033569217193871737, 0.021360894665122032, -0.01836605928838253, 0.005144484806805849, -0.011396517045795918, -0.00004242458817316219, -0.030533766373991966, 0.0022984843235462904, 0.024186652153730392, -0.01638072542846203, -0.013415294699370861, 0.009721831418573856, -0.060053810477256775, 0.018391186371445656, -0.06048334017395973, 0.0006845886236988008, 0.008317999541759491, -0.027725357562303543, 0.03057124651968479, 0.035587336868047714, 0.08777550607919693, -0.01096823625266552, 0.003962276969105005, -0.061676274985075, 0.047920722514390945, 0.007922216318547726, 0.03898944705724716, -0.02533484809100628, 0.03992096707224846, -0.03552026301622391, 0.003988332115113735, -0.060245659202337265, -0.009815370664000511, 0.033749520778656006, 0.023834241554141045, -0.010404873639345169, -0.03185201808810234, -0.021196501329541206, -0.007789670489728451, 0.012924231588840485, -0.010996902361512184, 0.02755085751414299, -0.020121358335018158, -0.04099033400416374, -0.00808409322053194, -0.021647348999977112, 0.07176598161458969, -0.0211819838732481, 0.016203327104449272, 0.023582637310028076, -0.03181066736578941, -0.01777750998735428, 0.034034594893455505, -0.025014158338308334, -0.04610782861709595, -0.016093404963612556, 0.004376422148197889, 0.027904173359274864, 0.044169168919324875, -0.0200230423361063, -0.029956720769405365, -0.02168632298707962, 0.015995638445019722, -0.030738241970539093, -0.02223188243806362, -0.0009734892519190907, 0.004739033058285713, 0.007050235290080309, -0.025016844272613525, -0.0028725960291922092, -0.0288863368332386, 0.007008142303675413, -0.003433709731325507, 0.0077263484708964825, -0.07923398911952972, -0.00264458148740232, 0.06318914145231247, -0.011773733422160149, -0.011290214024484158, -0.020546160638332367, -0.006328836549073458, 0.0494026280939579, -0.01711522787809372, 0.018903054296970367, 0.005321578588336706, 0.01301190722733736, -0.02278164215385914, 0.01117037609219551, -0.03703758493065834, -0.011625852435827255, 0.0515933632850647, 0.015253041870892048, 0.06441765278577805, 0.04837772622704506, 0.02997530996799469, -0.01814054325222969, 0.006173895671963692, 0.012677948921918869, 0.021950015798211098, 0.014113231562077999, 0.03346870467066765, -0.034592170268297195, -0.02766949124634266, 0.03353450074791908, 0.0008571979124099016, 0.028297847136855125, -0.007133646868169308, -0.037208832800388336, 0.006261864211410284, 0.004733963403850794, -0.029871050268411636, -0.011210953816771507, 0.013644672930240631, -0.07003980129957199, 0.0077395252883434296, -0.0054443334229290485, -0.03785616531968117, 0.04710422456264496, 0.011336952447891235, -0.05102234706282616, -0.04573989287018776, -0.016298232600092888, -0.06920439004898071, -0.025335460901260376, -0.020322006195783615, -0.010182838886976242, 0.03725721314549446, -0.030073825269937515, 0.009679784066975117, -0.003826361382380128, 0.05729108303785324, -0.046181805431842804, -0.08600536733865738, -0.045468129217624664, -0.009215924888849258, -0.01164246629923582, 0.051093220710754395, 0.04229704290628433, -0.030042700469493866, 0.023166947066783905, -0.012456987984478474, 0.08209200948476791, 0.05608959123492241, 0.013114777393639088, -0.023651860654354095, 0.053488727658987045, 0.008909442462027073, 0.07031658291816711, -0.026751087978482246, -0.0334790013730526, 0.12852789461612701, 0.06167551502585411, 0.060641661286354065, -0.053385406732559204, 0.024798257276415825, 0.03886761888861656, 0.018735073506832123, -0.005652297753840685, 0.002112233079969883, 0.052024636417627335, 0.028594713658094406, 0.07394835352897644, 0.02454506792128086, 0.0008292077109217644, 0.019919851794838905, 0.037501078099012375, -0.036314014345407486, -0.022217625752091408, -0.0031502137426286936, 0.048628661781549454, 0.01747865602374077, -0.029853954911231995, -0.040355343371629715, -0.03391885757446289, -0.010433387011289597, -0.009396163746714592, -0.04422009736299515, -0.011089266277849674, 0.01610969565808773, 0.014843340031802654, 0.00003410893987165764, 0.02288929559290409, 0.008994394913315773, 0.009960652329027653, -0.004979339893907309, -0.015339457429945469, 0.01736789382994175, -0.05059005692601204, 0.00542807811871171, 0.013582953251898289, 0.02448633871972561, -0.014804806560277939, -0.020507143810391426, 0.054450951516628265, -0.029090819880366325, -0.023245489224791527, -0.08066228777170181, 0.01571742445230484, 0.0047392463311553, -0.018995366990566254, -0.0393860787153244, -0.013179579749703407, 0.023368418216705322, -0.013792646117508411, -0.0051397825591266155, 0.030208846554160118, 0.002898881444707513, -0.025741152465343475, 0.003632001345977187, -0.01432478241622448, 0.035584356635808945, -0.037489186972379684, 0.0012784114805981517, 0.003977249842137098, -0.03638839349150658, -0.04997524619102478, -0.01245051622390747, 0.047709155827760696, -0.00032014353200793266, 0.020560549572110176, 0.02587992697954178, -0.018485892564058304, -0.0211845263838768, 0.003788459813222289, -0.026115335524082184, 0.005404511000961065, 0.008767757564783096, 0.010585436597466469, 0.02856419049203396, -0.013087263330817223, -0.00479727890342474, 0.019053509458899498, -0.019947659224271774, 0.02259160205721855, -0.01248991023749113, -0.0048491437919437885, 0.027370566502213478, 0.0111771859228611, 0.056755129247903824, 0.015569968149065971, 0.017443669959902763, 0.05598168447613716, 0.020653819665312767, -0.022618068382143974, -0.011347881518304348, 0.013069513253867626, -0.06317916512489319, -0.01315611507743597, -0.026535915210843086, 0.08170585334300995, 0.029362579807639122, 0.006289830897003412, 0.023714154958724976, -0.01373429223895073, -0.024584146216511726, -0.01699998788535595, -0.01963241584599018, -0.008182337507605553, -0.06888577342033386, 0.022988826036453247, -0.01750248670578003, -0.01726933941245079, 0.05687757954001427, -0.01885991171002388, -0.017734766006469727, 0.0341922827064991, 0.009201779030263424, -0.04731350392103195, 0.00501756789162755, 0.013450277037918568, -0.041556067764759064, 0.014500531367957592, 0.004265110939741135, -0.01607602648437023, -0.04542189836502075, -0.03393961861729622, -0.00034300211700610816, -0.01866525411605835, 0.03245454654097557, 0.004185626748949289, -0.0071163480170071125, 0.021574361249804497, 0.00926935113966465, 0.025280283764004707, -0.0570831261575222, 0.02925857901573181, -0.00016619898087810725, -0.011294161900877953, -0.029395438730716705, -0.014841071330010891, 0.01957375556230545, -0.06753229349851608, -0.05933613330125809, 0.004209081642329693, -0.0033332554157823324, 0.04825208708643913, 0.017993515357375145, 0.0007001243066042662, 0.011657381430268288, 0.06532187014818192, -0.02520328015089035, -0.01930847205221653, -0.03843381255865097, -0.0146980294957757, 0.014094678685069084, 0.00826432928442955, 0.009290085174143314, 0.009849048219621181, -0.024469923228025436, 0.03287891298532486, 0.06323590874671936, -0.014651628211140633, -0.006970512680709362, 0.028400177136063576, 0.027166463434696198, -0.010679136961698532, 0.030123721808195114, -0.008001220412552357, 0.02309393882751465, 0.04143126308917999, -0.0039147865027189255, 0.010424538515508175, -0.034838370978832245, 0.014550555497407913, -0.10457687079906464, -0.014119544066488743, 0.017548348754644394, -0.015154334716498852, 0.02785537578165531, -0.004512484651058912, 0.028874507173895836, 0.051365599036216736, -0.017385000362992287, 0.004897213075309992, -0.030947739258408546, 0.020052574574947357, -0.02008208818733692, 0.05054851993918419, -0.023910941556096077, 0.017232969403266907, 0.019860928878188133, 0.014436465688049793, 0.043281909078359604, 0.005721597466617823, -0.022848885506391525, -0.0353933610022068, -0.026824375614523888, 0.009240992367267609, 0.017360348254442215, -0.021517829969525337, 0.003822093829512596, -0.029619639739394188, -0.0007765531190671027, 0.02788599580526352, -0.025954924523830414, 0.010991028510034084, 0.0024951633531600237, 0.014782057143747807, 0.011576438322663307, 0.03003787435591221, -0.014024708420038223, -0.0061857146210968494, -0.054182831197977066, 0.005231109447777271, 0.014906557276844978, 0.005665891338139772, -0.030604401603341103, 0.03925522044301033, 0.022538892924785614, 0.0044221458956599236, -0.031582318246364594, 0.01479433011263609, -0.0042779408395290375, -0.015562045387923717, -0.006123264320194721, 0.002315820660442114, -0.0037310386542230844, -0.028065552935004234, -0.012289105914533138, -0.05119713768362999, 0.02824453078210354, 0.045741066336631775, 0.015451379120349884, -0.008367069065570831, -0.02339858189225197, -0.028951704502105713, 0.003301067277789116, -0.002672868547961116, 0.011032810434699059, 0.014952091500163078, -0.05072768032550812, -0.003913027234375477, 0.014159989543259144, -0.0013576209312304854, 0.022578904405236244, -0.0308378953486681, -0.01878327690064907, 0.03214579075574875, 0.006145702674984932, -0.0029785828664898872, -0.01780744455754757, -0.016835585236549377, 0.015521415509283543, -0.10376149415969849, 0.051661647856235504, 0.026051871478557587, -0.02998950704932213, -0.08010507375001907, 0.010306267067790031, -0.021949708461761475, 0.06009526550769806, 0.0028253893833607435, 0.005584291648119688, 0.0024150952231138945, -0.03796105831861496, 0.01224470790475607, 0.024478496983647346, -0.06471219658851624, 0.035003889352083206, -0.015579735860228539, -0.037272144109010696, -0.029104476794600487, 0.01873662695288658, 0.0128048500046134, -0.0026964384596794844, -0.021609608083963394, -0.031040800735354424, -0.0015024257590994239, 0.004782190080732107, -0.027357157319784164, 0.04570871964097023, -0.02320609614253044, -0.0012676427140831947, 0.02326570264995098, -0.028895188122987747, 0.03308773785829544, 0.05096051096916199, -0.005705331917852163, -0.018626144155859947, 0.020871426910161972, -0.04611312225461006, -0.0021281952504068613, -0.003739304142072797, -0.001570967840962112, 0.008410380221903324, -0.05035904794931412, -0.020624646916985512, 0.019603170454502106, -0.07969804853200912, -0.017745254561305046, 0.031249815598130226, 0.0046405550092458725, 0.04338372126221657, 0.01914810948073864, 0.04080798849463463, -0.03049609251320362, -0.029235225170850754, -0.0034276496153324842, -0.01646442711353302, 0.05179961770772934, -0.013204329647123814, 0.011285143904387951, 0.014901877380907536, 0.009358181618154049, -0.0012969246599823236, -0.025230100378394127, 0.05269108712673187, -0.046387720853090286, 0.00833214446902275, 0.025436755269765854, -0.013368561863899231, 0.02993842586874962, 0.042006637901067734, -0.026423031464219093, 0.05061188340187073, -0.039502739906311035, 0.035763930529356, -0.04106070101261139, -0.01570722460746765, 0.01229897141456604, -0.018356043845415115, -0.025069143623113632, 0.03253476694226265, 0.024292560294270515, 0.01261324342340231, 0.002020886167883873, 0.018256569281220436, 0.010743430815637112, -0.015203197486698627, 0.031621504575014114, -0.040745675563812256, 0.007687747478485107, -0.007770739495754242, 0.004690677393227816, -0.027563707903027534, -0.023833340033888817, 0.014017668552696705, 0.034735482186079025, 0.034327615052461624, -0.049698472023010254, -0.02635187655687332, 0.000980822485871613, 0.044775281101465225, 0.00799497589468956, -0.013067176565527916, -0.047366056591272354, 0.040891729295253754, 0.00638591917231679, -0.017540045082569122 ]
<p>I'm working on an ongoing data analysis project about a series of live educational seminars. Each of my data points represents one such event, and for each one I have a multitude of categorical variables, as well as a couple quantitative ones that are my desired response variables (total revenue and number of attendees).</p> <p>One trend I'm interested in looking at is how the frequency of these events affects my two response variables. Over the years, we have increased the frequency of the events and I'd like to determine whether or not it makes sense to continue doing so. I've created a couple of variables to help track this frequency:</p> <p><code>NEAREST.SEM</code> - the number of days between this event and the nearest one to it chronologically in either direction</p> <p><code>LAST.SEM</code> - the number of days between this event and the nearest one to it chronologically <em>before</em> it</p> <p><code>WEEKLY.SEMS</code> - the total number of events held during the 7-day period starting on Monday within which this event falls</p> <p>Depending on how I do the analysis, these three variables seem to have varying significance, but the one that seems to consistently come out on top is <code>NEAREST.SEM</code>, which I have found to be significant at the 0.01 level in one test and the 0.001 level in another. The other two variables are significant in predicting revenue but not number of attendees, which is not ideal since we are more interested in number of attendees. (The data for revenue is not representative of the total revenue for each event due to certain special offers for repeat customers that aren't taken into account there.)</p> <p>Increasing the frequency of events seems to decrease each event's individual performance, but has so far increased overall performance. I'd like to determine the "turning point" at which overall performance will either dip or level off. Unfortunately, this is going to be tough to predict because my best-fitted variable, <code>NEAREST.SEM</code>, isn't as good a representation of increased frequency. Note, for example, that it would look exactly the same whether 4 or 5 events were held per week--it would always have the value of 1 in such situations. In fact, any time that events are grouped in clusters of consecutive days, we'll always get 1 for them on this variable...</p> <p>One option would be to just use <code>WEEKLY.SEMS</code> as a predictor of revenue, which it is well correlated with, but as I said, we'd much rather do this analysis based on number of attendees, a better measure of an event's success.</p> <p>So I really have two questions here:</p> <ol> <li><p>Any suggestions on my dilemma of which variable to use and how to deal with the problems I laid out above?</p></li> <li><p>Once I decide on a predictor factor, how can I go about estimating the average decrease in revenue increasing to various frequencies will have? Should I run a multiple regression using all my variables and use the coefficient on the predictor factor? Or should I run a regression with just the one factor and my response and use that coefficient? Or is there a better test than regression to use?</p></li> </ol> <p>(By the way, I'm using R for my analysis and I'd appreciate any advice specifically tailored for that language.)</p> <p>UPDATE: I have tried creating two new measures, one that's the average distance in days of the nearest event on either side, and one that's the number of events within 3 days in both directions...neither of them had any significant correlation. I'm running out of ideas here...</p>
48,550
[ -0.02944149076938629, -0.028561055660247803, 0.005215968005359173, 0.006695328745990992, 0.014321180060505867, 0.03237343207001686, 0.018642039969563484, -0.026669736951589584, 0.022806499153375626, -0.012680258601903915, 0.005095545202493668, 0.061166223138570786, 0.02697099559009075, 0.03719624504446983, 0.05033452436327934, -0.00023352479911409318, 0.005838511046022177, 0.016626175493001938, -0.0041665551252663136, -0.01114454586058855, -0.00983432400971651, 0.013499122112989426, 0.032886236906051636, -0.006803990341722965, -0.020317191258072853, 0.01990915834903717, 0.018888717517256737, -0.012064557522535324, -0.04088590666651726, 0.0504741445183754, -0.03352643921971321, -0.04773213714361191, -0.01536736823618412, 0.030547061935067177, 0.020873194560408592, 0.040627121925354004, 0.005997153930366039, -0.020289132371544838, -0.030617795884609222, 0.026347100734710693, -0.0023024254478514194, 0.00826280191540718, 0.0015574430581182241, 0.043728556483983994, 0.014811995439231396, 0.00826205499470234, -0.027715526521205902, 0.0290348082780838, 0.05428171530365944, -0.01755627989768982, 0.07796268165111542, -0.028076903894543648, 0.005736967548727989, 0.0023725698702037334, -0.030744433403015137, -0.018494321033358574, 0.06565599143505096, 0.04626939073204994, 0.011641893535852432, -0.02518354170024395, 0.008967001922428608, -0.05808749049901962, -0.04700872674584389, -0.019452322274446487, -0.010703274980187416, 0.03429190814495087, -0.02529919706285, 0.0041630263440310955, 0.044419508427381516, -0.03518148139119148, 0.012507492676377296, 0.013834100216627121, 0.024562645703554153, 0.013419406488537788, 0.054000839591026306, -0.05275304988026619, 0.023559441789984703, -0.016319291666150093, 0.038256630301475525, 0.05100536346435547, -0.015528162010014057, -0.012991659343242645, 0.016847874969244003, 0.008368529379367828, 0.04509155824780464, -0.03472025692462921, 0.06287290155887604, -0.07505161315202713, -0.008871132507920265, 0.0258940476924181, -0.022851143032312393, 0.0105972271412611, 0.03747302666306496, 0.011533643119037151, -0.02493445575237274, 0.03129531070590019, 0.006991623435169458, -0.01135075930505991, -0.006728280335664749, 0.010524573735892773, -0.03006143495440483, -0.06728653609752655, 0.01082754135131836, 0.03609416261315346, -0.022757094353437424, -0.008678417652845383, -0.02990800328552723, -0.03865809738636017, -0.01691650226712227, -0.03951658308506012, -0.010774645954370499, 0.0025685052387416363, 0.034569595009088516, -0.004649248905479908, -0.013184991665184498, -0.010981464758515358, -0.012919235043227673, -0.01989695057272911, 0.04092546924948692, 0.05268286541104317, 0.058159828186035156, -0.030854064971208572, -0.007186707574874163, -0.0386994294822216, -0.017832228913903236, -0.01202488038688898, -0.00032272207317873836, -0.02751481533050537, -0.026601670309901237, 0.052598901093006134, -0.003237094497308135, 0.005814280826598406, 0.0736318826675415, -0.01077674888074398, 0.03383336216211319, 0.024351123720407486, -0.04187576100230217, -0.022752344608306885, 0.03687853738665581, -0.0003378356050234288, 0.02498823218047619, -0.05893596261739731, -0.004217781126499176, 0.02125311642885208, 0.02716243639588356, 0.061164602637290955, 0.00391171220690012, -0.008300695568323135, 0.02718675136566162, 0.03615638241171837, -0.04662138596177101, 0.025379059836268425, -0.02844398096203804, -0.02154047228395939, -0.0364774651825428, -0.05155539885163307, 0.000060483427660074085, 0.02679263986647129, -0.019166836515069008, -0.0033132885582745075, 0.0582016259431839, -0.01898626983165741, -0.031136298552155495, -0.018125982955098152, 0.03487714007496834, 0.002384378807619214, 0.06275128573179245, 0.012648269534111023, -0.0062805661000311375, 0.03223207965493202, 0.004959431476891041, 0.021691055968403816, 0.026908783242106438, 0.017490237951278687, 0.027771947905421257, -0.0021057259291410446, 0.03998960927128792, -0.02861550822854042, -0.0044522336684167385, 0.03942038491368294, -0.02291015163064003, -0.0521499440073967, -0.04085209593176842, 0.0029329205863177776, 0.0368526466190815, 0.022914959117770195, -0.0031600049696862698, -0.02234143204987049, 0.04584791883826256, -0.04292498156428337, -0.05565967410802841, -0.03220755234360695, -0.014163938350975513, -0.009708167985081673, -0.03918919339776039, 0.029570162296295166, 0.0034807235933840275, 0.008757405914366245, 0.02142629399895668, 0.005850124638527632, -0.028502782806754112, -0.0033444403670728207, 0.03582919389009476, -0.05370326712727547, -0.02313064970076084, 0.04560878127813339, 0.019984092563390732, -0.020125441253185272, 0.02514474280178547, -0.04510612040758133, -0.029254060238599777, -0.026477443054318428, -0.04874807968735695, 0.044632114470005035, -0.030183255672454834, 0.0007412732229568064, 0.018085576593875885, 0.024567928165197372, -0.01237042248249054, 0.0234968401491642, -0.060716673731803894, 0.028877366334199905, 0.05404341593384743, 0.0033204592764377594, 0.010207523591816425, -0.02357620932161808, 0.010621866211295128, 0.03613228723406792, -0.006470725405961275, -0.02156096324324608, -0.06110135093331337, 0.013361772522330284, 0.014471359550952911, 0.014748702757060528, -0.0036351101007312536, 0.027789931744337082, 0.06687161326408386, -0.0015384082216769457, -0.020556826144456863, 0.05379713699221611, 0.002714423928409815, 0.02421710640192032, 0.018039705231785774, 0.01243477500975132, 0.009669392369687557, -0.004429346416145563, 0.02349172718822956, -0.0011848120484501123, 0.024055106565356255, 0.002881227759644389, 0.03538467735052109, 0.028790952637791634, 0.0228858795017004, -0.002666778862476349, -0.026896759867668152, -0.007314041256904602, 0.06190864369273186, -0.026401517912745476, -0.03391050547361374, 0.0724763497710228, 0.01229918748140335, 0.0014527939492836595, 0.015076429583132267, -0.05232313275337219, -0.004183593206107616, 0.03454199805855751, -0.019077401608228683, 0.0050872559659183025, 0.01620885729789734, -0.042545661330223083, 0.012370077893137932, -0.017817918211221695, -0.022484248504042625, -0.06160140410065651, -0.009949150495231152, 0.03802885860204697, 0.014420339837670326, 0.03540839999914169, -0.03152436763048172, -0.031451351940631866, 0.03142194077372551, -0.00444469740614295, 0.041328683495521545, 0.011164323426783085, -0.05859983712434769, -0.01375671662390232, 0.005504061467945576, -0.02700638771057129, 0.02262076549232006, 0.018325792625546455, -0.05656653270125389, 0.07321512699127197, 0.013807496055960655, -0.04863150045275688, -0.029953397810459137, -0.03687869757413864, 0.008969675749540329, 0.002434637164697051, -0.008155891671776772, 0.0810128003358841, 0.017178477719426155, -0.06365732103586197, 0.0008381176739931107, -0.036077965050935745, 0.000980512355454266, -0.06029631569981575, 0.0008224789053201675, -0.027703627943992615, 0.0011479489039629698, -0.023043883964419365, 0.015550533309578896, 0.018704989925026894, 0.0049561928026378155, -0.06467828154563904, -0.03905577212572098, -0.002275914652273059, -0.012663309462368488, 0.0564611479640007, -0.01624232530593872, 0.03428344428539276, 0.08276408165693283, 0.04602523520588875, -0.018231704831123352, -0.0512588694691658, -0.0025593137834221125, -0.018770115450024605, -0.016715597361326218, 0.01719994843006134, 0.010066444054245949, -0.001566312275826931, -0.014441391453146935, -0.016801178455352783, 0.05723654851317406, 0.0682450383901596, -0.01301069650799036, 0.030498139560222626, 0.033299438655376434, -0.017562689259648323, -0.03390788286924362, 0.04405558481812477, 0.028920447453856468, -0.03267502784729004, 0.034035660326480865, -0.005910579580813646, 0.0063124410808086395, -0.014011010527610779, -0.024479404091835022, 0.005905818194150925, -0.041087936609983444, -0.0011937078088521957, 0.01981477253139019, -0.013716915622353554, 0.009863384999334812, -0.07013414055109024, -0.033450815826654434, 0.010650352574884892, 0.043909065425395966, -0.033286407589912415, 0.012787679210305214, 0.06855731457471848, 0.08663236349821091, -0.037559278309345245, -0.015484635718166828, -0.024997737258672714, -0.0103308679535985, 0.017450788989663124, -0.0550578311085701, -0.01685030199587345, 0.03146710246801376, 0.05533461645245552, 0.03822828084230423, -0.006806314457207918, -0.03861797973513603, -0.02290688455104828, -0.0638049840927124, 0.010003208182752132, -0.039404433220624924, 0.047959696501493454, 0.02001236565411091, 0.02875465340912342, 0.02815064787864685, -0.01654638908803463, 0.012726956978440285, 0.01633273996412754, -0.058897677809000015, 0.04465009644627571, -0.036153681576251984, 0.006025572773069143, 0.021314727142453194, 0.005298880860209465, 0.012723179534077644, -0.001254543079994619, 0.002740337047725916, 0.001045609125867486, 0.02485112100839615, -0.035370029509067535, -0.005807755049318075, -0.029126610606908798, 0.0031462600454688072, -0.017403438687324524, -0.015854397788643837, 0.018363885581493378, -0.007214572746306658, 0.03790802136063576, 0.02590935118496418, -0.030898092314600945, 0.0006462355377152562, -0.011377347633242607, -0.005336875095963478, 0.01029179897159338, 0.026779331266880035, 0.020895255729556084, 0.029306812211871147, -0.0750376358628273, 0.0357661210000515, 0.02346864901483059, 0.002168049803003669, 0.06026627495884895, -0.04961423575878143, -0.051911476999521255, -0.012211384251713753, -0.029895607382059097, 0.04571031406521797, 0.020315559580922127, 0.024654870852828026, -0.016443705186247826, 0.046560630202293396, 0.019460994750261307, -0.04054522141814232, -0.005968412384390831, 0.06968263536691666, 0.014394925907254219, -0.001414144760929048, -0.030984995886683464, -0.027889486402273178, 0.013187366537749767, -0.009021173231303692, 0.022657474502921104, 0.045671772211790085, 0.030228421092033386, -0.018600450828671455, 0.004987829364836216, -0.009500239044427872, -0.05346059426665306, -0.013080131262540817, -0.010235704481601715, 0.04192996397614479, -0.006195418071001768, -0.021586844697594643, 0.01563984341919422, 0.014935918152332306, 0.020983615890145302, -0.003083983436226845, 0.02200104109942913, -0.13612805306911469, -0.033837828785181046, 0.05431457608938217, 0.05147825926542282, -0.06260985881090164, -0.05988948047161102, -0.030452357605099678, -0.022795649245381355, -0.0075715347193181515, -0.0680902898311615, 0.01187810953706503, 0.021382100880146027, 0.027630968019366264, -0.050891321152448654, -0.02869691699743271, -0.06850483268499374, 0.014162763021886349, -0.05316158011555672, 0.05783892795443535, -0.04028124734759331, -0.05324946343898773, -0.08429475128650665, 0.030658764764666557, 0.04344822093844414, 0.026553208008408546, -0.03041301667690277, -0.06658735871315002, 0.0076623824425041676, -0.030174022540450096, -0.02407197095453739, -0.05629228428006172, 0.01989816501736641, 0.011787787079811096, 0.03948914632201195, 0.013166716322302818, 0.00014816813927609473, -0.003939444664865732, 0.009775265119969845, 0.008421196602284908, -0.014516541734337807, -0.014686929993331432, -0.023441284894943237, 0.032842352986335754, 0.028781864792108536, -0.016496863216161728, 0.01624823734164238, 0.03253156319260597, -0.016305675730109215, 0.05013806000351906, -0.03018220327794552, -0.02957725338637829, 0.016081849113106728, 0.004538979846984148, -0.014977909624576569, -0.023259516805410385, -0.02211596630513668, 0.007862147875130177, -0.0359124019742012, 0.032258957624435425, -0.006837897468358278, 0.011409381404519081, -0.004386437125504017, 0.02097243070602417, -0.020355956628918648, -0.01006760448217392, 0.027264388278126717, 0.03033358044922352, -0.03727142512798309, -0.0315847210586071, 0.049998827278614044, -0.038005392998456955, 0.019358225166797638, -0.0011995552340522408, -0.04840535297989845, -0.004008924122899771, 0.031612101942300797, -0.004681114107370377, -0.010867958888411522, -0.011381647549569607, 0.01130710169672966, -0.03606995940208435, 0.04214956611394882, 0.04033529385924339, -0.012653008103370667, -0.01519803050905466, 0.05016329512000084, -0.015090213157236576, 0.0011088016908615828, -0.0052038230933249, 0.04010945186018944, -0.02265259064733982, 0.010358094237744808, -0.03578133136034012, -0.06095772609114647, 0.02510700561106205, 0.03530881181359291, -0.04120782017707825, -0.019073553383350372, -0.03454665467143059, -0.007828609086573124, -0.010035635903477669, -0.0030801997054368258, 0.03892692178487778, -0.06038999557495117, -0.018758760765194893, 0.006094520911574364, 0.00400272011756897, 0.07791805267333984, 0.027347657829523087, 0.003636191599071026, 0.027579594403505325, 0.04701186716556549, -0.0173215139657259, -0.041335608810186386, -0.007409476675093174, -0.029345445334911346, -0.013862259685993195, -0.012826125137507915, 0.0013596704229712486, 0.04650067538022995, -0.034910719841718674, -0.014187862165272236, 0.021955955773591995, -0.0005198094877414405, 0.040455516427755356, -0.040741413831710815, 0.028058532625436783, -0.00537470867857337, -0.019609274342656136, -0.029453618451952934, 0.054296042770147324, -0.021349666640162468, -0.010462315753102303, -0.003876646514981985, 0.008875087834894657, -0.02734670601785183, 0.046948276460170746, 0.05433332547545433, 0.015480218455195427, 0.02211729995906353, -0.03195233643054962, -0.00012997268640901893, 0.02970072254538536, 0.02411728724837303, 0.016545014455914497, -0.020709659904241562, 0.026125196367502213, 0.00476015405729413, -0.009084208868443966, -0.038084521889686584, -0.03958987817168236, 0.0509028397500515, 0.029417749494314194, 0.027326542884111404, 0.05412979796528816, 0.018681392073631287, 0.02698180079460144, -0.018689168617129326, -0.0019301006104797125, -0.007073406130075455, 0.001702099572867155, 0.0555591881275177, -0.0329628549516201, -0.01872549019753933, 0.02663034200668335, 0.005990893114358187, -0.01942584104835987, 0.01609305664896965, 0.0006773198256269097, 0.011798448860645294, 0.04332856833934784, -0.025730252265930176, -0.03621659055352211, 0.001303751952946186, -0.00606068829074502, 0.03695769980549812, -0.030924836173653603, -0.03641882538795471, -0.0004631554475054145, 0.042674850672483444, -0.03036772459745407, -0.05546288192272186, -0.016628894954919815, -0.05076693743467331, -0.00892794318497181, 0.005601715296506882, -0.021382171660661697, 0.023299548774957657, 0.019084015861153603, 0.04603321850299835, 0.031191537156701088, 0.019001884385943413, -0.047536686062812805, -0.060253340750932693, -0.01875624805688858, -0.011606495827436447, -0.07439342141151428, 0.06985744088888168, -0.02768574468791485, -0.016462242230772972, 0.021942391991615295, -0.034813884645700455, 0.004928633105009794, -0.005659539718180895, 0.02235081046819687, 0.04111802205443382, 0.062372468411922455, 0.02420360967516899, -0.028285913169384003, -0.02280125394463539, -0.014459007419645786, 0.13128748536109924, 0.08172694593667984, 0.026827050372958183, -0.040199849754571915, 0.029255907982587814, 0.0534498505294323, 0.008089577779173851, 0.008081291802227497, -0.026946131139993668, 0.003890126943588257, 0.01200676616281271, 0.08347898721694946, 0.042935729026794434, 0.0007564251427538693, 0.036537330597639084, 0.0270105991512537, -0.017276838421821594, 0.014611344784498215, 0.0007655236404389143, 0.0071429102681577206, 0.04087931290268898, 0.00487253675237298, -0.0183201115578413, 0.019820543006062508, 0.00707633001729846, -0.014111892320215702, -0.008410871028900146, -0.013234376907348633, -0.031686097383499146, -0.040122710168361664, -0.03769027069211006, 0.018503103405237198, 0.015892041847109795, 0.0055571552366018295, -0.023569878190755844, 0.0332920216023922, 0.023226790130138397, -0.03803430497646332, 0.002931893803179264, 0.0362732857465744, -0.00353020871989429, -0.014074678532779217, 0.005593220237642527, 0.006303167901933193, -0.060693368315696716, -0.016754871234297752, -0.06235289201140404, -0.0001116857019951567, 0.007255006581544876, -0.003600510535761714, -0.005785684566944838, 0.0019755021203309298, 0.026810957118868828, -0.018832990899682045, -0.003009994514286518, 0.04312469810247421, 0.0005477714003063738, -0.03515999764204025, 0.0038459168281406164, -0.0019320201827213168, 0.011064223013818264, 0.013410781510174274, 0.02799319103360176, 0.04556668549776077, -0.012121476233005524, -0.018670061603188515, -0.024463728070259094, 0.03644406795501709, -0.006723529193550348, -0.011041168123483658, 0.041925713419914246, -0.012439334765076637, -0.04659189656376839, -0.025981128215789795, 0.015156693756580353, -0.0026073234621435404, -0.007809331174939871, -0.020945094525814056, 0.00022712856298312545, -0.023903751745820045, -0.036063265055418015, 0.02629646100103855, -0.001678116270340979, -0.008335034362971783, -0.05248856544494629, 0.025068094953894615, 0.023435145616531372, 0.01436693500727415, 0.026959460228681564, 0.005615095607936382, 0.006063490174710751, 0.05639733374118805, 0.028146976605057716, -0.04209483414888382, -0.04136134684085846, 0.022491781041026115, -0.03877861797809601, 0.008541298098862171, 0.0043310364708304405, 0.10248531401157379, 0.0027444816660135984, -0.027943294495344162, 0.03396017104387283, -0.01530393399298191, -0.03451535850763321, 0.0094452491030097, 0.0007892473367974162, -0.014999400824308395, -0.011523466557264328, 0.0029061702080070972, -0.030410027131438255, -0.015716657042503357, -0.006975108757615089, -0.008848639205098152, -0.041502926498651505, 0.003219965845346451, -0.03033347800374031, -0.013987626880407333, 0.04234571382403374, -0.014721157029271126, 0.01962677575647831, -0.019621439278125763, -0.026894092559814453, -0.06251699477434158, -0.04012719541788101, -0.03198089450597763, -0.007706835865974426, -0.004334546625614166, 0.019466398283839226, -0.008294519037008286, 0.00007940117211546749, 0.043685220181941986, 0.019056590273976326, 0.04183371365070343, -0.0037942302878946066, 0.024609239771962166, -0.010566876269876957, 0.024564048275351524, -0.005348399747163057, -0.05432102456688881, 0.014025049284100533, -0.01955431140959263, -0.04557662829756737, 0.03501752391457558, -0.002153832232579589, 0.021838106215000153, 0.013067158870398998, 0.013205010443925858, -0.016003422439098358, 0.012092296034097672, -0.03263426944613457, -0.025032587349414825, -0.019269254058599472, 0.035675328224897385, 0.05198565870523453, 0.006963120773434639, -0.008185512386262417, 0.03809894621372223, -0.005323745775967836, 0.004004037939012051, 0.03900664299726486, -0.019351201131939888, -0.003326087025925517, -0.00819183886051178, -0.058153629302978516, 0.009116817265748978, 0.03437424078583717, -0.011254650540649891, 0.06537532806396484, 0.012988337315618992, -0.021979959681630135, 0.029527833685278893, 0.004318383056670427, -0.015551677905023098, -0.04360780119895935, -0.03850087523460388, 0.0014516218798235059, -0.03757760301232338, 0.030861524865031242, -0.02196115255355835, -0.005843499209731817, -0.001827490283176303, -0.008218147791922092, 0.04411545395851135, 0.013334672898054123, 0.013731997460126877, -0.02212916873395443, 0.029197191819548607, 0.02513585053384304, -0.0015516255516558886, 0.015549900010228157, 0.002039880957454443, 0.024755267426371574, 0.012674059718847275, 0.0233372300863266, -0.041536878794431686, -0.020977208390831947, -0.016658637672662735, 0.007768495008349419, -0.03396541625261307, 0.01616274192929268, -0.06311552971601486, 0.020108385011553764, 0.030170612037181854, -0.018018102273344994, 0.01039791014045477, 0.026304878294467926, 0.015798190608620644, 0.01832442916929722, 0.06364364922046661, 0.039589494466781616, -0.0010677126701921225, -0.009365237317979336, -0.007917913608253002, -0.0035294685512781143, 0.03602324798703194, -0.01857827417552471, 0.04061637446284294, 0.04326193034648895, -0.03768662363290787, 0.00902725663036108, -0.03715186193585396, -0.00022563956736121327, -0.0006403354345820844, -0.014794738031923771, -0.0033307205885648727, 0.000018622633433551528, -0.007949067279696465, 0.027552979066967964, -0.02204243279993534, 0.017735902220010757, 0.040601059794425964, 0.019548935815691948, -0.008415968157351017, 0.027150990441441536, 0.008799108676612377, -0.026842214167118073, -0.003810856956988573, -0.012617512606084347, -0.006624346133321524, -0.031312212347984314, 0.02287905663251877, -0.004297119099646807, -0.01703239418566227, -0.03823866322636604, 0.0170151237398386, -0.03139648213982582, 0.05629197880625725, -0.01924295350909233, 0.008465572260320187, 0.06231814622879028, 0.009198717772960663, 0.04645489156246185, -0.11669914424419403, 0.04254307970404625, 0.00024740141816437244, -0.003007159335538745, -0.02007305435836315, -0.040431685745716095, -0.02245284803211689, 0.03734276816248894, 0.07150030881166458, -0.009332462213933468, -0.016191137954592705, 0.002134192967787385, 0.036384496837854385, 0.01880030892789364, -0.029663540422916412, 0.045792315155267715, -0.013932697474956512, 0.005879638716578484, -0.02222697250545025, -0.033727191388607025, 0.0023081512190401554, 0.005252297967672348, 0.0016219044337049127, -0.0222485288977623, 0.01725352555513382, -0.023808913305401802, -0.02248348481953144, 0.002456542570143938, 0.00745463278144598, -0.03234022855758667, 0.02856200374662876, 0.012684732675552368, -0.02303999476134777, 0.016111036762595177, 0.001403829432092607, -0.0664178878068924, 0.0440857857465744, -0.037311799824237823, -0.019150229170918465, 0.03889603540301323, 0.01663009077310562, -0.004504016134887934, -0.04925801232457161, 0.013127188198268414, 0.012190469540655613, -0.03371082991361618, 0.014370324090123177, -0.00040820444701239467, 0.0017357752658426762, 0.01792091876268387, -0.004279034212231636, 0.019299646839499474, -0.003555797040462494, -0.033972494304180145, 0.022625911980867386, 0.026871755719184875, 0.03025052510201931, -0.019431767985224724, 0.015874555334448814, 0.02675919234752655, 0.02303522825241089, -0.002848291303962469, -0.0015334479976445436, 0.02670065313577652, -0.01629432663321495, -0.02842000499367714, 0.05988239124417305, -0.020408092066645622, 0.013400287367403507, 0.029541699215769768, 0.019737789407372475, 0.025896286591887474, -0.04264490306377411, 0.02172696776688099, -0.04688740149140358, -0.03467953950166702, 0.0008353697485290468, 0.025986460968852043, 0.02997184358537197, -0.0049835131503641605, -0.015823524445295334, 0.00441561546176672, 0.04659219831228256, -0.002242951886728406, -0.028702804818749428, -0.02520330809056759, 0.027278460562229156, 0.0030683784279972315, -0.021421393379569054, -0.023448767140507698, -0.03331468999385834, -0.017538441345095634, -0.03011956438422203, 0.0202194657176733, 0.029505932703614235, 0.000008065493602771312, 0.0030040782876312733, 0.0002345921820960939, -0.00048028238234110177, 0.015453373081982136, -0.053164444863796234, -0.03640371188521385, -0.0641658678650856, 0.05523202568292618, -0.0076471599750220776, -0.0202260073274374 ]
<p>I've fit a mixed linear model to some longitudinal data. I'm interested in the differences in patterns of decrease in the dependent variable according to group status, and my hypothesis particularly predicts a difference between the groups in trajectory of change at between specific ages. The data shows a significant interaction between group and the linear and quadratic effects of age, but I don't know if there is a way to assess this interaction for one part of the age range, or if I need to be able to do so in order to interpret my results as bing supportive of my hypothesis.</p> <p>NB I'm using the nlme package in R</p>
36,868
[ -0.04096284508705139, -0.04141239821910858, -0.005403304472565651, -0.012421296909451485, 0.02999642863869667, 0.009299789555370808, -0.02201271429657936, -0.02658723294734955, 0.050047311931848526, -0.07112445682287216, 0.062369246035814285, 0.03813309967517853, 0.06817727535963058, 0.0018826194573193789, 0.02375689707696438, 0.010079821571707726, -0.018955040723085403, -0.03536788001656532, -0.02512982301414013, 0.002071329392492771, -0.050868116319179535, 0.013294563628733158, -0.009494527243077755, 0.004552897531539202, -0.02247549407184124, 0.031865544617176056, 0.03616378828883171, -0.03595183789730072, -0.006037430837750435, 0.03339327871799469, -0.01832776889204979, -0.026270831003785133, 0.012704090215265751, 0.03622088581323624, 0.021967444568872452, -0.027359729632735252, -0.004220982082188129, -0.04746485874056816, -0.019537512212991714, 0.039524469524621964, -0.08990025520324707, -0.008236256428062916, 0.014838853850960732, 0.05721620097756386, -0.036909136921167374, 0.03261302039027214, -0.013338304124772549, 0.01532223355025053, 0.058632779866456985, -0.0138124730437994, 0.06169503182172775, 0.01679953746497631, 0.021131280809640884, 0.008668439462780952, -0.03197288513183594, 0.0028958760667592287, 0.052424196153879166, 0.053108230233192444, 0.016688529402017593, -0.027580030262470245, -0.013515135273337364, -0.01949167810380459, 0.02483711577951908, 0.014002561569213867, -0.03038695827126503, 0.0059648859314620495, 0.006751697976142168, -0.01737949252128601, 0.03827895224094391, -0.03230959177017212, -0.026927124708890915, 0.014405905269086361, 0.05518552288413048, 0.009497212246060371, 0.01486740168184042, -0.046311285346746445, 0.02159772254526615, 0.02338721603155136, 0.02506769634783268, 0.040908053517341614, -0.032847486436367035, 0.005833225790411234, 0.020210813730955124, 0.03510550782084465, -0.002481672912836075, -0.031510937958955765, 0.08123475313186646, -0.03895481303334236, 0.044027648866176605, 0.029230697080492973, -0.01752828061580658, 0.016741249710321426, 0.0423760749399662, 0.04670575261116028, -0.062445200979709625, 0.018497245386242867, -0.012749118730425835, 0.014655285514891148, 0.04500441253185272, 0.009733437560498714, 0.012918354943394661, -0.029688512906432152, 0.022455884143710136, 0.05303138867020607, -0.017834385856986046, -0.0006880164728499949, -0.05030513182282448, -0.022189538925886154, -0.0011087715392932296, -0.03313397243618965, 0.013228906318545341, 0.009727001190185547, -0.012968319468200207, -0.03010563738644123, 0.030204609036445618, -0.029049281030893326, -0.04221586510539055, -0.03607895225286484, 0.06952729821205139, 0.0675053745508194, 0.03130077198147774, -0.028600016608834267, 0.03679285943508148, 0.013728642836213112, -0.04246102273464203, 0.033485930413007736, 0.0156523697078228, -0.043399613350629807, -0.06211845949292183, 0.08966504782438278, 0.02837553806602955, -0.021230902522802353, 0.011852513998746872, -0.03563246876001358, 0.028683682903647423, 0.0062380763702094555, -0.0537952296435833, -0.02166970632970333, 0.021011341363191605, -0.014733982272446156, 0.02768121287226677, -0.03608989715576172, 0.0019774497486650944, 0.02985968440771103, 0.08028672635555267, -0.01607062853872776, 0.011591635644435883, 0.02835902012884617, 0.011583627201616764, 0.008235524408519268, -0.017238812521100044, 0.008035629987716675, -0.021631482988595963, -0.021564330905675888, -0.004778494127094746, -0.0960637703537941, 0.029033685103058815, 0.02931077778339386, -0.012926323339343071, 0.029580133035779, 0.06491270661354065, 0.00447203079238534, -0.05050623044371605, 0.011007371358573437, 0.03617530316114426, 0.011344165541231632, 0.04363000765442848, -0.038919590413570404, 0.016062244772911072, 0.00550435483455658, 0.01493173185735941, 0.04573645070195198, 0.038736242800951004, 0.06459084153175354, 0.049796201288700104, -0.009149947203695774, 0.015629030764102936, -0.013040829449892044, -0.03942844644188881, -0.008736535906791687, -0.05089208856225014, -0.02320907823741436, -0.059592656791210175, -0.010582685470581055, 0.005766936112195253, 0.03578322380781174, -0.017188552767038345, -0.006551156751811504, 0.06457438319921494, 0.0025363434106111526, -0.04317731410264969, -0.08677772432565689, 0.023855214938521385, 0.012388953007757664, -0.049714215099811554, 0.012360656633973122, -0.004378707148134708, 0.031820181757211685, -0.029362965375185013, -0.029672322794795036, -0.029523028060793877, 0.008233608677983284, 0.005651148501783609, -0.027376938611268997, 0.003189058043062687, -0.02643124759197235, 0.05564665049314499, -0.010904934257268906, 0.033726733177900314, -0.031686197966337204, -0.02424667961895466, 0.030729176476597786, -0.02421419508755207, 0.02170703187584877, -0.01880122534930706, 0.026190578937530518, -0.04410272836685181, -0.015907656401395798, -0.0016499621560797095, 0.05517924949526787, -0.049980029463768005, 0.04227901250123978, 0.05169585719704628, -0.00397088099271059, 0.00006069858864066191, -0.0035380490589886904, 0.022275632247328758, 0.0068628909066319466, -0.05851105600595474, 0.009748350828886032, -0.02770596370100975, -0.028294632211327553, 0.025662750005722046, 0.018759096041321754, -0.011761368252336979, 0.027570687234401703, 0.05355661362409592, -0.003582538338378072, -0.014319297857582569, 0.025563698261976242, -0.011138783767819405, -0.013162798248231411, 0.011515275575220585, 0.020329488441348076, 0.0034789820201694965, 0.015229575335979462, 0.03908663988113403, 0.004475056193768978, 0.02758302539587021, -0.010018622502684593, 0.0019760318100452423, 0.04625213146209717, 0.008475546725094318, -0.022981205955147743, -0.03806724771857262, -0.0364721454679966, 0.05267927423119545, -0.01656380668282509, -0.005080369766801596, 0.05098290741443634, 0.012742899358272552, -0.0048545063473284245, 0.016049351543188095, 0.012481717392802238, 0.044605474919080734, 0.03054635040462017, -0.03250369802117348, -0.004048996139317751, 0.005506440531462431, -0.017923252657055855, 0.014913098886609077, -0.009887720458209515, -0.012377321720123291, -0.017653698101639748, -0.01616724394261837, 0.008062494918704033, 0.006692532915621996, 0.014676480554044247, -0.05133950710296631, -0.016444211825728416, 0.024074731394648552, -0.007637789007276297, 0.0299020167440176, -0.006618608720600605, -0.027004925534129143, 0.008492108434438705, -0.024862434715032578, -0.015937551856040955, 0.023602480068802834, 0.03569057211279869, -0.0009284218540415168, 0.024553479626774788, -0.0036979196593165398, -0.05886075273156166, -0.04362533241510391, -0.032298337668180466, -0.02166208252310753, -0.015431134961545467, 0.00943007506430149, 0.03867550939321518, 0.012581699527800083, -0.020930711179971695, 0.009165331721305847, -0.03861718624830246, 0.0023587436880916357, -0.012496009469032288, -0.018207941204309464, 0.010858156718313694, 0.025442201644182205, 0.01571878418326378, 0.021294407546520233, -0.016461025923490524, 0.020497865974903107, -0.0825539231300354, -0.09024056792259216, 0.028188837692141533, 0.035044051706790924, 0.004782703705132008, -0.0046399920247495174, 0.007192367222160101, 0.05281924456357956, 0.026289673522114754, -0.023707043379545212, -0.0698172003030777, -0.015197866596281528, -0.02331564947962761, 0.015304296277463436, 0.0549464225769043, -0.015028297901153564, 0.01388520747423172, 0.014285511337220669, -0.021931715309619904, 0.019288813695311546, 0.04655971750617027, 0.014836498536169529, -0.00047633860958740115, 0.02955600805580616, -0.0058710309676826, 0.031626589596271515, -0.0010252719512209296, 0.00166106887627393, -0.01036246307194233, 0.01673271134495735, -0.02252785675227642, 0.027717869728803635, 0.005784058943390846, -0.07602820545434952, 0.011645857244729996, 0.004614369943737984, 0.0023955400101840496, 0.020225798711180687, 0.03641057759523392, 0.028430568054318428, -0.0075111049227416515, 0.014843221753835678, -0.0017872467869892716, 0.044436175376176834, -0.001625979202799499, -0.010926062241196632, 0.035880595445632935, 0.031344521790742874, -0.004359802696853876, -0.007019918877631426, 0.0254119373857975, -0.00607890821993351, 0.0333087183535099, -0.043607547879219055, -0.01897871494293213, 0.010287835262715816, -0.010729425586760044, 0.0020839988719671965, 0.002273700898513198, -0.02237747609615326, 0.0048483009450137615, -0.05342748388648033, 0.011323065496981144, -0.011204578913748264, 0.03708188980817795, 0.018652815371751785, 0.014199492521584034, -0.004620244726538658, -0.019864721223711967, 0.000990792061202228, -0.03904976323246956, -0.04532339796423912, 0.03816390410065651, -0.020331650972366333, 0.003682071343064308, 0.049632441252470016, 0.022333407774567604, 0.021287057548761368, -0.0021488454658538103, -0.008568861521780491, -0.013430757448077202, 0.05195830389857292, 0.004224217962473631, -0.016899337992072105, -0.03628343343734741, -0.005849102977663279, 0.019643671810626984, 0.008665964007377625, 0.015548347495496273, -0.02389659360051155, -0.0052710785530507565, 0.01942371390759945, 0.02686186507344246, -0.029407987371087074, -0.04673915356397629, -0.024911273270845413, 0.022085560485720634, 0.04818800464272499, 0.008105313405394554, -0.02625277079641819, -0.04395675286650658, 0.06181085482239723, 0.0019222729606553912, 0.012686382047832012, 0.017537910491228104, 0.01413287315517664, 0.0007728036143817008, -0.005594496615231037, 0.0025732950307428837, 0.01870710775256157, -0.000333038013195619, 0.005795405246317387, 0.004484004341065884, 0.04084038361907005, 0.03182089328765869, -0.04673047736287117, 0.04126647859811783, 0.0626937597990036, 0.04347730055451393, 0.00923189427703619, -0.0633540228009224, -0.006332970689982176, 0.01725618727505207, 0.017735177651047707, 0.018831737339496613, 0.01664150133728981, 0.03148796409368515, -0.0011351037537679076, 0.07081581652164459, 0.006288280710577965, -0.06042369082570076, -0.007504426874220371, -0.0018467562040314078, 0.02514774352312088, -0.03184971213340759, -0.03542906790971756, 0.01767243631184101, 0.03915088251233101, 0.033926766365766525, 0.020075401291251183, 0.03026307374238968, -0.11405638605356216, 0.0028138284105807543, 0.028223244473338127, 0.04078953340649605, -0.03279780223965645, -0.04039525240659714, 0.009467199444770813, 0.0008737972821108997, 0.03249593451619148, 0.007223710883408785, 0.04356531426310539, -0.009179774671792984, 0.005546391475945711, -0.050093330442905426, -0.022271282970905304, -0.02042834274470806, 0.01629612036049366, -0.026660261675715446, -0.0005675175343640149, -0.01780855655670166, -0.029808759689331055, -0.01031648088246584, 0.03811388462781906, 0.01815476454794407, 0.051251646131277084, -0.0002592019154690206, -0.005356914829462767, 0.027070604264736176, 0.009870629757642746, -0.037789251655340195, -0.04998946189880371, 0.058383382856845856, 0.013819274492561817, 0.010359454900026321, 0.05873379856348038, -0.015835262835025787, -0.006005086470395327, 0.007464694790542126, 0.026940051466226578, -0.01539160218089819, -0.03127977252006531, -0.006091229617595673, 0.08686885982751846, 0.036740515381097794, 0.026346616446971893, 0.047577906399965286, 0.045881595462560654, -0.015742480754852295, -0.0006804544827900827, -0.024158675223588943, 0.014895190484821796, -0.01901133731007576, -0.03601376712322235, -0.03199087083339691, -0.04071694612503052, 0.02061832882463932, 0.07470493018627167, -0.019400708377361298, 0.0298253633081913, -0.027863776311278343, -0.003703352762386203, 0.020979639142751694, 0.019129998981952667, -0.03686543554067612, 0.0036478599067777395, 0.031046446412801743, -0.004275121260434389, -0.013630961999297142, -0.03584257513284683, 0.031625427305698395, 0.0019690946210175753, 0.010615156032145023, 0.01465254370123148, -0.03478102758526802, 0.029858848080039024, 0.020004237070679665, -0.03561801090836525, 0.020762167870998383, 0.022952953353524208, 0.02408796362578869, -0.006993797607719898, 0.0018282196251675487, -0.03489045426249504, -0.020374031737446785, 0.024385837838053703, 0.04957275092601776, -0.029089732095599174, 0.05424484238028526, 0.01778922602534294, 0.018097849562764168, 0.010538809932768345, -0.015921112149953842, -0.060217004269361496, -0.07671648263931274, 0.005678598303347826, -0.00041267176857218146, -0.003846958978101611, -0.03421548381447792, 0.0007712919032201171, -0.02014997974038124, -0.009162862785160542, 0.021584555506706238, 0.06599592417478561, -0.016782736405730247, -0.000960068660788238, -0.01906309276819229, -0.001440986292436719, 0.0768112912774086, 0.013065668754279613, -0.0016150441952049732, 0.01118211168795824, -0.0010537547059357166, -0.002909864531829953, -0.027090154588222504, 0.019124289974570274, -0.035226188600063324, 0.022764110937714577, -0.040484100580215454, 0.01644180528819561, 0.06855568289756775, -0.05370478332042694, -0.040926240384578705, 0.028423532843589783, -0.03160715103149414, 0.019754579290747643, -0.022693825885653496, 0.0011298793833702803, -0.02067319117486477, -0.013524340465664864, 0.004010259639471769, 0.013502601534128189, 0.003641420276835561, -0.04788034409284592, 0.04529714584350586, -0.01747453771531582, -0.0599459633231163, 0.022798506543040276, 0.058592479676008224, 0.02417006343603134, 0.0013531793374568224, 0.0038184337317943573, -0.030590195208787918, 0.006808614358305931, -0.021582169458270073, -0.009486549533903599, -0.011532784439623356, 0.01991642266511917, -0.05805700644850731, -0.04383998364210129, -0.0035103277768939734, -0.0024135855492204428, 0.06792252510786057, -0.027059676125645638, 0.04063655063509941, 0.06432967633008957, -0.040187954902648926, -0.030184080824255943, -0.035543158650398254, 0.006406520493328571, -0.011902740225195885, -0.023263394832611084, 0.04479103162884712, -0.025215886533260345, -0.010105052962899208, 0.05276767164468765, 0.005369632970541716, 0.018147485330700874, 0.05969483405351639, 0.024150902405381203, 0.006900749169290066, 0.06813224405050278, -0.0027132269460707903, -0.06335898488759995, 0.020841829478740692, -0.04587313160300255, -0.004632408730685711, -0.06891659647226334, 0.01960550993680954, 0.020291252061724663, 0.08686628192663193, 0.032968007028102875, -0.03140762448310852, -0.025820255279541016, -0.05447078123688698, 0.006194110494107008, 0.04109484702348709, -0.004963710904121399, 0.04106546938419342, 0.05498649179935455, 0.022394638508558273, -0.01345688197761774, -0.006081641186028719, -0.020941779017448425, -0.04626202955842018, -0.031000137329101562, -0.03559498488903046, -0.016522301360964775, 0.0004367552464827895, -0.01072558294981718, -0.018940994516015053, 0.0017067267326638103, -0.046292588114738464, -0.0182456374168396, -0.007210739888250828, 0.033219341188669205, -0.02045094221830368, 0.07585781812667847, 0.0005203793989494443, -0.0036769688595086336, 0.017232336103916168, 0.016580859199166298, 0.12189743667840958, 0.047802068293094635, 0.013776968233287334, -0.0629531666636467, 0.03551647812128067, 0.022088177502155304, -0.010344007983803749, -0.005704820621758699, -0.024506520479917526, -0.032733041793107986, -0.02728075347840786, 0.028161359950900078, 0.06525392830371857, 0.013664552941918373, 0.0009446322801522911, 0.03442326933145523, -0.04050477594137192, -0.008021934889256954, 0.03493257611989975, -0.022670244798064232, -0.009914616122841835, 0.0074815149419009686, -0.02702931873500347, 0.01467045396566391, 0.0012750067980960011, -0.0264557097107172, -0.010008499957621098, -0.00476977089419961, -0.016964541748166084, 0.01319472398608923, -0.04275326803326607, 0.012792394496500492, 0.01677277870476246, 0.030101049691438675, -0.042631376534700394, 0.002911464311182499, -0.005149087402969599, -0.022996142506599426, 0.028196975588798523, 0.04861937463283539, -0.03020421415567398, -0.026096001267433167, -0.045247018337249756, -0.006438685581088066, -0.04909627139568329, -0.03218113258481026, -0.010383592918515205, 0.04301609843969345, 0.025517698377370834, -0.026424219831824303, -0.017728935927152634, 0.01567763276398182, 0.00858154147863388, -0.045201871544122696, -0.04656975716352463, 0.022371547296643257, 0.014968953095376492, 0.0009240061044692993, 0.002324459608644247, -0.020891347900032997, -0.006736395414918661, 0.00014246863429434597, -0.006605788599699736, 0.034847427159547806, -0.046321239322423935, 0.0014844719553366303, -0.05067430064082146, -0.00966694112867117, -0.0010569019941613078, -0.02322818711400032, 0.03362586349248886, -0.0017570912605151534, -0.02757773920893669, 0.006383649073541164, 0.029284533113241196, 0.048802051693201065, 0.028958754613995552, -0.02082446590065956, -0.03363051638007164, -0.011444280855357647, -0.0708659291267395, 0.029449593275785446, -0.022125041112303734, 0.00555422343313694, -0.02289600856602192, 0.01406827662140131, 0.04691046103835106, 0.029799684882164, -0.017494702711701393, 0.008710908703505993, -0.00917968899011612, 0.02381894364953041, 0.019937079399824142, -0.06226981058716774, -0.0403582789003849, 0.038466498255729675, -0.012536101043224335, -0.017065340653061867, -0.03933282196521759, 0.08210735023021698, -0.015226469375193119, -0.022188711911439896, -0.0019146051490679383, 0.028580589219927788, -0.0012240211945027113, 0.011796846985816956, 0.04149084538221359, -0.03668868541717529, -0.015727689489722252, -0.02278771996498108, 0.03262694180011749, 0.00006592098361579701, -0.02154557965695858, -0.05793392285704613, -0.043754514306783676, 0.007500631734728813, -0.043006278574466705, -0.01814865879714489, 0.0002573377569206059, -0.024626923725008965, -0.017360292375087738, -0.028818950057029724, -0.01083059050142765, -0.06437176465988159, -0.012430346570909023, 0.02255052886903286, -0.021659674122929573, 0.03535717725753784, -0.02100045047700405, -0.025549443438649178, -0.012757339514791965, 0.05274614319205284, -0.004943749867379665, 0.005945330020040274, -0.01239584106951952, 0.009769076481461525, -0.033379148691892624, 0.05336390808224678, 0.0004379419260658324, -0.047215934842824936, 0.01609113998711109, -0.04434628412127495, -0.02899785153567791, 0.05260147899389267, -0.00032709716469980776, 0.011125718243420124, 0.014350728131830692, 0.015336096286773682, -0.013318333774805069, 0.02059829980134964, -0.01098718959838152, -0.03580232709646225, -0.016943510621786118, -0.041207849979400635, -0.011748855002224445, 0.003725578775629401, -0.003391035133972764, 0.007548048160970211, -0.028091827407479286, 0.024945762008428574, 0.029617181047797203, -0.021947836503386497, -0.023562153801321983, -0.04798337444663048, -0.029286865144968033, 0.036411285400390625, -0.0013717723777517676, 0.006933420896530151, 0.06464949250221252, 0.048861291259527206, -0.031340595334768295, 0.02165427803993225, 0.02729601413011551, 0.006702123209834099, -0.08618617802858353, -0.02677716128528118, -0.008015519939363003, 0.04496755823493004, 0.02259969525039196, -0.06875070184469223, -0.00348849524743855, 0.03503667190670967, -0.010106081143021584, 0.018001742660999298, 0.010420070961117744, 0.031671181321144104, -0.06250112503767014, -0.004036265891045332, -0.026507221162319183, -0.0021765425335615873, -0.008692796342074871, 0.04919175058603287, 0.03850577771663666, 0.014224601909518242, 0.0039145988412201405, -0.024429112672805786, 0.013282665982842445, -0.02302587404847145, 0.043218664824962616, -0.07956093549728394, 0.01956598088145256, -0.041295669972896576, -0.048024505376815796, 0.037923336029052734, -0.04140177741646767, 0.047631047666072845, 0.024723082780838013, 0.004563755821436644, -0.005116719752550125, 0.03289676830172539, 0.033062927424907684, -0.027211464941501617, 0.025532199069857597, -0.003596183843910694, -0.030236506834626198, 0.047229815274477005, -0.0073636979795992374, -0.011324985884130001, -0.0066463821567595005, -0.020590925589203835, 0.006941580679267645, -0.010850212536752224, -0.0036501334980130196, -0.017071425914764404, -0.014375822618603706, -0.023082509636878967, -0.005789341405034065, -0.018609048798680305, 0.01152561604976654, -0.006969634909182787, -0.0370979942381382, 0.030927462503314018, 0.042242422699928284, -0.037254270166158676, 0.015033894218504429, -0.010447829961776733, -0.01699678786098957, -0.017330806702375412, 0.004565537441521883, 0.0062707290053367615, -0.04759692773222923, -0.020366819575428963, -0.009280514903366566, 0.011502605862915516, -0.04550965130329132, 0.038418907672166824, -0.029964638873934746, 0.02339191921055317, -0.057650718837976456, 0.009007781744003296, -0.015125215984880924, -0.030218524858355522, 0.02833273820579052, -0.06490247696638107, 0.05159049108624458, 0.04103609547019005, -0.0002170484367525205, -0.030476849526166916, 0.008685192093253136, -0.0418449267745018, -0.020471151918172836, 0.05345547944307327, -0.009366553276777267, 0.005478002596646547, -0.03115255944430828, -0.009569907560944557, 0.003130170749500394, 0.0003793472424149513, 0.03815634176135063, -0.031629908829927444, 0.00485788332298398, -0.02315012738108635, -0.004158192779868841, -0.016911527141928673, -0.002586057409644127, 0.019747935235500336, -0.011112554930150509, 0.013053909875452518, 0.0035189944319427013, 0.0015221083303913474, 0.0100230248644948, 0.038631368428468704, -0.018115196377038956, 0.017763707786798477, 0.025000562891364098, 0.03327665477991104, 0.02736741118133068, -0.013473356142640114, -0.039376650005578995, 0.0531463660299778, -0.028762564063072205, -0.0027557741850614548, 0.014537421055138111, 0.0020424174144864082, -0.03332897648215294, -0.04603475332260132, 0.0033635911531746387, 0.026633942499756813, -0.003356275847181678, 0.0017546876333653927, 0.03654519468545914, 0.020198792219161987, 0.02411935292184353, 0.00852908380329609, 0.0032735944259911776, 0.016129309311509132, 0.002108246088027954, 0.039675142616033554, 0.024228421971201897, 0.017531925812363625, 0.00287736882455647, -0.01094319112598896, -0.0008087121532298625, 0.009432568214833736, 0.008237045258283615, 0.00601579574868083, 0.03535209223628044, -0.002995121292769909, 0.014620037749409676, 0.013018411584198475, -0.0042389086447656155, 0.052798010408878326, -0.0010115817422047257, -0.0013381247408688068, 0.019511010497808456, -0.07391542196273804, 0.01890544407069683, -0.04173057898879051, -0.025917179882526398, -0.04034699499607086, 0.01527499221265316, 0.06701592355966568, 0.034819912165403366, -0.00028595910407602787, 0.017002137377858162, -0.0041674901731312275, -0.04423202574253082, 0.039149221032857895, 0.0014232560060918331, 0.006982628721743822, -0.017850928008556366, -0.001876181224361062, -0.00570128858089447, -0.02419956773519516, -0.033216122537851334, -0.04651150479912758, 0.02285458892583847, 0.016306407749652863, 0.04089367762207985, -0.03420126810669899, -0.0037967690732330084, -0.00003389428093214519, 0.02653639018535614, -0.049350637942552567, -0.022739339619874954, -0.05281342938542366, -0.002287691691890359, 0.016095811501145363, -0.003501711180433631 ]
<p>I recently read a paper made a logistic regression and used a table like this to summarise the model:</p> <pre><code>data.frame(predictors = c("drat", "mpg"), "chi squared statistic" = c("x", "x"), "p-value" = c("x", "x")) predictors chi.squared.statistic p.value 1 drat x x 2 mpg x x </code></pre> <p>The data.frame presented the chi-squared and p value (the x's) for each predictor in the logistic regression model, and thus allowed to see at a glance which predictors were most important.</p> <p>I have made this logistic regression model:</p> <pre><code>mtcars_log_reg &lt;- glm(vs ~ drat + mpg, mtcars, family = "binomial") </code></pre> <p>How can I fill in the x's for the above table using R code?</p>
74,159
[ -0.024316906929016113, 0.014827768318355083, 0.0027553008403629065, 0.011617477051913738, 0.012686498463153839, 0.03780559077858925, -0.008904529735445976, -0.022367747500538826, 0.03663942962884903, -0.006851676385849714, 0.02439967542886734, 0.046532221138477325, 0.05213680863380432, 0.029657434672117233, 0.061552707105875015, 0.024844177067279816, -0.0317247211933136, -0.0018933842657133937, -0.006445626262575388, -0.026221439242362976, 0.012662245891988277, -0.005470495205372572, 0.012989657931029797, 0.03276081755757332, -0.006374552845954895, 0.07211597263813019, 0.039927903562784195, -0.01092913094907999, 0.02781575731933117, 0.061808936297893524, -0.04470159485936165, -0.005736135877668858, 0.014911577105522156, 0.03585589677095413, 0.026599569246172905, 0.018039630725979805, -0.017423579469323158, -0.015686847269535065, 0.00933040864765644, 0.029546469449996948, -0.0039350129663944244, -0.012662338092923164, 0.04477078095078468, 0.00593952089548111, 0.01844765990972519, 0.008740492165088654, -0.013764245435595512, -0.02218175120651722, 0.05208496376872063, -0.03539133816957474, 0.07366921007633209, -0.022532733157277107, 0.04456786438822746, 0.03857763111591339, -0.037734001874923706, 0.01457286812365055, 0.06241374462842941, 0.06380341202020645, -0.0032999138347804546, -0.05527511611580849, -0.0034365851897746325, -0.016453081741929054, -0.008474616333842278, -0.015191170386970043, -0.031270064413547516, 0.00537704024463892, -0.0214098934084177, -0.01936010643839836, 0.08060413599014282, -0.022195536643266678, 0.0029819554183632135, 0.03552265837788582, 0.027103334665298462, -0.02688143216073513, 0.023165713995695114, -0.05211956053972244, 0.0248259324580431, -0.011543064378201962, 0.017939677461981773, 0.013380303978919983, -0.013295735232532024, 0.016069039702415466, 0.02733195386826992, 0.02837599441409111, -0.022045867517590523, -0.0013808106305077672, 0.03928997367620468, -0.025222010910511017, 0.03312614560127258, 0.036920852959156036, -0.013776722364127636, 0.021043678745627403, 0.050009746104478836, -0.0006665678811259568, -0.026082757860422134, 0.033417701721191406, -0.027059704065322876, 0.05118090659379959, 0.025041600689291954, 0.015637604519724846, 0.012644044123589993, -0.010799414478242397, 0.017352253198623657, 0.022919852286577225, -0.06362640112638474, -0.0051165311597287655, -0.02062903717160225, -0.01657995395362377, 0.004335968755185604, -0.040463436394929886, -0.025876358151435852, 0.004816731903702021, 0.026871228590607643, -0.018034419044852257, 0.013090960681438446, -0.04841423034667969, -0.049008987843990326, 0.0009646730613894761, 0.03553229570388794, 0.0432455949485302, 0.05107693746685982, -0.0037100533954799175, 0.04821959137916565, -0.022523576393723488, -0.06182078644633293, 0.030439814552664757, -0.009742776863276958, 0.02541929855942726, -0.023367533460259438, 0.03906041756272316, -0.03077034465968609, -0.02746216207742691, 0.045401230454444885, 0.03485804423689842, 0.021754110231995583, -0.015278113074600697, -0.07863399386405945, -0.029166758060455322, -0.01264019776135683, -0.016836203634738922, 0.01006312109529972, -0.06838555634021759, -0.011857097037136555, 0.03896743431687355, 0.03547094389796257, 0.019368929788470268, 0.012879817746579647, 0.010312983766198158, -0.013553736731410027, 0.028251152485609055, -0.014647499658167362, -0.0195863489061594, -0.04394807294011116, -0.021432790905237198, -0.00972808338701725, -0.06256011873483658, 0.00640213442966342, 0.02458786405622959, -0.015846241265535355, -0.026884691789746284, 0.042909394949674606, -0.01126547995954752, -0.010792829096317291, -0.02638765424489975, -0.009320401586592197, -0.009829070419073105, 0.05492190644145012, -0.005086726043373346, 0.008962728083133698, 0.01671457476913929, -0.010139239020645618, 0.0008663258631713688, -0.002801179187372327, 0.0481443889439106, 0.049909379333257675, 0.0032187364995479584, -0.006700604688376188, -0.011892341077327728, 0.007621734868735075, 0.037062931805849075, -0.04872402921319008, -0.03231735900044441, -0.015239886939525604, -0.02500549703836441, 0.018986137583851814, 0.03803578391671181, 0.00522799463942647, -0.065000981092453, 0.048624489456415176, -0.05189468339085579, -0.045016057789325714, -0.06698790937662125, 0.010690255090594292, -0.034129705280065536, -0.009090112522244453, -0.004540177062153816, 0.020207839086651802, 0.01473438274115324, -0.004720843862742186, -0.00945362076163292, -0.0413779579102993, -0.042433712631464005, 0.031653162091970444, -0.048604100942611694, -0.048160452395677567, 0.03173846751451492, 0.04952491819858551, -0.041553158313035965, 0.05556221678853035, -0.03121769055724144, -0.007356390822678804, 0.03557296469807625, -0.005582382902503014, -0.0016674433136358857, -0.05440683662891388, -0.01309163123369217, -0.0021569274831563234, 0.027745965868234634, -0.0161345973610878, 0.0332002155482769, -0.07757818698883057, 0.053985003381967545, 0.06555254757404327, 0.01648656837642193, -0.0027050788048654795, -0.03808964043855667, -0.021407559514045715, 0.06432491540908813, -0.01488172635436058, -0.04529711231589317, -0.05181267112493515, -0.010551529936492443, 0.017820294946432114, -0.017066871747374535, -0.0393560528755188, -0.017498109489679337, 0.0585411936044693, -0.010303376242518425, 0.029812494292855263, 0.04134093597531319, -0.016222476959228516, 0.022056372836232185, 0.011306045576930046, -0.0020718614105135202, 0.008234835229814053, 0.005434565711766481, 0.04712677374482155, 0.008772118017077446, 0.031778980046510696, 0.005367637146264315, -0.005500039551407099, 0.03668347746133804, -0.03070114552974701, -0.014636611565947533, -0.04982331395149231, -0.03381248190999031, 0.05341075733304024, -0.012008067220449448, 0.03241389989852905, 0.05141177773475647, 0.04422203078866005, -0.017364460974931717, -0.0012883271556347609, 0.03799969330430031, -0.010712887160480022, 0.06610267609357834, -0.041999999433755875, -0.02203383855521679, 0.00283565791323781, -0.03605266287922859, 0.03789961710572243, -0.019627880305051804, -0.047826409339904785, -0.05839812383055687, 0.05404815077781677, 0.02556842379271984, -0.007826577872037888, 0.026328211650252342, 0.011602015234529972, -0.062219876796007156, -0.019556241109967232, -0.038877636194229126, 0.005879978649318218, 0.00007415592699544504, -0.05266290903091431, -0.04329236224293709, -0.029252149164676666, 0.0028735660016536713, 0.02789483778178692, -0.04176795482635498, -0.033893268555402756, -0.012078926898539066, -0.040498703718185425, -0.04461889714002609, -0.008446590974926949, 0.0035604648292064667, -0.0033909976482391357, 0.0009724019328132272, 0.01857644133269787, 0.013387134298682213, 0.011969010345637798, -0.032228898257017136, 0.022291261702775955, -0.08926297724246979, -0.00963062047958374, -0.025462983176112175, 0.004095365293323994, 0.024659637361764908, -0.0012708030408248305, 0.03285019472241402, 0.007696760818362236, -0.018071793019771576, 0.010560342110693455, -0.06493384391069412, -0.035583920776844025, -0.0012630621204152703, 0.00928441807627678, 0.019077973440289497, -0.008095084689557552, -0.019456109032034874, 0.052984900772571564, 0.029520144686102867, -0.04929496720433235, -0.059728287160396576, 0.0013824583729729056, -0.007008873857557774, -0.0341155119240284, 0.015425152145326138, 0.031165190041065216, 0.02874656580388546, 0.04296012222766876, -0.00008240734314313158, 0.007365892641246319, 0.025020595639944077, 0.019650112837553024, 0.006777724251151085, 0.004780948627740145, 0.00468634394928813, -0.01490311324596405, 0.02694963477551937, 0.011207766830921173, -0.015788577497005463, 0.0331529825925827, -0.0036080777645111084, 0.02184056118130684, -0.03337583318352699, -0.032282911241054535, -0.012742502614855766, -0.015910908579826355, 0.0380324125289917, 0.003080065129324794, 0.012699129059910774, 0.029955275356769562, -0.04737192019820213, -0.005073093809187412, 0.033582039177417755, 0.018933428451418877, -0.013935809023678303, -0.00677921948954463, 0.027927886694669724, 0.013850132934749126, -0.03161308914422989, 0.036917977035045624, 0.0047785439528524876, -0.0010024744551628828, 0.026137525215744972, -0.03233586624264717, -0.03160719946026802, 0.05394774675369263, 0.04574748873710632, 0.007531790062785149, -0.011139551177620888, -0.01039853971451521, 0.048881202936172485, -0.05742109939455986, -0.01482403464615345, -0.015772029757499695, 0.05287142097949982, 0.02853373996913433, 0.03322551026940346, 0.0032213160302489996, -0.0324525460600853, 0.021777845919132233, -0.020119432359933853, -0.06242028623819351, 0.023349720984697342, 0.02926887571811676, 0.0009353287750855088, 0.01831633783876896, -0.04511177912354469, 0.048747897148132324, -0.03455242142081261, 0.010113504715263844, 0.038281869143247604, -0.009794630110263824, -0.030990593135356903, 0.015072617679834366, 0.02681870572268963, -0.002089208224788308, 0.0006554365390911698, 0.009734232909977436, 0.04921063408255577, 0.030983159318566322, 0.010865811258554459, 0.0554177463054657, 0.003218298777937889, -0.0009256714838556945, -0.008448055945336819, 0.011421041563153267, 0.0369449183344841, 0.03138651326298714, 0.01675417460501194, 0.01607660949230194, -0.05130147933959961, 0.03271762654185295, -0.010675936006009579, 0.04646443575620651, 0.06294550001621246, 0.011455105617642403, 0.002549712546169758, -0.0053635165095329285, -0.007485623005777597, -0.00218741106800735, 0.01673833467066288, -0.012272633612155914, 0.012264258228242397, 0.051292095333337784, 0.055591002106666565, -0.04285891726613045, 0.022394772619009018, 0.0510806180536747, 0.009560971520841122, -0.013466169126331806, -0.021125033497810364, 0.02712748944759369, -0.02511722780764103, 0.005720078479498625, 0.007804339751601219, 0.006037184502929449, 0.009112953208386898, 0.0013227283488959074, 0.01692372001707554, -0.017915934324264526, -0.047303128987550735, -0.013245487585663795, 0.025699183344841003, 0.018331360071897507, 0.019433312118053436, -0.03243502229452133, 0.001188861671835184, 0.030297942459583282, 0.018311554566025734, 0.009696127846837044, -0.02275887317955494, -0.07839438319206238, 0.006236062850803137, 0.02853781171143055, 0.06037683039903641, -0.010577959008514881, -0.019523389637470245, -0.014209795743227005, 0.013194875791668892, 0.025408783927559853, -0.01909494958817959, 0.04163498431444168, -0.03180770203471184, -0.00028789418865926564, -0.0008617544081062078, -0.010415717959403992, -0.06199141964316368, -0.0032500638626515865, -0.0433858260512352, 0.02325974777340889, 0.0020236088894307613, -0.04142942279577255, -0.05930470675230026, 0.03733733296394348, -0.02796354703605175, 0.05022371560335159, -0.005033784545958042, -0.026850689202547073, 0.0006753905909135938, 0.04578443989157677, -0.018457887694239616, -0.025332313030958176, -0.006410741247236729, 0.0041383979842066765, -0.022955989465117455, 0.050591178238391876, 0.014986250549554825, -0.015726903453469276, 0.035095080733299255, 0.025579649955034256, -0.0235541220754385, -0.007428282871842384, -0.033633749932050705, -0.004639781080186367, 0.011586200445890427, -0.0005769221461378038, 0.058554671704769135, 0.036272574216127396, -0.0454583615064621, 0.012571264058351517, -0.049386586993932724, -0.0007444858201779425, -0.012406684458255768, -0.023265695199370384, -0.06082064285874367, 0.00264758407138288, -0.013861428946256638, 0.007475178223103285, -0.01706273853778839, 0.012822157703340054, -0.028060920536518097, 0.006713673938065767, 0.018249085173010826, 0.022869301959872246, -0.018062157556414604, 0.001951417070813477, 0.011897191405296326, 0.030670028179883957, 0.01501899678260088, -0.03931809216737747, 0.0199255533516407, -0.01503642275929451, -0.02498398721218109, 0.0031997081823647022, -0.04434515908360481, 0.012897598557174206, -0.0005601798184216022, -0.016745999455451965, 0.011191897094249725, -0.013831821270287037, -0.005499997176229954, 0.0051073599606752396, 0.023416968062520027, -0.017216738313436508, -0.044776201248168945, -0.04079494997859001, 0.027974605560302734, 0.032544247806072235, 0.006533944513648748, -0.03559219464659691, 0.02886415645480156, -0.012166989035904408, -0.004133128095418215, -0.059849537909030914, -0.06649764627218246, 0.024639025330543518, -0.029240943491458893, -0.03818061947822571, -0.030436482280492783, -0.017303811386227608, -0.005781690124422312, 0.007858647033572197, -0.00987547542899847, 0.02286597713828087, -0.0234056543558836, 0.013551317155361176, -0.01692851074039936, 0.0209498330950737, 0.06378808617591858, 0.03411238268017769, -0.025825735181570053, 0.028403390198946, -0.035758983343839645, -0.051894091069698334, 0.023242764174938202, -0.011827739886939526, -0.04168664664030075, -0.006406628061085939, -0.03696400672197342, 0.03377690538764, 0.023510275408625603, 0.0017616814002394676, -0.004276704508811235, -0.010948626324534416, 0.004830687306821346, 0.012519821524620056, -0.05965638905763626, 0.00007222504063975066, -0.017979420721530914, 0.008452876470983028, 0.0031652229372411966, 0.006963169667869806, -0.023144954815506935, 0.010267488658428192, 0.01988651230931282, -0.026554500684142113, 0.03382209688425064, 0.018210487440228462, 0.09840413928031921, 0.029203126206994057, 0.019830932840704918, 0.007020727265626192, -0.026546915993094444, 0.06172293797135353, 0.03302403539419174, -0.014263621531426907, 0.00864624883979559, 0.026396846398711205, -0.0065151480957865715, -0.01865895837545395, -0.0015942155150696635, -0.008123936131596565, 0.053543996065855026, -0.017176523804664612, 0.0268248300999403, 0.04851224273443222, 0.006638262886554003, 0.01701740361750126, -0.028289999812841415, -0.02589464746415615, -0.02208721451461315, 0.03043840080499649, 0.06073373183608055, -0.007503672502934933, -0.0020352748688310385, 0.03255046531558037, -0.005287246312946081, 0.030308950692415237, 0.02606060355901718, 0.010261907242238522, 0.003243898507207632, -0.005925759207457304, 0.007445701397955418, -0.014749943278729916, 0.02966121770441532, -0.011139551177620888, 0.02047475427389145, -0.042249057441949844, -0.016048649325966835, 0.0270511656999588, 0.034460220485925674, 0.022336874157190323, -0.019593138247728348, -0.052713166922330856, -0.0624157190322876, -0.015072635374963284, 0.0006350257317535579, -0.005289947614073753, 0.037395503371953964, -0.001535630552098155, 0.02418970875442028, -0.01171686127781868, 0.007454242091625929, -0.026820603758096695, -0.08473954349756241, -0.00287229148671031, 0.018752513453364372, 0.01099922601133585, 0.03960590437054634, 0.0220250952988863, -0.04394274204969406, 0.013614606112241745, -0.024525925517082214, 0.022565610706806183, -0.031437452882528305, 0.046760015189647675, -0.003644500859081745, 0.08119569718837738, 0.006172852590680122, 0.01598542556166649, -0.004257118795067072, -0.034020859748125076, 0.09659433364868164, 0.06640811264514923, 0.03715232387185097, -0.0640212818980217, 0.009586330503225327, 0.013816320337355137, 0.0062457723543047905, 0.0021493772510439157, -0.017670683562755585, 0.005390047095716, -0.010870859958231449, 0.0297712329775095, 0.025727586820721626, 0.006431101355701685, -0.00012844393495470285, 0.04137064516544342, -0.024555891752243042, -0.04740482196211815, -0.0045423321425914764, 0.011112812906503677, -0.005675846245139837, -0.02385585382580757, -0.08618617802858353, 0.02236894890666008, 0.03832479193806648, -0.03669761121273041, -0.04331544414162636, -0.018752379342913628, -0.012826874852180481, 0.012451726011931896, -0.006159789860248566, 0.009699154645204544, 0.009286019019782543, 0.039070479571819305, -0.014783946797251701, -0.018239619210362434, 0.03065389394760132, 0.025444168597459793, 0.005630117375403643, 0.04600778594613075, 0.006403919775038958, 0.019144462421536446, -0.0027244912926107645, 0.021021191030740738, -0.025875745341181755, -0.01849198155105114, -0.03592315688729286, 0.038595620542764664, -0.024705033749341965, -0.01571638695895672, -0.017503025010228157, 0.04450572282075882, -0.00870458222925663, -0.029940765351057053, -0.04249516502022743, 0.07395578920841217, 0.015145563520491123, -0.0007182899280451238, -0.03002028912305832, 0.002465211320668459, 0.021443160250782967, 0.007858853787183762, 0.03828445449471474, 0.02358075976371765, -0.019940514117479324, -0.007294073235243559, -0.09015470743179321, 0.07143385708332062, -0.03262220695614815, 0.003009781939908862, 0.019767168909311295, -0.017974691465497017, -0.011630823835730553, -0.03926808759570122, 0.013240962289273739, 0.010547637939453125, -0.005123192444443703, -0.017011525109410286, 0.023598521947860718, -0.0019170485902577639, -0.056135281920433044, 0.017135262489318848, -0.010629340074956417, 0.005712929181754589, -0.029658138751983643, -0.019647864624857903, 0.048015959560871124, 0.033201735466718674, -0.003034529509022832, 0.02327408269047737, -0.025216568261384964, 0.05530104786157608, -0.05213092267513275, -0.06665217131376266, -0.03174300491809845, 0.025327205657958984, -0.03702373802661896, -0.017894474789500237, -0.020875433459877968, 0.0875949114561081, 0.0200802069157362, 0.021536825224757195, 0.007992953062057495, 0.044791463762521744, 0.014875148423016071, 0.0061380998231470585, 0.029631685465574265, -0.011562340892851353, 0.01273778360337019, -0.003210460301488638, 0.013821953907608986, -0.016336070373654366, -0.030551711097359657, -0.050670936703681946, -0.06441674381494522, 0.040392275899648666, -0.03472074866294861, -0.05055713281035423, 0.03138478100299835, -0.025839529931545258, -0.005393785424530506, -0.02254362776875496, 0.03135136514902115, -0.07209434360265732, 0.0006975223659537733, 0.008232181891798973, -0.06834704428911209, -0.0035341798793524504, 0.004962352570146322, -0.05238713324069977, 0.03407078608870506, 0.03447471186518669, -0.0000657076234347187, 0.021580688655376434, -0.030780235305428505, 0.007520364597439766, 0.03528992086648941, 0.04549824818968773, -0.05413911119103432, -0.009351026266813278, 0.028338268399238586, -0.05420848727226257, 0.002230301033705473, 0.021754609420895576, -0.01079950388520956, 0.0226010549813509, -0.02309027500450611, 0.026281507685780525, -0.040430326014757156, 0.028390761464834213, -0.03613783046603203, -0.012983376160264015, -0.01496695913374424, 0.0034023697953671217, 0.032451480627059937, -0.00026293250266462564, 0.0038297930732369423, 0.002721058437600732, -0.017854003235697746, -0.006268679164350033, 0.08527475595474243, 0.02903822623193264, -0.00620255246758461, 0.012077673338353634, 0.005092233885079622, 0.036224909126758575, -0.0027711838483810425, -0.010757064446806908, 0.0065996102057397366, 0.04557010903954506, -0.014567346312105656, 0.022473454475402832, -0.020742086693644524, 0.026859451085329056, -0.09116660803556442, -0.06019333004951477, 0.0008868216536939144, 0.011725734919309616, 0.013564471155405045, -0.051388099789619446, -0.014721154235303402, 0.0053926268592476845, -0.009279795922338963, -0.004691257141530514, 0.049364861100912094, -0.02073640562593937, -0.015526763163506985, 0.04085695743560791, 0.011437778361141682, 0.02181337960064411, 0.044352661818265915, 0.006561790127307177, 0.02969030663371086, -0.010141974315047264, 0.015569539740681648, -0.06776134669780731, -0.02202952466905117, 0.022999918088316917, -0.0050042541697621346, -0.047819849103689194, 0.03984891623258591, -0.004167553503066301, -0.03809811919927597, 0.013930277898907661, 0.014978062361478806, 0.04881234094500542, 0.018272776156663895, -0.0005947043537162244, 0.021737096831202507, 0.07555091381072998, 0.023017337545752525, 0.001865821541287005, 0.002990284701809287, 0.03843623027205467, 0.03814707696437836, 0.021162541583180428, -0.040382321923971176, 0.02748558111488819, 0.03740938380360603, -0.0033101721201092005, -0.015666062012314796, 0.029455527663230896, -0.0022842010948807, 0.015011594630777836, -0.04847249016165733, -0.0019541513174772263, 0.026049267500638962, -0.05037212744355202, -0.01787470653653145, -0.07379986345767975, 0.00438110064715147, 0.03174540773034096, 0.03373384103178978, -0.03645035997033119, 0.03793435916304588, -0.005805728491395712, -0.017618410289287567, 0.003447020659223199, 0.0258285254240036, -0.012018449604511261, -0.02732483670115471, 0.0037821971345692873, 0.02147052064538002, -0.025909721851348877, -0.004248233512043953, 0.0074221910908818245, -0.0661528930068016, 0.020296037197113037, -0.043634235858917236, 0.008497845381498337, 0.054671965539455414, -0.005509822629392147, 0.055678077042102814, -0.07871342450380325, 0.05256202816963196, 0.011355620808899403, -0.020227478817105293, -0.03754160925745964, -0.012880041263997555, -0.027643958106637, 0.018784064799547195, 0.042327880859375, 0.009566619992256165, -0.001484544831328094, -0.03251899406313896, 0.03890563175082207, -0.017790572717785835, -0.024984031915664673, 0.04497268423438072, 0.006546373479068279, -0.02309984527528286, -0.036490511149168015, -0.014950231648981571, 0.007210939656943083, 0.0002952753275167197, 0.023060237988829613, 0.004505236633121967, -0.007703517563641071, -0.013302179984748363, -0.045863259583711624, 0.01014864630997181, -0.02040000632405281, -0.01819872297346592, 0.022701773792505264, -0.0007554474868811667, -0.0106514235958457, 0.07298379391431808, 0.011679768562316895, -0.05883810296654701, 0.02531168982386589, -0.09281104058027267, -0.03433399647474289, 0.03537524491548538, -0.02779654785990715, 0.003162044333294034, -0.020718101412057877, 0.03711174055933952, 0.025640692561864853, -0.009794538840651512, -0.012135625816881657, 0.030357347801327705, 0.040885258466005325, 0.04256197437644005, -0.02190241776406765, -0.01781499944627285, -0.025505227968096733, -0.062105175107717514, -0.009004378691315651, 0.0008981840801425278, -0.006081790663301945, 0.023806624114513397, 0.003058207454159856, 0.012370544485747814, -0.021126197651028633, 0.03924669325351715, 0.012268267571926117, 0.040369827300310135, -0.02269561216235161, 0.009956962428987026, 0.007645907811820507, -0.04045337438583374, 0.040010616183280945, -0.015852902084589005, -0.012990378774702549, 0.03587060049176216, -0.04425384849309921, -0.0008666703943163157, -0.06436795741319656, -0.005774510558694601, -0.048425137996673584, -0.01041912566870451, 0.02027839422225952, 0.043756432831287384, -0.02317836508154869, 0.02718738280236721, 0.034158170223236084, 0.0022643147967755795, 0.0013251103227958083, -0.005820577032864094, 0.021998250856995583, -0.023400885984301567, 0.003003291320055723, 0.00226926663890481, -0.016852956265211105, -0.018140027299523354, 0.009735530242323875, 0.05075860023498535, 0.03313630819320679, 0.0008110333001241088, -0.05613836646080017, -0.010361219756305218, -0.017457017675042152, 0.048046767711639404, -0.051034118980169296, -0.011284161359071732, -0.028757095336914062, -0.001485233660787344, 0.011065413244068623, -0.040094371885061264 ]
<p>Actually I thought Gaussian Process is a kind of Bayesian method, since I read many tutorials in which GP is presented in Bayesian context, for example, in this <a href="http://see.stanford.edu/materials/aimlcs229/cs229-gp.pdf" rel="nofollow">tutorial</a>, just pay attention to page 10.</p> <p>Suppose the GP prior is $$\pmatrix{h\\ h^*} \sim N\left(0,\pmatrix{K(X,X)&amp;K(X,X^*)\\ K(X^*,X)&amp;K(X^*,X^*)}\right)$$, $(h,X)$ is for the observed training data, $(h^*,X^*)$ for the test data to be predicted. And the actually observed noisy output is $$Y=h+\epsilon$$, where $\epsilon$ is the noise, $$\epsilon\sim N(0,\sigma^2I)$$. And now as shown in the tutorial, we have $$\pmatrix{Y,Y^*}=\pmatrix{h\\ h^*}+\pmatrix{\epsilon\\ \epsilon^*}\sim N\left(0,\pmatrix{K(X,X)+\sigma^2I&amp;K(X,X^*)\\ K(X^*,X)&amp;K(X^*,X^*)+\sigma^*I}\right)$$, and finally by conditioning on $Y$, we could have $p(Y^*|Y)$, which is called as predictive distribution in some books or tutorials, but also called posterior in others.</p> <p><strong>QUESTION</strong></p> <ol> <li><p>According to many tutorials, the predictive distribution $p(Y^*|Y)$ is derived by conditioning on $Y$, if this is correct, I don't understand why GP Regression is Bayesian? Nothing about Bayesian is used in this conditional distribution derivation, right?</p></li> <li><p>However, I don't actually think the predictive distribution should be just the conditional distribution, I think it should be $$p(Y^*|Y)=\int p(Y^*|h^*)p(h^*|h)p(h|Y)dh$$, in the above formula, $p(h|Y)$ is the posterior, right?</p></li> </ol>
74,160
[ -0.009912724606692791, 0.002884770045056939, 0.04544352367520332, -0.06912892311811447, 0.04172360524535179, 0.014421424828469753, -0.01112437155097723, -0.0415826141834259, 0.01608647219836712, -0.042228586971759796, 0.04416946694254875, 0.018724311143159866, 0.08473284542560577, 0.01232980377972126, 0.020314322784543037, 0.0345127210021019, -0.03318486735224724, 0.034992534667253494, 0.0010911677964031696, 0.0071278223767876625, 0.002381320344284177, 0.016464270651340485, 0.0006103229243308306, -0.021294819191098213, -0.021371694281697273, 0.032653503119945526, 0.009866115637123585, -0.006723830010741949, -0.018286731094121933, 0.044432397931814194, -0.03339150547981262, -0.02198498323559761, 0.012928796000778675, 0.013061829842627048, -0.002552089747041464, -0.0023820113856345415, -0.0032747345976531506, -0.021223433315753937, -0.02362017333507538, 0.019768308848142624, -0.023289812728762627, -0.030782580375671387, 0.020135818049311638, 0.04049159958958626, -0.03357141092419624, 0.02483166754245758, -0.013515384867787361, -0.043165173381567, 0.03545346111059189, -0.020120741799473763, 0.022383088245987892, -0.014253196306526661, 0.0031982571817934513, 0.05379154905676842, -0.013007734902203083, 0.014308294281363487, 0.05841667950153351, 0.06469180434942245, -0.03565213456749916, -0.06797751784324646, -0.0023469196166843176, -0.021463638171553612, 0.0052636610344052315, -0.018084820359945297, -0.018121536821126938, -0.003004883648827672, 0.006058815401047468, -0.03731849044561386, -0.00656963000074029, -0.016467170789837837, 0.010739103890955448, 0.01194754522293806, 0.018258051946759224, -0.03848454728722572, 0.0464344322681427, 0.026501266285777092, -0.031852494925260544, 0.050669241696596146, 0.043022383004426956, -0.0007296356488950551, 0.028007440268993378, 0.0033260309137403965, -0.001517620636150241, 0.02461579628288746, -0.013382602483034134, 0.008786100894212723, 0.06583479791879654, -0.013025783933699131, 0.03892598673701286, 0.010907076299190521, -0.041465919464826584, 0.018216457217931747, 0.010001403279602528, -0.04220079258084297, -0.011309792287647724, 0.07964341342449188, -0.0011110928608104587, 0.0008014941122382879, -0.012942705303430557, -0.023922450840473175, -0.014527380466461182, -0.04011707752943039, -0.029645316302776337, 0.06800113618373871, -0.034891389310359955, -0.023159490898251534, 0.0035005377139896154, 0.010214890353381634, -0.0379028394818306, -0.04012921079993248, -0.06006235629320145, 0.03778856247663498, -0.02608138881623745, 0.012613287195563316, -0.011902841739356518, -0.007918287068605423, 0.010535904206335545, -0.030808893963694572, 0.05262897536158562, 0.06932083517313004, 0.006291789468377829, -0.01627355068922043, 0.009384128265082836, -0.03847378492355347, -0.037960365414619446, 0.008996566757559776, 0.030295025557279587, -0.029562128707766533, -0.03308563306927681, 0.03134100139141083, 0.014813735149800777, -0.008642072789371014, 0.03154647722840309, 0.025634171441197395, -0.005164093337953091, 0.007271008566021919, -0.09691321849822998, -0.01851639710366726, 0.03463707119226456, -0.03271898999810219, 0.04434043914079666, -0.031245289370417595, 0.005815625656396151, 0.025432473048567772, 0.03910118713974953, -0.023519370704889297, 0.04131704941391945, 0.02711864747107029, 0.01082376204431057, -0.005234632641077042, -0.020874936133623123, -0.0259964931756258, -0.010907882824540138, -0.010592681355774403, -0.04357010871171951, -0.0705200582742691, 0.002858063904568553, 0.01509336568415165, -0.010835971683263779, -0.011104503646492958, 0.023894261568784714, 0.005901474971324205, -0.013344842940568924, -0.007403873372823, 0.004514382220804691, -0.062236618250608444, 0.0587468296289444, 0.05697931721806526, 0.07012707740068436, 0.02984078973531723, -0.020758092403411865, 0.005289849359542131, -0.006251869723200798, 0.05156301334500313, 0.04442698881030083, -0.040751826018095016, -0.0009864429011940956, -0.03438057377934456, 0.0012179827317595482, -0.01792106032371521, -0.07507695257663727, -0.002344621578231454, 0.030706381425261497, 0.015516833402216434, -0.026902321726083755, 0.020987417548894882, 0.03458673879504204, 0.02235422469675541, 0.030180640518665314, -0.058879200369119644, -0.03481326997280121, -0.0753999799489975, -0.007277338299900293, 0.009832555428147316, -0.0030169205274432898, 0.04010223597288132, -0.025162599980831146, -0.0005313663277775049, 0.009645561687648296, -0.020172638818621635, -0.026563281193375587, -0.005979984998703003, 0.025219706818461418, -0.030333418399095535, 0.02272249199450016, 0.07648522406816483, 0.030933387577533722, 0.03142249211668968, 0.053839292377233505, -0.04015333577990532, -0.01826402172446251, 0.003791721072047949, -0.015226492658257484, -0.0066062090918421745, -0.008640688844025135, -0.05690618231892586, 0.03477272018790245, -0.002091513480991125, -0.021195314824581146, 0.0011464942945167422, -0.0846630111336708, 0.033462781459093094, 0.1030697375535965, -0.007045416161417961, -0.016531862318515778, -0.017044033855199814, -0.028605062514543533, 0.033840592950582504, -0.016957875341176987, 0.0011393798049539328, -0.02276039496064186, -0.03190477937459946, 0.02096499130129814, 0.04048800840973854, -0.025761062279343605, 0.009316092357039452, 0.04107389226555824, 0.040532369166612625, 0.006744288839399815, 0.02511250041425228, -0.010007411241531372, -0.05096472054719925, 0.028898606076836586, -0.03320375457406044, 0.0016273619839921594, 0.011702509596943855, 0.016021940857172012, 0.02837585099041462, 0.05417554825544357, 0.0005511417402885854, -0.005197241902351379, 0.07357200235128403, 0.006606232840567827, -0.009037856012582779, -0.026534846052527428, -0.012425696477293968, -0.006859472952783108, 0.006937715224921703, 0.008631216362118721, 0.023958228528499603, 0.0038504258263856173, -0.025436215102672577, -0.06414567679166794, -0.016430577263236046, -0.008841234259307384, 0.047209709882736206, -0.038290947675704956, 0.03661048412322998, 0.0280615147203207, -0.042381126433610916, 0.03116619773209095, -0.009300808422267437, 0.011662590317428112, -0.02237793058156967, -0.0015591215342283249, 0.049640268087387085, 0.01854890026152134, -0.0035396486055105925, -0.041438449174165726, -0.026774149388074875, 0.012451767921447754, 0.0055625829845666885, 0.05463476479053497, 0.016430091112852097, -0.02926049940288067, -0.02455064281821251, -0.06710588932037354, 0.001985246315598488, 0.029205653816461563, -0.01266782358288765, -0.014635330997407436, -0.024102833122015, -0.022559233009815216, -0.0548202320933342, -0.024231398478150368, -0.028195584192872047, -0.0029475486371666193, -0.01622942090034485, -0.009174933657050133, 0.06446985900402069, 0.014810962602496147, -0.0054739248007535934, 0.027640989050269127, 0.01433551125228405, -0.017178645357489586, -0.037168797105550766, -0.029201366007328033, -0.00560030248016119, 0.000035387842217460275, 0.049854401499032974, 0.049623195081949234, -0.03340214863419533, -0.00567295216023922, -0.050446901470422745, -0.03357711806893349, 0.019852107390761375, 0.00004146456194575876, 0.013928703032433987, 0.002945271320641041, 0.0017349598929286003, 0.08182675391435623, 0.013787595555186272, -0.01398392766714096, -0.00554627226665616, 0.009590042755007744, -0.03974100202322006, -0.01844269596040249, 0.02041180618107319, 0.003999986220151186, 0.01935115084052086, 0.024434156715869904, -0.02180064655840397, -0.010760600678622723, 0.045426007360219955, 0.009976061061024666, -0.006485086865723133, -0.009360498748719692, -0.022535404190421104, -0.005914452485740185, 0.01815810799598694, -0.00973664689809084, -0.03354283794760704, -0.02067858725786209, 0.02179352380335331, 0.020054148510098457, 0.027913084253668785, -0.045362118631601334, 0.012742279097437859, -0.010879508219659328, -0.02019645646214485, -0.0386800654232502, 0.03332291916012764, 0.010651882737874985, -0.048417069017887115, -0.023817287757992744, -0.020345192402601242, 0.017541904002428055, -0.005416089203208685, 0.008398355916142464, 0.018326716497540474, 0.017968682572245598, -0.002713834634050727, -0.01993558369576931, -0.002926778281107545, -0.03513243421912193, 0.05513761565089226, -0.0006374540971592069, -0.007760791108012199, -0.019886553287506104, 0.010856175795197487, 0.00231228768825531, 0.010228779166936874, -0.004637827165424824, 0.008863665163516998, -0.0369732528924942, 0.02604656293988228, -0.010325971059501171, 0.032265421003103256, -0.009783254005014896, 0.043221570551395416, 0.016061976552009583, -0.015836898237466812, 0.022785017266869545, -0.015447288751602173, -0.05801783502101898, -0.02802197076380253, 0.009361887350678444, -0.05781060829758644, 0.03367481380701065, -0.016484804451465607, 0.07077735662460327, -0.03139662742614746, 0.031787049025297165, -0.016470756381750107, -0.0012504199985414743, -0.03015143983066082, 0.021397072821855545, -0.055587075650691986, -0.024799734354019165, -0.005046555306762457, -0.0018633927684277296, 0.03258960694074631, -0.013258373364806175, 0.021422307938337326, 0.04394178092479706, -0.0043552410788834095, 0.005176390055567026, 0.025545958429574966, 0.03923816233873367, 0.033817119896411896, 0.025217682123184204, 0.044951651245355606, 0.06811520457267761, -0.018889058381319046, 0.03984328731894493, 0.008459470234811306, 0.07629654556512833, 0.07593163102865219, -0.04898826405405998, -0.0022635054774582386, -0.030845388770103455, -0.05232527107000351, 0.01819537952542305, 0.02027800679206848, 0.017103243619203568, -0.02724381536245346, 0.02664661407470703, -0.01680489256978035, -0.01704079657793045, 0.00881538912653923, 0.045052919536828995, 0.0010954764438793063, -0.006722691003233194, 0.008674715645611286, -0.007422630209475756, 0.0027594859711825848, -0.010542651638388634, 0.02269771695137024, -0.0115928640589118, -0.025026043877005577, -0.021566476672887802, 0.03659622371196747, 0.016709666699171066, -0.01115784328430891, -0.008620058186352253, 0.05944414436817169, 0.014749095775187016, 0.009906740859150887, -0.02859335206449032, 0.01481163315474987, 0.05577453225851059, 0.04343471676111221, 0.009018844924867153, -0.0017173505621030927, -0.03167688846588135, -0.010977545753121376, 0.04410192742943764, 0.0017048268346115947, -0.005182672291994095, 0.008728071115911007, -0.05372803285717964, -0.06399267166852951, 0.00260099652223289, -0.00019544553651940078, 0.008150523528456688, -0.0164053812623024, 0.017177769914269447, 0.009113187901675701, -0.009286751970648766, -0.06305330991744995, -0.002438078634440899, -0.016452666372060776, 0.010966047644615173, -0.05005292221903801, -0.022011974826455116, -0.0012042755261063576, -0.040422048419713974, -0.028345415368676186, 0.04921577125787735, -0.027917567640542984, -0.018187301233410835, 0.009458872489631176, 0.053319577127695084, 0.00484564108774066, -0.07108178734779358, 0.03339086472988129, 0.04043317213654518, -0.0022514646407216787, 0.056012049317359924, -0.038045238703489304, -0.05473433434963226, 0.027194390073418617, 0.024869132786989212, -0.02933722920715809, 0.016430292278528214, -0.01830725185573101, 0.037702642381191254, 0.012184616178274155, 0.012248196639120579, 0.06849699467420578, -0.0008190102525986731, -0.01815866492688656, -0.01823948137462139, -0.05955006182193756, -0.003926871344447136, -0.04746086895465851, -0.003345842007547617, -0.049425236880779266, 0.012323953211307526, 0.012255626730620861, 0.040334004908800125, 0.035318974405527115, 0.04518820717930794, -0.03162054345011711, -0.022826705127954483, 0.012447883374989033, 0.017071956768631935, -0.018448159098625183, 0.034281160682439804, -0.0448601134121418, 0.015922527760267258, 0.024945680052042007, 0.003926857840269804, 0.00013696716632694006, 0.001470262068323791, 0.024972906336188316, 0.026618022471666336, -0.001047807396389544, -0.00902634859085083, -0.023680565878748894, -0.012128040194511414, 0.04030351713299751, 0.005864408332854509, 0.0421144962310791, 0.015513262711465359, 0.005505767650902271, 0.014875425957143307, -0.045123837888240814, -0.020078208297491074, -0.003390974598005414, -0.0165171567350626, 0.0040664575062692165, 0.001696878345683217, -0.030272575095295906, 0.014994760043919086, -0.005329286679625511, -0.05417850613594055, 0.00010326586198061705, 0.006471568252891302, -0.04560396820306778, -0.03584088757634163, -0.027035381644964218, 0.007043417077511549, -0.02419046312570572, -0.06484071910381317, -0.002430716995149851, 0.009567329660058022, -0.031449515372514725, -0.02860858105123043, 0.018699022009968758, 0.004071387462317944, 0.040186505764722824, 0.019752826541662216, -0.013483093120157719, 0.008863350376486778, -0.01913643814623356, 0.0016811257228255272, 0.012844759039580822, 0.028982942923903465, -0.024672621861100197, 0.003635856555774808, -0.05122769996523857, -0.031065410003066063, 0.024754900485277176, -0.004257270134985447, -0.017501313239336014, 0.012839434668421745, 0.02988416887819767, -0.01028467621654272, -0.04540053755044937, -0.05477035045623779, -0.007439601235091686, 0.00005565694300457835, -0.005493802484124899, -0.028096361085772514, 0.022927911952137947, 0.007899600081145763, 0.06767785549163818, 0.0008705091895535588, 0.005154748912900686, 0.01987161487340927, 0.05849189683794975, -0.024727165699005127, 0.015576555393636227, 0.010031532496213913, -0.017846902832388878, 0.032740458846092224, 0.003642793744802475, 0.02569909393787384, 0.05361344665288925, 0.0254406426101923, -0.03753615543246269, -0.012108596973121166, -0.09407876431941986, 0.022737307474017143, 0.05797684192657471, -0.013450869359076023, 0.0612335205078125, 0.0128162931650877, -0.01830679178237915, -0.015885721892118454, -0.038940999656915665, -0.0031714460346847773, -0.010497997514903545, 0.006870131008327007, 0.0031859518494457006, -0.02118714153766632, -0.011194474063813686, 0.043185699731111526, 0.0028031880501657724, -0.040542121976614, 0.002469074446707964, -0.00812778901308775, 0.0313500314950943, 0.001870220061391592, -0.059763677418231964, -0.033639173954725266, 0.028000852093100548, -0.03059227019548416, 0.02941378951072693, -0.05095133185386658, -0.03560655191540718, 0.016964031383395195, 0.06714098155498505, 0.007555685471743345, -0.04726913943886757, -0.012560793198645115, -0.07603286951780319, 0.009433435276150703, 0.02220163680613041, -0.021547872573137283, 0.03543548658490181, -0.000881062587723136, 0.015085187740623951, 0.020870115607976913, 0.044251449406147, -0.0364597886800766, -0.09175947308540344, -0.02431500144302845, -0.01490131113678217, 0.006775460671633482, 0.028167428448796272, 0.019555602222681046, -0.058407846838235855, 0.00801988784223795, -0.014435823075473309, 0.04584449902176857, 0.04720873385667801, 0.030486248433589935, -0.02857166901230812, 0.1033744290471077, -0.028316808864474297, 0.019608985632658005, -0.007915708236396313, -0.008627423085272312, 0.14180119335651398, 0.08725612610578537, 0.029490891844034195, -0.04192061722278595, 0.009150524623692036, -0.020051229745149612, -0.03392454981803894, -0.0180727019906044, 0.0058703371323645115, 0.015528485178947449, -0.02895018830895424, 0.010206433944404125, 0.016297869384288788, 0.0021906450856477022, -0.0020430157892405987, 0.03620588406920433, -0.04012933745980263, -0.03625664487481117, -0.008287333883345127, -0.00038722524186596274, -0.020199328660964966, 0.005710358265787363, -0.005946778692305088, 0.0095291119068861, -0.010973434895277023, 0.01201627217233181, -0.015323314815759659, 0.0016704217996448278, 0.006369388196617365, 0.027186287567019463, 0.016511529684066772, -0.0068043130449950695, -0.01588195189833641, -0.01779693178832531, 0.017375456169247627, 0.009436678141355515, 0.030467063188552856, -0.03593629226088524, -0.0031986141111701727, 0.020107755437493324, -0.012378405779600143, -0.001971675781533122, 0.006776758935302496, -0.004699256736785173, -0.015452542342245579, -0.022516578435897827, -0.04945949837565422, 0.08647728711366653, -0.018284281715750694, 0.01123619731515646, -0.00961437076330185, 0.0004095999465789646, 0.005614453926682472, -0.043599195778369904, 0.03452713415026665, 0.04702893644571304, 0.07341297715902328, -0.025067031383514404, -0.023413097485899925, -0.01789897494018078, 0.03180760517716408, -0.022386934608221054, 0.0517534576356411, 0.008183919824659824, -0.03968445956707001, -0.04028354957699776, -0.025070710107684135, 0.04879514500498772, 0.006646996829658747, 0.046776074916124344, 0.013463511131703854, -0.008767515420913696, -0.006824397016316652, -0.06800463050603867, -0.007457902189344168, 0.009411564096808434, 0.005144870840013027, -0.0064745633862912655, -0.01296708919107914, -0.020485147833824158, -0.04261806234717369, 0.03217971324920654, -0.04527349770069122, -0.0017065145075321198, -0.03228342905640602, -0.04011853039264679, 0.005820956081151962, 0.060458939522504807, 0.02237970568239689, 0.0020743203349411488, -0.009061590768396854, 0.01186166238039732, 0.043957244604825974, -0.0459066703915596, -0.06677598506212234, 0.023686138913035393, -0.03918571025133133, -0.002951652742922306, 0.023937908932566643, 0.05741589143872261, 0.03886077553033829, 0.0507362000644207, -0.03004913032054901, 0.025667496025562286, -0.009262817911803722, -0.0219112616032362, -0.019542735069990158, -0.008608284406363964, 0.03531888127326965, 0.019656268879771233, 0.03087441436946392, -0.03455852344632149, 0.018359124660491943, 0.02270563505589962, -0.016911575570702553, 0.012822893448174, -0.012962237000465393, -0.023753993213176727, 0.016336368396878242, 0.003421052126213908, 0.05038062110543251, -0.008600154891610146, 0.0020428691059350967, 0.01143761444836855, 0.015777161344885826, 0.01191618386656046, 0.005481919273734093, -0.01825771853327751, -0.004447436425834894, 0.003564936574548483, -0.022499466314911842, 0.0413094237446785, -0.011438995599746704, 0.029689226299524307, -0.009722196497023106, 0.0342692993581295, -0.02851218171417713, 0.022529318928718567, -0.0009370240150019526, -0.025211172178387642, 0.03250754624605179, -0.06064401566982269, -0.05603897199034691, 0.027571862563490868, 0.04009241610765457, 0.03554384782910347, -0.0007885977393016219, 0.02878568135201931, -0.043648611754179, 0.0023030538577586412, -0.023751309141516685, 0.00426770094782114, -0.014687076210975647, 0.006208732258528471, -0.023241961374878883, -0.03861318528652191, 0.041402291506528854, 0.012830558232963085, 0.02980344370007515, 0.0243599321693182, 0.004901848267763853, -0.008462897501885891, -0.013415742665529251, 0.02205846458673477, -0.0516018345952034, 0.012180225923657417, 0.022885451093316078, 0.02860993891954422, -0.015545259229838848, 0.011445914395153522, -0.013169495388865471, 0.03345821052789688, -0.0068583241663873196, -0.003952991217374802, -0.06777451932430267, -0.01043129712343216, 0.059364672750234604, 0.012477179057896137, 0.06933557242155075, -0.016065066680312157, -0.004159793257713318, 0.04128541797399521, -0.0499374195933342, 0.04741319641470909, 0.04900656268000603, -0.018402449786663055, -0.010216258466243744, 0.009330782108008862, -0.022355414927005768, 0.030824368819594383, 0.017772430554032326, 0.0173443965613842, 0.039636626839637756, 0.040464531630277634, 0.024065200239419937, -0.02624581567943096, -0.02423132210969925, 0.013585674576461315, 0.01279853843152523, -0.013475590385496616, 0.03670087829232216, -0.026070360094308853, -0.002246321877464652, 0.016062114387750626, 0.0697515681385994, 0.01535650622099638, -0.02335430681705475, 0.0267621036618948, 0.01833069883286953, 0.017723971977829933, 0.03251634165644646, -0.002505732234567404, 0.006457099691033363, 0.013330060057342052, -0.0003784766886383295, 0.03896887227892876, 0.035985179245471954, 0.021361205726861954, -0.019742406904697418, -0.03363102301955223, -0.016459988430142403, 0.03210790082812309, -0.020574355497956276, -0.034429993480443954, 0.028670424595475197, 0.013115736655890942, -0.03767696022987366, -0.019677985459566116, 0.0016051232814788818, -0.05106162279844284, 0.03305967524647713, 0.03950529918074608, -0.013262112624943256, -0.029458971694111824, 0.013408893719315529, -0.02643713541328907, -0.06497196853160858, 0.04380384087562561, -0.02770192362368107, -0.011506070382893085, -0.04032781720161438, 0.0050573041662573814, 0.024199441075325012, -0.04880203306674957, -0.01997297629714012, -0.005881136748939753, -0.06525182723999023, 0.026214510202407837, -0.021322738379240036, 0.01580948941409588, -0.02358691394329071, -0.00048760679783299565, 0.001186972949653864, -0.05091715231537819, 0.0791543647646904, 0.021591544151306152, -0.058643486350774765, -0.018932215869426727, -0.0071032983250916, -0.014305494725704193, -0.008110901340842247, 0.033830612897872925, 0.03370172902941704, -0.011403035372495651, -0.0032206857576966286, 0.03087664023041725, 0.01313695777207613, -0.07883339375257492, 0.028555449098348618, 0.010302765294909477, -0.00674937991425395, -0.03219855576753616, 0.0051694586873054504, 0.005498948041349649, 0.04427351802587509, 0.020943930372595787, 0.0003595643793232739, 0.0308965053409338, 0.020548956468701363, -0.012843058444559574, 0.014751242473721504, 0.016149967908859253, 0.01663566380739212, 0.06776295602321625, -0.043462302535772324, 0.0004885845119133592, 0.03626328706741333, -0.006197915878146887, -0.05476696044206619, -0.028866007924079895, -0.00623904587700963, -0.023618435487151146, -0.017697762697935104, -0.02159086987376213, 0.006584382150322199, -0.040035948157310486, -0.015381152741611004, 0.055232927203178406, -0.047845494002103806, 0.0061546750366687775, 0.05220915004611015, 0.02317708171904087, 0.04297708719968796, -0.005130968987941742, 0.004652054514735937, 0.012353473342955112, -0.018992049619555473, 0.014806938357651234, 0.03686818853020668, 0.0470050573348999, -0.017781468108296394, 0.004359815269708633, 0.015723126009106636, 0.0028985165990889072, 0.002000080654397607, -0.00510409427806735, 0.044828902930021286, -0.0552251935005188, -0.011105491779744625, -0.0009082941105589271, -0.04893781989812851, -0.020829394459724426, -0.003836243413388729, 0.007386478595435619, 0.0657641664147377, -0.039589591324329376, -0.03643111512064934, -0.004146014805883169, 0.021606802940368652, -0.022851141169667244, -0.003828653832897544, -0.002459248760715127, 0.024960367009043694, 0.013197586871683598, 0.010964586399495602, 0.018547801300883293, -0.03289071470499039, 0.018154315650463104, -0.06569494307041168, -0.0065468186512589455, 0.06540616601705551, -0.006281429436057806, 0.004502248950302601, -0.036072321236133575, -0.010328751988708973, -0.03135163336992264, 0.021374667063355446, 0.01928022690117359, 0.015638673678040504, -0.06485136598348618, -0.018925314769148827, -0.004110629204660654, 0.015660010278224945, -0.044384315609931946, 0.050613515079021454, -0.01875706948339939, 0.003970439545810223, 0.010532018728554249, -0.00972205214202404 ]
<p>I have a two data-sets of a set of subjects with values for their baseline and followup visit. I would like to do a repeated measure test to see whether there is a significant difference between the two sets (baseline &amp; followup). I know I can do a simple paired t-test. But I need to adjust my values for covariates like age, etc...</p> <p>I would like to perform a GLM method (if possible) to see whether there is a significant difference between the two sets with the covariate adjustments. Please advice how can I do this in R.</p>
74,161
[ -0.03157506510615349, 0.017385460436344147, -0.009635094553232193, 0.033838022500276566, 0.011927171610295773, 0.022037435322999954, 0.029935820028185844, -0.03483949229121208, 0.05042886361479759, -0.0021215432789176702, 0.052796412259340286, 0.049261655658483505, 0.05430776625871658, -0.013039862737059593, 0.04407459497451782, -0.004138858988881111, -0.016638468950986862, -0.02035091631114483, -0.00808167364448309, 0.023055430501699448, -0.014411102049052715, -0.001535154297016561, 0.024353962391614914, -0.00990288332104683, -0.03499038890004158, 0.037257831543684006, 0.01687813363969326, -0.05512940511107445, -0.015185976400971413, 0.04825899749994278, -0.07310793548822403, -0.028518274426460266, -0.007240902632474899, 0.02278982847929001, 0.008262863382697105, -0.03656933084130287, -0.05620082467794418, -0.005655193235725164, -0.012228207662701607, 0.024447308853268623, -0.019662929698824883, -0.05152563005685806, 0.014740991406142712, 0.036758676171302795, 0.023608440533280373, 0.002998148323968053, -0.04376915842294693, -0.034449443221092224, 0.03953178972005844, -0.03156774863600731, 0.060215774923563004, 0.002710485365241766, 0.07433996349573135, 0.0357096828520298, -0.0027452826034277678, -0.007421604823321104, 0.0729181244969368, 0.05935124307870865, 0.016982929781079292, -0.03385350853204727, -0.028005393221974373, -0.04886495694518089, 0.014530197717249393, -0.0020037961658090353, -0.05910707265138626, 0.0036832003388553858, -0.01875879429280758, -0.00181538553442806, -0.002896443009376526, -0.03778780996799469, 0.004504830110818148, 0.017166586592793465, 0.047985050827264786, -0.01916465349495411, -0.004605523310601711, -0.019628051668405533, 0.00007413722778437659, -0.009343042969703674, 0.024087075144052505, 0.05422213301062584, -0.009870465844869614, -0.030274352058768272, 0.01222698949277401, 0.057946715503931046, 0.0009487865027040243, -0.02408854104578495, 0.0556933656334877, -0.018731866031885147, 0.004059562459588051, 0.061139483004808426, 0.0055962237529456615, -0.011924421414732933, 0.06838086992502213, 0.02380475029349327, -0.06266934424638748, 0.018431538715958595, -0.017766853794455528, 0.02742086350917816, -0.005262927617877722, 0.027585361152887344, -0.007395969238132238, -0.061459049582481384, 0.0298946313560009, 0.01724545657634735, -0.015476550906896591, 0.007005946710705757, -0.018223503604531288, -0.00820221472531557, 0.011994770728051662, -0.013134857639670372, -0.011134940199553967, 0.02889016829431057, -0.00805691722780466, -0.026845252141356468, 0.04768316447734833, -0.033610425889492035, -0.04163793846964836, -0.047659099102020264, 0.056387729942798615, 0.05712093040347099, 0.07180952280759811, -0.018603254109621048, 0.005764213390648365, -0.022265512496232986, -0.03430808335542679, -0.009304496459662914, 0.01823997311294079, -0.05312506854534149, -0.021531065925955772, 0.0830783098936081, -0.018469376489520073, -0.013600731268525124, 0.025288593024015427, -0.006868790835142136, 0.014624263159930706, 0.0037412247620522976, -0.06287185847759247, -0.024775518104434013, 0.009768226183950901, -0.022296106442809105, 0.011288360692560673, -0.0663667842745781, 0.016654126346111298, -0.00828294176608324, 0.0305907242000103, 0.04568682610988617, 0.02571215108036995, 0.01903795823454857, 0.004434176720678806, 0.011338163167238235, -0.004072579089552164, -0.021120421588420868, -0.03524516895413399, -0.024569379165768623, -0.027305975556373596, -0.10243085026741028, 0.005748161114752293, 0.024414008483290672, -0.016364607959985733, 0.01715117134153843, 0.014039120636880398, -0.009944301098585129, -0.00530957942828536, 0.0012318819062784314, 0.03955719247460365, -0.014367680996656418, 0.040047504007816315, -0.018550200387835503, 0.029485946521162987, 0.03473281487822533, -0.03302006796002388, 0.009454545564949512, 0.05242724344134331, 0.031097395345568657, 0.016606032848358154, -0.018579406663775444, 0.018514780327677727, 0.007317849900573492, 0.014450302347540855, 0.04198042303323746, -0.009359179995954037, -0.030517620965838432, -0.0368875190615654, -0.06243330240249634, 0.029183415696024895, 0.010182717815041542, -0.0143801961094141, 0.00409654900431633, 0.0555446520447731, -0.0454288013279438, -0.027498159557580948, -0.08841940015554428, -0.013985966332256794, 0.027668224647641182, -0.020389661192893982, 0.01011691428720951, -0.013194175437092781, 0.07237862050533295, -0.017101164907217026, -0.026413965970277786, 0.00934621412307024, -0.013720675371587276, 0.01592286303639412, -0.05467602610588074, -0.01903143711388111, 0.012430706061422825, 0.0699065774679184, -0.007569813635200262, 0.061607085168361664, -0.027249978855252266, -0.02718318998813629, -0.002194749191403389, -0.0337635800242424, 0.010527419857680798, -0.006771974265575409, -0.032291289418935776, 0.004848455544561148, 0.0032577584497630596, -0.017053164541721344, 0.041157014667987823, -0.06803891062736511, 0.061179693788290024, 0.08775696903467178, -0.019489232450723648, 0.011480197310447693, -0.04824943467974663, 0.008658096194267273, 0.02399596944451332, -0.05085380747914314, -0.041630662977695465, -0.0401989184319973, -0.020982615649700165, 0.03956562653183937, 0.010883670300245285, -0.0021811658516526222, 0.038512345403432846, 0.05514606088399887, -0.02739301137626171, 0.004194244276732206, 0.050861746072769165, 0.014423183165490627, -0.037470895797014236, -0.0025421008467674255, 0.03172922506928444, 0.005855482071638107, 0.011344950646162033, 0.02176894247531891, 0.006287460681051016, 0.04957563430070877, 0.0330355130136013, 0.012197482399642467, 0.04922788590192795, 0.019509119912981987, -0.023124918341636658, -0.057540085166692734, -0.02062975987792015, 0.0553300678730011, 0.0008958848775364459, 0.012942404486238956, 0.048654746264219284, 0.024304257705807686, -0.033815398812294006, 0.019821027293801308, -0.003023731056600809, 0.020643671974539757, 0.032740313559770584, -0.04003370180726051, -0.00738108204677701, 0.007604364305734634, -0.025632554665207863, 0.029981421306729317, -0.012098374776542187, -0.040805384516716, -0.019870895892381668, 0.0019636822398751974, -0.0069083175621926785, -0.015120424330234528, 0.011362135410308838, -0.02900487743318081, -0.015415345318615437, 0.03199191391468048, -0.03223961591720581, 0.010288262739777565, 0.0057047284208238125, -0.044632166624069214, 0.0002460987016092986, -0.009863565675914288, 0.007070841267704964, -0.010723396204411983, 0.001986398361623287, 0.03176351264119148, 0.044589534401893616, 0.05569352209568024, -0.03818464279174805, -0.007773210294544697, -0.027933375909924507, 0.01600681245326996, -0.0005147047922946513, -0.016269881278276443, 0.03982535004615784, 0.029697462916374207, -0.017302218824625015, -0.008274426683783531, -0.028558753430843353, 0.004878532607108355, -0.005285175517201424, -0.007212659809738398, 0.005121455993503332, 0.02404475025832653, -0.002742033451795578, 0.03149697557091713, -0.046423252671957016, -0.02777712233364582, -0.07734936475753784, -0.03748222440481186, 0.056883979588747025, 0.023372190073132515, 0.029679518193006516, 0.00026511336909607053, -0.03093702718615532, 0.05345585197210312, 0.031788721680641174, 0.0051259975880384445, -0.07248533517122269, -0.011896355077624321, -0.009045282378792763, -0.02253594435751438, -0.00010994613694492728, 0.03096311166882515, 0.010513064451515675, 0.009290570393204689, 0.010238914750516415, -0.008821839466691017, 0.07397845387458801, 0.026226608082652092, -0.027938371524214745, 0.005704565439373255, 0.0427781417965889, 0.026629535481333733, 0.01642296276986599, -0.005095113068819046, -0.030055437237024307, -0.002364270854741335, 0.021375278010964394, 0.010616224259138107, -0.023734260350465775, -0.043174322694540024, -0.000683378370013088, 0.01067415252327919, -0.008861529640853405, -0.02515137568116188, 0.032140351831912994, 0.02784666419029236, -0.027455344796180725, -0.023938197642564774, 0.04386737570166588, 0.010384469293057919, -0.047679074108600616, 0.019775021821260452, 0.04208507388830185, 0.004925037734210491, -0.012476789765059948, 0.005327907390892506, 0.00059295300161466, -0.012945621274411678, 0.007647531572729349, -0.029445284977555275, -0.022127604112029076, 0.015588328242301941, 0.030357519164681435, 0.006297597195953131, -0.0036172622349113226, -0.034093331545591354, 0.023784995079040527, -0.029339972883462906, 0.0028846210334450006, -0.008344202302396297, 0.036940064281225204, -0.007115749176591635, 0.02192508801817894, 0.042780276387929916, -0.016056418418884277, 0.008491668850183487, -0.0623876191675663, -0.060198839753866196, 0.028095941990613937, -0.007238178979605436, -0.009074279107153416, 0.0486651249229908, -0.009254425764083862, 0.013137946836650372, 0.01692288927733898, 0.03706119582056999, -0.012000786140561104, 0.014055203646421432, -0.006731272209435701, 0.005407125689089298, -0.027605734765529633, 0.011745315976440907, -0.0027156854048371315, 0.004182844422757626, -0.0009748932207003236, -0.03932442516088486, 0.006307917181402445, 0.014342286624014378, 0.006478084716945887, -0.0032650644425302744, -0.03848670795559883, 0.008350147865712643, 0.034489598125219345, 0.059973977506160736, 0.033163852989673615, 0.04555561766028404, -0.038706209510564804, 0.0397663451731205, -0.00910331029444933, 0.010207093320786953, 0.022468339651823044, 0.0070375134237110615, -0.022393660619854927, -0.03289586305618286, -0.03166155889630318, -0.004315597470849752, 0.03359494358301163, 0.013105954974889755, -0.03268732503056526, 0.028742706403136253, 0.035890694707632065, -0.034273963421583176, 0.0006628947448916733, 0.057899925857782364, 0.033420298248529434, 0.0004962834063917398, -0.023965002968907356, -0.003546793246641755, 0.019331330433487892, -0.011466332711279392, 0.03180273249745369, 0.012838337570428848, 0.001495884614996612, -0.014394395984709263, 0.038708750158548355, -0.01498598325997591, -0.026925792917609215, 0.012996715493500233, 0.018151702359318733, 0.05489644035696983, 0.011849600821733475, -0.022971006110310555, -0.015208969824016094, 0.04883744195103645, 0.014088519848883152, 0.008837226778268814, 0.006686868146061897, -0.06905911862850189, 0.01989768072962761, 0.028477681800723076, 0.03708714619278908, -0.020647656172513962, -0.02715126983821392, -0.018132179975509644, -0.014655353501439095, 0.027439802885055542, -0.02503758855164051, -0.017153257504105568, -0.030064642429351807, -0.014023656025528908, -0.0393366776406765, -0.012374350801110268, -0.07000427693128586, 0.012720595113933086, -0.054712288081645966, 0.020056862384080887, 0.006002515554428101, -0.05531010404229164, -0.03411751613020897, -0.004194769077003002, -0.0016469963593408465, 0.052759189158678055, -0.01340357307344675, -0.027236104011535645, 0.050270937383174896, 0.0009025497129186988, -0.022280365228652954, -0.03434694558382034, -0.01062273420393467, -0.0027675935998559, -0.000872564094606787, 0.04846847057342529, 0.022135598585009575, -0.015968745574355125, 0.0012605489464476705, 0.017056355252861977, 0.009435591287910938, -0.0081008430570364, -0.0018883553566411138, 0.043735966086387634, 0.02978730946779251, -0.03096236102283001, 0.06787627935409546, -0.008121081627905369, 0.011191083118319511, 0.016981936991214752, -0.02137846313416958, 0.007418463472276926, -0.04326422140002251, -0.046984389424324036, -0.032210033386945724, -0.034192755818367004, -0.01623818650841713, 0.047459788620471954, -0.0006673124153167009, 0.02810751460492611, -0.031814590096473694, -0.006250468082726002, 0.06362691521644592, 0.04622465372085571, -0.0039876350201666355, 0.006156819872558117, 0.03177490830421448, 0.0020931761246174574, 0.007074529305100441, -0.020348435267806053, 0.012908076867461205, -0.0268790815025568, 0.005629709921777248, -0.004382998216897249, -0.06849110871553421, 0.023473944514989853, -0.014872693456709385, -0.030524155125021935, -0.025293368846178055, -0.04039260745048523, 0.026908108964562416, -0.028285278007388115, 0.03491051122546196, -0.025495462119579315, -0.048306792974472046, -0.011119335889816284, 0.03990600258111954, -0.010957049205899239, -0.019062133505940437, -0.0358995757997036, 0.033438071608543396, -0.02480599842965603, -0.0065020606853067875, -0.07138480991125107, -0.024571318179368973, 0.021802181378006935, 0.004244814161211252, 0.013060125522315502, -0.006270734127610922, 0.0215254295617342, -0.024421103298664093, -0.008105268701910973, -0.04504669830203056, 0.0699974074959755, -0.022419072687625885, -0.006004591006785631, -0.021182972937822342, 0.024280548095703125, 0.043211665004491806, -0.025225108489394188, 0.012061175890266895, 0.008799422532320023, -0.013757049106061459, -0.033941108733415604, -0.01715864986181259, -0.003665734315291047, -0.02724974788725376, -0.008003846742212772, -0.06407026946544647, 0.019486049190163612, 0.036804184317588806, -0.041447579860687256, -0.048556357622146606, -0.007136977277696133, -0.027531461790204048, 0.021677298471331596, -0.05396433174610138, -0.021340306848287582, -0.011145555414259434, -0.012321029789745808, -0.05791044980287552, 0.008881515823304653, 0.01640601083636284, -0.036608900874853134, 0.0368836335837841, 0.037789396941661835, 0.0002752553264144808, -0.004376452416181564, 0.056797854602336884, -0.00971568189561367, -0.011311223730444908, -0.011253539472818375, -0.026899496093392372, 0.015856914222240448, -0.0030741551890969276, -0.014235548675060272, 0.03007488325238228, 0.013658566400408745, -0.06504743546247482, -0.012069907039403915, -0.021022368222475052, -0.039780765771865845, 0.04599156603217125, 0.008787821978330612, 0.04465598985552788, 0.0860050618648529, -0.002728637307882309, 0.04189378395676613, 0.0015124003402888775, 0.026123154908418655, 0.01191384345293045, 0.009221681393682957, 0.06314989179372787, -0.022417038679122925, -0.003529846901074052, 0.05167178064584732, 0.044556811451911926, 0.039052851498126984, 0.05116292089223862, -0.01627613976597786, 0.013739874586462975, 0.02774937078356743, -0.015899186953902245, -0.035591620951890945, 0.023424573242664337, -0.016603223979473114, -0.009177046827971935, -0.04868949204683304, -0.026535801589488983, 0.05139140412211418, 0.05263735353946686, 0.0064521413296461105, -0.027277201414108276, -0.020802844315767288, -0.07876674085855484, 0.011204918846487999, 0.06342407315969467, -0.0075728693045675755, 0.031589943915605545, 0.044073108583688736, 0.0016660961555317044, -0.01220868993550539, -0.0037005310878157616, -0.039686284959316254, -0.060673873871564865, -0.033815011382102966, 0.022835854440927505, 0.009278634563088417, 0.019563892856240273, 0.009592864662408829, -0.009339479729533195, 0.025929013267159462, -0.037713129073381424, -0.004463977180421352, 0.006189628504216671, 0.021341321989893913, -0.03214819356799126, 0.07678750902414322, 0.0061687082052230835, -0.010766129940748215, 0.007804736029356718, 0.011405806988477707, 0.12125174701213837, 0.06337673962116241, 0.043792977929115295, -0.10918744653463364, 0.034359391778707504, 0.02537744864821434, -0.025115005671977997, -0.02742134965956211, 0.01557689718902111, 0.011222642846405506, 0.0069036781787872314, 0.0627044215798378, 0.041458696126937866, 0.027863455936312675, 0.000276389328064397, 0.06626635044813156, -0.005133178550750017, -0.01129133626818657, 0.028210286051034927, -0.0017269019735977054, -0.01701899990439415, -0.004264334682375193, -0.0041334605775773525, 0.035524435341358185, -0.010388266295194626, -0.004188348539173603, -0.026298120617866516, 0.020142599940299988, -0.015799151733517647, 0.019825546070933342, -0.017498517408967018, 0.015673769637942314, -0.024757875129580498, 0.021325230598449707, -0.01758386939764023, 0.026224952191114426, 0.012323955073952675, 0.00645099114626646, 0.0016489491099491715, 0.0029248755890876055, -0.0036080379504710436, 0.02002473548054695, -0.01199956052005291, 0.023577546700835228, -0.03404875844717026, -0.035053011029958725, -0.030799686908721924, 0.06856825202703476, -0.018060550093650818, -0.003751724259927869, 0.005805310793220997, -0.0020369873382151127, 0.00277886725962162, -0.02890854701399803, -0.0023906156420707703, 0.052994683384895325, 0.01934153586626053, -0.023897938430309296, 0.024017052724957466, -0.03551061451435089, 0.04444129019975662, -0.018683822825551033, 0.05866346135735512, 0.02646266110241413, -0.01832130365073681, -0.03001365438103676, -0.029383739456534386, 0.04117680341005325, 0.0002874218625947833, -0.012796989642083645, 0.023323098197579384, -0.008970922790467739, -0.007869905792176723, -0.0020959547255188227, 0.012495561502873898, 0.012508904561400414, -0.006847932003438473, 0.00658857636153698, 0.0002928097965195775, -0.039382144808769226, -0.02012304961681366, 0.02467956207692623, -0.013917651027441025, 0.022099804133176804, -0.014506082981824875, -0.04775319620966911, 0.032014571130275726, 0.03449644148349762, 0.01824909634888172, 0.01015695370733738, -0.0061819604597985744, 0.04525315761566162, 0.04211669787764549, -0.08231516182422638, -0.011208051815629005, -0.014433315023779869, -0.01711433194577694, -0.026299741119146347, -0.051110927015542984, 0.05170165374875069, 0.018348680809140205, 0.0015736435307189822, -0.022684060037136078, 0.022137045860290527, -0.041544485837221146, 0.029539283365011215, 0.019518965855240822, -0.04546085000038147, 0.013858431950211525, -0.02958047389984131, 0.008792441338300705, 0.017201680690050125, -0.02717651054263115, -0.02079605683684349, -0.05527972802519798, 0.013095570728182793, -0.02809998393058777, 0.013312664814293385, 0.013751407153904438, -0.005832860246300697, 0.0015016886172816157, -0.02382524684071541, -0.030620316043496132, -0.052516721189022064, -0.024529388174414635, 0.015973849222064018, -0.0037455344572663307, -0.003716429229825735, 0.017138289287686348, -0.01830998621881008, 0.003412404330447316, 0.07346682250499725, 0.01947285421192646, 0.03934234380722046, 0.03005700185894966, 0.02065204456448555, -0.022553136572241783, 0.03616991639137268, -0.0005741947679780424, -0.047850362956523895, 0.039708882570266724, -0.05584263801574707, -0.01501520350575447, 0.01568247191607952, 0.025802848860621452, 0.03525041416287422, -0.006714280229061842, -0.021781371906399727, -0.008129814639687538, 0.052223872393369675, -0.012803716585040092, -0.03560388833284378, -0.014928339049220085, 0.01326811220496893, 0.00231174542568624, -0.023757455870509148, 0.025716757401823997, 0.011716371402144432, -0.010583699680864811, 0.004348161164671183, 0.042939480394124985, -0.005952440667897463, 0.029589001089334488, -0.022227279841899872, 0.0028987275436520576, -0.0039376248605549335, 0.001974042970687151, -0.0097560565918684, 0.04207213222980499, 0.041937459260225296, -0.007861199788749218, 0.011442102491855621, -0.04473007470369339, 0.014272703789174557, -0.07710447162389755, 0.005711711011826992, -0.023959241807460785, 0.010668033733963966, 0.023550596088171005, -0.058969613164663315, 0.023559628054499626, 0.05413040518760681, 0.009108425118029118, 0.0167703814804554, -0.013225521892309189, -0.027114836499094963, -0.015170551836490631, 0.01564633846282959, 0.004769318271428347, -0.017499610781669617, 0.0005097428802400827, 0.03140607103705406, 0.04398031905293465, 0.03668203204870224, 0.010305832140147686, -0.03980350121855736, -0.025898294523358345, -0.013328575529158115, 0.029010402038693428, -0.10045617073774338, -0.011634076945483685, -0.026116976514458656, -0.03190772235393524, 0.015899263322353363, 0.0031123568769544363, 0.01834797114133835, 0.020101185888051987, 0.05922519788146019, 0.02610859088599682, 0.0766480341553688, 0.017596762627363205, 0.02172168716788292, 0.011847286485135555, -0.04766048863530159, -0.015691742300987244, 0.010857879184186459, 0.00036261408240534365, 0.009022898972034454, 0.051831070333719254, -0.009549332782626152, -0.006055179052054882, 0.024816390126943588, -0.008859293535351753, -0.03253435716032982, -0.03261489048600197, -0.010690412484109402, 0.024282382801175117, -0.03657812252640724, -0.029234932735562325, -0.04525064677000046, 0.0035060562659054995, 0.04689209908246994, 0.00866751465946436, -0.032966818660497665, 0.0054069990292191505, -0.01142690796405077, -0.021875714883208275, -0.00015918177086859941, -0.006246616598218679, 0.02702610194683075, -0.06425318121910095, -0.014366352930665016, -0.028571393340826035, 0.006628483533859253, -0.018871091306209564, 0.026859337463974953, -0.027749603614211082, 0.0385730005800724, -0.03470459207892418, 0.020405123010277748, 0.03282701596617699, 0.01873682253062725, -0.0036680037155747414, -0.04776064306497574, 0.05828935652971268, 0.03182966262102127, -0.022455742582678795, -0.03993591293692589, 0.021198665723204613, -0.04912786930799484, 0.010435977019369602, 0.07488011568784714, 0.00944475643336773, 0.0051310695707798, -0.005991718266159296, 0.04819437116384506, 0.008712908253073692, -0.057825587689876556, 0.05573801323771477, -0.015254354104399681, -0.03489267826080322, 0.010106144472956657, 0.00409613735973835, 0.03287939727306366, 0.029165204614400864, -0.006420924793928862, -0.0223363246768713, -0.007535960990935564, -0.007518148049712181, -0.03735761344432831, 0.016831932589411736, 0.023938041180372238, -0.0238327793776989, 0.02119230292737484, -0.015159111469984055, 0.020430365577340126, 0.02043207362294197, 0.005457725841552019, -0.04105743020772934, 0.06236455589532852, -0.0530894435942173, -0.025188922882080078, 0.006314875558018684, 0.00462081003934145, -0.05195682868361473, -0.05795779824256897, -0.006398077122867107, 0.008509313687682152, -0.0285139549523592, 0.027799881994724274, 0.047077205032110214, 0.03146854788064957, 0.0013325921026989818, -0.02821025624871254, 0.036478836089372635, 0.0012926815543323755, 0.01734721101820469, 0.013529294170439243, 0.008402450010180473, 0.003780837869271636, -0.004184863530099392, 0.004206486977636814, 0.015592041425406933, -0.017267141491174698, 0.017266059294342995, -0.014522845856845379, 0.039190370589494705, 0.003780757077038288, -0.010553689673542976, -0.010419598780572414, -0.024596041068434715, 0.03801844269037247, -0.001984860049560666, 0.00005935199442319572, 0.014326158910989761, -0.0787668451666832, -0.016138210892677307, -0.028266064822673798, -0.02212296426296234, -0.039848629385232925, -0.0014471178874373436, 0.0246406439691782, 0.005427062977105379, 0.02418060414493084, 0.031000278890132904, 0.01573113538324833, -0.04451947286725044, -0.004684786312282085, -0.01629113219678402, 0.034904845058918, -0.0018324778648093343, -0.014814207330346107, -0.03029697947204113, -0.006785130128264427, -0.07308303564786911, -0.018708093091845512, 0.031755294650793076, 0.03958814591169357, 0.04727588966488838, -0.027633950114250183, 0.004379256162792444, 0.006673802621662617, 0.03710668534040451, -0.0943107083439827, -0.015078636817634106, -0.03717729449272156, -0.0015052335802465677, -0.017978431656956673, -0.01091783307492733 ]
<p>I'm studying regression analysis but I'm struggling with really understanding how degrees of freedom are calculated. For example, if we have the simple scenario where $Y_i=\beta_0+\beta_1 X_i + \epsilon_i$ (and all the standard assumptions hold) then I read</p> <p>$\frac{1}{\sigma^2} \sum_{i=1}^n (\hat{Y}_i - \bar{Y})^2 \sim \chi^2_{1}$</p> <p>This seems reasonable when you make an argument like "$\hat{Y}_i$ has two parameters and so two degrees of freedom but $\bar{Y}$ takes one degree of freedom and so you're left with 1", but I guess I'm looking for an argument that's more theoretically grounded. Why does that summation have the same distribution as a standard normal squared?</p> <p>I was able to understand why $\frac{1}{\sigma^2} \sum_{i=1}^n (Y_i-\bar{Y})^2 \sim \chi^2_{n-1}$ by considering the sum of squares as a projection of the $\epsilon_i$ onto a space of dimension $n-1$. A proof for the above case that follows that kind of argument would be fantastic!</p>
74,162
[ -0.03307391330599785, -0.016637589782476425, 0.01793578267097473, -0.008942860178649426, 0.03854706138372421, 0.034739356487989426, 0.012282338924705982, 0.00466947490349412, 0.02929917350411415, -0.06554723531007767, 0.019345887005329132, 0.009600941091775894, 0.07291887700557709, -0.01233082078397274, 0.016027074307203293, 0.01591830886900425, -0.04819226264953613, 0.04197058454155922, -0.027076533064246178, -0.008767043240368366, -0.000020964975192327984, 0.06713565438985825, 0.02822941541671753, -0.013119065202772617, -0.03589260205626488, 0.038800615817308426, 0.015263217501342297, -0.02150900289416313, 0.0034763640724122524, 0.06539212167263031, -0.023801593109965324, -0.01213626004755497, 0.012756433337926865, 0.04419710114598274, 0.004073146730661392, -0.024518247693777084, -0.010207041166722775, -0.011936566792428493, 0.012385860085487366, 0.03896598517894745, -0.032997723668813705, -0.01944146119058132, -0.010583845898509026, 0.022486990317702293, -0.03063415177166462, 0.020232100039720535, -0.02563367411494255, -0.04334915429353714, 0.03950003534555435, -0.04869190976023674, 0.1041051596403122, -0.013032599352300167, 0.04540485516190529, 0.06322427093982697, -0.006197651848196983, 0.0019310455536469817, 0.02371351793408394, 0.02744286321103573, 0.01224181056022644, -0.05550997704267502, -0.022993750870227814, -0.03369881585240364, 0.02782217599451542, 0.012627515010535717, -0.010968122631311417, 0.007712462916970253, 0.020428702235221863, -0.00336147821508348, 0.012092186138033867, -0.037042777985334396, 0.02989308536052704, 0.024202294647693634, 0.02279464155435562, -0.030735956504940987, -0.017240149900317192, 0.013049693778157234, 0.02595205046236515, 0.007097812835127115, 0.058376654982566833, 0.012533929198980331, 0.009086547419428825, 0.02171519584953785, 0.03401985391974449, 0.026805266737937927, 0.0319439060986042, -0.002240999834612012, 0.07756838947534561, -0.015197154134511948, 0.03738390654325485, 0.038245271891355515, 0.0020031409803777933, -0.0011097175301983953, 0.06200729310512543, -0.0008949873154051602, -0.051889222115278244, 0.03387372940778732, -0.02364598587155342, 0.01944672130048275, 0.012646469287574291, -0.019058872014284134, -0.049160219728946686, -0.050144799053668976, 0.005375040229409933, 0.05548281595110893, -0.006124595180153847, -0.00781872496008873, -0.03501223027706146, 0.026181966066360474, 0.007749924901872873, -0.021433230489492416, -0.03607458248734474, 0.01599171943962574, -0.014697130769491196, 0.010753754526376724, 0.0021433692891150713, -0.008582578971982002, -0.02880421280860901, -0.0083030229434371, 0.039871420711278915, 0.08391471207141876, 0.019222112372517586, -0.006611526012420654, -0.007585996761918068, -0.008950402028858662, -0.021461330354213715, 0.03350003436207771, 0.039160728454589844, -0.019118059426546097, -0.050722088664770126, 0.03013327158987522, 0.020284121856093407, -0.020321905612945557, 0.013937626965343952, 0.03481432795524597, 0.015492092818021774, -0.0006544086500070989, -0.1340142786502838, -0.045684993267059326, 0.03968549892306328, -0.039216648787260056, -0.010678221471607685, -0.06394852697849274, 0.0065345149487257, 0.04380376636981964, 0.08840718120336533, -0.03508102148771286, 0.06198763847351074, -0.008031285367906094, 0.02750510163605213, 0.027452440932393074, -0.022658349946141243, -0.05111243948340416, -0.010374411009252071, -0.05971623957157135, -0.013479958288371563, -0.05916610732674599, 0.06828611344099045, 0.028976093977689743, 0.0070063266903162, -0.009474488906562328, 0.048349905759096146, 0.024371586740016937, -0.005837442819029093, 0.017438143491744995, 0.02266901172697544, -0.0296616367995739, 0.06930308789014816, 0.017757626250386238, 0.03124668076634407, 0.03761516511440277, -0.002513580024242401, 0.007189007010310888, 0.004981423728168011, 0.08409375697374344, 0.02760905958712101, -0.021104471758008003, -0.004918144084513187, -0.014373298734426498, -0.006871584802865982, 0.0026601399295032024, -0.0828167200088501, -0.02860194258391857, -0.031152622774243355, 0.03128177672624588, 0.022159412503242493, 0.03897447884082794, 0.012560611590743065, -0.030959829688072205, 0.00851688627153635, -0.07247553020715714, -0.018811656162142754, -0.0813714787364006, -0.026356585323810577, -0.003858866635710001, -0.024627039209008217, 0.019596528261899948, 0.0352017842233181, 0.02550523541867733, -0.02084033377468586, 0.007956333458423615, -0.027779893949627876, 0.009883159771561623, 0.05350542813539505, -0.03500278666615486, 0.030731048434972763, 0.03106449916958809, 0.0658099502325058, 0.025356475263834, 0.060870617628097534, -0.014868596568703651, -0.05261451005935669, 0.032179780304431915, -0.041156284511089325, 0.01648983731865883, 0.021977046504616737, -0.006990077439695597, -0.011703568510711193, -0.02585141733288765, -0.03642737492918968, 0.04123062267899513, -0.05475669354200363, 0.07396934181451797, 0.06506278365850449, -0.016561903059482574, -0.03554900735616684, 0.008361449465155602, 0.036345940083265305, -0.028879931196570396, -0.03352030739188194, 0.010614077560603619, -0.010262878611683846, -0.022679639980196953, 0.012877732515335083, 0.0664542093873024, -0.03776568919420242, -0.006803066004067659, 0.05961322411894798, 0.025127405300736427, 0.011562234722077847, 0.02074243873357773, -0.01392935961484909, -0.01653657667338848, -0.002152292290702462, -0.045532066375017166, 0.0010594045743346214, -0.0212215818464756, 0.009060441516339779, 0.007680491544306278, 0.006281042471528053, 0.022563258185982704, -0.015356111340224743, 0.054269034415483475, -0.017357023432850838, -0.005856119561940432, -0.02350291609764099, 0.015422667376697063, 0.04409370943903923, -0.013836626894772053, 0.003867072518914938, 0.015668202191591263, -0.0016669497126713395, 0.002272768411785364, -0.04549035057425499, 0.010595700703561306, 0.02859661541879177, 0.011200807057321072, -0.026445703580975533, 0.020797133445739746, 0.023759037256240845, -0.01302566658705473, 0.014989649876952171, -0.04768252745270729, -0.033202700316905975, 0.005781683139503002, -0.0038968923036009073, 0.021348729729652405, 0.029998045414686203, 0.01340844389051199, 0.00442379480227828, -0.011128698475658894, -0.0015617073513567448, 0.025184979662299156, 0.045531317591667175, 0.008398903533816338, -0.042119767516851425, -0.011696704663336277, -0.06472020596265793, 0.020797548815608025, 0.03316039592027664, -0.006640542298555374, -0.007957913912832737, 0.008585430681705475, -0.007290619891136885, -0.06290126591920853, -0.04387781769037247, -0.027048233896493912, -0.014056243002414703, -0.013923159800469875, -0.020941587164998055, 0.035658515989780426, -0.03516700118780136, -0.03616013005375862, 0.05810236930847168, -0.006548112258315086, -0.031331609934568405, -0.019373426213860512, -0.018969396129250526, 0.01525160577148199, -0.00318242353387177, 0.019219497218728065, -0.003455516416579485, -0.01450252067297697, -0.02028045617043972, -0.027581529691815376, -0.06680276989936829, 0.013400327414274216, 0.015883462503552437, 0.05487052723765373, 0.022842004895210266, -0.052373189479112625, 0.0915403664112091, 0.002371168229728937, -0.0004246954049449414, -0.01718343049287796, 0.012391597032546997, -0.02336980029940605, -0.02611982449889183, 0.06768005341291428, 0.018886879086494446, -0.0029814261943101883, 0.0600457563996315, 0.0021261584479361773, 0.02869000844657421, 0.042240019887685776, -0.022374825552105904, -0.01940295100212097, -0.003160265041515231, -0.013170832768082619, 0.0075454795733094215, 0.00529819680377841, 0.007983616553246975, -0.0284762904047966, -0.005603978876024485, 0.02699143812060356, 0.03664745017886162, 0.01404095720499754, -0.04682585224509239, 0.027571145445108414, -0.011724120005965233, 0.015325265005230904, -0.07370894402265549, 0.05212726071476936, 0.007882628589868546, -0.025227492675185204, 0.007517232559621334, 0.01615976169705391, 0.03222013637423515, -0.03461093828082085, -0.007124339696019888, 0.009980429895222187, 0.024213092401623726, 0.004456268157809973, -0.0007902781362645328, 0.0003265173581894487, -0.014167148619890213, 0.02837749570608139, -0.029979217797517776, -0.0171926561743021, 0.02790757827460766, 0.046143993735313416, 0.0019416772993281484, -0.030370449647307396, -0.024240219965577126, 0.0028791148215532303, -0.055863384157419205, 0.024065783247351646, -0.024831736460328102, 0.052567142993211746, 0.00649884482845664, 0.03778756409883499, -0.029067249968647957, -0.03607500344514847, -0.015531505458056927, -0.02440657652914524, -0.04795987159013748, 0.0010081807849928737, 0.008823848329484463, -0.01665276102721691, -0.0026766720693558455, -0.00286596966907382, 0.046072643250226974, -0.022369803860783577, 0.013368194922804832, -0.00015289903967641294, -0.00415415782481432, -0.02736995741724968, -0.004431977402418852, -0.04455980286002159, -0.022711046040058136, -0.0050776032730937, 0.043065596371889114, 0.012832364067435265, -0.02339589037001133, -0.018038706853985786, 0.036697547882795334, -0.028345447033643723, 0.005710614379495382, -0.03994043916463852, 0.028979748487472534, -0.004170685075223446, 0.031729284673929214, 0.026759445667266846, -0.006058469880372286, 0.002831890247762203, 0.009074296802282333, 0.004640655126422644, 0.052429500967264175, 0.03801066428422928, -0.0016239919932559133, -0.012296438217163086, -0.03743942081928253, -0.01813528500497341, 0.0057153478264808655, 0.014792745001614094, 0.0298053789883852, 0.003561388235539198, 0.06349191069602966, 0.017656171694397926, -0.030482565984129906, 0.034630559384822845, 0.03736894950270653, -0.017949875444173813, 0.017382672056555748, -0.034557193517684937, -0.004012391436845064, -0.02832169458270073, 0.01066520344465971, -0.001785285654477775, -0.009234818629920483, -0.0030581182800233364, 0.007317692972719669, 0.015977609902620316, -0.009602571837604046, 0.008406823500990868, -0.01469454076141119, 0.04875650629401207, 0.06519303470849991, -0.0019314035307615995, -0.029832512140274048, -0.0020135105587542057, 0.06224740296602249, 0.06067519262433052, 0.0338868722319603, -0.030597515404224396, -0.011878199875354767, -0.01684134639799595, 0.010875201784074306, -0.002918655751273036, -0.027118410915136337, -0.0023187357001006603, 0.003780654165893793, -0.024645034223794937, 0.036848682910203934, 0.0004594147321768105, 0.007516589481383562, 0.027554068714380264, -0.011485513299703598, -0.0008727402309887111, -0.031567174941301346, -0.07031404972076416, 0.010584339499473572, 0.002022123895585537, 0.046922873705625534, -0.031837839633226395, -0.021674757823348045, -0.07784339040517807, -0.027798451483249664, 0.016878647729754448, 0.07178261131048203, 0.014115440659224987, -0.015785396099090576, -0.010159862227737904, 0.05645967647433281, 0.0011819330975413322, -0.06526201218366623, 0.032092008739709854, 0.03198891133069992, 0.00877060741186142, 0.03395099192857742, -0.03425457701086998, -0.05788405239582062, 0.019613783806562424, 0.011326255276799202, -0.03733721747994423, -0.015647079795598984, -0.009026535786688328, 0.04166567698121071, 0.038770291954278946, 0.036517463624477386, 0.042564768344163895, -0.0014922923874109983, 0.0005646775243803859, 0.011809592135250568, -0.037898797541856766, 0.018811725080013275, 0.01766148954629898, -0.054218050092458725, -0.040539808571338654, 0.004613397642970085, 0.010669384151697159, 0.0013494121376425028, 0.013941069133579731, 0.04540469869971275, 0.0047712731175124645, -0.030145570635795593, -0.005651129875332117, 0.04300092160701752, 0.01855616085231304, -0.023107409477233887, 0.02679191529750824, 0.04495800659060478, 0.029659662395715714, -0.017743414267897606, 0.02536533959209919, -0.014391771517693996, -0.022589486092329025, 0.024945681914687157, -0.012720688246190548, 0.01525108516216278, -0.039036985486745834, -0.021940194070339203, -0.007969789206981659, -0.03151864558458328, -0.007874250411987305, -0.02714727818965912, 0.02432093769311905, -0.004355534445494413, -0.03768821060657501, -0.013407636433839798, -0.004931214731186628, -0.008915196172893047, 0.02461228333413601, -0.03925279900431633, -0.02497836947441101, -0.0018081070156767964, 0.0009781818371266127, -0.09447440505027771, -0.001693416852504015, -0.019921565428376198, -0.003936071880161762, -0.009258386678993702, -0.03608376532793045, 0.00589754618704319, -0.002604823326691985, -0.05398506671190262, 0.017799587920308113, 0.045515432953834534, -0.016377896070480347, -0.018207788467407227, -0.013296428136527538, 0.039797715842723846, 0.06721403449773788, -0.055073920637369156, -0.0290115587413311, 0.028941191732883453, -0.029280032962560654, -0.0014911774778738618, -0.00545690068975091, 0.04528505355119705, -0.05235617980360985, 0.01764509826898575, -0.014321714639663696, -0.051012422889471054, -0.003953147679567337, -0.028923513367772102, -0.03811720758676529, 0.011962304823100567, -0.009023250080645084, 0.01973874308168888, -0.037507180124521255, -0.019501319155097008, -0.014252712950110435, 0.037324950098991394, -0.0008470751345157623, 0.002652757568284869, -0.02257675863802433, -0.03532353788614273, 0.050099000334739685, 0.0012764467392116785, 0.021402373909950256, 0.015664994716644287, 0.04628029838204384, 0.0013393197441473603, 0.013881275430321693, -0.008737617172300816, -0.011399743147194386, 0.029428794980049133, 0.049957577139139175, -0.013548462651669979, 0.019556980580091476, 0.033416565507650375, -0.023968949913978577, -0.027426281943917274, -0.045032087713479996, 0.04669196903705597, 0.051098890602588654, -0.025829104706645012, 0.028230251744389534, 0.04784657061100006, -0.00292382319457829, -0.0356513150036335, -0.02305574156343937, -0.025165610015392303, -0.03668849542737007, -0.015672236680984497, 0.022675927728414536, -0.02838169038295746, -0.052612412720918655, 0.042595647275447845, 0.040609754621982574, -0.028060145676136017, 0.034093841910362244, 0.017822766676545143, 0.011704988777637482, 0.03769320249557495, -0.013658578507602215, -0.02579810470342636, 0.07404396682977676, -0.024394992738962173, 0.021907854825258255, -0.011326615698635578, -0.002162247896194458, 0.028556423261761665, 0.028586996719241142, -0.004220760427415371, -0.07380436360836029, -0.06538785994052887, -0.023530250415205956, 0.004927720408886671, 0.0401979424059391, -0.018757132813334465, 0.03165273740887642, -0.037175532430410385, 0.011682363227009773, -0.018455972895026207, 0.016624117270112038, -0.028232742100954056, -0.07637786120176315, -0.022797349840402603, 0.009407730773091316, -0.022906824946403503, 0.008446021936833858, -0.00467454269528389, -0.03914976492524147, -0.030033733695745468, -0.047349460422992706, 0.00549677200615406, 0.025380637496709824, 0.02241605892777443, 0.0001272992230951786, 0.05715728551149368, 0.022546671330928802, -0.004146973602473736, -0.010334867052733898, -0.0019451307598501444, 0.0963597223162651, 0.08007768541574478, 0.032228484749794006, -0.05387759953737259, -0.0002104581508319825, 0.0028459476307034492, -0.016177833080291748, -0.013737556524574757, 0.005456977523863316, 0.023193471133708954, 0.030743634328246117, 0.019469404593110085, 0.05771861597895622, 0.008191544562578201, -0.023837732151150703, 0.013624376617372036, -0.030360693112015724, -0.018748542293906212, -0.02528528869152069, -0.004377665929496288, -0.007463504560291767, -0.006487433332949877, -0.037316080182790756, -0.029967259615659714, -0.008439119905233383, -0.025779293850064278, -0.0009811923373490572, -0.023730965331196785, -0.00950024463236332, -0.006509498693048954, -0.05315982177853584, -0.002297134604305029, 0.01348812971264124, 0.01883194036781788, -0.02382706291973591, 0.027714112773537636, 0.01192023791372776, -0.03739943727850914, 0.023553263396024704, 0.010892670601606369, -0.037460993975400925, 0.01598791591823101, 0.04284394904971123, 0.006250736769288778, -0.024222481995821, -0.029313281178474426, -0.03465888276696205, 0.059077925980091095, -0.026134954765439034, -0.014077316038310528, -0.0022797381971031427, -0.021688109263777733, 0.022748306393623352, -0.04190497100353241, 0.005268104374408722, 0.017799416556954384, 0.05705145001411438, -0.021617835387587547, -0.0008541507413610816, -0.025562120601534843, 0.02848103456199169, 0.00043400246067903936, 0.033343538641929626, 0.021556252613663673, -0.04883559048175812, -0.036712273955345154, 0.0048418291844427586, 0.03930255025625229, 0.016297629103064537, -0.015437901951372623, 0.006706315092742443, 0.005683024413883686, -0.017084024846553802, -0.003194645047187805, 0.0014924464048817754, -0.02046564780175686, 0.018681630492210388, -0.004849649034440517, 0.012857862748205662, -0.018648868426680565, -0.025440366938710213, -0.00466109998524189, -0.05362623929977417, 0.01675986498594284, -0.03440793976187706, -0.044426433742046356, 0.029357658699154854, 0.05369477719068527, 0.0009433545055799186, -0.009746121242642403, 0.0010939438361674547, 0.042672719806432724, 0.032948922365903854, -0.06748881936073303, -0.03780278563499451, 0.015787344425916672, -0.02079247683286667, 0.014874333515763283, -0.0018729828298091888, 0.03882298991084099, 0.023483317345380783, 0.04448333755135536, -0.017718592658638954, 0.04551847651600838, -0.029396159574389458, 0.004442732781171799, 0.024414706975221634, -0.04518433287739754, 0.03242475166916847, 0.060111548751592636, 0.031380441039800644, -0.016121292486786842, -0.030836110934615135, -0.02709374949336052, -0.041886501014232635, -0.002220944967120886, -0.011519323103129864, -0.038522396236658096, 0.006153243128210306, 0.011799211613833904, 0.02448505349457264, 0.005055970046669245, -0.010043912567198277, -0.023388730362057686, 0.011464850045740604, 0.035495974123477936, 0.00029105081921443343, -0.00008591095684096217, -0.009867122396826744, -0.033816296607255936, -0.021226467564702034, 0.03972572460770607, 0.02121405489742756, 0.036265596747398376, -0.018634505569934845, 0.007636585738509893, -0.004970472771674395, 0.043412476778030396, -0.029833413660526276, -0.03154832497239113, 0.03739658743143082, -0.02088896743953228, -0.040260229259729385, 0.015286280773580074, -0.013959468342363834, 0.057835981249809265, 0.01223121676594019, -0.0030453030485659838, -0.042120710015296936, 0.02301114611327648, -0.016368916258215904, 0.019646955654025078, -0.004503380507230759, 0.007282517850399017, -0.0035129059106111526, -0.05033344775438309, 0.014622887596487999, -0.022264588624238968, -0.005666648503392935, 0.01939276047050953, 0.022651903331279755, -0.031236758455634117, -0.0070284465327858925, 0.012768212705850601, -0.018813299015164375, 0.0033994955010712147, 0.00474485382437706, 0.03264237567782402, 0.014669184572994709, 0.03630652278661728, -0.05458417907357216, 0.019466029480099678, -0.028214599937200546, 0.032153986394405365, -0.0923987403512001, -0.03830192610621452, 0.01476982980966568, 0.028632454574108124, 0.02907419390976429, -0.06321364641189575, 0.01168921496719122, 0.035475607961416245, -0.07745583355426788, -0.009997263550758362, -0.020469356328248978, -0.01127468328922987, -0.05349946767091751, 0.002464442979544401, 0.003084497293457389, 0.04114687815308571, 0.055797092616558075, 0.02794875204563141, 0.011291379109025002, -0.004839929286390543, 0.0008052908815443516, -0.026981083676218987, -0.001809352426789701, 0.0073078530840575695, -0.008080722764134407, -0.04662179574370384, 0.05332273989915848, -0.01207214966416359, -0.04324375092983246, 0.07229319214820862, 0.00588136725127697, -0.010992496274411678, 0.013632590882480145, 0.00441792793571949, 0.01763150468468666, 0.01992921531200409, 0.021605229005217552, 0.007672237232327461, 0.009312363341450691, 0.015508176758885384, 0.057021986693143845, 0.017590124160051346, -0.024018926545977592, -0.027765728533267975, 0.028173066675662994, -0.006727093830704689, -0.02953529544174671, 0.01241989154368639, 0.007349103689193726, -0.01370356883853674, 0.01803405024111271, -0.003672101069241762, -0.008747648447751999, -0.0118888970464468, 0.05306076258420944, -0.058554667979478836, -0.012503553181886673, 0.020969998091459274, 0.04878055676817894, -0.023266658186912537, -0.0034502774942666292, 0.00801022071391344, -0.048054229468107224, 0.026496201753616333, 0.023198846727609634, 0.0030977409332990646, -0.048275526612997055, -0.022874977439641953, 0.014409096911549568, -0.0030776052735745907, 0.008304037153720856, -0.030490826815366745, -0.03857846185564995, 0.009753566235303879, 0.015074730850756168, 0.021122314035892487, -0.033749811351299286, -0.04164435341954231, -0.0007796282880008221, -0.08566120266914368, 0.054159875959157944, 0.026649314910173416, -0.008829858154058456, -0.00891947653144598, 0.02725939266383648, -0.03975263983011246, -0.025189928710460663, 0.07881265133619308, 0.023171547800302505, 0.011379997245967388, 0.003775812452659011, 0.03919771686196327, 0.01085755042731762, -0.04235057160258293, 0.027047235518693924, -0.020677227526903152, -0.05447964742779732, -0.02945633791387081, -0.006267883349210024, 0.017577901482582092, 0.002848926931619644, 0.010205925442278385, 0.0016378543805330992, 0.04307796061038971, 0.002611370524391532, -0.03578093275427818, 0.06300880014896393, 0.020887263119220734, -0.019492682069540024, 0.053987279534339905, 0.008276892825961113, 0.014800780452787876, 0.03049689531326294, -0.019272875040769577, -0.036097362637519836, 0.0019942200742661953, 0.010409352369606495, -0.02158399112522602, -0.04003189131617546, 0.02594936639070511, -0.007734210696071386, -0.043569788336753845, 0.016107115894556046, 0.017384253442287445, -0.011446034535765648, -0.017746219411492348, 0.05132202059030533, 0.014817182905972004, 0.019243862479925156, -0.00035227759508416057, 0.0010404105996713042, 0.011457527987658978, 0.007597436662763357, 0.020136861130595207, 0.009413221850991249, 0.03886855021119118, 0.004647884052246809, -0.013090488500893116, 0.024729324504733086, -0.024776889011263847, 0.021928338333964348, -0.030225591734051704, 0.012822882272303104, -0.04524359107017517, -0.02039960026741028, -0.002480200259014964, -0.023152774199843407, 0.01325202826410532, -0.001027918653562665, -0.012701140716671944, 0.052634451538324356, -0.029091764241456985, -0.008177638985216618, -0.010469465516507626, -0.006399244535714388, -0.02454223856329918, -0.04092860221862793, 0.003539761994034052, 0.0758051946759224, 0.011229859665036201, -0.013189876452088356, -0.0070342980325222015, -0.029475608840584755, 0.027504045516252518, -0.005027384031563997, 0.015692923218011856, 0.008590998128056526, 0.0004024870868306607, -0.013980738818645477, -0.028522267937660217, -0.019452588632702827, -0.005330442450940609, 0.05846915394067764, 0.03375564515590668, 0.011314941570162773, -0.02230389416217804, -0.04807756841182709, -0.0013313103700056672, 0.07157009840011597, -0.04997514560818672, -0.02533237636089325, -0.03338329866528511, 0.057437289506196976, -0.02275727689266205, -0.017033977434039116 ]
<p>I have a problem with logistic regression. I had found out (<a href="http://www.uk.sagepub.com/burns/website%20material/Chapter%2024%20-%20Logistic%20regression.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>) that one of the assumptions of logistic regression model should be min. of for example 50 observations per predictor. But if I had created dummy variables in Stata using "i." operator, does every dummy category count as new predictor?</p> <p>example: </p> <ul> <li>i.maritalstatus</li> <li>1=Ref.</li> <li>2</li> <li>3 ... </li> </ul> <p>Thank You very much. </p>
74,163
[ -0.05617921054363251, 0.0070832036435604095, -0.010325628332793713, 0.006990713998675346, 0.009397867135703564, -0.0031092632561922073, -0.05444222688674927, -0.011965874582529068, 0.04891609773039818, -0.027295174077153206, 0.03670289367437363, 0.03307397663593292, 0.04626721143722534, 0.016160862520337105, -0.009694421663880348, 0.017846589908003807, -0.005186946131289005, 0.020675338804721832, 0.0006732521578669548, 0.0017972206696867943, -0.027755573391914368, 0.03075217641890049, 0.043240681290626526, 0.010266128927469254, 0.0009149649413302541, 0.06540905684232712, 0.032193541526794434, -0.0014457893557846546, 0.008007902652025223, 0.038615062832832336, 0.01291623990982771, -0.02973201870918274, 0.006481651682406664, 0.02149745635688305, 0.030046764761209488, -0.00804422702640295, -0.016302011907100677, -0.015718095004558563, -0.00480722775682807, -0.016277510672807693, -0.01551846694201231, 0.011153425090014935, -0.005997320171445608, 0.018879789859056473, -0.01214978750795126, 0.020929425954818726, 0.012934839352965355, -0.00828826054930687, 0.03372658044099808, -0.03639468550682068, 0.05240684375166893, 0.01592312753200531, 0.029157308861613274, 0.041907407343387604, -0.03260412812232971, 0.006577234715223312, 0.05076448619365692, 0.07304269075393677, -0.021668707951903343, -0.013386476784944534, -0.047220077365636826, -0.017048969864845276, 0.006600348278880119, -0.03571240231394768, -0.019009506329894066, 0.04673862084746361, -0.019469955936074257, 0.00570286437869072, 0.029338648542761803, -0.010537425987422466, 0.022121239453554153, -0.0416034571826458, 0.0281047560274601, -0.002503608353435993, 0.004593155812472105, -0.01843506470322609, 0.003154990030452609, 0.00948154367506504, 0.01798415370285511, 0.03987658768892288, -0.002882243599742651, 0.005212640855461359, 0.012645116075873375, 0.033303048461675644, 0.03363252803683281, -0.001697359373793006, 0.07908491045236588, -0.019461283460259438, 0.027333557605743408, 0.022318562492728233, -0.021926403045654297, 0.005218492355197668, 0.045166969299316406, -0.0054404838010668755, -0.0031217036303132772, 0.02917463891208172, 0.00040209706639871, 0.04770693555474281, -0.0025851901154965162, 0.022659771144390106, -0.017382459715008736, -0.03831563517451286, 0.028295103460550308, 0.05139186978340149, -0.04149011895060539, 0.020864859223365784, -0.05080018565058708, -0.02542833797633648, 0.018546776846051216, -0.04350319877266884, -0.014658333733677864, -0.000864565372467041, 0.015080925077199936, 0.002696127397939563, -0.024678941816091537, -0.029126690700650215, -0.03406831994652748, -0.027896979823708534, -0.0013664581347256899, 0.026727594435214996, 0.04166409745812416, -0.050239335745573044, 0.010786139406263828, -0.04335378110408783, -0.04458960145711899, 0.04445872828364372, 0.013774692080914974, 0.00379333458840847, -0.06805592775344849, 0.04445129632949829, 0.020472632721066475, -0.033433426171541214, 0.021206222474575043, 0.04361109063029289, 0.002538413507863879, -0.02128767780959606, -0.08757682889699936, -0.05583842471241951, -0.005553467199206352, -0.03181992471218109, 0.021981561556458473, -0.0947418138384819, -0.034198157489299774, -0.019707050174474716, 0.03229201212525368, -0.015687644481658936, 0.04487275332212448, 0.053647466003894806, 0.0414833128452301, 0.04873117059469223, -0.033301472663879395, -0.012562437914311886, -0.07138729095458984, -0.04213828966021538, 0.0012495927512645721, -0.08117169141769409, -0.0065119294449687, -0.004280094522982836, -0.009554358199238777, 0.0022970594000071287, 0.035368505865335464, -0.006815451662987471, -0.022542692720890045, 0.02885514125227928, 0.001592687563970685, -0.03935980424284935, 0.08101040869951248, -0.004980721976608038, 0.048604778945446014, 0.023686619475483894, 0.0032925382256507874, -0.0009420793503522873, 0.0004522870003711432, 0.06719804555177689, 0.03792654350399971, -0.014121079817414284, -0.0006465282058343291, -0.04074426740407944, 0.03377123549580574, 0.03153063356876373, -0.04481886327266693, -0.02156040444970131, 0.0072883665561676025, -0.010362090542912483, -0.009184361435472965, 0.0170830637216568, -0.010379556566476822, -0.017028437927365303, 0.025759223848581314, -0.05875997617840767, -0.051158610731363297, -0.026869427412748337, 0.02601574920117855, -0.0037178252823650837, -0.008317210711538792, 0.0012214648304507136, 0.027043448761105537, 0.06402206420898438, -0.02825932763516903, 0.008207470178604126, -0.028923170641064644, -0.039846405386924744, 0.03133007511496544, -0.06362776458263397, 0.002152570290490985, 0.034887634217739105, 0.03519964590668678, -0.016451723873615265, 0.04794549569487572, -0.06574873626232147, -0.031795863062143326, 0.050567563623189926, 0.01992417313158512, 0.0470283180475235, -0.029841028153896332, -0.014883102849125862, 0.016133766621351242, -0.00676710857078433, -0.02961994893848896, 0.04020651802420616, -0.06037849560379982, 0.044243767857551575, 0.03349517285823822, -0.0018849490443244576, -0.016542159020900726, 0.012224920094013214, -0.008626621216535568, 0.017171982675790787, -0.026249559596180916, -0.026034869253635406, -0.05113007500767708, -0.012453905306756496, 0.044676873832941055, 0.005126642528921366, -0.040831711143255234, 0.0013796854764223099, 0.0453595370054245, -0.0009341316763311625, 0.024756286293268204, 0.01178884319961071, -0.015733279287815094, -0.017308039590716362, 0.014825244434177876, 0.031960856169462204, -0.012458911165595055, 0.02872200310230255, 0.028419746086001396, -0.014286109246313572, 0.04566172882914543, -0.01052358839660883, -0.007823356427252293, 0.0790591686964035, -0.030528659000992775, 0.009117444045841694, -0.013235650025308132, -0.02443377487361431, 0.0636199414730072, -0.042785413563251495, 0.011446963995695114, 0.04966241866350174, 0.030387962237000465, -0.03826173394918442, 0.01566469296813011, 0.007580234203487635, -0.010858297348022461, 0.08161991834640503, -0.01894437149167061, 0.017171498388051987, -0.0026614516973495483, -0.039716191589832306, -0.0015207817777991295, 0.0026153128128498793, -0.020751947537064552, -0.03541141748428345, 0.0037393029779195786, 0.04340256378054619, -0.02037142589688301, 0.027368595823645592, -0.02046755887567997, -0.013921886682510376, 0.00043203606037423015, -0.015147574245929718, 0.05104049667716026, -0.009675761684775352, -0.04577786102890968, -0.027978170663118362, -0.015942679718136787, -0.03648059815168381, 0.006549498997628689, -0.02627062425017357, -0.027775337919592857, 0.017555514350533485, -0.04230191558599472, -0.0358976386487484, 0.006971090100705624, -0.013615228235721588, 0.015261444263160229, -0.014389511197805405, -0.004154979716986418, 0.015261656604707241, 0.02206716127693653, -0.05438443645834923, -0.024255238473415375, -0.04095853492617607, -0.01442292332649231, -0.010871770791709423, -0.034171491861343384, 0.025461921468377113, 0.01545116025954485, -0.005742277484387159, 0.046914149075746536, -0.026670895516872406, 0.0071775526739656925, -0.08780533820390701, -0.06345745921134949, 0.0018615004373714328, 0.028469128534197807, 0.01316610537469387, 0.018762141466140747, -0.02706211246550083, 0.04806875064969063, 0.027090439572930336, -0.03268752992153168, -0.05245843529701233, -0.026163939386606216, -0.013020208105444908, -0.049234773963689804, 0.035952553153038025, -0.002797358436509967, -0.017128942534327507, 0.027729392051696777, 0.002720668213441968, 0.000979483244009316, 0.019984737038612366, 0.014497893862426281, 0.0030315390322357416, 0.0074967266991734505, 0.007636270020157099, -0.03262542188167572, 0.06144126132130623, 0.04624064639210701, -0.024628406390547752, -0.008400768041610718, -0.037911612540483475, 0.05332956463098526, -0.018082458525896072, -0.02476140297949314, 0.010468419641256332, -0.025283515453338623, 0.011178070679306984, -0.024032151326537132, -0.02231442555785179, 0.017672426998615265, -0.05630217865109444, -0.014895857311785221, -0.02365385740995407, 0.009473161771893501, -0.009761840105056763, -0.009776630438864231, 0.014716303907334805, -0.0073339855298399925, 0.0061612119898200035, 0.027417480945587158, -0.031240690499544144, -0.011045112274587154, 0.02498472109436989, 0.008921358734369278, -0.02653391845524311, 0.022813182324171066, 0.030924776569008827, 0.003545173443853855, -0.004085715860128403, -0.059910744428634644, 0.025201743468642235, -0.03293652832508087, -0.03560858964920044, 0.0053885579109191895, 0.048677653074264526, 0.01193272229284048, 0.0167430080473423, 0.0019455332076177, -0.02081824280321598, -0.0047095888294279575, 0.0077185858972370625, -0.06533771753311157, 0.010386745445430279, 0.007929899729788303, 0.0012533896369859576, 0.04348570853471756, -0.062034498900175095, 0.02814704179763794, -0.040800388902425766, 0.00008596076077083126, 0.012326001189649105, 0.004666751250624657, -0.029460223391652107, -0.002414093818515539, 0.010454192757606506, -0.01990364119410515, 0.033143140375614166, -0.0083305137231946, -0.005985156632959843, -0.008862410672008991, 0.008849565871059895, 0.021697433665394783, 0.011904988437891006, -0.023874694481492043, -0.047905243933200836, -0.008612401783466339, 0.006395999807864428, 0.06708275526762009, 0.03018295019865036, -0.005374758038669825, -0.06550299376249313, 0.02848215214908123, -0.02656245417892933, 0.04996563121676445, 0.029052136465907097, -0.01813868246972561, -0.025143994018435478, -0.023329447954893112, -0.00086116703459993, 0.000475927023217082, 0.0032381454948335886, 0.022381572052836418, 0.01849392056465149, 0.04746206849813461, 0.025924887508153915, -0.02726028673350811, -0.004751368425786495, 0.08464577794075012, 0.03308263048529625, 0.006953433156013489, -0.01965317316353321, -0.004310464020818472, 0.0002667618391569704, 0.017671458423137665, 0.024768667295575142, -0.019880203530192375, 0.012238319031894207, 0.01233394630253315, 0.07999484241008759, -0.027470290660858154, -0.02449844405055046, -0.011461847461760044, 0.020722288638353348, 0.036904700100421906, -0.0053383042104542255, -0.046492740511894226, 0.04080667346715927, 0.009576709941029549, 0.03288044407963753, 0.035665325820446014, 0.03259808570146561, -0.09780013561248779, 0.024822816252708435, 0.018701577559113503, 0.028796369209885597, -0.05072815343737602, -0.04087395966053009, -0.004084439016878605, 0.012356585822999477, 0.03316143900156021, -0.05446740612387657, -0.010001440532505512, -0.016476156190037727, 0.02857942134141922, -0.003038231749087572, -0.05261237919330597, -0.058560434728860855, 0.013694459572434425, -0.004821727517992258, 0.007722781039774418, 0.013762280344963074, -0.0029806680977344513, -0.03545399010181427, 0.032103244215250015, -0.003947838209569454, 0.06381954997777939, -0.027371054515242577, 0.007606307044625282, 0.02557627111673355, 0.02016197144985199, -0.025726690888404846, -0.05205455794930458, 0.02033373713493347, 0.00742891663685441, -0.008882367052137852, 0.035912901163101196, 0.0022805568296462297, -0.007942799478769302, -0.01552146952599287, 0.06932276487350464, -0.04004048556089401, -0.022149711847305298, -0.06056443229317665, 0.03071719966828823, -0.0478849932551384, -0.019706547260284424, 0.03407829627394676, 0.035327211022377014, 0.015515127219259739, 0.010271054692566395, -0.04426132142543793, 0.0269874669611454, -0.03147779032588005, -0.04831639304757118, -0.04648248478770256, 0.006190982181578875, 0.01795022375881672, 0.01031051017343998, -0.015159034170210361, -0.004433018155395985, -0.030358392745256424, -0.012973104603588581, -0.003097423817962408, 0.0490269809961319, -0.028532017022371292, 0.025688091292977333, -0.01004940364509821, 0.039762675762176514, -0.0011321395868435502, -0.04601476341485977, 0.020199762657284737, -0.020807713270187378, 0.0029942162800580263, 0.00601829681545496, -0.004408508073538542, 0.008068131282925606, -0.0056387679651379585, -0.02482846938073635, 0.005629904568195343, -0.024105528369545937, 0.02373896911740303, -0.012631944380700588, 0.002388736931607127, -0.01563563384115696, -0.03829938918352127, 0.02017878368496895, -0.007471644319593906, -0.003446969436481595, -0.002342968713492155, -0.009306342341005802, 0.02356002852320671, -0.0070297131314873695, -0.026238983497023582, -0.0643455982208252, -0.05232393741607666, 0.026352064684033394, -0.045609232038259506, -0.06546255946159363, -0.025087552145123482, -0.002575857797637582, -0.03549991548061371, -0.03987288847565651, -0.010969233699142933, 0.05559908598661423, -0.01155077200382948, -0.022119708359241486, -0.012332798913121223, 0.04315327852964401, 0.04776120185852051, 0.03721834719181061, -0.04155481606721878, -0.0017241515452042222, -0.01998608559370041, -0.007539173122495413, 0.013576441444456577, 0.008238923735916615, -0.021892741322517395, -0.009330694563686848, -0.02652137540280819, 0.0005140102002769709, -0.0019780572038143873, 0.010095459409058094, 0.024357670918107033, -0.02365087904036045, -0.017589233815670013, 0.035779133439064026, -0.05409974977374077, 0.00010897711763391271, -0.023004552349448204, 0.004434383939951658, -0.02766048163175583, 0.042686812579631805, 0.010410173796117306, 0.009338286705315113, 0.04430828616023064, 0.00962737575173378, 0.005234421696513891, 0.014052736572921276, 0.07958655059337616, 0.03750329464673996, 0.028320567682385445, -0.001785251428373158, -0.03613929823040962, 0.05010141804814339, 0.03096000663936138, -0.03766397014260292, 0.0007439317414537072, 0.016467837616801262, -0.01719113066792488, -0.03324782848358154, -0.035208266228437424, 0.02399761788547039, 0.025141581892967224, 0.019149821251630783, 0.017197202891111374, 0.042341198772192, -0.007655313704162836, 0.02964501827955246, -0.047450482845306396, 0.00393651332706213, -0.000139212905196473, 0.014299045316874981, 0.04574676975607872, -0.011985212564468384, -0.013764766044914722, 0.048188284039497375, 0.018249567598104477, 0.021634813398122787, 0.044090427458286285, 0.01813410595059395, 0.03550652042031288, -0.009513020515441895, -0.026364410296082497, -0.05290732905268669, -0.0003535322321113199, -0.031494446098804474, 0.0006085240165702999, -0.03580327704548836, -0.008882982656359673, 0.01357930526137352, 0.03103497438132763, 0.03411686420440674, -0.033900413662195206, -0.035002078860998154, -0.02467154711484909, 0.025386154651641846, 0.011614897288382053, -0.00561547139659524, 0.031418099999427795, -0.02063489891588688, -0.0024009058251976967, 0.0054545216262340546, 0.023806244134902954, -0.0259221363812685, -0.07459679991006851, -0.050675466656684875, -0.026435991749167442, 0.0013644410064443946, 0.02665928192436695, -0.005520997103303671, -0.02735009975731373, 0.022990593686699867, -0.042879536747932434, 0.007672331761568785, -0.021277520805597305, 0.03584178164601326, 0.03525479510426521, 0.06593447923660278, 0.03640345484018326, 0.04092303290963173, 0.008841410279273987, 0.012457638047635555, 0.14448991417884827, 0.0883226990699768, 0.022673960775136948, -0.036881495267152786, 0.008451313711702824, 0.03488174080848694, 0.010101553052663803, -0.0016282983124256134, 0.00014987171743996441, -0.003620886942371726, -0.03484542667865753, 0.04255712032318115, 0.02887427806854248, 0.024326058104634285, -0.00034069688990712166, 0.07335488498210907, -0.026575857773423195, -0.04260414466261864, 0.008279679343104362, -0.000453784829005599, 0.010514172725379467, -0.015581822022795677, -0.00862510222941637, 0.025959493592381477, 0.01542217843234539, -0.017789429053664207, -0.03301365301012993, 0.02359737455844879, -0.017928561195731163, 0.010974791832268238, -0.05015844106674194, -0.031577691435813904, 0.057960961014032364, 0.0202917642891407, -0.011733047664165497, 0.00149836007039994, 0.02388565056025982, -0.012719407677650452, -0.017818203195929527, 0.034538961946964264, -0.05490371584892273, 0.017783062532544136, 0.04415901005268097, -0.016234522685408592, -0.03340526297688484, -0.018115412443876266, -0.055747393518686295, 0.03958375006914139, -0.034744955599308014, 0.03328844532370567, -0.02899574674665928, 0.008402878418564796, -0.005737200379371643, -0.03380707651376724, -0.034929145127534866, 0.03536808863282204, 0.015767574310302734, -0.009282448329031467, -0.044392604380846024, -0.019343633204698563, 0.014453139156103134, 0.006762880831956863, 0.020384810864925385, 0.004065810702741146, -0.02762393094599247, -0.016720224171876907, -0.021804703399538994, 0.034907594323158264, -0.010811633430421352, 0.009166436269879341, 0.029143746942281723, -0.01760789565742016, -0.04391928389668465, -0.032735425978899, 0.015863116830587387, 0.03107387386262417, 0.036923427134752274, -0.018110573291778564, -0.01915745809674263, -0.042117033153772354, -0.03973523527383804, -0.03138488158583641, -0.008266432210803032, -0.018702374771237373, -0.05369877815246582, 0.01495305635035038, 0.027400141581892967, 0.05663809925317764, -0.02189006470143795, 0.01555943675339222, 0.02845899946987629, 0.042463518679142, -0.021117936819791794, -0.021387891843914986, -0.0007772481185384095, 0.03598608449101448, -0.036519408226013184, 0.01778717152774334, -0.02870764210820198, 0.038185738027095795, 0.01784336566925049, 0.056581173092126846, 0.00831605028361082, 0.06392931938171387, 0.003322517266497016, 0.060918670147657394, 0.035733308643102646, -0.050137847661972046, 0.01144446711987257, 0.03095037303864956, 0.004613586701452732, -0.026733871549367905, -0.02520095184445381, -0.035754088312387466, -0.042574893683195114, 0.05326513200998306, -0.026315271854400635, -0.05445186421275139, -0.0041557010263204575, -0.008916805498301983, 0.021131625398993492, -0.030390964820981026, -0.027954472228884697, -0.035231977701187134, -0.006847233045846224, 0.006348549388349056, -0.022978898137807846, -0.006969787180423737, 0.027760904282331467, -0.006580739747732878, 0.02412758208811283, 0.05910506099462509, 0.015724606812000275, -0.01345164142549038, -0.011132553219795227, 0.03055489994585514, 0.007333904504776001, 0.041260071098804474, -0.021200360730290413, -0.023695221170783043, 0.006133437156677246, -0.017987530678510666, 0.004111891612410545, 0.04221789166331291, -0.021456841379404068, 0.02464984729886055, 0.06517389416694641, 0.008610299788415432, -0.017148906365036964, 0.08726856112480164, -0.01257590763270855, 0.011411143466830254, -0.02607479691505432, 0.015739312395453453, 0.03338388353586197, 0.003336953930556774, -0.010078571736812592, 0.05042220279574394, -0.03502029553055763, 0.017690930515527725, 0.07734131813049316, 0.0013452765997499228, -0.014126184396445751, 0.015195782296359539, 0.017815180122852325, 0.03377384692430496, 0.002916054567322135, 0.013415036723017693, 0.012417670339345932, 0.04223113879561424, -0.0008259525056928396, 0.05807057395577431, -0.0034920985344797373, 0.0461723692715168, -0.09928911924362183, -0.04268680140376091, 0.01278507336974144, 0.03704855591058731, 0.029591556638479233, -0.05817848816514015, -0.004765592515468597, 0.012590975500643253, -0.031852155923843384, 0.01550852321088314, 0.035837624222040176, -0.014829440042376518, -0.04476858302950859, -0.0033195570576936007, -0.03461434692144394, 0.007574357558041811, 0.02238057181239128, 0.007324438076466322, 0.0003240159130655229, 0.04131569340825081, 0.010693060234189034, -0.051002271473407745, -0.009034380316734314, 0.01777813397347927, 0.0036053836811333895, -0.030146343633532524, 0.03852766007184982, -0.050216883420944214, -0.06383238732814789, 0.051633015275001526, 0.015496613457798958, 0.03142137452960014, 0.0418105386197567, 0.015253192745149136, 0.01713462732732296, 0.050886742770671844, 0.03328515589237213, 0.027122164145112038, 0.011887889355421066, 0.05483395233750343, 0.0031721668783575296, 0.03543569892644882, -0.005865724757313728, 0.0005589593201875687, 0.03027341142296791, -0.03301973640918732, -0.05711620673537254, -0.006784047000110149, -0.004361792467534542, 0.009702972136437893, -0.013252079486846924, 0.00154308439232409, -0.01028437353670597, -0.0214061439037323, 0.007533479481935501, -0.03631475567817688, 0.015923501923680305, 0.06310329586267471, 0.006835614331066608, -0.011305894702672958, -0.020672310143709183, -0.0059960996732115746, -0.024507662281394005, 0.006192117463797331, 0.01676151342689991, 0.0007477190811187029, -0.07364435493946075, 0.009043525904417038, 0.013465670868754387, -0.004747082944959402, -0.02091064676642418, 0.03169107064604759, -0.049152448773384094, 0.04533788189291954, -0.030863866209983826, -0.026792697608470917, 0.02677137777209282, -0.01748066395521164, 0.010491784662008286, -0.08002215623855591, 0.0685906857252121, -0.00012055863771820441, -0.027180830016732216, -0.04646369814872742, -0.03309956565499306, -0.031499020755290985, -0.004471325781196356, 0.03104497119784355, 0.0018482408486306667, 0.0008311343262903392, 0.005624935496598482, 0.024286719039082527, -0.004668814595788717, -0.0013469225959852338, 0.0342491939663887, 0.021877383813261986, -0.008275256492197514, -0.02610182948410511, -0.015284259803593159, -0.007181367836892605, 0.005211813375353813, 0.012595725245773792, -0.006066435482352972, -0.008308801800012589, 0.007969724014401436, -0.01050366461277008, 0.01987607032060623, -0.014828241430222988, 0.014067025855183601, 0.057190097868442535, 0.011493216268718243, 0.02613702416419983, 0.015954310074448586, -0.02234816551208496, -0.039897650480270386, 0.022614190354943275, -0.026478933170437813, -0.014345185831189156, 0.007696731016039848, 0.00021248655684757978, -0.028107579797506332, -0.0071663749404251575, 0.03822459280490875, 0.035963453352451324, 0.011322993785142899, 0.03649367764592171, 0.0184207521378994, 0.02802407555282116, 0.053835656493902206, -0.04475891590118408, -0.007782473228871822, 0.01092638447880745, -0.07127445936203003, 0.014189908280968666, 0.03196771442890167, -0.004680566024035215, -0.0027976769488304853, -0.005047524347901344, 0.00997932255268097, -0.008366644382476807, 0.029924754053354263, 0.02693004161119461, 0.04032548889517784, 0.023343613371253014, -0.01014760322868824, -0.0009511345415376127, 0.0007893095025792718, 0.06042686104774475, 0.007423532661050558, 0.0023328792303800583, 0.004200358875095844, -0.03300044685602188, -0.018171628937125206, -0.0626256987452507, 0.006077754311263561, -0.040936220437288284, -0.005049466621130705, 0.01580926403403282, 0.04961840435862541, 0.014401888474822044, -0.008334946818649769, 0.007351390086114407, -0.03796018287539482, 0.00042765241232700646, -0.013144630007445812, 0.0352579690515995, 0.01556751411408186, 0.006132840178906918, -0.027408970519900322, -0.013331376947462559, -0.0015535772545263171, -0.028392989188432693, 0.04682059958577156, 0.06944996118545532, -0.0006332290358841419, -0.03019760549068451, -0.047892291098833084, -0.020877167582511902, 0.04208362475037575, -0.020702289417386055, -0.004030563402920961, -0.06436114013195038, -0.0033515319228172302, -0.007812348660081625, -0.04990954324603081 ]
<p>I am an ml noob. I have a task at hand of predicting click probability given user information like city, state, os version, os family, device, browser family browser version, city, etc. I have been recommended to try logit since logit seems to be what MS and Google are using too. I have some questions regarding logistic regression like:</p> <p>Click and non click is a very very unbalanced class and the simple glm predictions do not look good. How to make the data work through this?</p> <p>All variables I have are categorical and things like device and city can be numerous. Also the frequency of occurrence of some devices or some cities can be very very low. So how to deal with what I can say is a very random variety of categorical variables?</p> <p>One of the variables that we get is device id also. This is a very unique feature that can be translated to a user's identity. How to make use of it in logit, or should it be used in a completely different model based on a user identity?</p>
74,164
[ -0.05052919313311577, -0.013534370809793472, 0.02835603803396225, 0.0167885422706604, 0.02553989179432392, 0.014764473773539066, -0.038792241364717484, -0.027420539408922195, 0.040861669927835464, -0.04610562324523926, 0.03842684254050255, 0.03794075921177864, 0.054157137870788574, 0.007589500863105059, 0.022678401321172714, -0.012277883477509022, 0.03484199941158295, -0.019451526924967766, -0.007486769463866949, 0.023565491661429405, -0.02218393236398697, 0.02030446194112301, 0.009111178107559681, -0.01114443689584732, -0.0161985382437706, 0.04716823250055313, -0.0028210284654051065, -0.040651727467775345, 0.008677275851368904, 0.044157058000564575, -0.0372578389942646, -0.00079943030141294, -0.011075547896325588, 0.02546469308435917, -0.008944596163928509, 0.0184372216463089, -0.035574473440647125, -0.02070503868162632, -0.024969598278403282, -0.007725657429546118, -0.010292546823620796, 0.003303924575448036, 0.03365517407655716, 0.03272782266139984, -0.0030258120968937874, -0.0055107129737734795, -0.019571049138903618, -0.014667082577943802, 0.017265714704990387, -0.031275831162929535, 0.04834641516208649, -0.009007352404296398, 0.05214828997850418, 0.05178815498948097, -0.016744669526815414, 0.02295294776558876, 0.058575090020895004, 0.06574055552482605, -0.01310395821928978, -0.02137695625424385, -0.0047763194888830185, -0.04781084880232811, 0.004226079210639, -0.05017627403140068, -0.002818554174154997, 0.042817890644073486, -0.005186669994145632, -0.006092320661991835, 0.07390119135379791, -0.015969978645443916, 0.04932393133640289, -0.002425817074254155, 0.03402002900838852, 0.011610167101025581, 0.0018595452420413494, -0.0479796826839447, 0.02215026691555977, -0.0007683651056140661, 0.04430228844285011, 0.008111946284770966, -0.0033081145957112312, 0.018568312749266624, -0.000043530919356271625, 0.02068139798939228, 0.04634375870227814, -0.033625759184360504, 0.04709693044424057, -0.02273605950176716, -0.007592147681862116, 0.04363533854484558, -0.039229199290275574, -0.0007172105833888054, 0.04991111159324646, 0.011564724147319794, -0.050748370587825775, 0.0575222484767437, 0.004644682165235281, 0.04083921015262604, 0.029356515035033226, 0.01683468371629715, -0.007567295804619789, -0.026672696694731712, 0.010464628227055073, 0.0635889545083046, -0.02763761766254902, -0.027140263468027115, -0.011369832791388035, -0.03283166140317917, -0.00912370067089796, -0.036203619092702866, -0.013357586227357388, -0.00020532349299173802, -0.01255313865840435, -0.001597306807525456, 0.016829852014780045, -0.024873889982700348, -0.033406298607587814, -0.04944928362965584, 0.025878140702843666, 0.05237358808517456, 0.028225449845194817, -0.0439940020442009, 0.02474544383585453, -0.06255419552326202, -0.03245547041296959, 0.01565084606409073, 0.0036302756052464247, -0.018702397122979164, -0.019425107166171074, 0.046360697597265244, -0.03456418216228485, -0.04856155067682266, 0.026827462017536163, 0.010472848080098629, 0.035857729613780975, 0.01016815472394228, -0.07723519951105118, -0.045767102390527725, 0.018171245232224464, -0.045626699924468994, 0.007574042305350304, -0.04502497985959053, -0.009538521058857441, -0.004597721621394157, 0.046316660940647125, 0.003998275380581617, 0.020902350544929504, 0.05349383503198624, 0.007771475240588188, 0.00040377446566708386, -0.028979793190956116, 0.012170400470495224, -0.03567814081907272, 0.008045714348554611, -0.015141069889068604, -0.0888732299208641, 0.03774530068039894, -0.005572146270424128, 0.010833146050572395, -0.033450957387685776, 0.04241516813635826, 0.008676006458699703, -0.05181964486837387, -0.0075525990687310696, -0.0013210033066570759, -0.010802889242768288, 0.07586167752742767, -0.020350323989987373, 0.05791400372982025, 0.03345063701272011, -0.01605754904448986, 0.009343431331217289, 0.029201101511716843, 0.04473146051168442, 0.0328642800450325, 0.02134072035551071, 0.0027404441498219967, -0.06331676244735718, -0.012824646197259426, -0.0005217676516622305, -0.014912369661033154, -0.025261379778385162, -0.028742674738168716, -0.02063368819653988, 0.005996042862534523, 0.00917659979313612, 0.006499261595308781, -0.011382426135241985, 0.049967195838689804, -0.041776783764362335, -0.06640429049730301, -0.04904764145612717, 0.035128332674503326, -0.017708133906126022, 0.00789845921099186, 0.009593675844371319, -0.02376393973827362, 0.027246829122304916, -0.001311018131673336, -0.020271573215723038, -0.044571295380592346, -0.014300590381026268, 0.018781591206789017, -0.04345669969916344, -0.03833277150988579, 0.039246831089258194, 0.010376682505011559, -0.04428131505846977, 0.03343908116221428, -0.030942382290959358, -0.042733535170555115, 0.028216399252414703, 0.01976732723414898, -0.013382997363805771, -0.029159903526306152, -0.029893355444073677, 0.017284255474805832, -0.008618422783911228, -0.04356972128152847, 0.01187666691839695, -0.054557014256715775, 0.053446631878614426, 0.06658978760242462, 0.00514184171333909, 0.011234215460717678, 0.015785561874508858, -0.034938909113407135, -0.012480881065130234, -0.02510724402964115, -0.005546468310058117, -0.059978850185871124, 0.001091713085770607, 0.030111143365502357, -0.024059657007455826, -0.0025812096428126097, 0.032343216240406036, 0.04844207316637039, 0.04435785487294197, 0.02392536960542202, -0.011218341998755932, -0.012067991308867931, 0.008783437311649323, 0.004507976118475199, 0.01690627634525299, 0.01333430502563715, 0.010217155329883099, 0.004623352084308863, -0.00790250301361084, 0.02012506127357483, -0.015753554180264473, -0.03437207639217377, 0.05115494504570961, -0.000046658995415782556, -0.013645409606397152, -0.034608494490385056, 0.001251587294973433, 0.05755874514579773, 0.002426772378385067, -0.004600010812282562, 0.05830666795372963, 0.019742300733923912, -0.0006161469500511885, 0.007183308247476816, -0.004836077801883221, 0.009679080918431282, 0.04073788970708847, -0.0515153594315052, -0.032393552362918854, 0.010681678541004658, -0.053155284374952316, 0.04165789112448692, 0.014302203431725502, -0.025601498782634735, -0.04515713080763817, 0.01525574829429388, 0.01639394275844097, -0.017459014430642128, 0.01969984732568264, -0.006854247767478228, -0.07016096264123917, 0.00944212544709444, -0.023352624848484993, -0.0031725456938147545, 0.004604910034686327, -0.07014399766921997, 0.011807173490524292, -0.04112397879362106, -0.008035635575652122, 0.03535708785057068, -0.0003117111336905509, -0.024815410375595093, 0.020374124869704247, 0.006350236479192972, -0.06571692228317261, -0.017338942736387253, -0.05407680571079254, 0.006547978147864342, -0.006732380483299494, -0.01898542046546936, 0.0059493305161595345, 0.0009124542120844126, -0.025150492787361145, 0.0093341413885355, -0.039730943739414215, -0.022359594702720642, -0.01993044652044773, -0.015833934769034386, 0.03346077352762222, 0.010257283225655556, 0.029324261471629143, 0.021603386849164963, -0.0014961533015593886, 0.017717968672513962, -0.09645333886146545, -0.04981531947851181, 0.05214934051036835, 0.0016541603254154325, 0.05924917757511139, 0.0019048613030463457, 0.003810181515291333, 0.07229883223772049, 0.03820100799202919, -0.02384035848081112, -0.060853708535432816, -0.0322674959897995, -0.023127039894461632, -0.03561744838953018, -0.004623182583600283, 0.03389083966612816, -0.00048025764408521354, 0.013894966803491116, -0.00498268473893404, -0.010147311724722385, 0.03619833290576935, -0.0013130430597811937, 0.008374623954296112, 0.06255423277616501, 0.0026994538493454456, 0.002054978162050247, 0.05406457558274269, 0.03381095081567764, -0.028077496215701103, 0.03605648875236511, -0.028693586587905884, 0.00885855033993721, 0.011873233132064342, -0.03170351684093475, 0.018591253086924553, -0.0068283239379525185, 0.007337024435400963, -0.03307114169001579, -0.014565137214958668, -0.008383946493268013, -0.07705715298652649, 0.0066315652802586555, 0.017123034223914146, 0.03541915491223335, -0.015497607178986073, 0.024850482121109962, 0.06861048936843872, 0.03329651057720184, -0.012718131765723228, -0.042165227234363556, -0.008628671057522297, -0.013777460902929306, 0.003813386894762516, -0.008452128618955612, 0.006492228712886572, 0.013926271349191666, 0.042452774941921234, -0.009786712937057018, -0.0068227993324398994, -0.03628051280975342, -0.01088973879814148, -0.05846221745014191, -0.0008569196797907352, -0.011564546264708042, 0.04826115816831589, -0.00367816723883152, -0.008432780392467976, 0.025677457451820374, -0.027569320052862167, -0.0022160664666444063, 0.031246298924088478, -0.0626458004117012, 0.014956485480070114, 0.00333571364171803, -0.013139334507286549, 0.002489557024091482, -0.05178738012909889, 0.05325337499380112, -0.00006609574484173208, 0.01812874525785446, -0.0021210273262113333, 0.00589849054813385, -0.022656792774796486, 0.013527752831578255, -0.00979895330965519, -0.012045982293784618, -0.011148624122142792, -0.03145976364612579, -0.00447934539988637, 0.03209301829338074, 0.002081275684759021, 0.02492676116526127, 0.016208648681640625, -0.036538124084472656, -0.0037103204522281885, -0.012625182047486305, 0.00028235779609531164, 0.036051832139492035, -0.003522289451211691, -0.010381980799138546, -0.04652469977736473, 0.018685560673475266, 0.0011666454374790192, 0.04739176481962204, 0.07203779369592667, -0.005772057455033064, -0.031889334321022034, -0.05948537960648537, -0.062484364956617355, 0.024082133546471596, 0.029206424951553345, 0.008470783941447735, 0.026782574132084846, 0.04811093211174011, 0.051303476095199585, -0.046290136873722076, -0.018063027411699295, 0.06470615416765213, 0.028255650773644447, -0.03571688383817673, -0.027650432661175728, 0.009946315549314022, -0.022241326048970222, -0.003067828482016921, 0.021572725847363472, 0.01167925726622343, -0.007382101844996214, -0.00858156569302082, 0.018515167757868767, -0.021356727927923203, -0.026759503409266472, 0.017768938094377518, 0.015095598995685577, 0.040937390178442, -0.002378846285864711, -0.08004766702651978, 0.0024092597886919975, 0.0672188401222229, 0.018026703968644142, 0.027991753071546555, 0.02120986208319664, -0.10122797638177872, 0.01616019383072853, 0.061099663376808167, 0.04896163567900658, -0.044225264340639114, -0.0020118942484259605, -0.01819349080324173, 0.04108363762497902, -0.013525629416108131, -0.032933980226516724, 0.00871313363313675, -0.008417665027081966, 0.012931635603308678, -0.003929636906832457, -0.004124414175748825, -0.049264609813690186, -0.003938497509807348, -0.03740653395652771, 0.03949667513370514, -0.03848683461546898, -0.01503254845738411, -0.05126726254820824, 0.021707290783524513, -0.007092328276485205, 0.04476891830563545, -0.021795954555273056, -0.030311740934848785, 0.046690721064805984, 0.029084576293826103, -0.006418281234800816, -0.027340717613697052, 0.0052893394604325294, 0.016793720424175262, -0.011458342894911766, 0.041759468615055084, -0.0028534261509776115, -0.03300471231341362, 0.003573312656953931, 0.029291635379195213, -0.01685311086475849, -0.01596306636929512, -0.02680223435163498, 0.0029667511116713285, -0.006443808786571026, -0.005739666521549225, 0.04634798690676689, 0.005787569563835859, 0.01789681613445282, 0.004696310963481665, -0.050641439855098724, -0.012878675013780594, -0.023155156522989273, -0.049401648342609406, -0.024740375578403473, -0.030992446467280388, -0.003943167626857758, 0.006629189010709524, 0.015280117280781269, 0.03231823071837425, -0.02664550393819809, -0.014911334961652756, -0.013233193196356297, 0.0218505896627903, -0.012063009664416313, 0.00011764764349209145, 0.018041031435132027, 0.03692064434289932, 0.005462281405925751, 0.0026907946448773146, -0.002509858924895525, -0.004541186150163412, 0.03647446259856224, -0.00889228843152523, -0.022926948964595795, 0.012410184368491173, -0.03534713387489319, -0.027409499511122704, -0.003635871922597289, -0.03090530075132847, 0.02928672917187214, 0.04041349142789841, 0.035543292760849, 0.01304997131228447, -0.052505940198898315, -0.005657872650772333, 0.01304340735077858, 0.0027397326193749905, 0.04158155620098114, -0.05090624466538429, 0.0425792820751667, -0.03625086694955826, -0.03238675743341446, -0.051170799881219864, -0.04040677100419998, 0.014659727923572063, -0.028064165264368057, -0.05724010616540909, -0.01358777191489935, 0.02153243124485016, -0.03541458025574684, -0.04025087133049965, -0.00897922646254301, 0.015087304636836052, -0.014534351415932178, 0.021286826580762863, -0.009813081473112106, 0.0353865846991539, 0.07927242666482925, 0.021852320060133934, -0.009049862623214722, -0.012340136803686619, -0.024799352511763573, -0.0142325758934021, -0.01494590938091278, 0.015446276403963566, -0.016532449051737785, -0.03427586704492569, -0.0201262254267931, 0.015657583251595497, 0.03240052983164787, -0.02769608050584793, 0.00480536837130785, 0.020097745582461357, -0.0014451644383370876, -0.0067717768251895905, -0.034921251237392426, 0.02901262231171131, 0.04041791707277298, 0.002938775811344385, 0.009873369708657265, 0.03842483460903168, -0.033287715166807175, 0.004138925112783909, 0.07970030605792999, 0.005371596664190292, 0.012322782538831234, 0.013211422599852085, 0.06053699553012848, 0.014023343101143837, 0.04914066940546036, -0.012501515448093414, -0.019691118970513344, 0.08879391103982925, 0.0006726264837197959, -0.005279786419123411, -0.00033111206721514463, 0.02108880877494812, -0.039454516023397446, -0.03271026909351349, -0.04095776006579399, 0.0024422043934464455, 0.03503331542015076, -0.0043766736052930355, 0.03465443477034569, 0.06667444109916687, -0.00535432156175375, 0.006025567185133696, -0.012124232016503811, -0.021749621257185936, -0.014360184781253338, 0.026014093309640884, 0.056549690663814545, 0.04348531365394592, -0.013046013191342354, 0.01203646045178175, 0.014660421758890152, 0.06432080268859863, 0.025233067572116852, 0.03694168105721474, 0.016276266425848007, 0.04551321268081665, -0.013737938366830349, -0.03142406418919563, 0.02661421149969101, -0.03664298355579376, 0.013086332939565182, -0.05170411244034767, -0.017529290169477463, 0.03844523802399635, 0.016533421352505684, 0.012830945663154125, -0.05131985619664192, -0.03710341081023216, -0.08911801129579544, 0.015630654990673065, 0.016410011798143387, 0.007694856729358435, 0.015042303130030632, 0.022918984293937683, 0.01732059381902218, -0.004967562388628721, -0.00023007162963040173, -0.020453795790672302, -0.11458758264780045, -0.04082446172833443, -0.031116237863898277, -0.03284904733300209, -0.0016406199429184198, 0.010721592232584953, -0.01609973795711994, 0.029767006635665894, -0.04155915975570679, 0.019602183252573013, -0.003296984825283289, 0.03132537752389908, 0.024038437753915787, 0.08379565179347992, -0.013453089632093906, 0.011053257621824741, -0.030965181067585945, 0.006986979860812426, 0.11834847182035446, 0.08256348222494125, 0.043400928378105164, -0.07556748390197754, -0.027264153584837914, 0.01667727157473564, -0.004547858610749245, -0.027818713337183, -0.00821977760642767, 0.0014623090391978621, 0.022146670147776604, 0.064978688955307, -0.041356999427080154, 0.015165182761847973, -0.006674010306596756, 0.09024924784898758, -0.024928854778409004, -0.013154339045286179, 0.013568054884672165, -0.00155887589789927, -0.020794745534658432, -0.016733502969145775, -0.04283026605844498, -0.0007656870293430984, -0.021719040349125862, -0.010130586102604866, 0.0166805237531662, -0.03491060063242912, 0.016474392265081406, -0.016355160623788834, 0.0072761522606015205, -0.008883485570549965, 0.020876877009868622, 0.011120025999844074, 0.012742227874696255, -0.02396158128976822, -0.0043580131605267525, -0.03603450208902359, 0.01094743236899376, 0.026799796149134636, -0.005796744022518396, -0.02872868999838829, -0.016546567901968956, 0.022592725232243538, -0.027319852262735367, -0.037846583873033524, -0.03846488893032074, 0.04623150825500488, -0.043411415070295334, -0.01540121715515852, -0.0005302042700350285, 0.04992641508579254, -0.03123297356069088, -0.015277626924216747, -0.037817664444446564, 0.020305035635828972, 0.057211462408304214, -0.008581599220633507, -0.01414206437766552, -0.05780462175607681, 0.02878636308014393, 0.0017610673094168305, 0.01966290920972824, -0.003248254070058465, -0.0023726890794932842, 0.004379326943308115, -0.015285844914615154, 0.03869906812906265, -0.003310004249215126, 0.019520042464137077, 0.010257312096655369, -0.02137046493589878, -0.02693263627588749, -0.04048292711377144, 0.01928694173693657, -0.03818561136722565, 0.009704286232590675, -0.022897716611623764, 0.008007701486349106, -0.02165653184056282, -0.030057532712817192, -0.011163635179400444, -0.012101858854293823, 0.01965881884098053, -0.045682262629270554, 0.04572620987892151, -0.0035673542879521847, 0.03968086838722229, 0.027453474700450897, 0.04422307014465332, -0.015689458698034286, 0.009084255434572697, -0.005421502981334925, -0.023750079795718193, -0.001163317239843309, -0.020741857588291168, -0.04222239553928375, -0.0001638758840272203, -0.012168590910732746, 0.046817488968372345, 0.009820463135838509, 0.01108485646545887, -0.0019114413298666477, 0.024155268445611, 0.01539610791951418, 0.008115782402455807, -0.012081330642104149, -0.06192586570978165, -0.023747321218252182, -0.016896653920412064, 0.009457855485379696, 0.005302239675074816, -0.05219367891550064, -0.026945022866129875, -0.018522880971431732, 0.015855060890316963, -0.019495481625199318, -0.037087637931108475, -0.005444036331027746, 0.005324705969542265, 0.0493113249540329, 0.001705302856862545, -0.005203611217439175, -0.029858779162168503, 0.03579149395227432, 0.0006410275236703455, -0.04974992200732231, 0.030345365405082703, 0.01973991096019745, 0.008498935028910637, 0.0022004107013344765, 0.008436664007604122, 0.023933306336402893, 0.00054406828712672, 0.009077618829905987, 0.034830112010240555, -0.03963671624660492, 0.06618401408195496, -0.05774965509772301, -0.009448215365409851, 0.037512991577386856, -0.036575235426425934, -0.011266347020864487, 0.040492668747901917, -0.03155592083930969, 0.03424103185534477, 0.025041954591870308, -0.015855539590120316, 0.03655167669057846, 0.053681693971157074, -0.014797049574553967, -0.0180797316133976, -0.014721695333719254, 0.022259587422013283, 0.03395259007811546, 0.03347063437104225, 0.0018628506222739816, 0.020110342651605606, 0.001351587357930839, 0.019765580072999, 0.08038550615310669, 0.0015212891157716513, -0.006723462603986263, 0.023862721398472786, 0.02845720760524273, 0.05507844686508179, -0.01479170098900795, 0.007205206900835037, 0.027834627777338028, 0.053818315267562866, -0.025069545954465866, 0.009992334060370922, 0.03233417496085167, 0.014220872893929482, -0.0682893767952919, -0.049006976187229156, 0.04327342286705971, -0.013993815518915653, 0.04515741020441055, -0.052051693201065063, 0.0002825017145369202, 0.02514031156897545, -0.05613526701927185, -0.013134597800672054, 0.01870735175907612, -0.012771283276379108, -0.03802114725112915, -0.002013782039284706, 0.008889866061508656, 0.02103944681584835, 0.010077614337205887, 0.01524118147790432, 0.03552694991230965, 0.036443546414375305, 0.00013085959653835744, -0.04464757815003395, -0.014396886341273785, 0.01578410156071186, 0.00028674976783804595, -0.05238018557429314, 0.059431467205286026, -0.04135412722826004, -0.028114836663007736, 0.04766499251127243, -0.009331279434263706, 0.00015034753596410155, 0.06089296564459801, 0.02449679560959339, 0.0228662621229887, 0.03095608949661255, 0.039004795253276825, -0.011978083290159702, -0.024145418778061867, 0.02935248613357544, 0.028547829017043114, 0.05088869854807854, -0.003213559277355671, 0.02023494616150856, 0.002032364485785365, -0.010192039422690868, -0.014205927029252052, 0.009561460465192795, -0.028891392052173615, -0.0015494730323553085, -0.00735353073105216, 0.003971083089709282, -0.0143112288787961, -0.018063873052597046, 0.012968719005584717, -0.04429108649492264, 0.0005794407916255295, 0.04040880128741264, -0.010608005337417126, 0.0037826455663889647, -0.008490096777677536, -0.030884109437465668, -0.04245687276124954, 0.03552651032805443, -0.008187704719603062, 0.00215980876237154, -0.051876284182071686, 0.02712198719382286, 0.012456745840609074, -0.029652100056409836, -0.010259495116770267, -0.01541803777217865, -0.043552570044994354, 0.03937694430351257, -0.031682420521974564, 0.029157735407352448, 0.05308690294623375, -0.014687646180391312, 0.017325302585959435, -0.05838153511285782, 0.07319110631942749, 0.029587216675281525, -0.02400507964193821, -0.026614317670464516, -0.01102181151509285, -0.03967089205980301, 0.020516840741038322, 0.05048226937651634, -0.027165314182639122, -0.0007372340769506991, -0.0006116439471952617, 0.04184352979063988, -0.016686080023646355, -0.022371821105480194, -0.008669123984873295, 0.003070157254114747, -0.033798567950725555, -0.05141859129071236, 0.00897848978638649, -0.00536322733387351, 0.0007976757478900254, 0.012887537479400635, -0.03272068873047829, 0.015106556937098503, 0.008139101788401604, -0.004884670488536358, 0.008410499431192875, -0.013126754201948643, 0.016854681074619293, 0.055581480264663696, 0.027478298172354698, 0.001234159106388688, 0.007420953828841448, 0.0032405685633420944, -0.049784157425165176, 0.06572859734296799, -0.020926980301737785, -0.04473188892006874, -0.014364207163453102, 0.009870532900094986, 0.0008473805501125753, -0.03380672261118889, 0.007231426890939474, 0.027434300631284714, 0.01371628325432539, 0.04010849818587303, 0.02556377835571766, 0.03134210407733917, 0.045751120895147324, 0.012256805785000324, 0.017278315499424934, 0.02117859572172165, -0.02043578028678894, 0.0064513301476836205, 0.008539232425391674, 0.004826594144105911, 0.005020229611545801, 0.026155700907111168, 0.02705189399421215, 0.03235163912177086, 0.06218913197517395, -0.025695083662867546, 0.08001028746366501, -0.04591513052582741, 0.027483591809868813, 0.011441085487604141, 0.027773277834057808, 0.03139656409621239, 0.029041005298495293, -0.01620234176516533, 0.04739891737699509, -0.03748451545834541, -0.0022563582751899958, -0.03140067309141159, -0.02564059942960739, -0.04389304295182228, -0.006847844924777746, 0.005682688672095537, 0.07660599052906036, 0.00452786311507225, 0.013105289079248905, 0.02616851031780243, 0.023552430793642998, 0.014681370928883553, 0.0069296532310545444, 0.016205711290240288, -0.025703558698296547, -0.008844666182994843, 0.0030544523615390062, -0.049920711666345596, 0.028591472655534744, -0.020301787182688713, -0.00987065490335226, 0.04805469885468483, 0.02647428959608078, -0.024318065494298935, -0.017067518085241318, -0.0015194191364571452, 0.023425666615366936, -0.04149753227829933, -0.012680117972195148, -0.044564388692379, 0.00791996717453003, 0.0030576831195503473, -0.03969757631421089 ]
<p>My response variable is number of Fishing cat scats and I am using a zero-inflated poisson regression model to see the effect of the predictor variables on habitat use of Fishing cats. The predictor variables are Reed area, Vegetation Area and Agricultural area. </p> <p>Now, before using the GLM, I used scatterplots to see what the trends are between the response variable and each predictor variable based on my data and in it I saw that Fishing cats are negatively impacted by increase in agricultural area. However, the GLM is showing a positive correlation of Fishing cats with Agricultural area which is significant. However, when I take Agricultural area alone in the GLM, it shows an insignificant negative correlation. I do not know what to interpret out of this. I tried interactions also thinking that interaction with one of the predictors might have a positive effect on Agricultural area. Here is what it looks like:</p> <pre><code>Call: zeroinfl(formula = No_FC ~ Reed_area + Veg_area * Agril_area) Pearson residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -1.20907 -0.37197 -0.29263 -0.23930 6.97929 Count model coefficients (poisson with log link): Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) -2.64186 0.98692 -2.6769 0.0074315 ** Reed_area 1.88105 0.52355 3.5928 0.0003271 *** Veg_area 2.38728 0.64685 3.6906 0.0002237 *** Agril_area 2.05895 0.71096 2.8960 0.0037791 ** Veg_area:Agril_area -1.55241 0.86485 -1.7950 0.0726528 . Zero-inflation model coefficients (binomial with logit link): Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) -0.68988 1.82259 -0.3785 0.7050 Reed_area -0.72748 1.00656 -0.7227 0.4698 Veg_area 0.39630 1.34636 0.2944 0.7685 Agril_area 1.64785 1.15165 1.4309 0.1525 Veg_area:Agril_area 0.50427 1.30075 0.3877 0.6983 --- Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1 Number of iterations in BFGS optimization: 17 Log-likelihood: -134.02 on 10 Df. </code></pre> <p>It shows that the interaction term is also negatively affecting Fishing cat habitat use. Here is what it looks like when I take Agricultural area alone.</p> <pre><code>fishing_cat.glm &lt;- zeroinfl(No_FC~Agril_area) &gt; summary(fishing_cat.glm) Call: zeroinfl(formula = No_FC ~ Agril_area) Pearson residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -0.68839 -0.43312 -0.31080 -0.20735 8.16459 Count model coefficients (poisson with log link): Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 0.85358 0.18532 4.6059 4.107e-06 *** Agril_area -0.31194 0.26974 -1.1565 0.2475 Zero-inflation model coefficients (binomial with logit link): Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 0.16657 0.34396 0.4843 0.628200 Agril_area 1.30806 0.40498 3.2299 0.001238 ** --- Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1 Number of iterations in BFGS optimization: 16 Log-likelihood: -146.93 on 4 Df </code></pre> <p>Could you kindly give me some direction as to how I can circumnavigate this problem?</p>
36,880
[ -0.00413016090169549, -0.008058270439505577, 0.010184991173446178, 0.04230954125523567, 0.03218255564570427, -0.0017735706642270088, 0.00634613586589694, -0.03344365954399109, 0.046621646732091904, -0.06349049508571625, -0.004870198201388121, 0.024390537291765213, 0.050794459879398346, 0.016341213136911392, 0.033417847007513046, -0.002315080724656582, -0.00004599163730745204, -0.011441868729889393, 0.04311810061335564, -0.029987163841724396, 0.015429488383233547, 0.045425496995449066, 0.041230205446481705, 0.017885705456137657, 0.013760696165263653, 0.1000770702958107, 0.0009806286543607712, -0.008064775727689266, -0.004380637314170599, 0.01239981409162283, -0.024546904489398003, -0.05073446407914162, -0.009246553294360638, 0.05324264243245125, 0.032525524497032166, 0.023037584498524666, -0.030700702220201492, -0.014084124006330967, -0.009035993367433548, 0.03372906893491745, 0.000864268746227026, -0.023074105381965637, 0.006693181116133928, 0.003137110499665141, -0.0036400682292878628, 0.0035751801915466785, -0.010112334974110126, -0.025934239849448204, 0.09190962463617325, 0.02528279460966587, 0.0361122228205204, 0.015940096229314804, 0.03475338965654373, 0.03091663122177124, 0.0016468360554426908, -0.0010808835504576564, 0.04307447373867035, 0.03334469348192215, -0.05277159810066223, -0.06881283968687057, 0.015563685446977615, -0.02930668741464615, -0.01412295177578926, -0.038242876529693604, -0.011127110570669174, -0.0016461152117699385, 0.017574492841959, -0.028107281774282455, 0.02779833972454071, -0.025371138006448746, 0.024918271228671074, 0.0165718961507082, 0.013690049760043621, 0.0012592847924679518, -0.011288351379334927, -0.029572801664471626, -0.0032708917278796434, 0.03798054903745651, 0.0522606335580349, 0.01568390429019928, -0.023492803797125816, 0.028558475896716118, 0.0006069860537536442, 0.03375229984521866, 0.0655447393655777, -0.0019373740069568157, 0.015310828574001789, -0.013399198651313782, 0.031308144330978394, 0.01447279006242752, -0.033725108951330185, 0.017693793401122093, 0.06843754649162292, -0.02578010968863964, -0.026904858648777008, 0.0599786713719368, 0.0013070609420537949, 0.017308257520198822, 0.0007774616242386401, -0.0059018307365477085, -0.04299744963645935, -0.049713134765625, 0.0008108704350888729, 0.028210842981934547, -0.03544437885284424, -0.00011841769446618855, -0.04963270202279091, -0.019388293847441673, 0.004725417587906122, -0.07566235959529877, 0.0011192082893103361, 0.017677437514066696, 0.009190035983920097, 0.006540096830576658, -0.014282290823757648, -0.035269465297460556, -0.016445469111204147, 0.0018627988174557686, 0.03158161789178848, 0.034596625715494156, 0.02097712643444538, -0.024956757202744484, 0.01888945885002613, -0.012981895357370377, -0.06864835321903229, 0.012934175319969654, 0.01246589981019497, -0.042169515043497086, -0.02381422556936741, 0.07157322019338608, -0.002711470704525709, -0.005722618196159601, 0.045662835240364075, 0.005764781031757593, 0.024179622530937195, 0.009800557047128677, -0.04468337818980217, -0.02191871404647827, 0.04906877502799034, 0.003607241902500391, 0.047125790268182755, -0.023303331807255745, -0.005397002212703228, 0.016955547034740448, 0.03437171131372452, 0.024433450773358345, 0.011313521303236485, 0.06021504104137421, 0.017487626522779465, -0.001133408979512751, -0.07216258347034454, -0.009369614534080029, -0.02826790139079094, -0.01901106908917427, -0.02677810750901699, -0.05781766027212143, 0.018986228853464127, -0.01857888326048851, -0.00928119570016861, 0.01646561175584793, 0.05919594317674637, -0.0013880619080737233, -0.014905059710144997, -0.022942550480365753, -0.013302569277584553, -0.020247923210263252, 0.037602681666612625, -0.018199624493718147, 0.013902256265282631, 0.04802911356091499, -0.003867063671350479, -0.011823113076388836, -0.02238909713923931, 0.06477051228284836, 0.04402593895792961, -0.019630886614322662, 0.04658298194408417, -0.06952272355556488, -0.013287365436553955, 0.019958285614848137, -0.0555039718747139, -0.016904598101973534, -0.05685748904943466, -0.01876728981733322, 0.0676819309592247, 0.08130846172571182, -0.032667163759469986, -0.030665306374430656, 0.03356441110372543, -0.05323709920048714, -0.038613297045230865, -0.03344820439815521, -0.008061902597546577, -0.004925972782075405, -0.007094185799360275, 0.010719647631049156, 0.02213691547513008, 0.03288036584854126, -0.005464079789817333, 0.036909446120262146, -0.029832366853952408, 0.0061660390347242355, 0.03984663635492325, -0.03932619094848633, 0.03772735595703125, 0.045152872800827026, 0.01328385341912508, -0.022263500839471817, 0.008547884412109852, -0.028123764321208, -0.041476186364889145, 0.044849421828985214, -0.01078794151544571, -0.019775645807385445, 0.01510006096214056, -0.029431981965899467, 0.032926853746175766, -0.006632219534367323, -0.04948676750063896, 0.025321131572127342, -0.05453954637050629, 0.0459938570857048, 0.049802396446466446, -0.03854214772582054, 0.008774915710091591, 0.023880576714873314, -0.014908685348927975, 0.02905692346394062, -0.0466008186340332, -0.008295434527099133, -0.052577320486307144, -0.004011598415672779, 0.06500963866710663, 0.024622557684779167, -0.011923544108867645, 0.002640854800119996, 0.026761267334222794, -0.022957608103752136, -0.004621829837560654, 0.04314229637384415, -0.0058954753912985325, 0.02213786356151104, 0.02985864132642746, 0.039362769573926926, 0.0055742040276527405, -0.03145931288599968, 0.04587338864803314, -0.00532633438706398, 0.057271748781204224, -0.03176063299179077, -0.0378941111266613, 0.054015032947063446, 0.0009332718909718096, -0.007087841164320707, -0.013583981432020664, 0.02402644045650959, 0.029392434284090996, -0.049190402030944824, 0.036375802010297775, 0.05758966878056526, 0.036193013191223145, 0.0023504882119596004, 0.00716216117143631, -0.022493727505207062, -0.0026053606998175383, 0.03643803298473358, -0.03222484886646271, -0.002977333962917328, 0.012166831642389297, -0.05518774315714836, 0.015453631989657879, -0.009375401772558689, -0.05568285286426544, -0.03185538202524185, -0.00416308781132102, 0.04413933679461479, 0.019933635368943214, 0.011273326352238655, -0.021570486947894096, -0.017214331775903702, -0.02974739857017994, 0.0237877294421196, 0.029081547632813454, 0.015988599509000778, -0.053398098796606064, -0.01804438605904579, 0.0003402440343052149, 0.023091141134500504, -0.007620766758918762, -0.02963184006512165, -0.034220319241285324, 0.004638472106307745, -0.010484060272574425, -0.057814572006464005, -0.02163325436413288, -0.04169750586152077, -0.014037498272955418, 0.009189212694764137, -0.03555481508374214, 0.031121226027607918, 0.028692113235592842, -0.030795658007264137, 0.005786547437310219, -0.03860408067703247, 0.021957512944936752, -0.05373551324009895, -0.030994029715657234, -0.0103224515914917, -0.010137930512428284, 0.02861526794731617, -0.01811811700463295, -0.03203843533992767, -0.007936691865324974, -0.06393260508775711, -0.04189521446824074, -0.021524125710129738, 0.01296415738761425, 0.032243430614471436, -0.018393822014331818, -0.007528523448854685, 0.06444311141967773, 0.010478565469384193, -0.023158153519034386, -0.03979827091097832, 0.017467869445681572, -0.03594835102558136, -0.011766524985432625, 0.0015208199620246887, 0.0051090894266963005, 0.05822139233350754, 0.052288856357336044, -0.01981046050786972, 0.07766170799732208, -0.00002761999894573819, 0.01878727786242962, -0.003426190698519349, 0.034330449998378754, -0.0072230263613164425, 0.010380744002759457, 0.02532590553164482, 0.0362270213663578, 0.01038979273289442, 0.008119802922010422, -0.03507035970687866, -0.017694035544991493, 0.02074529603123665, -0.04282781854271889, -0.022464754059910774, 0.01641741581261158, 0.035525210201740265, -0.03014233522117138, -0.013601141050457954, 0.04523851349949837, -0.02164434641599655, -0.014728397130966187, -0.025687724351882935, 0.07004031538963318, -0.04332076013088226, -0.004619910381734371, 0.05042671039700508, 0.011403796263039112, -0.014209408313035965, 0.0011474591447040439, -0.029710903763771057, 0.021856985986232758, 0.025096949189901352, -0.0037108955439180136, 0.01133984886109829, 0.04175553098320961, 0.02430284582078457, -0.0005965345189906657, -0.06609512120485306, -0.01955491118133068, 0.012913632206618786, -0.0444403700530529, -0.028348684310913086, -0.017688270658254623, 0.02131257951259613, 0.0003487486974336207, 0.013034068048000336, -0.00929335318505764, -0.0007552487659268081, -0.011032570153474808, 0.019981082528829575, -0.05200664699077606, 0.014870177023112774, 0.003934953361749649, 0.011764798313379288, 0.03578568622469902, -0.048161592334508896, 0.005690565798431635, -0.02244541235268116, -0.00700384983792901, -0.03193292021751404, -0.015947172418236732, -0.046211615204811096, 0.03966984897851944, -0.0048180799931287766, 0.006433443166315556, -0.024588115513324738, 0.012295368127524853, 0.02811751514673233, 0.005829165689647198, 0.05189304053783417, 0.0446527823805809, 0.003636931302025914, -0.021721787750720978, -0.052627794444561005, -0.004128046799451113, 0.03673746436834335, 0.052146974951028824, 0.03652725741267204, 0.0062807900831103325, -0.026278557255864143, 0.056691594421863556, 0.025219224393367767, 0.02773796208202839, 0.0041916449554264545, 0.0009103670599870384, -0.025740472599864006, -0.026215001940727234, -0.008073230274021626, -0.013067424297332764, 0.018422910943627357, 0.024701369926333427, -0.0034843478351831436, 0.04590921849012375, 0.01927758753299713, -0.024993188679218292, 0.0108634103089571, 0.00950815249234438, 0.030012568458914757, 0.022443467751145363, 0.007677093148231506, -0.028604716062545776, -0.0008800781215541065, -0.020059287548065186, 0.03308354318141937, -0.010255438275635242, 0.010334487073123455, 0.0005382840754464269, 0.048845645040273666, -0.023216359317302704, -0.037099216133356094, -0.0028737455140799284, 0.020861921831965446, 0.021199939772486687, -0.027322139590978622, -0.038846611976623535, -0.007060525473207235, 0.012854425236582756, 0.03366737440228462, 0.01913384161889553, 0.02457277849316597, -0.09298518300056458, -0.028511706739664078, 0.017688849940896034, 0.045458368957042694, -0.02107047289609909, -0.019515374675393105, -0.0570417121052742, -0.0398300439119339, -0.04436832293868065, -0.06806494295597076, 0.022086061537265778, -0.035841748118400574, 0.013894576579332352, -0.01419254019856453, -0.038903381675481796, -0.06794089823961258, -0.008081246167421341, -0.03463902696967125, 0.025406168773770332, -0.010757246054708958, -0.03406013920903206, 0.008746786043047905, 0.04311061277985573, -0.009677608497440815, 0.02733205072581768, 0.0029752166010439396, -0.010389795526862144, 0.0218159519135952, 0.024539798498153687, 0.010654970072209835, -0.060312800109386444, 0.04431268945336342, 0.0009862433653324842, 0.043573763221502304, 0.0595674104988575, 0.000015468973288079724, 0.011337987147271633, 0.009409639984369278, 0.03895397484302521, -0.0368022657930851, -0.03240453079342842, -0.028353242203593254, 0.005145036615431309, -0.009947930462658405, -0.017568005248904228, 0.0718352273106575, 0.040033191442489624, -0.01944701373577118, 0.019926777109503746, -0.043068770319223404, 0.001426602597348392, -0.015954647213220596, -0.040686383843421936, -0.04245495796203613, 0.006296873092651367, -0.0014539937255904078, 0.006134703289717436, -0.03488355129957199, 0.021909644827246666, -0.04768602177500725, 0.024031084030866623, 0.040341440588235855, 0.003947357181459665, -0.017502471804618835, 0.021063674241304398, -0.022195592522621155, 0.035246752202510834, 0.010188661515712738, -0.03857457637786865, 0.007447655312716961, -0.01208611112087965, -0.03786630928516388, -0.003041438292711973, -0.016148218885064125, 0.012413081713020802, 0.023294202983379364, -0.024250201880931854, -0.0026252763345837593, -0.0221701767295599, 0.01581311598420143, 0.02902975305914879, -0.0041860793717205524, -0.0191984660923481, -0.03685145080089569, -0.020603809505701065, 0.016193736344575882, 0.03616545721888542, 0.02008156292140484, 0.014348077587783337, -0.0073650190606713295, 0.019125470891594887, -0.001391541096381843, -0.06331618875265121, -0.048498570919036865, -0.020622747018933296, 0.019587183371186256, -0.028336141258478165, -0.02870793081820011, -0.054116927087306976, -0.014498337171971798, 0.015896931290626526, -0.008561130613088608, 0.05088362842798233, -0.08271870017051697, -0.01964624971151352, -0.0009799266699701548, 0.02439258061349392, 0.062458060681819916, -0.025002412497997284, 0.010300768539309502, 0.014422506093978882, -0.030861027538776398, -0.025577083230018616, 0.028764890506863594, -0.022145621478557587, -0.019993780180811882, -0.030854828655719757, -0.013204529881477356, -0.007078749127686024, -0.008249527774751186, 0.04703591391444206, -0.03475571051239967, -0.023770911619067192, 0.0000033873145639518043, 0.010118518024682999, 0.0021340595558285713, -0.030460119247436523, 0.006148542743176222, 0.021882155910134315, -0.009797974489629269, -0.004496556706726551, -0.020146137103438377, -0.01259151566773653, 0.055749185383319855, -0.04673343896865845, -0.03966536372900009, 0.02707458660006523, 0.07243192195892334, 0.02005542628467083, 0.014654013328254223, 0.0003117574960924685, -0.0012110610259696841, 0.05180681124329567, -0.017422780394554138, 0.01572316326200962, 0.018057959154248238, 0.061023738235235214, -0.048885054886341095, -0.01247219555079937, -0.02742118202149868, -0.028414009138941765, 0.03790546953678131, -0.01915558986365795, 0.027912359684705734, 0.01864750124514103, -0.022083956748247147, 0.006456395611166954, -0.07837564498186111, -0.009242851287126541, 0.026077894493937492, -0.005607303231954575, 0.06599138677120209, -0.04767648130655289, 0.013816160149872303, 0.04034014418721199, 0.013543283566832542, 0.05662846192717552, -0.005384768825024366, 0.014082792215049267, 0.025133587419986725, 0.032719310373067856, -0.028835933655500412, -0.0520300455391407, 0.03372626751661301, 0.005906502716243267, 0.010025265626609325, 0.003939429298043251, -0.02722986601293087, 0.04747617989778519, 0.04682811349630356, -0.007135628256946802, -0.0797804445028305, -0.008706777356564999, -0.03384933993220329, 0.018527045845985413, -0.010602159425616264, -0.01602519117295742, 0.025379838421940804, -0.007720980327576399, 0.05849315971136093, -0.009893866255879402, 0.047358255833387375, -0.031650397926568985, -0.07861180603504181, 0.0016271115746349096, -0.04329349845647812, 0.014829750172793865, 0.03460448607802391, -0.009616727009415627, -0.02854349836707115, 0.034237075597047806, -0.055879395455121994, 0.02791222184896469, -0.012641457840800285, -0.014368466101586819, -0.008014467544853687, 0.03646868094801903, 0.0038771741092205048, 0.017918776720762253, -0.015632353723049164, -0.00802803598344326, 0.15041761100292206, 0.02162173204123974, 0.024217089638113976, -0.07537435740232468, -0.015564275905489922, 0.03809750825166702, 0.021569153293967247, -0.04307188093662262, -0.06046094000339508, 0.020890286192297935, -0.015138464979827404, 0.06570232659578323, 0.01926925778388977, 0.06271965056657791, -0.011276185512542725, 0.06215883791446686, -0.04213739559054375, -0.011498802341520786, -0.01615992747247219, 0.014759478159248829, 0.009511247277259827, -0.025199251249432564, -0.032966502010822296, 0.023123253136873245, 0.004077243153005838, 0.008569120429456234, -0.00538319256156683, 0.023940222337841988, 0.009548144415020943, -0.000716358539648354, -0.05028814822435379, -0.0008010619785636663, -0.014401131309568882, 0.018622620031237602, -0.012222366407513618, -0.008861593902111053, -0.010384459048509598, -0.018240220844745636, -0.0002690491091925651, 0.024169303476810455, -0.0454258918762207, 0.021462487056851387, 0.03403467312455177, 0.03114159218966961, -0.04021899029612541, -0.036957357078790665, -0.034850236028432846, 0.05375434085726738, -0.005541118327528238, -0.03266051411628723, -0.023701516911387444, 0.0159657783806324, 0.018341390416026115, -0.013930754736065865, -0.02070421166718006, 0.020108191296458244, 0.0011999545386061072, -0.011475808918476105, 0.006381584797054529, -0.015145845711231232, 0.015559782274067402, 0.0029876395128667355, 0.047182101756334305, 0.038960862904787064, -0.021495681256055832, -0.019715946167707443, -0.051162850111722946, 0.0602324903011322, 0.020191283896565437, 0.021139567717909813, 0.050668857991695404, -0.015932641923427582, 0.009946394711732864, -0.015930281952023506, -0.021629750728607178, -0.0006134423310868442, 0.030671847984194756, -0.015510156750679016, -0.014513416215777397, -0.03777589648962021, -0.0295634213835001, 0.01486246008425951, -0.06348153203725815, 0.027921181172132492, -0.07921238243579865, -0.031872641295194626, -0.035013701766729355, 0.023326532915234566, 0.019804883748292923, 0.03490462154150009, -0.055111851543188095, 0.051164351403713226, 0.015796177089214325, -0.033410269767045975, -0.03254331275820732, 0.02064630016684532, -0.044627249240875244, -0.0033989548683166504, -0.024006936699151993, 0.05081891268491745, 0.009340244345366955, 0.04159333556890488, -0.007888856343925, 0.021923987194895744, 0.008235153742134571, 0.0079969996586442, 0.017885394394397736, -0.01975550316274166, 0.029726671054959297, 0.03302101790904999, -0.004500559531152248, -0.024235162883996964, 0.005878561642020941, -0.011456264182925224, -0.06030910089612007, 0.002596530131995678, -0.023278480395674706, -0.04461413621902466, 0.02045772783458233, -0.03930908069014549, 0.016115155071020126, 0.0092261778190732, -0.025119205936789513, -0.07120484858751297, -0.012219726108014584, 0.017468247562646866, -0.04328862577676773, 0.0016348814824596047, 0.0030123877804726362, -0.03575408086180687, 0.03788027539849281, 0.0528097040951252, -0.04291544109582901, -0.003174853278324008, -0.01395599264651537, 0.048670463263988495, 0.034607019275426865, 0.03531593829393387, 0.03058329038321972, -0.021848753094673157, 0.023090697824954987, -0.018828462809324265, -0.016465097665786743, 0.010002488270401955, -0.009942595846951008, 0.028751377016305923, -0.009826336987316608, -0.004605085123330355, -0.034367483109235764, 0.049947589635849, 0.00023731050896458328, 0.02443871833384037, -0.05784085765480995, 0.008913005702197552, 0.028036318719387054, -0.009408475831151009, -0.0014897729270160198, 0.016997287049889565, -0.007997017353773117, 0.0038954743649810553, 0.07568496465682983, -0.010799475014209747, 0.0033756266348063946, -0.006234025117009878, -0.05656416714191437, -0.01932983286678791, 0.012896194122731686, -0.025888849049806595, -0.002380756428465247, 0.06549879163503647, -0.0011962548596784472, 0.007778331637382507, 0.020019063726067543, 0.049477215856313705, -0.05374249443411827, 0.016939904540777206, 0.0024204386863857508, 0.004948711022734642, 0.01220337301492691, -0.026773324236273766, 0.010358856059610844, 0.011964697390794754, -0.022413814440369606, 0.012893096543848515, 0.005389396101236343, 0.0067319017834961414, -0.04490235820412636, -0.007433160673826933, -0.0021017107646912336, -0.016694534569978714, 0.049897417426109314, -0.02241184003651142, 0.02044670283794403, 0.03024625964462757, -0.018212419003248215, -0.022153986617922783, -0.007602705154567957, 0.02036367543041706, 0.015217493288218975, -0.04661911353468895, -0.005671507678925991, -0.045039545744657516, -0.004999822471290827, 0.00265291053801775, 0.0010733521776273847, -0.0065661100670695305, 0.040768079459667206, 0.04670284688472748, 0.01949792541563511, 0.06594695895910263, 0.03693035989999771, 0.03087533265352249, -0.025983715429902077, 0.00443583820015192, 0.034525588154792786, -0.0004287992196623236, -0.030365094542503357, 0.028469771146774292, -0.02156660705804825, -0.021815557032823563, 0.007918091490864754, 0.04058060795068741, -0.0035863430239260197, 0.008718941360712051, 0.012377637438476086, 0.02953919768333435, -0.0317692831158638, 0.0017585905734449625, 0.00817226991057396, -0.04140670597553253, -0.0009024711325764656, 0.05130167677998543, 0.01184653677046299, -0.029923994094133377, -0.021510746330022812, 0.025628669187426567, -0.012056924402713776, -0.002988723572343588, -0.01425015926361084, 0.0013038967736065388, -0.04345494136214256, -0.014337550848722458, -0.05525015667080879, 0.01709648221731186, -0.03499353677034378, 0.032321833074092865, -0.061158355325460434, 0.016320429742336273, -0.028968648985028267, -0.01260619331151247, 0.006837464403361082, 0.03601702302694321, 0.04755108430981636, -0.08233126997947693, 0.05289732292294502, 0.025308771058917046, -0.02334102801978588, -0.033256273716688156, -0.006555359810590744, -0.05417296290397644, 0.013078059069812298, 0.022324303165078163, -0.019505519419908524, -0.0001359446905553341, -0.025600165128707886, 0.04276719689369202, -0.005991267040371895, 0.0013584846165031195, 0.05837317183613777, 0.030103806406259537, -0.030278285965323448, 0.0065928571857512, -0.00517354067414999, 0.01901172287762165, 0.011256130412220955, -0.01098691951483488, 0.0217741671949625, -0.01467808522284031, -0.00959672313183546, -0.022604601457715034, 0.04384705051779747, 0.019994022324681282, 0.017649667337536812, 0.057570282369852066, 0.011830179020762444, 0.04300672560930252, 0.03875007852911949, 0.004425812512636185, -0.035387247800827026, 0.04007359594106674, -0.02571236900985241, -0.008997154422104359, 0.03550967574119568, 0.020606251433491707, 0.025479590520262718, -0.06097067892551422, 0.022925352677702904, -0.005401416216045618, -0.01587563008069992, -0.009554281830787659, 0.014314786531031132, 0.004933595657348633, 0.052647873759269714, -0.01976156234741211, 0.014271095395088196, -0.011289906688034534, -0.00606015557423234, 0.03874598443508148, 0.0264266449958086, 0.04284161329269409, 0.04061039909720421, -0.0038388364482671022, 0.03941257670521736, 0.0023039167281240225, 0.03265678137540817, -0.012953457422554493, 0.057151637971401215, -0.049033403396606445, 0.012111937627196312, 0.027899909764528275, 0.010520320385694504, 0.024356713518500328, 0.03506828472018242, 0.010605035349726677, 0.017002549022436142, -0.04643593728542328, -0.018059663474559784, 0.000489560654386878, -0.015553957782685757, -0.021220490336418152, 0.004791616462171078, 0.0012242445955052972, -0.001593291643075645, 0.03789609670639038, 0.027213959023356438, 0.017079012468457222, -0.02909894287586212, -0.007318508345633745, -0.0055376458913087845, -0.017831699922680855, -0.007639946416020393, 0.005516784731298685, 0.014658472500741482, -0.010204721242189407, 0.020941775292158127, -0.018533168360590935, 0.029001619666814804, 0.029002144932746887, -0.00032186295720748603, -0.05218593403697014, -0.028977805748581886, -0.007136035710573196, 0.03725701943039894, -0.04962087795138359, -0.049498651176691055, 0.007122516166418791, -0.00448507908731699, 0.014645878225564957, -0.05457010120153427 ]
<p>I'm trying to find a test that will allow me to test the relationship between a categorical dependent variable and several independent variables that are both continuous (interval) and ordinal. </p> <p>If there is no such test, it would also makes theoretical sense for me to turn the variable "around". That is, I could use a statistical test (if such exists) that allows me to test the effect of a categorical independent variable on several dependent variables that are both continuous and ordinal.</p> <p>I hope this makes sense and would be grateful for any help.</p>
74,165
[ -0.03404221683740616, -0.0042491573840379715, -0.002256743609905243, 0.038259971886873245, 0.028339149430394173, -0.02020510472357273, 0.01802980899810791, 0.011236264370381832, 0.0371973030269146, -0.02353438176214695, 0.03851835057139397, 0.029184237122535706, 0.03404877334833145, 0.006127300206571817, -0.003080319846048951, 0.011280444450676441, -0.027133656665682793, 0.013753705658018589, -0.005539260804653168, -0.007124813739210367, -0.01400657556951046, 0.017182115465402603, 0.029632946476340294, -0.006547071970999241, 0.003068475052714348, 0.03868211805820465, 0.014788779430091381, -0.02886020950973034, 0.020031763240695, 0.04377148672938347, -0.01618281751871109, -0.04065370932221413, -0.0039028788451105356, 0.05462802201509476, -0.018927620723843575, 0.003519460093230009, 0.0022442294284701347, 0.00964494701474905, -0.040636636316776276, 0.013718588277697563, -0.0229896642267704, 0.004144144710153341, -0.007292404305189848, 0.055712342262268066, 0.011730317957699299, 0.008320864289999008, 0.003989510238170624, -0.022695928812026978, 0.032571882009506226, -0.02618391439318657, 0.12193043529987335, -0.0350671112537384, 0.03347897157073021, 0.029146751388907433, -0.005990513600409031, -0.011314110830426216, 0.05697975680232048, 0.07847569137811661, -0.010358050465583801, -0.03885006159543991, -0.0446193665266037, -0.038692183792591095, 0.0008324019145220518, -0.018188826739788055, -0.047077227383852005, 0.044352833181619644, -0.003422086127102375, -0.022105883806943893, 0.02746601402759552, -0.013621833175420761, -0.00312781217508018, 0.015920870006084442, 0.07540170848369598, -0.019559767097234726, -0.002132934518158436, -0.03386889770627022, 0.02445465698838234, 0.02012774348258972, 0.033824313431978226, 0.04687068611383438, -0.010289104655385017, 0.002104035345837474, 0.013253860175609589, 0.04292086884379387, 0.024178428575396538, -0.03388376533985138, 0.05289919301867485, -0.021198781207203865, -0.007394545245915651, 0.02983233332633972, -0.03979086875915527, -0.0544990710914135, 0.03657199814915657, 0.051402077078819275, -0.05436195433139801, 0.024953506886959076, -0.03687205910682678, 0.006196854170411825, -0.0012339986860752106, -0.005607190541923046, 0.021308228373527527, -0.00662047928199172, 0.025282610207796097, 0.046570900827646255, -0.016686081886291504, 0.029349543154239655, -0.012424489483237267, 0.00008639069710625336, 0.003916125278919935, -0.013315573334693909, -0.017538439482450485, 0.0306446123868227, 0.0070643299259245396, 0.03171411156654358, 0.02000468783080578, -0.012396292760968208, -0.02775445021688938, -0.02541641891002655, 0.034761715680360794, 0.05632205307483673, 0.054292235523462296, -0.04193345829844475, 0.03602094575762749, -0.008291071280837059, -0.03692835941910744, 0.016275180503726006, 0.0026490238960832357, 0.00857827439904213, -0.0031138365156948566, 0.05709916725754738, -0.024062035605311394, -0.02751942165195942, 0.026598284021019936, 0.012582431547343731, 0.03623044490814209, -0.007133861538022757, -0.08177272230386734, -0.06016002222895622, 0.004123336635529995, 0.017303209751844406, -0.012001349590718746, -0.05170746520161629, 0.019131619483232498, 0.03990483283996582, 0.02352399379014969, 0.029679585248231888, 0.025591859593987465, -0.003559739561751485, -0.00862299557775259, 0.028398195281624794, -0.02744896523654461, -0.024275952950119972, -0.0006724487175233662, -0.033064842224121094, -0.00022296133101917803, -0.08303128927946091, 0.007489398587495089, -0.006476215552538633, 0.017212117090821266, -0.004094460513442755, 0.039860792458057404, 0.042729683220386505, -0.015518446452915668, -0.006478567607700825, 0.03583207353949547, -0.0018589308019727468, 0.060508765280246735, -0.03668729215860367, 0.008538476191461086, -0.011664273217320442, 0.01960521750152111, 0.03165432810783386, 0.0581582672894001, 0.05745627358555794, 0.021737858653068542, -0.033904027193784714, -0.02364380843937397, -0.032485272735357285, 0.0024668367113918066, -0.0031648846343159676, -0.036816682666540146, -0.026110433042049408, -0.028067266568541527, -0.02266864851117134, 0.031596891582012177, 0.036188967525959015, -0.0072435722686350346, -0.048443619161844254, 0.04251907393336296, -0.06634404510259628, -0.04768802225589752, -0.03400787338614464, 0.0023480693344026804, -0.015158090740442276, -0.05884981527924538, 0.03049279749393463, 0.02082662284374237, 0.059416137635707855, -0.033121258020401, -0.013007592409849167, -0.029777629300951958, -0.023180106654763222, 0.028286825865507126, -0.030992304906249046, 0.03779250383377075, 0.058088548481464386, 0.07539265602827072, -0.02068146876990795, 0.005592333152890205, -0.022821111604571342, -0.03903369978070259, 0.00534891476854682, -0.05720826983451843, 0.020623814314603806, -0.018781589344143867, 0.014551045373082161, 0.029358604922890663, 0.019938157871365547, -0.021307237446308136, 0.04481562599539757, -0.0602894052863121, 0.07644281536340714, 0.038849666714668274, 0.023781228810548782, 0.003938979934900999, -0.0069757369346916676, 0.02173484116792679, -0.0053319502621889114, -0.02481638267636299, 0.0015298976795747876, -0.03147664666175842, 0.03469973802566528, 0.020832600072026253, -0.0016893931897357106, -0.04636527970433235, 0.04200451448559761, 0.05446917191147804, 0.04254395514726639, -0.010477755218744278, 0.05429179221391678, 0.012457017786800861, -0.01645163632929325, -0.018525518476963043, 0.0011899686651304364, 0.04507050663232803, 0.016644438728690147, 0.02933848835527897, 0.011093644425272942, 0.058127228170633316, -0.016414348036050797, -0.012066862545907497, 0.004131431691348553, -0.020588304847478867, 0.03207709640264511, 0.008234832435846329, -0.03893326595425606, 0.05968736112117767, -0.029519250616431236, 0.02068588323891163, 0.052380286157131195, 0.00027020557899959385, -0.011413881555199623, 0.023111125454306602, 0.007592026609927416, 0.01581554487347603, 0.04178537800908089, -0.07398601621389389, 0.004243876319378614, 0.027926763519644737, -0.024652021005749702, -0.0030710434075444937, -0.016885647550225258, -0.02853415533900261, -0.05679234117269516, -0.004481509793549776, 0.0008098845719359815, 0.02179786004126072, 0.04356643930077553, 0.013662218116223812, -0.001523147919215262, 0.011642100289463997, -0.044242702424526215, 0.013769805431365967, -0.01522571500390768, -0.012752850539982319, -0.01831195317208767, -0.009720233269035816, -0.019613448530435562, 0.03492148965597153, -0.01650957018136978, -0.0367615781724453, 0.04967912659049034, 0.013516036793589592, -0.07364386320114136, -0.006757709663361311, -0.020616915076971054, 0.0032884522806853056, -0.034384358674287796, -0.0234824251383543, 0.024294236674904823, 0.03515525534749031, -0.042563632130622864, 0.028800267726182938, -0.026669109240174294, -0.023348340764641762, -0.030828280374407768, -0.003399933222681284, 0.006473973393440247, -0.013647998683154583, 0.02160298451781273, 0.018954284489154816, -0.012501542456448078, -0.007040126249194145, -0.08047518134117126, -0.10278941690921783, 0.03578689694404602, 0.01454906165599823, 0.040758077055215836, 0.013304983265697956, -0.029726501554250717, 0.05268438160419464, 0.005770034156739712, -0.027043180540204048, -0.0760326012969017, -0.010178769007325172, -0.014358880929648876, -0.0037473300471901894, 0.02630295790731907, 0.003316344693303108, 0.025115130469202995, 0.0073875850066542625, 0.029923224821686745, 0.01854611560702324, 0.004945328924804926, 0.0029453535098582506, 0.015109697356820107, 0.03916312754154205, 0.029672592878341675, -0.035338785499334335, 0.01572098210453987, 0.013296080753207207, -0.023982342332601547, -0.007610762491822243, 0.002366394270211458, 0.013426285237073898, 0.005863723810762167, -0.029405781999230385, 0.008980763144791126, -0.01306974608451128, -0.007538518402725458, -0.032068558037281036, 0.02893134020268917, 0.008142998442053795, 0.010379482991993427, 0.003592933528125286, 0.028266219422221184, 0.046858374029397964, -0.022316405549645424, 0.014814483001828194, 0.06549863517284393, 0.034362856298685074, -0.03468242660164833, -0.007126907352358103, -0.005520151928067207, -0.0483468733727932, 0.05331714078783989, -0.04234183579683304, -0.013322864659130573, 0.0472947396337986, 0.014647954143583775, 0.05907432362437248, 0.00007056201866362244, -0.047649215906858444, 0.06474145501852036, -0.03811110183596611, 0.032916486263275146, -0.02908315509557724, 0.025094714015722275, 0.018464019522070885, 0.07801100611686707, 0.03238093852996826, -0.002357796300202608, 0.014612233266234398, 0.008974337950348854, -0.03283613175153732, 0.0222151018679142, -0.011375905014574528, 0.0030407733283936977, 0.01784205250442028, -0.0034679207019507885, 0.023469479754567146, -0.012089811265468597, -0.01478253398090601, 0.002731817541643977, 0.017560381442308426, -0.020224012434482574, -0.00755382189527154, -0.020931048318743706, -0.023231560364365578, 0.019200703129172325, 0.0024931977968662977, 0.0009462796151638031, -0.03666340187191963, 0.03143409639596939, 0.03576534241437912, -0.007694116327911615, -0.04198005795478821, -0.02802293375134468, -0.018473230302333832, 0.01597973145544529, 0.039716705679893494, 0.021121345460414886, 0.026576749980449677, -0.02046891115605831, 0.06809139996767044, -0.030773993581533432, 0.04677951708436012, 0.012781703844666481, -0.041484981775283813, -0.02310274727642536, -0.044570356607437134, -0.012209998443722725, -0.0029767213854938745, 0.03158991411328316, 0.025089632719755173, -0.014333824627101421, 0.06128155067563057, 0.026669206097722054, -0.03534513711929321, 0.022131197154521942, 0.08537834137678146, 0.02827642485499382, -0.024367723613977432, -0.007325226441025734, -0.02478763274848461, -0.009560003876686096, -0.004453614819794893, 0.030061541125178337, 0.022792726755142212, -0.020448893308639526, 0.004597566090524197, 0.043344561010599136, 0.006074308417737484, -0.021649934351444244, -0.025075167417526245, -0.010806900449097157, 0.025944232940673828, -0.01332955714315176, -0.059098683297634125, 0.031215637922286987, 0.03384938836097717, 0.04070676863193512, 0.036167606711387634, -0.003613288514316082, -0.10293502360582352, 0.06496313214302063, 0.059680622071027756, 0.03395836800336838, -0.049379248172044754, -0.004541072994470596, -0.008525824174284935, -0.005950158927589655, 0.06614093482494354, -0.037381600588560104, 0.02473500557243824, -0.007824525237083435, 0.00896016787737608, -0.022483764216303825, -0.02509286254644394, -0.013110626488924026, 0.014644677750766277, -0.006108077242970467, -0.008679362945258617, 0.004736656788736582, -0.004707693587988615, -0.04668496921658516, 0.00772590609267354, 0.02789744734764099, 0.05744515359401703, 0.004943830892443657, -0.010822776705026627, 0.011730213649570942, -0.0012921049492433667, -0.05788324028253555, -0.051188234239816666, 0.0372956357896328, 0.002504058415070176, 0.0061453599482774734, 0.06417509913444519, -0.0006255762418732047, -0.02384207770228386, -0.014566397294402122, -0.00916463416069746, -0.04018840938806534, 0.03435412049293518, -0.00527571514248848, 0.03251955285668373, -0.0006333237397484481, 0.0013529331190511584, 0.016106801107525826, 0.05074585601687431, 0.0007862785132601857, -0.005346493795514107, -0.0099155493080616, 0.019397294148802757, -0.024279961362481117, -0.038981713354587555, -0.0025268555618822575, -0.03440120443701744, -0.018981682136654854, -0.007953384891152382, -0.029536999762058258, -0.01492700818926096, -0.01885152980685234, -0.006608141120523214, -0.01988515816628933, 0.015857791528105736, 0.0041923364624381065, -0.013783588074147701, -0.002004437381401658, 0.017183665186166763, 0.006388158071786165, -0.01641908474266529, 0.03288916125893593, -0.004019734915345907, 0.001261796336621046, -0.004004881717264652, -0.05302326753735542, 0.017297636717557907, -0.026084208860993385, -0.027117962017655373, -0.0072675482369959354, -0.020157532766461372, 0.029602058231830597, -0.03986595198512077, 0.028335729613900185, -0.006410230416804552, -0.0303840022534132, -0.031539782881736755, 0.05301232263445854, 0.009191574528813362, 0.058606572449207306, -0.036599695682525635, 0.043288711458444595, -0.017985321581363678, -0.013351359404623508, -0.06987161189317703, -0.07939356565475464, 0.038092344999313354, 0.018282627686858177, -0.02655126340687275, -0.04022282361984253, 0.016647791489958763, -0.012338017113506794, 0.004623327404260635, -0.034659843891859055, 0.06458993256092072, 0.0068281604908406734, -0.009209289215505123, -0.028670618310570717, -0.002325346227735281, 0.03700285032391548, 0.03584721311926842, -0.01177151408046484, 0.0077654458582401276, -0.016291504725813866, -0.0022994601167738438, 0.015296176075935364, -0.019988907501101494, -0.020736955106258392, -0.01350562646985054, -0.019022230058908463, -0.0004442286735866219, 0.011793246492743492, -0.03694476559758186, -0.051517635583877563, -0.003221936523914337, -0.00840086117386818, 0.009821904823184013, -0.03967161104083061, 0.006193017587065697, -0.012590828351676464, -0.022026676684617996, -0.019519321620464325, 0.029415544122457504, -0.03178262710571289, -0.014590594917535782, 0.0002919164835475385, -0.002553418278694153, -0.07751531898975372, 0.037417881190776825, 0.09456682950258255, 0.04123074188828468, 0.014356011524796486, -0.002430198946967721, 0.02455085702240467, -0.002015230478718877, 0.014855670742690563, -0.029324691742658615, -0.013877611607313156, 0.025534704327583313, -0.054314132779836655, 0.0011173898819833994, -0.0048889657482504845, -0.0284979697316885, 0.029806150123476982, -0.014459876343607903, 0.042059436440467834, 0.06136917322874069, 0.021038824692368507, -0.005958748981356621, 0.0006413712399080396, -0.00003014193680428434, -0.0031363924499601126, 0.013040046207606792, 0.03312430903315544, -0.01048267912119627, 0.013721166178584099, 0.016511641442775726, 0.05274846404790878, -0.003472944488748908, 0.049921002238988876, 0.02015726827085018, 0.013068965636193752, 0.04675978422164917, -0.03301367536187172, -0.04124091938138008, 0.05260800942778587, -0.07260873913764954, 0.02131192944943905, -0.05747668072581291, -0.01795940287411213, 0.023499686270952225, 0.03213629499077797, -0.0341799296438694, -0.03387405350804329, -0.03170864284038544, -0.04461536929011345, 0.040437787771224976, 0.007972579449415207, 0.01943134143948555, 0.026698753237724304, -0.008231785148382187, 0.05110902711749077, 0.0040381490252912045, 0.020308909937739372, -0.030149422585964203, -0.05434081703424454, -0.028708621859550476, -0.01484202966094017, -0.04849826917052269, 0.027503272518515587, -0.019799629226326942, -0.02339855767786503, -0.003291672095656395, -0.028651710599660873, -0.024412373080849648, 0.007366749923676252, 0.02030506357550621, 0.007998976856470108, 0.04917340725660324, 0.011433516629040241, 0.006541637238115072, 0.010133780539035797, 0.009345040656626225, 0.10071838647127151, 0.06688105314970016, 0.03375644609332085, -0.08670398592948914, 0.031114812940359116, 0.019661933183670044, 0.03238295391201973, -0.028209645301103592, 0.002993319183588028, 0.006311992648988962, -0.022846177220344543, 0.04962209612131119, 0.06136051565408707, 0.029751351103186607, 0.00911212433129549, 0.08141659945249557, 0.005037426482886076, -0.0103955352678895, -0.0005341816577129066, 0.0003981214831583202, -0.032863762229681015, -0.023435762152075768, -0.014372728765010834, 0.004232592880725861, -0.0009332908084616065, -0.009930582717061043, -0.009343634359538555, -0.007951087318360806, 0.02637415938079357, 0.02702602557837963, -0.035409536212682724, -0.0014852924505248666, 0.027116023004055023, 0.02812543511390686, -0.06734964996576309, -0.017258478328585625, 0.0014325098600238562, -0.013768430799245834, -0.003357306821271777, 0.015684448182582855, 0.002296634018421173, -0.028082339093089104, 0.00008659398736199364, 0.020296793431043625, -0.040338557213544846, -0.03206460550427437, -0.0391964428126812, 0.012118864804506302, 0.012760513462126255, -0.00620905589312315, -0.05171559378504753, 0.00593248475342989, -0.008954934775829315, -0.03715497627854347, -0.009315649047493935, 0.015338370576500893, 0.015679677948355675, -0.02631099708378315, -0.017962398007512093, -0.0218046922236681, 0.018816234543919563, -0.028075644746422768, 0.039859868586063385, 0.0005227996734902263, -0.04267369583249092, -0.014951266348361969, -0.022106990218162537, 0.034883763641119, 0.01628037728369236, -0.03529007360339165, 0.013814750127494335, -0.023793809115886688, -0.005838669370859861, 0.04316186532378197, 0.004004885908216238, 0.003005781676620245, 0.008530802093446255, 0.006249310448765755, -0.019605012610554695, -0.020969413220882416, -0.0030391719192266464, 0.011654823087155819, -0.022910092025995255, -0.025868630036711693, -0.04889173433184624, 0.014968007802963257, 0.031172970309853554, 0.008580212481319904, 0.014095939695835114, 0.03218735009431839, -0.01903114654123783, 0.03915620967745781, 0.02420334331691265, -0.05300955846905708, -0.04258640110492706, -0.03134920448064804, -0.016431735828518867, -0.01997784897685051, -0.024662088602781296, 0.046126145869493484, 0.01682867296040058, 0.023483438417315483, 0.015517793595790863, 0.016166025772690773, -0.009540317580103874, 0.04596737027168274, 0.037312086671590805, -0.04332984983921051, 0.0033560749143362045, 0.0007556836353614926, 0.003271469147875905, -0.026942502707242966, -0.02815338410437107, -0.07389995455741882, -0.02360760048031807, -0.006168275140225887, -0.03375399485230446, -0.03231637179851532, -0.007355233188718557, -0.016920220106840134, 0.02269977331161499, -0.03361339122056961, -0.004047759808599949, -0.05120900645852089, -0.03764330595731735, -0.005993545055389404, 0.0024224217049777508, -0.00007628738967468962, 0.016403090208768845, 0.005647658370435238, 0.011362284421920776, 0.02803739719092846, 0.021072739735245705, -0.01979801058769226, 0.008980297483503819, 0.023648027330636978, 0.040755338966846466, 0.03495032712817192, -0.02121097594499588, 0.000998439616523683, 0.02553408592939377, -0.037574175745248795, 0.007094801869243383, 0.01650778204202652, -0.015948383137583733, 0.05161695554852486, 0.015508386306464672, -0.02921757847070694, -0.013397356495261192, 0.05376249924302101, -0.00007064988312777132, -0.018543045967817307, -0.039048828184604645, -0.008314402773976326, -0.012933562509715557, 0.007031261920928955, -0.020140694454312325, 0.01117048878222704, -0.04221929609775543, 0.012648058123886585, 0.05473571643233299, -0.0003879941359627992, -0.01128360629081726, 0.026217518374323845, -0.00033737276680767536, 0.005987613461911678, 0.017458895221352577, -0.01755351386964321, 0.04300560802221298, 0.03759731724858284, -0.03358667716383934, 0.041892241686582565, 0.004634895361959934, 0.04018523544073105, -0.08991190791130066, -0.011602402664721012, -0.001566717866808176, 0.02837112918496132, 0.04458148777484894, -0.06040261685848236, 0.02476213499903679, 0.011295720934867859, -0.056535378098487854, -0.0046859015710651875, -0.0061389547772705555, -0.03774779289960861, -0.034343987703323364, -0.02256843075156212, -0.007577683310955763, 0.01025948952883482, 0.029035579413175583, 0.024710489436984062, 0.005014912225306034, 0.028107764199376106, -0.023370515555143356, -0.0372304804623127, 0.0036278970073908567, -0.011886720545589924, 0.04853042960166931, -0.08431226015090942, 0.005810147151350975, -0.014796537347137928, -0.029937632381916046, 0.05985209718346596, -0.00008421851816819981, 0.04826962575316429, 0.04728172719478607, 0.07520739734172821, 0.007225036155432463, 0.049436043947935104, 0.010971399024128914, 0.001976478612050414, -0.05956565588712692, 0.014353721402585506, 0.012503378093242645, 0.03370009735226631, -0.02201891876757145, -0.009850900620222092, 0.05024486407637596, -0.027947720140218735, -0.03346212953329086, 0.01137296948581934, -0.012330896221101284, -0.011497617699205875, -0.009103900752961636, -0.026484310626983643, 0.005137678235769272, -0.013340403325855732, 0.030543727800250053, -0.054274242371320724, -0.0328686460852623, 0.013306530192494392, 0.0027348825242370367, 0.0020187529735267162, -0.003648496000096202, -0.012991189956665039, -0.03093498758971691, -0.0022872036788612604, 0.004178217612206936, 0.025129087269306183, -0.05817679688334465, 0.003478446276858449, -0.03202865272760391, 0.01621994376182556, -0.021934283897280693, -0.033972274512052536, 0.010446038097143173, 0.05307278037071228, -0.0220323596149683, -0.024125611409544945, 0.029579440131783485, -0.03027789108455181, 0.0268277358263731, -0.08175221085548401, 0.0681169182062149, 0.019739583134651184, -0.017367243766784668, -0.013800538145005703, 0.022163495421409607, -0.040606848895549774, -0.047647107392549515, 0.053172726184129715, -0.005646263714879751, -0.005286313593387604, -0.01978267915546894, 0.03422767296433449, -0.005454142112284899, -0.07130393385887146, 0.007645131088793278, -0.009672622196376324, -0.04573386162519455, -0.02628416381776333, -0.013894802890717983, 0.015103260055184364, -0.03150857612490654, 0.04054271802306175, 0.0077682617120444775, 0.022121433168649673, -0.029301239177584648, -0.019710304215550423, 0.009842341765761375, 0.005832375958561897, -0.017387742176651955, 0.04222075641155243, -0.005677567794919014, 0.008261852897703648, 0.001263299840502441, -0.008056405931711197, -0.040998052805662155, 0.037047602236270905, -0.002474173903465271, 0.0015097403666004539, -0.010877624154090881, 0.056370146572589874, -0.05086509510874748, -0.051761068403720856, -0.0006488358485512435, 0.01003352366387844, -0.06904780119657516, -0.006490732077509165, 0.02518760785460472, 0.04038587585091591, 0.031569115817546844, -0.02494882605969906, -0.017324795946478844, 0.015189767815172672, -0.04562433063983917, 0.04617570713162422, 0.011803769506514072, 0.05134713277220726, 0.020469576120376587, -0.01157587580382824, 0.02742130309343338, -0.024719512090086937, 0.011675726622343063, -0.010821415111422539, 0.03097609430551529, 0.015907425433397293, -0.01994551159441471, 0.03084057755768299, -0.01763647049665451, 0.04949735850095749, 0.042247552424669266, -0.0024484405294060707, 0.031760767102241516, -0.026268215849995613, 0.03521767258644104, -0.024767912924289703, -0.002481962088495493, -0.025694916024804115, 0.003092386294156313, 0.04747515544295311, -0.010395151562988758, -0.029910534620285034, 0.01110826339572668, 0.013046436943113804, -0.034505847841501236, -0.0030511515215039253, -0.014064355753362179, 0.019303839653730392, -0.036128733307123184, -0.01080287341028452, -0.005250922404229641, -0.0022656386718153954, -0.04047602787613869, -0.03086121752858162, 0.04067382961511612, 0.024426644667983055, 0.02684824913740158, -0.012271301820874214, -0.00958284642547369, 0.005203363951295614, 0.04857242479920387, -0.05710239335894585, -0.039882417768239975, -0.0526367649435997, 0.01988709717988968, 0.015214315615594387, -0.008555205538868904 ]
<p>I am calling the R MICE routines into SPSS to do multiple imputations. My question is how to save the multiple imputed data sets as SPSS files for later analyses.<br> Any help would be greatly appreciated.</p> <p>DLuo</p>
74,166
[ -0.07084127515554428, 0.018208306282758713, 0.006958276964724064, 0.008759590797126293, -0.002920282306149602, -0.0001420799089828506, -0.009883490391075611, -0.02430403232574463, 0.03136492148041725, 0.019084639847278595, 0.014198653399944305, 0.0582733154296875, 0.017126834020018578, -0.014027596451342106, -0.004943236242979765, -0.02099158801138401, -0.016954615712165833, 0.036136195063591, 0.034012895077466965, 0.014658578671514988, -0.027171393856406212, 0.041185036301612854, 0.017095837742090225, -0.019795401021838188, 0.007745677605271339, 0.03186652436852455, 0.01276015117764473, -0.03321946784853935, -0.014018277637660503, 0.03178934380412102, -0.023354792967438698, -0.015321091748774052, -0.0011314763687551022, 0.020018720999360085, 0.007111615035682917, -0.01228070817887783, -0.035481300204992294, -0.02867274172604084, 0.009642957709729671, 0.01668667420744896, 0.0005951881757937372, -0.024631954729557037, 0.02048870176076889, 0.03934037685394287, -0.0005227013607509434, -0.012393561191856861, -0.017800167202949524, 0.020719198510050774, -0.0020439988002181053, -0.018357105553150177, 0.051805540919303894, -0.015757326036691666, 0.05425924062728882, 0.05868316441774368, -0.009024427272379398, 0.02398630976676941, 0.021263308823108673, 0.07458984851837158, 0.0024795380886644125, -0.03586567938327789, 0.01631600223481655, -0.04243098571896553, 0.025222893804311752, -0.0008526170859113336, -0.029374560341238976, -0.0015376879600808024, 0.003333902219310403, 0.026343103498220444, 0.06823465973138809, -0.02915976010262966, 0.023723667487502098, 0.025414030998945236, 0.04217014089226723, -0.015052855014801025, 0.03098650835454464, -0.021909555420279503, 0.019963063299655914, 0.0028320627752691507, 0.0420183390378952, 0.03260002285242081, 0.023165211081504822, 0.039532605558633804, 0.022201983258128166, 0.015181919559836388, 0.012206784449517727, -0.0018827732419595122, 0.06426694244146347, -0.024515347555279732, 0.023176761344075203, 0.009892633184790611, 0.01857195608317852, -0.01459504570811987, 0.06499671190977097, 0.015309172682464123, -0.008508384227752686, 0.010926402173936367, -0.011388208717107773, 0.059233181178569794, -0.01452375017106533, -0.006064159329980612, 0.027894845232367516, -0.0027176993899047375, 0.0220827404409647, 0.03988087177276611, -0.04620690271258354, -0.0017390421126037836, -0.03090611845254898, -0.013615270145237446, -0.00590575160458684, -0.047196801751852036, -0.021401984617114067, 0.026158271357417107, 0.010932983830571175, 0.011670859530568123, 0.03772382438182831, -0.005194342695176601, -0.02306629903614521, 0.00552337197586894, 0.038620248436927795, 0.05748964101076126, 0.05219927430152893, -0.04621199518442154, 0.024479977786540985, -0.033162422478199005, -0.05582933500409126, 0.03522804006934166, -0.013246647082269192, -0.01140890084207058, -0.030613360926508904, 0.019427305087447166, -0.008021311834454536, -0.038664285093545914, 0.037407632917165756, -0.0028407631907612085, 0.03473436087369919, 0.013701267540454865, -0.09118225425481796, -0.07725539058446884, -0.0009101602481678128, -0.0671907439827919, 0.02066565491259098, -0.058836255222558975, -0.009912519715726376, -0.00869847647845745, 0.07716219872236252, -0.00442499341443181, 0.0012314502382650971, 0.04791862890124321, 0.04186105728149414, -0.013276420533657074, -0.008115249685943127, -0.020211663097143173, -0.05320945754647255, -0.021707944571971893, -0.012925649993121624, -0.09033207595348358, 0.018262915313243866, 0.029213586822152138, -0.020007126033306122, -0.015170940198004246, 0.008476492017507553, 0.012647797353565693, 0.022648252546787262, -0.008149072527885437, 0.01061001792550087, -0.024061521515250206, 0.03429141640663147, -0.023640500381588936, 0.025783903896808624, 0.02838410623371601, -0.030366430059075356, 0.022325845435261726, 0.007207630202174187, 0.06113826110959053, 0.014401528052985668, -0.004951419308781624, -0.03380130976438522, 0.01021385658532381, -0.006852992344647646, 0.006906028371304274, -0.045596543699502945, -0.059015654027462006, 0.0075651174411177635, 0.008377311751246452, 0.04030189290642738, 0.03313830867409706, 0.025188807398080826, -0.06306175142526627, 0.034442346543073654, -0.07473736256361008, -0.05703451484441757, -0.07982154935598373, 0.04059060662984848, -0.026677846908569336, -0.028829364106059074, -0.020727673545479774, -0.0024311202578246593, 0.005770538933575153, 0.011054244823753834, -0.026254089549183846, -0.052045825868844986, -0.009823652915656567, 0.03760267049074173, -0.026694798842072487, -0.051472991704940796, 0.04045877233147621, 0.043055810034275055, -0.04810839891433716, 0.0009573792922310531, -0.03245316445827484, -0.013197129592299461, -0.011749772354960442, -0.042267538607120514, 0.01497590634971857, -0.008576611988246441, -0.011769769713282585, 0.029683591797947884, 0.03130606934428215, -0.03327694535255432, 0.004843884147703648, -0.005527237895876169, 0.025758635252714157, 0.05725185573101044, 0.015940198674798012, -0.04224630445241928, -0.012057250365614891, 0.004236198496073484, 0.02504308521747589, -0.039645105600357056, -0.0008160502766259015, -0.03614553064107895, -0.037103064358234406, 0.030791955068707466, -0.005125707481056452, -0.051768530160188675, 0.016932731494307518, 0.036384936422109604, -0.005893018562346697, 0.0028124006930738688, 0.03269143030047417, -0.032132502645254135, -0.005355260334908962, -0.00932300928980112, -0.0003991230914834887, 0.03705298528075218, 0.016037341207265854, -0.007192614488303661, 0.0014685007045045495, 0.04516340419650078, 0.009354513138532639, 0.014559710398316383, 0.014232389628887177, 0.03464294597506523, -0.013006806373596191, -0.021795175969600677, -0.017744487151503563, 0.020663462579250336, -0.013101068325340748, 0.02033337391912937, 0.0380016528069973, 0.005723921582102776, -0.011322499252855778, 0.06455304473638535, -0.007093853782862425, 0.010418945923447609, 0.044880207628011703, -0.03324611112475395, 0.006338146049529314, 0.0038438942283391953, -0.049849797040224075, 0.020236877724528313, -0.01857111044228077, -0.029090145602822304, -0.05041472613811493, 0.023334378376603127, 0.03002926893532276, -0.0018231485737487674, 0.061240702867507935, -0.04773791506886482, -0.014303093776106834, 0.01786387339234352, -0.0211779847741127, 0.034836817532777786, 0.04205893352627754, -0.013072277419269085, -0.015629984438419342, -0.019447535276412964, -0.01879563368856907, 0.018179094418883324, -0.00975356437265873, -0.04416734352707863, 0.02491130493581295, 0.04417554661631584, -0.0674312636256218, -0.028792263939976692, 0.015224482864141464, 0.000990288332104683, 0.006693159695714712, 0.010072987526655197, 0.026412082836031914, 0.022049512714147568, -0.026646828278899193, -0.0018302514217793941, -0.05663107708096504, -0.003667110577225685, 0.0024380655959248543, -0.009201405569911003, -0.002385880099609494, -0.01248949859291315, -0.0017132587963715196, -0.04210712015628815, -0.023730354383587837, -0.00902610830962658, -0.05042451247572899, -0.04250037297606468, 0.039511989802122116, 0.021691473200917244, 0.017145346850156784, 0.02562168799340725, 0.013687292113900185, 0.10535699874162674, 0.015865109860897064, -0.03438692167401314, -0.046161532402038574, -0.03515227884054184, -0.04072277620434761, -0.026476126164197922, 0.016321096569299698, 0.008779200725257397, 0.015751760452985764, -0.03282768279314041, 0.019299576058983803, 0.014395161531865597, 0.05661270394921303, -0.006586004514247179, 0.013629455119371414, 0.009553167968988419, -0.018033720552921295, -0.027468794956803322, 0.03392527997493744, 0.01566430926322937, 0.004485448356717825, 0.018196940422058105, -0.038977887481451035, 0.011118301190435886, -0.005977226886898279, -0.07390249520540237, -0.0034038082230836153, -0.02542564831674099, 0.016158491373062134, -0.0697823315858841, 0.015016111545264721, 0.06495590507984161, -0.022122718393802643, -0.0039723580703139305, 0.022460995241999626, 0.04830874502658844, -0.046477317810058594, -0.015176655724644661, 0.0527060441672802, 0.017907189205288887, -0.012244121171534061, -0.010096088983118534, -0.07169381529092789, -0.0057761408388614655, 0.028093528002500534, 0.00275259162299335, -0.010776621289551258, 0.049298085272312164, 0.03099963068962097, -0.005801104940474033, -0.004759606439620256, -0.015280324034392834, 0.044697389006614685, -0.07251214981079102, 0.006420974154025316, -0.02676432393491268, 0.0364551767706871, 0.02117038145661354, 0.026084013283252716, 0.014316934160888195, -0.015185851603746414, 0.004196355119347572, 0.0034684748388826847, -0.06658437848091125, -0.004041892476379871, -0.007984839379787445, 0.03031313046813011, 0.014443889260292053, -0.005086773540824652, 0.0242436695843935, -0.008272410370409489, 0.000016475290976813994, 0.004170513246208429, 0.0064949821680784225, -0.02417628839612007, 0.0024279258213937283, -0.029341137036681175, 0.002101974096149206, -0.01641889475286007, 0.06392966210842133, -0.0006919474108144641, -0.009246657602488995, 0.027340827509760857, 0.010645397938787937, -0.023678651079535484, -0.015885552391409874, -0.012995798140764236, 0.004992256872355938, -0.0052254460752010345, 0.025797821581363678, 0.04549047350883484, 0.025264304131269455, -0.033714283257722855, 0.0017019459046423435, -0.007970532402396202, 0.0178153645247221, 0.05541733279824257, 0.008451079949736595, -0.04614842310547829, -0.03162853792309761, 0.029769310727715492, 0.014007213525474072, -0.006623446941375732, -0.00004687086766352877, 0.0014402511296793818, 0.03869153559207916, 0.028130246326327324, -0.042493563145399094, 0.010395579040050507, 0.04185662046074867, 0.048707522451877594, -0.018921347334980965, -0.016080517321825027, 0.00896705873310566, -0.00477837398648262, -0.012183045037090778, 0.011252676136791706, 0.03070872090756893, 0.004075697157531977, 0.009649820625782013, 0.0004827625525649637, -0.0056150550954043865, -0.014984192326664925, 0.02036871574819088, 0.018284184858202934, 0.0714867040514946, 0.01166629884392023, -0.01984025165438652, 0.015852509066462517, 0.06372726708650589, 0.010303164832293987, 0.01989375799894333, -0.015647554770112038, -0.07857689261436462, -0.010659553110599518, 0.026231341063976288, 0.020374005660414696, -0.014892015606164932, 0.018601907417178154, -0.02801048383116722, -0.013864506967365742, 0.05361736938357353, -0.05656566470861435, 0.011655952781438828, -0.011972500942647457, -0.006228878162801266, -0.0507320873439312, -0.012961064465343952, 0.012712748721241951, -0.012908874079585075, -0.053119342774152756, 0.04404602199792862, -0.01623009517788887, -0.0013074169401079416, -0.032087329775094986, 0.014872576110064983, 0.004436137154698372, 0.08895884454250336, 0.01245198305696249, 0.013416674919426441, 0.011655247770249844, 0.01784965768456459, -0.0125791160389781, -0.03272833302617073, 0.011905863881111145, 0.01488084252923727, 0.006790114566683769, 0.0738922730088234, -0.01610240340232849, -0.015282310545444489, 0.03472311422228813, 0.005001999903470278, -0.023556219413876534, -0.014118924736976624, -0.04702511802315712, -0.0037219126243144274, 0.026649584993720055, 0.02334974892437458, 0.03609662503004074, 0.042305316776037216, 0.009908429346978664, 0.020413801074028015, -0.056178346276283264, 0.017930375412106514, -0.021687272936105728, -0.06979288905858994, -0.04492231085896492, 0.006193125620484352, -0.01109049841761589, 0.002077048644423485, 0.011982407420873642, 0.03320680931210518, -0.02870146930217743, -0.02738388068974018, 0.04139082506299019, 0.04333660006523132, -0.004668912384659052, 0.010733168572187424, 0.0034987437538802624, 0.023327622562646866, -0.020905880257487297, -0.028974585235118866, 0.035000670701265335, -0.039557408541440964, -0.01952752284705639, 0.025167478248476982, -0.09055370837450027, 0.012508010491728783, -0.03125029429793358, -0.036990340799093246, 0.009763425216078758, -0.02451147884130478, -0.015607769601047039, -0.04210874065756798, 0.045197587460279465, 0.0157401692122221, -0.038540806621313095, -0.00773217249661684, 0.06299670785665512, 0.01645195670425892, 0.02016391046345234, -0.03263803571462631, 0.03504158928990364, -0.003551879897713661, -0.003075601300224662, -0.04969974234700203, -0.07131177186965942, -0.015354206785559654, 0.01926462911069393, -0.019668541848659515, -0.029606681317090988, -0.0010440126061439514, 0.005519032012671232, -0.004860903136432171, -0.01718890480697155, 0.006502017844468355, -0.025727301836013794, -0.006724715232849121, -0.044038400053977966, 0.007516929414123297, 0.0725245401263237, 0.01822488009929657, 0.014187371358275414, 0.014092354103922844, -0.02877270057797432, -0.012634243816137314, -0.004594636149704456, 0.003676455933600664, -0.009372766129672527, -0.041530344635248184, -0.006796979811042547, 0.0003765781584661454, 0.03861203044652939, 0.03118388168513775, 0.01884937286376953, 0.027919374406337738, -0.03109513781964779, -0.028874985873699188, -0.05922389030456543, -0.005564600694924593, -0.0362839475274086, 0.009764458984136581, -0.020453758537769318, -0.009129657410085201, -0.013144422322511673, 0.05057261511683464, 0.016254985705018044, -0.022673295810818672, -0.00005738503023167141, 0.014371205121278763, 0.06326038390398026, 0.006389338988810778, 0.002073459792882204, 0.018407421186566353, -0.01153575535863638, 0.012278484180569649, 0.022938670590519905, 0.03261847048997879, -0.027384165674448013, 0.01871088705956936, -0.02881109155714512, -0.013054093345999718, -0.05450235679745674, -0.027796391397714615, 0.05251554399728775, -0.0277058444917202, 0.03019632399082184, 0.030684208497405052, -0.04094438627362251, -0.032930415123701096, -0.07104617357254028, -0.0024158095475286245, -0.002431944478303194, 0.04471256211400032, 0.09293464571237564, 0.014004303142428398, -0.03834686055779457, 0.029092924669384956, 0.015526754781603813, 0.0528610534965992, 0.06302134692668915, 0.022154787555336952, -0.011696603149175644, 0.009836339391767979, -0.019705815240740776, -0.03776024281978607, -0.027958542108535767, -0.04123276099562645, 0.012702547945082188, -0.03867046907544136, -0.07488681375980377, 0.04176880791783333, 0.047659244388341904, 0.018173307180404663, -0.039848074316978455, -0.008813407272100449, -0.03243144601583481, -0.0028771336656063795, 0.017174169421195984, -0.03511811047792435, -0.0006001092260703444, 0.010178820230066776, 0.058636393398046494, -0.016125382855534554, 0.011647079139947891, -0.0305426474660635, -0.06950139999389648, -0.014734791591763496, -0.03207908943295479, -0.03894677385687828, 0.03322353586554527, -0.005799240432679653, 0.009796741418540478, -0.008374781347811222, -0.00806372333317995, -0.016827914863824844, -0.028740093111991882, 0.05205131322145462, -0.020250214263796806, 0.05208371952176094, 0.012065713293850422, 0.004243649076670408, -0.025606362149119377, -0.020780501887202263, 0.13967721164226532, 0.08202410489320755, 0.0801815539598465, -0.07690539211034775, 0.002026681788265705, 0.01371108926832676, 0.03895837068557739, -0.022234385833144188, -0.009535628370940685, 0.009043673984706402, -0.03373477980494499, 0.04836037755012512, 0.05461570993065834, -0.0071011753752827644, 0.04760020971298218, 0.07097367197275162, -0.028761321678757668, 0.00034082765341736376, -0.005853717215359211, 0.010835215449333191, -0.010234994813799858, -0.03478028625249863, -0.05135054886341095, 0.001657863729633391, 0.01568404771387577, -0.035184454172849655, -0.009555725380778313, -0.0026709986850619316, 0.02867966517806053, 0.0023626023903489113, -0.019298791885375977, 0.016600796952843666, -0.012082420289516449, 0.043046217411756516, -0.013035730458796024, -0.013810683973133564, 0.0211864672601223, -0.022623633965849876, 0.02966141887009144, 0.025605762377381325, 0.04540582001209259, 0.0272664874792099, -0.007717466913163662, -0.005606465041637421, -0.06236880272626877, -0.018602518364787102, -0.01033332571387291, 0.027517972514033318, -0.00978083349764347, -0.02529800683259964, -0.03809499740600586, 0.014925937168300152, 0.026064859703183174, -0.06869959086179733, -0.048812057822942734, 0.030428465455770493, 0.012825820595026016, 0.017073962837457657, -0.001503750099800527, -0.015576617792248726, -0.039676569402217865, 0.010377124883234501, 0.007736848201602697, -0.009805811569094658, -0.018473127856850624, -0.008350619114935398, -0.02061537094414234, 0.007073523011058569, -0.0034771112259477377, 0.04216843470931053, 0.0010816433932632208, -0.011224913410842419, -0.006799062713980675, -0.02609543688595295, 0.01733805611729622, 0.008637587539851665, -0.017242182046175003, -0.02846343256533146, 0.014910908415913582, -0.027309102937579155, -0.08096189796924591, 0.017556864768266678, 0.0033328626304864883, -0.012396846897900105, -0.024282697588205338, -0.010642241686582565, 0.048893123865127563, 0.05934848636388779, 0.030387982726097107, 0.007946444675326347, -0.03140825405716896, 0.04617001488804817, 0.015649281442165375, -0.026439087465405464, -0.026048852130770683, 0.009715198539197445, -0.07445334643125534, 0.025152448564767838, -0.048172373324632645, 0.06313765048980713, 0.018213599920272827, 0.0326734222471714, 0.00967163685709238, 0.02200833149254322, 0.05268729850649834, 0.03440574184060097, -0.007672638166695833, -0.08164514601230621, 0.0038603737484663725, -0.0201948843896389, -0.012763802893459797, -0.012562788091599941, 0.021215101704001427, -0.03380884975194931, -0.02947455272078514, 0.025365034118294716, -0.03685065358877182, -0.06654971837997437, 0.023432213813066483, 0.023540684953331947, 0.05829762667417526, 0.011207845993340015, 0.0317680761218071, -0.032807622104883194, -0.027983980253338814, -0.016195125877857208, -0.044506169855594635, -0.0013390097301453352, -0.010200095362961292, -0.028858739882707596, 0.04159426689147949, 0.02027153968811035, -0.03889583796262741, -0.0022827526554465294, 0.02324768714606762, -0.010201379656791687, 0.020207421854138374, 0.06993123888969421, -0.01855349726974964, -0.01672978512942791, -0.007543262559920549, -0.05604568496346474, -0.024931015446782112, 0.012247174046933651, 0.0008005199488252401, 0.053862739354372025, 0.04324846714735031, -0.01117900013923645, -0.04172256588935852, 0.07561081647872925, -0.04444026201963425, -0.046090565621852875, -0.011900464072823524, 0.01905176416039467, -0.010956982150673866, 0.03714922443032265, -0.0004589207819662988, 0.013522348366677761, 0.011044449172914028, 0.010337154380977154, 0.061855241656303406, 0.028759058564901352, -0.011968794278800488, 0.0001929850986925885, 0.02816828526556492, -0.014183511957526207, -0.011668659746646881, 0.0013080862117931247, 0.034906696528196335, 0.03722892329096794, -0.018348511308431625, 0.01259054709225893, 0.024202249944210052, 0.013548709452152252, -0.06982718408107758, 0.009596261195838451, -0.018840676173567772, 0.03466540947556496, 0.02343176305294037, -0.008898131549358368, -0.0051667820662260056, 0.03778035566210747, -0.05472780764102936, -0.0006787294987589121, -0.03042793646454811, 0.010406146757304668, -0.0229493398219347, 0.03012586198747158, -0.023369522765278816, 0.016267819330096245, 0.041746772825717926, 0.00838208757340908, 0.02649465762078762, -0.01759866438806057, 0.008650020696222782, -0.032910872250795364, -0.04166601598262787, 0.00955147948116064, 0.016931332647800446, -0.03562384843826294, 0.046601925045251846, -0.022807957604527473, -0.033181048929691315, 0.017657730728387833, -0.025246554985642433, 0.008998820558190346, 0.048671185970306396, 0.019047975540161133, 0.013566233217716217, 0.037335142493247986, -0.011656547896564007, 0.021158495917916298, -0.004227915778756142, -0.004286723677068949, 0.043742407113313675, -0.0077269962057471275, -0.06508246064186096, 0.05004414543509483, 0.026031024754047394, -0.03301936760544777, -0.010959651321172714, 0.01514623686671257, -0.012640776112675667, -0.015157490968704224, -0.008820196613669395, 0.008158492855727673, 0.03139372915029526, -0.007689021527767181, -0.012597156688570976, -0.029317177832126617, 0.03668808564543724, 0.04695456475019455, 0.003464781679213047, 0.006676170043647289, 0.03520059585571289, 0.012357613071799278, -0.03995417803525925, -0.006581571418792009, -0.009965477511286736, -0.0032326083164662123, -0.054254401475191116, -0.013025493361055851, 0.01916574314236641, 0.007342185825109482, -0.025165259838104248, 0.007140259724110365, -0.015508536249399185, 0.05323714762926102, -0.007727040909230709, 0.005450847093015909, 0.010265110991895199, -0.03581980615854263, 0.0037947380915284157, -0.02558954805135727, 0.025603225454688072, 0.002895675366744399, -0.04267370328307152, -0.01988055557012558, -0.02060052566230297, -0.004976733587682247, 0.016311852261424065, 0.04228030890226364, -0.007426186464726925, 0.01297391951084137, -0.024241913110017776, 0.05241777002811432, 0.0172922033816576, -0.053079813718795776, 0.0650591105222702, 0.025374291464686394, -0.01559432689100504, 0.010826858691871166, -0.022085992619395256, 0.002024156739935279, 0.012274356558918953, 0.016374364495277405, -0.00839771144092083, 0.014073885977268219, 0.021213741973042488, 0.004448308143764734, -0.02363673783838749, -0.0003470939991530031, -0.04422586038708687, 0.01652637869119644, -0.0329890213906765, -0.018399735912680626, 0.06153644621372223, 0.010496927425265312, -0.03868710994720459, 0.041759658604860306, -0.03907541558146477, -0.0004950460861437023, -0.005457089748233557, 0.0023595124948769808, -0.01571968011558056, -0.06528114527463913, 0.01773868501186371, 0.00696364464238286, 0.014167329296469688, 0.022435355931520462, 0.05206391215324402, 0.02275039441883564, 0.05167728289961815, 0.03104078583419323, 0.013464121147990227, -0.003825621446594596, -0.023200809955596924, 0.03940018638968468, 0.03230621665716171, -0.014417840167880058, 0.0056771826930344105, -0.029729850590229034, 0.017298072576522827, 0.030705545097589493, 0.007915369234979153, 0.021393654868006706, 0.00907464325428009, -0.04612300917506218, -0.021267352625727654, -0.0014152465155348182, -0.011139118112623692, 0.01752864569425583, 0.0016731750220060349, -0.024661503732204437, 0.03255607560276985, -0.034776415675878525, 0.028645748272538185, -0.05212413892149925, -0.013556324876844883, -0.059128813445568085, 0.041863180696964264, 0.024044739082455635, 0.05142393708229065, -0.002743071410804987, 0.016882579773664474, 0.02034352906048298, -0.005832870956510305, 0.022070087492465973, -0.022657230496406555, 0.004696527495980263, -0.017506739124655724, 0.010337717831134796, 0.0014602791052311659, -0.03283281996846199, 0.00638450076803565, 0.019426466897130013, 0.0001762619212968275, 0.020425554364919662, 0.01353415660560131, -0.0730275958776474, -0.031599096953868866, 0.005802628584206104, 0.024194888770580292, -0.005809325259178877, -0.04437894746661186, -0.014739179983735085, 0.02992665022611618, -0.0010911248391494155, 0.007792782969772816 ]
<p>I originally planned on path analysis utilizing multivariate multiple regression to test my hypothetical model - but I am not getting my sample size. I have looked at non-parametric regression techniques but - am not sure how I can develop my model using these techniques - or if a path model would even be useful at this point. I need a minimum N of 155 per my power analysis for my planned analyses - I currently have 45 and don't see much hope in increasing that number substantially within my somewhat limited timeframe ... so, Any suggestions?</p>
74,167
[ -0.02064521797001362, -0.046895645558834076, 0.0034442893229424953, -0.001870655920356512, 0.06347987055778503, -0.008221889846026897, -0.010852507315576077, -0.04918063059449196, 0.020259806886315346, -0.026777101680636406, 0.03648785501718521, 0.027684733271598816, 0.05399389564990997, -0.01707502081990242, -0.023060671985149384, 0.005475843790918589, -0.022394584491848946, 0.014323360286653042, 0.020812638103961945, -0.03689172491431236, 0.007993433624505997, 0.01729334518313408, -0.005785003770142794, -0.02579699456691742, -0.01475508138537407, 0.0652601569890976, 0.03457726910710335, -0.01954650692641735, 0.0010607599979266524, 0.03109273687005043, -0.013337694108486176, 0.0032214021775871515, 0.009795465506613255, 0.09719093143939972, -0.00261037889868021, -0.013989496044814587, -0.023189490661025047, -0.0387604683637619, -0.014665501192212105, 0.010477211326360703, -0.020927736535668373, -0.010527142323553562, -0.018336687237024307, 0.006032694596797228, -0.008118398487567902, 0.02348078042268753, -0.0028834552504122257, -0.047016777098178864, 0.03229215368628502, -0.039205025881528854, 0.10417301207780838, 0.03008800931274891, 0.04526905342936516, 0.007871922105550766, 0.00042502660653553903, -0.02688094787299633, 0.05546732246875763, 0.07009174674749374, 0.0004381026665214449, -0.019106965512037277, -0.013551117852330208, -0.026830242946743965, 0.009229323826730251, -0.042320817708969116, -0.03488517180085182, 0.01495255809277296, -0.018192557618021965, -0.01800651289522648, 0.014139221049845219, 0.013864940032362938, 0.04296058416366577, 0.00586762186139822, 0.050874143838882446, -0.0002186497877119109, -0.014317474327981472, -0.01978090964257717, 0.022481024265289307, 0.024078568443655968, 0.020093057304620743, 0.04541177302598953, -0.03747755289077759, -0.003213332500308752, 0.004222486633807421, 0.036210495978593826, 0.004299192223697901, 0.008747640997171402, 0.03790650889277458, -0.028090722858905792, 0.001647130586206913, 0.022608064115047455, -0.03730305656790733, -0.017072929069399834, 0.0806131660938263, 0.01724281720817089, -0.03321143239736557, -0.009664029814302921, -0.032962020486593246, 0.033424459397792816, -0.006293728016316891, 0.004434834234416485, -0.011166594922542572, -0.044774316251277924, 0.0010671843774616718, 0.03981027752161026, -0.0047641959972679615, 0.005209140479564667, 0.006894457153975964, 0.00952641200274229, -0.005467782728374004, -0.002866040449589491, -0.011303375475108624, 0.02602539397776127, 0.03391876071691513, -0.030528398230671883, 0.02929549664258957, -0.006360433530062437, -0.044353216886520386, -0.062285106629133224, 0.05601070448756218, 0.0801452025771141, 0.04041772708296776, -0.03889361023902893, 0.03835359215736389, -0.03550448268651962, -0.0347851999104023, 0.011024842970073223, 0.0015947479987517, -0.01443339791148901, -0.018632054328918457, 0.018341029062867165, 0.017768271267414093, -0.03339650109410286, 0.015877174213528633, 0.00006943789048818871, 0.07763800770044327, 0.015488538891077042, -0.0705629214644432, -0.04064178839325905, 0.040520720183849335, -0.024463318288326263, 0.01417527161538601, -0.049256883561611176, 0.015963397920131683, -0.0037276637740433216, 0.08555606752634048, 0.0009418682311661541, 0.03923846408724785, 0.03607286140322685, 0.03965049982070923, 0.023752335458993912, -0.05331075191497803, 0.03140835464000702, -0.05161241069436073, 0.011076528578996658, -0.008151784539222717, -0.09525332599878311, 0.05044456571340561, 0.03152709826827049, -0.008677938021719456, -0.018634939566254616, 0.018060067668557167, 0.028341541066765785, -0.0188580434769392, -0.023601001128554344, 0.022213077172636986, -0.0379420630633831, 0.07447967678308487, -0.052396610379219055, 0.028393365442752838, 0.010742776095867157, 0.013499857857823372, 0.007119616959244013, 0.05136971175670624, 0.03761182725429535, 0.061388760805130005, -0.007520067971199751, 0.019345222041010857, 0.0011012600734829903, -0.004841955378651619, -0.016165131703019142, -0.040302228182554245, -0.05291183665394783, -0.0013008590321987867, 0.008876757696270943, 0.0183201152831316, 0.03942171484231949, -0.014128223992884159, -0.04201606661081314, 0.024620462208986282, -0.04626543074846268, -0.040915198624134064, -0.06796146184206009, 0.05035549774765968, -0.01007147692143917, -0.022701406851410866, 0.00036266440292820334, -0.032016314566135406, 0.03756548464298248, -0.029012437909841537, -0.034120067954063416, -0.026616577059030533, -0.008123022504150867, 0.04149487242102623, -0.04096600040793419, -0.020088322460651398, 0.046847131103277206, 0.05452125519514084, -0.029733311384916306, 0.03252047672867775, -0.05829538032412529, -0.06665311008691788, -0.015968700870871544, -0.053586069494485855, 0.0127188041806221, -0.0315416157245636, -0.023650214076042175, -0.014014331623911858, -0.004982417449355125, -0.026853404939174652, 0.05306198447942734, -0.01432961318641901, 0.09984114021062851, 0.04441453889012337, 0.007692805025726557, -0.01099441945552826, -0.0059323376044631, -0.006169911008328199, -0.007647533901035786, -0.047544389963150024, -0.007048774976283312, -0.04380905255675316, -0.02675086446106434, 0.03264474496245384, -0.0529300756752491, -0.06196565926074982, -0.011914990842342377, 0.055029407143592834, -0.006630920805037022, 0.024908997118473053, 0.00854289997369051, 0.012153667397797108, -0.016432004049420357, -0.018537374213337898, 0.021453291177749634, 0.004143628757447004, -0.013601278886198997, 0.012137088924646378, 0.009770710952579975, 0.04454004764556885, 0.00449149077758193, -0.023762613534927368, 0.026390032842755318, 0.01548464410007, -0.012873243540525436, -0.03320939466357231, -0.010456232354044914, 0.054393935948610306, -0.0025841002352535725, -0.019421199336647987, 0.0417792983353138, -0.02588493749499321, 0.0008731491398066282, -0.008631437085568905, -0.031768880784511566, 0.02454913966357708, 0.02781747095286846, -0.022035490721464157, 0.025867756456136703, 0.013140082359313965, -0.031995248049497604, 0.006870937999337912, -0.01812666654586792, -0.04185306280851364, -0.03710319474339485, 0.01983674056828022, 0.012202618643641472, 0.0069032469764351845, 0.03117295727133751, -0.006018994841724634, -0.028972115367650986, -0.004929369781166315, 0.017495539039373398, -0.016082871705293655, 0.01086732093244791, -0.07217633724212646, -0.035854700952768326, 0.003239176468923688, 0.00947000551968813, 0.022760361433029175, -0.0339505635201931, -0.002704247832298279, 0.04012856259942055, -0.011926177889108658, -0.07828795909881592, -0.024345366284251213, -0.004887691233307123, -0.006026016548275948, -0.03360751271247864, -0.02591753378510475, 0.04258923605084419, 0.023898830637335777, -0.050615064799785614, 0.04342006519436836, -0.006749422289431095, -0.024813726544380188, 0.0017086633015424013, 0.021712366491556168, 0.022415924817323685, -0.01508786529302597, -0.0007154633640311658, 0.01760263182222843, -0.02386411279439926, 0.011052184738218784, -0.060699768364429474, -0.06468690186738968, 0.03190899267792702, -0.0013986240373924375, 0.03874388709664345, 0.009302904829382896, -0.027035845443606377, 0.06059549003839493, 0.019069813191890717, -0.026096902787685394, -0.06785202771425247, -0.027757303789258003, -0.0007674964144825935, -0.031220775097608566, 0.030134622007608414, 0.0241070743650198, -0.004081524442881346, -0.010271478444337845, -0.02868175506591797, 0.00011757852917071432, 0.044089097529649734, 0.018637830391526222, 0.018440714105963707, 0.02334919013082981, -0.014161701314151287, 0.01840783841907978, -0.0025187633000314236, 0.014545523561537266, -0.04721961170434952, 0.03580037131905556, -0.030873317271471024, 0.016870979219675064, 0.004259367007762194, -0.056749630719423294, -0.008839486166834831, -0.009404860436916351, 0.012558323331177235, -0.023130513727664948, -0.023465923964977264, -0.010099207051098347, -0.046935759484767914, -0.021068643778562546, 0.04458968713879585, 0.012504312209784985, -0.01892654225230217, 0.020534759387373924, 0.0283158291131258, 0.007669810671359301, 0.008425002917647362, 0.020431332290172577, -0.024295225739479065, 0.008479160256683826, -0.02214481495320797, 0.00011399929644539952, -0.01697593368589878, 0.0376371406018734, 0.030726999044418335, 0.05480942875146866, 0.0009099749731831253, -0.01667172834277153, -0.0041978685185313225, -0.037704598158597946, 0.006760059390217066, -0.042412202805280685, 0.04492688551545143, 0.0025284425355494022, 0.011609969660639763, -0.001286150305531919, -0.01996905729174614, 0.008559404872357845, 0.008981362916529179, -0.08617591857910156, 0.030209092423319817, -0.036389295011758804, -0.01289915107190609, 0.01771952398121357, -0.00976311694830656, -0.0011380420764908195, -0.008574704639613628, 0.02876456081867218, 0.01767268031835556, 0.03891957551240921, -0.009101053699851036, 0.03332969918847084, -0.03200212121009827, 0.0017142447177320719, 0.017101338133215904, 0.005583057180047035, 0.007594287395477295, -0.0038871020078659058, 0.013072063215076923, 0.029283354058861732, -0.0043464465998113155, -0.07607467472553253, -0.027331307530403137, 0.011546886526048183, 0.004958471283316612, 0.01634378172457218, 0.03923775255680084, 0.016340557485818863, -0.04080847278237343, 0.04984663054347038, -0.02708984911441803, 0.04428786411881447, 0.04712579771876335, 0.042839761823415756, 0.03151433914899826, -0.0510830394923687, 0.01128577534109354, 0.037354469299316406, 0.015915274620056152, 0.01242220588028431, -0.02667365036904812, 0.050459038466215134, -0.009466067887842655, -0.06025329977273941, -0.018404977396130562, 0.04124582186341286, 0.050533831119537354, -0.0033156725112348795, -0.04613953083753586, 0.006620350293815136, 0.010131915099918842, -0.01312644500285387, 0.0165995005518198, -0.007786572445183992, 0.003683625953271985, -0.009654170833528042, 0.020816383883357048, -0.011098731309175491, -0.030368762090802193, 0.0005140748689882457, -0.01187136396765709, 0.06522002816200256, -0.0028474177233874798, -0.05972810462117195, 0.000015447863916051574, 0.03537403792142868, 0.0070856413803994656, 0.02123817801475525, 0.03284803777933121, -0.10545674711465836, 0.013880736194550991, 0.051071032881736755, 0.03995925188064575, -0.030819661915302277, 0.0008981816936284304, 0.006712949834764004, -0.002889455296099186, 0.01947817951440811, -0.001864741905592382, -0.00048809987492859364, 0.009496498852968216, 0.04241709038615227, -0.04605553299188614, -0.021649759262800217, -0.06076917052268982, -0.005370995029807091, -0.021935515105724335, -0.01993592269718647, -0.026805659756064415, -0.006396439857780933, -0.008866463787853718, 0.03262333571910858, -0.006356837227940559, 0.052035875618457794, -0.029287993907928467, -0.019733937457203865, 0.01282696146517992, 0.04758868366479874, 0.007651930674910545, -0.05314438045024872, 0.006047165486961603, 0.014391094446182251, -0.011857109144330025, 0.03578338399529457, 0.0070969220250844955, -0.04797110706567764, 0.030550405383110046, -0.022348757833242416, -0.037260789424180984, -0.01110928226262331, -0.05036962404847145, 0.05271871015429497, -0.022731197997927666, -0.004614796489477158, 0.040819473564624786, 0.031237829476594925, 0.025655023753643036, -0.006347935181111097, -0.010201280936598778, 0.05499914661049843, -0.016612518578767776, -0.03790826350450516, -0.028627436608076096, -0.013518293388187885, -0.0036144517362117767, 0.047220371663570404, -0.00320612033829093, 0.021563677117228508, -0.05152424797415733, -0.030520260334014893, -0.008283184841275215, -0.0038629770278930664, 0.029560966417193413, 0.021554194390773773, 0.021019797772169113, 0.004599119070917368, 0.014337376691401005, -0.002719002775847912, -0.008146912790834904, -0.01914811134338379, 0.013707833364605904, 0.014309263788163662, -0.022607870399951935, -0.01049209013581276, -0.022734999656677246, -0.030871672555804253, 0.03661269322037697, -0.009592444635927677, 0.03691542148590088, -0.01802193932235241, 0.007350240834057331, 0.017144663259387016, -0.05780700594186783, 0.02026730217039585, 0.044575054198503494, -0.011830480769276619, 0.02046322077512741, -0.02318492904305458, 0.009192338213324547, -0.04617726057767868, 0.0003955878200940788, -0.03728456422686577, -0.05494902655482292, 0.013066700659692287, -0.03576706722378731, -0.010752825997769833, -0.013191338628530502, -0.0067792595364153385, -0.030446693301200867, -0.02924211695790291, -0.016284484416246414, 0.05862811580300331, -0.006751591805368662, -0.008051106706261635, 0.000020764862711075693, 0.03604131564497948, 0.0330519936978817, 0.004027326591312885, -0.033718619495630264, -0.008676874451339245, -0.039317481219768524, -0.016579637303948402, -0.007523129694163799, 0.005685483571141958, -0.03185825049877167, -0.034205205738544464, -0.05106096714735031, 0.005845665466040373, 0.06592503190040588, -0.02886451967060566, -0.006588197313249111, -0.025796381756663322, -0.015820149332284927, 0.011447996832430363, -0.02220754697918892, -0.007964864373207092, 0.01441118959337473, 0.014309337362647057, 0.006386641412973404, 0.015639714896678925, -0.013695456087589264, 0.015929995104670525, 0.030897799879312515, 0.03432744741439819, 0.008949127979576588, 0.011819939129054546, 0.024469044059515, 0.025414925068616867, 0.03952657803893089, 0.0026868118438869715, -0.02612326666712761, 0.02566945180296898, 0.016122478991746902, -0.012393532320857048, 0.012089191935956478, 0.005765294190496206, -0.012057960964739323, -0.06740099936723709, -0.03437139838933945, 0.001015781657770276, 0.034569770097732544, 0.004522094503045082, 0.004466220736503601, 0.06076714023947716, -0.010545965284109116, 0.0019563590176403522, -0.0011951097985729575, 0.00039574888069182634, -0.012937743216753006, 0.022051308304071426, 0.06361620128154755, -0.003637654008343816, -0.003263153601437807, 0.039838455617427826, 0.000054312797146849334, 0.024921102449297905, 0.06261055916547775, 0.03995668143033981, 0.02226271480321884, 0.0398528128862381, -0.01680430769920349, -0.029727144166827202, 0.013314380310475826, -0.0535951629281044, 0.013919980265200138, -0.04252877086400986, 0.016998108476400375, 0.0397733673453331, 0.05497661605477333, -0.008227575570344925, -0.02042810060083866, -0.004856040235608816, -0.0417337566614151, -0.035250041633844376, 0.03638361021876335, -0.012470055371522903, 0.014456391334533691, 0.022747496142983437, 0.02305769920349121, -0.00941356923431158, 0.03958703950047493, -0.018525823950767517, -0.03726008161902428, -0.020403118804097176, -0.0036694800946861506, -0.04648863524198532, 0.03057386539876461, -0.008084116503596306, -0.013178718276321888, 0.01199861615896225, -0.02489016205072403, -0.015526097267866135, -0.01189193781465292, 0.035141073167324066, -0.0021814533974975348, 0.0789252519607544, 0.004250705242156982, -0.006749093998223543, -0.012172185815870762, 0.003273161593824625, 0.13217918574810028, 0.1212894394993782, 0.0075911711901426315, -0.0417032428085804, 0.03167030215263367, -0.011511193588376045, -0.01889066770672798, -0.02997487783432007, 0.01578320935368538, -0.005201207939535379, -0.04672293737530708, 0.025032496079802513, 0.03627016767859459, -0.02094566635787487, 0.017497528344392776, 0.09664921462535858, -0.014915752224624157, -0.035590674728155136, 0.028932789340615273, -0.017063859850168228, -0.013987286947667599, -0.04003714397549629, -0.023797042667865753, 0.047780510038137436, 0.002737488830462098, -0.053457312285900116, 0.00333707919344306, -0.02719544619321823, 0.0020667817443609238, 0.0023486297577619553, -0.009323357604444027, -0.010505403392016888, 0.023834405466914177, 0.04821627587080002, -0.02244386449456215, -0.02691722847521305, 0.019520670175552368, -0.0541054792702198, -0.002477574162185192, 0.0704566016793251, 0.01827932894229889, 0.00027708589914254844, -0.032084349542856216, 0.0064462036825716496, -0.05103056877851486, -0.03745100647211075, 0.008961696177721024, 0.02328798547387123, 0.01587195135653019, -0.012837628833949566, -0.019581982865929604, 0.025554871186614037, 0.02596624195575714, -0.010560274124145508, -0.005588915664702654, 0.011636525392532349, 0.05557582527399063, -0.03461704030632973, -0.02367258444428444, 0.015094298869371414, -0.01622505486011505, 0.01913168467581272, 0.03725792095065117, -0.000040005856135394424, -0.010260266251862049, -0.008812431246042252, -0.04062175750732422, 0.04684301093220711, 0.02603236213326454, -0.020493848249316216, 0.0022300006821751595, 0.012285023927688599, -0.030750257894396782, 0.023855939507484436, 0.056234925985336304, 0.0012990754330530763, 0.02788730151951313, -0.001300124917179346, -0.013118340633809566, -0.0304197259247303, -0.0025488908868283033, 0.011045578867197037, -0.02239079400897026, -0.012484307400882244, -0.04129813611507416, 0.0013346710475161672, -0.006347616668790579, 0.0523347333073616, 0.022745711728930473, 0.04147351160645485, -0.007063465658575296, 0.03719371184706688, 0.03525044396519661, -0.06550136208534241, 0.018501725047826767, -0.014414173550903797, -0.05288713797926903, -0.01853802613914013, -0.012596063315868378, 0.028296206146478653, -0.029301661998033524, 0.006322813220322132, 0.009245923720300198, 0.022563569247722626, -0.01797361485660076, -0.0071170334704220295, 0.0033788797445595264, -0.09115586429834366, -0.001365660922601819, -0.003750164294615388, -0.005794830154627562, -0.015808410942554474, -0.0085389893501997, -0.02730051800608635, -0.016378143802285194, 0.016473442316055298, -0.020871123299002647, -0.011543258093297482, 0.0422338992357254, -0.008101491257548332, 0.02839222550392151, -0.04213785007596016, 0.034897856414318085, -0.02620796300470829, 0.0008806795231066644, 0.0009322481346316636, 0.031117765232920647, 0.009152570739388466, 0.006117039360105991, -0.017504999414086342, -0.00023630564101040363, 0.04899698495864868, -0.007649008650332689, 0.014347624033689499, 0.0033953990787267685, -0.01633480004966259, 0.00144644221290946, 0.018225451931357384, -0.03790603578090668, -0.01407040748745203, 0.05239536240696907, -0.04920303449034691, -0.049869708716869354, 0.0106522087007761, -0.0030319737270474434, 0.05878077819943428, 0.0402611568570137, -0.004783679265528917, -0.026248931884765625, 0.027971576899290085, -0.0012185018276795745, -0.01072021760046482, -0.02538212016224861, 0.028206922113895416, -0.04839923232793808, 0.00007998846558621153, 0.0018261180957779288, 0.012593178078532219, 0.013618765398859978, 0.0517442487180233, 0.05345459654927254, -0.0008663469925522804, 0.016467837616801262, 0.03232162073254585, -0.007585207000374794, -0.010096395388245583, -0.011564920656383038, -0.027213921770453453, 0.05446779355406761, 0.052835166454315186, -0.024863705039024353, 0.029346661642193794, -0.010700815357267857, 0.04418168216943741, -0.07299140840768814, -0.007703894749283791, -0.02921953983604908, 0.0034981858916580677, 0.04177689179778099, -0.044286806136369705, -0.014916051179170609, 0.024071810767054558, -0.05526209622621536, -0.009871241636574268, 0.003542386693879962, 0.007078472059220076, -0.03449534997344017, -0.02277904748916626, -0.020020095631480217, 0.018294980749487877, 0.017556332051753998, 0.04151033237576485, 0.034255754202604294, 0.04637238755822182, 0.026780540123581886, -0.035161372274160385, 0.008964774198830128, 0.016495071351528168, -0.003598338458687067, -0.06304190307855606, 0.018286773934960365, -0.049777574837207794, -0.036003824323415756, 0.027193812653422356, -0.028827959671616554, 0.061867937445640564, 0.018049517646431923, 0.0220252126455307, 0.009660093113780022, 0.06717581301927567, 0.026720041409134865, -0.010010648518800735, 0.02206587605178356, -0.027615714818239212, -0.0010320530273020267, 0.027693970128893852, 0.0013579297810792923, 0.0052763125859200954, 0.021306384354829788, -0.006396126002073288, -0.031035246327519417, -0.009576847776770592, -0.004603027831763029, -0.0016144777182489634, 0.016573313623666763, -0.040886394679546356, -0.031232167035341263, 0.005895946640521288, 0.001641336246393621, -0.05358423665165901, -0.013989356346428394, 0.0387125127017498, 0.0004487720725592226, -0.025708094239234924, 0.015752829611301422, -0.00899538118392229, -0.031079374253749847, 0.005131808575242758, 0.013054152019321918, 0.0194677896797657, -0.039652712643146515, -0.0037748273462057114, -0.01444887463003397, -0.024438394233584404, -0.04550141841173172, -0.0016992547316476703, -0.028208265081048012, 0.022649846971035004, -0.022322755306959152, 0.010100670158863068, 0.04646539315581322, -0.011085174977779388, 0.045993372797966, -0.05923501402139664, 0.07151471823453903, -0.0011772970901802182, 0.005926727782934904, -0.0328923724591732, 0.0174212958663702, 0.00027905142633244395, -0.015248622745275497, 0.07505521923303604, -0.023124026134610176, -0.004726380575448275, -0.01826321892440319, 0.02834703028202057, -0.008922237902879715, -0.05357887223362923, 0.04297224432229996, -0.008746490813791752, -0.02628404274582863, -0.04363136738538742, -0.03569861501455307, 0.057459332048892975, 0.013882332481443882, 0.02185116894543171, -0.01610199362039566, -0.0026999497786164284, 0.014158863574266434, -0.009008475579321384, 0.034249112010002136, -0.011484349146485329, -0.014020102098584175, 0.048635948449373245, -0.0028651352040469646, -0.0058792768977582455, 0.04563937336206436, -0.018624242395162582, -0.0639827772974968, 0.02786479890346527, -0.006030315067619085, -0.0076659005135297775, 0.008575554005801678, -0.021606339141726494, 0.025276286527514458, -0.05512116104364395, 0.005695509258657694, 0.032583411782979965, -0.022791411727666855, 0.036934997886419296, 0.04601621255278587, 0.031307153403759, -0.0057191671803593636, -0.01928633637726307, 0.022225668653845787, 0.014774701558053493, 0.009485713206231594, -0.003969851415604353, 0.0006413351511582732, 0.03340786322951317, 0.006070263683795929, 0.033192045986652374, 0.04171081632375717, -0.01739715039730072, 0.05883068963885307, -0.013207593932747841, 0.025139445438981056, -0.04528932645916939, -0.016278374940156937, 0.03807240352034569, 0.008745399303734303, 0.03814462572336197, 0.002709172433242202, 0.0015413560904562473, 0.09815695136785507, -0.021210283041000366, -0.023560650646686554, -0.00715613504871726, -0.03381136804819107, -0.034260720014572144, 0.014067700132727623, -0.0014372284058481455, 0.03553462028503418, 0.015624020248651505, 0.029501816257834435, 0.020812103524804115, -0.019597681239247322, 0.015498104505240917, -0.001562262885272503, 0.05163588374853134, -0.009913146495819092, -0.027296578511595726, -0.05820700526237488, -0.01615707203745842, 0.00045659695751965046, -0.026031777262687683, 0.030683016404509544, 0.014798525720834732, 0.009982828982174397, -0.01619030348956585, -0.010163528844714165, 0.027184229344129562, 0.07574538886547089, -0.04213302582502365, -0.041260987520217896, -0.01919131726026535, -0.019292348995804787, -0.009024711325764656, -0.029638895764946938 ]
<p>I am trying to fit a multi-group latent growth curve model using censored data in Mplus. I have been able to fit a multi-group model using uncensored data, and a single group model using the censored data. Is there a way to combine these?</p> <p>When I have tried to combine these, the error message suggests using KNOWNCLASS with the TYPE=MIXTURE. Is this then a latent class or finite mixture model?</p>
74,168
[ -0.044739291071891785, -0.03380285203456879, 0.016743911430239677, 0.021405788138508797, -0.0235916618257761, 0.019398856908082962, -0.013597813434898853, -0.032378751784563065, 0.009954188950359821, -0.03722814843058586, 0.04942980036139488, 0.02259458228945732, 0.0743325725197792, 0.04113686457276344, 0.0062637594528496265, 0.019518110901117325, -0.004420967306941748, -0.009835817851126194, -0.008179434575140476, 0.02678503282368183, -0.06056889146566391, 0.001292356988415122, -0.004680533427745104, -0.03670471906661987, 0.0022133723832666874, 0.04490315914154053, 0.014034951105713844, -0.01179657131433487, -0.010198187083005905, 0.030140729621052742, -0.009270311333239079, -0.034367673099040985, -0.005509462207555771, 0.02770121395587921, -0.004481237381696701, 0.007232376374304295, -0.037106942385435104, 0.0011763271177187562, -0.03212437033653259, 0.02731267362833023, -0.025505393743515015, -0.022142916917800903, -0.0030311341397464275, 0.026808949187397957, -0.000817770604044199, 0.04492148011922836, -0.01830482669174671, 0.010399006307125092, 0.04252638667821884, -0.01619131676852703, 0.07536670565605164, -0.02114447019994259, 0.013293354772031307, 0.021565601229667664, -0.04457346349954605, 0.014677000232040882, 0.0731336921453476, 0.09039031714200974, 0.035214271396398544, -0.03633776679635048, -0.051798347383737564, -0.021347349509596825, 0.030169488862156868, -0.023116249591112137, -0.05290409177541733, 0.007104193326085806, -0.0038437789771705866, -0.009065365418791771, 0.01786847785115242, 0.010104691609740257, -0.011673159897327423, 0.0013892989372834563, 0.05601123720407486, -0.009711704216897488, 0.049987517297267914, -0.0022096713073551655, -0.02076607383787632, 0.07871610671281815, 0.05046630650758743, -0.008077898994088173, 0.00731511740013957, 0.026496829465031624, -0.027217406779527664, 0.0066914367489516735, 0.0137419318780303, 0.005734168458729982, 0.10425180196762085, 0.004399210214614868, 0.007987619377672672, 0.03126383200287819, -0.06221979111433029, 0.022013841196894646, 0.030427901074290276, 0.03342008590698242, 0.0025342777371406555, 0.044163573533296585, -0.01672518625855446, 0.02883661724627018, -0.00105473049916327, 0.02719249203801155, -0.019027866423130035, -0.02876676619052887, -0.0043206410482525826, 0.022726301103830338, -0.0029859545174986124, -0.0003845858736895025, -0.034994758665561676, -0.01945190504193306, 0.003912434447556734, -0.02128012664616108, 0.015856323763728142, 0.01532518956810236, 0.0137194087728858, -0.01799355074763298, 0.0112554170191288, 0.005985558032989502, -0.03964591026306152, -0.028392458334565163, 0.06118207052350044, 0.04548552632331848, 0.047524791210889816, -0.04976522549986839, 0.04253365844488144, -0.054036643356084824, -0.0774274617433548, 0.0022265210282057524, 0.015498988330364227, -0.014405968599021435, -0.039172034710645676, 0.07580537348985672, 0.009051279164850712, -0.049299731850624084, 0.03240111470222473, 0.014942181296646595, -0.002627582987770438, -0.00409744493663311, -0.06696360558271408, -0.046257808804512024, -0.015489807352423668, -0.01216534711420536, 0.01936141401529312, -0.03167834132909775, 0.0029892136808484793, 0.03198377043008804, 0.06613350659608841, -0.012171291746199131, 0.028819294646382332, -0.00896297488361597, 0.03261182829737663, -0.012370687909424305, 0.010457275435328484, -0.004578005988150835, -0.02278171293437481, 0.013497103936970234, -0.04389696195721626, -0.10249900072813034, 0.015672456473112106, 0.034615833312273026, -0.01878679171204567, 0.031017737463116646, 0.023178797215223312, -0.01806989684700966, 0.009356988593935966, -0.019849473610520363, 0.023621246218681335, -0.020701175555586815, 0.04319639876484871, -0.04623705521225929, 0.03960100933909416, 0.02991466596722603, -0.003873351728543639, 0.04240747541189194, 0.03178343549370766, 0.05315526947379112, 0.0016188439913094044, 0.0029265847988426685, -0.020584966987371445, -0.035767313092947006, 0.015134471468627453, 0.06489025801420212, -0.029871542006731033, -0.014391767792403698, -0.034535638988018036, -0.025130245834589005, 0.011558801867067814, -0.00997304916381836, 0.021939659491181374, -0.04187292233109474, 0.01866563782095909, -0.023226942867040634, -0.03580518439412117, -0.06201225519180298, 0.009532350115478039, -0.04312673583626747, -0.02965918369591236, 0.011725731194019318, -0.012966364622116089, 0.0355369858443737, 0.018463924527168274, -0.06355035305023193, -0.049568600952625275, 0.0066761234775185585, 0.011129185557365417, -0.014595738612115383, -0.015173942781984806, 0.006157583557069302, 0.06298711895942688, -0.03559865429997444, 0.01752600260078907, -0.00025854341220110655, -0.04553826153278351, -0.0016485857777297497, -0.017652519047260284, 0.004144694656133652, -0.005226947832852602, -0.010449103079736233, -0.033593058586120605, 0.04051519185304642, -0.03693430498242378, 0.030802404507994652, -0.02182629331946373, 0.05131664127111435, 0.05488370731472969, -0.0032013566233217716, -0.0018387151649221778, -0.03074868954718113, 0.004651985131204128, 0.02729758992791176, -0.03373882919549942, -0.0069672842510044575, -0.037810277193784714, -0.024356888607144356, 0.030575260519981384, -0.01479825284332037, -0.0360741913318634, 0.028904875740408897, 0.020129693672060966, 0.006536989007145166, -0.009983561001718044, -0.016061315312981606, -0.006936275400221348, -0.010581595823168755, 0.025788621976971626, 0.04521017149090767, 0.004316160921007395, 0.0035057510249316692, 0.017048420384526253, -0.018338795751333237, 0.03821604698896408, -0.003697789739817381, 0.009827687405049801, 0.05311533808708191, 0.04746773838996887, 0.001247235806658864, -0.031657736748456955, -0.009053581394255161, 0.003180569503456354, -0.0032478352077305317, 0.03720251843333244, 0.02467859908938408, -0.01144228596240282, -0.0503137968480587, 0.017718201503157616, -0.03507999703288078, 0.02910720743238926, 0.05314206704497337, -0.03253355994820595, -0.0004657060489989817, 0.008782844059169292, -0.032221660017967224, -0.015585079789161682, 0.029341544955968857, -0.04182986170053482, -0.050689589232206345, 0.07033054530620575, 0.011179594323039055, 0.00026048871222883463, 0.05049851909279823, -0.08376295119524002, -0.04455236345529556, 0.023138659074902534, 0.00431586941704154, 0.055169727653265, 0.003072421532124281, -0.053628548979759216, 0.009333612397313118, -0.016710272058844566, -0.06278558820486069, 0.01781594567000866, 0.02448269911110401, -0.03450708091259003, 0.011800535954535007, -0.019915973767638206, -0.021252082660794258, -0.03958909213542938, -0.00869581289589405, -0.006095074582844973, 0.00669911690056324, 0.0048481193371117115, -0.00012439773126970977, -0.004156414419412613, -0.03221771493554115, 0.020519405603408813, -0.04539613425731659, -0.00486421212553978, -0.014728620648384094, -0.004145498387515545, 0.017749108374118805, 0.020914457738399506, 0.013702181167900562, 0.04060232639312744, -0.00720372935757041, 0.016634134575724602, -0.05682680755853653, -0.05045545473694801, 0.03576412796974182, -0.004330360796302557, 0.018595540896058083, 0.02686169371008873, 0.04041837155818939, 0.059471748769283295, 0.007224489934742451, -0.023791994899511337, -0.033455271273851395, -0.014967957511544228, -0.0383576862514019, -0.009364750236272812, 0.03469519689679146, 0.014086558483541012, 0.022762082517147064, 0.004457579925656319, 0.004728887230157852, -0.0006475234986282885, 0.06571437418460846, 0.02846609428524971, 0.022407379001379013, 0.029792534187436104, -0.010948299430310726, 0.002143538324162364, 0.022794460877776146, 0.01275077648460865, -0.005811519455164671, 0.0032519404776394367, -0.007671156898140907, 0.04931172356009483, 0.020115530118346214, -0.032299015671014786, 0.008851408027112484, 0.011365707032382488, 0.008090334013104439, -0.061571381986141205, 0.011865273118019104, 0.03699590638279915, -0.032668158411979675, -0.0033582504838705063, 0.011724652722477913, 0.025954801589250565, -0.021355239674448967, -0.013021103106439114, 0.05656483769416809, 0.053576625883579254, 0.0016610848251730204, -0.03709886968135834, -0.027192411944270134, -0.014213007874786854, 0.04815000295639038, -0.005804103333503008, 0.013177817687392235, 0.0025103085208684206, 0.021131163462996483, 0.019193490967154503, 0.03175859898328781, -0.021798450499773026, -0.0021165008656680584, -0.07639975100755692, 0.034954868257045746, -0.034274667501449585, 0.03386969864368439, 0.021355625241994858, 0.01402255892753601, 0.027437087148427963, -0.03274659812450409, 0.021195372566580772, 0.028536226600408554, -0.048168957233428955, 0.04321558400988579, -0.017172548919916153, -0.008612150326371193, 0.007885932922363281, -0.012597700580954552, 0.026364827528595924, -0.007584870792925358, -0.018416818231344223, 0.011255679652094841, 0.012991968542337418, -0.0323566310107708, 0.0054330723360180855, -0.02419319935142994, -0.014832236804068089, 0.0004202348936814815, 0.015549639239907265, 0.015386716462671757, 0.03203682228922844, 0.03523143380880356, 0.03747471421957016, 0.038171280175447464, -0.020189421251416206, 0.0047815409488976, -0.013464206829667091, -0.014681546948850155, 0.039106763899326324, -0.004021437838673592, 0.043178144842386246, -0.0034591308794915676, 0.014026862569153309, -0.0018480157013982534, 0.04188040643930435, 0.03320072963833809, -0.011500163935124874, -0.01789926178753376, -0.03068183921277523, -0.03422847390174866, 0.031193198636174202, 0.0247975941747427, -0.009061458520591259, -0.005696396809071302, 0.038192760199308395, 0.021364182233810425, -0.07930892705917358, -0.00941846240311861, 0.08751025050878525, -0.0037009790539741516, -0.022427504882216454, 0.01126341987401247, -0.009478436782956123, 0.0031566566321998835, -0.027279386296868324, 0.009459796361625195, 0.058737386018037796, 0.016716018319129944, -0.025758082047104836, 0.03929956257343292, -0.008776558563113213, -0.04334717243909836, -0.0069544934667646885, 0.0040665301494300365, 0.01008845865726471, 0.010338988155126572, -0.03995184600353241, 0.037902239710092545, 0.05954825505614281, 0.0040500713512301445, 0.03009767085313797, 0.029263600707054138, -0.10532930493354797, 0.004540564026683569, 0.014315362088382244, 0.0314125157892704, -0.023037031292915344, -0.006267832592129707, -0.023980187252163887, -0.006501611787825823, -0.010635126382112503, -0.008095912635326385, 0.020307917147874832, 0.016147980466485023, -0.005581847857683897, -0.028074461966753006, -0.0012964151101186872, -0.057029083371162415, 0.008553585968911648, -0.024614762514829636, -0.027629245072603226, 0.003571960609406233, -0.012944256886839867, -0.015144307166337967, 0.04163116589188576, 0.0019772844389081, 0.05901286378502846, -0.031857315450906754, -0.006859662476927042, 0.03420053794980049, 0.033303141593933105, -0.030711492523550987, -0.04519006609916687, 0.024788878858089447, 0.010448722168803215, -0.04070282727479935, 0.06588491797447205, -0.019228389486670494, -0.01837632618844509, 0.035699669271707535, -0.008420002646744251, -0.008802883327007294, 0.025159969925880432, -0.04695605859160423, 0.040051694959402084, 0.00416354276239872, 0.0019185311393812299, 0.0417729951441288, 0.03258924186229706, 0.02039230614900589, -0.013809668831527233, -0.06352316588163376, 0.04452328756451607, -0.054700106382369995, -0.02373739704489708, -0.03376702964305878, -0.00644253846257925, -0.009738474152982235, 0.02104734443128109, 0.009126652032136917, 0.0011239886516705155, -0.03184881806373596, -0.05559507757425308, 0.013582809828221798, 0.002931714989244938, -0.014320313930511475, -0.007130395621061325, 0.03078036941587925, 0.0005584109458141029, 0.00033717663609422743, -0.016782626509666443, 0.013764746487140656, -0.06183422729372978, 0.0005886213621124625, -0.00240896875038743, -0.04992576315999031, 0.02192584052681923, 0.036547672003507614, -0.015229039825499058, 0.02471793070435524, -0.042341314256191254, 0.020930873230099678, -0.0004971257876604795, 0.05095120891928673, -0.009797800332307816, 0.0021712370216846466, 0.0006867590127512813, 0.009038694202899933, 0.0023511287290602922, 0.04644313454627991, -0.01770191639661789, 0.08272625505924225, 0.0001998623920371756, -0.01715259999036789, -0.044106435030698776, -0.034736186265945435, 0.008899473585188389, -0.0021439846605062485, -0.027527812868356705, -0.03819803521037102, -0.02113451063632965, 0.0011727162636816502, -0.024196190759539604, -0.022598816081881523, 0.04697246849536896, 0.008094879798591137, -0.01819172315299511, -0.06684601306915283, 0.04479147121310234, 0.0515541136264801, 0.0004770864325109869, 0.02390453778207302, 0.01237226091325283, 0.008326011709868908, -0.011496290564537048, 0.010496973991394043, 0.01829240284860134, -0.026500295847654343, -0.006200728937983513, -0.033400896936655045, 0.01311512477695942, 0.08769123256206512, -0.044575586915016174, -0.00993801187723875, 0.039429761469364166, 0.022404009476304054, 0.00838962197303772, -0.016932206228375435, 0.016344644129276276, -0.033061642199754715, -0.0014136600075289607, -0.02006675861775875, 0.021382097154855728, -0.01392724085599184, -0.0015886432956904173, 0.03556257113814354, -0.029356613755226135, -0.06186451390385628, 0.03794325888156891, 0.08714444935321808, 0.006838746834546328, 0.0014293050626292825, -0.015947094187140465, -0.0261060930788517, 0.015576806850731373, 0.0037411144003272057, 0.021236887201666832, 0.033515166491270065, 0.05010662600398064, -0.029288649559020996, 0.016698257997632027, -0.013188717886805534, -0.017143575474619865, 0.0700860396027565, 0.01403003465384245, 0.04684235155582428, 0.0569828599691391, -0.024172190576791763, -0.012713484466075897, -0.039101604372262955, -0.002620634390041232, 0.004538236651569605, 0.0011957846581935883, 0.06873290240764618, -0.04184309393167496, -0.027488568797707558, 0.047015558928251266, 0.0028079506009817123, 0.012140211649239063, 0.058837179094552994, -0.0026714482810348272, 0.0009639456402510405, 0.021290550008416176, 0.004510622937232256, -0.013657075352966785, 0.04290621355175972, -0.052166033536195755, 0.011323332786560059, -0.054954249411821365, -0.008681949228048325, -0.012104064226150513, 0.030613936483860016, 0.009427271783351898, -0.030918976292014122, -0.011727147735655308, -0.05418463796377182, 0.025754094123840332, 0.006849880795925856, 0.004131966736167669, 0.038476306945085526, -0.009478036314249039, 0.03609713912010193, 0.00949111022055149, 0.05117485299706459, -0.04091978818178177, -0.07914119958877563, -0.042724721133708954, -0.022828483954072, -0.017425483092665672, -0.0037637557834386826, -0.012615283951163292, -0.03607017919421196, 0.0033711197320371866, -0.041621722280979156, 0.03477328643202782, -0.022167131304740906, 0.059340402483940125, 0.007283153012394905, 0.02121083065867424, 0.01611255668103695, 0.04059375822544098, 0.0021600257605314255, -0.0007469196571037173, 0.14461345970630646, 0.07000955939292908, 0.04819686338305473, -0.04835506156086922, 0.04392709583044052, 0.0204933974891901, -0.01159587875008583, 0.00018617183377500623, 0.022217733785510063, -0.005334294866770506, 0.009813733398914337, 0.020573480054736137, 0.06098837032914162, -0.023424433544278145, 0.023934245109558105, 0.0552210658788681, -0.002874140627682209, -0.013184708543121815, 0.00399828189983964, -0.024212345480918884, 0.004699117038398981, -0.018222341313958168, -0.014681326225399971, -0.004582018591463566, 0.02635495364665985, -0.03594326600432396, -0.026930805295705795, -0.03805967792868614, 0.03272644057869911, 0.024388454854488373, -0.007959744893014431, -0.004021927248686552, 0.002487393096089363, 0.02213822491466999, 0.03575073555111885, -0.0541972890496254, -0.023418758064508438, -0.019136566668748856, -0.004113704897463322, 0.05751738324761391, 0.010418851859867573, -0.012465167790651321, -0.027311822399497032, -0.013462688773870468, -0.03746990114450455, -0.026858869940042496, -0.019243130460381508, 0.02046121098101139, -0.03636517748236656, -0.0028029894456267357, 0.034256309270858765, -0.012005842290818691, -0.005521585699170828, -0.014743088744580746, -0.05150258168578148, -0.0005488311289809644, 0.03510352224111557, -0.004562764428555965, -0.011341935954988003, -0.03960965573787689, 0.011691498570144176, -0.005345318466424942, 0.015100877732038498, -0.019657278433442116, -0.008599711582064629, -0.002064415020868182, -0.059285108000040054, 0.022350525483489037, 0.007328635547310114, 0.03264443203806877, 0.023426475003361702, -0.044300515204668045, -0.005375992972403765, 0.005675516556948423, 0.009622449055314064, 0.018186569213867188, 0.019309695810079575, -0.02882642112672329, -0.014836729504168034, -0.06197687238454819, -0.0433700829744339, 0.019742349162697792, 0.0066491831094026566, -0.02817310392856598, -0.06177419424057007, -0.0006961351027712226, 0.0011589467758312821, 0.056695252656936646, 0.02439960092306137, 0.02361341193318367, 0.011694565415382385, 0.04243632033467293, 0.006883176974952221, -0.026303019374608994, 0.008064906112849712, -0.013727767392992973, -0.02688348852097988, 0.010203560814261436, -0.006617676001042128, 0.06934520602226257, 0.018703008070588112, 0.02743430994451046, -0.016149230301380157, -0.005487901624292135, 0.0015236883191391826, 0.022665806114673615, -0.0016092890873551369, -0.0545731820166111, -0.004756977315992117, -0.005931610707193613, 0.02051537297666073, -0.0021859449334442616, -0.00002419735938019585, -0.033947303891181946, -0.05272761732339859, 0.02363627403974533, -0.021384380757808685, -0.019506555050611496, 0.00852790754288435, -0.004417732823640108, 0.000802991446107626, -0.04072887822985649, -0.0060381474904716015, -0.045038506388664246, -0.012695364654064178, -0.010525256395339966, 0.0085319047793746, -0.019167043268680573, -0.0031995319295674562, -0.02611989714205265, 0.007047737017273903, 0.04241757094860077, 0.01120628509670496, -0.013819918036460876, -0.025068610906600952, 0.029224323108792305, 0.015295742079615593, 0.0547122023999691, 0.022774163633584976, 0.006196118425577879, 0.013337819837033749, -0.0465230792760849, -0.031071478500962257, -0.005128567572683096, 0.04803752899169922, 0.041205067187547684, 0.01673990488052368, -0.0012973687844350934, -0.01719885878264904, 0.03277925029397011, -0.041480902582407, -0.03379322960972786, -0.039140358567237854, -0.01447996310889721, 0.020874973386526108, 0.018788840621709824, -0.0431768037378788, 0.008594040758907795, -0.02061331830918789, 0.029537931084632874, 0.02552325464785099, 0.027970118448138237, -0.021603694185614586, -0.0011487338924780488, -0.002475763438269496, 0.03772537782788277, 0.026651542633771896, 0.0059129330329597, 0.033787474036216736, 0.03290499374270439, 0.0258577149361372, 0.042834747582674026, 0.00916059035807848, -0.01490730419754982, -0.07768520712852478, -0.01824835129082203, -0.005711382254958153, 0.013145319186151028, 0.007920322008430958, -0.040538888424634933, 0.002188662765547633, 0.02828587405383587, -0.04269322007894516, -0.025157755240797997, -0.05664396286010742, 0.01690635271370411, -0.056234996765851974, 0.01823544315993786, -0.059740953147411346, 0.02107103168964386, 0.011414360255002975, 0.044641587883234024, 0.04582863673567772, 0.00835722777992487, -0.014796074479818344, -0.02311612293124199, -0.031777314841747284, -0.026762977242469788, 0.061234958469867706, -0.05450639873743057, 0.06653108447790146, -0.04968331754207611, -0.009119818918406963, 0.02405734173953533, -0.012372254393994808, 0.014933155849575996, 0.07366383075714111, 0.0474051907658577, 0.03404222056269646, -0.0004566519637592137, 0.023449374362826347, 0.015582806430757046, -0.023684516549110413, 0.013149687089025974, 0.0024646937381476164, 0.010439813137054443, -0.0409180112183094, -0.024644481018185616, -0.010649602860212326, -0.04767569527029991, 0.0033754545729607344, 0.03078394941985607, -0.04671476408839226, -0.0021945261396467686, -0.04603007808327675, -0.030540859326720238, -0.0008137259865179658, -0.023715294897556305, 0.015575924888253212, -0.035731710493564606, -0.014881609939038754, 0.05466616526246071, 0.023628143593668938, -0.023666013032197952, 0.03488772362470627, -0.005263317842036486, -0.03376488760113716, -0.0006716391653753817, -0.020588409155607224, -0.00446537509560585, 0.03513243421912193, -0.012839754112064838, 0.014602231793105602, -0.008095884695649147, -0.019349025562405586, -0.013965219259262085, -0.03484448418021202, 0.04546736180782318, -0.05249256268143654, 0.014916508458554745, -0.000980780110694468, -0.003476726822555065, 0.007598765194416046, -0.04366600513458252, 0.07207450270652771, -0.0006298392545431852, -0.010266282595694065, -0.013809743337333202, -0.006414860486984253, -0.021939942613244057, 0.027473989874124527, 0.05360918864607811, -0.01615692675113678, 0.02038392424583435, 0.00393751822412014, 0.02682165615260601, 0.015628160908818245, -0.0205815639346838, 0.018661482259631157, 0.022927548736333847, -0.0100600216537714, -0.0074484762735664845, 0.015900811180472374, 0.017821475863456726, -0.01758315972983837, 0.038060512393713, -0.04541226103901863, -0.013713494874536991, 0.04595145583152771, -0.04434755817055702, 0.0038350028917193413, -0.007379018701612949, -0.004266808275133371, 0.025585737079381943, -0.014027012512087822, -0.0023244426120072603, 0.05574202910065651, 0.0157130379229784, -0.05490623414516449, 0.022500064224004745, -0.020010825246572495, -0.031366199254989624, 0.028943218290805817, -0.012092003598809242, -0.05218195915222168, -0.05339779704809189, -0.024562783539295197, 0.013216235674917698, -0.04034896939992905, 0.021924613043665886, 0.03257337585091591, -0.011448894627392292, 0.05484879016876221, -0.024050412699580193, 0.0238625630736351, 0.0010354118421673775, -0.04616222158074379, 0.04822864010930061, 0.007857222110033035, 0.009458910673856735, -0.02954125963151455, 0.003999881912022829, 0.005999866873025894, -0.015362025238573551, 0.03610939532518387, -0.0033967390190809965, 0.00767317321151495, -0.038710348308086395, -0.04075624793767929, 0.0015046068001538515, -0.010370480827987194, 0.01538342610001564, -0.0060793133452534676, -0.026187986135482788, 0.0505940280854702, -0.0323081910610199, 0.012932018376886845, -0.04413903132081032, -0.034345291554927826, -0.03617468848824501, 0.0035436544567346573, 0.016977228224277496, 0.05379937216639519, 0.04506946727633476, -0.002145831473171711, -0.042715251445770264, -0.03260579705238342, 0.029821226373314857, -0.021954035386443138, 0.03278205543756485, -0.02891589142382145, -0.018205733969807625, -0.013222724199295044, -0.059044718742370605, 0.0013725108001381159, -0.05301779508590698, 0.02781582809984684, 0.008911782875657082, 0.03976108133792877, -0.05999573692679405, -0.024221712723374367, 0.01636236347258091, 0.052974142134189606, -0.013220238499343395, -0.046227484941482544, -0.026521848514676094, 0.0036215560976415873, 0.03579220175743103, -0.01313916314393282 ]
<p>I have used Kendall's tau to examine whether there is a correlation between a number categorical variables, as I have a small sample. However, I also want to test whether some variables might have an confounding effect on some of the relationships. Unfortunately, with SPSS you can only use partial correlation using Pearson. </p> <p>I was wondering whether it make sense to use Pearson to examine the effect of confounding variables? If not, what would you suggest?</p> <p>Thanks </p>
74,169
[ -0.03458043560385704, -0.015534146688878536, 0.027207329869270325, -0.0001581953401910141, 0.03387756273150444, 0.022386908531188965, 0.033367715775966644, -0.004796275869011879, 0.019415754824876785, -0.022416217252612114, 0.01653197780251503, 0.056105807423591614, 0.026920245960354805, 0.05344916880130768, -0.011350549757480621, 0.016367003321647644, -0.01360362395644188, -0.00542585039511323, -0.022158576175570488, 0.00561505788937211, -0.02213348262012005, 0.03001304343342781, -0.005346201825886965, 0.010769731365144253, -0.020951582118868828, 0.05787607654929161, -0.002939588390290737, -0.059692706912755966, 0.047246355563402176, 0.033140819519758224, -0.022832170128822327, -0.011670452542603016, 0.00792077835649252, 0.038772404193878174, 0.00388744636438787, -0.0011411196319386363, -0.03485801815986633, -0.002785751596093178, -0.010931928642094135, 0.029083900153636932, -0.03989110887050629, -0.02885737270116806, -0.003510759910568595, 0.026178507134318352, 0.0040676225908100605, 0.03062651865184307, 0.013640998862683773, 0.0018813246861100197, 0.003119851229712367, -0.04667816311120987, 0.04747936502099037, 0.024976208806037903, 0.01772497035562992, 0.06405453383922577, -0.01803271658718586, 0.006767009384930134, 0.04600225389003754, 0.04924445226788521, -0.02776973508298397, -0.06748443841934204, 0.01355358213186264, -0.04269352927803993, 0.019012201577425003, -0.041615020483732224, -0.026274260133504868, 0.0455896258354187, 0.01467058714479208, -0.005088076461106539, 0.041846465319395065, -0.006561238784343004, 0.03277766704559326, 0.02912232093513012, 0.04108696058392525, -0.00427438085898757, -0.02840868942439556, -0.05277087911963463, 0.03092041239142418, 0.0214522797614336, 0.06178441271185875, 0.0338539220392704, 0.006407867651432753, -0.006227869540452957, 0.025412892922759056, 0.03796888515353203, 0.015520683489739895, 0.002545192837715149, 0.04596204683184624, -0.03383675962686539, -0.0214109905064106, 0.031977277249097824, -0.0375857874751091, -0.0025001573376357555, 0.035449620336294174, 0.04094597324728966, -0.0262792706489563, 0.01428441982716322, -0.040525227785110474, 0.05038423463702202, 0.00859750434756279, 0.0376204289495945, -0.007981613278388977, -0.011548537760972977, 0.02021818235516548, 0.03061230480670929, -0.012165272608399391, 0.014957167208194733, -0.014936345629394054, 0.012480517849326134, 0.008376367390155792, -0.044616591185331345, -0.035317856818437576, -0.004316811449825764, -0.006375834811478853, -0.005415067076683044, 0.04498539865016937, -0.02655124105513096, -0.026664886623620987, -0.007190381176769733, 0.053497642278671265, 0.08527511358261108, 0.03933905437588692, -0.053622424602508545, 0.013473059982061386, -0.02491377480328083, -0.03812570124864578, 0.04127093777060509, 0.017782455310225487, -0.045480139553546906, -0.011001212522387505, 0.06050635501742363, 0.005786248482763767, -0.01503189280629158, 0.012525607831776142, -0.009634963236749172, 0.05561668053269386, 0.00997932255268097, -0.05823519453406334, -0.06013839691877365, 0.033227723091840744, 0.0027575157582759857, -0.001535602379590273, -0.02690841071307659, -0.006610641721636057, 0.026908544823527336, 0.06461947411298752, -0.00868999119848013, 0.055645573884248734, -0.018070511519908905, 0.02690272592008114, 0.020891278982162476, -0.05965787544846535, -0.05824744701385498, -0.0038165170699357986, -0.01787795126438141, 0.0001714799291221425, -0.11377037316560745, 0.0024775087367743254, 0.023883868008852005, 0.015864090994000435, -0.006559350993484259, 0.06989135593175888, -0.002044311258941889, -0.020984601229429245, 0.0025457008741796017, -0.008281596004962921, -0.02026877924799919, 0.03400493785738945, -0.016933152452111244, 0.031390558928251266, 0.005229010246694088, 0.008943195454776287, 0.026379123330116272, 0.04480249434709549, 0.03316449373960495, 0.017184628173708916, -0.0349159799516201, -0.004664860665798187, -0.00758498627692461, 0.02145019732415676, -0.02143736183643341, -0.05074969306588173, -0.011590317822992802, -0.05760834738612175, 0.018649833276867867, 0.01996452361345291, 0.06013556569814682, 0.00004807162986253388, -0.01758815348148346, 0.039893150329589844, -0.041494470089673996, -0.10006897151470184, -0.05516006797552109, 0.023219125345349312, -0.05246691778302193, -0.04779241234064102, 0.024600517004728317, 0.00955640897154808, 0.01796163246035576, -0.008756847120821476, 0.026972223073244095, -0.03592238575220108, 0.006218538619577885, 0.019916344434022903, -0.04925910010933876, 0.03965706005692482, 0.03208252787590027, 0.04383392632007599, -0.04159776493906975, 0.009582229889929295, -0.05739607289433479, -0.0621599443256855, 0.0351853184401989, -0.01398675236850977, 0.0221388041973114, -0.013620595447719097, -0.027475062757730484, 0.02029567025601864, -0.003431300399824977, -0.04336357116699219, 0.025677712634205818, -0.042121343314647675, 0.09584244340658188, 0.0574960820376873, 0.01828436739742756, 0.021243898198008537, 0.00122601178009063, 0.049566563218832016, -0.024352842941880226, -0.00011295308650005609, 0.010208459571003914, -0.0346841998398304, 0.002703731879591942, 0.03732758387923241, -0.017536301165819168, -0.06089549884200096, 0.014584274031221867, 0.050640422850847244, -0.004712889902293682, -0.026861118152737617, -0.001347320037893951, -0.001345378695987165, -0.006202020216733217, -0.03369423374533653, 0.03643504157662392, 0.015671413391828537, -0.012220307253301144, 0.019161606207489967, 0.0077078440226614475, 0.04988596960902214, -0.006094569340348244, -0.02965041995048523, 0.027418216690421104, 0.006258146837353706, 0.04791912063956261, 0.006406839471310377, -0.044741515070199966, 0.026404574513435364, -0.04078591614961624, 0.009842785075306892, 0.01513089518994093, -0.020446937531232834, 0.013920620083808899, 0.017009345814585686, -0.0541277714073658, 0.01660751923918724, 0.015508209355175495, -0.025939414277672768, 0.006392560433596373, 0.00905595812946558, -0.02513849176466465, 0.0019232822814956307, -0.0026989879552274942, -0.04286373779177666, -0.045068852603435516, 0.042543355375528336, 0.04739611595869064, -0.004380527418106794, 0.052728429436683655, -0.006596283987164497, -0.01024708990007639, -0.023697342723608017, -0.016063392162322998, -0.0056260135024785995, 0.01564701832830906, -0.09578364342451096, -0.04214504361152649, -0.004428294952958822, -0.014081921428442001, 0.010327880270779133, -0.05664914473891258, -0.005086092744022608, 0.019016651436686516, -0.0046052937395870686, -0.023350773379206657, -0.02742995135486126, 0.007226599846035242, -0.03181298449635506, -0.014455911703407764, -0.016613656654953957, 0.006351349875330925, 0.01931719109416008, -0.053284935653209686, 0.0026285615749657154, -0.02721901796758175, -0.029994526877999306, 0.013100390322506428, -0.014995791018009186, 0.008262909017503262, -0.012887663207948208, -0.014104665257036686, -0.009262926876544952, -0.045164234936237335, -0.008041995577514172, -0.05053306370973587, -0.04568189010024071, 0.049970369786024094, 0.03850901126861572, 0.05026532709598541, -0.02293423004448414, -0.019259244203567505, 0.07035569101572037, 0.022376546636223793, -0.009629893116652966, -0.0553094707429409, -0.023935625329613686, -0.03714526817202568, -0.022729739546775818, 0.044701192528009415, -0.013599825091660023, -0.00873799342662096, 0.004061352461576462, -0.014790129847824574, 0.014552929438650608, 0.05271071940660477, 0.02789491042494774, 0.021846866235136986, 0.006724017672240734, -0.008683298714458942, -0.028926463797688484, 0.015078449621796608, 0.017399678006768227, -0.053289350122213364, 0.008731618523597717, -0.005078739486634731, 0.035062771290540695, -0.016071083024144173, -0.023341909050941467, -0.004193590953946114, -0.026283377781510353, 0.0016609110170975327, -0.03165717422962189, 0.014096866361796856, 0.008543822914361954, -0.011692178435623646, -0.009416291490197182, 0.04731881991028786, 0.016243020072579384, -0.03730851784348488, 0.012421066872775555, 0.07750115543603897, 0.0558723509311676, -0.01638760231435299, -0.023210905492305756, -0.020344920456409454, -0.018026556819677353, 0.045226287096738815, -0.02736838161945343, -0.01689482294023037, 0.06136569380760193, 0.056276749819517136, 0.05225982517004013, 0.0071649858728051186, -0.03355163708329201, 0.015327372588217258, -0.06309474259614944, 0.0038755564019083977, -0.047042135149240494, 0.058265309780836105, 0.03261232748627663, 0.0474393367767334, 0.026797879487276077, -0.044387295842170715, -0.01850701868534088, 0.05034840852022171, -0.06037665531039238, 0.01897219941020012, 0.010877357795834541, -0.022862473502755165, 0.03953240439295769, -0.025388658046722412, 0.015255840495228767, -0.02348656766116619, 0.0072507127188146114, -0.005983153358101845, 0.012462942861020565, -0.012614130042493343, 0.013930696994066238, -0.022733327001333237, -0.011327299289405346, 0.011050346307456493, 0.02236049622297287, -0.005808200687170029, -0.0052925581112504005, 0.032997485250234604, 0.02030661702156067, -0.035192180424928665, -0.012970122508704662, -0.016982661560177803, 0.00981480348855257, 0.02755136974155903, 0.04816990718245506, 0.0012816194212064147, 0.002290846314281225, -0.02181520313024521, 0.0366780124604702, -0.006154950708150864, 0.037082161754369736, 0.034519340842962265, -0.03159191831946373, -0.013086630031466484, 0.00543590122833848, 0.0018914614338427782, -0.037909433245658875, 0.030126579105854034, 0.0038267956115305424, -0.016109691932797432, 0.053214021027088165, 0.025974931195378304, -0.07240647822618484, -0.0035391368437558413, 0.04056622460484505, 0.042077019810676575, -0.013245467096567154, -0.024483835324645042, -0.014531484805047512, -0.023086443543434143, -0.008700788021087646, 0.030427847057580948, 0.05396014824509621, -0.015498293563723564, 0.014635791070759296, 0.05100977048277855, -0.021614892408251762, -0.04521577060222626, 0.0011726133525371552, 0.008061709813773632, 0.01723424717783928, -0.0022041117772459984, -0.04645892605185509, 0.05012047663331032, 0.041675809770822525, 0.002112245885655284, 0.023826511576771736, 0.017643583938479424, -0.07564050704240799, 0.004334313329309225, 0.08855866640806198, 0.07150189578533173, -0.03076324239373207, -0.005530593916773796, -0.009271792136132717, -0.01697533205151558, 0.07045713812112808, -0.061792001128196716, 0.013652697205543518, -0.025036446750164032, 0.037593256682157516, -0.025089986622333527, -0.03918665647506714, -0.03250786289572716, 0.03368527814745903, -0.005661459639668465, 0.02783525362610817, 0.010608674958348274, -0.010562573559582233, -0.028541937470436096, 0.006109342910349369, 0.011138017289340496, 0.03809164837002754, 0.0116024324670434, -0.0453157015144825, 0.0015507001662626863, 0.015643233433365822, 0.01287231408059597, -0.04490528255701065, 0.016302263364195824, -0.02285471186041832, -0.01721939444541931, 0.026577409356832504, -0.0007117119967006147, -0.0267951637506485, -0.005049506668001413, -0.010109981521964073, -0.019139885902404785, -0.012262269854545593, -0.020000221207737923, 0.05001140758395195, 0.00939567107707262, 0.009147361852228642, 0.03277803584933281, 0.06096165254712105, 0.0003290853346697986, -0.0071235536597669125, -0.020555680617690086, 0.016610806807875633, -0.008027714677155018, -0.002990728709846735, -0.01953003741800785, -0.04751157388091087, -0.005855751223862171, 0.03996145725250244, 0.005542962811887264, 0.033872269093990326, -0.01635357365012169, 0.019494391977787018, 0.015226522460579872, 0.02754065953195095, -0.00907254870980978, 0.004065238405019045, 0.01292228139936924, -0.027781087905168533, 0.024344732984900475, -0.02531471475958824, 0.03139277920126915, 0.001676789135672152, -0.011725619435310364, -0.019336018711328506, -0.03949788585305214, 0.03341122344136238, -0.018558688461780548, -0.010332100093364716, -0.014403768815100193, -0.002668574685230851, 0.017141928896307945, -0.0033357194624841213, 0.0292598158121109, -0.02288184128701687, -0.05378224328160286, 0.005463704001158476, 0.05175819247961044, -0.02910441905260086, 0.045557670295238495, -0.02231629565358162, 0.06458692997694016, -0.020142994821071625, -0.01113928109407425, -0.04828524589538574, -0.04997331649065018, 0.004069163464009762, -0.0042433179914951324, 0.005119084380567074, -0.006329317111521959, 0.009622679091989994, -0.021584121510386467, -0.017959097400307655, -0.02162868343293667, 0.05584758520126343, -0.023847848176956177, -0.007727158721536398, -0.023510878905653954, -0.025434652343392372, 0.025553852319717407, 0.0034355707466602325, -0.012587537057697773, 0.02123456820845604, -0.03300190344452858, -0.008911983110010624, 0.004451083485037088, -0.016297144815325737, -0.001367094344459474, -0.026720771566033363, -0.040431320667266846, -0.01497285533696413, 0.031534526497125626, 0.006950249895453453, -0.010092661716043949, -0.0024980255402624607, -0.020320868119597435, 0.010407923720777035, -0.04112871736288071, 0.00025547962286509573, 0.008699147962033749, -0.01438902411609888, -0.01579248532652855, -0.009506016969680786, -0.02766234055161476, -0.0029672840610146523, 0.018543362617492676, 0.009099764749407768, -0.07029116153717041, 0.01284938957542181, 0.07632362842559814, 0.01949969492852688, 0.03219578415155411, -0.03246702626347542, -0.012888099066913128, 0.006422983482480049, 0.03975474461913109, -0.008891253732144833, 0.013876969926059246, 0.02862396091222763, 0.0016982158413156867, 0.005349314771592617, -0.013053828850388527, -0.033272601664066315, 0.08716981112957001, 0.01237704697996378, 0.038781650364398956, 0.06157022342085838, -0.008731731213629246, -0.012431753799319267, -0.006228344049304724, 0.00750625878572464, -0.008915229700505733, 0.017188414931297302, 0.030579490587115288, -0.017349116504192352, 0.03702911362051964, 0.02608536183834076, 0.03342052549123764, -0.0010169829474762082, 0.02992735244333744, 0.012601192109286785, 0.049139562994241714, 0.038996629416942596, -0.010954644531011581, -0.06094241887331009, 0.015245173126459122, -0.06964185833930969, -0.00029071615426801145, -0.03776918724179268, -0.032496463507413864, 0.01610998436808586, 0.019014090299606323, -0.027968550100922585, -0.047907505184412, -0.03542356565594673, -0.018667621538043022, 0.02155601792037487, -0.01782781444489956, -0.03816878795623779, 0.01494636945426464, -0.006478452123701572, 0.06507178395986557, 0.006214219611138105, 0.027213428169488907, -0.050699613988399506, -0.09803406149148941, -0.03853602707386017, -0.004248964134603739, 0.005324311554431915, 0.008897933177649975, -0.025763755664229393, -0.02882763370871544, 0.029328234493732452, -0.04767205938696861, 0.009120721369981766, -0.02181611768901348, 0.011418268084526062, -0.008764035999774933, 0.04122277349233627, -0.006338789593428373, 0.005497089121490717, 0.032918207347393036, 0.0016800694866105914, 0.10488136112689972, 0.011040273122489452, 0.029865136370062828, -0.06933266669511795, 0.010336100123822689, -0.00674391258507967, 0.006703601684421301, -0.032724786549806595, 0.014333570376038551, -0.022495634853839874, -0.04262009635567665, 0.045862242579460144, 0.055143311619758606, 0.048046138137578964, -0.01649983786046505, 0.09278719872236252, -0.025806015357375145, -0.027141470462083817, -0.003827638691291213, 0.0006063553737476468, -0.003385412273928523, -0.054988961666822433, -0.005000128410756588, -0.020687095820903778, -0.007461452390998602, 0.018702786415815353, -0.04834451153874397, 0.00984917301684618, -0.01914912648499012, 0.01956978067755699, -0.03855667635798454, 0.02388099581003189, 0.03372347727417946, 0.01889999583363533, -0.034854788333177567, -0.017658134922385216, 0.023495713248848915, -0.05401083827018738, 0.004514551255851984, -0.004412768874317408, -0.02904803864657879, -0.0030234684236347675, 0.01880020648241043, 0.007321386598050594, -0.04485985264182091, 0.014363567344844341, -0.032395295798778534, 0.03015175648033619, 0.014865931123495102, -0.0038597502280026674, -0.023099875077605247, 0.01680126041173935, 0.012810003943741322, -0.009196581318974495, -0.026760701090097427, -0.0025558590423315763, 0.023144396021962166, -0.043038416653871536, 0.005307035520672798, -0.029907412827014923, -0.015635231509804726, -0.017442507669329643, 0.05532536655664444, 0.043427322059869766, -0.028124749660491943, 0.005769185721874237, -0.02110530622303486, 0.045063525438308716, 0.03345269709825516, -0.022212088108062744, 0.008828860707581043, 0.021290570497512817, -0.035310257226228714, 0.0027376655489206314, 0.012043370865285397, 0.016964610666036606, 0.048664793372154236, -0.014143260195851326, 0.015373393893241882, -0.03985112905502319, -0.035017553716897964, 0.018984641879796982, -0.013973499648272991, -0.0097670191898942, -0.07658451795578003, 0.009687860496342182, 0.025918150320649147, 0.03124787099659443, -0.001943719806149602, -0.00819709338247776, -0.008195683360099792, 0.04155923053622246, 0.03278560936450958, -0.03052545338869095, -0.04362734034657478, -0.009702724404633045, -0.0022306281607598066, 0.007520228158682585, -0.03724215552210808, 0.03758532553911209, 0.0247893538326025, 0.037813976407051086, -0.005514245945960283, 0.02541298419237137, -0.0061316280625760555, 0.013208921998739243, 0.00019754210370592773, -0.05730583891272545, -0.01002954039722681, 0.00021641833882313222, 0.013784325681626797, -0.02936619147658348, -0.012750680558383465, -0.05654730647802353, 0.001688784104771912, 0.009187323041260242, -0.026286238804459572, -0.03455212712287903, 0.0007416133303195238, 0.01757640205323696, 0.020800117403268814, -0.025023354217410088, 0.009965553879737854, -0.10301916301250458, -0.023564327508211136, -0.00573380384594202, 0.015229647979140282, 0.004847888834774494, 0.03298332169651985, -0.030434515327215195, 0.05084012821316719, 0.060587428510189056, 0.013712202198803425, -0.0077852592803537846, -0.019074691459536552, 0.012473882175981998, 0.021036475896835327, 0.07922156155109406, -0.009594550356268883, 0.00631334725767374, 0.027362067252397537, -0.027275240048766136, 0.010568022727966309, 0.0021613717544823885, -0.014380993321537971, 0.019887233152985573, 0.015311799012124538, 0.0258778128772974, -0.032582830637693405, 0.03785840794444084, 0.008430753834545612, -0.009400900453329086, -0.014018873684108257, -0.0013942084042355418, 0.00387615617364645, -0.0043875547125935555, -0.0033749714493751526, 0.005854908376932144, -0.02433209866285324, 0.039701059460639954, 0.0642523542046547, 0.014876271598041058, -0.008880472742021084, 0.014218419790267944, -0.011769965291023254, -0.02377963811159134, -0.005013884976506233, -0.041530318558216095, 0.030986439436674118, 0.03931106999516487, -0.021130597218871117, 0.018172776326537132, 0.03367045149207115, 0.05480559542775154, -0.10726170986890793, -0.03087957203388214, 0.011933539994060993, 0.023749444633722305, 0.02234545908868313, -0.04834285378456116, -0.006071404553949833, 0.024446342140436172, -0.06330271065235138, 0.03695157170295715, 0.005866160616278648, -0.03250473365187645, -0.031020862981677055, 0.0411817841231823, 0.02099081315100193, 0.036173563450574875, 0.02764914184808731, 0.022797752171754837, 0.019570237025618553, 0.018419161438941956, 0.023885220289230347, -0.011334085837006569, -0.01837981306016445, -0.03291434049606323, 0.01933687925338745, -0.052436843514442444, 0.038419514894485474, -0.025145264342427254, -0.05707232654094696, 0.012114891782402992, -0.005368322599679232, 0.042251769453287125, 0.03435584530234337, 0.029680248349905014, -0.012099282816052437, 0.05048372969031334, 0.04651819169521332, -0.03215799853205681, 0.007002020254731178, 0.003561462974175811, 0.003421720815822482, 0.06271486729383469, -0.01392452698200941, 0.024790918454527855, 0.018724238499999046, -0.025151312351226807, -0.03286756947636604, 0.018229104578495026, 0.01986726000905037, -0.0068605574779212475, -0.012505913153290749, -0.009693199768662453, 0.010037795640528202, 0.03399787098169327, 0.031168224290013313, -0.070185586810112, -0.002888692542910576, 0.025534993037581444, 0.02446625381708145, -0.008668887428939342, -0.006141957361251116, -0.019197627902030945, -0.00837939977645874, -0.0016430421965196729, -0.0017493418417870998, 0.03256688639521599, -0.04043044522404671, 0.0032791823614388704, -0.020798327401280403, 0.014208035543560982, -0.03828396275639534, -0.00249471259303391, 0.0024202202912420034, 0.06391437351703644, -0.04562000185251236, 0.005687866825610399, 0.024241425096988678, 0.0051872567273676395, 0.03806507959961891, -0.03458563983440399, 0.022946331650018692, -0.015706432983279228, -0.030061926692724228, -0.035875964909791946, 0.0008205714984796941, -0.061910003423690796, -0.0217929407954216, 0.04155222326517105, -0.04465195909142494, 0.0541028156876564, -0.03583882004022598, 0.0204444769769907, -0.005149641074240208, -0.03513479232788086, 0.01387791894376278, 0.0026646337937563658, -0.024696581065654755, -0.004312340170145035, 0.0064236936159431934, 0.013616310432553291, 0.022436106577515602, -0.007598724216222763, -0.02335589937865734, 0.07728902250528336, 0.006703008897602558, -0.020773792639374733, 0.02178022637963295, 0.00941484048962593, -0.024015193805098534, 0.017653757706284523, -0.009364699013531208, 0.01804996468126774, 0.05822883918881416, -0.012101703323423862, -0.020910387858748436, 0.060846034437417984, -0.016031354665756226, 0.0019886719528585672, 0.014379903674125671, 0.008458216674625874, -0.05753064155578613, -0.035279132425785065, -0.005495521239936352, 0.012887966819107533, -0.0544942207634449, 0.014945794828236103, 0.016597330570220947, 0.02805217169225216, 0.027270564809441566, -0.016691775992512703, 0.0009647024562582374, 0.0229440126568079, -0.04167482629418373, 0.03984460234642029, 0.019595108926296234, 0.01372549682855606, 0.000011242227628827095, 0.003998662810772657, 0.017725223675370216, -0.011865027248859406, 0.0005193643737584352, -0.02662455104291439, -0.0007406945223920047, -0.036238204687833786, -0.01656835898756981, 0.02966589294373989, 0.015500727109611034, 0.05907812714576721, 0.02373555488884449, -0.011781486682593822, 0.0337846502661705, -0.03927496820688248, 0.009674979373812675, -0.02563592419028282, -0.008095604367554188, -0.030942779034376144, 0.000186056291568093, 0.023494845256209373, 0.03433181345462799, 0.010079176165163517, -0.0336853563785553, 0.008851776830852032, -0.042417023330926895, -0.0016218747477978468, -0.0215580016374588, 0.033751148730516434, -0.0505199059844017, 0.003257416421547532, -0.01733064465224743, -0.011066549457609653, 0.001551615190692246, -0.04128626734018326, 0.05143814533948898, 0.06015385314822197, 0.005303435493260622, -0.04037122428417206, -0.0328589528799057, -0.002020458923652768, 0.04467865079641342, -0.029254166409373283, -0.0267306137830019, -0.04056405648589134, 0.008826442062854767, 0.014613589271903038, -0.022699667140841484 ]
<p>I'm having issues forecasting a model of the following form.</p> <pre><code>y1 &lt;- tslm(data_ts~ season+t+I(t^2)+I(t^3)+0) </code></pre> <p>It fits my data very well, but I run into a problem when attempting to do this:</p> <pre><code>forecast(y1,h=72) </code></pre> <p>This is the error that R gives me.</p> <pre><code>"Error in model.frame.default(Terms, newdata, na.action = na.action, xlev = object$xlevels) : variable lengths differ (found for 't') In addition: Warning message: 'newdata' had 72 rows but variables found have 1000 rows" </code></pre> <p>As far as I can tell, this has something do with using <code>tslm</code> and having the cubic function in it. If I just use <code>tslm(data_ds~season+trend)</code> everything works out fine, but I specifically need the model mentioned earlier. How can I forecast my model?</p>
74,170
[ -0.0234699547290802, -0.014600640162825584, 0.03630241006612778, -0.01078229583799839, 0.00340656959451735, -0.009323864243924618, -0.01052995678037405, -0.009886831045150757, 0.04152509197592735, 0.0010269187623634934, 0.0328851081430912, 0.05573480576276779, 0.04389394819736481, 0.060607004910707474, 0.04702996462583542, -0.004945030901581049, 0.008191511034965515, 0.01024905126541853, 0.029835272580385208, -0.004847125615924597, 0.000776691478677094, -0.001678231405094266, -0.009030809625983238, 0.014008675701916218, 0.031108638271689415, 0.057362377643585205, -0.005348826292902231, 0.013937868177890778, 0.01433360856026411, 0.05020769312977791, -0.03282215818762779, -0.03240643069148064, 0.02369876764714718, 0.043386008590459824, 0.027120837941765785, -0.0016188864829018712, -0.010389215312898159, -0.03997345641255379, -0.036622487008571625, 0.012967479415237904, -0.015985488891601562, 0.02901574783027172, 0.0051163602620363235, 0.04521319270133972, -0.04484615847468376, 0.01869991607964039, -0.006690084934234619, -0.01633232831954956, 0.07626379281282425, -0.0243682898581028, 0.09779651463031769, -0.019363926723599434, 0.0680609941482544, 0.03826587647199631, -0.02023989148437977, 0.00131444470025599, 0.07730550318956375, 0.054722100496292114, -0.015268394723534584, -0.05589214339852333, 0.019463924691081047, -0.047700826078653336, -0.014590074308216572, -0.013127542100846767, -0.04572340101003647, 0.010586116462945938, -0.01604057103395462, -0.027296196669340134, 0.02038264274597168, -0.06675589084625244, 0.03041991963982582, 0.0019426108337938786, 0.01887338235974312, -0.002704189857468009, 0.017567530274391174, -0.031329937279224396, 0.019488411024212837, 0.008299249224364758, 0.05900752544403076, 0.03305436670780182, -0.0017406513215973973, 0.04072774574160576, -0.006686769891530275, 0.009835945442318916, 0.025206537917256355, 0.019308723509311676, 0.043783728033304214, -0.027014609426259995, 0.012534617446362972, 0.026741012930870056, -0.0028622448444366455, 0.051048263907432556, 0.08838342875242233, -0.009805249981582165, -0.017863890156149864, 0.050470154732465744, 0.000753383559640497, 0.03563787043094635, 0.0005135521641932428, 0.016773303970694542, -0.014032984152436256, -0.05188269168138504, -0.008625593967735767, 0.0330260805785656, -0.019650660455226898, -0.002447189297527075, -0.02831527777016163, -0.02386803925037384, -0.022433249279856682, -0.04393785819411278, -0.00009181464702123776, 0.0001484374370193109, -0.00681751174852252, -0.01569829136133194, -0.02729411981999874, -0.03262985497713089, -0.03551042079925537, 0.022794146090745926, 0.02055993862450123, 0.041398655623197556, 0.057755306363105774, -0.015376953408122063, 0.05543852224946022, 0.002498733578249812, -0.05054103955626488, 0.01537847425788641, 0.0010867437813431025, -0.003123181639239192, -0.03817158564925194, 0.049421798437833786, 0.009565402753651142, -0.05686353147029877, 0.026021158322691917, -0.02173842489719391, 0.0479954332113266, -0.030162423849105835, -0.09169712662696838, -0.06834416836500168, 0.004258435219526291, -0.010366636328399181, 0.004899176768958569, -0.04196169599890709, 0.018378913402557373, 0.02173854410648346, 0.07937005907297134, 0.004541031550616026, 0.052002839744091034, 0.027504010125994682, 0.03036794625222683, 0.035418879240751266, -0.052403524518013, -0.008527630008757114, 0.0020617861300706863, -0.010090288706123829, 0.0018880076240748167, -0.05596216768026352, -0.00391327403485775, 0.014704633504152298, -0.023863160982728004, 0.003465957473963499, 0.02767476625740528, -0.003790847724303603, -0.00033210415858775377, 0.007783320266753435, -0.004439855460077524, -0.059351734817028046, 0.08223177492618561, -0.007727794349193573, 0.04651877284049988, 0.047379784286022186, -0.012355570681393147, 0.005616570357233286, 0.01950877718627453, 0.057277824729681015, 0.03151429817080498, 0.000745812023524195, 0.009727942757308483, -0.019522137939929962, 0.0024023859295994043, 0.0543268546462059, -0.042794376611709595, -0.0342869870364666, 0.020329030230641365, 0.011354854330420494, 0.03358541056513786, 0.05199060216546059, -0.011174232698976994, -0.004764749202877283, 0.05751512944698334, -0.06404142081737518, -0.03750576078891754, -0.0328771136701107, 0.0025180934462696314, -0.014363846741616726, -0.007230881601572037, -0.0029160398989915848, -0.015618636272847652, 0.040969349443912506, -0.0068372637033462524, -0.02632000856101513, -0.003244432620704174, 0.029063377529382706, 0.051577601581811905, -0.024330750107765198, 0.032093361020088196, 0.036620527505874634, 0.03324686363339424, -0.020847905427217484, 0.02798188291490078, -0.022931337356567383, 0.005621407181024551, 0.017449628561735153, -0.03468075022101402, 0.040107931941747665, -0.0487045980989933, -0.027287324890494347, -0.023655381053686142, -0.0010241776471957564, -0.0026774080470204353, 0.06447888910770416, -0.05117557942867279, 0.046508561819791794, 0.06906571984291077, 0.017402248457074165, 0.012667516246438026, 0.0009460963192395866, 0.012000440619885921, 0.03707762807607651, -0.013640903867781162, 0.015090945176780224, -0.04783331975340843, 0.01546571496874094, 0.06578106433153152, -0.007989170961081982, -0.024436989799141884, 0.006639939732849598, 0.054967593401670456, -0.024472858756780624, 0.03957366943359375, 0.08252573758363724, -0.022003257647156715, 0.023842625319957733, -0.0037572316359728575, 0.02035033330321312, 0.03937144577503204, -0.0006105061620473862, 0.03218196704983711, -0.02477726899087429, 0.03170161694288254, -0.013225863687694073, -0.043090369552373886, 0.03268782049417496, 0.0037951860576868057, 0.03404881805181503, -0.013558604754507542, -0.022400258108973503, 0.05348484590649605, -0.021792801097035408, -0.0347670279443264, 0.04452892765402794, 0.02510036714375019, 0.009883797727525234, -0.005985009018331766, -0.0005362443043850362, 0.0031604596879333258, 0.07371832430362701, -0.027234120294451714, -0.004136697389185429, 0.01612999476492405, -0.0391588918864727, -0.0023632701486349106, 0.012871787883341312, -0.06409719586372375, -0.0747421383857727, 0.015575641766190529, 0.0073240878991782665, 0.0005339559866115451, 0.022455982863903046, -0.009149188175797462, -0.0313539057970047, 0.007523457054048777, -0.04403853043913841, 0.001692294143140316, -0.03318366780877113, -0.034229058772325516, 0.019954340532422066, -0.005961026065051556, -0.0387691967189312, 0.025172142311930656, -0.005018832627683878, -0.0058874934911727905, 0.017119208350777626, -0.03933979198336601, 0.00047405585064552724, -0.030770529061555862, -0.03257108852267265, 0.014785048551857471, -0.0011480083921924233, -0.02647421881556511, 0.029524633660912514, 0.005854304414242506, -0.061646729707717896, -0.01601269654929638, -0.048307761549949646, -0.011333977803587914, -0.044093914330005646, 0.012827109545469284, -0.010270620696246624, -0.013831255957484245, 0.029713371768593788, 0.015002110041677952, -0.0025804091710597277, 0.02246670052409172, -0.047129642218351364, -0.04849410057067871, 0.007291633635759354, 0.02518525719642639, 0.013686803169548512, 0.01600431650876999, -0.03406217321753502, 0.07058562338352203, 0.02313750796020031, -0.019367024302482605, -0.0621328204870224, -0.014031549915671349, -0.023020824417471886, -0.06472604721784592, 0.04699688032269478, -0.004559360444545746, 0.01334462035447359, 0.008921807631850243, -0.0007120925583876669, 0.028993865475058556, 0.01826750859618187, -0.007779291365295649, -0.03560691699385643, 0.011348411440849304, -0.022214442491531372, -0.01795211061835289, 0.035392437130212784, 0.013181604444980621, 0.014061493799090385, 0.008267436176538467, -0.023455359041690826, -0.01149930153042078, -0.014629879966378212, -0.022169163450598717, -0.010036537423729897, -0.012279480695724487, 0.07026690244674683, -0.027980390936136246, 0.005728638265281916, -0.014423507265746593, -0.0366424024105072, 0.007813150994479656, 0.007648575585335493, 0.03448779881000519, -0.025413023307919502, -0.018651733174920082, 0.031538594514131546, 0.010339008644223213, -0.04383602365851402, 0.03242418169975281, -0.028108129277825356, 0.021305641159415245, 0.014372066594660282, -0.022502761334180832, 0.012797038070857525, 0.07002504914999008, 0.007929894141852856, 0.010528028011322021, 0.04130159318447113, -0.008405347354710102, -0.015595209784805775, -0.055095087736845016, 0.007341109681874514, -0.0013555320911109447, 0.04163495451211929, 0.04707741364836693, 0.01917387545108795, 0.03573274984955788, 0.0034249653108417988, 0.04687377065420151, -0.02359772101044655, -0.038554467260837555, 0.02691839449107647, 0.006711043883115053, -0.030481647700071335, 0.010410229675471783, -0.005893885623663664, -0.016580697149038315, -0.012270487844944, 0.030896442010998726, 0.039418112486600876, -0.014802521094679832, -0.03674190118908882, -0.0008109962800517678, -0.023533867672085762, 0.023094352334737778, -0.045194584876298904, 0.0054064542055130005, 0.020771920680999756, -0.026078902184963226, 0.020937826484441757, 0.022640107199549675, -0.021740928292274475, -0.0348503552377224, -0.022801555693149567, 0.016042113304138184, 0.03680228069424629, 0.007642928045243025, 0.022731510922312737, 0.0023394909221678972, -0.03288275748491287, -0.006257146131247282, 0.008161276578903198, 0.010547257959842682, 0.038571037352085114, 0.03693101182579994, -0.036724064499139786, -0.037296559661626816, 0.01902865432202816, 0.04343891516327858, 0.01097493153065443, 0.024408597499132156, 0.013556307181715965, 0.06244499981403351, 0.006501560099422932, 0.004777517169713974, 0.019101852551102638, 0.05268886685371399, -0.00916910357773304, 0.015555474907159805, -0.00651219766587019, 0.01730748824775219, -0.028743926435709, 0.004540120251476765, 0.01545802503824234, -0.009659879840910435, 0.015447847545146942, -0.026805555447936058, 0.005296456627547741, -0.056373193860054016, -0.033719390630722046, 0.013845915906131268, 0.01889169216156006, 0.047217581421136856, -0.010861771181225777, -0.04739686846733093, 0.01783440262079239, 0.028686441481113434, -0.0035830484703183174, 0.014941268600523472, -0.004578634165227413, -0.10993576794862747, 0.007773339282721281, 0.039133064448833466, 0.030161669477820396, -0.040703557431697845, -0.01950138807296753, -0.04753287136554718, -0.017844341695308685, 0.019000576809048653, -0.04741160571575165, 0.032429780811071396, -0.037474289536476135, -0.003429515054449439, -0.00276676076464355, -0.03695444017648697, -0.056910865008831024, 0.005151126999408007, -0.04277246072888374, 0.049975503236055374, 0.01504451222717762, -0.010709913447499275, -0.014320965856313705, 0.03318511322140694, -0.010559258982539177, 0.0265231654047966, -0.005252000875771046, -0.04386120289564133, -0.006081254221498966, 0.013821044005453587, -0.042076244950294495, -0.025142747908830643, 0.024814356118440628, -0.02938181534409523, -0.01351659931242466, 0.00014744915824849159, 0.001140630804002285, -0.0023034506011754274, 0.0096658980473876, 0.017639102414250374, 0.003351834835484624, -0.015689276158809662, -0.04779128357768059, -0.004178615286946297, 0.01675579883158207, 0.003896278329193592, 0.04260050132870674, 0.028051232919096947, 0.012480680830776691, -0.00009631430293666199, -0.045745767652988434, -0.013749641366302967, 0.019037654623389244, -0.05444244295358658, -0.07565249502658844, -0.00598336523398757, 0.00001560009150125552, 0.03108391910791397, -0.019767824560403824, 0.007762675639241934, -0.0626126378774643, -0.03303691744804382, 0.005941169336438179, 0.05250813066959381, 0.025716861709952354, -0.03422047570347786, 0.007917393930256367, 0.002216178923845291, -0.017207808792591095, -0.008642900735139847, 0.019576406106352806, -0.03742147237062454, 0.012543143704533577, 0.029730718582868576, -0.018587633967399597, 0.019053122028708458, -0.004454987123608589, -0.006188550032675266, -0.014611468650400639, -0.00998030137270689, 0.01600772514939308, -0.001746043679304421, 0.04166858270764351, 0.002239147201180458, -0.03445403277873993, -0.0018028946360573173, 0.011731225997209549, -0.014828050509095192, 0.019234446808695793, -0.059023160487413406, 0.05950315296649933, -0.02301567792892456, -0.008062556385993958, -0.05366447940468788, -0.07446873933076859, 0.020535074174404144, -0.024669157341122627, -0.022420862689614296, -0.0037374498788267374, -0.028616158291697502, -0.027272196486592293, 0.03151167929172516, -0.05863010138273239, 0.04645561799407005, -0.020004956051707268, 0.017366580665111542, -0.0010139670921489596, 0.022038212046027184, 0.05220246687531471, -0.008626759983599186, 0.007900390774011612, 0.018159756436944008, 0.010901367291808128, -0.0225765872746706, -0.0034824085887521505, -0.0025031648110598326, -0.05652766674757004, -0.0076016453094780445, -0.004142775200307369, -0.01706886850297451, 0.041473377496004105, -0.0010445036459714174, 0.001351187820546329, 0.017170727252960205, 0.022613275796175003, 0.013143207877874374, -0.06748564541339874, 0.017780981957912445, -0.010057276114821434, -0.01704738661646843, -0.022201061248779297, -0.005138832610100508, -0.008353241719305515, 0.010106301866471767, -0.015828542411327362, -0.0007432581624016166, 0.020237650722265244, 0.015108348801732063, 0.04953977093100548, -0.0013399310410022736, 0.031742945313453674, -0.020047573372721672, 0.0017981408163905144, 0.023359667509794235, 0.05747140198945999, 0.010408919304609299, -0.008652240969240665, 0.02146131359040737, -0.013160567730665207, -0.016168057918548584, 0.006371472496539354, 0.05758178234100342, 0.062437742948532104, -0.028363917022943497, 0.04097583889961243, 0.03434024751186371, 0.01762840896844864, 0.01965256780385971, -0.05008111894130707, -0.008822170086205006, -0.0017038830555975437, 0.041002724319696426, 0.059013593941926956, 0.002662080805748701, -0.007508371025323868, 0.031296949833631516, 0.006025640293955803, 0.04912973567843437, 0.04111480340361595, -0.023148423060774803, -0.022173715755343437, 0.00650760205462575, -0.01568894274532795, -0.026761893182992935, 0.024492627009749413, -0.014980252832174301, 0.0023926859721541405, -0.0090709263458848, 0.008959004655480385, 0.049633633345365524, 0.018962273374199867, 0.014377142302691936, -0.034950654953718185, -0.023804252967238426, -0.0379626639187336, -0.04523904249072075, 0.04880838841199875, -0.02426903508603573, 0.03720315918326378, 0.015626778826117516, 0.029801607131958008, 0.019915863871574402, 0.026053491979837418, -0.04893830418586731, -0.05653833597898483, -0.013238858431577682, -0.03383246809244156, -0.01788969896733761, 0.03644008934497833, 0.055143292993307114, 0.011924018152058125, -0.04628228023648262, -0.03592240810394287, 0.015619050711393356, 0.011444130912423134, 0.035881102085113525, 0.0446489192545414, 0.04383545741438866, -0.008673500269651413, -0.0036008269526064396, -0.018995195627212524, 0.035953689366579056, 0.12571296095848083, 0.07706723362207413, 0.06987009942531586, -0.0467333048582077, 0.03496827185153961, 0.009373145177960396, 0.005160801112651825, -0.03881985694169998, -0.025570526719093323, 0.006139727309346199, -0.010070791468024254, 0.05264642462134361, 0.038045287132263184, -0.02551141194999218, 0.00485834339633584, 0.01723277010023594, -0.050538502633571625, -0.012110140174627304, 0.0258216243237257, -0.019706016406416893, 0.003688798053190112, -0.032833654433488846, -0.06651297211647034, 0.02314404398202896, -0.027945108711719513, -0.005125638097524643, 0.008993699215352535, -0.002111458219587803, -0.015645207837224007, 0.030910801142454147, -0.02685137838125229, -0.0022389378864318132, -0.000363204104360193, 0.036483339965343475, 0.012954591773450375, -0.0009406174067407846, -0.006774512585252523, -0.027019377797842026, 0.0311872661113739, 0.05570722371339798, 0.010273582302033901, 0.037047628313302994, -0.015378464944660664, -0.0018755828496068716, -0.013750836253166199, -0.02865607663989067, -0.006654812954366207, 0.0248258039355278, -0.0039413743652403355, -0.011467235162854195, -0.00902255717664957, 0.003167537972331047, -0.01731947250664234, -0.0304112546145916, 0.0006614638259634376, 0.0022870958782732487, 0.023112278431653976, -0.0023479603696614504, -0.013116040267050266, -0.016039082780480385, 0.006894209887832403, 0.003377041546627879, 0.0174141563475132, 0.043855976313352585, -0.03982541710138321, 0.010377421975135803, -0.029309989884495735, 0.06145678833127022, -0.01371658593416214, -0.015758566558361053, 0.005055271089076996, -0.017363643273711205, -0.05191614851355553, -0.042742639780044556, 0.021195918321609497, 0.031755562871694565, 0.004134258255362511, -0.021959729492664337, 0.018922701478004456, -0.02806241251528263, -0.05238591134548187, -0.0314103327691555, 0.0026381672360002995, -0.015135277062654495, -0.0002842146495822817, 0.032789912074804306, 0.028045188635587692, 0.014712012372910976, 0.008734184317290783, 0.039786309003829956, -0.0027644620276987553, 0.05908750370144844, -0.00321909599006176, -0.04915241524577141, -0.039355069398880005, 0.014162053354084492, 0.002734029432758689, -0.019951488822698593, 0.003662672359496355, 0.07314836233854294, 0.038215529173612595, 0.03883427754044533, -0.030656995251774788, 0.040144339203834534, -0.010157052427530289, 0.004621665924787521, 0.044847309589385986, -0.04257732629776001, 0.028464870527386665, -0.005059702787548304, -0.008340277709066868, -0.05047408118844032, -0.028905320912599564, -0.04428832605481148, -0.011874713934957981, 0.011029975488781929, -0.038989096879959106, -0.0880529060959816, 0.01832413487136364, 0.0030476090032607317, 0.007151395548135042, -0.011379880830645561, 0.010958991013467312, -0.019139442592859268, -0.010808573104441166, -0.006271268706768751, -0.041687700897455215, -0.026056447997689247, 0.006726591847836971, -0.05541318282485008, -0.014345063827931881, 0.01749458722770214, -0.010023703798651695, 0.004153478890657425, -0.05802301689982414, -0.04116779565811157, 0.0298785287886858, 0.06661926209926605, -0.048384543508291245, 0.005197552498430014, 0.04707687720656395, -0.037967532873153687, -0.0017030604649335146, 0.003376023843884468, -0.00960394088178873, 0.033529363572597504, 0.009329980239272118, 0.0047956472262740135, 0.0031248044688254595, 0.06833788752555847, -0.04947051405906677, 0.031867317855358124, -0.021456405520439148, 0.0027491396758705378, 0.030342521145939827, -0.014396960847079754, 0.010315412655472755, 0.0025678491219878197, -0.011139300651848316, 0.0019398820586502552, 0.07929869741201401, 0.020289776846766472, -0.0106395548209548, -0.03940052166581154, -0.026763085275888443, 0.0010977921774610877, 0.005426943302154541, -0.00436425069347024, 0.05300644412636757, 0.038800518959760666, -0.03156029060482979, 0.018844682723283768, -0.0045277816243469715, 0.051186297088861465, -0.0903511568903923, -0.017142530530691147, -0.005620392505079508, 0.01859411969780922, 0.002972159767523408, -0.058681637048721313, 0.021237166598439217, 0.04739145562052727, -0.027442120015621185, 0.011040294542908669, 0.02240200899541378, 0.0001285567705053836, 0.005271289497613907, 0.027688615024089813, -0.019748670980334282, 0.017584268003702164, 0.07470571994781494, 0.01434052363038063, 0.026677953079342842, -0.002068424830213189, 0.014672142453491688, -0.05147679150104523, -0.004552629776299, 0.024757515639066696, 0.01235794648528099, -0.024984708055853844, 0.013790336437523365, -0.03897584229707718, -0.024647844955325127, 0.014279453083872795, -0.03463888540863991, 0.04253435507416725, 0.011116926558315754, 0.00020395930914673954, 0.025657935068011284, 0.052691128104925156, 0.028801867738366127, -0.004352041985839605, 0.015676798298954964, -0.004425878170877695, 0.024028131738305092, 0.009886449202895164, 0.01185658760368824, 0.024285728111863136, 0.006677759811282158, -0.02511914260685444, -0.0351705364882946, 0.02007078006863594, -0.016810860484838486, 0.001463963882997632, -0.05150008946657181, 0.00023660535225644708, -0.0006110806716606021, -0.06266441941261292, 0.0016963114030659199, 0.014866222627460957, -0.007636220194399357, 0.045558687299489975, 0.016349315643310547, -0.02438480034470558, -0.027777768671512604, -0.007538050413131714, -0.059813618659973145, -0.0042617362923920155, -0.01987321861088276, -0.01161093171685934, -0.04472837224602699, 0.008240447379648685, -0.0027474083472043276, -0.03573600575327873, -0.027584705501794815, 0.0031692194752395153, -0.05233069136738777, 0.08038540184497833, -0.0031149708665907383, 0.010155921801924706, 0.00792468897998333, -0.002612430602312088, 0.023266790434718132, -0.11517190933227539, 0.049748532474040985, -0.025424493476748466, -0.020917246118187904, -0.016497520729899406, -0.0005522894789464772, -0.05013243481516838, -0.01034530345350504, 0.008291743695735931, -0.01754867658019066, 0.04707326367497444, -0.005908957216888666, 0.014161664061248302, -0.030116714537143707, -0.029947394505143166, 0.02083505690097809, 0.021594444289803505, -0.023288872092962265, -0.00005140560824656859, -0.03578362241387367, 0.030892083421349525, -0.01668611913919449, 0.02032068558037281, 0.009536288678646088, 0.03978859633207321, 0.024425281211733818, -0.051448993384838104, 0.01183287613093853, 0.027004333212971687, -0.026500891894102097, 0.022952115163207054, -0.01384397316724062, -0.001030864892527461, 0.025880374014377594, 0.008925840258598328, -0.04618634283542633, -0.009743391536176205, -0.06387487053871155, 0.002223237417638302, 0.020700857043266296, -0.003587648505344987, 0.00885813683271408, -0.04249566048383713, -0.006485050544142723, 0.027332821860909462, -0.009874735958874226, 0.007638305425643921, 0.028337989002466202, 0.0008852910832501948, 0.026884838938713074, -0.027501940727233887, -0.00759924529120326, -0.014666418544948101, 0.009892835281789303, 0.004517081659287214, -0.0057982346042990685, 0.02602231875061989, -0.022013280540704727, 0.014125791378319263, 0.029869651421904564, -0.040722209960222244, 0.017003029584884644, -0.022939879447221756, 0.07614029943943024, 0.002709529595449567, -0.043502774089574814, -0.015115909278392792, -0.005612419452518225, 0.017479319125413895, 0.007978749461472034, -0.041420213878154755, 0.04155251756310463, -0.038155924528837204, -0.010730793699622154, -0.047551173716783524, 0.001764801680110395, -0.00005067695019533858, 0.017562484368681908, -0.032930269837379456, 0.03636862337589264, -0.010644507594406605, 0.029754409566521645, 0.03148628771305084, -0.03188395872712135, 0.001882938900962472, -0.00932465773075819, -0.04037240520119667, -0.05247698351740837, 0.02242281474173069, -0.014818448573350906, 0.006214783061295748, -0.02966514602303505, -0.017477408051490784, 0.026324689388275146, 0.045393213629722595, 0.0018535185372456908, -0.06355102360248566, -0.05067027732729912, 0.023057138547301292, 0.008298470638692379, -0.05184977501630783, -0.024559082463383675, -0.02942616119980812, 0.019977016374468803, -0.02585386112332344, -0.05001075193285942 ]
<p>Can anyone report on their experience with an adaptive kernel density estimator?<br> (There are many synonyms: adaptive | variable | variable-width, KDE | histogram | interpolator ...)</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_kernel_density_estimation" rel="nofollow">Variable kernel density estimation</a> says "we vary the width of the kernel in different regions of the sample space. There are two methods ..." actually, more: neighbors within some radius, KNN nearest neighbors (K usually fixed), Kd trees, multigrid...<br> Of course no single method can do everything, but adaptive methods look attractive.<br> See for example the nice picture of an adaptive 2d mesh in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method" rel="nofollow">Finite element method</a>.</p> <p>I'd like to hear what worked / what didn't work for real data, especially >= 100k scattered data points in 2d or 3d.</p> <p>Added 2 Nov: here's a plot of a "clumpy" density (piecewise x^2 * y^2), a nearest-neighbor estimate, and Gaussian KDE with Scott's factor. While one (1) example doesn't prove anything, it does show that NN can fit sharp hills reasonably well (and, using KD trees, is fast in 2d, 3d ...) <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ulkUd.png" alt="alt text"></p>
74,171
[ -0.03494328632950783, 0.02274322137236595, 0.04070848971605301, -0.02322639897465706, 0.03450847417116165, 0.018271585926413536, 0.009327981621026993, -0.04581127688288689, 0.023037269711494446, -0.06345795094966888, 0.011104125529527664, 0.06728900969028473, 0.09497256577014923, 0.04115729033946991, -0.017548643052577972, -0.037642840296030045, 0.0022906120866537094, -0.015929242596030235, -0.02049800008535385, -0.04750329256057739, -0.010966528207063675, 0.014743645675480366, -0.010048887692391872, -0.05896352231502533, -0.030692463740706444, 0.026243072003126144, -0.0130571648478508, -0.05198344960808754, 0.017227021977305412, 0.062103744596242905, -0.025545749813318253, -0.02936691604554653, 0.014804677106440067, 0.02516883611679077, 0.02047938108444214, -0.002635164652019739, -0.0267329178750515, -0.046983301639556885, -0.01664469763636589, 0.02607523836195469, 0.004413668066263199, -0.028083428740501404, -0.0325469970703125, 0.02231578528881073, -0.008170977234840393, 0.028142200782895088, 0.030658571049571037, -0.07136949896812439, 0.027481835335493088, -0.05033731460571289, 0.07482729852199554, 0.006877682637423277, 0.01207143347710371, 0.043759893625974655, -0.026997078210115433, 0.00709820631891489, 0.0031870834063738585, 0.06989827752113342, -0.0007153306505642831, -0.043942034244537354, 0.009950459934771061, -0.008540150709450245, 0.012489911168813705, 0.015745099633932114, -0.006995480507612228, 0.038619883358478546, 0.011577491648495197, -0.05898172780871391, 0.011261825449764729, -0.019051793962717056, 0.018838146701455116, 0.007099861744791269, 0.059395503252744675, 0.004224469885230064, 0.02244460955262184, -0.011726710945367813, 0.015046428889036179, 0.01201029121875763, 0.03325444459915161, 0.018845099955797195, 0.00027403380954638124, -0.007989577949047089, 0.023574883118271828, -0.020276544615626335, 0.011514423415064812, 0.03622637316584587, 0.0794082060456276, -0.018939893692731857, -0.002257577609270811, 0.04259445518255234, -0.01199162658303976, -0.004677208140492439, 0.0355394147336483, 0.00015691027510911226, -0.022077741101384163, 0.01872711069881916, 0.0052060820162296295, 0.04436873272061348, 0.008343872614204884, -0.0015715755289420485, 0.01304328627884388, -0.015508318319916725, 0.007215081714093685, 0.041336026042699814, -0.01530863344669342, -0.017767632380127907, -0.0289083793759346, -0.006895104888826609, -0.005601635668426752, -0.02789326012134552, -0.04339113086462021, 0.02478272095322609, 0.010435362346470356, -0.023822324350476265, 0.04615599289536476, -0.035002607852220535, 0.006429292261600494, 0.017270579934120178, 0.0176130011677742, 0.09630310535430908, 0.007562938146293163, -0.01178926695138216, 0.01703985407948494, -0.026799742132425308, -0.050798360258340836, 0.02423570305109024, 0.03518626093864441, -0.037246979773044586, -0.045985475182533264, 0.056643638759851456, 0.012650517746806145, 0.0036084172315895557, 0.045880358666181564, -0.04001390188932419, 0.02674768678843975, -0.015515660867094994, -0.046203337609767914, -0.04912780597805977, 0.01487769652158022, 0.016064809635281563, 0.023809488862752914, -0.03764305263757706, -0.007487901486456394, 0.03354518488049507, 0.03339994326233864, -0.0036895836237818003, 0.012859325855970383, -0.019665680825710297, 0.060212280601263046, -0.004553802311420441, -0.07223783433437347, -0.01946074515581131, 0.01656326651573181, -0.004546809941530228, -0.03785298764705658, -0.06641799956560135, 0.045926693826913834, 0.04520178213715553, -0.00036443438148126006, -0.02763466350734234, 0.04436523839831352, 0.030283907428383827, -0.03275839239358902, -0.01611281745135784, -0.006665658205747604, -0.004490320570766926, 0.0629221498966217, 0.03241855651140213, 0.054741259664297104, 0.0001730806689010933, 0.005016029346734285, 0.033475298434495926, 0.022807149216532707, -0.001208554138429463, 0.031131336465477943, -0.03069780394434929, 0.010502409189939499, -0.006579962559044361, 0.033787041902542114, 0.020731721073389053, -0.05251671373844147, -0.006098499521613121, 0.03116803802549839, -0.009596477262675762, 0.007230735383927822, 0.04310056194663048, 0.0069367727264761925, -0.022508906200528145, 0.06685919314622879, -0.03816915303468704, -0.03016253001987934, -0.029959743842482567, 0.007705200929194689, -0.04693904146552086, -0.017426123842597008, 0.03188442066311836, -0.008900715038180351, -0.03167958930134773, -0.01919529400765896, -0.05131072923541069, -0.00940206740051508, 0.010216251015663147, 0.02207931876182556, -0.02794838137924671, -0.01088546309620142, 0.0239704679697752, -0.01922404021024704, -0.03711886703968048, 0.02872302010655403, -0.06414613872766495, -0.020794479176402092, 0.0038462139200419188, -0.026602214202284813, 0.02866467833518982, -0.03662152588367462, -0.0217630285769701, 0.006069031078368425, 0.004491699859499931, -0.010795649141073227, -0.0022123162634670734, -0.0674605444073677, 0.03916887938976288, 0.07596172392368317, 0.015783796086907387, -0.006568079348653555, 0.03954622894525528, -0.0439453050494194, -0.03036418929696083, 0.020542046055197716, -0.01578931324183941, -0.06508300453424454, 0.006363712716847658, 0.06375430524349213, 0.037619322538375854, -0.028908437117934227, 0.00015691698354203254, 0.06262248754501343, 0.01040900219231844, 0.039707403630018234, -0.008865922689437866, -0.02677321992814541, -0.024171076714992523, 0.018232591450214386, 0.02055048756301403, 0.014016471803188324, -0.0026724552735686302, 0.02790297381579876, 0.004483974538743496, 0.02677192911505699, -0.020115172490477562, -0.008935927413403988, 0.03648529201745987, -0.00856216624379158, 0.006559512112289667, 0.009796949103474617, -0.01960516721010208, 0.02205265685915947, -0.04005984589457512, -0.048695094883441925, 0.029474353417754173, -0.008069702424108982, 0.03616687282919884, -0.03414629027247429, -0.017694009467959404, 0.025273669511079788, 0.019445810467004776, -0.030843013897538185, 0.00039235944859683514, 0.016716403886675835, 0.0009610534179955721, -0.005393069703131914, -0.0073158317245543, -0.015550356358289719, -0.05035892501473427, 0.005714897066354752, 0.021749213337898254, 0.04652617499232292, -0.018066853284835815, 0.0022780217695981264, -0.015614276751875877, -0.033422186970710754, -0.003633416024968028, 0.054792024195194244, 0.036511752754449844, -0.039854731410741806, 0.03937224671244621, 0.012681121937930584, 0.003047458827495575, 0.03843078017234802, 0.006481030955910683, -0.008615043014287949, 0.004253411199897528, -0.009298640303313732, -0.041190072894096375, 0.050973352044820786, -0.02811972238123417, 0.02972523309290409, -0.017996467649936676, 0.010926215909421444, 0.04595205560326576, -0.01030659582465887, -0.018328698351979256, 0.0405120775103569, -0.023019377142190933, -0.02951863966882229, -0.05769859254360199, 0.011771881952881813, 0.014943602494895458, -0.0005744528025388718, 0.008944804780185223, 0.060913339257240295, -0.011556529439985752, 0.029063323512673378, -0.0193014033138752, -0.06898678839206696, 0.024444902315735817, -0.044669635593891144, 0.0923791453242302, -0.00982170645147562, 0.0045862626284360886, 0.07684556394815445, 0.01673213206231594, -0.03953413665294647, -0.023803669959306717, -0.006862155627459288, -0.030158359557390213, 0.003336865222081542, 0.03564165532588959, -0.014415434561669827, -0.002478757407516241, 0.0017760958289727569, 0.005874486640095711, 0.027987472712993622, 0.06002425402402878, 0.008574236184358597, -0.019557438790798187, 0.02343468740582466, -0.010721210390329361, -0.010663303546607494, 0.05262371525168419, 0.03590085729956627, -0.01845625601708889, -0.013270133174955845, -0.03772438317537308, -0.05238503962755203, 0.010242351330816746, -0.042122360318899155, 0.010624962858855724, -0.017351655289530754, 0.011059576645493507, -0.04104948416352272, 0.0010729879140853882, 0.005854653660207987, -0.04656282812356949, 0.008180233649909496, 0.031291790306568146, 0.05655287951231003, 0.006326040253043175, -0.032832928001880646, 0.02740682289004326, 0.04947010055184364, -0.0015723276883363724, 0.0052360608242452145, 0.005464169662445784, 0.01066600251942873, 0.03165515512228012, -0.01788780651986599, -0.009692921303212643, 0.028524931520223618, 0.02825341746211052, 0.008410943672060966, -0.017868835479021072, -0.03403957188129425, 0.042988043278455734, -0.07950061559677124, 0.014007057063281536, -0.03757023811340332, 0.05076822265982628, 0.018371885642409325, 0.027007821947336197, 0.04130870848894119, -0.01534727681428194, 0.018015127629041672, -0.008843508549034595, -0.07064981758594513, -0.013467079028487206, -0.018727008253335953, 0.011102589778602123, 0.024126481264829636, -0.033838968724012375, 0.02295825257897377, 0.009851409122347832, 0.01026547234505415, -0.016139980405569077, 0.043569110333919525, -0.040159936994314194, -0.022572478279471397, -0.021563513204455376, -0.02883639559149742, -0.0012220634380355477, 0.010267317295074463, 0.025914272293448448, -0.009889048524200916, 0.024202534928917885, 0.01494990848004818, -0.013428613543510437, -0.02048088237643242, -0.002942184451967478, -0.010277807712554932, 0.002265439834445715, 0.05281030014157295, -0.017712466418743134, 0.030422814190387726, -0.023803800344467163, 0.01866842247545719, 0.0010038651525974274, 0.08286517858505249, 0.03512462228536606, 0.0027254633605480194, 0.007119619753211737, -0.026671534404158592, -0.04990515485405922, -0.01666506752371788, 0.029712693765759468, -0.022472290322184563, 0.007768360432237387, 0.036239512264728546, 0.011147279292345047, -0.040095455944538116, -0.0024439909029752016, 0.03566238656640053, 0.006646376568824053, 0.007820835337042809, -0.044347308576107025, -0.004679874517023563, 0.023696022108197212, 0.014810181222856045, 0.03972387686371803, -0.01932196319103241, 0.00531628867611289, 0.013052806258201599, 0.026616618037223816, -0.022583022713661194, 0.012404684908688068, -0.006330795586109161, 0.03978295996785164, 0.012294317595660686, -0.042748693376779556, 0.011269286274909973, 0.013181392103433609, 0.021620357409119606, 0.051222532987594604, 0.0177009217441082, -0.02285846136510372, -0.07563415169715881, 0.0017062482656911016, 0.059558529406785965, 0.029938355088233948, -0.012571272440254688, 0.024878937751054764, -0.07885553687810898, -0.032116763293743134, 0.053000401705503464, -0.0041528078727424145, 0.013076810166239738, -0.033318668603897095, 0.0076145692728459835, 0.0011941022239625454, -0.011511665768921375, -0.008356545120477676, -0.007075589615851641, -0.019963011145591736, 0.02954881824553013, -0.0179037693887949, -0.026463350281119347, -0.03272998332977295, 0.0825461894273758, 0.004348456393927336, 0.07088617235422134, -0.0034882170148193836, -0.05437063053250313, -0.01827104575932026, -0.0020894117187708616, -0.020526422187685966, -0.05462493374943733, 0.04950188845396042, 0.018624799326062202, 0.0042952969670295715, 0.027138158679008484, -0.025548458099365234, -0.05382867157459259, -0.004216131288558245, -0.0221850723028183, -0.04656277596950531, 0.007683289237320423, 0.012636061757802963, 0.06708121299743652, 0.02332683838903904, 0.0265763308852911, 0.051422372460365295, 0.022869400680065155, 0.005119625013321638, 0.01596939004957676, -0.04891681671142578, 0.007069703657180071, -0.014333999715745449, 0.002039204817265272, -0.05669843778014183, -0.013800917193293571, -0.035946015268564224, -0.007685631047934294, 0.011276100762188435, 0.053898509591817856, -0.05575994774699211, -0.008593549951910973, 0.04773682355880737, 0.025555718690156937, 0.02666311152279377, 0.019347624853253365, 0.01862342096865177, 0.01926274783909321, 0.032154958695173264, -0.02813679166138172, 0.0052054887637495995, 0.016014153137803078, -0.0014282356714829803, 0.030911913141608238, -0.015088094398379326, -0.025037448853254318, -0.058216556906700134, -0.008730982430279255, 0.010681955143809319, -0.02843528613448143, 0.05258505418896675, -0.000898845843039453, 0.06615085899829865, 0.02150404267013073, -0.03089865669608116, 0.02454858087003231, -0.014915022067725658, -0.041486531496047974, 0.08142715692520142, -0.02047010324895382, 0.013567433692514896, -0.00398632837459445, 0.05529089272022247, -0.06031707674264908, -0.03175308555364609, 0.05521473288536072, 0.004050391726195812, -0.026941033080220222, -0.053410548716783524, 0.010995745658874512, -0.013829752802848816, -0.011888593435287476, 0.024025175720453262, 0.05140272527933121, -0.01807074248790741, -0.00717106694355607, 0.015233456157147884, 0.027414493262767792, 0.06903598457574844, 0.0017226497875526547, 0.007262004539370537, 0.022260937839746475, -0.013842267915606499, -0.005595468450337648, 0.0017364178784191608, 0.0006415079697035253, -0.04200384020805359, 0.038969941437244415, -0.024700334295630455, -0.005108691286295652, 0.03941033035516739, -0.006407714448869228, -0.0071856677532196045, 0.04145911708474159, -0.010415924713015556, 0.0010058532934635878, -0.020178698003292084, -0.006076606456190348, -0.05751650035381317, -0.02482420578598976, -0.032172445207834244, -0.009786436334252357, -0.021764663979411125, 0.015410793013870716, 0.0481535904109478, -0.005741740111261606, 0.01751287840306759, -0.006237410940229893, 0.03622596338391304, -0.006611865945160389, -0.019533880054950714, 0.037179358303546906, -0.06692034751176834, 0.03661876171827316, -0.004137283656746149, -0.01156318373978138, 0.028820840641856194, 0.055632397532463074, -0.030701952055096626, -0.030664395540952682, -0.02397555485367775, 0.011395747773349285, 0.03902088850736618, -0.04428108036518097, 0.03393383324146271, 0.031905218958854675, -0.012995904311537743, -0.014787471853196621, -0.019162705168128014, -0.03629239276051521, -0.025254936888813972, -0.04481508210301399, 0.051052115857601166, 0.030658746138215065, 0.014968499541282654, 0.014907152391970158, 0.0048360577784478664, -0.012492761947214603, 0.028886891901493073, -0.037742722779512405, 0.03462674468755722, 0.036769211292266846, -0.02287304401397705, -0.0553741529583931, 0.03838628903031349, -0.011124842800199986, 0.015215557999908924, -0.027705032378435135, -0.05247616022825241, 0.05449165776371956, 0.016864202916622162, -0.014190379530191422, -0.017262643203139305, -0.049651362001895905, -0.03471982479095459, 0.00839715264737606, -0.000289159914245829, -0.024906450882554054, -0.0009720989619381726, -0.0055282930843532085, -0.012360533699393272, 0.023551808670163155, 0.002455640584230423, -0.0429997518658638, -0.0883386954665184, -0.004390804562717676, -0.013070427812635899, -0.055063508450984955, 0.020620988681912422, 0.03626061975955963, -0.05512836575508118, 0.03796900436282158, -0.0024500228464603424, 0.04620826989412308, 0.02666064165532589, 0.01638873480260372, 0.02353503555059433, 0.04418925940990448, -0.019147371873259544, 0.002212841296568513, -0.035691630095243454, -0.051892440766096115, 0.12075314670801163, 0.028264852240681648, 0.0481092594563961, -0.029906602576375008, 0.0007002254715189338, -0.03855763003230095, -0.0023463424295186996, -0.006689762230962515, 0.01784076914191246, 0.005676121450960636, 0.012002956122159958, 0.0335586816072464, 0.041641902178525925, 0.012127470225095749, 0.017558958381414413, 0.06850982457399368, 0.011317822150886059, -0.003300109878182411, 0.006265663541853428, -0.019842062145471573, 0.011820106767117977, 0.0013105613179504871, -0.04791507124900818, 0.03972445800900459, -0.0046849921345710754, 0.010789354331791401, -0.056765805929899216, -0.015175819396972656, 0.02102678269147873, 0.01951834000647068, -0.03919585049152374, 0.015247222036123276, 0.010746324434876442, -0.001165172434411943, 0.007820340804755688, 0.003765582572668791, 0.008636881597340107, -0.028751220554113388, 0.0041730282828211784, 0.03497079387307167, -0.003631113562732935, -0.01579110138118267, -0.005769145209342241, -0.018255993723869324, -0.008439396508038044, -0.03586176037788391, -0.029775556176900864, 0.04161437228322029, 0.023556696251034737, 0.012026169337332249, 0.01734813302755356, 0.016843706369400024, 0.015970299020409584, -0.02507719025015831, -0.01000222098082304, -0.02475634030997753, 0.04673447832465172, 0.010400923900306225, 0.005208888091146946, -0.000987180625088513, 0.018757976591587067, -0.000811122648883611, 0.028001682832837105, 0.03360217809677124, -0.033928900957107544, -0.03832757845520973, -0.022004995495080948, 0.05301303789019585, 0.005007455125451088, -0.02803252823650837, -0.03443419188261032, -0.012191136367619038, -0.014915436506271362, 0.001908469363115728, -0.028612053021788597, 0.008449639193713665, 0.05570653825998306, -0.03537699952721596, -0.03249463811516762, -0.0044291638769209385, -0.03559175878763199, 0.017432862892746925, -0.026490701362490654, 0.0030805030837655067, -0.06306084245443344, 0.02207277901470661, 0.05557964742183685, -0.006015421822667122, 0.024461930617690086, 0.005934248678386211, -0.023480519652366638, 0.007903601974248886, -0.008469679392874241, -0.07776006311178207, -0.018790820613503456, 0.007706470787525177, -0.025131847709417343, 0.007700702175498009, -0.017594993114471436, 0.04231002554297447, 0.008340192958712578, -0.0003110009420197457, 0.014072678051888943, 0.024715572595596313, -0.05103383958339691, 0.044661883264780045, 0.0040376936085522175, -0.04284617677330971, 0.003876820905134082, -0.03721698001027107, 0.004157974384725094, -0.02486763708293438, -0.006219832226634026, -0.04507416859269142, 0.004248057026416063, -0.041249681264162064, 0.0009881728328764439, -0.0026549731846898794, -0.01059776172041893, -0.03378396853804588, 0.036527421325445175, 0.014373465441167355, 0.0029910029843449593, 0.011221347376704216, -0.036790501326322556, -0.039175987243652344, 0.03195042908191681, -0.005825843662023544, -0.02117067016661167, -0.0030321269296109676, 0.01771753467619419, 0.016763631254434586, 0.010137143544852734, 0.022572195157408714, 0.016035601496696472, -0.004778258502483368, 0.0034987356048077345, 0.037560611963272095, -0.045374564826488495, -0.030671758577227592, 0.04476315900683403, -0.039943844079971313, -0.07553595304489136, 0.017642978578805923, -0.029584765434265137, -0.00020724475325550884, 0.0030755726620554924, 0.016210312023758888, -0.050091229379177094, 0.06845603883266449, -0.018818305805325508, -0.0075240470468997955, -0.03371243551373482, -0.013885259628295898, 0.0034916060976684093, -0.02367641218006611, -0.0038047386333346367, -0.04309708625078201, 0.009277304634451866, 0.04593411833047867, -0.021568581461906433, 0.00041856715688481927, -0.02755163423717022, 0.028645109385252, -0.03105701319873333, 0.0017492893384769559, -0.013109231367707253, 0.00477180490270257, 0.050492607057094574, 0.040838822722435, -0.033808935433626175, 0.03283342719078064, -0.027401914820075035, 0.010942215099930763, -0.10798559337854385, 0.0007895476301200688, 0.010311659425497055, 0.004127405118197203, 0.03780163452029228, -0.04219529777765274, -0.018678834661841393, 0.021462352946400642, -0.07840337604284286, 0.06009140610694885, -0.017538167536258698, 0.00255796336568892, -0.06510880589485168, 0.013115957379341125, -0.011172343976795673, -0.022874023765325546, 0.004264603368937969, 0.052930351346731186, 0.02181851491332054, 0.015684403479099274, -0.012606842443346977, 0.009831855073571205, 0.00023526673612650484, 0.006553801707923412, 0.02472325973212719, -0.05619768425822258, 0.05227280035614967, -0.045425113290548325, -0.03834419697523117, 0.024960428476333618, -0.013213238678872585, 0.015362394973635674, 0.010739557445049286, 0.01300953421741724, -0.008647464215755463, 0.03846272453665733, 0.04530233517289162, -0.01569712720811367, -0.01283196173608303, -0.010136596858501434, -0.011486358940601349, 0.01841064728796482, -0.03674433380365372, 0.026915842667222023, 0.018137285485863686, -0.021103164181113243, -0.014423024840652943, 0.014148964546620846, -0.002054651267826557, -0.044605471193790436, 0.018539700657129288, 0.016284555196762085, 0.019126707687973976, 0.01338566280901432, 0.013551048003137112, -0.0176436398178339, -0.014364820905029774, -0.004773308057337999, 0.025271113961935043, 0.013936083763837814, 0.06392215937376022, -0.021724896505475044, -0.03205399960279465, 0.004812067374587059, -0.03556583449244499, -0.0151718370616436, -0.05574142932891846, 0.005842618178576231, -0.007264875341206789, 0.02247116155922413, 0.013450165279209614, -0.009065221063792706, -0.017647532746195793, 0.0447978749871254, -0.009306476451456547, 0.028515402227640152, 0.025976693257689476, 0.0015833211364224553, -0.0022802394814789295, -0.09651520848274231, 0.07117509841918945, 0.009420769289135933, -0.04211732745170593, -0.015596287325024605, -0.015346205793321133, 0.0018301013624295592, 0.0015920428559184074, 0.04621965438127518, -0.030988622456789017, 0.018901260569691658, -0.020676184445619583, 0.022039510309696198, 0.011734286323189735, -0.05564648285508156, -0.004463291727006435, -0.021944651380181313, -0.026114439591765404, 0.015482340939342976, -0.005539177916944027, 0.0007807290530763566, 0.0018662462243810296, 0.03683531656861305, 0.019412020221352577, 0.004841539543122053, 0.010614483617246151, -0.020774956792593002, 0.024354977533221245, 0.025185085833072662, -0.017667287960648537, 0.02387380413711071, -0.007816443219780922, -0.0006563786882907152, -0.029019005596637726, -0.006647061090916395, -0.010873815976083279, 0.02288060635328293, -0.041913941502571106, -0.03653290495276451, -0.02064405381679535, -0.003940468188375235, 0.021560944616794586, -0.059328190982341766, -0.012347330339252949, 0.01978985220193863, -0.038196925073862076, -0.0140463188290596, 0.04575738683342934, 0.0090553667396307, 0.051809217780828476, 0.02865779586136341, 0.024672359228134155, 0.022346533834934235, -0.026100218296051025, -0.0026442010421305895, 0.02081039361655712, 0.010380968451499939, -0.010639790445566177, 0.014534994028508663, 0.040140535682439804, -0.024305637925863266, 0.03525439649820328, -0.015017273835837841, 0.01733766309916973, -0.029387224465608597, -0.04667576029896736, 0.024026956409215927, -0.010452603921294212, -0.022858137264847755, -0.006523762829601765, -0.05469081550836563, 0.053450003266334534, 0.015183855779469013, -0.048077501356601715, 0.007462517824023962, -0.021781770512461662, 0.0027179198805242777, 0.006761759519577026, -0.015908246859908104, 0.05355832725763321, 0.003725165966898203, 0.036440134048461914, 0.003911999985575676, 0.008164215832948685, 0.04978908225893974, 0.004728695377707481, 0.039229970425367355, -0.03682735562324524, -0.0015950248343870044, 0.044146135449409485, 0.009381183423101902, -0.013611708767712116, -0.04146762192249298, 0.02108440175652504, 0.037407636642456055, 0.020881948992609978, -0.004319674335420132, -0.02853328175842762, -0.004632517695426941, 0.08982584625482559, -0.0735323578119278, 0.010145582258701324, -0.03173939883708954, -0.010469582863152027, 0.024428099393844604, -0.025773219764232635 ]
<p>I've got a model that I've developed in R, but also need to express in SAS. It's a double GLM, that is, I fit both the mean and (log-)variance as linear combinations of the predictors:</p> <p>$E(Y) = X_1'b_1$</p> <p>$\log V(Y) = X_2'b_2$</p> <p>where Y has a normal distribution, $X_1$ and $X_2$ are the vectors of independent variables, and $b_1$ and $b_2$ are the coefficients to be estimated. $X_1$ and $X_2$ can be the same, but need not be.</p> <p>I can fit this in R using gls() and the varComb and varIdent functions. I've also written a custom function that maximises the likelihood using optim/nlminb, and verified that it returns the same output as gls.</p> <p>I would now like to translate this into SAS. I know that I can use PROC MIXED:</p> <pre><code>proc mixed; class x2; model y = x1; repeated /group = x2; run; </code></pre> <p>However, this only gives me what I want if I have 1 variable in the /GROUP option. If I enter 2 or more variables, MIXED can only handle this by treating each individual combination of levels as a distinct group (that is, it takes the cartesian product). For example, if I have 2 variables in $X_2$, with 3 and 4 levels respectively, MIXED will fit 12 parameters for the variance. What I want is for the log-variance to be additive in the variables specified, ie 6 parameters.</p> <p>Is there a way of doing this in MIXED or any other proc? I could probably code something in NLP, but I'd really prefer not to.</p>
74,172
[ -0.04974440485239029, 0.005363635718822479, -0.007164668757468462, -0.006634910590946674, 0.024707581847906113, 0.00014767439279239625, 0.009920877404510975, -0.015145473182201385, 0.041123323142528534, -0.04978303238749504, 0.0280650295317173, 0.051409170031547546, 0.05533462017774582, 0.00933912768959999, 0.04338480904698372, 0.0022231973707675934, -0.00928034819662571, 0.004380127415060997, 0.004410170018672943, 0.010862045921385288, -0.0219684187322855, 0.005135428160429001, -0.006164240650832653, -0.03094569407403469, 0.03328599035739899, 0.058833345770835876, 0.014213396236300468, -0.0537690706551075, 0.024763140827417374, 0.050413575023412704, -0.005240944214165211, -0.02161109447479248, 0.01540745422244072, 0.0447516068816185, 0.019100595265626907, 0.0008208226645365357, 0.000070717025664635, 0.009434593841433525, -0.02736041508615017, 0.03515378758311272, -0.08231373876333237, 0.023920316249132156, 0.02831766940653324, 0.022247595712542534, -0.014021465554833412, 0.021870026364922523, -0.027826564386487007, 0.01913236454129219, 0.032817188650369644, -0.058402083814144135, 0.0595722459256649, -0.003827230539172888, 0.03050343133509159, 0.009437779895961285, -0.03736802190542221, 0.01806768774986267, 0.078739233314991, 0.06517402082681656, 0.005334489978849888, -0.04144895449280739, -0.0014168566558510065, 0.002313483040779829, 0.025593910366296768, -0.01073568593710661, -0.04300911724567413, -0.01723608374595642, 0.006080831401050091, -0.021775929257273674, -0.011751925572752953, 0.008988726884126663, 0.02380039356648922, 0.008720394223928452, 0.06371033191680908, 0.009186613373458385, 0.003034305525943637, -0.05849460884928703, 0.017727935686707497, 0.0009724535630084574, 0.0394732691347599, 0.014736324548721313, 0.0016880555776879191, 0.010834749788045883, -0.012064985930919647, 0.016482548788189888, -0.015469777397811413, -0.013356921263039112, 0.05458420515060425, -0.020860066637396812, 0.033217303454875946, 0.02431725710630417, 0.009229978546500206, 0.036108728498220444, 0.06375766545534134, 0.05499107763171196, -0.06068301573395729, 0.03982081636786461, -0.005467506125569344, 0.023347843438386917, 0.010827450081706047, 0.04340576380491257, -0.006229866296052933, -0.03323228657245636, 0.010982374660670757, 0.06136995181441307, -0.023291531950235367, -0.010067756287753582, -0.004717281088232994, -0.02223939448595047, -0.002106673549860716, -0.015095178969204426, 0.010597148910164833, 0.009091287851333618, -0.022960595786571503, -0.0419701486825943, -0.01338235568255186, -0.03288990259170532, -0.038929544389247894, -0.030379945412278175, 0.03768263757228851, 0.052609678357839584, 0.045408912003040314, -0.04445002228021622, 0.031171875074505806, -0.012212214060127735, -0.041143327951431274, -0.031885288655757904, -0.022569110617041588, -0.009377440437674522, -0.06371881067752838, 0.05674999579787254, 0.011002780869603157, -0.016241244971752167, 0.0662345141172409, 0.007352855522185564, -0.012666270136833191, -0.016016885638237, -0.02623354271054268, -0.06380786001682281, -0.012829914689064026, -0.03159552067518234, 0.042998313903808594, -0.07132592797279358, 0.007924134843051434, 0.0290712658315897, 0.05082682520151138, 0.0034912165720015764, 0.02662852592766285, 0.03602904826402664, 0.027321413159370422, -0.008259984664618969, -0.021590784192085266, -0.009612233377993107, -0.03926757723093033, -0.030708113685250282, -0.01822594925761223, -0.07328935712575912, 0.04261926934123039, -0.008090014569461346, -0.037396881729364395, 0.010877318680286407, 0.04465289041399956, 0.0006840763380751014, 0.003424594644457102, -0.026138911023736, 0.0266014002263546, -0.007650168612599373, 0.05753961205482483, 0.009204736910760403, 0.018870320171117783, 0.03477255627512932, -0.005911312997341156, -0.0282285176217556, 0.011568614281713963, 0.045145634561777115, 0.04578084871172905, -0.034524984657764435, 0.01158067211508751, 0.009606398642063141, 0.014465060085058212, 0.032867059111595154, -0.03271861746907234, -0.021910639479756355, -0.028398092836141586, -0.013646319508552551, 0.027068693190813065, 0.00963497068732977, -0.0002477790112607181, 0.0271166805177927, 0.07722777873277664, -0.017858795821666718, -0.020775431767106056, -0.09816674143075943, -0.020259840413928032, 0.025644373148679733, -0.0340329147875309, 0.04720405861735344, 0.017713909968733788, 0.01772957667708397, 0.012556069530546665, -0.04620561748743057, -0.03278850018978119, 0.009301459416747093, 0.051657840609550476, -0.014846410602331161, -0.006216827780008316, 0.018298543989658356, 0.028941664844751358, -0.0232904851436615, 0.04693225026130676, -0.013169505633413792, -0.0282173752784729, 0.006005111150443554, -0.017409058287739754, 0.007559722755104303, 0.012309917248785496, 0.023874936625361443, 0.007610192988067865, -0.0025930090341717005, -0.021998567506670952, 0.03620676323771477, -0.06119499355554581, 0.03106863796710968, 0.07859363406896591, -0.0021347200963646173, 0.0073923771269619465, 0.011809887364506721, -0.009014911949634552, -0.0016258687246590853, -0.040306560695171356, -0.014176493510603905, -0.04046005755662918, 0.013011815026402473, 0.03133988752961159, 0.0332900695502758, -0.03419839218258858, 0.01234777458012104, 0.04325250908732414, -0.016283636912703514, 0.014303607866168022, 0.05156973749399185, -0.030128799378871918, -0.0023494178894907236, 0.018973464146256447, 0.0032694258261471987, 0.03579181060194969, 0.00624034134671092, 0.016023604199290276, 0.05377107486128807, 0.029952984303236008, 0.046753160655498505, -0.008489235304296017, 0.03504176437854767, 0.0479586198925972, -0.001923494040966034, -0.007847791537642479, -0.029442327097058296, 0.06132721155881882, -0.0028969545383006334, 0.02549998089671135, 0.06408553570508957, 0.028456255793571472, -0.03371792286634445, 0.019056977704167366, -0.006779768969863653, 0.011994106695055962, 0.04301127418875694, -0.029447492212057114, -0.017788853496313095, -0.0118376724421978, -0.04337671399116516, 0.027618195861577988, 0.01553304586559534, -0.008212356828153133, -0.04305392503738403, 0.05016181617975235, -0.021350283175706863, -0.017728032544255257, 0.012185005471110344, -0.03438212350010872, -0.04377644509077072, 0.010418500751256943, -0.008677166886627674, 0.04611361399292946, -0.03401196748018265, -0.05744212120771408, 0.0058276597410440445, -0.026339922100305557, 0.023864461109042168, 0.013386543840169907, -0.019484486430883408, -0.05674617365002632, 0.03838920593261719, -0.0407089963555336, -0.06789332628250122, -0.012357615865767002, -0.02573813498020172, -0.0038406415842473507, -0.01825265772640705, -0.024157689884305, 0.027510926127433777, 0.018850818276405334, -0.014411335811018944, -0.029768764972686768, -0.068687304854393, -0.006602839101105928, -0.028980273753404617, 0.013606477528810501, 0.001141428598202765, 0.013680379837751389, 0.004296768922358751, 0.039569955319166183, -0.020649924874305725, -0.01132915634661913, -0.05532761663198471, -0.05296890065073967, 0.020481601357460022, 0.05213836953043938, 0.016017762944102287, 0.0009738125954754651, 0.0075061689130961895, 0.07889370620250702, 0.0076596699655056, -0.021466650068759918, -0.051366399973630905, -0.0195786003023386, 0.01357028353959322, -0.01786099746823311, 0.044156428426504135, -0.0026564898435026407, 0.01234951987862587, 0.04621024429798126, -0.016985353082418442, -0.006612427998334169, 0.0513572171330452, 0.019467243924736977, -0.007685615681111813, 0.019980978220701218, -0.010764610022306442, 0.007079227361828089, 0.028939945623278618, 0.03725022077560425, -0.011063995771110058, 0.017619604244828224, -0.013359015807509422, -0.028725214302539825, -0.0042757997289299965, -0.04159417375922203, -0.027197344228625298, -0.000669571221806109, 0.015232356265187263, -0.027199026197195053, 0.017412006855010986, 0.036790329962968826, -0.0344293937087059, 0.008316154591739178, 0.023729698732495308, 0.007754652760922909, -0.03359968215227127, -0.0086149787530303, 0.03564419969916344, 0.04495885968208313, 0.0074308174662292, -0.018563568592071533, 0.027017440646886826, 0.005226718727499247, 0.020878689363598824, -0.015961507335305214, 0.003313586115837097, 0.041454970836639404, 0.021697066724300385, 0.017079362645745277, -0.01754775457084179, -0.017093170434236526, 0.01805354654788971, -0.07071170955896378, 0.03538702055811882, -0.02535575069487095, 0.05444715917110443, 0.03476305678486824, 0.054649531841278076, -0.0019670024048537016, -0.019838808104395866, 0.03100450709462166, -0.023788249120116234, -0.05006701499223709, 0.003262891201302409, 0.005544734187424183, 0.0389070026576519, 0.01132535096257925, -0.030273105949163437, 0.006977434270083904, -0.04886586591601372, -0.004698232281953096, 0.0242245364934206, 0.014666677452623844, -0.01757916249334812, -0.008199787698686123, -0.0054902671836316586, -0.031961649656295776, 0.014056555926799774, 0.0312960222363472, 0.009401592426002026, -0.020919794216752052, 0.008640403859317303, 0.033169012516736984, 0.013219868764281273, -0.013931061141192913, -0.027208169922232628, -0.004696583840996027, -0.0003680307709146291, 0.04529832303524017, 0.025299610570073128, 0.04499131068587303, -0.032203447073698044, 0.039082109928131104, -0.01801920495927334, 0.03096260130405426, 0.040061526000499725, 0.007695878855884075, -0.0009563149069435894, -0.0021478820126503706, -0.008417326025664806, 0.025705981999635696, 0.015444003976881504, 0.0033682705834507942, -0.003430995624512434, 0.020335577428340912, 0.01811191812157631, -0.05444801598787308, -0.005955898202955723, 0.09180836379528046, 0.018784914165735245, -0.009764754213392735, -0.008459051139652729, 0.013256783597171307, -0.007449409458786249, 0.005743995308876038, 0.04397754743695259, -0.02844301611185074, 0.006689818110316992, -0.002474642125889659, 0.01993536949157715, -0.028205784037709236, -0.01219991222023964, 0.01558460108935833, 0.02716904692351818, 0.03737355023622513, 0.041148364543914795, -0.04133802279829979, -0.008692139759659767, 0.06584176421165466, 0.007533486932516098, 0.04140229523181915, 0.016726912930607796, -0.07297250628471375, -0.001712828641757369, 0.051489897072315216, 0.05739569291472435, -0.02862893044948578, 0.021751992404460907, -0.012429537251591682, -0.00912657380104065, 0.02436378225684166, -0.029136979952454567, 0.016444174572825432, -0.03679881989955902, 0.003287965664640069, -0.02298862487077713, -0.024038471281528473, -0.04234914481639862, 0.015303338877856731, -0.01232454925775528, -0.003954583778977394, -0.004839150235056877, -0.032494254410266876, -0.017973503097891808, 0.019088920205831528, 0.007711911108344793, 0.04314291477203369, -0.0262300968170166, -0.025376904755830765, 0.045225802809000015, 0.05077917501330376, -0.011761074885725975, -0.02666996791958809, 0.0036545689217746258, 0.03028705343604088, -0.037296317517757416, 0.05945667251944542, -0.029320459812879562, -0.038264766335487366, 0.021030765026807785, 0.005157433450222015, 0.02059655450284481, -0.012804103083908558, 0.0073335496708750725, 0.05564185231924057, 0.020215006545186043, -0.0016520434292033315, 0.04597608745098114, 0.03646644204854965, 0.010551800951361656, -0.0003269002481829375, -0.057168614119291306, 0.011838618665933609, -0.02278735116124153, -0.08306556195020676, -0.07262254506349564, -0.006850102916359901, -0.01765730232000351, 0.023103700950741768, -0.01073352713137865, 0.020075423642992973, -0.030762894079089165, -0.02034672722220421, 0.027636390179395676, 0.03917507454752922, 0.002020053332671523, -0.0008421561797149479, 0.0020873211324214935, 0.005969034507870674, -0.007132696453481913, -0.033771730959415436, 0.021481864154338837, -0.020859936252236366, -0.015775887295603752, 0.01640736497938633, -0.042109664529561996, 0.021989237517118454, -0.010766767896711826, 0.00033031907514669, 0.012991364113986492, -0.004859413020312786, 0.024056451395154, 0.021109184250235558, 0.059060074388980865, -0.008635058999061584, -0.04714937135577202, 0.005707150790840387, 0.015285354107618332, 0.00767509825527668, -0.007793215569108725, -0.033115204423666, 0.03963002189993858, -0.019003143534064293, -0.006040023174136877, -0.07913470268249512, -0.06543675065040588, 0.0067304098047316074, -0.01972620002925396, 0.0003563542559277266, -0.07015570998191833, 0.002141124801710248, -0.025494782254099846, 0.01243861485272646, -0.009470787830650806, 0.06554358452558517, -0.01576383225619793, 0.010516653768718243, -0.024355188012123108, 0.03519735112786293, 0.051211535930633545, 0.025256747379899025, -0.0041061327792704105, 0.012282190844416618, 0.0024442304857075214, -0.008791560307145119, 0.03004557453095913, -0.01781526952981949, -0.03757898136973381, -0.011314930394291878, -0.02706405334174633, 0.009179219603538513, 0.059054698795080185, -0.022156450897455215, -0.00988742709159851, -0.0048223743215203285, -0.013920051977038383, -0.006947661750018597, -0.020240366458892822, -0.009260551072657108, -0.05542130395770073, 0.024867750704288483, -0.05319301038980484, 0.0031717608217149973, -0.021062904968857765, 0.0017816866748034954, 0.002281958470121026, 0.0031240046955645084, -0.018802650272846222, 0.013595161959528923, 0.061555154621601105, 0.03641887754201889, -0.0029102920088917017, 0.01957065425813198, -0.022123677656054497, 0.063325434923172, 0.010987471789121628, -0.001680700108408928, 0.046623874455690384, 0.03427791967988014, -0.03211914747953415, -0.0273529551923275, -0.004512993153184652, -0.04600287228822708, 0.051774054765701294, -0.046002645045518875, 0.02756873145699501, 0.03947502002120018, -0.03968236967921257, 0.017392579466104507, -0.0501590371131897, 0.00028348222258500755, -0.003863738616928458, 0.013576613739132881, 0.07570388913154602, 0.0010059095220640302, -0.026772234588861465, -0.006502046715468168, 0.03326953575015068, 0.049970414489507675, 0.038396477699279785, -0.0025547537952661514, 0.03575795143842697, -0.023059040307998657, -0.04943431168794632, -0.03308463841676712, 0.027797356247901917, -0.04530354216694832, 0.0005347817786969244, -0.04733559489250183, -0.03445985168218613, 0.02999131567776203, 0.016343655064702034, -0.0030424115248024464, -0.05222003534436226, -0.02775050699710846, -0.054100025445222855, 0.006762341596186161, 0.021700656041502953, -0.012800091877579689, 0.04312873259186745, 0.009151524864137173, 0.025349313393235207, 0.0005593522801063955, 0.033340439200401306, -0.056507207453250885, -0.09821777790784836, -0.008709302172064781, -0.017855318263173103, -0.01081164926290512, 0.03553730621933937, 0.019481318071484566, -0.016831502318382263, 0.015661604702472687, -0.06550358980894089, 0.03696008399128914, -0.017392925918102264, 0.052920013666152954, 0.019601689651608467, 0.07534010708332062, -0.002189674647524953, 0.023096291348338127, -0.03217482566833496, -0.003809866961091757, 0.13546060025691986, 0.061408936977386475, 0.06005990505218506, -0.09531550109386444, 0.013072888366878033, 0.018066098913550377, -0.009582651779055595, 0.005469989962875843, -0.030697576701641083, -0.0304799135774374, -0.034004684537649155, 0.02745765820145607, 0.07553619891405106, 0.04195861145853996, -0.009661144576966763, 0.03188551589846611, -0.04062092676758766, -0.019508108496665955, 0.038969434797763824, 0.0147728705778718, -0.008130509406328201, -0.003988762851804495, -0.032240454107522964, -0.011230872943997383, 0.03710934892296791, -0.019434364512562752, -0.04614167660474777, -0.010666231624782085, -0.0061162482015788555, 0.033688485622406006, -0.00022151676239445806, 0.004527810495346785, 0.0026819338090717793, 0.0011206879280507565, 0.025101175531744957, -0.039029043167829514, -0.005525411572307348, -0.023253755643963814, -0.007164602167904377, 0.03658987954258919, 0.0016603914555162191, 0.0007966732955537736, -0.0013920932542532682, 0.004263705108314753, -0.0391354002058506, -0.030509985983371735, -0.01976899243891239, 0.03865695372223854, -0.04225757345557213, -0.0052396333776414394, 0.012853207997977734, -0.010436007753014565, 0.019184507429599762, -0.035461511462926865, -0.0367409773170948, 0.03171259164810181, 0.028400113806128502, -0.0036111511290073395, 0.009550879709422588, -0.01767214760184288, 0.03249378502368927, -0.02671113982796669, 0.019198326393961906, 0.004682321101427078, -0.04838645085692406, 0.0035501758102327585, -0.062358323484659195, 0.04701476916670799, 0.004720956087112427, -0.004849124699831009, 0.03031403198838234, -0.006750268861651421, -0.03025658056139946, -0.01915222965180874, 0.05173248052597046, 0.008830729871988297, 0.005713475868105888, -0.014981508255004883, -0.0057714818976819515, -0.02588503062725067, -0.03748970478773117, 0.0019647800363600254, -0.01361732929944992, 0.007388307247310877, -0.03879135847091675, -0.007892554625868797, 0.02189919538795948, 0.02267760969698429, -0.00447828508913517, 0.01727294735610485, -0.025240309536457062, 0.05356811359524727, -0.025348326191306114, -0.06599482893943787, -0.043573278933763504, 0.026475509628653526, -0.020332511514425278, -0.0028909125830978155, 0.013027120381593704, 0.06442158669233322, -0.026755813509225845, 0.028496133163571358, -0.03601909056305885, 0.05482101067900658, -0.015385281294584274, -0.011115871369838715, 0.00876421295106411, -0.030866442248225212, 0.0137884970754385, -0.025325842201709747, 0.03429573029279709, -0.009352211840450764, -0.03451771289110184, -0.043259650468826294, -0.045072734355926514, 0.012162452563643456, -0.049393657594919205, -0.0468209944665432, 0.03400914743542671, -0.02540808729827404, -0.006746315397322178, -0.03880074992775917, 0.013608134351670742, 0.01966085471212864, 0.014185097068548203, -0.02089019864797592, -0.014212554320693016, 0.0025279088877141476, -0.0000017981889186557964, -0.0414150096476078, -0.03150738403201103, 0.05532833933830261, 0.018056390807032585, 0.029884377494454384, 0.01703583635389805, -0.010282563045620918, -0.03520850092172623, 0.05847684293985367, -0.042276639491319656, -0.004806166980415583, 0.017215346917510033, -0.04745212197303772, -0.01155284233391285, -0.002430006628856063, 0.008707198314368725, 0.02311091125011444, 0.02492605708539486, 0.016218755394220352, -0.034680452197790146, 0.02313101291656494, -0.0319640189409256, -0.009494217112660408, -0.021131392568349838, 0.017942875623703003, 0.025897178798913956, -0.02462766133248806, 0.011544454842805862, 0.021655544638633728, -0.04441673308610916, 0.02837156131863594, 0.022230030968785286, -0.014516938477754593, 0.005465930327773094, 0.007112300023436546, -0.012674519792199135, 0.0385664626955986, 0.009964325465261936, -0.009898317977786064, 0.01306554302573204, 0.03701215237379074, -0.03234796226024628, 0.029551969841122627, 0.00899902917444706, 0.024146979674696922, -0.09191592782735825, -0.007768526207655668, 0.030869727954268456, -0.0013329294743016362, -0.01277152355760336, -0.06576437503099442, 0.007418596185743809, 0.019030041992664337, -0.030744075775146484, -0.040507495403289795, 0.002003074623644352, -0.005297675728797913, -0.027558214962482452, 0.028463080525398254, -0.05197611451148987, -0.010909502394497395, -0.0016019702889025211, 0.01420699805021286, 0.031904298812150955, -0.0055230907164514065, 0.021974505856633186, -0.044898536056280136, -0.023630360141396523, -0.018761958926916122, 0.06074222922325134, -0.048213113099336624, 0.030797161161899567, -0.02626531943678856, -0.003357567824423313, 0.031555891036987305, -0.014965491369366646, 0.04813676327466965, 0.017760002985596657, 0.008596722967922688, -0.03782486915588379, 0.03948400542140007, 0.04923040792346001, 0.00892593152821064, 0.023597491905093193, 0.02296536974608898, -0.005071725230664015, 0.01024708990007639, -0.018689163029193878, 0.0040251282043755054, 0.013230467215180397, 0.02957180328667164, -0.013794505037367344, 0.04131956771016121, -0.013898993842303753, -0.03846931457519531, -0.03332486376166344, -0.012149626389145851, -0.0016252642963081598, -0.029360076412558556, -0.013013890944421291, -0.0461328849196434, 0.021272066980600357, 0.0409361757338047, 0.026420295238494873, -0.02222023345530033, -0.006944201420992613, -0.010895130224525928, -0.005297323688864708, -0.02627125196158886, 0.007704088930040598, 0.0023833177983760834, -0.027505958452820778, -0.024865303188562393, 0.03888433054089546, 0.002462256234139204, 0.0032770687248557806, 0.01764245703816414, -0.030142420902848244, 0.056859079748392105, -0.04315812513232231, 0.05042017996311188, 0.016019076108932495, 0.00025712873321026564, 0.03864479437470436, -0.06538011133670807, 0.06582345068454742, 0.02449875883758068, 0.006244314834475517, -0.03260521963238716, 0.0005962219438515604, -0.017154114320874214, 0.026993779465556145, 0.0480697862803936, -0.0007289815694093704, -0.001862300792708993, -0.002561765955761075, 0.05713968724012375, -0.002581864595413208, -0.026410311460494995, 0.0672728642821312, -0.011251415126025677, -0.023053670302033424, -0.06330548226833344, -0.02419624663889408, -0.014371508732438087, 0.007565314881503582, 0.00765543757006526, -0.0364723801612854, -0.008686214685440063, -0.033665627241134644, -0.020978108048439026, 0.000913512718398124, -0.012503041885793209, -0.01952934078872204, 0.010882619768381119, -0.017743408679962158, -0.03545130416750908, 0.012787507846951485, 0.029913514852523804, -0.03762323036789894, 0.018883077427744865, -0.02939663454890251, -0.02216360904276371, -0.003393792547285557, 0.027202855795621872, -0.012190653942525387, -0.04373878613114357, 0.03858422115445137, -0.012341027148067951, -0.03660409152507782, -0.004630578216165304, 0.050618723034858704, 0.005408589728176594, 0.04385920241475105, -0.02234339341521263, 0.002869605552405119, -0.010989989154040813, 0.02147722616791725, 0.017998434603214264, -0.007680055685341358, 0.01366158202290535, -0.0037876120768487453, -0.014848791994154453, 0.044628482311964035, 0.00038251467049121857, 0.04254055768251419, -0.02034740522503853, 0.044519100338220596, -0.027253251522779465, -0.025863543152809143, 0.024815678596496582, -0.03372259438037872, 0.04465751349925995, -0.009191700257360935, 0.0010184402344748378, 0.05038045719265938, -0.029569271951913834, 0.006023479159921408, -0.055586595088243484, -0.0039237141609191895, 0.009674230590462685, -0.018336260691285133, -0.007150763180106878, 0.04141416400671005, 0.0019894137512892485, 0.0009894825052469969, -0.026068927720189095, -0.05792084336280823, 0.0260905921459198, 0.0022728978656232357, 0.010595323517918587, -0.02840203419327736, -0.011941375210881233, -0.001940196263603866, -0.060010988265275955, -0.05408073589205742, -0.020082883536815643, 0.01432278286665678, 0.035106997936964035, 0.028250334784388542, -0.03111317940056324, -0.031138623133301735, 0.04083748534321785, 0.04993271082639694, -0.06572666764259338, -0.0013757020933553576, -0.04258682206273079, -0.03161183372139931, -0.01255946047604084, -0.0044634658843278885 ]
<p>Let random variables $X$ and $Y$ be independent Normal with distributions $N(\mu_{1},\sigma_{1}^2)$ and $N(\mu_{2},\sigma_{2}^{2})$. Show that the distribution of $(X,X+Y)$ is bivariate Normal with mean vector $(\mu_{1},\mu_{1}+\mu_{2})$ and covariance matrix</p> <p>$$ \left( \begin{array}{ccc} \sigma_{1}^2 &amp; \sigma_{1}^2 \\ \sigma_{1}^2 &amp;\sigma_{1}^2+\sigma_{2}^2 \\ \end{array} \right).$$</p> <p>Thanks .</p>
74,173
[ -0.0398881770670414, -0.023810120299458504, 0.0003091701655648649, -0.005772543605417013, 0.0453343391418457, -0.01028785016387701, 0.004163006786257029, -0.04867066070437431, 0.03352878615260124, -0.0639444962143898, 0.06881286948919296, 0.017656760290265083, 0.05555987358093262, 0.023481566458940506, 0.04988032579421997, -0.006928096991032362, -0.030757343396544456, 0.018469197675585747, 0.0023919674567878246, 0.011933150701224804, -0.02262929081916809, 0.015299654565751553, 0.05159595236182213, -0.015667814761400223, -0.020783059298992157, 0.05458517000079155, 0.017786793410778046, -0.04448715224862099, 0.014621938578784466, 0.06893742829561234, -0.01998094469308853, -0.03787688538432121, 0.031609319150447845, 0.0569571927189827, -0.0033611345570534468, -0.00844530574977398, -0.011727134697139263, 0.009539061225950718, 0.01946057565510273, 0.00604779738932848, -0.047637734562158585, -0.024788329377770424, 0.005203823558986187, 0.0418480783700943, -0.009686442092061043, -0.0034445002675056458, -0.010059621185064316, -0.030037762597203255, 0.02791498601436615, -0.028839873149991035, 0.1162971556186676, -0.005066238809376955, 0.0578710101544857, 0.03288132697343826, -0.01246530469506979, -0.008121764287352562, 0.035003919154405594, 0.07888783514499664, 0.03905060142278671, -0.06802871078252792, 0.02086162008345127, -0.06344535946846008, -0.01448102854192257, 0.0018027914920821786, -0.055695146322250366, -0.0014476857613772154, 0.006069699767976999, -0.03355750814080238, -0.009152747690677643, -0.0020077277440577745, -0.0053284503519535065, 0.024206161499023438, 0.0485149584710598, -0.028148628771305084, -0.02188734896481037, -0.0077141812071204185, 0.0272759310901165, 0.01722319982945919, 0.028147147968411446, -0.001656307140365243, 0.027413861826062202, 0.03207944333553314, 0.03070337325334549, 0.0072055901400744915, 0.004084620624780655, 0.003936278633773327, 0.09493400901556015, -0.007171307690441608, 0.005420220550149679, 0.01471586525440216, -0.0021183870267122984, -0.00018857719260267913, 0.052888695150613785, 0.013491620309650898, -0.049939658492803574, 0.06328065693378448, -0.030543526634573936, 0.03210849687457085, 0.012953766621649265, -0.02256365865468979, -0.020935183390975, -0.04295840486884117, 0.03192613646388054, 0.081168532371521, 0.014818820171058178, -0.01301818061619997, -0.03277464956045151, 0.043426014482975006, -0.022819848731160164, -0.017611423507332802, -0.03860685974359512, 0.026555489748716354, -0.0026084796991199255, -0.028878120705485344, 0.033259253948926926, 0.004375247750431299, 0.002657405100762844, 0.008718914352357388, 0.03846048563718796, 0.08280117064714432, 0.05881152302026749, -0.007034008856862783, 0.018810801208019257, -0.005602783989161253, -0.035834793001413345, 0.03390217944979668, 0.014886568300426006, -0.0030790711753070354, -0.073685422539711, 0.04891522228717804, 0.0002376124175498262, -0.007930254563689232, -0.021197346970438957, 0.009713812731206417, 0.004832422826439142, -0.011681951582431793, -0.07193423062562943, -0.02309204451739788, 0.030657516792416573, -0.038991864770650864, 0.013230918906629086, -0.05891525372862816, 0.011685595847666264, 0.03347978740930557, 0.06307224929332733, -0.03601786121726036, 0.055884070694446564, -0.010929095558822155, 0.025786854326725006, 0.019436528906226158, 0.0024815162178128958, -0.029585354030132294, -0.027919994667172432, -0.03268633410334587, -0.01059993077069521, -0.08262670785188675, -0.00028905525687150657, 0.017221450805664062, 0.006144186947494745, -0.03276538476347923, 0.010602729395031929, -0.007774126250296831, -0.00868630688637495, -0.017747076228260994, 0.032429005950689316, -0.041617318987846375, 0.039411984384059906, 0.027437034994363785, 0.020041653886437416, 0.033962931483983994, -0.02316715195775032, 0.04495692998170853, -0.005461754277348518, 0.0732189267873764, 0.03155834227800369, -0.030493471771478653, -0.02266383357346058, 0.023877421393990517, 0.01615205779671669, 0.03641517460346222, -0.037000566720962524, -0.019588300958275795, -0.06909685581922531, -0.0013966901460662484, 0.019503135234117508, 0.035622235387563705, 0.026283754035830498, -0.017769252881407738, 0.030125590041279793, -0.04219553619623184, 0.016203854233026505, -0.08140229433774948, -0.0006663121748715639, 0.016741132363677025, -0.04157553240656853, 0.02012793906033039, 0.008316103368997574, 0.035480696707963943, 0.007821580395102501, -0.02294505573809147, -0.03947892412543297, 0.0006967955268919468, 0.025521516799926758, -0.04046667367219925, 0.0037487507797777653, 0.018367605283856392, 0.06931256502866745, 0.0024365708231925964, 0.04940328001976013, -0.03177015855908394, -0.026860598474740982, 0.012709444388747215, 0.00006400192069122568, 0.007641511503607035, -0.015245032496750355, -0.0030480201821774244, -0.016170861199498177, 0.009751620702445507, -0.011034207418560982, 0.05292882025241852, -0.04914773628115654, 0.02944791316986084, 0.05588994175195694, -0.008629989810287952, -0.0178774893283844, -0.004651778377592564, 0.04944637790322304, 0.0017663345206528902, -0.022138671949505806, -0.03219561651349068, -0.042918384075164795, 0.015227433294057846, 0.02579454518854618, 0.04986155405640602, -0.06361507624387741, 0.027296004816889763, 0.009021857753396034, 0.06290140002965927, 0.002729562344029546, 0.03849651664495468, -0.0016984902322292328, -0.03271304443478584, 0.008533654734492302, 0.014643036760389805, 0.015490861609578133, -0.008327734656631947, -0.02490454725921154, 0.013819205574691296, 0.033846862614154816, 0.03490743041038513, -0.029577037319540977, 0.056913699954748154, -0.025713659822940826, 0.0004599025414790958, 0.001134067540988326, -0.002539500594139099, 0.03766012564301491, -0.005367436911910772, 0.008999131619930267, 0.0394267663359642, 0.017016222700476646, -0.04184795916080475, 0.001929225865751505, 0.013154436834156513, 0.016495993360877037, 0.000887228874489665, -0.03074302338063717, -0.005647611804306507, 0.015218401327729225, -0.013485963456332684, 0.018476877361536026, 0.004948804154992104, -0.020405350252985954, -0.014848795719444752, 0.008498179726302624, 0.00822522398084402, 0.020742816850543022, 0.023621104657649994, -0.011118506081402302, -0.053793005645275116, 0.006010865792632103, 0.004712579306215048, 0.021910248324275017, -0.013741674832999706, -0.046558089554309845, 0.006402458064258099, -0.06093456596136093, 0.014131797477602959, 0.04331183061003685, -0.020396068692207336, 0.004860059358179569, 0.016869546845555305, -0.0034920373000204563, -0.03599579259753227, -0.005035851150751114, -0.03335696458816528, 0.0470820814371109, -0.060699332505464554, -0.003953063394874334, 0.02612435445189476, 0.031214095652103424, -0.04682468622922897, 0.007252016570419073, -0.010750419460237026, -0.06157622113823891, -0.010646088048815727, -0.02975374460220337, 0.04160893335938454, -0.010523977689445019, 0.05273772031068802, 0.03205864876508713, -0.04326482489705086, -0.004076241049915552, -0.07176316529512405, -0.053794603794813156, 0.01947614923119545, -0.017142511904239655, 0.02699481137096882, -0.008906601928174496, -0.03071429207921028, 0.028667088598012924, 0.03558146208524704, 0.0037681576795876026, -0.0033263282384723425, 0.012181086465716362, 0.005912597291171551, -0.04959537088871002, 0.055296171456575394, 0.009861398488283157, -0.015136931091547012, 0.07269392162561417, 0.03302931413054466, -0.01430604513734579, 0.06750338524580002, 0.000003120886276519741, -0.03282308951020241, -0.007139509543776512, -0.0034404555335640907, -0.018578743562102318, 0.030084431171417236, -0.00961785577237606, -0.0190030075609684, 0.0030491456855088472, 0.04727441444993019, 0.046377625316381454, -0.006197139620780945, -0.022628460079431534, 0.03054659254848957, -0.04207581654191017, 0.008507846854627132, -0.05463028326630592, 0.03837423399090767, 0.027726728469133377, -0.04451970383524895, -0.02588454633951187, 0.01181711908429861, 0.005486845504492521, -0.014155488461256027, 0.009945354424417019, 0.04180077090859413, 0.004422902129590511, 0.007990471087396145, -0.013256614096462727, -0.024121100082993507, -0.003153357421979308, 0.022890053689479828, -0.059272464364767075, -0.02067004144191742, 0.02305617555975914, 0.02690965309739113, -0.012290485203266144, -0.02931315079331398, -0.02007596753537655, 0.01135681476444006, -0.07770393788814545, 0.037172041833400726, -0.022209888324141502, -0.007635454181581736, 0.0027130211237818003, 0.06386733055114746, -0.006294143386185169, -0.003990308381617069, 0.02208140306174755, -0.021012283861637115, -0.05150149017572403, -0.01533141452819109, -0.03136194124817848, -0.01014724187552929, 0.030999980866909027, -0.05370033159852028, 0.016029249876737595, -0.03097248449921608, 0.02581879496574402, -0.009179029613733292, -0.010623646900057793, -0.049693409353494644, -0.01764143630862236, -0.04073556512594223, -0.04805833473801613, 0.0028168896678835154, -0.0018133779522031546, 0.028237681835889816, -0.029219171032309532, 0.024067357182502747, 0.03119209036231041, -0.02651927061378956, -0.008883476257324219, -0.040771618485450745, 0.010611641220748425, 0.03692887723445892, 0.016175126656889915, 0.00021188663959037513, 0.03304972127079964, 0.020542379468679428, 0.002523601520806551, -0.029738260433077812, 0.06507624685764313, 0.022056162357330322, 0.000027843962016049773, -0.01738109439611435, -0.04778706282377243, -0.033641453832387924, -0.017786985263228416, 0.030079040676355362, 0.0025365841574966908, 0.0006333408528007567, 0.049275707453489304, 0.046630725264549255, -0.02227858081459999, 0.021156173199415207, 0.06361305713653564, 0.03133130818605423, -0.013552077114582062, -0.004162946715950966, -0.012526767328381538, -0.015237456187605858, -0.020136091858148575, 0.013396363705396652, -0.012340744957327843, -0.03475318104028702, 0.001649017445743084, 0.034773897379636765, 0.0007189859170466661, 0.009546477347612381, 0.0033131351228803396, 0.007470239419490099, 0.042485907673835754, 0.026045694947242737, -0.02245134487748146, -0.012811491265892982, 0.04879694804549217, 0.013639247976243496, 0.03488221392035484, -0.010904796421527863, -0.03363961726427078, 0.022666750475764275, 0.04845179617404938, 0.028879240155220032, -0.009359482675790787, -0.013338244520127773, -0.027728339657187462, 0.006206388585269451, 0.04110439494252205, -0.021113719791173935, 0.029980124905705452, 0.026818715035915375, 0.008765814825892448, 0.021919887512922287, -0.011339519172906876, -0.06189607456326485, 0.02056390419602394, -0.005087485071271658, 0.029581604525446892, 0.0016451250994578004, -0.04613752290606499, -0.06314091384410858, -0.013384191319346428, 0.03238952159881592, 0.07856273651123047, -0.00010708995978347957, -0.018093271180987358, -0.011797759681940079, 0.049436554312705994, 0.00617053871974349, -0.06768245249986649, 0.02280689775943756, 0.02482805773615837, -0.02807932160794735, 0.048023901879787445, -0.013850927352905273, -0.013279575854539871, 0.02763587236404419, -0.0020931109320372343, -0.008873035199940205, 0.06902477145195007, 0.006593234371393919, 0.06106416881084442, 0.04143289104104042, 0.013558953069150448, 0.026482636108994484, -0.012924694456160069, 0.010718869976699352, -0.02102319896221161, -0.036855071783065796, 0.01697809435427189, -0.025137165561318398, -0.0452868677675724, -0.03376109525561333, 0.006859173532575369, 0.0070137744769454, 0.005691071040928364, -0.021891659125685692, 0.025395099073648453, -0.05042194202542305, -0.021452367305755615, 0.007925866171717644, 0.04695570841431618, 0.011793547309935093, 0.010347601026296616, -0.0011290877591818571, 0.015483062714338303, 0.0010660741245374084, -0.02312616817653179, 0.019652394577860832, -0.045004334300756454, -0.011987672187387943, -0.0016928780823946, -0.017245041206479073, 0.022181903943419456, -0.04182034730911255, -0.03442356362938881, -0.036595966666936874, -0.02242821268737316, 0.013064767234027386, -0.027194516733288765, 0.016088921576738358, 0.01536768302321434, -0.04314862936735153, -0.01710009016096592, 0.051867906004190445, 0.002943894360214472, 0.03151768818497658, -0.020563477650284767, 0.02464030683040619, 0.010894035920500755, -0.003781902836635709, -0.07601949572563171, -0.044886764138936996, -0.015367877669632435, -0.013598787598311901, 0.02238110639154911, -0.04788580536842346, 0.001553037902340293, -0.04234490171074867, -0.04272618517279625, -0.01805501990020275, 0.043885745108127594, -0.022879771888256073, -0.050900205969810486, 0.01257588155567646, -0.008146015927195549, 0.04419468715786934, -0.029501648619771004, 0.024646563455462456, -0.0067947376519441605, -0.03377232328057289, -0.0038702019955962896, 0.011237019672989845, 0.02112479694187641, -0.01692846044898033, -0.0018122185720130801, -0.011321889236569405, -0.03130681812763214, 0.06357422471046448, -0.06025834381580353, -0.020100438967347145, 0.012830184772610664, 0.004255464766174555, -0.021940629929304123, -0.02940666489303112, -0.015924550592899323, -0.002743345685303211, 0.020038612186908722, -0.012319875881075859, -0.02688891440629959, -0.00901566818356514, 0.0013409863458946347, 0.025672204792499542, 0.007755738217383623, -0.010197016410529613, -0.0034878491424024105, 0.0759800523519516, 0.006176290567964315, 0.015304279513657093, -0.01549606490880251, 0.035270560532808304, 0.017455250024795532, -0.0027986408676952124, -0.02074696496129036, 0.03250386193394661, 0.01452915370464325, -0.04813459515571594, -0.011785409413278103, -0.028872478753328323, 0.008281337097287178, 0.05905250459909439, -0.03690394014120102, 0.017785092815756798, 0.04558742046356201, 0.005788558628410101, -0.011246777139604092, -0.0314914844930172, 0.01514272578060627, -0.008266626857221127, -0.000877042708452791, 0.05056118220090866, -0.002885563764721155, -0.016450373455882072, 0.04705888405442238, 0.0388222336769104, -0.021108023822307587, 0.019045889377593994, -0.00046504641068167984, 0.0004372315888758749, 0.007453093305230141, -0.006475523579865694, -0.029041867703199387, 0.03215278312563896, -0.06149691343307495, -0.01742366887629032, -0.02271702140569687, -0.037229910492897034, 0.03768511489033699, 0.010619321838021278, -0.029185745865106583, -0.0072899553924798965, -0.029757773503661156, -0.010156115517020226, 0.0027302780654281378, 0.023883167654275894, 0.004446263890713453, 0.02438962273299694, 0.03648025542497635, 0.02262209728360176, -0.008189233019948006, 0.03310678154230118, -0.020833060145378113, -0.08664834499359131, -0.008022819645702839, -0.005102509167045355, -0.019358590245246887, 0.023769952356815338, 0.003183601889759302, -0.000977126182988286, -0.009041724726557732, -0.02336627058684826, -0.002531480509787798, 0.02433331497013569, 0.036326825618743896, -0.008738460950553417, 0.07721296697854996, -0.009628424420952797, 0.012628859840333462, 0.01733943447470665, -0.009006533771753311, 0.08410995453596115, 0.0607355535030365, 0.01961306482553482, -0.05105353519320488, 0.02039126306772232, -0.0011603040620684624, -0.0564139261841774, -0.04955717921257019, 0.01469273492693901, -0.013229615986347198, 0.0006489022052846849, 0.035839859396219254, 0.03357930853962898, 0.01971488818526268, -0.018359875306487083, 0.0372198112308979, -0.04417683184146881, -0.05900345742702484, -0.024299781769514084, -0.00108008598908782, -0.029987772926688194, 0.010008580051362514, -0.06775009632110596, 0.025476835668087006, -0.018604880198836327, -0.0014385910471901298, -0.05164610594511032, -0.00989091582596302, 0.01303116325289011, -0.0010329645592719316, -0.003944574389606714, -0.014871034771203995, 0.04175176844000816, 0.0012507690116763115, -0.014290173538029194, 0.005121782422065735, 0.04179856926202774, -0.052022773772478104, 0.02551889605820179, 0.0006840453133918345, -0.0006062129396013916, 0.02227620780467987, 0.03752448409795761, 0.013282375410199165, -0.03928804770112038, -0.016823597252368927, -0.01779058389365673, 0.05879315733909607, -0.04547588899731636, -0.02165149711072445, 0.0034988378174602985, -0.008783013559877872, 0.01366360206156969, -0.032021842896938324, -0.026749776676297188, 0.01645936816930771, 0.04659461975097656, -0.005020882934331894, 0.017472464591264725, -0.01210099458694458, 0.04358436167240143, 0.009949327446520329, 0.03973041847348213, 0.003015113528817892, -0.015008801594376564, -0.025602316483855247, -0.008612183853983879, 0.06308228522539139, 0.018412211909890175, 0.010100003331899643, -0.020803118124604225, -0.040537092834711075, -0.012254438363015652, -0.010273357853293419, 0.033440712839365005, -0.0002550128265284002, 0.029564622789621353, 0.03111988492310047, -0.018077287822961807, -0.0032001598738133907, -0.07693041115999222, -0.00816557090729475, -0.01718240976333618, -0.0020233055111020803, -0.03679657727479935, -0.023710640147328377, 0.025561202317476273, 0.037688612937927246, 0.016403770074248314, -0.0024740141816437244, -0.000049506470531923696, 0.06257317215204239, 0.020617231726646423, -0.02516857348382473, -0.012609785422682762, -0.01148892380297184, -0.005910188890993595, -0.02632228285074234, -0.04306700453162193, 0.04823397845029831, 0.0339394174516201, 0.06920097023248672, -0.0072576310485601425, 0.03059731237590313, -0.06051235646009445, -0.010953322052955627, 0.022836236283183098, -0.04767785593867302, 0.0009715962805785239, 0.020431900396943092, 0.0472199022769928, -0.018449317663908005, 0.0077597033232450485, 0.008025850169360638, -0.02196086384356022, 0.028471525758504868, -0.03591711074113846, -0.018365534022450447, -0.031853996217250824, -0.001116800936870277, 0.02836924046278, -0.023169057443737984, -0.010207745246589184, 0.00021935281984042376, 0.025428611785173416, 0.004114571493119001, -0.0312364362180233, -0.041772134602069855, 0.015632353723049164, -0.012067620642483234, 0.02030477114021778, 0.0426093190908432, 0.019668860360980034, 0.028576165437698364, -0.0029482755344361067, 0.018896980211138725, -0.03369288146495819, 0.0404132604598999, -0.028160275891423225, 0.021819906309247017, 0.03399994969367981, -0.0029763809870928526, 0.03376196324825287, -0.010061927139759064, 0.024739427492022514, 0.03273651376366615, -0.001320496667176485, -0.02799534983932972, -0.036527179181575775, 0.06979384273290634, -0.03204259276390076, -0.0027949269860982895, -0.013911165297031403, 0.02141621895134449, -0.01895037479698658, -0.007088177837431431, -0.00753115676343441, 0.0004964544204995036, 0.015299856662750244, 0.02518925815820694, 0.025413386523723602, 0.000499679590575397, -0.008189082145690918, 0.025823477655649185, 0.010531657375395298, 0.03453778848052025, 0.003405632684007287, -0.020056236535310745, 0.037584707140922546, 0.04147518798708916, -0.02004619874060154, 0.04352613165974617, -0.056538619101047516, -0.012327266857028008, -0.07455991953611374, -0.00372861186042428, 0.06065263971686363, -0.005010249093174934, 0.06831303238868713, -0.03237741068005562, -0.0019524437375366688, 0.022105371579527855, -0.05118338763713837, -0.02466522715985775, -0.026544246822595596, -0.022308455780148506, -0.02460000477731228, 0.031626004725694656, -0.020536212250590324, 0.04769158735871315, 0.00016722685541026294, 0.04712849482893944, 0.039627235382795334, 0.04226360097527504, -0.011481493711471558, -0.027061088010668755, -0.03764781728386879, -0.02610757015645504, 0.022300615906715393, -0.03496662899851799, 0.049138393253088, -0.0029246944468468428, -0.00937067810446024, 0.007794022094458342, 0.022013381123542786, -0.01820901222527027, 0.010487130843102932, 0.035676952451467514, 0.021668417379260063, 0.04262154921889305, -0.00037233615876175463, 0.005165320821106434, 0.044942401349544525, -0.012792958877980709, 0.019010446965694427, 0.011834494769573212, -0.06051114201545715, -0.02650970220565796, 0.03814191743731499, -0.010828183963894844, -0.030391253530979156, 0.019962381571531296, -0.008038069121539593, -0.03742985427379608, 0.008912133984267712, -0.016538605093955994, 0.01422436535358429, -0.053853727877140045, 0.029379313811659813, -0.044943083077669144, -0.02403194084763527, 0.031541213393211365, 0.02417004108428955, -0.013011329807341099, 0.016204748302698135, 0.026646774262189865, -0.0610477514564991, 0.0014894831692799926, 0.0049871401861310005, 0.007258238270878792, -0.07636383175849915, -0.01786607876420021, 0.015973439440131187, -0.01336484681814909, -0.0015840157866477966, -0.03834672272205353, -0.053184326738119125, 0.02345653995871544, 0.017875179648399353, 0.028095373883843422, 0.0004006953095085919, -0.008268214762210846, -0.030068133026361465, -0.04523353651165962, 0.01372644491493702, 0.04981335997581482, -0.012103736400604248, -0.04688369110226631, 0.007533373776823282, -0.03920692950487137, 0.003976949956268072, 0.058568067848682404, 0.0092695951461792, -0.0026766967494040728, -0.025406815111637115, 0.04098616912961006, 0.02185555174946785, -0.055028460919857025, 0.04742228612303734, -0.020512757822871208, -0.066978320479393, -0.031026920303702354, -0.02320062555372715, 0.044275280088186264, 0.00630994001403451, 0.004495060537010431, -0.010310722514986992, 0.0025731984060257673, 0.03769790381193161, -0.022966109216213226, 0.00576578825712204, 0.004256069660186768, -0.021253904327750206, 0.055139172822237015, -0.034166302531957626, -0.021560272201895714, 0.004486744292080402, -0.0004072937008459121, -0.038112521171569824, 0.03304576873779297, -0.02796953357756138, -0.011840078979730606, -0.040930043905973434, 0.01091783307492733, 0.005832511931657791, -0.07986985146999359, 0.000979963457211852, 0.05036092922091484, -0.04254579916596413, -0.037938814610242844, 0.0532502606511116, 0.022701365873217583, 0.027552608400583267, 0.013007530942559242, 0.009844116866588593, 0.01151546835899353, 0.005696128588169813, 0.04818744584918022, 0.030857760459184647, -0.007032142486423254, -0.02861819416284561, -0.01826689951121807, 0.022244174033403397, -0.021939832717180252, 0.0643341913819313, -0.02476242370903492, 0.014138339087367058, -0.04635858163237572, -0.018976546823978424, 0.0014806672697886825, -0.023702656850218773, 0.04069840535521507, 0.01440958771854639, -0.02198580466210842, 0.0656801238656044, -0.0498233325779438, 0.001205488690175116, -0.014015262946486473, -0.018936356529593468, -0.04157782718539238, -0.015161036513745785, 0.03185521066188812, 0.027303507551550865, 0.014994264580309391, 0.0013613150222226977, -0.012442358769476414, -0.047593917697668076, 0.03719168156385422, -0.012899158522486687, 0.02455281652510166, -0.025187969207763672, 0.011886056512594223, 0.01033597718924284, -0.0013527428964152932, -0.02082069031894207, -0.018600573763251305, 0.00612672558054328, 0.05438266694545746, 0.00936262309551239, -0.0074114007875323296, -0.013336710631847382, 0.0053073083981871605, 0.05850872024893761, -0.07815133035182953, -0.015669476240873337, -0.032702405005693436, -0.002114973496645689, -0.026523685082793236, -0.010672753676772118 ]
<p>I am asked to draw a scatterplot and to compute a correlation coefficient for the following situation. A group of subjects are measured for a blood characteristic before and after surgery.</p> <p>Is it OK to correlate before-and-after data?</p> <p>I know that it is not OK to perform correlations on non independent data. I feel this is such a case--the two measurements are made on the same subjects--they should be correlated. </p> <p>I know that correlating data to the change over time is not OK--but that is obvious and it is not the case here.</p> <p>Also correlating two variables measured repeatedly on the same sample is a huge No. But again it is not my case.</p>
36,892
[ -0.037270400673151016, -0.01857469044625759, -0.025387106463313103, -0.003944655880331993, 0.06147770583629608, 0.019898461177945137, -0.0012726683635264635, 0.026617921888828278, 0.04176735132932663, -0.020920557901263237, 0.05785070359706879, 0.037436142563819885, 0.04101588577032089, 0.03443977236747742, 0.03942378610372543, -0.0020574310328811407, -0.014316139742732048, 0.004779644310474396, 0.0129112983122468, -0.00036593753611668944, 0.0072617363184690475, -0.002927319845184684, -0.0019347590859979391, -0.009327773004770279, -0.02892005816102028, 0.046462398022413254, -0.008212694898247719, -0.04500856250524521, 0.03483996167778969, 0.0553576685488224, -0.06528465449810028, -0.0355091318488121, 0.012980352155864239, 0.05768661946058273, 0.03522373363375664, -0.014132056385278702, -0.026928629726171494, -0.004479456227272749, -0.002147889928892255, 0.03732282295823097, -0.02120509371161461, -0.03249641880393028, 0.008082961663603783, 0.0504065677523613, 0.016353311017155647, 0.019198063760995865, -0.023978302255272865, -0.037600189447402954, 0.018100250512361526, -0.03419651463627815, 0.09577565640211105, -0.0179743655025959, 0.06507827341556549, 0.03241190314292908, -0.023471863940358162, 0.004697252064943314, 0.0524478554725647, 0.0502801313996315, 0.0061830938793718815, -0.049871694296598434, -0.004773363471031189, -0.03514965996146202, 0.02524210885167122, 0.024200662970542908, -0.040883906185626984, 0.02205880545079708, -0.022666137665510178, 0.002040707040578127, 0.033358726650476456, -0.00792076624929905, 0.011435208842158318, 0.05232368782162666, 0.059043724089860916, -0.06041643023490906, 0.02360820211470127, -0.04640047252178192, 0.04223077744245529, -0.016158655285835266, 0.023650318384170532, 0.03956010192632675, -0.0011638072319328785, 0.03778693452477455, 0.03002084419131279, 0.042330317199230194, 0.032760139554739, -0.018019620329141617, 0.08003439009189606, -0.034375615417957306, 0.010566586628556252, 0.03707784414291382, -0.00454770727083087, 0.025392284616827965, 0.03326978534460068, 0.026783742010593414, -0.02557498775422573, 0.015491164289414883, -0.03296705335378647, 0.05995626375079155, -0.00020536957890726626, -0.016804806888103485, -0.008450481109321117, -0.04336653649806976, 0.01415110845118761, 0.03086446225643158, -0.034188300371170044, -0.015426878817379475, -0.04203375056385994, 0.014663147740066051, -0.0011719471076503396, -0.047381460666656494, -0.021959885954856873, -0.01575012505054474, 0.028917571529746056, -0.0010452527785673738, 0.03290277719497681, -0.03957223519682884, -0.01053023710846901, 0.006682926788926125, 0.054351069033145905, 0.06941333413124084, 0.03815020993351936, -0.007529238238930702, 0.0007568954024463892, -0.002670519519597292, -0.02182200737297535, 0.0007876724121160805, 0.03749570623040199, -0.013613978400826454, -0.05043329298496246, 0.0626261979341507, -0.007365964353084564, -0.019785961136221886, 0.025993552058935165, -0.026474913582205772, 0.03679472208023071, 0.02034425549209118, -0.08572887629270554, -0.060895659029483795, 0.034262560307979584, -0.024636419489979744, -0.013919263146817684, -0.06935657560825348, 0.019866880029439926, 0.005998325068503618, 0.07001115381717682, 0.022215060889720917, 0.003975072409957647, -0.001693833153694868, 0.050934672355651855, -0.008029955439269543, -0.01029430702328682, -0.003990529105067253, -0.009794870391488075, -0.04265971481800079, -0.03450910747051239, -0.07297214865684509, -0.007410673424601555, 0.03519223630428314, 0.008428076282143593, -0.02430219016969204, 0.0228860042989254, -0.02188052237033844, -0.01653522439301014, 0.0019594989717006683, -0.0018974351696670055, -0.020050786435604095, 0.05836992338299751, -0.0015634860610589385, 0.03401676192879677, 0.019515199586749077, 0.01602948270738125, 0.02363392524421215, 0.009728596545755863, 0.04714960977435112, 0.04889383539557457, -0.007476183585822582, 0.0320306234061718, 0.004861155059188604, 0.013944071717560291, 0.01633439213037491, -0.019353093579411507, -0.04907361790537834, -0.037911586463451385, -0.006426420994102955, 0.03951125591993332, 0.055595315992832184, 0.015847928822040558, -0.0084904870018363, 0.02824791520833969, -0.034197986125946045, -0.009816729463636875, -0.08366630971431732, 0.013605930842459202, -0.017168618738651276, -0.03835533186793327, 0.019453031942248344, 0.002145053818821907, 0.034292902797460556, -0.0037283150013536215, -0.04309464991092682, -0.03435167670249939, -0.004614122677594423, 0.04084887355566025, -0.032841045409440994, 0.01806906796991825, 0.03782103583216667, 0.02570102922618389, -0.006705682259052992, 0.02988039329648018, -0.011868288740515709, -0.02144511044025421, 0.02315494418144226, -0.03451277315616608, -0.0025706253945827484, -0.03300557658076286, -0.006831776350736618, 0.014998362399637699, 0.01648390106856823, -0.04153414070606232, 0.037293098866939545, -0.04381657764315605, 0.07961121946573257, 0.05109388753771782, -0.0159169789403677, -0.007420836016535759, 0.004678651690483093, 0.03767237067222595, 0.009456454776227474, -0.02243976667523384, -0.042924899607896805, -0.04467381536960602, 0.018693914636969566, 0.019063031300902367, 0.04630798473954201, 0.004135035909712315, 0.007585854735225439, 0.04585886746644974, 0.013651183806359768, 0.0003286675491835922, 0.021708616986870766, 0.0003218766942154616, -0.016416039317846298, -0.005055904854089022, 0.014576147310435772, 0.020243041217327118, -0.020373517647385597, -0.01995878666639328, -0.014169320464134216, 0.02789822220802307, 0.02547803521156311, -0.00992078147828579, 0.045382872223854065, 0.006373596377670765, 0.006468494422733784, -0.0045988005585968494, -0.02370699681341648, 0.033087704330682755, -0.011084641329944134, 0.039268892258405685, 0.023020533844828606, 0.008994480594992638, -0.022134840488433838, 0.01122833788394928, -0.024745311588048935, -0.005470258183777332, 0.024734318256378174, -0.030239420011639595, -0.005242739804089069, 0.00515876105055213, -0.0029351471457630396, 0.013138349168002605, -0.03019598498940468, -0.017464078962802887, -0.011699802242219448, 0.011713232845067978, 0.011639928445219994, -0.007511519361287355, 0.056583892554044724, -0.03790518641471863, -0.033101484179496765, -0.003560860874131322, -0.019824093207716942, 0.007764418609440327, 0.020910678431391716, -0.055953167378902435, 0.0006596380844712257, -0.011731465347111225, 0.009240965358912945, 0.02850550226867199, -0.021022720262408257, -0.011227643117308617, 0.011076432652771473, 0.007179701700806618, -0.06875012069940567, -0.021764205768704414, -0.00875185988843441, -0.014272397384047508, 0.01590549573302269, -0.018147844821214676, 0.04820829629898071, -0.020905034616589546, -0.04020530357956886, -0.003665114287286997, -0.03678327798843384, -0.007704492658376694, -0.02057274430990219, -0.007833071984350681, 0.013378400355577469, -0.01422192808240652, -0.004236534237861633, 0.015631025657057762, -0.05735218524932861, -0.04533877968788147, -0.0527333989739418, -0.07456368207931519, 0.03137541189789772, -0.009584824554622173, 0.052923597395420074, -0.03267707675695419, -0.022243324667215347, 0.03697091341018677, 0.00023053471522871405, -0.03489743173122406, -0.030234504491090775, -0.016753558069467545, -0.03482519090175629, -0.0014390057185664773, 0.02648376300930977, 0.016924679279327393, 0.018152039498090744, 0.01485722791403532, 0.007562792394310236, 0.027300147339701653, 0.054320547729730606, 0.012907196767628193, -0.011897111311554909, 0.03714141249656677, 0.06737978011369705, 0.020721226930618286, 0.03228020295500755, 0.015769032761454582, -0.016407867893576622, 0.012087780982255936, 0.0022309469059109688, 0.005952385254204273, 0.023323671892285347, -0.04046610742807388, 0.018210651353001595, -0.018524622544646263, 0.037844426929950714, -0.06103458255529404, 0.003866261336952448, 0.03922257944941521, -0.005170497577637434, -0.029746416956186295, 0.05095042660832405, 0.019094038754701614, -0.0279814675450325, -0.006725213024765253, 0.0714976042509079, 0.014264300465583801, -0.01825694553554058, 0.009462821297347546, -0.0045597003772854805, 0.0009176501189358532, 0.07190810889005661, -0.04676204174757004, 0.021289167925715446, 0.036491040140390396, 0.03847074508666992, 0.002303095068782568, -0.03134382888674736, -0.04760655015707016, -0.002428229432553053, -0.08755102008581161, -0.0286285188049078, 0.0021262853406369686, 0.039628613740205765, 0.020147692412137985, 0.05896807834506035, 0.031086014583706856, -0.018254868686199188, 0.03366975113749504, 0.0018255087779834867, -0.07345608621835709, 0.03922511264681816, -0.00808799546211958, 0.027789227664470673, 0.039821743965148926, -0.03230356052517891, 0.013428173959255219, -0.03179693594574928, 0.004239404108375311, -0.002071712864562869, 0.03734290972352028, -0.015994660556316376, 0.015105758793652058, -0.05175438150763512, 0.004315197002142668, -0.018263041973114014, 0.0061004809103906155, 0.024641189724206924, 0.012910694815218449, 0.06329504400491714, 0.035918932408094406, 0.023493679240345955, -0.0042334431782364845, -0.004958553239703178, -0.0008427365683019161, 0.0199480839073658, 0.026230009272694588, 0.003609119914472103, 0.014195319265127182, -0.01315529365092516, 0.03026292473077774, -0.003652672516182065, -0.009411845356225967, 0.016818253323435783, -0.010263326577842236, -0.013131367973983288, -0.03180203586816788, -0.030956681817770004, -0.01093093492090702, 0.046492382884025574, 0.022550923749804497, -0.01337374746799469, 0.015593812800943851, 0.020863793790340424, -0.047830939292907715, 0.030769918113946915, 0.0903540551662445, 0.05059538409113884, -0.016904007643461227, -0.016500171273946762, -0.0021806666627526283, 0.004604742396622896, -0.013122709468007088, 0.029558241367340088, 0.016423441469669342, 0.00012858268746640533, -0.010833358392119408, 0.023794593289494514, -0.012172321788966656, -0.028486793860793114, 0.003679974703118205, 0.011917192488908768, 0.02977306954562664, 0.02325979433953762, -0.020394980907440186, 0.012476342730224133, 0.036665454506874084, -0.001505484920926392, 0.039539892226457596, -0.011300761252641678, -0.08650392293930054, 0.0019022849155589938, 0.05126722902059555, 0.05567139387130737, -0.04501660168170929, -0.020500846207141876, -0.03657616302371025, -0.015551447868347168, 0.03578563407063484, -0.021786190569400787, 0.009541541337966919, -0.03580285608768463, -0.021752238273620605, -0.02141333743929863, -0.03293231874704361, -0.062240879982709885, 0.0426693856716156, -0.009970714338123798, 0.0013112258166074753, -0.007492502219974995, -0.03451128676533699, -0.036478590220212936, -0.0476885661482811, 0.008117778226733208, 0.07562897354364395, -0.0337664932012558, -0.024299228563904762, -0.008357356302440166, 0.02225593291223049, -0.014328433200716972, -0.0470440648496151, 0.020298196002840996, 0.010113174095749855, 0.01199773047119379, 0.052389465272426605, 0.0018087702337652445, -0.005748443771153688, -0.014816545881330967, -0.016580773517489433, -0.020327270030975342, -0.008247548714280128, -0.01326115895062685, 0.10252396762371063, 0.02928263507783413, -0.01913589984178543, 0.0637463629245758, 0.042655039578676224, 0.000011464935596450232, -0.010139023885130882, -0.026292171329259872, 0.015363622456789017, -0.017860984429717064, 0.011667013168334961, -0.04048483818769455, -0.020036298781633377, -0.0366540364921093, 0.04449908062815666, -0.019464436918497086, 0.009673504158854485, -0.05198301002383232, 0.018375925719738007, 0.027988450601696968, 0.02556862309575081, 0.005265381652861834, 0.0034987153485417366, 0.031713102012872696, -0.011606124229729176, -0.021073870360851288, -0.042201459407806396, -0.0005966973840259016, -0.022863350808620453, -0.01572301983833313, 0.04337820038199425, -0.05896737799048424, -0.0170440673828125, -0.017978327348828316, -0.023214345797896385, -0.003659152891486883, -0.03680500015616417, 0.009221253916621208, 0.002392070135101676, 0.05102560669183731, 0.01982315070927143, -0.03779579699039459, 0.010561898350715637, 0.05952606350183487, 0.01629246585071087, 0.013003306463360786, -0.042857248336076736, 0.027492878958582878, 0.014468993991613388, 0.007097473833709955, -0.06913800537586212, -0.06373252719640732, 0.01646725833415985, -0.011557484045624733, -0.011925301514565945, -0.029166972264647484, -0.013012701645493507, -0.04346698522567749, -0.03456994518637657, -0.018205199390649796, 0.03184898942708969, 0.00016037079330999404, -0.032911449670791626, 0.023581553250551224, 0.0015093720285221934, 0.09375625103712082, -0.02411230280995369, 0.004385098349303007, -0.012818829156458378, -0.03806997463107109, -0.03405444324016571, 0.007663181982934475, -0.007269150577485561, -0.013906236737966537, -0.022040393203496933, -0.05851622298359871, 0.011982466094195843, 0.0559503547847271, -0.042029354721307755, -0.04516749083995819, 0.0012799600372090936, -0.028139134868979454, -0.010185150429606438, -0.029196493327617645, -0.010140234604477882, -0.027517346665263176, 0.03396815061569214, -0.005893048830330372, 0.008650027215480804, -0.01730981469154358, -0.017877673730254173, -0.004643356427550316, -0.009790198877453804, -0.03117964416742325, 0.027303600683808327, 0.06361709535121918, 0.002688293345272541, -0.010313557460904121, -0.012624903582036495, -0.026147903874516487, 0.019353017210960388, 0.013653462752699852, -0.014119327999651432, -0.00721528846770525, 0.0231152456253767, -0.04982494190335274, -0.0299752876162529, 0.0018497532000765204, -0.02776676043868065, 0.07261672616004944, 0.0009983855998143554, 0.05450325086712837, 0.055266816169023514, -0.000370984518667683, 0.003359119640663266, -0.018631670624017715, -0.005862971302121878, -0.03055880405008793, -0.027041180059313774, 0.05118659883737564, -0.02394001930952072, -0.0473797544836998, 0.013442601077258587, 0.03547561168670654, 0.022123245522379875, 0.03292030096054077, 0.015291375108063221, -0.004243398550897837, 0.031732939183712006, 0.00564657524228096, -0.06888836622238159, 0.03535439074039459, -0.030019862577319145, 0.011328347027301788, -0.06282137334346771, -0.04149458929896355, 0.021023254841566086, 0.01712050288915634, -0.00380090344697237, -0.06527341902256012, -0.014562651515007019, -0.01795743964612484, -0.027358239516615868, 0.0060340422205626965, -0.023351136595010757, 0.03557346761226654, 0.0030402573756873608, 0.03628440573811531, -0.00403935369104147, 0.036272432655096054, -0.02441239170730114, -0.06954725831747055, -0.03620106726884842, -0.0317009799182415, 0.000274728488875553, 0.04386066645383835, -0.009510480798780918, -0.029455211013555527, 0.016741832718253136, -0.03135204687714577, 0.03662208840250969, 0.014678539708256721, 0.042154744267463684, -0.03416573256254196, 0.08310655504465103, 0.004002369940280914, 0.015990516170859337, -0.002346955006942153, 0.005923616234213114, 0.09681578725576401, 0.0657881647348404, 0.009431859478354454, -0.031074540689587593, 0.03705547749996185, 0.006619720719754696, 0.00006491275416919962, -0.012937490828335285, 0.052414607256650925, -0.024187332019209862, -0.018039628863334656, 0.06601186841726303, 0.031341422349214554, 0.030428674072027206, -0.009304155595600605, 0.06343356519937515, -0.003344738855957985, -0.02451816387474537, -0.0011757301399484277, -0.005935922730714083, -0.00993121787905693, 0.005298036616295576, -0.021052245050668716, 0.01112520694732666, -0.01414661668241024, -0.03961675614118576, -0.01911018043756485, -0.0049916161224246025, 0.0018331932369619608, 0.02280382439494133, -0.034701503813266754, 0.015831686556339264, 0.016938569024205208, 0.00813239999115467, -0.05745436251163483, -0.007010112050920725, 0.0213366337120533, -0.019587527960538864, 0.015179315581917763, 0.019686149433255196, 0.0030655208975076675, -0.013449382036924362, 0.020472537726163864, 0.022579744458198547, -0.06701729446649551, -0.03540044277906418, -0.004615767393261194, 0.061157677322626114, -0.010625651106238365, -0.00012694098404608667, -0.01681325025856495, -0.0015048504574224353, 0.023401563987135887, -0.048132725059986115, -0.054092925041913986, 0.0034861317835748196, 0.020109428092837334, -0.03298550099134445, 0.022173840552568436, -0.03524323180317879, -0.024891424924135208, -0.00601911498233676, 0.03743763267993927, 0.03261164575815201, -0.016868388280272484, 0.017169632017612457, -0.03060292825102806, 0.055264875292778015, -0.010244454257190228, 0.018779022619128227, 0.004734869580715895, -0.005094472784548998, -0.04241250082850456, 0.014729924499988556, 0.023058641701936722, 0.01412196271121502, 0.04775145649909973, 0.002200004644691944, -0.02723611332476139, -0.024521904066205025, -0.061302751302719116, 0.03542998060584068, 0.006614273879677057, -0.021571891382336617, -0.022259686142206192, -0.025302937254309654, 0.04347282275557518, 0.058505620807409286, -0.013655724003911018, 0.001083109644241631, -0.013037127442657948, 0.03627802059054375, 0.04478888213634491, -0.03255394101142883, -0.018560992553830147, -0.007834389805793762, -0.030395643785595894, -0.004847972188144922, -0.027956075966358185, 0.03802797943353653, 0.013192940503358841, 0.04743993654847145, -0.010131588205695152, 0.04195646941661835, 0.023170841857790947, 0.01897168904542923, 0.0032225807663053274, -0.032435305416584015, 0.006226141005754471, -0.020661676302552223, 0.0045615676790475845, -0.008905689232051373, -0.025970572605729103, -0.02456715516746044, -0.008749277330935001, -0.0021941412705928087, -0.031052744016051292, -0.006577176507562399, 0.005222855135798454, -0.019045835360884666, 0.0029670833609998226, -0.017136232927441597, 0.023447876796126366, -0.08173119276762009, -0.0025391753297299147, 0.007125573698431253, -0.009461005218327045, -0.00862408522516489, 0.057792894542217255, -0.027994047850370407, 0.03993772715330124, 0.06082097440958023, 0.01177865732461214, 0.009545092470943928, -0.003133405465632677, 0.0022492087446153164, -0.0008565013413317502, 0.04614539444446564, -0.007366069592535496, -0.0032059471122920513, 0.020556839182972908, -0.053685933351516724, -0.02159876748919487, 0.004738088697195053, 0.01629433035850525, 0.02096881903707981, -0.00466851145029068, 0.0042604501359164715, 0.007636356167495251, 0.030624326318502426, -0.027202889323234558, -0.014592187479138374, -0.01716907136142254, 0.005509113427251577, -0.010526875033974648, 0.017291292548179626, 0.009539293125271797, 0.018894828855991364, -0.012402879074215889, 0.04869897663593292, 0.03609051927924156, 0.016707396134734154, -0.005954409018158913, -0.01313020195811987, 0.02023344859480858, 0.013945152051746845, -0.005063232500106096, -0.0008164370665326715, 0.0253349170088768, 0.07470595091581345, -0.021136421710252762, 0.03141585364937782, 0.0029564567375928164, 0.01342710293829441, -0.08715924620628357, -0.020645570009946823, -0.0031983372755348682, 0.01760660484433174, 0.03775417432188988, -0.04188300669193268, -0.0211089625954628, 0.013937495648860931, -0.04914725571870804, 0.017156053334474564, -0.005453117657452822, -0.041779305785894394, -0.00900492537766695, 0.045389775186777115, -0.016672132536768913, 0.014601731672883034, 0.054967544972896576, 0.05559132248163223, 0.022147011011838913, 0.010702934116125107, 0.025722790509462357, 0.004656452219933271, -0.05733779817819595, -0.007039213087409735, -0.0045329611748456955, -0.050428539514541626, 0.012994207441806793, -0.01991691254079342, -0.02816375531256199, 0.011548373848199844, -0.027784710749983788, 0.012803114019334316, 0.03453375771641731, 0.020563796162605286, -0.007251428440213203, 0.013265280053019524, 0.013853843323886395, -0.039713047444820404, -0.016963228583335876, 0.013616763986647129, 0.010557244531810284, 0.056295499205589294, -0.02958066202700138, 0.04308461397886276, -0.002340999199077487, -0.026697970926761627, -0.015298016369342804, 0.008609860204160213, -0.016468346118927002, -0.03444879129528999, 0.007268449757248163, -0.0038550016470253468, -0.007072052452713251, 0.0024182922206819057, 0.00503256032243371, -0.04270635172724724, -0.025338225066661835, 0.04032537341117859, 0.01565578579902649, -0.017966341227293015, 0.02344471774995327, -0.006289651617407799, -0.02951580472290516, -0.0059353685937821865, -0.0011048964224755764, -0.011475486680865288, -0.04089033976197243, 0.007585079409182072, -0.046600766479969025, -0.02679121121764183, -0.02189916931092739, -0.014184681698679924, -0.020668189972639084, 0.06402774155139923, -0.030082251876592636, -0.003814344061538577, 0.012670770287513733, -0.010432598181068897, -0.012236354872584343, -0.04082026332616806, 0.027286717668175697, 0.020961390808224678, -0.04117313399910927, -0.05869649723172188, -0.025054197758436203, -0.050914157181978226, 0.05102723836898804, 0.057645637542009354, 0.00222931825555861, 0.0008729454129934311, -0.03435320034623146, 0.02450915239751339, 0.007653689943253994, -0.04483046382665634, 0.05952947214245796, -0.02131243795156479, 0.005857986398041248, -0.014136862009763718, 0.006688126362860203, 0.027473999187350273, 0.017479626461863518, -0.022154757753014565, -0.052864301949739456, 0.028254523873329163, 0.01809755153954029, -0.02939002402126789, 0.04261868819594383, -0.002144512953236699, -0.051236215978860855, 0.048774078488349915, 0.016346696764230728, 0.018638918176293373, 0.03880629688501358, 0.008830608800053596, -0.07300122082233429, 0.028896646574139595, -0.03565870597958565, -0.03704136610031128, 0.0005821905797347426, 0.011151188053190708, -0.024964025244116783, -0.0871800035238266, 0.00584995374083519, 0.04170900210738182, -0.03949185833334923, -0.008066828362643719, 0.05359777808189392, 0.019760122522711754, -0.0007934793829917908, -0.021938350051641464, 0.005627148784697056, 0.013280199840664864, -0.0017609217902645469, -0.014066038653254509, 0.009713525883853436, 0.03624045103788376, 0.008430181071162224, -0.0007142924587242305, 0.05738333612680435, 0.0007025469094514847, -0.02163088135421276, -0.0031098495237529278, 0.028679978102445602, -0.04703132063150406, -0.0029589510522782803, 0.015582566149532795, 0.002474543871358037, 0.04187517613172531, 0.008444191887974739, 0.0033527298364788294, 0.01579972542822361, -0.046178292483091354, 0.029096702113747597, -0.0035524137783795595, -0.03226567804813385, -0.060707490891218185, 0.006415610201656818, 0.0566718615591526, 0.038696758449077606, 0.014523038640618324, -0.02935102954506874, -0.012123155407607555, -0.023248139768838882, 0.005336304660886526, -0.0017565438756719232, 0.020611893385648727, -0.035051409155130386, -0.009313754737377167, -0.02419811487197876, -0.012288686819374561, -0.032453667372465134, -0.04141603410243988, 0.0430368073284626, 0.033614449203014374, 0.010553156957030296, 0.0007883692742325366, -0.011085920967161655, -0.0012295807246118784, 0.06063905358314514, -0.09560904651880264, -0.025817716494202614, -0.04642225801944733, 0.023596519604325294, 0.014099312014877796, 0.0034009392838925123 ]
<p>Let $f_i(y)$ for $i = 1, \ldots, n$ be valid PDF’s, and let $a_i ∈ (0, 1)$ be constants, such that $\sum_{i=1}^n a_i= 1$.</p> <ol> <li>Show that the function $f(y) = \sum_{i=1}^n a_i\, f_i(y)$ is a valid PDF.</li> <li>If $E [Y_i] = \mu_i$ and $\text{Var}(Y_i) = σ^2_i$, show that<br> (i) $E[Y] = \sum_{i=1}^n a_i\, \mu_i$, <br> (ii) $E[Y^2_i] = \mu^2_i + σ^2_i$.</li> </ol> <p>I understand the basic requirements for PDF's but for whatever reason I am drawing a total blank.</p>
31,273
[ -0.040696922689676285, -0.006814897526055574, 0.028115039691329002, -0.038295648992061615, 0.027780240401625633, -0.00883147306740284, 0.012577061541378498, -0.04396619275212288, 0.006899289786815643, -0.051418572664260864, 0.0521567165851593, 0.015925591811537743, 0.09088975191116333, 0.02882644161581993, 0.027186468243598938, -0.038792215287685394, -0.027537919580936432, 0.0142600042745471, -0.03991911560297012, 0.000962291844189167, -0.030148308724164963, 0.03273762762546539, 0.009703383781015873, -0.017186282202601433, -0.04016520082950592, 0.02180284820497036, 0.04027482867240906, 0.013064741156995296, 0.014748585410416126, 0.09016995877027512, -0.06697089970111847, -0.013600108213722706, 0.01081688329577446, 0.023415839299559593, -0.011793604120612144, 0.016515616327524185, -0.04335992783308029, 0.00945921428501606, 0.02777722105383873, 0.010958168655633926, -0.034806977957487106, -0.01642732135951519, 0.01032272819429636, 0.024962931871414185, -0.04328107088804245, 0.03198546543717384, 0.018898945301771164, 0.004993648733943701, 0.02570519596338272, -0.03480709716677666, 0.09315074980258942, -0.002911166287958622, 0.03440818935632706, 0.06290273368358612, 0.0023502446711063385, 0.00766541576012969, 0.020901689305901527, 0.044945910573005676, -0.005861142184585333, -0.036082517355680466, -0.019361920654773712, -0.01757582649588585, 0.04148447513580322, -0.03171307221055031, -0.024186350405216217, 0.00913453008979559, 0.019436968490481377, -0.038151707500219345, 0.011251557618379593, -0.011235019192099571, 0.02732865698635578, 0.01936260238289833, 0.01015406008809805, -0.030377760529518127, 0.012129179202020168, 0.012807317078113556, 0.007867459207773209, 0.026920314878225327, 0.04466196522116661, 0.019615119323134422, 0.04685989022254944, 0.039069611579179764, 0.03466574102640152, 0.00936969369649887, 0.020757416263222694, 0.01469319686293602, 0.09942889213562012, 0.012401438318192959, 0.04909211024641991, -0.003477990860119462, 0.026900753378868103, -0.016321025788784027, 0.054672859609127045, -0.006240601651370525, -0.04899180307984352, 0.05280647799372673, -0.01750212348997593, 0.013913764618337154, -0.018750276416540146, -0.04288646578788757, -0.021687792614102364, -0.05000573769211769, 0.05855736508965492, 0.04850722476840019, -0.023088395595550537, 0.011681797914206982, -0.05179568752646446, -0.00696939043700695, -0.016153618693351746, 0.015476703643798828, -0.019483229145407677, 0.05043628811836243, -0.036623258143663406, 0.0061158789321780205, 0.01021833997219801, 0.02681605890393257, 0.002268743235617876, -0.00029385637026280165, 0.019020551815629005, 0.05236544832587242, 0.04554850608110428, -0.0089632673189044, -0.00924524012953043, -0.02447575516998768, -0.039988644421100616, 0.036514852195978165, 0.01415255293250084, 0.005983481649309397, -0.07148826867341995, 0.049650728702545166, -0.002764534205198288, -0.007955308072268963, -0.0010939117055386305, 0.03639674559235573, -0.002280057640746236, -0.0024648294784128666, -0.08231324702501297, -0.052438873797655106, 0.03068418987095356, -0.032705459743738174, 0.01410507783293724, -0.06127254664897919, 0.00379377999342978, 0.0420762374997139, 0.05622734874486923, -0.019704829901456833, 0.02826916240155697, -0.0016557229682803154, 0.02798912674188614, 0.001988133881241083, -0.03453090414404869, -0.04125608131289482, -0.0027698175981640816, -0.039099376648664474, -0.017716046422719955, -0.05493282526731491, 0.01792394556105137, 0.02415054850280285, -0.03221818059682846, -0.04644965007901192, 0.04489307478070259, 0.003649055026471615, 0.013730363920331001, -0.031967949122190475, 0.0074218763038516045, -0.031220242381095886, 0.034613579511642456, 0.03449788689613342, 0.027390850707888603, 0.010449156165122986, -0.04548618197441101, 0.02859307825565338, -0.007059992756694555, 0.03453969955444336, 0.05650240182876587, -0.026002589613199234, -0.044617775827646255, -0.03147532045841217, 0.029592927545309067, 0.0419604629278183, -0.014438879676163197, -0.013326767832040787, -0.06769202649593353, -0.019947513937950134, -0.004324841313064098, 0.016207750886678696, 0.023832108825445175, 0.002231898019090295, -0.002154792193323374, -0.06017117574810982, -0.017444586381316185, -0.06620139628648758, 0.02272043377161026, -0.011918742209672928, -0.07181695848703384, 0.006225095596164465, -0.0031008683145046234, 0.005610670428723097, 0.000264868198428303, -0.019280392676591873, -0.03780145198106766, -0.001873256522230804, 0.019008444622159004, -0.0002695229777600616, 0.011818147264420986, 0.026769237592816353, 0.051850441843271255, 0.00628634262830019, 0.04651223123073578, -0.018756084144115448, -0.042982906103134155, -0.05343496799468994, -0.0024877372197806835, 0.013607976958155632, 0.002001371467486024, 0.0021628383547067642, 0.02619236893951893, 0.0011754606384783983, -0.006294697057455778, 0.00537883909419179, -0.07988481223583221, 0.022912949323654175, 0.04723421111702919, 0.014018896967172623, -0.01124399621039629, 0.03856683522462845, 0.06129857897758484, 0.00932059995830059, -0.012581666931509972, -0.007250462658703327, -0.0248283501714468, 0.0055496240966022015, 0.02615317702293396, 0.07158450782299042, -0.03814172372221947, -0.005986527539789677, 0.034802164882421494, 0.024325354024767876, -0.007849786430597305, 0.009027094580233097, 0.01144816167652607, -0.06611941009759903, -0.006425802130252123, -0.01592937484383583, 0.018956545740365982, -0.0006999628385528922, -0.0088356276974082, -0.014836224727332592, 0.020473957061767578, 0.007635121699422598, 0.0008291166159324348, 0.04893457144498825, -0.020009858533740044, -0.011754553765058517, 0.01598585955798626, 0.013566290028393269, 0.007765325251966715, -0.001772188814356923, -0.012167466804385185, 0.02091343328356743, -0.019739100709557533, 0.006531061604619026, 0.00406000716611743, -0.010281315073370934, 0.03167649358510971, -0.006787403021007776, -0.004459036979824305, -0.041646067053079605, 0.028019553050398827, -0.03148999437689781, 0.0027645977679640055, -0.010390612296760082, -0.06197702884674072, 0.01809745654463768, -0.02046651765704155, 0.012453502044081688, 0.006068793591111898, 0.014700585976243019, -0.008481906726956367, -0.02928834967315197, -0.010762716643512249, -0.02207908220589161, 0.03326224535703659, -0.017280425876379013, -0.03890876844525337, -0.0036754515022039413, -0.04318325221538544, 0.025880269706249237, 0.012409373186528683, -0.028852472081780434, 0.011081399396061897, 0.046470969915390015, 0.0021167879458516836, -0.051169294863939285, -0.0013132303720340133, -0.017050638794898987, 0.01216895505785942, -0.03911515697836876, -0.027058104053139687, 0.009737028740346432, -0.007813358679413795, -0.04956940561532974, 0.032136719673871994, -0.009201676584780216, -0.01203687023371458, -0.05317079648375511, -0.019126195460557938, 0.03534170985221863, -0.021613841876387596, 0.03453527018427849, 0.015010424889624119, -0.05499263480305672, -0.02674504742026329, -0.048432573676109314, -0.06035018339753151, 0.0064718397334218025, -0.009937581606209278, 0.044015880674123764, 0.0036098917480558157, -0.050949275493621826, 0.04594060406088829, 0.04542142152786255, -0.014461737126111984, -0.01575581170618534, 0.011916427873075008, 0.009961461648344994, -0.07389473915100098, 0.010313850827515125, -0.0031463499180972576, -0.02763758786022663, 0.055972449481487274, 0.044238410890102386, -0.02708784118294716, 0.06902363896369934, -0.03217798098921776, -0.016650870442390442, -0.0031100481282919645, -0.02829410880804062, -0.00026583042927086353, 0.0503564216196537, 0.012602717615664005, 0.006397831719368696, -0.020782064646482468, 0.027992920950055122, 0.03078639693558216, 0.03882686793804169, -0.0499081127345562, 0.025849105790257454, -0.010154266841709614, 0.02012636326253414, -0.07219503074884415, 0.05949639528989792, 0.010916318744421005, -0.05968885123729706, -0.006792988628149033, 0.013521666638553143, 0.022771375253796577, -0.004414993803948164, 0.007215186487883329, 0.0502871572971344, 0.0255158469080925, -0.010482561774551868, -0.0033118666615337133, -0.04774641990661621, -0.025249050930142403, 0.04452759027481079, -0.03399539738893509, 0.0026334598660469055, 0.03744695335626602, 0.018121985718607903, 0.010821662843227386, -0.043442338705062866, -0.01924673467874527, -0.018374003469944, -0.05569298565387726, 0.03305133432149887, -0.02178967371582985, 0.04835217818617821, 0.024810295552015305, 0.0607883520424366, -0.01413292158395052, -0.02536018379032612, 0.036452800035476685, -0.00882085133343935, -0.037519752979278564, -0.003070146543905139, 0.00835803709924221, -0.007796555291861296, -0.024446865543723106, -0.01665744185447693, 0.03366631641983986, -0.008613057434558868, 0.027286790311336517, -0.021740587428212166, 0.021670065820217133, -0.022002046927809715, -0.025298696011304855, -0.03979012742638588, -0.04666578769683838, -0.013601891696453094, 0.06224505975842476, 0.01773134246468544, -0.0017144490266218781, 0.04279737547039986, 0.04030292108654976, -0.025318235158920288, -0.027360575273633003, -0.0072523076087236404, 0.028328651562333107, 0.013312711380422115, 0.018933724611997604, 0.008447346277534962, 0.021389514207839966, 0.013610916212201118, 0.017903286963701248, 0.03134363889694214, 0.06173154339194298, 0.03850345313549042, -0.008584395982325077, -0.032223187386989594, -0.020955326035618782, -0.037439100444316864, 0.0038562538102269173, 0.04761941358447075, 0.023862015455961227, -0.012647337280213833, 0.04644215852022171, 0.01289092842489481, -0.04029466211795807, 0.03764932602643967, 0.03686494007706642, -0.00523397047072649, 0.009918746538460255, -0.005212301854044199, -0.02048843912780285, -0.002753697568550706, -0.006152949761599302, -0.005423386115580797, -0.008512011729180813, -0.030848657712340355, -0.012342230416834354, 0.03185166418552399, 0.009068942628800869, -0.011374406516551971, 0.008806312456727028, 0.036727942526340485, 0.025860542431473732, 0.0050079855136573315, -0.057931531220674515, 0.035541750490665436, 0.0748249962925911, 0.03368932753801346, 0.03945646807551384, -0.019039427861571312, -0.021204905584454536, 0.003913187421858311, 0.042946211993694305, 0.06825853139162064, 0.002558943582698703, 0.002199826529249549, -0.0253179669380188, -0.005287312436848879, 0.03764720633625984, -0.005420097149908543, 0.03675103932619095, -0.0031135748140513897, -0.020638352259993553, 0.022004522383213043, -0.0457104854285717, -0.04889104515314102, 0.016321079805493355, 0.020480608567595482, 0.05235522240400314, -0.0473141148686409, -0.018631236627697945, -0.054900553077459335, -0.028573988005518913, 0.015435959212481976, 0.07785321772098541, -0.03542819991707802, 0.008435252122581005, -0.013083646073937416, 0.04882963374257088, 0.0008550938800908625, -0.05572529137134552, 0.008727463893592358, -0.0010389917297288775, -0.00427120178937912, 0.01800413429737091, -0.002358613768592477, -0.061962105333805084, 0.01286257617175579, 0.008013946004211903, -0.0201947633177042, 0.06795928627252579, -0.0362706184387207, 0.05089697986841202, 0.060902439057826996, 0.06852828711271286, 0.04295738413929939, 0.05619024485349655, 0.02223183773458004, 0.014858171343803406, -0.04344097152352333, -0.03095192462205887, -0.024434227496385574, -0.030723936855793, -0.04728291183710098, 0.018133442848920822, -0.01876348815858364, 0.0018021247815340757, 0.004536300897598267, 0.025059059262275696, -0.004927773028612137, -0.027204718440771103, 0.010851831175386906, 0.03353014960885048, -0.0018670761492103338, -0.015697143971920013, -0.025767453014850616, 0.02626458927989006, 0.0015616083983331919, 0.005624784156680107, 0.012074536643922329, -0.007645226549357176, 0.0020059722010046244, 0.01469383854418993, -0.00336237414740026, 0.02397286705672741, -0.06472034007310867, -0.005774880759418011, -0.013361486606299877, -0.026177361607551575, 0.047790367156267166, 0.01479730848222971, 0.027727872133255005, 0.03173934668302536, -0.03848383203148842, -0.02604622393846512, 0.03152022510766983, 0.008254792541265488, 0.035520039498806, -0.029045486822724342, 0.03901796042919159, 0.00612241867929697, -0.007604279555380344, -0.0657254159450531, -0.0036707762628793716, -0.0070264642126858234, 0.0006946155917830765, -0.028020445257425308, -0.049145739525556564, 0.010168083012104034, -0.02958008460700512, -0.014998217113316059, -0.01506982184946537, 0.02339259162545204, 0.0005475240177474916, -0.042408138513565063, -0.005155934952199459, 0.005652574356645346, 0.06765569001436234, -0.02376047894358635, 0.020520370453596115, 0.03773295134305954, -0.013966759666800499, -0.026087896898388863, -0.0002793983439914882, 0.044691067188978195, -0.00990016758441925, -0.00630769832059741, 0.013163721188902855, -0.042698465287685394, 0.009470564313232899, -0.01027914322912693, -0.0273930374532938, 0.021829143166542053, -0.004299988504499197, -0.016197482123970985, -0.0016849890816956758, -0.018193086609244347, -0.03534213826060295, 0.017353681847453117, -0.027075788006186485, -0.005011692643165588, -0.004065383691340685, -0.01562502048909664, 0.015406562946736813, 0.003011497901752591, 0.017923109233379364, 0.021620919927954674, 0.08950009942054749, -0.028352541849017143, -0.012096424587070942, 0.014982917346060276, 0.03548040986061096, 0.035920485854148865, -0.002710619242861867, -0.0155982980504632, 0.02204493060708046, 0.021106062456965446, -0.04871509224176407, -0.026507927104830742, -0.0552016980946064, 0.01604868471622467, 0.07231096178293228, -0.0028262613341212273, 0.012877808883786201, -0.0013711778447031975, -0.007326291874051094, -0.011854597367346287, -0.047858502715826035, -0.005405455827713013, -0.022360997274518013, -0.004169431049376726, 0.024638932198286057, -0.006659058853983879, -0.012620627880096436, 0.02538761869072914, 0.008864952251315117, 0.014937281608581543, 0.011324997060000896, 0.014244157820940018, 0.009919388219714165, 0.026133257895708084, -0.03344837203621864, -0.059045273810625076, 0.046947307884693146, -0.04976825788617134, 0.02091510407626629, 0.00042523886077106, -0.047362059354782104, 0.060419220477342606, 0.04537437856197357, -0.014344562776386738, -0.010264463722705841, 0.0033542795572429895, -0.047317761927843094, 0.0050794873386621475, 0.035959821194410324, -0.014685243368148804, 0.05583566427230835, -0.02523794211447239, 0.058790143579244614, -0.005858531687408686, 0.009107773192226887, -0.038194168359041214, -0.07783446460962296, -0.004721918608993292, -0.02920990251004696, -0.04156074672937393, 0.035455167293548584, -0.007604029029607773, -0.023734280839562416, -0.0285925455391407, -0.0013802123721688986, 0.0076500773429870605, 0.0011730421101674438, 0.014325748197734356, -0.021379798650741577, 0.05864843726158142, -0.008667933754622936, 0.03749571740627289, -0.03145240247249603, 0.00008538296242477372, 0.12443779408931732, 0.062243759632110596, 0.027390945702791214, -0.05060584470629692, 0.007278976961970329, -0.027329683303833008, -0.002116674790158868, -0.007592895533889532, 0.03014979138970375, -0.02090361900627613, -0.008128722198307514, 0.014343176037073135, 0.06415976583957672, -0.004423338919878006, -0.005985687021166086, 0.026868369430303574, -0.03669591248035431, -0.04452342540025711, -0.0027856037486344576, -0.012868105433881283, -0.037851180881261826, -0.0066683790646493435, -0.061505526304244995, 0.00628876406699419, -0.0031485583167523146, -0.03642911836504936, 0.001616066787391901, -0.02932465448975563, 0.013748426921665668, 0.00546454731374979, -0.006346291396766901, -0.019112566486001015, 0.03681996837258339, 0.004882413428276777, 0.00107197358738631, -0.0009852128569036722, 0.018441084772348404, -0.06318046152591705, 0.005446026101708412, 0.04797884821891785, 0.009995766915380955, -0.009586534462869167, 0.006944599095731974, 0.0017952007474377751, -0.0188443586230278, -0.045785170048475266, -0.04238767921924591, 0.028813328593969345, -0.021036610007286072, 0.006759376730769873, -0.009857394732534885, -0.008612609468400478, -0.006622859742492437, -0.03928626328706741, 0.015056051313877106, 0.007534243166446686, 0.02666112594306469, -0.02540338784456253, 0.008015740662813187, -0.05380099266767502, 0.01521989330649376, 0.00944675225764513, 0.05637764185667038, 0.030486484989523888, -0.03990864008665085, -0.035642944276332855, 0.00034859965671785176, 0.027059009298682213, 0.011314593255519867, 0.007006803061813116, -0.025918813422322273, 0.0003011831140611321, -0.02061477117240429, -0.042483851313591, 0.031161420047283173, -0.012705888599157333, 0.026753701269626617, 0.03214387595653534, 0.011994740925729275, 0.0022169200237840414, -0.06110621243715286, -0.003930593375116587, -0.020429370924830437, -0.0017454058397561312, -0.027559109032154083, -0.04297378286719322, 0.027826132252812386, 0.013648821972310543, 0.053591758012771606, -0.04886321350932121, -0.008716664277017117, 0.05918582156300545, 0.04299566149711609, -0.01577940583229065, -0.028909198939800262, -0.01449271198362112, 0.020209548994898796, -0.0012064538896083832, -0.011310008354485035, 0.036680322140455246, 0.034373361617326736, 0.06128433719277382, 0.01073849480599165, 0.010015313513576984, -0.05034736916422844, -0.0015440542483702302, -0.0034881210885941982, -0.03801804035902023, 0.011972200125455856, 0.05300632119178772, 0.02515757828950882, -0.007715447340160608, -0.005863814149051905, 0.0009199695778079331, 0.013097267597913742, 0.005497919861227274, -0.02856632135808468, -0.04171546921133995, -0.0006806933670304716, -0.019394222646951675, 0.010468166321516037, -0.026155047118663788, 0.007740464527159929, 0.009021789766848087, -0.001529919682070613, -0.0012748670997098088, -0.0018532590474933386, -0.020807864144444466, 0.004784111864864826, -0.03141549974679947, -0.01319945603609085, 0.057829927653074265, 0.018966220319271088, 0.001874264795333147, -0.013679884374141693, 0.00989086739718914, -0.02825348637998104, 0.03996295854449272, -0.030672119930386543, -0.021244117990136147, 0.017468487843871117, -0.016729429364204407, -0.009534663520753384, -0.0013256220845505595, 0.022560814395546913, 0.03694131225347519, 0.03581695258617401, -0.012036734260618687, -0.018872803077101707, 0.05073752999305725, 0.003569049062207341, 0.02705398201942444, -0.015522696077823639, -0.004934174474328756, 0.01000157929956913, -0.008412417955696583, 0.02832273207604885, -0.004930619150400162, 0.02617037110030651, 0.01761803589761257, -0.007624882273375988, -0.022865677252411842, -0.038252875208854675, 0.030761240050196648, 0.010907149873673916, -0.0218016617000103, -0.00996383000165224, -0.01139339990913868, 0.04046693444252014, 0.031922873109579086, -0.03403414785861969, 0.03139474615454674, -0.05000441148877144, -0.008821946568787098, -0.09409794211387634, -0.03222707659006119, 0.048561032861471176, 0.033413488417863846, 0.01864112913608551, -0.06742183864116669, 0.002895396202802658, 0.03314284607768059, -0.037859417498111725, -0.05448802560567856, 0.004388776142150164, 0.016682548448443413, -0.002765257842838764, 0.03699200972914696, -0.024932458996772766, 0.015413286164402962, 0.020285340026021004, 0.022036753594875336, 0.002296040067449212, 0.04081224277615547, -0.0041735474951565266, -0.011932078748941422, -0.015901533886790276, 0.033424269407987595, 0.009041089564561844, -0.0776044949889183, 0.055614322423934937, -0.03580119088292122, 0.023830140009522438, 0.009704860858619213, 0.02517511136829853, 0.006302488502115011, -0.02445259876549244, 0.0065957605838775635, 0.013679001480340958, 0.03245792165398598, 0.010015694424510002, 0.017175348475575447, 0.03659810498356819, -0.019804466515779495, 0.023797575384378433, 0.013544912450015545, -0.05784028023481369, -0.058883026242256165, 0.060865774750709534, 0.018397660925984383, -0.05021445453166962, 0.013858691789209843, 0.009930817410349846, -0.05388671159744263, 0.02025509439408779, -0.00823049247264862, -0.013052847236394882, -0.025978805497288704, 0.06875938922166824, -0.017943566665053368, -0.022234734147787094, 0.04387246444821358, 0.017981745302677155, -0.016752349212765694, 0.002919872524216771, -0.006983742583543062, -0.06604178249835968, 0.03596094623208046, 0.016209939494729042, -0.026784075424075127, -0.031784769147634506, 0.00065797776915133, -0.008006551302969456, 0.0218792837113142, 0.02282221056520939, -0.02326168119907379, -0.04308467358350754, -0.016680890694260597, -0.003226611064746976, -0.008445972576737404, -0.0005750388954766095, -0.004773250315338373, -0.0044511170126497746, -0.05824888497591019, 0.05400221049785614, 0.039174649864435196, -0.002793604275211692, -0.02676679566502571, -0.012691622599959373, -0.046603914350271225, 0.010697131045162678, 0.07773337513208389, 0.010532006621360779, 0.006993630900979042, 0.008773276582360268, 0.03606390580534935, 0.04759149253368378, -0.05214175581932068, 0.031560614705085754, -0.03769553825259209, 0.008933315984904766, -0.011782145127654076, 0.00918700359761715, -0.013522517867386341, 0.004799438640475273, 0.03808905929327011, -0.021932918578386307, 0.004924714099615812, 0.005151411518454552, -0.0361357219517231, 0.0012484515318647027, 0.01924104057252407, -0.03321095183491707, 0.06917732954025269, -0.010891900397837162, -0.0013008868554607034, 0.008627891540527344, -0.03882722184062004, -0.04806946963071823, 0.02755594439804554, -0.045035090297460556, -0.011142043396830559, -0.0342668853700161, 0.023476749658584595, 0.021412895992398262, -0.08436179906129837, -0.005087919998914003, 0.03875783458352089, -0.03521883115172386, -0.012329685501754284, 0.050939127802848816, 0.055814508348703384, 0.0389498732984066, 0.02993486449122429, 0.022297797724604607, -0.0010794807458296418, -0.024176055565476418, 0.0077986824326217175, -0.002154189394786954, 0.02834988757967949, -0.026679860427975655, -0.005518381018191576, 0.0234222412109375, -0.027887647971510887, 0.022451845929026604, -0.00407462939620018, 0.03787413239479065, -0.043588411062955856, -0.030164845287799835, 0.01933070458471775, -0.02655349113047123, -0.001797507400624454, 0.0047674947418272495, -0.02981441281735897, 0.0635111927986145, -0.04719755798578262, 0.023955248296260834, -0.028755847364664078, -0.02117770165205002, -0.036900315433740616, 0.0176656823605299, 0.046322207897901535, 0.03247785195708275, 0.02530457265675068, 0.01856060139834881, -0.020737342536449432, -0.004015242215245962, 0.03239580616354942, -0.037270985543727875, 0.018918992951512337, 0.0157486442476511, -0.0016350623918697238, 0.005488134920597076, -0.0018717828206717968, -0.005008387845009565, 0.022186873480677605, -0.005855989176779985, 0.020359965041279793, 0.014216143637895584, -0.004862332250922918, -0.030995238572359085, -0.010602928698062897, 0.061967883259058, -0.05641534924507141, 0.039022497832775116, -0.031721752136945724, -0.006863634567707777, -0.0054029920138418674, -0.04445184767246246 ]
<p>I have a <code>SPSS</code> Output for a logistic regression. This output reports two measure for the model fit, <code>Cox &amp; Snell</code> and <code>Nagelkerke</code>.</p> <p>So as a rule of thumb, which of these R² measures would you report as the model fit?</p> <p>Or, which of these fit indices is the one that is usually reported in journals?</p> <hr> <p>Some Background: The regression tries to predict the presence or absence of some bird (capercaillie) from some environmental variables (e.g., steepness, vegetation cover, ...). Unfortunately, the bird did not appear very often (35 hits to 468 misses) so the regression performs rather poorly. Cox &amp; Snell is .09, Nagelkerke, .23.<br> The subject is environmental sciences or ecology.</p>
49,889
[ -0.04544641077518463, -0.02850964292883873, -0.0023245904594659805, 0.031197184696793556, -0.025406338274478912, 0.029107550159096718, 0.014273574575781822, -0.03648970648646355, 0.022540507838129997, -0.026596397161483765, 0.0418994314968586, 0.06162983179092407, 0.04047676920890808, 0.02669699490070343, -0.01578039862215519, 0.012415627017617226, -0.037371858954429626, -0.0006418111152015626, -0.0022482718341052532, -0.01420715730637312, -0.00861586257815361, 0.01313443761318922, 0.027657918632030487, -0.005951889790594578, 0.02368778921663761, 0.06826680153608322, 0.0373455174267292, 0.0014627387281507254, 0.008760245516896248, -0.02061682939529419, -0.05663316696882248, -0.025376949459314346, 0.002395218936726451, -0.010363412089645863, 0.02184186317026615, 0.010591333732008934, -0.018077310174703598, -0.009525645524263382, -0.014063805341720581, 0.05305003374814987, 0.015487794764339924, -0.012998132035136223, 0.03246141970157623, 0.010523349978029728, -0.014860711060464382, 0.036771610379219055, -0.02055671438574791, -0.0493091456592083, 0.005947049241513014, -0.030225325375795364, 0.05922609567642212, 0.026260094717144966, 0.007285819388926029, 0.030868524685502052, 0.005529806017875671, 0.0130250733345747, 0.03795093297958374, 0.040419355034828186, -0.02870979532599449, -0.04900556057691574, -0.03893997147679329, -0.027008870616555214, -0.021850358694791794, 0.01591760292649269, -0.022507525980472565, -0.0049668848514556885, 0.0167376808822155, -0.011469051241874695, 0.08685425668954849, -0.00668510515242815, -0.0008188937790691853, -0.012976576574146748, 0.052034102380275726, 0.01028645969927311, 0.03356429189443588, -0.05587625876069069, -0.004762486554682255, 0.0776926651597023, 0.029825974255800247, -0.014235615730285645, -0.015130307525396347, -0.025440195575356483, 0.002212026622146368, 0.041946277022361755, 0.019003111869096756, -0.0006408257177099586, 0.06912478804588318, -0.023589404299855232, -0.02545417658984661, 0.019110191613435745, -0.01379826758056879, 0.01946449652314186, 0.05886392667889595, 0.01685202866792679, -0.014539601281285286, 0.04439384862780571, 0.009304005652666092, 0.047290656715631485, -0.023744335398077965, -0.014848265796899796, -0.043833572417497635, -0.058795321732759476, 0.014026830904185772, 0.07923602312803268, -0.020854344591498375, 0.003302772296592593, -0.04778002202510834, -0.024027911946177483, -0.030136622488498688, -0.0464276559650898, 0.030081938952207565, 0.014452674426138401, -0.012176726944744587, -0.01692531257867813, 0.04331784322857857, 0.007798411883413792, -0.014589027501642704, -0.03127651661634445, 0.02970896102488041, 0.07981240749359131, 0.046341218054294586, 0.006515354383736849, 0.01028917171061039, -0.01649484969675541, -0.0538601353764534, 0.03024245798587799, 0.006155673880130053, -0.020988117903470993, -0.019230131059885025, 0.0352921299636364, -0.02392876334488392, -0.02837613970041275, 0.01457385253161192, -0.01973130740225315, 0.012241089716553688, 0.02945924550294876, -0.0853310376405716, -0.06997427344322205, 0.01773320697247982, 0.022475983947515488, 0.04210924357175827, -0.04128221049904823, -0.017115619033575058, 0.06048085168004036, 0.04345100745558739, 0.015659427270293236, 0.017045797780156136, 0.03529684618115425, 0.019107185304164886, 0.007998280227184296, -0.016467221081256866, -0.001048948848620057, -0.03568212687969208, -0.05787031352519989, -0.036188654601573944, -0.03929394111037254, 0.020745867863297462, 0.03032839298248291, 0.0027746555861085653, -0.0016959020867943764, 0.03803250193595886, 0.00013493100414052606, 0.025432409718632698, 0.004667582456022501, 0.0400213785469532, -0.0189942829310894, 0.06678729504346848, -0.010169697925448418, 0.03846457600593567, 0.021196046844124794, -0.003900794079527259, 0.0049522933550179005, 0.027397222816944122, 0.02520480938255787, 0.07181322574615479, 0.0031712574418634176, 0.03382999822497368, -0.03366909921169281, -0.027536666020751, 0.029178008437156677, -0.06516644358634949, -0.01876082643866539, -0.015871312469244003, -0.007777552120387554, 0.013701229356229305, 0.06901376694440842, 0.0023164539597928524, -0.01375075988471508, 0.10701067000627518, -0.031639840453863144, -0.03908573463559151, -0.03327767178416252, -0.0023721088655292988, 0.024854490533471107, -0.022221432998776436, 0.058734018355607986, -0.021818891167640686, -0.0028016753494739532, 0.017678996548056602, 0.0339365191757679, -0.015554443933069706, -0.028665754944086075, 0.06897153705358505, -0.018882397562265396, -0.00999465212225914, 0.07611971348524094, 0.039578717201948166, -0.0008943157736212015, 0.03955257683992386, -0.005751003511250019, -0.020726295188069344, 0.022435206919908524, 0.005286832805722952, -0.017615647986531258, -0.04584001004695892, -0.01411188393831253, -0.00025005495990626514, 0.03895166143774986, -0.03521927073597908, 0.013069701381027699, -0.0623285248875618, 0.03733993321657181, 0.039505522698163986, 0.023733152076601982, 0.0366540402173996, 0.028958052396774292, -0.02240871824324131, 0.017973730340600014, -0.04497814550995827, -0.005862236954271793, -0.031156882643699646, -0.007587139029055834, 0.018727626651525497, -0.0035421287175267935, -0.036827296018600464, 0.022241229191422462, 0.027045484632253647, 0.011508019641041756, -0.024920472875237465, 0.02901429682970047, -0.011605088599026203, -0.007715159095823765, 0.01920797862112522, -0.004185902886092663, 0.016103606671094894, -0.012761867605149746, -0.007917915470898151, -0.020146101713180542, 0.07188154757022858, -0.015708325430750847, 0.01847148686647415, 0.06373380124568939, -0.009653455577790737, -0.019303839653730392, -0.016706882044672966, -0.025831591337919235, 0.04799075797200203, -0.02152204141020775, -0.02426430583000183, 0.08915721625089645, 0.004501517862081528, -0.010188921354711056, 0.03101281449198723, -0.004022934008389711, 0.06300497055053711, 0.0486258789896965, -0.005035554524511099, -0.014138090424239635, 0.04139389097690582, -0.04353252798318863, 0.0064529068768024445, -0.03333089128136635, -0.021675927564501762, -0.052344392985105515, 0.015421565622091293, 0.03024160861968994, 0.009824802167713642, -0.003636507550254464, -0.013582306914031506, -0.0036177614238113165, 0.012262612581253052, -0.03148278594017029, 0.025679001584649086, -0.0037759561091661453, -0.04865149408578873, -0.002320278901606798, -0.0472082756459713, 0.038196977227926254, 0.01225112285465002, -0.022959304973483086, -0.03212108835577965, 0.039031315594911575, -0.03535671904683113, -0.02150646783411503, -0.03842731565237045, -0.03484782949090004, -0.03110683523118496, 0.013073584996163845, -0.03914426639676094, 0.020757751539349556, -0.0033870497718453407, -0.006019108463078737, 0.01827649585902691, -0.03136449679732323, -0.019339274615049362, -0.027027996256947517, -0.010179812088608742, 0.0336381196975708, 0.003559003584086895, 0.004461116623133421, 0.005749344360083342, -0.013005160726606846, -0.014755367301404476, -0.10848516970872879, -0.08734370023012161, -0.012941963970661163, 0.021681657060980797, 0.045016996562480927, -0.00937190093100071, 0.012551498599350452, 0.03790914639830589, -0.0013072730507701635, -0.01489882543683052, -0.06805461645126343, 0.015154263935983181, -0.05502864718437195, -0.0007099634385667741, -0.024915309622883797, 0.00013366719940677285, 0.059170693159103394, 0.024739405140280724, -0.03650742024183273, 0.019687701016664505, 0.018202759325504303, 0.007722463924437761, -0.015497378073632717, 0.05037778988480568, -0.014295939356088638, -0.02974918857216835, 0.030460920184850693, 0.035512927919626236, -0.021451445296406746, 0.046655476093292236, -0.020896118134260178, 0.0218045637011528, 0.02584691159427166, -0.0655624195933342, -0.03302241116762161, -0.021930567920207977, 0.0009576272568665445, -0.006603315472602844, -0.0027589111123234034, 0.013176965527236462, -0.033809736371040344, -0.01857723481953144, 0.007178113330155611, 0.016452185809612274, 0.016206804662942886, -0.01516489777714014, 0.06218567118048668, 0.012205485254526138, 0.014876713044941425, 0.024830380454659462, -0.023086484521627426, 0.004796645604074001, 0.018830161541700363, -0.019764473661780357, -0.046747494488954544, 0.05965578183531761, 0.0019406873034313321, 0.03199204057455063, -0.01895672082901001, -0.037543848156929016, 0.00486047612503171, -0.054333511739969254, -0.022236716002225876, -0.007863633334636688, 0.03702903911471367, 0.017647910863161087, -0.023070596158504486, 0.008802777156233788, -0.007147155236452818, 0.02452678233385086, 0.01821048930287361, -0.03677477315068245, 0.025055864825844765, -0.015887100249528885, 0.014628512784838676, 0.054542116820812225, -0.019948367029428482, 0.035857051610946655, -0.03192118927836418, 0.06972553580999374, 0.035287171602249146, 0.048765555024147034, -0.0011859923833981156, 0.0010687093017622828, -0.014089157804846764, -0.005188335664570332, -0.023174036294221878, -0.008886841125786304, 0.0016477161552757025, -0.016646897420287132, 0.05615873634815216, 0.05147183686494827, 0.0059841531328856945, -0.013659580610692501, 0.034658558666706085, -0.0020960376132279634, 0.010144534520804882, 0.002084277803078294, 0.007196246646344662, 0.006912102457135916, -0.010624954476952553, 0.01445841882377863, -0.0012280328664928675, 0.04000718146562576, 0.002643395448103547, 0.012965906411409378, -0.013749992474913597, -0.010077739134430885, -0.009995493106544018, -0.022705726325511932, 0.04291768744587898, -0.023604828864336014, 0.016549313440918922, 0.028831275179982185, 0.012343279086053371, -0.025103183463215828, 0.044638942927122116, 0.03205207735300064, 0.028282225131988525, -0.005232112016528845, -0.006700557190924883, 0.02990473434329033, -0.019319765269756317, -0.001218023942783475, 0.02714727632701397, 0.02786167711019516, 0.010653786361217499, -0.04529426991939545, 0.041427988559007645, -0.031084010377526283, -0.021561596542596817, -0.036575738340616226, 0.03056934103369713, -0.002418339252471924, -0.01438876986503601, -0.052689049392938614, -0.0035959735978394747, 0.0762438103556633, 0.020450806245207787, -0.0016563329845666885, 0.007257221732288599, -0.05957384780049324, -0.008190267719328403, 0.05171561986207962, 0.030468575656414032, -0.028671352192759514, -0.04683801904320717, -0.03468870744109154, -0.005855143535882235, 0.0044982885010540485, -0.021168090403079987, 0.009548261761665344, -0.019399361684918404, 0.018832044675946236, -0.022306572645902634, -0.0342017263174057, -0.041255589574575424, 0.03168811276555061, -0.006645269226282835, 0.04584166407585144, 0.008883357979357243, -0.04857702553272247, -0.02357759326696396, 0.009866537526249886, 0.010023213922977448, 0.031084539368748665, 0.015364992432296276, -0.03863440454006195, 0.011184044182300568, 0.018781213089823723, -0.0023793226573616266, -0.010163998231291771, -0.014336868189275265, -0.004637410864233971, -0.022730201482772827, 0.05512753874063492, 0.022695843130350113, -0.017659269273281097, 0.020911231637001038, 0.0017849543364718556, -0.019745081663131714, -0.012769084423780441, -0.03852332383394241, 0.012937179766595364, 0.04685991257429123, -0.011789660900831223, 0.04494335502386093, 0.05349617823958397, 0.002856263192370534, -0.019430851563811302, -0.04498971626162529, -0.005686053540557623, -0.012348350137472153, -0.03834300488233566, -0.0294282715767622, -0.024158140644431114, -0.03380836918950081, -0.0019256334053352475, -0.015071045607328415, 0.049995649605989456, -0.051123231649398804, 0.02730894647538662, 0.01176024042069912, 0.013715406879782677, -0.00458040414378047, -0.005714439786970615, 0.002875893609598279, 0.014236733317375183, -0.00009657511691330001, -0.005563897546380758, -0.015306948684155941, -0.017443794757127762, -0.044080182909965515, 0.036772504448890686, -0.00006270546145970002, 0.033636365085840225, -0.0020320643670856953, -0.017884373664855957, -0.0007746549090370536, -0.050557222217321396, 0.047671813517808914, -0.03594052791595459, 0.00004288971467758529, 0.010573232546448708, -0.04996241629123688, -0.03544823080301285, 0.027678556740283966, 0.025611354038119316, 0.05313095450401306, -0.012730329297482967, 0.04063344746828079, -0.023169750347733498, -0.01565883867442608, -0.07970796525478363, -0.03649386018514633, 0.009946410544216633, 0.026470305398106575, -0.03969130292534828, 0.008984421379864216, 0.005410527810454369, -0.01734897680580616, -0.0035400893539190292, -0.014090185053646564, 0.056717660278081894, -0.06487488001585007, -0.034005433320999146, -0.028778398409485817, 0.021551843732595444, 0.03786933049559593, 0.0030065649189054966, 0.005341034848242998, 0.024709569290280342, 0.0017038092482835054, -0.0010495982132852077, 0.023608572781085968, -0.00725264148786664, -0.02968251146376133, -0.029240578413009644, -0.046480391174554825, 0.028358543291687965, 0.010103855282068253, -0.009272855706512928, 0.024337537586688995, 0.0358242467045784, -0.021538417786359787, 0.002658228622749448, 0.01805509626865387, 0.015071175992488861, 0.0007870066910982132, -0.001455301302485168, -0.025555040687322617, 0.007073713466525078, 0.02471381612122059, -0.0012219675118103623, 0.01780010387301445, 0.020663954317569733, 0.013283990323543549, -0.0039176298305392265, 0.08669230341911316, 0.004628073889762163, 0.0444427952170372, 0.0001832733250921592, -0.007690469268709421, 0.04740995168685913, 0.03331678733229637, -0.006382509600371122, -0.018261630088090897, 0.023840423673391342, -0.0155195826664567, 0.006262880750000477, -0.040420353412628174, 0.0028660090174525976, 0.08581896871328354, -0.04200975224375725, 0.011016199365258217, 0.022546734660863876, -0.008462684229016304, 0.008102585561573505, -0.03717147186398506, -0.009124113246798515, -0.014827998355031013, 0.024639107286930084, 0.04180755093693733, -0.024723857641220093, 0.007601106073707342, 0.04493557661771774, 0.021704085171222687, 0.0161515474319458, 0.039462506771087646, 0.018334779888391495, 0.03465791791677475, 0.03727186843752861, -0.042239960283041, -0.043589409440755844, 0.008268160745501518, -0.028111500665545464, -0.002389419125393033, -0.01884663850069046, -0.011871837079524994, 0.039731040596961975, 0.0469796247780323, 0.003948833327740431, -0.06439206749200821, -0.005427082534879446, -0.057086024433374405, -0.001202315092086792, -0.0017117446986958385, -0.028609860688447952, 0.0027833429630845785, 0.022405922412872314, 0.02275213599205017, 0.0011132073123008013, 0.009775888174772263, -0.039844781160354614, -0.0558045357465744, -0.008840213529765606, -0.007860936224460602, -0.026257045567035675, 0.03205960988998413, 0.017525402829051018, -0.03119574673473835, -0.007298409007489681, -0.06485939770936966, 0.027181269600987434, 0.02524678222835064, 0.003929664846509695, 0.01161537691950798, 0.03950445353984833, 0.009670290164649487, -0.019377727061510086, -0.018342984840273857, -0.0348854586482048, 0.10985920578241348, 0.07418537884950638, 0.05472297593951225, -0.0640089213848114, -0.020556684583425522, -0.015207349322736263, 0.017849495634436607, -0.010417801328003407, -0.055381014943122864, 0.03815826401114464, -0.006434659939259291, 0.07208980619907379, -0.0062907421961426735, 0.03953448310494423, -0.014957806095480919, 0.025514287874102592, -0.0423719584941864, 0.014536352828145027, -0.0024457937106490135, 0.010216738097369671, 0.01401058491319418, 0.001779588870704174, -0.01013102475553751, -0.0022973050363361835, 0.014065371826291084, -0.01760847307741642, -0.04577384144067764, -0.03371657058596611, -0.016893168911337852, 0.017476992681622505, -0.019891446456313133, -0.0017310408875346184, -0.006656154990196228, 0.04905885457992554, -0.00615558261051774, 0.017672115936875343, 0.05842692032456398, -0.03321518376469612, -0.007862444967031479, 0.02799517661333084, -0.022499551996588707, -0.020105868577957153, 0.009958364069461823, 0.013586512766778469, -0.034670714288949966, -0.023231111466884613, -0.009413672611117363, 0.03189532831311226, 0.019115900620818138, -0.015673236921429634, -0.029527323320508003, 0.01390852127224207, -0.01044019591063261, -0.06511872261762619, -0.026438061147928238, -0.007392118684947491, 0.010707136243581772, -0.04539943486452103, -0.021104658022522926, -0.01410610880702734, 0.03588798642158508, -0.01998901553452015, 0.01821831800043583, 0.04490359500050545, -0.02112714946269989, -0.024511631578207016, -0.031110385432839394, 0.08366293460130692, -0.0038824817165732384, 0.020968634635210037, 0.028609391301870346, -0.006760210730135441, -0.0521886944770813, 0.004713444039225578, 0.028323177248239517, 0.0008850167505443096, -0.011274971067905426, -0.04072294384241104, -0.021786527708172798, -0.08149232715368271, -0.07264994084835052, 0.006575457286089659, -0.015407854691147804, 0.005295639857649803, -0.09065992385149002, -0.02297416888177395, -0.01384056732058525, 0.021518373861908913, 0.019041696563363075, 0.01593848504126072, -0.013777824118733406, 0.05789406597614288, 0.010956850834190845, -0.06813092529773712, -0.03167896345257759, 0.03359571844339371, -0.048560697585344315, 0.0021794417407363653, -0.011341475881636143, 0.05483891814947128, 0.0014579282142221928, 0.007816341705620289, -0.018790660426020622, 0.007361440919339657, 0.0019775270484387875, 0.0022261347621679306, 0.011393941007554531, -0.04996335506439209, -0.01870597153902054, 0.0032835383899509907, -0.004267002921551466, -0.042429372668266296, -0.016675060614943504, -0.0346636027097702, -0.03238872066140175, -0.029430555179715157, 0.009995055384933949, -0.03484633192420006, 0.029583681374788284, -0.004395599476993084, 0.008430923335254192, -0.020075449720025063, 0.017820090055465698, -0.05330585315823555, -0.028421906754374504, 0.026184750720858574, -0.0233868807554245, -0.012157676741480827, 0.03104373998939991, -0.003351402236148715, 0.03732378035783768, 0.017310693860054016, 0.021079879254102707, 0.05151957646012306, 0.01901821419596672, -0.01320566050708294, -0.016309749335050583, 0.0677475556731224, -0.03069334849715233, -0.02265061065554619, 0.008666946552693844, -0.032092612236738205, -0.04559863358736038, 0.04049599915742874, -0.01899637281894684, 0.008526378311216831, -0.022212257608771324, 0.05684380233287811, -0.06569088250398636, 0.04024801030755043, -0.0004492645966820419, -0.002412577159702778, -0.0007115977350622416, -0.006991255097091198, -0.018635544925928116, -0.01466242503374815, -0.009918180294334888, -0.021832862868905067, -0.018816355615854263, 0.045835964381694794, 0.060830917209386826, 0.01714484952390194, -0.0001556194620206952, -0.021948138251900673, -0.04248447343707085, 0.00327090616337955, -0.006678109522908926, -0.03271247446537018, 0.03749724105000496, 0.026941532269120216, -0.026043251156806946, 0.015934430062770844, -0.010482045821845531, 0.011297672986984253, -0.05247447267174721, -0.02668140083551407, 0.012386074289679527, 0.008278308436274529, 0.0012357246596366167, -0.03493256866931915, 0.022212661802768707, 0.04528558626770973, -0.029435228556394577, -0.0010983331594616175, 0.035224951803684235, 0.004066603723913431, -0.06468354165554047, 0.00867260992527008, -0.008400063030421734, -0.008078766986727715, 0.029343491420149803, 0.031493350863456726, 0.0221050214022398, 0.03884987533092499, -0.02710535004734993, -0.03841752931475639, -0.01700749434530735, 0.02340434305369854, -0.001667424221523106, -0.047565244138240814, 0.019725337624549866, 0.009214471094310284, 0.00788475014269352, 0.030534526333212852, -0.006971054710447788, 0.031491272151470184, 0.04879502207040787, 0.013995573855936527, 0.025994161143898964, 0.056670308113098145, 0.04901661351323128, -0.0003574116562958807, -0.012015581130981445, -0.022981485351920128, 0.011206726543605328, 0.03735503554344177, -0.023229192942380905, 0.0011833301978185773, -0.03694336488842964, -0.03253776207566261, -0.0482795424759388, 0.029636090621352196, -0.00939100980758667, -0.007909910753369331, -0.012700487859547138, -0.0057510738261044025, 0.01089103240519762, -0.0401170440018177, -0.010685212910175323, -0.051670487970113754, 0.024529000744223595, 0.02302074059844017, 0.0005030457978136837, -0.07319239526987076, 0.03938136249780655, -0.027997195720672607, -0.027755485847592354, -0.0326404832303524, -0.025418458506464958, -0.01005331426858902, -0.01737321726977825, -0.04251594468951225, -0.02409578301012516, 0.004888849798589945, -0.01996687799692154, 0.011998094618320465, -0.06719356775283813, 0.0401010699570179, -0.03024308569729328, -0.017002373933792114, 0.03485710173845291, 0.02251698635518551, 0.06710714101791382, -0.06695829331874847, 0.06510910391807556, 0.014210820198059082, 0.006293255370110273, -0.0380844920873642, -0.024711973965168, -0.017386164516210556, 0.013317626900970936, 0.05251936987042427, -0.014631671831011772, 0.007844507694244385, -0.02504171058535576, 0.021276453509926796, 0.028493143618106842, -0.01005481369793415, 0.062290258705616, -0.007856566458940506, -0.008936348371207714, -0.03493884950876236, -0.015925677493214607, -0.01845487207174301, 0.009866715408861637, 0.04868278652429581, 0.02694706805050373, 0.02694014087319374, 0.015330491587519646, -0.027418414130806923, 0.02107558213174343, -0.01987253874540329, 0.015903940424323082, 0.050562016665935516, -0.006246235221624374, -0.021863030269742012, 0.045712850987911224, 0.003452943405136466, -0.0456833653151989, 0.07807765156030655, -0.01926368661224842, -0.04786955565214157, 0.05154674872756004, -0.013297760859131813, 0.02127636782824993, -0.05547728016972542, -0.003930263686925173, 0.04252702742815018, 0.008147351443767548, -0.015929831191897392, 0.04460560530424118, 0.007451854180544615, 0.036272380501031876, -0.015468612313270569, 0.015324625186622143, 0.048626381903886795, -0.0002591184456832707, -0.019667791202664375, 0.012310950085520744, 0.03769080713391304, 0.0040526497177779675, -0.02055514231324196, 0.02470378205180168, -0.021377604454755783, 0.045827433466911316, -0.01795836351811886, 0.029785076156258583, -0.016513438895344734, 0.002094853902235627, 0.012980586849153042, -0.02568688429892063, 0.007123768329620361, -0.016678739339113235, -0.02470940724015236, 0.03853525221347809, -0.02168603241443634, -0.0026644498575478792, -0.05037572979927063, 0.0010067785624414682, -0.031090091913938522, -0.0038872421719133854, 0.05512881651520729, 0.008393731899559498, 0.015458885580301285, 0.019337933510541916, -0.0001451763091608882, 0.00021401714184321463, 0.036114100366830826, 0.0003181107749696821, 0.008232487365603447, -0.014444022439420223, 0.012855522334575653, -0.02777968905866146, 0.004003171343356371, -0.002275097416713834, 0.00453008571639657, 0.03721647337079048, 0.009053383953869343, -0.01404832024127245, -0.025110604241490364, -0.03344123065471649, 0.0053642201237380505, 0.07213673740625381, -0.04397163540124893, -0.037666551768779755, -0.028789030387997627, 0.015419427305459976, 0.0018139064777642488, -0.034074995666742325 ]
<p>I'm willing to apply machine learning with <code>R</code> (I will start with random forests then maybe have a look at NNs) on some data, but I don't know where to start, probably because I don't know which words to put on my problem and what to google for.</p> <p>My data consist in a set of events of type A, each of which contains both some specific variables and a (variable) number of elements of type B with their own variables.</p> <p>A typical example of such data would be horse racing : each race has its own parameters along with a list of horses and their own parameters.</p> <p>Now, of course the training has to be done on each element of type A independently, so tutorials using basic <code>iris</code> data won't work — or at least I don't understand how to apply them on events of type A instead of elements of type B.</p> <p>How should I organize my data set or feed it to <code>randomForest</code> ? Or which keywords should I use to find relevant documentation on this kind of topic ? (I tried "grouped data" without much success…)</p> <p>NB : For a start I can discard the common variables of each A event, if needed. But still every B element has to be considered equal of other B elements <em>inside</em> a single A event, and independently from other A events.</p> <p><strong>Update :</strong> I've found a workaround which may work in my particular situation (still to be tested, my DB needs reorganization). The workaround is to consider parameters of the A events as parameters of each B element, so the problem simply becomes a set of B elements. However I'm not satisfied with this solution and anyway I'm not sure it could be applicable to other similar problems, the question is still open.</p>
36,893
[ -0.033731669187545776, -0.03873150423169136, -0.021952718496322632, 0.03256678581237793, 0.03151725232601166, 0.008895942009985447, -0.023337550461292267, -0.048763033002614975, 0.00437065027654171, 0.008292561396956444, 0.04152945056557655, 0.019931044429540634, 0.011809603311121464, 0.03669914975762367, 0.031162867322564125, 0.0011793853482231498, 0.0044651878997683525, -0.0012302602408453822, 0.02241138555109501, -0.03786427527666092, -0.010978278703987598, 0.0016590137965977192, 0.016558293253183365, 0.015467515215277672, -0.011223220266401768, 0.03952893614768982, 0.008737889118492603, -0.02820711024105549, -0.026781434193253517, 0.03862529620528221, -0.03956574201583862, -0.041375353932380676, 0.0024979999288916588, 0.0420641228556633, 0.029581336304545403, 0.034049585461616516, -0.050712570548057556, -0.03118121810257435, -0.03844534978270531, 0.005955882836133242, -0.016590187326073647, 0.005574225913733244, -0.030969155952334404, 0.06780018657445908, -0.03103797137737274, 0.007343942299485207, -0.00287768617272377, -0.005059132352471352, -0.016355611383914948, -0.05961911752820015, 0.06302675604820251, -0.03138831630349159, 0.06458679586648941, 0.050376348197460175, -0.04182440787553787, -0.03634091839194298, 0.051897790282964706, 0.0740489736199379, 0.021524475887417793, -0.037780143320560455, -0.009696820750832558, -0.02632324770092964, -0.003586613805964589, 0.018532706424593925, -0.04475608095526695, -0.020643318071961403, -0.010415204800665379, 0.009113525040447712, 0.013276341371238232, -0.01975215971469879, 0.04045256972312927, 0.029525291174650192, 0.045341525226831436, 0.031316954642534256, 0.019086353480815887, -0.021957941353321075, 0.017012789845466614, 0.01618260145187378, 0.06077266484498978, 0.013371146284043789, -0.04411265254020691, 0.019321810454130173, 0.015442979522049427, 0.01573253609240055, 0.0518619567155838, -0.03072107583284378, 0.05564082786440849, -0.04373442381620407, -0.00031398507417179644, -0.04695325717329979, -0.03751198202371597, -0.02176145650446415, 0.028154615312814713, -0.01857890747487545, -0.07289518415927887, 0.04303404688835144, -0.020942987874150276, -0.011253277771174908, 0.023034386336803436, -0.014035511761903763, 0.0031135044991970062, -0.0549943707883358, 0.012021774426102638, 0.059815049171447754, -0.01913832314312458, -0.030491845682263374, -0.0394112765789032, -0.016693025827407837, -0.007132803089916706, -0.004320670384913683, -0.026213742792606354, 0.008617780171334743, -0.005639870185405016, 0.019906872883439064, 0.008679249323904514, -0.03885477036237717, -0.02169632352888584, 0.005501179490238428, 0.04723155498504639, 0.044710852205753326, 0.07896072417497635, -0.042229361832141876, 0.014558335766196251, -0.020816072821617126, -0.03128466755151749, 0.005428874399513006, -0.0005415230989456177, -0.010579190216958523, -0.04117455333471298, 0.041497133672237396, -0.018800843507051468, -0.01088530384004116, 0.028569504618644714, -0.01878107525408268, 0.0021753960754722357, -0.005291570443660021, -0.06780050694942474, -0.047102320939302444, 0.021080927923321724, -0.04250656068325043, -0.02627544105052948, -0.05084088817238808, -0.021839896216988564, 0.027071023359894753, 0.0511530376970768, -0.009535487741231918, 0.054892122745513916, 0.013018646277487278, 0.024081312119960785, 0.026483362540602684, 0.01362209115177393, -0.01280962023884058, -0.03519067540764809, 0.02341476082801819, -0.04916528984904289, -0.06170952320098877, 0.040458839386701584, -0.0009448918863199651, -0.035686708986759186, 0.03868303447961807, 0.0362018458545208, -0.032031040638685226, 0.012876869179308414, -0.0032671538647264242, 0.0428772009909153, 0.0022234907373785973, 0.06000804901123047, 0.027373429387807846, 0.06199484318494797, 0.02004762925207615, 0.024102075025439262, 0.03031052276492119, 0.04559531435370445, 0.030930737033486366, 0.07289573550224304, -0.016968034207820892, -0.0032707196660339832, 0.010729454457759857, 0.0056706820614635944, 0.002631793962791562, -0.009642641060054302, -0.06685703992843628, -0.007993384264409542, 0.013797340914607048, 0.03235814720392227, 0.03521612286567688, 0.029027791693806648, -0.009941093623638153, 0.06811971962451935, -0.02907441183924675, -0.010507039725780487, -0.0732252448797226, -0.019653160125017166, -0.05244690552353859, 0.004264350980520248, 0.031916067004203796, -0.00747198099270463, -0.002378008794039488, -0.006683447863906622, -0.04331646114587784, -0.038837283849716187, 0.03032696060836315, 0.03280866518616676, -0.031490229070186615, -0.03509585186839104, 0.03297415003180504, -0.004726890940219164, -0.030813556164503098, 0.04030988737940788, -0.030852962285280228, -0.06593597680330276, 0.007708841469138861, -0.05474754050374031, -0.009137419052422047, -0.01294333953410387, -0.015902364626526833, 0.03163300082087517, 0.019283326342701912, -0.03885911777615547, -0.007287411950528622, -0.07155491411685944, 0.05038582161068916, 0.05517236888408661, 0.017359714955091476, -0.0001586269645486027, 0.012364629656076431, 0.02903994359076023, 0.024810291826725006, -0.014109622687101364, -0.013752816244959831, -0.06044354289770126, -0.019811678677797318, 0.027046842500567436, -0.0030304540414363146, -0.04395686462521553, 0.015323511324822903, 0.061567407101392746, 0.04915134236216545, 0.018305158242583275, 0.060046520084142685, -0.022160422056913376, 0.005535779520869255, 0.03189048171043396, 0.030151350423693657, 0.013209959492087364, 0.01697530783712864, 0.0299898162484169, -0.00772658409550786, 0.007152638863772154, -0.0033580437302589417, 0.023725369945168495, 0.03944006562232971, 0.04596051201224327, -0.004372805822640657, -0.025233324617147446, -0.039045512676239014, 0.031372327357530594, -0.03313153237104416, -0.00717459712177515, 0.03722398728132248, 0.051244743168354034, -0.03895484656095505, 0.01887837052345276, -0.01696566492319107, 0.036497075110673904, 0.030477959662675858, -0.0006128008826635778, 0.042017024010419846, 0.01794322021305561, -0.0066543021239340305, 0.011033376678824425, -0.006954699754714966, -0.028871305286884308, -0.0631406307220459, 0.028768427670001984, 0.01691966876387596, 0.0055350190959870815, 0.023493731394410133, -0.024477561935782433, -0.004983148537576199, -0.015359986573457718, -0.009034699760377407, 0.0006806188030168414, -0.0015871193027123809, -0.043984994292259216, 0.018219808116555214, -0.005805185995995998, -0.02274085395038128, 0.03630315884947777, 0.00758527684956789, -0.0587192140519619, 0.03156808763742447, -0.0028491723351180553, -0.0545206144452095, 0.004561510402709246, -0.021693117916584015, 0.03335622698068619, -0.021117573603987694, -0.019419165328145027, 0.062287066131830215, 0.024366335943341255, -0.051274921745061874, 0.024920174852013588, 0.011376001872122288, 0.010966487228870392, -0.02737320400774479, -0.025004789233207703, -0.0005118556437082589, 0.0031157059129327536, -0.010484499856829643, 0.04416229948401451, 0.008236882276833057, 0.02088681049644947, -0.04063050076365471, -0.05254598706960678, -0.008395525626838207, 0.011210699565708637, 0.04587637260556221, 0.01963563822209835, 0.02618618868291378, 0.05270308628678322, 0.021517040207982063, -0.032804712653160095, -0.006659995764493942, -0.028749996796250343, -0.013430394232273102, -0.020298199728131294, 0.005528403911739588, 0.024896319955587387, -0.00420357147231698, 0.007930594496428967, 0.031081879511475563, 0.020269664004445076, 0.06402359157800674, -0.024117743596434593, 0.0029977408703416586, 0.05812859535217285, 0.06619416922330856, 0.006810125429183245, 0.04515994340181351, 0.050886865705251694, -0.030934380367398262, 0.02643837220966816, -0.006624503992497921, -0.016054753214120865, 0.023667391389608383, -0.0356089323759079, 0.031098678708076477, -0.028057491406798363, 0.015755154192447662, 0.00025465377257205546, 0.008646463043987751, -0.010672584176063538, -0.029909184202551842, -0.009656784124672413, 0.017539508640766144, 0.06701061874628067, -0.007465529255568981, -0.015147491358220577, 0.05517864599823952, 0.05731755495071411, -0.017816446721553802, -0.04801430180668831, -0.0393805205821991, -0.0036406831350177526, 0.0009061654563993216, -0.020092559978365898, 0.0446380078792572, 0.018897805362939835, 0.015915587544441223, 0.035692643374204636, 0.013212665915489197, -0.049084052443504333, 0.007973131723701954, -0.06654676049947739, 0.005213563330471516, -0.05113493278622627, 0.04881802946329117, -0.01799371838569641, 0.05795682221651077, 0.02065187878906727, -0.007815503515303135, 0.05263800173997879, 0.014781785197556019, -0.04924547299742699, 0.00006197969196364284, 0.0006941223982721567, -0.0077507104724645615, 0.015180700458586216, -0.02122705616056919, 0.035739753395318985, -0.013321418315172195, 0.0010292278602719307, -0.007576931267976761, -0.006420389283448458, -0.009736718609929085, 0.0029173402581363916, -0.03201578930020332, -0.057084597647190094, -0.002813249360769987, 0.004415490664541721, 0.004284045193344355, 0.016559626907110214, 0.0334409661591053, 0.03267167881131172, -0.0011656514834612608, -0.04507526010274887, -0.021522149443626404, -0.02043493650853634, -0.006939216051250696, 0.03751421347260475, 0.022931404411792755, 0.024068046361207962, -0.0485241636633873, -0.006293709389865398, 0.018522530794143677, 0.05404204502701759, 0.022863617166876793, 0.001226995256729424, -0.010356850922107697, -0.02484084479510784, -0.055746227502822876, 0.02477720007300377, 0.04540463909506798, 0.0359668955206871, 0.006918019615113735, 0.014309659600257874, 0.039367325603961945, -0.06791519373655319, -0.009775086306035519, 0.04542253538966179, 0.003828836139291525, -0.014707790687680244, 0.008215558715164661, 0.012087577022612095, 0.022884130477905273, -0.03029206022620201, 0.017440343275666237, 0.02950178273022175, 0.015639692544937134, -0.010191215202212334, 0.045376043766736984, -0.007103987969458103, -0.02900366112589836, 0.029639707878232002, 0.00961975660175085, 0.03544626757502556, 0.013396740891039371, -0.03209846094250679, -0.02507171221077442, 0.03499996289610863, 0.04176163300871849, 0.022179633378982544, -0.003416795050725341, -0.07575570791959763, 0.012654595077037811, 0.05166931822896004, 0.052325289696455, -0.0405435785651207, -0.032971497625112534, -0.03363681584596634, -0.034537848085165024, 0.018714115023612976, -0.05582014098763466, 0.015593334101140499, 0.009356771595776081, 0.01357950922101736, -0.04146003723144531, -0.02616691030561924, -0.007315434515476227, 0.03117549791932106, -0.04254293069243431, 0.07275719195604324, 0.00025355155230499804, -0.04985065758228302, -0.019415661692619324, 0.0027940368745476007, 0.039525676518678665, 0.0360330268740654, -0.03647950664162636, -0.04960531368851662, -0.017811741679906845, 0.004588528536260128, -0.006945247296243906, -0.07388482987880707, 0.00689428485929966, 0.012265052646398544, -0.00034935836447402835, 0.009088452905416489, 0.00037145637907087803, -0.04725738614797592, 0.016196507960557938, 0.009065747261047363, -0.009972873143851757, -0.012229671701788902, -0.043225739151239395, 0.052162494510412216, 0.05033592879772186, 0.005945093929767609, 0.023544905707240105, 0.010992069728672504, -0.01018929947167635, 0.0006617524195462465, 0.0002769375860225409, 0.0032241633161902428, -0.002821939764544368, -0.007509608753025532, -0.04450257122516632, -0.010295184329152107, -0.012951831333339214, 0.02620173618197441, -0.0028572282753884792, 0.011934737674891949, -0.03335503861308098, -0.02654683031141758, -0.042075831443071365, 0.009812631644308567, -0.030010832473635674, -0.04469268396496773, -0.006180699449032545, -0.006748254410922527, -0.0380333811044693, 0.015457645989954472, 0.026192329823970795, -0.040593795478343964, 0.008452551439404488, 0.0016614972846582532, -0.05717257410287857, 0.0062224119901657104, -0.08896913379430771, -0.022709030658006668, -0.00916710402816534, -0.02337963879108429, 0.0717519149184227, -0.008276157081127167, 0.04519389942288399, 0.03975403308868408, -0.02534434199333191, -0.027484547346830368, 0.010746925137937069, 0.030892789363861084, 0.002783764386549592, -0.06225813180208206, -0.0039638434536755085, -0.016492262482643127, -0.025364497676491737, -0.04230977222323418, -0.016959015280008316, 0.020404454320669174, -0.027052901685237885, 0.004319736268371344, -0.06322474777698517, 0.006581859663128853, -0.020452357828617096, -0.019092312082648277, -0.03337055444717407, 0.06693638861179352, -0.047511838376522064, -0.014072146266698837, -0.011916174553334713, -0.00892572570592165, 0.0852675512433052, 0.0338340625166893, 0.009561489336192608, 0.013679644092917442, 0.003867912804707885, 0.013787694275379181, 0.008361090905964375, 0.02077382244169712, -0.025548530742526054, 0.022276096045970917, -0.01151495985686779, 0.027431460097432137, 0.044681474566459656, -0.0012551158433780074, 0.036052193492650986, 0.012085387483239174, -0.020038746297359467, 0.010116561315953732, -0.03851310908794403, -0.009490592405200005, 0.026109302416443825, -0.0073222811333835125, -0.03293181210756302, 0.04246051609516144, 0.00870304461568594, 0.008637622930109501, 0.023755760863423347, -0.016545245423913002, -0.01125950738787651, 0.011728916317224503, 0.07859145849943161, -0.020805228501558304, 0.03318455070257187, -0.008863861672580242, -0.015449310652911663, 0.06182229518890381, -0.01097069401293993, 0.045218754559755325, -0.0055053140968084335, 0.011255172081291676, -0.0295034758746624, -0.012825982645154, -0.03420648351311684, -0.024583125486969948, 0.03371267020702362, 0.0007333370740525424, 0.056636493653059006, 0.06870167702436447, 0.02050960250198841, 0.02111341990530491, -0.026126954704523087, 0.0265470240265131, -0.014375224709510803, 0.031103547662496567, 0.03691108524799347, 0.019564663991332054, -0.0015157266752794385, 0.01956380531191826, 0.027937743812799454, 0.014117212034761906, 0.01891431026160717, -0.001374817336909473, 0.037147507071495056, 0.008838662877678871, -0.042026981711387634, -0.027395159006118774, 0.0034746918827295303, -0.05786106362938881, -0.007883514277637005, -0.024968689307570457, -0.02127934619784355, 0.05048574507236481, 0.06713647395372391, -0.0209834985435009, -0.014564490877091885, -0.026496564969420433, -0.08446746319532394, 0.01492137461900711, 0.018543945625424385, 0.009325426071882248, 0.006549030542373657, 0.007859759964048862, -0.0013483592774719, -0.015373151749372482, 0.006700715981423855, -0.04550487920641899, -0.06285404413938522, -0.031818896532058716, -0.03178681433200836, -0.039193831384181976, 0.04539867490530014, 0.006316445302218199, -0.03979634866118431, 0.01881358027458191, -0.012714534066617489, 0.001109776902012527, 0.011983739212155342, 0.023323437198996544, -0.037220548838377, 0.04776937887072563, -0.01180994976311922, 0.027655642479658127, -0.0048903170973062515, -0.008489242754876614, 0.12750674784183502, 0.06675500422716141, 0.08123087137937546, -0.042862795293331146, -0.004096693824976683, 0.018606191501021385, 0.0007571883616037667, -0.009200402535498142, -0.026746924966573715, 0.05027197673916817, 0.011875507421791553, 0.013737610541284084, 0.011474299244582653, 0.05358641594648361, -0.020504644140601158, 0.04767655208706856, -0.00007195015496108681, -0.0063404361717402935, -0.004208680242300034, 0.012369954027235508, 0.01939624361693859, 0.0034864135086536407, -0.03742599859833717, -0.0206333938986063, 0.04920513182878494, 0.005179653875529766, -0.018021712079644203, -0.015342592261731625, 0.004190627485513687, -0.018802663311362267, 0.03156764432787895, -0.00006956329161766917, 0.008680854924023151, 0.0208887942135334, 0.018992789089679718, 0.02347881905734539, 0.012122618034482002, -0.013711124658584595, -0.00039693067083135247, -0.00860076304525137, 0.039210040122270584, -0.022228827700018883, -0.014041878283023834, 0.0037848528008908033, -0.03780648484826088, -0.04821931570768356, -0.04105133190751076, 0.02738109789788723, -0.02739202044904232, -0.011758402921259403, 0.006029972806572914, -0.008269967511296272, -0.016291646286845207, -0.02008502371609211, 0.0022001343313604593, 0.007031040266156197, 0.034718964248895645, -0.028539570048451424, 0.008608845062553883, 0.010141170583665371, 0.03407787159085274, -0.03688004985451698, 0.006974029820412397, 0.013295655138790607, 0.008288492448627949, -0.010810298845171928, -0.07208891957998276, 0.020766081288456917, 0.00465998612344265, -0.005246770102530718, -0.025743724778294563, -0.027254285290837288, -0.0027331316377967596, -0.012750783003866673, 0.013760090805590153, 0.029177889227867126, 0.006702220533043146, -0.01145409606397152, 0.008007554337382317, -0.0011358580086380243, 0.018403170630335808, 0.0039788889698684216, -0.02223183959722519, -0.002726114820688963, -0.032738327980041504, -0.019368303939700127, 0.02093728817999363, 0.02738472819328308, 0.02406134642660618, 0.032050322741270065, -0.013879824429750443, 0.05151522904634476, 0.034814395010471344, -0.06337349116802216, -0.028525499626994133, -0.015016493387520313, -0.0428667813539505, 0.025484098121523857, 0.029757210984826088, 0.07404331862926483, 0.016687709838151932, 0.04073918238282204, 0.0047782850451767445, 0.016211599111557007, 0.012148983776569366, 0.01571403443813324, -0.005050269421190023, -0.06468496471643448, -0.008599722757935524, 0.02469765394926071, -0.010433780029416084, -0.030787598341703415, -0.04388626664876938, -0.016920626163482666, -0.022124774754047394, 0.028869302943348885, -0.039565570652484894, -0.04477920010685921, 0.014660686254501343, -0.036272332072257996, 0.013482248410582542, -0.01738814450800419, 0.017318639904260635, -0.03138094022870064, -0.04226034879684448, -0.0007378719164989889, -0.05137835070490837, -0.026375915855169296, 0.00000970888686424587, 0.02723127417266369, 0.014583363197743893, 0.001799413119442761, -0.02249934710562229, -0.003214057767763734, 0.01174721959978342, -0.002748131053522229, -0.012682992033660412, 0.05170184746384621, -0.014896232634782791, -0.028881970793008804, 0.02802208997309208, -0.0548594705760479, -0.002492016414180398, 0.0113602876663208, 0.01282558124512434, 0.05947929993271828, 0.014294256456196308, -0.027918173000216484, -0.0045852623879909515, 0.040310587733983994, -0.028408337384462357, -0.04105360805988312, -0.0002012077166000381, -0.0015950335655361414, 0.018666835501790047, -0.009379029273986816, 0.04702317342162132, 0.014418700709939003, -0.04033845663070679, 0.008983513340353966, 0.04485015571117401, 0.02439167909324169, -0.0443975105881691, 0.05404195934534073, 0.001532163587398827, 0.023229176178574562, -0.007915770635008812, 0.0056264158338308334, 0.027654385194182396, 0.014171522110700607, -0.022238973528146744, 0.010833187028765678, -0.014856435358524323, 0.028702571988105774, -0.08826570212841034, -0.02414955012500286, 0.0389392115175724, 0.004703357815742493, 0.04001102223992348, -0.05689452216029167, 0.004424800630658865, -0.043789368122816086, -0.05824548378586769, 0.0038787308149039745, 0.011667155660688877, 0.015079607255756855, -0.032106924802064896, 0.023119578137993813, -0.04687171056866646, 0.010312225669622421, -0.008954272605478764, 0.03273589164018631, 0.03112206421792507, 0.032895006239414215, -0.008898257277905941, -0.041446130722761154, -0.02822769433259964, 0.028026480227708817, 0.041277483105659485, -0.047453269362449646, 0.04231899604201317, -0.015188673511147499, -0.04572785645723343, 0.02974437177181244, -0.02662193961441517, 0.023422854021191597, 0.03123256377875805, 0.036290064454078674, 0.013666004873812199, 0.019748786464333534, 0.025399066507816315, -0.02084355801343918, -0.028301622718572617, 0.005325056612491608, 0.01274191215634346, 0.014662770554423332, -0.02602342702448368, 0.040594495832920074, 0.025296121835708618, -0.02848692238330841, -0.01486385241150856, 0.004299315623939037, -0.05692128464579582, -0.0540669746696949, 0.0066756680607795715, -0.004366982728242874, 0.01848781108856201, -0.0008713771821931005, -0.04573461785912514, 0.0025492010172456503, 0.05355891212821007, 0.011305870488286018, -0.013650523498654366, 0.02420320175588131, 0.021773487329483032, 0.00978660024702549, -0.033684391528367996, -0.009865078143775463, 0.030209461227059364, -0.028072962537407875, -0.037963010370731354, 0.014983823522925377, 0.006761365104466677, -0.014157761819660664, -0.026516780257225037, -0.016578136011958122, -0.006180430296808481, 0.019129540771245956, 0.01339954324066639, 0.0041324240155518055, 0.03249697387218475, 0.00994676724076271, 0.035982679575681686, -0.09482982009649277, 0.034325435757637024, 0.015400877222418785, -0.008979431353509426, -0.03432517498731613, -0.005785108078271151, -0.0344301238656044, -0.007185508031398058, 0.04565780609846115, -0.0269541684538126, 0.023984270170331, 0.02492496743798256, 0.018232280388474464, 0.014904893934726715, -0.01957658864557743, 0.047329194843769073, -0.035297565162181854, -0.011770427227020264, -0.029628274962306023, -0.04434413090348244, 0.0037443023175001144, -0.00862972903996706, 0.0016183456173166633, 0.0030413297936320305, -0.004540618509054184, 0.018187541514635086, 0.02091905288398266, 0.007055284921079874, -0.008913752622902393, 0.011665553785860538, -0.004097746219485998, 0.02049236185848713, -0.005273682065308094, 0.012488061562180519, 0.02412640117108822, -0.03650938719511032, 0.059385836124420166, -0.06617727875709534, -0.045496463775634766, 0.030413715168833733, -0.004052580799907446, 0.026938874274492264, -0.0814148485660553, -0.012272844091057777, -0.0013504595262929797, -0.029524369165301323, -0.0050059533677995205, 0.004147286992520094, 0.009984629228711128, 0.04935339465737343, 0.02278861589729786, 0.012429719790816307, -0.03629418462514877, -0.04959395155310631, -0.011798668652772903, -0.015705185011029243, 0.031608592718839645, -0.0010570470476523042, -0.023365233093500137, 0.03782190755009651, -0.012316128239035606, 0.05273057147860527, -0.020971713587641716, 0.016171671450138092, -0.005018416792154312, -0.012224129401147366, 0.01930277608335018, -0.019107608124613762, 0.0073453220538794994, 0.033807769417762756, 0.012357683852314949, 0.04139045253396034, -0.023587144911289215, -0.0012603697832673788, -0.060967106372117996, 0.02074573002755642, 0.0051870448514819145, 0.01915394701063633, -0.005872315261512995, -0.012333293445408344, -0.0015004391316324472, 0.0007059091003611684, 0.02368619665503502, -0.01163453422486782, 0.046605829149484634, -0.018232354894280434, 0.0436503142118454, -0.0011578748235478997, -0.04164881631731987, 0.003435681574046612, -0.0020121994893997908, -0.034801844507455826, -0.07940960675477982, 0.01718427799642086, 0.07144567370414734, -0.0017032255418598652, -0.015370682813227177, -0.011875267140567303, 0.017130935564637184, 0.026500103995203972, -0.0458495207130909, 0.023322543129324913, -0.048454832285642624, 0.017556840553879738, -0.01704213209450245, -0.023933669552206993 ]
<p>I came across a paper related to Bayesian decision theory where the absolute loss function is introduced somewhat straightforwardly. This is part of the result.</p> <p>$\frac{\partial}{\partial a}\int_{-\infty}^a (a-\theta)\! f(\theta|y) \, \mathrm{d}\theta$ = $\int_{-\infty}^a \! f(\theta|y) \, \mathrm{d}\theta$ = $Pr(\theta\leq a|y)$</p> <p>Since the upper limit of the integral depends on "a", differentiation under the integral sign can not be applied directly. I have been trying to adequate the leibniz rule to reach this result but I think the solution might be much more simpler.</p>
45,212
[ -0.017847338691353798, -0.03650937229394913, -0.00398118793964386, -0.056272413581609726, 0.032031409442424774, 0.016101757064461708, -0.023353563621640205, -0.005452199373394251, 0.020531343296170235, -0.007831676863133907, 0.009975172579288483, 0.0319741815328598, 0.07799462974071503, 0.06694227457046509, -0.006535574793815613, -0.01248777937144041, -0.020057274028658867, -0.02258487418293953, -0.04188356176018715, -0.029895184561610222, 0.007617151830345392, 0.04265346750617027, 0.02002948895096779, -0.03855755925178528, -0.00722203403711319, 0.0014998489059507847, 0.01751253940165043, 0.005503392778337002, -0.022373361513018608, 0.10133636742830276, -0.010847843252122402, -0.018422609195113182, -0.007541730999946594, 0.04918132722377777, 0.03398536890745163, 0.009504512883722782, -0.015445281751453876, -0.023003414273262024, -0.03095482476055622, 0.03541901707649231, -0.0020105624571442604, -0.027617188170552254, -0.002562059788033366, 0.07022208720445633, -0.03613147512078285, -0.013635581359267235, 0.046660009771585464, -0.05774162337183952, 0.035685040056705475, -0.06680842489004135, 0.05093330889940262, -0.002296230522915721, 0.05794333294034004, 0.03250693902373314, 0.01845528930425644, -0.03098907135426998, 0.0186629518866539, 0.0778416246175766, -0.006392699666321278, -0.04456087946891785, -0.03091517649590969, -0.03497983515262604, -0.010905774310231209, -0.02019181102514267, -0.016188306733965874, 0.005721199791878462, 0.005645291414111853, -0.06716801971197128, 0.021444931626319885, -0.00924601685255766, 0.008475876413285732, 0.017956674098968506, 0.024325285106897354, -0.021132661029696465, 0.011094974353909492, 0.003921157214790583, 0.009763846173882484, 0.020064570009708405, 0.013655546121299267, 0.05084073916077614, 0.007594490889459848, 0.024575548246502876, 0.07689795643091202, 0.05650470405817032, -0.0004974207258783281, 0.011342586949467659, 0.07101597636938095, -0.03138982132077217, -0.0032690444495528936, 0.030664987862110138, -0.047003474086523056, 0.025489619001746178, 0.011621760204434395, -0.048284683376550674, -0.05000942572951317, 0.04555821418762207, -0.01994450017809868, 0.018902916461229324, 0.004336104728281498, -0.04182271659374237, -0.02167579159140587, -0.04398084804415703, 0.0012802929850295186, 0.06672576069831848, 0.004913559183478355, -0.04501558095216751, -0.043514806777238846, 0.02737763151526451, -0.019543923437595367, -0.03440098091959953, -0.017146743834018707, 0.04195703566074371, -0.002645891858264804, -0.006924331653863192, -0.02954619936645031, -0.019286731258034706, 0.0022059939801692963, -0.027905786409974098, 0.001689838944002986, 0.07660021632909775, 0.0653277337551117, -0.020063135772943497, 0.03473848104476929, -0.01261756382882595, -0.06387032568454742, 0.025189120322465897, 0.009300378151237965, 0.013904988765716553, -0.04497557505965233, 0.019836071878671646, -0.011835712939500809, -0.008865786716341972, 0.045468199998140335, 0.0015829040203243494, 0.015257935971021652, -0.024438465014100075, -0.039392583072185516, -0.0449589341878891, 0.021681006997823715, -0.009020650759339333, 0.01906234584748745, -0.03687146678566933, 0.01844649203121662, 0.06600659340620041, 0.04967221990227699, 0.0507194809615612, 0.03927495330572128, 0.00659991754218936, 0.0019068740075454116, -0.016454709693789482, -0.028656840324401855, -0.005373126361519098, 0.005349546205252409, -0.015074221417307854, -0.023588532581925392, -0.051957812160253525, 0.04962841793894768, 0.014381364919245243, -0.01642988808453083, -0.04777674004435539, 0.051604557782411575, -0.01827716827392578, -0.01844038814306259, -0.030451131984591484, -0.00668284622952342, -0.042776044458150864, 0.10421903431415558, 0.04303101450204849, 0.008140064775943756, 0.013233626261353493, 0.042351022362709045, 0.006995123811066151, 0.00010894155275309458, 0.03422752395272255, 0.04228397458791733, -0.04034612327814102, 0.000689718930516392, -0.05673769488930702, 0.04189254343509674, 0.021378574892878532, 0.009458544664084911, -0.010365753434598446, -0.03836767002940178, 0.03333218768239021, -0.01941407285630703, 0.024019205942749977, 0.011814725585281849, -0.013517103157937527, 0.05203084275126457, -0.06961649656295776, -0.016055362299084663, -0.04167906939983368, 0.04621633142232895, -0.014906885102391243, -0.01313868910074234, 0.03763894736766815, -0.008178954012691975, -0.021726755425333977, -0.04713643714785576, 0.02001207135617733, -0.007597220130264759, -0.014255856163799763, 0.02640349604189396, -0.009494321420788765, 0.020283279940485954, 0.03895437717437744, 0.05607376992702484, 0.014408301562070847, 0.023982025682926178, -0.07476163655519485, -0.039801206439733505, -0.0033633625134825706, -0.04284055158495903, 0.05125638097524643, -0.009440706111490726, -0.021119292825460434, -0.011163300834596157, -0.01999933086335659, 0.011451018042862415, 0.006525280419737101, -0.07696432620286942, 0.04674070328474045, 0.050514377653598785, 0.02656088024377823, 0.023717006668448448, 0.039781153202056885, 0.008480370044708252, -0.00489982683211565, -0.00620020879432559, -0.03370559215545654, -0.030611833557486534, -0.015637634322047234, 0.061506133526563644, 0.025121057406067848, -0.02134077437222004, 0.015568231232464314, 0.03130345791578293, -0.040076516568660736, 0.048080556094646454, 0.014460479840636253, 0.0099085234105587, -0.04218485578894615, 0.0037254649214446545, 0.018022408708930016, 0.00046801730059087276, 0.020139804109930992, 0.00963856466114521, 0.0010681133717298508, 0.05409858375787735, -0.014976910315454006, -0.031176967546343803, 0.012048822827637196, -0.02974781207740307, 0.05165446922183037, 0.01820201799273491, -0.015561159700155258, 0.04064540937542915, -0.03681564703583717, 0.025173725560307503, -0.028251271694898605, -0.013286208733916283, -0.014193051494657993, -0.001093087950721383, -0.027960095554590225, 0.06017492339015007, 0.005719466134905815, -0.04230664670467377, 0.0055870418436825275, 0.027794554829597473, -0.01289658434689045, 0.021457882598042488, -0.017321817576885223, -0.028250370174646378, -0.016987299546599388, 0.006000634748488665, 0.03458625078201294, 0.01928953267633915, 0.006460592150688171, -0.013055720366537571, -0.028429027646780014, -0.023114733397960663, -0.006931765470653772, 0.006710506975650787, 0.01785244047641754, -0.0585496760904789, -0.006453396286815405, -0.005430277902632952, -0.0009179844055324793, 0.08039446920156479, -0.009838960133492947, -0.008675781078636646, -0.010098264552652836, -0.015678247436881065, -0.06745269149541855, -0.018705114722251892, -0.00904097966849804, -0.006166625302284956, -0.015514385886490345, -0.012721913866698742, 0.022118695080280304, 0.0008340940694324672, -0.006534668151289225, 0.02725997567176819, -0.01742476038634777, -0.04839765280485153, -0.033677518367767334, 0.03020503744482994, 0.01398217212408781, -0.016035260632634163, 0.011051423847675323, 0.021656842902302742, -0.052276063710451126, -0.008904712274670601, -0.09266112744808197, -0.06420066207647324, 0.008230002596974373, 0.006675976328551769, 0.0014965421287342906, 0.009992978535592556, -0.03170579671859741, 0.09181176871061325, 0.030283739790320396, -0.031053639948368073, 0.004887535236775875, 0.014513272792100906, 0.007507929112762213, -0.007605071645230055, -0.03506208583712578, 0.008040583692491055, -0.028226245194673538, 0.0398864671587944, -0.001947714015841484, 0.021865034475922585, 0.03506467118859291, 0.017605943605303764, -0.006157599855214357, 0.03420595824718475, 0.020925700664520264, -0.0019709179177880287, 0.03455880656838417, 0.0552726574242115, 0.009965081699192524, 0.03697540983557701, -0.011547899805009365, 0.04902547225356102, -0.009767156094312668, -0.02830098569393158, 0.029727159067988396, -0.020689265802502632, 0.008228725753724575, -0.025926966220140457, 0.021247263997793198, -0.02358718030154705, -0.009242492727935314, 0.0193195678293705, 0.01730596087872982, 0.01954069919884205, -0.0317903570830822, 0.023503897711634636, 0.039628271013498306, 0.03730981424450874, -0.01391671597957611, -0.04322536662220955, -0.0008128178888000548, -0.0039741527289152145, 0.012367486022412777, -0.0200054869055748, -0.007945706136524677, 0.006859683431684971, 0.011489600874483585, -0.005285048391669989, -0.019743744283914566, -0.02340685762465, -0.008215837180614471, -0.007200436666607857, 0.019118383526802063, -0.017049923539161682, 0.031602051109075546, 0.03250836580991745, 0.04597035050392151, 0.033554039895534515, 0.028639938682317734, 0.027392148971557617, 0.02849269099533558, -0.11475103348493576, 0.007212347351014614, -0.0040793390944600105, -0.025071531534194946, -0.010429413057863712, 0.0023264684714376926, 0.055538732558488846, -0.04858732223510742, -0.0024541434831917286, -0.024782130494713783, -0.0019037614110857248, -0.06452248990535736, 0.01130037009716034, -0.02056233398616314, -0.031896624714136124, -0.05419057607650757, 0.0008347234106622636, 0.03091711364686489, -0.027189716696739197, 0.015692895278334618, 0.03863385692238808, -0.035749275237321854, -0.03447752818465233, -0.04066208004951477, 0.005425162613391876, 0.03384009003639221, 0.042274877429008484, 0.019102079793810844, 0.015729442238807678, -0.03586549684405327, 0.030773768201470375, -0.01056983508169651, 0.06806415319442749, 0.027698710560798645, -0.013683946803212166, -0.04857421666383743, -0.07447665929794312, -0.011362909339368343, -0.011096145026385784, 0.011548349633812904, -0.019670819863677025, -0.02054818905889988, 0.029802320525050163, 0.006428317632526159, -0.012416062876582146, -0.003586558625102043, 0.027530556544661522, -0.0020822188816964626, 0.014541451819241047, -0.017812101170420647, 0.011232428252696991, -0.011581817641854286, 0.011702382005751133, -0.004523548763245344, -0.008267364464700222, -0.03693976625800133, -0.01902838796377182, 0.021731426939368248, -0.0019260758999735117, 0.0018570059910416603, -0.011292229406535625, -0.005548812448978424, 0.020614847540855408, 0.02035669982433319, -0.030584461987018585, 0.0375744067132473, 0.02191188745200634, 0.03836299851536751, 0.02567443624138832, -0.005199688486754894, -0.02512521855533123, -0.009992515668272972, 0.04250410199165344, 0.08165442943572998, 0.01206692960113287, 0.0030823382548987865, -0.053762126713991165, -0.06145746260881424, 0.051174458116292953, -0.004444862250238657, 0.03663508594036102, -0.043483369052410126, 0.016755878925323486, 0.012718934565782547, -0.07244489341974258, -0.022578001022338867, 0.010811155661940575, 0.002729981206357479, 0.006012513302266598, 0.010126329958438873, 0.010150461457669735, -0.0150128910318017, 0.010461246594786644, -0.0022554276511073112, 0.04685155674815178, 0.013060234487056732, -0.03157738968729973, -0.006166943348944187, -0.009934939444065094, -0.04104529321193695, -0.06232019141316414, 0.029082003980875015, -0.012308676727116108, -0.012077359482645988, 0.021236879751086235, -0.049723170697689056, -0.04526246711611748, 0.04129130393266678, -0.004011598415672779, -0.036853089928627014, 0.048860516399145126, 0.010432735085487366, 0.052421074360609055, 0.05000557750463486, -0.011750034056603909, 0.0512041300535202, -0.0002823349495884031, 0.012643218040466309, 0.0054205660708248615, -0.024920305237174034, 0.012565180659294128, -0.009434428997337818, 0.005175948143005371, -0.05264654755592346, -0.02664918079972267, -0.0509711429476738, 0.006379719823598862, 0.030935244634747505, -0.008923429995775223, -0.014238166622817516, -0.018446747213602066, -0.039050158113241196, -0.005328300874680281, -0.03215143084526062, -0.017279595136642456, 0.009134235791862011, 0.034308288246393204, 0.026748672127723694, 0.04310004413127899, 0.016454923897981644, -0.042645495384931564, 0.020171374082565308, 0.03252065181732178, -0.021248962730169296, 0.013398364186286926, -0.02816152572631836, -0.018851758912205696, 0.05975307524204254, -0.026369061321020126, 0.029755981639027596, -0.01977817714214325, 0.0037510700058192015, -0.018282325938344002, 0.0031721568666398525, -0.04530034959316254, 0.00046660524094477296, -0.03144921362400055, 0.04742015153169632, -0.06303499639034271, -0.02633453905582428, -0.046397991478443146, 0.001275087590329349, -0.06377344578504562, -0.014171055518090725, 0.008325417526066303, 0.011590804904699326, -0.015800492838025093, -0.02626240812242031, -0.009981458075344563, 0.015232890844345093, -0.0247344933450222, 0.0019365233602002263, 0.03756130114197731, -0.042789679020643234, 0.029557012021541595, -0.0013003478525206447, -0.006129151210188866, 0.05030819773674011, 0.008629001677036285, 0.014542604796588421, 0.02353537641465664, -0.01678602211177349, 0.010400800965726376, 0.024840401485562325, 0.02168072760105133, -0.02980390004813671, 0.002440911717712879, 0.0166516974568367, 0.004839527420699596, 0.006307372357696295, -0.004525958094745874, -0.033100008964538574, -0.0068929921835660934, 0.006612032651901245, -0.019742058590054512, 0.0009309687302447855, 0.014098312705755234, -0.0020161874126642942, -0.00945526547729969, -0.001099180313758552, -0.03485962375998497, 0.0013688027393072844, -0.01641712337732315, 0.021561026573181152, 0.0110131511464715, 0.012816247530281544, 0.0006887335912324488, 0.07463136315345764, -0.014901069924235344, -0.0221581868827343, 0.05294756591320038, -0.0006617638864554465, 0.04316067323088646, -0.033180613070726395, 0.019520875066518784, -0.021507475525140762, -0.010309979319572449, -0.054968055337667465, -0.03438596427440643, -0.08122888952493668, 0.00996859185397625, 0.02612735517323017, 0.015599280595779419, 0.020079247653484344, 0.020217344164848328, 0.01196309830993414, -0.03211532533168793, -0.06304039061069489, -0.06966997683048248, 0.005829834379255772, -0.03802609443664551, 0.025157945230603218, 0.003242830978706479, 0.01275071781128645, 0.033445749431848526, 0.011743538081645966, -0.036620888859033585, 0.02428337000310421, -0.006612672004848719, 0.03268423303961754, 0.030056502670049667, -0.017641225829720497, -0.024445224553346634, -0.004057507496327162, -0.04508141428232193, 0.03185534104704857, -0.01055331714451313, -0.03877906873822212, 0.060493580996990204, 0.03878491371870041, 0.00286390190012753, -0.024390140548348427, -0.011356884613633156, -0.024757254868745804, 0.020139647647738457, 0.05161668732762337, 0.03944660723209381, 0.047972287982702255, 0.0016156217316165566, 0.014230425469577312, -0.0050280154682695866, 0.03941554203629494, -0.01830069161951542, -0.03316217660903931, -0.03483208268880844, -0.05293968692421913, -0.05174783244729042, 0.019890883937478065, -0.013353105634450912, 0.002582334680482745, 0.012506633996963501, -0.031523317098617554, 0.025739943608641624, 0.037149909883737564, 0.015760255977511406, -0.006621874403208494, 0.05979754403233528, -0.018254349008202553, 0.03652322664856911, 0.0038932268507778645, -0.00009187155228573829, 0.12228479236364365, 0.06252126395702362, 0.02677360363304615, -0.055724095553159714, 0.015996472910046577, -0.02376256324350834, 0.03199794143438339, -0.060278814285993576, 0.01503666304051876, 0.015400745905935764, 0.0008405605331063271, 0.010183751583099365, 0.03211182728409767, -0.0003107299271505326, -0.04044118523597717, 0.05309195816516876, -0.0332363024353981, -0.0106690414249897, 0.038360051810741425, 0.03265605494379997, -0.027016334235668182, 0.01318624522536993, -0.02777288109064102, 0.02720806747674942, -0.004842397756874561, -0.03464614599943161, -0.017740407958626747, 0.01674235425889492, -0.02777642011642456, -0.031703997403383255, -0.012316687032580376, -0.010071264579892159, 0.028002958744764328, 0.013138404116034508, 0.017885126173496246, -0.0013617619406431913, 0.03034041076898575, 0.0028443164192140102, 0.000027508667699294165, 0.034369565546512604, 0.03604719042778015, 0.0016878520837053657, 0.002096888842061162, 0.017678292468190193, -0.01823759451508522, -0.024034857749938965, -0.015780452638864517, 0.03748627007007599, 0.0033146615605801344, 0.005649860482662916, 0.01084008440375328, -0.04799896851181984, 0.024166671559214592, -0.013530977070331573, 0.013379150070250034, 0.05938704311847687, -0.006678223609924316, -0.0027781955432146788, -0.0317281037569046, 0.060438770800828934, 0.03400044143199921, 0.01852460578083992, 0.01385291013866663, 0.005051188170909882, -0.04087033495306969, -0.011639128439128399, -0.02178836613893509, -0.009738157503306866, 0.027913976460695267, -0.015338962897658348, -0.021686214953660965, 0.0029084528796374798, -0.03658420965075493, 0.0025623440742492676, -0.031037993729114532, -0.024480756372213364, 0.04687156528234482, -0.01135965995490551, 0.023130038753151894, -0.009521281346678734, -0.02317309007048607, -0.011384288780391216, -0.0731131061911583, 0.002689138986170292, -0.003672828897833824, -0.023998599499464035, -0.00016577247879467905, -0.011803295463323593, -0.028287570923566818, -0.03468538075685501, 0.025265255942940712, 0.03762057051062584, 0.02602454274892807, -0.020129237323999405, 0.010200844146311283, -0.00919833593070507, -0.04403182864189148, 0.01851549930870533, 0.028143424540758133, 0.05145877227187157, 0.0394989475607872, 0.06053739786148071, -0.004683319013565779, 0.005350168794393539, -0.03966453671455383, 0.013413062319159508, -0.02506466954946518, -0.035625018179416656, -0.007356570102274418, 0.011620779521763325, 0.02337154559791088, -0.023719020187854767, 0.0019598521757870913, -0.02003205195069313, 0.01550449151545763, -0.002677598502486944, 0.04079727455973625, -0.01608860120177269, 0.02277420647442341, 0.029637228697538376, 0.027360808104276657, -0.0025169348809868097, 0.03615138307213783, 0.0063580903224647045, -0.0020111410412937403, -0.0425538644194603, -0.015326268039643764, -0.014711183495819569, 0.02478490024805069, 0.0025128077249974012, -0.045393869280815125, -0.0018060164293274283, -0.0005015617934986949, -0.005280793644487858, -0.026830404996871948, 0.029007969424128532, -0.012556710280478, 0.029501404613256454, -0.011246777139604092, -0.03585134819149971, 0.0006879210704937577, -0.05968736484646797, -0.06196301802992821, 0.02463988959789276, 0.03268251195549965, 0.025097070261836052, 0.01623455435037613, -0.02182609960436821, -0.025718295946717262, 0.03883274644613266, 0.03571879863739014, -0.03372686728835106, 0.01167515479028225, -0.00347928237169981, -0.0034205045085400343, -0.00861289817839861, 0.024937987327575684, -0.003151305252686143, 0.03597041964530945, 0.005317642353475094, -0.005939649883657694, 0.0049661798402667046, -0.009657928720116615, 0.024953210726380348, -0.01812816597521305, -0.006235497538000345, -0.02050258032977581, -0.020379995927214622, 0.03827183321118355, 0.017698736861348152, -0.010364081710577011, 0.011371081694960594, 0.0049672978930175304, 0.0311202984303236, -0.10718240588903427, 0.007052126340568066, -0.024430464953184128, 0.03652675077319145, 0.035914886742830276, -0.08675314486026764, 0.05978288874030113, 0.017398260533809662, -0.01772601157426834, 0.012606293894350529, -0.016761884093284607, 0.02594757080078125, -0.045315634459257126, 0.002338814316317439, -0.044794149696826935, 0.028977517038583755, 0.0021786459255963564, 0.02179630659520626, 0.06586802750825882, 0.024927765130996704, -0.013910055160522461, -0.05153953284025192, 0.005571477115154266, 0.04223029688000679, -0.01902385987341404, -0.03757354989647865, 0.075372613966465, 0.005100231152027845, -0.037198252975940704, 0.05623030662536621, -0.018810218200087547, 0.02877158857882023, -0.0027600699104368687, 0.05460108071565628, 0.03869490697979927, -0.0006033602403476834, 0.015482168644666672, -0.011276391334831715, 0.02001677080988884, -0.0029310667887330055, 0.03170119598507881, 0.01022184919565916, -0.016344936564564705, 0.017011307179927826, 0.0040877582505345345, -0.023239579051733017, -0.061007071286439896, 0.016658475622534752, 0.004054810851812363, -0.018515944480895996, 0.0026270109228789806, -0.025669638067483902, -0.008733402006328106, -0.03871815279126167, 0.00004276846084394492, -0.014646638184785843, -0.005965201649814844, 0.06202365830540657, -0.020886920392513275, 0.0008815425680950284, -0.006307618692517281, -0.012221132405102253, -0.06700807064771652, 0.022675415500998497, 0.011934999376535416, -0.011110246181488037, -0.016336936503648758, 0.03195791691541672, -0.018344465643167496, 0.01139135006815195, -0.01398835051804781, -0.0025223949924111366, -0.05731319263577461, -0.018934771418571472, -0.0022071644198149443, 0.02373569644987583, 0.0018239901401102543, -0.023353945463895798, 0.006630455609411001, -0.10673606395721436, 0.0499991811811924, -0.004696348682045937, -0.03427676111459732, 0.018026210367679596, 0.00138595059979707, -0.010267236270010471, -0.03556125611066818, 0.04814589023590088, -0.002416561357676983, -0.014905883930623531, 0.01810377836227417, 0.007774934638291597, -0.04221373051404953, -0.03595944866538048, 0.01166005153208971, -0.032859500497579575, 0.020054029300808907, -0.03782321885228157, 0.020352574065327644, 0.029877444729208946, 0.027072247117757797, -0.027740195393562317, 0.028604187071323395, 0.00194018823094666, 0.01232389360666275, -0.03183289244771004, 0.02960258722305298, -0.012560090981423855, -0.0019964338280260563, 0.03071846254169941, 0.014068028889596462, 0.01978147402405739, -0.035117264837026596, -0.05108603835105896, -0.07943930476903915, 0.028613107278943062, -0.014367516152560711, -0.03409784659743309, -0.0028634387999773026, 0.0132369389757514, 0.031812336295843124, -0.04718796908855438, -0.019141416996717453, 0.06688562035560608, -0.03783363103866577, 0.020015345886349678, 0.04191097617149353, 0.007409658282995224, 0.0715620219707489, 0.02875692769885063, 0.024742860347032547, 0.022004250437021255, 0.009997492656111717, 0.017921268939971924, -0.00036059654667042196, 0.009653428569436073, -0.011513087898492813, 0.008664126507937908, 0.050803959369659424, -0.012645499780774117, 0.0232520904392004, -0.01555425301194191, 0.03161215782165527, -0.03330546244978905, 0.0029126210138201714, 0.005188014358282089, -0.024082181975245476, -0.02776584029197693, 0.008341476321220398, 0.004272666294127703, 0.08652324974536896, 0.018136542290449142, 0.018445951864123344, -0.02104441076517105, 0.021160269156098366, -0.03436886891722679, 0.024586983025074005, 0.020643986761569977, 0.014963383786380291, -0.03554200753569603, -0.0070763034746050835, 0.009630806744098663, -0.033753134310245514, -0.013247035443782806, -0.03297580033540726, 0.016482757404446602, 0.03437144681811333, -0.0035476661287248135, 0.0015504996990785003, -0.032438844442367554, -0.038032617419958115, -0.02253510057926178, 0.018795328214764595, 0.03439102694392204, 0.0635993704199791, 0.010428481735289097, -0.005004077218472958, 0.009081167168915272, 0.04261567443609238, -0.037239447236061096, 0.018622975796461105, 0.005766091402620077, 0.030891763046383858, 0.018777837976813316, -0.03235393762588501 ]
<p>in a one way anova F test when F=37.45; df1=5; df2=40 what is the P value? I tried several software, and the result is &lt;0.0001. I know it sounds weird that I need a really small number of possibility. However, I really need it for a publication. I greatly appreciate if anyone can help on this issue. Please let me know the exact number if you can calculate it.</p> <p>thanks</p>
36,894
[ -0.0561087541282177, 0.007749081589281559, -0.02129523456096649, 0.012111383490264416, 0.05776664614677429, 0.025456074625253677, -0.0015965444035828114, -0.027633599936962128, 0.0003256011987105012, -0.007112713064998388, 0.04296732321381569, 0.024763349443674088, 0.038529425859451294, 0.01783052645623684, 0.02075948193669319, -0.002253280021250248, -0.015591313131153584, 0.0008065112051554024, 0.0024068437051028013, -0.013490994460880756, -0.014343437738716602, 0.05148919299244881, 0.024421364068984985, -0.01697847805917263, -0.01834063045680523, 0.0785469114780426, 0.04533170536160469, -0.02056988701224327, 0.005455575417727232, 0.04995729401707649, -0.021643532440066338, -0.025748997926712036, 0.0008589695207774639, 0.02217116579413414, 0.034017499536275864, 0.01944751664996147, -0.011227789334952831, -0.016640419140458107, -0.01389117818325758, 0.01647532545030117, -0.0028262222185730934, 0.000392506190109998, 0.01244554203003645, 0.004610999953001738, 0.025459928438067436, -0.014472397044301033, -0.0021004886366426945, -0.015494237653911114, 0.035954054445028305, -0.031151611357927322, 0.08141003549098969, 0.016419943422079086, 0.06177796050906181, 0.03390587121248245, -0.013107063248753548, -0.009670238010585308, 0.0721868947148323, 0.03637493774294853, -0.014545255340635777, -0.06632581353187561, -0.061393674463033676, -0.03877176344394684, 0.0070359790697693825, -0.011090273968875408, -0.06302300840616226, -0.0038990159519016743, -0.0484231673181057, -0.01461829710751772, 0.03556312993168831, -0.016436327248811722, 0.01777501031756401, 0.0050806039944291115, 0.06573779135942459, -0.02296604961156845, 0.023389417678117752, -0.035451460629701614, 0.03741007670760155, -0.004294613376259804, 0.045058660209178925, 0.04710501432418823, -0.03884636610746384, 0.012348049320280552, -0.0027481841389089823, 0.030544303357601166, 0.024109113961458206, -0.02714436687529087, 0.06316260993480682, -0.02003096230328083, 0.006615796592086554, 0.02542673610150814, -0.05159671604633331, -0.031584788113832474, 0.06954623013734818, 0.015573293901979923, -0.015093009918928146, 0.03849010914564133, -0.025774214416742325, 0.055444106459617615, -0.031034378334879875, -0.003970147576183081, -0.0008663900080136955, -0.054586827754974365, 0.03515684977173805, 0.06493296474218369, -0.01116867084056139, -0.0052202255465090275, -0.005788139067590237, 0.012095602229237556, 0.0023609185591340065, 0.00036294490564614534, 0.0007557232747785747, 0.060079243034124374, -0.0005436610081233084, -0.020921042189002037, 0.04002406448125839, -0.025357119739055634, -0.02654307521879673, -0.002729169325903058, 0.07976491749286652, 0.04039301723241806, 0.06378356367349625, -0.013609937392175198, 0.027130084112286568, -0.028156815096735954, -0.026607276871800423, 0.008501057513058186, 0.010891636833548546, 0.005033108871430159, -0.017725365236401558, 0.09208560734987259, -0.014986308291554451, -0.027210095897316933, 0.02556445263326168, -0.005291217006742954, 0.023105109110474586, 0.035831548273563385, -0.07181182503700256, -0.0701766088604927, 0.03641631454229355, -0.03007531352341175, -0.015078475698828697, -0.08163363486528397, 0.0012244232930243015, 0.018596218898892403, 0.05063815414905548, -0.010553967207670212, -0.0005889544845558703, -0.010100494138896465, 0.03575048968195915, 0.02616547793149948, -0.041161585599184036, -0.005362244322896004, -0.036469150334596634, -0.041620343923568726, 0.006663267035037279, -0.06402295082807541, 0.009012577123939991, 0.0028464188799262047, 0.029858723282814026, -0.018864857032895088, -0.0008171608787961304, 0.00029110253672115505, -0.024779869243502617, -0.0026781826745718718, -0.007912537083029747, -0.019978336989879608, 0.07385966181755066, -0.027709534391760826, -0.012183735147118568, -0.015229013748466969, -0.02885437197983265, 0.01752735860645771, -0.014782947488129139, 0.03388463333249092, 0.036295127123594284, -0.002366777742281556, -0.027609433978796005, -0.026285821571946144, 0.060995250940322876, -0.0016864086501300335, -0.02304953709244728, 0.0165682602673769, -0.030173689126968384, -0.011275778524577618, 0.042679037898778915, 0.013962969183921814, -0.002463011536747217, -0.017588505521416664, 0.00851428136229515, -0.044941019266843796, -0.033678241074085236, -0.08786012977361679, 0.0072031812742352486, 0.011537867598235607, -0.021828729659318924, 0.001493087038397789, 0.00977617409080267, 0.008347898721694946, -0.025669779628515244, -0.03678413853049278, -0.04533366113901138, -0.03319421038031578, 0.02859344705939293, -0.05878479406237602, -0.02446451596915722, 0.07000800967216492, 0.06070198863744736, -0.02443058416247368, 0.06069047003984451, -0.058451976627111435, -0.016063233837485313, -0.02130153216421604, -0.02045566216111183, -0.00003376715540071018, -0.018493041396141052, -0.024175051599740982, 0.0021299091167747974, 0.020860580727458, -0.02491583116352558, 0.017093276605010033, -0.054596200585365295, 0.07185695320367813, 0.052818845957517624, 0.03657491132616997, -0.004398301709443331, -0.016649603843688965, 0.014262533746659756, -0.005729250144213438, -0.04554073512554169, -0.02359440177679062, -0.043597567826509476, 0.005121949594467878, 0.061904169619083405, -0.027351437136530876, -0.015101074241101742, 0.03368556872010231, 0.04719606414437294, 0.02843862771987915, 0.0031500784680247307, 0.056582238525152206, 0.0021463115699589252, -0.024289483204483986, 0.0014628811040893197, 0.03363046050071716, 0.04204985126852989, 0.0021533307153731585, 0.02237263321876526, 0.004813290201127529, 0.06567066162824631, 0.027428556233644485, -0.009465403854846954, 0.030676424503326416, 0.0021156456787139177, -0.0020382648799568415, -0.057183887809515, 0.015437709167599678, 0.014597619883716106, 0.0021050029899924994, -0.002929472364485264, 0.038799893110990524, 0.006309262476861477, -0.016297001391649246, 0.01278093084692955, -0.03094538114964962, 0.021496625617146492, 0.007145619485527277, -0.03854332119226456, -0.007114363834261894, 0.005095797590911388, -0.012641128152608871, 0.022977443411946297, -0.023411238566040993, -0.009428034536540508, -0.009850896894931793, 0.01508698333054781, 0.0017401243094354868, 0.00619836850091815, 0.05309595540165901, -0.038145292550325394, -0.02672402933239937, 0.008427939377725124, -0.03151855990290642, 0.01618541218340397, 0.00591822387650609, -0.06728751957416534, -0.012518473900854588, -0.013511080294847488, -0.007130536716431379, 0.025437651202082634, -0.003888980485498905, -0.01115285512059927, 0.040285877883434296, -0.011456272564828396, -0.036851558834314346, -0.03737601265311241, -0.01727232336997986, 0.01682226173579693, -0.02048564702272415, -0.0006523227202706039, 0.0017249035881832242, 0.01825772412121296, 0.010665085166692734, 0.012470989488065243, -0.021113798022270203, -0.019338827580213547, -0.029627442359924316, 0.009683004580438137, 0.026053640991449356, -0.02296329103410244, -0.007038685027509928, 0.0058353617787361145, -0.01113507803529501, -0.01867389865219593, -0.04103871434926987, -0.07044845819473267, -0.014829649589955807, 0.0037800143472850323, 0.009048689156770706, -0.007502271793782711, -0.02610095776617527, 0.060116082429885864, 0.03617692366242409, -0.04395313560962677, -0.044918399304151535, -0.0007288996130228043, 0.0023606684990227222, -0.025559965521097183, 0.02552741765975952, 0.0337679460644722, -0.023949984461069107, 0.06209469586610794, -0.011627650819718838, 0.0010484069352969527, 0.03369901329278946, 0.018637901172041893, 0.004369765520095825, 0.036660972982645035, -0.0009572951821610332, -0.01065835915505886, 0.03803502023220062, 0.030991651117801666, -0.009703296236693859, 0.012001881375908852, 0.008623072877526283, 0.04294456169009209, 0.0018715225160121918, -0.025097915902733803, 0.010125354863703251, -0.05340336635708809, 0.038054320961236954, -0.06631078571081161, 0.03564361482858658, 0.007329349406063557, -0.0164586640894413, -0.007704680319875479, -0.001051157945767045, 0.04104927182197571, -0.04354598745703697, -0.02556697465479374, 0.061398450285196304, 0.009782706387341022, 0.008273260667920113, -0.03034972958266735, -0.005160863045603037, -0.003878542687743902, -0.01684454083442688, 0.00964006781578064, -0.04306516423821449, 0.054452307522296906, 0.05437842011451721, 0.031237883493304253, 0.009775578044354916, -0.031605709344148636, 0.036151476204395294, -0.03138823062181473, 0.012355848215520382, -0.02001294121146202, 0.024254633113741875, 0.01061922125518322, 0.05595928058028221, -0.003338101552799344, -0.00017164107703138143, -0.027889132499694824, -0.004644865170121193, -0.05264239385724068, 0.06478450447320938, -0.012581507675349712, -0.05986399203538895, -0.032818298786878586, -0.0035439657513052225, 0.014026994816958904, -0.03866984695196152, 0.01995951496064663, 0.018305525183677673, 0.03758079931139946, -0.03462732955813408, -0.0007739510620012879, -0.004930214490741491, -0.010043777525424957, -0.007486238144338131, 0.030933333560824394, 0.03624720126390457, -0.029720906168222427, 0.05918823927640915, 0.02460191585123539, -0.047805577516555786, -0.03049432300031185, -0.013228186406195164, 0.004094872623682022, 0.016904566437005997, 0.058969028294086456, 0.024024290964007378, 0.017985409125685692, -0.025247769430279732, 0.04718119278550148, -0.006495202425867319, 0.05123564973473549, 0.07509610056877136, -0.0008798879571259022, -0.02243007719516754, -0.047237616032361984, 0.008070576936006546, -0.023994924500584602, 0.018814433366060257, -0.04832931235432625, 0.006712141912430525, 0.030515247955918312, -0.0003156792663503438, -0.07169180363416672, 0.01612776704132557, 0.07231642305850983, 0.017676271498203278, -0.032168880105018616, -0.04557505622506142, -0.029808759689331055, -0.029736975207924843, 0.016684208065271378, 0.009016620926558971, 0.02994919754564762, 0.024776261299848557, -0.021611928939819336, 0.019521232694387436, -0.025702467188239098, 0.0037872139364480972, -0.021041328087449074, 0.0029364326037466526, 0.018205109983682632, -0.013538654893636703, -0.04413623362779617, 0.009521665051579475, 0.04213408753275871, 0.038531579077243805, 0.033695124089717865, -0.012059519998729229, -0.05421815440058708, 0.02566317841410637, 0.024357469752430916, 0.04109122231602669, -0.06355271488428116, 0.02047836408019066, -0.011272188276052475, -0.003891753265634179, 0.033529795706272125, -0.009853183291852474, 0.0036668286193162203, 0.005291468929499388, 0.0001975366030819714, 0.011109473183751106, -0.004963168408721685, -0.07106684893369675, 0.0030857278034090996, -0.0028460293542593718, 0.008376264944672585, 0.001726042479276657, -0.039661068469285965, -0.03428800404071808, 0.009702711366117, 0.02900994010269642, 0.020951788872480392, -0.016905471682548523, 0.0035102516412734985, 0.019105738028883934, 0.03502105921506882, -0.00842377170920372, -0.03391334041953087, 0.030048880726099014, -0.017910713329911232, -0.0049239834770560265, 0.03465897589921951, -0.028017587959766388, -0.03551234304904938, 0.048987507820129395, -0.019558560103178024, 0.008131338283419609, -0.0239470973610878, -0.011634169146418571, 0.020115796476602554, 0.009196436032652855, 0.009853866882622242, 0.06714567542076111, -0.00549330236390233, -0.006513677071779966, -0.012764992192387581, -0.03461842983961105, 0.035038407891988754, -0.008506199344992638, -0.019521331414580345, -0.050890784710645676, -0.0015404247678816319, -0.02045123279094696, 0.02116312086582184, 0.03551732748746872, 0.012933942489326, -0.024742906913161278, -0.007370726205408573, 0.005633796565234661, 0.002302115084603429, 0.027380364015698433, -0.009586363099515438, 0.02024891972541809, -0.004582966212183237, 0.006692112889140844, -0.0072933584451675415, 0.0038339863531291485, -0.025999510660767555, 0.0013330995570868254, -0.0062010809779167175, -0.028767509385943413, 0.013410440646111965, -0.006730291061103344, -0.059556007385253906, 0.016200648620724678, -0.06735923141241074, 0.01591668091714382, -0.026181545108556747, 0.025121649727225304, 0.013093525543808937, -0.03630846366286278, -0.027457481250166893, 0.0596296563744545, 0.0029746938962489367, 0.06840788573026657, -0.05622834712266922, 0.041305411607027054, -0.03296887129545212, 0.010684140026569366, -0.04709907993674278, -0.01025705598294735, 0.06272304803133011, 0.02626340091228485, -0.03686174005270004, -0.025559967383742332, -0.05147818103432655, -0.02735282853245735, -0.011613751761615276, -0.01591365411877632, 0.0519997663795948, 0.0020005451515316963, -0.033003054559230804, -0.014167385175824165, 0.0010488985572010279, 0.06861133873462677, 0.0017933903727680445, 0.014140244573354721, 0.019878970459103584, -0.041070591658353806, -0.036383386701345444, 0.034525610506534576, 0.01948649249970913, -0.040890373289585114, -0.021129069849848747, -0.016096651554107666, -0.00757017033174634, -0.008405087515711784, -0.045324452221393585, 0.012011497281491756, -0.000988079933449626, 0.005956873297691345, 0.015729203820228577, -0.028119396418333054, 0.04356813430786133, -0.01831670291721821, 0.027990730479359627, 0.014037921093404293, -0.003881035838276148, -0.01599937304854393, 0.012481114827096462, -0.005438413470983505, -0.0038951144088059664, -0.0058189029805362225, -0.0012190218549221754, 0.09342865645885468, 0.0009798487881198525, 0.022874007001519203, -0.018759040161967278, -0.019561205059289932, 0.011104199104011059, 0.03655310347676277, -0.03816787898540497, -0.01984431967139244, 0.026429465040564537, -0.023405063897371292, -0.0061598969623446465, -0.0035866391845047474, -0.004896147176623344, 0.05069383233785629, -0.007322688587009907, 0.013569342903792858, 0.05985010042786598, 0.03222363069653511, -0.031155532225966454, 0.019906669855117798, -0.007643946912139654, 0.008678746409714222, 0.036543574184179306, 0.042191602289676666, 0.01106619369238615, -0.007069610059261322, 0.025640949606895447, -0.010307682678103447, 0.024515407159924507, 0.06351985037326813, 0.022767046466469765, 0.03196089342236519, 0.031287554651498795, -0.01595385931432247, -0.03754588961601257, 0.012412208132445812, -0.02630983665585518, 0.005267341621220112, -0.05400548875331879, -0.010764655657112598, 0.07208055257797241, 0.0270550474524498, -0.0019114792812615633, -0.04494611918926239, -0.040190599858760834, -0.006215601693838835, 0.010735304094851017, 0.008584601804614067, -0.015719613060355186, -0.015432500280439854, -0.004438802134245634, 0.02794654294848442, -0.018965264782309532, 0.02046475000679493, -0.004210018552839756, -0.03660518303513527, -0.05613573640584946, -0.03146294504404068, -0.023653525859117508, 0.07074142247438431, -0.009941179305315018, -0.03264949098229408, -0.016549348831176758, -0.0015680642100051045, 0.015635155141353607, -0.01408152375370264, 0.05483833700418472, -0.00930123869329691, 0.05243825539946556, 0.00611474085599184, 0.05220992490649223, 0.02476428635418415, 0.0005255517899058759, 0.09988793730735779, 0.07196322828531265, 0.04295312613248825, -0.038379281759262085, 0.03635050356388092, -0.01805771142244339, -0.005389945115894079, -0.007203986868262291, 0.02565423585474491, -0.0126954959705472, -0.020251130685210228, 0.04872572422027588, 0.04173382744193077, 0.018032781779766083, 0.00022583012469112873, 0.056244708597660065, -0.023075778037309647, -0.030009426176548004, -0.0038868586998432875, 0.009610156528651714, -0.02122008427977562, -0.06537315994501114, -0.01957095041871071, -0.026589753106236458, 0.0003553299466148019, 0.0158232469111681, -0.02234131097793579, -0.022401725873351097, 0.004546819720417261, -0.04037094861268997, -0.0024062374141067266, -0.021119143813848495, 0.025028089061379433, 0.029375484213232994, -0.02886362001299858, -0.00024005457817111164, 0.032249804586172104, -0.02864033542573452, -0.013733593747019768, 0.048426952213048935, -0.015113255009055138, -0.0006687947898171842, 0.0035922478418797255, 0.00849955901503563, -0.019113965332508087, -0.021119646728038788, 0.01122232899069786, 0.017737194895744324, 0.013663130812346935, -0.01700511947274208, -0.03025510162115097, 0.010283726267516613, -0.02333928272128105, -0.014628078788518906, -0.03296737000346184, 0.01887299120426178, 0.04155845567584038, 0.003948175348341465, -0.029961658641695976, -0.017758868634700775, 0.028134772554039955, -0.018231101334095, 0.007286950945854187, 0.033102940768003464, -0.047475602477788925, -0.010949905961751938, 0.021332690492272377, 0.088831327855587, 0.0279222521930933, -0.013859615661203861, 0.0066039785742759705, -0.018505815416574478, -0.03404644504189491, -0.004591961391270161, 0.013104818761348724, 0.0018463629530742764, 0.01995796151459217, -0.0009129103273153305, -0.0033686186652630568, -0.00488635990768671, -0.043538663536310196, 0.012954141944646835, -0.006384270265698433, -0.004368212074041367, -0.06619763374328613, -0.0112887192517519, 0.014100976288318634, 0.05078938230872154, -0.0024872671347111464, 0.010797335766255856, -0.0007214079378172755, 0.016821296885609627, 0.025992752984166145, -0.03553090617060661, -0.0014880694216117263, 0.037438489496707916, -0.022923700511455536, -0.022824177518486977, -0.04089333117008209, 0.07952861487865448, 0.005133653059601784, 0.012724053114652634, 0.041675541549921036, 0.003205562010407448, -0.04456480219960213, -0.019530072808265686, -0.0031986134126782417, -0.04045502468943596, 0.008224689401686192, 0.00033085609902627766, -0.02301802858710289, -0.04322439804673195, -0.038726311177015305, -0.03299955278635025, -0.01738186553120613, -0.006909083109349012, 0.0015940701123327017, -0.0401458740234375, -0.021186795085668564, 0.000981813413091004, -0.03742917627096176, -0.0399438813328743, 0.03272704407572746, -0.04282143712043762, -0.006198753137141466, 0.04254573956131935, 0.008940009400248528, -0.009876713156700134, 0.011415823362767696, -0.010918833315372467, 0.017713719978928566, 0.036030128598213196, 0.01767474040389061, 0.03834408149123192, 0.002391399582847953, 0.03272324055433273, 0.01291644386947155, 0.04888056591153145, -0.026788122951984406, -0.018777545541524887, 0.0710366740822792, -0.1009317934513092, -0.06278730183839798, 0.02568254992365837, 0.02089342474937439, 0.054414648562669754, -0.008469099178910255, 0.004915740806609392, -0.03538728505373001, 0.08489704132080078, -0.00293618137948215, -0.048753298819065094, -0.0372898131608963, 0.015531961806118488, -0.000249648408498615, -0.0010150494053959846, -0.014099420048296452, -0.00328247738070786, -0.012080427259206772, 0.04008321464061737, 0.03259182348847389, 0.007273707538843155, 0.004584039095789194, 0.01965014450252056, 0.0018882955191656947, 0.027668844908475876, 0.028571413829922676, -0.02289770171046257, 0.005762877874076366, 0.045404817909002304, 0.0053628371097147465, 0.0028869558591395617, -0.031805191189050674, 0.01000240258872509, -0.07770848274230957, -0.0133746899664402, 0.00022615640773437917, 0.0069711883552372456, 0.02218405157327652, -0.053908251225948334, 0.000014865250705042854, 0.0441412478685379, -0.07559699565172195, 0.005139758810400963, 0.006355174817144871, -0.006688121240586042, -0.029177706688642502, 0.006996870506554842, -0.029184363782405853, 0.07856050878763199, 0.042020536959171295, 0.012467372231185436, 0.04621708765625954, -0.011343755759298801, 0.021485941484570503, -0.036638546735048294, 0.019368376582860947, 0.03139705955982208, -0.022907903417944908, -0.09624087065458298, 0.009710139594972134, -0.011048372834920883, -0.015787940472364426, 0.022013258188962936, -0.028716320171952248, 0.012342526577413082, 0.01306140422821045, 0.043834250420331955, 0.018990864977240562, 0.07534593343734741, -0.0049847085028886795, 0.021080907434225082, -0.04970069229602814, 0.022705458104610443, -0.021932333707809448, 0.012223332189023495, -0.06855861097574234, 0.0074713826179504395, 0.004761684685945511, 0.001276814378798008, -0.054886817932128906, 0.018006954342126846, -0.022035468369722366, -0.012046637013554573, -0.009203620254993439, -0.013957451097667217, -0.005405118223279715, -0.015512390993535519, 0.01775677688419819, -0.03971248120069504, 0.01903495378792286, 0.017554374411702156, 0.047883253544569016, -0.029126832261681557, 0.022222008556127548, -0.012933154590427876, -0.052637793123722076, 0.014076192863285542, -0.011247176676988602, -0.008350982330739498, -0.04329541325569153, -0.007104387506842613, 0.026110820472240448, -0.0258740596473217, -0.004056483041495085, -0.027959920465946198, -0.03900473937392235, 0.027574287727475166, -0.007048329804092646, -0.010685109533369541, 0.024166399613022804, -0.011577197350561619, 0.0014774826122447848, -0.09137702733278275, 0.053717903792858124, -0.010391565971076488, -0.005938882939517498, -0.03844160586595535, 0.050652746111154556, -0.04798051714897156, 0.012625780887901783, 0.011548755690455437, 0.021956127136945724, -0.01800968497991562, -0.0023539094254374504, -0.004107464104890823, 0.02280253730714321, -0.07849784940481186, 0.04084290936589241, -0.0018373684724792838, -0.04082047566771507, -0.021743346005678177, -0.0041040414944291115, 0.03386937081813812, -0.0006535920547321439, -0.009509867057204247, -0.014630059711635113, 0.011808402836322784, 0.011306117288768291, 0.012071840465068817, 0.04277048632502556, 0.02298072725534439, 0.0011896491050720215, 0.08427207171916962, -0.027941083535552025, -0.0013648016611114144, 0.02089681848883629, 0.05029016733169556, -0.04577796533703804, 0.04674282297492027, -0.032611627131700516, -0.052284907549619675, 0.021081145852804184, -0.002092807786539197, -0.0047853924334049225, -0.0675576850771904, 0.01983247883617878, 0.025590600445866585, -0.027815701439976692, -0.007309057749807835, 0.0029289000667631626, 0.028590209782123566, 0.006243028212338686, -0.014723684638738632, 0.009569744579494, -0.02434024214744568, -0.014162867330014706, -0.02019205316901207, 0.01844486966729164, 0.014295278117060661, -0.002811003476381302, 0.04269829019904137, 0.013883154839277267, -0.030687833204865456, 0.020700152963399887, 0.007614969741553068, 0.004134284798055887, -0.019864056259393692, -0.00013785282499156892, 0.008514647372066975, 0.02350788004696369, 0.02833383157849312, 0.0065314495004713535, -0.013947158120572567, 0.04943191260099411, -0.02819693647325039, 0.004820007365196943, -0.037457242608070374, 0.03364581987261772, -0.005765040870755911, 0.024325141683220863, 0.04153132066130638, 0.03920365124940872, -0.006939877290278673, 0.017530322074890137, 0.014803794212639332, -0.007711963728070259, 0.02630896121263504, -0.05021020770072937, 0.015074964612722397, -0.012331482023000717, -0.013196938671171665, -0.059893347322940826, 0.030429670587182045, -0.03533075377345085, 0.007963932119309902, 0.034981586039066315, -0.014368526637554169, 0.015081999823451042, -0.0364130474627018, -0.034474849700927734, 0.019950252026319504, 0.044206809252500534, -0.01194407232105732, -0.019764134660363197, -0.0009767082519829273, 0.026243941858410835, 0.001614541164599359, -0.009790855459868908 ]
<p>I have two separate time series, indexed by time in nanoseconds. They both measure the same thing but because they come about in two completely different ways, the number of observations they each give are not only irregularly spaced but are also different in number and don't align. Even the time is on different clocks so even the small subset of indices which match are not necessarily referring to exactly the same time.</p> <p>When I just look at points for each every millisecond (anything from 0 to upwards of 30 observations in different millisecond buckets), match the values to timestamp, and plot all such coinciding observations the time series look identical (this is over 200,000 points). Yet cross correlating them gives very bad values, like <code>0.03</code> or <code>0.16</code>. And if I zoom in on these at sets of 20 or so consecutive points I begin to see all the misalignment generating this. I can look at zoomed out plots and actual values to ascertain myself that they are "generally speaking" measuring the same thing and hovering similary, but I'm not sure how to do this with time series tools or a proper statistic. If the index sets were of the same length then I would consider smoothing over less granular buckets, but because they are not, it's a bit harder to come up with something to translate "the zoomed out graphs look the same" into a number. What are some things I can do in this scenario?</p>
36,895
[ -0.024356108158826828, -0.010710032656788826, -0.06138976663351059, -0.0016804775223135948, 0.045712344348430634, 0.005766910966485739, 0.007522799074649811, -0.003695898689329624, 0.012173227034509182, 0.007968348450958729, 0.01976269669830799, 0.03589333966374397, 0.04765155911445618, 0.015838220715522766, 0.02374132163822651, -0.027650877833366394, -0.009221870452165604, 0.0028605747502297163, 0.004108664114028215, -0.02733311988413334, 0.014278535731136799, -0.0030273953452706337, 0.0393364317715168, -0.011657340452075005, -0.04422741383314133, 0.005466207396239042, 0.019032206386327744, -0.031180329620838165, -0.04080920293927193, 0.012485869228839874, -0.03879409283399582, -0.05266673117876053, 0.014116636477410793, 0.029656335711479187, 0.012823016382753849, -0.0008063162676990032, -0.03338569775223732, -0.04876979440450668, -0.05672341585159302, 0.062164414674043655, -0.054360080510377884, 0.005991809535771608, -0.0167116429656744, 0.04792391508817673, -0.013478306122124195, 0.0061048949137330055, -0.0026964081916958094, 0.007035194430500269, 0.04143603518605232, -0.03222731500864029, 0.07998579740524292, 0.005017546936869621, 0.05525059252977371, 0.0433318167924881, -0.03945070132613182, -0.005118428263813257, 0.07760409265756607, 0.07072992622852325, -0.037227094173431396, -0.04794671759009361, -0.00928416382521391, -0.024172674864530563, -0.0021638027392327785, -0.002617541467770934, 0.00009810720075620338, 0.06383153796195984, -0.03470483422279358, -0.013946857303380966, 0.01935419626533985, -0.05023916810750961, 0.012634987011551857, 0.013953160494565964, 0.06931889802217484, -0.03319118171930313, 0.0268337894231081, -0.03426213562488556, 0.02764463610947132, 0.013083970174193382, 0.06473152339458466, 0.06200692430138588, -0.0217727217823267, 0.0020562366116791964, 0.03450968861579895, 0.05180412903428078, 0.059523921459913254, 0.024932274594902992, 0.06494979560375214, -0.05149193853139877, 0.009803171269595623, 0.036872319877147675, -0.015830935910344124, 0.006036980077624321, 0.055844638496637344, -0.014394035562872887, -0.033865101635456085, 0.03370008245110512, -0.0011518239043653011, -0.0007643963908776641, -0.015174618922173977, -0.006751338951289654, -0.018312446773052216, -0.04056830331683159, 0.01807716302573681, 0.03044973313808441, 0.004117246717214584, 0.013222855515778065, -0.014812979847192764, -0.008204097859561443, -0.03694241866469383, -0.005865653045475483, -0.013719165697693825, -0.03234352543950081, 0.01787787303328514, -0.0130320955067873, 0.04329390451312065, 0.018905533477663994, -0.0031544798985123634, 0.0016198127996176481, 0.05415245518088341, 0.05289914086461067, 0.04704262316226959, -0.009335902519524097, 0.02883560210466385, -0.023320194333791733, -0.07025044411420822, 0.012900548987090588, 0.008162466809153557, -0.027387559413909912, -0.03347285836935043, 0.0676780566573143, 0.010492530651390553, -0.0147719606757164, 0.05399072542786598, -0.0523354709148407, 0.0735604390501976, 0.020268183201551437, -0.07857474684715271, -0.05556247755885124, 0.04271949082612991, 0.0013796804705634713, 0.01481818500906229, -0.0612308569252491, 0.01387394592165947, -0.0448448583483696, 0.031538937240839005, 0.016420619562268257, 0.013521523214876652, 0.005728683900088072, 0.01000621821731329, 0.022905077785253525, -0.009942350909113884, -0.01406175084412098, -0.02803053893148899, -0.028536401689052582, -0.015069725923240185, -0.03572840616106987, -0.030670035630464554, 0.026524340733885765, -0.019025448709726334, -0.014873506501317024, 0.02451375313103199, -0.0006675536278635263, -0.029065288603305817, 0.01641063764691353, 0.03391673415899277, -0.037052303552627563, 0.0445500947535038, -0.004876171238720417, 0.013454467989504337, 0.027308553457260132, -0.017499670386314392, -0.00638078898191452, 0.04977886378765106, 0.03703337907791138, 0.04602811858057976, -0.039388708770275116, -0.002981838770210743, 0.00921088270843029, -0.022413959726691246, 0.035851337015628815, -0.014240982010960579, -0.04387035220861435, -0.02363428846001625, -0.030007310211658478, 0.05641636624932289, 0.033250533044338226, -0.0034705931320786476, -0.0519595593214035, 0.02098175883293152, -0.07531926035881042, -0.02884840779006481, -0.06538281589746475, -0.034303728491067886, -0.021565446630120277, 0.007672104984521866, 0.07042612880468369, -0.01595558598637581, 0.013934998773038387, -0.013683024793863297, -0.028717506676912308, 0.018981903791427612, 0.011079184710979462, 0.030364133417606354, -0.033939626067876816, -0.011436044238507748, 0.046348754316568375, 0.010701403021812439, 0.012853175401687622, 0.01790788769721985, -0.00930220726877451, -0.06340096145868301, -0.002304217079654336, -0.07778356969356537, 0.01256516482681036, -0.019062364473938942, -0.009139635600149632, 0.02922484092414379, 0.002118882955983281, -0.015185351483523846, 0.009748687967658043, -0.03452223539352417, 0.055179353803396225, 0.07422326505184174, -0.021415485069155693, -0.03669876605272293, -0.011248004622757435, 0.045713718980550766, 0.016598675400018692, -0.023246144875884056, -0.031386252492666245, -0.058460209518671036, -0.011224598623812199, 0.049311619251966476, 0.0379246324300766, 0.014355163089931011, -0.016912313178181648, 0.08324119448661804, 0.07080353796482086, -0.003936753608286381, 0.01822688989341259, 0.007086467929184437, -0.0017240977613255382, 0.00010053410369437188, 0.004708374850451946, 0.003350975923240185, 0.0011160550639033318, 0.0412917323410511, -0.009595008566975594, 0.038148581981658936, 0.004697299096733332, 0.0091716842725873, 0.007481819484382868, 0.0031102318316698074, 0.016177132725715637, -0.014238939620554447, -0.013438090682029724, 0.015136023983359337, 0.0186608899384737, -0.007049040403217077, 0.021710693836212158, 0.011573233641684055, -0.009766405448317528, 0.016763081774115562, -0.003505424130707979, 0.003868846921250224, 0.02950037084519863, -0.030766917392611504, -0.019172070547938347, 0.015824444591999054, -0.02035323902964592, 0.04597265645861626, 0.0020493718329817057, -0.04216305539011955, -0.06125253811478615, 0.033623289316892624, -0.0022766233887523413, 0.0172067079693079, 0.026794658973813057, -0.05666300281882286, -0.03775244578719139, -0.009286078624427319, -0.013749059289693832, 0.040648434311151505, 0.014924397692084312, -0.017040463164448738, 0.02897537127137184, 0.007576582487672567, 0.014011411927640438, 0.0034013111144304276, -0.02957317605614662, 0.023050427436828613, 0.005220816470682621, 0.009502318687736988, -0.05500601604580879, -0.0186154805123806, -0.030461860820651054, 0.0486377589404583, -0.03120633028447628, 0.007596961688250303, 0.05034315213561058, -0.025666063651442528, -0.06904520094394684, 0.01759226620197296, -0.004323976114392281, 0.014760107733309269, -0.008643850684165955, 0.006244154646992683, -0.008954609744250774, 0.0007982716197147965, -0.02589588239789009, 0.025528552010655403, -0.018112903460860252, -0.03440755233168602, -0.027516016736626625, -0.06835689395666122, 0.02337401919066906, -0.02313309535384178, 0.01210957020521164, -0.01051484327763319, -0.02662096731364727, 0.0316498689353466, 0.01083256397396326, -0.01791929453611374, -0.04883794113993645, 0.014782455749809742, -0.03169586881995201, 0.015823060646653175, 0.02058832347393036, -0.010318465530872345, 0.02556530386209488, -0.00387384882196784, 0.009400371462106705, 0.04206748679280281, 0.07838289439678192, 0.0015982133336365223, 0.02173597738146782, 0.045183904469013214, 0.018985476344823837, 0.02713604085147381, 0.013467353768646717, 0.045831285417079926, -0.03562680259346962, 0.005953208543360233, 0.0246269591152668, -0.004846818745136261, 0.02163887582719326, -0.06667107343673706, 0.03409939631819725, -0.008061878383159637, 0.022957822307944298, -0.06353234499692917, 0.01294950395822525, 0.018567875027656555, -0.00924797635525465, -0.057857487350702286, 0.04503105208277702, 0.045471422374248505, 0.005346817430108786, 0.022008610889315605, 0.07095630466938019, 0.03917064145207405, -0.016516100615262985, -0.0014594009844586253, -0.01532141026109457, -0.0017825443064793944, 0.0348125621676445, -0.050627123564481735, 0.0030390070751309395, 0.04404342174530029, 0.0002122089936165139, 0.02163805440068245, -0.007205411791801453, -0.03507664054632187, -0.00946599617600441, -0.08507601916790009, -0.008742321282625198, -0.03225536644458771, 0.03615327924489975, 0.028152987360954285, 0.048087071627378464, 0.027525683864951134, -0.003143015783280134, -0.022262418642640114, -0.014170614071190357, -0.04092330485582352, 0.02447408251464367, -0.0037140033673495054, -0.025171561166644096, -0.027591107413172722, -0.010315208695828915, 0.008477975614368916, -0.019255895167589188, 0.03498947247862816, 0.015716347843408585, 0.042797673493623734, -0.021582577377557755, 0.0038264670874923468, -0.01177709735929966, 0.006748934276401997, -0.020714856684207916, -0.006421215832233429, 0.001569855259731412, -0.007979661226272583, 0.06860238313674927, 0.055962782353162766, -0.002442082855850458, -0.015242530032992363, -0.026766451075673103, 0.015483373776078224, 0.007273376453667879, 0.0288222786039114, 0.004695214331150055, 0.00653271097689867, -0.024117814376950264, 0.03058617189526558, 0.040981475263834, 0.00033442402491346, 0.03363250195980072, -0.008452340960502625, -0.017831631004810333, -0.03571651875972748, -0.04509393498301506, 0.026638373732566833, 0.03507488593459129, 0.03020314872264862, -0.010008913464844227, 0.023250874131917953, 0.05958223715424538, -0.046390362083911896, 0.018412232398986816, 0.06358453631401062, -0.0005944984732195735, -0.010573074221611023, -0.02646188996732235, -0.04331284761428833, 0.0030937017872929573, 0.02372918091714382, 0.026998592540621758, 0.024148529395461082, 0.005630065221339464, -0.021985944360494614, 0.041054461151361465, -0.03372640162706375, -0.019178222864866257, -0.007521784398704767, 0.022751998156309128, 0.047468043863773346, 0.007963050156831741, 0.020932327955961227, 0.026562966406345367, 0.027567237615585327, 0.02575291320681572, 0.042393945157527924, -0.015018263831734657, -0.1060175895690918, -0.0009702176903374493, 0.030146436765789986, -0.03604983165860176, -0.02762603759765625, -0.031005442142486572, -0.06273107975721359, 0.00485583022236824, 0.046504583209753036, -0.018372859805822372, 0.012896592728793621, 0.009183842688798904, 0.03798460215330124, -0.04554427042603493, -0.012761969119310379, -0.011472618207335472, 0.01090599037706852, 0.004630877170711756, 0.04753310605883598, -0.029038410633802414, -0.015031734481453896, -0.020212775096297264, 0.013623004779219627, 0.031001480296254158, 0.05310920253396034, -0.0010874017607420683, -0.005721245426684618, 0.00020831162692047656, -0.015244354493916035, -0.013563351705670357, -0.081271231174469, 0.024500582367181778, 0.01583649218082428, 0.011746281757950783, 0.04624525457620621, -0.002286645583808422, -0.012868941761553288, 0.006659342907369137, 0.0050001079216599464, 0.004605561029165983, -0.00041942461393773556, -0.019472256302833557, 0.05147334188222885, 0.04934268072247505, 0.05108484625816345, 0.05421341955661774, 0.03334767743945122, 0.000007765296686557122, 0.017548324540257454, -0.04169513285160065, 0.047590576112270355, -0.028139039874076843, 0.018167011439800262, -0.020421253517270088, 0.00012401003914419562, -0.035694994032382965, 0.018716007471084595, -0.009546438232064247, 0.03865024819970131, -0.03219986334443092, -0.001012196997180581, -0.005537048913538456, 0.05036350339651108, 0.023826679214835167, -0.002653033472597599, 0.04333646968007088, 0.00341399316675961, -0.0038766893558204174, 0.008673988282680511, 0.03315049037337303, -0.007374983746558428, -0.040332358330488205, 0.010102315805852413, -0.038003601133823395, 0.01788652129471302, -0.013138446025550365, 0.02110174298286438, -0.0022544909734278917, -0.01948269084095955, 0.0054162247106432915, 0.010608655400574207, 0.04480917379260063, 0.019824763759970665, -0.02413000911474228, -0.0006285124691203237, 0.009281085804104805, -0.006292018108069897, 0.03475404530763626, -0.06522709876298904, -0.0011979015544056892, 0.008547432720661163, -0.0037826928310096264, -0.08338409662246704, -0.049786586314439774, 0.04237467795610428, -0.001024717465043068, -0.02411435917019844, -0.0419299490749836, 0.005631679203361273, 0.012043540365993977, 0.005001075565814972, -0.0023766402155160904, 0.029983757063746452, -0.007787519600242376, -0.052062325179576874, -0.01934351585805416, 0.01654120348393917, 0.08899842947721481, -0.009865731000900269, 0.012046588584780693, -0.012138526886701584, 0.02168855629861355, -0.035989318042993546, 0.018130743876099586, 0.04630527272820473, -0.025717025622725487, 0.0008156325202435255, -0.0420379564166069, -0.015867331996560097, 0.039329223334789276, -0.056777894496917725, 0.008041853085160255, 0.017310278490185738, 0.01773962751030922, 0.0363151952624321, -0.027609048411250114, 0.0132992472499609, -0.020707016810774803, -0.0051893023774027824, -0.052485544234514236, -0.008305749855935574, -0.020392006263136864, -0.01350334845483303, 0.010392843745648861, -0.00632822047919035, -0.02825739234685898, 0.0296880304813385, 0.04334951192140579, -0.029848778620362282, -0.02207275666296482, 0.007573215290904045, 0.005653520114719868, 0.01975596323609352, -0.019458480179309845, 0.008417983539402485, -0.0014446686254814267, 0.005622511729598045, -0.037145886570215225, -0.006314659491181374, -0.011042118072509766, -0.04256788641214371, 0.07595661282539368, 0.00841209664940834, 0.06673379242420197, 0.030834553763270378, -0.004932429641485214, -0.0015326091088354588, -0.016049109399318695, -0.0021028912160545588, 0.005292433779686689, -0.009788662195205688, 0.046303555369377136, -0.008222652599215508, -0.010208364576101303, 0.011371612548828125, 0.032654307782649994, 0.04670614376664162, 0.02426838129758835, -0.02480289526283741, 0.015660760924220085, 0.04144938662648201, -0.01675473339855671, -0.027978433296084404, 0.053066156804561615, -0.023800287395715714, 0.017377255484461784, 0.0017836273182183504, -0.014658472500741482, 0.04300681874155998, 0.025740886107087135, -0.04280857741832733, -0.007456187158823013, -0.03621910512447357, -0.06857319176197052, 0.025354044511914253, 0.032757680863142014, -0.006141448859125376, 0.020084096118807793, 0.007427874952554703, 0.030558384954929352, 0.018168313428759575, -0.018671751022338867, -0.06160733103752136, -0.0716886967420578, -0.029243484139442444, -0.03663620725274086, -0.016666250303387642, 0.03171662241220474, -0.023248378187417984, -0.04620131850242615, 0.026425676420331, 0.006196561269462109, 0.006600961089134216, -0.02598721906542778, -0.009683477692306042, -0.03916342183947563, 0.07979512214660645, -0.004287172108888626, 0.013875528238713741, -0.0487736240029335, -0.014235153794288635, 0.10775669664144516, 0.06348305940628052, 0.009780187159776688, -0.05111779645085335, 0.018284182995557785, 0.03391985222697258, 0.017138028517365456, -0.04204719886183739, 0.0641293078660965, 0.03346024453639984, 0.00266570458188653, 0.034227337688207626, 0.05165824666619301, 0.031141720712184906, -0.007161390036344528, 0.062205713242292404, 0.007440794724971056, 0.03740653395652771, -0.027154171839356422, 0.014767424203455448, 0.05967916175723076, -0.012387914583086967, -0.08546562492847443, -0.00617506168782711, -0.0643862932920456, -0.001784711261279881, -0.00365140731446445, -0.020639726892113686, -0.002431390108540654, 0.025078142061829567, -0.051592957228422165, 0.06362588703632355, 0.041650671511888504, -0.01589546911418438, 0.017016520723700523, -0.020837843418121338, 0.027092881500720978, 0.02462974563241005, 0.042207032442092896, -0.007003174163401127, 0.029879245907068253, 0.0032944928389042616, -0.02231750078499317, 0.011003023944795132, -0.018136348575353622, -0.02801438234746456, -0.04642117768526077, 0.02259405516088009, -0.019303729757666588, -0.007850242778658867, -0.002979894867166877, -0.004378629848361015, -0.005365611519664526, -0.04467584565281868, -0.00265750871039927, -0.02312816120684147, -0.003116495441645384, -0.015123295597732067, 0.01291979942470789, -0.0041473931632936, 0.033022064715623856, 0.003665168769657612, 0.03408825024962425, -0.033198341727256775, 0.026537291705608368, -0.016757085919380188, 0.005097624380141497, 0.0757429376244545, -0.03913838416337967, -0.020318912342190742, 0.026280757039785385, -0.025453617796301842, -0.031158560886979103, -0.015671268105506897, -0.021737411618232727, -0.003435640363022685, 0.019253356382250786, 0.008307384327054024, -0.01976020447909832, -0.022519070655107498, -0.014117477461695671, 0.0154441362246871, -0.01109902560710907, -0.012967600487172604, -0.02116198092699051, -0.02064395323395729, 0.056454047560691833, 0.047754693776369095, -0.0013806662755087018, 0.04098651185631752, -0.029365750029683113, 0.05550285056233406, 0.025824183598160744, -0.03224562108516693, 0.004288282711058855, -0.018160028383135796, -0.012320456095039845, -0.009364943020045757, -0.023310765624046326, 0.072846420109272, 0.025539694353938103, -0.0071786679327487946, 0.007466880138963461, 0.0208914652466774, 0.018969006836414337, 0.01895541325211525, -0.011433624662458897, -0.03901800513267517, -0.009935854002833366, -0.0034704520367085934, -0.013283254578709602, -0.020928358659148216, -0.02719792164862156, -0.04445713013410568, 0.0018117537256330252, 0.001148553448729217, 0.0057218181900680065, -0.02408667467534542, 0.021468838676810265, 0.006705200299620628, -0.00999470241367817, -0.02587016485631466, -0.006036025937646627, -0.04778550565242767, -0.02850959636271, -0.049142587929964066, -0.017311353236436844, 0.012821698561310768, 0.014057488180696964, -0.00661522476002574, -0.013245261274278164, 0.010957011952996254, 0.028766077011823654, -0.014300224371254444, 0.001456851838156581, 0.01650439016520977, -0.008067077025771141, 0.032710444182157516, -0.04172419756650925, -0.05351235345005989, 0.003636372974142432, 0.0018569370731711388, -0.08203975856304169, 0.06535857170820236, -0.009899259544909, 0.002078382298350334, 0.011629542335867882, -0.016856782138347626, -0.01837484911084175, 0.05065048485994339, -0.012579139322042465, 0.0011065525468438864, 0.01584966666996479, 0.0030519801657646894, -0.0019052403513342142, 0.013158900663256645, 0.02219708450138569, 0.005437580868601799, -0.005841503851115704, -0.007896174676716328, 0.02555813640356064, 0.03031001053750515, 0.007605991791933775, -0.026655491441488266, -0.012252097018063068, 0.015175683423876762, -0.012935931794345379, -0.02493629977107048, 0.05644368752837181, 0.04218151792883873, -0.01901838183403015, -0.005111796781420708, -0.007492681499570608, 0.008908228017389774, -0.046159617602825165, 0.00572974281385541, -0.005866992752999067, 0.0027052233926951885, 0.021487338468432426, -0.029034649953246117, -0.016216924414038658, 0.032914359122514725, -0.04227020591497421, 0.028552699834108353, -0.013465696014463902, -0.009704064577817917, -0.026332367211580276, 0.025888677686452866, -0.0022993830498307943, 0.0072627197951078415, 0.07164663076400757, 0.007824260741472244, 0.028198610991239548, 0.03386421129107475, -0.010766119696199894, 0.0014516962692141533, 0.00886339507997036, -0.010607914067804813, 0.016361966729164124, -0.03149493783712387, 0.012356698513031006, -0.052491798996925354, -0.029035620391368866, 0.012182439677417278, -0.0571712851524353, -0.016191529110074043, 0.0008449025917798281, 0.022375883534550667, 0.009617460891604424, 0.023075083270668983, -0.0023308524396270514, -0.008823810145258904, -0.02330080233514309, -0.02084263414144516, 0.0029522026889026165, 0.010364912450313568, -0.004520644899457693, 0.0168510302901268, 0.0334705151617527, -0.03722124174237251, -0.00518327159807086, -0.01736002415418625, -0.003734163474291563, -0.0009662612574175, -0.004917110316455364, 0.014595694839954376, 0.07387223839759827, -0.008909059688448906, 0.009379306808114052, -0.030091969296336174, 0.028465161100029945, 0.06291201710700989, -0.008690577931702137, -0.01947922818362713, -0.01654370315372944, -0.03557087481021881, -0.02953578531742096, -0.010355538688600063, 0.021964343264698982, 0.004839497618377209, -0.05371988192200661, -0.02536439709365368, -0.02841338887810707, -0.030653322115540504, -0.022650981321930885, -0.012656310573220253, -0.014196685515344143, 0.07514941692352295, -0.0022885510697960854, -0.01752394624054432, 0.04262369126081467, 0.006967353634536266, -0.015224924311041832, -0.07660354673862457, 0.017386777326464653, 0.0038009716663509607, -0.012669007293879986, -0.05606789514422417, -0.016772527247667313, -0.03459741920232773, 0.033849310129880905, 0.03475717455148697, 0.01887478679418564, 0.00833672285079956, -0.004702320322394371, -0.016326414421200752, 0.030516106635332108, -0.03594839200377464, 0.005556897260248661, -0.013528072275221348, -0.011973537504673004, 0.05849454924464226, -0.03566058725118637, -0.014900436624884605, -0.008083643391728401, 0.005450339522212744, -0.0129093611612916, 0.013404801487922668, 0.030406013131141663, -0.03689210116863251, 0.02881966158747673, -0.049107104539871216, -0.010894265957176685, 0.02068977802991867, 0.017253795638680458, -0.005114983767271042, 0.03536545857787132, 0.0036426251754164696, -0.07129087299108505, 0.04780464619398117, -0.008334123529493809, -0.019274471327662468, -0.005458786152303219, -0.02090481109917164, 0.011954800225794315, -0.07208306342363358, -0.016878606751561165, 0.01487744227051735, -0.008635474368929863, -0.00869537703692913, 0.05121440812945366, 0.018135283142328262, -0.0029753262642771006, -0.021270131692290306, 0.03787597641348839, 0.018436916172504425, 0.043369539082050323, 0.03409898281097412, -0.003620599629357457, 0.04119467735290527, 0.0014718696475028992, -0.012037232518196106, -0.016444813460111618, -0.005838269833475351, 0.038985174149274826, -0.005526426713913679, 0.06342733651399612, -0.0028394071850925684, -0.03459654375910759, -0.004291960038244724, -0.019034305587410927, -0.009746248833835125, 0.024346046149730682, -0.007560050114989281, 0.04055872932076454, -0.05827641859650612, -0.0035949896555393934, -0.03549214079976082, -0.02435545064508915, -0.018416738137602806, 0.049337368458509445, -0.02858799323439598, -0.003696128958836198, -0.014285692945122719, -0.01413843035697937, -0.013366948813199997, -0.0008240739116445184, 0.00512225367128849, -0.04752742126584053, -0.0013938146876171231, -0.013571880757808685, 0.005240411031991243, 0.003664362709969282, -0.010611096397042274, -0.06040510907769203, -0.047755174338817596, 0.035167038440704346, 0.0011374012101441622, 0.00921188946813345, -0.010701249353587627, -0.028016259893774986, -0.023897293955087662, 0.034573644399642944, -0.11502640694379807, -0.048531387001276016, -0.018901875242590904, 0.010205449536442757, 0.015424319542944431, -0.016633441671729088 ]
<p>Let $X_1, X_2...X_n$ be iid with $f(x,\theta)=\dfrac{2x}{\theta^2}$ and $0&lt;x\leq\theta$. Find $c$ such that $\mathbb{E}(c\hat{\theta})=\theta$ where $\hat{\theta}$ denotes MLE of $\theta$.</p> <p>What I have tried: I found the MLE of $f(x;\theta)$ to be $\max\{X_1,X_2\cdots X_n\}$ (which aligns with the answer at the back) but now I am stuck at this question. The answer given is $\dfrac{2n+1}{2n}$.</p> <p>I would have proceeded as: $$\begin{align*} \mathbb{E}(c\hat{\theta})&amp;=\theta\\ \int_0^\theta c \dfrac{2x}{y^2} &amp;=\theta \quad (y = \max\{x_1,x_2,\cdots,x_n\})\\ \dfrac{1}{y^2}\int_0^\theta c .{2x}{} &amp;=\theta \end{align*}$$ But continuing this way gives me an answer far off from the one in the book (I don't have a term of n to begin with).</p> <p>Help! Hints only please, no complete solutions.</p>
74,174
[ -0.03905724734067917, -0.009040738455951214, 0.010670158080756664, -0.012401329353451729, -0.001876024529337883, -0.018080372363328934, 0.013398890383541584, -0.0582449771463871, 0.04616127163171768, -0.026374852284789085, 0.02810409665107727, 0.05674799904227257, 0.08159179985523224, 0.05916938930749893, 0.02073330245912075, 0.014823844656348228, -0.056168198585510254, 0.0093759223818779, 0.002302943728864193, 0.005472240969538689, -0.03691878914833069, 0.05314641445875168, 0.010087456554174423, -0.05447626858949661, -0.033762942999601364, 0.02583727426826954, 0.03755249083042145, -0.025739779695868492, -0.0338812880218029, 0.08893950283527374, -0.04525386169552803, -0.036327846348285675, 0.02265825681388378, 0.019607050344347954, 0.015988700091838837, 0.019335035234689713, -0.03564046323299408, -0.011552851647138596, 0.017817972227931023, 0.027477838099002838, -0.04809174686670303, -0.016424231231212616, 0.004182103555649519, 0.03375452384352684, -0.0033542721066623926, -0.0015023681335151196, 0.005666556768119335, -0.04484144598245621, 0.01972043327987194, -0.049354005604982376, 0.1084386557340622, -0.01305028609931469, 0.026578258723020554, 0.03500312566757202, -0.0032240066211670637, -0.02087399922311306, 0.032530203461647034, 0.0663113221526146, 0.003998482599854469, -0.03940872102975845, -0.03283628448843956, -0.04527631774544716, 0.012164843268692493, 0.004737437702715397, -0.03864217549562454, 0.030338414013385773, 0.007217484060674906, -0.03767775744199753, -0.0002490087936166674, -0.01334209181368351, 0.028736399486660957, 0.008818065747618675, 0.03768597170710564, 0.014225491322577, -0.012355784885585308, 0.002307624090462923, 0.054649729281663895, 0.03113439306616783, 0.01024217065423727, 0.022599518299102783, -0.022188346832990646, 0.039159081876277924, 0.03585611656308174, 0.04049514979124069, -0.027158910408616066, 0.041040487587451935, 0.09961013495922089, 0.010800437070429325, 0.005896694492548704, 0.047870103269815445, 0.003163952613249421, 0.026687156409025192, 0.06638626754283905, -0.06247484311461449, -0.04166708141565323, 0.005980949383229017, -0.022516710683703423, 0.02450242079794407, -0.017626263201236725, -0.027920441702008247, -0.016868306323885918, -0.028785288333892822, -0.039486292749643326, 0.05153092369437218, -0.023548483848571777, -0.009923450648784637, -0.026193387806415558, -0.019783981144428253, -0.0007576316129416227, -0.0039605023339390755, -0.022068828344345093, 0.05017511174082756, 0.008886739611625671, 0.031688664108514786, 0.0033445998560637236, 0.009088723920285702, -0.008621182292699814, 0.02194579690694809, 0.012871433980762959, 0.0426408052444458, 0.03823969513177872, -0.008717616088688374, 0.04045950993895531, -0.02521330863237381, -0.03150048851966858, 0.02782624028623104, 0.01586952805519104, 0.004973282106220722, -0.06566867977380753, 0.04483518376946449, 0.018674375489354134, -0.011201097629964352, 0.021104663610458374, 0.03762165084481239, -0.008065111003816128, -0.027538493275642395, -0.049817826598882675, -0.050316885113716125, 0.04062587022781372, -0.02278229221701622, 0.042348749935626984, -0.06214585900306702, 0.016695555299520493, 0.05246761068701744, 0.07688005268573761, 0.01431804895401001, 0.05040798336267471, 0.008806504309177399, 0.011770314536988735, 0.0011879217345267534, -0.03272739797830582, -0.0021200147457420826, -0.011395011097192764, -0.010424939915537834, 0.0018143521156162024, -0.01633923128247261, 0.04309140145778656, 0.000520601577591151, -0.008225223049521446, -0.029355166479945183, 0.06629513949155807, -0.013969266787171364, -0.022563721984624863, -0.008077112026512623, 0.04791643097996712, 0.001316793030127883, 0.10862560570240021, 0.043316371738910675, 0.03153877705335617, 0.009024882689118385, 0.0046482696197927, 0.03202104941010475, -0.015121008269488811, 0.04136548936367035, 0.05971488729119301, -0.03167685121297836, -0.03773341327905655, -0.030150512233376503, 0.02741544134914875, 0.027042770758271217, -0.024100231006741524, 0.009624863043427467, -0.03919587656855583, -0.009841394610702991, 0.030503150075674057, 0.04726101830601692, 0.004838126711547375, -0.022125152871012688, -0.003056599758565426, -0.009470133110880852, -0.000741985160857439, -0.050773702561855316, 0.00764862634241581, 0.03910992294549942, -0.027317462489008904, 0.03016451559960842, -0.030509009957313538, 0.01833753101527691, -0.01961137354373932, 0.009293096140027046, -0.017053445801138878, 0.010518583469092846, 0.021938256919384003, -0.019842112436890602, 0.052412956953048706, 0.030047960579395294, 0.04412524774670601, 0.023537665605545044, 0.02231057547032833, -0.05652288720011711, 0.012179342098534107, 0.006360860075801611, -0.0074630314484238625, 0.041338276118040085, -0.012292314320802689, -0.005418797023594379, -0.013624003157019615, 0.0038034820463508368, 0.0050047836266458035, 0.026096180081367493, -0.05895523726940155, 0.06476321816444397, 0.04047359526157379, 0.013599114492535591, 0.03939209505915642, 0.006834734231233597, 0.021990971639752388, 0.0038590615149587393, -0.026490675285458565, -0.03016684763133526, -0.027734650298953056, 0.005824951454997063, 0.024455435574054718, 0.05690968036651611, -0.06938113272190094, -0.0027458632830530405, 0.07778849452733994, 0.015599721111357212, -0.006647435016930103, 0.012687020003795624, -0.0029471053276211023, 0.0004961181548424065, 0.01210729032754898, 0.039092157036066055, 0.005793984048068523, 0.028936291113495827, -0.0031336210668087006, 0.02849278599023819, 0.01323594432324171, 0.028937682509422302, -0.02311677858233452, 0.054419565945863724, 0.01919829472899437, 0.007571856491267681, -0.00697585241869092, 0.03380103409290314, 0.030023952946066856, -0.000768811849411577, -0.013757369481027126, 0.014850309118628502, 0.03333117812871933, -0.024222567677497864, -0.013103364035487175, 0.00022610774612985551, 0.0644116997718811, 0.014749107882380486, -0.0339023619890213, -0.016350852325558662, 0.028749750927090645, -0.015339718200266361, -0.005452517420053482, -0.02081960253417492, -0.06830935180187225, -0.01473182626068592, -0.010266758501529694, 0.0328371487557888, 0.0033711541909724474, 0.014978883787989616, -0.0037795589305460453, -0.015893634408712387, -0.03431974723935127, -0.021820301190018654, 0.02281481958925724, -0.013647385872900486, -0.0929139032959938, -0.03711490333080292, -0.0314674936234951, 0.006246532313525677, 0.0425136536359787, -0.015796326100826263, 0.001048808335326612, 0.029461462050676346, -0.034288275986909866, -0.0621991902589798, 0.01504380814731121, -0.030505429953336716, 0.02605460025370121, -0.048388008028268814, -0.02418552339076996, 0.024703750386834145, -0.003437238745391369, -0.00829968973994255, 0.008717651478946209, -0.015705065801739693, -0.04767220467329025, -0.024254806339740753, 0.027422796934843063, 0.016529135406017303, 0.014036680571734905, 0.0406886488199234, 0.02067742869257927, 0.012588863261044025, -0.013987286947667599, -0.10944271087646484, -0.027092011645436287, -0.018298514187335968, -0.017279116436839104, -0.04321145638823509, 0.0026373201981186867, -0.00671607768163085, 0.05622991919517517, 0.018611697480082512, -0.03183523565530777, 0.0027922755107283592, 0.0056936172768473625, 0.012599234469234943, -0.0238825511187315, 0.023158995434641838, 0.010162637569010258, -0.0008967264438979328, 0.03837806358933449, -0.006457196082919836, 0.003238827455788851, 0.07482998818159103, -0.02545579895377159, 0.02100183069705963, 0.031099896878004074, -0.0018048468045890331, -0.018377430737018585, 0.04686225205659866, 0.05285078287124634, -0.01555770356208086, 0.024494986981153488, 0.04275059327483177, 0.011515690945088863, -0.010053854435682297, -0.031681470572948456, -0.000633912393823266, -0.03644649311900139, 0.006442238576710224, -0.001719126245006919, 0.04213816300034523, 0.013065874576568604, -0.022112412378191948, 0.014829027466475964, 0.014962568879127502, 0.02676762081682682, -0.028457531705498695, 0.020486347377300262, 0.019937504082918167, 0.0029884641990065575, -0.0051282853819429874, 0.001155963633209467, -0.020783718675374985, -0.0031585150863975286, 0.01252350676804781, -0.004729405511170626, -0.02244124561548233, 0.035143204033374786, 0.013872488401830196, 0.035002585500478745, -0.014798563905060291, -0.00566796725615859, 0.010625824332237244, -0.03190663084387779, 0.037724800407886505, -0.03019963949918747, 0.024840764701366425, 0.013929788023233414, 0.019746053963899612, 0.03465380147099495, -0.0072774398140609264, 0.029436903074383736, 0.018282050266861916, -0.10538683831691742, 0.0036833523772656918, -0.019220037385821342, 0.025708600878715515, 0.00031497623422183096, -0.0045981076546013355, 0.07382068037986755, -0.022973520681262016, 0.03374604880809784, 0.0074296859093010426, 0.004707283340394497, -0.03766234591603279, -0.0064650592394173145, -0.026760080829262733, 0.0007694761734455824, -0.0051324013620615005, 0.06089850887656212, -0.0013791498495265841, -0.0772966668009758, 0.0177692212164402, 0.04621895030140877, -0.03660092130303383, -0.0003609985869843513, -0.032806895673274994, -0.0028828212525695562, 0.008423138409852982, 0.016850875690579414, -0.02883310616016388, 0.010143013671040535, -0.006579909007996321, 0.0003975450817961246, -0.026966946199536324, 0.06001828610897064, 0.0527203269302845, -0.000927636690903455, -0.04799451306462288, 0.0013719543348997831, -0.0067903934977948666, -0.011181125417351723, 0.027599584311246872, 0.03281169757246971, 0.006613615900278091, 0.06585889309644699, 0.007910491898655891, -0.025318657979369164, 0.0347398966550827, 0.06627592444419861, -0.011783924885094166, 0.002658245852217078, 0.015657620504498482, -0.036657556891441345, -0.036958321928977966, 0.022833779454231262, 0.005218056961894035, -0.059967465698719025, -0.033347126096487045, -0.029231850057840347, 0.06951828300952911, -0.0017121401615440845, -0.025029679760336876, -0.0018738619983196259, -0.005968831013888121, 0.039581965655088425, 0.0019648405723273754, -0.046947598457336426, 0.01594177633523941, -0.0029319790191948414, 0.010682682506740093, 0.0154656320810318, -0.02718447893857956, -0.02906256914138794, -0.0061949496157467365, 0.038241490721702576, 0.053062502294778824, -0.015767117962241173, -0.03745562955737114, -0.023634960874915123, 0.003916797693818808, 0.03342863544821739, -0.03781742602586746, 0.036714229732751846, -0.030997708439826965, -0.0539308562874794, -0.03916189819574356, -0.035975292325019836, -0.05919260159134865, -0.022030949592590332, 0.010650008916854858, 0.0174445528537035, -0.02611863799393177, -0.007636520080268383, -0.03343546763062477, 0.0012990004615858197, 0.023738322779536247, 0.04767459258437157, -0.01542682759463787, -0.038169968873262405, 0.002433447167277336, 0.02602468803524971, -0.024320758879184723, -0.04126613959670067, 0.013325758278369904, -0.005756580736488104, -0.02251090109348297, 0.025394469499588013, -0.02455637790262699, -0.06210406497120857, 0.030480865389108658, -0.002215947490185499, -0.012813704088330269, 0.029640596359968185, -0.018974198028445244, 0.047197967767715454, 0.05122266337275505, 0.03197852894663811, 0.08770544826984406, 0.033483076840639114, 0.03208297863602638, -0.012829207815229893, -0.030093083158135414, 0.026635650545358658, -0.025523414835333824, -0.03716331347823143, -0.047538917511701584, -0.04320970177650452, -0.029007740318775177, 0.03014395385980606, -0.006696677301079035, 0.034662600606679916, -0.07415638118982315, 0.01570284552872181, 0.0063087223097682, 0.04037989303469658, 0.02394593320786953, 0.003555295756086707, 0.006051012314856052, 0.02842997945845127, 0.042061448097229004, -0.014586133882403374, 0.021424850448966026, -0.042305078357458115, 0.007482745219022036, 0.024100517854094505, -0.004890399519354105, -0.017061157152056694, -0.05215967446565628, -0.0435233935713768, -0.03172915056347847, -0.04134077951312065, 0.07264158129692078, -0.012319691479206085, 0.005465127527713776, -0.009649695828557014, -0.005738036707043648, -0.05247814208269119, 0.015267761424183846, 0.010972809046506882, 0.03912102431058884, -0.03320454806089401, -0.014257261529564857, -0.0033101688604801893, -0.022412477061152458, -0.0709368884563446, -0.03611872345209122, -0.0038091205060482025, 0.008471877314150333, 0.014927787706255913, -0.021704532206058502, 0.012961259111762047, -0.008045620284974575, -0.021582987159490585, 0.009265736676752567, 0.04601042717695236, -0.026317713782191277, -0.010318528860807419, -0.016346964985132217, 0.019346216693520546, 0.04604622721672058, 0.027335042133927345, -0.03560493513941765, 0.03335154056549072, -0.00190188258420676, -0.023115620017051697, -0.004140977747738361, 0.01802973635494709, -0.027958743274211884, -0.005589241161942482, -0.021525656804442406, 0.030781453475356102, 0.05302656069397926, -0.01908237487077713, -0.022919578477740288, 0.02366352453827858, 0.021741585806012154, -0.022929592058062553, -0.02220962941646576, -0.04012296721339226, -0.024060944095253944, 0.016271553933620453, 0.0011996605899184942, -0.005622001830488443, -0.04199471324682236, -0.01123132649809122, 0.009276669472455978, -0.011868942528963089, -0.006228768266737461, -0.00438855541869998, 0.08282892405986786, -0.017665689811110497, -0.02185642533004284, -0.006680701393634081, 0.019562868401408195, -0.01581897772848606, 0.011111863888800144, 0.005227656103670597, -0.001573041663505137, 0.015323338098824024, -0.06432176381349564, -0.009419144131243229, -0.05613669380545616, 0.03885919228196144, 0.0904230996966362, -0.020315131172537804, 0.00046770006883889437, 0.026138028129935265, 0.00034908982343040407, -0.04533396661281586, -0.03506912291049957, -0.042819794267416, -0.002534083090722561, -0.003950301557779312, 0.03379074111580849, -0.012228051200509071, -0.01636100746691227, 0.06902215629816055, 0.01518259197473526, 0.01578858308494091, 0.017767269164323807, -0.005831378512084484, 0.022714218124747276, -0.0010251074563711882, -0.030742652714252472, -0.026292888447642326, 0.007022705860435963, -0.012852675281465054, 0.013320188038051128, -0.03396023064851761, -0.02958962321281433, 0.027947383001446724, 0.02650909125804901, 0.012465552426874638, -0.010073333978652954, -0.033258069306612015, -0.022977575659751892, -0.02137301117181778, 0.041622959077358246, -0.024880612269043922, 0.02121567912399769, 0.025531277060508728, 0.0047506666742265224, -0.024886304512619972, 0.01208393182605505, -0.00389203242957592, -0.06768929958343506, -0.011558309197425842, -0.016234101727604866, -0.04197616130113602, -0.002536012791097164, 0.03991568833589554, -0.019892117008566856, 0.02295917458832264, -0.026967084035277367, -0.005108647048473358, 0.004835568834096193, 0.014112128876149654, -0.010364074259996414, 0.092845618724823, 0.03185083344578743, 0.02455204166471958, -0.020321888849139214, -0.008624851703643799, 0.09336888045072556, 0.03521052747964859, 0.005601189564913511, -0.05828661099076271, 0.017588390037417412, -0.033000871539115906, -0.00008832216553855687, -0.06047487631440163, 0.017802713438868523, -0.012064273469150066, 0.0014496101066470146, 0.0006251030135899782, 0.06600997596979141, 0.028078923001885414, 0.022555897012352943, 0.03145855292677879, -0.0022618097718805075, -0.039866238832473755, -0.021254179999232292, 0.021888764575123787, 0.0012057452695444226, 0.0061531891115009785, -0.05997799336910248, 0.008181028999388218, -0.038273051381111145, 0.016456428915262222, -0.04738553240895271, 0.0009206285467371345, -0.005586417391896248, -0.013410628773272038, -0.039301373064517975, -0.01812242530286312, 0.007938082329928875, -0.018322495743632317, -0.01758785918354988, 0.025109650567173958, 0.039487287402153015, 0.02288568578660488, 0.04794047400355339, 0.03543329983949661, 0.01252294797450304, 0.030517786741256714, 0.06749574095010757, -0.01065841130912304, -0.021410895511507988, -0.040023040026426315, -0.026717958971858025, 0.06611648201942444, -0.00873179454356432, -0.014681133441627026, 0.03307056054472923, -0.00782636646181345, -0.030934380367398262, -0.033711545169353485, -0.003549322485923767, 0.009105845354497433, 0.004079057835042477, -0.03538757190108299, 0.01423577219247818, -0.03063701093196869, 0.04227796941995621, 0.03134063258767128, 0.02102513611316681, 0.031646229326725006, -0.03525371104478836, -0.01179554220288992, -0.0391659215092659, 0.052824750542640686, 0.030034923925995827, -0.0054143997840583324, 0.0013228025054559112, -0.043641891330480576, -0.013247955590486526, -0.022802015766501427, -0.004143249709159136, -0.013734341599047184, 0.04889760538935661, -0.01817465014755726, -0.04660215601325035, -0.010984997265040874, -0.048951875418424606, -0.024250628426671028, 0.003266626736149192, 0.026004021987318993, -0.030131306499242783, -0.018100332468748093, -0.007748140022158623, -0.012348555959761143, -0.008201624266803265, 0.006252518389374018, 0.007540693040937185, 0.05499470233917236, 0.03050532378256321, -0.028489509597420692, -0.035665761679410934, -0.006851655896753073, -0.006032665725797415, -0.018511580303311348, -0.00950573105365038, 0.06766626238822937, -0.01053315494209528, 0.02417396381497383, 0.0017649400979280472, -0.006340553518384695, -0.043756335973739624, 0.017891887575387955, 0.015156058594584465, -0.048058781772851944, 0.01306210644543171, 0.03523320332169533, 0.03743709251284599, -0.016045719385147095, -0.027274610474705696, -0.015269506722688675, -0.018177904188632965, -0.009267379529774189, 0.000011186292795173358, -0.0629597157239914, -0.009904944337904453, -0.005485126283019781, 0.0225831288844347, -0.018617821857333183, 0.03613315895199776, -0.010735745541751385, 0.0344758965075016, 0.007531946990638971, -0.014468037523329258, -0.0465400293469429, 0.051004428416490555, -0.02722647599875927, -0.06075049191713333, -0.003527270397171378, -0.005723859649151564, -0.0038051302544772625, -0.008521451614797115, -0.024184372276067734, -0.012495574541389942, 0.04429399594664574, -0.03345566615462303, -0.019635558128356934, 0.033929482102394104, -0.017104821279644966, -0.018418578431010246, -0.002947016851976514, -0.010517354123294353, 0.0611780509352684, 0.021408412605524063, -0.009517226368188858, -0.020288052037358284, 0.03611930087208748, -0.042867839336395264, -0.025661448016762733, -0.03080655075609684, -0.004733966663479805, 0.015021893195807934, 0.011399311013519764, 0.01527490932494402, 0.006927812471985817, 0.010472848080098629, 0.05042039975523949, 0.054186128079891205, 0.01822866126894951, -0.040036868304014206, 0.026232866570353508, -0.004141727462410927, 0.03554745391011238, 0.022521961480379105, -0.0006540314061567187, 0.02709883265197277, 0.0048910267651081085, -0.029340673238039017, 0.030529070645570755, -0.045309700071811676, 0.032725315541028976, -0.08616475015878677, -0.0004190806648693979, 0.006739306729286909, 0.027797197923064232, 0.07416912913322449, -0.04747701808810234, -0.013015051372349262, 0.03909561038017273, -0.03129258006811142, 0.0005366215482354164, 0.004598267842084169, -0.011960274539887905, -0.02147110551595688, 0.01869492046535015, -0.03880969062447548, 0.00390921114012599, 0.02124561183154583, 0.0417775921523571, 0.03320510685443878, -0.003979802597314119, -0.03081117384135723, -0.04848829656839371, -0.015008781105279922, 0.015583236701786518, 0.031447041779756546, -0.016755586490035057, 0.06645507365465164, -0.03601716831326485, -0.020307715982198715, 0.042444076389074326, -0.008171423338353634, 0.003672685008496046, -0.025588754564523697, -0.006664009299129248, -0.018938317894935608, 0.051048312336206436, 0.028167245909571648, -0.019006511196494102, 0.04829816520214081, -0.010918895713984966, 0.016806961968541145, 0.017992354929447174, -0.029675250872969627, -0.015680192038416862, 0.02810071036219597, 0.023283222690224648, -0.06548503041267395, 0.01551666110754013, 0.026057204231619835, -0.006810668855905533, 0.017742767930030823, -0.002583215245977044, 0.025380559265613556, -0.03425315022468567, 0.0423777773976326, -0.037402521818876266, -0.05790894851088524, 0.009905974380671978, 0.010893572121858597, 0.022093720734119415, -0.02010822296142578, -0.0021303368266671896, -0.04569008946418762, -0.01454688236117363, 0.01836973801255226, -0.047581057995557785, -0.04584861546754837, -0.014297645539045334, 0.006847774609923363, -0.016214141622185707, 0.041909899562597275, -0.021973665803670883, -0.06803368777036667, 0.0044365860521793365, -0.009025819599628448, 0.009093751199543476, 0.00318860518746078, -0.005102743394672871, -0.021975278854370117, -0.06061527505517006, 0.026571208611130714, 0.007120003458112478, -0.015426610596477985, -0.011400846764445305, 0.00382539932616055, 0.001284967758692801, -0.028543412685394287, 0.05797383934259415, 0.015037632547318935, 0.00012901274021714926, 0.00295690237544477, 0.0030147347133606672, 0.03703461214900017, -0.07157496362924576, 0.011816700920462608, -0.012666446156799793, 0.0012276716297492385, -0.0065308017656207085, 0.023233328014612198, 0.02755255624651909, -0.023033548146486282, 0.006082004867494106, 0.01915632374584675, 0.021044133231043816, 0.023254644125699997, -0.00787252839654684, -0.001664998708292842, -0.01448856107890606, -0.0022636433131992817, 0.07693977653980255, 0.015292513184249401, -0.010482453741133213, 0.015440467745065689, 0.006240824703127146, -0.04712868109345436, 0.042519375681877136, -0.042360588908195496, -0.03298432007431984, -0.037951793521642685, 0.01600470207631588, -0.008023407310247421, -0.04704422876238823, -0.010942251421511173, 0.05459164083003998, -0.04051089286804199, -0.0335751511156559, 0.030308200046420097, 0.019522642716765404, 0.033054281026124954, 0.024028385058045387, -0.005356900859624147, 0.01430943887680769, 0.00007784512126818299, 0.03170258551836014, -0.00434821005910635, 0.028583409264683723, -0.015076410956680775, 0.0015800157561898232, 0.030361395329236984, -0.012935717590153217, 0.0008348656119778752, -0.012846403755247593, 0.0420507974922657, -0.052070580422878265, -0.05511099845170975, 0.010974272154271603, -0.008137332275509834, 0.005801687482744455, -0.022623969241976738, -0.027981584891676903, 0.0380396731197834, 0.005402612034231424, -0.006308906711637974, -0.04370977729558945, 0.003403860842809081, -0.023723701015114784, 0.011513261124491692, 0.05050254985690117, -0.015482346527278423, -0.026340508833527565, 0.008922933600842953, 0.010862977243959904, -0.002464212477207184, 0.03033583052456379, -0.017084697261452675, 0.01920393668115139, 0.010184451937675476, -0.006548224948346615, -0.03842772915959358, -0.03551051393151283, -0.02792946994304657, -0.040468621999025345, 0.014260063879191875, 0.0438053160905838, 0.016720516607165337, 0.004820032976567745, -0.0029123839922249317, -0.009498844854533672, 0.054749198257923126, -0.04062722623348236, -0.0173890870064497, -0.02909955382347107, 0.0067131407558918, -0.009384063072502613, -0.044803157448768616 ]
<p>Bear with me as I try to word this question well (I'm a mathematical modeler, but not a statistics guru).</p> <p>We want to assess the response patterns of a binary timeseries. The data are from people answering questions for information they have not previously seen. The scenario is that answers are either correct <em>or</em> incorrect, and they have to get an answer correct twice in a row before it is "retired." Since people have not previously seen the information, the "perfect" pattern is <code>0-1-1</code>, meaning the person answered incorrectly, then was presented the correct answer/information, then retained that for the next two attempts.</p> <p>I'm trying to assess people's "trend" and am seeking a pointer to how this might be possible. It's not enough to collect responses, since two people having 3 correct responses and 3 incorrect responses might reflect very different "trends." To wit:</p> <ul> <li>Person A: <code>0-0-1-0-1-1</code></li> <li>Person B: <code>1-0-1-0-1-0</code></li> </ul> <p>In the first case, the person experiences a trend toward understanding. In the second, the person is alternating with no trend toward understanding. Ideally, we'd come up with some number normalized to assess some distance from the perfect <code>0-1-1</code> pattern. For instance, <code>1-0-1-1</code> would be more distant than <code>0-0-1-1</code>, but closer than <code>0-0-0-1-1</code>. Even a distance from 0, 1, or some other arbitrary point would be good if it was internally consistent.</p> <p>My first thought would be to look for something in signal analysis– assess the periodicity of the signal of responses. However, I was wondering if the statistics community has some manner to assess a binary sequence like this. Of course, I'm not looking for an easy answer (since there might not be one) but pointers in the right direction would be helpful.</p> <h2>Edit to address @gung's questions:</h2> <p>I don't expect that the timeseries will be more than 10 to 20 attempts max. Mean number of attempts per question seems to be about 2.8 for well written questions. The series will be different for each user's response to each question, with thousands of users answering generally on the order of 10 questions each (i.e somewhere between 1 and 100, depending on how long they participate). </p> <p>I'm looking to rank individual users per question and per group of questions, but also try to rank questions by groups of users (i.e. this question was poor because many users flipped back and forth between 0 and 1).</p>
74,175
[ -0.04987168684601784, -0.04928182438015938, -0.011660388670861721, -0.007734391838312149, 0.03398442268371582, 0.008213868364691734, 0.04974772781133652, 0.022514939308166504, 0.019254447892308235, 0.009413020685315132, 0.042276132851839066, 0.027385229244828224, 0.0015416322275996208, 0.013924051076173782, 0.038209158927202225, 0.009351229295134544, 0.0018771616742014885, 0.016627252101898193, -0.026804910972714424, -0.00922609306871891, 0.025538820773363113, -0.02095618098974228, 0.03183938190340996, 0.016808683052659035, -0.05700807273387909, 0.011936021968722343, 0.040160637348890305, -0.03530629351735115, -0.01616492308676243, 0.06470438092947006, -0.057314466685056686, -0.04409271106123924, 0.013020619750022888, 0.045356106013059616, 0.019359653815627098, 0.04791238531470299, 0.0013410174287855625, -0.014795641414821148, -0.016175825148820877, 0.05165019631385803, 0.006109199952334166, -0.024643175303936005, -0.020433643832802773, 0.016449792310595512, -0.014684546738862991, -0.011944237165153027, -0.023208370432257652, 0.00921657495200634, 0.03798694163560867, -0.01865452527999878, 0.0730292797088623, -0.033194344490766525, 0.0051913633942604065, -0.008400779217481613, 0.007065757643431425, -0.024300657212734222, 0.07605025172233582, 0.033124689012765884, 0.009484370239078999, -0.06726314127445221, -0.031396813690662384, -0.0260324589908123, -0.01379712950438261, 0.022832460701465607, 0.005029400810599327, 0.042511485517024994, -0.003547831205651164, -0.005290597211569548, 0.058805689215660095, -0.022710150107741356, -0.018846461549401283, 0.043200187385082245, 0.0485546812415123, -0.020908735692501068, 0.02224021963775158, -0.05289332568645477, -0.015903286635875702, 0.0007953591411933303, 0.001626556389965117, 0.058201100677251816, -0.04036310315132141, -0.014885217882692814, 0.0020274531561881304, 0.06553369015455246, 0.018310699611902237, -0.01263365987688303, 0.06488915532827377, -0.05293666943907738, -0.035378653556108475, 0.038060594350099564, 0.011133567430078983, -0.014991676434874535, 0.017916271463036537, -0.00032018934143707156, -0.04496913030743599, 0.05910899117588997, -0.004134557209908962, 0.02192562259733677, 0.017682243138551712, -0.014615045860409737, 0.00019336366676725447, -0.036826830357313156, 0.004539281129837036, 0.023078106343746185, -0.032356832176446915, 0.024933235719799995, -0.050381071865558624, -0.022206986322999, -0.03343023359775543, -0.03288913890719414, -0.010826248675584793, 0.009821941144764423, 0.024714915081858635, 0.01008454617112875, -0.017413340508937836, -0.03156918287277222, -0.020159652456641197, -0.027485040947794914, 0.08555271476507187, 0.04359295964241028, 0.0479741208255291, -0.018667742609977722, 0.0032691643573343754, -0.02864592894911766, -0.06091129779815674, -0.04213110730051994, 0.01360356155782938, -0.00680204201489687, -0.024908455088734627, 0.06198085844516754, -0.015379700809717178, 0.02577778697013855, 0.055864136666059494, -0.03270692005753517, 0.005474312696605921, 0.01842813566327095, -0.07226330041885376, -0.04355907812714577, 0.020924188196659088, 0.018058260902762413, -0.04019283503293991, -0.06258371472358704, 0.008384483866393566, 0.04186522960662842, 0.021389184519648552, 0.037908658385276794, 0.006358663085848093, 0.01800614595413208, 0.024908270686864853, 0.04776185750961304, 0.0163570623844862, 0.03439225256443024, -0.004915696568787098, -0.0187176913022995, -0.014775705523788929, -0.018846098333597183, 0.012127967551350594, 0.044364508241415024, -0.02052036114037037, -0.019135234877467155, 0.023163218051195145, 0.01341635175049305, -0.02252470701932907, -0.021667031571269035, 0.005560307763516903, 0.005531737115234137, 0.07164177298545837, -0.004174510948359966, 0.001550710410811007, 0.018510829657316208, -0.0038536530919373035, 0.03665094077587128, 0.00021728886349592358, 0.006300424691289663, 0.05128857120871544, -0.05825907364487648, 0.006542959250509739, 0.0007439024047926068, 0.0023361635394394398, -0.018664024770259857, -0.05284973978996277, -0.03695042058825493, -0.0453638955950737, 0.03593709319829941, 0.007055449299514294, 0.014022859744727612, -0.020735621452331543, 0.011972419917583466, 0.024479882791638374, -0.033557623624801636, -0.00477941008284688, -0.03998052701354027, -0.011563112027943134, 0.0035380178596824408, -0.023733848705887794, 0.024711715057492256, -0.03883880376815796, 0.013319290243089199, -0.01839330419898033, -0.0008138238918036222, -0.015387250110507011, 0.0025216033682227135, 0.04555594176054001, -0.02352045103907585, -0.008674690499901772, 0.033255916088819504, 0.007340031675994396, -0.030079735442996025, 0.022843530401587486, -0.037027757614851, -0.0002947901957668364, -0.006173453293740749, -0.023219231516122818, 0.0469382144510746, -0.0009545085486024618, 0.022991599515080452, 0.03682081401348114, 0.014911984093487263, -0.009645679034292698, -0.0103830611333251, -0.050826605409383774, 0.059921540319919586, 0.05220356583595276, -0.0030280689243227243, -0.013918560929596424, 0.008979671634733677, -0.005289304070174694, 0.01810556836426258, -0.01967783086001873, -0.032773129642009735, -0.07437607645988464, 0.010763094760477543, 0.032472819089889526, 0.023360582068562508, -0.02745934948325157, 0.021452713757753372, 0.05923271179199219, 0.03367636725306511, -0.047859132289886475, 0.02218955010175705, -0.037543971091508865, 0.002041031839326024, -0.004852970130741596, -0.02489996887743473, 0.0015980966854840517, 0.019667726010084152, 0.024835506454110146, -0.014002135954797268, -0.022503595799207687, 0.06428086757659912, 0.018358347937464714, -0.008500158786773682, 0.00349813187494874, 0.015008754096925259, -0.04329853877425194, -0.014039795845746994, -0.001902678981423378, -0.008702564984560013, -0.019102061167359352, 0.06161312386393547, -0.005209058057516813, 0.015987448394298553, 0.003951054997742176, 0.00608969759196043, -0.0006800204864703119, 0.023199081420898438, 0.0006986281950958073, 0.009670409373939037, 0.028085749596357346, -0.02572452649474144, 0.032751910388469696, -0.03743089362978935, -0.050837237387895584, -0.012909192591905594, -0.01711421087384224, 0.021472828462719917, 0.04699475318193436, 0.0026821631472557783, -0.030681602656841278, 0.008082493208348751, 0.01707417517900467, 0.012158774770796299, 0.03134915232658386, -0.01629679836332798, -0.06316140294075012, -0.010446060448884964, 0.0219716876745224, 0.004826270043849945, 0.022110790014266968, 0.02342873066663742, -0.03511121869087219, 0.05124562978744507, -0.008685541339218616, -0.0642293244600296, -0.0169171541929245, -0.04010090231895447, 0.011662473902106285, -0.004245301242917776, 0.005964135751128197, 0.07076547294855118, 0.025669457390904427, -0.11304857581853867, 0.04454539343714714, -0.051187913864851, -0.03000766783952713, -0.027171267196536064, -0.040837496519088745, -0.0017803988885134459, 0.0006389508489519358, 0.01988498866558075, -0.014898370951414108, 0.0002083162689814344, -0.0032970223110169172, -0.05640863627195358, -0.06778759509325027, 0.0031893395353108644, -0.021646304056048393, 0.05334126949310303, 0.005893766414374113, 0.030030183494091034, 0.07256507128477097, 0.020050475373864174, -0.00620175339281559, -0.01759503223001957, 0.010195387527346611, -0.015503967180848122, -0.018292075023055077, 0.04301343485713005, 0.05733257532119751, 0.020455941557884216, -0.01621044985949993, -0.005619422998279333, 0.06154824048280716, 0.05683699622750282, -0.005789706949144602, 0.020973987877368927, 0.01805969513952732, 0.033067215234041214, 0.004369636531919241, 0.004561335779726505, 0.022180423140525818, -0.03730503097176552, -0.01503209862858057, 0.010602707974612713, -0.008629330433905125, 0.039657700806856155, -0.028469355776906013, 0.03077438473701477, -0.027024883776903152, -0.0032348823733627796, -0.016851192340254784, 0.008097585290670395, 0.014070472680032253, -0.02331903949379921, -0.05615968629717827, 0.015148480422794819, 0.025081323459744453, 0.0030423449352383614, -0.010642279870808125, 0.08602385222911835, 0.0344979390501976, -0.001551189343445003, -0.013459114357829094, -0.004567819181829691, 0.014470868743956089, 0.037942614406347275, -0.054553158581256866, 0.015258446335792542, 0.025050751864910126, 0.047583263367414474, 0.04514899104833603, 0.009314721450209618, -0.041244249790906906, -0.012961848638951778, -0.048586901277303696, -0.009016900323331356, -0.04050486534833908, 0.04461565241217613, -0.01715625636279583, 0.03740299493074417, 0.01920180208981037, 0.0014872064348310232, 0.015068015083670616, 0.020162496715784073, -0.06241053715348244, -0.0036896124947816133, -0.01451115496456623, -0.02220919355750084, 0.013414617627859116, 0.018033144995570183, 0.025251107290387154, -0.03257042542099953, 0.006336814258247614, 0.009829464368522167, 0.0529201366007328, -0.053536009043455124, -0.007111145183444023, 0.014187577180564404, 0.0021540496964007616, -0.03175429627299309, 0.011366810649633408, 0.017245039343833923, 0.01636085845530033, 0.06666436791419983, 0.023396490141749382, 0.03947446867823601, 0.009362157434225082, -0.027496909722685814, -0.012394650839269161, 0.010648254305124283, 0.021964481100440025, 0.0011364020174369216, 0.0319809690117836, -0.05010085925459862, 0.015509700402617455, -0.0012459310237318277, 0.008520781062543392, 0.036594558507204056, -0.02430448681116104, 0.007005875930190086, -0.010924466885626316, -0.029158063232898712, 0.007791468873620033, 0.03409386798739433, 0.012594022788107395, 0.029423411935567856, 0.02604273334145546, 0.030684908851981163, -0.02873721346259117, 0.030587267130613327, 0.04345227777957916, -0.036340150982141495, -0.019708098843693733, -0.023871038109064102, 0.008390569128096104, 0.014210211113095284, 0.0241566002368927, -0.012659922242164612, 0.05469634756445885, 0.0276887658983469, -0.010305468924343586, 0.03293556347489357, 0.05226973444223404, -0.035232167690992355, -0.009820881299674511, 0.002598554827272892, 0.008586050942540169, 0.019516052678227425, 0.006465716753154993, -0.025825681164860725, 0.04422275722026825, 0.05376267060637474, 0.004945427644997835, -0.028460051864385605, -0.10418365150690079, -0.04036210849881172, 0.048474717885255814, 0.05774712190032005, -0.03508354350924492, 0.00021949577785562724, -0.04614875465631485, -0.037252165377140045, 0.024520307779312134, -0.024462668225169182, 0.019666967913508415, -0.02076355181634426, -0.004452885594218969, -0.03839585930109024, -0.006410619243979454, -0.05462528392672539, 0.02571338228881359, -0.03969581797719002, 0.03981911763548851, 0.012412838637828827, -0.018141159787774086, -0.06162704527378082, 0.019023984670639038, 0.021233266219496727, 0.05172675475478172, -0.0736563503742218, -0.0022248912137001753, -0.005917102098464966, -0.010607062838971615, -0.018414292484521866, -0.039595842361450195, 0.04908965900540352, 0.0107107600197196, -0.021689770743250847, 0.02221938595175743, -0.01239724364131689, -0.04030143469572067, -0.0065118176862597466, 0.018911926075816154, 0.01617732085287571, 0.011138816364109516, -0.023287391290068626, 0.06451573967933655, 0.01614793948829174, 0.00659968750551343, 0.03498425707221031, 0.05305984988808632, -0.007831200025975704, -0.0044740648008883, -0.025977371260523796, -0.026245836168527603, -0.02457813359797001, 0.018999580293893814, -0.01862575113773346, 0.006946112494915724, -0.06485104560852051, 0.04288443922996521, 0.00664926553145051, 0.013593597337603569, 0.009386388584971428, -0.005625028163194656, -0.0014010773738846183, 0.0069416887126863, -0.026936788111925125, 0.013259213417768478, -0.016456443816423416, -0.028287271037697792, 0.0019314039964228868, 0.0011265435023233294, 0.05038034915924072, -0.09187418967485428, -0.029751017689704895, 0.029852500185370445, -0.020352372899651527, 0.0010213942732661963, -0.019024182111024857, -0.025685692206025124, 0.011742420494556427, -0.03238864988088608, 0.05565287917852402, 0.00699569471180439, 0.016834983602166176, 0.00723858829587698, 0.002195879351347685, -0.01799420453608036, 0.039294712245464325, -0.02864891104400158, 0.02085771970450878, -0.023863326758146286, 0.026470063254237175, -0.01817871443927288, -0.004791192710399628, -0.03802115470170975, -0.03713950514793396, 0.04506266117095947, 0.0269553754478693, -0.019132819026708603, -0.018327785655856133, -0.003736669197678566, 0.035150568932294846, -0.006348556838929653, 0.02418716996908188, 0.015434768982231617, -0.03163899481296539, -0.02958216518163681, -0.016764376312494278, 0.002215486252680421, 0.08710461109876633, 0.02386011928319931, -0.020049097016453743, 0.020307371392846107, -0.008961842395365238, -0.008115598931908607, -0.03280271217226982, -0.010898721404373646, -0.04370603337883949, -0.025975782424211502, -0.05567348375916481, 0.011116103269159794, 0.03939749300479889, -0.05166393518447876, -0.010387017391622066, 0.0056343674659729, -0.04207029566168785, 0.017353108152747154, -0.03976674750447273, -0.007203294895589352, -0.036368995904922485, -0.0016412318218499422, -0.056257907301187515, -0.0363946333527565, -0.017820006236433983, -0.0069635105319321156, 0.01061171293258667, 0.013477270491421223, -0.08657141774892807, 0.008725648745894432, 0.03641730174422264, 0.0036275412421673536, -0.024913646280765533, 0.010080888867378235, -0.010988956317305565, 0.043789174407720566, 0.017816197127103806, 0.0030582775361835957, 0.011593353934586048, 0.015943780541419983, -0.009649861603975296, -0.02723148837685585, -0.012341395951807499, -0.05895186960697174, 0.07440735399723053, 0.029609277844429016, 0.046779364347457886, 0.003401984227821231, 0.008907724171876907, 0.00375975389033556, -0.013462398201227188, 0.019366033375263214, -0.013476161286234856, 0.007736233063042164, 0.01377023383975029, -0.025196272879838943, -0.005987744778394699, 0.041778936982154846, 0.029630646109580994, 0.009759106673300266, 0.026754137128591537, 0.015427129343152046, -0.0075714848935604095, 0.04561038315296173, -0.04919173941016197, -0.04363970085978508, 0.020536324009299278, -0.05180957540869713, 0.030962485820055008, 0.009816738776862621, -0.041572440415620804, 0.024961840361356735, 0.041779518127441406, -0.006172060966491699, -0.03918137401342392, -0.002632230520248413, -0.07077761739492416, -0.010835920460522175, 0.025024661794304848, -0.004738297779113054, 0.033440180122852325, -0.014440223574638367, 0.02383473515510559, -0.012763714417815208, 0.018717288970947266, -0.0043204305693507195, -0.0772542878985405, -0.021484723314642906, 0.006768792401999235, -0.06043357402086258, 0.06390377134084702, 0.021070389077067375, 0.022027332335710526, -0.007157234940677881, -0.02938934788107872, 0.040345899760723114, 0.03893846645951271, 0.03136693313717842, -0.04943190515041351, 0.04943649098277092, -0.0045182970352470875, 0.019180091097950935, -0.03794077783823013, -0.025863848626613617, 0.12948735058307648, 0.0641152486205101, 0.03256770595908165, -0.0522296279668808, 0.01548271719366312, 0.030156191438436508, 0.02347501553595066, -0.007748263888061047, 0.023121817037463188, 0.05066662281751633, -0.0021048467606306076, 0.04788191616535187, 0.06246200203895569, 0.02745591104030609, 0.004476518370211124, 0.05887053161859512, -0.00019286065071355551, -0.024695901200175285, 0.00797731988132, 0.04743382707238197, 0.04015957564115524, 0.02372933365404606, -0.035914696753025055, -0.0032996926456689835, 0.01866445690393448, -0.02304113656282425, -0.013580587692558765, -0.007854513823986053, 0.00036779831862077117, -0.009196392260491848, -0.005112429149448872, 0.053803637623786926, 0.02568991109728813, 0.005764703266322613, -0.017273006960749626, -0.029308147728443146, 0.008558091707527637, -0.01770813763141632, 0.013248611241579056, 0.04121413454413414, -0.009622951969504356, -0.007271691225469112, 0.013082756660878658, -0.008122816681861877, -0.03868165984749794, -0.015802625566720963, -0.06342707574367523, 0.028306081891059875, -0.018984340131282806, -0.029614100232720375, -0.013190149329602718, -0.021943120285868645, -0.013157661072909832, -0.026885293424129486, -0.01740107126533985, 0.04325646907091141, 0.026322467252612114, -0.02227318286895752, -0.03508395329117775, 0.021439209580421448, -0.005093934014439583, -0.0153113454580307, -0.0002993165689986199, 0.0027691014111042023, -0.019560599699616432, -0.04248926416039467, -0.0028950716368854046, 0.07229450345039368, -0.0023540332913398743, 0.010365141555666924, 0.005425308831036091, -0.02014884725213051, -0.043331753462553024, 0.02359219454228878, -0.0024320457596331835, 0.014250144362449646, 0.026645487174391747, 0.02285667136311531, -0.002928653499111533, -0.006362473592162132, -0.022434096783399582, 0.03000260517001152, 0.010494748130440712, 0.010167400352656841, -0.0436323843896389, 0.0024337961804121733, 0.0341363251209259, 0.040241122245788574, 0.004768676590174437, -0.0017439427319914103, 0.050068192183971405, 0.09297148138284683, 0.017590617761015892, -0.06398962438106537, -0.02578028477728367, 0.002384993014857173, -0.018461542204022408, 0.007860115729272366, -0.033752962946891785, 0.0928557813167572, 0.027391567826271057, -0.004254264757037163, 0.01540714967995882, 0.001521961996331811, -0.024728883057832718, 0.00010474103328306228, -0.01217119861394167, -0.030355658382177353, -0.036848653107881546, -0.010840358212590218, -0.00545760802924633, -0.01875481754541397, -0.04015636816620827, -0.03308388963341713, 0.007911963388323784, -0.004178112372756004, 0.009243538603186607, -0.0246569886803627, 0.02767838165163994, -0.020933017134666443, -0.04702530428767204, -0.024784712120890617, 0.0014050797326490283, -0.009037422016263008, -0.016862891614437103, -0.02884107083082199, -0.016461094841361046, 0.02327091246843338, 0.0056564281694591045, -0.013213015161454678, 0.03374524787068367, 0.053952690213918686, 0.0025915971491485834, 0.03508139029145241, 0.003993856720626354, 0.00590917281806469, -0.028737260028719902, 0.020177926868200302, -0.012161847203969955, -0.035477910190820694, 0.01972520723938942, -0.03762638941407204, -0.029653847217559814, 0.033371374011039734, 0.008805040270090103, -0.006131979636847973, -0.02101963385939598, -0.02131713554263115, 0.026943091303110123, 0.012599878013134003, 0.0008792460430413485, -0.011483689770102501, -0.00406219344586134, 0.005254218354821205, -0.004947843961417675, 0.015375652350485325, 0.003681703470647335, 0.012621549889445305, -0.04154813662171364, 0.009212957695126534, 0.07208751142024994, -0.0041569857858121395, -0.019681917503476143, -0.012343183159828186, -0.027310853824019432, -0.00469317426905036, -0.016062146052718163, -0.013280552811920643, 0.005125246476382017, 0.015812186524271965, -0.004206182435154915, 0.026364052668213844, -0.020554127171635628, -0.023047471418976784, -0.055416472256183624, 0.011501248925924301, 0.029596397653222084, 0.029414964839816093, 0.016020838171243668, -0.04394889622926712, -0.011785815469920635, 0.010453995317220688, -0.03165099397301674, 0.037169672548770905, 0.013226790353655815, -0.0005158714484423399, -0.017065836116671562, 0.026026785373687744, -0.029801001772284508, 0.013009140267968178, 0.039949484169483185, 0.020366478711366653, 0.02839166671037674, 0.03138577938079834, -0.026369314640760422, -0.01077264454215765, -0.009998930618166924, 0.0038537969812750816, 0.02337336353957653, -0.02359270490705967, 0.024763109162449837, -0.046606335788965225, -0.009458585642278194, 0.037851449102163315, -0.0162439476698637, 0.04230967164039612, 0.00934761855751276, 0.04295060783624649, 0.012274435721337795, 0.05370056629180908, -0.0015182428760454059, -0.03889482840895653, -0.02690681256353855, -0.029359709471464157, -0.002939182333648205, 0.045119088143110275, -0.023000240325927734, 0.017295628786087036, 0.029489925131201744, 0.002644619671627879, -0.03589353337883949, 0.023569095879793167, -0.023790942505002022, -0.0318148136138916, -0.0085117407143116, 0.012398011982440948, 0.019749362021684647, -0.024743178859353065, -0.01255756989121437, -0.06520786881446838, 0.00018360333342570812, 0.0015889317728579044, 0.031415585428476334, 0.0010905496310442686, 0.0047503309324383736, -0.008160571567714214, -0.020418331027030945, 0.02725467085838318, -0.004844538401812315, -0.002032024785876274, -0.055173709988594055, -0.030919987708330154, -0.02127460204064846, 0.042993463575839996, -0.011528373695909977, -0.030742868781089783, -0.011253898963332176, 0.05468667298555374, -0.026585891842842102, -0.03634549677371979, 0.008513416163623333, -0.046940818428993225, 0.015258654952049255, -0.0860237404704094, 0.05054952949285507, 0.006792507134377956, 0.03414779528975487, -0.0433378629386425, -0.03001062385737896, -0.047175031155347824, 0.033573705703020096, 0.0860726609826088, -0.00835383404046297, -0.031120723113417625, -0.013864606618881226, -0.005233074072748423, 0.018913667649030685, -0.015867190435528755, 0.04551929235458374, -0.025388896465301514, -0.016021447256207466, -0.0015391960041597486, -0.006384752690792084, -0.0009619856718927622, -0.0035229576751589775, 0.007772132754325867, -0.024965202435851097, -0.008947683498263359, -0.027065321803092957, -0.033058978617191315, 0.03297313675284386, 0.03345303609967232, -0.01695578172802925, 0.012786606326699257, 0.011423705145716667, 0.009323891252279282, 0.03774981573224068, 0.006486523896455765, -0.08560225367546082, 0.011328354477882385, -0.028244180604815483, -0.06599505990743637, 0.01398277934640646, 0.014124457724392414, 0.03251885622739792, -0.07009442895650864, -0.027003852650523186, 0.012005380354821682, -0.004473689012229443, -0.006698089186102152, 0.04031775891780853, -0.015427794307470322, 0.022531287744641304, -0.004688373301178217, 0.025119923055171967, 0.005151628982275724, -0.0028151306323707104, 0.029222898185253143, 0.008102103136479855, 0.04589495435357094, -0.030835440382361412, 0.061582427471876144, -0.006693897768855095, -0.007410739082843065, 0.025646133348345757, -0.007139828056097031, 0.027210740372538567, -0.001559973694384098, 0.06252843886613846, 0.08044541627168655, -0.019416864961385727, -0.04273426532745361, 0.042617812752723694, 0.019317571073770523, 0.03887070342898369, -0.03713463619351387, 0.0026887226849794388, -0.008526412770152092, -0.0018785183783620596, -0.031384944915771484, -0.0063491459004580975, 0.019225016236305237, -0.022059082984924316, -0.010286250151693821, -0.0011022364487871528, 0.01724741794168949, -0.00846847239881754, 0.021154267713427544, -0.02719246968626976, 0.02247035689651966, 0.010070869699120522, 0.006664058659225702, 0.011153695173561573, -0.02750629372894764, -0.08639223128557205, -0.030814645811915398, 0.029058394953608513, 0.008210320957005024, 0.03687193989753723, -0.05902191624045372, 0.012059925124049187, -0.012277722358703613, 0.03446037322282791, -0.023682549595832825, 0.0045857857912778854, -0.06382868438959122, 0.04240039363503456, 0.010626299306750298, -0.05276782065629959 ]
<p>I work on a website that gets around 150,000 unique visitors a month.</p> <p>I am proposing to sample one in 1,000 people visiting the site with a pop-up survey as described in this <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/39319/bayesian-user-survey-with-a-credible-interval">question and answer about calculating credible intervals for survey data</a>. When we ran this survey in the past, giving it to all our users for a week, about 1 in 5 answered the question and 4 in 5 dismissed the pop-up without answering.</p> <p>My Program Manager and my Director want to know what the justification for sampling 1 in 1,000 is (I was hoping this would minimize user annoyance by sampling at a low rate, and if the rate is low I would not need to set "supercookies" to keep track of who has taken the survey already, I'd just survey them again if they use the site so much.) They also question why, in the previous question and answer, this issue of size of the population the sample is from does not figure into the calculation of the credible interval.</p> <p>(How) do sampling rate (1% sampled vs. 1 per thousand) and completion rate affect the quantification of how certain we are about our results and conclusions? Or is it just the number of samples that matter without regard to knowing the total population size?</p>
74,176
[ -0.041610874235630035, -0.05086643248796463, 0.018249329179525375, -0.024790599942207336, 0.04829902574419975, -0.011277636513113976, -0.00037414071266539395, -0.03727356344461441, -0.01726778782904148, 0.006044492125511169, 0.0547703392803669, 0.05785789340734482, 0.04468437656760216, 0.028177672997117043, -0.005827502813190222, 0.027622202411293983, 0.0011067255400121212, 0.03713703528046608, -0.009041275829076767, -0.00005169345604372211, 0.010916449129581451, 0.007297861855477095, 0.034614138305187225, -0.0379205085337162, -0.04183197021484375, 0.026238663122057915, 0.015888690948486328, -0.01845887303352356, 0.025063486769795418, 0.0728408545255661, -0.06011315807700157, -0.01393984816968441, 0.04446442425251007, 0.03738703206181526, 0.008822825737297535, 0.028346937149763107, -0.027590086683630943, -0.00022876269940752536, -0.00194302829913795, 0.03994898498058319, -0.044394511729478836, 0.030129730701446533, 0.007438153959810734, 0.006113232113420963, -0.013810429722070694, -0.009426943026483059, -0.017816590145230293, -0.030192097648978233, 0.03716156631708145, 0.00010145515989279374, 0.04689406231045723, 0.0006453562527894974, 0.02704424038529396, 0.0026249962393194437, 0.001787233049981296, -0.029566165059804916, 0.044184643775224686, 0.049691420048475266, -0.04276994243264198, -0.03633686155080795, -0.02741953544318676, -0.035821281373500824, -0.006429600063711405, -0.007803970482200384, -0.018222980201244354, 0.06075819209218025, -0.027056477963924408, -0.02223101072013378, 0.032518401741981506, -0.022466111928224564, 0.023247050121426582, 0.03132907673716545, 0.010586573742330074, -0.00597739452496171, 0.015232454054057598, -0.06236808001995087, 0.018920060247182846, 0.042951975017786026, 0.045044977217912674, 0.05228201672434807, -0.041385453194379807, -0.0073808329179883, 0.03438461944460869, 0.04515407234430313, 0.0308024063706398, -0.032997969537973404, 0.07178492099046707, -0.03327411785721779, 0.012014882639050484, -0.012945109978318214, -0.010869153775274754, -0.007355095818638802, 0.06441283971071243, 0.005583266727626324, -0.029340926557779312, 0.0302963275462389, -0.03697684034705162, 0.08333252370357513, -0.02249632589519024, -0.011623121798038483, -0.019561734050512314, -0.06725451350212097, 0.036285724490880966, 0.052407510578632355, -0.03781142085790634, -0.013441761955618858, -0.03572508692741394, -0.023989982903003693, -0.01953713782131672, -0.0426701195538044, -0.017443673685193062, -0.007545578293502331, 0.0016286197351291776, 0.015131254680454731, 0.016411496326327324, 0.014528520405292511, 0.019095223397016525, -0.017194712534546852, 0.05887888744473457, 0.029730426147580147, 0.03646792098879814, 0.01538198534399271, -0.0004688611952587962, -0.03438251465559006, -0.05765364691615105, 0.02225489541888237, 0.011970861814916134, -0.023231299594044685, -0.032160572707653046, 0.02053433284163475, 0.0022683213464915752, -0.01306217722594738, 0.04509880766272545, 0.00780988996848464, 0.03927105292677879, 0.012800325639545918, -0.06993405520915985, -0.03769736364483833, 0.04251394793391228, 0.0221459548920393, -0.02739713527262211, -0.07077936828136444, 0.0062820506282150745, 0.03055950254201889, 0.025704599916934967, 0.00316590815782547, 0.06160784885287285, -0.011028733104467392, 0.019890010356903076, 0.006022413726896048, -0.044682908803224564, -0.002041839761659503, -0.022060738876461983, -0.015948548913002014, -0.0350794792175293, -0.06579694896936417, 0.0179878119379282, 0.020314177498221397, 0.009203107096254826, -0.043318141251802444, 0.024035988375544548, 0.026705840602517128, -0.02530706487596035, -0.03615661710500717, 0.05140042304992676, -0.031889479607343674, 0.0907519981265068, -0.010650193318724632, 0.031676970422267914, 0.014439179562032223, -0.044877856969833374, 0.0033859130926430225, 0.026288891211152077, 0.011411873623728752, 0.04914421588182449, -0.038819100707769394, -0.005248703993856907, -0.003784365952014923, 0.021251261234283447, 0.00034453292028047144, -0.029286453500390053, -0.011857966892421246, -0.007994335144758224, -0.024870147928595543, 0.03736892715096474, 0.03359938785433769, 0.014476447366178036, -0.03432059288024902, 0.03598172590136528, -0.05838550999760628, -0.047410234808921814, -0.07884326577186584, -0.004074962809681892, 0.012002813629806042, -0.014849700033664703, -0.002267757896333933, -0.028677433729171753, -0.02135857567191124, -0.013727650046348572, -0.020273001864552498, -0.02665843814611435, -0.007521592080593109, 0.0722949206829071, -0.053547512739896774, -0.029904015362262726, 0.03210952505469322, 0.026789451017975807, -0.023293448612093925, 0.024333756417036057, -0.033852413296699524, -0.07289203256368637, -0.01630096137523651, -0.007569105830043554, 0.005438142456114292, -0.02391742914915085, -0.02158951759338379, -0.013712060637772083, 0.02053660899400711, -0.02639719285070896, 0.05789466202259064, -0.050066184252500534, 0.06652460247278214, 0.03426763042807579, -0.016917657107114792, 0.0004298578714951873, 0.031790584325790405, 0.0185259860008955, -0.02056589350104332, -0.03151850029826164, -0.01080123521387577, -0.0727938786149025, -0.0003430865181144327, 0.07646474242210388, -0.023656683042645454, -0.010503457859158516, -0.007807738613337278, 0.04097425937652588, 0.02098170667886734, -0.0030389316380023956, -0.00003619475683080964, 0.00466308044269681, -0.05339242145419121, -0.003375770291313529, -0.00447720056399703, 0.01868511363863945, 0.02936316840350628, -0.010092814452946186, -0.0018355133943259716, 0.02159973420202732, 0.04236156493425369, 0.033479757606983185, 0.03152909129858017, -0.0009169405093416572, -0.008516407571732998, 0.010953957214951515, 0.027036147192120552, 0.03471735119819641, -0.019551370292901993, -0.044229455292224884, 0.014303341507911682, -0.0021223195362836123, -0.0010966690024361014, -0.011037535965442657, -0.014057784341275692, 0.019085919484496117, 0.05468868836760521, -0.04991057142615318, -0.015032286755740643, 0.017854085192084312, -0.017144836485385895, 0.003662751754745841, -0.026192545890808105, -0.06459212303161621, -0.005405312404036522, 0.008560949005186558, 0.03389705717563629, 0.014882063493132591, 0.057980164885520935, -0.04232157766819, -0.039979930967092514, 0.003208333160728216, 0.008162274956703186, -0.03292878344655037, -0.025927050039172173, -0.03818199411034584, -0.017003746703267097, 0.04332517459988594, -0.029083432629704475, 0.02561151050031185, 0.010068530216813087, -0.009924176149070263, -0.003999765962362289, 0.008392357267439365, -0.0381331741809845, -0.007110626436769962, -0.04804358258843422, 0.015072980895638466, 0.008919036015868187, -0.013753903098404408, 0.04577287659049034, 0.03476061671972275, -0.03305131196975708, 0.04647998511791229, -0.0014915408100932837, -0.017388897016644478, -0.037443459033966064, 0.012543286196887493, -0.014257087372243404, -0.01593121886253357, -0.019424133002758026, -0.004688320681452751, 0.00578512717038393, -0.012495309114456177, -0.048214755952358246, -0.08786367624998093, 0.010997943580150604, 0.008161199279129505, 0.04234635457396507, 0.011389591731131077, -0.0017289248062297702, 0.0895857885479927, 0.04069649055600166, -0.03329810872673988, -0.00673214765265584, -0.04526267945766449, -0.013908948749303818, 0.005402884446084499, 0.007829018868505955, -0.002399723744019866, -0.013517948798835278, 0.026799308136105537, -0.00804116576910019, 0.006616177503019571, 0.01652655564248562, 0.0009216099861077964, 0.018610097467899323, 0.015936601907014847, 0.0053825643844902515, 0.009867195039987564, -0.003717974293977022, 0.042426519095897675, -0.04534118250012398, 0.0024826982989907265, -0.038155846297740936, 0.025069233030080795, 0.03352874889969826, -0.026895487681031227, 0.018042579293251038, 0.00011494840873638168, 0.01499146968126297, -0.011742928996682167, 0.028347093611955643, 0.009638482704758644, -0.03810306638479233, -0.013143669813871384, -0.0005167749477550387, 0.02415807731449604, -0.04231259971857071, -0.03223729506134987, 0.08038527518510818, 0.047043781727552414, -0.016875354573130608, -0.024157507345080376, -0.00012044862523907796, -0.005229033064097166, -0.0099320774897933, -0.013325138948857784, -0.02850027196109295, 0.021418260410428047, 0.05770295113325119, 0.026272164657711983, -0.02478606440126896, -0.04787413030862808, -0.035467907786369324, -0.0660218670964241, 0.012773200869560242, -0.03713172301650047, 0.046183183789253235, -0.03388291969895363, 0.04665463790297508, 0.011603203602135181, 0.012789761647582054, -0.03404781222343445, 0.062169354408979416, -0.040112316608428955, 0.003838517004624009, -0.032599929720163345, -0.012325829826295376, 0.002329654060304165, -0.026105917990207672, 0.08266383409500122, 0.020292945206165314, -0.01233226340264082, -0.030968032777309418, 0.03523726016283035, -0.021868683397769928, 0.040361929684877396, -0.011383077129721642, 0.007193308789283037, 0.014587102457880974, 0.024366699159145355, -0.010742001235485077, 0.004314850550144911, 0.04543513059616089, 0.05104723572731018, -0.014970117248594761, -0.02798016183078289, -0.007479213178157806, 0.002872166922315955, 0.004887362476438284, 0.017095355316996574, 0.01808539405465126, 0.022038230672478676, -0.05523820221424103, 0.03458211198449135, -0.010247202590107918, 0.05389353632926941, 0.05215863510966301, -0.044844888150691986, -0.018802674487233162, -0.06624185293912888, -0.0272888895124197, 0.03233065828680992, 0.0022424361668527126, -0.03827767074108124, 0.001738642225973308, 0.06646110862493515, 0.0002722592616919428, -0.025012992322444916, 0.06125809624791145, 0.030016615986824036, 0.0047142687253654, 0.002625493798404932, -0.012570276856422424, 0.03401007875800133, 0.009281178005039692, 0.0024335922207683325, -0.02258629910647869, 0.08044145256280899, 0.014931499026715755, -0.035766925662755966, 0.006238565780222416, 0.010670674033463001, -0.04029286652803421, 0.01671864464879036, 0.019130541011691093, 0.03390343114733696, 0.0038936107885092497, -0.027705393731594086, 0.010546034201979637, 0.02736463025212288, 0.05417373776435852, 0.012758595868945122, -0.0018080259906128049, -0.06940829753875732, -0.012203657999634743, 0.02920534834265709, 0.05755578726530075, -0.06383556872606277, 0.02461119182407856, -0.03530038893222809, 0.007497097365558147, 0.033444639295339584, -0.02832917496562004, 0.014520197175443172, -0.007328860927373171, 0.03980866074562073, -0.018411526456475258, -0.013472338207066059, -0.021656876429915428, 0.00017481084796600044, -0.033671554177999496, 0.033160820603370667, -0.013359028846025467, 0.01531034056097269, -0.03304803743958473, 0.02551264874637127, 0.05116564780473709, 0.10391940921545029, -0.03961734101176262, -0.01860967092216015, 0.00836716778576374, -0.01271149329841137, -0.03159280866384506, -0.038331612944602966, 0.02518877014517784, 0.012201952748000622, -0.03247794881463051, 0.02535853534936905, -0.022938616573810577, -0.04979223757982254, 0.04188324883580208, 0.012279869057238102, 0.0046464018523693085, -0.021183909848332405, -0.026673104614019394, 0.02773069404065609, 0.030679291114211082, 0.027506450191140175, 0.03479107841849327, 0.031162237748503685, -0.007339361123740673, 0.012608278542757034, -0.0015164114302024245, -0.017675340175628662, -0.02698487788438797, -0.009764337912201881, -0.015459329821169376, 0.005508431699126959, -0.05704112723469734, 0.01993568427860737, 0.03795578330755234, -0.0028483576606959105, -0.02430182695388794, -0.046057552099227905, 0.023317772895097733, 0.020557330921292305, 0.04065091162919998, 0.01749207079410553, -0.016942227259278297, 0.016854431480169296, -0.007849129848182201, 0.01734285056591034, 0.03750833868980408, -0.03102125972509384, 0.01096929982304573, 0.011484595946967602, -0.03861449286341667, -0.0057002222165465355, -0.05695720762014389, -0.01567838527262211, 0.03504113107919693, -0.04557962715625763, 0.029026256874203682, -0.013417772948741913, 0.05090190842747688, -0.010646652430295944, -0.04121217504143715, -0.01749112270772457, 0.013536444865167141, -0.003912698943167925, 0.049837034195661545, -0.013067211955785751, 0.02959614060819149, -0.021349607035517693, 0.001634789165109396, -0.07965333014726639, -0.02672034688293934, 0.0354880690574646, 0.02827901393175125, -0.032647665590047836, -0.033278487622737885, 0.008234662003815174, -0.011218410916626453, -0.002152997301891446, -0.014894772320985794, 0.009771540760993958, -0.00814401637762785, -0.01848028227686882, -0.01980886608362198, -0.002499951282516122, 0.07071453332901001, -0.00523711834102869, 0.013608301058411598, 0.012151085771620274, -0.003243879647925496, -0.029190218076109886, 0.0007294378592632711, -0.0018750408198684454, -0.05717433989048004, -0.05717037245631218, -0.01036883145570755, -0.018219182267785072, 0.027151240035891533, -0.028438586741685867, 0.0024236380122601986, 0.0022940021008253098, -0.006821334827691317, 0.020855112001299858, -0.016589375212788582, 0.020692555233836174, 0.012980938889086246, 0.003953043837100267, -0.04279232770204544, 0.03409590572118759, 0.004797128029167652, -0.005277876742184162, 0.03434399515390396, 0.01798265054821968, 0.020432066172361374, 0.015952017158269882, 0.04099234938621521, -0.018198814243078232, 0.03181380778551102, -0.02301078476011753, -0.007125810720026493, 0.047589488327503204, 0.01717328652739525, -0.021217122673988342, 0.00545109249651432, 0.008066298440098763, 0.008421268314123154, -0.04015517607331276, -0.004915763158351183, -0.028925420716404915, 0.03659974783658981, 0.014422095380723476, 0.04992491006851196, -0.0015496312407776713, -0.005971802398562431, 0.015475434251129627, -0.007056156639009714, 0.026716111227869987, -0.042424071580171585, 0.02948974445462227, 0.01118574570864439, -0.040845971554517746, -0.01818917691707611, 0.033825669437646866, 0.01054664421826601, 0.02077687904238701, 0.03213921934366226, 0.033545009791851044, 0.04460465535521507, 0.054069604724645615, -0.046662889420986176, -0.031127220019698143, 0.013872603885829449, -0.03813518211245537, 0.016529623419046402, 0.01307542435824871, -0.04164857417345047, 0.050439976155757904, 0.0084469523280859, 0.0077235461212694645, -0.004576391540467739, 0.019826004281640053, -0.03416424244642258, -0.004020966589450836, -0.007653771433979273, 0.04016583412885666, 0.010112587362527847, -0.0311078280210495, -0.0007386148208752275, -0.01076595950871706, 0.03909452259540558, 0.004213657695800066, -0.04770676791667938, -0.04611154645681381, -0.023365400731563568, -0.07054238766431808, 0.010091711767017841, -0.003883877070620656, -0.016034023836255074, 0.0034412750974297523, -0.04622435197234154, 0.0177580788731575, -0.013399263843894005, 0.023736106231808662, -0.02364293485879898, 0.056993938982486725, 0.001776259858161211, 0.055519845336675644, -0.046981584280729294, 0.010367107577621937, 0.10448252409696579, 0.07559209316968918, 0.025371400639414787, -0.04744359850883484, 0.014132557436823845, 0.03337664529681206, 0.027970073744654655, -0.02181556634604931, -0.004721060395240784, 0.00485340878367424, -0.03389715775847435, 0.06484875082969666, 0.029302772134542465, 0.0007385264034382999, 0.004564999602735043, 0.04134005680680275, -0.01535860076546669, -0.012735683470964432, 0.03025340661406517, 0.02775934897363186, -0.0010894531151279807, -0.03969200327992439, -0.015413719229400158, 0.008587402291595936, -0.010450209490954876, -0.054871972650289536, 0.022297333925962448, -0.03526150435209274, -0.0422702431678772, 0.01969461888074875, -0.01957019977271557, 0.014332031831145287, 0.014565404504537582, 0.0009143765782937407, -0.012513222172856331, -0.028480255976319313, -0.0031574824824929237, -0.0314006432890892, -0.02410416677594185, 0.08427876979112625, -0.02967711351811886, -0.005357691552489996, -0.043770600110292435, 0.06799738854169846, -0.044313959777355194, -0.023427559062838554, -0.040809135884046555, 0.0103384330868721, -0.023820148780941963, 0.03167567402124405, -0.032097991555929184, -0.04755641520023346, -0.020368102937936783, -0.02360573224723339, 0.0272720605134964, 0.029395610094070435, -0.0009200496133416891, -0.010706890374422073, -0.06359687447547913, -0.0050489711575210094, 0.030374184250831604, -0.02042095921933651, 0.015265354886651039, 0.03127084672451019, -0.04269513487815857, -0.03721019998192787, 0.00987290684133768, -0.007544958032667637, 0.009873369708657265, 0.0060326652601361275, 0.012449461035430431, -0.010098242200911045, -0.07143665105104446, 0.009270303882658482, -0.012340751476585865, -0.023894021287560463, 0.03656749054789543, -0.0012867827899754047, 0.03390134498476982, -0.012634551152586937, -0.0019254363141953945, 0.010782482102513313, -0.019849274307489395, -0.016772828996181488, -0.0528259202837944, -0.028883296996355057, -0.0035447748377919197, 0.00458117388188839, 0.008651980198919773, 0.00006910784577485174, 0.0017688716761767864, 0.03219030424952507, 0.001722106710076332, -0.02865580841898918, -0.013482042588293552, 0.013176445849239826, -0.06160597875714302, 0.016318801790475845, 0.012681632302701473, 0.061223775148391724, -0.028015706688165665, 0.009032323956489563, 0.04553600400686264, -0.022789109498262405, 0.016743022948503494, 0.025653040036559105, 0.0024046958424150944, -0.04657154530286789, -0.02853139117360115, 0.0123905623331666, -0.023001277819275856, -0.002300143940374255, -0.032056476920843124, -0.035775166004896164, 0.009580638259649277, 0.010177386924624443, -0.0025617273058742285, -0.04241837188601494, 0.0021917419508099556, -0.004090907983481884, -0.01836797036230564, -0.023397674784064293, -0.020674489438533783, -0.007162651978433132, -0.012738754041492939, -0.01913372240960598, 0.024951906874775887, 0.02747696451842785, -0.033745598047971725, -0.0013816144783049822, 0.00010055047459900379, 0.020182011649012566, 0.006130674853920937, 0.008863520808517933, 0.01853197067975998, 0.02823180891573429, 0.02268160879611969, 0.03640144318342209, -0.05560756474733353, -0.017104066908359528, 0.0892828106880188, -0.07201939076185226, -0.03426550328731537, 0.04203379154205322, 0.0007802546606399119, 0.032465118914842606, 0.027748551219701767, -0.019301850348711014, 0.009740146808326244, 0.024787263944745064, -0.0494837649166584, -0.01845438964664936, 0.00736650126054883, 0.03973552957177162, 0.02439514547586441, 0.011480598710477352, -0.013186605647206306, 0.013841064646840096, 0.012345228344202042, 0.036341261118650436, 0.04986310377717018, -0.005253008101135492, -0.016589025035500526, -0.03043648600578308, 0.004011170007288456, -0.008790189400315285, 0.0033018887042999268, -0.00742751220241189, 0.010933756828308105, 0.04194504767656326, -0.023272717371582985, 0.018878471106290817, -0.020577197894454002, -0.022937249392271042, -0.06890904158353806, -0.024387981742620468, -0.004151346627622843, 0.038479194045066833, 0.01563071645796299, -0.00594234187155962, -0.01238800585269928, 0.03420470282435417, -0.044544316828250885, -0.0030293536838144064, 0.013080278411507607, 0.00357014499604702, -0.04953803867101669, 0.0024674697779119015, -0.006349371746182442, -0.002459424315020442, -0.006343547720462084, 0.009190659038722515, -0.010946148075163364, 0.032887205481529236, 0.0031228119041770697, -0.011402531526982784, -0.010640368796885014, 0.04346700385212898, -0.04191460460424423, -0.06857647001743317, 0.02719653770327568, -0.017951034009456635, -0.0004301263834349811, 0.07083895802497864, 0.019975723698735237, 0.06772743165493011, 0.02888575755059719, 0.033232059329748154, 0.015079846605658531, 0.03593642637133598, 0.0881359726190567, 0.006213374435901642, -0.023862652480602264, 0.019365092739462852, 0.007398063316941261, 0.043647199869155884, 0.021466851234436035, 0.007402085233479738, 0.059340521693229675, -0.009679386392235756, -0.008397574536502361, 0.0506313294172287, -0.0171339213848114, 0.011904886923730373, 0.0015669112326577306, 0.006561062298715115, -0.009525212459266186, -0.006449311040341854, 0.037533439695835114, -0.06392635405063629, 0.021334555000066757, 0.04415959492325783, -0.019274478778243065, -0.03239875286817551, -0.002026072470471263, 0.01825982704758644, -0.03564523905515671, 0.028868740424513817, -0.020969320088624954, -0.010948855429887772, -0.07130241394042969, -0.0017368741100654006, -0.008059725165367126, 0.020426150411367416, 0.028491070494055748, 0.002743201795965433, -0.03426534682512283, 0.054673828184604645, -0.017287692055106163, 0.006833215709775686, -0.002750982530415058, 0.010124780237674713, -0.017108742147684097, -0.054242782294750214, 0.09655328840017319, -0.0149519182741642, 0.02727493643760681, -0.06094825640320778, -0.046042490750551224, -0.013175465166568756, 0.012797651812434196, 0.04285459965467453, 0.0184534452855587, -0.001000773161649704, 0.02544354647397995, -0.011783469468355179, -0.017879119142889977, -0.04058236628770828, 0.03453739359974861, -0.0413060337305069, -0.014639449305832386, -0.012020965106785297, -0.017155969515442848, 0.011005891487002373, -0.0008205627673305571, 0.02932659164071083, -0.01722981035709381, 0.031122354790568352, 0.0069913542829453945, -0.0025068132672458887, 0.05512215569615364, 0.009028605185449123, 0.01030883751809597, 0.027838975191116333, -0.004315404687076807, 0.023241980001330376, 0.02805052511394024, 0.005296614486724138, -0.0647403746843338, 0.022568123415112495, -0.02287624031305313, -0.055473726242780685, 0.027974272146821022, 0.0072478908114135265, 0.0016886182129383087, -0.07044247537851334, 0.008080155588686466, 0.021208470687270164, -0.04553097486495972, 0.007863723672926426, 0.007250287104398012, 0.005887971725314856, 0.0031322110444307327, -0.03312685713171959, 0.04418991133570671, 0.0017436386551707983, -0.04533621296286583, -0.005994003266096115, 0.01915833167731762, 0.031057387590408325, -0.025216130539774895, 0.03145575895905495, 0.05202420800924301, 0.0057706828229129314, 0.0546477735042572, 0.006545933894813061, 0.04852292314171791, -0.03452812507748604, -0.025925014168024063, 0.0493694543838501, -0.012982462532818317, -0.016255833208560944, 0.03310905769467354, 0.02098989672958851, 0.06977915018796921, 0.007528984919190407, 0.010585200041532516, -0.043204378336668015, -0.0018541035242378712, -0.03760671615600586, -0.004981466569006443, -0.007885871455073357, 0.03375105559825897, -0.013110615313053131, -0.004392572212964296, 0.02392939291894436, 0.012799744494259357, 0.03268951550126076, -0.04400170221924782, -0.006715336814522743, 0.004436768125742674, 0.010091722942888737, -0.028913669288158417, -0.003101975889876485, 0.002605497371405363, 0.0036740179639309645, 0.003071034559980035, -0.0018360563553869724, -0.0034473976120352745, -0.005082040559500456, -0.025350650772452354, -0.0025540594942867756, 0.04585549235343933, -0.02181057073175907, 0.0037875333800911903, -0.02014346979558468, 0.03162915259599686, -0.010720050893723965, -0.029791248962283134 ]
<p>Is anyone aware of good data anonymization software? Or perhaps a package for R that does data anonymization? Obviously not expecting uncrackable anonymization - just want to make it difficult. </p>
74,177
[ -0.012788528576493263, 0.004835924133658409, -0.015199392102658749, -0.0007764822221361101, 0.019186904653906822, -0.019611191004514694, -0.018234524875879288, 0.00623613316565752, -0.00317129073664546, -0.05605373904109001, 0.03492679074406624, 0.0431150421500206, 0.02345290221273899, 0.032789040356874466, 0.04166824743151665, -0.04767056927084923, -0.020992804318666458, -0.007091134786605835, -0.012949355877935886, 0.003533011768013239, 0.028769832104444504, 0.016007360070943832, 0.0044760326854884624, -0.012825618498027325, -0.01878238469362259, 0.03286546468734741, 0.0036041459534317255, -0.02177061326801777, -0.008810898289084435, 0.052324775606393814, -0.04111520200967789, -0.01328955590724945, 0.0005598636926151812, 0.0175268966704607, 0.0014984478475525975, -0.02481348067522049, -0.07608822733163834, -0.028474099934101105, -0.0026431092992424965, 0.01700446754693985, -0.05741678923368454, -0.03840289264917374, 0.004055566154420376, 0.05914709344506264, 0.008600407280027866, -0.0029756533913314342, 0.0030871834605932236, -0.018052170053124428, 0.01361480075865984, -0.021394280716776848, 0.06738203018903732, 0.0005729015101678669, 0.009610180743038654, 0.01896393671631813, -0.019767949357628822, 0.03590988740324974, 0.041877225041389465, 0.07712682336568832, -0.010098225437104702, -0.05471096560359001, -0.01986410655081272, -0.0030945204198360443, 0.007674884516745806, -0.026767147704958916, -0.03926249220967293, 0.016094012185931206, -0.022793089970946312, -0.021710790693759918, 0.02300218679010868, -0.004405816085636616, -0.0000051981683100166265, 0.02029971405863762, 0.03287340700626373, 0.011769277043640614, -0.005756231490522623, 0.004556263331323862, -0.01956207863986492, -0.0019493007566779852, 0.08433008193969727, 0.037826403975486755, 0.011185800656676292, 0.01438895333558321, 0.006907517556101084, 0.02689068205654621, 0.012380734086036682, -0.014768360182642937, 0.05204394832253456, -0.01790320873260498, 0.004545761272311211, 0.0343581922352314, -0.030137211084365845, -0.011387974955141544, 0.07391728460788727, 0.011465334333479404, -0.019008249044418335, 0.03015495464205742, -0.03403754159808159, 0.06262876093387604, -0.010680417530238628, -0.05244859308004379, 0.0015884082531556487, 0.009219860658049583, -0.008337367326021194, 0.05356891453266144, -0.014153063297271729, -0.025344569236040115, -0.0316426120698452, -0.004151470027863979, 0.025328930467367172, -0.02823716774582863, -0.012873700819909573, 0.004908632021397352, -0.030994253233075142, -0.049797188490629196, 0.02062414027750492, -0.02631058730185032, -0.004396812524646521, -0.007281176745891571, 0.01774042472243309, 0.09301725029945374, 0.026224851608276367, -0.013897665776312351, 0.04464739188551903, -0.03472409397363663, -0.021558739244937897, -0.0013761234004050493, 0.062358174473047256, -0.027289720252156258, -0.0528545007109642, 0.04873916134238243, -0.0006088527734391391, -0.07129167020320892, 0.04962798207998276, -0.02988477796316147, 0.037776879966259, -0.029921866953372955, -0.1005716547369957, -0.07738512754440308, 0.032671622931957245, -0.0028537462931126356, 0.029974568635225296, -0.028525695204734802, -0.00006759521056665108, -0.005438381340354681, 0.031267404556274414, 0.028967013582587242, 0.03493322432041168, 0.01792510785162449, 0.032499074935913086, -0.006722230464220047, -0.01932775229215622, -0.002293291734531522, -0.01439307164400816, -0.007129043806344271, -0.02088376134634018, -0.044785190373659134, 0.010124266147613525, 0.02187655121088028, -0.03706148639321327, -0.019022708758711815, 0.03613252937793732, 0.017887141555547714, -0.006572335492819548, 0.006473987363278866, 0.0170611459761858, -0.03544614464044571, 0.026336969807744026, -0.021542446687817574, 0.07197970896959305, 0.004208040423691273, -0.011234158650040627, 0.07650142163038254, 0.028198253363370895, 0.04641740769147873, 0.01239494513720274, -0.025276055559515953, -0.00856578629463911, -0.029502786695957184, 0.03250909969210625, 0.025246411561965942, -0.0217623021453619, -0.018968934193253517, 0.037859171628952026, -0.0379134826362133, 0.02536267228424549, 0.012526996433734894, 0.036375921219587326, -0.05235383287072182, 0.07541559636592865, -0.04540048912167549, -0.03191418945789337, -0.06621447950601578, 0.019854871556162834, -0.03565960004925728, -0.014576825313270092, -0.0004619089013431221, 0.022942818701267242, 0.008390727452933788, -0.02531738206744194, -0.031903792172670364, -0.0178714357316494, 0.00989433191716671, 0.050414517521858215, -0.02722981944680214, -0.021830065175890923, 0.03965628147125244, 0.023678861558437347, -0.04031539708375931, 0.052177783101797104, -0.020849335938692093, -0.053016893565654755, -0.005811077076941729, -0.02247617021203041, 0.025322292000055313, -0.04656222090125084, -0.013436228968203068, 0.03674434870481491, -0.006100644823163748, -0.01086551696062088, 0.01607191190123558, -0.05833818390965462, 0.018531721085309982, 0.036840084940195084, 0.06283537298440933, -0.007996398955583572, -0.010033664293587208, 0.03737259283661842, -0.026500046253204346, -0.07003964483737946, 0.0007570039597339928, -0.04321997985243797, -0.004028331488370895, 0.09166908264160156, 0.00010588412260403857, -0.03701931610703468, 0.021071460098028183, 0.0360923632979393, 0.03237320855259895, 0.042217496782541275, 0.00883901584893465, -0.01760384812951088, -0.016825107857584953, 0.021242588758468628, 0.01143964845687151, -0.0076154679991304874, 0.030002297833561897, 0.015658840537071228, -0.02326432801783085, 0.07448702305555344, 0.018041526898741722, -0.030658533796668053, 0.03142842650413513, -0.00804088357836008, -0.010328155010938644, 0.0019339770078659058, -0.0076569668017327785, 0.02810578979551792, -0.05369270592927933, 0.0035909952130168676, -0.016313660889863968, 0.02970355935394764, -0.009268946945667267, 0.007601077202707529, -0.025983937084674835, 0.014847790822386742, 0.02603573352098465, -0.049226708710193634, 0.0365782305598259, 0.018587414175271988, -0.017522066831588745, 0.02592559903860092, -0.02020108886063099, 0.018346361815929413, -0.035441894084215164, 0.027141693979501724, 0.034372083842754364, -0.00774685014039278, -0.010149382054805756, -0.032583434134721756, -0.02860395610332489, 0.02814755216240883, -0.021813010796904564, 0.020007090643048286, 0.03177411109209061, -0.06366033852100372, -0.005478663835674524, 0.001528105465695262, -0.05261851102113724, 0.03360834717750549, -0.020015599206089973, -0.0040284800343215466, 0.0114938635379076, 0.002704426646232605, -0.059427451342344284, -0.013105555437505245, 0.0025894376449286938, -0.013697651214897633, -0.041214559227228165, 0.02127632312476635, -0.009325450286269188, -0.0012166346423327923, -0.00800266768783331, 0.006104257423430681, -0.033665671944618225, 0.007116092834621668, 0.0005427840515039861, -0.027490584179759026, 0.035938993096351624, 0.0034364184830337763, -0.02679603174328804, 0.032738398760557175, -0.022789644077420235, -0.015298496000468731, -0.040406353771686554, -0.03911744803190231, 0.05444994941353798, -0.00855733547359705, 0.0014606860931962729, 0.012192944064736366, -0.002974697621539235, 0.05415131896734238, 0.049713995307683945, -0.03735180199146271, -0.030090058222413063, -0.03851790726184845, -0.01597377099096775, -0.03121466375887394, 0.009570210240781307, -0.0053571667522192, 0.033471640199422836, -0.01249073725193739, 0.007208372000604868, -0.0018926585325971246, 0.05500705540180206, 0.00248348293825984, 0.0013748245546594262, 0.027751296758651733, 0.012736836448311806, 0.02119046077132225, 0.015589404851198196, 0.027908410876989365, -0.015445235185325146, 0.023173760622739792, 0.022622473537921906, 0.025328336283564568, 0.02066238969564438, -0.03243599086999893, -0.029551353305578232, 0.00041770850657485425, 0.049165140837430954, -0.0353495292365551, -0.010615105740725994, -0.004718259442597628, -0.01402439083904028, 0.003935732878744602, 0.027740933001041412, 0.018237845972180367, -0.00910544116050005, 0.007622532546520233, 0.033089809119701385, 0.02998868003487587, -0.027380745857954025, 0.011830334551632404, -0.022200794890522957, -0.0009999012108892202, 0.0030028338078409433, 0.02330491878092289, 0.02011500857770443, 0.06645166128873825, 0.0190924983471632, 0.01678866147994995, 0.019868260249495506, -0.02293906919658184, 0.05397988483309746, -0.08422573655843735, 0.013796014711260796, -0.039878346025943756, 0.041881877928972244, 0.011847589164972305, 0.03235049545764923, 0.015364916063845158, 0.005240170750766993, -0.02638096734881401, 0.033128440380096436, -0.046126239001750946, 0.015463868156075478, -0.04360777884721756, 0.010847285389900208, 0.003923091106116772, 0.007485600188374519, 0.010353464633226395, 0.03550475090742111, 0.012994901277124882, -0.0278019942343235, 0.020483292639255524, -0.036997515708208084, -0.02080952189862728, -0.0006011631339788437, 0.0018765140557661653, -0.01799103058874607, 0.044028058648109436, -0.017676997929811478, 0.011719491332769394, 0.02366049960255623, 0.021181931719183922, 0.004191466607153416, -0.012240848504006863, -0.022061126306653023, -0.026373814791440964, 0.007268605288118124, 0.0374356247484684, 0.008801676332950592, 0.01526219118386507, -0.017554091289639473, 0.0016540618380531669, -0.05329008027911186, 0.01847313530743122, -0.008991008624434471, 0.01808832213282585, -0.039368193596601486, -0.07124762237071991, -0.045057445764541626, 0.02004369907081127, -0.0021893007215112448, -0.02907385490834713, 0.03095650114119053, 0.021262817084789276, 0.023999495431780815, -0.05388219654560089, 0.002076457953080535, 0.08911726623773575, 0.038689807057380676, 0.008919141255319118, 0.027039268985390663, -0.04884357377886772, 0.00783595535904169, -0.002066289307549596, -0.015540482476353645, 0.030089985579252243, 0.008116686716675758, 0.01137007400393486, -0.0077391196973621845, -0.024716399610042572, -0.023872477933764458, -0.014043953269720078, 0.06075485050678253, 0.06380578130483627, -0.02229742705821991, 0.015330868773162365, 0.030807452276349068, 0.026557058095932007, 0.015407870523631573, 0.007668673526495695, 0.0012480452423915267, -0.09388186782598495, 0.010971371084451675, 0.07196291536092758, 0.04555628076195717, 0.0004628979368135333, -0.03116791509091854, -0.03611142560839653, -0.07071133702993393, 0.028771881014108658, 0.0005415136110968888, 0.010346664115786552, -0.03168131038546562, -0.018328802660107613, -0.00947776809334755, 0.0018123059999197721, -0.012313918210566044, -0.014095493592321873, -0.018251363188028336, 0.026065576821565628, 0.02135668322443962, -0.03363095223903656, -0.07169338315725327, 0.016273988410830498, 0.0022879389580339193, 0.04604983702301979, 0.00410349341109395, 0.005307184532284737, 0.06024210527539253, 0.03928138315677643, -0.029759440571069717, -0.06867839395999908, 0.014640646986663342, 0.008682215586304665, -0.0035349284298717976, 0.07183454185724258, -0.049055784940719604, -0.03441289812326431, 0.0011691886465996504, 0.021331073716282845, -0.03679506480693817, -0.011626098304986954, -0.022937044501304626, 0.024986011907458305, 0.014693304896354675, -0.00505033740773797, 0.03537698835134506, 0.05076258257031441, 0.01424633339047432, 0.0026406394317746162, -0.06105978786945343, 0.033875253051519394, -0.03891048952937126, -0.024850910529494286, -0.053993694484233856, -0.01597798615694046, -0.03634245693683624, -0.0005263164057396352, 0.025148389860987663, 0.017740925773978233, -0.0355827771127224, -0.008734401315450668, 0.01389596052467823, 0.018062017858028412, -0.019472112879157066, 0.012211699038743973, -0.0015244513051584363, 0.01976373977959156, -0.04059329628944397, -0.00436793826520443, 0.018848758190870285, -0.006781504023820162, -0.029445355758070946, 0.017921162769198418, -0.052474819123744965, 0.01423207763582468, -0.03244036063551903, -0.05972426384687424, 0.03772984445095062, -0.0030351157765835524, 0.06362628936767578, -0.010510987602174282, 0.006264808587729931, -0.01780848391354084, -0.10227929055690765, 0.0040174564346671104, 0.032231755554676056, -0.02759663574397564, 0.04470841959118843, -0.032352231442928314, 0.042169153690338135, -0.06052572280168533, -0.0362657867372036, -0.042508456856012344, -0.05448363721370697, 0.027392562478780746, -0.030591551214456558, -0.029743026942014694, -0.06560242176055908, 0.018967026844620705, -0.03394898399710655, 0.004196961410343647, -0.004342745989561081, 0.036319587379693985, -0.007592584937810898, 0.02196306362748146, -0.0012812657514587045, -0.005006881430745125, 0.026347151026129723, 0.0099642938002944, 0.03360980749130249, 0.0031394255347549915, 0.0007964877295307815, 0.003218497848138213, 0.019909244030714035, 0.02388921193778515, -0.021905289962887764, 0.015141625888645649, -0.028131064027547836, -0.014664273709058762, 0.029384788125753403, -0.00681157736107707, 0.03901505842804909, -0.0025211963802576065, 0.016843462362885475, -0.003938014153391123, -0.039030469954013824, 0.022335629910230637, -0.02069786749780178, -0.009420282207429409, -0.06214231997728348, -0.007553080562502146, -0.023264264687895775, 0.023098792880773544, 0.024857675656676292, -0.028803816065192223, -0.003479811828583479, 0.002729864325374365, 0.04447479546070099, 0.021077372133731842, 0.023455580696463585, -0.02891048789024353, -0.038854051381349564, 0.02715907245874405, -0.01373832393437624, 0.02997342310845852, 0.01657979190349579, -0.0066200136207044125, -0.056129422038793564, -0.07275386154651642, -0.034049250185489655, -0.014796093106269836, 0.012175430543720722, -0.004373735282570124, 0.0483991876244545, 0.04508008807897568, -0.0031769319903105497, -0.015577108599245548, -0.019496550783514977, -0.03302767127752304, 0.013457007706165314, 0.00294940616004169, 0.04948553070425987, 0.024023130536079407, -0.0051965611055493355, 0.014780464582145214, 0.0020357733592391014, 0.02413157746195793, 0.06793177872896194, 0.017194069921970367, 0.0183253213763237, 0.03156930208206177, -0.03051186539232731, -0.041483569890260696, -0.0064730397425591946, -0.03531401976943016, 0.013266755267977715, -0.021789196878671646, -0.03368625044822693, 0.04546910151839256, 0.015590161085128784, 0.048740487545728683, -0.04657977074384689, -0.023930611088871956, -0.06646686047315598, 0.051451828330755234, 0.034728679805994034, -0.0006973612471483648, 0.03368373215198517, -0.005534169729799032, 0.006883895490318537, -0.02867083251476288, 0.03304020315408707, 0.020302660763263702, -0.09008903056383133, -0.043151721358299255, -0.009879686869680882, -0.04603258892893791, 0.03383471444249153, 0.0104212686419487, -0.006438793148845434, 0.006439163815230131, -0.05369484797120094, 0.005703143775463104, 0.004997916053980589, 0.04572583734989166, -0.01037183403968811, 0.06091001257300377, -0.02086234651505947, 0.03349388390779495, -0.00605103699490428, 0.002464860677719116, 0.11370912194252014, 0.07581359893083572, 0.06789219379425049, -0.09272874146699905, 0.033178236335515976, 0.029879558831453323, -0.0017858928767964244, -0.044618409126996994, 0.02751629799604416, 0.0205399002879858, 0.0032704349141567945, 0.04189388081431389, 0.060826245695352554, 0.0014037967193871737, 0.02219948172569275, 0.062445349991321564, -0.016776544973254204, 0.002698440570384264, 0.02044767141342163, -0.006400137208402157, 0.01247298065572977, -0.029393335804343224, -0.07929731905460358, -0.014112194068729877, -0.008324324153363705, -0.04386597126722336, -0.031205061823129654, -0.022433552891016006, 0.02340749092400074, 0.025388404726982117, -0.017588380724191666, 0.008021298795938492, -0.01456447597593069, 0.01692197471857071, 0.005390119273215532, -0.0076542748138308525, 0.018324390053749084, -0.019677206873893738, -0.0010328334756195545, 0.011715298518538475, 0.022092437371611595, 0.012002826668322086, -0.029087167233228683, -0.012030983343720436, -0.036158572882413864, -0.013402965851128101, 0.003419718937948346, 0.029992179945111275, -0.03320333734154701, -0.004112615250051022, 0.0008249160018749535, 0.0018157674930989742, 0.0003164822410326451, -0.038952458649873734, -0.004595344420522451, 0.0173320509493351, 0.037209413945674896, 0.01224326528608799, 0.012299802154302597, -0.010919365100562572, 0.038060322403907776, -0.03034318797290325, 0.024011878296732903, 0.015699973329901695, -0.018754830583930016, 0.014971766620874405, -0.03163214400410652, -0.016688233241438866, 0.004352999851107597, 0.021006794646382332, 0.019938692450523376, -0.01905444636940956, -0.01634141057729721, -0.008800656534731388, -0.012430685572326183, 0.014256251975893974, 0.01987413689494133, -0.02830352820456028, 0.04144304245710373, -0.0011421580566093326, 0.005449762102216482, 0.014922317117452621, -0.04307937994599342, 0.007987617515027523, -0.021798858419060707, -0.03279326111078262, 0.04383910819888115, 0.024679843336343765, 0.012592002749443054, 0.009683392941951752, -0.007291856687515974, 0.014268452301621437, 0.021087169647216797, -0.029731106013059616, 0.028796788305044174, -0.026008671149611473, -0.046246908605098724, 0.02145206183195114, -0.010375541634857655, 0.04118163138628006, 0.027477608993649483, 0.0019795524422079325, -0.008913753554224968, 0.00678266491740942, -0.03921724110841751, 0.005000472534447908, -0.016164328902959824, -0.06125437468290329, -0.0042824214324355125, -0.0019999186042696238, -0.01108585949987173, -0.01605505868792534, -0.02602563053369522, -0.02464747242629528, -0.02328406646847725, 0.00683077285066247, -0.012689616531133652, -0.017989661544561386, 0.03254394605755806, 0.00934864766895771, 0.0033589086961001158, -0.030454780906438828, 0.014750526286661625, -0.021064573898911476, -0.020405814051628113, -0.00812616478651762, -0.009384176693856716, 0.02699514850974083, 0.010767234489321709, 0.013216990046203136, 0.038812875747680664, 0.04829062521457672, -0.0037120357155799866, -0.0019728525076061487, 0.02607518620789051, 0.04624084383249283, 0.011267567984759808, 0.06828410178422928, -0.013945626094937325, -0.038264498114585876, 0.03985946625471115, -0.06426484137773514, -0.05830475315451622, -0.0013608396984636784, -0.021520251408219337, 0.01408532913774252, 0.004392348695546389, -0.038695838302373886, -0.017652828246355057, 0.08479605615139008, -0.0015862430445849895, -0.03365639969706535, 0.005409759934991598, 0.024261215701699257, 0.004522273782640696, 0.04232512786984444, 0.023150887340307236, -0.03304809331893921, -0.01677350141108036, 0.03653820976614952, 0.05093260109424591, 0.027514642104506493, -0.012252661399543285, 0.01758260652422905, -0.002780203241854906, 0.04616555944085121, 0.019226541742682457, 0.012498409487307072, 0.03259003162384033, 0.038582973182201385, -0.04168112576007843, 0.05044994503259659, 0.03589288517832756, 0.018817700445652008, -0.07284905761480331, 0.025299495086073875, 0.01561302412301302, 0.02042984403669834, 0.030720410868525505, -0.07798067480325699, 0.028724430128932, 0.014714742079377174, -0.06409207731485367, 0.009807922877371311, -0.026348311454057693, 0.003151952987536788, -0.02096252515912056, 0.03161463141441345, -0.04242412745952606, -0.0066772098653018475, 0.04692201316356659, 0.028209470212459564, 0.04129277914762497, 0.016138244420289993, -0.025342974811792374, -0.02671637386083603, -0.00462864525616169, 0.011050945147871971, 0.01359486859291792, -0.09238217771053314, 0.019123269245028496, -0.017104456201195717, 0.0021182226482778788, 0.02744903415441513, -0.027782728895545006, -0.0029112317133694887, 0.019199330359697342, 0.043684110045433044, 0.03161204233765602, 0.03226660192012787, 0.019116751849651337, 0.0036093415692448616, -0.014046083204448223, 0.017179030925035477, 0.0007200521067716181, 0.021161437034606934, 0.020788921043276787, 0.02088116481900215, -0.018161486834287643, 0.01673341542482376, 0.018897956237196922, 0.03274565935134888, -0.03350181505084038, 0.015228979289531708, -0.04196404293179512, -0.003944513387978077, 0.0052977632731199265, -0.021392162889242172, 0.01598299853503704, -0.026672715321183205, 0.00812690518796444, 0.04251968115568161, 0.02511654794216156, 0.006894560996443033, 0.05184781178832054, -0.00898297131061554, -0.044291310012340546, 0.02415878139436245, -0.015381589531898499, 0.0012584388023242354, -0.07037842273712158, 0.016889510676264763, 0.001217994256876409, -0.009323940612375736, 0.0044563766568899155, 0.007959592156112194, -0.006565281189978123, 0.040624167770147324, -0.011372501961886883, -0.008254132233560085, 0.020922213792800903, -0.005118060857057571, 0.004543250426650047, -0.0632590726017952, 0.08474506437778473, 0.0022396324202418327, 0.03762124851346016, -0.032363954931497574, 0.016867855563759804, -0.027346480637788773, -0.001139288884587586, 0.0567474290728569, -0.04785631224513054, 0.0029206806793808937, -0.038045745342969894, 0.0576864555478096, -0.009334461763501167, -0.0230555422604084, 0.04427066817879677, -0.006887446623295546, -0.0025093730073422194, -0.0021363436244428158, -0.03318342939019203, -0.0024934608954936266, 0.008038802072405815, -0.015220935456454754, -0.006212691776454449, -0.00590155553072691, 0.022632533684372902, -0.0027433354407548904, 0.027119414880871773, 0.0034987994004040956, -0.020101774483919144, 0.007963817566633224, 0.02097712643444538, -0.0010726356413215399, 0.045110978186130524, -0.0053026555106043816, -0.006356218364089727, 0.06990928947925568, -0.04792385548353195, -0.04140526056289673, -0.006530859041959047, 0.0005737486644648015, -0.02063734643161297, -0.04771525785326958, 0.008755058981478214, -0.008034341968595982, -0.024390915408730507, -0.0058167241513729095, 0.034087248146533966, -0.020982053130865097, 0.03464407101273537, 0.03680429607629776, 0.036402489989995956, 0.03370879590511322, -0.009500178508460522, 0.000057333207223564386, 0.013638107106089592, 0.010843971744179726, -0.0040747313760221004, 0.009935615584254265, 0.02304866723716259, -0.037014592438936234, 0.04959164187312126, 0.022435519844293594, 0.051364462822675705, -0.04063678905367851, -0.04473796859383583, 0.01790473610162735, -0.0331617146730423, 0.006811574567109346, -0.01884237304329872, -0.037598978728055954, 0.05012211203575134, -0.060104288160800934, -0.007030793000012636, -0.04002638906240463, -0.03269589692354202, -0.0357804112136364, 0.0008576618856750429, -0.020855296403169632, 0.040165919810533524, -0.013932284899055958, 0.011780969798564911, -0.0030984024051576853, 0.014484498649835587, 0.05413619056344032, -0.02524811215698719, 0.027096066623926163, -0.013420232571661472, -0.00008197539136745036, -0.04217333719134331, -0.048505984246730804, 0.024935277178883553, -0.04127611592411995, 0.025625629350543022, 0.007673716638237238, 0.014347205869853497, -0.004923416301608086, 0.0037150660064071417, -0.0021666691172868013, 0.033389098942279816, -0.056168559938669205, 0.018602261319756508, -0.003333903383463621, -0.014786076731979847, -0.0333060622215271, 0.0004580967943184078 ]
<p>I’m reading a paper and really struggling with one appendix. Basically they derive conditional expectation of a multivariate normal, conditioning on absolute values. </p> <p>Let $$\boldsymbol y = \begin{bmatrix} \boldsymbol y_{a}^{\top} \\ \boldsymbol y_{b}^{\top} \end{bmatrix} $$</p> <p>$$\boldsymbol y \sim \mathcal{N}({\boldsymbol 0},{\Sigma_{y}})$$</p> <p>where $$ \Sigma_{y} = \begin{bmatrix} \Sigma_{aa} &amp; \Sigma_{ab}\\ \Sigma_{ba} &amp; \Sigma_{bb} \end{bmatrix}$$</p> <p>it is known that $E[y_a|y_b]=\Sigma_{ab}\Sigma_{bb}^{-1} \boldsymbol y_b $</p> <p>The bit I'm struggling with is:</p> <p>Let</p> <p>$\boldsymbol y_a=y_1$ and $\boldsymbol y_b^\top=(y_2,y_3) .$ We want to calculate the conditional expectation: $ E[y_1|y_2 = l_2, |y_3|=l_3]. $ Define $f(\boldsymbol y_b) = e^{-1/2 \boldsymbol{ y_{b}^{\top}\Sigma_{bb}^{-1}y_{b}}} $ and let $\boldsymbol l_b = (l_2,l_3)$</p> <p>according to the paper it is easy to show that:</p> <p>$ E[y_1|y_2 = l_2, |y_3|=l_3] = \boldsymbol{\Sigma_{ab} \Sigma_{bb}^{-1} \{ i_{11}^{(2,2)}-\tanh[l_{b}^{\top} i_{11}^{(2,2)} \Sigma_{bb}^{-1}i_{22}^{(2,2)} l_{b}]i_{22}^{(2,2)}l_{b}\}} $</p> <p>where $i_{ij}^{(m,n)}$ is the index matrix.</p> <p>Then they continue with a even more complicated conditional expectation which I would also like to understand. The link the paper: <a href="http://web.mit.edu/wangj/Public/Publication/Wang94.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://web.mit.edu/wangj/Public/Publication/Wang94.pdf</a> page 163.</p> <p>I would be extremely grateful if somebody would be able to help me with this.</p> <p>Many thanks. </p>
74,178
[ -0.03312172368168831, -0.009839095175266266, 0.015736959874629974, -0.015936752781271935, 0.027750659734010696, 0.042502984404563904, -0.008514516055583954, -0.02241724357008934, 0.012718725018203259, -0.038752805441617966, 0.04975408315658569, 0.03766077756881714, 0.02168523706495762, -0.005230312701314688, 0.021406717598438263, 0.024327611550688744, -0.038578156381845474, 0.009914365597069263, -0.030015191063284874, -0.0065531060099601746, 0.01537473127245903, -0.00034384909668006003, 0.01658416911959648, -0.03590173274278641, 0.008320415392518044, 0.029488712549209595, 0.0035145289730280638, -0.00708924001082778, -0.006195440888404846, 0.0852496325969696, -0.04318542033433914, -0.05715067684650421, 0.027529610320925713, -0.002102940110489726, 0.0014466256834566593, 0.04398336634039879, -0.005629353225231171, -0.007767434697598219, 0.0028958956245332956, 0.021466335281729698, -0.02761068195104599, 0.02333107404410839, -0.0030177817679941654, 0.047040149569511414, -0.029950285330414772, 0.047445639967918396, -0.04002601280808449, -0.02529033087193966, 0.0113070672377944, -0.037479519844055176, 0.10185907036066055, -0.002570320386439562, 0.029993966221809387, 0.0632772371172905, -0.009393241256475449, -0.016730813309550285, 0.03130524605512619, 0.05111256241798401, 0.030524881556630135, -0.04717295244336128, 0.009239532053470612, -0.03649512305855751, 0.010091518051922321, -0.031046433374285698, -0.048341602087020874, -0.008085931651294231, 0.030827313661575317, 0.01127923745661974, 0.023182649165391922, -0.00029039286891929805, 0.04096043109893799, -0.0155574856325984, 0.03302009031176567, -0.05094010382890701, -0.01292428933084011, 0.01839727908372879, 0.00016710287309251726, 0.017357315868139267, 0.019658850505948067, 0.01261882297694683, 0.014733920805156231, 0.0458599254488945, 0.005148762837052345, 0.008645799942314625, -0.004702965263277292, 0.01231023296713829, 0.08761779218912125, -0.020640511065721512, 0.04548878222703934, -0.008143923245370388, -0.010008390061557293, 0.013644841499626637, 0.03649329021573067, -0.03192127123475075, -0.04765147343277931, 0.07699305564165115, 0.000006368113190546865, 0.02456057257950306, -0.010298344306647778, 0.0003139223263133317, -0.007000419311225414, -0.056909795850515366, 0.03734615817666054, 0.05731537938117981, -0.01018331479281187, -0.02639695443212986, -0.02659088373184204, 0.02964029274880886, -0.012474299408495426, -0.03901859372854233, -0.0075475918129086494, 0.07902618497610092, -0.0264535341411829, 0.003199879312887788, 0.026514649391174316, -0.01492693554610014, 0.021865317597985268, 0.03202991560101509, 0.0070766001008450985, 0.04345171898603439, 0.04819957911968231, -0.03284960240125656, -0.030129509046673775, -0.0005489179166033864, -0.039237428456544876, 0.001925986842252314, -0.012671266682446003, 0.025468241423368454, -0.0746709555387497, 0.0683392882347107, 0.018195845186710358, -0.023251082748174667, 0.026957593858242035, 0.027600549161434174, 0.005302358418703079, -0.008149326778948307, -0.11342805624008179, -0.0429236926138401, 0.018391292542219162, -0.0053289830684661865, 0.02073390781879425, -0.04976640269160271, -0.006403192412108183, 0.03549136221408844, 0.04543222114443779, 0.014756483025848866, 0.049481701105833054, 0.034028563648462296, 0.02542474865913391, -0.005580661352723837, -0.04457158222794533, -0.04144732281565666, -0.029001442715525627, -0.006900859996676445, -0.017262782901525497, -0.06305477768182755, 0.0026676615234464407, 0.01921410858631134, -0.017213543877005577, -0.030516009777784348, 0.04369327798485756, 0.010741166770458221, 0.007766013033688068, -0.009272011928260326, 0.0010451850248500705, -0.052675846964120865, 0.04140637442469597, -0.009800403378903866, -0.008115424774587154, 0.016142545267939568, 0.006399525795131922, 0.008738293312489986, -0.03363511711359024, 0.07166211307048798, 0.05433109402656555, -0.05757094919681549, -0.02072623372077942, -0.047618135809898376, 0.028124315664172173, 0.03915851563215256, -0.049784641712903976, -0.005445368122309446, -0.032921724021434784, -0.015574386343359947, 0.017388205975294113, 0.05175495520234108, 0.008024975657463074, -0.001678922795690596, 0.008743621408939362, -0.05762583389878273, -0.02871028520166874, -0.07308065891265869, 0.0034126697573810816, 0.019363757222890854, -0.04764581099152565, 0.020443683490157127, -0.003759205574169755, -0.006512247025966644, 0.01857891120016575, 0.015521830879151821, 0.0171139407902956, -0.010621370747685432, 0.048027876764535904, -0.01783461682498455, 0.02561863325536251, 0.029576824977993965, 0.046216245740652084, 0.014511331915855408, 0.031879719346761703, -0.04277908802032471, -0.01752355322241783, 0.03135823458433151, -0.031740956008434296, 0.024203792214393616, 0.0013604516861960292, -0.017355674877762794, -0.003941057249903679, -0.01479017548263073, -0.03666231408715248, 0.009086772799491882, -0.059220340102910995, 0.008211985230445862, 0.03202991187572479, -0.01907842978835106, -0.0027842943090945482, 0.010698355734348297, 0.03823322057723999, 0.0457623116672039, -0.00434570899233222, -0.0016712177312001586, -0.04613891616463661, -0.004702629987150431, 0.013514130376279354, 0.04201626405119896, -0.029850276187062263, 0.02644381672143936, 0.02110115997493267, 0.0069764708168804646, -0.013834930956363678, 0.05013584345579147, 0.03469132259488106, -0.02362947165966034, 0.01432116236537695, -0.011141706258058548, 0.028197305276989937, 0.011172068305313587, -0.012548955157399178, 0.008942564949393272, 0.044893115758895874, 0.01999748684465885, -0.0433276891708374, 0.06260938942432404, 0.0027922652661800385, 0.008068705908954144, -0.02045939490199089, 0.009692123159766197, 0.01993762142956257, -0.02581668831408024, 0.028234325349330902, 0.028897732496261597, 0.00157079566270113, -0.03488839790225029, 0.0361836776137352, -0.03354954347014427, 0.002777411602437496, 0.0389384962618351, -0.04765458032488823, 0.027620555832982063, 0.02846645377576351, -0.006247133482247591, 0.0271369107067585, 0.015098619274795055, -0.02264522574841976, -0.011264591477811337, -0.037483204156160355, 0.020398663356900215, 0.006278194021433592, 0.02162853069603443, -0.05561135709285736, -0.012092608027160168, 0.004416346084326506, 0.03163539245724678, 0.04472551494836807, -0.03549005091190338, -0.05651175230741501, -0.005472518038004637, -0.012448023073375225, -0.020247960463166237, 0.01805228181183338, -0.02670113556087017, -0.028192920610308647, 0.048091910779476166, -0.006446869112551212, -0.06015700101852417, -0.04788023233413696, -0.006677328143268824, 0.010339087806642056, -0.017090411856770515, -0.04534514248371124, 0.038569364696741104, 0.0347876138985157, -0.03649877384305, -0.008820696733891964, -0.0121536273509264, -0.007420879788696766, -0.012358755804598331, -0.007013418711721897, -0.0171586275100708, 0.01704075187444687, 0.052565570920705795, 0.03680643439292908, -0.027800345793366432, -0.035050880163908005, -0.07079437375068665, -0.02843508869409561, 0.016381924971938133, 0.01741386577486992, 0.0028380192816257477, -0.015970712527632713, -0.0317862294614315, 0.11241687834262848, 0.023377178236842155, -0.0068364571779966354, -0.016075575724244118, 0.022870903834700584, -0.015849335119128227, -0.05549897253513336, 0.02782323770225048, 0.0031624389812350273, -0.01342407800257206, 0.07554572075605392, -0.019643623381853104, 0.008037944324314594, 0.07306566834449768, 0.014308974146842957, -0.009360241703689098, -0.005281503312289715, -0.027120430022478104, 0.007636585272848606, 0.04494886472821236, -0.0034114497248083353, 0.04370620846748352, -0.008782570250332355, 0.03530684858560562, 0.03927726671099663, -0.008532778359949589, -0.049097225069999695, 0.02094629406929016, -0.05832178145647049, -0.025463227182626724, -0.05829605087637901, 0.042841751128435135, 0.012236216105520725, -0.04698871076107025, 0.007951627485454082, 0.00718576880171895, 0.014340930618345737, -0.01973513700067997, 0.010034982115030289, 0.09302804619073868, 0.036733172833919525, -0.02309688925743103, -0.02400260418653488, 0.004692416172474623, -0.021037908270955086, 0.026389872655272484, -0.03632084280252457, -0.019860684871673584, -0.0093279629945755, 0.04833860695362091, -0.018982982262969017, -0.01734350435435772, -0.0033609848469495773, -0.013536388985812664, -0.024103112518787384, 0.02099115215241909, -0.014340288005769253, 0.02482161670923233, 0.04679448530077934, 0.07104407995939255, -0.025581086054444313, -0.006863251328468323, 0.026571616530418396, -0.004729028325527906, -0.04367620125412941, 0.01658746227622032, -0.041888199746608734, -0.022859910503029823, 0.0037909368984401226, 0.004148399922996759, 0.08370748907327652, -0.03582460805773735, 0.01203203946352005, -0.028982629999518394, 0.022599797695875168, -0.026519974693655968, -0.03072044625878334, -0.04418341815471649, -0.021219274029135704, -0.02236243151128292, 0.017259743064641953, 0.02465716563165188, -0.007852189242839813, 0.006060132756829262, 0.013346919789910316, -0.059709157794713974, -0.04983825609087944, -0.036412015557289124, 0.01747046783566475, 0.04092013090848923, 0.030809031799435616, -0.008805850520730019, 0.04385869950056076, 0.0032518943771719933, 0.021708596497774124, 0.011702095158398151, 0.01658300869166851, 0.036674559116363525, -0.009081751108169556, -0.010316075757145882, -0.019351748749613762, -0.006852487102150917, 0.016246093437075615, 0.011255251243710518, 0.0009184962254948914, -0.017970269545912743, 0.05700279399752617, 0.01772434264421463, -0.03286916762590408, 0.020917776972055435, 0.02498641423881054, 0.02087472379207611, 0.045122191309928894, -0.029976416379213333, 0.008179356344044209, -0.01682206057012081, -0.02537711337208748, 0.03318142890930176, -0.02939939685165882, -0.04618849605321884, -0.035735875368118286, 0.05941097438335419, -0.032820556312799454, 0.014274239540100098, 0.035543009638786316, 0.023735277354717255, -0.006952917668968439, 0.021851155906915665, -0.047251146286726, 0.02207048609852791, 0.03829249367117882, 0.014563249424099922, 0.032735250890254974, -0.006719440687447786, -0.02533234842121601, 0.014116902835667133, 0.03326589614152908, 0.054488424211740494, -0.023551421239972115, -0.018942510709166527, -0.04974809288978577, -0.02164469286799431, 0.005240974947810173, -0.003197512123733759, 0.0044294134713709354, -0.0019485729280859232, 0.014489489607512951, 0.008920097723603249, -0.013593129813671112, -0.058717988431453705, 0.007083127275109291, -0.01860135979950428, 0.009560126811265945, -0.02781853824853897, -0.037611450999975204, -0.03000560961663723, -0.0037016612477600574, 0.04033956676721573, 0.0455627366900444, -0.05964893102645874, -0.00987543910741806, -0.01684020645916462, 0.05492549389600754, -0.0012627372052520514, -0.06355410814285278, 0.02892007678747177, 0.008790696039795876, -0.01147203054279089, 0.0289772916585207, -0.021742846816778183, -0.016752077266573906, 0.04361714422702789, -0.004527213517576456, 0.018554776906967163, 0.026219189167022705, 0.021261807531118393, 0.07716328650712967, 0.04638049378991127, 0.01809018664062023, 0.050184015184640884, 0.021877707913517952, 0.025268038734793663, 0.017443150281906128, -0.038628894835710526, -0.019206728786230087, -0.01518356241285801, -0.01705392263829708, -0.07167895138263702, -0.008675867691636086, 0.029793038964271545, 0.05322861671447754, -0.029860353097319603, 0.020024625584483147, -0.012022936716675758, -0.052867304533720016, -0.003684727242216468, 0.0038090699817985296, -0.013687478378415108, -0.03698469325900078, -0.00041439355118200183, 0.0067278253845870495, 0.008167343214154243, -0.026711754500865936, 0.02059856429696083, -0.027465853840112686, 0.019977344200015068, -0.005242495331913233, -0.03146016225218773, 0.023258965462446213, -0.026366988196969032, -0.021073170006275177, -0.03224407136440277, -0.03636634722352028, 0.031967613846063614, -0.03105965442955494, 0.026170192286372185, 0.0017247622599825263, -0.005988536402583122, -0.014532978646457195, 0.02384989708662033, -0.01266204472631216, 0.001520168618299067, -0.04241775721311569, 0.007758941035717726, 0.002677095588296652, -0.01347368210554123, -0.04827223718166351, -0.04720567911863327, -0.007139981724321842, 0.00426628440618515, -0.008376875892281532, -0.054840099066495895, -0.03508957475423813, -0.00966924149543047, -0.03152100741863251, 0.014315557666122913, 0.036889590322971344, -0.06472055613994598, -0.01883848011493683, 0.003076330292969942, -0.008903473615646362, 0.053016386926174164, -0.01237755548208952, -0.025955574586987495, 0.037443049252033234, -0.0014800259377807379, -0.0073181563057005405, 0.026939358562231064, 0.007056228816509247, -0.013420730829238892, 0.013464617542922497, -0.025381676852703094, -0.004832311999052763, 0.02885613590478897, -0.02778967097401619, -0.030613720417022705, 0.009482978843152523, 0.03957240656018257, -0.008142032660543919, 0.004485744517296553, -0.03697845712304115, 0.008099268190562725, 0.015267531387507915, -0.0253604706376791, -0.018649138510227203, 0.0017799066845327616, 0.0010682342108339071, 0.0012068236246705055, 0.014364438131451607, -0.010840344242751598, 0.006600496359169483, 0.09774123877286911, 0.007280082441866398, 0.015348749235272408, -0.011385245248675346, 0.007339738309383392, 0.026205716654658318, -0.015588498674333096, 0.014626064337790012, 0.02180536463856697, -0.004962050821632147, -0.047412000596523285, -0.029270151630043983, -0.07789554446935654, 0.021566404029726982, 0.04232373833656311, 0.040405306965112686, 0.041090838611125946, 0.05302509292960167, -0.011305881664156914, -0.03772132843732834, -0.061108969151973724, 0.017814956605434418, 0.018538672477006912, -0.027871061116456985, 0.05625048652291298, -0.033471278846263885, -0.0013070311397314072, 0.030086617916822433, 0.02694908156991005, -0.029580894857645035, 0.043596312403678894, 0.01913411170244217, 0.013234632089734077, 0.01713702641427517, 0.009162968024611473, -0.05816592648625374, 0.06486400961875916, -0.03845607116818428, 0.024286817759275436, -0.005051860120147467, -0.008740798570215702, 0.03061305359005928, 0.045150745660066605, -0.01032399944961071, -0.034574177116155624, -0.037783779203891754, -0.03663697466254234, -0.006925102788954973, 0.043870605528354645, -0.011349819600582123, 0.0488867461681366, 0.012758851051330566, 0.04762076959013939, -0.025123922154307365, 0.03472232073545456, 0.0035954408813267946, -0.06897914409637451, -0.025956902652978897, -0.0414799340069294, -0.008965114131569862, -0.024210114032030106, -0.004405721090734005, 0.011368638835847378, 0.0319378636777401, -0.046392038464546204, 0.0513848252594471, 0.03425022214651108, 0.05696357786655426, -0.014948179945349693, 0.07698635756969452, 0.02013039030134678, 0.02116987481713295, 0.001965165603905916, 0.0004130228189751506, 0.13255879282951355, 0.048025425523519516, 0.04654082655906677, -0.10720283538103104, 0.03560488671064377, -0.010214216075837612, -0.018398402258753777, -0.04296327754855156, 0.005369215272367001, -0.00998014211654663, -0.003543779021129012, -0.004871724639087915, 0.05062718689441681, 0.004829959943890572, -0.04237964749336243, 0.002149642910808325, -0.03120284713804722, -0.04818907007575035, 0.0027215606532990932, -0.005108986049890518, -0.03934672102332115, -0.04692637547850609, -0.03964086249470711, -0.0031958415638655424, -0.009075095877051353, -0.02906869724392891, -0.014647310599684715, -0.02471091039478779, 0.00039625904173590243, -0.012154102325439453, -0.01425805501639843, -0.00296428962610662, 0.051282040774822235, -0.005080504808574915, 0.006450433284044266, 0.022705284878611565, 0.02161525748670101, -0.014074176549911499, 0.018370097503066063, 0.00860680267214775, -0.0025616351049393415, 0.03427763655781746, 0.01445471215993166, 0.011705906130373478, -0.014530406333506107, -0.055722426623106, -0.026492029428482056, 0.05875890329480171, 0.00029143583378754556, -0.020705465227365494, -0.021262969821691513, 0.006390505004674196, 0.007325077895075083, -0.0417058989405632, 0.024847527965903282, -0.005396958906203508, -0.01681593433022499, -0.03841300681233406, -0.00026375323068350554, 0.019807681441307068, 0.035273026674985886, 0.004262320697307587, 0.0279768668115139, 0.005249164532870054, -0.008889214135706425, 0.0038056066259741783, 0.017595432698726654, 0.014737523160874844, -0.007956895977258682, 0.007261177990585566, -0.028219591826200485, -0.01890789344906807, -0.012013095431029797, -0.05447932332754135, 0.01478408370167017, -0.021637097001075745, 0.02204488404095173, 0.012628338299691677, 0.0019237262895330787, -0.053783513605594635, -0.051474496722221375, -0.03252426162362099, -0.007430924568325281, -0.026306945830583572, 0.0009636390605010092, 0.005538748577237129, 0.025916755199432373, 0.030825266614556313, 0.016061728820204735, -0.03450446203351021, 0.03832929953932762, 0.02442667819559574, 0.03194563463330269, -0.021223554387688637, -0.03109852224588394, 0.04713084548711777, -0.012127700261771679, 0.025741035118699074, 0.018265530467033386, 0.05138969421386719, 0.012662652879953384, 0.055318914353847504, -0.013912329450249672, 0.015294726006686687, -0.03776095062494278, -0.01618184708058834, 0.002600471256300807, -0.015164785087108612, 0.014119773171842098, 0.056375615298748016, 0.01318079512566328, -0.017322521656751633, 0.008464428596198559, 0.01723024621605873, 0.03003935143351555, 0.04037155956029892, -0.02750893123447895, -0.015735987573862076, -0.03229096159338951, 0.011205322109162807, 0.01317334733903408, -0.013520919717848301, 0.0008737995522096753, 0.009506951086223125, 0.01632782258093357, 0.023720264434814453, -0.009335566312074661, -0.06113429367542267, 0.013348881155252457, 0.0006528267404064536, 0.0019688354805111885, 0.030735697597265244, 0.011386523023247719, 0.007906748913228512, -0.048110783100128174, -0.01569685898721218, -0.03211024031043053, 0.053944047540426254, -0.015238413587212563, 0.0007715509855188429, 0.012331468053162098, -0.036306027323007584, -0.011663665995001793, -0.011700996197760105, 0.041243355721235275, 0.0345182828605175, 0.024201443418860435, -0.02242266945540905, -0.05786318704485893, 0.01871257834136486, -0.010989678092300892, 0.001069608610123396, -0.0431753434240818, 0.002175711328163743, -0.006173401605337858, -0.011613651178777218, 0.00564047135412693, 0.0015059339348226786, 0.011174608953297138, 0.040677186101675034, 0.020417941734194756, -0.07571222633123398, -0.04416411742568016, 0.019985103979706764, 0.019244147464632988, -0.013637267984449863, -0.01723203994333744, 0.0101314103230834, 0.04102315753698349, 0.031171517446637154, -0.013709514401853085, 0.03417927026748657, -0.008519699797034264, 0.008103822357952595, -0.06498788297176361, -0.016185391694307327, 0.03490840643644333, -0.010248232632875443, 0.037562474608421326, -0.05019864812493324, -0.01158683467656374, 0.050081223249435425, -0.019260866567492485, -0.024014625698328018, 0.016238361597061157, 0.0045129344798624516, -0.03560614213347435, 0.02165433019399643, -0.002396019408479333, -0.00984411220997572, -0.008405485190451145, 0.004297173582017422, 0.028216490522027016, 0.03693409636616707, 0.01708524487912655, -0.0439639575779438, -0.014499052427709103, 0.037380896508693695, 0.039672981947660446, -0.05175556242465973, 0.03414442390203476, -0.030795123428106308, -0.025213269516825676, 0.05437598004937172, 0.003538340562954545, -0.012742921710014343, -0.0059341127052903175, 0.04646030068397522, -0.013164271600544453, 0.026698872447013855, 0.012313039042055607, 0.009165408089756966, 0.06575175374746323, -0.0072437431663274765, 0.06966226547956467, 0.0005623740726150572, -0.017303168773651123, -0.007207630202174187, 0.003927583806216717, -0.03344647213816643, -0.021578319370746613, -0.004604751709848642, -0.008093281649053097, 0.0036912185605615377, -0.01197261456400156, -0.03680916875600815, -0.02839726023375988, -0.075251504778862, 0.029866648837924004, -0.017615627497434616, -0.008623404428362846, 0.04919138178229332, 0.02239716611802578, -0.03675779327750206, -0.0019184963312000036, -0.0007055202731862664, -0.0407099686563015, 0.05289534479379654, 0.02746848203241825, -0.012530216947197914, -0.06316839158535004, -0.018993549048900604, -0.00922681950032711, 0.004178622271865606, -0.03758249804377556, -0.03099558688700199, -0.06800298392772675, 0.0032092039473354816, -0.035237591713666916, -0.021556776016950607, -0.030691495165228844, 0.006666404195129871, -0.0021841563284397125, -0.08657833933830261, 0.050406813621520996, 0.028504440560936928, -0.040145765990018845, -0.03774391487240791, 0.020190443843603134, -0.028077321127057076, -0.0016740466235205531, 0.03642331436276436, 0.037407878786325455, -0.006480843760073185, -0.00803412590175867, 0.053855378180742264, 0.015695827081799507, -0.022019241005182266, 0.020489411428570747, 0.008224018849432468, -0.019221020862460136, -0.0399334691464901, -0.01757844164967537, 0.023607827723026276, 0.004495274741202593, 0.0058340029790997505, 0.01032185647636652, -0.0019829452503472567, 0.01287476159632206, -0.031340502202510834, 0.010937731713056564, -0.0035011342260986567, -0.06156346946954727, 0.061932772397994995, 0.013796086423099041, 0.00700963893905282, 0.004516359884291887, -0.002515999600291252, -0.021149011328816414, 0.023748597130179405, -0.01440927479416132, 0.018928520381450653, -0.0074689146131277084, 0.03181913495063782, 0.016919367015361786, -0.044069528579711914, -0.03512624651193619, 0.034258630126714706, -0.022078102454543114, -0.002818640321493149, 0.036462217569351196, -0.008490155450999737, 0.03411073610186577, 0.0010953197488561273, 0.04156504571437836, 0.036051541566848755, -0.010593635030090809, 0.052655041217803955, -0.030681448057293892, 0.020763656124472618, -0.03075326792895794, 0.012161578051745892, 0.0696626529097557, -0.03898962587118149, 0.014584711752831936, -0.02305532805621624, 0.03495083749294281, -0.014965992420911789, -0.012689322233200073, 0.011629757471382618, -0.0050738719291985035, -0.023422708734869957, 0.01734147220849991, 0.0005759439081884921, 0.04155205190181732, -0.06064503267407417, 0.011583100073039532, 0.016531385481357574, 0.0336158461868763, 0.008479712530970573, 0.015243561007082462, 0.0021946693304926157, -0.01993078738451004, 0.031807493418455124, 0.003933358937501907, -0.02617385797202587, -0.008653578348457813, -0.0006608220865018666, -0.010173872113227844, -0.013217120431363583, 0.01483886782079935, 0.008097401820123196, 0.015027765184640884, -0.027197256684303284, -0.00558612821623683, -0.0037592705339193344, 0.0020032485481351614, 0.02259881980717182, 0.04199657961726189, -0.02925775572657585, -0.005160690750926733, 0.010088169947266579, 0.06103847548365593, -0.03031950816512108, -0.02618679776787758, -0.03227604180574417, 0.014552213251590729, -0.004209473729133606, -0.010777910239994526 ]
<p>Trying to understand the solution given to this homework problem:</p> <p>Define random variables $X$ and $Y_n$ where $n=1,2\ldots%$ with probability mass functions:</p> <p>$$ f_X(x)=\begin{cases} \frac{1}{2} &amp;\mbox{if } x = -1 \\ \frac{1}{2} &amp;\mbox{if } x = 1 \\ 0 &amp;\mbox{otherwise} \end{cases} and\; f_{Y_n}(y)=\begin{cases} \frac{1}{2}-\frac{1}{n+1} &amp;\mbox{if } y = -1 \\ \frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{n+1} &amp;\mbox{if } y = 1 \\ 0 &amp;\mbox{otherwise} \end{cases} $$</p> <p>Need to show whether $Y_n$ converges to $X$ in probability.</p> <p>From this I can define the probability space $\Omega=([0,1],U)$ and express the random variables as functions of indicator variables as such:</p> <p>$X = 1_{\omega &gt; \frac{1}{2}} - 1_{\omega &lt; \frac{1}{2}}$ and $Y_n = 1_{\omega &lt; \frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{n+1}} - 1_{\omega &gt; \frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{n+1}}$</p> <p>And from the definition of convergence in probability, we need find to show that $P\{|Y_n-X|&gt;\epsilon\}$ does or does not converge to zero. Which can be written as:</p> <p>$P\{|1_{\omega &lt; \frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{n+1}} - 1_{\omega &gt; \frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{n+1}} - 1_{\omega &gt; \frac{1}{2}} + 1_{\omega &lt; \frac{1}{2}}| &gt; \epsilon \}\;\;(1)$</p> <p>Now it's easy to see that $\epsilon &lt; 2$ for this to hold, but the solution given states that:</p> <p>$P\{|Y_n-X|&gt;\epsilon\} = 1 - \frac{1}{n+1} \;\; (2)$</p> <p>Thus $Y_n$ does not converge in probability to $X$.</p> <p>My problem is that I don't see the reasoning between (1) and (2). Can anyone shed some insight into intermediate steps/reasoning required to make this step?</p>
74,179
[ -0.006943487096577883, -0.0318339578807354, 0.02803715318441391, -0.0036274511367082596, 0.022052591666579247, 0.009300372563302517, 0.0004906137473881245, -0.0199105367064476, 0.03261407092213631, -0.016087966039776802, 0.019211864098906517, 0.022882502526044846, 0.03197414055466652, -0.02228706143796444, 0.014965850859880447, 0.04831584542989731, -0.03597510978579521, 0.029098723083734512, -0.020628279075026512, -0.031147047877311707, -0.01603490673005581, 0.026408933103084564, 0.07956044375896454, -0.0029141828417778015, -0.046971824020147324, 0.0125440564006567, 0.00633007800206542, -0.02357277274131775, 0.039062757045030594, 0.02941664308309555, -0.03632287308573723, -0.020113009959459305, 0.0026607562322169542, 0.018814362585544586, -0.014100016094744205, 0.018125109374523163, -0.036383435130119324, -0.007516342680901289, 0.017875049263238907, 0.02416055090725422, -0.0175826083868742, -0.020643265917897224, -0.008430052548646927, -0.011018420569598675, 0.002513215411454439, -0.0043612392619252205, 0.004760713316500187, -0.011857437901198864, 0.01646767556667328, -0.016742167994379997, 0.08035226911306381, -0.03049924224615097, 0.03154228255152702, 0.04778654873371124, 0.021248791366815567, -0.04220157489180565, 0.04041845723986626, 0.08800245076417923, -0.0026305937208235264, -0.04037262499332428, -0.028523538261651993, -0.03819217160344124, -0.010409696027636528, -0.015115069225430489, -0.01415126770734787, 0.01459871232509613, 0.01945364475250244, 0.0007765723275952041, 0.007451996672898531, 0.015818804502487183, 0.04664619639515877, 0.01585724577307701, 0.019596731290221214, -0.010194884613156319, 0.001534284558147192, 0.006843124981969595, 0.01569933071732521, -0.0064429789781570435, 0.012720090337097645, 0.025593655183911324, -0.0034022650215774775, 0.01825847290456295, -0.00400268379598856, -0.003449823008850217, 0.001407488132826984, -0.008567946963012218, 0.05988428369164467, 0.005578162148594856, 0.02066933549940586, 0.01498511154204607, -0.009336334653198719, -0.0013106492115184665, 0.04062593728303909, -0.03737293928861618, -0.036586880683898926, 0.04711051657795906, -0.025752993300557137, -0.023490775376558304, -0.00035341278999112546, -0.014634765684604645, -0.01855599321424961, -0.10020541399717331, 0.032177772372961044, 0.07150096446275711, -0.04753546044230461, 0.0049853199161589146, -0.0381595678627491, 0.008906014263629913, -0.03127998486161232, 0.0045485710725188255, -0.039096418768167496, 0.06863999366760254, -0.00767575204372406, 0.021257473155856133, 0.01618954725563526, 0.0075790598057210445, -0.018594874069094658, -0.05382488667964935, -0.003996991086751223, 0.06484640389680862, 0.0759594663977623, 0.01790725439786911, 0.010648822411894798, -0.01741815358400345, -0.06333628296852112, 0.012326064519584179, 0.020757758989930153, 0.012803361751139164, -0.008701388724148273, 0.05456509813666344, -0.0041458215564489365, -0.003254274372011423, 0.01861509680747986, 0.06648527830839157, 0.07047169655561447, 0.018927324563264847, -0.08727575093507767, -0.03804381936788559, 0.03447308391332626, -0.030543938279151917, 0.014093560166656971, -0.07829500734806061, 0.01804831251502037, 0.05085457116365433, 0.056354302912950516, -0.010968086309731007, 0.019504500553011894, 0.013005181215703487, 0.02178337797522545, 0.035054463893175125, -0.032705798745155334, -0.02669486403465271, -0.01755959540605545, -0.02890671230852604, 0.011493724770843983, -0.043929945677518845, 0.029917631298303604, 0.007122353184968233, -0.0351625420153141, -0.07278027385473251, 0.03417690098285675, -0.020892277359962463, 0.01563454233109951, -0.021742219105362892, -0.002798724453896284, -0.027471082285046577, 0.06909449398517609, 0.028375159949064255, 0.0040726629085838795, 0.06887909770011902, -0.006766343954950571, 0.02387302741408348, -0.002918799174949527, 0.027461664751172066, 0.04404124617576599, -0.07215794175863266, -0.045231565833091736, -0.020054303109645844, -0.010637803934514523, 0.050968918949365616, -0.008456876501441002, -0.007867553271353245, -0.05904106795787811, 0.002301012398675084, 0.033160340040922165, 0.022188358008861542, 0.040753062814474106, 0.007688101381063461, 0.03010147251188755, -0.04396547004580498, -0.026182780042290688, -0.05558300018310547, -0.016859089955687523, 0.013911678455770016, -0.015754327178001404, 0.023722518235445023, -0.020634010434150696, -0.023982226848602295, -0.02710598148405552, 0.013938389718532562, -0.06040645018219948, 0.02707231603562832, 0.028828958049416542, -0.061895497143268585, 0.011739809066057205, 0.0400937981903553, 0.0503934808075428, -0.009980403818190098, 0.05814462900161743, -0.05235319957137108, -0.008373239077627659, -0.0064580244943499565, -0.01953204907476902, 0.021381767466664314, 0.007899668999016285, -0.0003853414673358202, 0.031330548226833344, -0.03971593454480171, 0.0031644313130527735, -0.0058198366314172745, -0.07217193394899368, 0.053693607449531555, 0.10321084409952164, -0.008821717463433743, -0.007242374122142792, 0.005445664748549461, -0.0017931488109752536, 0.02369522862136364, -0.012804470956325531, -0.011834912933409214, -0.03952417150139809, -0.018794404342770576, 0.04000561684370041, 0.0907612144947052, -0.02329345792531967, 0.0017679015873000026, 0.07621052116155624, -0.02196725644171238, 0.010205305181443691, 0.020438887178897858, 0.0003229078429285437, -0.0005185113986954093, 0.007323699537664652, 0.0028849251102656126, 0.022715270519256592, 0.010825560428202152, -0.004343484062701464, 0.04063038527965546, 0.013733861036598682, -0.019106272608041763, -0.006768687628209591, 0.06321683526039124, -0.0021599873434752226, -0.0014277087757363915, 0.000608042988460511, -0.00252240477129817, 0.020028982311487198, 0.0027179517783224583, -0.031653616577386856, 0.04498995095491409, 0.019361529499292374, 0.012728862464427948, -0.010786151513457298, -0.02717670239508152, 0.014723142609000206, 0.07183635979890823, -0.026252590119838715, -0.06435583531856537, 0.02934371680021286, -0.006449853535741568, 0.0008245498756878078, 0.005419681314378977, -0.09489280730485916, 0.0007940752548165619, -0.049042195081710815, 0.05149523913860321, -0.007759009022265673, -0.036089446395635605, -0.04950905591249466, 0.009733317419886589, 0.011221644468605518, 0.023052191361784935, 0.02698659896850586, 0.014524185098707676, -0.05714164301753044, 0.0014762214850634336, -0.025093110278248787, 0.002521870657801628, 0.008680121041834354, -0.0001593238121131435, -0.01727576181292534, 0.007766067981719971, -0.0013534676982089877, -0.04099910706281662, -0.04331209138035774, -0.03385936841368675, 0.044429194182157516, -0.0382244773209095, -0.020741334185004234, 0.09451977163553238, -0.022855989634990692, -0.018152613192796707, 0.0008286451920866966, -0.05847537890076637, -0.04791521653532982, -0.052220363169908524, -0.036641690880060196, 0.0307293850928545, 0.011739067733287811, 0.028323758393526077, -0.01000654511153698, 0.02586536854505539, -0.01097275409847498, -0.05099864304065704, -0.08709773421287537, -0.00676638213917613, 0.015443486161530018, 0.04792647436261177, -0.006018978077918291, -0.012699137441813946, 0.06469226628541946, 0.04700593277812004, -0.006992938928306103, -0.024851806461811066, 0.028833609074354172, -0.035144172608852386, -0.015198475681245327, 0.0009761820547282696, 0.012684942223131657, -0.0019516234751790762, 0.04441109672188759, -0.004130701068788767, 0.03635215386748314, 0.04781216382980347, 0.005746130831539631, 0.028813041746616364, 0.05021015554666519, -0.03317726403474808, 0.02583157829940319, 0.009984315373003483, -0.006485814694315195, -0.0010714706731960177, 0.000948354892898351, 0.012181808240711689, 0.004137296695262194, -0.032420363277196884, -0.02907196804881096, 0.019884329289197922, -0.005003612022846937, 0.019147098064422607, -0.02389157935976982, 0.07477575540542603, 0.009009402245283127, -0.024637283757328987, 0.003908650483936071, -0.039160970598459244, 0.08507167547941208, -0.01235880795866251, 0.05175364390015602, 0.0453801304101944, 0.04821834713220596, -0.023986823856830597, 0.01664097048342228, 0.013919088058173656, -0.03498680517077446, 0.029598884284496307, -0.03593967482447624, -0.019849637523293495, 0.01739569753408432, 0.02075679413974285, -0.0017601230647414923, 0.02259809710085392, 0.005958493798971176, -0.01873222179710865, -0.01935688965022564, -0.00983463879674673, -0.027964765205979347, 0.061011988669633865, 0.036860231310129166, 0.051877520978450775, -0.023204805329442024, -0.020312657579779625, -0.030967270955443382, -0.030657924711704254, -0.056061938405036926, -0.003345123026520014, -0.029097773134708405, 0.02894667722284794, -0.0444224588572979, 0.04090723395347595, 0.023124366998672485, -0.02844563126564026, 0.015853263437747955, -0.009306943975389004, 0.01739184558391571, -0.05387090891599655, -0.020594025030732155, -0.04319285601377487, -0.028329836204648018, 0.006989398971199989, 0.03487018868327141, -0.004909540992230177, -0.006583146285265684, 0.01460159569978714, -0.0004142638063058257, -0.01080874539911747, 0.003397470572963357, -0.023346371948719025, -0.022134466096758842, 0.05204736441373825, 0.020177893340587616, 0.008579128421843052, 0.050739586353302, 0.0016481926431879401, 0.01292067114263773, 0.03175020590424538, 0.06104331836104393, 0.021562427282333374, -0.03390809893608093, -0.022164128720760345, -0.013955917209386826, 0.006288276053965092, 0.02708832547068596, 0.02784949168562889, 0.0022741174325346947, 0.01053182128816843, 0.04988313838839531, -0.025995846837759018, -0.0032663235906511545, 0.01528362650424242, 0.04428224638104439, -0.04277060180902481, 0.036610834300518036, -0.027381284162402153, -0.015509050339460373, -0.07291176170110703, 0.02780582569539547, 0.024716682732105255, -0.02286856807768345, -0.018104389309883118, 0.010716303251683712, 0.04722568765282631, 0.03617532551288605, 0.007965384982526302, -0.009076663292944431, 0.03090224228799343, 0.02427775226533413, 0.022046806290745735, -0.05998002365231514, 0.051672641187906265, -0.009946340695023537, 0.017301127314567566, 0.019721684977412224, 0.016232499852776527, -0.011592959985136986, -0.012359550222754478, 0.031169580295681953, 0.018487969413399696, -0.004872321151196957, 0.004256930202245712, -0.05580995976924896, -0.02677127718925476, 0.033680565655231476, -0.022926928475499153, 0.011449105106294155, 0.002916082041338086, 0.016772450879216194, 0.01963295042514801, -0.07641182094812393, -0.06909970939159393, -0.02177301049232483, 0.023220375180244446, 0.004725402686744928, -0.02720029465854168, -0.03357459604740143, -0.03562471643090248, -0.007156175095587969, 0.03018008917570114, 0.07926644384860992, -0.051952723413705826, -0.008490608073771, 0.0049248309805989265, 0.04197602719068527, 0.03010712005198002, -0.05787051096558571, 0.053516287356615067, 0.015104911290109158, 0.01329614594578743, 0.005752691067755222, -0.027232447639107704, -0.08397532999515533, 0.05016561597585678, -0.011832277290523052, -0.024802764877676964, 0.024326464161276817, -0.007130910642445087, 0.03404351696372032, 0.03911596164107323, -0.014422559179365635, 0.0061647966504096985, 0.048335008323192596, 0.017485100775957108, 0.05821425840258598, -0.03317848592996597, -0.006012433208525181, -0.033601902425289154, -0.004455966874957085, -0.05112609639763832, -0.01669650338590145, 0.0076533411629498005, 0.037989165633916855, 0.04056773707270622, 0.013884659856557846, -0.022459153085947037, -0.006677463185042143, 0.020317059010267258, 0.0038989742752164602, 0.016870710998773575, 0.02373897284269333, -0.018254918977618217, 0.0008247297955676913, 0.041009724140167236, -0.02046966925263405, 0.03290102630853653, -0.024945218116044998, -0.01727980375289917, 0.03756219148635864, 0.0010026661911979318, -0.0009974308777600527, -0.04881898686289787, -0.006096228491514921, -0.02695891261100769, -0.03306436911225319, 0.02455088496208191, 0.023229705169796944, 0.010499164462089539, 0.010566412471234798, -0.008332310244441032, -0.03460517153143883, 0.016930529847741127, 0.029925260692834854, 0.0007557192002423108, 0.014725271612405777, 0.0022263643331825733, 0.021972140297293663, 0.0015012966468930244, -0.04629748687148094, -0.03542128950357437, -0.026064276695251465, -0.0008644170011393726, -0.013582688756287098, -0.04988902807235718, 0.024001915007829666, 0.013764512725174427, 0.0015168024692684412, 0.018131230026483536, 0.002215868793427944, -0.03687874227762222, -0.03931647539138794, 0.008346563205122948, 0.008240671828389168, 0.07268049567937851, -0.01078280620276928, -0.026091093197464943, 0.028081003576517105, -0.02176121063530445, -0.05812081694602966, -0.007546897977590561, -0.00158777111209929, -0.04695511981844902, -0.036653582006692886, -0.022626062855124474, 0.0059660193510353565, 0.033185750246047974, -0.04413536190986633, -0.014606663025915623, 0.03270500898361206, 0.02392786741256714, -0.003719538915902376, -0.0014017793582752347, -0.017173198983073235, 0.021277930587530136, -0.017971832305192947, 0.012976009398698807, 0.0027738616336137056, -0.019399335607886314, -0.04898693412542343, 0.06003902107477188, -0.04807176813483238, 0.016358796507120132, 0.009786346927285194, 0.035586487501859665, -0.014748482964932919, -0.005909919738769531, -0.0019549590069800615, 0.001646279008127749, 0.029145890846848488, -0.0011386115802451968, -0.01769530028104782, 0.003846388543024659, 0.02086121030151844, -0.029099609702825546, -0.01992224156856537, -0.07443657517433167, 0.011403440497815609, 0.06785231828689575, 0.03401609882712364, 0.018729928880929947, 0.03321506455540657, 0.00878794863820076, 0.009400172159075737, 0.009553179144859314, 0.016461117193102837, 0.019344042986631393, -0.005264731589704752, 0.020208226516842842, -0.050482865422964096, -0.022239776328206062, 0.03103991411626339, 0.01601427048444748, 0.025821877643465996, 0.0008652067626826465, -0.02009318768978119, 0.023169809952378273, 0.050977472215890884, -0.031220944598317146, -0.03656391426920891, 0.02802197076380253, -0.019786102697253227, 0.03884179890155792, -0.01640564762055874, -0.04968540742993355, 0.02387349121272564, 0.026784414425492287, -0.036890290677547455, -0.036686718463897705, -0.0209968201816082, -0.028237788006663322, 0.0026753207203000784, 0.00495119346305728, 0.0017489180900156498, 0.019836246967315674, -0.007384978700429201, 0.03857044130563736, -0.007103959564119577, 0.03139198571443558, -0.006427977699786425, -0.06142473965883255, -0.013050996698439121, -0.009769831784069538, -0.04173113778233528, 0.0009558139718137681, -0.008126218803226948, 0.020263193175196648, 0.007568396162241697, -0.009338515810668468, -0.03140527009963989, 0.0511665865778923, 0.011357750743627548, -0.03404610604047775, 0.08717416971921921, 0.0023933816701173782, 0.07640194892883301, -0.030185218900442123, 0.013567706570029259, 0.10710889846086502, 0.042910441756248474, 0.010785410180687904, -0.03475075587630272, -0.028249632567167282, -0.015142782591283321, -0.0018136315047740936, -0.028973288834095, 0.0030311383306980133, 0.03128828480839729, -0.0024062099400907755, 0.04146112501621246, 0.03817638382315636, -0.01056207437068224, -0.014230750501155853, 0.00477283401414752, -0.03079215995967388, -0.026818130165338516, 0.00031361315632238984, -0.001314884633757174, -0.030000576749444008, 0.017244229093194008, 0.0086893979460001, 0.0014456280041486025, -0.01537388563156128, -0.017737066373229027, -0.03676670417189598, -0.0012328188167884946, 0.03890521824359894, -0.0015206964453682303, 0.0021232657600194216, 0.003280030097812414, 0.02617950551211834, -0.03770182281732559, -0.002696441486477852, 0.037259284406900406, -0.0005118129192851484, -0.06819464266300201, 0.02972370572388172, 0.02667907066643238, 0.00471100490540266, -0.0005462394910864532, 0.00363650219514966, -0.006461953278630972, -0.030291935428977013, -0.024813538417220116, -0.023331012576818466, 0.04683045297861099, 0.01531047374010086, 0.0002411686728009954, -0.02097790688276291, -0.00012709916336461902, -0.021100390702486038, -0.048150915652513504, 0.009605662897229195, 0.012888067401945591, 0.034072887152433395, -0.013720219023525715, 0.0014836086193099618, -0.04898485913872719, 0.0016523220110684633, 0.023099295794963837, 0.03290126100182533, 0.05249131843447685, -0.04103568196296692, -0.011802258901298046, -0.01683487370610237, 0.029308002442121506, 0.027446821331977844, 0.015272694639861584, -0.029669076204299927, 0.02560194954276085, 0.016539916396141052, -0.021473607048392296, -0.009962160140275955, -0.029433883726596832, 0.023060839623212814, 0.04573245346546173, -0.011334880255162716, 0.0021880643907934427, -0.0800393670797348, 0.013934718444943428, -0.03239263966679573, -0.022786948829889297, -0.013909191824495792, -0.039804790169000626, -0.0033720415085554123, 0.045923374593257904, 0.018189510330557823, -0.042071711272001266, 0.004933825694024563, 0.06677153706550598, 0.021685335785150528, -0.027922682464122772, -0.05320262163877487, -0.004923494998365641, -0.010291545651853085, 0.017484089359641075, -0.02689128741621971, 0.03780130296945572, 0.03178848698735237, 0.014793572016060352, 0.029377833008766174, 0.012921156361699104, -0.06084735691547394, 0.022892434149980545, -0.019965801388025284, -0.019324982538819313, 0.028648607432842255, 0.021879736334085464, 0.03177762031555176, -0.03506532311439514, -0.04335525631904602, -0.006887522060424089, 0.016650285571813583, 0.0012583715142682195, -0.00042607131763361394, -0.021900421008467674, -0.02549782581627369, -0.007682764437049627, 0.03531622141599655, 0.011450429446995258, 0.0023167498875409365, 0.0005114165833219886, -0.02748960442841053, -0.004647135268896818, 0.0062540494836866856, -0.042066365480422974, 0.01569000631570816, 0.025955375283956528, 0.005221795290708542, 0.03851008042693138, 0.011535453610122204, 0.0008796486654318869, -0.016354450955986977, 0.04425816610455513, -0.001982077956199646, 0.034480929374694824, -0.02602042444050312, 0.00971602275967598, 0.049743637442588806, -0.03310450166463852, -0.028995735570788383, 0.014417245052754879, 0.04672912880778313, 0.06338310986757278, 0.014514021575450897, 0.015708550810813904, -0.06350864470005035, 0.026181872934103012, -0.051006752997636795, 0.009469779208302498, 0.0024908974301069975, 0.01247535552829504, 0.007820520550012589, -0.0301151555031538, -0.00993418414145708, 0.02160448208451271, 0.027780862525105476, -0.005315702874213457, 0.046080030500888824, -0.03961643949151039, -0.03813810274004936, 0.016010703518986702, -0.014767457731068134, 0.002534866565838456, -0.007031942717730999, 0.022981222718954086, 0.038456544280052185, -0.0004487971600610763, -0.009175112470984459, 0.0049193063750863075, -0.05168309807777405, -0.03229032829403877, -0.07740221917629242, -0.03900901600718498, 0.020030241459608078, 0.03127957135438919, 0.056115537881851196, -0.015575443394482136, -0.02083175629377365, 0.012082003988325596, 0.004864383954554796, 0.0048921857960522175, 0.01051931083202362, -0.02500571496784687, -0.04100959748029709, 0.01164327748119831, -0.03928158059716225, 0.00640476681292057, 0.015230206772685051, 0.026001036167144775, 0.03334541618824005, 0.005002326797693968, -0.006663795094937086, -0.019051169976592064, 0.03821645677089691, -0.006779856514185667, -0.019602112472057343, -0.016186881810426712, 0.05980509892106056, -0.03213144838809967, 0.017214728519320488, 0.060240160673856735, 0.02509809471666813, -0.026777351275086403, 0.01642511785030365, 0.029368653893470764, -0.0007200539112091064, 0.02801775187253952, 0.023723749443888664, 0.03535836562514305, 0.004853885620832443, -0.02168385125696659, 0.04598413035273552, -0.023566806688904762, -0.026750128716230392, -0.021444525569677353, 0.027204666286706924, -0.03858930990099907, -0.05068914219737053, -0.007779978681355715, 0.021770011633634567, -0.006767922546714544, 0.024006128311157227, -0.0274135023355484, -0.02837248146533966, -0.037966612726449966, 0.024009691551327705, -0.005323322955518961, -0.035632286220788956, 0.02121165581047535, 0.02609724923968315, -0.022846287116408348, -0.02246031165122986, 0.02683700993657112, -0.04984883591532707, 0.028504295274615288, 0.012114009819924831, -0.027005044743418694, -0.03581657260656357, -0.0038889371789991856, -0.0001935793407028541, 0.021499812602996826, 0.0008179068099707365, -0.0421786792576313, -0.05635948106646538, 0.0028204985428601503, -0.013143709860742092, -0.0020215041004121304, -0.0018632697174325585, 0.015008019283413887, -0.03456348925828934, -0.08634553849697113, 0.01635114476084709, 0.024192413315176964, -0.042548321187496185, -0.015878545120358467, 0.0027322261594235897, -0.05090439319610596, 0.009468474425375462, 0.031335968524217606, 0.028467679396271706, -0.0037920139729976654, 0.0002595306432340294, 0.00021248022676445544, 0.04732154682278633, -0.04720776528120041, 0.031102633103728294, -0.05541884899139404, -0.03611046075820923, -0.018337307497859, -0.0011706335935741663, 0.028748396784067154, 0.0012296716449782252, 0.029004758223891258, 0.013742124661803246, -0.03469175100326538, -0.018518580123782158, -0.012302166782319546, 0.01892217993736267, -0.029535658657550812, 0.009545624256134033, 0.022438449785113335, -0.05655423551797867, 0.025713464245200157, -0.004164910409599543, -0.010975101962685585, -0.05845049396157265, 0.010827518068253994, -0.02158982679247856, 0.0009569884277880192, 0.004237799905240536, -0.011667088605463505, 0.006997877731919289, -0.053272027522325516, -0.040930718183517456, 0.030623139813542366, -0.036949992179870605, -0.0252031609416008, 0.01372715923935175, 0.0201819259673357, 0.0463334396481514, 0.035670310258865356, -0.005757917184382677, 0.00617570336908102, 0.0128284627571702, 0.013129085302352905, 0.019259478896856308, 0.024259183555841446, -0.050649091601371765, 0.031735148280858994, 0.028219031170010567, -0.007130860351026058, 0.011588088236749172, 0.019616644829511642, 0.012120756320655346, -0.04001789540052414, -0.0029624912422150373, 0.025020673871040344, -0.039450958371162415, -0.01785106584429741, 0.06063297018408775, -0.0023893658071756363, 0.04630741477012634, -0.004783770069479942, 0.06168081611394882, 0.017358941957354546, 0.00738353468477726, -0.06053576245903969, 0.001976017840206623, 0.008523134514689445, 0.020277101546525955, 0.006658230908215046, 0.03457021713256836, 0.011078432202339172, -0.009432912804186344, 0.0006127844681032002, -0.02291949838399887, -0.016789879649877548, 0.02117878384888172, 0.0016748765483498573, 0.0002858823863789439, -0.026299992576241493, 0.010823152028024197, -0.020543595775961876, -0.015310632064938545, 0.03253141790628433, 0.03821120038628578, -0.023697415366768837, -0.005510537885129452, -0.01945974864065647, 0.058547552675008774, -0.039671942591667175, 0.0036979615688323975, -0.03450858220458031, -0.006925900932401419, 0.021116210147738457, -0.030126189813017845 ]
<p>I have situation in which I compare many genomic regions between two or more cell lines (CL). Each region is covered by n probes measuring the level of methylation (continuous variable). The coverage (value of n = sample size per region, generally varies between 4 and 20) is different for different regions (array property, property of the base pair sequence) . However, for 1 region n is the same for all CLs.</p> <p>For example (n=2, A &amp; B)</p> <p>region 1 has 5 measurements in each cell line.</p> <pre><code>region 1, CL A: 23 9 80 62 31 region 1, CL B: -98 -65 -19 -95 -23 </code></pre> <p>region 2 has 10 measurements within the region (bigger region and/or better coverage)</p> <pre><code>region 2, CL A: 66 7 31 89 100 81 63 93 33 0 region 2, CL B: 17 -50 -89 -46 -52 -80 -7 -26 -62 -26 </code></pre> <p>The data has one additional property: the measurements WITHIN one cell line &amp; region are correlated, e.g. if one of the measurements (one genomic locus) gives a high methylation value, the adjacent locus is more probable to also be high. I have illustrated this by the sign of the numbers in the demo data. (There is no repeated measurement involved.)</p> <p>The number of regions of interest concerns several thousand regions.</p> <p>I want to do 2 things</p> <ol> <li>Test for each region whether A differs from B. Currently I use a Mann Whitney U test for this if n=2 (A,B) or Kruskal Wallis if n>2 (A,B,C,...) . I have been told that because of the correlation, the assumption of independence of the measurements (=samples) fails and I should use a permutation test. Is the approach as implemented in the "coin" package in R (<a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/coin/vignettes/coin.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/coin/vignettes/coin.pdf</a>) applicable to this problem (conditional counterpart of unconditional tests).</li> <li>Correct for multiple testing. As my sample sizes vary between the regions I am at a loss here. The p-values do not seem to be comparable because of this, so application of default FWER based correction might not be possible, right?</li> </ol> <p>I would very much appreciate any insight. Thanks a lot.</p>
61
[ -0.028834516182541847, 0.020066624507308006, 0.031188933178782463, 0.028984446078538895, 0.019996900111436844, -0.009577595628798008, 0.00007987255958141759, -0.04622757062315941, 0.020808806642889977, -0.03816896677017212, 0.0707196369767189, -0.00017704273341223598, 0.017639363184571266, -0.005154074635356665, -0.009061460383236408, 0.000688216823618859, -0.015987271443009377, 0.03458871692419052, 0.0001079607754945755, -0.01603534258902073, 0.023474447429180145, 0.0019622365944087505, 0.023647306486964226, -0.017432527616620064, -0.037629157304763794, 0.044554416090250015, 0.01994764432311058, -0.052277080714702606, -0.003948107361793518, 0.054385412484407425, -0.05643964931368828, -0.04585874453186989, 0.03442919999361038, 0.002302327658981085, 0.03419370949268341, -0.02028849348425865, 0.018342945724725723, 0.0017130165360867977, 0.008956292644143105, 0.019629649817943573, -0.08039353787899017, -0.011797911487519741, -0.039342641830444336, 0.027593260630965233, 0.024775294587016106, 0.015842368826270103, -0.004716421011835337, -0.006011222023516893, 0.014470327645540237, -0.03171997517347336, 0.09914547950029373, -0.016597501933574677, 0.04175199568271637, 0.014854912646114826, -0.009296094998717308, -0.0169414971023798, 0.040782731026411057, 0.06483734399080276, 0.014089046977460384, -0.03019542805850506, -0.026328038424253464, -0.043480850756168365, 0.0002446760190650821, -0.04618882015347481, -0.0339057631790638, 0.03414582833647728, -0.014081749133765697, 0.008277504704892635, 0.00972833577543497, -0.018139474093914032, 0.02156701311469078, 0.011928004212677479, 0.036737002432346344, -0.031867653131484985, -0.004066674504429102, -0.005184904206544161, -0.0029497561044991016, 0.019090889021754265, 0.02896263264119625, 0.018976910039782524, 0.0013193496270105243, 0.03219213709235191, 0.0012214166345074773, 0.019817044958472252, 0.04623931646347046, -0.057665158063173294, 0.006283673457801342, -0.042866289615631104, 0.012148060835897923, 0.04948434233665466, -0.012176550924777985, -0.03075464256107807, 0.06184394657611847, 0.032986853271722794, -0.04275304824113846, 0.027098078280687332, -0.017510637640953064, 0.03400183841586113, -0.012848678976297379, 0.013712812215089798, -0.01748720183968544, -0.047664087265729904, 0.015446634031832218, 0.07130228728055954, -0.012707523070275784, -0.016193006187677383, -0.026312455534934998, -0.020229646936058998, -0.028965046629309654, -0.0030844109132885933, 0.007246127352118492, 0.033903706818819046, -0.006765957456082106, 0.014623249880969524, 0.01910817250609398, -0.02373966947197914, -0.021724199876189232, 0.0009221533546224236, 0.05637131258845329, 0.07205807417631149, 0.04743286594748497, -0.036845918744802475, -0.007527834735810757, -0.033340923488140106, -0.0070104231126606464, 0.006059452425688505, -0.01295519433915615, 0.017951734364032745, 0.0057656955905258656, 0.030576009303331375, 0.02285069413483143, -0.010033166967332363, 0.04471122846007347, -0.007148838602006435, 0.017474554479122162, -0.010047770105302334, -0.08843021839857101, -0.03790334239602089, 0.03681306540966034, -0.046631425619125366, 0.02156051993370056, -0.043710146099328995, -0.018770910799503326, 0.021522048860788345, 0.07134152203798294, -0.018475525081157684, 0.04111729934811592, 0.008146747015416622, 0.005748645402491093, 0.033091455698013306, -0.006180838216096163, 0.005605567246675491, -0.02706027217209339, -0.011561582796275616, -0.02162374183535576, -0.05845341458916664, 0.025073140859603882, 0.033259548246860504, -0.015276122838258743, 0.03338690847158432, -0.007955553010106087, 0.020469650626182556, -0.008035960607230663, -0.014362916350364685, 0.016216497868299484, -0.007147433236241341, 0.07185574620962143, 0.011121099814772606, 0.026684727519750595, 0.05865315720438957, -0.04281788691878319, 0.000965899380389601, 0.011363934725522995, 0.058023326098918915, 0.05774393305182457, 0.014590319246053696, 0.026880033314228058, -0.036702994257211685, 0.02101117931306362, 0.01665022410452366, -0.004963335115462542, -0.008256104774773121, -0.025805845856666565, 0.01126607321202755, 0.029589464887976646, 0.00756247341632843, -0.028097033500671387, 0.014123466797173023, 0.07415525615215302, -0.05545390769839287, -0.04441223666071892, -0.023444635793566704, -0.025589168071746826, 0.010195340029895306, -0.06995263695716858, 0.022982699796557426, -0.0022695509251207113, -0.0045386794954538345, 0.01577082648873329, -0.0641234815120697, -0.04069824889302254, -0.007596622686833143, 0.058386627584695816, -0.04023797810077667, -0.010910369455814362, 0.0013163650874048471, 0.010675618425011635, -0.025713782757520676, 0.041662491858005524, -0.012882934883236885, -0.015134895220398903, 0.04286878556013107, -0.034203656017780304, -0.003197310259565711, 0.000034281056286999956, 0.014639943838119507, -0.009773144498467445, 0.008555971086025238, -0.05128663778305054, 0.06086084619164467, -0.060953229665756226, 0.044640667736530304, 0.05402452498674393, 0.015636004507541656, 0.0027225983794778585, -0.02606680989265442, 0.0021566026844084263, 0.03731285035610199, -0.028918877243995667, -0.01945996657013893, -0.09449516236782074, -0.044186659157276154, 0.021278735250234604, 0.028451289981603622, -0.005649177823215723, -0.026764510199427605, 0.03323190286755562, -0.027114709839224815, 0.00016593436885159463, 0.030120456591248512, 0.02292063646018505, -0.024104440584778786, 0.03234604373574257, -0.0017114612273871899, 0.02125045843422413, 0.006812674924731255, 0.02253805100917816, 0.012124412693083286, 0.08322631567716599, -0.02380361221730709, -0.008791926316916943, 0.034068960696458817, 0.03368448466062546, -0.02854743041098118, -0.03292915225028992, 0.02052944339811802, 0.03848545625805855, -0.0323922373354435, 0.04762296378612518, 0.04545481130480766, 0.00421066302806139, -0.012648818083107471, -0.029338404536247253, -0.030451815575361252, -0.01748526841402054, 0.03733730688691139, -0.032655879855155945, -0.013790302909910679, 0.0030491510406136513, -0.031081756576895714, 0.021948453038930893, -0.013706639409065247, -0.014397806487977505, -0.010872489772737026, 0.041391097009181976, 0.05160432681441307, 0.0058852327056229115, 0.019760766997933388, -0.0467437207698822, -0.021689780056476593, -0.0016067371470853686, 0.00032085186103358865, 0.0415404848754406, -0.00780822429805994, -0.04181107506155968, -0.020641563460230827, -0.009069794788956642, -0.0007632029592059553, -0.01171816699206829, -0.017911404371261597, -0.04270656779408455, 0.019750360399484634, 0.030145591124892235, -0.03437524661421776, -0.0061330413445830345, -0.0017482051625847816, 0.015546297654509544, -0.024778636172413826, -0.02582792192697525, 0.05308666452765465, 0.03729275241494179, -0.05932898074388504, 0.029824431985616684, -0.04206351563334465, 0.02288607694208622, -0.008525216951966286, -0.010389691218733788, 0.008475810289382935, 0.010011626407504082, 0.024003950878977776, 0.06315819174051285, -0.013206756673753262, -0.016344599425792694, -0.032105185091495514, -0.04573754593729973, 0.03624843433499336, -0.020695099607110023, 0.08107570558786392, -0.027099046856164932, 0.01769380457699299, 0.05798189342021942, 0.043802957981824875, 0.002374466275796294, -0.016044672578573227, -0.0019002181943506002, -0.04169679433107376, -0.011463256552815437, 0.03618680313229561, 0.025262245908379555, -0.003167852060869336, -0.011180047877132893, 0.011181519366800785, 0.03705643489956856, 0.021872583776712418, -0.017289139330387115, 0.007719732820987701, 0.03912897780537605, 0.03886772692203522, -0.040669821202754974, 0.02941931039094925, 0.036732714623212814, 0.02363697998225689, -0.016445545479655266, 0.0029453295283019543, -0.026725534349679947, -0.022320078685879707, -0.06381505727767944, -0.0004065638640895486, 0.02590322680771351, 0.02264946699142456, -0.01939529925584793, -0.006879738532006741, 0.029036981984972954, -0.0401521734893322, 0.00322301359847188, 0.032798368483781815, 0.0625159814953804, 0.0027236323803663254, 0.00525047117844224, 0.07416554540395737, 0.028020497411489487, 0.004305197391659021, 0.04472411051392555, -0.0016215506475418806, 0.004858773201704025, 0.001097335945814848, -0.05636904016137123, -0.02512325718998909, 0.012481802143156528, 0.06574172526597977, 0.006976812146604061, -0.03473623842000961, -0.016830626875162125, 0.0271745715290308, -0.032675910741090775, -0.013043027371168137, -0.01756238378584385, 0.02543707564473152, 0.007903020828962326, 0.03690261021256447, 0.003724793903529644, -0.030903760343790054, -0.008835790678858757, -0.02755719982087612, -0.07551894336938858, 0.0070358868688344955, 0.00160694750957191, -0.014917208813130856, -0.010507487691938877, -0.07135550677776337, 0.0630137249827385, 0.009253631345927715, 0.01296429056674242, -0.0010466347448527813, 0.0469193235039711, -0.016548139974474907, 0.0497092604637146, -0.008553728461265564, -0.017222294583916664, -0.023430779576301575, 0.03136831521987915, 0.022958815097808838, -0.0064628105610609055, 0.04261333867907524, 0.004602893255650997, 0.00391827616840601, 0.025728221982717514, 0.005394383333623409, 0.002714611357077956, 0.0016555883921682835, 0.06498166918754578, 0.014984417706727982, 0.028389720246195793, -0.05310877040028572, -0.013515392318367958, 0.007150974124670029, 0.014170817099511623, 0.07843830436468124, -0.019319778308272362, 0.006475874222815037, 0.0002784305834211409, -0.02073214389383793, -0.010078446939587593, 0.03322906792163849, 0.018987150862812996, -0.02987731620669365, 0.05657753720879555, 0.015779204666614532, -0.014556651003658772, 0.004953571129590273, 0.032828014343976974, 0.03097669407725334, 0.013449775986373425, -0.02047278732061386, -0.009961653500795364, 0.020861592143774033, 0.00915746483951807, 0.03292623907327652, 0.0067350962199270725, 0.02794210985302925, -0.016815533861517906, 0.03533819317817688, -0.02981746941804886, -0.03592165559530258, 0.027523212134838104, 0.028156254440546036, 0.027897896245121956, -0.037932977080345154, -0.027113182470202446, 0.009407749399542809, 0.013645289465785027, -0.02223380282521248, 0.04674682021141052, 0.003201516345143318, -0.07010329514741898, -0.014167389832437038, 0.037046488374471664, 0.026227643713355064, -0.006045517046004534, -0.02674776129424572, -0.04284948855638504, 0.007125061471015215, 0.0063029006123542786, -0.011351586319506168, 0.010244596749544144, -0.003520664758980274, 0.017816968262195587, -0.07385288178920746, -0.03672878444194794, -0.03366265818476677, 0.04278986155986786, -0.030412590131163597, -0.017046740278601646, -0.04879666119813919, -0.024320034310221672, -0.028997570276260376, -0.012002984993159771, 0.03022979572415352, 0.051467109471559525, -0.05281348526477814, -0.028263436630368233, 0.054663874208927155, 0.023170268163084984, 0.01359106320887804, -0.020934460684657097, 0.03585325926542282, -0.010411538183689117, 0.023971324786543846, 0.034995947033166885, 0.025229085236787796, -0.0037491286639124155, 0.042371075600385666, -0.010627257637679577, -0.03684642165899277, 0.01064637303352356, 0.00912159588187933, 0.09002331644296646, 0.014970844611525536, -0.02758227288722992, 0.027888506650924683, 0.004370450042188168, 0.009539367631077766, 0.015706537291407585, -0.07441466301679611, -0.016951458528637886, -0.017830077558755875, -0.011993300169706345, -0.014742323197424412, -0.03146321699023247, -0.004208180122077465, 0.032643791288137436, -0.007245191838592291, 0.004907557275146246, -0.03399032726883888, 0.022241879254579544, 0.010723477229475975, 0.017169581726193428, -0.009618250653147697, -0.000276238628430292, -0.01448493916541338, 0.020411575213074684, -0.007514773402363062, -0.009912976995110512, 0.05130700767040253, -0.02253984846174717, -0.000023183456505648792, 0.02335832454264164, -0.05466800555586815, -0.03748125582933426, -0.030243106186389923, -0.026773881167173386, 0.014782220125198364, 0.017186542972922325, 0.024826696142554283, 0.030580084770917892, 0.024048883467912674, -0.028470750898122787, -0.04716509208083153, -0.02628280594944954, 0.04373868182301521, -0.00989835150539875, 0.04083336144685745, -0.022966016083955765, 0.04520140588283539, -0.03728391230106354, 0.018809137865900993, -0.04796900972723961, -0.020758721977472305, -0.01653169095516205, -0.016332723200321198, 0.013795994222164154, -0.08070389926433563, -0.03604269027709961, -0.00700741820037365, -0.022721290588378906, 0.0053225355222821236, 0.009082564152777195, -0.027239693328738213, 0.008616987615823746, -0.003954552114009857, 0.0327724926173687, 0.08120843768119812, -0.009755950421094894, -0.015414421446621418, 0.03224094957113266, -0.015763940289616585, 0.02343631163239479, -0.0031115561723709106, -0.029722819104790688, -0.04130719602108002, -0.013890985399484634, -0.01096371654421091, 0.0071664913557469845, 0.033130042254924774, -0.03404572233557701, -0.08174365013837814, -0.035273827612400055, -0.016911348327994347, -0.001108151045627892, -0.03867262974381447, -0.049946386367082596, -0.024168409407138824, -0.015672456473112106, -0.04513978958129883, 0.01870974898338318, -0.010786690749228, -0.01967763714492321, 0.012615025043487549, -0.024381745606660843, -0.003359780414029956, 0.018763383850455284, 0.05108286067843437, -0.013928685337305069, 0.012444702908396721, -0.04943607375025749, -0.024389829486608505, 0.059383027255535126, -0.02094251848757267, 0.002087815897539258, 0.00280048162676394, 0.016944939270615578, -0.019124682992696762, 0.003192649222910404, -0.056563880294561386, 0.007939734496176243, 0.028161359950900078, 0.033802833408117294, 0.04639758542180061, 0.04147031158208847, -0.03147316351532936, 0.019849581643939018, -0.016650797799229622, 0.003700228640809655, -0.010518682189285755, 0.011351214721798897, 0.04988334700465202, 0.003871895605698228, -0.019465038552880287, 0.0623592771589756, -0.002784175332635641, 0.02600141614675522, 0.03790365159511566, 0.003480216721072793, 0.04260938614606857, 0.023075643926858902, -0.01127135194838047, -0.03389858081936836, 0.03430400788784027, -0.02091248147189617, -0.009651917964220047, -0.03250690922141075, 0.0019426732324063778, 0.02898738533258438, 0.07072563469409943, 0.014656947925686836, -0.04061417654156685, -0.03400767967104912, -0.0475260391831398, 0.015445012599229813, 0.04072820022702217, -0.010292806662619114, 0.03666863963007927, 0.001125108334235847, 0.04423854872584343, 0.004262187518179417, 0.019226953387260437, -0.038244012743234634, -0.044344741851091385, 0.016775721684098244, -0.034822698682546616, -0.05771283805370331, 0.02091607078909874, -0.0173672903329134, -0.025996968150138855, 0.02632468193769455, -0.008683164604008198, 0.04462443292140961, 0.006782937329262495, 0.01619013585150242, -0.027660949155688286, 0.07174213975667953, 0.015321917831897736, 0.037712518125772476, -0.029754508286714554, -0.017994916066527367, 0.15864410996437073, 0.06972303241491318, 0.04419979825615883, -0.04700157418847084, 0.017779501155018806, 0.01927986927330494, 0.006775040179491043, -0.03754054754972458, -0.04290005564689636, 0.04379940405488014, -0.015620354562997818, 0.03811420127749443, 0.052841778844594955, 0.03540107235312462, 0.01774926669895649, 0.06086764857172966, -0.0453975535929203, -0.002181858755648136, 0.03298553451895714, 0.00781917292624712, -0.003505084430798888, -0.015568719245493412, -0.015978846698999405, -0.004814883228391409, 0.03879130631685257, -0.014520087279379368, -0.040727291256189346, 0.013689737766981125, -0.016576699912548065, 0.0179812740534544, -0.014868478290736675, -0.0017016014317050576, 0.0011414270848035812, -0.009825744666159153, -0.03148613125085831, -0.026922203600406647, -0.003608119208365679, -0.041242197155952454, 0.022373074665665627, 0.008813077583909035, -0.03598766028881073, -0.008779317140579224, 0.013522537425160408, 0.041752997785806656, -0.021940328180789948, 0.005546674132347107, -0.038127657026052475, 0.04655025899410248, 0.006684574298560619, -0.042818255722522736, 0.003865731880068779, 0.04677734151482582, 0.023082764819264412, -0.023512301966547966, -0.049330759793519974, 0.02796809934079647, 0.0019717193208634853, -0.011348661035299301, -0.015092948451638222, -0.030745480209589005, 0.03250980004668236, -0.019611835479736328, 0.044973280280828476, 0.005865069571882486, -0.001175567856989801, -0.016941484063863754, -0.029570331797003746, 0.03697477653622627, 0.026723351329565048, 0.023566704243421555, -0.012870937585830688, -0.019983993843197823, -0.021171223372220993, 0.0150670874863863, -0.010323725640773773, 0.0010946310358121991, 0.02537955343723297, -0.0020294126588851213, -0.018444709479808807, 0.019361315295100212, 0.007513438817113638, -0.0009761215187609196, -0.02472846396267414, -0.040298279374837875, -0.01680321991443634, -0.006260786205530167, 0.037875302135944366, 0.0219208225607872, -0.01538185402750969, 0.03634382784366608, -0.012696844525635242, 0.05679010599851608, 0.018752537667751312, -0.04489729180932045, 0.0011905004503205419, -0.025901706889271736, -0.041738152503967285, -0.020708635449409485, -0.04974888265132904, 0.06409622728824615, 0.025298411026597023, 0.003617654787376523, -0.028512675315141678, 0.02734256535768509, -0.03962690010666847, -0.0007812350522726774, 0.00831080973148346, -0.048930179327726364, 0.013158115558326244, 0.0011582764564082026, 0.02448953501880169, -0.033906545490026474, -0.010025464929640293, -0.0508267916738987, -0.032589349895715714, 0.0454237274825573, -0.05371718108654022, -0.03232821077108383, -0.006104947533458471, 0.006662101950496435, -0.00570879690349102, -0.011845306493341923, -0.048281848430633545, -0.03259864076972008, 0.015299178659915924, -0.030743153765797615, 0.00292953010648489, -0.010898820124566555, 0.009513349272310734, -0.010628027841448784, -0.009356881491839886, 0.04946349561214447, 0.017674239352345467, 0.0196640957146883, 0.002314449055120349, 0.01627342961728573, 0.024769404903054237, 0.04153949022293091, 0.03442225977778435, 0.011002814397215843, 0.0330379493534565, -0.03872709721326828, -0.0442642904818058, 0.01264974195510149, -0.028592383489012718, 0.02368103340268135, -0.01235202606767416, 0.023772014304995537, -0.03166060894727707, 0.022399915382266045, -0.008976294659078121, 0.0071439896710217, 0.004368395544588566, 0.04416555166244507, 0.03058098442852497, -0.022617574781179428, -0.02511151134967804, 0.00902295857667923, 0.007742463611066341, 0.011758980341255665, 0.050343602895736694, 0.01688660867512226, -0.008792713284492493, -0.02473042905330658, -0.07368214428424835, 0.03496574983000755, -0.03262356296181679, -0.007966200821101665, 0.019927650690078735, 0.06597071141004562, -0.05780867859721184, 0.021276405081152916, -0.01166125014424324, 0.02232646569609642, -0.0932534784078598, -0.04594918712973595, -0.0029843077063560486, 0.025602811947464943, 0.02176905795931816, -0.025297436863183975, -0.005215643905103207, 0.013222829438745975, -0.04230562224984169, 0.03167823329567909, -0.011949566192924976, 0.011679379269480705, -0.054499708116054535, 0.0020193832460790873, -0.037324465811252594, -0.004603351466357708, 0.032776542007923126, 0.015231178142130375, 0.029868964105844498, 0.03770739957690239, -0.0171587523072958, -0.046684302389621735, -0.03883328288793564, -0.02193726971745491, 0.03089974634349346, -0.08073752373456955, 0.012356688268482685, 0.009447007440030575, -0.009742768481373787, -0.0006783051649108529, -0.05646413192152977, 0.009993481449782848, 0.028690069913864136, 0.02708439901471138, 0.01559409499168396, 0.028005868196487427, 0.03674592822790146, 0.010006160475313663, 0.00293459533713758, -0.02943330816924572, 0.019917631521821022, -0.006189510691910982, -0.020680109038949013, 0.013485861010849476, 0.03038840927183628, -0.011184275150299072, 0.013772019185125828, 0.014366716146469116, -0.01650143601000309, 0.02216380089521408, 0.01602363772690296, 0.00801683496683836, 0.021812792867422104, 0.01826253905892372, -0.026296604424715042, -0.04029577597975731, 0.01258555706590414, 0.0304038655012846, 0.031133297830820084, -0.01609904132783413, 0.009827280417084694, -0.011717858724296093, -0.040224239230155945, -0.02227957360446453, -0.03890657797455788, -0.004961986094713211, -0.07055267691612244, 0.009106378071010113, -0.041761185973882675, 0.03013215772807598, -0.006528282072395086, 0.0012917766580358148, -0.027777550742030144, 0.03209096938371658, -0.049071695655584335, 0.005320929456502199, -0.024189116433262825, 0.024037081748247147, 0.02313334122300148, -0.07377700507640839, 0.05639994516968727, -0.007257202640175819, -0.0009884771425276995, -0.036173585802316666, -0.013368719257414341, -0.035332225263118744, 0.03820236027240753, 0.04330900311470032, 0.034309979528188705, 0.022077754139900208, -0.0283814650028944, 0.045142270624637604, 0.03645707294344902, -0.07097723335027695, 0.046325165778398514, -0.02235712856054306, -0.019118616357445717, -0.021352222189307213, -0.023293638601899147, 0.003970414400100708, 0.03334968909621239, 0.012042731046676636, -0.011638007126748562, 0.005463836714625359, 0.008951387368142605, -0.002482352312654257, 0.024301838129758835, -0.035327062010765076, 0.004075063392519951, 0.005575921386480331, -0.004802096169441938, 0.0023618570994585752, 0.02113506756722927, 0.03568367287516594, -0.0488380491733551, 0.032814376056194305, -0.06449747085571289, -0.022706789895892143, 0.03888748586177826, 0.024750642478466034, -0.010595501400530338, -0.04492642357945442, 0.0251796655356884, -0.010800404474139214, -0.051353342831134796, -0.03497801721096039, 0.03413347899913788, -0.005110347643494606, 0.011666876263916492, 0.029699500650167465, 0.01934722624719143, -0.027782313525676727, -0.027701349928975105, -0.0020888843573629856, -0.021853556856513023, -0.005761028733104467, 0.009120541624724865, -0.007468242663890123, 0.04820841923356056, -0.040687404572963715, 0.03205769136548042, -0.0013482143403962255, 0.04103389009833336, -0.005247722379863262, -0.03182676061987877, 0.033127687871456146, -0.01228058710694313, -0.001869906671345234, 0.0011680659372359514, -0.011547237634658813, 0.049572017043828964, -0.05102531611919403, 0.02190869115293026, -0.04331883043050766, -0.04176009073853493, -0.008971933275461197, 0.0037455842830240726, -0.002819390268996358, 0.0005957260727882385, 0.0027769654989242554, 0.04758492112159729, -0.03287791833281517, -0.010753355920314789, 0.014309183694422245, -0.031185384839773178, 0.03582270070910454, -0.0039469036273658276, 0.017378468066453934, 0.016141684725880623, -0.0036928835324943066, -0.008573764003813267, -0.014178089797496796, -0.006149788852781057, 0.03466014936566353, 0.021367426961660385, -0.041672106832265854, -0.016392890363931656, -0.007342073600739241, 0.03249815106391907, -0.029381653293967247, -0.04412198066711426, -0.039666883647441864, 0.022875560447573662, 0.00797428097575903, -0.006619803607463837 ]
<p>I'm trying to fit linear mixed models to 3 different DV (so three models). I understand that REML gives less biased variance estimates. As im more interested in the fixed effects, I use ML for the initial stepwise model reduction based on AIC-values, and use REML to fit my final (reduced) models. </p> <p>However, if I got that right, REML ignores the fixed part for fitting the model, right? And since 2 of my 3 models have only very little random variance, I'm confused whether I should completely stick to ML-estimates? What is your opinion on this? Am I right in my understanding of REML vs. ML?</p>
74,180
[ -0.024322589859366417, 0.019862452521920204, -0.028359930962324142, -0.01897599920630455, 0.010910242795944214, 0.03642720356583595, -0.0017083100974559784, -0.04179507866501808, 0.0296466127038002, -0.035911768674850464, 0.011100469157099724, 0.03255710378289223, 0.07132028043270111, -0.02064998634159565, 0.030559757724404335, -0.013314864598214626, -0.02177760936319828, -0.023410076275467873, 0.007642206270247698, -0.0004720004217233509, -0.02587961219251156, 0.046708639711141586, 0.0280887670814991, -0.00846845842897892, -0.024799184873700142, 0.04109921678900719, 0.033697545528411865, -0.015566248446702957, 0.029587918892502785, 0.029922014102339745, -0.03705940023064613, -0.015015330165624619, -0.019848724827170372, 0.02912539802491665, -0.014666851609945297, 0.010353273712098598, -0.01995810680091381, -0.015490928664803505, -0.0379718653857708, 0.0679752305150032, -0.030471188947558403, 0.01149207167327404, -0.015216534957289696, 0.030621906742453575, -0.009607996791601181, 0.015168656595051289, -0.001420831773430109, -0.006448501255363226, 0.03398798033595085, -0.05161985382437706, 0.0869106575846672, -0.00517326919361949, 0.018286097794771194, 0.05694453418254852, -0.003788909176364541, 0.015717286616563797, 0.058436039835214615, 0.07471413910388947, 0.0038492444436997175, -0.015430506318807602, -0.019490139558911324, -0.03545945882797241, 0.05089690908789635, 0.009156912565231323, -0.026483973488211632, 0.049452297389507294, 0.011672478169202805, -0.010931277647614479, 0.03577285259962082, 0.0026871159207075834, 0.01829090528190136, 0.010932336561381817, 0.040603820234537125, 0.009494006633758545, 0.03129074349999428, -0.02821030467748642, -0.004340772051364183, 0.0030564721673727036, 0.03998272493481636, 0.037376563996076584, -0.011976830661296844, -0.002059571910649538, -0.0003265876439400017, 0.027767809107899666, 0.020788047462701797, -0.031234106048941612, 0.04594019427895546, -0.021763980388641357, 0.001668435987085104, 0.00599350081756711, -0.01582331210374832, 0.01991291344165802, 0.03368391469120979, 0.026579301804304123, -0.03466244786977768, 0.046917542815208435, 0.018404610455036163, 0.018440719693899155, 0.005309161730110645, 0.010924546979367733, -0.0669185146689415, -0.028195779770612717, -0.01343940943479538, 0.05196473374962807, -0.028758274391293526, 0.01695847325026989, -0.015291035175323486, 0.01872449368238449, -0.03360065817832947, -0.030728625133633614, 0.008138137869536877, -0.0006831864593550563, -0.023679299280047417, -0.028617046773433685, 0.031690049916505814, 0.00391674879938364, -0.006749795749783516, -0.03638942912220955, 0.08063346892595291, 0.06087888777256012, 0.01907535083591938, -0.03332656994462013, 0.039298586547374725, 0.0022690279874950647, -0.058087486773729324, 0.0014251527609303594, 0.011443015187978745, -0.03377683088183403, -0.03393024578690529, 0.05824274942278862, 0.005952438339591026, -0.033747367560863495, 0.04671420902013779, -0.00700785918161273, 0.016536636278033257, -0.02125425823032856, -0.02245519310235977, -0.057277608662843704, 0.024663086980581284, -0.04629969224333763, 0.031152011826634407, -0.03589525446295738, -0.009457016363739967, 0.025516558438539505, 0.04623720794916153, 0.01563599705696106, 0.026080427691340446, 0.0061804247088730335, 0.013522629626095295, -0.01025461032986641, -0.05604912340641022, -0.02747226692736149, -0.037383440881967545, 0.013895287178456783, -0.060467008501291275, -0.09992952644824982, 0.027365967631340027, 0.00957532413303852, 0.013690879568457603, 0.0013006203807890415, 0.05066070705652237, 0.014503940008580685, -0.014408356510102749, 0.020484579727053642, 0.01162171270698309, -0.001938427216373384, 0.05364219844341278, -0.04105799272656441, 0.057455893605947495, 0.02363974042236805, -0.0008219776209443808, 0.030448593199253082, 0.005158583167940378, 0.07976185530424118, 0.053182996809482574, -0.0036246736999601126, -0.0017126313177868724, 0.010971794836223125, 0.0247860848903656, 0.054190196096897125, -0.06430505961179733, 0.0050499592907726765, -0.013094302266836166, -0.038184020668268204, -0.018965907394886017, 0.0578579306602478, -0.03147882595658302, 0.008295045234262943, 0.05744719132781029, -0.009023160673677921, -0.028507372364401817, -0.058932673186063766, -0.012677963823080063, -0.0012638053158298135, -0.008715893141925335, 0.029076341539621353, 0.017473511397838593, 0.01813325472176075, -0.022231966257095337, -0.03161090984940529, -0.037190139293670654, 0.010017110034823418, 0.010658877901732922, -0.016130417585372925, 0.04760459065437317, 0.03435029834508896, 0.043678250163793564, -0.03745163604617119, 0.06529626250267029, -0.03302296623587608, -0.014803743921220303, 0.007101817522197962, -0.014558256603777409, -0.0033996612764894962, -0.0026096999645233154, -0.02081148698925972, -0.001905385171994567, 0.00978876929730177, -0.016778282821178436, 0.03590688481926918, -0.03691009432077408, 0.07021312415599823, 0.02174476534128189, -0.04273845627903938, 0.007544796448200941, 0.013970873318612576, 0.002121823374181986, -0.011196736246347427, -0.029313771054148674, -0.0019392460817471147, -0.0011831483570858836, -0.037710756063461304, 0.028949493542313576, 0.017717206850647926, -0.038415536284446716, 0.03182223066687584, 0.05994875729084015, 0.01287994533777237, 0.04052203148603439, 0.027913853526115417, -0.014570782892405987, -0.019754882901906967, 0.018020303919911385, 0.023867914453148842, -0.021579600870609283, 0.01884639263153076, 0.016237162053585052, 0.008863498456776142, 0.040623147040605545, -0.016771350055933, -0.03032740205526352, 0.053192347288131714, 0.0318792462348938, 0.023998228833079338, -0.010267245583236217, -0.03701765835285187, 0.010523766279220581, -0.021255116909742355, 0.034983646124601364, 0.039470456540584564, 0.015247008763253689, -0.006535124033689499, 0.012953155674040318, 0.006264535244554281, 0.05886242166161537, 0.012539051473140717, -0.006146532017737627, -0.002502214862033725, 0.02552446536719799, 0.0043924846686422825, 0.010362508706748486, -0.02646554447710514, -0.01716151461005211, -0.04057782515883446, 0.03229580819606781, -0.01843012124300003, -0.017903951928019524, 0.012835732661187649, -0.03695617988705635, -0.0038062373641878366, -0.008948281407356262, -0.012917116284370422, 0.034761227667331696, 0.007023135665804148, -0.05678228661417961, 0.03184191510081291, -0.03910885751247406, -0.01960928551852703, 0.010358300060033798, 0.02772277221083641, -0.005430031102150679, 0.03264770284295082, -0.012804162688553333, -0.048527322709560394, -0.03590261563658714, -0.010374498553574085, -0.0006855822866782546, -0.00878941360861063, -0.006130699533969164, 0.03648054227232933, 0.007687715347856283, -0.02603856846690178, -0.017964044585824013, -0.04990110918879509, -0.016971880570054054, -0.0065949223935604095, 0.008245079778134823, 0.025171224027872086, -0.01507427915930748, 0.03643745183944702, 0.015350041911005974, -0.06750676035881042, 0.026373011991381645, -0.05361595377326012, -0.038315512239933014, 0.015017260797321796, 0.03119584545493126, 0.019277101382613182, 0.029896890744566917, -0.050113897770643234, 0.05674741789698601, 0.056777290999889374, -0.03907058760523796, -0.028591562062501907, -0.0078909732401371, 0.0011377166956663132, -0.048747483640909195, 0.03755160793662071, 0.009730539284646511, -0.002396973315626383, 0.03863442316651344, -0.005815897136926651, 0.009725417010486126, 0.023838449269533157, 0.029377752915024757, 0.033504337072372437, 0.04028919339179993, 0.010078096762299538, -0.04720298573374748, 0.007617560680955648, 0.018474368378520012, 0.012034345418214798, 0.013574285432696342, -0.015822574496269226, 0.030003545805811882, 0.01337423175573349, -0.034137580543756485, 0.030188146978616714, -0.03650599718093872, -0.0039601135067641735, 0.00552775664255023, 0.01676134020090103, 0.016471832990646362, -0.03492524102330208, -0.009602062404155731, -0.022547733038663864, 0.018051233142614365, -0.0416482649743557, 0.015931036323308945, 0.04663161188364029, 0.01590762287378311, 0.002553600585088134, -0.02017674408853054, -0.020496506243944168, -0.02745789662003517, 0.026283888146281242, -0.01583912968635559, -0.01087376568466425, 0.04206821322441101, 0.024150777608156204, -0.008238309063017368, -0.023289108648896217, -0.03225100785493851, -0.03006920963525772, -0.07374447584152222, 0.03141246363520622, -0.03570951148867607, 0.038187943398952484, -0.008344234898686409, 0.023961612954735756, 0.0033658668398857117, -0.026084087789058685, 0.0013189009623602033, -0.01517565455287695, -0.02404349111020565, 0.03788583725690842, -0.009976805187761784, -0.00011959387484239414, 0.001872982014901936, -0.011236270889639854, 0.019853146746754646, -0.03476226329803467, -0.007457237225025892, -0.03735010325908661, -0.0006620174972340465, -0.02063220739364624, 0.019747557118535042, -0.025142038241028786, -0.022936902940273285, -0.0013738240813836455, 0.046431709080934525, -0.006209789775311947, -0.027573544532060623, 0.009240088053047657, 0.027548395097255707, -0.02282281406223774, 0.004248138517141342, -0.037146903574466705, -0.00021587121591437608, 0.0021310329902917147, 0.02665802650153637, 0.054628681391477585, 0.013257013633847237, -0.03376283869147301, 0.0363769568502903, 0.0395241342484951, 0.027027789503335953, 0.026647698134183884, -0.01870460994541645, -0.031329475343227386, -0.014770732261240482, -0.03345327451825142, 0.03234466537833214, 0.028859851881861687, -0.007341946475207806, -0.0006829336052760482, 0.057229138910770416, 0.0015393694629892707, -0.01070813275873661, -0.009015927091240883, 0.05714105814695358, 0.011246348731219769, 0.004404962994158268, -0.053770434111356735, 0.00597321568056941, -0.005715338978916407, 0.0103287473320961, 0.047198787331581116, 0.0005052389460615814, 0.001630708109587431, -0.015203718096017838, 0.06858314573764801, -0.06154129281640053, -0.022466793656349182, 0.003556973533704877, 0.027798453345894814, 0.012206672690808773, 0.024735309183597565, -0.032601021230220795, 0.024604780599474907, 0.06993608176708221, 0.0038096571806818247, 0.026239246129989624, 0.01752733252942562, -0.07748444378376007, 0.022324087098240852, 0.05475990101695061, 0.035747990012168884, -0.06518365442752838, 0.002362969098612666, -0.023296840488910675, 0.009295475669205189, -0.008908122777938843, -0.02830594591796398, -0.008089371956884861, -0.0012991444673389196, -0.00438351184129715, -0.03739621117711067, -0.033772751688957214, -0.0371856726706028, 0.01253504678606987, 0.0016857023583725095, 0.031244762241840363, -0.02995261736214161, -0.01213366724550724, -0.03982673957943916, 0.010233220644295216, 0.0029338086023926735, 0.04027368500828743, 0.03619592636823654, -0.004230029881000519, 0.03553544357419014, 0.03623785823583603, -0.015027221292257309, -0.06674061715602875, 0.026247752830386162, -0.0018886006437242031, 0.005403301678597927, 0.0422506257891655, -0.02360427752137184, -0.027491828426718712, 0.028793061152100563, 0.02767891250550747, 0.002325791632756591, 0.0032136687077581882, -0.012638756074011326, 0.042046256363391876, 0.023666871711611748, 0.025594178587198257, 0.06729427725076675, 0.0014117491664364934, 0.008856257423758507, -0.015604463405907154, -0.0053697810508310795, 0.011129745282232761, -0.048464223742485046, -0.049651000648736954, -0.04882901906967163, -0.021758880466222763, -0.008275721222162247, 0.03434024006128311, -0.02106577903032303, 0.04581190273165703, -0.022134600207209587, -0.0272710919380188, 0.001925758901052177, 0.03595868870615959, -0.00860782340168953, -0.014467336237430573, -0.00633209478110075, 0.027524450793862343, -0.025526853278279305, -0.0411740317940712, 0.009487073868513107, -0.01383549626916647, 0.01958818919956684, 0.010599585250020027, -0.0484158992767334, 0.04204393923282623, 0.023716431111097336, -0.02830706164240837, -0.000989178312011063, -0.006622675806283951, -0.0203617662191391, -0.015465383417904377, 0.014076801016926765, -0.008425112813711166, -0.05081428587436676, 0.005015920847654343, 0.00009687033161753789, -0.026927191764116287, 0.051303401589393616, -0.006790338549762964, 0.052886441349983215, -0.007631235755980015, 0.006421539932489395, -0.06541814655065536, -0.040008120238780975, -0.029533734545111656, -0.015309197828173637, -0.007759139407426119, -0.008469164371490479, 0.004039160441607237, -0.010644322261214256, -0.0288735032081604, 0.010477407835423946, 0.07098107784986496, -0.05187466740608215, 0.03176647797226906, -0.019245760515332222, 0.010087099857628345, 0.07127957791090012, -0.02727530151605606, -0.014485940337181091, 0.012351468205451965, -0.038212236016988754, -0.03242265805602074, 0.004271521233022213, 0.04122534766793251, -0.0033595303539186716, 0.03399348631501198, -0.04033241048455238, -0.02495548129081726, 0.0790519267320633, -0.02067567966878414, 0.0052955979481339455, 0.047136034816503525, 0.03274068608880043, -0.008136587217450142, -0.062096837908029556, -0.0011567084584385157, 0.018174272030591965, 0.015151886269450188, 0.00037749423063360155, 0.04091399908065796, -0.02281823195517063, -0.02070089802145958, 0.0427686832845211, -0.03595047444105148, -0.022485854104161263, 0.008700549602508545, 0.08608563989400864, -0.00039738521445542574, 0.03101988136768341, -0.021747224032878876, -0.0064114793203771114, 0.05606921389698982, -0.037044767290353775, 0.02569199725985527, 0.02778618410229683, 0.046152494847774506, -0.027040308341383934, -0.03937910124659538, -0.030807264149188995, 0.013709099031984806, 0.059222929179668427, -0.02509516105055809, 0.07133924961090088, 0.040423888713121414, -0.002818075940012932, 0.01152418926358223, -0.04994498938322067, -0.023533372208476067, -0.0018562832847237587, -0.017590252682566643, 0.06721475720405579, -0.02664751186966896, -0.007103042211383581, 0.0041974992491304874, -0.0006086642970331013, 0.02600264549255371, 0.017692850902676582, 0.015244736336171627, 0.01917680725455284, 0.04066747799515724, 0.022428076714277267, -0.02583574503660202, 0.015135891735553741, -0.049055591225624084, 0.005492080003023148, -0.005615271627902985, -0.0255555622279644, 0.04924250766634941, 0.06926404684782028, 0.017313266173005104, -0.07053733617067337, -0.033253297209739685, -0.06734966486692429, 0.020464826375246048, 0.0009404944721609354, -0.0006902836030349135, 0.03387036547064781, -0.002704294165596366, 0.044497568160295486, 0.0013649610336869955, 0.01995190419256687, -0.017543768510222435, -0.105805404484272, -0.02779567614197731, -0.007045838516205549, 0.02000400982797146, 0.012792869471013546, -0.005929744802415371, -0.05243328958749771, -0.027148067951202393, -0.05002444609999657, 0.0319238118827343, -0.02680298127233982, 0.011821545660495758, -0.015529261901974678, 0.04304223880171776, 0.0005345257231965661, 0.014542936347424984, 0.004557545762509108, -0.02520277537405491, 0.10619081556797028, 0.06517797708511353, 0.030111385509371758, -0.1103929728269577, 0.01604096032679081, 0.02468864619731903, -0.012792346067726612, 0.014006492681801319, -0.01486380398273468, 0.011039932258427143, 0.01404592115432024, 0.0428440198302269, 0.03760096803307533, -0.009689061902463436, -0.006704940926283598, 0.03711174055933952, 0.002132628345862031, -0.0452805794775486, -0.003858460346236825, 0.005232664756476879, 0.05099397152662277, -0.006994924042373896, -0.027903594076633453, 0.016738444566726685, -0.006919511128216982, -0.000540551554877311, -0.0204069372266531, -0.0011145947501063347, -0.013814999721944332, 0.030287612229585648, 0.0011006371350958943, 0.025052227079868317, -0.015678133815526962, 0.027880314737558365, -0.023729532957077026, -0.004326009191572666, -0.0006014890968799591, -0.01054918672889471, 0.019587261602282524, 0.05267614871263504, 0.01506111677736044, -0.06145473197102547, 0.0025457146111875772, -0.021317295730113983, -0.0619126632809639, -0.059094179421663284, -0.03293405473232269, 0.034928902983665466, -0.008412331342697144, -0.053874723613262177, 0.014917450957000256, -0.02125999890267849, 0.016727782785892487, -0.07040126621723175, 0.0011169364443048835, 0.02439279854297638, -0.006000086665153503, -0.02046140842139721, -0.021685197949409485, -0.035129204392433167, 0.023480579257011414, 0.001877679955214262, 0.0070336563512682915, 0.013690557330846786, -0.025564445182681084, -0.026964185759425163, -0.02650817669928074, 0.04881574213504791, 0.0020437792409211397, 0.004250011406838894, 0.0261816568672657, -0.014454695396125317, -0.025907132774591446, -0.003468829905614257, 0.03519153967499733, 0.018868079409003258, 0.027734247967600822, -0.04211445525288582, 0.005633414722979069, -0.02029494382441044, -0.08049385994672775, -0.001700771739706397, -0.0009113044361583889, 0.002713364316150546, -0.056169454008340836, 0.001114838058128953, 0.0004745938058476895, 0.035921595990657806, 0.027876099571585655, 0.04684920236468315, -0.00002953206785605289, 0.061933740973472595, -0.015725789591670036, -0.06725087761878967, 0.019329676404595375, 0.01243861299008131, -0.061343900859355927, 0.015580286271870136, -0.01562618277966976, 0.032133106142282486, 0.0018510300433263183, 0.015931101515889168, -0.0543481707572937, 0.06623463332653046, 0.0005946899182163179, 0.005223751533776522, 0.002361087827011943, -0.06969362497329712, 0.020197423174977303, 0.017289167270064354, 0.002994468668475747, -0.03460446372628212, 0.029798824340105057, -0.051980651915073395, -0.017141588032245636, 0.0072405291721224785, -0.02096465602517128, -0.04355061054229736, 0.029969243332743645, -0.01740596815943718, 0.005748741328716278, -0.026549488306045532, -0.01670229434967041, -0.008327270857989788, 0.005472431890666485, 0.04352988302707672, 0.009262536652386189, 0.009303146973252296, -0.03143768757581711, 0.0037567473482340574, -0.02223408967256546, 0.024830730631947517, -0.014671234413981438, -0.015717579051852226, -0.013783612288534641, 0.01571887917816639, 0.007131867576390505, 0.05507861077785492, -0.045211754739284515, 0.01560049969702959, 0.031673867255449295, -0.01921747252345085, 0.00008375167817575857, 0.01663629151880741, 0.00532345287501812, 0.006751460023224354, 0.043477803468704224, 0.013603166677057743, -0.04236743971705437, 0.07857916504144669, -0.012250927276909351, -0.005579633638262749, -0.05274069681763649, 0.014987319707870483, 0.02602202631533146, 0.0027713230811059475, -0.012453784234821796, -0.005693840328603983, -0.004225835204124451, 0.07399618625640869, 0.045794278383255005, 0.004055780358612537, 0.014678528532385826, -0.014841526746749878, -0.020128052681684494, 0.023226452991366386, 0.024275891482830048, -0.0022372256498783827, 0.021293366327881813, 0.0540158636868, -0.007212327793240547, 0.043440498411655426, 0.016435658559203148, -0.02136947214603424, -0.07410579174757004, 0.00039164218469522893, 0.009663240052759647, -0.00987970270216465, -0.007324506063014269, -0.05711644887924194, -0.012898242101073265, 0.04184082895517349, -0.034086503088474274, -0.026362106204032898, -0.030714672058820724, -0.00904383510351181, -0.03679625317454338, 0.013705677352845669, -0.014187878929078579, -0.004153141751885414, -0.031736187636852264, -0.015317286364734173, 0.01530408300459385, 0.01466100849211216, -0.0003186889225617051, -0.029234062880277634, -0.03148499131202698, 0.002100097481161356, 0.020592475309967995, -0.07700920850038528, 0.04039272293448448, -0.05488908290863037, -0.0492774099111557, 0.01965869776904583, -0.004191010259091854, 0.013972927816212177, 0.0044538769870996475, 0.03249257057905197, 0.016839975491166115, 0.01641939952969551, 0.040995556861162186, 0.024158962070941925, 0.05184898525476456, -0.01074259914457798, 0.016482803970575333, 0.018451770767569542, -0.04045233502984047, 0.021693238988518715, 0.009431003592908382, -0.003512858645990491, -0.02157796546816826, 0.002502837684005499, -0.0067046647891402245, -0.009784849360585213, -0.0070119211450219154, -0.015211835503578186, 0.00404016301035881, -0.03323969617486, 0.001185659901238978, -0.03484945744276047, 0.03142322227358818, 0.05387447401881218, 0.040368061512708664, -0.03426424786448479, 0.013844351284205914, -0.03686048090457916, -0.027621787041425705, -0.04446527361869812, 0.011664951220154762, -0.023042291402816772, -0.06639081239700317, 0.0006993655697442591, 0.04205397889018059, -0.027059096843004227, -0.033219583332538605, 0.03363027423620224, -0.03899739682674408, 0.018557026982307434, -0.02140350267291069, 0.007743493188172579, -0.006674235686659813, -0.022602226585149765, -0.014435280114412308, -0.0903574675321579, 0.07444579899311066, 0.017924141138792038, -0.027989869937300682, -0.02915729209780693, -0.034784261137247086, 0.0030544623732566833, 0.027376241981983185, 0.016647230833768845, 0.004976220428943634, 0.04367569088935852, -0.025940915569663048, 0.04234524071216583, 0.010286173783242702, -0.06717173010110855, 0.04148750379681587, -0.005274173803627491, 0.00632640952244401, -0.005960711278021336, -0.03460562229156494, -0.03801019862294197, 0.011638956144452095, 0.010442031547427177, -0.009783641435205936, 0.023356968536973, -0.0039560869336128235, 0.015485350973904133, 0.0008148398483172059, 0.046440254896879196, -0.0015746460994705558, 0.027783656492829323, -0.029865631833672523, 0.015515808016061783, 0.023727940395474434, 0.01005686353892088, -0.03984091058373451, 0.025252575054764748, -0.03031187690794468, 0.014913714490830898, 0.0036170741077512503, 0.0028439308516681194, -0.008878041058778763, -0.050607409328222275, 0.044608257710933685, 0.019056670367717743, -0.041994184255599976, -0.01709791272878647, 0.013022487983107567, 0.018837857991456985, 0.06117317080497742, 0.03364424780011177, 0.020792117342352867, 0.026487229391932487, -0.013092612847685814, 0.013737019151449203, 0.016890183091163635, 0.06674549728631973, 0.007813883014023304, -0.04049534350633621, 0.002706271829083562, -0.030103905126452446, 0.014272697269916534, -0.019457677379250526, 0.06133617088198662, -0.015524170361459255, -0.036995723843574524, 0.010983952321112156, -0.03023921139538288, 0.018053144216537476, -0.03893756493926048, 0.0033222874626517296, 0.044662654399871826, -0.054400552064180374, 0.002199209062382579, -0.0332869216799736, -0.0451413169503212, 0.0005395027110353112, 0.01798434741795063, 0.0012055995175614953, 0.04366149380803108, 0.002414993243291974, 0.01738549768924713, -0.0025218527298420668, -0.02028697170317173, 0.027113955467939377, -0.02506803534924984, 0.025585543364286423, -0.03407019004225731, 0.003927232697606087, -0.055383291095495224, -0.014663559384644032, -0.026292331516742706, -0.030361920595169067, 0.004337369929999113, 0.028060419484972954, 0.02176574431359768, -0.039061859250068665, -0.051800306886434555, 0.01091271173208952, 0.007373248692601919, -0.06376726925373077, -0.023966653272509575, -0.03612835332751274, -0.012781732715666294, 0.010211482644081116, 0.03593118116259575 ]
<p>I am building a model with a highly significant interaction. This interaction was one of our main hypotheses. It is clear, however, that the form that the interaction takes does not represent a meaningful change across levels of either variable (one of which is <strong>time</strong>). The interaction is of 2 quadratic terms (and all lower order terms). Less terms in the model do not fit the data well. Higher order terms do not improve fit. With the quadratic interaction, we see the predicted trends for different levels of covariates begin together for early time, diverge slighlty for middle timings, and then reconverge for late time values. At most, the differences in the ranges of our data are not clinically meaningful. And the convergence at the end of the time range indicates that subjects end up in the same place anyways. Our best explanation for the divergence in the middle time is a change in selection criteria for entry into the study (not well documented, just possibility). </p> <p>We have categorized the 2 predictors and tested that interaction, so as not to force a functional form. The predicted values for this show some similar trends to the quadratic interaction initially modeled, but is not as rigid or uniform. Additionally, we tested the interaction in a smaller, independently collected sample and found nothing indicating an interaction. </p> <p>In short, my question is what more do we need to officially write off this interaction? The trouble I see is that this was pretty much <strong>what we wanted to test</strong>, and we found something statistically significant, yet it appears to not be the greatest fit for the data, nor offer a clinically important interpretation.</p>
74,181
[ -0.026653051376342773, -0.007402339484542608, -0.010917282663285732, -0.01122474204748869, 0.03082067333161831, 0.03604080155491829, 0.021721340715885162, -0.04003506526350975, 0.048769813030958176, -0.017327604815363884, 0.0471644289791584, 0.01325796265155077, 0.07120321691036224, 0.0024879046250134706, -0.008181179873645306, 0.0021894839592278004, 0.019313642755150795, -0.02384350262582302, 0.011839549988508224, -0.01492200419306755, -0.02968619391322136, 0.02077329531311989, -0.001495490549132228, 0.01876183971762657, -0.04341746121644974, 0.04334043711423874, 0.04069173336029053, -0.04635818675160408, -0.023087473586201668, 0.03820734843611717, -0.040319815278053284, -0.02568715438246727, 0.018961824476718903, 0.011015679687261581, 0.009827183559536934, -0.006210174411535263, -0.010729869827628136, -0.032925549894571304, 0.01545126736164093, 0.06118122115731239, -0.014525738544762135, -0.02152569778263569, -0.03280087560415268, 0.06212881579995155, -0.023599904030561447, -0.0005735757877118886, -0.027987925335764885, -0.0031044587958604097, 0.06806235760450363, -0.03970779478549957, 0.039853502064943314, 0.03187636658549309, 0.044240981340408325, 0.027197446674108505, -0.02975708618760109, -0.028322020545601845, 0.04283250495791435, 0.07804600149393082, 0.010604354552924633, -0.05379081144928932, -0.047157786786556244, -0.0028261553961783648, 0.009326232597231865, 0.031620658934116364, -0.022382192313671112, 0.005112643353641033, 0.0035849022679030895, -0.030719513073563576, 0.02073199301958084, -0.05344489589333534, -0.007155287079513073, 0.006572014186531305, 0.04160880669951439, 0.02630322054028511, 0.03116074576973915, -0.017016835510730743, 0.0006419215933419764, 0.007650097366422415, 0.009582489728927612, 0.031158918514847755, -0.04713137820363045, -0.022429635748267174, 0.018550993874669075, 0.03328579664230347, -0.004191200714558363, 0.03276440501213074, 0.042107246816158295, -0.03528536111116409, 0.01683318428695202, 0.03964480012655258, -0.0641886293888092, 0.04787087067961693, 0.07472284883260727, 0.008641238324344158, -0.05158468708395958, 0.016393497586250305, -0.005386571865528822, 0.03190482407808304, 0.03101734071969986, 0.0196375772356987, -0.028888311237096786, -0.04897134006023407, 0.009378137066960335, 0.046291809529066086, 0.017863718792796135, -0.0029684484470635653, -0.025952091440558434, -0.026856543496251106, 0.009912309236824512, -0.04966607317328453, 0.002955697476863861, 0.021636962890625, -0.014025241136550903, 0.008069352246820927, 0.017337361350655556, -0.0249138455837965, -0.03087454102933407, -0.022252775728702545, 0.09002917259931564, 0.04290439933538437, 0.07794837653636932, -0.027845310047268867, 0.010526690632104874, -0.03798545524477959, -0.03691454604268074, -0.011376571841537952, 0.024213748052716255, -0.02588474005460739, -0.05578240007162094, 0.06530287116765976, 0.016181424260139465, 0.01778484880924225, -0.0019013466080650687, -0.03086109831929207, 0.024600772187113762, 0.026660334318876266, -0.06950442492961884, -0.013607906177639961, 0.029319800436496735, -0.00785891991108656, 0.020922880619764328, -0.06699690222740173, -0.016055317595601082, 0.02025248482823372, 0.10027994960546494, -0.010302881710231304, -0.0042015500366687775, 0.009592653252184391, 0.042606864124536514, 0.020930765196681023, -0.039438825100660324, -0.01621166430413723, -0.045786164700984955, -0.01720864698290825, -0.026459110900759697, -0.07634974271059036, -0.024609128013253212, 0.06368132680654526, -0.01330722589045763, 0.000978867057710886, 0.03862455487251282, -0.03245120868086815, -0.013521901331841946, -0.0018334219930693507, 0.038550421595573425, -0.007787811104208231, 0.03927310183644295, -0.028927842155098915, 0.009667608886957169, 0.050000209361314774, 0.03719595447182655, 0.04052640125155449, 0.05235547199845314, 0.05167558789253235, -0.006246392149478197, 0.007756732404232025, 0.04003249481320381, -0.017630424350500107, -0.04440437629818916, 0.0024011533241719007, -0.01758267916738987, -0.042931221425533295, -0.05614936724305153, -0.008539790287613869, 0.0004757805145345628, 0.0495903380215168, -0.048950206488370895, -0.027368389070034027, 0.026890000328421593, -0.013347776606678963, -0.02777992933988571, -0.0688905268907547, 0.005606628954410553, -0.002757041482254863, -0.048553839325904846, 0.026605868712067604, -0.0239345021545887, 0.04295434430241585, -0.0007866896339692175, 0.004763562697917223, -0.030351700261235237, -0.013896860182285309, 0.049454059451818466, -0.003697784384712577, 0.04026445373892784, 0.03666967153549194, 0.03728784620761871, -0.03923962265253067, 0.02936517633497715, -0.0313534140586853, -0.058424804359674454, 0.03060274012386799, -0.01687593385577202, 0.03416329249739647, -0.042091254144907, -0.0024537413846701384, -0.026745660230517387, -0.04816393926739693, -0.012226145714521408, 0.0368327721953392, -0.06125703081488609, 0.08448028564453125, 0.024305259808897972, -0.007283859420567751, -0.0008615722763352096, 0.055405475199222565, 0.041671205312013626, -0.0029812981374561787, -0.02264120802283287, 0.0065649100579321384, -0.022138983011245728, -0.029617268592119217, 0.04661093279719353, 0.020632673054933548, -0.013640804216265678, 0.032227687537670135, 0.03787755221128464, 0.01206306740641594, 0.001875576563179493, 0.04529277980327606, 0.017647944390773773, -0.018511829897761345, 0.011269565671682358, 0.024938564747571945, 0.012277639470994473, -0.027528101578354836, 0.0008522935095243156, -0.009651604108512402, 0.028105106204748154, -0.015155650675296783, 0.0051634483970701694, 0.04562077671289444, 0.04220513254404068, 0.02916087955236435, -0.014087152667343616, -0.03146069869399071, 0.027827441692352295, -0.010824073106050491, 0.01591499336063862, 0.0575125627219677, 0.02004106156527996, 0.0004354524426162243, -0.011175541207194328, -0.028354153037071228, 0.00004701702710008249, 0.021620571613311768, -0.026219738647341728, 0.0010247339960187674, 0.010703399777412415, -0.030888989567756653, -0.0011673779226839542, -0.020241839811205864, -0.03880694508552551, -0.0036842222325503826, -0.031862255185842514, -0.01581220142543316, 0.015596650540828705, 0.02286999672651291, -0.034176599234342575, -0.008962064981460571, 0.011302737519145012, -0.023485999554395676, 0.023814452812075615, 0.011404449120163918, -0.042297765612602234, -0.003050200641155243, -0.023917503654956818, -0.00028285180451348424, 0.049153923988342285, 0.004244382493197918, -0.0195767842233181, 0.017630601301789284, -0.019984601065516472, -0.05134636163711548, -0.037164345383644104, -0.01096343994140625, 0.0034699435345828533, -0.013493972830474377, -0.04606467857956886, 0.04541043937206268, 0.007535867393016815, -0.044776055961847305, 0.01950015313923359, 0.01031535118818283, -0.014626930467784405, -0.01357585284858942, 0.015902802348136902, 0.017503026872873306, 0.0074733709916472435, 0.008013992570340633, 0.0032908478751778603, -0.015698377043008804, -0.013697714544832706, -0.08630522340536118, -0.07022669166326523, 0.04974779859185219, -0.020948702469468117, 0.053164370357990265, -0.03703552857041359, -0.008852636441588402, 0.05647393688559532, 0.001508963294327259, 0.020359739661216736, -0.04574833810329437, 0.01724673993885517, -0.0454992949962616, 0.005656497552990913, 0.014695310033857822, 0.020882615819573402, 0.013945044949650764, 0.02119491435587406, -0.020265862345695496, 0.008081445470452309, 0.04427402839064598, 0.03023500367999077, -0.029744965955615044, 0.05162380263209343, 0.014262226410210133, 0.015362467616796494, -0.009439452551305294, 0.027901172637939453, -0.009513176046311855, 0.014423936605453491, -0.01181798242032528, -0.0039264545775949955, 0.005444460082799196, -0.061798736453056335, 0.018903138116002083, 0.010790353640913963, -0.02135096862912178, 0.0043169911950826645, -0.00542775634676218, 0.02036307007074356, -0.03066612221300602, -0.03871414065361023, 0.03273116424679756, 0.047890499234199524, -0.004593837074935436, 0.026682931929826736, 0.05964994430541992, 0.011610755696892738, 0.005816799588501453, 0.016983047127723694, -0.03193695470690727, -0.028167761862277985, 0.013951096683740616, -0.017145102843642235, -0.0002041725820163265, 0.023196034133434296, -0.01744174025952816, 0.006489637307822704, -0.027352340519428253, -0.03547182306647301, -0.010772498324513435, -0.05225634574890137, -0.006512569263577461, -0.024217279627919197, 0.04621157422661781, -0.005269052926450968, 0.013487826101481915, 0.008934006094932556, -0.04496495798230171, -0.011329625733196735, 0.010918849147856236, -0.05576824024319649, 0.019608132541179657, -0.026257716119289398, 0.018560873344540596, 0.047125235199928284, 0.006660442799329758, 0.01804700866341591, -0.018442267552018166, -0.006067685782909393, -0.02507900819182396, 0.040539275854825974, -0.013467113487422466, 0.00704096769914031, -0.056299980729818344, 0.00614460464566946, -0.04023168981075287, 0.005423079244792461, 0.027385786175727844, -0.009276656433939934, 0.046098459511995316, 0.05912022665143013, -0.02929571084678173, 0.016766196116805077, -0.04086299613118172, 0.017235908657312393, 0.07610943913459778, 0.022232815623283386, 0.03128346800804138, 0.01334247924387455, -0.052590273320674896, 0.037655849009752274, 0.007552590221166611, 0.021503400057554245, 0.03382126986980438, -0.016747545450925827, -0.0006806686869822443, -0.05032508075237274, -0.05909166485071182, -0.005244388245046139, 0.036602362990379333, 0.003809248097240925, 0.001380400499328971, 0.05419578403234482, 0.023229165002703667, -0.03450574725866318, 0.03921112045645714, 0.05728745087981224, 0.0426587350666523, 0.007865218445658684, -0.03383230045437813, -0.026843618601560593, 0.005714922212064266, -0.015307311899960041, 0.03348863869905472, 0.003229244612157345, 0.00795498676598072, -0.027448613196611404, -0.002412905218079686, -0.0232656579464674, -0.011303056962788105, 0.001797087606973946, 0.008294088765978813, 0.040248848497867584, 0.017785821110010147, -0.004979385063052177, 0.0033536062110215425, 0.03105437010526657, 0.03724086284637451, 0.02712336927652359, 0.061767641454935074, -0.0897538810968399, -0.014789287932217121, 0.034108761698007584, 0.04467028006911278, -0.024731747806072235, -0.03887278214097023, -0.006177587900310755, -0.004912497941404581, 0.026749389246106148, -0.011016806587576866, 0.02941213920712471, -0.014147169888019562, 0.007457403931766748, -0.02729840949177742, -0.04854975640773773, -0.06220298632979393, 0.01972324773669243, -0.013020334765315056, 0.0134382713586092, 0.015647336840629578, -0.03785766288638115, -0.017760097980499268, 0.022458938881754875, 0.015311269089579582, 0.04123832657933235, -0.04541581869125366, -0.008351423777639866, 0.0315590426325798, -0.019114002585411072, -0.029097730293869972, -0.08350930362939835, 0.025218868628144264, -0.009550375863909721, -0.00941865798085928, 0.0590326189994812, -0.031486231833696365, -0.009024687111377716, -0.01109918300062418, 0.022265080362558365, -0.010398325510323048, -0.002352306619286537, -0.029726367443799973, 0.07809357345104218, 0.03615449368953705, -0.0018721611704677343, 0.04576237127184868, 0.01937353052198887, -0.01802239380776882, 0.006548628211021423, -0.01427253894507885, -0.004419872537255287, -0.026136502623558044, 0.01782476156949997, -0.04353532940149307, 0.007849316112697124, -0.03570561110973358, 0.043915994465351105, -0.0037986787501722574, 0.015379522927105427, -0.03977842256426811, 0.010514769703149796, 0.014834696426987648, -0.008652301505208015, -0.023117665201425552, 0.0019080713391304016, 0.01109872292727232, -0.016642164438962936, 0.0029107704758644104, 0.005608657840639353, 0.011565030552446842, -0.02610146440565586, -0.005087885074317455, 0.034495752304792404, -0.02473146840929985, -0.024668868631124496, 0.015592277981340885, -0.027423901483416557, -0.02109907753765583, -0.00525472080335021, 0.017996182665228844, -0.026245923712849617, -0.006467698607593775, -0.007787211798131466, -0.04176931455731392, -0.005445779301226139, 0.03815294802188873, 0.005090778693556786, 0.028198691084980965, 0.017950884997844696, 0.021211666986346245, 0.0007439052569679916, -0.004471280612051487, -0.0465812012553215, -0.05517597869038582, 0.036169033497571945, 0.007734762970358133, -0.032845932990312576, -0.006904637906700373, -0.0007295195828191936, -0.07059665769338608, -0.014051957055926323, 0.001594996196217835, 0.05527176707983017, 0.0023967998567968607, -0.014557216316461563, 0.00557448947802186, 0.05617526173591614, 0.056748997420072556, 0.013123535551130772, 0.005273997783660889, 0.026214785873889923, -0.00735540920868516, -0.032065264880657196, -0.010800997726619244, 0.0354393869638443, -0.015064427629113197, 0.0034349795896559954, -0.04524751752614975, 0.002018585568293929, 0.059646666049957275, -0.021634764969348907, -0.028906479477882385, 0.005766951013356447, -0.032562773674726486, 0.02184586226940155, -0.013242758810520172, -0.003783836495131254, 0.0020215013064444065, 0.034155912697315216, 0.017660504207015038, 0.04102115333080292, 0.028877243399620056, -0.03297916054725647, 0.05654424801468849, -0.0020674127154052258, -0.0626581460237503, 0.00022779253777116537, 0.03257061541080475, 0.008098243735730648, 0.021886050701141357, -0.007696160115301609, -0.005656570661813021, 0.05887331813573837, 0.011152266524732113, 0.00965137965977192, 0.024122875183820724, 0.01605411432683468, -0.05052266642451286, -0.027156509459018707, -0.045364364981651306, 0.013530129566788673, 0.05568903684616089, -0.012935473583638668, 0.00886820163577795, 0.01620865985751152, -0.037558663636446, -0.015651755034923553, -0.03225259855389595, 0.014225432649254799, -0.004128706641495228, -0.02256423979997635, 0.06738593429327011, -0.004527153447270393, 0.009268797934055328, 0.05306318774819374, 0.020242366939783096, 0.0316338837146759, 0.03200344741344452, 0.05435257405042648, 0.0158312376588583, 0.06454675644636154, 0.008858487010002136, -0.06543277204036713, 0.03440428525209427, -0.05895829573273659, -0.0025058328174054623, -0.038145821541547775, 0.0187962856143713, 0.04727613180875778, 0.08340675383806229, 0.0181929599493742, -0.05161808431148529, -0.05396413058042526, -0.07442314177751541, -0.027837030589580536, 0.0383281484246254, -0.015724865719676018, 0.03105907328426838, 0.00045170841622166336, 0.05671359598636627, 0.030650174245238304, 0.00021569931413978338, -0.050652265548706055, -0.07865281403064728, -0.018386710435152054, -0.01827183924615383, -0.002488953759893775, 0.030636638402938843, -0.007786162663251162, -0.03132873401045799, 0.00795485358685255, -0.03529011458158493, -0.027950668707489967, -0.006972584407776594, 0.0015493500977754593, -0.015680823475122452, 0.0730009377002716, 0.008445631712675095, -0.011338591575622559, 0.013797631487250328, -0.010443208739161491, 0.12361197918653488, 0.08066632598638535, 0.008351079188287258, -0.03096485510468483, 0.03917183354496956, -0.006715150084346533, -0.007529496680945158, -0.01062499638646841, 0.023749662563204765, 0.00688204588368535, -0.0329052098095417, 0.04358728975057602, 0.03635218366980553, 0.022788507863879204, -0.01449364423751831, 0.05605290085077286, -0.07593102008104324, -0.02373332343995571, 0.024669885635375977, 0.0011335675371810794, 0.001008819555863738, -0.013558121398091316, 0.010759335942566395, 0.01036325003951788, -0.019668586552143097, -0.01717478595674038, -0.0015450745122507215, 0.008717628195881844, -0.025121115148067474, -0.004375105258077383, -0.028070688247680664, 0.037928223609924316, 0.013813837431371212, 0.018326764926314354, -0.01260325126349926, -0.0317535437643528, 0.014449778012931347, -0.032401371747255325, 0.004712911322712898, 0.041742969304323196, -0.0042656054720282555, -0.01920420490205288, 0.0126258609816432, 0.030677082017064095, -0.043148864060640335, -0.0422237403690815, -0.03281048312783241, 0.057997774332761765, -0.005332394037395716, -0.0351557619869709, -0.02156686596572399, -0.0044059595093131065, 0.028140254318714142, -0.054225578904151917, -0.03686413913965225, -0.002858206629753113, 0.018784141167998314, -0.02432265691459179, 0.018528396263718605, -0.013938763178884983, 0.018287813290953636, 0.02355995960533619, 0.02094203606247902, 0.02437502145767212, -0.03460999205708504, -0.02219434641301632, -0.041050128638744354, 0.03955535963177681, -0.005384810268878937, 0.02654200792312622, -0.0003853922535199672, 0.010294757783412933, -0.022383257746696472, 0.002388015389442444, 0.022557543590664864, 0.02086612395942211, 0.02654704637825489, -0.0036177258007228374, -0.015182176604866982, -0.06140192598104477, -0.05262139439582825, 0.00923922285437584, -0.009202572517096996, 0.015905119478702545, -0.058272071182727814, -0.01754898950457573, 0.019976038485765457, 0.051120709627866745, -0.005036040674895048, 0.02163546159863472, -0.037006981670856476, 0.06148471683263779, -0.006755644455552101, -0.04668288305401802, -0.029029738157987595, 0.005566462408751249, -0.007073358632624149, -0.012464689090847969, -0.01570180617272854, 0.06707394868135452, -0.005140780471265316, 0.005310489796102047, 0.02347392961382866, 0.04490736499428749, 0.010354665108025074, 0.014585725963115692, 0.03339368849992752, -0.03933927044272423, -0.011675599031150341, -0.015520327724516392, 0.02669956535100937, 0.0010697119869291782, -0.017387328669428825, -0.05367636680603027, -0.02441016025841236, 0.012755819596350193, -0.012768312357366085, -0.02341488189995289, -0.006437219213694334, -0.029674220830202103, 0.0037282072007656097, -0.03942547366023064, 0.007617552764713764, -0.0521710067987442, 0.0009727852302603424, 0.016377568244934082, -0.01534244790673256, 0.03677954897284508, 0.029360301792621613, -0.00798908993601799, -0.019753659144043922, 0.008669466711580753, -0.011882278136909008, -0.025772739201784134, -0.01544371247291565, -0.026759779080748558, -0.004213947337120771, 0.050508368760347366, -0.05585654824972153, -0.05321253091096878, 0.005747090093791485, -0.03349098935723305, -0.03667796775698662, 0.02745829150080681, 0.012832753360271454, 0.010702592320740223, 0.045287229120731354, 0.013787918724119663, -0.002478289883583784, 0.022982435300946236, -0.005590860731899738, -0.028195422142744064, -0.0004507616104092449, -0.005053510889410973, -0.030865663662552834, -0.03350986912846565, 0.006000632420182228, 0.04711315780878067, -0.016313809901475906, 0.02909340150654316, 0.05195300281047821, 0.012290865182876587, -0.03501333296298981, -0.012568805366754532, -0.008613736368715763, 0.03066181018948555, -0.028802359476685524, -0.015539418905973434, 0.055113743990659714, 0.0385165810585022, -0.033649079501628876, 0.03139593079686165, -0.009883002378046513, 0.014300682581961155, -0.06941532343626022, -0.02574383281171322, -0.035624947398900986, 0.03860950469970703, 0.032538771629333496, -0.06922851502895355, 0.0030826532747596502, 0.009428818710148335, -0.035456106066703796, 0.004884323105216026, -0.005145184230059385, 0.008903454057872295, -0.029147908091545105, -0.027025341987609863, -0.03720735013484955, -0.01228119246661663, 0.023427382111549377, 0.011940001510083675, 0.006716668605804443, 0.033122215420007706, 0.003809395944699645, -0.023469293490052223, 0.011884491890668869, -0.005743164103478193, -0.012412932701408863, -0.047962486743927, 0.032339341938495636, -0.03963768854737282, -0.04343787953257561, 0.036318112164735794, -0.008651886135339737, 0.016851386055350304, 0.03440701216459274, 0.0017072279006242752, 0.007126555312424898, 0.04764280095696449, 0.01855175942182541, -0.008102551102638245, 0.023714788258075714, -0.0005073152133263648, -0.006218137219548225, 0.0528111606836319, -0.012231999076902866, 0.011178083717823029, 0.021237336099147797, -0.008486264385282993, -0.0006636112229898572, 0.018943071365356445, -0.012350108474493027, 0.00948081724345684, -0.01923820562660694, 0.016716111451387405, -0.0053721144795417786, -0.00964634120464325, -0.010303092189133167, -0.02874527871608734, -0.040893636643886566, 0.03756481781601906, 0.05549030005931854, -0.027853528037667274, 0.0013408069498836994, -0.04839855432510376, -0.011822199448943138, 0.009199615567922592, 0.004412856884300709, 0.005761200562119484, -0.03140877187252045, -0.033270712941884995, -0.050486158579587936, -0.00005638194488710724, -0.04478832334280014, 0.008026701398193836, -0.028007403016090393, 0.031715165823698044, -0.04839848354458809, 0.03219843655824661, -0.0014683945337310433, -0.022948240861296654, 0.04322027787566185, -0.09343381971120834, 0.03426520526409149, 0.01790720969438553, -0.020476598292589188, -0.03867178410291672, -0.018318766728043556, -0.025514665991067886, 0.0075498903170228004, 0.07395464181900024, 0.010861462913453579, -0.0384085476398468, -0.005711844190955162, 0.03305887430906296, -0.019233612343668938, -0.012243255972862244, 0.04333101958036423, -0.013243168592453003, 0.029005546122789383, -0.011642228811979294, 0.0014114829245954752, 0.02230633795261383, 0.028352919965982437, 0.025183478370308876, -0.03621058166027069, 0.0038490842562168837, 0.0166470967233181, 0.015303496271371841, 0.018763191998004913, -0.018853889778256416, -0.035632990300655365, 0.05558580905199051, 0.012918624095618725, 0.034212514758110046, 0.013550654985010624, -0.02151188813149929, -0.059241726994514465, 0.04238320514559746, -0.03294381871819496, -0.02719159424304962, 0.026881976053118706, 0.018187424167990685, -0.004661028739064932, -0.049986738711595535, -0.003056149696931243, 0.026785127818584442, -0.027486100792884827, 0.022475717589259148, 0.040572069585323334, 0.03457117825746536, 0.03710681200027466, 0.003675000509247184, -0.0005447692237794399, 0.0034723926801234484, -0.004608832765370607, 0.017059363424777985, 0.009770425967872143, 0.03532886877655983, 0.02094624750316143, 0.012176942080259323, 0.02093680575489998, -0.018394267186522484, 0.01267505344003439, -0.0015535179991275072, 0.013075255788862705, -0.024245966225862503, -0.012029618956148624, 0.001881239004433155, 0.01061203796416521, 0.022802431136369705, -0.00005704753857571632, 0.016057249158620834, 0.037978991866111755, -0.031760379672050476, -0.01861966960132122, 0.002814192557707429, -0.021385785192251205, -0.00441818218678236, 0.018728751689195633, 0.05757632106542587, -0.0067047602497041225, -0.0008930960320867598, -0.014507030136883259, 0.015425165183842182, -0.03291551023721695, -0.022891206666827202, 0.013742984272539616, 0.025214755907654762, -0.011208788491785526, -0.002109027234837413, -0.024756893515586853, -0.01458260789513588, -0.037649162113666534, -0.02619767375290394, 0.05712536349892616, 0.050301264971494675, 0.06526699662208557, -0.058456771075725555, 0.006242990028113127, -0.013337839394807816, 0.03629521280527115, -0.07042928785085678, 0.0062530767172575, -0.034908343106508255, 0.0061804018914699554, -0.0031401931773871183, -0.009978920221328735 ]
<p>Which components should use for plotting in a PCA analysis? Should it be component 1 versus component 2, or any combination that shows clustering is okay to use?</p> <p>Also, I have seen that in a few cases the axis labels mention the variance that is shown (e.g. it says "Principal component 1 (Var. 58.09%)"). Does this mean that in these plots only a part of the corresponding axis is shown (i.e. is it zoomed-in)?</p>
74,182
[ -0.027036568149924278, 0.010403257794678211, -0.03926294669508934, -0.024103255942463875, 0.05952254682779312, 0.021203525364398956, -0.03344673663377762, -0.022283246740698814, -0.00021276771440170705, -0.04500551149249077, 0.027691040188074112, 0.044294677674770355, 0.057644106447696686, 0.0430554561316967, -0.007326116319745779, -0.017030293121933937, 0.009947571903467178, -0.011614383198320866, -0.011243581771850586, 0.019490055739879608, -0.005951123312115669, 0.0011679213494062424, 0.02133130095899105, 0.008955971337854862, -0.016825929284095764, 0.06638529151678085, 0.014180822297930717, 0.005083164665848017, 0.021858161315321922, 0.02742369845509529, -0.05006597191095352, -0.012636606581509113, 0.014116678386926651, 0.02214794047176838, 0.039853159338235855, -0.023515643551945686, -0.016510356217622757, -0.03222202509641647, -0.014756039716303349, 0.053464923053979874, -0.04967199265956879, -0.0003340991388540715, 0.019281620159745216, 0.009871413931250572, -0.009183253161609173, 0.021473942324519157, -0.002427896950393915, -0.03353950008749962, 0.03711695596575737, -0.04984590783715248, 0.0911959782242775, 0.029943570494651794, 0.033620044589042664, 0.022142712026834488, -0.024673283100128174, -0.001510811853222549, 0.05513693019747734, 0.06077692285180092, -0.02953830175101757, -0.07039632648229599, 0.010567799210548401, 0.007296021096408367, -0.004162818659096956, -0.04693463444709778, -0.032602932304143906, 0.04854313284158707, 0.0055046905763447285, -0.02059468999505043, 0.04134582728147507, -0.0037438927683979273, 0.026542719453573227, 0.007580254692584276, 0.016348402947187424, -0.04573783278465271, -0.01468379981815815, -0.016585450619459152, 0.011951012536883354, 0.031156374141573906, 0.04771583899855614, 0.015353845432400703, 0.04092174768447876, 0.014239960350096226, 0.01932140439748764, -0.015595978125929832, 0.03041628934442997, 0.03083222359418869, 0.0688413605093956, 0.0001478085177950561, -0.00423840107396245, 0.006184229627251625, -0.005603305529803038, 0.030864480882883072, 0.016214143484830856, 0.0020479196682572365, -0.034662146121263504, 0.016232475638389587, -0.0035290694795548916, 0.0375017486512661, 0.004161075223237276, -0.008921454660594463, -0.006561686284840107, -0.02013266272842884, 0.018341582268476486, 0.040377192199230194, -0.02056531049311161, -0.018666721880435944, -0.039519548416137695, -0.008928806520998478, -0.014265765435993671, -0.02280493453145027, -0.01635642535984516, 0.019271057099103928, 0.00956620555371046, -0.005281900987029076, 0.03190694749355316, -0.004588661715388298, 0.008421138860285282, 0.01696544699370861, 0.03967411816120148, 0.05463283881545067, 0.034786634147167206, -0.010516560636460781, 0.015107499435544014, 0.0021482957527041435, -0.04969244822859764, 0.01002197153866291, 0.003926984500139952, -0.013801425695419312, -0.029073024168610573, 0.05913835018873215, -0.00929186586290598, -0.015070688910782337, 0.04816153272986412, -0.02588745392858982, 0.019359489902853966, 0.009125802665948868, -0.09862719476222992, -0.03721817955374718, 0.04560094699263573, -0.05671653151512146, 0.014344142749905586, -0.07743566483259201, -0.012427669018507004, 0.009783737361431122, 0.03488820046186447, -0.021777426823973656, 0.0008840596419759095, 0.004029758274555206, 0.027851581573486328, -0.006153865251690149, -0.05812043696641922, -0.01429265271872282, -0.007473279722034931, -0.04594796150922775, -0.022708380594849586, -0.07349444925785065, -0.0033278679475188255, 0.052442505955696106, 0.011920865625143051, -0.025475235655903816, 0.03161158412694931, -0.016975412145256996, 0.009074464440345764, -0.008285005576908588, -0.028162462636828423, 0.0007628817693330348, 0.043129812926054, -0.01231914572417736, 0.05712166428565979, 0.022198600694537163, -0.012136765755712986, 0.023549776524305344, 0.010442458093166351, 0.03412948176264763, 0.06218675151467323, 0.01798846945166588, -0.028356516733765602, 0.023309916257858276, 0.00591439101845026, 0.025691771879792213, -0.06427616626024246, -0.0415034256875515, -0.007457238622009754, 0.01197199709713459, 0.008624105714261532, 0.04581667110323906, -0.004015366546809673, -0.07627938687801361, 0.036654964089393616, -0.03260989859700203, -0.042481496930122375, -0.06479786336421967, 0.03238832578063011, -0.04055750370025635, -0.033773135393857956, 0.03054293803870678, 0.01178023498505354, -0.00408542063087225, -0.0029650270007550716, 0.001693554688245058, -0.027278468012809753, 0.0025073003489524126, 0.024653032422065735, -0.04244792088866234, -0.02317911945283413, 0.051345158368349075, 0.03761623799800873, 0.0018502415623515844, 0.029790252447128296, -0.04402012750506401, -0.05485955625772476, 0.0008247628575190902, -0.04874817654490471, 0.01866636797785759, 0.0009150667465291917, -0.007721420377492905, -0.024909770116209984, 0.04148966073989868, -0.03507384657859802, 0.010992842726409435, -0.03515608236193657, 0.07057631015777588, 0.07112164050340652, -0.01922135427594185, -0.014222899451851845, -0.019091559574007988, 0.015728158876299858, 0.008990035392343998, -0.028358587995171547, 0.004944635555148125, -0.0375714935362339, -0.004697201307862997, 0.07319220900535583, 0.02213134430348873, -0.031072603538632393, 0.0193862896412611, 0.060428131371736526, 0.03831151872873306, 0.0010483026271685958, -0.00035197267425246537, -0.0025917666498571634, -0.04377448931336403, -0.010794737376272678, 0.02666032873094082, -0.03522220626473427, 0.001952311024069786, 0.008515680208802223, -0.002480394672602415, 0.05841422080993652, 0.00916745513677597, 0.002028506249189377, 0.0676955133676529, -0.027803009375929832, 0.013837986625730991, 0.01199783943593502, -0.019417012110352516, 0.05178318917751312, -0.006757485214620829, 0.03260550647974014, 0.010554404929280281, 0.02587309293448925, -0.02766839973628521, 0.004328086972236633, -0.029124118387699127, -0.022312195971608162, 0.05787418782711029, -0.06608064472675323, -0.004838654305785894, 0.005731847602874041, -0.00925467163324356, 0.006162405014038086, -0.05869253724813461, -0.03686896339058876, -0.03122360073029995, 0.01946570910513401, 0.08135587722063065, -0.011123612523078918, 0.062235135585069656, -0.03664499893784523, -0.04519668221473694, 0.005987909622490406, 0.0032261915039271116, -0.007451570592820644, 0.018405856564641, -0.048463791608810425, 0.007065363693982363, -0.020414939150214195, 0.02567545883357525, -0.0004853726422879845, -0.03200135380029678, -0.0062484596855938435, 0.010254723951220512, 0.0038548605516552925, -0.03906678408384323, -0.032081086188554764, -0.008993374183773994, 0.04213722050189972, -0.010829516686499119, -0.03406247869133949, 0.024242959916591644, 0.004852081183344126, 0.000557794061023742, -0.0046495189890265465, -0.027124211192131042, -0.0040076239965856075, 0.007987627759575844, 0.008714963681995869, 0.012178268283605576, 0.0030959241557866335, -0.04793286696076393, 0.04459657520055771, -0.048598285764455795, 0.002874072641134262, -0.014571301639080048, -0.07406667619943619, 0.0008367231930606067, -0.0008496774244122207, 0.017003199085593224, -0.0074429502710700035, -0.05329778790473938, 0.07322777062654495, 0.011455870233476162, -0.03010297194123268, -0.030529728159308434, 0.005226228851824999, -0.0674428939819336, -0.027033161371946335, 0.007391767576336861, 0.0055616325698792934, 0.02251376211643219, 0.016829848289489746, -0.021579047664999962, 0.02243269421160221, 0.05315462872385979, 0.014075953513383865, 0.001094356644898653, 0.036299191415309906, 0.009339072741568089, -0.027147212997078896, 0.021177319809794426, 0.03900948166847229, -0.03202925622463226, 0.01515945140272379, -0.006234029307961464, 0.015687689185142517, 0.015703868120908737, -0.013307546265423298, 0.005742179229855537, -0.045451849699020386, 0.03587883710861206, -0.0761180892586708, 0.004715068265795708, 0.037821002304553986, 0.03485190495848656, 0.011591155081987381, 0.020862983539700508, 0.025964006781578064, -0.033897507935762405, -0.02849968895316124, 0.05988195538520813, 0.03319980204105377, 0.0003570381086319685, -0.010769694112241268, 0.01787124201655388, 0.0008962959982454777, 0.03923378884792328, 0.005491526331752539, 0.008728543296456337, 0.07195107638835907, 0.022700166329741478, 0.017388591542840004, 0.03620797023177147, -0.04333072155714035, 0.026199346408247948, -0.08057356625795364, 0.031976066529750824, -0.03151189908385277, 0.010591546073555946, -0.01723785325884819, 0.049245305359363556, 0.022443169727921486, -0.003920604940503836, -0.016926690936088562, 0.009449446573853493, -0.04523526504635811, 0.00834660604596138, -0.018414411693811417, 0.0036489430349320173, -0.02656412497162819, 0.017552198842167854, 0.023931777104735374, 0.004997543059289455, 0.020862942561507225, 0.010375948622822762, 0.03050904907286167, -0.029382791370153427, 0.011366983875632286, -0.0006716941716149449, 0.0027685225941240788, -0.03146866336464882, 0.011507585644721985, 0.03987738490104675, -0.010658281855285168, 0.06947295367717743, 0.04486951231956482, -0.019958214834332466, -0.0228972639888525, 0.033475611358881, -0.014605710282921791, 0.021005557850003242, 0.042670708149671555, -0.026970192790031433, -0.001554011250846088, -0.012611818499863148, 0.04168861359357834, 0.01426380779594183, 0.07353734970092773, 0.01949106901884079, -0.0026225971523672342, -0.0030529233627021313, -0.019619448110461235, -0.020551875233650208, -0.02965228632092476, 0.011574906297028065, -0.013306837528944016, -0.02533859945833683, 0.014085974544286728, 0.01697893813252449, -0.06741295009851456, 0.0033456531818956137, 0.0655079260468483, 0.03392297774553299, -0.0024431212805211544, -0.046389903873205185, -0.027949579060077667, -0.010721360333263874, -0.005728633143007755, 0.0063657513819634914, 0.013250271789729595, -0.020093563944101334, 0.012275001034140587, 0.02370958775281906, -0.03638528659939766, -0.022770456969738007, -0.010667678900063038, 0.03398336470127106, 0.03345118463039398, 0.027754170820116997, -0.021656785160303116, 0.03129420056939125, 0.03780088946223259, 0.05779791250824928, 0.027869340032339096, -0.018933463841676712, -0.06229535490274429, -0.017479732632637024, 0.0518602691590786, 0.0308371651917696, -0.04628907889127731, -0.036665696650743484, -0.04610908031463623, 0.002358660101890564, 0.026343245059251785, -0.05226854607462883, 0.0256153903901577, -0.019635451957583427, 0.015674849972128868, -0.05177398771047592, -0.03333034738898277, -0.043793994933366776, -0.017063302919268608, 0.01394941471517086, 0.038530364632606506, -0.0222577266395092, -0.021279780194163322, -0.0341913104057312, 0.02776661515235901, -0.012655091471970081, 0.0756077915430069, 0.0030209319666028023, -0.015747755765914917, -0.0020123333670198917, 0.011986500583589077, -0.022728824988007545, -0.07299354672431946, 0.012314029969274998, 0.037706825882196426, -0.015439801849424839, 0.0737571194767952, -0.01483994908630848, -0.024612141773104668, 0.006080098450183868, -0.0011718978639692068, 0.0001635696244193241, -0.010776259936392307, -0.007187408860772848, 0.047640781849622726, 0.03569650650024414, -0.014091615565121174, 0.07677287608385086, 0.015959233045578003, 0.011944124475121498, -0.012285854667425156, -0.05438508465886116, 0.03296386078000069, -0.03492755815386772, -0.00951964221894741, -0.028186814859509468, -0.007379547227174044, -0.016753800213336945, 0.013209153898060322, -0.00276388181373477, 0.05227653682231903, -0.03996104747056961, -0.019023163244128227, 0.013538934290409088, 0.0589490607380867, 0.021313844248652458, 0.008468205109238625, 0.02076420933008194, 0.0385899618268013, -0.0027385198045521975, 0.019826900213956833, 0.04230821877717972, -0.011858911253511906, -0.01853455789387226, 0.043276816606521606, 0.0027029570192098618, -0.0008689045789651573, -0.03720478713512421, -0.006614231038838625, 0.0025185146369040012, -0.05450376868247986, 0.044162362813949585, -0.02496715635061264, 0.027908045798540115, 0.05265473574399948, -0.07114259898662567, -0.032745130360126495, 0.0019339547725394368, 0.0040900870226323605, 0.05602126196026802, -0.051493510603904724, 0.06890960782766342, -0.04221684858202934, 0.01171465776860714, -0.06103646755218506, -0.050927188247442245, 0.0019866125658154488, 0.01611836440861225, -0.022654544562101364, -0.011471242643892765, -0.0005933496868237853, 0.018563162535429, -0.01878896728157997, -0.011398977600038052, 0.0166250541806221, -0.03606802970170975, -0.016670551151037216, -0.002803982002660632, 0.01927960105240345, 0.09834137558937073, -0.00310503039509058, 0.002980132820084691, 0.029472174122929573, -0.034753888845443726, -0.020264267921447754, -0.00232802820391953, 0.03148018196225166, -0.03735208883881569, -0.00524086644873023, -0.03514651209115982, 0.029577801004052162, 0.04353372007608414, -0.002698209835216403, -0.000492745777592063, 0.008811073377728462, 0.019805962219834328, 0.0011506325099617243, -0.03400628641247749, -0.009350670501589775, -0.03144656866788864, -0.0024304846301674843, -0.0005557028343901038, -0.00866524688899517, -0.03117983043193817, -0.010340050794184208, 0.026732489466667175, 0.023815924301743507, -0.011396100744605064, 0.058547019958496094, 0.06459357589483261, -0.021578066051006317, 0.007388056721538305, -0.02259969338774681, -0.03371966630220413, 0.01649455353617668, 0.018810493871569633, 0.0321960411965847, 0.004994519986212254, 0.022076556459069252, -0.025924615561962128, -0.010957115329802036, -0.019258569926023483, -0.02514994889497757, 0.06089794635772705, 0.02885117568075657, 0.04406219720840454, 0.07857822626829147, 0.0007219378603622317, 0.004358496982604265, -0.06872772425413132, 0.009254924021661282, -0.02940726839005947, -0.0024735289625823498, 0.042426276952028275, -0.02581615187227726, -0.007546824403107166, 0.016387630254030228, 0.01888304576277733, 0.017352603375911713, 0.02071976289153099, 0.03473249077796936, 0.007600025273859501, 0.004129878710955381, -0.0023638971615582705, -0.06341149657964706, -0.014489256776869297, -0.01556635182350874, 0.04125948250293732, -0.02719021774828434, -0.03573782742023468, 0.031882394105196, 0.04795506224036217, -0.019852161407470703, -0.05184194818139076, 0.003979723900556564, -0.02725527435541153, -0.004393770359456539, 0.0056098406203091145, 0.0069959270767867565, 0.004838895983994007, -0.052800875157117844, 0.0656483992934227, -0.004925871267914772, 0.021308138966560364, -0.014533907175064087, -0.061955295503139496, -0.07454362511634827, 0.02659684233367443, -0.029918191954493523, 0.019371377304196358, -0.027259306982159615, -0.05732471123337746, 0.012782098725438118, -0.0272710882127285, 0.01761944219470024, -0.028300076723098755, 0.029721267521381378, -0.016302790492773056, 0.0413961261510849, -0.022963441908359528, 0.006350250914692879, 0.00770690618082881, -0.014133448712527752, 0.09677542001008987, 0.08307251334190369, 0.024815358221530914, -0.0486476793885231, 0.05271832272410393, -0.0031173566821962595, 0.01833248883485794, -0.02199976146221161, 0.023932576179504395, 0.0011788294650614262, 0.01053209975361824, 0.04458780586719513, 0.038871705532073975, -0.002355690114200115, -0.004563920199871063, 0.06273390352725983, -0.01639205776154995, -0.03160376846790314, -0.001952668884769082, -0.0041501023806631565, -0.01944662071764469, -0.001980461413040757, -0.04716217890381813, -0.007015977520495653, 0.013105962425470352, -0.01932966522872448, -0.017343590036034584, -0.025613930076360703, 0.021422773599624634, -0.016673194244503975, -0.021194832399487495, 0.004671118687838316, 0.023130228742957115, 0.012273565866053104, -0.016195012256503105, -0.03811349347233772, -0.007930165156722069, -0.042499713599681854, 0.002851520897820592, 0.020963434129953384, -0.00996116828173399, -0.029776647686958313, 0.031302355229854584, 0.0007498523918911815, -0.061005737632513046, -0.03623385727405548, -0.013373344205319881, 0.026840314269065857, -0.007928915321826935, 0.02091873250901699, -0.020225562155246735, 0.019298996776342392, -0.01484024990350008, -0.06254885345697403, -0.010605857707560062, 0.0071491580456495285, 0.022442763671278954, 0.00011905024439329281, -0.018935944885015488, -0.04726004973053932, 0.0024171099066734314, -0.04839170351624489, 0.027806123718619347, 0.0067943003959953785, 0.007662739604711533, -0.0032694118563085794, -0.04837224632501602, 0.023868096992373466, 0.010618714615702629, 0.017782369628548622, 0.006613482255488634, -0.003183400724083185, -0.0163950826972723, -0.015223057940602303, 0.014103963039815426, 0.0003731803735718131, 0.026312800124287605, 0.015439141541719437, 0.006252271123230457, -0.00849015824496746, -0.0371512807905674, 0.03660762682557106, -0.028100382536649704, -0.018453747034072876, -0.047083962708711624, 0.041189808398485184, 0.04953141510486603, 0.040613070130348206, 0.02207917347550392, 0.017632953822612762, -0.03500790894031525, 0.046551965177059174, 0.015045637264847755, -0.004808431025594473, -0.004925511311739683, 0.03280105069279671, -0.004574012476950884, -0.026768682524561882, 0.007019401527941227, 0.06222667172551155, 0.043228231370449066, -0.016561852768063545, -0.0022255494259297848, 0.011468891985714436, 0.007925079204142094, 0.008365383371710777, 0.023221900686621666, -0.047022514045238495, 0.011906838044524193, -0.006874450016766787, -0.013141343370079994, -0.05777955427765846, -0.025402212515473366, -0.02678898721933365, -0.027826257050037384, -0.014685504138469696, 0.02941114455461502, -0.022974973544478416, -0.006598667241632938, 0.01707230880856514, 0.015624555759131908, -0.045006029307842255, -0.023783937096595764, -0.024024633690714836, -0.007008844520896673, -0.010031837038695812, -0.00032636700780130923, -0.0038993756752461195, 0.00943481083959341, 0.009447600692510605, 0.017518986016511917, 0.042190372943878174, 0.012116159312427044, 0.038123611360788345, -0.0007963427342474461, -0.004007104318588972, -0.015771988779306412, 0.035505421459674835, -0.030870715156197548, -0.025155439972877502, 0.06159152090549469, -0.058945003896951675, -0.023087147623300552, 0.005595778115093708, -0.004573502112179995, 0.010663199238479137, 0.011979912407696247, -0.0005603117751888931, -0.013144244439899921, 0.028372814878821373, -0.025426480919122696, -0.03897266834974289, -0.008094971999526024, 0.03511727228760719, 0.0011450611054897308, 0.021241838112473488, 0.006968948524445295, -0.0138009674847126, -0.020049070939421654, 0.03624437376856804, 0.05315883085131645, -0.006112967152148485, -0.029325250536203384, 0.005824893247336149, -0.01603793539106846, 0.007594715803861618, 0.009885670617222786, -0.024170931428670883, 0.07393484562635422, 0.020476514473557472, -0.027287762612104416, 0.031321123242378235, -0.018344612792134285, -0.0045569539070129395, -0.047431331127882004, -0.04257190227508545, -0.017315657809376717, 0.009319685399532318, 0.006263642106205225, -0.062426548451185226, -0.013646263629198074, 0.05743899568915367, -0.03888753056526184, 0.037267230451107025, 0.008039461448788643, -0.02608143724501133, -0.019305376335978508, 0.03372989222407341, 0.011370415799319744, 0.05968616157770157, 0.01586923748254776, 0.007956115528941154, 0.012550541199743748, 0.025240357965230942, 0.013510712422430515, -0.0192770566791296, 0.019811710342764854, 0.03937171399593353, -0.011514956131577492, -0.07558290660381317, 0.03608843684196472, -0.027087610214948654, -0.03985612094402313, 0.013970104046165943, 0.004707911983132362, 0.03999986872076988, 0.082325279712677, -0.01854684017598629, -0.01802998222410679, 0.01645146682858467, 0.018081123009324074, -0.023676443845033646, -0.029337966814637184, -0.00520955678075552, 0.030450955033302307, 0.024709336459636688, 0.0012278216890990734, 0.03427964821457863, 0.029305316507816315, -0.022969292476773262, -0.017841780558228493, -0.035261306911706924, -0.04075023531913757, -0.03879044950008392, -0.032102782279253006, -0.011916491203010082, -0.010714150033891201, -0.0019486745586618781, 0.017937632277607918, -0.02840249054133892, -0.018862273544073105, 0.047790564596652985, -0.009555090218782425, 0.006506133824586868, 0.017260396853089333, 0.01535878051072359, -0.029806025326251984, 0.018726829439401627, -0.0018030497012659907, -0.014791599474847317, -0.05937913805246353, -0.0033317164052277803, 0.015655050054192543, -0.04418870061635971, -0.008145786821842194, -0.02880493737757206, 0.011187619529664516, 0.03405997157096863, -0.005914215464144945, -0.0163789801299572, 0.03409245237708092, -0.03374526649713516, -0.01552539225667715, -0.05457785353064537, 0.04810823127627373, -0.001833536778576672, -0.06277792900800705, -0.04591456428170204, 0.00586729496717453, -0.06289950758218765, 0.041969358921051025, 0.018507780507206917, 0.008100510574877262, 0.027132680639624596, -0.02819322794675827, 0.022915523499250412, 0.021948587149381638, -0.06270246207714081, 0.06538353860378265, 0.007540035992860794, -0.021668240427970886, -0.02874576672911644, -0.02438976988196373, 0.00034380838042125106, 0.02134040929377079, 0.023074300959706306, -0.0016773565439507365, 0.04645835608243942, 0.008571424521505833, 0.003944116178900003, 0.04341423884034157, -0.021862830966711044, -0.022827129811048508, 0.04602966830134392, -0.007700259331613779, -0.00010912428115261719, 0.052317433059215546, -0.024434546008706093, -0.0282747782766819, 0.004934107419103384, -0.01601712964475155, -0.01177494041621685, 0.0399678573012352, 0.008630574680864811, 0.017390722408890724, -0.09078654646873474, 0.008456287905573845, 0.004165496211498976, -0.017000233754515648, -0.003460059640929103, 0.03757134824991226, 0.028181303292512894, 0.01305369008332491, 0.004442459437996149, 0.03775037080049515, 0.024301951751112938, -0.0024517534766346216, 0.011365348473191261, 0.006349852308630943, 0.03609735518693924, 0.01894456148147583, 0.000681501638609916, -0.0005430393503047526, -0.011325870640575886, 0.015780258923768997, -0.022996867075562477, 0.06026656925678253, -0.051359761506319046, 0.015481939539313316, 0.028323424980044365, -0.0053118993528187275, 0.0440342053771019, -0.00979339424520731, -0.012824278324842453, 0.04254533722996712, -0.05722254887223244, -0.010501096956431866, -0.0539940670132637, -0.017028506845235825, -0.021665723994374275, -0.026607614010572433, 0.01524179708212614, 0.06538331508636475, 0.0033059583511203527, 0.012900940142571926, -0.047105822712183, -0.013562016189098358, 0.03864000737667084, -0.03926029056310654, 0.043454334139823914, -0.021750569343566895, 0.02914493903517723, -0.03745817020535469, -0.005803105421364307, -0.037183623760938644, -0.008601943962275982, 0.016186749562621117, 0.016186431050300598, 0.017602303996682167, -0.02064288593828678, -0.029556797817349434, 0.0031548081897199154, 0.03558390215039253, -0.04507695883512497, -0.03231772780418396, -0.033397868275642395, 0.005977509543299675, 0.02965119108557701, -0.0041342186741530895 ]
<p>I am wondering if there is a way of calculating the following:</p> <p>I have a bag with 5 balls numbered from 1 through 5 that are going to be drawn. Due to different weights, the balls have different probabilities of being drawn:</p> <p>$P(Ball1) = 0.4$<br> $P(Ball2) = 0.3$<br> $P(Ball3) = 0.1$<br> $P(Ball4) = 0.1$<br> $P(Ball5) = 0.1$ </p> <p>There will be three draws. After each draw the balls are put back into the bag:</p> <ul> <li>Draw 1: Three balls</li> <li>Draw 2: Three balls</li> <li>Draw 3: Two balls </li> </ul> <p>Now, is it possible to calculate the probability that each ball will have been chosen at least once along the three draws?</p> <p>Disclaimer: I am not sure if the title is totally correct, but I think that my problem is a variant of <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/5520/">Expected number of uniques in a non-uniformly distributed population</a> - and therefore the similar title. Correct the title as you think it may be more correct.</p> <p>My question is how to calculate this: $Pr(Ball1 &gt; 0, Ball2 &gt;0, Ball3 &gt; 0, Ball4 &gt;0, Ball5 &gt; 0)$ given 3 + 3 + 2 balls drawn.</p> <p><em>Edit</em>: The balls that are drawn (3 + 3 + 2) are always drawn at once which would imply that the Fisher's noncentral hypergeometric distribution is what I am looking for. Note that if the drawing would happen ball by ball, Wallenius' noncentral hypergeometric distribution, would be the distribution of choice.</p>
34,224
[ -0.07672786712646484, -0.06982219219207764, 0.027607159689068794, -0.00894719548523426, 0.03216991946101189, -0.023581180721521378, -0.02487577311694622, -0.009374943561851978, -0.01224528905004263, -0.022190269082784653, 0.010702293366193771, 0.033579885959625244, 0.047795526683330536, 0.024831516668200493, 0.012363210320472717, 0.007324374746531248, -0.006464492529630661, 0.016060354188084602, 0.003603057935833931, -0.036944568157196045, -0.008288982324302197, 0.0371297225356102, 0.0000693095353199169, -0.019407514482736588, -0.04900830239057541, 0.0196611899882555, 0.04111000522971153, -0.03743591159582138, 0.01996716298162937, 0.07318654656410217, -0.016525689512491226, 0.019044553861021996, 0.06683199852705002, 0.038967862725257874, 0.01666269823908806, 0.0316067710518837, -0.02680199220776558, -0.03660203516483307, -0.02412896417081356, 0.0022589974105358124, -0.04443976283073425, -0.0004564325208775699, -0.006299641449004412, 0.02444560080766678, -0.04782337695360184, -0.003889289451763034, 0.009735951200127602, -0.029581604525446892, 0.023395363241434097, -0.04794158786535263, 0.10436562448740005, 0.021748390048742294, 0.029238127171993256, -0.00594692537561059, -0.061679720878601074, -0.011790736578404903, -0.003555408213287592, 0.0567670613527298, 0.013190537691116333, -0.024447467178106308, -0.06091545149683952, -0.05125415697693825, 0.02561018615961075, -0.05502311512827873, -0.03201090544462204, -0.009518532082438469, -0.0004516908375080675, -0.00105521478690207, 0.027290934696793556, -0.03475315123796463, 0.008883604779839516, 0.04228600114583969, 0.09589620679616928, -0.03759593516588211, 0.0012135050492361188, 0.005419915542006493, 0.019277973100543022, -0.003181865205988288, 0.03415404632687569, 0.020369073376059532, -0.02595142461359501, -0.004347180016338825, 0.04897919297218323, 0.02819025330245495, 0.03750171139836311, -0.011057266965508461, 0.028224457055330276, -0.003217050340026617, 0.006110120099037886, 0.00467541441321373, 0.006737969815731049, -0.013063444755971432, 0.07766763120889664, 0.00249692820943892, -0.052499569952487946, 0.053061071783304214, -0.014323161914944649, 0.023264490067958832, -0.020889369770884514, -0.005926127079874277, 0.002142573008313775, -0.07622072845697403, 0.03633097931742668, 0.06765951216220856, -0.013132335618138313, -0.023404860869050026, -0.0428309366106987, -0.025486774742603302, 0.0015925189945846796, -0.0022694666404277086, 0.006029051728546619, 0.02262885496020317, 0.00032440904760733247, -0.028316622599959373, 0.003037571907043457, 0.016604257747530937, -0.03173333778977394, 0.017181817442178726, 0.036435678601264954, 0.042622942477464676, 0.033072322607040405, -0.009875066578388214, 0.030236560851335526, -0.05911340191960335, 0.005929809063673019, 0.004455198533833027, 0.017896287143230438, -0.030200568959116936, -0.031867124140262604, 0.07138874381780624, -0.017952749505639076, 0.015993859618902206, 0.05214444920420647, -0.00792983453720808, 0.021994804963469505, -0.027087846770882607, -0.028544481843709946, -0.05559856817126274, 0.022201739251613617, -0.0366477444767952, -0.03347237408161163, -0.03216325119137764, 0.00835973396897316, 0.048523418605327606, 0.06098714843392372, 0.014994087629020214, 0.007281213998794556, 0.0022644372656941414, 0.03821086511015892, 0.04803282395005226, -0.019778847694396973, 0.02093433402478695, -0.02581787295639515, -0.021492771804332733, -0.015421799384057522, -0.08282152563333511, 0.04266791418194771, -0.0011582805309444666, -0.0054681445471942425, -0.02914063073694706, 0.047032784670591354, 0.024080870673060417, 0.010431215167045593, -0.035567961633205414, 0.0035915656480938196, -0.02034849300980568, 0.0679418072104454, -0.0018580756150186062, 0.003420419991016388, -0.008342619985342026, 0.019262608140707016, 0.02221749536693096, -0.012122535146772861, 0.07218965142965317, 0.0657709538936615, -0.04463927075266838, 0.032723039388656616, -0.002705830615013838, 0.024926386773586273, -0.005782283842563629, 0.010306674055755138, 0.02768445946276188, 0.031600672751665115, -0.015890594571828842, 0.003629721002653241, -0.001476184232160449, -0.0013412825064733624, -0.019695745781064034, -0.003334770677611232, -0.007645830977708101, -0.027400832623243332, -0.05392560362815857, -0.009133263491094112, -0.001775244134478271, -0.009850727394223213, 0.043263230472803116, 0.017174629494547844, 0.010549143888056278, 0.036245059221982956, -0.029081158339977264, -0.04375239834189415, 0.018299221992492676, 0.03857725113630295, -0.04295794293284416, -0.030907653272151947, 0.06354847550392151, 0.028726622462272644, -0.006674960721284151, 0.04038625210523605, -0.0672910287976265, -0.04236067458987236, 0.026592427864670753, 0.0002567808551248163, 0.02473263069987297, 0.006051305681467056, 0.04351959750056267, 0.02620839513838291, 0.00635909428820014, 0.0057232496328651905, 0.04128086194396019, -0.07780636847019196, 0.04183521121740341, 0.05595634505152702, 0.0017731889383867383, 0.0005018727388232946, -0.0033726529218256474, -0.011804383248090744, 0.013575195334851742, 0.011710663326084614, -0.04330810531973839, -0.025758907198905945, 0.032870814204216, 0.0008548501064069569, 0.0020187764894217253, -0.028772229328751564, 0.025047991424798965, 0.042381998151540756, 0.017307566478848457, -0.010804334655404091, 0.05015645921230316, 0.003486253321170807, 0.0025702642742544413, 0.0009853732772171497, 0.03509043902158737, 0.030599413439631462, 0.01406550407409668, -0.005337625741958618, -0.009197005070745945, 0.024300556629896164, 0.000010194435162702575, -0.03233695775270462, 0.014907041564583778, -0.007701341062784195, 0.006275322288274765, -0.03806394711136818, 0.012670235708355904, 0.046935390681028366, 0.003500279039144516, 0.013377772644162178, 0.029634255915880203, 0.03527802601456642, 0.005221147555857897, 0.004882181528955698, -0.03580625727772713, -0.008740147575736046, 0.041844259947538376, -0.036448314785957336, 0.03737000748515129, 0.012724095024168491, -0.02866874448955059, 0.010667320340871811, -0.011144579388201237, 0.022899504750967026, -0.031236395239830017, 0.005861221347004175, -0.027172209694981575, 0.0011397887719795108, 0.0012110936222597957, -0.026254232972860336, -0.009711386635899544, 0.002074148505926132, -0.014673820696771145, -0.007642829790711403, 0.013842158950865269, -0.09675084799528122, -0.003979582339525223, -0.003452918492257595, -0.02591785043478012, 0.0035736386198550463, 0.005688741337507963, -0.040783047676086426, 0.0733654722571373, 0.015885889530181885, -0.04735375568270683, -0.0067453533411026, -0.05577954649925232, 0.015597936697304249, -0.03770413249731064, 0.013040801510214806, 0.051754266023635864, -0.011474378407001495, -0.048608507961034775, 0.01913195289671421, -0.0360211543738842, -0.05552736297249794, -0.01817401312291622, 0.02121877670288086, -0.003603812772780657, -0.03935495764017105, 0.017120830714702606, 0.010112075135111809, 0.004844514653086662, -0.04606322571635246, -0.06836953014135361, -0.04216736927628517, -0.014808659441769123, -0.01414943765848875, 0.031504157930612564, 0.025241002440452576, -0.0344478115439415, 0.061696842312812805, 0.0631147027015686, -0.023658903315663338, -0.015696411952376366, 0.008765798062086105, -0.02175164595246315, -0.02620980329811573, -0.009188348427414894, 0.0023643309250473976, -0.02541193552315235, 0.019193222746253014, 0.0328870490193367, 0.027451621368527412, 0.05894884094595909, 0.0009186874376609921, 0.019476735964417458, 0.04218019172549248, 0.005893109366297722, -0.004803937394171953, 0.030990365892648697, -0.02173885703086853, -0.050047844648361206, 0.014682821929454803, 0.007102340459823608, 0.007757691666483879, 0.016120770946145058, 0.0015255698235705495, 0.04347545653581619, -0.01071181707084179, 0.02619326487183571, -0.017821993678808212, 0.040758196264505386, 0.0012386253802105784, -0.0669330358505249, -0.011977288872003555, 0.018474554643034935, 0.08228527754545212, -0.02637680061161518, 0.003939824644476175, 0.051532644778490067, 0.070253886282444, -0.04659654572606087, -0.03296187147498131, -0.008556858636438847, -0.008620882406830788, 0.018206389620900154, -0.025812361389398575, -0.010092661716043949, -0.006657247431576252, 0.05658508092164993, -0.010848602280020714, 0.017493808642029762, -0.03600968420505524, -0.00239701010286808, -0.07549049705266953, 0.012858577072620392, -0.01225985586643219, 0.0205062348395586, -0.007808097172528505, 0.010560015216469765, 0.01996602676808834, -0.03321238234639168, -0.013476883061230183, -0.0088065005838871, -0.07538505643606186, 0.006535778753459454, 0.0014071697369217873, 0.01480228640139103, -0.01154909934848547, -0.02034708485007286, 0.026402663439512253, -0.007300280965864658, 0.020267898216843605, 0.0041741011664271355, 0.021323036402463913, -0.05572983995079994, 0.0047688959166407585, -0.018891170620918274, -0.020689403638243675, 0.0015818740939721465, 0.05299702659249306, -0.0006375232478603721, -0.028860799968242645, 0.06449469923973083, 0.03224296495318413, -0.026087628677487373, 0.014158547855913639, -0.042446818202733994, 0.01375364325940609, 0.00875834096223116, 0.031267520040273666, 0.03996209055185318, 0.0719500407576561, -0.005156110506504774, -0.010264189913868904, -0.06009487435221672, 0.039639271795749664, 0.02846166305243969, -0.012764491140842438, -0.0028338530100882053, -0.028103746473789215, 0.005335551220923662, 0.02693106234073639, 0.019147226586937904, -0.02025471441447735, 0.026921719312667847, 0.045474354177713394, -0.005045671481639147, -0.010285151191055775, -0.0012290357844904065, 0.03436233475804329, -0.008927005343139172, -0.018306590616703033, -0.02107245661318302, 0.03953150659799576, -0.00013763614697381854, 0.0012345088180154562, -0.039487339556217194, 0.007672564126551151, 0.011004841886460781, -0.003727103816345334, 0.059135470539331436, 0.004563046619296074, -0.0017451421590521932, -0.0037820416036993265, 0.0015595186268910766, 0.057091642171144485, -0.024169595912098885, -0.04871372878551483, 0.05481512472033501, 0.03949414938688278, 0.00897225271910429, 0.0029410794377326965, -0.009723793715238571, -0.04235978052020073, -0.0018629578407853842, 0.030092256143689156, 0.05917901545763016, -0.026439066976308823, 0.05231522396206856, -0.027127958834171295, 0.03880360722541809, 0.013864557258784771, -0.03966602683067322, 0.024861715734004974, -0.003938016016036272, -0.016737421974539757, 0.024220788851380348, -0.026131069287657738, -0.04182510823011398, 0.02506520412862301, -0.002012592041864991, 0.023588642477989197, -0.03341694921255112, 0.03046894446015358, -0.017153317108750343, 0.03455657884478569, 0.0026664664037525654, 0.042345233261585236, -0.017112702131271362, 0.010122552514076233, -0.003424844006076455, 0.05255304276943207, 0.013623789884150028, -0.05464506149291992, 0.02143418788909912, 0.00502143194898963, -0.020489197224378586, 0.05340634658932686, -0.046222299337387085, -0.018223216757178307, -0.015524979680776596, -0.017443086951971054, -0.0030895695090293884, 0.009551106952130795, -0.0330505333840847, 0.047307830303907394, 0.02547251246869564, 0.013004113920032978, 0.058343641459941864, 0.006367787718772888, 0.005698159337043762, -0.014095700345933437, -0.028224334120750427, 0.029598431661725044, -0.04051357880234718, 0.013680742122232914, -0.03819439187645912, 0.005980766378343105, -0.04655872657895088, 0.0526035837829113, -0.022221015766263008, -0.00022427219664677978, -0.001992929959669709, -0.03513692319393158, 0.007696293294429779, -0.0007076311740092933, 0.018835820257663727, 0.0762312114238739, -0.019121894612908363, 0.0003144433721899986, -0.014415380544960499, 0.03156858682632446, 0.00664812047034502, -0.02257460355758667, 0.040260203182697296, 0.010160412639379501, -0.010205749422311783, -0.01537046767771244, -0.03292843699455261, -0.019317209720611572, -0.0025650649331510067, -0.03518040105700493, 0.04866201803088188, -0.00024759749067015946, 0.03660843148827553, 0.02075887843966484, -0.02697787433862686, -0.007818232290446758, 0.015222173184156418, -0.03893883153796196, -0.0036236117593944073, -0.018056530505418777, 0.03214915096759796, -0.002318555722013116, 0.0036310325376689434, -0.0757787674665451, -0.008218037895858288, -0.0012310431338846684, 0.0058896164409816265, -0.004787667654454708, -0.02387596294283867, -0.026916347444057465, -0.0035675540566444397, -0.049460269510746, -0.01377514936029911, 0.05574822425842285, -0.014072095975279808, -0.017624549567699432, 0.0071111153811216354, 0.03295142576098442, 0.07146701961755753, 0.009199630469083786, -0.005499154329299927, 0.01234410423785448, 0.0016901378985494375, -0.02825971692800522, -0.02905092015862465, -0.010492214933037758, -0.03451891615986824, -0.030223174020648003, 0.02824689820408821, 0.021077165380120277, 0.054667577147483826, -0.0587090365588665, -0.024196967482566833, 0.014596179127693176, -0.01730998232960701, 0.008108626119792461, -0.016107609495520592, -0.007999837398529053, -0.032635368406772614, -0.012863323092460632, -0.03167377784848213, 0.036596622318029404, -0.013785667717456818, -0.018734989687800407, 0.05837683752179146, 0.00495629059150815, -0.018262086436152458, 0.006701701786369085, 0.09909725934267044, 0.02076169103384018, 0.014493855647742748, -0.004433534108102322, -0.005223139189183712, 0.021732764318585396, 0.002844393951818347, -0.011471598409116268, -0.02915983274579048, 0.008001642301678658, -0.03514328598976135, -0.024122267961502075, -0.028886152431368828, 0.029891790822148323, 0.05845973640680313, -0.020035674795508385, 0.03157739341259003, 0.044874418526887894, 0.019827885553240776, -0.007523541338741779, 0.028928974643349648, -0.011345031671226025, -0.03205300495028496, 0.011923625133931637, 0.047618381679058075, -0.018857834860682487, 0.03851015865802765, 0.029759488999843597, 0.04117555171251297, 0.038135312497615814, 0.0599428229033947, -0.013132776133716106, -0.008836628869175911, 0.06628743559122086, -0.04808135703206062, -0.020729143172502518, -0.0011159016285091639, -0.01841278187930584, 0.024744292721152306, -0.04199576750397682, -0.06562399119138718, 0.0374072827398777, 0.02928004413843155, -0.03261386230587959, -0.06142961233854294, -0.02902570553123951, -0.03410227596759796, 0.011918587610125542, 0.025115126743912697, -0.012549739331007004, 0.009687052108347416, -0.0009800742845982313, -0.007450528908520937, -0.004168511833995581, 0.020470192655920982, -0.038856543600559235, -0.05331440642476082, -0.02454649843275547, -0.05001159757375717, -0.031018026173114777, -0.012731334194540977, 0.004604593850672245, -0.0022711188066750765, 0.003045720048248768, 0.002518212189897895, 0.026235060766339302, -0.003698123851791024, 0.05258408933877945, 0.005056736525148153, 0.10526679456233978, -0.00999673642218113, 0.08331091701984406, -0.014285840094089508, -0.0015611184062436223, 0.11131411790847778, 0.04824032261967659, 0.045624177902936935, -0.03258395940065384, 0.013035171665251255, -0.004288561642169952, -0.0194396935403347, 0.01940464787185192, -0.027069738134741783, -0.01403362862765789, -0.0003383482981007546, 0.04817852005362511, 0.07226262241601944, -0.01936216466128826, 0.0027293500024825335, 0.03509504720568657, -0.05088281258940697, -0.0040188501589000225, -0.012638838961720467, 0.04067510366439819, 0.0489322654902935, -0.02719855308532715, -0.02144598215818405, 0.025394625961780548, 0.023218536749482155, -0.0014450043672695756, -0.04064330458641052, -0.022002210840582848, 0.003995134495198727, 0.012498665601015091, 0.010771787725389004, -0.017980284988880157, 0.0014699302846565843, -0.03226213529706001, 0.003182066371664405, 0.010296588763594627, 0.04206656664609909, -0.06941509991884232, 0.04452592507004738, 0.06915699690580368, 0.03679444268345833, -0.0016622402472421527, -0.0056970249861478806, 0.0110750338062644, -0.0415780134499073, -0.010657032020390034, -0.03812341019511223, 0.0253345537930727, -0.03856349736452103, -0.011645817197859287, -0.021012894809246063, -0.03637166693806648, 0.03876902163028717, -0.0644204393029213, -0.02455925941467285, -0.01588304713368416, 0.021658431738615036, -0.0368879958987236, -0.01769299805164337, -0.005416845437139273, 0.03522581234574318, 0.05555859953165054, 0.018411707133054733, 0.011554524302482605, -0.03533219173550606, -0.04099002480506897, -0.022055799141526222, 0.022347822785377502, 0.008810296654701233, -0.04004589840769768, -0.02181977592408657, 0.015150226652622223, -0.04658818989992142, 0.0004816887085326016, -0.029771899804472923, 0.007682702504098415, 0.03261015564203262, -0.002833405276760459, -0.024055663496255875, 0.041707102209329605, -0.03651747107505798, -0.008157063275575638, -0.037170734256505966, -0.013759852387011051, -0.016719460487365723, 0.014508347027003765, -0.01063804142177105, 0.014838548377156258, 0.0038805510848760605, -0.021341191604733467, 0.00920768454670906, 0.05186959356069565, -0.012709615752100945, -0.031246019527316093, -0.0001426551170879975, -0.009278819896280766, -0.030069595202803612, 0.01154666393995285, -0.037485264241695404, 0.058708325028419495, -0.013272210024297237, 0.026420345529913902, -0.019533958286046982, 0.013557870872318745, 0.027305953204631805, 0.019876932725310326, -0.031073791906237602, -0.06316865980625153, -0.00515276612713933, 0.01291316282004118, -0.028865186497569084, -0.021376701071858406, -0.02673961967229843, -0.020879073068499565, -0.04125601053237915, -0.00770541513338685, -0.03521563112735748, -0.0398404598236084, -0.0398288257420063, -0.032353609800338745, 0.02472424879670143, -0.0006679301150143147, 0.006203120574355125, 0.030095107853412628, -0.02827397733926773, 0.02051706053316593, 0.007603044155985117, -0.04122239351272583, 0.04843119531869888, 0.0018191769486293197, -0.028256366029381752, 0.00932227075099945, 0.009532974101603031, 0.04423381760716438, -0.005730625707656145, 0.020650522783398628, -0.0188598670065403, 0.019447308033704758, -0.0227101668715477, -0.01998632214963436, 0.05470981448888779, -0.05696416273713112, -0.020297637209296227, 0.04405400902032852, 0.018472516909241676, 0.022425450384616852, 0.05799495801329613, 0.007951364852488041, -0.044514916837215424, 0.032309241592884064, -0.0601031519472599, -0.016912031918764114, -0.0022083569783717394, 0.014532871544361115, 0.014004303142428398, -0.021660802885890007, -0.02195243537425995, 0.0493660494685173, -0.03696928173303604, 0.01404509972780943, 0.04285648092627525, -0.012591864913702011, -0.009729240089654922, 0.03974584490060806, 0.0071206106804311275, 0.0056249406188726425, 0.009102917276322842, -0.01228357944637537, -0.0004642398562282324, 0.07276549190282822, -0.043145596981048584, 0.028575200587511063, -0.012737720273435116, -0.0502222403883934, -0.07317803800106049, -0.016908520832657814, 0.012686037458479404, 0.006068423856049776, 0.0154946930706501, -0.0667533203959465, 0.020755799487233162, -0.003449154319241643, -0.021012913435697556, 0.03934314846992493, -0.021794939413666725, -0.031115753576159477, -0.06954234093427658, 0.018774470314383507, -0.023044828325510025, -0.008646978996694088, 0.02145908959209919, 0.026652060449123383, 0.02007739618420601, 0.01652294583618641, -0.0067811026237905025, -0.0185615923255682, 0.005200061481446028, 0.00016720101120881736, 0.003520302940160036, -0.0335162915289402, 0.03725196048617363, -0.003257490461692214, -0.03178650885820389, 0.022382240742444992, -0.04188307747244835, -0.024134598672389984, -0.01331761758774519, 0.006560003850609064, -0.009496555663645267, 0.008900175802409649, 0.03308110684156418, 0.008008860982954502, 0.008645684458315372, 0.00042833734187297523, 0.036324746906757355, -0.007254894357174635, -0.04080650582909584, 0.030019810423254967, 0.03063243255019188, 0.023118022829294205, -0.027760574594140053, 0.019915811717510223, -0.0016104744281619787, -0.014874732121825218, 0.001523501006886363, -0.013277169317007065, -0.02204134315252304, 0.03453727811574936, 0.029894491657614708, -0.044085197150707245, 0.026760950684547424, 0.031103402376174927, 0.0042252009734511375, -0.012042730115354061, 0.02417209930717945, -0.02140631340444088, -0.05781697481870651, 0.01393919624388218, 0.017537064850330353, 0.002748671919107437, -0.029390234500169754, -0.04682990908622742, 0.004886237438768148, 0.008607487194240093, -0.006955881603062153, -0.05495570972561836, -0.054244864732027054, 0.006300798617303371, -0.01071621011942625, 0.009506486356258392, 0.007175316568464041, 0.01565566286444664, -0.00009788653551368043, -0.058704327791929245, 0.040055613964796066, 0.03243299946188927, -0.019852258265018463, -0.049337975680828094, -0.037629224359989166, -0.02800607495009899, 0.028015917167067528, 0.05563146620988846, -0.007260214537382126, 0.007594089023768902, 0.02081233263015747, -0.0007552920724265277, 0.018634578213095665, -0.041120465844869614, 0.017216594889760017, -0.025524964556097984, -0.010725048370659351, -0.037442564964294434, 0.009124965406954288, 0.02807534486055374, -0.018405377864837646, 0.029262932017445564, -0.024097321555018425, -0.03844248130917549, -0.002249188022688031, -0.017117425799369812, 0.01785849593579769, -0.010811835527420044, 0.022654306143522263, 0.024855921044945717, -0.026082942262291908, -0.004386500455439091, -0.037495311349630356, 0.020317567512392998, -0.015348087064921856, 0.04018227383494377, -0.025033673271536827, -0.03075999580323696, -0.038378141820430756, -0.011789045296609402, -0.010582303628325462, -0.05753688886761665, -0.00029808259569108486, 0.03145794942975044, -0.05185938626527786, -0.025779400020837784, 0.010327432304620743, 0.03653111681342125, 0.03449990227818489, 0.01290824357420206, -0.021542146801948547, 0.00032654847018420696, -0.006786203011870384, 0.0019812111277133226, 0.04666869714856148, 0.008815213106572628, 0.017311038449406624, -0.006706426851451397, -0.026670515537261963, -0.004478872288018465, 0.04616735875606537, 0.005029056686908007, 0.07176072150468826, 0.0026660936418920755, -0.04651298001408577, 0.009230665862560272, 0.002978923264890909, 0.026366394013166428, -0.013276727870106697, -0.011049151420593262, 0.055674441158771515, 0.034917596727609634, 0.012667308561503887, -0.017621925100684166, -0.007744989823549986, 0.019369114190340042, 0.0094184260815382, 0.0052212318405508995, 0.0013135636691004038, 0.01388123445212841, 0.017498131841421127, -0.028199639171361923, 0.000005625825906463433, 0.025683460757136345, -0.03501567989587784, 0.030118724331259727, -0.008980968967080116, 0.0053328233771026134, 0.0025425711646676064, -0.06273441016674042, 0.024075813591480255, -0.04554690420627594, 0.027774609625339508, 0.023635853081941605, 0.06552324444055557, -0.02961968071758747, -0.01759369485080242, 0.021516121923923492, 0.055510327219963074, -0.02861199527978897, -0.01883540116250515, -0.02986176125705242, 0.02765909768640995, 0.018841207027435303, 0.006236248649656773 ]
<p>Can anyone suggest where to obtain the results of the 10,000 coin flips (i.e., all 10,000 heads and tails) performed by John Kerrich during WWII?</p>
34,226
[ -0.0073530348017811775, -0.04992470145225525, -0.03608642518520355, -0.0526447556912899, 0.05110390484333038, -0.0014670602977275848, -0.05567329004406929, 0.00010800441668834537, -0.018063005059957504, -0.036677535623311996, 0.058069586753845215, 0.027400651946663857, 0.020365793257951736, 0.04767000675201416, 0.00004399394310894422, 0.007495719939470291, -0.01199409831315279, 0.0357634499669075, -0.012608079239726067, -0.04054604470729828, 0.02751782350242138, -0.005587435327470303, -0.04680340364575386, -0.012810024432837963, -0.016240417957305908, 0.007815582677721977, 0.012974699959158897, -0.009963384829461575, 0.0073335301131010056, 0.052953798323869705, -0.03287547826766968, -0.03717682510614395, 0.028975551947951317, 0.01360949408262968, 0.025230184197425842, -0.007184865418821573, -0.03571952506899834, -0.041709642857313156, -0.01364124659448862, 0.007230827584862709, -0.014799327589571476, 0.004580334760248661, 0.02430719882249832, 0.02606966346502304, -0.004696671385318041, 0.017143016681075096, -0.03225957602262497, -0.024972714483737946, -0.029607584699988365, -0.04991781339049339, 0.020520396530628204, 0.027889197692275047, -0.000445511017460376, -0.004121499601751566, 0.030852459371089935, 0.016927000135183334, 0.04113634675741196, 0.04523227736353874, 0.004897781647741795, -0.03997545689344406, 0.004642064683139324, -0.03239516168832779, -0.011843583546578884, 0.0331527404487133, -0.043783221393823624, 0.009060259908437729, -0.009029010310769081, -0.040443453937768936, -0.0006730813765898347, -0.05108429491519928, 0.015991659834980965, 0.06599223613739014, 0.0633043646812439, 0.015525168739259243, -0.010073036886751652, -0.026260368525981903, 0.00379016506485641, -0.021715568378567696, 0.03314051404595375, 0.022004252299666405, 0.001895247376523912, 0.016066107898950577, 0.01680685207247734, 0.02329399064183235, 0.01873594895005226, -0.017852744087576866, 0.06506606191396713, -0.033586256206035614, 0.01781979389488697, 0.015255482867360115, -0.021101152524352074, 0.014102940447628498, 0.023570826277136803, 0.02741301991045475, -0.10354895144701004, -0.012367471121251583, 0.02153085172176361, 0.09135797619819641, 0.0009992208797484636, -0.03397030755877495, 0.018677854910492897, -0.027125461027026176, -0.013040888123214245, 0.07124987989664078, -0.015194874256849289, 0.011012106202542782, -0.0004021555359940976, 0.03746943175792694, -0.053142063319683075, -0.008588015101850033, -0.0026076820213347673, 0.015371528454124928, 0.012554069980978966, 0.004460075870156288, -0.005046984180808067, -0.0011061156401410699, 0.03221559524536133, -0.006952816620469093, 0.03500796854496002, 0.031730860471725464, 0.042166899889707565, -0.003018656512722373, -0.016806859523057938, -0.060961298644542694, -0.03537990152835846, 0.027131324633955956, 0.053232066333293915, -0.025564804673194885, -0.05067513883113861, 0.04812037572264671, 0.014391802251338959, -0.018221992999315262, 0.0418219156563282, 0.010541399009525776, 0.021321507170796394, -0.025859883055090904, -0.08017881959676743, -0.03223150596022606, 0.02907778136432171, 0.002362702041864395, -0.023712992668151855, -0.06716564297676086, 0.04996177554130554, 0.03415520116686821, 0.00852680578827858, 0.0011349322739988565, 0.025643493980169296, -0.02441307343542576, 0.006692143157124519, 0.00781270395964384, -0.009081217460334301, 0.027532419189810753, 0.0007642507553100586, -0.022110458463430405, -0.0008919649408198893, -0.08493361622095108, 0.018127424642443657, 0.03320157155394554, -0.0030177419539541006, -0.05140354111790657, 0.009526833891868591, 0.04561657831072807, -0.008073968812823296, -0.029267866164445877, -0.03509548306465149, -0.02318876050412655, 0.10811224579811096, 0.012012800201773643, -0.008348705247044563, -0.04338553547859192, -0.02629868872463703, 0.05393902212381363, 0.03333592414855957, 0.025593040511012077, 0.01744959130883217, -0.06719880551099777, 0.044190309941768646, -0.000661535537801683, 0.012522708624601364, -0.01987214758992195, 0.0021156955044716597, 0.00893666036427021, -0.00403981376439333, 0.028381245210766792, 0.02786942571401596, 0.024859169498085976, -0.01994464360177517, -0.012843129225075245, 0.027168860659003258, -0.04432449862360954, -0.01401458214968443, -0.03636927902698517, 0.0015695627080276608, 0.00614514434710145, -0.021499058231711388, 0.02242925576865673, -0.014811810106039047, 0.0621124729514122, 0.020021850243210793, -0.06084422394633293, -0.006191292777657509, -0.009465739130973816, 0.07205061614513397, -0.042987532913684845, -0.046227164566516876, 0.07105239480733871, 0.038856446743011475, -0.023166488856077194, 0.024045269936323166, -0.03366097807884216, 0.004956929013133049, -0.0008243211195804179, -0.007976669818162918, 0.00649655656889081, 0.050931524485349655, 0.03230385109782219, -0.005326457787305117, -0.007303805556148291, 0.021750811487436295, -0.030313657596707344, -0.02732183039188385, 0.038118790835142136, 0.05438220500946045, 0.029498189687728882, -0.02014891989529133, 0.020381223410367966, 0.007161442656069994, -0.009736857376992702, 0.00027263950323686004, -0.03530576080083847, -0.04382847622036934, -0.0017406027764081955, 0.020451074466109276, 0.0402875579893589, -0.017990469932556152, 0.000713150657247752, 0.027782343327999115, 0.03703070059418678, 0.017465855926275253, 0.015521138906478882, -0.05343874916434288, -0.01268723327666521, -0.0302943903952837, -0.007579702418297529, -0.004093644674867392, 0.042795825749635696, 0.008345094509422779, 0.014735394157469273, -0.03921090066432953, 0.04338492080569267, -0.049912936985492706, -0.0219336599111557, 0.0020614478271454573, -0.009688655845820904, -0.0100234504789114, -0.04927864670753479, 0.021602094173431396, -0.03639787435531616, -0.03241846710443497, -0.0004283044545445591, 0.02471987158060074, -0.006874106824398041, 0.0022042652126401663, -0.05965220555663109, 0.03328907862305641, -0.0005181881133466959, -0.037640661001205444, 0.012394909746944904, 0.06635241955518723, -0.012360218912363052, 0.0048539587296545506, -0.027517002075910568, -0.01136382669210434, -0.04311478137969971, 0.023949824273586273, 0.01163547020405531, 0.012593094259500504, 0.008516720496118069, -0.022833380848169327, -0.058540280908346176, 0.007685061078518629, -0.02337338775396347, 0.018739841878414154, 0.03332503139972687, -0.10311992466449738, 0.030972188338637352, -0.0017642357852309942, -0.014774785377085209, 0.01882532611489296, -0.005958546418696642, 0.00008590236393501982, 0.060167599469423294, 0.009820410050451756, -0.060222432017326355, 0.0049356878735125065, 0.0013830030802637339, 0.005668673198670149, -0.03658336028456688, 0.006370550021529198, 0.033545058220624924, 0.052081845700740814, -0.030983097851276398, 0.048315804451704025, -0.002021735068410635, -0.037176404148340225, -0.04386080428957939, 0.006211493629962206, 0.02124115824699402, -0.00817797426134348, -0.018453920260071754, -0.027011016383767128, 0.005262557417154312, -0.01981480047106743, -0.04218331724405289, -0.05548905208706856, 0.03004334308207035, 0.015347268432378769, 0.05218949168920517, 0.012590965256094933, 0.007728719152510166, 0.04462768882513046, 0.01840508170425892, -0.05803467705845833, -0.03253937140107155, 0.027852868661284447, 0.008202885277569294, 0.005374643485993147, -0.00769411725923419, 0.009341751225292683, 0.003820730373263359, 0.034235913306474686, -0.017856504768133163, 0.0040266430005431175, 0.041234493255615234, 0.004319310188293457, -0.042361363768577576, 0.049087900668382645, -0.038179412484169006, 0.00043413566891103983, -0.004775517620146275, 0.021785542368888855, -0.05069941282272339, 0.010972104966640472, -0.014345632866024971, 0.018622664734721184, 0.004326042719185352, -0.048358142375946045, 0.04733918979763985, 0.019831422716379166, 0.012027550488710403, -0.03405715152621269, 0.028568819165229797, -0.04107774794101715, -0.0288491602987051, 0.01996070332825184, 0.027180884033441544, 0.026198171079158783, -0.009688318707048893, 0.054507285356521606, -0.008348042145371437, 0.032307859510183334, -0.024697547778487206, -0.009299885481595993, -0.004814993590116501, -0.013384894467890263, 0.03413200005888939, -0.016688527539372444, -0.008831536397337914, 0.03948776423931122, 0.016421139240264893, 0.0067849913612008095, -0.007063994184136391, 0.0025859433226287365, 0.013817899860441685, -0.04141673445701599, 0.01453783642500639, -0.036752741783857346, 0.03304455056786537, -0.006729258224368095, 0.06078930199146271, 0.021607376635074615, 0.00411253934726119, -0.01994297280907631, 0.010978806763887405, -0.05869816988706589, 0.014786352403461933, -0.03126547485589981, -0.014395718462765217, -0.03458331525325775, -0.008987008593976498, 0.06003648787736893, -0.015298176556825638, -0.018259312957525253, 0.003088319441303611, 0.03638038784265518, -0.054668646305799484, 0.046314384788274765, -0.04431173577904701, -0.022034339606761932, 0.011462125927209854, 0.06065789982676506, 0.02751818485558033, 0.004609614610671997, 0.025359615683555603, -0.007634438574314117, -0.019976431503891945, 0.014060507528483868, -0.02823949046432972, 0.03169525787234306, -0.03447861596941948, 0.05100620910525322, 0.01299535296857357, 0.01028023473918438, -0.060407355427742004, 0.035185061395168304, -0.026821427047252655, 0.04483845829963684, 0.021243464201688766, 0.008042916655540466, -0.051819879561662674, -0.017048699781298637, 0.009415031410753727, 0.020486904308199883, -0.0013089595595374703, 0.00460853660479188, 0.03291304036974907, 0.007120165973901749, 0.015144558623433113, -0.02736993320286274, 0.009937346912920475, 0.08445936441421509, -0.023482749238610268, 0.007550235837697983, -0.0031227227300405502, -0.005671225488185883, -0.0181767325848341, 0.0015256667975336313, 0.008139322511851788, 0.028072604909539223, 0.009409787133336067, -0.01470048539340496, 0.07240766286849976, -0.003724766196683049, -0.012665004469454288, 0.02459450252354145, -0.010055014863610268, 0.061450958251953125, -0.009983227588236332, 0.019406037405133247, 0.03905493766069412, 0.03160136565566063, 0.028251463547348976, 0.050649963319301605, -0.03645214065909386, -0.04190840944647789, -0.0052191209979355335, 0.0457611046731472, 0.022388562560081482, -0.05692042410373688, 0.03352343663573265, -0.09140392392873764, -0.01480126939713955, 0.05187885835766792, -0.017084626480937004, 0.012484281323850155, 0.002388832625001669, 0.014605884440243244, -0.0016482637729495764, -0.0013283248990774155, -0.00639330642297864, 0.025234408676624298, -0.017101727426052094, 0.028809085488319397, -0.04116681590676308, 0.026112986728549004, -0.00419878214597702, 0.0009346933802589774, 0.04777167737483978, 0.049766506999731064, -0.00419851066544652, 0.006320481654256582, 0.003542910562828183, -0.016545729711651802, -0.021524891257286072, -0.06740937381982803, -0.006661972962319851, -0.02948695607483387, -0.0022936284076422453, 0.0966033935546875, -0.03806525468826294, -0.053473107516765594, 0.026348209008574486, -0.027982011437416077, 0.00661269947886467, -0.009467849507927895, -0.01854545995593071, 0.03605130687355995, 0.020170345902442932, -0.013441442511975765, 0.04664990305900574, 0.043360330164432526, -0.01445896178483963, -0.011531221680343151, 0.0007278851117007434, 0.04367513954639435, 0.012044004164636135, 0.009819586761295795, -0.01590229943394661, 0.011871051043272018, -0.0680556669831276, 0.03138788789510727, -0.005333688110113144, 0.061136454343795776, 0.0007477476610802114, -0.0023230770602822304, -0.03583328798413277, 0.008269982412457466, -0.0001350889215245843, -0.0293866116553545, -0.00991882849484682, 0.028198132291436195, -0.01758451759815216, -0.022848019376397133, 0.03753957897424698, -0.004340619780123234, -0.0029516953509300947, -0.024326391518115997, -0.03741816058754921, 0.01345521118491888, -0.06986431032419205, -0.007316270377486944, 0.021291550248861313, 0.019662586972117424, 0.038985319435596466, -0.012605656869709492, 0.022693155333399773, 0.05008190497756004, -0.06608960032463074, -0.026780953630805016, -0.03359738737344742, 0.02187877707183361, 0.019337670877575874, -0.04099315404891968, 0.02237730659544468, 0.01860664039850235, 0.03430624306201935, -0.039013784378767014, -0.03496614098548889, 0.0216392669826746, 0.015974977985024452, -0.010712435469031334, -0.05206497758626938, 0.024827904999256134, -0.015392088331282139, 0.009015881456434727, -0.021325770765542984, 0.03562237694859505, -0.020635001361370087, 0.047884777188301086, 0.011879854835569859, 0.00808830838650465, 0.05839592590928078, -0.004494803491979837, -0.025664372369647026, 0.08308704942464828, 0.006626209244132042, 0.005262043327093124, 0.012840084731578827, -0.0076313926838338375, -0.022086506709456444, -0.004028153605759144, 0.0027477319817990065, 0.01707315444946289, -0.020757263526320457, -0.007799433544278145, 0.02214553765952587, 0.013356009498238564, -0.02273743413388729, 0.03877301141619682, -0.006720333360135555, -0.010221078991889954, -0.05155012384057045, 0.038235776126384735, -0.009821543470025063, 0.0008625741465948522, 0.024174902588129044, 0.004375190008431673, 0.010506239719688892, 0.02127700299024582, -0.009796149097383022, 0.034263625741004944, 0.07316593080759048, 0.0014724393840879202, -0.03675562143325806, -0.002604203764349222, -0.03457190841436386, 0.014920189045369625, 0.026637757197022438, 0.01422978937625885, 0.03651691973209381, 0.010749097913503647, -0.007027909625321627, -0.04113050922751427, -0.034561578184366226, 0.008931218646466732, 0.04490820690989494, 0.005849354900419712, 0.023114686831831932, -0.006094752345234156, 0.016637003049254417, 0.02460610494017601, 0.009396456182003021, 0.0012546847574412823, 0.014752446673810482, 0.0062147341668605804, 0.05323799327015877, 0.03745117038488388, -0.0028776954859495163, 0.012064671143889427, -0.003182872198522091, 0.05062100663781166, -0.01998962089419365, 0.0028637300711125135, 0.014300335198640823, -0.012366453185677528, -0.03758768364787102, -0.01671651192009449, -0.016127103939652443, -0.05846692994236946, -0.0008009739685803652, -0.010086387395858765, -0.0072396742179989815, 0.016999470070004463, 0.016744889318943024, -0.009976120665669441, -0.02825498953461647, -0.053560949862003326, -0.0424470417201519, -0.02177608571946621, -0.0012172756250947714, -0.0033809139858931303, -0.03265615925192833, 0.00494361761957407, 0.029931552708148956, -0.031118523329496384, -0.058803997933864594, -0.01037297397851944, -0.04619428142905235, -0.01161941047757864, -0.02456766366958618, -0.08464091271162033, 0.03548261895775795, -0.005644060205668211, -0.021554436534643173, 0.030723122879862785, -0.038264624774456024, 0.019351597875356674, 0.005679892376065254, 0.027851661667227745, -0.002620768267661333, 0.07355349510908127, 0.004296815488487482, 0.002273618709295988, -0.0007564182160422206, -0.019464151933789253, 0.1481774002313614, 0.027623044326901436, 0.016625266522169113, -0.05938805267214775, -0.017328757792711258, -0.020841216668486595, 0.02634502574801445, -0.008620641194283962, 0.01127664279192686, 0.011910151690244675, 0.010958102531731129, 0.03912646323442459, 0.03724748268723488, 0.022868765518069267, -0.0006807929021306336, 0.005926169920712709, 0.005331661086529493, -0.02256087213754654, 0.026746131479740143, 0.022235417738556862, -0.02193375863134861, -0.05482420697808266, -0.03466859087347984, 0.04202642664313316, 0.004384300205856562, -0.041210565716028214, -0.01531158946454525, 0.007206035312265158, 0.015827026218175888, 0.029879113659262657, -0.010875963605940342, 0.009780388325452805, 0.040603138506412506, 0.01933828741312027, -0.03887263312935829, -0.00047122183605097234, 0.0043797665275633335, -0.012342558242380619, 0.043575484305620193, 0.0399506650865078, 0.034567419439554214, -0.015537341125309467, -0.03344222158193588, -0.00293095619417727, -0.05829616263508797, -0.029899962246418, -0.009883175604045391, 0.014364026486873627, -0.045987602323293686, 0.00033160392194986343, -0.042906008660793304, -0.06662032008171082, 0.02399144321680069, -0.032076574862003326, -0.027922775596380234, -0.0073884935118258, 0.01719238981604576, -0.039299916476011276, -0.043510280549526215, 0.000694452493917197, 0.0011048598680645227, -0.05818958207964897, 0.05026645585894585, 0.005240254104137421, -0.005910965148359537, -0.05951864644885063, 0.007765302434563637, 0.020385893061757088, 0.01417616568505764, -0.03304857760667801, -0.03419706970453262, -0.03312722593545914, -0.019048744812607765, -0.0033263596706092358, -0.002163798315450549, -0.004246243741363287, 0.009773305617272854, 0.0165205467492342, -0.033316440880298615, 0.004400733392685652, 0.007722774054855108, 0.0030480714049190283, -0.06260185688734055, -0.003250213572755456, 0.009444263763725758, -0.02680264040827751, 0.024486837908625603, 0.011399277485907078, -0.02160412073135376, 0.0001309928047703579, -0.007583077065646648, 0.023373819887638092, 0.021761322394013405, -0.03684438765048981, -0.003800562582910061, -0.0018230617279186845, -0.0520075187087059, -0.004437141586095095, -0.01075552124530077, 0.050287216901779175, 0.07092056423425674, 0.02557232603430748, 0.02397623471915722, -0.004634114447981119, 0.003054094035178423, 0.019472798332571983, 0.030881213024258614, -0.06739143282175064, 0.0006970544927753508, 0.0044101872481405735, 0.03204561397433281, -0.02756098285317421, -0.033195432275533676, -0.034215763211250305, 0.04507136717438698, 0.02903606928884983, -0.008000178262591362, 0.011547531001269817, -0.021593235433101654, -0.006084360182285309, 0.010573735460639, 0.008708122186362743, 0.026692721992731094, -0.0028369377832859755, 0.01258360780775547, -0.02918158657848835, 0.007852476090192795, 0.005170293152332306, -0.0013578004436567426, 0.05316230654716492, -0.019206183031201363, 0.036601509898900986, 0.018077736720442772, -0.04048796370625496, 0.0063118585385382175, -0.003919088747352362, 0.05511325225234032, 0.07786732167005539, 0.0041171954944729805, -0.03052365966141224, 0.03559137135744095, -0.07395684719085693, -0.048810917884111404, 0.04239213094115257, -0.0071277073584496975, 0.0036944972816854715, 0.04982353001832962, -0.013664178550243378, -0.01854279637336731, 0.03429554030299187, -0.025170160457491875, -0.02429456077516079, 0.03971705585718155, 0.011445465497672558, 0.04229125380516052, 0.006879618391394615, -0.005708596669137478, -0.017661111429333687, -0.011086955666542053, 0.022596677765250206, 0.07230113446712494, 0.03131487965583801, 0.01627781055867672, 0.015113763511180878, 0.013707369565963745, 0.01858856901526451, 0.01292197685688734, -0.0041941432282328606, 0.0018785373540595174, 0.04237684980034828, -0.03931095451116562, 0.04223444312810898, -0.019241485744714737, 0.02167516015470028, -0.06091028451919556, 0.0020857553463429213, -0.009317790158092976, -0.010965303517878056, 0.03156668320298195, -0.029727695509791374, -0.02367372065782547, 0.01105415914207697, -0.060900066047906876, 0.06231456995010376, -0.006242108531296253, -0.04078090563416481, -0.046165548264980316, 0.013457883149385452, -0.00006731895700795576, 0.009021821431815624, 0.003663048380985856, 0.02418610081076622, 0.04718879982829094, -0.007192624732851982, -0.020358342677354813, 0.026493621990084648, -0.023209277540445328, -0.011664866469800472, -0.005052382126450539, 0.0019514586310833693, 0.04056278616189957, -0.027123648673295975, -0.07996568083763123, 0.04696711152791977, -0.020076744258403778, 0.022758906707167625, -0.05326196178793907, 0.028015462681651115, -0.022499460726976395, 0.03302768990397453, -0.003588426625356078, 0.012954207137227058, 0.008582191541790962, 0.018538974225521088, 0.015199409797787666, 0.03361360728740692, -0.011698472313582897, 0.009272160939872265, 0.02249036729335785, -0.010556532070040703, -0.06412812322378159, 0.047903671860694885, 0.015086059458553791, -0.00976481195539236, -0.0037237354554235935, -0.006009777542203665, 0.028744718059897423, -0.008123552426695824, 0.011020759120583534, -0.05003876984119415, 0.002044007182121277, 0.02435005083680153, -0.013650729320943356, 0.04901253432035446, 0.06129689887166023, -0.026722755283117294, -0.041618380695581436, -0.004445233382284641, 0.007262646220624447, -0.04786570742726326, -0.017852572724223137, 0.009693299420177937, 0.05004732310771942, 0.04137725383043289, 0.014298354275524616, -0.019650042057037354, -0.051976434886455536, 0.0008470597094856203, 0.010059534572064877, 0.009063759818673134, 0.035987913608551025, -0.009087879210710526, -0.00016065590898506343, -0.04676678404211998, 0.026727646589279175, -0.006300891749560833, 0.03892388567328453, -0.006731850560754538, -0.024373311549425125, -0.0016055423766374588, -0.009868662804365158, 0.018740234896540642, -0.04479753226041794, -0.017715200781822205, -0.04746498540043831, -0.014140358194708824, 0.01618230901658535, -0.05027657747268677, 0.036136921495199203, -0.03327268734574318, -0.010141681879758835, 0.000024902643417590298, -0.026576094329357147, 0.009682062081992626, 0.004091660026460886, 0.0034857678692787886, 0.0011707399971783161, -0.012760457582771778, -0.024828411638736725, -0.01422988623380661, 0.017788458615541458, 0.04242817312479019, 0.03202073648571968, 0.013405381701886654, -0.005218048579990864, 0.011808366514742374, 0.010958238504827023, 0.012972620315849781, -0.06264359503984451, 0.0744328647851944, 0.004710389766842127, -0.03242703154683113, 0.01599818654358387, -0.001853001769632101, 0.046638067811727524, -0.05671440809965134, 0.016582533717155457, 0.025248663499951363, 0.006934864446520805, -0.00035412368015386164, 0.02744283340871334, 0.0046696895733475685, 0.002742285840213299, -0.003789355047047138, 0.014807670377194881, 0.0019343059975653887, -0.03076603263616562, 0.011331984773278236, 0.02113916166126728, 0.029753658920526505, 0.02188689447939396, -0.010455268435180187, 0.020161885768175125, -0.02726023830473423, 0.042088281363248825, -0.016065102070569992, 0.017706096172332764, -0.031552210450172424, -0.020224429666996002, 0.028421558439731598, -0.052100274711847305, -0.07202079892158508, -0.002296798164024949, -0.02462027035653591, 0.09144793450832367, -0.022607408463954926, 0.020290203392505646, -0.06309761852025986, 0.006743482779711485, -0.009016264230012894, -0.005460161715745926, -0.010538809932768345, -0.00246488768607378, -0.04577425867319107, -0.02773604542016983, 0.00419083796441555, 0.04774206876754761, 0.04789546877145767, -0.008425424806773663, 0.013491681776940823, 0.0005218277219682932, 0.02235550992190838, -0.009232273325324059, -0.06044069677591324, -0.026523081585764885, -0.04634510353207588, 0.009546412155032158, -0.012076080776751041, 0.004863454028964043, 0.010788319632411003, -0.037193965166807175, -0.02588321827352047, 0.03569899499416351, -0.024978993460536003, -0.023398131132125854, -0.02845575660467148, 0.05663716793060303, -0.013783895410597324, 0.03922370821237564 ]